Download "Борис общается со зрителями онлайн. Прямая линия с Кагарлицким. ( Борис Кагарлицкий и кот Степан)"
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F-KY74ZnUfVE%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
Please wait. We're preparing links for easy ad-free video watching and downloading.
Similar videos from our catalog
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252F0XC5cftcjBU%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FMGfJvRq67Hc%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FMQQsoOmULHo%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FXX56piMBd7Y%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FZxoB0Y7Xww4%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FjbS-ZIzvv94%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FsCXrJho1n5Q%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FtCFiCPuW89E%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FtZg1zeA_R6g%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FxKI9HtXu__o%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
Video tags
Subtitles
Russian
00:00:08
[music]00:00:35
[music]00:01:20
Good evening dear viewers here00:01:23
today again on rabkor Stream from home I00:01:28
Boriska Gorlitsky Editor-in-Chief00:01:30
insight channel rabkor But today00:01:32
we changed the genre a little because we00:01:37
we have, among other things, everything and00:01:39
Discord I hope some of you know00:01:42
most of you probably know00:01:54
you ask questions directly00:01:57
in fact today they will00:01:59
questions and only direct questions00:02:02
which without moderation are not e through Maxim00:02:08
directly asked right into my ears00:02:10
right into my ears you can now00:02:12
I'll ask you questions via Discord00:02:15
answer them but again if00:02:19
there are some things that are unclear00:02:35
because there are no donations from Discord00:02:38
there won’t be and all the questions go straight but00:02:41
dear viewers, you understand perfectly well00:02:43
what for00:02:56
there is00:03:01
yes, the description has basically everything00:03:05
options for how else you can provide support00:03:08
worker correspondent and even through Bitcoin if00:03:12
for some reason your account is in bitcoins and because00:03:16
borders through patreons and so on and so forth00:03:19
next question look what is written there00:03:21
In general, there is Sberbank there anyway00:03:24
you can support us but the trouble is00:03:28
that today we will not be able to ask00:03:31
donation questions and00:03:34
Well, or rather, you can ask this00:03:37
no one will interfere but we can’t00:03:39
It’s okay to answer them because00:03:41
today As they say, just a different genre00:03:44
Yes, we work in a different mode and00:03:48
so, well, those who just want to let us00:03:53
donate00:03:56
as it were, as they say, you are welcome00:04:00
the one who wants00:04:02
let him try to ask the question00:04:05
log into Discord and through Discord with00:04:08
I'll let Maxim contact us now00:04:09
word that we explained how it all is00:04:11
works00:04:12
So00:04:14
I'm so lucky00:04:30
and it was heard now00:04:43
[music]00:05:02
let's listen now So maximum00:05:08
So00:05:12
everything is in order Now it sounds normal like this00:05:15
you need to raise your hand, go in first00:05:17
discord link to Discord so link to00:05:21
Discord is in the description of this stream and in00:05:24
pinned comments if correct00:05:25
I remember Follow the link and it’s there00:05:28
separate channel Now I’ll tell you how it is00:05:31
it's called exactly broadcast00:05:33
now 134 people with a limit of 5000:05:37
at most this is probably what if we00:05:41
there we will get closer to 50 better00:05:43
ask questions go out but if00:05:45
approach 50 if not 5000:05:47
man, you don't have to come out here00:05:51
actually there is a separate one00:05:52
broadcast from where Boris can be seen and heard00:05:54
also So there are no problems with this either00:05:57
should be open Stream at the same time00:05:58
and you don’t have to log into Discord00:06:02
now I'll add it then00:06:05
first people Well, let's launch it00:06:09
questions00:06:11
Those who have already raised their hand are probably already there00:06:15
there are such00:06:16
we can listen now00:06:20
So00:06:29
So00:06:32
boiler so to speak And then you can00:06:35
invite someone to the podium because00:06:36
that I don’t see a button for something00:06:39
this00:06:40
but I found everything00:06:43
Well, I invited00:06:45
the first person he has in theory00:06:47
highlighted00:06:49
that's all I can say here so that I can00:06:52
checked whether you can hear it at all or not00:06:57
but I don't hear anything yet man00:07:00
the person doesn't actually say anything00:07:02
just silent00:07:03
but he went out alarmed and is silent, but this is00:07:07
by the way, the way to communicate the message So Well00:07:12
like there was some kind of sound, I didn't know anything00:07:15
I hear it for now00:07:20
problem with the microphone man yes it is00:07:23
another person is disconnected00:07:36
[music]00:07:40
Well I'm listening00:07:45
actually keep an eye on the discord because00:07:47
What00:07:49
you get a notification when I00:07:51
I invite you to the podium00:07:53
You must agree to go to the podium00:07:56
That is, you can refuse yourself00:07:59
asks to probably go to the podium Well, yes00:08:01
Let's invite another one, let's00:08:03
let's try00:08:06
but now I hear Hello00:08:08
Comrade Mauser, your word, Comrade Mauser00:08:13
[music]00:08:20
and the rest they think you ever00:08:23
invite someone again like00:08:25
simply or Plan B team There is such a thing00:08:28
pretty left maybe still00:08:30
some of these comrades Well Stas00:08:34
I'm just not going to invite you because00:08:36
which systematically throws mud at us00:08:39
that would be kind of weird00:08:40
invite Moreover, to the best00:08:44
time00:08:45
we were always ready to invite the most00:08:47
different people but00:08:50
Here he has a platform on television00:08:52
he can broadcast from there how much he needs00:08:54
anything, for example Semyon Uralova00:08:56
We didn’t think about serving any Well00:08:58
[ __ ], I'll answer very simply. What do these people have?00:09:01
people have TV I just don't00:09:04
I agree that we invite00:09:05
liberals we invite different people Yes00:09:08
we really talk about some00:09:10
liberal or left liberal00:09:11
We invite characters also because00:09:14
that they have a much larger audience and they00:09:16
bring their audience and thereby00:09:19
on the contrary, it makes it possible, first of all,00:09:21
audience to become familiar with the existence00:09:23
work hard and still get acquainted with our00:09:26
glances And so there is uh00:09:28
certain logic and00:09:31
we don't hide it, but on the other hand00:09:35
parties please We invite and00:09:37
such people as Boris Yulin or00:09:42
Alexander Batov about which there is no way00:09:45
don’t wait for liberalism No sideways00:09:48
But00:09:50
please Dmitry Kozhnikov we had yes00:09:53
that is, please we have enough00:09:55
there are a lot of these that are called hard00:09:58
Bolshevik left on the channel and always00:10:01
it will definitely be but I'll tell you straight00:10:06
the current circumstances of people00:10:09
who take a supportive position00:10:12
military operations and00:10:14
support that00:10:16
does00:10:18
Russian state00:10:20
[music]00:10:23
Ukraine00:10:25
in general this is the position we will not do00:10:29
to promote the more we do not00:10:32
we will give our word to these people simply by00:10:34
for one simple reason that they seem to have00:10:37
they have all the television00:10:38
in general media00:10:42
some kind of environment that is huge00:10:45
State and Let's additional00:10:49
we won’t do this well on the site00:10:53
Thanks for the answer00:10:58
so I invite the next one00:11:02
I invite you to press the actual button00:11:11
[music]00:11:14
I'll invite you again00:11:18
doesn't believe the call00:11:21
good luck next there00:11:24
let's next these when again00:11:27
if you ask, then we’ll launch them00:11:31
So for now, look00:11:36
Yes yes hello00:11:41
I’m just so personal to you00:11:43
The question is that the connection with the situation is weak Well00:11:46
could you also be threatened with dismissal and00:11:49
if you have any additional00:11:51
sources of income that will allow you00:11:53
more What is called afloat Good00:11:56
the question is because it is very relevant00:11:59
Look, I've already been fired from Ranhigs00:12:02
I definitely have to give credit to my colleagues00:12:04
from Russia They behaved very correctly00:12:06
that is, they should have fired me they00:12:09
I was warned that they were firing me00:12:11
but they delayed this process Well00:12:14
literally for almost six months That is00:12:16
even it seems to me a little more than00:12:20
six months, that is, they Well, in general, somewhere00:12:22
so they If we are talking about No, not for six months Well00:12:26
a few months less00:12:27
the process was delayed and in the end we will let it go00:12:30
What is called an amicable agreement?00:12:31
that I really uh00:12:34
left voluntarily I was paid for vacation00:12:38
I was paid again, uh, a bonus for00:12:43
good job in general Well in a good way00:12:46
broke up As they say That's it00:12:48
it was not like Lobanov’s00:12:50
just Well, literally in 24 hours uh00:12:54
illegally completely squeezed out of Moscow State University and00:12:58
in general it was all very ugly00:13:01
Although I noticed that in the case of mullet00:13:03
after all, uh, gardeners themselves don’t care about this00:13:07
signed That is, he found a project that00:13:09
it's called not afraid to write this00:13:12
I wasn't afraid of it because of my reputation.00:13:14
in appearancebut00:13:15
still gardens apparently like a reactor00:13:18
uh, well, after all, it’s a world-class university00:13:21
name uh with some00:13:25
yet again00:13:27
traditionally he refused to do this00:13:31
and now I teach in Shadrinka in00:13:35
shalinka I have half the bet00:13:38
professorial but there is professorial00:13:41
the rate is generally very funny there00:13:43
my professorial salary is 34,00000:13:46
half the professor's rate I have in00:13:48
mind clean, that is, even if I00:13:51
now they will deprive this rate But of course00:13:53
it will be unpleasant but not fatal, but Slava00:13:58
God I have books coming out and by the way00:14:01
speaking now it has already become00:14:02
feel that is lately00:14:04
after I was hired as an agent00:14:05
my books began to sell more and00:14:08
more active and this compensates a little00:14:11
at least Lost is transcribed00:14:13
money, well, plus thank God I have it00:14:15
family that supports me And this00:14:18
also doesn’t allow you to stay afloat well00:14:20
plus there are some savings. Well00:14:23
let's say the situation is tense, but not00:14:27
catastrophic so far00:14:31
I understand Thank you please but anyway00:14:34
case00:14:45
so good00:14:49
so I invite you diet I understand00:14:51
hidden nickname00:14:56
Yes, I'm listening to you. Hello.00:15:00
Boris Yurievich comrade behind the microphone00:15:02
Hello Hello I am more I00:15:05
I'm not here anymore to ask a question00:15:07
but more for the sake of gratitude because I00:15:11
I want to say a huge thank you of course00:15:13
to the workers' correspondent for being a workers' correspondent00:15:15
carries out such a progressive lilac00:15:18
activities and of course Huge00:15:20
thanks for the large quantity00:15:21
various guests And of course00:15:24
to all those who listened so to speak and00:15:28
took out streams with the participation of Well, of course00:15:32
Klim00:15:33
Sanchara huge chronic Hi so00:15:36
say So I hope for the appearance of such00:15:39
guests in the future of course again here00:15:42
and a small question of course in terms of00:15:46
exactly00:15:47
Are you planning to00:15:50
in the future conversation with such00:15:54
representatives of the left movement as00:15:56
Alexander Batov from the Russian Labor00:15:59
front since now there is such a thing00:16:02
quite interesting, more precisely outlined00:16:04
quite an interesting trend00:16:07
by Russian Post due to the fact that00:16:10
like many probably present here00:16:13
they know that Russian Post is now00:16:15
going through some pretty bad times00:16:16
when they told us that in October00:16:19
nineteenth year when she00:16:21
privatized they said that00:16:23
Yes00:16:25
of course of course00:16:29
will be the same as in the west or in00:16:33
in the east, roughly speaking, yes Well, later00:16:35
of course00:16:36
they were silent about it all, that’s what I wanted00:16:40
would of course hear about the results00:16:42
fight RTS because00:16:46
thanks again00:16:49
RT in terms of material I00:16:52
I'll brag, no matter how it sounds00:16:56
distributing materials among let's say00:16:59
since I'm well00:17:01
close to the military unit let's say00:17:06
spread among precisely in our00:17:09
military town and more00:17:12
materials just about that00:17:16
that Russian Post fought more accurately00:17:19
postmen and OPS operators fought for00:17:23
your rights so a big hello to you00:17:27
I mean you this audience and00:17:30
Certainly00:17:31
microphone Thank you so much for00:17:35
provided00:17:36
to the platform to speak00:17:38
thank you well first of all thank you very much00:17:41
I’ll say right away of course and Revy Mayer and00:17:45
naturally we will have beetles, I will be a beetle00:17:49
I'm texting now, we decided00:17:51
make a stream dedicated to the story00:17:53
military mercenaries and mercenary riots00:17:56
so he promised that00:17:59
remote or in Moscow when it is in00:18:01
In general, somehow we will do this with him. He himself00:18:04
said it was an interesting topic, but we00:18:05
Now this topic has become extremely relevant00:18:07
So00:18:09
unfortunately for some yes yes00:18:13
Well, there's something to talk about there00:18:16
you understand that you start on the sixteenth00:18:19
century, by the way, I highly recommend Klipsanych00:18:21
Well I think maybe maybe I00:18:25
I think I'm wrong with mine after all00:18:26
the tips were absolutely cool00:18:29
video about the general00:18:31
[music]00:18:36
that's it00:18:38
great video by the way I'm there too00:18:41
I found out a lot of unexpected details here00:18:43
By the way, I found out that in fact the descendants00:18:47
Wolfenstein was none other than Max00:18:49
Veder, an outstanding sociologist That's it, that means00:18:53
in short and revy master you are also somewhat00:18:55
since they invited him he says that00:18:56
will definitely come will come but00:18:58
very busy Well, I think it will be all the same00:19:00
so yes since I yes I I am close00:19:03
familiar with so to speak Well now I00:19:06
I'll pronounce it more correctly00:19:08
funeral Komsomol00:19:11
quite big health problems00:19:13
precisely in terms of dental K00:19:16
Unfortunately this is public information.00:19:18
himself Well, that is, yes that's why Yes he00:19:23
he just can’t Yes, he even said that it was00:19:26
I can’t treat my teeth That’s right00:19:29
there was some kind of I invite you and I have one too00:19:31
called problem Well anyway00:19:33
In short, I can tell you completely00:19:37
responsibility that we would invite them00:19:38
invite and00:19:40
in general, all invitations are active. This is not00:19:44
so what in general yes that's what concerns00:19:46
Batova, yes, relatively recently00:19:48
was but invited again I am Alexander00:19:51
I'll just be very glad to see you because00:19:53
last time he talked with Zhenya00:19:57
Rodionova as far as I remember but quite00:19:59
can I do too very good Yes00:20:01
yes And so I want to tell you as I00:20:04
citizen living in the territory00:20:06
Irkutsk region, more precisely in the city00:20:08
Yakutsk, I really want to tell you so00:20:12
see in the future in our city00:20:14
Wonderful I love your city very much This is00:20:17
wonderful city one of my favorites00:20:19
cities may even be generally simple00:20:22
I'm always very pleased to come00:20:24
so I'll try to be sure yes00:20:27
Well, let's see how it turns out00:20:36
Thank you very much comrades for the microphone00:20:40
Let's reel00:20:46
[music]00:20:54
Thanks a lot00:20:57
So here I am00:21:00
thank you excellent00:21:04
and I wanted to ask this question00:21:07
as far as I understand the transition from00:21:09
socialism to communism means00:21:12
Well, either complete or very00:21:15
serious replacement of human labor00:21:19
robotic00:21:22
and it turns out that then this way00:21:26
marketability is overcome But then00:21:28
It seems to me that there is a problem that00:21:31
will motivate people to work because00:21:33
what it seems in the absence of some00:21:37
such motivation00:21:40
big problems in society because00:21:42
if people don't work00:21:44
It’s not clear what they are actually doing00:21:46
that is, it can be creative work00:21:47
But what will prompt this? Which00:21:50
possible mechanisms could be00:21:52
Well, basically, let's start with the same thing00:21:55
Indeed this is the least understood and00:21:57
least developed question because00:21:59
Well, because we don’t have this experience00:22:02
we have experience, so to speak, of attempts00:22:04
Socialist transformations00:22:07
more or less radical more or00:22:10
less successful, that is, roughly speaking00:22:11
held to date00:22:13
socialist society We do not have00:22:15
but we have the experience of societies that uh well00:22:20
they say they were built in Soviet terms00:22:22
Socialism Oh, how they won00:22:25
but we know that we didn’t really win and in00:22:29
including, by the way, because00:22:30
the problem of marketability remains to that extent00:22:33
unsolved and how theoretically00:22:36
including the problem Well, of course, defeat or00:22:39
Victory is not connected, of course, only with00:22:42
theory As you understand perfectly well, but00:22:45
In general, we now understand perfectly well that00:22:47
mmm at least uh period00:22:52
socialist society00:22:54
commodity relations00:22:56
are overcome only partially, but then00:22:59
there is What is called Now here00:23:00
modern sociology00:23:02
decommodification yes that is when00:23:03
some00:23:04
phenomena that00:23:07
regulate market relations00:23:10
are already starting00:23:12
regulated by direct00:23:14
needs but how can we say00:23:16
healthcare00:23:17
education science00:23:21
a significant part of the infrastructure and so on00:23:24
on and on and on and on and on00:23:26
the topic of access to information, knowledge and so on00:23:29
Further00:23:30
That is, it happens00:23:32
gradual apparently Deca modification00:23:34
some areas of life and now about00:23:38
communism is a society which00:23:40
will00:23:43
as we assume based on00:23:46
Marxist theory grow out of00:23:47
Socialism because by the way But if so00:23:50
take it quite correctly in Soviet00:23:52
I emphasize Marxism all the time00:23:54
Socialism is just the first phase00:23:55
there is a little bit of communism here. Dispute about words00:23:57
begins between us saying that is00:23:59
so a little dogmatic but00:24:02
Now let's get back to your question00:24:04
Barça actually has a concept00:24:07
Overcoming labor00:24:09
not just liberation of labor first00:24:12
Liberation of labor then Overcoming00:24:13
labor, that is, what will replace labor?00:24:18
labor, according to Marx, should replace00:24:20
activity00:24:21
that is, people do00:24:26
not only what they pay for or what00:24:30
they have to do it to earn money00:24:31
everything is for bread and do what feels good00:24:34
interesting and00:24:36
what's useful is that they have motivation for it00:24:40
self-realization or creative motivation00:24:43
and so on But further just00:24:45
the most interesting question remains A00:24:47
exactly how to do it so that practically00:24:49
any activity00:24:51
turned into creative or00:24:54
at least it was getting interesting00:24:55
meaningful, bright, and so on00:24:58
again we assume that apparently on00:25:00
level of high technologies that are now00:25:01
already visible quite easily00:25:04
switch to activity type00:25:06
other That is, if we are talking about let's say00:25:09
computer programs then you don't00:25:13
you will definitely be for the rest of your life00:25:14
there to draw pictures yes Or vice versa00:25:18
design something00:25:21
equipment You can switch from00:25:22
one type of activity another00:25:24
presumably here But I'm honest with you00:25:27
I will say that this is still some kind of future00:25:29
which we can foresee sooner00:25:32
theoretically in practice you probably00:25:34
you will see at least within00:25:37
what will happen in our life with you?00:25:41
commodity economy in significantly00:25:44
at least00:25:46
to a large extent and well so be it00:25:50
maintain such an incentive as00:25:51
just money Yes, for which you can do something00:25:55
buy buy or00:25:57
with which you can pay for something but00:26:01
nevertheless, it seems to me that someone wants00:26:04
say that you understand Well, we are very much00:26:07
we do even now about capitalism00:26:09
because they pay for it and because00:26:11
that we are interested or because we00:26:12
read useful or because uh this00:26:15
other people want from us yes00:26:18
when about meetings It's big00:26:20
the number of people seems to be here00:26:22
trust that everyone will00:26:24
engage in creative activities00:26:26
somewhat dangerous but I think that00:26:30
a question that is not you not me not even00:26:33
Marx cannot answer and could not00:26:36
answer completely in advance because00:26:37
this is some kind of image this is a trend00:26:41
in the direction which it will probably be00:26:43
humanity move that's what I said00:26:46
such a question yes If I understand correctly00:26:48
that the movement to communism is00:26:51
robotization yes automation that means00:26:54
Is this what socialism will have a task00:26:57
build this thing as quickly as possible00:27:00
because Socialism is like such a phase00:27:01
transitional and, as it were, historical experience00:27:04
showed that somehow if she doesn’t move00:27:07
forward then moves backward Will it stand?00:27:11
such a task00:27:12
Start to force this here00:27:14
automation, I think that’s just not it00:27:18
so that it’s the other way around but just the other end00:27:20
you start not uh Socialism will be00:27:23
try to force robotization00:27:25
on the contrary, robotization automation will00:27:28
raise the question of socialism00:27:30
simply because capitalism00:27:33
built You exploit living labor and00:27:36
exploiting living labor you simultaneously00:27:37
you create a consumer for yourself, you understand A00:27:41
this is a mutual connection with mass00:27:44
robotization is disappearing and the economy must00:27:47
be built slightly under another00:27:48
principles therefore precisely00:27:50
objective tendency towards00:27:52
robotization is being created at the same time00:27:54
objective possibilities of need00:27:55
Socialist solutions00:27:58
Yes, but it seems that under capitalism it’s like this00:28:01
full robotization to happen Looks like00:28:02
can't That's why Yes absolutely00:28:04
true, that's why it's necessary00:28:06
Socialism is also why00:28:11
ok thank you please so i will00:28:15
add people in advance then00:28:17
I will add and disable microphones and00:28:20
say in advance that including the microphone00:28:21
to prepare for something like that00:28:24
didn’t understand the meeting, but it’s already two00:28:26
person00:28:29
[music]00:28:30
next then00:28:32
I understand, I turn on the microphone00:28:34
[music]00:28:36
and talk00:28:51
I wanted to ask you00:28:53
historical question exists00:28:56
the opinion that the emergence of fascist regimes00:29:00
in Europe in the 30s it was00:29:02
caused, as it were, by fear of00:29:05
Soviet Union and if it weren’t for00:29:08
the Soviet Union, that is, it would be00:29:09
some kind of capitalist government00:29:11
how would this affect the political00:29:14
Genesis is in Germany, Hitler is the same00:29:17
came to power as in our reality00:29:19
you see, we can't talk about00:29:23
parallel reality because we are not00:29:25
we know how it all happened but00:29:27
actually speaking, I still wouldn’t say00:29:30
that fascism in Europe was associated before00:29:33
just with fear of the USSR But no matter how00:29:37
strange fear of the USSR with the same00:29:39
success even with great success you can00:29:41
explain and successes became democracy and00:29:44
introduction of any social policy measures00:29:48
I don't remember the authors, but here's my last one00:29:52
long digression in the book there is a link to00:29:55
a book by two Scandinavian historians00:29:58
which are called Bolshevik00:30:00
roots of the welfare state That is00:30:02
how did the Russian revolution affect00:30:05
various kinds of social reform in00:30:07
Western countries, first of all, of course00:30:09
Scandinavian countries even more so Here they are00:30:11
there were nearby and that's why I00:30:15
I think there is a broader process00:30:17
a fairly common point of view00:30:19
and it seems to me in general that she doesn’t know00:30:23
fully or partially but still true00:30:25
or at least it contains00:30:26
grain of truth that fascism is the answer to00:30:31
A crisis00:30:33
capitalism in the form in which it00:30:35
existed then in the twenties and00:30:38
at the same time answer part part00:30:42
ruling class for the rise of the working class00:30:45
movement of various kinds of other radical00:30:47
anti-system movements and this is it00:30:50
combination of Cree when up ruling plate00:30:52
speed does not know what to do and growth00:30:55
system calls from the Worker00:30:58
class from all sorts of others00:31:00
radical left and populist left00:31:03
movements is pushing part of the ruling00:31:07
class so let's go00:31:09
let's take everything that is called hard under00:31:13
control00:31:14
Let's let these black guys rise to power00:31:16
shirts even if we don't like them00:31:18
cute because in a different way00:31:21
We can’t handle it sooner on our own, but here we go00:31:23
then maybe we can figure it out somehow00:31:26
I repeat this quite often00:31:29
meeting opinions I think very00:31:32
biggest in the world right Did he play here00:31:34
some role Soviet Union Yes partly00:31:37
Maybe, but I think it's not the most00:31:39
the main thing is at least not the only thing00:31:42
so yes00:31:45
So00:31:47
some historians claim that00:31:50
Hitler was financed by various circles00:31:54
capitalist including00:31:55
American British so that he is just00:31:57
destroyed communism Well destroyed00:32:00
understand communism first00:32:04
I don't even know how we know this information00:32:07
there is information on financing00:32:12
Hitler's party in00:32:15
book00:32:17
Alexander Abramovich Galkin00:32:20
I don’t remember the name of the book about fascism00:32:23
but in general Alexander can Google it00:32:25
Galkin and there it is very well shown there00:32:28
there is data because after the crash00:32:31
the Nazi regime raised accounting00:32:33
who financed it was published00:32:36
there were large German concerns but00:32:39
It's interesting that many of them00:32:40
They financed not only Hitler00:32:42
financed many other parties then00:32:44
there theyare00:32:46
Well, throughout the spectrum, communists of course00:32:49
They didn’t give me any money, I became a democrat too, but00:32:51
some even center-left parties00:32:53
the group was sometimes financed by them00:32:57
these then tried to justify that we didn’t00:32:59
only the Nazis were given money and about00:33:02
some English or American00:33:04
financing00:33:06
Hitler's00:33:07
parties00:33:09
No data00:33:11
this is some speculation and that was the main thing00:33:14
there would be no need to understand, why?00:33:16
the British bourgeoisie to finance00:33:19
game which is tasked with revenge00:33:23
Germany in the war against England and France00:33:26
just think for yourself Yes because00:33:28
primary entrepreneurship00:33:30
geopolitical task00:33:31
guitarism was a struggle against England and00:33:35
France and it’s not just by chance00:33:37
it turned out that means at first they fought00:33:39
against the French and then against them00:33:42
There is no USSR, but a revision of Versailles00:33:45
treaties and the fight against the French00:33:53
the most important task of the communists00:33:56
[music]00:34:06
so let me remind you once again what for00:34:09
those who just connected what questions00:34:10
Today we are asking in discord a link to00:34:13
Discord is in the description of both the stream and00:34:15
pinned comments up So who00:34:18
wants to join there is a separate one00:34:20
channel with broadcast where it is duplicated00:34:22
and you can join if you want00:34:24
ask a question be sure to raise00:34:25
hand so that I understand that you can00:34:27
add when I add you to you00:34:29
notifications come with which you should00:34:31
agree that you are ready to join00:34:33
to your request I turn off the microphone and00:34:35
you stand in line for several00:34:37
people actually staples I'm like this00:34:40
I understand you asked a question and I remind you that00:34:44
donation questions are not asked today00:34:47
Of course you can donate a lot00:34:50
a lot of donations have already arrived today00:34:52
messages just thank you for00:34:54
broadcast well like that Yes Thank you very much00:34:58
for those who send Donat so uh next00:35:01
e As I said in Archa, let’s turn it on00:35:04
microphone00:35:07
Oh hello hello00:35:10
microphone works00:35:12
uncle is just really constant00:35:16
Akora subscriber and I’m already somewhere00:35:18
For six months I have been asking the same questions about00:35:20
Walter Benjamin but on the podium they say00:35:22
usually not about your favorite thing about the island00:35:24
social therefore the question is00:35:27
Putin's government isn't exactly00:35:30
now with all this Yes, but still 200000:35:34
years she essentially changed the policy00:35:37
privatization on more such jardistic00:35:40
reasons in that00:35:42
body privatization is more based on00:35:44
rent etc. And is it possible00:35:47
to say that in general the privatization process00:35:49
many economic processes in Russia00:35:51
They have such more vegetarian00:35:54
character rather than liberal00:35:56
but you see, there is a general point of view00:35:59
that some00:36:01
degrading regions of Russia have long lived00:36:03
in an ancap situation they just don’t talk about it00:36:07
know and00:36:08
Mikhail Svetov doesn’t know about this yet either00:36:11
But00:36:13
How can I tell you there is an element of this00:36:16
here is spontaneous libertarianism with00:36:19
sides of the Russian ruling class00:36:22
parts Oddly enough Russian00:36:24
officials who believe that it is necessary00:36:28
just everything00:36:29
give uh not even to the market at all00:36:32
give it somewhere yes What doesn’t matter Well, I see00:36:35
what could we, uh, steal? What?00:36:39
we can't steal, let's say someone00:36:40
takes it away and something might turn out like this00:36:42
this is given in the regions, but to me00:36:45
it seems that in relation to large00:36:47
the mechanism still works for structures00:36:49
such a completely traditional privatization00:36:51
let's see by the way they are new now00:36:54
preparing privatization programs I hope00:36:55
that it will not be implemented but in00:36:58
anyway we'll see what happens00:37:00
introduce00:37:07
but I know that there are major works on00:37:11
military sociology such as00:37:12
Proudhon's War and Peace but here's how it works00:37:17
military sociology for example in relation00:37:19
to the current conflict If the enemy00:37:21
consists of the zoological process00:37:22
exercise when people in the trenches howl at00:37:25
on the front there every day you can die00:37:27
this is how it is carried out under such conditions00:37:29
some pathological studies Well00:37:31
strictly speaking, they are not carried out Although00:37:33
I remind you that ours are also regular authors00:37:37
comrade Alexander Rybin how he led00:37:40
he was involved in the research00:37:42
observation in the fourteenth year in00:37:44
Lugansk militia, what did he do? Well00:37:46
I just went to join the militia and signed up00:37:51
received00:37:53
How to say00:37:55
order to be00:37:59
garden How to say mortar fighter00:38:02
commands and carried the mortar pipe to00:38:06
yourself on the way00:38:07
interviewed his comrades00:38:12
militia In general, I collected quite a lot00:38:14
great materials Well, I'm risking my life Yes00:38:18
completely understandable, but another example00:38:21
this is what the Ukrainian side did00:38:25
not on Tatarskaya00:38:26
which00:38:28
studied a woman in conflict conditions00:38:31
That is, she spent a lot of time00:38:35
on the line of contact but that was all00:38:37
until the age of 22, naturally, she was both00:38:41
sides00:38:42
the lines of this division of the so-called and00:38:47
the women themselves about how they00:38:50
perceive what is happening00:38:52
quite big so important00:38:54
the research she did so00:38:58
Research is being done, but it’s only qualitative00:39:01
what is called not just of course00:39:02
research00:39:05
Please00:39:15
so next then00:39:19
so I turned on the microphone I won’t use a better nickname00:39:22
pronounce00:39:26
Who we have now is all so blurry00:39:28
you can say this00:39:32
still silent00:39:36
looks like the person has problems with the microphone but00:39:39
dear viewers, stay tuned00:39:43
microphones right because man00:39:45
didn't fix it00:39:47
the very first one was00:39:51
but let's next one then okay00:39:55
not guilty honestly00:40:00
then MT Space00:40:03
including microphone00:40:06
Can you hear me Hello Boris Yurievich00:40:09
hello all listeners00:40:11
present speakers at my podium00:40:13
literally 3-4 small questions like this00:40:16
Well, I'll probably start with the first one00:40:19
concerns me and many including00:40:24
regional leftists What is called what00:40:26
you think about the Okies and how they are growing up00:40:29
in my opinion, by leaps and bounds every little bit00:40:32
maybe not every week but at some point00:40:35
cities beyond the Urals especially open00:40:37
almost a new department for example00:40:39
organization of communist nationalists yes00:40:41
meaning00:40:43
It seems like yesterday I don’t remember, well, in Barnaul00:40:46
For example, the organization I opened00:40:48
visiting circumstances literally there00:40:51
roughly speaking due to the fact that I'm resting00:40:54
Well, first of all, I’m very happy for them because00:40:57
that the guys are doing the right thing and00:41:01
you see, this is also very important because00:41:04
some organizations that00:41:06
pretends to be communist and00:41:09
seems to even hold brands00:41:11
communists Unfortunately occupied00:41:14
social-shay position saying here00:41:17
Lenin's language00:41:18
or whatever militaristic position we want00:41:22
you understand perfectly well what I mean00:41:25
as a result But people I understand00:41:28
which previously focused either on00:41:30
The Communist Party of the Russian Federation is either on paintwork or on00:41:34
official guide of the krp or rare00:41:38
case, but sometimes even this happens00:41:39
communists in Russia because uh00:41:42
regions, everything is very unique and00:41:44
here and there quite decent people who00:41:47
were00:41:48
expelled from the Communist Party of the Russian Federation did not find another place00:41:50
for myself Except for the communists of Russia Although00:41:52
of course it is00:41:54
horror horror-horror But but nevertheless Well00:41:57
settled down somewhere and all these00:42:02
official habitual communist00:42:03
brands anyway In my opinion00:42:05
are now clearly compromised and here00:42:07
an organization of communists appears00:42:09
Internationalists who claim that00:42:12
we are against there we are against And we stand on00:42:15
communist police we are quite00:42:17
We stand on Lenin’s positions, let’s remember that00:42:20
Lenin spoke and made time First00:42:22
world war and therefore their growth is quite00:42:24
naturally Well, the second point again00:42:26
uh in the regions you yourself say why there00:42:30
all this is growing because it's not so00:42:33
there are many organizations to join00:42:35
now by the way speaking uh some00:42:38
organization exactly here Anti00:42:42
militaristic let's say00:42:44
opposed00:42:47
theirs and so on, but now they are not like00:42:51
they grow everywhere but they are everywhere somehow00:42:52
start to attract people's attention00:42:55
With00:42:57
first of all with looks and if they are alive00:43:01
these organizations If not destroyed if00:43:03
they are capable if they are visible then contact them00:43:06
people are starting to join in. It's very00:43:08
good process very correct but I00:43:10
I think that in the future of course there will be00:43:11
there will be an integration of different lefts00:43:14
initiatives and groups are not a single thing00:43:18
necessarily homogeneous yes it is possible00:43:20
there will be some kind of Federation of coalition and00:43:22
so on but I see it as uh part00:43:26
very cool very natural process00:43:29
no more questions00:43:33
three questions three questions said Yes you are00:43:37
tell me three questions00:43:40
they're small, just let's go00:43:44
It’s precisely in the regions that there are problems in00:43:47
that organizations really00:43:49
some that you can join00:43:51
having some different views of their own00:43:53
there are leftists there, they don’t bread you like that00:43:57
no If you remember Krasnoyarsk for example00:43:59
also my second homeland is essentially a city00:44:02
millionaire where there is no practical00:44:05
opposition political scrap in00:44:08
principle The leader of public opinion and we00:44:12
with the guys we were just trying to create our own00:44:14
some kind of political about political00:44:16
a party that essentially claimed to be00:44:18
some kind of focus00:44:21
like this00:44:23
I see politics all over the city00:44:25
just because it's alternative00:44:27
there were no platforms Just corny00:44:30
Is it really so highly optimized and00:44:33
what can you do with this except00:44:36
like some kind of meditation or PR00:44:38
of their own associations00:44:40
but you know first of all really00:44:42
let’s say in Krasnoyarsk I can’t00:44:47
judge there by the way Andrey Vakulen recently00:44:49
already deceased there showed some00:44:55
I was almost his right hand00:44:58
one of ours, this mug here00:44:59
as a matter of fact, yes, you see, but here I am00:45:03
I came to Krasnoyarsk then, you know00:45:05
here What a thing and society in general00:45:08
optimized very politically probably00:45:10
not so much intimidated as00:45:13
confused and don’t see the possibility of something00:45:16
do Hmm I think there are Yes elements here00:45:21
there is fear, so I am deeply not only in00:45:24
fear did you know there are regimes00:45:26
worse than the current one, at least in00:45:28
in terms of domestic policy Here But here00:45:32
watch now in Yakutsk Andrey Danilov00:45:36
uh00:45:37
left the Communist Party of the Russian Federation and began to gather around himself00:45:39
people, specialists from Yakutia appeared like this00:45:43
coalition organization and now we see00:45:46
yes guys are growing and expanding00:45:51
Danilov will now run for office00:45:54
to the Yakutsk City Council Well, I see00:45:58
again the point is that we are great00:46:00
we understand that the world will not change because00:46:02
that will be elected to the city council but this00:46:05
a company around which can collect00:46:07
can bring people00:46:09
some kind of propaganda can be simple00:46:11
please pay attention to yourself00:46:13
noticed but because often people don’t00:46:16
they know, there are some two leftists sitting here00:46:18
maybe in one entrance or in neighboring ones00:46:21
entrances they have no idea what they are00:46:23
each other and when they begin to connect00:46:25
uh then suddenly you find out there are two and three00:46:29
much more00:46:34
Well, the second little one is quite real00:46:38
here's a little question what do you think about00:46:40
such an organization that has existed for a year00:46:42
s 5 7 Like Ole FSB Well, yes00:46:47
all the time he even says something not Elvis00:46:50
yes And the lion SD Here00:46:54
good Another one of those leftists00:46:57
[music]00:46:59
democratic organization00:47:02
They are also present in some chats00:47:05
and I think I even visited them a couple of times00:47:10
that is, it is connected with them in projects but00:47:13
[music]00:47:18
I think that00:47:20
this one is more juicy there00:47:23
organization but you know what I said00:47:30
yep so no more questions yes00:47:33
last microquestion microwave questions00:47:36
games00:47:39
yes, when you stream with subscribers in games from00:47:43
Paradox intractive00:47:45
Heroes Kruzak Europe so on we are bye00:47:49
couldn't even cope with children's elision00:47:53
I was able to pass it, we can handle it with Rome00:47:56
There are no special problems, just how not00:47:58
we can finish it but I don’t know I don’t know00:48:03
I just don’t have time to play everything yet00:48:06
write a swamp, well, in general, we’ll try00:48:08
do more game streams but00:48:12
sorry we can't cope00:48:15
[music]00:48:19
so Tyler is next then uh and00:48:23
preparing underscore dissent00:48:25
so with Tyler's keys00:48:30
Hello Hello00:48:36
I would first like to join00:48:40
thanks to one of the speakers you00:48:42
you are really doing a very good job00:48:43
and I would like to say the following that I00:48:48
I want to note that one of the features00:48:50
worker correspondent has always been in close contact with00:48:52
viewer and streams with live communication in00:48:55
Discord is probably one of the best00:48:57
there would be more breakthroughs in this direction00:49:00
such participation, especially your participation in00:49:03
life of the server and more like this00:49:07
broadcasts more often Visit the channel00:49:11
questions for00:49:12
I will definitely come in just not00:49:15
I can handle it. Honestly, I don’t have time.00:49:17
listen to you00:49:19
my question00:49:21
yesterday it was dedicated to yesterday's discussion00:49:25
which took place in Molodezhny00:49:28
university of modern socialism00:49:30
which was dedicated00:49:33
June 24 my question is that many leftists00:49:38
Media 24th00:49:40
they said it was necessary immediately00:49:43
develop a number of measures while operations00:49:45
coordination of movement mobilization in00:49:47
Russia to work out00:49:49
a joint answer to the horror that awaited us00:49:52
Besides, just a couple of days ago00:49:55
incident occurred by the commander of the 58th Army00:49:58
Major General Popov and actually00:50:02
question How to promote work in this00:50:05
direction if there are already some results00:50:07
about this if there is already some00:50:09
Organization or as soon as ended00:50:12
all companions all companions in this00:50:15
direction abruptly ended when we00:50:17
we'll see some kind of left force on00:50:19
political arena and00:50:22
What an experience00:50:24
leftist organization in Russia You are in that00:50:28
including personally00:50:30
learned from the events of June 2400:50:35
Well first of all the work is going on00:50:38
I’m not talking about the fact that it’s just June 2400:50:42
right after00:50:43
all the time just real time00:50:47
there were consultation contacts and so on00:50:49
That is, well, I just can’t tell you in detail00:50:53
tell who called whom What00:50:57
discussed and so on00:50:59
yes if this quantity is Dasha00:51:02
social life but it shouldn't00:51:05
be too streetwise that's it00:51:08
in general, well, we walked almost constantly00:51:13
some negotiations discussion00:51:17
I don't see any reason to be so crazy00:51:20
be nervous because00:51:22
we will still have events we will uh00:51:26
at the first stage while we are not00:51:29
main characters anyway00:51:33
we'll be a little behind00:51:36
and nothing can be done about it but00:51:38
this is how the story develops00:51:40
But00:51:42
communication contacts00:51:45
that information coordination of positions is00:51:49
goes What is called constantly in real00:51:50
time and00:51:52
there is all of course one moment when00:51:55
will need to go out relatively speaking00:51:57
raise some kind of common flag in which00:51:59
form it’s not entirely clear yet, but I00:52:03
I'll tell you what this means in general. Well, uh00:52:07
a significant part of the main actors00:52:09
the flank is ready and there are no special problems with it00:52:13
it will be that it can be done quite00:52:14
fast, the main thing is that there is no false start00:52:17
Because there is always a risk that00:52:20
Well, you start crowing too early and00:52:24
then nothing blooms00:52:26
So00:52:29
I got it Thanks for the answer and actually00:52:33
connection with this incident when preparing00:52:42
I think it will be sooner00:52:45
military-political military hardware00:52:47
some more complex combined00:52:50
riot00:52:52
even a revolution will be something more00:52:54
combined but something will be a hundred00:52:57
percent00:52:59
Thanks again thank you for your00:53:03
hand over the work00:53:05
my thanks to the cat Stepan of course00:53:10
until the next one then gums just let's00:53:14
not very long good Everything turned on00:53:18
microphone Maybe I'm answering for too long00:53:20
damn, just a shorter answer00:53:24
Hello00:53:29
I have a question00:53:31
modern organizations00:53:35
precisely of the Marxist persuasion00:53:39
I understand that you don't have time00:53:42
keep track of their call, not that much00:53:44
figure it out00:53:45
here I have00:53:48
when was choosing which organization00:53:50
I had three organizations to speak to00:53:52
rsd Roth Front Union of Marxists was still00:53:58
And so I wanted to ask which one00:54:01
organization personally you can00:54:02
recommend and what you can each00:54:04
from these organizations say Well rsd is00:54:07
this is the most advanced00:54:09
intellectual personnel of the organization with00:54:12
standing in such positions00:54:14
the orthodox euro left that is there00:54:17
there must be a lot of feminism00:54:19
things are easier there for everyone00:54:22
there is again no need to understand me So00:54:25
that I’m against it, but I’m just recording that00:54:27
this is it like this00:54:28
there is a different kind of orthodoxy, so to speak00:54:31
old Marxist orthodoxy this is00:54:33
new00:54:34
Orthodoxy they adhere to very clearly00:54:37
but good So they stick with it later00:54:40
Rot Front Well, I don’t really understand00:54:44
because00:54:46
all sorts of changes took place there and now00:54:49
for example, I don’t really understand that’s how I understand it00:54:51
that Sasha Batov aside now Roth00:54:54
Front or not Rot Front what even if00:54:57
I don’t follow him a little, but in any case00:54:59
case this is so more orthodox00:55:01
traditional organization here00:55:06
Leninist persuasion What else did you say?00:55:10
Okay, it's just a new organization.00:55:13
relatively new just now00:55:14
is being formed00:55:15
Yes00:55:18
Alexander is standing there00:55:22
the most famous personalities are00:55:24
really like that00:55:27
probably the most organization00:55:40
Well, what you like is what they00:55:42
formed00:55:47
[music]00:55:52
missed one detail Yes00:55:56
and the new red ones Oh yes Well yes the new red ones00:56:01
these are new colors00:56:02
Komsomol is also the result of a split or00:56:05
stirring inside one of the Komsomol00:56:11
result00:56:18
I’m in favor of making it as wide as possible00:56:21
unite at the same time understand I don't00:56:24
I think that all organizations need00:56:26
What is called mixing into a homogeneous00:56:29
mass Let there be different currents And let00:56:32
there will be disagreements Let there be differences00:56:33
ideological roots I don't see it00:56:36
Problems00:56:38
I again try to cooperate with00:56:42
by everyone who stands on the internationalist00:56:44
positions fundamentally to the issue00:56:46
social00:56:48
you understand, yes, then I think that00:56:54
now the most important broad association00:56:56
a Specifically, people very often choose not00:56:59
organization from other people with whom00:57:01
they have contacts with whom00:57:03
normal mutual understanding even if00:57:05
we will take an ideological topic then we00:57:07
We understand perfectly well that guys00:57:09
from prime numbers Where Oleg belongs00:57:12
Komolov They're probably not quite00:57:13
identical in00:57:15
his00:57:17
let's say to the ideologems Yes, but they have00:57:21
some general ones00:57:22
in general00:57:24
resultant What is this called?00:57:27
anti-capitalism and00:57:29
undoubtedly00:57:32
methodological-economic thinking A00:57:35
further Here they have gathered into a team00:57:38
the team works so it's very00:57:41
it is important not just to choose a physiological00:57:42
organization and to join such a team00:57:45
which will work if you have00:57:47
which are easy and interesting for you and most importantly00:57:51
effective But can give Soviet00:57:53
work00:57:54
adjoin understanding By the way, something from you00:57:57
what depends? That is, you too can have yours00:57:59
participation somehow influence including00:58:01
the image of this organization00:58:05
Thank you very much for your answer please00:58:08
very wise man he finished his liver00:58:11
Well, let's say there's no need to get distracted00:58:15
yes On other topics just enough time00:58:18
strongly00:58:19
So00:58:23
By the way, how do you feel? Well00:58:27
you know, if people just sit and00:58:30
read texts, that's good, but there is00:58:33
problems that this can and will end00:58:36
That's why00:58:38
when everything just appeared at once00:58:40
warned the guys from this party not00:58:42
there will be a merger of study circles00:58:45
Marxism will not turn out to be a party. Well,00:58:47
the party didn't work out shouldn't00:58:50
turn out But if these are mugs00:58:51
self-education or vice versa some kind of environment00:58:55
where the Marxist community is formed00:58:58
thinking mostly young people00:59:00
but why not? What's wrong with that?00:59:04
Well, rather the second reason is actually00:59:07
which I ask this question and not00:59:09
any other is what I am00:59:12
I'm trying to figure out for myself which one00:59:14
organization suits me better while I00:59:16
look at people00:59:19
Marxists look at people where you want00:59:22
more comfortable and where it can bring00:59:24
more benefit00:59:26
it was comfortable00:59:28
[music]00:59:35
[music]00:59:39
So00:59:41
landing is all right00:59:43
So here it is00:59:49
if the question is very short01:00:26
ok Let people be with me or with us01:00:29
will contact you and we will think about how this is possible01:00:32
organize and how to arrange it01:00:34
everything moves on so well to the next one01:00:37
Thank you01:00:38
So I before there is the word Now01:00:42
I'll tell you01:00:43
at most, in my opinion, it’s already simple01:00:46
a lot of people the next maximum will be me01:00:48
before that I wanted to remind you that if you01:00:50
exactly like the apartment here you can01:00:52
support him with a donation via Discord there01:00:54
It’s not called rubbing, in my opinion, I’m turning it on01:00:59
microphone maximum01:01:01
Hello Boris Yuriy reporter team01:01:04
All viewers01:01:06
two short questions so specific and01:01:10
a little down to earth compared to01:01:12
by what Boris Yuryevich said from above you01:01:14
support any in any form01:01:16
relationship with Georgy Fedorov, considering01:01:19
that you were good friends01:01:21
I was nineteen01:01:22
I answer right away I don’t communicate with him now01:01:25
I'm really really upset01:01:28
what is happening now with Georgy or01:01:31
with the decision he made01:01:34
when did he decide to join?01:01:36
a fair Russia and at that same time01:01:39
the moment when other people left there01:01:41
I told him directly Well, even me now01:01:44
I’ll say we sat and talked with him.01:01:47
I was even a little confused and just didn’t01:01:49
said what needed to be said01:01:52
then I wrote a letter about this here01:01:54
honestly I won’t guide you he01:01:57
wrote a letter that he is doing very01:01:59
wrong choice and what is wrong01:02:01
free choice patent with you more01:02:03
things that I will regret later01:02:06
I am deeply confident that this will happen later01:02:09
I don’t feel very good about being sorry01:02:11
I think this is very01:02:13
Decency Generally a decent person01:02:14
which is really like01:02:17
it says01:02:19
support01:02:22
and so on, but he did a number of very, very01:02:26
wrong decisions01:02:30
Yeah but I want his excuse What01:02:33
called notice on recent01:02:35
conferences held by the club01:02:37
angry Patriots, he's the only one there01:02:40
my only one who put forward the left01:02:42
agenda And besides, he did it so contentedly01:02:44
convincingly and boldly But that’s exactly what I’m doing01:02:47
that he said that I feel for him01:02:48
still with respect and and just01:02:51
humanly very good we more than once01:02:53
they helped each other and it’s quite possible01:02:55
To interact more in the future01:02:59
Thank you yes And the second question is related to01:03:03
rabkor policy from rabkor thanks01:03:05
you have always been famous for being invited01:03:08
not only people from their left01:03:11
Mug movements to a variety of01:03:13
political views there Sobchak before01:03:16
porridge for example, but I understand that you don’t01:03:20
want to see those who clearly support01:03:22
yours now Yes, this is so important01:03:25
your position is new01:03:27
She was always fundamentally01:03:29
case if certain boundaries01:03:30
you see, we haven’t invited you before, well01:03:33
for example, here's a few simple ones01:03:36
periodically we were told to invite01:03:38
which are actually purely01:03:41
humanly speaking, if periodically01:03:42
I've come across this, but he's not a bad guy01:03:45
actually just between you and me But man01:03:48
who nevertheless nevertheless led01:03:51
let her at a certain stage in her01:03:53
life but like this01:03:55
chauvinistic Russian Propaganda but01:03:58
We01:03:59
we can't invite him even though01:04:01
not everything he says is complete nonsense01:04:03
and sometimes there are some sensible thoughts01:04:06
but there are certain limits01:04:08
let's say now I think that for us01:04:12
a principled position is a position01:04:13
antibiolitaristic01:04:17
Okay ok thank you and that's it01:04:20
good01:04:21
So01:04:23
so so so next person d well01:04:27
the person hid the nickname D ellipsis and behind it01:04:29
getting ready01:04:31
Roman is turning on the microphone01:04:36
Good afternoon good evening01:04:39
Yes01:04:41
I didn't hide01:04:45
I have a question01:04:47
already asked once on the last stream on01:04:50
about the arrest01:04:52
deputy ministers figures The question is01:04:55
the dirt on the top has begun, trying to friend01:04:58
imprison a friend01:05:02
By the way, after your question I looked01:05:05
I still haven’t found what they are01:05:07
specifically now they are dividing because there01:05:09
clearly divide something is going on01:05:12
redistribution is possible just01:05:14
digital resources01:05:15
probably some very serious ones01:05:17
money flows are divided, again taking into account01:05:21
that all these people adore us01:05:23
digitalization01:05:24
there is a holiday today there is something there01:05:27
are fuming about this01:05:29
so there is some very01:05:32
[music]01:05:34
the porridge turned out delicious, but this one specifically01:05:37
I can't comment on the story because01:05:40
that I still haven’t found it, hmm01:05:44
how and what happened in this01:05:47
specific case But what is going on is a struggle01:05:50
about the top and the struggle at the top has already begun What01:05:52
called for destruction I'm in it01:05:53
deeply confident and this is what it means even01:05:56
not the first bell, but the sound is sooner01:05:59
even01:06:02
this is the last question if you can01:06:04
comment about this01:06:07
recent withdrawal01:06:10
lieutenant general01:06:12
fifty-eighth Well, we already asked01:06:14
you see, I’ll also say that it’s clear that01:06:17
This01:06:18
indirectly related to the Prigozhin case, but I01:06:21
I don't think this is a pure continuation01:06:23
do Prigogine I think that by the way01:06:25
guys Very good outside the war This is01:06:28
commented there is one01:06:29
telegram channel is not war but Yes01:06:33
I've had to come here a couple of times too01:06:35
write some small messages01:06:38
They correctly said that this is it01:06:41
General like Popov it turned out that01:06:44
called between a rock and a hard place01:06:46
that is, on the one hand, growing01:06:48
dissatisfaction in the troops of this Judging by01:06:49
everything is a fact, including01:06:51
mobilized including this for sure01:06:53
conditional captains major lieutenant colonels01:07:02
which is also not united and is still going on there01:07:05
squabble ah-and major general by the way01:07:08
This is a very interesting position01:07:11
must answer I'm very sorry for the title01:07:14
interesting title yes title uh why01:07:16
because mmm it's like the oldest01:07:20
from uh from senior officers not yet01:07:23
generals and vice versa the youngest01:07:25
generals that is, that is01:07:28
major general yes he is already a general of course01:07:30
but he hasn't come off yet, here's the colonel01:07:34
Lieutenant Colonel Mayorov there and so on01:07:35
and on the other side he’s already here01:07:38
general status and it is clear that01:07:41
it is people in such ranks who very often01:07:43
turn out to be conductors of some kind01:07:45
always going from bottom to top And here he is01:07:48
tries to do it but01:07:51
In general, of course the signal will not get through. This01:07:53
It's clear01:07:56
How do you feel about the writers' strike?01:08:00
and actors in America this01:08:02
even look01:08:05
positively of course Look in01:08:07
rabkor the latest most sex that I01:08:10
I managed to make a review video there so far01:08:14
the whole fragment is just screenwriters01:08:27
Thank you for what you do Thank you01:08:31
You feel so good01:08:33
next then01:08:35
Novel01:08:37
and I will repeat again that if you want01:08:41
ask a question, then you need to go to the link in01:08:44
Discord and there will be a special channel01:08:47
and if he fixes the microphone, raise your hand01:08:51
I immediately add you to our donor01:08:55
So another microphone of the novel01:08:57
so Hello, I have two questions01:09:03
If I have time, a very short third01:09:04
the first question I heard from many people01:09:08
very different opinions on01:09:10
material condition of the Soviet people01:09:12
Union That is, it was conditionally like01:09:15
the master rode and let’s say that at 14001:09:18
rubles it was very difficult to survive and now01:09:22
it was some kind of paradise and I would like to hear01:09:25
the opinion of a person who has lived in01:09:27
Soviet Union Didn't have time to explore this01:09:30
the topic in more depth, how after all01:09:32
average Soviet person01:09:33
lived in terms of that there in terms of products in01:09:36
in terms of clothing and then I think so01:09:39
Soviet operas, of course, some lived better01:09:41
others understand one thing worse01:09:44
Moscow intelligentsia who01:09:46
especially something so creative01:09:49
prosperous woman who lived at a glance01:09:52
very good and complained the most01:09:54
Well, well, yes, that's another thing people in01:09:59
some small provincial01:10:01
town that is, very differently but but A01:10:04
I think so that the Soviet man lived01:10:06
not bad but meager, you see in01:10:08
what's the matter that is why exactly01:10:09
this intelligentsia complained and therefore01:10:12
that on the one hand this is everything necessary01:10:14
for life01:10:15
was and was available and was01:10:19
Well as a rule01:10:23
It's inexpensive, that is, it wasn't needed01:10:26
save or save for a long time in order to01:10:29
get everything you need for life01:10:32
on the other hand, as soon as you01:10:35
went beyond the basic necessary01:10:37
very serious things could start here01:10:39
problems in terms of what is needed01:10:41
speculators were buying it01:10:43
accordingly you had no money and01:10:45
in terms of the fact that there was simply a shortage of something01:10:47
But something didn’t happen at all. Well, then01:10:49
all these complaints about the deficiency begin01:10:51
there are, as it were, two levels, you know, that is01:10:53
the first level is the level of what you need01:10:55
you just need well in order to live and01:10:58
that's it in general one way or another01:11:00
Soviet man was but but but if01:11:03
want to live more diversely01:11:04
brightly more richly Well then they arose01:11:07
problems and this does not mean that01:11:09
the problem could not be solved by these problems01:11:11
it was possible to solve they were decided by people but01:11:13
Damn, this is exactly the problem. Well, then01:11:15
depends on how you felt about it01:11:18
there will be different sensations, that is, if01:11:19
the person was generally pleased and01:11:23
for his existence or if he01:11:26
solved these problems very easily01:11:27
next level that also happened that's all01:11:31
ok Yes if he was either extremely01:11:34
dissatisfied Or, on the contrary, these problems He01:11:36
could not decide stubbornly due to a number of01:11:39
household01:11:41
reasons or And that means again from the region01:11:44
so many01:11:46
there were differences between01:11:48
cities by level of supply between01:11:50
other than that there were supply categories after all01:11:52
remember uh yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes yes01:11:58
well, it’s not even about the Far North01:12:01
there were just cities, cities were closed01:12:03
were Well, through Moscow Leningrad01:12:06
I think what else has anyone submitted to this01:12:08
category there is Moscow Leningrad plus01:12:11
closed cities of some kind01:12:12
Arzamas There are 16, in my opinion that’s generally true01:12:15
better than in Moscow it was and in Moscow01:12:17
carried some things, well, you know01:12:19
yes if you applied to some category01:12:21
people who received the order, let's say yes01:12:24
so-called order or some01:12:26
special distributor And such people too01:12:28
there was a lot01:12:29
enterprise status and so on01:12:33
there could even very well be01:12:34
skilled workers or engineers01:12:35
then everything was fine with you, the other one is the same01:12:38
definitely an engineer at another company01:12:39
less rich less powerful less01:12:42
status and suddenly it turns out that something is01:12:45
his colleague for the same 1450 and 140-150 rubles01:12:49
gets But another person gets01:12:52
neighboring enterprise receive the same01:12:54
140-150 rubles and not a damn thing about this01:12:56
can't get you understand what you have01:12:58
there is no closed distributor on01:13:00
the enterprise of some other vouchers there01:13:03
there’s something else in Czechoslovakia you don’t understand01:13:05
Therefore, this is the first basic01:13:08
the foundation looked like And then start01:13:10
diversity problems started at all01:13:12
very big01:13:14
I understand you, thank you very much. Very much01:13:16
detailed answer and my second question01:13:18
concerns01:13:19
social democracy as such, that is, I01:13:22
not very much left I just had01:13:24
I have friends who are in serious trouble01:13:26
difficult situation and I understand01:13:28
why do they need to be supported?01:13:30
if it supported conditional01:13:31
state they wouldn't have problems Well01:13:34
I understand why the market is bad in this01:13:35
situations that is, Why do we Okay01:13:38
arrange government support A01:13:40
that's when a person starts his own business and01:13:42
it grows to some point even01:13:43
social democracy as far as I understand01:13:45
discourse helmets this is all somehow not01:13:48
considered wrong at least01:13:49
that's exactly what I saw a lot01:13:50
expressed this account that01:13:52
social democracy still Well, bad01:13:54
exactly the presence of a market, that's how it is01:13:56
It’s impossible in life to understand anything at all01:14:00
case again, it doesn’t even matter if you like it01:14:03
you or I don't like it but01:14:05
Mark the market01:14:07
it doesn’t work, it might break itself by the way01:14:10
how was the time of war communism and so01:14:12
further And then the question will not be01:14:14
so that the damn communists cancel01:14:15
the market is that the market canceled itself01:14:18
and therefore the Damned come to power01:14:19
communists because no one but them01:14:22
can no longer cope with this situation because01:14:23
that they at least understand that01:14:24
what to do in this situation But in principle01:14:27
Well, yes, a planned economy It may well01:14:31
include market elements01:14:33
Fine01:14:34
and that is, here we are talking about complete01:14:37
destruction is relatively speaking if01:14:39
man built his own I'm just trying01:14:42
find this comman Ground Since01:14:44
for a while he is a master right away01:14:46
as soon as the master01:14:49
hard so hard orthodox01:14:53
communist but I'll tell you I think that01:14:57
we need to be more pragmatic and more01:14:59
realistic but uh yeah Socialism is not01:15:05
about the market but this does not mean that communism01:15:07
or even more so Socialism means how01:15:11
ideology as an approach what is needed01:15:13
ban everything immediately or uh everything01:15:16
cancel market relations because01:15:17
it just won’t work and I remind you that01:15:20
even steel in general eh didn’t do it but01:15:23
there are very instructive works01:15:26
Vladimir Rogovin Stalin in the LPR where01:15:31
show exactly how Stalin's01:15:32
economics using market systems01:15:35
Thank you very much if you have time alone01:15:38
very short question from myself very01:15:40
short there very short in what01:15:43
Dostoevsky Why did he shoot like that?01:15:45
talked with the guys who are philologists They01:15:47
they say that01:15:48
there were many writers similar But01:15:51
for some reason it was Dostoevsky who did this01:15:52
imprinted in history, literature and01:15:54
everywhere in general Well, it seems to me that01:15:57
Dostoevsky01:15:58
showed some very broken very01:16:01
dramatically the inner psychology of people01:16:03
Well, Tolstoy is also a great psychologist, but01:16:06
uh, Dostoevsky's heroes are more like that01:16:09
say01:16:10
more tense more01:16:13
dramatic within oneself and more uh as it were01:16:17
Extentively tragic that's probably how it is01:16:20
he means he signed up with a specialist for01:16:23
the West still needs to understand this too01:16:25
Thank you all very much01:16:31
so next01:16:34
the next one is how Lenin prepares the man01:16:39
with a nickname starting with ha So banks I01:16:43
including microphone01:16:47
oh they turned it on01:16:49
Hello Leningrad I have one like this01:16:52
question for you Boris Yuryevich01:16:55
interesting guests come but the most01:16:58
Safronov is interesting, but that’s not true01:17:02
have you ever thought about inviting01:17:06
Stream this as his Radikhovsky Leonid01:17:08
By the way, he’s quite Radikhovsky01:17:09
interestingly tells And without himself01:17:12
left Yes, he is more or less trying01:17:14
explain the essence of lineism and so on and me01:17:19
By the way, it’s depressing that there are some here01:17:21
characters love to make references very much01:17:24
on Meister and other Stalinist belts01:17:26
degenerates01:17:29
to visit the streams01:17:34
wrestling and other things in order, even a little01:17:38
familiar only I want to say Well01:17:40
please don't call anyone01:17:41
degenerate please01:17:47
I, too, am by no means a Stalinist.01:17:50
Bruta anti-Stalinist But I mean01:17:52
another thing is that it’s just our principle of no one01:17:55
never insults even if we01:17:58
people don't agree This is the first second01:18:01
Yes, it’s so interesting01:18:04
between you and me the author is so alive01:18:08
And by the way, he lives somewhere not very good01:18:10
far from me but really a long time ago01:18:12
I haven’t seen him, maybe we’ll even think about it01:18:15
only then then we’ll fly to you right away01:18:18
we invite too many liberals, well01:18:20
In general, thank you for the offer. We will have it.01:18:22
inmind01:18:23
Thank you01:18:24
so uh01:18:26
this is the next Mr. High01:18:29
microphone and getting ready01:18:32
[music]01:18:33
Yes01:18:38
[music]01:19:05
Alya Thank you01:19:08
so return the question01:19:11
so to speak, long ago since childhood01:19:15
diapers of leftist views and in general01:19:19
do what I lead01:19:27
no sound01:19:33
microphone turned off01:19:35
Hello01:19:37
Everything is fine, I'm just sorry01:19:40
The irony of fate was like this for me01:19:45
relatives came for this01:19:48
came now when mine began01:19:50
it's their turn to come01:20:01
let's go then01:20:05
Relatives always come somehow evil01:20:07
so you think then now he’ll ask a question01:20:10
then we'll be back01:20:15
[music]01:20:23
Yes01:20:26
actually I am01:20:28
[music]01:20:30
and I paid for such a team a year ago01:20:35
talented people and actually we are ours01:20:40
the situation is so interesting that I01:20:42
the man himself01:20:44
Marxist views01:20:48
cooperative although we are still well01:20:51
didn't register so let's say01:21:04
one American, so to speak, India01:21:07
developer who comes in handy01:21:09
treats others kindly01:21:12
developers of fan games and actually01:21:14
he even has this initiative01:21:18
what does it support01:21:20
fan games are popular here I am01:21:23
interesting, let's say we had01:21:25
socialist society would be01:21:27
it is acceptable that we would have some01:21:29
cooperative which01:21:31
collaborates with01:21:33
the person who owns the copyright01:21:36
rights She game community which we ourselves01:21:39
count and therefore We are obliged to01:21:42
laws01:21:43
That country, as it were, should be deducted, as it were01:21:46
Sasha's penny of income to him01:21:49
This could even exist.01:21:51
such an interesting situation in01:21:53
socialism Well, if we have one country01:21:56
where the socialists have already stopped01:21:58
there is no relationship in another yet01:22:00
maybe you need to do something01:22:04
respect the rights here is another question that I01:22:06
I think that socialist relations01:22:07
will be installed maybe01:22:09
unevenly but still gradually and01:22:13
quite quickly in different countries of the world and01:22:15
there is a very interesting question here01:22:17
what to do with ace rights because01:22:19
Well, by the way, by the way, you know there is01:22:22
In general, the differences in concept are the author's01:22:23
rights and01:22:24
intellectual property because01:22:27
that copyrights need something01:22:29
respect because otherwise they are just authors01:22:31
they will die of hunger but intellectual01:22:34
property is not about copyright01:22:35
rights are about corporate01:22:37
property when vice versa copyright01:22:39
rights are alienated in favor of the corporation in01:22:42
the benefit of large companies that are further01:22:44
are already trading these rights and so on01:22:46
is it precisely about alienation not about01:22:48
provision for alienation of copyrights01:22:50
right and in this sense it just seems to me01:22:53
copyright is good and normal01:22:55
Well, another thing is the scale of payments01:22:58
do matter but anyway01:23:00
copyright is ok and01:23:02
Naturally, but intellectual01:23:05
ownership when corporations own01:23:07
this alienation of real authors must01:23:10
creative rights is bad This is mine01:23:12
position but I think accordingly01:23:15
a new legal framework will be formed01:23:20
It was like they said that he was just a yes01:23:23
So then right away01:23:27
so to the smoke, that's who to the smoke01:23:31
I'm listening so I turned on the microphone01:23:35
Hello Boris, I am incredibly glad to see you01:23:39
see Yes I'm glad to hear01:23:44
I found your book there in Moscow01:23:50
I have a few interesting ones01:23:52
the first questions will be related to fight01:23:56
How do you feel about what's there?01:23:58
happens they are fighting01:24:00
justice or is it still something01:24:03
more complicated Well, you know, I'm with one01:24:06
sides01:24:11
These problems arise, among other things, due to01:24:14
because we immediately think that this is paradise01:24:15
earthly or if more than once we are earthly01:24:18
We understand that everything is very complicated01:24:19
difficulties problems but in general all of them01:24:22
they do it right and in general everything is there01:24:24
normal and in general This is already the one01:24:27
the most either01:24:30
vice versa Soviet01:24:34
workers' councils and so on, really01:24:38
in fact01:24:40
overall it is certainly very progressive01:24:43
phenomenon for the Middle East01:24:47
taking into account women's rights Labor01:24:50
relationships that are established01:24:51
enough after all01:24:54
based on01:24:56
respect for workers and so on, but not01:24:59
you have to think that everything is perfect there and that01:25:01
this corresponds to some ideal01:25:04
either Narco communism Or vice versa01:25:07
workers' socialism and so on well01:25:09
It’s just more complicated up close, of course.01:25:12
probably doesn't look so perfect01:25:14
beautiful but disappointment arises01:25:17
Just when you first imagine01:25:19
some too beautiful picture If01:25:21
you won't imagine uh then you01:25:24
there won't be any disappointment because01:25:25
I know a lot of people then gave birth01:25:27
began to criticize but also01:25:29
significant time because they01:25:31
they expected too much from her01:25:33
measure your expectations a little and then you01:25:35
see the real picture She's not like that01:25:37
bad01:25:40
the second question will be related to01:25:43
artificial intelligence What do you think?01:25:45
Is it possible that all functions01:25:48
control will be transferred to the systems01:25:51
which will be based on powerful01:25:53
neural networks and a revolution may take place01:25:57
generally absolutely no blood, that is, a thread01:26:00
any capitalists and artificial01:26:04
the intellect will be engaged01:26:06
redistribution of all resources Can01:26:09
is artificial intelligence01:26:11
take possession of some equivalent01:26:14
personality and cannot remove parasites01:26:19
you see, the point is that the first01:26:21
distribution does not happen like this01:26:22
a certain Optimum common to everyone01:26:25
this is the result of a balance of interests01:26:27
who also fight each other01:26:30
friend understand let's say01:26:31
Well, I always give an example of what you have01:26:34
there are limited resources01:26:36
resource for example some territory there01:26:38
how many square meters are there and alone01:26:41
they want to make a playground there01:26:42
others doggy playground and third01:26:46
parking lot here maybe01:26:49
you will find some compromise01:26:50
there may be no solution but anyway01:26:53
so here's the full program for everyone01:26:56
this simply won’t satisfy and01:26:58
uh That's why01:27:00
actually speaking, any human ones01:27:03
decisions related to interests interests01:27:05
will never be for everyone without exception01:27:08
the same and will never be so01:27:11
all interests could be fully01:27:14
immediately satisfy that is, someone01:27:15
you'll have to make room, you'll have to01:27:17
priority develop priorities in that01:27:20
numbers are developed not only based on01:27:22
some economic optics but based on01:27:26
ethical standards that in this01:27:28
community have developed. For example, we01:27:30
We think that cars are not very good01:27:33
great and uh and children are better but01:27:37
someone says no Children Of course they are01:27:39
so nasty are better than dogs01:27:40
that's what it means if in this community01:27:43
animals are valued higher then probably01:27:45
Maybe there will be a dog there after all01:27:47
the site first and then there will be01:27:49
look for another space already for01:27:51
children's playground in the third place already01:27:53
for a car Or maybe vice versa01:27:54
You see, he can say yes, well there01:27:57
Almost no one here has children, but01:27:59
car and everyone understands that is01:28:00
it depends each time01:28:03
specific alignment and balance of forces01:28:05
balance of interests01:28:07
artificial intelligence neural networks can01:28:09
they are very helpful in optimizing the solution01:28:12
can't make decisions they can01:28:14
optimize your decisions very much01:28:16
effectively, that’s their task01:28:18
By the way, right now, in general, again01:28:21
an important term that we have little01:28:22
thermopots are consumed Yes, the code is01:28:25
uh01:28:26
robots yes, that is, robots that01:28:29
work in collaboration with a person01:28:31
there is a person and he gives them a task and01:28:34
accordingly they help her01:28:37
noun or vice versa suggests01:28:39
What should a person do sooner or later for01:28:41
solutions to one or another problem that01:28:43
formulates himself And that's why I think that01:28:46
probably networks will not replace people01:28:51
artificial intelligence revolution but01:28:54
evolution01:29:01
And the next question is also related to01:29:04
artificial intelligence How is it01:29:06
will happen under communism but I01:29:09
already directly told how people will be01:29:12
use it if you even imagine01:29:13
you have some plans for the organ01:29:16
which should01:29:17
including as a result of expression of will01:29:20
people define tasks but priority01:29:25
have determined have already laid down these determined01:29:28
priorities formulated in01:29:30
artificial intelligence He has already calculated01:29:32
the most effective solution to these01:29:34
tasks that we democratically01:29:37
formulated01:29:39
so I mean artificial01:29:43
intelligence will be someone after all01:29:45
is being developed Well of course it will be01:29:49
is currently being developed with someone01:29:57
What exactly influenced what was there01:30:03
collapse or are they really there01:30:07
did something like that01:30:13
but it was the result of being on time01:30:15
brought reforms01:30:17
and the top was definitely reactionary01:30:19
but it didn’t just become reactionary either01:30:21
so suddenly everything was fine and01:30:24
appeared out of the blue What01:30:25
traction handle which is specially01:30:27
strangely collapsed No of course gradually01:30:29
the Soviet Union was decomposing01:30:32
bureaucracy its corruption01:30:35
turning into selfish01:30:37
a self-sufficient group which As a result01:30:39
Of course, he was already defending his interests further01:30:42
including falling apart01:30:44
but this group is not from the sky01:30:47
fell down she was grown from the very01:30:50
Soviet society here Come on01:30:52
after all, the next thing and let's then01:30:54
Now let's limit ourselves to one question01:31:02
How do you feel about the theory that01:31:05
The Soviet Union prepared one way or another01:31:08
a group of military men was formed01:31:10
industrialists together with generals01:31:12
which was beneficial and which01:31:14
participated directly in this no01:31:17
Well, what kind of Generals bourgeoised everyone01:31:21
and began to use Soviet01:31:24
leaders to promote their ideas01:31:26
Well, the decomposition was gradual Look01:31:29
again in a new book in debt01:31:31
retreat the whole head is just a union01:31:32
and including just about destruction01:31:34
Soviet Union for reasons that01:31:37
led to collapse that's why let's01:31:39
I'm sending texts now, look01:31:42
please just so everyone has time01:31:44
so that everyone has time to ask questions Who01:31:47
wants to give Let's try no more than one01:31:49
question you started the following is being prepared01:31:52
Mikhail, a person with01:31:55
Nickname starting south so Michael01:32:00
confused speak01:32:02
Hello Hello Yes yes01:32:05
Hello Bryce Yulich Hello Rabkor01:32:08
Thank you, of course, for your work in general with01:32:12
I enjoy reading your new book and01:32:14
this question has a lot to do with it01:32:17
I would like to ask if you are familiar with01:32:19
modern can be said to be a philosopher01:32:21
socialist Dmitry Wednesday That's it01:32:25
first No01:32:27
Dmitry Sereda has not read just now01:32:30
I'll write it down and look for it and watch it01:32:37
but he has translations recently made01:32:40
analytical Marxist translation01:32:43
I think it would be interesting if there is01:32:47
opportunity01:32:48
if they use your rhetoric like that01:32:51
he's more of an ethical socialist01:32:53
I think you would have01:32:56
gone missing01:32:58
but I understand In general Dmitry Sereda01:33:01
will call01:33:03
fix and01:33:05
[music]01:33:08
series01:33:11
Okay then next one01:33:17
and getting ready01:33:22
Hello01:33:25
and your microphone is turned on01:33:27
I don't hear anything no but yes now01:33:32
audible yes yes audible01:33:34
Good evening I am a political science student01:33:38
I would like to ask the next question I01:33:40
I'm going to do well01:33:42
scientific activity, that is, it is possible01:33:43
go there01:33:45
teacher Here we go01:33:47
write work based on the system01:33:50
analysis, you could just suggest01:33:53
on some problem area01:33:54
which is less affected by the classics01:33:56
and where could one say that?01:33:58
and of course I wanted to open up01:34:01
in the future if it is possible to see01:34:03
you as one of the licensers01:34:05
my research Well, I don’t know where you are01:34:08
you write because I'm still in01:34:10
share me bye from there01:34:12
God bless01:34:14
I didn’t get expelled, I hope it’s about the future01:34:17
for a while now01:34:20
well what a problem area for01:34:22
political scientists01:34:24
I think that01:34:27
in principle, of course, a very wide range01:34:31
so But01:34:33
let's say now it seems to me very01:34:36
this topic of the crisis of modern times is interesting01:34:39
political institutions there are parties01:34:43
elections and so on precisely in the context01:34:45
system crisis try to look like01:34:47
global crisis of 200801:34:50
influenced the evolution of political01:34:54
processes Well, that is, for example, a fall01:34:56
trust in parties, emergence of new ones01:34:58
populist movements and the emergence outside01:35:01
parliamentary new movements here01:35:02
starts in 2008 How is it01:35:05
appears precisely against the background01:35:07
global economic processes01:35:09
global crisis Well somewhere in this01:35:11
the area around this seems to me01:35:12
it would be interesting to search because here01:35:14
there is something new that is just relevant01:35:16
research yes this is research01:35:18
current process, it is quite possible01:35:20
use her number system analysis01:35:23
so good next Mr. E answers01:35:27
Mr. is responsible for him and then I01:35:31
I'll launch Aion, it didn't work01:35:34
adjust the microphone where the speed is therefore01:35:36
he recorded a voice message01:35:42
So01:35:43
Mr. Yes01:35:48
Hello comrades Yes I had01:35:52
question but I understand that probably not01:35:56
will allow you to set or01:35:58
uniter is enough to unite and that's enough01:36:00
literary01:36:03
plan01:36:14
I'll still ask the one I was going to ask01:36:17
it means I've been interested in coming for a long time01:36:21
what kind of treats, naturally, besides01:36:24
stern01:36:25
I'm playing around with Stepan. That's how he treats01:36:28
son, you guessed it. He loves cheese very much.01:36:33
Guess what, he loves cheese and he has it specially for him01:36:36
We have a whole begging ceremony01:36:39
separate cheese here he even me01:36:41
pat on the shoulder first then01:36:44
get a little lost in the cheek counters01:36:46
Then01:36:48
it turns out that it’s still a small piece01:36:53
more egg whites01:36:56
naturally loves boiled eggs01:36:59
[music]01:37:00
he has such treats but cheese01:37:04
this is his favorite Yes, but very much01:37:07
give a little of it give a lot of it Harmful only01:37:10
in small pieces very small01:37:12
was01:37:13
there is a serious question, oh well01:37:29
here in the chat they were discussing digital01:37:31
ruble and worry about it And in general01:37:35
issues of digitalization of this Yes I can01:37:37
be a little behind I just01:37:39
the life situation is such that I have no time01:37:42
these things happen here in some places recently01:37:45
still in the apartment In Which Tom01:37:49
apartment at some point01:37:52
it means some kind of voting took place01:37:54
digital there, well, about the HOA, apparently01:37:58
some questions and was appointed01:38:00
I missed the date because it's my own01:38:03
there were problems, but you were just01:38:06
you're interested01:38:08
questions like this have been raised before01:38:11
discussed01:38:12
do such initiatives have any effect at all?01:38:15
there are improvisations Well, I don’t know at the level01:38:20
cooperatives Where do they live?01:38:22
discussed As far as I understand Although maybe01:38:24
I missed this, as for01:38:26
digital ruble but I don't see it here01:38:29
not really any problems01:38:31
incredible possibilities I think that01:38:33
you know, even purely material resources01:38:35
which must be in order to01:38:37
completely digitize everything and so that everything01:38:39
it’s easy to reduce it to digital transactions01:38:41
no even in Russia I will notice even in Russia01:38:44
products that Russia by the way01:38:46
is far from a backward country in this01:38:49
On the contrary, she is advanced01:38:50
By the way, now many of our relaxants01:38:52
come to uh somewhere there in01:38:56
Montenegro in uh Latin America01:38:59
somewhere else suddenly discovers that01:39:01
many parameters of Russia are more01:39:03
advanced in terms of the notorious01:39:05
digital services and so on platforms01:39:07
services and other things, well, even in Russia01:39:10
they repeated clearly the impossibility from everyone01:39:13
digitize transactions absolutely01:39:15
now it’s unrealistic and that’s why it’s a little early01:39:18
we are discussing When will this happen?01:39:20
reality Well then, in general it seems to me01:39:22
there will be a little different society01:39:26
of course they will01:39:29
try to do this seriously, really like01:39:32
usually do01:39:36
Well, let's now move on to01:39:38
next question01:39:39
[music]01:39:44
[music]01:39:52
[music]01:39:57
I found it01:40:00
Hello Boris it didn’t work out01:40:03
ask a question on discord01:40:06
due to technical problems, so I’m writing this down01:40:09
voice I would like to ask this question01:40:12
raise01:40:13
regarding salaries of employees in the field01:40:16
education01:40:18
When I was at university I watched01:40:21
huge difference in salaries between01:40:25
senior junior employees01:40:28
for example, the rector or dean of the faculty could01:40:33
receive a salary of 500 thousand rubles or01:40:36
more some astronomical numbers01:40:39
At the same time, the usual employees there are01:40:43
departments, teachers could there01:40:47
25-35 thousand are received by people who01:40:50
studied01:40:52
and specialty and graduate school and in general01:40:57
spent a lot of time studying and studying01:40:59
both science and teaching, that is, but01:41:02
their salaries are extremely low in general01:41:06
treat this proposal01:41:09
such an idea to raise the minimum01:41:13
salaries of any general employees in01:41:16
education sector up to 100 thousand rubles01:41:19
Here at the same time the maximum salary for01:41:22
Rectors, for example, limit radicals01:41:25
bar 250 thousand rubles How do you do this01:41:30
look at another one so small01:41:33
question regarding01:41:35
The Constitution of the Russian Federation is01:41:39
this article 7 and part two says01:41:44
that Russia is a social State and01:41:47
Russia is being established01:41:50
guaranteed minimum size01:41:52
wages but01:41:54
this formulation is extremely01:41:56
vague and accordingly now we01:42:00
we see that the minimum wage is only 15 there01:42:04
18 thousand what if after the decimal point you can01:42:09
It would be nice to add the following:01:42:12
words that are installed01:42:14
guaranteed minimum size01:42:15
remuneration, which is determined by01:42:18
based on a single package of goods and services01:42:21
the composition of the package is determined based on01:42:23
documents containing prices for social01:42:28
significant goods and services01:42:30
procedure for drawing up this document01:42:33
collected from all regions01:42:36
regional parliaments How are you01:42:39
look01:42:41
Let's start from the end01:42:44
the minimum basket is not the minimum wage and01:42:47
the minimum basket should be01:42:49
secured and nothing special about it01:42:51
no big deal, it's not very complicated01:42:54
Is the problem completely solvable and is it written down?01:42:57
it is in the Constitution in legislation 1001:42:59
the question is fundamentally important that this01:43:02
was and that it was ensured it01:43:05
Moreover, it may well be ensured01:43:07
I think this will help01:43:09
increased demand and increased dynamism01:43:11
economics This is the first Second regarding01:43:16
education, yes, we have crazy gaps01:43:20
and not only between01:43:23
employees and top management01:43:26
administratively, it’s generally between01:43:28
those who simply teach and those who01:43:30
has an administrative position as01:43:32
only a person occupies something01:43:34
he has an administrative position01:43:35
starts to get crazy not crazy maybe01:43:37
heavenly begins dynamic salary01:43:40
The higher he moves01:43:41
administrative ladder while uh01:43:43
number of hours worked01:43:47
scientific or even the same01:43:49
he has no administrative work01:43:51
it increases absolutely01:43:52
unfair and most importantly ineffective01:43:55
need to radically cut salaries01:43:58
tops and thereby increase01:44:01
salaries for the majority of employees01:44:04
I think there should be some standards here01:44:06
plus this is also very desirable01:44:08
that was01:44:10
university self-government that is01:44:12
so that people just really choose01:44:14
vectors were adopted by collective01:44:16
some decisions including the decision on01:44:18
payment because, well, when these sit there01:44:23
people with 500,000 receive a million01:44:26
they get it and there’s some kind of01:44:28
an infinite number of vice-rectors01:44:29
who are unclear what they do in general01:44:32
all this is a complete disgrace then it happens01:44:33
that they eat up so much money that these01:44:36
money by the way is not necessary only01:44:38
I need to increase my employee's salary. Is it possible?01:44:40
for example, it was necessary to hire laboratories who01:44:43
would make it easier to work the same01:44:45
teachers and these teachers had01:44:48
more free time less01:44:50
paperwork and so on That is, it01:44:52
complex thing but in principle you are right01:44:54
Yes, you need to raise your salary01:44:57
teachers and education workers01:45:00
and at the same time, well, do something about these01:45:02
monstrous and many times overestimated01:45:06
not even university salaries01:45:10
participations which are simply stolen by01:45:12
fact of the matter A university funds01:45:15
so next question from mr.01:45:20
so who's there and geeks Nord is getting ready01:45:23
then so Mr. n I turned on the microphone yes01:45:30
Hello01:45:33
Yes yes I can hear you01:45:36
Will you still keep in touch with Danil?01:45:39
Grigoriev, keep an eye on his work01:45:41
want to invite01:45:44
I check in periodically Daniil serious01:45:48
economist and01:45:51
New channel did quite well01:45:55
quality channel dedicated01:45:57
economic body01:46:00
we even had the idea of having a debate01:46:04
between Gregory Danil Gregory and01:46:07
Grigory Bazhen they studied all the more01:46:09
together01:46:10
So I think that we will probably do this01:46:12
Somehow, in any case, I01:46:16
I have a very positive attitude towards work01:46:19
really01:46:21
does serious things01:46:25
so next01:46:37
microphone only01:46:42
[music]01:46:44
so geek No, well, I included it for you But that’s all01:46:49
I hear yes yes hello01:46:52
but apparently01:46:59
historical Question what were01:47:01
prospects for the people01:47:03
socialist government01:47:04
it really could have happened01:47:07
how diverse would its composition be?01:47:13
And01:47:15
there was or some potential that it could01:47:18
would change the further course of the Revolution and01:47:21
don't give an example01:47:24
I would like to be more precise01:47:28
to say yes I would like to say that01:47:31
he probably would have had prospects, but01:47:34
there are several problems01:47:36
You see, when he proposed all this01:47:40
was, to put it mildly, not an idiot Yes, he was01:47:44
I knew it would help a lot01:47:46
mitigate the conflict that arose after01:47:49
transfer of power by the council but01:47:52
as you remember01:47:58
unacceptable conditions namely this01:48:01
resignation of Lenin and Trotsky, you know?01:48:04
the resignation of Lenin and Trotsky would mean01:48:06
most likely all systems here are collapsing01:48:10
it's not even that this is Tom Lenin01:48:13
or Trotsky is not for his ambitions01:48:14
agree no, these were the key ones01:48:16
figures and key figures specifically for01:48:20
in order to spend some kind of life01:48:22
consistent radical and urgent01:48:25
politics If you remove these figures then01:48:28
it comes back to the situation01:48:30
close to the one before01:48:32
October Revolution That is, when01:48:34
asking for Kerch actually was01:48:35
incapacitated and uh you see there are two01:48:39
extremes yes that is on the one hand01:48:41
The Bolsheviks pursued a tough policy01:48:44
which01:48:45
exacerbated the conflict and contributed to01:48:48
By the way, I don’t agree with the civil war01:48:50
when someone says that the Bolsheviks01:48:51
started a civil war first01:48:53
this is not technically true, but it was started after all01:48:57
Bolsheviks And secondly, you can’t do everything01:49:00
reduce only to the actions of the Bolsheviks then01:49:03
that the country was heading towards civil war01:49:05
naturally, but conflict and01:49:09
the severity of this confrontation could01:49:11
would be less, more the balance of forces01:49:14
could have been a little different but that's on01:49:16
one pole Why did the stone protrude01:49:18
for homogeneous socialist01:49:20
government on the other hand01:49:22
I repeat If it were not uh01:49:27
ineffective simply put monkeys and01:49:30
Trotsky would not be effective otherwise01:49:33
most likely it would end with her01:49:36
just collapsed but still01:49:38
most likely it would slide down again01:49:39
citizen or what dictatorship So01:49:43
unfortunately I'm not sure what was there01:49:45
good chances though maybe01:49:47
Alexander Shubin has a different opinion01:49:49
[music]01:49:51
so good good01:49:57
and getting ready01:50:00
[music]01:50:06
microphone to01:50:09
create Good evening Can you hear me Yes yes01:50:14
Good evening Boris Yuryevich Good evening01:50:16
to all viewers please tell me01:50:20
at least occasionally if you have the opportunity01:50:23
monitor foreign channels01:50:26
which also01:50:28
answers here events news or01:50:32
educational here is the left stylistic01:50:36
prospects01:50:37
And in particular, here I am just a continuation01:50:41
I want to ask specifically: Do you know01:50:45
Maybe you've heard about the Second channel?01:50:48
American Youtube channel and there it is01:50:52
there is a review of more news01:50:57
parts of American international ones too from01:51:00
Socialist agenda and perhaps01:51:05
would it be interesting for you to invite01:51:07
example of a leader like this contact on01:51:11
Stream Well, somehow do it there01:51:13
English perhaps later with01:51:15
discuss, for example, the situation in01:51:19
America Yes, that’s exactly the left movement01:51:21
some perspectives thank you Well right away01:51:25
I admit that lately I01:51:27
I just can’t keep up with the foreign channel01:51:29
track Although I but the last time01:51:32
tracked01:51:35
Western including left channels in01:51:38
the time when I was with Frid's convoy Yes, that's it01:51:41
when these Truckers are in Canada01:51:43
went and protested and watched how01:51:46
different channels reacted to these events01:51:49
but thanks for the channel tip At the end01:51:53
I'll definitely take a look and maybe01:51:55
We'll do something. Thanks anyway.01:51:57
big And it’s good that I’ll remind you what you need01:52:00
spend more time on foreign01:52:02
channels and now we can become very01:52:04
provincial for our problems01:52:11
so take it then, let's turn on the microphone now01:52:21
no one else is invited, that's all who01:52:24
stayed here in line and that's it01:52:27
the microphone is getting ready01:52:30
Yes01:52:33
I'm listening01:52:37
Dear Boris01:52:39
Dear listeners, I ask a question from the page01:52:42
Verksynskaya Homeland of Mikhail Alexander01:52:44
Sholokhova Yes01:52:45
please congratulate my fellow countrywoman Alina01:52:48
stavrodina happy birthday and much better01:52:50
go to work with a degree in political science01:52:52
and then go into the opposition01:52:54
thank you politics01:52:56
Well first of all, congratulations, tell me again01:53:00
whom do you say yours01:53:04
Homeland yes yes01:53:07
So congratulations Alina01:53:10
wonderful Alina, you see01:53:13
someone cares about you01:53:16
Congratulations once again I think it's01:53:19
very very must be nice01:53:22
not so much that I congratulate you01:53:24
that's how people think about your01:53:28
the name is once again in a good context01:53:31
repeat So01:53:34
keep people like this01:53:36
Well, what about01:53:40
political science Where to go but with these on01:53:43
actually now of course01:53:46
there are no wide opportunities, but there are01:53:50
remains only Academic if01:53:52
taking such a job just has nothing to do with01:53:54
power with some big business then01:53:57
remains easier of course at first01:53:59
Academic work plus some01:54:00
gradually independent journalism01:54:03
which is actually on our Internet01:54:05
still there is, and moreover, well, I wouldn’t01:54:08
said that she can feed there yet01:54:11
They feed a lot But at least she gives01:54:13
satisfaction And so far Unfortunately01:54:15
bye At this stage today I'm talking01:54:18
probably about today today01:54:19
need to look for some academic01:54:21
position and then with this Academic01:54:24
move position When they start01:54:26
new interesting events go to01:54:29
work like some leftists01:54:32
organizations by association when they are already01:54:34
will really be able to present e What01:54:36
called a request to work with01:54:40
political experts I think this01:54:42
will be very soon01:54:44
so good bye thank you01:54:47
next Papkin and kirkent is getting ready01:54:55
[music]01:54:56
enabled Yes01:54:59
I can hear perfectly everyone at once Thank you I will01:55:04
brief so as not to waste time at the beginning01:55:06
I would like to hear the short one live01:55:08
feedback on the idea of carrying out stricter01:55:13
scientific debates01:55:15
with summing up arguments with such more01:55:19
such an analysis of the progress of the dispute discussion in01:55:23
whole or01:55:25
such relevance in general and in selection01:55:29
in particular and also if you have any01:55:33
ideas for creating a positive program01:55:36
conditional future left01:55:38
communist01:55:40
governments are also on platformers Well01:55:45
I immediately think you wrote something to me01:55:47
if maybe you maybe it's another me01:55:49
wrote But I had01:55:51
So you wrote Yes, the answer is positive01:55:54
Yes, as an idea, this is all true, but not well01:55:58
Let's just say, developing you already the idea that01:56:01
we need clear rules these rules are needed01:56:04
develop and need to find a participant01:56:08
who are ready according to these rules01:56:10
discuss And by the way I don’t believe in this01:56:13
nothing01:56:14
terrible nothing can be solved just well01:56:16
any idea to make it work01:56:19
must be specified and then01:56:21
needs to be implemented with specific steps A in01:56:25
in principle we will develop culture01:56:27
debate and do and try so I don't01:56:31
I am sure that what we will do in the coming01:56:32
time will be fully consistent01:56:35
to your wish that this is you completely01:56:37
will satisfy but the steps in this01:56:40
direction exactly in this direction like this01:56:42
you offer E we will do you01:56:44
here you are absolutely right absolutely right and01:56:47
pointing in the right direction Yes01:56:49
it all needs to be structured01:56:51
make more scientifically more serious without01:56:54
questions This is absolutely true and Well01:56:57
just understand that not all at once01:56:58
it turns out here And about the software01:57:02
things but now we will be with different01:57:04
colleagues and comrades create what01:57:07
in English it is called policy and papers01:57:08
that is01:57:10
project proposals for specific01:57:12
questions That is, even a little earlier01:57:13
this was done by the Institute of Globalization01:57:16
social movements while it existed01:57:17
we should have closed it now, but01:57:20
There is such a practice and we are working on it01:57:24
some of it is already starting to happen01:57:31
I think there are two more people right now01:57:34
let's answer so so so next and this01:57:38
pumpkin just answered yes yes then01:57:40
the next cry and Dmitry gets ready01:57:44
[music]01:57:50
Yes01:57:54
you can hear perfectly01:58:01
those events01:58:03
And01:58:06
transmit01:58:11
different questions because for example I01:58:14
I feel very good01:58:20
that is, he said in one film01:58:24
that Lenin himself conveyed it very accurately01:58:29
There is01:58:30
in some critics said that01:58:34
that is, he is so thoughtful and so on01:58:37
That is, well, okay, I want to say01:58:41
Sorry, I'll answer right away because01:58:44
don’t delay, that means you need to look01:58:47
just distinguish two different things01:58:49
an artistically successful film and accuracy01:58:51
transmission of events because for example I01:58:54
I really love the movie Lenin in October01:58:56
great movie exactly like a movie01:58:59
Of course, its prototype was not yet mine01:59:01
film in October of Einstein Well and then with01:59:04
Shchukin If I'm wrong in the role of Lenin01:59:06
wonderful film Lenin in October but01:59:08
Let's tell the truth this is not about that01:59:13
how it really was it's simple01:59:14
very good movie you understand very much01:59:17
good movie well acted01:59:19
beautifully staged but it's there01:59:22
half is not true Well, it’s not that it’s not true01:59:25
Well, it wasn’t like that, but I’m not saying that01:59:27
Trotsky's plot was removed Yes, that's it01:59:32
I can't hear you, sorry01:59:35
Hello01:59:37
we found out later and relied on something01:59:40
to continue This is more but01:59:43
again so very idealized01:59:46
the film is idealized but it seems to me01:59:48
conveys the events quite accurately, but he01:59:51
some01:59:53
idealized so to speak in terms of01:59:55
images This is at the beginning of the century too01:59:57
dedicated to Lenin and films that01:59:59
films that give a fairly accurate02:00:02
picture of events02:00:04
this is Lenin in Poland02:00:07
definitely everything is close enough to02:00:09
facts and July 6 July 6 - it was generally02:00:14
a masterpiece of Soviet cinema because the film02:00:16
it was a job with great difficulty02:00:19
Mikhail Sharov as Lenin the cabin crew02:00:23
which was very non-standard02:00:25
unusual for Soviet cinema02:00:28
Lenin but it seems to me much closer to02:00:31
reality and there Well, almost everything02:00:35
exactly on the clock02:00:37
as it was therefore if you need02:00:39
find out how these two films were for you02:00:42
I recommend it if you just want02:00:43
watch good Soviet movies about02:00:46
revolution02:00:50
to the comrades who are in our college02:00:52
interested so to speak Well, here I am02:00:54
answered yes02:00:57
thank you please this evening is so good02:01:01
then the last hour Dmitry will be but02:01:03
before that I will say that I started voting02:01:06
in the Telegram channel Do you like this one02:01:08
new section02:01:10
there are already 50 votes but in the end I still02:01:14
I'll let you down Okay, so turn on the microphone02:01:17
Dmitry02:01:19
listening Good evening Good evening Maxim02:01:34
Tell me please02:01:36
or rather, even arrange it in order02:01:40
I already know I already know02:01:43
dress like sociology02:01:45
I’ll tell you right away Marx, then the choice is which02:01:49
Gabe makes this question easy for me02:01:52
remember because someone is starting there02:01:54
say oh Max is not a sociologist at all yes02:01:56
or is there something else or am I completely different02:01:59
I'll name three no02:02:01
Yes Yes02:02:04
well with me Just with me Just because02:02:07
that strictly for me this is order02:02:08
absolutely obvious, at least for02:02:11
that02:02:13
your methodology in which they work yes02:02:15
this is exactly so, that is, of course Marx on02:02:17
first place second place02:02:20
to others I’ll even tell you just in depth02:02:23
because of course they are all very02:02:25
deep02:02:26
thinkers but02:02:27
nevertheless, every time you rise02:02:31
we go down to a new level a little bit02:02:33
because of course02:02:35
Marx In my opinion it is essential02:02:38
larger than Weber With all the enormous02:02:41
Weber's Max value02:02:43
but durge is still up to that level02:02:48
generalizations of the analysis that was characteristic02:02:51
for example, Max is a rapper, he’s still on02:02:54
my opinion does not reach this scale02:02:58
scientific02:02:59
analysis but at the same time Derben too02:03:01
absolutely gorgeous and that's all I really am02:03:04
time I remind you that when Lenin gave02:03:06
your definition of the classes that02:03:10
him in this definition02:03:14
divided precisely according to the place of public02:03:17
division of labor is in general02:03:19
essentially the definition02:03:24
Marx and what is called in one bottle02:03:26
so everything is simple with me02:03:31
Thank you02:03:34
to you for your help Your work with02:03:37
you're just a worker's reporter for us02:03:40
[music]02:03:42
brings a lot of joy02:03:49
so good and let me read it anyway02:03:52
donations that are at least higher than 500 rubles02:03:55
Yes, just so that, well, they just aren’t anywhere02:03:58
donated so that people wouldn’t be offended02:04:00
well, quite a lot came today02:04:03
donatov so Sergey Thank you Boris02:04:07
Yuryevich for the new book I hope she is in02:04:09
the difference from the previous one will be found by clicking on02:04:12
By the way, I’ll immediately inform you about the new one02:04:15
the book here arose the Queen experienced02:04:17
problems that they write to me that we would02:04:20
with pleasure it was published but sanctions02:04:22
Prohibited from signing a contract with02:04:24
a person living in Russia02:04:26
I am now leading Russian residents with them02:04:28
negotiations How to get around sanctions02:04:29
imagine who would have thought that I02:04:31
I'll work out so I can get around02:04:32
sanctions especially together with English02:04:35
the publisher will see what comes of it02:04:37
it will work out though02:04:39
so-so02:04:44
next02:04:46
curious everyman 777 rubles 5902:04:49
kopecks thanks for the work02:04:52
so Anton from the mail thousands of rubles Thank you02:04:56
for your work to find for further02:04:59
discuss the issue anyway02:05:01
We support you as much as we can02:05:07
so Dead Kraken m good stream everyone02:05:12
and getting answers to thousands of questions02:05:15
rubles If they said02:05:17
Sony I apparently yes Sonya 1000 rubles 786 Well02:05:22
1886 rubles without any02:05:25
message Thank you all very much02:05:27
Thank you02:05:28
so so so this is already the second page 302:05:31
400 rubles without message02:05:33
fan of Stepan for 500 rubles after all02:05:36
apparently asking a question Hello02:05:38
Dear Boris Klyuch Thank you and02:05:40
Abkor commander wanted to know for your work02:05:42
What do you think of the works of Michel Foucault?02:05:44
Well, I’ll say right away that I rate it very highly02:05:48
first Foucault02:05:50
again if you read my last02:05:53
the book contains Foucault references a couple of times and02:05:56
another thing is that in the discussion between02:05:58
helmets Foucault and Misha RTO I in general rather02:06:03
on the side was who showed that02:06:09
this is control, this is discipline02:06:13
which Foucault said actually has02:06:17
limits and the little man is very good02:06:20
eludes knows how to elude02:06:23
disciplinary practices described by Foucault02:06:27
It seems to me that in this sense it’s a bit of a fuku02:06:31
exaggerated the question one side of the coin02:06:33
just showed02:06:34
on the other side of the coin there is about it02:06:37
again, here's my current book02:06:39
a long digression of several paragraphs02:06:42
Well, in general, yes, I think that Foucault of course02:06:47
definitely a very big thinker and uh02:06:51
in general02:06:52
he gave me a lot including02:06:55
So, well, the last Donat, there are a lot of donations02:06:58
but as I said purely for the sake of exception02:07:01
so that people don’t feel sorry for money, I read02:07:03
relatively large recent Donat02:07:05
krakens today and sent this not today02:07:10
then there is no more donation at all 13 1302:07:12
was 13 was Stream Yes, I don’t remember, well02:07:17
then everyone already answered02:07:19
Well, dear viewers then we02:07:21
We're just finishing up now02:07:23
We were a little late so we started at 502:07:27
minutes02:07:28
8 respectively ending at 10:09 And I02:07:32
I think everyone liked the practice and02:07:35
I liked it too I think it's02:07:38
it was useful and interesting and we will repeat it02:07:41
this format is the only thing, tell me02:07:43
Maxim How did the voting end?02:07:46
How did the audience react to this format with you?02:07:49
because02:07:50
probably not only those who voted02:07:52
those who asked questions asked questions02:07:54
at least they're happy with what they have02:07:56
there was an opportunity to go on air and here's how02:07:58
the rest of the audience reacted 20002:08:01
Human02:08:02
don't like 7 percent answered all02:08:05
answered equally 23 percent and exactly 70 A02:08:08
already 71 percent answered like it, that is02:08:11
the balance is in favor of those who like it02:08:13
Well that means what we do02:08:16
someone likes it and those who like it02:08:18
more than those who don't like it at all02:08:21
dear viewers, we will try not to02:08:25
to enrich but just try02:08:26
do what interests you and02:08:29
useful but at the same time of course we will02:08:31
continue your own agenda02:08:34
please who is not subscribed02:08:36
Subscribe to our channel very much02:08:38
please like it because02:08:41
you need to like in order to02:08:43
more people saw this channel and noticed02:08:46
so that YouTube shows us in02:08:49
in short, like the recommendations02:08:51
be sure to like it yet02:08:53
The stream has ended, do you have more for this?02:08:56
a few seconds quickly quickly02:08:58
Lastly, like and of course02:09:01
thank you very much to everyone who asked02:09:03
today's questions Many thanks to everyone who02:09:05
I joined via Discord and got through02:09:09
before us Many thanks to those who gave02:09:11
donations Many thanks to all of you dear02:09:14
viewers for supporting us02:09:18
let's create this channel togetherDescription:
НАСТОЯЩИЙ МАТЕРИАЛ (ИНФОРМАЦИЯ) ПРОИЗВЕДЕН, РАСПРОСТРАНЕН И (ИЛИ) НАПРАВЛЕН ИНОСТРАННЫМ АГЕНТОМ КАГАРЛИЦКИМ БОРИСОМ ЮЛЬЕВИЧЕМ, ЛИБО КАСАЕТСЯ ДЕЯТЕЛЬНОСТИ ИНОСТРАННОГО АГЕНТА КАГАРЛИЦКОГО БОРИСА ЮЛЬЕВИЧА. ✅Задать вопрос с донатом: https://www.donationalerts.com/r/rabkortv ✅Отправить пожертвование на освещение дела Кагарлицкого и работу канала «Рабкор»: 2200 7004 3856 6977 (Тинькофф) ✅Карта для международных переводов: 4165 9816 0119 6631 ✅Поддержать нас на Бусти: https://boosty.to/rabkorleft ✅Криптокошелёк: https://taplink.cc/rabkor Вышла новая книга Бориса Кагарлицкого “Долгое отступление”. Можно приобрести напрямую в издательстве со скидкой. Промокод: РАБКОР2023 https://www.directmedia.ru/book-697767-dolgoe-otstuplenie/ *** У Рабкора теперь есть дискорд: https://discord.com/invite/3eZyrkUZD7 Презентация Организации коммунистов-интернационалистов во Владивостоке: https://docs.google.com/forms/d/e/1FAIpQLScy7glswMqE9ROR7oCbCM4Dj-iA71OFzw3sStPbzIKhKhX82g/viewform
Preparing download options
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players
Questions about downloading video
How can I download "Борис общается со зрителями онлайн. Прямая линия с Кагарлицким. ( Борис Кагарлицкий и кот Степан)" video?
http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.
Which format of "Борис общается со зрителями онлайн. Прямая линия с Кагарлицким. ( Борис Кагарлицкий и кот Степан)" video should I choose?
The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.
Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Борис общается со зрителями онлайн. Прямая линия с Кагарлицким. ( Борис Кагарлицкий и кот Степан)" video?
The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.
How can I download "Борис общается со зрителями онлайн. Прямая линия с Кагарлицким. ( Борис Кагарлицкий и кот Степан)" video to my phone?
You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.
How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Борис общается со зрителями онлайн. Прямая линия с Кагарлицким. ( Борис Кагарлицкий и кот Степан)"?
The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.
How can I save a frame from a video "Борис общается со зрителями онлайн. Прямая линия с Кагарлицким. ( Борис Кагарлицкий и кот Степан)"?
This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.
What's the price of all this stuff?
It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.