Download "Непростой Разговор: Борис Акунин / @true_russia"

Please wait. We're preparing links for easy ad-free video watching and downloading.

Previous video: Аркадий Дубнов / Персонально ваш // 17.05.2022 Next video: Без посредников. Алексей Венедиктов* / 22.05.24

Без посредников. Алексей Венедиктов* / 22.05.24

Без посредников. Алексей Венедиктов* / 22.05.24

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Аркадий Дубнов / Персонально ваш // 17.05.2022

Аркадий Дубнов / Персонально ваш // 17.05.2022

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Навальная за русских! Тело Навального. Самоубийство Мурза. Журавель. 69 минут. Кашин* и Лазерсон

Навальная за русских! Тело Навального. Самоубийство Мурза. Журавель. 69 минут. Кашин* и Лазерсон

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Пастуховские четверги / Владимир Пастухов и Лиза Аникина // 16.06.2022

Пастуховские четверги / Владимир Пастухов и Лиза Аникина // 16.06.2022

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Утренний разворот / Передача «Троицы» / Борис Кагарлицкий* / Маша Майерс и Ирина Баблоян / 17.05.23

Утренний разворот / Передача «Троицы» / Борис Кагарлицкий* / Маша Майерс и Ирина Баблоян / 17.05.23

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Кандидат против Путина на выборах 2024. Борис Надеждин: Утренний разворот / 01.11.23

Кандидат против Путина на выборах 2024. Борис Надеждин: Утренний разворот / 01.11.23

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Белковский + Бунтман / 22 сен 2023 @BelkovskiyS

Белковский + Бунтман / 22 сен 2023 @BelkovskiyS

Channel: Белковский

Белковский + Бунтман // 04.05.2023 @BelkovskiyS

Белковский + Бунтман // 04.05.2023 @BelkovskiyS

Channel: Белковский

Утренний разворот / Соловей* / Потапенко / Красильщик / Гельфанд / Лазерсон и Аникина // 18.03.23

Утренний разворот / Соловей* / Потапенко / Красильщик / Гельфанд / Лазерсон и Аникина // 18.03.23

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Вадим Радионов / Персонально ваш // 20.10.23 @i_gryanul_grem

Вадим Радионов / Персонально ваш // 20.10.23 @i_gryanul_grem

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

венедиктов

пастухов

живой гвоздь

политика

00:00:00

Hello everyone, I served Elena as and this is a

00:00:03

difficult conversation about black and white, in

00:00:06

principle, anything can be him

00:00:09

or me, but these are not opposites since they are

00:00:12

always clusters of each other’s colors

00:00:14

and the perception of how yin black or yam

00:00:18

white will depend on many

00:00:20

factors my guest today the writer is

00:00:22

Boris Akunin, but what if we consider

00:00:24

Russia from the position of them I, what we are

00:00:28

today and we will see positive and

00:00:30

negative will depend on

00:00:31

many factors, yes, of course,

00:00:34

these are still very personal questions, I think

00:00:37

that everyone will answer it

00:00:39

differently, they are native there is a very

00:00:42

difficult conversation ahead because we are now

00:00:43

living in very difficult times,

00:00:46

what are difficult times difficult

00:00:48

times when some things become

00:00:51

very simple black and white, for

00:00:54

example, are you for war or are you against

00:00:58

war are you for the dictatorship of the elite against the

00:01:01

dictatorship there on this matter there, for

00:01:06

example, with fluctuations of which there is no answer, the answer is

00:01:08

clear, but there are things that are very difficult,

00:01:12

there are things in which it’s really

00:01:14

like the yin and yang of the incomprehensible grandfather black

00:01:17

comes with white and they are all mixed, this is

00:01:20

something that torments us but many of us now in these

00:01:24

months so much because that

00:01:28

one of the most important

00:01:32

aspects of our where and my

00:01:34

existence is given to this zone, this is a question of identification itself,

00:01:38

because we are people, that is to say,

00:01:42

Russian culture, people from Russia, what is

00:01:46

happening now

00:01:50

in the world, what is happening now with

00:01:53

Russia, this is an absolutely

00:01:55

absolutely unbearable

00:01:59

situation and

00:02:00

this is a time when attitudes towards Russia have not

00:02:04

only changed in a

00:02:05

catastrophic way in the world, this is a time when

00:02:07

each of us is rethinking our

00:02:09

own relations with Russia and our

00:02:12

own attitude towards Russia, and I know

00:02:17

that many of us, many of those who have left

00:02:21

now or before, feel a very

00:02:23

strong desire to sever these ties

00:02:26

to distance myself, to say that I don’t want

00:02:29

to have anything to do with this, it has nothing to do with it,

00:02:32

I know one of the writers there,

00:02:36

and now suddenly he says, I will write

00:02:39

in English, one of the journalists

00:02:41

starts making programs in

00:02:43

English, I can imagine what is

00:02:45

happening there now I don’t know with

00:02:48

Russian young people and children

00:02:51

who were born abroad, many

00:02:54

have a desire to completely

00:02:56

erase this entire Russian half from themselves

00:02:57

and completely assimilate,

00:02:59

distance themselves, and so on and so

00:03:01

forth,

00:03:02

and when I talk about a complex

00:03:06

relationship,

00:03:08

I don’t mean the relationship of the state

00:03:10

of the Russian Federation, everything is clear to me here,

00:03:13

for me the state of the Russian

00:03:16

Federation

00:03:18

no longer exists,

00:03:20

the state of the Russian Federation

00:03:22

no longer exists, we are talking about

00:03:25

relationships specifically with Russia with

00:03:29

Russian culture with the fact that the

00:03:32

Russian world has now become a dirty word, yes this is a

00:03:36

phrase from which many simply

00:03:38

begin to promise

00:03:41

because it is completely

00:03:43

compromised, although it’s not

00:03:45

Russian conditions, don’t call conditions the world, it seems like there’s

00:03:47

nothing bad, so

00:03:48

each of us has to

00:03:50

make our own choice and

00:03:53

I have to make such a choice, and on the one hand,

00:03:56

psychologically,

00:03:57

due to the circumstances, it seems like

00:04:00

it would be much

00:04:03

easier for me to do this than many others because,

00:04:05

firstly, I have been living in Europe for a long time and

00:04:09

have not been to Russia for many years;

00:04:11

secondly, I have no problems with the language;

00:04:15

thirdly, in fact, I

00:04:16

even have British citizenship;

00:04:18

I applied for British citizenship when

00:04:22

Putin changed the constitution;

00:04:24

it became clear that he was going to become a

00:04:26

monarch, I thought, well, if

00:04:29

monarchs were to be served, according to the data,

00:04:31

honest monarchs would be better than a fake monarchy, not to

00:04:35

mention the fact that I like Elizabeth the Second

00:04:36

about a million times more than

00:04:38

Vladimir 1,

00:04:40

but for me this is not the way,

00:04:44

but for me this is not the way at all I’m here I

00:04:47

had some kind of speech here to the

00:04:49

English audience and they

00:04:52

introduced me there obviously as if wanting to

00:04:55

please me if in British

00:04:57

delicacy as Church invited a

00:04:59

Georgian writer I had to make

00:05:02

an amendment to say that I was Georgian and both a

00:05:04

Russian writer and a Russian the writer and

00:05:10

this combination of the Russian writer for me

00:05:13

does not reveal one from the other,

00:05:16

Russian culture is part of me and this is

00:05:20

probably the main fate since I

00:05:22

write and

00:05:24

I very clearly see in front of me these

00:05:26

two Russias, one of which I love and the

00:05:31

other which I hate,

00:05:34

you can Is it possible to transfer

00:05:36

yin-yang to any phenomenon and concept,

00:05:39

let’s say the attitude towards death in Russia, on the

00:05:42

one hand, there is an immortal regiment and on the

00:05:44

other, tens of hundreds of unburied

00:05:48

Russian soldiers in Ukraine, this is also

00:05:50

part of the culture, too, and how they

00:05:53

are compared,

00:05:56

but they

00:05:58

probably are not inserted in any way because

00:06:01

if you’re talking about the Immortal

00:06:03

Regiment action, it started out as something alive and

00:06:06

something

00:06:08

real, then it turned into something

00:06:11

lawns and quite meaningless, like everything

00:06:14

that

00:06:15

the hand of

00:06:18

this state touches,

00:06:24

no, I’m not even thinking about that right now

00:06:27

you are talking about people who go out there

00:06:30

somewhere to some kind of government officials, these same

00:06:33

people about whom it is now

00:06:35

customary in general in the world to talk

00:06:38

badly about how passive they are and how they

00:06:40

support the dictatorship, how they are all

00:06:42

to blame, all that stuff, and again I

00:06:45

I think in terms of this, and apparently

00:06:51

due to my

00:06:54

Japanese education, I soon

00:06:57

had a dialogue with the writer Mikhail

00:06:59

Shishkin several years ago where I talked about the fact that

00:07:03

there are two completely separate and

00:07:08

Russian forces, 2 social forces, and

00:07:12

which are constantly fighting among themselves

00:07:15

for

00:07:17

some kind of spiritual power over the

00:07:19

main population who look in

00:07:22

both directions and choose these two

00:07:26

hostile forces have existed in Russia there for at

00:07:28

least 200 years, they have completely

00:07:31

different ideals, they have completely different

00:07:35

heroes, those who are heroes for us,

00:07:39

as a rule are enemies and

00:07:41

vice versa, so if you start

00:07:45

to make up such that Lena and I don’t know the

00:07:48

Pentium of

00:07:49

my heroes and my anti-heroes, I’m sure

00:07:53

that this will be a conclusion that is something

00:07:55

opposite compared to the pantheon of

00:07:57

some Vladimir Putin,

00:07:59

relatively speaking, give them as an example,

00:08:01

with several of your heroes and

00:08:03

anti-heroes, which was clear, yes,

00:08:06

that means, of course,

00:08:10

my favorite hero from the earliest years is the

00:08:13

author of the story of bygone years,

00:08:16

historians argue what his name was, not

00:08:18

old or Sylvester, it doesn’t matter, but this

00:08:21

man without whom we would not know

00:08:24

the history of Russia in general, that’s how he saw it,

00:08:27

how they wrote down how we teach those whom

00:08:31

he loved loved those and loved ones whom he did

00:08:35

not love and I don’t know rightly or wrongly

00:08:38

dark are considered villains, it really warms my

00:08:40

soul the thought that the most important person in

00:08:43

ancient Russian history was a writer,

00:08:46

but this no, it seems to give hope and in

00:08:49

general for the fact that with Russia everything may be

00:08:51

bad because a country that

00:08:53

begins with literature, no one is a

00:08:56

lost country, then if you move

00:08:58

further through the Middle Ages, I really

00:09:01

like

00:09:02

Nil Sorsky, this is an ideologist of non-covetousness, a

00:09:07

man who tried unsuccessfully

00:09:09

to turn the Orthodox Church away from

00:09:13

Caesar in spirituality, here he is it didn’t

00:09:17

work out because you forgot other

00:09:19

interests

00:09:21

interesting and touching, but either

00:09:24

some beautifully stuffy novices

00:09:27

who naturally fell into fate in the Russian

00:09:30

fortress or there the first Russian

00:09:33

intellectual

00:09:34

Radishchev whose soul was

00:09:37

wounded by suffering became from this, in

00:09:40

fact, the history of the intelligentsia in Russia began

00:09:42

with the fact that the soul

00:09:44

became wounded, well, of course, the

00:09:46

main person in general in Russian history

00:09:50

and culture is Pushkin, with whom we were

00:09:53

all incredibly lucky; difficulties

00:09:56

in imagining what Russia would be like

00:09:57

without Pushkin because he brought

00:10:01

there this wonderful

00:10:03

living thing our

00:10:06

idea of humor our

00:10:07

idea of the beautiful and not beautiful and in

00:10:09

the language in general, our idea of

00:10:13

the beautiful and the ugly

00:10:14

comes largely from the cannon. The most interesting thing

00:10:17

is that if you ask people from the

00:10:18

opposite camp, they will not call Pushkin either,

00:10:20

it will be another Pushkin, it

00:10:23

will be Pushkin, the author of the Borodino anniversary to the

00:10:27

slanderers of Russia, these absolutely

00:10:29

some of these senseless graphs

00:10:31

masks and poems, from my point of

00:10:33

view, dreams are not the opposite, but

00:10:36

Chekhov, of course, is the

00:10:40

best in human qualities of

00:10:43

all Russian writers, Korolenko is

00:10:46

such a good person that it

00:10:48

even prevented him from being a very good

00:10:49

writer;

00:10:50

writers are really good at it, but he is

00:10:52

still without Woland everything doesn’t happen for some,

00:10:55

but Korolenko was a completely

00:10:56

human being and she or there, but of course

00:11:00

any of us would name Andrei Sakharov,

00:11:03

although Sakharov, from a literary point of view, is

00:11:07

also a very difficult

00:11:10

character, let’s not forget that

00:11:12

he is the inventor of the hydrogen bomb and that it is

00:11:15

quite possible that we humanity will perish

00:11:19

due to the fact that a wonderful man Andrei

00:11:22

Sakharov invented the hydrogen bomb if

00:11:25

someone writes somewhere a

00:11:27

novel called humanity and we

00:11:30

are all heroes of this work

00:11:32

it will be literary and the plot is a very

00:11:34

strong move I can tell you about

00:11:35

anti-heroes if you want

00:11:38

but Ivan the formidable

00:11:41

Ivan the Terrible is no coincidence, to tell

00:11:45

all these people for and did not go to the official

00:11:47

historical party, they get so angry when

00:11:50

you start calling Ivan the Terrible a

00:11:53

villain and a murderer, then to my

00:11:56

stress monuments they say Irakli

00:11:58

Vitaly is a foreigner and when people is he

00:12:01

important to them or what a vile Pyotr

00:12:04

Andreevich tolstoy this same KGB

00:12:07

officer Peter 1, who has committed all sorts of

00:12:12

disgusting

00:12:13

acts, is a world champion in survival or

00:12:18

some founder of the current

00:12:20

cesspool propagandists Thaddeus

00:12:22

Bulgarin

00:12:23

or an eternal traitor and without azef who,

00:12:28

so to speak, killed from the other side from

00:12:30

this country in Soviet times,

00:12:32

of course

00:12:34

Stalin

00:12:36

Stalin of course I was a champion on this list

00:12:39

until recently. On

00:12:45

February 24, I

00:12:49

told him that I went out to work as usual

00:12:51

in the morning to write a book that I was

00:12:53

very interested in, the code name is

00:12:55

bright people of Russian history about the role of

00:12:58

personality in history, bright people as with a

00:13:01

plus sign as with a minus sign

00:13:04

because It often happens that villains move

00:13:05

history much more actively than any

00:13:07

positive characters, and suddenly

00:13:10

all this happened, and now I

00:13:14

think with some horror and disgust that it

00:13:17

may well turn out

00:13:19

that the brightest and largest

00:13:22

personality in Russian history seems to be

00:13:23

Vladimir Putin,

00:13:25

this means a person who cares On

00:13:28

February 24, and treated the comic villain with such a reaction to anything, he

00:13:33

suddenly turned out to be not at all comical.

00:13:37

Now we are in a situation where these

00:13:40

people, but he is definitely the same age as the Russian

00:13:41

state and does not raise the same doubts,

00:13:43

may well destroy life on the

00:13:45

planet because he threatens with nuclear

00:13:47

weapons who then will be the

00:13:50

most important Herve personality in Russian

00:13:53

history if not he and you there if the person

00:13:55

who is a travers

00:13:59

look if in the east the concept and

00:14:02

I is fundamental this in Russia

00:14:05

after about

00:14:08

1915 such a concept was important with the

00:14:11

main symbol should have become

00:14:14

black square, I don’t think Russia is a black

00:14:18

square, I don’t think that you can’t understand it with your mind, you

00:14:22

can’t measure it with a common yardstick, that’s how

00:14:26

only a poet can speak,

00:14:27

as a poet doesn’t have to be smart, he’s

00:14:32

strong in others with his qualities, so

00:14:36

if I don’t understand something, I try to

00:14:38

understand it, I try to find

00:14:41

an explanation for this, and by the way, in relation to

00:14:44

Russia, I tried to do this with my

00:14:48

very

00:14:49

[music] or something

00:14:50

like the royal

00:14:53

arithmetic mind, which means I

00:14:56

began to think that everyone, of course, to talk

00:15:01

about some kind of national mentality is a

00:15:04

rather dubious activity; generalizing is

00:15:07

always risky and nevertheless We all

00:15:10

know and understand that there is some kind of

00:15:13

collective Russian that differs from the

00:15:16

collective British or from the

00:15:17

collective Chinese, so I somehow

00:15:21

began to think about how to determine this formula.

00:15:25

There are

00:15:27

several cultures that are not

00:15:31

alien to me, besides Russian, I decided that I would start with

00:15:33

them so as not to it was mixed in that this is an

00:15:35

emotional thing to say, and I am

00:15:38

interested in the formula of

00:15:41

what a given culture strives for, what

00:15:44

it considers commendable, what it

00:15:46

considers beautiful, because every

00:15:49

phenomenon must be judged because of

00:15:51

the best that is in it and because of what it

00:15:54

could become, what it would like to become what does

00:15:56

he strive for they smell some kind of

00:15:58

qualities that are often caused by

00:16:00

injuries there are incidents and so on, well,

00:16:04

I decided everything should be a triad

00:16:07

that I should be nearby and because the

00:16:10

detachments they are more accustomed to coming from the trinity there is

00:16:14

freedom equality and brotherhood

00:16:16

peace work May

00:16:18

quiet Kirchi kinder three points already

00:16:22

allow you to create some kind of

00:16:24

volume, so I began to think about what

00:16:28

formulas the British family takes

00:16:30

because, but I live in Britain, I look

00:16:33

around and I’m interested, so I thought that

00:16:38

this is the British ideal

00:16:41

formula, what’s in this culture

00:16:44

is considered the most commendable and worthy,

00:16:47

probably, firstly, of course,

00:16:50

freedom is unconditional because England is the first

00:16:53

country that touched freedom

00:16:55

back in the

00:16:56

13th century with the Liberty Charter, secondly, it is

00:17:01

certainly a divider, the dignity of which is

00:17:04

inextricably linked with freedom, without

00:17:07

freedom it does not exist, and thirdly, this is

00:17:09

probably honestly, the game is fair play,

00:17:12

that is, this is the correct one, this

00:17:14

squad is quite nice, let's

00:17:17

try about France, which you

00:17:19

are going to

00:17:21

figure out there, no, you think where,

00:17:24

absolutely, since 1789, that's liberty, that's

00:17:29

for sure, but about equality and brotherhood, I do

00:17:31

n't think so, it seems to me that the other two

00:17:34

components French, these bastards of the triad

00:17:37

are, firstly,

00:17:40

such a spirit, sublimity and spray, and just like that, to

00:17:44

rise above the ground,

00:17:46

aspiration, such faith and of course

00:17:49

beauty, like this, this is freedom, I do

00:17:54

n’t know, as if from a teacher,

00:17:56

sublimity of spirit, varnish, such

00:17:58

elation and beauty, this is French

00:18:01

detachment is also nice, we respect the Japanese,

00:18:03

who, frankly speaking, are not strangers to me,

00:18:06

who interest me very keenly, well,

00:18:09

firstly, of course, the feeling of a

00:18:11

long, long time, and secondly, this is the word

00:18:16

for which there is no exact correspondence in the

00:18:17

Russian language, it is also called sits down,

00:18:20

this is a quality that in Japanese

00:18:23

is considered the most the main thing is such

00:18:26

sincerity, authenticity, genuine, yes,

00:18:29

because what is hara-kiri,

00:18:31

this is a samurai showing his pipe,

00:18:34

look, I have nothing to hide, with this

00:18:37

act of mine I demonstrate my

00:18:39

connection, this is where in the literature

00:18:43

you can talk about someone in demand in the same Kiev,

00:18:44

often in demand. there is among the virgin lands to be

00:18:46

satiated, how to translate it in Russian,

00:18:49

there is not even an exact translation, but this is a very

00:18:51

important quality and the third quality is,

00:18:53

of course, beauty too, but not like the

00:18:56

French because Japanese beauty

00:18:59

is beauty that does not hit the eye, it will be

00:19:01

genes, it is hidden beauty, it is a constant

00:19:04

requiring some qualifications and

00:19:05

some training, also a nice

00:19:07

series turns out, but now let’s move on to the

00:19:11

difficult task, let’s move on to the Russian strand

00:19:14

and

00:19:17

it also turns out very beautiful and

00:19:22

completely different. I won’t take from the

00:19:24

thieves’ triad the very glory of autocracy

00:19:28

in Orthodoxy, the people because this is a

00:19:30

triad that is beneficial to the state and it

00:19:34

was always beneficial to the state, and

00:19:36

now it is called differently, but to give a

00:19:38

complete hint, it was preserved and the

00:19:40

autocracy was preserved and Orthodoxy

00:19:43

was preserved and the nationality was preserved, the

00:19:46

nationality is the style of Russian

00:19:48

television, this untied snow

00:19:51

there with such a dense presence through the teeth,

00:19:54

as if a conversation in which the authorities

00:19:55

are talking to the people here we are and the people, I’m

00:19:57

with you, I’m the people, I’m not with these bespectacled

00:20:00

mia, here I am the people’s power for soaking in

00:20:03

the toilet, this is what the people of

00:20:05

Russian diplomacy with others

00:20:06

distributed to the diplomat, that is, it’s not

00:20:08

only from the people’s balance of the main

00:20:10

ones, you can’t even have the president

00:20:12

remember another president,

00:20:15

I think that this Lavrov

00:20:18

is talking on the sidelines with the

00:20:21

plans there until 7, not like he will talk

00:20:22

in front of television cameras, this is all being done, to

00:20:25

say for the Russian branch, I am

00:20:27

absolutely sure of this, so if

00:20:29

we talk about Russianness, what is

00:20:32

Russianness? triad yes, it seems to me

00:20:35

that the first component is the truth,

00:20:41

here is the desire to get to the very essence,

00:20:44

right down to the self-destructive sti

00:20:47

what about the brother, this is the notorious one,

00:20:49

explained by the fact that the truth

00:20:51

has always been given very difficult in this country, you

00:20:55

always had to reach it with your

00:20:56

mind and with risking your life to get to the bottom of this,

00:20:58

therefore, this is a very important thing, searching for water,

00:21:00

you are the truth who are leading there Russian

00:21:01

literature and Russian philosophy and Russian

00:21:05

political activism, the

00:21:07

second feature that is considered highly

00:21:11

commendable and valuable is compassion and

00:21:14

it is, of course, directly related to

00:21:19

great Russian literature, but also

00:21:21

all- with Orthodoxy, because I am a

00:21:24

non-religious church-going person,

00:21:26

I understand that real,

00:21:28

unalloyed Orthodoxy is built

00:21:30

primarily on compassion, and

00:21:32

finally, of course, the third feature is this kind of

00:21:37

breadth,

00:21:40

breadth, which is explained, again, by the fact

00:21:42

that a person always he was not free, he

00:21:44

was shackled, he was squeezed, he was yearning all the time

00:21:47

because to straighten his

00:21:50

shoulders and somehow breathe freely and

00:21:53

breadth is something very much what he

00:21:57

strives for, as it seems to me, such a

00:22:00

national thing of forest nature, of course,

00:22:02

and space Russian also matters here,

00:22:03

that is, at its best,

00:22:08

Russian is such an archetypal person, this is

00:22:12

some kind of compassionate and spiritual

00:22:16

generous prada seeker, this is not the

00:22:18

worst picture, there is no smell of a black square here,

00:22:22

but

00:22:25

when we look at Russian history and

00:22:28

when we look around us, we Every now and

00:22:32

then we see a completely different Russian

00:22:33

person who behaves completely

00:22:36

differently, who means he will be shot

00:22:39

in Katyn, who will commit atrocities in the

00:22:44

gulag, who will create

00:22:47

this horror in the riot until such an eternal,

00:22:52

such an eternal thing with a washing

00:22:56

machine on a tank, well, that’s something like that

00:22:59

and now for the whole world he

00:23:02

has completely obscured that Russian

00:23:04

person whom I love at home and which I

00:23:07

described above, the world sees only I could,

00:23:10

now the Russian Russian is this one

00:23:14

and this one also exists, it is

00:23:17

passed down from generation to generation,

00:23:19

this muddy

00:23:21

dark

00:23:23

tradition of water with a dog heads on a broom,

00:23:27

and at the same

00:23:29

time, these people consider themselves

00:23:33

real Russians,

00:23:34

real patriots,

00:23:39

but

00:23:41

let's move on from

00:23:43

where it comes from where it

00:23:45

comes from this muddy and

00:23:48

dirty

00:23:49

force to which now this muddy stuff

00:23:52

that has fallen to the surface where it

00:23:54

comes from

00:23:56

why so many people are so willing rolling around

00:24:00

in this mud, this is also something

00:24:02

national, something Russian, which is

00:24:04

Russian, so I remember my Soviet

00:24:07

childhood, although I had a very short

00:24:09

period of this Soviet childhood, I got it, but I

00:24:11

remember

00:24:12

the teacher who humiliated you there

00:24:14

and was cruel and remember any Soviet

00:24:18

hospital when to bring you to

00:24:20

us, don’t sit there and now I’ll

00:24:23

sew your mouth up there people so this is for me

00:24:26

I always take if Putin they will

00:24:29

always remain these people who

00:24:30

work in the hospital in prison I don’t have a site

00:24:33

in any woman’s who does not see you as

00:24:35

a person and who

00:24:37

humiliate you and trample you under this power, this is the very

00:24:42

quality, the very properties that all my

00:24:45

life I have considered my main enemy in

00:24:49

Russia, and

00:24:51

this is not something

00:24:53

fatal, this is not something mystical, this is

00:24:57

not there is something incurable because

00:25:01

this syndrome has you, if you will, of

00:25:04

a disease and I completely understand the

00:25:07

specific reason, the

00:25:08

historical reason, I would call the

00:25:12

key factor by which the

00:25:15

value of each individual

00:25:18

person in a country of

00:25:20

civilization is determined, and the

00:25:23

level

00:25:25

of development or lack of

00:25:27

self-esteem

00:25:29

is the most important factor because a

00:25:32

person or a culture or a country where

00:25:37

self-esteem is highly developed

00:25:39

will lead and

00:25:41

will respect both oneself and others because

00:25:45

otherwise it is unworthy to behave if we

00:25:47

look at the history of Russia we will see

00:25:51

that

00:25:52

self-esteem and

00:25:55

tyranny are incompatible things for tyranny

00:25:59

any tyranny self-esteem

00:26:00

dignity is the main enemy, that’s why

00:26:02

I hate Stalin most of all,

00:26:07

because Stalin, as a person who is

00:26:10

certainly very capable and very

00:26:13

calculating, systematically trampled down his

00:26:17

subjects’ self-

00:26:18

esteem, they all had to

00:26:21

go through humiliation, he simply

00:26:23

organically did not bring people around him

00:26:26

who had a sense of self

00:26:29

dignity and now our current Stalin

00:26:33

is completely on his way

00:26:37

to you remember this security council,

00:26:39

these mean these same slaves who are

00:26:42

already sitting in their heads, this is

00:26:44

how they have degrees of dignity 0

00:26:50

not a single person with

00:26:51

self-esteem after it came to February 24,

00:26:55

the state a person who cares about

00:26:57

the good of the state, they

00:26:59

would not have remained at their post in their own skin,

00:27:03

have you seen these people resign at least once there, they

00:27:05

understand everything, many of them and

00:27:08

I am

00:27:10

disgusted by these so-called

00:27:11

systemic liberals

00:27:13

who keep afloat, this

00:27:16

means this cunning ship because

00:27:19

they have there is no self-esteem

00:27:21

because each of them thinks there

00:27:23

only for themselves

00:27:24

they find for themselves 150,000 critical

00:27:27

truth of course

00:27:28

you know this most developed intellect in

00:27:32

this sense is very helpful you will always

00:27:34

find well, how are people but what about Don

00:27:36

how is everything really all very

00:27:37

simple

00:27:39

and clear and this is the

00:27:42

lack of self-esteem

00:27:45

is the main Russian problem,

00:27:49

I have my

00:27:53

character for centuries, and since Petrovich Fandorin in one

00:27:56

of the novels

00:27:58

says, or rather says, we write in a diary

00:28:01

that there are proverbs and sayings that

00:28:03

hate Russians, so they collect in

00:28:08

it will be here this one is not

00:28:12

national, but you know this,

00:28:17

love me little black, the

00:28:20

elite will all go away,

00:28:24

everyone needs to eat, and

00:28:28

we won’t survive this with a whip, and you won’t break the neck from bowing, this is

00:28:32

all this, all the

00:28:35

result of the fact

00:28:37

that the state constantly kept people,

00:28:41

as it were, for the code

00:28:42

she bent her face to the ground look look

00:28:46

at the dirt look at the sky don’t look

00:28:48

in order for people to become different the

00:28:52

conditions of life in society

00:28:56

must change the

00:28:58

moral rules of

00:29:00

the state good states of the bad

00:29:02

differ in that in a good

00:29:03

state it is beneficial for the average person to

00:29:05

be good it is beneficial to behave

00:29:09

decently,

00:29:10

and vice versa, and here at the moment in the

00:29:12

modern Russian state it is

00:29:14

advantageous to behave indecently, it is

00:29:16

advantageous to be put, it is

00:29:19

advantageous for you to be an informer, it is advantageous

00:29:21

not to contradict your superiors in anything,

00:29:25

and guess what you want, this is all a

00:29:29

disgusting set of qualities and he has

00:29:32

long traditions to tell, this is what I

00:29:42

hate this very phenomenon called the Russian mentality,

00:29:48

these diseases have

00:29:51

positive results, doesn’t it

00:29:54

really depend on the state? It’s hard for me to

00:29:57

understand a woman who talks to

00:29:59

her son who is fighting in Ukraine, she

00:30:02

tells him that she

00:30:03

killed God with her own hands from Ukrainian children,

00:30:06

this is the same not only Putin is to blame for this,

00:30:10

chicken brains are to blame for this, the

00:30:13

inhabitants of probably any country have them, that’s why

00:30:17

I would

00:30:18

n’t

00:30:21

talk about this particular specific case, but the state, of course,

00:30:24

depends on a lot, the state in general

00:30:27

is needed for,

00:30:30

first of all, it seems to me, in order to

00:30:34

set the

00:30:37

tone for behavior even to a greater extent it

00:30:40

depends from state to state,

00:30:41

of course the function is to protect, help the

00:30:46

weak and not interfere too much with those who can

00:30:49

and want to work, as if the right hand of freedom is

00:30:51

correctly set up, but

00:30:55

there are also

00:31:00

separate functions for the first person of

00:31:01

the state,

00:31:02

this is also very important because the person and

00:31:05

that is, the person and his main task is

00:31:08

to set an example of decent behavior

00:31:11

so that you want to behave the way

00:31:14

he behaves, and this is

00:31:18

how it is, just like Shakespeare, here are two

00:31:23

faces, look at Vladimir Putin and

00:31:26

look at Zelensky, how they both

00:31:28

behave in this particular situation

00:31:31

Of course, we must also take into account the fact that the

00:31:34

universal, as it were, an actor, this comes easier to him,

00:31:37

well, Putin, himself of the country, has been

00:31:39

sitting there in the corner of power for a long time,

00:31:40

so that we could

00:31:42

learn what signals they give to

00:31:45

society,

00:31:46

as always, each of them, looking at

00:31:50

him, is about to, if the country should to

00:31:52

imitate him as the country will imitate with

00:31:55

such whom it will imitate as if sit

00:31:58

100 times about the mass such a first person with

00:32:00

such such a thing

00:32:03

French leaders are respected except for Chirac

00:32:08

advisors have always been people of culture

00:32:13

to dedicate or philosophers and writers

00:32:15

still macron

00:32:17

advises the writer has not placed a number

00:32:19

people who, in this case, Vladimir

00:32:22

Putin has

00:32:23

some other advisers to the

00:32:26

kind of culture we see, listen to the writer,

00:32:36

I’m honestly not sure that the head

00:32:39

of state can listen to the writer

00:32:40

because a writer is still a

00:32:42

rather

00:32:45

specific occupation and

00:32:49

state issues of public

00:32:51

administration are

00:32:52

not included in their number is another matter that there is a

00:32:56

head of state soup, most likely any

00:32:58

person in a very large

00:33:00

responsible position should have a set of

00:33:02

such tuning forks in different areas by

00:33:05

which he checks his decisions among

00:33:09

them, of course, there should

00:33:11

be people from the field of culture

00:33:13

because culture, among other things it is

00:33:15

also very important for the state and

00:33:18

public administration, it creates an

00:33:21

atmosphere in society, it gives it

00:33:23

some ideas for the direction of development, and so on and so

00:33:26

on, no, well,

00:33:29

about Vladimir Putin, and even to be honest, I have

00:33:32

n’t even

00:33:34

thought about it

00:33:36

for a long time,

00:33:39

besides, based on the general ideas that

00:33:44

when some kind of test occurs, like

00:33:46

this is a disaster, for some reason it is necessary, it means on the

00:33:50

highway, and for some reason you need to go through

00:33:52

this difficult stage, this is this test, I

00:33:59

naturally think about what will happen next,

00:34:02

what will happen then, what will happen to Russia what

00:34:06

will happen to the Russians and here, too,

00:34:08

it turns out like this, but there are

00:34:11

holes

00:34:13

here now, as it seems to me, there are two

00:34:17

options, or it

00:34:21

means that it will win and

00:34:24

Russia will turn into such a huge

00:34:27

North Korea that is a teacher of

00:34:29

nuclear missiles from the rest of

00:34:31

the world and will then rot for God knows how many

00:34:34

years and everyone will flourish there,

00:34:38

what I listed above is the meanness of

00:34:41

denunciation, servility, fear, this will

00:34:46

eat up generation after generation of living

00:34:49

people, be maimed, so it will turn

00:34:53

into such a I don’t know monster and things

00:34:55

for the whole world, this is a terrible idea and an

00:34:57

old idea and there is a second option he is

00:35:01

also very

00:35:02

[music]

00:35:04

heavy scary Russia in fact

00:35:07

now the current situation there is only

00:35:09

one way to cleanse and

00:35:12

rehabilitate and restore your

00:35:14

reputation this method is called

00:35:16

revolution

00:35:18

this is also a

00:35:23

dramatic tragic path this is the

00:35:26

path of purification but I don’t see 3 options

00:35:32

because everything the rest will

00:35:35

still be stained with dirt, for a long time

00:35:39

I have a feeling of

00:35:40

some kind of excellent bankruptcy

00:35:43

because

00:35:45

my generation,

00:35:48

we are kneeling, that is, this is the segment of

00:35:51

life for which we are responsible,

00:35:58

in August 1991 we stood in the

00:36:03

rain near the white house

00:36:04

we were a little afraid when we started

00:36:07

shooting,

00:36:08

three of us were killed, and

00:36:11

we all decided that from now on

00:36:16

Russia will have a happily ever after, we can

00:36:18

relax,

00:36:20

this new state has arisen,

00:36:22

tricolor,

00:36:24

double-headed eagle, everyone is free,

00:36:27

everything is fine, 30 years have passed, this is

00:36:31

the state in the

00:36:33

creation of which we took part,

00:36:35

you can say that it was our

00:36:37

state,

00:36:38

we didn’t preserve it, it has turned into who

00:36:42

what has it turned into is some kind of

00:36:45

major personal file a

00:36:48

file for the defeat of our generation and

00:36:51

now to pull Russia out of the mud and

00:36:55

raise it there somehow to rebuild it will be the

00:36:57

next generations who could have our children

00:36:59

there not for or already

00:37:01

We left this to our grandchildren, and

00:37:07

this,

00:37:09

even along with all sorts of other difficult

00:37:11

thoughts that have been overwhelming me in recent

00:37:14

months, this may be the hardest thing,

00:37:16

what options can there be and what

00:37:21

hopes for a revolution, if so, even if they are

00:37:23

fake, these polls are still 80

00:37:25

percent satisfied, I understand that of this

00:37:30

combination, let them be fake, are

00:37:32

these polls or are they fake, are they not

00:37:33

fakes, if they are fake, you can

00:37:35

ignore my personal one, Vera Shosh, I don’t

00:37:37

believe in any polls in a state in

00:37:40

which it’s scary to tell the truth, but

00:37:42

when I’m even a little uncomfortable for the

00:37:44

respected Levada Center, what he operates

00:37:46

seriously with these figures

00:37:49

where things are going in the right direction in

00:37:52

the wrong direction you want to know

00:37:54

in order to be on a company professional you are a

00:37:56

professional sociologist ask an indirect

00:37:58

question from which it will add up

00:37:59

to tell the real picture where these polls are

00:38:01

maybe they are somewhere but I don’t see them

00:38:04

so here

00:38:06

it means, well, what will happen next, there is

00:38:10

nothing new under the sun, it will be the same as it

00:38:12

has always been, we are dealing with an extremely

00:38:15

ineffective corrupt system

00:38:17

that cannot even fulfill the

00:38:19

vile tasks it sets for itself,

00:38:22

we see all this very well in the

00:38:24

example of this war, in the example of this

00:38:26

economics, using the example of this science,

00:38:31

these are

00:38:33

individuals who do not produce anything, we

00:38:36

see the level of physical thinking, all

00:38:39

the hope that is connected is that

00:38:42

God willing, ours will not abandon Beijing, and already the fact

00:38:45

that Russia, the Russian Federation,

00:38:47

will become a Chinese colony, God bless him,

00:38:49

only you can sit here for us

00:38:53

can continue for a long time only in one case, in

00:38:56

fact, if the Western leaders

00:38:59

finally decide that rather than the Russian

00:39:02

revolution, the transformation of this huge

00:39:04

space in Yugoslavia where everyone is at

00:39:07

war with everyone and there are nuclear weapons in them is better to

00:39:09

let this Saddam Hussein survive

00:39:11

than to overthrow him and a new gene will appear, it is

00:39:13

better to let in

00:39:15

This very dictator sits there and scares everyone with his

00:39:19

missiles, then the option is quite

00:39:21

real and

00:39:23

terrible specifically for Russia and for everything

00:39:26

that we talked about above, if this

00:39:30

does not happen, but it’s all falling apart, it will

00:39:33

all fall apart for economic reasons due

00:39:35

to the grave mistakes that it endlessly

00:39:39

makes this incompetent leadership

00:39:41

will be the same as February 17,

00:39:45

when no composition was needed,

00:39:47

no revolutionary and they

00:39:49

were all either you in migration or in Siberia and

00:39:51

still everything is fine

00:39:56

with Ukraine, I hope everything will be fine

00:40:02

because the situation now in Ukraine and

00:40:05

Ukrainians is terrible it’s really terrible and

00:40:08

yet I envy them in a certain sense

00:40:10

because everything is bad for them today,

00:40:13

but I don’t know that tomorrow everything will be

00:40:15

fine, but for the Russians today everything is bad and

00:40:19

tomorrow everything will be worse and everyone

00:40:21

knows and understands this too, Ukraine first

00:40:24

realized It’s

00:40:26

finally recognized itself as a real nation and has been recognized by the

00:40:31

whole world, it’s what they call seriously, it’s

00:40:34

finally appeared on the map as a big and

00:40:36

important country,

00:40:38

and God forbid that everything goes

00:40:42

well for it, I’m sure that everyone will help with this

00:40:46

if this very

00:40:50

bristling

00:40:51

Russian Federation dictatorship remains nearby then of

00:40:54

course there will be no peace for Ukraine, not for Europe, and for

00:40:58

the world, and there is

00:41:00

one more thing that I would like to

00:41:03

ask you, can I say that Boris

00:41:06

Akunin, her Grigory Chkhartishvili,

00:41:07

this is also a kind of yin-yang here, I have

00:41:10

more than one, I have several

00:41:12

pseudonyms, that’s why I not so much and not me as

00:41:14

such a Rubik's cube,

00:41:16

but I

00:41:21

never hid something that I think

00:41:24

as simply as a private person as a

00:41:28

person and now in general there are times

00:41:30

when it seems to me that the person

00:41:34

you are has some kind of public outlet he is

00:41:36

ashamed to remain silent,

00:41:38

the truth is now in such a situation,

00:41:41

silence is

00:41:43

tantamount to some kind of

00:41:46

captaincy, this is the 5th question, like the 5th question,

00:41:48

self-esteem, in

00:41:50

the end it all comes down to

00:41:51

I should probably make an amendment to

00:41:55

what I said above because this

00:41:57

applied to people who like me

00:42:00

are in security zone, if a

00:42:04

public person is

00:42:06

inside Russia, then for me personally, it will be

00:42:10

quite enough if he does not

00:42:12

participate in the abomination and does not

00:42:14

support them. We are now in a

00:42:17

situation where it is not even possible for a

00:42:21

public person to be complicit in this

00:42:25

crime, but now is an

00:42:27

act it’s just like it was like in the

00:42:30

USSR I’m saving myself and you communicate with people in

00:42:34

Russia you have friends left there and and

00:42:37

[music]

00:42:39

what changes did you see them again didn’t

00:42:42

come solution my friends left

00:42:46

simply because of the inability to endure this

00:42:49

atmosphere

00:42:50

out of reluctance to be even passive

00:42:52

accomplices are those who stayed

00:42:55

because of some

00:42:58

personal family circumstances that

00:43:00

cannot allow someone, as if

00:43:03

they say there, to leave him for everyone now is

00:43:06

very difficult and for me it is very

00:43:10

bright and scary for

00:43:13

me, naturally, since I am a writer, I

00:43:17

receive a lot of feedback there are connections

00:43:19

there from readers who write to me every

00:43:21

day in large numbers, so I

00:43:23

have some idea of

00:43:26

the mood, in any case, among people

00:43:29

who are interested in me to some extent,

00:43:31

and this in the office is not necessarily

00:43:34

some pleasant at the time container thing

00:43:36

art is full people write to me

00:43:39

something in the spirit of, well, how can you be

00:43:41

such an interesting writer and

00:43:44

such a bad person, I don’t know, and

00:43:47

why do you not like Russia

00:43:51

and why are you such a Russophobe, this is

00:43:55

written by people for whom,

00:43:57

apparently, Russia really is

00:43:59

like that putin

00:44:01

landi and who doesn’t like putin here doesn’t like

00:44:03

russia it’s just these people like you

00:44:05

personally i don’t like

00:44:08

another parallel and make germany

00:44:11

[music]

00:44:13

after the war there was a

00:44:17

very difficult period of

00:44:21

911 fications and the children of the leaders of the reich were caught on fire

00:44:25

and then the whole the country

00:44:28

you learned to understand what actually

00:44:31

happened to him, we will succeed

00:44:32

if we follow the scenario when

00:44:34

the revolution occurred, we are not North Korea,

00:44:37

this will be a very big difference between the

00:44:40

new Russia and

00:44:42

post-war Germany because

00:44:44

Germany was defeated in the war, it

00:44:46

was occupied a completely different

00:44:48

story in Russia there will be a revolution,

00:44:53

this will set the tone by people who were not

00:44:56

defeated and who

00:44:58

won, and

00:45:00

therefore, of course,

00:45:02

the country will have to very seriously

00:45:05

deal with its memory of people

00:45:08

who committed crimes, for example, I am a

00:45:12

categorical and principled

00:45:14

opponent of lustration

00:45:16

because illustrations are something

00:45:18

administrative and I am for a fair trial

00:45:22

for the personal responsibility of each

00:45:24

person for what

00:45:25

he did or did not do, whether he should have done it or not,

00:45:31

and I am a supporter of the ancient and

00:45:35

medieval rule

00:45:38

that it is better to release the guilty than

00:45:41

to convict the innocent, and I think that in

00:45:44

Russia for many years there will be

00:45:46

trials in which the country will

00:45:49

first of all, deal with yourself,

00:45:52

what is possible, what is not, what you need to be

00:45:55

responsible for, what you don’t need to be responsible for, this

00:45:58

will be a very important healing

00:45:59

process

00:46:04

for your football

Description:

Почему слова "русский мир" оказались скомпрометированы, и почему писатель Борис Акунин выбрал быть подданным британской монархии? Что за две раздельные России существуют последние 200 лет? Как определить русскую ментальность? Кто главный враг тирании? Обо всём этом и не только сооснователь фонда "Настоящая Россия" Елена Серветтаз говорит с писателем и также сооснователем фонда "Настоящая Россия" Борисом Акуниным. Подписывайтесь на YouTube-канал "Настоящей России": @true_russia. 🔔 Последние новости и анонсы программ с YouTube-канала «Живой гвоздь», а также контент от наших постоянных гостей и экспертов на официальном телеграм-канале: https://t.me/livegvozd Подписаться на Youtube-канал Дилетант: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuIE7-5QzeAR6EdZXwDRwuQ?sub_confirmation=1 📌 Живой гвоздь в аудиоформате: SoundCloud: https://soundcloud.com/user-524451485 Яндекс.Музыка: https://music.yandex.ru/showcaptcha?cc=1&mt=9AFE68005EDBD15F1D721D7A37DBDD4C6E4F68B5DE5F9925133F52F152D41C4B14827F19754E869064B1DC0C4EF2D48360733D68571C3A8AF9C13B66C14B3274F4328A60B3F6B5CD31E46D68D179FDFF71744362DE614BCD554DE551A0E33B20628F71A077177CFBB12D0E82C5F054E76D8B06F6F33F76364038808AF967EF657519B29E9B32CBFC51EBA3B5541F157A4948C40D24DB631A83D9014B90C8D75E2183F76E212A9760C76D806B8AA8A2338F6E03C128118B4B0280209870DAAAC926583D72BABAA22431D48AA28A1B51B27E61A9E5FE96AE0B0CE3A030&retpath=aHR0cHM6Ly9tdXNpYy55YW5kZXgucnUvYWxidW0vMjIxNDE2NTM_ZGlyPWRlc2M%2C_e3594d3da675bda0ba48ddf4d3ee4ceb&t=2/1716485432/e786822f0f1d3e68cf0d05055a9c9832&u=d72b613e-f359a74a-390c4900-2e977b5a&s=de97c9bf8f199c7c4d040cf0484d7e44 Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/%D0%B6%D0%B8%D0%B2%D0%BE%D0%B9-%D0%B3%D0%B2%D0%BE%D0%B7%D0%B4%D1%8C/id1616175210 Google Подкасты: https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9mZWVkcy5zb3VuZGNsb3VkLmNvbS91c2Vycy9zb3VuZGNsb3VkOnVzZXJzOjEwOTk2NzA5MDUvc291bmRzLnJzcw?sa=X&ved=0CAIQ4aUDahcKEwigxO3Eweb2AhUAAAAAHQAAAAAQEQ Магазин "Дилетант": https://diletant.shop/

Preparing download options

Popular

HD video

Only sound

All

* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."

** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players

Questions about downloading video

How can I download "Непростой Разговор: Борис Акунин / @true_russia" video?

http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.

Which format of "Непростой Разговор: Борис Акунин / @true_russia" video should I choose?

The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.

Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Непростой Разговор: Борис Акунин / @true_russia" video?

The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.

How can I download "Непростой Разговор: Борис Акунин / @true_russia" video to my phone?

You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.

How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Непростой Разговор: Борис Акунин / @true_russia"?

The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.

How can I save a frame from a video "Непростой Разговор: Борис Акунин / @true_russia"?

This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.

What's the price of all this stuff?

It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.