Download "Виктор Шендерович* / Персонально ваш // 15.07.2022 @V.Shenderovich"

Please wait. We're preparing links for easy ad-free video watching and downloading.

Previous video: Белковский + Бунтман // 04.05.2023 @BelkovskiyS Next video: В Человеческом измерении. Неделя с Леонидом Гозманом* и Ириной Баблоян // 05.02.2023

В Человеческом измерении. Неделя с Леонидом Гозманом* и Ириной Баблоян // 05.02.2023

В Человеческом измерении. Неделя с Леонидом Гозманом* и Ириной Баблоян // 05.02.2023

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Белковский + Бунтман // 04.05.2023 @BelkovskiyS

Белковский + Бунтман // 04.05.2023 @BelkovskiyS

Channel: Белковский

венедиктов

пастухов

живой гвоздь

политика

00:00:19

[music]

00:00:42

15 hours in the capital you are watching the youtube

00:00:46

channel living nail my name is Erin

00:00:48

balayan this program is personal your

00:00:50

personal your today Viktor

00:00:52

Shenderovich writers and foreign agent

00:00:55

hello Viktor Anatolych and hello

00:00:58

hello first of all subscribe to the channel subscribe to

00:01:00

Viktor Anatolyevich in the

00:01:03

telegram channel subscribe on me in the

00:01:05

telegram channel, in general, for everything you need to

00:01:07

subscribe, subscribe to everything that is under the

00:01:10

video, all the information is there, don’t be lazy, please

00:01:12

do us a favor and like,

00:01:14

of course, put it if it’s not for me,

00:01:16

dolce quiz so definitely a

00:01:18

listener, but everything is so delicious, I don’t even

00:01:21

know but let's start with the latest news,

00:01:23

I honestly thought that

00:01:25

Andrei Pivovarov would already be sentenced

00:01:28

to this very thing, they haven't put

00:01:30

Rogozin out there yet, they sent

00:01:33

Manturov out, they appointed him to a new position,

00:01:36

this is actually just now, how are you, Steve, in

00:01:38

general, the meaning of this inside is dripping,

00:01:42

as for they have, of course, this

00:01:44

intraspecific whole history means

00:01:47

intraspecific Darwinism of that something ate

00:01:50

someone ate

00:01:52

in the current historical period nothing

00:01:55

matters except

00:01:58

death through a slash resignation of removal and

00:02:02

Putin and the end of the war in Ukraine

00:02:06

policy changes to reach, so to

00:02:10

speak, from reaching the bottom and pushing off

00:02:12

from it and to try how to emerge

00:02:15

big, the country will run out of air in the lungs,

00:02:18

this is the only thing that

00:02:20

matters, everything will become details of the zara

00:02:23

war, I don’t worry since I was in the

00:02:25

opposition, it was in the Kremlin where they made the party

00:02:28

homeland, if you remember, yes a paw of pizza and

00:02:31

then went to Brussels then went to

00:02:33

Baikonur then where else will he be

00:02:35

left without funding, everything

00:02:37

will be fine with him, yes it won’t sink, everything

00:02:41

else is also of great importance

00:02:43

because no economics, all

00:02:46

economic

00:02:48

details pale before the fact of war,

00:02:52

even from an economic point of view,

00:02:54

no economics

00:02:56

can be normal in wartime there is a cheater on the

00:02:58

Gaidar forum and I said ten

00:03:01

years ago, Gaidar’s formulas forums,

00:03:04

no one gives a [ __ ] about the meanings, but where and where

00:03:08

Sechin or Kadyrov can go into the treasury and

00:03:10

take as much money as they need, there can’t

00:03:12

be any h&k Friedman, I’ll give away the reforms,

00:03:15

all nonsense, everyone was shaken by a concussion, that’s

00:03:18

unity what matters is

00:03:22

when when will this end

00:03:24

for Ukraine and, as a consequence, for Russia

00:03:28

because we are connected by one chain and while

00:03:31

I am still at war in Ukraine while Russia

00:03:35

the aggressor asked you no, no, he’s dying, it’s

00:03:39

just a delayed death, a delayed

00:03:41

fine from and everything is on the way Schoenberg and you, I

00:03:45

understand that it’s not like

00:03:47

we’ve talked a million times, we’ve probably talked about the

00:03:49

conclusion, you think that everything won’t be

00:03:52

Putin and everything will end right away, the place will start in

00:03:55

the morning, it won’t be empty, everything will start, everything will

00:03:57

end, and

00:04:00

that- then a new one will begin no will begin on

00:04:02

may begin may begin there is a chance

00:04:05

for the beginning of the exit given the beginning you whoever

00:04:09

is here I

00:04:11

don’t know the speculation about Patrushev which means but whoever

00:04:14

comes

00:04:15

will be simply pragmatic until the task is

00:04:20

cynical the task is to get away from sanctions lift

00:04:23

sanctions before the personal personal

00:04:26

economic task is to get investments

00:04:28

to get technology before the sanctions are lifted,

00:04:32

that without everything, not everything rots and dies,

00:04:34

and it

00:04:35

stopped

00:04:37

degrading, which means whoever comes, the

00:04:41

technocrat bears and technologically the task is

00:04:44

more or less 1 to begin to get out of the so-

00:04:47

called dead ends that have driven the

00:04:51

country Putin, or in other words,

00:04:53

which country has gone

00:04:55

blind under the leadership of the path and

00:04:58

continues to put pressure on the gas, leaning against

00:05:01

at least this wall and so on, but but so

00:05:04

the absolute, whoever comes, it will not be

00:05:08

you, he was on fire, it will be repeated, there will be

00:05:09

no liberal at the first stage of the mouth

00:05:11

will be Gotti are quite cynical people from

00:05:14

very Putin’s entourage, at

00:05:17

best, some technocrats, at

00:05:19

worst, the same killers but a killer with

00:05:22

whom we can already

00:05:24

talk, yes there will be some points of

00:05:26

contact, contacts, and then

00:05:30

separate

00:05:31

agreements will be different for the West and who

00:05:34

can start to behave then these are

00:05:36

the details, I repeat, the changes

00:05:38

will happen, they will happen inside Russia in

00:05:41

no other way, unfortunately,

00:05:43

nothing will happen outside and

00:05:46

that’s why those people, those politicians today

00:05:49

who are already a sign of protest against Putin

00:05:56

are hanging on

00:05:58

us who have a war regime and you very

00:06:02

seriously,

00:06:04

so talk to me about this call again

00:06:06

for one minute that's

00:06:08

all and now again here I am

00:06:11

literally the last phrase changing

00:06:13

the creamy here it goes what

00:06:15

you buy

00:06:18

are those who are inside the country and are in

00:06:20

prison much more of a political factor

00:06:22

than those who are outside

00:06:24

minutes painters pajero

00:06:27

yes

00:06:29

I you know I remember our broadcast with you,

00:06:34

too, already on a live nail, it was

00:06:36

approximately after the Buche and I asked you

00:06:40

how to generally live further after this,

00:06:43

and to be honest, after the fact that yesterday

00:06:46

I saw Vinnytsia and everyone saw it and after the

00:06:49

answer from the official Ministry of Defense

00:06:51

that everyone needed would have been destroyed,

00:06:54

I don’t understand at all how it became

00:06:57

acceptable, how the death of children is

00:07:00

acceptable, but there is no death of children for the

00:07:03

viewers of Channel 1 2, Margarita Simonyan already told you that the

00:07:07

compartments were destroyed,

00:07:09

the Ministry of Defense told you, before the

00:07:11

staff was covered, there is nothing there, but this

00:07:16

there is nothing, they live in a

00:07:18

sealed bubble of their own, and son of a bubble, they are

00:07:22

comfortable in this bubble, they are already afraid to

00:07:25

leave there, I believe this is a bubble and they do

00:07:28

n’t want to traumatize everyone, so we already have, in

00:07:32

my opinion, inoperable Stockholm

00:07:35

syndrome, I already talked about them being

00:07:37

hostages and too long ago and deeply

00:07:39

so that they grow together, they are

00:07:42

saturated with the smell of the bandits who

00:07:45

captured who I have someone Marie

00:07:48

is recording about this who is

00:07:51

actually happy this is also a detail

00:07:54

unfortunately for a huge bromine on the quality of

00:07:57

millions there is no dead girl in

00:08:01

Vinnitsa and yes there is nothing this is just a

00:08:04

defeat started the headquarters of the nations or is it so cozy

00:08:07

that then it will fly to them and most

00:08:10

likely will fly in thin players and rockets, and even the

00:08:12

fact that their children and grandchildren will

00:08:15

die, including Sasha Vino, is not

00:08:18

to blame, but they are not able to

00:08:21

simply imagine this under that song of theirs due to

00:08:23

lack of education and being able to

00:08:25

imagine this, Masyanya and to me as a

00:08:28

test, or Kuvaev suggested it until once

00:08:32

I tried to feed on the fantasy of Oleg

00:08:34

Kuvaev as the author of the axes, well, I don’t know, maybe it

00:08:39

affects someone, I doubt it, I doubt it, but it

00:08:42

can be excluded but eyes, viktan,

00:08:44

that is, eyes, you are not you, who are you, it

00:08:48

was impossible for people to miss, I don’t know,

00:08:50

maybe I have tapes, of course

00:08:53

not and Verona so that we live in the same, you and

00:08:56

I have the same reform, tunnels, otherwise the

00:08:58

consumers of Solovyov and Simonyan have different

00:09:00

information why say the eyes

00:09:02

were gouged out a long time ago for this they closed intel

00:09:04

and in 2001 to gouge out the eyes and already in

00:09:09

2000 there was the fourth year before during

00:09:12

Beslan

00:09:16

when the star rose

00:09:18

Mrs. Simonyan

00:09:20

Beslan would have been impossible under the old

00:09:24

inter what would have been impossible to shoot

00:09:26

from tanks at a mined school, if

00:09:28

television broadcast live and

00:09:31

showed how this happens, that this

00:09:34

became possible only with the suppressed,

00:09:36

only to attract proper television,

00:09:38

pay attention a year before in

00:09:41

Nord-Ost, Putin was hysterical when

00:09:44

NTV was no longer Gus Inskaya and already

00:09:46

Gazprom’s, but after all, by inertia,

00:09:49

they showed before they showed what was

00:09:52

happening and what kind of hysteria

00:09:54

Putin was in and how then we drove her organs into a

00:09:57

gallop, and even then, but when they

00:10:00

finally, so to speak, rolled the

00:10:02

picture under the asphalt, these very eyes of

00:10:05

which the dead were gouged out, there are no these

00:10:08

television cameras that they show no to

00:10:10

this chronicle that we see, I see from the outside to

00:10:12

look like no, they gouged out their eyes and

00:10:17

now people collect the

00:10:20

center of mass with pears and pump them up, then they see up to 1

00:10:24

hectare, the Nazi headquarters was destroyed, great, it’s

00:10:26

very convenient for them to become,

00:10:28

but what about me now, I understand that I

00:10:32

I ask absolutely naive questions, but they

00:10:34

torment me and I can’t do anything about it,

00:10:35

but what about these

00:10:37

endless comments under photographs

00:10:39

and the poor girl that this is how they should be,

00:10:41

but they see it, I just do

00:10:45

n’t understand where it comes from this is anger,

00:10:47

how it is cultivated, you know,

00:10:50

it is cultivated, we know how it has been

00:10:52

cultivated for more than twenty years, yes, by

00:10:55

all that Putin’s propaganda

00:10:57

television, yes, this is incitement, in the language of

00:11:01

the criminal code, this is yes, incitement to

00:11:04

hatred, incitement of hatred, incitement of national hatred,

00:11:06

incitement, it is hatred, this

00:11:09

has been going on for a decade of

00:11:11

Ukraine, Ukrainians are not used otherwise

00:11:15

than in a contemptuous or hostile

00:11:16

meaning,

00:11:18

yes, this is science to erase and show not

00:11:23

donation, this is all up to either

00:11:25

contemptuous or simply hostile

00:11:27

Nazi, well, that means, yes, they brought up

00:11:30

these those who are already rejoicing at the death of

00:11:34

children, but to a large extent I think

00:11:38

all the same, well, comment by comment,

00:11:41

there are special people who write

00:11:42

these comments mentally team axis then I

00:11:46

suspect that the

00:11:48

Russian people do not consist of people

00:11:50

who take pleasure in thinking

00:11:52

that rockets are torn to shreds of a child, for the

00:11:55

most part this is precisely from such a

00:11:58

hysterical reaction, this is an attempt to

00:12:01

drown out the remnants of conscience with a scream there are remnants

00:12:04

of common sense in general when

00:12:08

the voice rises, as a rule, and the

00:12:10

Jupiter service means you are wrong, and

00:12:13

when such rage begins,

00:12:16

as a rule, this rage drowns out it’s just an

00:12:18

attempt to drown out one’s own

00:12:20

common sense recently published by

00:12:22

Medusa yesterday, it seems, published the

00:12:24

results of a closed poll by VCIOM and yes

00:12:27

yes

00:12:28

the question is,

00:12:32

30 percent would like to end the war, and it’s those 30 percent

00:12:36

who said about it,

00:12:39

said about it, and how many others thought about it

00:12:41

and didn’t decide to say it, and now it’s a

00:12:44

vicious circle: 30 percent want

00:12:47

an end to the war, but for the word war,

00:12:49

each of them can go to prison for 10 years almost

00:12:52

true yes it means how to stop the war

00:12:56

if it can’t be double double

00:12:58

double

00:12:59

how can you stop it if I don’t name

00:13:03

how to stop something that doesn’t exist

00:13:06

yes this 30 percent is an amazing

00:13:10

figure I repeat that in an absolutely

00:13:12

totalitarian country

00:13:18

30 percent want salt and fixed state information stopping the war and

00:13:21

I assure you can be multiplied by two from the point

00:13:24

of view of the fact that for every one who said there was

00:13:27

one person who didn’t say but

00:13:31

understood thought of course God these

00:13:35

polls and me sociology I’m just how do

00:13:38

you feel about Vladimir Vladimirovich

00:13:39

Putin yes I had a miniature about this in

00:13:43

St. Petersburg Thursday metrics in the first year and

00:13:46

2001 before this text was written

00:13:51

about a hundred employee schedule for 5 in hysterics

00:13:54

screaming yes yes yes yes of course because it’s

00:13:57

scary to think about deciding that no

00:13:59

2001 since then the country has come a

00:14:02

long way there on the side of North Korea

00:14:05

here so the paradox is

00:14:08

that in general, I think half of them definitely

00:14:12

want to end the war, but there are no

00:14:15

technologies to

00:14:16

end the war, there are no public

00:14:19

technologies, you can’t even say

00:14:21

this word without speaking to the parliament, the court,

00:14:23

going out into the street and

00:14:27

the only possibility if a change in

00:14:30

policy remains as it

00:14:32

was. something like a palace coup or

00:14:34

Mother Nature, which finally takes

00:14:36

this mental miracle before that, and

00:14:39

according to

00:14:40

no other sciences in no less such a

00:14:43

French way, this is elections, I understand

00:14:46

referendums, elections, courts

00:14:49

before

00:14:50

demonstration, yes, there is nothing of this,

00:14:52

parliament, there is nothing, the media, actually, a

00:14:55

discussion Therefore, unfortunately, we are on our

00:14:58

own if, although as a country, we have driven ourselves into an

00:15:01

absolute corner and there is

00:15:03

no legitimate way out of this corner for

00:15:07

this planet of rollers, unfortunately,

00:15:10

what can we just wait for, just wait for

00:15:13

the absence, listen, you know perfectly well

00:15:15

that it remains for everyone, here we

00:15:18

are talking to you yes Ilya Yashin Volodya

00:15:20

Kara-Murza about Alexei Barinov give they are

00:15:23

in prison

00:15:24

protesting they are not not leaving and I repeat they

00:15:29

are a factor of politics and in

00:15:30

existence is a factor of

00:15:32

domestic politics a very serious

00:15:35

factor

00:15:36

everyone then everyone decides for himself

00:15:41

what he is capable of what he is ready to sacrifice

00:15:43

what he is ready whether to do it

00:15:46

or not is ready is already a personal choice,

00:15:50

but it is clear that there are no

00:15:53

public mechanisms for a long time; they were

00:15:56

destroyed not in the twelfth

00:15:58

year of the guide Loman and in

00:16:00

1919, and when the same I didn’t try, he

00:16:04

I am his voter yes the correspondent and the same bright

00:16:07

ceiling come to municipal authorities to

00:16:10

remain municipal authorities, and they

00:16:13

simply broke their arms and legs, as you

00:16:14

remember, simply, and for example, Lev Ra

00:16:16

in the summer of 19, with a double or arms and legs,

00:16:19

just at a glance, even without

00:16:21

a poster

00:16:22

after the uncovered attempts to kill

00:16:26

Navalny, it seems to me that it was like

00:16:29

that fire . as if the last Putin had

00:16:33

gone beyond the last line, he was a politician of

00:16:37

such and such, well, for the West, for the West,

00:16:40

he was a politician, a heavy politician, yes, an ok three-

00:16:44

pack politician, from the moment when the

00:16:48

assassination attempt was uncovered, an

00:16:50

attempt to murder his main political

00:16:52

opponent was uncovered, he, so to speak, crossed this

00:16:55

line for him it’s impossible to go outside at all

00:16:58

and he has nothing to be ashamed of and all the

00:17:01

subsequent ones are already, well, like consequences, it’s too

00:17:03

late for him to drink Borzhom and in this sense

00:17:07

the situation is quite dramatic because it’s

00:17:09

unprecedented, I repeat because this is the

00:17:12

kind of cut off piece

00:17:14

with the impossibility of exiting power and with

00:17:18

nuclear weapons, this thing is unprecedented,

00:17:20

this is Saddam Hussein with nuclear weapons,

00:17:23

yes, this is very much,

00:17:28

you have said so much that I

00:17:31

would like

00:17:33

to divide it into several parts, firstly, about the poll, first

00:17:36

let’s poll 30 percent, I

00:17:39

listened yesterday to Borisychi Pastukhov, he

00:17:41

said that Putin has a

00:17:43

very sensitive feeling the mood of the masses is

00:17:46

very subtle, on an emotional level,

00:17:50

he really feels what the people need,

00:17:52

where they need to be caressed, where to cheer them up,

00:17:54

where to bribe them, do you agree with him, but he is a

00:17:59

tactical Putin, very successful, yes, yes,

00:18:02

he has the ability to save you fix

00:18:06

tactics, he is very strong in this, they found out more than

00:18:09

once and now we are finding out in the course of

00:18:12

hostilities that tactically he he he can

00:18:16

make unexpected strong decisions

00:18:18

only strategic ones that this is disastrous

00:18:20

then you are assuming the north and the same I

00:18:23

will ask you the question that this figure will

00:18:26

somehow push him towards peace with Ukraine I do

00:18:29

n’t think I answer

00:18:33

you perfectly understood what I wanted

00:18:35

to ask just yes and

00:18:38

logic no home no because

00:18:43

that is, he needs peace below which is

00:18:48

victory in brackets and he, in fact, the

00:18:51

unprecedented cruelty of war is

00:18:55

his negotiations with peace, he

00:18:59

intimidates further escalation, as if he is

00:19:01

pushing the camera on Ukraine under any

00:19:04

conditions, Ukraine is in a difficult

00:19:05

economic situation, Ukraine is in a

00:19:08

difficult economic situation, and your resource is being depleted until

00:19:12

[music] we are

00:19:17

stuck for a little bit now we will either

00:19:21

restart until or now pollock

00:19:25

we will try to connect again, but

00:19:28

this happens, you see, we are in different cities in

00:19:31

different countries even more than that, we sit and

00:19:33

quiz longer Durovich today in

00:19:35

the program, yours personally, my name is

00:19:36

Erin Bablo n this one, scold me for being

00:19:38

overly emotional, but

00:19:40

forgive me, what are the times, such an internal

00:19:43

state, I’m already trying as best I can,

00:19:47

be a little kinder, now we

00:19:50

’ll try to connect with Victor again

00:19:52

Anton, why are you just asking me to

00:19:54

ask something, you can

00:19:57

you can try asking a question, I’ll

00:20:00

peek into the chat and

00:20:03

I’ll try to isolate something from there

00:20:06

besides your squabbles with each other, and

00:20:09

if there is any problem, I’ll

00:20:11

definitely ask it, subscribe to

00:20:14

channel subscribe to my

00:20:16

telegram channel loot I but in the

00:20:18

description of this video subscribe to the

00:20:20

telegram channel Viktor Shenderovich and

00:20:23

he is also listed in the comments under

00:20:27

this broadcast you can donate if

00:20:29

you have such an opportunity we now also

00:20:31

have such an opportunity not it turns out that

00:20:32

we are

00:20:35

here so far hurray hurray ok then I’m here for now while you’re

00:20:40

entertaining

00:20:42

what they sent I turd stopped

00:20:46

at the fact that I’m fiddling with

00:20:49

reproach mailing in the summer on what conditions

00:20:51

Putin

00:20:52

would be ready for this world on the terms of

00:20:55

victory this explains the cruelty so

00:20:58

that Ukraine asked for peace, yes, to

00:21:02

zero on any terms, to push

00:21:05

Ukraine so that the world would be under this blackmail, yes

00:21:08

yes, with one again, YEN in another country,

00:21:11

gas economic, forgive me,

00:21:13

please, if you can turn on the camera,

00:21:15

we can’t see you, but the audience really wants to

00:21:18

see you, if

00:21:21

you’ll forgive me there's just the birthplace of the

00:21:25

camera icon if you manage to click

00:21:27

somehow just for now I'm

00:21:29

upset with you

00:21:31

unfortunately I'm

00:21:37

good not

00:21:39

too it's absolutely absolutely like the

00:21:42

good old days

00:21:46

bring

00:21:48

to powerless

00:21:51

means

00:21:54

here I suppose I believe that he's

00:21:57

pushing pushing in this way

00:22:00

Ukraine camera it would be his victory

00:22:01

it would be his victory Viktorovich, but haven’t you and

00:22:04

I already discussed this,

00:22:08

literally, and that’s how they present

00:22:10

everything to their consumer, and that’s the way it is, what’s

00:22:12

stopping him from announcing now, here we are,

00:22:16

this is some kind of

00:22:18

they can say anything terrible, the largest

00:22:20

group of Nazis was destroyed there

00:22:22

yesterday in

00:22:24

Vinnitsa or wherever and that’s it, that’s what

00:22:27

’s preventing it from being done: those who need to measure

00:22:30

those who doubt and will continue to

00:22:32

doubt, I’m not sure that Ukraine will

00:22:35

now agree to a cessation of

00:22:37

hostilities, that’s the same question double-edged, that

00:22:41

is, there is a war of mutual attrition, the

00:22:43

depletion of Ukraine is rapidly taking place in the

00:22:46

natural resources of the breast to

00:22:48

economic depletion in another country,

00:22:51

Ukraine is clearly not ready politically accurately

00:22:55

today mini Zelensky no one yes they will

00:22:59

not offer peace on Putin’s terms it is

00:23:03

completely impossible after everything you will

00:23:05

understand it rather this should

00:23:07

probably be asked by Ukrainian

00:23:09

political scientists, iron experts, so to speak,

00:23:12

Ukrainian politics, which

00:23:16

means I don’t know, I don’t know what

00:23:19

the balance looks like now, but

00:23:21

judging by the tactics of

00:23:24

Putin’s brutal tactics, we are

00:23:28

talking about continuing to talk about, so to speak, such a

00:23:31

cruel push for

00:23:34

peace on Putin’s terms,

00:23:39

let’s now take a little let's move away from

00:23:43

foreign policy and our domestic

00:23:46

politics and talk about the courts,

00:23:49

firstly Vladimir karma was imprisoned for being

00:23:51

behind bars or decorated, which means a

00:23:57

criminal case was opened against him

00:23:58

for 5 to 10 years

00:24:00

Goren he was given seven years today the sentence of

00:24:03

Andrei Pivovarov many don’t even

00:24:07

remember for that he has been in prison for more than a year,

00:24:11

five years, requested an investigation,

00:24:13

you know Viktorovich, I’m looking at the

00:24:15

verdict and lately I’ve been

00:24:17

going through the courts a lot and studying

00:24:20

all this for us, you can hit your wife

00:24:23

on the head with an ax and you can get 10 months for this,

00:24:27

and we know the police they can

00:24:29

rape a girl in their department

00:24:33

and they will be released, how is it that way,

00:24:38

well, give up rhetorical questions,

00:24:41

the policeman who raped the girl in the division,

00:24:43

he is not against Putin, and maybe

00:24:46

even if the girl is an oppositionist, so he

00:24:49

confirmed his stepfather’s commitment

00:24:50

to patriotism before rolling the layer here is the beginning of

00:24:56

the word Russia, you know he does not

00:24:58

pose a danger to his Barnett from

00:25:00

the state in the form in which there is

00:25:03

a state, like everything else here, self-government

00:25:06

in the West today there is a corporation

00:25:09

that has seized power and the only

00:25:12

task of this corporation is to

00:25:13

preserve this power, what other

00:25:16

tasks are not the whole punitive instrument, so to speak,

00:25:19

all the radars are punitive

00:25:22

aimed at those who threaten the authorities

00:25:26

bulk karma you will go into grief well yes

00:25:29

brewers

00:25:30

the one who

00:25:32

kills a spring with an ax or rapes and

00:25:36

kills but this is cool for those close to you and everyone

00:25:38

went through stitches half a century ago this is

00:25:41

class for you are close to them everything is fine they

00:25:43

can even be used that’s what

00:25:46

we can press for

00:25:48

Navalny’s psyche, he needs a corner, that’s great, but he

00:25:51

needs some lawless people, my husband

00:25:54

had someone no, someone who will cut

00:25:56

Khodorkovsky’s face there is a conclusion, yes,

00:25:59

Laszlo Bliv and very helpful people, you

00:26:01

can always come to an agreement with them, they are very

00:26:03

understanding, you can come to an agreement with them, they will

00:26:06

mark the correspondent Murza, you understand and

00:26:08

Navalny and Yashin, these are impossible, they are

00:26:10

enemies

00:26:11

once again, we are yours rhetorically, I understand

00:26:15

that you are rhetorical questions but not a

00:26:18

rhetorical answer, the point is that we

00:26:21

do not have a state in Russia, we do not have a

00:26:22

state in the European generally accepted

00:26:25

sense, the state was invented by what kind of

00:26:28

court by self-organization we we pay a little bit,

00:26:30

we collect taxes, we collect

00:26:33

money and give it away, so to speak, for our

00:26:35

needs, for communal needs, for defense

00:26:38

needs, on the security bed of medicine,

00:26:40

socially, this is the state and we are the time

00:26:43

where we regularly monitor how

00:26:46

our funds are spent, if

00:26:48

there is abuse, if it’s bad,

00:26:51

we choose expenses from the mother, and even if it’s good

00:26:53

to go through so that the check doesn’t stand

00:26:55

idle, this is an institution and Western

00:26:58

civilization in Russia there is a state, there is

00:27:02

such a big pain there, this

00:27:06

double-headed eagle

00:27:07

that just tears lives with the claws of the club,

00:27:11

dismantles everything that prevents him from sitting

00:27:13

up there under the name of the state, today it’s

00:27:17

simple, but we see just a bandit in

00:27:19

the range from Kadyrov, dear to the swindler,

00:27:22

demagogy scoundrels are simply a murderer and

00:27:26

therefore your rhetorical questions,

00:27:28

of course,

00:27:29

about the prosecutor's office are tailored to the

00:27:32

main thing is how efficiency to the

00:27:36

effectiveness of the Western prosecutor's office

00:27:38

is that it becomes safe to live, the

00:27:41

efficiency of

00:27:43

work of our prosecutor's office

00:27:45

is that it is safer than Putin

00:27:48

that Putin you can not be afraid of your eyes,

00:27:51

from the point of view of this efficiency, they

00:27:52

work very effectively, so they sit

00:27:55

in front of me, the sight of food is thirsty, they piled on, I

00:27:59

absolutely sincerely don’t understand, despite all

00:28:03

the popularity

00:28:05

with Vladimir car-car museum, I even more or

00:28:08

less understand on there the sanctions list, but that’s what’s

00:28:12

sick place West and so on

00:28:16

Gorinov this can be explained by the fact that this is

00:28:19

just a demonstrative flogging, keep quiet and

00:28:21

keep your head down and again, pressure is on

00:28:24

Yashin and Ilya Yashin just now up to a

00:28:28

millionaire blogger politician how does

00:28:31

Putin really think that

00:28:33

this somehow threatens his power I

00:28:36

ate the sheet and the dough,

00:28:38

I’m not just not just a blogger 1 million

00:28:43

and a blogger is also enough up to 1,000,000, this is

00:28:45

already an audience that is quite taken into account, yes,

00:28:49

this is not a small town and there are some crazy people there,

00:28:51

yes, I can’t wait to see such

00:28:54

crazy people, sorry, so to speak, on the

00:28:55

Internet

00:28:56

at all or more- less extremist

00:28:59

text of things to touch they look they

00:29:02

look

00:29:03

influence but the city crazy as

00:29:05

usual well it’s clear yes and amen

00:29:07

the city crazy but I’m the city

00:29:10

crazy about the report the report

00:29:12

is talking about a million a million this one

00:29:15

there let’s say four to five times more than

00:29:18

mine this is a very serious figure for them

00:29:21

already up to a million they start with

00:29:23

electoral such serious serious

00:29:26

matters upper secondly Ilya

00:29:28

was a municipal deputy

00:29:31

this is just an example

00:29:33

example of democracy of which they fear

00:29:36

like fire why with such a resource was it used to

00:29:39

not let not only or others to

00:29:42

0 but also others not allowing even

00:29:45

municipal elections to pass

00:29:48

through these institutions could leak out at a

00:29:52

critical moment

00:29:54

real energy could leak through these institutions;

00:29:57

voters, deputies have opportunities

00:30:00

for parliamentary requests, and for a

00:30:03

lot of them,

00:30:04

and for appeals given for commutation with

00:30:07

voters, this is a very serious resource

00:30:09

and they appreciate it it seems to me

00:30:12

quite adequate and the arrest of Yashin is,

00:30:15

of course, well, recognition of merit, yes,

00:30:19

I became a serious politician and I proved

00:30:23

myself, I must say that I have known him for a

00:30:25

long time, just about 20 years, and they did not

00:30:30

take him quite seriously from the very beginning,

00:30:32

but as a politician he proved that I

00:30:34

was wrong, for example, yes, he proved that

00:30:37

many who believed that he was not

00:30:39

serious enough were mistaken, and the

00:30:42

Kremlin, with this arrest, confirms its

00:30:46

serious status, including

00:30:48

potential status, or clearly as a

00:30:50

Russian politician, and

00:30:53

that’s all, but that’s all I am in clear proportion,

00:30:57

of course I am here, how much the

00:30:59

state spends on destroying a

00:31:01

politician is directly proportional to the actual

00:31:04

importance of this politician left with us, it

00:31:07

seems to me, but who is left with us?

00:31:09

Evgeniy Roizman stayed, Lev Shlosberg

00:31:12

stopped, stayed, but also or Galyamin,

00:31:15

what will they do then, what do you

00:31:18

think, and between you rats talking about the Kremlin

00:31:20

what will they do correspondent about

00:31:23

atoms machine and an understandable question, I think

00:31:26

Roizman and coal and not found a friend

00:31:28

pleased to hear him, yes, because we are

00:31:30

talking about the upcoming landings as a

00:31:33

completely inevitable thing, but these are people

00:31:35

whom I treat with incredible

00:31:37

respect and love, and I, too,

00:31:41

of course, of course, the

00:31:44

thing is that, well, from past rounds we

00:31:48

know about so the spokes of the Stalinist round that

00:31:51

there are personal lists, but that’s what the

00:31:57

api was written in with a red Stalinist pencil, people signed for the

00:32:00

destruction of personal political

00:32:03

opponents, we’ll put it on a

00:32:06

personal path, he’s doing a

00:32:07

personal thing to understand and then start

00:32:10

working the machine starts working the machine the

00:32:13

repressive apparatus has been created huge

00:32:16

funding huge

00:32:19

swollen intraspecific competition

00:32:21

is serious if you don’t show initiative

00:32:25

then another sits under you tempts you

00:32:29

to eat you alive another who takes the

00:32:31

initiative

00:32:32

so we see this initiative from the

00:32:35

seats under I we discussed for a week ago yes

00:32:39

the case of the scientist Kalkin yes

00:32:42

why they didn’t let him die two days there were

00:32:45

three days several days before death

00:32:47

it was clear the terminal stage he

00:32:49

almost didn’t live anymore why it was necessary to

00:32:51

understand the tubes yes yes and introduce him in

00:32:54

agony to die that the last two days a

00:32:56

trophy more monstrous mu

00:33:00

why do you have an answer why an

00:33:03

absolutely clear answer because the

00:33:05

investigator who was in charge of this case if he does

00:33:08

n’t manage to arrest Kolker before death

00:33:10

then it’s not at his expense he didn’t solve this case no

00:33:13

accused case don’t push until the

00:33:16

end check no

00:33:18

check no he doesn’t revealed the enemy of the people,

00:33:21

and so he revealed it, he managed to arrest the enemy of

00:33:25

the people, he won everything, he ticked the box,

00:33:29

he is in the plus, they will

00:33:30

pay a bonus, I don’t know what is there, that is,

00:33:34

he proved himself, and if he

00:33:37

proved himself, how did you

00:33:39

take it and didn’t arrest him because it’s a pity for the

00:33:43

consideration of mercy so you are an enemy, you are out of

00:33:47

considerations of mercy, then I didn’t

00:33:49

arrest the enemy, well, maybe it’s a

00:33:52

professional incompetence in today’s times,

00:33:54

by the way, as Alexander Cherkasov wrote,

00:33:57

there is something to compare with the fact that in 80 this

00:33:59

Andropov scam year, Andropov was

00:34:01

not taken under Andropov,

00:34:04

dissidents in the terminal stage of cancer were not arrested,

00:34:08

they were allowed until they were allowed they knew how to die a

00:34:11

natural death,

00:34:12

this is so that you understand at what point we

00:34:15

are approximately, that is, we went beyond the

00:34:18

Andropov point below below below

00:34:21

below we found the logic of currency dreams

00:34:23

of course with the Kolker scientist we didn’t Putin

00:34:26

ordered this machine to work and this is

00:34:29

the answer to your question

00:34:31

tops these are such noticeable figures this

00:34:35

will be discussed at the level of the

00:34:36

presidential administration on the old

00:34:38

square yes

00:34:40

cola who to take who not to take to intimidate someone squeeze

00:34:43

out I don’t know what else

00:34:46

to discount this will be discussed I

00:34:49

think that Roizman and Schlossberg and

00:34:50

maybe even Galyamin will

00:34:53

to discuss, so to speak, at some

00:34:55

serious level, their fate and then everything

00:34:58

works, you are a machine assembled, it

00:35:00

works without interruption, I just know

00:35:02

what I’m thinking about in our country, how many I do

00:35:05

n’t know 146 144 already and how many

00:35:09

millions of people have left there,

00:35:11

the main thing remains something

00:35:14

is this you definitely noted this is true not

00:35:19

8

00:35:20

means

00:35:22

anger but dying people well take

00:35:25

it any other for show

00:35:28

145 million but on average 145 million

00:35:37

why lie to a dying person forgive me again

00:35:40

if you imagine that your

00:35:43

question is not addressed to me but to the investigator

00:35:46

who is this did or the judge who

00:35:48

took only a conversation then this is a conversation with

00:35:51

aliens you don’t have a common language

00:35:53

you don’t have common concepts yes this is this you

00:35:57

are talking with inanimate nature yes

00:36:00

they don’t have these these ideas where

00:36:03

you are ashamed or scared yes or ashamed

00:36:06

or awkward they don’t have this, they don’t have this,

00:36:09

and they have priorities that you don’t have,

00:36:11

your dialogue is impossible because

00:36:14

there are no points, there are no points of contact,

00:36:17

I guess that’s why you’re calling this

00:36:20

question to me, but between us, soon there’s no

00:36:22

why take someone if you can, here

00:36:27

you’re grabbing you say your head, but

00:36:28

it’s terrible, it’s a shame, what does he understand with his

00:36:30

shoulders because he doesn’t know the

00:36:33

existence of these matters, it’s a shame this is a

00:36:36

very strange word this is a strange word

00:36:40

you understand the person is the judge who is this

00:36:44

judge who yes there are dozens of wrong

00:36:48

negotiations me you are the cruelest Howard

00:36:51

what is it’s a shame those people who are ashamed

00:36:54

they won’t come close to this

00:36:56

judge’s chair is already the last

00:36:58

conscientious judge I don’t remember the last name

00:37:01

and 15 years ago that ice was on

00:37:04

the air on radio freedom before there was a woman and

00:37:06

another judge was conscientious I

00:37:10

forgot the last names starting with the letter yes, there was some kind of

00:37:12

man who was there before the towers, we don’t

00:37:14

remember, here’s the judge who, yes, he was the

00:37:17

last of the Mohicans, it’s impossible, there’s just

00:37:19

no big ones there, this is

00:37:22

another rebirth, it’s

00:37:26

like in a Jewish joke, you know, grandma

00:37:29

said this for later. then when this

00:37:31

system collapses we will find ourselves in Russia, it

00:37:34

seems like a very

00:37:37

painful changeover painful

00:37:39

choice because it will be necessary to

00:37:42

change something radically, we need to clean out

00:37:44

this abscess and the abscess is huge and once

00:37:48

metastasizes throughout the body it is

00:37:51

unclear where to get and where to get

00:37:55

honest judges where to get menthol, yes,

00:37:58

instead of cops, or rather cops, it’s clear

00:38:00

where to get it, and instead of cops,

00:38:02

there were police officers,

00:38:04

that’s where to get police officers, cops, cops are a dime a dozen, and there are

00:38:07

those

00:38:11

who will break their arms, legs,

00:38:14

where to get judges by [ __ ] investigators

00:38:17

after decades on end before the

00:38:20

investigation Mom doesn’t catch Kadyrov, a

00:38:24

committee under investigation that doesn’t catch

00:38:26

Kadyrov, which doesn’t investigate

00:38:28

Nemtsov’s murder,

00:38:29

but investigates until bulk feed

00:38:33

results,

00:38:35

where to get others and the same country is the same

00:38:38

and the

00:38:40

defeat is very strong, these metastases

00:38:43

throughout the country and

00:38:46

this work was difficult, it was just a

00:38:48

painful question even for Germany where

00:38:51

all this hell continued for 12 years

00:38:54

only 12 years

00:38:56

this three decades then came

00:38:59

out three decades society came to its senses in the

00:39:02

sixties Marlene Dietrich

00:39:06

abandoned that x both spat on the

00:39:09

sixties 15 years after the death of

00:39:12

Hitler she was an enemy for a huge

00:39:17

number of Germans after 15 years

00:39:21

thirty years later, only

00:39:23

official German, so to speak,

00:39:26

officially German policy

00:39:28

called what happened in 1945

00:39:30

liberation and not defeat,

00:39:33

I repeat this after 12 years of hell, we have

00:39:37

different deadlines and we have no apologies

00:39:41

in sight for the American occupation

00:39:42

sector, we will have to

00:39:46

try something ourselves to do and I don’t

00:39:49

really understand this, so to speak, to be honest,

00:39:52

technology I think that quite

00:39:53

unprecedentedly there will be no experience, I still

00:39:56

hope that it will come to this in the foreseeable

00:39:58

future, but those questions that you take

00:40:00

them today are pointless to take tomorrow

00:40:03

they will be or the day after tomorrow when Russia

00:40:06

will reach the bottom or push off this bottom

00:40:09

and try, repeating, to get out into the air

00:40:12

before the air in the lungs runs out,

00:40:15

this will be a very, very important question,

00:40:17

what to do before, how to pull out by

00:40:21

what link to pull out the country, how to

00:40:23

do it so that judges,

00:40:25

police deputies,

00:40:28

well, we know four of them yes

00:40:32

Navalny Kara-Murza Yashin warriors

00:40:35

we know a few more schlossberg Galyamin

00:40:39

but where to get where to get such 500

00:40:43

500 before this tasks seriously

00:40:48

Putin very

00:40:50

successfully degraded from the right forgave her and

00:40:54

the way out will be the hardest but once again

00:40:58

it’s me all this is all tomorrow’s problems

00:41:01

today’s today from the name of

00:41:04

Vinnitsa today from the Alayev daily,

00:41:07

yes today, every day Russia

00:41:11

continues to destroy Ukraine and thereby

00:41:14

monstrously deepens the

00:41:18

fall, so to speak, monstrously because the

00:41:21

more terrible it will be what we did

00:41:24

in Ukraine is painful and more humiliating

00:41:27

and it will take longer for the way out later or

00:41:32

really death if if there is not

00:41:34

enough air if there is no longer

00:41:36

enough strength if the conditional Kara-Murza

00:41:40

Yashin if it turns out to be still a

00:41:44

marginal minority

00:41:46

to such an extent marginal that it

00:41:50

will no longer be able to follow them well, I

00:41:55

repeat this question to ask for but you

00:41:57

know this one questions from his day, I

00:41:58

just observed such a picture yesterday,

00:42:00

yesterday there were 3 appeal hearings on

00:42:04

Yashin’s fines and no one was allowed to go there,

00:42:07

that is, I broke through completely by

00:42:10

accident, but they filled the hall with students,

00:42:14

interns of the Faculty of Law,

00:42:17

they said that everyone who wants to listen to

00:42:19

everything is already in the hall therefore, no one who

00:42:22

came will be allowed in because the places are all

00:42:24

occupied, I talked to these students, I

00:42:28

’m curious, I went to talk to them,

00:42:30

the second-year students are sitting there and

00:42:33

asked whether they were convinced or what Ilya

00:42:36

was telling them about how a photograph of the

00:42:39

Vietnam War could discredit the

00:42:42

Russian army and so on on what they

00:42:44

told me well, the court the court show

00:42:46

the investigation will show you understand this is

00:42:48

tomorrow this is

00:42:51

yesterday this is the Hitler Youth but

00:42:54

this is the second to serve you will appear 2nd course

00:42:56

they are on steam extinguishing this course for almost

00:43:00

20 years these people have not seen anything sweeter than

00:43:03

carrots and and don’t paint Putin’s Russia

00:43:07

than the cleaner path in the field days of some and

00:43:09

now extinct fry that I won’t find

00:43:11

the beautiful apparently no I’m caught behind

00:43:15

the beginning of what but these people listen but they

00:43:18

’ll take them off further an individual question in

00:43:21

someone can a conscience be lodged on a babel

00:43:23

someone suddenly, yes, this is an

00:43:25

individual question, someone suddenly feels

00:43:27

ashamed, someone suddenly does something,

00:43:29

maybe he won’t tell you, but he

00:43:31

will understand something about himself, and someone will be confirmed in the

00:43:33

correctness of what is happening in the first place,

00:43:36

this tactic of hammering the court means

00:43:39

all sorts of Soviet vigilantes

00:43:41

gigabase.com this is quite Putin, some

00:43:43

vile tactics discussed Kovalev

00:43:46

Datashvili Lebron yes in all the

00:43:49

vigilantes in front of their eyes they don’t

00:43:52

invent anything, they take the most vile vile thing

00:43:53

that happened in Soviet times

00:43:56

and the

00:43:59

workers of the green team skins don’t need to

00:44:02

invent anything all this it was invented a long time ago,

00:44:04

but I repeat this all this is all in

00:44:07

some sense the past once again, here is

00:44:10

the depth of the fall, you understand that the period

00:44:14

matters the period matters up to

00:44:17

33 to 45 years before Hitler, this

00:44:22

still means that a

00:44:26

rather long rest of life

00:44:29

was before people people did not live a

00:44:31

significant part of their lives under Hitler,

00:44:33

no one except those who died lived

00:44:36

most of their lives under Hitler there was

00:44:39

some kind of reserve there was some kind of opportunity

00:44:40

or something that was and people remembered how it

00:44:43

could have been how it was yes yes or something

00:44:46

remained for later for some

00:44:48

next lesson in our case, the

00:44:51

molestation of 20 40 quarter of a century is about

00:44:55

1 to avoid a quarter of a century this is already

00:44:57

twice almost twice as much as all of

00:45:00

Hitler and this is a very serious very

00:45:03

serious question but I repeat this why

00:45:06

we are saying about tomorrow,

00:45:08

today,

00:45:09

what to do, it’s not clear at all, it’s completely

00:45:12

incomprehensible because the West is

00:45:15

obviously arriving in some kind of not exactly

00:45:18

confusion, but maybe

00:45:20

confusion because the resources that

00:45:22

turned out to be sufficient for the West turned out to be

00:45:25

insufficient the announcement of sanctions did not

00:45:28

stop the war did not change the internal

00:45:32

politics of Russia Putin’s

00:45:33

blackmail is possible considered generally

00:45:36

successful, repeated in practice, it

00:45:39

works strategically, it’s the death of Russia

00:45:41

here, it’s clear, but tactically it works,

00:45:45

and the prospect of the use of nuclear

00:45:48

weapons prevents Ukraine’s

00:45:51

own full-fledged confrontation from occurring, it’s

00:45:55

clearly a war of attrition and

00:45:59

psychological exhaustion, including

00:46:02

because Fariya is the first, so to speak,

00:46:04

Faria the rise passes and

00:46:07

everyday life begins, I’m already in the sixth month, we’ll soon go before

00:46:11

everyday life begins, it’s perceived as

00:46:14

everyday life, the war leaves the front pages, so

00:46:18

to speak, from the headlines and the spindles of

00:46:21

the news, it becomes the background, well, yes,

00:46:24

there’s a war going on, that’s how the weather is, not

00:46:27

floods somewhere on the batting it’s raining there’s a

00:46:31

war in Ukraine the world is getting used to this getting used to

00:46:34

this is what he achieved through as if

00:46:37

nothing had happened he continued on the rake but

00:46:40

someday they’ll come somewhere

00:46:42

here in Russia

00:46:45

well they’re already coming and that in Afghanistan we’re not

00:46:49

counting losses but I’m not I wanted to name

00:46:52

the number because yes, for sure,

00:46:54

which means they will find fault, but mine, yes, we

00:46:57

understand what we are talking about from

00:47:00

Afghanistan,

00:47:04

everything is absolutely clear, unprecedented, and

00:47:08

this is evidence of the degradation

00:47:11

that Putin caused with Russia,

00:47:14

because if you remember when there was the Chechen

00:47:16

war, yes, yes it

00:47:20

happened, it was the face there were

00:47:22

a human rights activist and the deputies got it and at the

00:47:26

memorial there was Kovalev there were businessmen ladies

00:47:29

got it we remember the history of Studenovskaya

00:47:32

there was an opportunity there was a million signatures

00:47:35

against the war well here that’s why the chances were

00:47:37

cleared then this is exactly what the speech is about

00:47:41

this and the speech is about this and the speech we can

00:47:44

measure against the Chechen war we can

00:47:47

measure the degradation of society because

00:47:49

during the Chechen war 1 it was possible for the

00:47:52

Deputy Prime Minister of the Russian government

00:47:54

to collect signatures against the war that is

00:47:57

leading the countries, it was possible for a deputy

00:48:00

to speak out against this, it was possible

00:48:03

around the clock on the same on TV, yes,

00:48:06

show the truth, investigation of the Budans,

00:48:09

and so on, yes that’s it all this was all

00:48:11

possible then and public opinion

00:48:14

existed and after some time it was

00:48:16

this public opinion that forced

00:48:20

Putin to agree to has a view

00:48:22

in combination with the resistance of the Chechens and

00:48:25

to a peace treaty, this is an example of

00:48:29

how the democratic mechanism works, the

00:48:31

first thing Putin did he destroyed,

00:48:34

gouged out his eyes, so he chose on TV,

00:48:37

rolled up under the asphalt and parliament and the courts

00:48:41

present everything to the Deputy Prime Minister who

00:48:43

brings a million signatures, if it

00:48:46

were possible,

00:48:47

there would be several million signatures

00:48:50

for ending the war with Ukraine within

00:48:53

a month, of course, of course, I will now

00:48:56

announce on television collecting signatures for

00:48:59

ending the war, losses in the form

00:49:03

of course, several million 10

00:49:06

million within a month, I just

00:49:08

guarantee that it doesn’t appear, but it’s

00:49:10

impossible, these instruments are broken, this is

00:49:13

degradation, what kind of man-made degradation,

00:49:17

this is what Putin won, he won on the

00:49:18

decorative and at the exit at the exit, these are

00:49:22

these people who don’t have a cop, you’re not

00:49:25

Deputy Prime Minister Nemtsov, not the parliament, not the

00:49:28

courts, people who are happy that we

00:49:32

broke them in, what they believe or want to believe in

00:49:35

Margarita Simonyan,

00:49:37

who was formed at

00:49:43

5 again, Victor disappeared a little of us, well,

00:49:48

nothing happens like that, okay, not scary,

00:49:51

you try advertising should be on now,

00:49:54

well, let's run it, if anything, let's let you

00:49:58

advertise, Perry, let's connect while

00:50:04

we have a paradoxical situation,

00:50:08

it's not just because it will remain in

00:50:11

history, let's fix it, Boris, you're just like a

00:50:13

child, you have the best means of

00:50:15

defense, no

00:50:17

[music]

00:50:22

embroider, we don't live in Russia there is a remainder, but there

00:50:25

must always be some kind together for

00:50:27

which you can die, this means who

00:50:30

proved the Georgian

00:50:33

ahead of the obstacles

00:50:41

[music]

00:50:44

we launched all the advertising just while we are reconnecting you

00:50:49

the picture yes yes yes beautiful you too,

00:50:52

finally I see the reward it’s

00:50:56

scary that now the

00:51:01

main thing is everything is in place, listen, but

00:51:03

first of all, they write here that for the first time in the first

00:51:06

week of the war,

00:51:08

Ponomarev collected about a million signatures

00:51:11

[music]

00:51:13

the race, but it didn’t become correct,

00:51:15

but only because Ponomarev is not a

00:51:18

deputy prime minister and because television

00:51:21

cannot tell me about it Yes, he doesn’t talk

00:51:24

about it, then again it is of a moral

00:51:27

nature, in addition to thanks to Ponomarev,

00:51:29

thanks to those who add signatures, this does not

00:51:32

become because the wheels are broken into

00:51:34

gears, forgive the racing transmission

00:51:36

of broken ones, this does not become a fact of

00:51:38

politics because when the Germans are under

00:51:42

television cameras, all federal channels directly

00:51:46

bring a million signatures this becomes a

00:51:49

fact of internal politics, a serious

00:51:52

factor that will come has a view

00:51:56

when the fry collects signatures, you

00:51:59

and I know about this,

00:52:02

this does not become about this, no one

00:52:04

will talk about the power of the video, it creates a feeling of walking the

00:52:08

need for support on a cart, you can’t say at

00:52:10

30 percent of the option

00:52:13

there, I’ll only say communicate with people's

00:52:15

support so changes will happen in

00:52:17

some way, well, unfortunately, so to speak,

00:52:20

others have an image of an accent, but it’s good, but

00:52:23

look, I’m watching, for example, I don’t watch

00:52:24

TV, well, let’s say I’m watching

00:52:26

TV and it’s 90

00:52:29

percent for me, and I’m sitting and thinking, well I don’t

00:52:32

support it, and that is, I

00:52:34

consider myself to be this minority of 10

00:52:37

percent and it’s always suppressed, well, it

00:52:39

can’t be you, but it’s human

00:52:42

nature to want to be in the majority, I

00:52:46

wrote the product at the stadium, I want to root

00:52:48

for the home team, it’s magnetizing,

00:52:51

I’ve been like this more than once you know, you get to the

00:52:53

stadium and catch yourself in the fact that you are

00:52:55

rooting for the home team, this centrifuge

00:52:58

spins you, and when 100,000, like in

00:53:00

Barcelona, I once got and I saw this

00:53:04

with my daughter, who absolutely doesn’t care that

00:53:05

Barcelona is just a rise,

00:53:08

my vi gti year old daughter who ended up

00:53:10

at the stadium sciences and at first she shrank

00:53:13

from the noise and hubbub, but at the end of the first

00:53:16

half she was waving her scarf and shouting

00:53:18

leopard because there was only an

00:53:20

arshak around and you were shouting leopard and this is dragging on

00:53:23

and so the centrifuge is a case of fugue and

00:53:26

you want to be with the majority and like this you

00:53:28

need to have a strong psyche and

00:53:31

and some experience we will admit, like my

00:53:34

experience of up to

00:53:35

20 years of experience of marginal

00:53:38

existence, and even the Soviet one, even under

00:53:41

marginal existence, that

00:53:43

if you seem to be a minority, it’s normal to say that does

00:53:45

n’t mean that I’m wrong,

00:53:47

moreover, it most likely means that

00:53:50

I will open, yes, because patp open and the

00:53:53

majority were Hitler and Stalin and

00:53:56

and in kyani it was a continuous holiday to open and the

00:53:58

majority means yes, but for this you need

00:54:01

to have a strong psyche and some

00:54:03

excuse me intelligence in order to

00:54:06

analyze what happened before in order to

00:54:09

remember the past maybe marginalized who

00:54:11

was marginalized the Duke was marginalized

00:54:13

child I in Sakharov, until then Kovalev,

00:54:16

they were all marginalized, which is not a decent

00:54:19

person in Russia, forgive the original there

00:54:22

for the most part, which

00:54:23

means it’s new to an ordinary person without

00:54:28

such experience, and without such experience, he is

00:54:32

uncomfortable in the minority, and

00:54:34

when suddenly everyone follows in the footsteps of the AT-1

00:54:37

no, of course you may be a little wrong, maybe not

00:54:41

everyone is wrong, maybe you are all against

00:54:44

the people, this is a very difficult

00:54:46

psychological thing, I once went through it

00:54:48

very

00:54:49

well in the Crimea region when my former

00:54:53

comrades told me that you were crazy,

00:54:56

why are you asking, yes, I

00:54:59

remember that this situation of absolute

00:55:01

marginality when there were just

00:55:03

a few people behind me, I remember how inside, yes,

00:55:06

because everything is shaking and vibrating,

00:55:09

maybe I can’t do something, somehow, yes, well,

00:55:11

something is wrong, damn it showed everything like that, yes,

00:55:15

but I remember my jitters may be

00:55:18

that everyone

00:55:19

is mistaken, I’m the only one who’s not mistaken, yes,

00:55:22

it works very well, this instinct is a

00:55:26

craving for the majority, this magnet of the

00:55:28

majority, if the Russian people

00:55:31

were told from TV, you know, half of

00:55:34

you are for the war, half are against, let’s

00:55:37

discuss and let’s discuss, let’s compare

00:55:40

the facts, let’s think Is this necessary, I

00:55:43

assure you, and it would have been completely different if

00:55:46

the situation would have been different and it would have shown everyone that

00:55:48

before a person has grown up, it is very difficult to go

00:55:50

against the majority, this is a very painful

00:55:53

story for a psychological teacher, and

00:55:57

before the eyes of the Sakharov at the Congress of

00:56:00

People’s Deputies,

00:56:01

who are buried behind the stump, they nod yes

00:56:05

after all, you have to be a sugar sugar to

00:56:09

stand and continue to talk, you have to

00:56:12

be intellectually a sugar, you have to

00:56:14

be able to wave as well as have this moral

00:56:16

strength, but many call call

00:56:20

their family friends in Ukraine and they

00:56:23

tell them that’s why why are you

00:56:25

doing this to us conditionally yes this is what

00:56:27

they say and in response they will show like on our

00:56:30

TV that it is you who are

00:56:31

bombing yourself, how this gap happens

00:56:33

when you don’t trust your loved ones until the

00:56:37

Stockholm syndrome is the most severe, you are

00:56:40

further from being taken hostage to a bandit

00:56:44

after some time it penetrates his

00:56:47

feeling in this part has been studied with the

00:56:49

most severe repeat of the inoperable

00:56:51

Stockholm syndrome,

00:56:53

sociologists and psychiatrists

00:56:55

someday, I think,

00:56:58

will study the experience and sociology of these

00:57:02

months in great detail and then there will be some maybe

00:57:04

more accurate answer and

00:57:07

dissertations will probably be defended on this

00:57:10

effect because what's more for so to

00:57:14

speak

00:57:15

research huge provided by

00:57:17

Russia of this Stockholm syndrome

00:57:19

someone is just happy fools

00:57:22

well, God bless them with health there are finished

00:57:25

and appreciate the scumbags and the

00:57:30

intellectual scumbags yes, well,

00:57:33

the range from Shvydkogo to Petrovsky I

00:57:36

don’t know there’s no wall of fruit there’s just people

00:57:39

who are all over the country are security forces and so

00:57:43

on, but a huge number of people

00:57:46

who are a little bit fools, yes they

00:57:49

too, I think, still make up the

00:57:51

absolute majority of these

00:57:52

clinical idiots, they helped yes, this is tens of

00:57:56

percent hardly hardly hardly but the

00:58:00

majority in my

00:58:03

opinion, these are the people of Stockholm syndrome,

00:58:05

people taken hostage, people of

00:58:08

neurosis, so I look at Facebook, a

00:58:12

huge number of wonderful

00:58:14

decent intelligent people

00:58:16

live as if in the corridor for someone there is a damper, there is

00:58:19

nothing seals to seals travel

00:58:24

to relatives close weather what a sunset that

00:58:28

is, people you can clearly see how a man

00:58:31

has set up balloons for himself and I don’t

00:58:33

see anything, here’s the sunset, here’s the tip and here are my children,

00:58:36

here’s rest, here’s my work, here’s

00:58:40

the performance and we’re rehearsing, and there’s nothing

00:58:42

beyond this,

00:58:43

this is pure neurosis, I know these people, I

00:58:47

understand that they know what’s going on

00:58:49

and understand that it’s a splash, but then if he

00:58:54

writes about it, then first of all,

00:58:56

he’s got 10 years for the word war, he must

00:59:00

himself, he must come out of this closet, this is

00:59:04

coming out, he must be out of the closet and he

00:59:06

must become a grief in the wash Yashin whether

00:59:08

Kara-Murza

00:59:09

he must change his life he must

00:59:12

risk his life

00:59:14

reproach for this again I dry this is

00:59:16

absolutely not a reproach reproach for this is

00:59:18

absolutely impossible no right

00:59:20

to demand

00:59:21

everyone is given their own including their own

00:59:24

measure of men from the 20th faith of intelligence having handed over

00:59:27

everything, everyone has their own measure, but it’s

00:59:30

impossible not to see this around me, here I am in

00:59:32

the neighborhood

00:59:33

outside and it’s clear his one horn watermelons are a

00:59:38

huge zone of this Stockholm

00:59:41

syndrome, I’m observing it, I see these blinders,

00:59:44

I see that one they’re afraid to turn their head and

00:59:48

roll it up, there’s a war going on

00:59:50

quickly the criminal is this disaster, what are you

00:59:53

doing than you should until when you need to

00:59:56

change your life and the tenant of which I am

00:59:59

without a third of the terus, I persuaded those who love the

01:00:02

ball should remember that the kit also

01:00:03

includes

01:00:05

spurs and a clip

01:00:07

spur whip spurs whip they will certainly be

01:00:11

included

01:00:13

now the whip touches those who decided to take off their

01:00:17

blinders and then this whip will reach those

01:00:21

who, yes, who wanted to go rustling,

01:00:24

I always remind you that there was a

01:00:27

good menu in German restaurants in

01:00:30

1939, 1938,

01:00:31

next door to Dachau, they brewed good beer,

01:00:34

everything was fine, everything was fine, but

01:00:37

then those who preferred blinders

01:00:40

received a spur of the whip from this is a question

01:00:43

of time, a

01:00:44

question of timing and a question of form, what it will

01:00:48

look like,

01:00:49

what it will look like and this whip it

01:00:52

could be a military disaster, it could

01:00:55

be an economic catastrophe, it could

01:00:57

be a final

01:00:59

political degradation along with the economic, it

01:01:02

could be a civil war with the collapse of

01:01:04

Russia, yes, we don’t know what it

01:01:07

will look like, well, history has a lot of

01:01:08

options, too, inventing it, don’t

01:01:11

just read the textbook and see it as it is,

01:01:13

Varya, you and I have already taken off for a minute,

01:01:15

dictation is good that we are only on YouTube,

01:01:18

yes they are on the radio, but it’s okay both

01:01:20

yes not scary nor scary thank you

01:01:24

very much I if you have the whole

01:01:26

proposal to finish I will give you yes

01:01:27

say finished before I have already said

01:01:30

three life sentences already

01:01:33

take care of me then thank you very much

01:01:36

thank you this was a program for personal

01:01:39

civic tarantul shenderovich

01:01:42

Russian writers The authorities consider this

01:01:44

wonderful man for some reason a

01:01:45

foreign agent, yes, thank you, I

01:01:48

was very glad to hear and see you, thank you

01:01:51

very much

Description:

В эфире писатель и журналист @V.Shenderovich*. Ведущая: Ирина Баблоян. Поддержать Живой Гвоздь: https://pay.cloudtips.ru/p/7edd7c0e Подписывайтесь на Ирину Баблоян в Телеграме: https://t.me/IrinaBabloyan Подписывайтесь на Виктора Шендеровича* в Телеграме: https://t.me/viktor_shenderovich * - признан российскими властями иностранным агентом. 🔔 Последние новости и анонсы программ с YouTube-канала «Живой гвоздь», а также контент от наших постоянных гостей и экспертов на официальном телеграм-канале: https://t.me/livegvozd Подписаться на Youtube-канал Дилетант: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuIE7-5QzeAR6EdZXwDRwuQ?sub_confirmation=1 📌 Живой гвоздь в аудиоформате: SoundCloud: https://soundcloud.com/user-524451485 Яндекс.Музыка: https://music.yandex.ru/album/22141653?dir=desc Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/%D0%B6%D0%B8%D0%B2%D0%BE%D0%B9-%D0%B3%D0%B2%D0%BE%D0%B7%D0%B4%D1%8C/id1616175210 Google Подкасты: https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9mZWVkcy5zb3VuZGNsb3VkLmNvbS91c2Vycy9zb3VuZGNsb3VkOnVzZXJzOjEwOTk2NzA5MDUvc291bmRzLnJzcw?sa=X&ved=0CAIQ4aUDahcKEwigxO3Eweb2AhUAAAAAHQAAAAAQEQ Магазин "Дилетант": https://diletant.shop/

Preparing download options

Popular

HD video

Only sound

All

* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."

** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players

Questions about downloading video

How can I download "Виктор Шендерович* / Персонально ваш // 15.07.2022 @V.Shenderovich" video?

http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.

Which format of "Виктор Шендерович* / Персонально ваш // 15.07.2022 @V.Shenderovich" video should I choose?

The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.

Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Виктор Шендерович* / Персонально ваш // 15.07.2022 @V.Shenderovich" video?

The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.

How can I download "Виктор Шендерович* / Персонально ваш // 15.07.2022 @V.Shenderovich" video to my phone?

You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.

How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Виктор Шендерович* / Персонально ваш // 15.07.2022 @V.Shenderovich"?

The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.

How can I save a frame from a video "Виктор Шендерович* / Персонально ваш // 15.07.2022 @V.Shenderovich"?

This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.

What's the price of all this stuff?

It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.