Download "Самая эффективная диета предков. Станислав Дробышевский // Наука. А поговорить?..."
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FyyVgwHduevQ%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
Please wait. We're preparing links for easy ad-free video watching and downloading.
Table of contents
Similar videos from our catalog
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F0kBIdkDQNz0%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252F5iWxwuBjiFI%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F85hPnNg8iwY%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FBz1u-qDjGAA%252Fsd2.jpg%253Fsqp%253D-oaymwEoCIAFEOAD8quKqQMcGADwAQH4AbYIgAKAD4oCDAgAEAEYZSBQKEYwDw%253D%253D%2526rs%253DAOn4CLAoah0oXZjWQP2-dCl9F0GwpUzrgA&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FFuyKCnUUG8Y%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FJPWuaQXdMbU%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FTImNTVqaY4U%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FTmIYIJuVUoE%252Fsd2.jpg%253Fsqp%253D-oaymwEoCIAFEOAD8quKqQMcGADwAQH4Ab4EgAKACIoCDAgAEAEYZSBSKEswDw%253D%253D%2526rs%253DAOn4CLB0vNohhxZ3mWjd0IuTdLY8yht1Jw&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252Fbo_-0ft9ZOw%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252Fl48ZIkVhwH4%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
Video tags
Subtitles
Russian
00:00:17
[music]00:00:21
Stanislav Drobyshevsky anthropologist00:00:24
Candidate of Biological Sciences00:00:25
popularizer of science associate professor of the department00:00:28
anthropology faculty of biology mg00:00:31
[music]00:00:41
[music]00:00:45
I have a question. We were in00:00:47
Rwanda and paid enough attention00:00:50
poor country If there with Western00:00:52
countries yes Or compare with Russia a00:00:55
people often eat there what they grew00:00:58
ate As they say meat ed00:01:00
everyone chews this sugar cane but everyone00:01:02
teeth as if they were incredible00:01:05
dear dentist That's why it's so when00:01:09
such a poor life but because it's not00:01:12
about poverty Never normal at all00:01:14
condition of teeth Well, in our villages if00:01:17
poor man usually has very bad teeth00:01:19
the quality isn't quite that's not how it works00:01:23
first of all, they always ate like that00:01:25
there is, over time, about consuls Until now00:01:28
porno prino eat so this is the option00:01:32
food to which a person basically00:01:33
adapted it's like eating properly00:01:36
people, look what they eat00:01:38
If you eat about the same00:01:40
it will probably be fine with you too00:01:41
childhood Well, really, you will live then00:01:43
30 years, probably, but it will be teeth00:01:45
good And secondly, if the speech is acceptable00:01:47
about every caries there, he’s a caries00:01:49
mainly not because of nutrition but because of00:01:52
violations of just nutrition as if in00:01:54
non-standard side due to stress00:01:56
eat when I start eating anything00:01:58
and I'm actually kind of stressed00:02:01
and there the pressure drops, that's when it goes bad00:02:03
nay bacteria get a chance there too00:02:05
there the enamel is destroyed. What if I am from childhood00:02:07
I live in this poverty and how is it for me00:02:09
it's normal it's not stress it's basically00:02:11
as if ordinary life Ugandan00:02:22
we are sitting on a chair Yes, there in the room00:02:26
patima, by the way, there is some kind of lantern there00:02:28
shining in the face This is completely wrong00:02:31
this is not how people should live at all00:02:32
once That's why, of course, teeth are falling out00:02:35
Of course, yes, and besides, we’re living again00:02:37
we don't have much, that is, I have up to00:02:39
For 20 years everything was fine with my teeth too00:02:40
more or less Well, there were a couple of careers00:02:42
some holes Oh well, they put MB there A00:02:44
now I don't have half of it anymore Well, I00:02:46
I turned 45 this summer00:02:48
yo Neanderthals three Neanderthals00:02:51
lived to such an age, that is,00:02:53
by Neanderthal standards I'm already there at the soybean00:02:55
in fact, well, as if they didn’t have00:02:58
especially likely to just lose these teeth00:03:01
because they00:03:02
died at the age of 20 I would too00:03:05
If they found a skull there it would be great00:03:07
teeth said about Drobyshevsky how00:03:09
preserved well of course 20 years you00:03:11
you want to say that your food is not00:03:14
It depends, or rather, your dentistry00:03:17
doesn't depend on what you eat. Well00:03:20
it's from a specific diet if it's a diet00:03:23
stable across different generations, as it were, well00:03:25
it’s almost as if it came before us00:03:27
no way Well, the same Eskimos Yes, they are there00:03:29
eat only fat by some laziness00:03:31
and they also have excellent teeth, these ones00:03:33
Ugandan00:03:34
reed and some kind of trouser Yes00:03:37
local there, what are they doing?00:03:39
some people eat bananas, they have everything too00:03:41
great, somewhere in Polynesia they are00:03:43
They only eat fish and everything is fine too00:03:45
there is, in principle, no specific diet00:03:47
It depends almost nothing. But there’s a change00:03:49
diets these are our ancestors Yes here are yours and mine00:03:53
ate grain and some other stuff00:03:56
peas Yes, there are turnips, I don’t know Well, something00:03:58
this is what I wish I had since childhood00:04:00
ate turnips, peas and bread and there00:04:03
I washed it down with pure spring water.00:04:05
maybe they had normal teeth too00:04:07
But that would be a little boring. Here we are00:04:10
We consume a lot of sugar, which00:04:12
ancestors almost never ate at all00:04:14
uh, there’s something else there Yes, there’s a lot of meat00:04:16
By the way, well, the ancestors are not so much either00:04:18
they ate there once a month maybe it was there00:04:21
we saw it and it was good, well, there it is00:04:22
some kind of milk, eggs still there00:04:24
was going somewhere Yes, that’s how it was00:04:27
the diet was very monotonous00:04:28
throughout life00:04:30
Well, here you have a choice of either eating00:04:32
how did ancestors have normal teeth but how00:04:36
it would be boring to eat like this00:04:38
it would be fun, but my teeth are falling out, so what?00:04:41
more generally not in principle not even from00:04:42
consistency of food it depends but just me00:04:45
I’m talking from stress. Well, for example, for me00:04:47
the teeth began to decay and there everyone00:04:49
karis arises when I'm from Chita00:04:51
my dear one went to Moscow, so even though I00:04:54
as if by origin such00:04:56
Central Russian, as it were, a character, but that’s all00:04:58
I lived the same childhood as I did00:05:00
air conditioning already then tamas And here00:05:03
sort of in the middle zone, but I don’t have it00:05:05
local, as it were, and my whole body00:05:07
trying to adapt to this strength00:05:08
they go away But they don’t go away on the teeth anymore Well, sort of00:05:11
the amount of strength in the body is quite00:05:13
limited especially since I arrived00:05:15
live in dorms where the chaos is endless00:05:16
Moreover, these were the nineties, well00:05:18
you can guess it was a mess there00:05:20
We also started cooking for ourselves00:05:23
It’s natural to cook for yourself too00:05:24
study continuously That is, I came00:05:26
as if I entered Moscow State University and all the time00:05:29
there's some tension, stress there, exams00:05:31
five past ten, that is, I’m at home00:05:33
I didn’t even try that hard at all00:05:35
and there’s some kind of running around, everything’s somehow not00:05:37
so everything is wrong and of course the teeth are there00:05:40
fell as if one with the other Well,00:05:42
I wish I lived in some village there00:05:43
this middle lane in the same place with00:05:45
birth to death maybe I still have00:05:47
I had normal teeth for a while00:05:52
[music]00:05:58
were00:06:04
[music]00:06:09
I wanted to ask you about the paleo diet00:06:12
Have you ever heard of such a fashionable thing?00:06:14
Well, where would I go?00:06:16
since in the twelfth year it means she was00:06:19
described as one of the main trends in00:06:22
diets are based on this00:06:25
popularity used to be this00:06:28
People have been suffering from delusions for years now00:06:30
100 but in the thirteenth year the diet began00:06:33
most popular weight loss method00:06:36
according to Google statistics Well okay Well this00:06:39
because Google appeared tritely before00:06:41
no one read the gu statistics00:06:43
because there was no Google So it's not00:06:46
about why she appeared00:06:48
in your opinion because this is commerce00:06:50
because someone made money from it00:06:52
money is still typical00:06:53
earns Let me read you a cheat00:06:56
went on a diet and tell me how much00:06:58
in general, people could eat in00:07:01
paleolithic means in the paleolithic era people00:07:03
engaged in gathering and hunting and00:07:05
Accordingly, there was a lot of meat in the diet00:07:07
fish nuts eggs raw seeds00:07:10
slightly less mushrooms, berries, fruits, vegetables and00:07:12
greens are not allowed, grains including bread00:07:16
pasta wheat half horn barley and others00:07:19
no legumes beans peas milk A00:07:23
some vegetable oils are nonsense00:07:27
doggy Well, the first part, what's in the water, what00:07:30
didn't eat here is the first part00:07:32
I subscribe directly and ate everything00:07:34
that's what is listed and the second is all nonsense00:07:37
because they didn’t eat cereals there00:07:39
Australopithecus ate cereals and in vain00:07:42
they basically ate this and00:07:44
nuts nuts there in the first part after all00:07:46
yes, well, there were vegetable oils and they ate00:07:48
they are vegetable oils, as it were, very much so00:07:50
they liked it Well, where would they be more00:07:51
quantity taken Of course, but they ate00:07:54
man from this sit elefan it00:07:58
almost almost it's not almost it's 1,300,000 years00:08:01
back in Spain in this spanking here and there00:08:05
traces of starch from this grain on00:08:07
teeth that is 1min 30000 - This is the most00:08:09
the ancient changes Europe in general in principle00:08:11
there is no ancient one And now it has starch00:08:14
grain Here and then what else is there00:08:17
legumes were listed there Yes in the same00:08:19
shanidar itself and to the kebar somewhere else00:08:22
there are legumes on the teeth, they ate peas00:08:25
Well, there’s a question: What specific one, as it were, But00:08:26
exactly what legumes ate that's normal00:08:30
in one of the caves, therefore, in the village00:08:34
Africa has a weapon where00:08:39
strengthened with casein That is, it is with milk00:08:42
Well, that is, this is for of course00:08:44
gluing as if They used Yes00:08:45
but that means they had milk00:08:48
and somehow they I don’t know him for some reason00:08:50
antelopes were planted and there was a dating there00:08:51
40,000 years if anything else00:08:54
somewhere there from to years and older We have00:08:56
most people lose the ability00:08:58
ut young adult form but in the Neolithic in00:09:02
several populations in at least00:09:03
Northern Europe, East Africa and00:09:05
India has developed a resistance to this matter00:09:08
and Well, I don’t know about you, but here I am00:09:10
I have stability, I’m from that Lucky one00:09:12
part that can drink milk00:09:15
we are already at least 7,000 years old but 7,00000:09:17
years is more than a long time actually00:09:19
during this time it’s possible to be normal00:09:21
eat milk that's why it's happening again00:09:23
this is nonsense, if there is an enzyme00:09:26
decomposing then it’s normal as if it’s possible00:09:28
drink Why not, because ancestors Yes00:09:31
some in some situations there00:09:32
ate some extreme food00:09:34
really only there mostly00:09:35
fat and there I just don’t know turnips00:09:36
some but that's because From00:09:38
hopelessness as soon as normal00:09:40
you give a person something normal, well if00:09:42
he is a normal person, he eats everything00:09:44
so the paleo diet is just la-la00:09:46
it’s not about anything at all, that’s why it’s scientific when00:09:49
tried to check it every time there00:09:51
it turns out so-so It’s like the only thing00:09:53
when it really works for00:09:55
weight loss if you take it when you are tough00:09:57
restrictions drive But in principle this is not00:09:59
Be sure to go on a diet, it’s possible00:10:01
I just eat less normal food. That’s it00:10:03
there will be the same effect, here I am on myself00:10:05
It’s not like I’m on a diet, yes00:10:07
I just checked at some point, well00:10:09
when there after the juice is already there with me00:10:11
age has noticed that I'm starting right00:10:13
getting fat Well, for me it looks like this Maybe it’s00:10:16
you can't tell, but I feel like00:10:18
it's like there's a fatty streak in me00:10:19
appears Well, I don’t know any there00:10:21
I bend down to tie my shoelaces, now00:10:24
I don’t have any laces and it’s just more difficult for me00:10:27
because the folds are collected and00:10:29
never happened before Well, this is unusual for me00:10:31
So I decided, well, let’s say00:10:34
staircase I used to run there Instantly00:10:36
and now I feel that I’m somehow not00:10:38
I'm running so briskly, well, this is for me00:10:40
tangible, at least for myself00:10:42
decided in my head I'm going to the dining room00:10:44
I come to the biofaker and this is what I want00:10:47
I took it all and now I want it00:10:49
this is this this is this and I only take00:10:51
so I started eating about twice as much00:10:53
less just deliberately and00:10:56
It really works a little bit00:10:58
like that, I recovered as if in00:11:00
reverse side So this is not na people00:11:02
that's why I'm still just a mess00:11:04
What can you say about the raw food diet?00:11:07
practice shows there have been studies00:11:09
special raw foodists that they have00:11:11
low body weight they are bony here00:11:13
to be honest some are on the verge00:11:15
their dystrophy is much worse. It’s all about00:11:18
reproduction is worth it for women here00:11:21
these evolutionary cycles are sometimes disrupted00:11:23
In general, it’s as if ovulation does not occur in00:11:25
men also produce sperm00:11:27
sharply reduced00:11:29
intellectual abilities sag00:11:30
Because if They eat raw meat00:11:33
they spend a lot of energy on00:11:35
digestion of food Well, not meat there00:11:36
no matter what, it doesn't matter what the plants are00:11:39
they put a lot of energy into00:11:41
digestion that is, of course they are there00:11:42
they get some kind of benefit from this in the end00:11:44
But if you spent something, it means it’s not00:11:47
spend money somewhere else00:11:49
amount of energy expended in00:11:51
in the body it’s not that limited, yes00:11:53
but there are quite definite frameworks and00:11:55
like you are nothing else then if you00:11:57
how much did you receive and spent? If you00:12:00
spent a lot on digestion So you00:12:02
don’t waste your thinking and00:12:04
there's something else there and we're wasting our brains00:12:06
if that 20% of the energy in the body if you00:12:09
there you spent 10% extra on00:12:11
digestion but brains will spend not 20 but 1000:12:13
and they will work half as much00:12:16
so you can be a raw foodist but with00:12:17
you saw the corresponding results00:12:19
these are the great achievements of raw foodists00:12:22
By the way, they will even tell you what they00:12:24
well that's the same for vegetarians00:12:25
they will tell you that there is such lightness in the body00:12:27
formed It's clear that it formed00:12:29
eat a person 10 masses after00:12:32
if he eats poorly he will have ease00:12:35
Yes, he’s giving you matanza right away00:12:39
Of course, they won’t remember Einstein00:12:42
they’ll remember, but honestly there’s still grief00:12:44
The question is, who would study it scientifically?00:12:48
and we just have examples00:12:50
any vegetarian communities00:12:52
I don’t know, recent Koreans Yes, Chinese00:12:54
recent Japanese recent Here they are00:12:56
The same Vietnamese ate only rice there00:12:57
there are the Indians there, but they were tall00:13:00
meter 50 And as soon as the meat is in00:13:02
XX century so they are now an average meter 6500:13:05
the size for the world is something like that00:13:07
Chinese basketball team Tam00:13:09
I'm scared to look at them like this00:13:10
look here and when the Japanese will be allowed in00:13:13
At the beginning of the 20th century, the Chinese meter 5000:13:16
the Japanese were called dwarfs with height00:13:18
islands that is when you are a person00:13:21
a one and a half meter dwarf is an occasion00:13:23
think about it, there might be something wrong00:13:24
so that's all right now, [ __ ] off and00:13:28
the average height of the Japanese Met 65 is00:13:30
world average00:13:32
value Well in Europe it is on average00:13:34
much higher actually now in00:13:36
Europe there Met 78 Well this is my height here I am00:13:38
seis is of average height absolutely But this00:13:40
Europeans are huge, it’s like it’s not the world00:13:42
small Here come the Japanese. By the way, very00:13:46
illustrative comparison of Northern Southern00:13:48
Korea because from some point00:13:50
The North began to live poorer after all.00:13:52
and their height difference is 16 cm, that’s generally00:13:56
like a lot How much in reality00:13:57
this is the difference X if we take it in the 19th century00:14:00
Europeans and Pygmies Well, at the same time00:14:03
it is clear that North South Koreans are00:14:04
the same people, genetics, they have everything00:14:06
strictly the same, it’s there, well, they’re all Kims00:14:08
completely, but 16 cm is only00:14:12
food these eat more meat00:14:14
everyone eats less meat, so there will be northern ones00:14:16
Koreans are better. They eat meat. Well, who would give it to them?00:14:18
as if yes Well, that’s when they’ll give it too00:14:21
will grow up quite easily00:14:24
evolutionarily, who wins?00:14:26
herbivore or meat eater actually00:14:28
some of the others depend on the others00:14:31
because mis food eat herbivores well00:14:34
this is a classic of the genre, there are producers00:14:37
- these are actually plants00:14:38
consumers of the first order are those00:14:40
that eat Plants and consumers00:14:42
second order who eat those who00:14:43
they eat plants and there are also consumers00:14:46
second order well third fourth00:14:48
fifth theoretically that is00:14:49
some kind of flea that bites00:14:51
wolf there is some kind of parasite00:14:53
the flea has here, and in the end there are decomposers00:14:56
who put it all back to00:14:57
carbon hydrogen oxygen of course and00:15:00
Everything returns to normal, but00:15:01
no one canceled the cycle Well, it’s impossible00:15:04
say that there are more meat eaters there00:15:06
There are fewer military men or there are just even number of them00:15:08
equally well, there is such a thing, there is a pyramid00:15:11
classical Well, the rule of ten is so00:15:13
called that is, on every next00:15:15
level of energy and substance consumption00:15:17
the amount decreases by about 10 times00:15:19
that is, roughly speaking, 10 tons of grass00:15:22
there will be a ton of cows per ton of cows there will be00:15:25
100 kg Wolves from 100 kg Wolves we will remove 1000:15:28
kg of fleas Well, 10 kg of fleas will grow00:15:33
a kilogram of mushrooms and these mushrooms themselves00:15:35
all this will be returned back to the soil and again00:15:37
there will miraculously be 10 tons of grass00:15:40
I see, that means, well, it works out00:15:44
herbivores Most of all so Why in00:15:48
human evolution after all00:15:50
herbivores did not win Well, how are we?00:15:54
omnivores What makes us so wonderful is that we00:15:57
Absolutely omnivores, we eat everything we give00:15:59
and as a rule we don’t complain too much. Well, if00:16:01
an adequate person at least And this00:16:03
winning strategy it started with us00:16:05
at least as early as the end of the Cretaceous period00:16:07
when we were size and shape00:16:09
the shrew was running around there00:16:11
branches and we were the most omnivorous of00:16:13
mammals of that time and everything00:16:15
subsequent times we have this00:16:21
nutritional00:16:26
since in principle it’s all the same00:16:28
balance around some abstract00:16:30
middle and always We ate everything Well00:16:32
when we became just people people uh00:16:35
our diet depended rather on what00:16:37
there is not what we want, but what do we like00:16:40
they give, that is, when they lived in the Arctic they didn’t eat00:16:42
I know there were reindeer somewhere00:16:44
they ate fish on the islands in Indonesia00:16:47
We lived in Africa and ate some roots there00:16:49
or there are [ __ ] nuts [ __ ] uh Well there you go00:16:52
what we eat, what we eat, this is a universal Neisha00:16:55
strategy Why we can live throughout00:16:57
planet that is, that is, if we00:16:59
arose I don't know from any there00:17:00
aardvark and would eat only ants00:17:03
Well, not far from everywhere we could be00:17:05
on the islands they couldn't there no00:17:06
ants Well, at least some00:17:09
Well, in large quantities, that's just00:17:11
somewhere in the shroud where the termites are ants00:17:12
in large quantities, well, I don’t know00:17:15
Kamchatka also has plenty of ants, and in some places00:17:17
there are few of them, but now we can, but00:17:20
It’s always worth remembering that we have00:17:22
There are actually limitations too00:17:24
for a long time we still didn't eat00:17:26
absolutely everything in a row, for example, we are very00:17:29
for a long time they almost ignored the fish, well00:17:33
ancient diet of fish, it is by the way in00:17:35
Israel discovers there is such00:17:36
Gesher Bino Yakov site there 780,000 years00:17:39
back and there they are, some locals there00:17:41
these perches were caught there by Karpov and then00:17:45
for a long long time too No one in particular there00:17:47
didn't worry about it because well, if you00:17:49
you live in the savannah and people walk past you00:17:51
herds of ungulates and a bunch of plants of all kinds00:17:53
why fish but it would be a hassle yes00:17:56
the scales there again, the bones are sharp Well, no00:17:58
I really need it, right there in this geshe00:18:00
fish Jacob they are the only Why00:18:01
caught that this was not the shore of the lake Well, in00:18:04
principle, this fish apparently splashed there00:18:06
it was just easy to get it underfoot00:18:08
near the shore, yes And most even when they00:18:10
they were sitting on the shore of something00:18:13
ignored yes since recent times there00:18:14
among Neanderthals, for example, sites where00:18:17
there are remains of fish, well, I don’t know on one00:18:19
I can literally count three pieces in my hand00:18:21
Well, there are four, maybe five there, very well00:18:23
Well, there's a little bit more in your pockets00:18:25
dreher montz00:18:28
those who have already sailed somewhere out there00:18:29
Oceania to some Timor or Buku00:18:32
there is something like that there they are already00:18:34
began to eat fish in full and00:18:35
even exclusively fish, although the ancestors00:18:38
in the trees Clearly she was never caught00:18:39
but we are so universal that we can00:18:41
so even octopuses there are anything but00:18:44
this is already in the later stages, there are types00:18:47
food we didn't eat00:18:48
almost never, well, something like that00:18:50
wood for example, well, basically00:18:52
the wood is edible, there are creatures that00:18:54
Are there some hares eating bark or there?00:18:56
there are deer feeding there, some kind of wasps there00:18:59
they eat some tree buds there00:19:01
We always ate the leaves, but the buds, well00:19:03
they're sticky, we didn't eat them, well practically00:19:05
never Well, everything else was enough00:19:08
Well, I think in some time of famine00:19:11
no Well, it’s clear that if everything is straight00:19:13
it’s bad to eat bark and kidneys if you’re hungry00:19:15
of course with the Hedgehog it's just anything but eat it00:19:19
you can’t Well, on an ongoing basis and so00:19:22
I don’t know some punishments there00:19:24
the bottom of primates was never by the way tra00:19:28
primates are quite hydrated Well, not so00:19:30
which is contraindicated but very exotic00:19:32
for primates, that is, herbivores00:19:34
occurred several times there are such00:19:36
bamboo lemurs in Madagascar here they are00:19:38
literally eat bamboo00:19:40
they slurp it so deliciously, we were there00:19:43
all sorts of fossils, several versions there00:19:45
any kind of hunger, including00:19:47
gigantic Well, modern gladness in00:19:49
Ethiopia So they eat grass and00:19:50
human beings are exceptions in this sense. We too00:19:52
pretty much herbivores well00:19:54
a grain of bread, yes, it's grass, but we00:19:57
ate in general Well, at least since the time00:19:59
Australopithecus when they came to the savannah00:20:01
there like 4 million years ago and they began there00:20:03
more or less how to eat this but on00:20:06
the first place came out only already in00:20:08
Neolithic when there was a producing economy00:20:10
Well, maybe a little earlier there kaya00:20:12
Tufi Xia culture is Middle Eastern00:20:14
when did they start collecting grains? Well, when00:20:16
everything else was eaten again as if from00:20:18
hopelessness because it's over00:20:20
normal there Gazelle tours doe Well00:20:22
let's do the grain to collect it00:20:24
it’s like in bulk and there’s desert all around00:20:26
In general, it’s as if there was a little special selection, but00:20:28
began to eat it uh Well, now we have bread00:20:30
everything comes to a head in an unexpected way, that is00:20:32
it's like a pretty exotic version00:20:34
and to put it mildly, not the most standard00:20:36
We also don’t have much roots either00:20:38
are meant to eat because well00:20:40
Primates are arboreal, like roots in00:20:42
on the ground right here it's the other way around but00:20:44
when we went out into the savannah they started saying something00:20:46
digging there and digging sticks all the work00:20:47
there are the same baboons or something there00:20:50
Even chimpanzees dig regularly00:20:51
who live in the forest and are roots00:20:53
they dig it up and now we have it there00:20:55
any potatoes at all00:20:56
By the way, it’s poisonous, if anything from there00:20:58
South America Yes, but nevertheless almost00:21:00
That's not the main food there in many places00:21:01
countries, well, there’s some kind of turnip00:21:03
rutabaga carrots what else is there?00:21:06
everything is also like roots. Well, there are roots00:21:08
root vegetables there it doesn’t matter tubers one way or another00:21:11
otherwise something underground00:21:13
and this is kind of non-standard for primates00:21:15
food but like starch it is starch00:21:17
So yes we can use it Well00:21:19
I actually ate something there before00:21:21
fruits are also starchy there00:21:23
basically So it’s also possible what you said00:21:26
about what they found in the parking lot there00:21:29
some fish bones but just too00:21:32
purely technical point How do I00:21:34
I understand that these are layers of soil and there you are00:21:37
find it, but it seems to me that the bones are fish00:21:39
so tender that they are well worth millions00:21:41
It's been years since it's already decomposed00:21:43
some kind of biological processing00:21:46
no no well, as we know fish bones00:21:50
from the end of the Cambrian period if anything00:21:53
Well, which is, to put it mildly, strong00:21:55
it was ancient and there are fish there in the Mesozoic00:21:57
Whenever00:21:58
Well, here 780,000 years is not even00:22:00
million That is, in principle, well, this is the bottom00:22:03
lakes and there is a shore of the lake so well there00:22:06
there aren't many of these bones, but they exist00:22:08
By the way, what’s cool about this is00:22:10
Geshe Yakov there are several plots there00:22:12
excavation there is a bottom that is just a bottom00:22:14
Wild things that are not related to humans and00:22:16
the bones are just intact there00:22:18
skeletons But exactly in that area00:22:20
which parking lot where the tools00:22:22
there are all sorts of things lying around there, those are the gills00:22:24
and heads That is, this is cutting fish00:22:27
Why do we know what they actually ate?00:22:28
so it’s clear that there’s fish in the lake00:22:30
it was found there and is found there now, but they00:22:32
they just cut up everything else somewhere00:22:34
They also ate there and apparently there are tails somewhere00:22:36
there is, but they didn’t find it. But here are the heads from00:22:38
gills Here they lie That's it00:22:40
so we know what it is00:22:41
active fishing Well, that is, for00:22:43
this does not require any special00:22:45
conditions so that here is a fish skeleton like this00:22:47
preserved No of course it is necessary therefore00:22:50
We actually have such finds00:22:51
count with your finger That is, we don’t have00:22:54
We only have fish bones, whatever00:22:56
Mega rare in fact is preserved00:22:57
in fact00:22:58
that is, well, if it weren’t so we00:23:00
just walked on the bones Well, here we are00:23:02
made from living organisms of the past Well00:23:05
here is our body Yes, these are the former00:23:08
are there any dinosaur trees? I don't00:23:10
I know there are people there, anyone, there are mushrooms, uh00:23:13
algae, that is, well, that’s all decomposers00:23:15
we decompose it there through three orders of magnitude00:23:17
that's all Let's pass on Yes And now we'll make ourselves00:23:19
Of these, 99.9 are there in the period about00:23:22
crumbles into dust and becomes00:23:24
something new that's why when we00:23:26
we find some fragments there00:23:29
it's like one in a billion maybe00:23:30
of what happened It’s clear and now00:23:32
specifically here Yes, they were cool00:23:34
the conditions are so wonderful00:23:36
Well, the place still needs to be found actually00:23:38
It’s actually okay to dig up, which is also helpful00:23:40
not a guarantee, but there are such things00:23:42
There aren't many places at all. Let's face it00:23:44
such sites with such antiquity, well there00:23:47
some dozens, let's say? So what?00:23:49
found such interesting food00:23:52
besides there is a bone of fish, what a god00:23:55
it hasn't even survived at all00:23:58
be sure to find the food itself, but you can00:24:00
find the person who ate this food Well00:24:02
here is my favorite example, woman MR 180800:24:06
from ko bifo This is in Kenya n 800 no less00:24:10
there one and a half million years ago00:24:12
This is the level of Tam Homa gaster man00:24:14
working Well, that is, he seems to already00:24:16
the man is so scary, these are still ancestors00:24:17
Pithecanthropus, in human terms00:24:19
talk and her whole skeleton is amazed00:24:22
perim And what is periostitis?00:24:24
overgrowth of the periosteum and all bones as00:24:26
such00:24:28
covered with a crust, well, like a candle when00:24:30
such [ __ ] is melting, that's all it is00:24:32
this is most likely from00:24:34
hypervitaminosis aa hypervitaminosis A00:24:37
you can get it either by eating again00:24:39
fish but in Kenya there in the middle of the savannah there00:24:41
where can I get it? Of course you can there00:24:43
there are walruses and polar bears, but also in00:24:45
Kenya is tense with this, you can00:24:47
theoretically the liver of a leopard, but there00:24:49
no one knows who will eat this liver00:24:51
and here is the most adequate option which00:24:53
there looms this honey with larvae00:24:56
because in bees it is the larvae00:24:58
contains some kind of transcendental00:24:59
amount of vitamin A And who eats honey00:25:02
with larvae there is a risk of developing00:25:03
periostitis is this hypert for and00:25:06
Apparently this woman leans on honey between00:25:09
among other things, modern African inhabitants in00:25:10
many areas and in South Africa00:25:12
Central and Eastern countries consume it00:25:15
honey in crazy quantities Well00:25:17
here are the pygmies in some seasons up to 80%00:25:20
calories come from honey and are generally weak00:25:22
I understand how you can eat 80% honey00:25:24
But they manage to do it by the way00:25:25
they complain that their bones hurt, well00:25:27
no one looked at their bones because they00:25:29
pygmies in Africa, as it were, who would go there00:25:30
got it from the doctors Well, the pygmies are still alive00:25:33
as if we don’t know what’s wrong with their bones00:25:35
Well, no one put them in the tomograph, but00:25:37
when they are already dying, as if again00:25:39
no one saw the skeletons, but for all00:25:42
signs this is it and this is still there00:25:44
one and a half Milne years ago there Milne 400 What00:25:47
something like this, there are others there00:25:50
another skull Well, almost the same00:25:52
the time there is a little older on the bottom00:25:55
jaws have a hole so wonderful00:25:58
which was initially mistaken for caries A00:25:59
then when we investigated I discovered that00:26:01
no, it’s not caries, it’s a consequence00:26:03
exposure to acidic unripe fruits there00:26:06
also most likely she loved a woman00:26:07
Fruits with sourness are like this00:26:10
unripe ones are still yellow00:26:11
even green ones with a side and here00:26:13
when you're so sour00:26:14
cool like uh Eco Gourmand Here she is00:26:17
I drilled a hole in myself with these acids00:26:19
it made her jaw hurt from00:26:22
she chewed this on the other side00:26:23
there are more jaws because it hurts00:26:25
if only this one would have caused her to get all twisted00:26:27
head and brains including distorted and00:26:29
She's such a good asymmetrical head00:26:31
Well, outwardly it was most likely not at all00:26:32
it wasn’t particularly visible, but it looked like skulls00:26:35
straight up It's great to see So that's it00:26:37
happens too00:26:38
[music]00:26:41
Yeah, who do paleontologists call the most00:26:45
Man's first ancestor and this is what he ate00:26:48
No, I don’t know, 65 million years ago or00:26:50
the very first ancestor is the first cell00:26:52
which appeared 4.5 billion years ago00:26:55
what I ate it was a long time ago Well00:26:58
no one knows, by the way there are two00:27:00
versions it was autotrophic or00:27:02
heterotrophic autotrophs are those that00:27:04
they can take non-organic matter and crypt from it00:27:07
organic matter And heterotrophic when we take00:27:09
ready-made organic matter and lay it out00:27:11
to other organics and accordingly How00:27:13
we consume there, oh well, that’s what it was like00:27:16
first We honestly don't know because00:27:19
autotrophically it is more complex, as if chemically00:27:22
but it’s kind of more profitable in principle, because00:27:24
what can you actually take from nothing?00:27:26
energy and heterotrophically it is simpler but for00:27:29
this must be some kind of organic matter00:27:31
and where would it come from if no one has it?00:27:33
synthesizes but in principle it can00:27:34
self-propelled without living organisms simply00:27:37
here in a natural way. And if you like00:27:40
suggest there 60 There 566 million years ago00:27:43
This is the beginning of the Cenozoic, this is purgatorius00:27:46
such an animal weighing 90 g maximum with00:27:48
brains less than 1 gma some little rat00:27:51
that this is not a baby rat, a rat is much more00:27:53
advanced here purgatorius strongly00:27:55
primitive, that is, outwardly it looks like00:27:57
Strictly speaking, a shrew is well sized00:28:00
Sonya somewhere. Yes, there are more mice there00:28:02
smaller than a rat but so spicy00:28:04
muzzle, well, there are jaws in principle00:28:06
and at the same time woody and at the same time the most00:28:09
the main thing is that he is an omnivore00:28:11
sharp lump for insects00:28:13
pierce By the way, we still have00:28:15
the digestive system contains enzymes00:28:17
for the digestion of chitin, that is, we are up to00:28:19
we can still eat less insects than00:28:21
some lemurs there have more00:28:22
copies of the Gene and we have fewer but there are00:28:25
By the way, also to the question of what this is in principle00:28:27
good food and now it's kind of like00:28:29
already and somehow it seems and not really Yes, but here I am00:28:31
and wanted to ask you why do you00:28:33
it seems that we have evolutionary now00:28:35
even disgust, well, disgust is00:28:37
purely culturally in Thailand they sell these00:28:39
some scorpions but this is entertainment00:28:42
This is entertainment for you and for the locals00:28:44
residents are often just eating food Well00:28:47
that's often the main thing there, well, scorpios00:28:49
Maybe they are there, but really not much00:28:50
massive and some kind of crickets or00:28:52
Locust when the Locust arrives00:28:55
it's not really a disaster because00:28:56
she will eat the harvest, it's a holiday on the contrary00:28:58
a lot of meat has arrived. It's great00:29:00
collect it in bags and eat it later00:29:02
joyfully here on the island lake I mean00:29:05
Tanganika in Tanzania uh there are uh tribes00:29:09
who make bread from Well, or I don't know00:29:11
sausages flatbreads what's there cutlets what's there00:29:14
can’t be called from midges, that is, there are such00:29:16
these little midges are flying over the lake Well00:29:19
they fly just like this in the fog00:29:21
thick and locals make mesh00:29:23
the hair is so thin and so thin00:29:26
the fliers seem to be waving in the air00:29:28
they just collect heaps of these same00:29:30
mosquitoes and bake cakes from them. So00:29:33
by the way, someone recently told me00:29:35
oh wonderful story, well, I wasn’t there00:29:37
I didn't eat this in this lake Well, by the way, I00:29:39
I tried it, it’s cool, but I’m not there00:29:41
got there but recently someone00:29:42
told how there was someone there00:29:45
Geological expedition or something00:29:48
that's the one who told me00:29:50
the girl she caught for fun00:29:52
mosquitoes because there were them there too Well00:29:54
somewhere we have a bunch of them in some tundra00:29:56
and made cutlets out of them, fried them and when00:30:00
they came from work, the hard worker, she told them00:30:03
I treated them there and happily devoured them00:30:04
they said it’s great, it’s absolutely delicious where00:30:07
you actually took this there in the middle00:30:09
that's nothing Yes, but she's there at the beginning00:30:11
their00:30:15
additional so far Here But it is so00:30:20
it is possible and in principle we are capable of it00:30:22
digest but returning to purgatorius00:30:23
he has a flat tooth on the back side00:30:26
Pover for crushing some already00:30:29
fruits from all the then mammals00:30:31
they were the most omnivorous, that is, at the same time00:30:33
there were times when there were much more insectivores00:30:35
much more herbivorous But these00:30:37
ate everything in a row and that’s actually still the case00:30:39
since we have here Well, basically here00:30:42
then there was a little more00:30:43
insectivorous for a while afterwards00:30:45
Fruit poison Nastya Well, here it is back and forth00:30:47
hesitated but from the very beginning we already00:30:49
were omnivores. How can you handle them?00:30:52
to the skeleton You are reading this, that he is here00:30:54
meat ate grass here and here fruits00:30:56
him Loki's teeth Well, there are a lot of ways to00:30:59
in fact the first way is Form00:31:02
the teeth and jaws themselves in insectivores00:31:05
they usually have an elongated muzzle Well00:31:07
because the jaw is tweezers to00:31:09
catch insects and there in front there are such00:31:11
elongated teeth will be sharp tufts00:31:13
quite sharp and on the molars molars00:31:15
sharp tubercles too, well for piercing00:31:17
chitin This is just external00:31:19
morphology is just with the eye You can already see00:31:22
as if you can’t even make a mistake there in general00:31:23
the next level especially means00:31:25
look at micro-damage to the enamel00:31:27
because depending on who is what00:31:29
She eats the enamel on her teeth in different ways00:31:31
wears out in different ways gets damaged Well00:31:34
insects have chitin sculpting00:31:36
such pimples Well, if there is a microscope00:31:37
look And generally quite tough on00:31:39
in fact it turns out like this00:31:41
characteristic grooves on the enamel of teeth Well00:31:43
especially since the teeth are really tiny00:31:44
Well, there's this little animal, she's all here00:31:46
like this and if these are any plants00:31:48
there are also some furrows there00:31:50
seeds for example yes but they are different uh different00:31:53
depth Well, because it’s like00:31:54
plant parts are not like hithi00:31:57
obviously if it's some kind of resin00:31:59
there won't be any boros at all00:32:01
of course it’s practically liquid Yes00:32:03
there's something else about the leaves and00:32:05
with such wear and tear it is possible00:32:07
do isotope analysis, that is, in00:32:09
depending on what we eat in00:32:11
different isotopes accumulate in the body00:32:13
By the way, different microelements and00:32:16
surprise this ratio it's millions00:32:18
it can be stored for years, that is, you can do it this way00:32:20
see what they ate do00:32:21
foot analysis This is a lot for some already00:32:23
made a variety of animals Well, usually00:32:26
let's say we have ungulates. Well, we're talking about them00:32:28
we guess well enough Yes00:32:29
something there or they are ungulates00:32:31
we have a predator, well, one hundred percent00:32:33
Predator we do isotope analyzes for them00:32:35
see what's going on there and then do it there00:32:37
some ancient person or00:32:39
there this purgatorius doesn’t matter00:32:40
look where it is on the graph00:32:42
distributed here, well, usually it’s somewhere in00:32:44
in the middle which is characteristically distributed00:32:46
Here’s how it’s possible. Yes, there’s more00:32:49
options for tartar Well, this is00:32:52
true for such ancients as Purgatorius00:32:54
doesn’t work, or rather no one has done it00:32:56
you can eat too, no one did it, but for00:32:58
modern ones are more or less there00:32:59
Neanderthals humans already have tartar00:33:02
Firstly, all sorts of things accumulate in it00:33:04
particles of what we ate just under00:33:06
You can look at the phytolith with a microscope00:33:09
Here are microparticles of plants Well, petrified00:33:11
cells actually Yes, or not even00:33:14
they were petrified from the very beginning there00:33:15
mineral as if there are elements e or00:33:18
some hairs, pieces of feathers00:33:21
mushroom spores there, smoke from the fire there00:33:25
only were not actually found in these00:33:26
teeth there is such a list there for two00:33:29
Neanderthals eat scales from a moth's wing00:33:31
for example, they wanted some kind of butterfly00:33:34
there are also such jokes and00:33:37
quite so technologically00:33:38
the advanced version is the same00:33:40
analyze tartar for DNA Well00:33:43
this is true only in later times00:33:45
it's working It's already there, it's late00:33:46
Neanderthal Sans Well because DNA is a deadline00:33:49
has little shelf life but is possible00:33:51
see what they ate there00:33:53
specifically animals here or there friend00:33:55
friend as an option here and there too but00:33:57
a lot of interesting things, by the way00:33:59
it’s always indicative of what’s in these00:34:01
there is something in the teeth and something that isn’t there sometimes happens00:34:03
so the absence of something is much greater00:34:05
actually more interesting like this00:34:07
Neanderthals from Els Drona who have00:34:09
Well, they are Neanderthals by definition00:34:12
you're supposed to eat some kind of meat, but they have00:34:14
in the teeth Well, specifically these ones didn’t have00:34:16
DNA of no ungulates at all in00:34:19
principle of mammals That is there00:34:21
that there wasn't something there00:34:22
poplar wood or willow wood or something00:34:24
there is some kind of controversy there again00:34:26
there are mushrooms and fly agaric by the way00:34:28
but this didn’t happen. Here they are, by the way, bark00:34:32
they were just chewing something, apparently from00:34:33
hunger As an option because00:34:35
Apparently they were starving, so they didn’t have00:34:37
as if in nutrition Some amount00:34:38
time for meat and apparently quite a lot00:34:41
for a long time in tartar not even00:34:42
Well, in the end it was discovered00:34:45
It was natural that they themselves were eaten00:34:47
because the neighbors apparently had exactly00:34:49
same problems Well, we're not neighbors00:34:51
they found it dumped somewhere00:34:53
they still died, but they ate these and went into a hole there00:34:56
left00:34:57
So we talked about the period there00:35:00
omnivorousness and00:35:02
insect when was it specifically00:35:06
herbivorous period what are the ancestors00:35:08
person exclusively here Well me00:35:10
it seems this is the simplest thing you live00:35:12
so if you don’t do anything in the shroud00:35:14
you don't have to run after any buffalo00:35:16
you pick a leaf and you give it to me Well, that’s it00:35:18
it was very close to the bison, that is, from00:35:21
insectivorous specific plant poison00:35:23
switched somewhere between 45 and 4 ml years ago00:35:27
when we started getting bigger00:35:30
Well, when the animal is big and weighs there00:35:32
more than half a kilogram at least for her00:35:34
it's hard to be an insectivore because well00:35:36
where would he get so many insects? Well00:35:37
there are sometimes all sorts of anteaters and00:35:39
so on, yes, but primacy in the trees there00:35:40
they can't catch so many insects and so00:35:43
they're tough there Why you want It's obvious that00:35:45
they become herbivores and so00:35:48
there, well, from 40 million LT per piece, as it were00:35:50
and further somewhere up to about 2 C5 million00:35:54
years ago That is, this is a huge period00:35:55
time from there 40 to 2 and a half00:35:58
when they ate Read only Plants, well00:36:02
in different types of fruits, mostly ours00:36:04
at least the ancestors there are Primates00:36:05
there are different ones, but our ancestors here are the fruits00:36:07
Well, listen to the leaves in some form But00:36:09
they didn't start eating meat00:36:11
Ice Age early It's somehow00:36:14
due to the fact that a weapon appeared there00:36:18
than to kill or butcher or even earlier00:36:22
well, the ice age is just that00:36:23
understand This actually just happened Well00:36:26
Let's face it, we're living in the Ice Age00:36:28
so if anything he is now Glacier00:36:30
well, because if there are polar00:36:32
hats in general, in principle, seem to be00:36:33
Measures of zloty we have there for half the planet Well00:36:35
this is what he is00:36:36
Glacial And how are they tools and how meaty are they?00:36:40
interconnected But it's much more00:36:42
ancient history is 2 s to approximately00:36:44
million years ago Well, more precisely 2,600,00000:36:47
years ago when our ancestors were just00:36:49
entered into intense competition with00:36:51
giant povna and all sorts of things00:36:53
There were plenty of other ungulates there00:36:55
new rodents appeared00:36:56
and we seemed to be defeated from this00:36:59
ecological niche of these00:37:00
herbivores as if there were herbivores00:37:02
supplanted and even more so due to seasonality00:37:04
approached the climate Well, in short, in general00:37:06
it became sad over there00:37:08
aridization in the sense of you00:37:10
repressed, this is how to understand it, well, that’s how it is00:37:12
how would they win, that is, they are better00:37:14
be fruitful they would better consume less for us00:37:16
it was just children who were hungry00:37:19
dead, well, there were actually two00:37:21
solutions one solution - it appeared00:37:23
paranthropus who switched to food00:37:24
also plants, but somehow00:37:26
xo some kind of sedge is edible00:37:28
which no one eats at all, so00:37:30
one and a half million years from dancing very much00:37:31
good, but they went to such lengths00:37:33
super vegetarian looking for a million years00:37:35
ago they became extinct, this is the question about00:37:37
supervent and they seem to have brains too00:37:39
they were not so-so there. And the second option00:37:42
this is actually Khoma who are the people00:37:44
appeared and began to eat meat because00:37:47
this time Well for the same reasons00:37:49
large ungulates are dying out and00:37:52
large predators are dying out and large ones00:37:54
the little ones disappeared as if they had nothing to do with it00:37:55
Kan Da a medium size class00:37:58
predators he seems to free up the moment well00:38:01
because there is competition from00:38:02
big ones disappeared and us from00:38:04
herbivores are being replaced by all these00:38:06
some kind of rodents, gazelles, and what about here?00:38:09
would be released and so we went there and00:38:12
began to consume meat and immediately began00:38:14
use a tool and that's it00:38:15
actually they appear synchronously00:38:17
bones with traces of tools there, broken00:38:19
sliced and the actual guns themselves. Well,00:38:22
there are guns of two main types, as it were00:38:24
Functionally, these are either healthy00:38:26
cobblestones to break the bone to00:38:27
bone marrow extract or brain00:38:30
Well, because it's pure fat. It's the same00:38:32
it’s just a holiday, no one has anything to do with it00:38:33
I can’t add, but there’s also a hyena00:38:35
something healthy00:38:39
you can chew them up and get them, and there are all these elephants00:38:43
the ancients are there in association with00:38:45
tools found everyone without a head, that is00:38:47
The tusks lie, the teeth lie, and the brain00:38:50
there is no box, everything is broken into dust00:38:52
4 kilos of brains because the second one00:38:54
version of the tools - this is with a cutting edge00:38:56
with which they began to cut the meat and here on00:38:58
bones with cuts there and cuts into00:39:01
bones are different from tooth marks00:39:04
predators and in form, as it were, and in00:39:06
location there are only predators00:39:08
are gnawing And others have chopped, here we are00:39:10
in our own way as if we were used00:39:11
actively hunted, including Well, sometimes00:39:13
and carrion also consumed examples of this00:39:14
too full, well, in short, we ate everything00:39:17
again, but meat has just become part of the diet00:39:19
so strong So what did you eat during00:39:21
Ice Age sun still00:39:25
for le period the sun sat in the same00:39:28
Africa and there They ate everything perfectly00:39:31
in a row and plants and just about anything00:39:34
Africa is rich, there's a lot of choice00:39:36
Moreover, this is not modern Africa00:39:37
those of that time are now already so victorious00:39:40
because there are just a lot of people and then00:39:42
the population density is lower and everything was00:39:43
great but if we talk about those who00:39:45
they came out of Africa on their own, as it were00:39:47
place and went somewhere there in Eurasia00:39:50
ate yes Mainly meat and Neanderthals00:39:52
which seem to be not quite us and00:39:54
Cro-Magnons Judging by the isotope00:39:57
ate almost exclusively meat00:39:59
yes, if you draw graphs there, nitrogen00:40:00
let's say some kind of carbon, well00:40:03
it’s better to spread nitrogen there with one00:40:05
the sides always look like ungulates00:40:06
animals, by the way, bears are there too00:40:08
always get in because they are also in00:40:09
They mainly eat plants later00:40:11
some hyenas then upstairs00:40:13
lions who have nothing at all but meat00:40:15
It’s scary and above Lviv there are Neanderthals00:40:18
and kormán that is, they are darker than00:40:21
lions Well, you can be a Leo if you eat00:40:24
Lviv for example00:40:26
Well, apparently that’s what they literally did00:40:28
there was just an article right there00:40:30
a week or so ago when they found it00:40:31
another lion killed there and so on00:40:33
I’ll beautifully pierce him right through with a spear00:40:35
right there somehow it hit him from behind00:40:37
Neanderthals just gobbled it up and00:40:40
Well, this is one of the finds, it’s just that00:40:42
just happened And basically like this00:40:43
were known before. They ate meat, well.00:40:45
because there is no choice in the tundra00:40:47
not rich Moreover, this is not Tundra, but there00:40:48
peregrina steppe near Glacier where00:40:51
very dry, a lot of grass and something to eat00:40:54
there's nothing special there Well, well, the grass is like that00:40:56
so inactive absolutely sedge there00:40:57
some kind of these cereals Well, there it is00:41:00
not some kind of purebred wheat, but00:41:02
some kind of nonsense there, that's it00:41:05
ate mostly meat00:41:08
Here are the rubble of Bones in the parking lots Well there00:41:11
thank God archeology already has them00:41:13
there are simply endless mountains there00:41:15
these bones are sometimes there for kilometers00:41:18
stretch Well, like in the bones there in00:41:20
some I don’t know I wanted my favorite00:41:21
second uh there anywhere there in the valleys00:41:24
the capital there is generally 5 km away like this00:41:26
condition there in Salute there Well, many places00:41:29
there are such things, but we did not become famous00:41:31
god specialized predators00:41:32
because before that we still00:41:33
herbivores were here and the plants00:41:35
consumed because for some reason00:41:36
the amount of Eh was still natural00:41:37
and it still exists, but for meat00:41:39
after all00:41:43
lightly immediately ran and there is culture00:41:45
began to develop but still00:41:47
it becomes impossible on the other hand we00:41:49
we know that the same, for example, chimpanzees with00:41:51
case they hunt and catch all sorts of duques there00:41:53
these are small antelopes there are cubs00:41:55
some kind of monkey Panov is still there00:41:57
something like that Well, here's each other00:41:59
by the way they eat regularly00:42:01
and there colobus fa nelot is very active Well00:42:04
These are monkeys too00:42:06
and they do it on purpose00:42:09
that's what's cool, by the way, they're at00:42:10
This meat is shared with this plant food00:42:12
never shares but meat is shared but according to00:42:15
we won’t see it in any way for the chimpanzees themselves, and00:42:17
moreover, by the bones they are there00:42:19
who did they eat? We won't see it either00:42:21
no way because they are not predatory00:42:23
and they don't gnaw bones they don't gnaw them00:42:26
So if we find the skeleton of this00:42:27
some kind of warthog I don't know00:42:29
who did they eat, uh, on the bones00:42:31
there will be no gnawing or splits00:42:34
they don’t use anything and they don’t use any tools00:42:36
there is no way to break it with stones00:42:38
and their teeth are purely herbivorous, but00:42:40
They don't eat there much every day00:42:42
meat there, well, I don’t know there per month00:42:44
let's say that's why when we see00:42:47
some ancient one00:42:48
Australopithecus and we see that the dental00:42:50
his system is plant-poisonous00:42:51
there are no signs of gnawing on the bones00:42:53
there's nothing, it doesn't mean anything00:42:55
this means that they can easily00:42:56
they could eat, but they just rarely did it00:42:59
Well, modern baboons are the same00:43:01
baboon, strictly speaking00:43:02
herbivorous animal and can do everything00:43:03
life eat plants Well, chimpanzees00:43:05
same thing But anyway00:43:08
They hunt quite vigorously. And what does it have to do with it anyway?00:43:10
collectively, too, what kind of antelopes are there00:43:11
they tear with their hands, they just tear them with their teeth, they don’t00:43:13
their teeth are gnawed by herbivores00:43:15
they just tear it apart with their hands like this00:43:17
cut in half and eat the meat, that's all the rest00:43:20
they throw it in and then the bones are clean00:43:21
little white ones lie down, listen, why sun00:43:24
most mammals eat00:43:26
grass big animals It would seem that00:43:28
If only they had meat and a lot of meat to eat00:43:31
you need to somehow fill up on whatever grass you are00:43:33
nae purely mathematically because to00:43:36
to eat meat you need to have it This is meat00:43:38
these plant poisons are what they are, well00:43:40
where would it come from on its own without00:43:42
animals, well, and moreover, actually00:43:44
in fact, herbivores are ungulates00:43:45
to be honest they are actually animals00:43:48
predatory animals, they're pretending00:43:50
herbivores Well, let's say a cow, yes00:43:52
the most banal animal she eats grass00:43:55
There's this grass in her stomach00:43:57
processed by bacteria Well, there in00:43:59
intestines then the same thing and it turns out00:44:02
there are many, many bacteria on the food and grass00:44:05
the cow eats these bacteria, she doesn't00:44:08
eats grass The cow itself does not have00:44:10
enzymes for digesting grass00:44:12
there's this four-chamber cunning nay00:44:14
stomach back and forth she's still there00:44:15
burps back swallows That's it00:44:18
exit She feeds on bacteria Wow00:44:20
like any vegetarian until then00:44:22
vegetarian as long as the light is on and00:44:24
everyone looks at him and the sausage and as soon as00:44:26
we turn off the switch and a little00:44:28
turn away then turn on again bam00:44:30
There's no more sausage for the gorina, here we have it00:44:33
the cow is from the same series, that is, She00:44:34
all so peaceful, as if yes, what if you take00:44:37
I don’t know any northern one00:44:38
deer is also a terrible beast00:44:40
eats lemingov there. How much do birds cost there in vain?00:44:42
some chicks eggs that is all00:44:44
what is there bones gnawing meat if there00:44:46
dead deer will lie around His others00:44:48
deer will eat only this way, although he has00:44:50
dental system Also completely plant-based00:44:51
poisonous, of course, and digestive00:44:53
the system seems to be a plant poison, but it00:44:56
needs calcium, here it is. Yes, he eats meat. Just00:44:58
who will give it to him? But when he finds it00:45:01
it will be easy to eat but clean00:45:02
mathematically you need to eat meat00:45:04
so that there is this meat that is someone00:45:05
must produce this meat00:45:07
plant poison itself00:45:08
produces this pure mathematics Well I00:45:10
I understand correctly that the invention of a weapon00:45:13
we don't care This one is in the foreground00:45:15
the food chain was not thrown out, that is, we00:45:17
anyway the Predator attacks there I don’t know00:45:20
to some Doe and that's what from00:45:22
this doe after there tiger or lion00:45:24
left we already finished eating sometimes it was like that00:45:27
there are such examples, that is, we did not go00:45:29
we haven’t killed ourselves yet, that all the spoils are ours00:45:32
No not really like that sometimes we were00:45:34
indeed the scavenger is the brightest00:45:35
example in Kobe Fora there is this00:45:37
location in Kenya and there is a skeleton00:45:39
a hippopotamus that was chewed up by lions and then00:45:42
people came and what was left after Lviv00:45:44
cut up and devoured this carrion00:45:46
quality in its purest form And where there are people00:45:48
the first ones consumed and, moreover, bones from00:45:51
traces of tools they belong to others00:45:53
age and size classes of animals00:45:56
than those with marks of teeth00:45:58
we hunted other animals than00:46:00
here are predators with different frequencies, as it were00:46:03
well, there are lions there, a little bit at a time00:46:05
they hunt, yes, there are leopards in their own way, and we00:46:07
in its own way, well, what are these choices?00:46:09
due to the big question Honestly00:46:11
speaking because well, about modern00:46:13
You can still guess Lviv, yes, well, lions00:46:15
there, to be honest, they catch everything00:46:17
people here's how they hunted there specifically00:46:19
We honestly don't know, well here we go00:46:20
they hunted antelopes there Well, they ate everything00:46:22
in a row there is a skeleton there from hedgehogs00:46:24
Zhika is close to the elephants, that’s all, well00:46:28
a hedgehog's jaw was found there with cuts from00:46:30
so characteristic there is an article00:46:32
beautiful and he has skin or But00:46:34
was Yes cool with Tatyana this topic Where00:46:37
Well, this is literally half a page and there00:46:39
two brilliant conclusions: what is the first?00:46:42
after all, there were apparently Brave Hunters00:46:44
on hedgehogs because well imagine00:46:45
the carrion ride is somehow quite sad00:46:47
it means it was an active hunt and the second00:46:50
the conclusion is what is before you gobble it up00:46:52
they took the hedgehog's skin off and guessed it00:46:55
Here00:46:56
Wow, well, because there instead A00:46:58
so the cooking went well, yes, but still like that00:47:01
as if this is cutting and not cooking00:47:03
cooking cooking by the way much later00:47:05
cooking went on for about 400,000 years00:47:07
back and later when the fire began00:47:09
It’s ok to use this at the beginning00:47:11
and managed without fire quite well00:47:13
about00:47:16
fell means about how much they fell00:47:19
I don't know if this can be understood at all00:47:22
scientists According to excavations, but were they poisoned?00:47:25
firstly, have they already eaten animal carcasses?00:47:28
Well, we have no resistance to corpse poison00:47:31
Well, it seems like there are some northern ones there00:47:32
the people there eat some kind of kopalchen00:47:34
and somehow resistance is developed there00:47:36
But this is true if you try really hard.00:47:39
so no, we are not scavengers after all00:47:40
on average, that is, we could eat this one Yes00:47:42
there's some kind of lying down there, well, but here00:47:45
It’s always worth remembering that in Africa there is carrion00:47:48
- it's not scary, it didn't fall in ours00:47:50
understanding because in African00:47:52
Savannah if someone died after 2 hours00:47:54
nothing will come from him because it’s right there00:47:56
a cloud of Marabou vultures will arrive00:47:58
Prisco there hyenas will come running 100% and in 200:48:02
there probably won't be an hour left of her00:48:03
nothing Well, there is skin and bones, yes00:48:06
Here it is. It will stink there for a long time.00:48:08
Of course there's some digging there, but it's all the same00:48:11
not edible that's why carrion in Africa00:48:14
It's most likely within two hours00:48:16
That is, if you look into your00:48:18
refrigerator, I guarantee that you have00:48:20
much more carrion than in African00:48:22
Sava there GTO ateko right here anyway00:48:26
you're probably sitting somewhere in a studio there Yes00:48:28
so we hardly made it to the refrigerator00:48:30
there with meat and there And there in the freezer it00:48:33
frozen beans already How many le Well00:48:35
It’s like it’s completely tinny. So00:48:37
that as if Carrion is not in Africa00:48:40
It’s scary it’ll just go out as if00:48:42
unless the hyenas find her by some miracle00:48:43
but it will just go rotten because00:48:45
It’s kind of hot and even more so there’s humidity00:48:46
was bigger than now Well that's why00:48:48
there seems to be no chance. Or you eat fresh00:48:50
the meat there is first fresh according to the classics, everything00:48:52
according to Bulgakov Well, either it’s no longer00:48:55
first freshness then you are not close00:48:56
come up to her and you can somehow00:48:59
generally understand that man is ancient00:49:01
a person died from poisoning for example no00:49:03
we won’t understand this because00:49:05
it doesn't affect the bones at all00:49:08
there is, we see a kind of skeleton. Why is he00:49:11
died if it's some kind of mechanical00:49:13
there are jokes Well, the leopard bit him to death00:49:15
there will be holes from the teeth, let's say yeah00:49:17
or someone there, well, if at later00:49:19
stages, someone hit him with a spear there00:49:20
there's a hole in his vertebrae, like Sung's00:49:23
let's say But these are the kind of things there00:49:26
Well, sometimes it’s because of illness. You can see what it’s like there00:49:28
there is a serious long illness there, but it is there00:49:30
the time of the Neanderthals only if not Well00:49:33
maybe they'll invent something else00:49:35
there's a clever way here, but it's simple00:49:38
the bones retain some00:49:40
long-term events but they are bones00:49:42
quite inert, like bone00:49:45
bone mass It’s bone mass and it doesn’t quickly00:49:49
it's changing so there's something there00:49:51
chronic processes and poisoning is00:49:53
the process is too fast, that is, what is there00:49:55
I ate it 2 hours later, already in the coffin and on00:49:58
bones it simply won’t be reflected there and00:49:59
nothing is rushing, that is, maybe00:50:02
then some analysis with a scraper00:50:04
some kind of soil there But if it's me00:50:06
I don’t know, at least 5,000 years have passed there00:50:08
so many times already with soil waters everything00:50:10
washed it back and forth. What if it’s there five00:50:12
the stone is already lying there and00:50:14
not a bone Well that's it Well maybe00:50:16
some technology will appear We are talking about00:50:18
DNA, you also thought it was impossible And in general00:50:20
there wasn't even a thought there at all00:50:21
it turns out Yes, but he is already this pub00:50:24
joyful runs with the Nobel Prize00:50:25
happy happy Tell me not with00:50:27
Is this related to the fact that our ancestors00:50:30
finally began to move from Africa00:50:32
here with the picture you gave me00:50:34
described that in 2 hours it’s all fast00:50:36
eaten nothing left What a shortage00:50:38
food and we need to move to where00:50:41
smaller than everyone else and you see more food there00:50:44
no Well, how is this, in principle, the basis of migration00:50:48
any what if everything here has already been eaten? But00:50:51
there is something else there Well, it’s clear that’s all00:50:52
they'll run there, it's like it's for everyone00:50:55
animals work it even for plants00:50:57
this works if the soil here is depleted00:50:59
But it’s all the more curious that people like00:51:03
since they haven’t migrated anywhere for a very long time then00:51:05
there are literally such people who turned out to be from00:51:07
all African creatures Well, not all there00:51:09
but most are the slowest and00:51:11
Homebody by us Even I don't know the aardvarks00:51:13
who are there anyway? That's such a pig on00:51:15
legs Yes, he barely crawls and eats ants00:51:17
and then they lived all over Eurasia, they were there00:51:19
in Ukraine found somewhere there in00:51:21
Kazakhstan, and people for the time being00:51:25
didn’t migrate anywhere, but sat in this00:51:26
By the way, other Primates in our Africa00:51:28
moved around, but people sat until00:51:30
the last most ancient people for00:51:32
outside Africa it is 2.400.000 years00:51:36
back Well, almost 2.5 there if there with00:51:38
in fractions00:51:39
and this is Vartaniya and then it’s basically there00:51:42
Jordan Yes, Africa is there, it’s all nearby00:51:44
located Well, 1,800 - this is in Georgia in00:51:47
Dmanisi Well, it’s like the first ones got out A00:51:50
before that there were already zebras and antelopes and00:51:53
all sorts of pigs and giraffes00:51:55
anyone there baboons ostriches elephants00:51:58
there were rhinoceroses and buffaloes running back and forth00:52:01
there are as many hyenas as you can fit, that is, us00:52:03
uniquely motionless were but somewhere00:52:05
right from one and a half million years ago00:52:07
it broke, we grew long legs and00:52:09
they started running uh Well, there’s food here anyway00:52:11
strictly speaking, nothing to do with it, that is how00:52:14
If only there was 100% enough food there, well, basically00:52:17
fauna, say, in Africa somewhere00:52:19
In India it is there according to the main indicators00:52:21
all the same well at that time00:52:22
at least it was and still is very similar00:52:23
in fact, this is the Middle East, well00:52:26
right there from the same Israel Yes there00:52:28
some Arabia to India Well now00:52:30
all this is such a dry strip and there00:52:32
was quite rich at the time, well00:52:33
humidity was higher temperature was warmer00:52:36
and it was good there, there was a lot of stuff00:52:38
the animals were grazing Well, that's why it was possible00:52:40
It’s quite possible to pass, but everyone has passed00:52:42
except people, and people haven't been around for a long time00:52:44
we went through this, this is a phenomenon, this is00:52:45
amazingly straight we went up two00:52:48
legs connections with what to get food00:52:51
faster or were there other reasons? Well there00:52:54
There were many reasons. As usual, there was00:52:56
two main points, firstly, we are still00:52:59
trees, strictly speaking, stood on two00:53:00
legs to walk on thick branches Well00:53:02
when the trees started to shrink00:53:04
Yes, there are thin branches that no longer hold us.00:53:07
we already weigh 30 kilograms there and we need to00:53:10
walk along these branches Well, more or less00:53:12
still thick, holding on to everything with his hands00:53:14
what is there and what happens is the so-called00:53:16
vertical climbing is so specific00:53:18
option e walking on branches Well00:53:20
chimpanzees now have such a thing, in principle, well00:53:22
only they have it there to a greater extent00:53:23
expressed even And it was like that among us00:53:25
and then we became the second moment00:53:28
get down to the ground as much as possible00:53:29
quickly climb back up the tree00:53:31
the number of trees is decreasing we00:53:34
we still only eat in the trees there00:53:36
for example, Ardipithecus there00:53:37
they did the political science analysis00:53:39
ate only on trees, nothing at all00:53:41
they didn't even touch the savannah and00:53:43
they wanted to give a damn, but they were already between the trees00:53:46
there are some clearings and you need to cross them00:53:49
and here is this adaptation in the form00:53:51
does not allow vertical climbing00:53:53
turn back on all fours00:53:55
generally in a shroud there on top of the grass00:53:56
It’s still more pleasant to watch there00:53:58
track the predator and they are waiting there right there00:54:00
When you get out of the tree and need to like00:54:02
you can quickly jump to the next one00:54:03
tree and there’s no way to climb back sooner00:54:05
food and not to become food as well00:54:08
yes, that is, it had nothing to do with food00:54:10
and then it indirectly turned out that yes00:54:12
with your hands you can also do something in the shroud00:54:14
Well, basically, they collect it with their hands00:54:16
monkeys are tearing in the trees Quite imaginable00:54:18
Well, that is, they also even collect by hand00:54:20
lemurs use their hands Well, if they have one00:54:22
chains and paws, so don’t take them there00:54:24
all sorts of objects, even rats jerking00:54:40
they take us when the fire appeared00:54:45
advanced the chain that we can00:54:49
we need to cook less because00:54:51
this meat No, well, we were predators00:54:54
already so omnivorous before this00:54:56
predators, yes, that is, we are 2 milna with00:54:58
half began to eat meat back and fire00:55:02
the first traces 1,600,000 years ago but their00:55:05
very few and massive ones somewhere around00:55:07
400,000 years ago and we’re nowhere in particular00:55:10
Not00:55:16
progressed, of course, but compared to others00:55:18
By the way, we have quite a few mammals00:55:19
low metabolism I must say And here’s how00:55:22
it would be great if you could be a part of this00:55:24
metabolism in general put on fire00:55:26
he seems to have already prepared the food, and we are already with00:55:29
broken molecular food bonds00:55:31
we consume and we need to chew less00:55:33
digest less and throughout00:55:35
for the next 300,000 years we have00:55:38
Jaws and stomachs decrease with00:55:40
the intestines can be seen in the chest00:55:43
which tapers to the pelvic bones00:55:44
which narrow, that is, well, well00:55:47
it's as if you can see the faces at all. Great00:55:48
because well, a jaw with teeth is00:55:49
the main thing is that we find in general and here00:55:52
300,000 years ago 400,000 years ago we00:55:54
they were still quite scary, well00:55:56
because the fire is just here00:55:57
started to use it normally and it is still00:55:59
couldn’t have much impact, but somewhere00:56:01
already by 100,000 years ago or there00:56:03
At fifty we are already almost like this00:56:05
now they are so straight decent00:56:08
steel, that is, it took, as it were,00:56:11
such a long gap00:56:12
time is good So I don’t know about Harari00:56:15
how do you feel about him? I read that00:56:18
the fire was not originally meant to be00:56:21
cook your own food like primitives here00:56:24
these burned the forest and survived that's all00:56:27
You're already burned Dead animal00:56:30
maybe not, well, Harry came up with this strictly00:56:32
speaking to Harari, it’s as if he didn’t00:56:35
an anthropologist and not an archaeologist, but to what extent00:56:38
I know he is a medievalist, he is a specialist00:56:40
about the Middle Ages That's why these are his00:56:42
there are fabrications, well they are in places00:56:44
more or less seems to hit the mark but00:56:46
about burning burning Of course because00:56:49
ethnographically this is the burning of the savannah00:56:51
we see Wherever people lived, there was someone00:56:54
burned something out here, Australian ones00:56:56
aborigines and I don’t know Indians there00:56:57
some Yes, and there are all and sundry00:56:59
Well, the Eskimos may not have set the ice on fire there, but00:57:01
because it doesn’t burn And that’s all00:57:04
Everything is yes Everything was burning something Here But this is yes And00:57:07
even chimpanzee monkeys in Uganda in the same00:57:10
Yes, in gombe they use it00:57:13
self-propelled fires for food00:57:15
there is some kind of lightning there00:57:16
will knock Yes there she is there regularly something00:57:18
lights up by itself There's just no00:57:20
any effort and the chimpanzees follow00:57:22
line of fire and collect fried drains Well00:57:25
there are some, I don’t know, these voles there00:57:27
there and burnt, here they are there00:57:29
collect and eat But apparently ancient00:57:32
people did about the same thing at first and00:57:35
We have layers like this in some places00:57:37
sols e nuno the most famous is in00:57:40
Toral has such a location in00:57:42
Spain uh Where uh river bank and there uh00:57:48
layers of silt alternate with layers00:57:50
ashes and there are quite a lot of them and00:57:52
there are a lot of animal bones and there are00:57:54
such a concept that they created fires00:57:57
some kind of grass coastal animals00:57:59
that means they ran and knitted in Tini and the people00:58:01
sat on top, ate it all joyfully and00:58:03
more than once there are whole bones there00:58:05
the mountains lie Well literally right there00:58:06
in layers they lie there and00:58:08
elephants there, just anyone, some deer there00:58:11
And there is also Taraba nearby00:58:12
ambro and two rice are still there first second00:58:15
Here But ambro she is there Podrevsky00:58:18
[music]00:58:24
when we can't be sure00:58:26
people set it on fire or it caught fire on its own00:58:28
Well, I was there in Spain after all00:58:31
quite humid climate so that it itself00:58:32
it caught fire, it’s not Africa after all00:58:34
there are self-propelled fires, they are also of course00:58:36
there are yes nuno after all There are too many00:58:38
a lot And here in one place in others00:58:39
there is no such thing in some places, but from some00:58:41
moment people even overdo it too00:58:43
not long ago there was an article about Malawi there00:58:45
very cool traced different as if00:58:48
Places there along some river valley00:58:50
local and the disappearance was traced00:58:53
local forests because of just these00:58:55
targeted burning and this is not00:58:56
that there is some kind of Neolithic00:58:58
later And these are just like that00:59:00
specifically the Stone Age Well, there are some00:59:01
hundreds of thousands of years, well there throughout00:59:03
for a long time this did not happen there00:59:04
one sitting and the number of scaffoldings straight00:59:06
specifically reduced and sol00:59:09
raw directional burning of forests and now00:59:12
Maybe just for hunting because00:59:14
these are definitely not farmers even there yet00:59:15
there was no agriculture nearby yet00:59:17
Well, most likely for hunting. Why else?00:59:20
and it itself wouldn’t burn like that in00:59:22
such a quantity after all00:59:25
Well, because if there is a concept, then what?00:59:26
I wouldn't use these same ones00:59:28
primitive people They are also ecological00:59:31
had no thinking at all00:59:32
as a rule, the degrees there lit this one00:59:34
the steppe there reaches to the horizon and what the heck with it00:59:36
as if we still have quiet steppes to the right00:59:38
left there for 100 km went there everything00:59:40
it's ok, here it is and still is00:59:42
most people are okay with this too00:59:44
sad by the way, Fire too00:59:46
when used when and not even in00:59:48
later times For example, among the most00:59:50
late Neanderthals when there was00:59:53
such one of the peaks of glaciation there there00:59:54
50,000 years ago they have the number00:59:57
the use of fire falls, that is,00:59:59
there are many more ancient ones and then bam01:00:01
gets smaller well because it01:00:03
Tundra they hunt reindeer and01:00:05
how to heat it, in general, that is01:00:07
you live in the tundra, what are you burning there?01:00:09
then you will, that is, they basically01:00:10
they knew it was like fire, but there wasn’t much choice01:00:12
was Well, the same as if we are now01:00:14
let's look at the sites of some Eskimos01:00:15
they know fire they know how to make it01:00:18
keep everything there, but they burn it there01:00:20
such Sheki with some seal fat01:00:22
there's a ftl there from and Well, they have a little light01:00:27
there are but they eat well now01:00:29
civilized, of course, it’s been there for 100 years01:00:31
ago we ate mostly raw meat01:00:33
By the way, there was still fire ahead01:00:37
Yes, dried meat in dry-curing that meat01:00:41
poured in. Apparently there are some other ones there01:00:43
habilis Well because in Africa If you01:00:45
put the meat there, it's wilted there within a day01:00:48
in any case, there’s nothing at all for this01:00:49
you don't need to do it01:00:53
you're swearing Well, so that there aren't hyenas there again01:00:55
some termites ate there Yes there01:00:57
the ants are somewhere higher up there01:01:02
hangs it already seems like a good way Well, here it is01:01:05
Well, this is Africa, well, that is, they01:01:06
then we already realized that this could be done somehow01:01:09
leave the future for the future of course01:01:11
no one left for sure poured in Well01:01:13
why not but it's all the same01:01:15
not a stock strictly speaking because well you01:01:17
eat this antipas anyway01:01:19
within two weeks anyway Well, you're fat01:01:22
there’s no way to save these tropical ones01:01:24
low-fat in general, I understand correctly01:01:26
that at the beginning we are not talking about any storage01:01:28
there was no talk of food, no storage, no01:01:32
went there until the late Neolithic01:01:34
actually, uh, there in the early Neolithic still01:01:36
They started storing some grain. Yes And so01:01:38
meat It’s clear that no one ever stocks up01:01:41
Well, we’re not particularly from archeology01:01:43
we know, to be honest, because it’s like01:01:44
we have determined that there are a lot of them out there01:01:46
let's say bones Well, there is a guess01:01:48
what is this pit where they store it01:01:50
meat in some eternal world01:01:51
gold Well, in principle, eternal peace is gold01:01:53
it will lie there for God knows how long01:01:54
It's like being in a refrigerator, it's even better there01:01:56
well, the mammoths are still lying around, if anything01:01:58
as if they have a shelf life of 40,000 years01:02:00
they have that but01:02:02
uh, most likely they didn’t care about it01:02:04
In general, such normal storage pits01:02:06
for example, for grain they are the most ancient01:02:09
in Tufi culture it is somewhere there01:02:10
12,000 years appear when01:02:13
a lot of grain and yes, that’s just too much01:02:14
you can fold it and basically let it be there01:02:16
there are some peas lying there to dry01:02:18
it would be even better to lie here But01:02:20
they have no hunters and opportunities and01:02:23
needs opportunity Net what they01:02:25
moving all the time Where will you be01:02:27
store Well, there’s a day or two there, as it were, yeah01:02:28
then you will still leave because you01:02:30
you'll eat everything here. Why, here you have food too01:02:33
there are so many walking around in herds that why01:02:35
you keep something, it's just in your head01:02:37
doesn’t fit What the hell, here you are01:02:40
you'll be there, I don't know, stock up01:02:41
any there I don’t know what happens there01:02:43
we have the most banal things01:02:45
bread crusts Yes, well, why, as it were, well01:02:47
if it went bad, throw it away if it was there01:02:49
ate normally. How should I store them?01:02:52
well, because it’s always there, as it were01:02:54
in access But if we were there in01:02:57
Middle Ages now we would keep everything01:02:59
there until the last minute because there is hunger01:03:01
every 5 years and we’ll store it here01:03:05
there was an abundance of these there is such a concept01:03:07
primordial abundance density01:03:08
the population is much smaller than ours01:03:10
the animals are much larger there are bones01:03:12
animals actually lie in layers01:03:14
in some places that’s why why store What for01:03:17
how and how to store it if it is01:03:20
Africa Well, you can wilt, but still01:03:21
it doesn't stay there that long, that's it Well01:03:24
few where salt is generally large01:03:26
quantity here in the permafrost Yes there01:03:28
maybe they killed some deer there?01:03:30
at the crossing there they put them in the permafrost01:03:32
Nina make Yes, you can use them there all winter01:03:34
eat but there the settlement becomes01:03:36
50 people each and such long-term01:03:38
enough when the fire appears, here you are01:03:41
what do you see, this is our usual01:03:44
fire pit That's how it's all equipped01:03:46
and they really started to fry01:03:49
first the meat or whatever they cook the stew01:03:52
started somehow This is a famous Chinese dish01:03:54
cooking has begun. Well, first thing -01:03:57
it's just hot, just throw the meat in01:04:00
the fire and wait for it to cook, well01:04:03
wait there's a lot of racing not on coals01:04:05
nothing like the dacha, well, here I am personally01:04:08
I watched Khaz do it, that is01:04:10
it’s clear these are modern people Yes, but they01:04:12
hunter gatherers I'm more than sure01:04:13
they always did the same thing, that is, in front of me01:04:15
here they are Yes, they shot from bows there01:04:17
some birds, well, what kind01:04:19
buntings something like a sparrow01:04:21
lit a fire Well, everything is done with chopsticks01:04:23
as expected01:04:24
Well, they have a fire made from tons of branches literally A01:04:27
everything is dry there, it’s like they’re acacia01:04:29
these resinous ones burn there for a very long time01:04:31
literally a few branches and here they are01:04:32
This bird is so much like hack01:04:53
plucked how many are there five people01:04:55
there was enough sparrow for five of them01:04:58
They also offered us We were still there01:04:59
there were five so well people are like01:05:02
kind and seemingly well-fed and happy01:05:05
happy there then the second sparrow01:05:07
they would have simply eaten themselves up there01:05:09
and this seems to be the simplest01:05:12
option I Well, I saw this live at Khaz01:05:14
yes, but in the films I saw this, it’s acceptable for01:05:16
Australian Aborigines are the same01:05:18
take the kangaroo with the fur there without removing it01:05:20
skins are not thrown at all just at01:05:22
the fire is going on again until you remember it in your stomach01:05:26
as Zaur means Done, here they get it01:05:28
the kangaroo is then torn off from her01:05:30
skin Well, it’s burnt there, it’s already clear01:05:32
Yes, all the wool is burnt. It stinks.01:05:33
it's probably incredible there then01:05:37
They'll gut it first, I won't gut it, but there01:05:39
throws characteristically, and it’s already there01:05:45
eats off01:05:51
this is how it was done because it was nearby01:05:54
bones are charred on one side01:05:56
on the other hand not charred or there01:05:57
half is like that, half is heavenly, that is, here01:05:59
it was without meat Yes it was with meat Well01:06:01
where the meat is, they didn’t put it on it, but that means01:06:03
raw meat was also normal There and01:06:06
cooler01:06:07
that there are different ways of dividing01:06:11
meat of this very thing this is this01:06:12
cool It's in kizeme too, by the way01:06:14
Israel has such a parking lot there01:06:16
traces of tools on the bones were well traced01:06:19
they collected statistics there and there is antiquity01:06:22
approximately 400,000 years ago Well, there’s more01:06:24
a lot of interesting things But these are here01:06:26
antelope bones they cut gazelles there01:06:28
or rather, well, it doesn’t matter if they have different cuts01:06:31
weapons with different strengths Under different01:06:33
corners, in contrast to the way from more01:06:35
late and Neanderthal sapien nah Where01:06:37
there are identical cuts on one bone. This is01:06:40
it means that these are more ancient ones there01:06:41
proto sapiens they took this Gazelle01:06:44
cut off some meat and give it to the next person01:06:46
dude And the next dude is sometimes different01:06:48
hand there he shoy let's say it could be yes01:06:50
there with another weapon with another force he is there01:06:52
small big cut something else01:06:54
gave to the third there to the fourth to the fifth01:06:56
how many of them were sitting there through all of this01:06:57
passed and later ones became more01:07:00
greedy and grabbed a piece there01:07:02
some rib and let's plan it01:07:03
and who the hell am I going to give it to? And here are these01:07:07
more ancient they are more like this01:07:08
the communists were hospitable yes01:07:11
I see, by the way, smoking too01:07:13
we know there is such a cave in this one01:07:17
whether Spain Portugal where there in01:07:18
Portugal Here And there are smoked eels01:07:20
the vertebrae there are so characteristic01:07:23
very smoky color01:07:25
cool to see, well, smoked eel He and01:07:27
Nowadays it’s normal in any restaurant01:07:29
goes for a lot of money even here and there01:07:32
so they could afford it and cooking01:07:35
also by the way was sometimes but rare there01:07:37
literally we have only one example so far from01:07:39
Paleolithic this is Shanidar this is in Northern01:07:42
araki cave shanidar and there is shanidar01:07:45
the third one is on his tartar 40%01:07:48
phytolith is grains of starch from barley and01:07:51
transformed like this what it is01:07:53
there was a var there they did experiments they took01:07:55
barley modern it there01:08:00
grinds exactly the boiled one01:08:02
this very starch is converted, that is01:08:04
Neanderthals there are about 60,00001:08:06
years ago they cooked01:08:09
cell01:08:11
for yourself or pearl barley It’s kind of like that01:08:13
option Well, something like them01:08:16
technically they did it incomprehensibly honestly01:08:18
saying Because they have no ceramics01:08:19
haven’t even been close yet but ethnography01:08:21
shows a bunch of ways in principle there01:08:24
all sorts of Indians there anyone Yes there01:08:25
Some kind of Itelmen, they are either made of leather01:08:28
they made such a wineskin and either there from01:08:30
some kind of bison stomach Well, that's already01:08:32
the finished vessel is basically poured into it01:08:34
water and throwing stones there from the third01:08:37
the stone boils with terrible force Well01:08:39
stones are heated on a fire, of course, and01:08:41
they have these hot stones01:08:42
heat capacity is large, they throw it into this water01:08:44
and there's mud gurgling right there, it's true01:08:47
it will be terrible, but it didn’t stop them01:08:49
they didn’t bother at all and it’s possible01:08:51
cook Yes, that’s all the more useful01:08:53
It’s interesting that not all modern people01:08:55
knew the principle of cooking, that's when it's acceptable01:08:58
Damn white English colonialists01:09:00
got to Australia That's it01:09:04
Australian Aborigines did not know how to cook01:09:06
and when the Europeans are already there01:09:07
metal pot to boil water then01:09:10
aborigines01:09:12
it's amazing you have all the water now01:09:14
destroy the ocean there, the ocean will disappear altogether01:09:17
they really really went into panic01:09:19
are there any Itelmen Indians?01:09:21
it’s ok with ilmen stones in general there01:09:24
Well, they did this in Kamchatka01:09:26
these vessels for cooking herbs with your hands01:09:29
women weaved vessels from blades of grass01:09:31
waterproof that can be thrown into01:09:33
hot stones and it doesn’t burn out01:09:35
miraculously Was there at all01:09:38
cannibalism was well because we have it01:09:42
Monkeys are just the same as chimpanzees01:09:44
that's why there are no special ones01:09:47
doubt that it was another matter01:09:49
that monkeys don’t chew cats and don’t01:09:52
break as I said today01:09:54
so you won't see it in the bones01:09:56
no way That's when it was eaten by a chimpanzee01:09:59
other chimpanzees Well, there will be a chimpanzee skeleton01:10:01
that's when tools appear here01:10:05
Yes, traces of cannibalism appear01:10:07
We now have two of these for the most01:10:09
early Khoma one all in the same kou bifree01:10:11
which I already mentioned here today01:10:13
By the way, it’s not a fact that cannibalism is because01:10:15
what is the femur there maybe it is01:10:16
Paranthropus is still a different genus and species01:10:18
so maybe from their point of view it is01:10:19
just some monkey who too01:10:21
you can eat this or maybe he and Khoma01:10:23
there's such a thing01:10:30
LM not01:10:32
less there is a female skull with notches on01:10:36
cheekbone here, it's like she was devoured, here she is01:10:40
such a dubious Khoma01:10:41
of course he has no brains that 420 g01:10:44
not rich, to be honest, but the signs01:10:46
her speech01:10:52
were a million years old and later there were completely01:10:55
By the way, it’s indicative of what we’ll say nearby01:10:57
Neanderthals had much more cannibalism01:10:59
more than the Komans we are kinder we are rare01:11:02
who they ate I understand, but then they ate their own01:11:06
from our own tribe or strangers is it us01:11:09
we don’t know, but because we have it01:11:11
Eaten bones but not written on it01:11:13
uh I'm mine yes yes Well here uh Els Dron Yes01:11:18
I already mentioned today There rather01:11:20
strangers ate everything because these01:11:21
Els Dron sy they are all relatives They01:11:23
all the relatives there are just brothers01:11:25
sisters right here relatives relatives there01:11:27
the maximum difference there is second cousins01:11:29
maybe there were some sisters there01:11:31
So they were most likely eaten by strangers01:11:34
who are also like Neanderthals But01:11:36
some left-wing Neanderthals and such01:11:38
There are plenty of examples, so hurry up01:11:41
in total, of course, strangers, recently I01:11:43
I read a book there, I can’t remember now01:11:45
I’ll make a name Well, in short about01:11:46
Neanderthals and there is such Western IP01:11:49
Therefore there is an American01:11:50
aspiration, they were Neanderthals01:11:52
Such darlings are so cute01:11:54
kind and when someone died they were like that01:11:57
suffered so much and that's why it01:11:58
ate some kind of Cro-Magnons there01:12:01
there is one parking lot there with traces01:12:02
Cannibalism is disgusting01:12:04
nasty bloodthirsty sapiens then01:12:07
You can't be like that, sapiens01:12:09
Neanderthals are such good-natured people01:12:11
devoured there on every second skeleton01:12:12
watch out for cannibalism, but that's when01:12:15
as if a person really wants it and he’s there01:12:16
wishful thinking indeed01:12:22
issues01:12:23
[music]01:12:30
what tell me has become a man and01:12:33
its food Agricultural01:12:35
revolution Well, it’s kind of contradictory01:12:39
as usual with all revolutions01:12:41
because on the one hand producing01:12:43
farming Well, there’s all sorts of millet. And there too01:12:45
goats or some sheep for starters Well01:12:47
the first sheep were it gave stability and01:12:51
if we already have a Barn in which there01:12:53
or pit storage at first Yes it was there01:12:55
underground and we fell asleep there again01:12:57
there is some of this barley and here01:12:59
We have all the victims in bulk, it’s possible to live01:13:01
well, stationary ones appear immediately01:13:03
settlements have large burial grounds there01:13:05
ritual centers a bunch of big guns01:13:08
which you don’t need to carry with you anymore01:13:09
I put it on a shelf there and it’s like01:13:11
civilization has just flooded and in01:13:14
at the beginning it is even before the producer01:13:16
Ntu fiso was back when it was here01:13:19
collecting is simply active Well, Well01:13:21
and even more so they began to live in the Neolithic01:13:24
as if in large quantities But01:13:27
stress has increased and by the way01:13:29
the first of these farmers cannibalism01:13:32
increases compared to hunters01:13:34
Natal had a lot then01:13:36
there were few Komans and the first01:13:38
there are a lot of neolithic ones again and there is murder there01:13:40
at every step there is straight early Neolithic01:13:42
some kind of tininess in general everyone there01:13:44
the second one was beaten and devoured because01:13:46
A lot of people are already getting on their nerves.01:13:48
who are these people, I don’t know them, let me give them01:13:50
I'll put it in my head just in case01:13:53
then other ways of communication are Paleolithic01:13:56
that it’s like I have a family and that’s it01:13:58
others It’s not at all a fact that people, as it were,01:14:00
eat even like, well, I don’t know deer01:14:02
ate a beaver there ate a man01:14:04
what difference does it make no matter how well he is not a person He01:14:06
In general, a stranger, as it were, but people, who are they?01:14:08
I know from birth These are exactly people01:14:10
verified as you are who is this01:14:11
meat, he'll eat me if he catches me01:14:14
people don't eat people, that means he's not human01:14:17
if I catch him, I'll eat him, right?01:14:19
People don't eat people, so he's not human.01:14:22
logic That’s the kind of thinking It’s also01:14:26
strictly speaking Paleolithic A01:14:28
there are a lot of people and population density01:14:30
big and this is how life begins but01:14:32
society which is the matter to settle01:14:35
and they were able to come to an agreement, as it were01:14:37
began to live normally and there began to01:14:40
large groups Well, that's about it01:14:41
some kind of government appears everything01:14:43
such and those who couldn’t eat it01:14:45
everything about each other But this is how it is01:14:48
bad side and stress increases01:14:51
epidemics begin again with a tooth01:14:53
straight pipe starts that's what01:14:54
today it was already said there karis u01:14:56
every second one there if not the first one01:14:59
in general, well, they began to live longer on the other01:15:01
sides Yes, but kind of worse Because01:15:04
Previously, Hunter per day occupied there for01:15:06
labor Well, it’s like getting food there01:15:08
an hour and a half to two hours there, well, when the food is on01:15:11
running around in herds yes And now you can01:15:13
waving a hoe there until the evening, in principle, and01:15:15
there are some ditches to dig there01:15:16
irrigation so you have to work01:15:19
the more their bone wear increases, but01:15:21
live longer That is, as it were01:15:26
That’s why the little one hurts before01:15:29
the team gets sick, they die01:15:31
or everyone is immune because they01:15:33
they just have relatives and genetics there01:15:34
the same And now the teams are large01:15:36
They're not all exactly related anymore01:15:38
and individual personalities appear01:15:40
who are carriers but do not die And others01:15:43
may not be so directly stable and01:15:45
this carrier will run on everyone01:15:47
sneeze and everyone will die, that’s massive01:15:50
epidemic Yes, if you can see it01:15:52
burial ground there immediately a crowd of people lies and01:15:55
as if they all died, well01:15:57
ethnography is known locally01:15:59
what was ahead we started to grow01:16:02
grain or domesticated here is large-horned01:16:04
cattle This is roughly parallel but at the beginning01:16:07
not large, just small horned 11,00001:16:09
years ago in the south in Mesopotamia steel01:16:12
grow grain there oats barley rye01:16:15
wheat and something else I forgot yes But01:16:17
it doesn’t matter, and it’s like they started to grow it01:16:20
and in the north in the registry office it is Northern Türkiye01:16:24
Syria, that's right there, Northern Iraq, well01:16:26
the oldest example is from Northern01:16:28
Iraq and Shanidar, well, this is Kurdistan01:16:30
which is the current Yes, they began to graze sheep there01:16:32
The first little animal was so useful01:16:35
it's a sheep, uh, later the goats arrive and01:16:38
cows and a little later pigs Well already01:16:41
much, much later there in the Bronze Age01:16:42
horses, well, somewhere donkeys are still in01:16:44
between uh but the first were sheep and in01:16:47
at the beginning somewhere you are thousands of years old, these two01:16:50
farming options were independent01:16:52
these with sheep these with grain Well, but then how01:16:55
Oh my God, the whole Middle East is there01:16:57
You can go there on foot in 3 days01:16:59
they seem to have mixed more or less and already01:17:02
already came to other territories01:17:04
Complex Neolithic When all this is already01:17:06
there is in place, as it were, both at the same time01:17:08
another thing, a couple thousand at first01:17:10
years was Independent cattle breeding one Well01:17:14
because in the registry office there is something like this01:17:16
climate what to grow there is not much what01:17:17
you'll actually grow up Well, it's clear that01:17:19
the first of these plant varieties were not very01:17:22
productive So are the little animals too01:17:24
sheep and goats They are generally mountain animals01:17:26
initially that's why somewhere there on01:17:28
it’s like they can’t live on this plain01:17:30
will become and then new breeds appear and01:17:32
Now many people perceive sheep as01:17:33
In general, it’s not a very steppe animal01:17:35
The steppe is like that, and all sorts of geese and chickens -01:17:38
this is the latest it's already much later01:17:40
yeah, well, we really don’t know, to be honest01:17:43
exactly when they were tamed there but01:17:44
in any case later Well, but from them it’s easy01:17:47
As with any birds, bones are less preserved01:17:49
and that's why we just have fewer finds01:17:51
corny Well, but apparently a little later and01:17:55
chickens are generally more Asian then01:17:57
eat bank chicken - this is Asia01:17:59
amazing thing means why if they01:18:02
still in parallel As you say01:18:03
these cultures developed01:18:05
agricultural In the sense of grain and01:18:07
sheep Which means these are the ones who suddenly learned01:18:10
to grow grain you can sow the whole01:18:13
don’t go to the field, don’t look for it again01:18:15
bison Why didn't they01:18:18
These people are not the ones who became vegetarians01:18:20
why aren't they like that?01:18:23
vegetarians No, well, they ate there01:18:25
99 percent of this grain itself01:18:28
Yes, well, Lord, I don’t know, Russian peasants01:18:30
at the beginning of the 20th century they ate only grain01:18:32
also there almost 100% Because if01:18:35
there is nothing else, but the beast is everything01:18:37
devoured there, not that he doesn’t want to go01:18:39
look But this is from poverty and not from01:18:40
desires are there Yes, it’s just a neighbor01:18:42
East there Azis is somewhere there in general01:18:45
who is hunting? That is, there were these animals but01:18:47
ended Purely physically, as if they were all01:18:49
devoured And even more so the climate has become01:18:52
change is the end of the Glacial01:18:53
period and climate changes And at the moment01:18:56
climate change is a massive beast01:18:58
always dying out and this is just like this01:19:00
[ __ ] happened they were still in Cybran01:19:02
culture was devoured 20,000 years ago01:19:04
everything you can do on tufi there01:19:06
somewhere from 15 to 10 they became active01:19:09
collect grain but still hunted01:19:11
what was left And somewhere around 1110 already01:19:14
They ate everything so much that it was only grain01:19:16
and all that was left was to start growing it01:19:18
there was collected before and here it is01:19:19
I had to grow it up to ceramic01:19:21
Neolithic e there abc Well there are different stages like01:19:24
if only he was drowned as if uh well01:19:28
because it's out of despair and01:19:30
basically the same story Well in the Middle01:19:32
In the East it was just earlier, but then01:19:34
the same thing happened later in China Well, at the beginning01:19:36
apparently in South and Vietnam even in01:19:38
Northern, rather, well, there are Indians further south01:19:41
then in Northern China there on the Huanghe01:19:43
Well, there are other varieties of rice in the south01:19:45
in the north there’s some kind of crap there then01:19:46
in South America in Central there for sure01:19:48
independent there is 100% there is corn somewhere01:19:50
Yes, there are Southern potatoes and peanuts01:19:52
are there any beans here and where else are there01:19:55
New Guinea apparently also has its own center01:19:57
domestication Well, then we caught up01:19:58
All kinds of India Africa there01:20:07
ten Stanislav, is there any Nakhodka here?01:20:11
there is the very first one01:20:13
recipe on the wall written I don't know01:20:16
now fantasy There is nothing there is nothing then01:20:19
there are a bunch of these01:20:20
archaeological which01:20:31
something else there is a floater floating there01:20:33
Well, they were such nuts, they cracked them with stones01:20:35
there are just stones with holes like that01:20:37
They01:20:38
smashed there in Portugal there01:20:42
Pini nuts Well, these are a type of pine nut01:20:45
more So they fried them there01:20:46
ate nuts like turnips01:20:51
e before the Neolithic there was the concept of a recipe It01:20:54
it’s just like that because it’s needed for the recipe01:20:57
so that you still have time and01:20:59
desire and some choice. But what if you01:21:01
you've been eating there all your life I don't know the groundhog01:21:03
there's a wonderful parking lot there01:21:05
98% there with pennies Well, actually There01:21:08
all fauna are marmots. It's like they were eating01:21:11
Surkov Well, these are already Cro-Magnons there01:21:13
quite late there 12 thousand I think01:21:14
years, that's just Surkov. Well, what will it be like?01:21:17
the kitchen is like marmots, well maybe they are01:21:18
of course there are smoked boiled marmots01:21:20
dried there I don’t know kvass01:21:23
But these are all marmots, most likely they are not01:21:25
you bother01:21:52
most likely much later, that's when01:21:54
you have plenty of time when you definitely have01:21:56
you won't die of hunger anymore and you don't have to01:21:58
run through the fields there after these gazelles01:22:00
So you can have fun and01:22:01
experiment But if so01:22:03
if ek Well, what if you spend all day01:22:06
All you do is run around there01:22:07
are you hunting for someone? Well, basically there01:22:09
maybe of course you run there for 2 hours too01:22:11
not all day of course but you won't01:22:14
most likely to do this though01:22:16
There are also excellent exceptions and such01:22:18
precedents For example, North American01:22:21
Indians Judging by the ethnography there was01:22:23
some very exquisite cuisine01:22:25
there are such recipes floating around there01:22:28
there you think they are, that's how they are all before01:22:30
that's what we came up with, but there are a lot of animals there01:22:33
there are some caribou deer there yeah01:22:35
there is not a moderate amount and they could01:22:37
I can’t afford them right now01:22:40
Play back what exactly they did but01:22:41
there's something right out of the teacher's head01:22:43
they were preparing uh and now they can By the way01:22:46
People like this often happen01:22:48
cooking that the locals01:22:51
use it for themselves but she doesn't care for anyone01:22:53
unknown because they seem to01:22:54
shy Well, this is ours01:22:56
banal, as it were, but no one talks about her01:22:58
knows Well, for example, in the same Tanzania Yes01:23:02
All my life I was sure that they had no01:23:04
there is no normal kitchen because well, here I am01:23:05
I've been there twice in Tanzania and not01:23:07
I haven't seen this kitchen anywhere at all01:23:09
no way. And then from the people who are there01:23:11
we lived there for 3 days, not like me01:23:12
they arrived and how long they lived there and01:23:15
like hanging out with the locals01:23:16
it turns out they have a very cunning one01:23:18
the kitchen is another matter; there is no room for that01:23:20
no restaurants nothing because01:23:22
restaurants are something so antler01:23:23
there will be European cuisine there Most likely there will be cuisine01:23:25
Well, or there for the Chinese Yes there01:23:26
some of these Chinese construction workers01:23:29
This is what everyone cooks. Why in01:23:31
go to a restaurant and eat the same thing01:23:33
you eat at home Well, here you go01:23:36
kitchen is almost unrealistic That is, it01:23:38
I need to become very close friends with someone01:23:40
so that he invites you straight home and treats you01:23:42
because they themselves eat every day. Well,01:23:44
and you won’t see it and there’s no way about it01:23:46
you won't know until you live here No I01:23:49
I haven’t eaten anything like this, I haven’t actually seen it01:23:51
this is even in the eyes, well, here's a man01:23:52
who seemed to see it and eat it, here he is01:23:54
says she's very normal there01:23:56
really good food, but that's all I'm saying01:23:59
for this you need to live there with them01:24:01
often ethnographers come there Yes01:24:03
there for a week at best, well there for01:24:05
a month and they're not exactly like buddies01:24:07
there they were invited home to treat them01:24:09
And if they treat you, it’s high01:24:12
guest that we will be his banal01:24:13
homey has no time to treat him to this01:24:15
something cool there What's cool01:24:17
it's European, yes it's American, well01:24:18
some kind of this is already generalized01:24:20
food and we come and see what they have01:24:22
all the food is the same as in Europe Well there you go01:24:24
there is no one of our own, she is, well,01:24:26
it's okay to do cooking01:24:28
fully when you first have01:24:31
food supply and you can already spend01:24:33
part as if for some kind of entertainment01:24:36
you have some free time, it’s trivial01:24:38
and it would be nice if you had pots here01:24:41
because in wicker grass of course01:24:42
great to do, well that’s basically what it is01:24:44
yes, but no matter how much you are there01:24:47
will do And when ceramics appears01:24:50
it appears approximately 10,000 years ago01:24:52
in such a massive manner Well, basically01:24:54
there are also ancient ones, but there are some isolated ones01:24:56
finds there are very rare in the Far01:24:58
East there we have there in China in01:25:00
Japan in Korea, well, literally01:25:01
some isolated pots like this01:25:03
normal about 10,000 years ago01:25:06
if you take Europe, there are generally 7,000 years01:25:09
basically that is, for 3,000 years01:25:11
later and then they start sculpting these01:25:13
pots And in them you can already cook01:25:14
the full program and you can ferment there01:25:16
and wander around there and then there’s alcohol01:25:18
appears and everything in the world is there, well01:25:21
if it is primitive it is alcohol in principle01:25:24
he can get it, but only if it’s there01:25:26
it will leaven somewhere under there01:25:28
fence and most likely will die, well who01:25:31
he will be rescued there and fed there01:25:32
to heat or, on the contrary, to cool01:25:34
And if this is Neolithic He is already in01:25:36
some kind of this01:25:39
[music]01:25:40
he won’t die from the drifting snow. He has a hole again.01:25:43
there are storage facilities and there are people around there01:25:45
200 people who, if anything, are there01:25:47
they'll run away, they'll save there somehow, there's a rollback here01:25:49
so you can ferment and so they begin01:25:52
and the first ones to find any dishes I didn’t01:25:55
I know these are coconut cups that01:25:58
still all over there in Thailand01:26:00
they sell it at every sha for sure by the way and01:26:02
there were but there was no chance of finding them01:26:04
obviously like this01:26:07
conditional such very vessels are in01:26:10
Hungary is such a parking lot, Chire and Rosni, this is01:26:13
they still have Neanderthals from the debris01:26:15
there are stalagmites like these, but01:26:18
only they are apparently not there for food01:26:20
some kind of ocher ra sense but if ocher could01:26:23
and something and something else actually Well they01:26:25
just so small, this size01:26:27
Well, that’s literally what these cups are like01:26:31
this is some normal ceramics01:26:33
appears, I said somewhere around 10,00001:26:35
some years ago before this01:26:36
they were definitely wooden01:26:38
Here, but we don’t see anything, as if yes01:26:41
we are full of ethnographic examples there01:26:43
the same Papuans of some Amazonian01:26:45
Indians have any wood there01:26:47
they make amazing things over there01:26:49
Siberia is everywhere, there are all these locals01:26:51
residents do01:26:52
But only you01:26:55
ethnographic And by the way, Yes there is01:26:57
mammoth ivory scoops on Yanskoye01:26:59
parking lot, this is the northeast of Siberia already01:27:03
and on the Yana River there is a gorgeous cemetery01:27:06
Mammoths and the parking lot of people who are well01:27:08
mostly there in general on the reindeer01:27:10
hunted but they didn’t even have Mammoths anymore01:27:12
killed And although they killed, there are also01:27:14
these are sewn together with bone tips but they are there01:27:17
Tusks were mainly used and from01:27:19
Tusks there are two beautiful scoops01:27:21
such deep, such bark, here's more01:27:24
it’s cool to decorate them so beautifully01:27:26
they have it but for what?01:27:29
used we don't know privately Maybe01:27:30
they were collecting some kind of ice cream there01:27:32
God knows the scoops themselves are there01:27:34
the functionality is unknown to us I don’t know there is01:27:37
Did you dig it up at some parking lot?01:27:39
we realized that this was the first ancient cafe there01:27:42
Well, that's not a catering outlet01:27:45
no, because a cafe is01:27:47
it is implied that someone is cooking a01:27:49
someone comes from outside Well, by01:27:51
definition01:27:59
is given but at best is already there in01:28:02
some kind of proto-state system01:28:04
Well, some Sumerians are already there01:28:06
yes, there was probably something like that and how01:28:08
it is not clear to prove there is a massive01:28:10
There is a massive production of ceramics there.01:28:12
production of Kabu there sorghum bricks Well01:28:14
maybe there was something food like that01:28:16
on the other hand, everyone basically has this01:28:17
there is something you will sell there in this01:28:19
cafe if everyone has the same thing here and Well I01:28:22
at least this is the oldest of these01:28:24
series I know this is already Pompeii Well there01:28:26
herculaneum pompeii what else is there here01:28:28
there are cafes there, there were no cafes there at all01:28:30
kitchens in houses there is just a distortion in01:28:32
on the other side, everyone ate only in01:28:34
cafes here But this is already like Vesuvius01:28:37
Yes, these are already historical times01:28:39
it wouldn't be interesting anymore, but it's right there01:28:41
these cafes they exist they are like this01:28:45
shalman as if this is what it is01:28:47
there are some kebabs being fried on the streets01:28:49
there and at some resorts01:28:51
something from the same series something like this01:28:53
eateries and prices are known for pita A01:28:57
because all these Herculaneum it was01:29:00
uh, well, like Courchevel for01:29:03
rich people where people just came01:29:05
hang out That is, this is essentially a resort01:29:09
rest is not the place where they lived. But there is01:29:12
here they are synchronous, as it were, and all sorts of things01:29:14
the estates have normal kitchens01:29:16
full-fledged there and Deauville wine01:29:17
some and the kitchens are all as they should be Well01:29:19
if there is a big estate there are a lot of people01:29:21
lives with them but will already be there01:29:22
some big cook there01:29:24
everything will ferment, basically like this01:29:27
kitchens then they are in these Knossos01:29:30
in the palace for example, oh well, this is another one01:29:33
Bronze Age but there it's not a cafe it's not01:29:38
as if about alcohol and in general01:29:41
drinks01:29:42
And when did you start drinking something other than water?01:29:47
in general, everyone is still normal people01:29:48
drink only water, this has never changed01:29:52
Honestly01:29:54
Eye Yes, as if We periodically do something01:29:56
we drink this, but in general it’s like ours01:29:58
excretory system all sorts of kidneys01:30:00
yes and all that they are intended01:30:02
filter water, not coffee or tea01:30:06
and moreover, all these drinks are like01:30:09
the rule is based on heating A for01:30:11
this again requires ceramics Well, that is01:30:13
in these wicker wooden ones01:30:15
there are a lot of leather bags there01:30:17
you can't cook anything, that's why it's like this for01:30:19
alcohol is not needed for is not needed but necessary01:30:23
time and again we need Security01:30:25
what I already managed to say is in the Neolithic01:30:27
appears and as soon as they appear01:30:30
pit storage where you put this grain01:30:32
there is the same barley Yes, he definitely got you01:30:34
will turn sour sooner or later at the bottom you are01:30:36
will still eat it out of greed01:30:38
guaranteed to you01:30:50
stick around Yes, those are the ones there01:30:53
ancient traces are there only later01:30:55
ceramics appears where there are traces there01:30:56
some kind of carbon deposits, that is, there used to be01:30:58
it turns out wheat alcohol and not01:31:01
wine, who knows, there are these01:31:04
There are actually grape seeds too01:31:07
actually, but its grapes were apparently domesticated01:31:09
it's further north and it's made from all sorts of barley01:31:13
it worked faster before, that's just it01:31:15
they started growing these grapes before01:31:18
such a berry is like it's just a joke01:31:19
would be entertainment Well, Hops There’s absolutely01:31:21
It’s kind of a confusing option. That’s it01:31:23
there is all sorts of barley beer It was01:31:25
in any case, the oldest one is Well, by the way01:31:28
approximately synchronous in North America01:31:30
the smoke has still appeared. As an option, well01:31:32
kani there drugs there in South America01:31:34
but we don’t know anything about them, but in01:31:36
North America has it in its teeth01:31:38
just this nicotine coating01:31:40
Well, but this is no longer food, of course, but01:31:42
food seems to continue to appear01:31:46
what is characteristic of those who used to become01:31:48
is their biggest consumption01:31:49
resistance to this has developed01:31:51
record holders by the way01:31:52
South American Indians who01:31:55
simply and from time immemorial they ate fruits01:31:57
fallen from the trees and under the rot, as it were, yes01:32:00
fermented there well because it01:32:02
the tropics there everything rots instantly So01:32:04
they end up with such resistance to01:32:05
alcohol which no one has at all01:32:07
Even in the Middle East they ended up01:32:09
doesn't drink alcohol at all, that's why01:32:12
they do drugs like me01:32:15
I recently read a book about the Amazon01:32:16
Indians that such a question was raised there?01:32:19
how to find out how to wear them in general01:32:20
there is no way to know how drugs work01:32:23
because it's impossible to find01:32:29
stoned by the opportunity to find out what's on01:32:32
they are influenced by drugs What01:32:36
there is another version I understand I'm interested01:32:38
the seasoning appears quite late01:32:41
or did they find in ancient times that01:32:43
such and such grass Maybe something there01:32:45
kill germs Well, probably something like that01:32:48
periodically used but again with us01:32:50
there is no evidence to be honest01:32:52
from ethnography we know what’s here and there01:32:54
someone is sticking something like that in the food01:32:57
some kind of plant rubbish there Well01:32:59
sometimes salt Well, where there is natural salt01:33:01
salt is from the same Khaz I personally saw there01:33:03
they collect things along the shores of this lake01:33:05
lumps of salt Well, they're just lying there and01:33:07
see there is a salt lake when it dries up01:33:09
there are just such fibrous crusts there01:33:12
they seem to use them. But this is how01:33:14
it would be like that sometimes, but we don’t have any01:33:17
there is no evidence. That is, it is clear that01:33:19
they could Yes, there are some herbs and01:33:22
brew some chamomile there01:33:24
Well, by the way, there are two examples, if anything01:33:26
actually, but there’s a question there, it’s like01:33:29
seasoning or01:33:31
this is a medicine drink01:33:34
not yet as an option medicine is all that01:33:37
the same esi drone that I am today01:33:39
mentioned where the Neanderthals were eaten01:33:41
family and one woman has teeth in01:33:45
tartar contains chamomile phytolith and01:33:47
yarrow and chamomile and yarrow01:33:49
Well, in principle, you can make tea from them01:33:51
of course, but what are they wearing?01:33:52
brewed it’s unclear to be honest, and so01:33:56
You can chew like this, but they are so bitter01:33:58
it would be so easy if you picked it from a bush and01:33:59
eating it's not very cool, but01:34:02
medicinally yes there seems to be an effect Yes01:34:04
that maybe this is medicine, well01:34:06
when the opportunity arose01:34:08
what to brew in some pot01:34:10
Well, this is again in the Neolithic Well01:34:12
They probably started brewing it right there01:34:14
what do you already have growing in the garden there?01:34:17
next door there under the fence you will be01:34:19
brew like this and sometimes it’s like this01:34:22
extremely valuable, as it were, for01:34:24
survival is like some kind of thing01:34:26
a spoon, or there’s a spoon all over it01:34:29
Well, such a small grass grows in the north01:34:31
her leaves are so round01:34:32
so curved like spoons really01:34:34
Here And there is a lot of vitamin C There it is there01:34:36
all northern aborigines eat in large quantities01:34:39
quantities because to prevent scurvy01:34:41
was Here's how it would be consumed Well there01:34:43
In general, the choice is not rich, as if it were possible01:34:45
in general there is this and this is Well as an option01:34:48
By the way, this is also a seasoning01:34:49
specific01:34:50
this is mus For example, among all sorts of Eskimos01:34:54
these northern comrades, by the way01:34:56
even the Europeans have some Norwegians01:34:57
same thing reindeer He got drunk01:35:00
Iago He's got it in his stomach01:35:04
semi-digested plant matter01:35:07
This is the seasoning I haven’t tried01:35:08
and I’m not going to. To be honest, but based on reviews01:35:12
she's so sour like that01:35:14
some specific smell and here it is01:35:17
The locals absolutely love it01:35:19
because vitamins are in their purest form here01:35:21
also like a seasoning, well, the northern one01:35:23
deer has something in his stomach anyway01:35:25
there is Well, something is probably yes It looks like01:35:28
coffee that the monkey is pumping out here01:35:31
this is not a monkey and the colors of the colors are01:35:36
well, vivea is a predatory one, well, she’s closer to a cat01:35:40
I really want to finish this program01:35:43
Stanislav's main family recipe01:35:45
Drobyshevsky, what do you like to eat? I01:35:48
all01:35:49
I eat that's why I don't know what it is01:35:52
this is the last thing I ate01:35:55
cooked something boiled01:35:56
pork tongue uh Well, my wife doesn’t01:35:59
he loves pork knitting and he loves it too01:36:01
she is there01:36:08
play the fool because she eats01:36:10
but pork is not pork, I just eat it01:36:13
for some reason she doesn't like it, well, well, well01:36:15
and it’s not like the family recipe is simple01:36:17
what was the last thing I cooked and ate and so on01:36:20
mainly if you let me go01:36:22
pickup, as it were, yes Well, that's what I'm there for01:36:24
as a student I ate some of this01:36:26
there's fried chicken legs and something like that01:36:28
rice here uh well how about me if01:36:31
I will feed you rice and chicken01:36:33
happy satisfied Well fried chicken01:36:35
as if that's all I don't need anything else01:36:37
or stewed I have all the recipes01:36:39
very simple sequence01:36:41
take something and put it on the frying pan01:36:44
Well, as an option, we wrap it in foil01:36:46
and into oven A and wait for it to cook01:36:49
Well, there I'll sprinkle some salt there01:36:51
yes there are sometimes some spices if01:36:52
I won’t forget there and so, well, salt and that01:36:55
Sometimes I forget, so I put it in and wait until01:36:57
will be cooked there in a saucepan in a frying pan01:36:59
oven it doesn't matter in general there01:37:01
fish meat anything Well, every time01:37:04
It turns out in short like a real ancient01:37:06
man into the fire And that's it01:37:10
yes thank you very much very interesting I have01:37:13
My jaw hurts already from smiling and laughing01:37:16
very cool friends thank you very much for01:37:19
watch us and support us without yours01:37:22
it would be enough to make donations for new episodes01:37:24
much more difficult I remind you that our01:37:26
Early premieres are available to sponsors01:37:28
issues and exclusive materials01:37:29
which were not included in the main video01:37:31
channel If you are in Russia subscribe to01:37:34
You can use us at the boost service If you are for01:37:37
outside Russia, you can issue01:37:38
subscription on the patreon platform Or01:37:41
become our sponsor right here in01:37:43
YouTuber to the sponsor button01:37:46
thanks to the Thanks to the creators button01:37:48
channel you can send one-time01:37:50
donations in any amount We01:37:52
working for you We appreciate your help we01:37:54
your agents and no one else's links to everything01:37:57
You will find support options in the description01:37:59
for this video and in the description01:38:03
[music]01:38:10
channelDescription:
Поддержать проект из России: https://boosty.to/apogovoritshow Поддержать проект из других стран: https://www.patreon.com/apogovorit Стать спонсором YouTube канала: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCp2J7GRxQ36QLqW4ReLLt5g/join Читай нас в Telegram: https://teleg.one/apogovoritofficial Ирина Шихман берет эксклюзивные интервью у самых неожиданных гостей! А поговорить?.. НАМ РАССКАЖУТ ВСЕ! НАСТОЯЩИЙ МАТЕРИАЛ (ИНФОРМАЦИЯ) ПРОИЗВЕДЕН И (ИЛИ) РАСПРОСТРАНЕН ИНОСТРАННЫМ АГЕНТОМ РФ ИРИНОЙ ЮРЬЕВНОЙ ШИХМАН ЛИБО КАСАЕТСЯ ДЕЯТЕЛЬНОСТИ ИНОСТРАННОГО АГЕНТА РФ ИРИНЫ ЮРЬЕВНЫ ШИХМАН 00:00:00 Почему у племен со скудным рационом такие хорошие зубы? 00:06:09 Как питались люди в каменном веке? И причем тут палиодиета? 00:11:05 О сыроедах и вегетарианцах 00:14:24 Травоядные и мясоеды: кого больше? 00:15:47 Человек — хищник, травоядный или всеядный? 00:17:24 Почему древние люди почти не ели рыбу? 00:18:46 Что не входило в рацион питания древних людей? 00:19:51 Когда начали есть хлеб? 00:21:26 Как кости рыб, найденные при раскопках, сохранились до наших дней? 00:23:49 Самые интересные находки 00:26:43 Кто самый первый предок человека и что он ел? 00:28:15 Почему эволюционно люди перестали есть насекомых? 00:29:04 Как в Африке делают котлеты из комаров 00:30:52 Чем отличаются зубы травоядных и хищников? 00:35:04 Растительноядные предки человека 00:36:12 Когда предки человека начали есть мясо? 00:39:20 Что ели во времена ледникового периода? 00:43:23 Почему большинство млекопитающих едят траву? 00:45:11 Предки людей были падальщиками? 00:46:29 Как охотились на ежей 00:47:18 Травились ли падалью? 00:50:27 Первобытные люди из Африки ушли на север из-за дефицита еды? 00:52:47 Почему люди стали ходить на двух ногах? 00:57:23 Как появление огня повлияло на питание и внешний вид человека? 00:59:10 Для чего древние люди выжигали леса? 01:03:30 Что появилось раньше: огонь или вяленное мясо? 01:04:22 Древние люди запасали еду? 01:06:36 Использование огня для приготовления пищи 01:10:32 Как неандертальцы варили пищу 01:12:34 Был ли каннибализм? 01:15:25 Как сельское хозяйство изменило жизнь человека? 01:18:55 Возникновение земледелия и скотоводства 01:20:56 Почему земледельцы не стали вегетарианцами? 01:23:05 Существовало ли понятие «рецепт»? 01:24:24 Когда возникла кулинария? 01:28:49 Первая найденная посуда 01:30:33 Существовали ли первобытные кафе? 01:32:35 Когда появились напитки и алкоголь? 01:35:33 Использовали ли древние люди приправы? 01:38:36 Любимые блюда Станислава Дробышевского Подпишись на канал https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCp2J7GRxQ36QLqW4ReLLt5g?sub_confirmation=1 *Instagram — принадлежит американской компании Meta, которую признали экстремистской, запрещён на территории РФ. **Meta — материнская компания Facebook, WhatsApp и Instagram. Признана экстремистской и запрещена на территории РФ
Preparing download options
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players
Questions about downloading video
How can I download "Самая эффективная диета предков. Станислав Дробышевский // Наука. А поговорить?..." video?
http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.
Which format of "Самая эффективная диета предков. Станислав Дробышевский // Наука. А поговорить?..." video should I choose?
The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.
Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Самая эффективная диета предков. Станислав Дробышевский // Наука. А поговорить?..." video?
The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.
How can I download "Самая эффективная диета предков. Станислав Дробышевский // Наука. А поговорить?..." video to my phone?
You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.
How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Самая эффективная диета предков. Станислав Дробышевский // Наука. А поговорить?..."?
The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.
How can I save a frame from a video "Самая эффективная диета предков. Станислав Дробышевский // Наука. А поговорить?..."?
This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.
What's the price of all this stuff?
It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.