background top icon
background center wave icon
background filled rhombus icon
background two lines icon
background stroke rhombus icon

Download "Как нам стирают историческую память"

input logo icon
Table of contents
|

Table of contents

0:00
Путь из «никогда больше» к «можем повторить»
1:52
Как власть меняет историческую память
3:53
С чего началось искажение исторической памяти
5:49
Кощунство над Георгиевским орденом
8:56
Символ Z и фашизм
10:46
Коллективная ответственность
13:49
Как мы будем восстанавливаться после войны
Video tags
|

Video tags

навальный
соболь
любовь соболь
фбк
navalny life
navalny live
навальный live
навальный лайф
навальный лайв
navalny
yfdfkmysq
алексей навальный
новальный
дудь
татьяна эйдельман
русская история
эйдельман
юрий дудь
история россии
георгиевские ленты
день победы
война в украине
война на украине
спецоперация на украине
домбасс
лнр
днр
мариуполь
херсонес
бомбежка мариуполя
обстрел мариуполя
обстрел харькова
обстрел львова
зеленский
владимир зеленский
Subtitles
|

Subtitles

subtitles menu arrow
  • ruRussian
Download
00:00:02
that's all all all days on May 9 we
00:00:07
always heard two phrases one of them
00:00:10
was never again and the other we can
00:00:12
repeat tell me maybe you can
00:00:14
explain somehow from a historical point
00:00:16
of view from a human one how it happened
00:00:19
how two such the opposite phrases
00:00:22
have been said for years by the descendants of the dead maniacs, but they were
00:00:27
not said at the same time; when I
00:00:29
was little, or even not very
00:00:31
little anymore, it never occurred to anyone to
00:00:34
say, we can repeat,
00:00:37
they said, despite all the aggressiveness of the
00:00:40
Soviet regime, of course, and all that stuff, but
00:00:43
the main thing was that never again this
00:00:45
should not be repeated was the main loss,
00:00:48
but we can repeat this, it has appeared in the
00:00:50
last, say, 10-15 years when, on the
00:00:53
one hand, such a
00:00:56
terrible militarization of our country is happening, and
00:01:00
this militarization, unfortunately, it seems to have
00:01:04
appropriated victory day for itself and is visible
00:01:08
every day like every year, like this
00:01:13
holiday, which before Prague with the colors of the eyes is
00:01:16
not a holiday at all, this is grief, this day
00:01:18
of remembrance of the dead,
00:01:20
how it turns more and more, this saber
00:01:22
rattling, this
00:01:25
becomes so false, empty,
00:01:29
children walk meaningless phrases about grandfathers
00:01:31
fought when there are veterans there, there are veterans
00:01:35
who are Ginny where to which some
00:01:39
mocking gifts like a bottle of
00:01:41
vodka and
00:01:44
at the same time this is
00:01:46
the aggressiveness we flew so these are 2
00:01:49
different levels
00:01:51
there is such a thing as historical
00:01:53
memory this is what is happening now you
00:01:57
said how it has changed it has privatized
00:02:00
the war how do you relate to me
00:02:02
to veterans and to the war,
00:02:03
it disappeared, how could it be erased?
00:02:08
historical memory is not erased after it
00:02:11
changes, and this is also something that, of course, the
00:02:18
regime has been completely thought out and consistently doing for the last 10 15
00:02:22
and actually all 20 years, this is a change
00:02:26
in historical memory, this is the creation of
00:02:28
fakes, this concerns not only war
00:02:30
is the rehabilitation
00:02:32
of the special services, when there are TV series
00:02:36
about the war in which there are such good SMERSH
00:02:39
sheep, and then there is someone there, this is the rehabilitation of
00:02:44
Stalin on the sly, when these
00:02:47
wild monuments appear, it seems like
00:02:50
this initiative does not happen on the ground either,
00:02:52
and the
00:02:54
sower is also connected, so completely
00:02:58
distorted the idea of ​​war,
00:03:01
for example, well, by the way, this of course
00:03:03
happened before now, it’s just intensifying
00:03:05
that you fought, you just get the feeling that
00:03:08
you fought and only our country had victims,
00:03:11
only our country, and the rest there, it’s
00:03:13
unclear, some stupid english Olya,
00:03:16
of course the second world war, they were
00:03:19
united within themselves allies, both the Americans
00:03:22
and the British made huge sacrifices and
00:03:26
by the way, the help from America to the Soviet Union
00:03:29
from America was enormous, this is all
00:03:31
deliberately forgotten, we are the only one and
00:03:33
they have always been ours this is this
00:03:36
concept,
00:03:37
this is not just some kind of historical
00:03:39
inaccuracy, it works
00:03:42
today to hostility Fatima
00:03:44
this is how it is deliberately distorted
00:03:48
propaganda historical memory is created
00:03:51
fake this is terrible
00:03:54
can you remember
00:03:56
what in your opinion was some of the
00:03:59
first such bells dream we are heading towards this
00:04:01
that it begins such a big
00:04:03
campaign to distort historical
00:04:06
memory distortions of history
00:04:08
but there is this version, or I know how
00:04:11
correct it is, that the first bell was
00:04:14
the appearance of a program of old songs, and
00:04:17
most importantly, I can’t even understand
00:04:21
at what time it was king tails grandfather in the
00:04:23
late 90s, a very cute program before they sang
00:04:27
songs from Soviet films, it’s all
00:04:31
very nice
00:04:32
this [ __ ] but it was like that and it was probably a
00:04:35
symptom of a chick, that is, this is the beginning of
00:04:37
the show, it
00:04:39
was so bad in the Soviet Union,
00:04:43
and then it just went and went and went
00:04:47
and
00:04:50
you will find out how you were neighbors for quite a long time
00:04:52
because there was, like,
00:04:56
one hole type they said one thing, well next to it,
00:04:59
say another, this is normal in a day
00:05:01
of critical society, but gradually,
00:05:04
maybe,
00:05:06
but I’m even sure that this
00:05:10
was not the first machine, but for me, a very
00:05:12
important thing was when they started destroying the
00:05:16
museum, first row 6, these are
00:05:20
some of the few places our country where
00:05:23
they tried to preserve the
00:05:25
memory of Stalin’s victims and
00:05:32
now, instead, there is a museum in memory of a
00:05:35
museum dedicated to Tinov,
00:05:38
this is a very
00:05:41
symptomatic thing, and then everything went
00:05:45
on and then along the lines I also wanted to
00:05:49
turn to the symbol that is now
00:05:51
used by the
00:05:52
Russian army by officials.
00:05:55
propaganda is the letter z and
00:05:58
often at first
00:06:00
only the letter z appeared as its basis, then they began to
00:06:03
put the St. George’s ribbon on its basis, but not
00:06:06
everyone knows what the
00:06:08
St. George’s ribbon originally meant, what kind of sign it is,
00:06:11
who was it given to, because in recent
00:06:13
years we have seen how they are there in transition
00:06:15
they sell for 10 rubles, can you
00:06:17
tell our viewers in more detail about this and
00:06:19
so that we can understand how much this distortion
00:06:21
is happening now, you know, this is how
00:06:26
these ribbons just appeared and for
00:06:28
some they are quite
00:06:30
decent, so friends did
00:06:33
n’t see anything like that in this, but the card is
00:06:37
your speech to those
00:06:39
who fought there and then there the similarity did not
00:06:42
always seem, well, besides the fact that they
00:06:45
very quickly also accepted some kind of
00:06:47
aggressive meaning connected with the DPR and LPR,
00:06:50
but for starters, this is blasphemy over the
00:06:54
Order of St. George on the St. George
00:06:58
Cross, a box of offerings to the St. George
00:07:00
Cross, receiving the St. George Cross
00:07:03
was a great merit,
00:07:07
it’s like being proud of coal by the fact that he received
00:07:12
this to give
00:07:14
for outstanding heroism to the soldier's
00:07:19
pride and quest of the officer, during
00:07:24
the term you are free, Nicholas II
00:07:26
was awarded the Cross of St. George, as when
00:07:29
he became my superiors and this shocked many
00:07:33
as they explained that he
00:07:35
inspires soldiers to feat as he is not
00:07:39
him he doesn’t fight for himself, why to him
00:07:42
it already seemed to be a conformation, and now when
00:07:45
any professional employee puts on a
00:07:48
St. George’s cross, you know, I
00:07:51
was once in a cafe next to the zoo
00:07:54
and there were two young mothers with
00:07:57
children and one of these
00:08:00
little boys had a St. George’s ribbon
00:08:05
the button of the needs was tied, it was much more stressful
00:08:08
with a fly, and it was clear that he
00:08:10
wanted to write and he was also touching himself all the time there, the
00:08:13
actor and this ribbon were rubbed, which means about
00:08:16
my personal belongings I’m adding here a little
00:08:18
boy, but this happens everywhere
00:08:22
and the St. George Cross is
00:08:25
the greatest in the order indeed, it has
00:08:28
become commonplace that there are not
00:08:30
ribbons that were lying around that are
00:08:32
tied to cars
00:08:34
that are in one in one clip under
00:08:40
these clowns that dress in military
00:08:42
uniforms the
00:08:43
singers of which you have long hair and
00:08:46
a cap on top and this is a mess,
00:08:49
this is blasphemy towards those who
00:08:51
I really completely agree with you
00:08:54
and I also wanted to know about this
00:08:57
letter z, but in general about symbolism,
00:09:00
how important it is, you
00:09:02
talked about the
00:09:04
connection with fascism, what are the common features here,
00:09:09
symbolism here plays some
00:09:12
important role in the creation of such an ideology,
00:09:15
aggressive and militant in
00:09:18
general, it is of course surprising how it
00:09:21
all appeared, that is, initially
00:09:23
it was just a sign of a Western group of forces, that’s
00:09:27
all, the speed of propaganda
00:09:30
promoted it, it’s amazing and this is
00:09:33
also something very bad, it says how
00:09:36
this scene was bought, it’s really like a
00:09:38
half you already have this one thing,
00:09:42
even I understand that someone has a status with
00:09:46
this zora, but for the Russian language
00:09:48
it’s such a sound before the selection of a machine like
00:09:51
something else and this whole aggressiveness
00:09:54
that is hobbling around in this insect is
00:09:58
scary to go, this is what they also choose here
00:10:02
such, but not some kind of dove of peace,
00:10:07
I don’t know, I don’t know the color they supposedly bring to
00:10:11
Ukraine to depict and pigeons don’t need
00:10:15
this, and of course the fact that now children
00:10:18
are lined up with this sign, this is I’m
00:10:21
sure that this is this, I’m sure that this is not
00:10:23
some kind of initiative individual kindergartens and
00:10:26
this was
00:10:28
the order and these people who
00:10:31
treat our children like this are their
00:10:34
buoys, I understand that these are probably not the worst
00:10:36
war criminals, but I am
00:10:39
sure that among those in the Russia of the future
00:10:41
they must go to trial, there
00:10:44
is often talk now about
00:10:48
collective and in the summer of the dispute, collective
00:10:50
or individual responsibility for
00:10:52
what is happening now in Russia
00:10:54
for what will start the war and we as a
00:10:57
people have not done anything about it, your
00:11:00
opinion, how is there any collective responsibility in this, can there
00:11:02
not be any, you
00:11:05
know I have a complicated relationship with this
00:11:09
concept because, well, in general, any
00:11:12
kind of collective community
00:11:16
seems quite far-fetched to me and I’ll say I
00:11:18
wrote a lot and thought about collective
00:11:20
pride under I don’t understand why we
00:11:23
should be proud of the successes of a sports
00:11:25
team or even why we should be
00:11:28
proud of Pushkin’s work, I can
00:11:31
enjoy Pushkin’s work I I might
00:11:33
want to share it there with my
00:11:35
foreign friends, you know, what does it
00:11:37
have to do with me, that I wrote people and
00:11:40
poems or something,
00:11:43
there’s a record bed and from here, I don’t
00:11:49
really understand how the whole community as a whole can be to blame,
00:11:52
although I’m very
00:11:56
interested about this there Nikolai uplay
00:11:57
will describe of course, but it seems to me that I
00:12:01
myself am nothing
00:12:03
but just
00:12:06
responsibility, as it seems to me, should
00:12:08
be personal; another thing is that every
00:12:11
citizen of Russia, probably,
00:12:15
to some extent, should experience
00:12:18
it, should live, once upon a time in another
00:12:23
world, they are guessing, I gave lectures about
00:12:25
civilians about revelations I started
00:12:28
Socrates who said that when
00:12:32
he was offered to escape in prison, he said
00:12:34
that he would not keep him because well,
00:12:36
he was part of this world, so I
00:12:39
said how many years I lived in Athens
00:12:41
apple to go there,
00:12:43
taking all my property, my family but I
00:12:46
didn’t leave and I obeyed the laws,
00:12:49
which means in this now I will be it’s like
00:12:51
my responsibility and the fact that we
00:12:55
live or lived there in this country is how
00:12:58
we wouldn’t behave obeyed we protested
00:13:01
we’re part of I would simply formulate
00:13:07
that not everyone was with As a cop, each of us
00:13:11
must think about what exactly the
00:13:14
responsibility of each of us is, and this
00:13:17
seems to me very important
00:13:19
about sports teams, I’ve been
00:13:22
thinking about this for a long time, why,
00:13:24
by right of birth, I need to root for a
00:13:26
football team that is in my city
00:13:28
and I could never imagine it explain yes,
00:13:31
although it is clear how all these
00:13:33
sports things work in order to
00:13:35
form patriotism and so
00:13:37
on among them among women up to the feet of
00:13:40
Dysport please take it very well
00:13:43
but only the causality of the national city
00:13:45
and
00:13:46
at least finally ask you
00:13:49
such a burning question,
00:13:52
we have already talked about it generation said
00:13:55
never again
00:13:57
and seemed to do everything for this and
00:13:59
remembered and
00:14:00
told stories, communicated with
00:14:02
veterans, but everything repeats itself,
00:14:05
how to do so that this does not
00:14:08
happen again,
00:14:09
this is an
00:14:11
incredibly complex question and an incredibly
00:14:13
complex thing, now I’m reading a
00:14:16
book about that and
00:14:18
they say the price of English street villa
00:14:21
Zingermans how the Germans were civilized again
00:14:25
means after the second problem
00:14:27
when practically German civilization collapsed by them
00:14:30
also what is happening send
00:14:32
and I understand that this was despite the fact that
00:14:36
Germany was conquered and the Allied
00:14:39
powers
00:14:41
facilitated this process of the righteous and there is
00:14:44
already a terribly long and painful thing and
00:14:48
when at first they just ordered everyone and I
00:14:52
had to agree with them, but in order for
00:14:56
something to appear in their heads, apparently it
00:14:59
took 20 years and it was very
00:15:02
scary to bear and it
00:15:04
is absolutely clear that we will be going
00:15:07
through something like this for a very long time
00:15:09
very painful, again, only through
00:15:12
the awareness by each of us of what
00:15:16
happened and what the
00:15:19
Russian troops are doing in Ukraine now;
00:15:21
only this is generally what the authorities are doing,
00:15:24
that we allow this, this is all so
00:15:26
that it is consciously rethought, this is
00:15:29
horror and very hard work,
00:15:33
I agree with you to the actions of those who now do
00:15:36
not realize what is happening and believe the
00:15:39
propaganda and refuse to believe that in
00:15:42
Ukraine the war that Russia started, they
00:15:44
will also go this way consciously, thank
00:15:47
you very much for taking the time to come
00:15:49
on the air with us, a very interesting conversation, we
00:15:52
hope to see you again in our ofir gal
00:15:55
typical archive thank you very much

Description:

«Происходит страшная милитаризация нашей страны. И эта милитаризация, к сожалению, как бы присвоила себе День Победы. И видно, как этот день с каждым годом превращается в бряцание оружием, становится фальшивым, пустым». Историк Тамара Эйдельман о Дне Победы, символе Z и коллективной ответственности. Становитесь нашим спонсором: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCgxTPTFbIbCWfTR9I2-5SeQ/join Поддержите нашу работу через криптокошельки: 🔸BTC: bc1qyxap9djvem9qmzcrfg2t8en0laqd4cxqwkjrkf 🔸ETH: 0x11E01A2CdB361581aF7191427B90BC2ebEe7544F 🔸LTC: ltc1q8es2hgr65sgfle3p5gpmja704kxucwf4gj96sm 🔸DOGE: DGPThdhCShnt61XCaAJYT873vEfCyCsY3C 🔸USDT (TRC20): THAqtvapuuPzZHq3TYWEeTBgmxBUUNsDw7 🔸USDT (ARBITRUM, ERC20, Polygon): 0x11E01A2CdB361581aF7191427B90BC2ebEe7544F 00:00 — Путь из «никогда больше» к «можем повторить» 01:52 — Как власть меняет историческую память 03:53 — С чего началось искажение исторической памяти 05:49 — Кощунство над Георгиевским орденом 08:56 — Символ Z и фашизм 10:46 — Коллективная ответственность 13:49 — Как мы будем восстанавливаться после войны Подписывайтесь на «Навальный LIVE» в соцсетях: Твиттер: https://twitter.com/navalnylive Инстаграм: https://www.facebook.com/unsupportedbrowser Телеграм: https://t.me/navalnylivechannel Фейсбук: https://www.facebook.com/unsupportedbrowser Обходить блокировки соцсетей и СМИ поможет VPN. Вот список сервисов, которым мы доверяем: 🔻NewNodeVPN: https://www.newnode.com/download 🔻Xeovo VPN xeovo.com (промокод zatelekom - 10%): https://xeovo.com/ 🔻Proton VPN: https://protonvpn.com/ 🔻Private Internet Access: https://www.privateinternetaccess.com/ru/ 🔻Express VPN: https://www.expressvpn.com/ 🔻FCK PKN: https://t.me/FCK_RKN_bot

Preparing download options

popular icon
Popular
hd icon
HD video
audio icon
Only sound
total icon
All
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players

Questions about downloading video

mobile menu iconHow can I download "Как нам стирают историческую память" video?mobile menu icon

  • http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.

  • The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.

  • UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.

  • UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.

mobile menu iconWhich format of "Как нам стирают историческую память" video should I choose?mobile menu icon

  • The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.

mobile menu iconWhy does my computer freeze when loading a "Как нам стирают историческую память" video?mobile menu icon

  • The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.

mobile menu iconHow can I download "Как нам стирают историческую память" video to my phone?mobile menu icon

  • You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.

mobile menu iconHow can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Как нам стирают историческую память"?mobile menu icon

  • The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.

mobile menu iconHow can I save a frame from a video "Как нам стирают историческую память"?mobile menu icon

  • This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.

mobile menu iconWhat's the price of all this stuff?mobile menu icon

  • It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.