Download "Прекрасная Россия Будущего. Новый «Путин». Александр Штефанов*: #СлухайЭхо // 13.11.23"

"videoThumbnail Прекрасная Россия Будущего. Новый «Путин». Александр Штефанов*: #СлухайЭхо // 13.11.23

О мышлении Патрушева и "миротворчестве" Путина - Алексей Венедиктов* / Утренний разворот // 04.11.22

О мышлении Патрушева и "миротворчестве" Путина - Алексей Венедиктов* / Утренний разворот // 04.11.22

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Теракт в Крокус Сити Холл / Алексей Венедиктов* и Сергей Бунтман / Будем наблюдать / 24.03.24

Теракт в Крокус Сити Холл / Алексей Венедиктов* и Сергей Бунтман / Будем наблюдать / 24.03.24

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

🔥СЕНСАЦИОННОЕ РАЗОБЛАЧЕНИЕ ПРИГ0ЖИНА! ЭРДОГАН ГОТОВ НА ВСЁ! ПРОРЫВ Зеленского @BelkovskiyS

🔥СЕНСАЦИОННОЕ РАЗОБЛАЧЕНИЕ ПРИГ0ЖИНА! ЭРДОГАН ГОТОВ НА ВСЁ! ПРОРЫВ Зеленского @BelkovskiyS

Channel: Белковский

Алексей Венедиктов* / #СлухайЭхо // 16.05.2023

Алексей Венедиктов* / #СлухайЭхо // 16.05.2023

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Пастуховские четверги / Владимир Пастухов и Алексей Венедиктов* // 27.04.2023

Пастуховские четверги / Владимир Пастухов и Алексей Венедиктов* // 27.04.2023

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Последствия теракта в Крокус Сити Холле / Шевченко, Шепелин*. Утро c Аникиной и Полонским

Последствия теракта в Крокус Сити Холле / Шевченко, Шепелин*. Утро c Аникиной и Полонским

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Беспилотники, Пригожин бросил вызов карликам, решение Киева о переговорах #НАБЕЛО @BelkovskiyS

Беспилотники, Пригожин бросил вызов карликам, решение Киева о переговорах #НАБЕЛО @BelkovskiyS

Channel: Белковский

венедиктов

пастухов

живой гвоздь

политика

00:00:51

[music]

00:01:18

So Hello dear friends

00:01:22

Foreign Agent Alexander Fanov is with you

00:01:24

today I was called to the Youtube channel

00:01:27

living nail to answer your

00:01:30

questions dear viewers of living nail I

00:01:33

see there are already some questions and now

00:01:35

I will answer them without unnecessary preludes,

00:01:38

I think so

00:01:39

And hello Alexander, the idea of the so

00:01:43

-called Russian world has collapsed. The

00:01:46

Soviets have failed. Putinism is not a

00:01:56

viable ideological formalized

00:01:59

except for the anti-smell. What alternative to these

00:02:02

three ideas do you see in the society of the coming

00:02:05

beautiful Russia of the future? Thank you.

00:02:08

Well, of course, this is democracy, and

00:02:15

democracy is the

00:02:16

highest value for the Russian people.

00:02:19

we have historical foundations for

00:02:22

always declaring this under ideology,

00:02:25

these things are being driven up, but in general, in

00:02:29

general for here you see citizen Arie

00:02:33

Elber Thank him for the question, he

00:02:36

lists ideas such as as if for

00:02:39

export, as if such ideas as

00:02:41

goods that can be offered for

00:02:44

external market Yes, the Russian world is

00:02:46

like an external one, but this is not an internal

00:02:48

idea. The Russian Russian world is building the

00:02:50

Russian world outside of Russia, and the

00:02:53

Soviet one is also like Buto, so

00:02:54

International, only Putinism here is

00:02:56

like this with amendments. And of course, in

00:02:59

Russia, Russia had something to sell to the

00:03:02

foreign market I was just recently on

00:03:05

air with Rabkor we recalled that Well,

00:03:09

if Vladimir Putin fully understood how the

00:03:11

modern world works And

00:03:14

decided to build the Russian world not with tanks

00:03:17

over the ruins of Mariupol, but for example, just

00:03:19

let Yandex enslave all of Eastern

00:03:21

Europe Yes because that we understand that

00:03:24

Russia has become a leader

00:03:26

in the IT sector in all respects, that

00:03:29

is, not a single country in the post-Soviet

00:03:32

space has the best IT services, there is

00:03:36

nothing better than Yandex stores, this is the

00:03:38

Russian world, then in just a

00:03:42

few years it would be possible to Kiev on

00:03:45

Yandex brand on Yandex Market order

00:03:47

Russian tanks there in Kiev they would have been assembled by

00:03:50

specialists through the software So the Ukrainians

00:03:53

wouldn’t have noticed anything And they already

00:03:55

have tanks on Khreshchatyk, you see, the thing here is that there is a

00:03:58

misunderstanding of this, somehow

00:04:01

I wanted it differently, but yes, I hope the question

00:04:04

was answered by Roma 34 Moscow Hello

00:04:06

Alexander, now many experts are

00:04:08

showing despondency, there is someone

00:04:10

saying that Russia has already disappeared, is it an

00:04:13

emotional embellishment or hope

00:04:14

for change and there really is very little hope

00:04:16

for change I think

00:04:18

they are quite big changes in any case there

00:04:20

will be What does it mean hopes for changes

00:04:22

and the system will change the situation will

00:04:26

change is another thing, for the better or for the worse,

00:04:27

this is another separate question

00:04:30

But in general, the trend of historical

00:04:33

processes in Europe over the

00:04:35

past centuries Well, let's say two

00:04:38

centuries, this is a general transition to such a

00:04:43

democratic, near liberal regime

00:04:46

We see that the role of dictatorships in Europe is

00:04:48

declining, first the role of absolute monarchies fell,

00:04:51

then the role of

00:04:53

dictatorships fell, the last dictatorships, in general,

00:04:56

such classic ones in Western Europe, already

00:04:57

ended in the middle, well, in the second

00:05:00

half of the last Century, and you understand,

00:05:02

Putinism here does not offer something so

00:05:04

powerful to reverse these there

00:05:07

is no tendency to reverse the tendency, they are there and

00:05:09

Russia sooner or later I think it will

00:05:11

go down

00:05:12

this

00:05:15

path. So the hopes seem to me to be the

00:05:18

best, but another thing is when this will happen

00:05:22

and soon we will be able to observe something like this.

00:05:26

One question you often

00:05:30

said that Putin killed politics Yes he

00:05:31

remained one question of importance are you

00:05:33

for or against the war, this

00:05:35

case is similar to the Soviet Union, doesn’t it

00:05:37

mean that after Putin there will be a new

00:05:39

Putin, I don’t really understand The question is not

00:05:41

similar to the Soviet Union, I’ll answer right away

00:05:43

that in the Soviet Union the opposition was

00:05:45

very different Yes, everyone wanted democracy and

00:05:48

there was unity in this, but at the same time there

00:05:51

was a very strong one, for example, the left

00:05:52

opposition, which at some point

00:05:53

could have gained the upper hand, but the right opposition still gained the upper hand,

00:05:55

you need to understand that the

00:05:58

right-wing democrats

00:06:03

[music]

00:06:13

are boiling over whether to make a new topical

00:06:15

film, for example, ordinary elections about

00:06:17

March two fourth years Yes, I don’t know

00:06:18

it will work It won’t work, of course I would like to

00:06:21

film it, now let’s see what

00:06:24

Boris

00:06:25

Nadezhdin will do, will he be able to

00:06:27

register as a

00:06:29

candidate and of course there may be

00:06:32

interesting material Yes, ordinary

00:06:34

elections about March and what year It would be

00:06:36

interesting I hope but we don’t know how it

00:06:40

will all happen. In what format,

00:06:42

because of course making a film about an

00:06:44

ordinary election without Zyuganov is also

00:06:46

interesting, of course, but something like this may

00:06:50

not

00:06:51

work out like that.

00:06:57

Yeah, hello Alexander. As you can see, with

00:07:01

complete federalization, where the Central

00:07:03

Government has 56 functions, for example defense countries

00:07:05

foreign

00:07:06

policy Well, I

00:07:09

see such a

00:07:12

question that federalization should be carried out

00:07:14

gently. It’s clear to say and not within the

00:07:16

framework of a political crisis, because

00:07:18

we see that sharp federalization within the

00:07:21

framework of the political crisis that happened

00:07:23

in the past years, it does not lead to the most powerful

00:07:27

consequences, but then Do you have regions

00:07:29

where they swallow as much sovereignty

00:07:31

as they can?

00:07:34

Well, maybe it will end in separatism and

00:07:37

all sorts of conflicts, including

00:07:39

armed ones. But of course, at least

00:07:42

bring it into line with the Constitution of the

00:07:44

Russian Federation. It would be

00:07:47

nice to have a situation in

00:07:52

federalism here.

00:08:00

Russian world It seems to me that I do

00:08:02

n’t

00:08:04

know banking applications Tinkova And

00:08:07

Sberbank even this is Russian mi Have you

00:08:09

ever, if any of you

00:08:11

have used banking applications not

00:08:14

in Russia but in neighboring countries They

00:08:16

understand what the Russian world is, these are the

00:08:19

applications that we need our

00:08:21

banks are offering our homeland, it’s just

00:08:26

wonderful and it

00:08:28

was possible to expand Russia’s influence on

00:08:32

nearby countries. This needs to be promoted,

00:08:34

but we don’t want the DPR and

00:08:43

LPR,

00:08:45

so you watched the video filmed in

00:08:48

Mariupol, apparently filmed from the PGO for

00:08:51

2 years about the celebration of Mariupol DM the day of

00:08:55

liberation from the DPR independence

00:08:57

Ukraine, did you try to come to

00:08:59

Mariupol in the twenty-first year? No, I didn’t

00:09:01

try, it’s unlikely that I would

00:09:04

have succeeded, it would have been very difficult for

00:09:06

Russian citizens to get through, but I didn’t try,

00:09:12

no, Alexander, do you know who the

00:09:15

signatories of the Minsk agreements are, DPR LPR and

00:09:18

Ukraine, judging by your video with a review of the

00:09:21

new textbook, I doubt it Well,

00:09:23

damn doubt it, doubt it, I could have

00:09:28

made a mistake somewhere, it’s

00:09:30

so difficult here with the questions they all ask

00:09:34

what to do for those who are against the war but do not

00:09:36

support Europe and

00:09:38

Ukraine, the collaborators stole the

00:09:41

pacifist rhetoric, but who is Ivan Ivanov

00:09:43

asking the question Who you were stolen by the pacifist

00:09:45

rhetoric Ivan

00:09:46

Ivanov there is no need to support Europe and

00:09:49

Ukraine I have a video which

00:09:50

actually on the cover of which it is written

00:09:53

for ROSI

00:09:54

VOM in

00:09:56

ut in When you speak out against the war

00:10:00

You speak directly for what and what

00:10:02

you stand for You stand for Russia

00:10:05

against the war You You worries that you are

00:10:09

probably

00:10:10

worried about the fate of your Motherland, you are

00:10:13

probably worried about the fact that a million of your

00:10:15

fellow citizens are dying at the front and

00:10:20

killing citizens of the country next to you in

00:10:23

general,

00:10:24

the cultures are quite close, you are probably

00:10:27

worried about what economic consequences

00:10:29

this war will have, you are probably

00:10:31

worried about and the political consequences of

00:10:33

this war are probably worried about you a

00:10:35

dictatorship that is intensifying during

00:10:38

this war, since war is always a

00:10:39

way for a dictatorship to intensify, probably

00:10:42

all this worries you and on the basis of

00:10:45

this you have the right to declare that you are

00:10:46

against the Ainu,

00:10:48

and at the same time you may be deeply

00:10:51

indifferent to the fate of the political project

00:10:53

called Ukraine, this is strange to you

00:10:57

It may be indifferent to European

00:10:59

rhetoric, some

00:11:02

European new ideological

00:11:04

discourses, you may not like it. You

00:11:07

may advocate for some kind of non-

00:11:09

Eurocentrism

00:11:16

about the anti-war resistance in

00:11:19

Nazi Germany, it’s interesting

00:11:21

what actually happens, despite the fact that

00:11:23

there were bright

00:11:26

communist underground fighters anti-fascist,

00:11:29

all these leftists were wonderful

00:11:31

guys, students from White Rose who

00:11:33

distributed leaflets, famous but

00:11:35

had real power, anti-war

00:11:39

citizens who, in fact, their composition

00:11:40

was very specific, they were

00:11:42

conservatives

00:11:43

and German officers,

00:11:48

Catholics and former officials of Weimar

00:11:51

Germany, this is a coalition which

00:11:54

you understand, neither the Soviet experience nor the experience of

00:11:57

Western countries

00:11:59

was close, these citizens they had

00:12:04

a chance to stop the war and of course

00:12:07

ideologically they were not close there to the

00:12:09

anti-fascist guys from the White Rose,

00:12:11

for example, that’s why

00:12:13

here it’s like such an example of one of them, that is,

00:12:18

there is no occupation pacifist

00:12:19

rhetoric pacifist rhetoric is general Well,

00:12:21

it’s like saying that I don’t know the rhetoric of

00:12:24

love for mankind was taken away from you I don’t know

00:12:27

Christians if there is, for example, Christianity

00:12:30

Don’t adhere to Will you not

00:12:32

profess the rhetoric of love for mankind

00:12:34

only because it was professed by Jesus

00:12:36

Christ in the Gospel of Matthew I think

00:12:39

that this is not you it

00:12:42

will convince

00:12:44

so how

00:12:49

difficult it is. So

00:12:52

how do people in Russia know about

00:12:55

Europe and its direction if they have never

00:12:57

been there? Yes, even if they were, what

00:12:59

gives you a little knowledge is this

00:13:01

story about the fact that you weren’t even there, the

00:13:04

person who came to the country of

00:13:05

tourists, he of course learns a lot,

00:13:07

feels a lot on himself, but

00:13:12

he doesn’t get information about the country in general terms, that

00:13:15

is, well, if I came to Germany Can

00:13:20

I talk about the macroeconomic

00:13:21

indicators of Germany Well, I probably can, but

00:13:25

how much data did my trip give me about this?

00:13:27

to Germany, which doesn’t seem so to me, but of

00:13:29

course they get information

00:13:33

from various sources, including on

00:13:35

TV, they say something about a

00:13:40

nail rotting on air and not on

00:13:42

their channel. Yes, something happened. Here

00:13:44

they set it up, launched it, called me,

00:13:49

Hello, how do you feel about

00:13:51

the philosophy of hayka and, in principle, the economy of the

00:13:53

Austrian school, I

00:13:56

’m

00:13:57

sorry, I

00:13:59

treat it

00:14:13

this way, for some reason I don’t see new

00:14:20

questions Hello Alexander Why do we

00:14:23

always reinvent the wheel Why

00:14:24

can’t we copy the working system and

00:14:27

apply it in Russia, yes, you can, for

00:14:30

example, the American system, also

00:14:32

tailored for messianism No, the

00:14:34

American system No I’m sure how long

00:14:35

she will work in Russia in many ways

00:14:37

and they are trying to copy our Elite, in

00:14:39

fact, we see from the latest

00:14:41

article of our

00:14:43

Kremlin ideologist Mr. Surkov that he

00:14:44

still associates Russia with such a common

00:14:47

northern world with Europe and the USA, in

00:14:50

fact, our Kremlin The Stars

00:14:53

are trying

00:14:56

to imitate their own

00:14:59

idea of the United States in many ways. But

00:15:02

they are trying to imitate this idea. So

00:15:05

Pak America is, of

00:15:08

course, ideologically inspired for the

00:15:10

Russian world. And many points in the

00:15:15

economic model there

00:15:17

are also copied from the Americans. There is

00:15:20

such a thing, but you understand? fits

00:15:23

from the American experience to Russia nano

00:15:27

no if we are talking about the American Well,

00:15:30

there are the most standard reproaches in the

00:15:31

American-American system: the

00:15:33

American healthcare system is

00:15:35

the most ineffective among the developed countries of

00:15:37

the world

00:15:39

and the American electoral system

00:15:42

is one of the most outdated among the developed

00:15:44

countries of the world with simply terrible

00:15:47

rudiments. Well this is the story about

00:15:50

the election of electors the

00:15:51

story about the winner takes everything in

00:15:54

some States the story about the fact that the

00:15:57

candidate who

00:15:59

gets fewer wins the elections As a result of the votes of

00:16:03

the voters Well, there are a lot of minuses and

00:16:07

it seems that every time we

00:16:09

talk about some kind of copying of the

00:16:10

system we will talk about these

00:16:12

nuances. And in a broad sense, of course,

00:16:15

the model of liberal democracy has existed in Russia for a long time;

00:16:19

it exists on paper, let’s declare it like that

00:16:23

in this sense. Well, yes, and

00:16:27

so

00:16:29

there are mines, or maybe we

00:16:32

came up with the separation of powers and wrote it into the Constitution No,

00:16:35

not

00:16:36

us and other wonderful things that, in

00:16:38

fact, the strong basis of any

00:16:40

modern

00:16:44

developed state, as a guest, treats the

00:16:46

confederal structure of Russia

00:16:47

negatively, is collapse inevitable With

00:16:49

such a structure? What are the disadvantages if the

00:16:57

republics leave Russia? Here are more

00:16:59

confederations, even now it’s difficult

00:17:01

to remember anything other than Switzerland

00:17:03

that was confederal and it worked Well,

00:17:06

that is, Maybe some form of the

00:17:09

British Commonwealth, but this is not a

00:17:11

confederation, yes, that is, we understand that

00:17:13

this is a very ephemeral political

00:17:16

entity. But

00:17:17

whether Russia will work like that, I don’t know,

00:17:21

I think not. And why is this necessary, too?

00:17:23

Good question. What are the disadvantages? if

00:17:25

the Republics leave us from Russia,

00:17:27

well,

00:17:29

loss of economic ties,

00:17:31

loss of political SV, as usual, any

00:17:33

disadvantages from the collapse of the country, pros there,

00:17:36

another matter can also be discussed there. Yes, I

00:17:38

think that when they talk about leaving

00:17:40

Russia, Nare SBK means one and

00:17:42

only Nare SBK where there are very

00:17:45

talented teenagers live and

00:17:47

collect very good medals, these on the

00:17:49

Republic mean

00:17:51

one

00:17:57

here or Russia from

00:18:06

[music]

00:18:12

her Alexander and you understand Why a

00:18:14

demonstration against military operations in

00:18:16

Gaza for the sake of preserving civilians

00:18:18

is equated to supporting

00:18:19

Hamas, you can’t calmly watch

00:18:21

people die because that Propaganda

00:18:24

works equally from all sides,

00:18:27

respectively,

00:18:30

if we had gone

00:18:33

on a march to demonstrate against the

00:18:36

fighting in Ukraine, Russian propagandists would have accused us of

00:18:39

supporting Bandera’s followers, the

00:18:41

fascist

00:18:43

regime there, if in Ukraine we had come out against the

00:18:46

fighting with

00:18:48

Russia, for example, in support of

00:18:50

Arrestovich’s program for freezing the conflict, you would be

00:18:52

accused of supporting

00:18:55

Russia

00:18:57

IP of

00:18:59

one NTE of the Kiev region in which

00:19:01

nothing happened and information about which

00:19:04

only the Ministry of Defense of

00:19:05

the Russian Federation has nothing to be

00:19:08

surprised about. Demonization of the opponent is

00:19:10

such an old favorite technique that

00:19:14

somehow you shouldn’t even even be surprised

00:19:19

This is accordingly when you

00:19:21

speak out against the Bost W

00:19:27

elo, that is, how does the

00:19:31

Israeli army justify its actions by the fact that Hamas

00:19:34

staged the most terrible terrorist attack

00:19:37

in the history of Israel, and accordingly, that

00:19:40

means you are justifying them. You, by

00:19:43

indirectly speaking out against military operations,

00:19:45

are preventing the destruction of their members Hamas,

00:19:48

as it were, yes, well, you can say so logically.

00:19:51

Therefore, here and there they will

00:19:57

say.

00:20:08

Will Alexander have content for Belarus,

00:20:10

its politics will be will be will be

00:20:12

examined about Lukashenko Lukashenko is

00:20:14

very interested. By the way, it’s on the yub.

00:20:16

Let’s do this for the audience. What’s on the

00:20:18

yube? there is only one recording

00:20:20

that is on YouTube but I want to find another one

00:20:23

they said that there is another one but it

00:20:25

is not on the tube Where Lukashenko talks with

00:20:27

Gorbachev before the collapse of the Soviet Union and

00:20:29

there would be very

00:20:31

wonderful chemistry between the

00:20:33

characters here is how Lukashenko can curry favor

00:20:36

directly with Mikhail Sergeevich

00:20:37

Gorbachev I

00:20:39

advise see everything there forty

00:20:42

second excerpt Alexander What could

00:20:45

be the solution to the problem of ineffectiveness of

00:20:46

the UN there is really no way out except to make

00:20:48

it stronger Well, there is no way to stop the UN The UN is an

00:20:52

ineffective organization it cannot

00:20:54

solve all the conflicts in the world it is not

00:20:56

created for this and there is an old joke

00:20:59

What

00:21:00

if two small countries start a war,

00:21:04

he intervenes and ends it, if a

00:21:07

large country attacks a small one, he

00:21:10

does nothing. And of course, in this

00:21:15

regard, he cannot

00:21:17

do anything; the structure there is exactly how

00:21:19

this

00:21:21

organization is built, but is this a reason to talk about

00:21:24

complete

00:21:25

ineffectiveness? Don is disgusted by

00:21:28

all

00:21:29

wars. Well, she probably shouldn’t, I’d like to,

00:21:33

but she’s not capable of it. So

00:21:36

disbanding it because it can’t

00:21:37

solve this specific problem is

00:21:38

stupidity. Well, that is, there are other problems

00:21:41

that He

00:21:43

solves. Alexander, how correct is it to

00:21:45

call the Russian Federation Russia? Well, The Constitution

00:21:47

says that I can

00:21:50

be guided by it How much money did you spend

00:21:53

on filming a film? Ordinary

00:21:54

denazification

00:21:57

m

00:21:59

on the

00:22:00

set 30,000 rubles, of which 20,000 for the

00:22:03

camera

00:22:05

And for editing another 80, that’s

00:22:15

how difficult it is Difficult with chatting with chat Good

00:22:20

evening, you were in the DPR How do peaceful people live there

00:22:23

if on their territory there are

00:22:25

military personnel with psychological trauma, imprisoned for

00:22:27

murder, what about the level of violence,

00:22:29

which even in the Russian Federation is increasing, but in the

00:22:31

dining cities there is nothing Well, that

00:22:34

is, conditionally in Mariupol, I

00:22:38

met the military in some kind of Well,

00:22:40

unsightly form once when I in

00:22:42

June I went there, apparently it was uh, money and the

00:22:45

prisoners were

00:22:47

uh in a hotel there in the city there is one hotel

00:22:50

hostel, we went there and there these

00:22:53

uh powerful convicts

00:22:55

were sitting with military intelligence tattoos,

00:22:58

well, they offered to smoke

00:23:02

some kind of prohibited ones substances Well, yes,

00:23:04

yes, some kind of unpleasant Contact is

00:23:07

probably not the most productive, but nothing

00:23:09

serious. No, you need to understand that the military

00:23:13

there are busy with their

00:23:15

bodies in Donetsk, conditionally, Donetsk is just a

00:23:17

large city with great control from the

00:23:19

military police, I don’t think that

00:23:22

anything is possible. then there is a case in the

00:23:24

horse waves, there was a terrible case, that

00:23:27

is, I collected these stories about how the

00:23:30

military commits

00:23:33

arbitrariness, in theory, the military when

00:23:35

they detain a civilian, as this

00:23:36

usually happens, usually the story of

00:23:39

arbitrariness that I have encountered, the

00:23:41

military suspects that something The

00:23:43

civilian is suspicious He’s probably a

00:23:46

Ukrainian gunner, this is the fear of all

00:23:48

the military, they’re all obsessed Oh,

00:23:51

gunner because gunner, let’s do this

00:23:53

on the territory of

00:23:55

liberated Ukraine, there are

00:23:58

a lot of these new territories, suddenly many

00:23:59

are unhappy with the fact that the Russian

00:24:01

army has arrived and, accordingly, hand over the

00:24:03

coordinator of the Russian army to Ukraine, why are

00:24:05

we them We condemn in every possible way And in general,

00:24:07

listen only to the Ministry of Defense of

00:24:08

the Russian Federation, and

00:24:11

accordingly, because of this, there is

00:24:13

a feeling that any Civilian

00:24:16

can be a gunner, such a

00:24:18

semblance of a spy Mania is born, according to their instructions, the

00:24:22

military cannot do anything there at all

00:24:24

except how they can detain a

00:24:25

person and hand him over his prosecutor's office

00:24:28

Well, or in short, transfer to the investigative authorities

00:24:29

in any case, the military

00:24:32

cannot judge, but in fact, in reality, when there is

00:24:35

no one to transfer to, for example,

00:24:38

in a particular locality there is

00:24:40

only one specific military

00:24:43

unit and civilians, this is where

00:24:45

the cruelty begins, because the

00:24:48

investigations from the military begin

00:24:56

Yes, and the Armed Forces and there the slightest suspicion they

00:25:00

will find your Ukrainian flag. You lived in Ukraine, you have to

00:25:03

understand for the last few

00:25:06

decades, you may have, for example, a

00:25:07

Ukrainian flag in your apartment, imagine

00:25:09

you didn’t burn it in a timely manner. Well, that’s it, and

00:25:12

terrible things can happen there. But

00:25:14

what? I heard it wasn’t really terrible,

00:25:17

but there are methods of physical pressure,

00:25:20

when a woman gets there, there

00:25:22

can also be terrible things,

00:25:24

but I haven’t heard about the murder of Kono.

00:25:28

And in general, what kind of murders are Russian

00:25:31

soldiers? Soldiers don’t kill anyone, listen to

00:25:33

the Ministry

00:25:34

of Defense,

00:25:37

so Alexander, what do you think about it? the

00:25:40

future location of Chechnya as part of

00:25:41

Russia after the establishment of democracy, where is

00:25:43

democracy in Russia or in Chechnya? That’s a

00:25:46

good question, but I don’t know how

00:25:49

complex this is. It’s really a complex problem

00:25:51

that requires a solution. Most likely, the

00:25:53

first democratic

00:25:54

government of Russia will put up with the

00:25:56

fact that there is no democracy in Chechnya

00:25:58

And gradually introduce a

00:26:01

democratic institution into Chechnya very gently

00:26:03

so as not to provoke a military conflict

00:26:06

or

00:26:07

not, there are always two options. Yes,

00:26:10

you can say anything about any thesis or

00:26:12

not, maybe in Chechnya this wildest

00:26:15

clan-based authoritarianism will end before

00:26:17

authoritarianism in Russia. Who knows? And

00:26:20

in this case too it will be easier if Chechnya

00:26:22

simply turns into an ordinary

00:26:25

North Caucasus region with its own specialties,

00:26:27

of course, but without these

00:26:29

wonderful talented Chechen

00:26:32

teenagers who earn medals and

00:26:36

state awards Alexander What do you think is

00:26:38

Shulman’s thesis that the teaching of history in the

00:26:40

Russian Federation needs to be reduced, the distorted

00:26:49

history in the Russian Federation needs to be reduced Shulman

00:26:52

apparently this is how Ekaterina Mikhailovna reads,

00:26:54

recognized as a disgraceful

00:26:56

agent, I don’t know, it seems to me no, well,

00:27:00

at all Let’s have an important discovery, the

00:27:02

veil of you at school is all here All the

00:27:05

viewers who are watching this right now were

00:27:07

probably taught history at school; you are not taught history at school so that

00:27:09

you can be such

00:27:12

historians not so that you go into

00:27:14

academic history, not so that

00:27:15

you do research, not even so

00:27:17

that you get a basis for the

00:27:19

humanities, they explain history to you so

00:27:22

that it would be easier for you, priva

00:27:24

patriotism, this is not how it is done in

00:27:27

all countries of the world because that is the

00:27:29

narrative historical, which is

00:27:30

taught to you in

00:27:32

textbooks, it is needed to

00:27:34

justify the very existence of

00:27:36

the state in which you live, to explain

00:27:38

its greatness, pros, cons, but at the

00:27:42

same time, instilling in you love for

00:27:45

it is bad. Is this good? But this is an

00:27:49

inevitable consequence of the national

00:27:51

state. Well, here it is, like this it

00:27:53

works and you even understand that even in the USA where a

00:27:55

lot of fragments from history can

00:27:59

be painted with black paint, even there history

00:28:01

is taught in general in this way and

00:28:05

still it is love for the country that is instilled,

00:28:08

also with a number of European countries.

00:28:12

And

00:28:15

therefore the teaching of history

00:28:17

will not be reduced. They will be revised.

00:28:20

programs will be revised, approaches,

00:28:23

narratives, but it’s quite difficult for me to imagine that

00:28:26

teaching history will be reduced,

00:28:28

and so that

00:28:32

the guide always understands

00:28:34

aggressive dictators aggressive

00:28:37

dictators aggressive wars are always

00:28:39

justified Well, or almost always with

00:28:41

reference to

00:28:43

history Adolf Hitler when

00:28:48

they add the third year of the ninth year, he directly

00:28:52

stated that on the one hand there is the history of

00:28:55

Czechoslovakia is several decades, two

00:28:59

decades of some incomprehensible nonsense, and

00:29:01

on the other hand there is a thousand-year

00:29:03

history, all of this was enough

00:29:05

to understand without any special

00:29:08

immersion, two simple theses

00:29:10

Czechoslovakia is a young state, a

00:29:11

thousand-year Reich, a thousand-year

00:29:14

Reich, as far as you understand, How much should the

00:29:17

teaching of history in schools be reduced so that something

00:29:20

like this

00:29:26

clearly the desire is always there justification found here to

00:29:29

do other things so that it does

00:29:32

n’t

00:29:33

happen Alexander Why were people not

00:29:35

informationally active in 2008

00:29:37

during the war in Georgia because it went on for

00:29:39

several days turning a blind eye to it didn’t

00:29:41

we allow it after

00:29:43

the war Well, what are you could have been done

00:29:46

when when the government starts a

00:29:48

small victorious war and it is

00:29:49

really a small victorious one you

00:29:51

can do little

00:29:54

Pramo

00:29:56

in 2003 these are the most massive

00:30:00

demonstrations in the history of mankind

00:30:02

comparable perhaps only to

00:30:03

demonstrations against the war in Vietnam

00:30:05

these are hundreds of thousands of people who took to the streets of

00:30:09

cities in the United States of America and

00:30:11

Great Britain This is truly an

00:30:15

amazing power of the demonstrators of a huge

00:30:18

mass of

00:30:19

people, but at the same time the war in Iraq for the United States

00:30:24

was small and victorious at that time, that is, the active phase of the operation

00:30:26

lasted month after month Saddam Hussein

00:30:28

was defeated, and the war in

00:30:31

Iraq itself could not be prevented in this way on the

00:30:32

other hand, there is the war in

00:30:34

Vietnam, which is simply not small and

00:30:35

not victorious, and therefore the demonstrators,

00:30:38

of course, brought the end of the war closer,

00:30:41

so there is no unique scenario for how to

00:30:43

stop wars; they don’t have how

00:30:45

civil society can influence the

00:30:47

government that got into the war;

00:30:49

war, even democracy is not a

00:30:50

vaccine from this because, well, the USA as

00:30:53

a whole was a democratic

00:30:54

democratic country, and Great Britain,

00:30:56

when they began military intervention in Iraq,

00:31:00

whether it helped them, I

00:31:03

don’t know, anyone here wants an ass to quote

00:31:08

Hermann Goering, who, while already a

00:31:12

defendant in Nuremberg,

00:31:14

explained to the American psychologist Gilbert that in

00:31:17

fact any people you can convince that

00:31:20

war is necessary. Well, say that this is a

00:31:26

betrayal of the people and say that war

00:31:29

in general was inevitable, everything and forward,

00:31:32

and this trick is performed by different

00:31:34

governments, regardless of whether the

00:31:36

democracy there is a Communist or

00:31:37

fascist

00:31:41

dictatorship. Alexander You were interested

00:31:43

in the torture of prisoners of war with both

00:31:45

sides in the conflict Well, is there really a

00:31:47

great chance of being killed already in captivity

00:31:50

or is this an attempt to pass off special cases as

00:31:52

permanent ones? We don’t have statistics and there

00:31:56

can’t be any

00:31:57

at the moment, it will be retrospective

00:32:01

and it very much depends on which unit you have that

00:32:04

will take prisoners That is,

00:32:07

if you were captured by the Dshrg Rusich Well, of

00:32:10

course, your chances of survival are approaching

00:32:13

zero. But on the other hand, the Dorg Rusich is a

00:32:16

very insignificant unit in the format of the entire

00:32:18

front,

00:32:21

and in fact, for the most part, it depends

00:32:25

on whether the fighters who captured you can

00:32:29

captivity to ensure your transportation to the

00:32:32

rear is safe for your life to take you

00:32:35

prisoner if like this it’s just short and the

00:32:37

group worked in all Wars If

00:32:40

you surrender and the Soldiers who take

00:32:42

you captive because of this do not see a threat to

00:32:44

their life, that is, they you are taken prisoner

00:32:46

and because of this they do not incur costs, then

00:32:48

most likely everything will be fine with you

00:32:50

Well, with

00:32:51

captivity If you surrender in

00:32:54

the middle of

00:32:56

the battle somewhere in a trench Where in one

00:32:59

country the battle is still going on in the trench

00:33:01

But here here you have already decided to

00:33:02

surrender Well, yes, well, the greatest

00:33:05

probability is that you simply

00:33:06

will not be taken prisoner and, accordingly, will simply be killed. Yes, there is

00:33:09

such a possibility. Unfortunately,

00:33:12

there is, but how do you feel about a new

00:33:15

subject in universities is the basis of the Russian

00:33:16

state Well, this is just the continuation of the

00:33:19

story about how historical science

00:33:21

is used to substantiate

00:33:23

state

00:33:25

patriotism I refuse to deny that it

00:33:41

happened that way no No this is not a question

00:33:46

this is also not a

00:33:48

question Alexander do you think that

00:33:51

humanity will sooner or later be able to

00:33:52

unite into one state Yes, it’s

00:33:54

unlikely, unfortunately, but the states are very

00:33:58

strong and we are now we see a trend towards

00:34:00

strengthening states and towards strengthening

00:34:02

state power and control,

00:34:05

and well, the model of unification is not entirely clear. That

00:34:09

is, if aliens arrive tomorrow

00:34:11

and say surrender

00:34:13

to man, yes, we are killing you. Then it is

00:34:17

possible, but in the absence of this external

00:34:19

factor which apparently will not be yes, well

00:34:22

very unlikely Unless there is a

00:34:25

new Genghis Khan yal tr Who

00:34:27

will unite everyone into one in a post-nuclear one

00:34:29

all into one state And of course

00:34:32

the probability is very small the state

00:34:34

simply clung too tightly to its

00:34:36

sovereignty and well, we now see how,

00:34:39

Excuse me, the

00:34:40

largest country in the world possessing

00:34:43

the largest nuclear potential

00:34:46

And with an army that before the war was considered the

00:34:49

second army in the world, attacked a country

00:34:52

that, in general, many rightly

00:34:54

called Fail State, that is, Russia

00:34:56

attacked Ukraine,

00:34:57

Ukraine had huge problems before the

00:34:59

war and now there is Ukraine -

00:35:02

well, let’s just

00:35:04

say it’s not the most successful developed

00:35:07

country and Russia justified its

00:35:11

claims to part of the territory of this very

00:35:14

Ukraine with some historical reasons. Well, look how everything

00:35:15

went for her. Well, actually, we see what this

00:35:18

leads to, this again. This is literally David

00:35:20

Glya

00:35:22

fighting and something is not very good

00:35:25

it turns out Our dear

00:35:28

lyaf, here you are talking about the whole

00:35:32

world where, in your opinion, Alexander, there is

00:35:36

a line between double standards and

00:35:37

autism in the context of wars waged by

00:35:40

different countries Well, I

00:35:43

mean where you can cite other

00:35:46

military conflicts as an example And where will it be

00:35:50

Look at autism to explore some T

00:35:53

to show it is different in what it is

00:35:57

not like you

00:35:59

want to give an example of another A and

00:36:04

build a comparison, that is, to conduct a

00:36:07

comparative analysis, this is normal when

00:36:09

you are a

00:36:20

countertenor

00:36:21

When they

00:36:25

tell you it’s bad that Russia is waging an

00:36:27

aggressive war today And you answer him to

00:36:31

this person And here is the USA in 2003 And

00:36:35

here in Vietnam And here in Libya But in

00:36:38

Yugoslavia this is of course And autism

00:36:41

because, well, if we lower it to the micro level,

00:36:45

then it’s literally Bad that Uncle

00:36:48

Vasya killed

00:36:50

a man and a counterargument and Pet also killed a

00:36:53

man but I don’t know which ship for

00:36:57

this reason Uncle Vas

00:37:00

will acquit Alexander. I was skipping. How the

00:37:04

Soviet-Finnish war is now presented in textbooks, and the Soviet-Finnish war

00:37:07

is presented as a

00:37:08

liberation of the Ukrainian and Belarusian

00:37:10

people, and the Soviet-Finnish war is presented

00:37:13

as a mistake in general, everything is like this

00:37:19

[music]

00:37:24

here's Alexander How do you feel about

00:37:27

Trotsky, do you think that he, too, was an

00:37:28

alternative to Stalin, like Bukharin, he

00:37:30

was an alternative to the collective

00:37:32

leadership in the party Trotsky, it was in

00:37:35

Trotsky that the highest party leaders

00:37:39

saw the threat of dictatorship after Lenin's death

00:37:42

they rightly saw the entire collective

00:37:45

leadership that was formed in the

00:37:47

late Lenin years, it attacked

00:37:51

Trotsky, that is, Trotsky was not defeated by

00:37:53

Stalin, Trotsky was defeated by the entire top of the

00:37:55

Bolsheviks, this is the obvious

00:37:58

thesis in fact, so did

00:38:00

Trotsky have a chance? Well, I don’t know, a military

00:38:03

coup, a new civil war I don’t

00:38:05

know what his chances were. He had very

00:38:06

little chances. There

00:38:08

was no alternative to Stalin, so it wasn’t

00:38:10

considered. An

00:38:11

alternative was either the dictatorship of Trotsky or the

00:38:13

continuation of collective leadership, and

00:38:15

then Stalin,

00:38:17

uh, embarked on the path of fighting the collective

00:38:20

leadership, very competently

00:38:24

splits the parties

00:38:27

in the bloc and taking the side of one

00:38:30

of these blocs, he never acted

00:38:32

alone against the rest of the elite, he always

00:38:35

acted in alliance with

00:38:37

someone, there was an alternative there, there

00:38:40

was an alternative to Stalin, this is the main one,

00:38:42

this is his legal position. And of

00:38:44

course, in my opinion,

00:38:47

Bukharin’s victory is conditional, which is also was

00:38:49

unlikely, this is a much better

00:38:52

alternative for Russian

00:38:55

history,

00:38:58

so Alexander recently watched your

00:39:01

broadcast with the light, you were arguing there about

00:39:03

whether to consider a strong state, what to consider a strong

00:39:06

state. So why is the strength of a

00:39:07

state measured by the strength of institutions? Well,

00:39:10

you know, because this is, of course, a

00:39:11

subjective approach. I I measure how to generally

00:39:14

measure the strength of a state. There are no

00:39:15

objective metrics to

00:39:18

measure the strength of a state. You can measure the strength of the army, the strength of the

00:39:19

economy, there are at least some

00:39:21

objective metrics, but the strength of the state,

00:39:22

what is it? You can say that it is the

00:39:25

sum of all objective facts, but it won’t

00:39:27

work out very well either, because how?

00:39:28

it is inside then strong when we talk

00:39:30

about the power of the state within

00:39:32

itself we talk about the power of Russia Russian

00:39:36

Federation What is the Russian Federation

00:39:38

and here we must decide the Russian

00:39:40

Federation - Is it Vladimir Putin and his

00:39:41

clique that seized power or the

00:39:43

Russian Federation is something else

00:39:46

and in fact, the majority and even the

00:39:49

pro-Putin wait will declare that Russia is

00:39:52

something else, but few will tell

00:39:54

you in plain sight that Russia is

00:39:57

inextricably linked with Vladimir Puma and without

00:39:59

Vladimir Tin there is no Russian Federation,

00:40:01

this is a rubbish statement.

00:40:04

Therefore, if the Russian Federation

00:40:06

exists in isolation from individuals, how

00:40:08

we measure its strength And here we measure its

00:40:11

strength Of course by institutions Because

00:40:13

institutions allow the state to protect

00:40:16

itself institutions are what we

00:40:19

inextricably link will hand over the

00:40:21

State of the

00:40:25

judicial court it seems this is the very

00:40:29

institution of the

00:40:30

judiciary The state is not

00:40:34

just a comrade Bortnikov or not just

00:40:39

some head of another law enforcement

00:40:41

agency, this is the institutional basis of

00:40:44

these law enforcement agencies, how they

00:40:45

work as an institution. The state is not

00:40:48

just Vyacheslav Volodin, it is how

00:40:50

parliamentarism works in it when all

00:40:52

these institutions have independent

00:40:55

power and can defend themselves simply by

00:40:58

Based on the fact of its

00:40:59

institutionalization in this state, we can

00:41:01

say that a

00:41:02

strong state cannot, by its own will,

00:41:07

for example, simply come to an agreement with the top

00:41:08

army and disperse the parliament. Well, it

00:41:11

wants to, but it can’t and is hindered by the

00:41:15

institutionalization of this

00:41:16

state, it understands that this is the end,

00:41:17

this is the way rebellion and Civil War,

00:41:20

a person wants to say that you know,

00:41:24

we had a Constitution before and now I

00:41:26

have introduced a new one and everything is canceled and reset,

00:41:29

I will go to the polls for the third time, but the head of the

00:41:32

Constitutional Court can’t come out there,

00:41:35

defends his institution and says No,

00:41:37

sorry,

00:41:38

and the head of the prosecutor’s office says that

00:41:41

this is does not comply with the law, but the

00:41:44

parliament also has its say and and it is

00:41:46

impossible. It doesn’t work out that one specific

00:41:48

person cannot rise above the Russian

00:41:50

Federation. That is why the strength of the

00:41:53

state within itself, in my opinion, is

00:41:55

determined precisely by the strength of institutions, but

00:41:57

you can argue with this, there are interesting

00:41:59

counterarguments. Well, I’m sending it to in general To the

00:42:01

stream With Michael's light, how much is there

00:42:02

when You understand, I'm now formalizing my

00:42:05

position, I'm expressing it confidently This is how it can

00:42:07

look And when the opponent is scanned that

00:42:09

she may not look so

00:42:12

confident Will the videos be similar to

00:42:14

Katya's analysis, for example, about the Holodomor in Ukraine

00:42:15

for three years I don’t like the term

00:42:17

Holodomor about hunger Will there be a video I

00:42:20

think not I think not there is

00:42:22

good material already on this topic

00:42:24

By the way, Sharifov has surprisingly good

00:42:27

material

00:42:30

m Alexander you are invited to their broadcasts by

00:42:34

Ukrainian YouTube channels Well, these are the big ones in

00:42:35

general Ukrainian No, they mention me, as I

00:42:39

understand it, sometimes, but that is, like a

00:42:42

conditionally living nail. I don’t know what,

00:42:46

popular politics, FBK,

00:42:48

Khodorkovsky, I don’t know, Novaya Gazeta is

00:42:51

currently forming, in

00:42:53

general, a lot of news agenda among the

00:42:56

opposition horse of Russia, these are some- then

00:42:58

such alternatives from Ukraine,

00:43:00

of course, they don’t call me, I’m not interested in

00:43:01

fencing another state

00:43:03

in general, an imperial and Rashi, why do they

00:43:07

need me? The question is whether

00:43:09

nonviolent resistance works in the

00:43:11

Muslim environment in Muslim

00:43:12

countries. Well, it worked in India. It’s certainly

00:43:15

not a Muslim country, but a country with a

00:43:18

significant share

00:43:21

Muslim

00:43:23

Nivka Rinskaya

00:43:26

future of pacifist ideas in such

00:43:27

regions It seems to me that yes, as

00:43:29

humanization increases, as the value of

00:43:32

human life grows, as

00:43:34

wealth grows, as the middle class grows,

00:43:36

because it is important to understand that

00:43:37

violent methods dominate not

00:43:38

only because it is ethically correct,

00:43:41

it is ethically correct it might have seemed

00:43:43

like several thousand years already there to many

00:43:45

people, but because the middle

00:43:48

class appeared and a huge

00:43:50

mass of citizens appeared who have what to lose

00:43:52

if earlier at the beginning of the 20th century you could

00:43:54

call the people to the Barricades

00:43:56

and they would go, you could go to the factory and

00:43:59

bring a fiery speech and workers

00:44:01

praise the rifles and go Kill

00:44:05

the police, now these workers When

00:44:07

you jump out and tell them so, they will

00:44:09

tell you Well, listen, somehow this is something

00:44:11

radical, I have a family, children, an apartment, a

00:44:14

mortgage, and in the end, these same workers,

00:44:16

they can only scream, go away, go away

00:44:18

to yours to the president that this is also, in fact, a

00:44:20

serious method

00:44:23

of struggle. But this is an objective factor, you can

00:44:26

treat it as you like, but this is so:

00:44:28

there is no longer that environment for

00:44:31

violent revolutionaries. People

00:44:34

who act violently do not have

00:44:35

this nutrient medium that

00:44:38

could be used, and that is why

00:44:41

the transition to non violence, it is becoming

00:44:43

wider and

00:44:44

wider, it’s just a given that I think that the

00:44:47

Muslim environment will also have

00:44:50

Although

00:44:51

Christianity has no

00:44:54

influence of Christianity as an ideology of

00:44:59

non-violence Good evening What will happen if the

00:45:01

second wave of mobilization begins And what

00:45:04

will happen if we refuse Well, if we

00:45:06

refuse I so I believe that nothing worse

00:45:09

than if you agree with you will not

00:45:12

happen, unlike the last

00:45:14

wave of mobilization, there is already a regulatory framework to

00:45:16

bring you to criminal responsibility, this

00:45:18

will probably be done if you

00:45:20

sing in refusal, but most

00:45:24

likely, in fact, do not follow the agenda, do not

00:45:28

follow the mobilization don’t go to

00:45:31

the military commissar, the military commissar, children, your lie, the military commissar

00:45:35

doesn’t want to laugh at you, he wants to

00:45:37

send you to storm Avdiivka, you want to

00:45:40

storm Avdiivka, I wouldn’t want you to storm

00:45:42

Avdiivka, and there’s no need to

00:45:44

storm anything at all, that’s

00:45:46

why most likely nothing will happen

00:45:48

because the authorities can’t handle it it’s just that with

00:45:51

such a flow of administrative criminal

00:45:54

cases, there will be several demonstrative cases

00:45:56

to scare the majority and this

00:45:58

will work, the

00:45:59

majority will be scared and go. But in

00:46:03

general, most likely, what we see is this

00:46:05

entire digital

00:46:06

database; digitalization of military registration and enlistment offices;

00:46:09

digitalization of data from all works;

00:46:11

it will lead to the fact that the Russian

00:46:13

state will receive its own hands, a

00:46:15

unique weapon, it will be able to choose

00:46:18

who to send to the front, that is, the

00:46:20

Russian state will be able to create a

00:46:23

conditionally point-based rating system among

00:46:24

conscripts

00:46:26

and select to the front those

00:46:31

who, by death, will cause the least harm to the

00:46:34

political regime of Vladimir Putin

00:46:36

sounds disgustingly immoral

00:46:39

Ancelotti

00:46:46

[music]

00:46:48

taxes you have ku loans then they will probably take you

00:46:54

nan in fact, such an opportunity is

00:46:57

such a weapon - This is quite serious

00:46:59

because it will allow Vladimir Putin to

00:47:00

painlessly rake out a huge

00:47:02

human reserve,

00:47:05

and so, well, we hope. Personally, I hope that my

00:47:09

numbers are just all a reversal and nothing

00:47:11

like that will happen because this is

00:47:12

some kind of horror,

00:47:17

and Alexander in the videos about the analysis of Stas

00:47:20

Vasilyev has a lot of interesting information,

00:47:21

you can reassemble them For a wider

00:47:22

audience without mentioning Stas for those

00:47:24

who are not interested

00:47:26

Interesting

00:47:28

story, this is happening to some extent, it’s

00:47:31

just in some different formats

00:47:33

gradually being done Alexander How do you

00:47:36

feel about the Cree? Well, well, the information

00:47:40

gypsy is a charlatan. I guess I don’t know how

00:47:43

to treat a person with very low

00:47:45

information hygiene, but at the same time,

00:47:47

he has, for example, on my topic, he

00:47:49

has interesting videos of the Russian spring during the

00:47:52

howl

00:47:54

of the year, there are interesting things which

00:47:57

you need to watch, but in general, well,

00:48:01

look at how Shariy covered the exit of

00:48:04

Russian troops from Kherson. What a

00:48:05

victory he inflated there, simply not based on anything,

00:48:07

based on what

00:48:09

someone wrote to him and introduced himself as a fighter of

00:48:11

either the Armed Forces of the Russian Federation or, well, just a person

00:48:14

a little out of control I think sometimes he does

00:48:17

n’t filter information very well, so do

00:48:33

you think Lenin understood in the

00:48:36

last years of his life, seeing and feeling

00:48:38

where things would go when Stalin came, the correctness of

00:48:40

Marx’s assertion of the possibility of a transition

00:48:42

to socialism only in a developed caste Yes, I do

00:48:45

n’t know, I don’t really want to we can’t speculate

00:48:46

about

00:48:47

this concept;

00:48:51

we can’t analyze

00:48:54

Stalin’s, this can be seen in the letter to the congress, and

00:48:57

he also saw the threat of Trotsky’s dictatorship,

00:49:00

this is also visible in the letter to the congress, well, that’s

00:49:04

all that can be said for sure on this topic

00:49:06

How long will the war last and how long

00:49:08

will the regime be able to withstand it the regime will be able

00:49:10

to withstand it for quite a long time, we were just

00:49:11

talking about this about what

00:49:12

tools it has for this,

00:49:15

how long it will last. Yes, we don’t know, that’s all.

00:49:17

We hope for March,

00:49:18

March twenty-four, for

00:49:22

this electoral cycle and for the fact that

00:49:25

something will change in it, if March

00:49:27

slips by, then you already need to look at the fall,

00:49:32

that is, the next stage associated with

00:49:35

hopes will be the fall, when the

00:49:38

fighting will simply be problematic because of the

00:49:39

dissolution because of the thaw. So

00:49:43

yes,

00:49:46

and if you were invited by Ukrainian

00:49:48

political bloggers, then you would

00:49:49

agreed Yes, there are problems with the Russian

00:49:51

law If it weren’t for that, I might

00:49:53

have agreed And

00:49:54

in general I refuse even unwanted Russian organizations

00:50:01

So

00:50:04

questions How do you search for media content for

00:50:07

your videos, how do you find old recordings

00:50:09

uploaded in 2014 How much

00:50:11

time does it take to search And is the

00:50:12

archive big? The archive turned out big.

00:50:16

There are hundreds of videos, as I find on Google and

00:50:21

in any search engine, in fact, there are

00:50:24

tools

00:50:27

to sort news and articles and other

00:50:30

materials by time, respectively, if

00:50:32

you

00:50:33

need a rally of some kind,

00:50:37

for example, on February 20, 2014 you

00:50:40

sorts first in a search engine, look

00:50:41

then look, it’s important that you need to watch

00:50:43

not only on

00:50:44

YouTube but also on VKontakte in Odnoklassniki

00:50:47

because they also posted videos there en

00:50:51

masse One of the rallies that would be in the

00:50:56

new phase of the ATO anti-terrorist

00:50:59

operation, I could only find it on

00:51:01

VKontakte Well, probably somewhere in Ukrainians

00:51:03

also have him on social networks. But among

00:51:05

Russians, I only found him on VKontakte, but

00:51:07

he wasn’t on YouTube or in the news.

00:51:10

Alexander, before the elections, the security forces will

00:51:13

take you seriously, do you have any

00:51:16

escape routes, who knows if the

00:51:17

escape routes will allow you to retreat, maybe

00:51:19

we won’t retreat they’ll give it So we’ll sit and

00:51:23

see, maybe we’ll retreat Who knows,

00:51:26

regrouping in

00:51:28

Kazakhstan

00:51:30

on the right bank of the

00:51:34

Dnieper The left bank doesn’t matter so

00:51:38

and Alexander Can you please

00:51:40

advise what he reads on the topic of the

00:51:41

civil war in Russia Shubina can

00:51:43

read Alexander Vladlenovich is a good

00:51:45

author And there is a book here, this is the

00:51:48

eighteenth year revolution washed in blood

00:51:52

nice material he has a whole series of

00:51:55

books an anarchist

00:51:57

sympathizes with the Ultra Left keep this in

00:52:00

mind well he Let's Sorry that he is not an

00:52:02

anarchist he is a researcher of anarchist

00:52:04

anarchism who is interested in anarchism

00:52:06

and who has spent a lot on this

00:52:08

research itself because of this he is a little

00:52:10

sympathizes with these forces in the horse

00:52:14

war Alexander How do you feel about Gandhi

00:52:16

’s philosophical resistance to

00:52:18

aggression Well, on the whole, don’t

00:52:20

you think it’s positive that his idea can be accepted by

00:52:21

Arova dictatorship seems so

00:52:25

insightful That’s what they also talked about

00:52:27

Why did it happen Why In developed

00:52:29

countries are non-violent the methods work

00:52:30

better because, well, the basis for non

00:52:32

-violent

00:52:33

resistance is greater today in developed

00:52:36

countries than for violent resistance,

00:52:43

so what do you think will happen after

00:52:46

Lukashenko leaves the political arena, what will be the

00:52:47

fate of Belarus? Belarus will be Freedom, a

00:52:49

democratic

00:52:50

country, Western-oriented Will there be

00:52:53

democratization? What will be the relationship with the

00:52:55

Russian Federation and the European Union

00:52:57

will have good relations with the Russian Federation, and especially if the

00:52:59

Russian Federation

00:53:01

ends the war by that time and will be a free country.

00:53:03

But if it is not, then

00:53:06

most likely relations with Russia

00:53:08

will be uh quite good because

00:53:10

economic ties are too strong uh

00:53:13

Not even democratic -

00:53:15

the government, even about the Western one,

00:53:16

will not want to break these ties,

00:53:18

plus you need to understand the

00:53:20

electoral mood of Belarusians, that

00:53:21

Belarusians en masse have a pretty good

00:53:23

attitude towards Russia, towards Russians towards Russians,

00:53:26

and

00:53:28

therefore, in fact, there is

00:53:33

every reason for the union

00:53:36

state to be preserved and for the

00:53:37

relations between Belarus and Russia

00:53:39

remained good, in fact, in

00:53:42

fact, such a Paradox for a

00:53:44

democratic Belarus, it would have been easier for the

00:53:45

Russian

00:53:47

Federation to unite with it within

00:53:51

one union

00:53:53

state, just used its

00:53:57

dictatorial powers to the detriment of the

00:54:00

union state, but it would have been

00:54:03

good there in the nineties and zeros as it is

00:54:05

now this will work I don’t know,

00:54:10

but Alexander How did you teach

00:54:13

history at the university? Are you satisfied with

00:54:14

this education or is it a continuation of

00:54:15

school patriotism? No, this is not a

00:54:17

continuation of school

00:54:20

patriotism, of course 30 seconds. Well, of course

00:54:24

they taught better there, let’s

00:54:26

run out of time in the meantime, and

00:54:29

Thank you all for that they were present

00:54:31

Thank you all for your questions,

00:54:35

subscribe to my Youtube channel

00:54:37

Alexander Shtifanov subscribe to the

00:54:38

Telegram channel subscribe to empty

00:54:40

support the living nail here

00:54:41

some QR codes were added that are not related to me

00:54:43

but click on them anyway

00:54:45

So follow the news Russia will be

00:54:47

free and this war will end sooner or

00:54:54

later

Description:

Поддержать Живой гвоздь: с карт российских банков https://pay.cloudtips.ru/p/7edd7c0e с карт иностранных банков https://www.donationalerts.com/r/zhivgvozd Boosty: https://boosty.to/zhivoygvozd Криптокошелёк: bc1qmdt96xvsun9a8qxvgakfx9gqy4x72penx5rm2p Trust Wallet: https://link.trustwallet.com/send?address=bc1qmdt96xvsun9a8qxvgakfx9gqy4x72penx5rm2p&asset=c0 В прямом эфире на вопросы зрителей отвечает блогер, историк-просветитель Александр Штефанов* @Chamade. Подписывайтесь также в Телеграме: https://t.me/alexandrshtefanov * – российские власти считают иностранным агентом Новый — пятый том комикса в серии «Спасти» уже в продаже! На этот раз авторы попытались вызволить из Тауэра наследников внезапно скончавшегося английского короля Эдуарда IV. Купить: https://diletant.shop/tproduct/596598185-351029717571-kniga-spasti-printsev-iz-tauera-tom-5 📌 Живой гвоздь в аудиоформате: https://podcast.ru/1616175210 🔔 Последние новости и анонсы программ с YouTube-канала «Живой гвоздь», а также контент от наших постоянных гостей и экспертов на официальном телеграм-канале: https://t.me/livegvozd Мобильное приложение "Эха": любимые программы в формате радиоприёмника. Простой интерфейс. Работа в фоновом режиме. Расписание эфиров. Скачать: в AppStore: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/%D1%8D%D1%85%D0%BE-online/id1639907671 в PlayMarket: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=online.echofm.app Сайт "Эха": https://echofm.online/ (если не открывается – ссылка на рабочую версию сайта всегда есть в тг-канале ЭХО FM https://telegram.org/ Подписаться на Youtube-канал Дилетант: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuIE7-5QzeAR6EdZXwDRwuQ?sub_confirmation=1 Магазин Дилетант: https://diletant.shop/ По вопросам взаимодействия: [email protected]

Preparing download options

Popular

HD video

Only sound

All

* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."

** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players

Questions about downloading video

How can I download "Прекрасная Россия Будущего. Новый «Путин». Александр Штефанов*: #СлухайЭхо // 13.11.23" video?

http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.

Which format of "Прекрасная Россия Будущего. Новый «Путин». Александр Штефанов*: #СлухайЭхо // 13.11.23" video should I choose?

The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.

Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Прекрасная Россия Будущего. Новый «Путин». Александр Штефанов*: #СлухайЭхо // 13.11.23" video?

The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.

How can I download "Прекрасная Россия Будущего. Новый «Путин». Александр Штефанов*: #СлухайЭхо // 13.11.23" video to my phone?

You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.

How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Прекрасная Россия Будущего. Новый «Путин». Александр Штефанов*: #СлухайЭхо // 13.11.23"?

The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.

How can I save a frame from a video "Прекрасная Россия Будущего. Новый «Путин». Александр Штефанов*: #СлухайЭхо // 13.11.23"?

This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.

What's the price of all this stuff?

It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.