Download "Алексей Венедиктов* / #СлухайЭхо // 16.11.2022"

"videoThumbnail Алексей Венедиктов* / #СлухайЭхо // 16.11.2022

Пригожин вернулся, Суровикин отстранён, Путин и БРИКС. Николай Петров*: Особое мнение / 22.08.23

Пригожин вернулся, Суровикин отстранён, Путин и БРИКС. Николай Петров*: Особое мнение / 22.08.23

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Утренний разворот / @khodorkovskyru* / Георгий Кунадзе / Курников и Баблоян / 06.11.22

Утренний разворот / @khodorkovskyru* / Георгий Кунадзе / Курников и Баблоян / 06.11.22

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Личный приём / @user-lj9pp2mx5b // 23.05.2022

Личный приём / @user-lj9pp2mx5b // 23.05.2022

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Почему у России и Запада не получилось дружбы? /Собченко, Венедиктов*, Кобаладзе / Агенты / 19.11.22

Почему у России и Запада не получилось дружбы? /Собченко, Венедиктов*, Кобаладзе / Агенты / 19.11.22

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Залужный в президенты? Вернется ли Арестович? Скандальный поцелуй. #НАБЕЛО @BelkovskiyS

Залужный в президенты? Вернется ли Арестович? Скандальный поцелуй. #НАБЕЛО @BelkovskiyS

Channel: Белковский

Алексей Венедиктов* и Сергей Бунтман / Будем Наблюдать // 1.10.22

Алексей Венедиктов* и Сергей Бунтман / Будем Наблюдать // 1.10.22

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

ЛГБТ-экстремизм. Раскол в руководстве Украины. Белковский*: Персонально ваш / 30.11.23 @BelkovskiyS

ЛГБТ-экстремизм. Раскол в руководстве Украины. Белковский*: Персонально ваш / 30.11.23 @BelkovskiyS

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Репрессии в СССР и России / История семьи Москалёвых / Лев Рубинштейн / Персонально ваш / 29.03.2023

Репрессии в СССР и России / История семьи Москалёвых / Лев Рубинштейн / Персонально ваш / 29.03.2023

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Один / Дмитрий Быков / Чехов и литература абсурда // 23.06.2022

Один / Дмитрий Быков / Чехов и литература абсурда // 23.06.2022

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

венедиктов

пастухов

живой гвоздь

политика

00:00:18

[music]

00:00:59

everyone a

00:01:00

more or less unique program if

00:01:03

you can see or hear Write we had

00:01:05

some minor

00:01:06

technical problems

00:01:08

So if you can see or hear there is no sound,

00:01:11

they don’t write

00:01:13

to me that there is no sound now there

00:01:15

seems to be sound Let’s check again

00:01:18

I won’t continue until there is no sound

00:01:20

naturally

00:01:22

Now audible Thank you Yulia from Minsk it's all

00:01:25

gone OK good thanks we caught up

00:01:28

at first there really was no sound

00:01:29

now There is sound Hello everyone let's start

00:01:31

as if from the beginning

00:01:33

if we can ban the tractor driver forever

00:01:36

so let's all thank you Let's

00:01:39

move on to today and

00:01:41

of course the first question is

00:01:43

Mr. Markov Mikhail Markov asked me,

00:01:47

he flew in about missiles and I

00:01:50

had a question just for me. There was a question: Why did

00:01:52

you

00:01:54

not comment on the story with

00:01:57

Poland in the evening while on social networks? That’s why I didn’t comment

00:01:59

because a lot of questions immediately arose

00:02:02

and only to zero hours 20

00:02:05

minutes when the Polish journalists I want to

00:02:09

praise them from Radio Z who were the first

00:02:12

to report

00:02:13

this unfortunate

00:02:16

story two people died Let

00:02:18

's not forget that

00:02:20

civilians died from the arrival of these

00:02:23

missiles So they wrote for about 20 minutes

00:02:26

that according to their information

00:02:29

this journalist with radio Z this is about missiles,

00:02:35

including the Ukrainian one, I’ll remind you that there are

00:02:37

two missiles, everyone forgot about it,

00:02:40

one maybe Russian, the other

00:02:42

maybe Ukrainian. What options arose

00:02:44

yesterday, in fact, I

00:02:47

immediately had two options that

00:02:49

probably 99 percent in total gave this the

00:02:52

option of a random arrival of a

00:02:55

Russian missile, naturally, and this air defense option,

00:02:58

which has already been in the history of these military

00:03:01

events over the past nine months. Yes, if a

00:03:04

missile is shot down, fragments fall, or the

00:03:07

missile itself falls, Ukrainian, naturally, by

00:03:10

air defense. And

00:03:14

I didn’t consider these two options there at all.

00:03:17

specially launched of course Anything can

00:03:19

happen

00:03:20

Anything can happen People happen military

00:03:23

actions were

00:03:24

specially launched into the territory of

00:03:26

Poland to provoke NATO and

00:03:29

Article 5 and all that, I didn’t

00:03:31

consider

00:03:33

these two options in total, then we had to

00:03:36

wait for

00:03:37

what kind of fragments and what trajectory

00:03:41

and there was simply no need nothing to write, but this

00:03:45

way or that or rosettes And why

00:03:47

shout, we all saw how Well, it’s clear that

00:03:51

when anonymous authors on social networks immediately

00:03:53

write, they know everything they know everything in advance,

00:03:55

all this can be ignored

00:03:58

when politicians naturally

00:04:01

use it a-a because they are

00:04:04

politicians and should use it, and

00:04:06

being politicians, they are obliged to

00:04:08

use it to their advantage, this is also

00:04:10

understandable, but I still waited for some

00:04:12

technical explanations, I still waited for the

00:04:14

word trajectory and still waited, uh,

00:04:17

when someone- at least one of the non-anonymous

00:04:21

authors will say about the

00:04:24

remnants of the missile markings Yes, here are two

00:04:27

very important words: trajectory with

00:04:29

colbide ah-ah, you probably saw the

00:04:32

photographs at night, all this is all the

00:04:35

NATO leadership. I mean the main one of the seven countries of the

00:04:38

big countries, they should have been all in one

00:04:40

place In Bali, by chance, they

00:04:43

gathered, that is, at first they gathered,

00:04:45

apparently they were all raised,

00:04:46

it was already late at night in Indonesia,

00:04:49

they were raised, they saw a photo of Sullivan

00:04:52

Blinkin and Biden sitting in this after sleep at

00:04:56

home, not in pajamas, of course, yes they

00:04:57

discuss then Biden calls Zelensky

00:05:00

Then Biden calls the President of Poland

00:05:02

Dude then Biden calls

00:05:05

Stoltenberg instantly NATO

00:05:08

Secretary General was working and had to

00:05:11

get patience and wait to describe

00:05:13

them are they all Ukrainian missiles or are they

00:05:15

all Russian missiles a-a I just think

00:05:20

that the viewers of the living nail and the listeners of

00:05:22

Echo of Moscow understand how to work with

00:05:24

information you need to get at least

00:05:26

something information not only opinion

00:05:28

not only Faith when people are there in their

00:05:31

churches They are the information kings who

00:05:34

begin their fantasies, not entirely

00:05:36

erotic, post the

00:05:38

first one who said the word

00:05:40

trajectory It was Biden, oddly enough,

00:05:43

and then the Polish President Duda, precisely

00:05:47

the Polish one the president of which

00:05:49

you would not suspect

00:05:51

Russia’s help or love for Russia

00:05:54

told the final Russian leadership

00:05:56

that it was quite possible that these were Ukrainian

00:05:58

missiles.

00:05:59

Then I was quite interested in whether

00:06:02

he would go there or whether they would demand that the

00:06:05

Russian ambassador be allowed there. I did not see

00:06:07

the reaction of the Russian embassy in Poland at all,

00:06:09

but the Ministry of Defense saw the Russian

00:06:12

in Poland I didn’t see how everything was in the

00:06:14

launches ah-ah I think that in the old days

00:06:17

it was and the ambassadors there would have immediately

00:06:19

asked the Foreign Ministry to see what

00:06:22

it was, but no, or at least express

00:06:24

condolences even if these were not Russian

00:06:26

missiles, well Strictly speaking,

00:06:29

the investigation continues, but

00:06:31

approximately everything is clear,

00:06:32

approximately of course, but the

00:06:35

Polish leadership in the person of the president

00:06:37

themselves declares that most likely this is an

00:06:39

air defense missile Yes, this was an accident

00:06:41

initially at night, but in my opinion the Prime Minister of

00:06:44

Poland said that this was an

00:06:46

isolated incident, this is not cannot be

00:06:48

regarded as an attack, moreover, I

00:06:50

’ll tell you a terrible thing that not only the

00:06:52

fifth article, but also the fourth article,

00:06:54

consultation there is a fourth article,

00:06:56

consultations are being carried out,

00:06:59

yes, but the

00:07:00

Poles are not that Yes, there is no need to rush to

00:07:03

conclusions until the facts have become clear Mark

00:07:05

Markova - it’s you, me I

00:07:07

’m actually answering your question and of course it’s very

00:07:10

offensive when people of your profession are not

00:07:13

politicians not not not not not not bloggers but

00:07:16

journalists begin to

00:07:18

issue conclusions as a statement,

00:07:21

say that according to the available data I don’t

00:07:24

know So it seems to me or something But we

00:07:28

we will wait for further investigation

00:07:30

now Ukraine has demanded to be

00:07:31

allowed into this investigation. And it is quite

00:07:34

natural. It seems to me that

00:07:36

Ukraine should be allowed into this investigation if

00:07:38

they say something about a Ukrainian missile. But

00:07:40

that’s for the Poles to decide. But this is, of course, a

00:07:43

dangerous story. Because if these

00:07:45

were Russian missiles. Yes. even if

00:07:47

they flew in by accident, it would give a

00:07:50

reason for Poland to appeal to the Council for the

00:07:52

fourth at least maximum

00:07:54

as for the fifth article about the fifth article about

00:07:57

collective defense, carefully give it to him by

00:07:59

becoming necessary. The fifth article does not mean

00:08:02

a machine gun,

00:08:04

this is not an automatic decision application of the

00:08:07

fifth article Yes, it is necessary The consent of all

00:08:10

and then attention Each country

00:08:13

individually, see article 5,

00:08:15

that is, Collective or individual

00:08:18

it is written in the fifth article makes a

00:08:20

decision on how it helps the article that was

00:08:22

attacked Well, it seems to

00:08:24

have resolved, it seems, maybe

00:08:28

it has temporarily resolved,

00:08:30

maybe something else- we don’t know, we’ll find out, but in

00:08:32

any case, for now we’ve taken a

00:08:36

step back from the edge. That’s approximately how it would be

00:08:39

if Russia hadn’t fired, there wouldn’t be

00:08:42

any missiles, writes Maria Fedorenko, this is

00:08:44

also true, we’re early now. Let’s figure out

00:08:47

how it fell on Polish territory, we can

00:08:50

talk in general

00:08:52

here in general, if Bogdan Khmelnitsky

00:08:56

had not turned to the Russian Tsar But of course,

00:08:58

the responsibility for all these stories lies

00:09:00

with my country, of course there is no dispute here

00:09:04

because on February 24 this is the very line because of

00:09:08

which it all started Well, maybe

00:09:10

earlier that’s why here Maria I’m with you

00:09:12

I agree, it’s just a road to nowhere. It’s

00:09:15

just a road to nowhere in any case.

00:09:17

I want to say that I condole with the

00:09:20

dead

00:09:22

Polish citizens

00:09:25

as well as the Ukrainian and Russian civilians

00:09:26

who died. By the way, yesterday in Shebekino three

00:09:29

civilians died due to

00:09:31

the circumstances, but these are not military personnel these are

00:09:35

people leading military affairs It’s civilians who are dying,

00:09:38

it’s terrible

00:09:41

they went on

00:09:45

like this

00:09:46

from Rostov-on-Don Grisha Thank you for

00:09:49

giving me 72 years old please Yes

00:09:52

tomorrow they will actually pronounce a verdict on the

00:09:55

first four positions on the tragedies h17 I

00:09:57

’ll show you the book right away we don’t have it

00:10:00

because it you have to order it on the planet,

00:10:03

but I just ordered it for myself and received it.

00:10:06

This is Vadim Lukashevich. You are well aware of the

00:10:08

mh17 tragedy, a very good dossier

00:10:11

was made by the BBC, and maybe tomorrow

00:10:14

Vladimir Pastukhov and I will also touch on this issue,

00:10:16

but when you go to the planet, I

00:10:19

think they accept more orders here are

00:10:22

two-volume heavy such a story

00:10:24

two-volume like this and of course tomorrow

00:10:27

Vladimir and I will touch on the question this is a

00:10:33

pale-faced person writing but a brick fell fell

00:10:36

also falls as Woland said a brick

00:10:38

just wo

00:10:41

n’t fall on a pale-faced person’s head for no reason You should need this would like to

00:10:44

know

00:10:46

Good evening Alekseevich Krasnodar Maxim

00:10:49

31 how do you like Prigozhin who accused the USA

00:10:51

of murder you need a sledgehammer this video

00:10:53

watch Whose stories are in need This

00:10:56

story is big and not yet finished we

00:10:58

don’t know what happened at all we don’t have

00:11:01

any data that this is not a production

00:11:04

we don’t have any data that this is a

00:11:05

production means the

00:11:08

investigative authorities of the Russian Federation are

00:11:09

conducting an investigation, I know this from Tatyana

00:11:12

Moskalkova, this is what I published in my

00:11:15

telegram channel on August 20-22 and the statement of the

00:11:20

Commissioner for Human Rights

00:11:21

Tatyana Moskalkova, which says

00:11:24

that the investigative authorities,

00:11:26

apparently based on her requests and inquiries with someone from

00:11:29

Ekaterina's spam they are investigating

00:11:31

this video, did this really happen

00:11:34

or not? And this is the time.

00:11:37

Therefore,

00:11:41

we don’t know this part.

00:11:44

It’s terrible, but there are doubts that this is not a

00:11:48

production; the second story is that

00:11:51

what is the role of Ukraine in this? here is the

00:11:55

adviser to the presidential office Mr.

00:11:58

Podolya says that Mr. Nuzhdin,

00:12:01

who was captured by the dude Wagner, let me

00:12:03

remind you,

00:12:05

will be very much released from the places

00:12:07

of detention where he was imprisoned for 27 years,

00:12:08

sentenced to 27 years, he was imprisoned for 20 years, which

00:12:11

means he signed the Consent to be exchanged.

00:12:15

I would like to see

00:12:17

and Mr. Sechkin is absolutely right here

00:12:21

who says Vladimir Osechkin bulagu

00:12:24

No, which says that it would be good to

00:12:26

look at this signed

00:12:28

statement,

00:12:30

it is

00:12:32

obvious that this story is broader

00:12:35

than the one that now seems to us, I have

00:12:38

no opinion on this issue,

00:12:42

there is no additional additional

00:12:45

information except that the investigative

00:12:47

authorities took this for investigation I

00:12:49

just don’t know, it was done by the FSB of the Ministry of Internal Affairs or the

00:12:51

Investigative Committee of the Prosecutor’s Office

00:12:53

Here But she’s coming That’s why

00:12:58

Prigozhin is trolling Of course

00:13:00

he’s defending himself with this, what if it was

00:13:02

really his people who did it

00:13:04

to defend themselves

00:13:07

Therefore we need an investigation to follow up on this

00:13:10

Well, let’s ask questions Alexey

00:13:14

Shelko I’ve already answered many times on this

00:13:16

question, therefore, there is no need to spam here,

00:13:23

it means,

00:13:26

well, what is Arrestovich doing?

00:13:30

Says Arrestovich. I won’t even argue with him

00:13:32

because that week the

00:13:35

loss figures were minimal

00:13:39

now. Sorry, I flew somewhere. Yes, I need

00:13:43

his last name, yes, thank you, thank you,

00:13:45

if anyone- then in the USA it is at the

00:13:48

political pinnacle,

00:13:50

I know there are always some

00:13:53

canceled in my opinion No, but I don’t know

00:13:55

Elena,

00:13:58

what do you think with just Eduard Ukraine

00:14:02

itself extradited the prisoner but so says

00:14:03

or stole the Russian so says

00:14:06

the adviser to the president’s office Mikhail podolyak of

00:14:08

the president I can’t think of Zelensky here,

00:14:11

I’m listening to Mikhail the Pole and he

00:14:14

says we exchanged him Hmm

00:14:18

Do you think it was stolen or not I

00:14:21

think like Mikhail Podolyak Are the

00:14:26

PMC fighters

00:14:28

officially prisoners of war

00:14:31

and I don’t know about the

00:14:35

Azov fighters

00:14:37

I know they exchange it we know

00:14:41

and what it is officially we don’t have a

00:14:43

military means there are no prisoners of war not a

00:14:45

single

00:14:46

war No what prisoners of war have been sensed

00:14:51

When a new comic will be released today I

00:14:54

tell Alexander Ivanov it means Today

00:14:57

we

00:14:59

watched this save Milyan Pugachev

00:15:03

I will try by the New Year

00:15:08

to create the composition of the Ukrainian army what

00:15:10

army does it have we are not at war Sapsan What are you

00:15:12

writing again there are no prisoners of war

00:15:18

so

00:15:20

yes Tatyana St. Petersburg there is

00:15:25

no investigation into war crimes Stanislav Yezhov I can’t

00:15:27

comment because I read

00:15:29

the transcript of the meetings it was directly

00:15:32

said that we don’t have a mechanism

00:15:35

now There is no mechanism for an

00:15:37

investigation of what is happening in

00:15:40

Ukraine from the point of view of the tribunal, there is no

00:15:42

tribunal because it is not the International

00:15:45

Criminal Court and not another UN body,

00:15:49

but this matter is now

00:15:52

out of jurisdiction, it is necessary to create a new

00:15:55

institution if we are talking about it But these

00:15:58

institutions are being created by the Security Council

00:16:00

How do you think it will vote Russia

00:16:04

And therefore this is a question. This is how it is from the

00:16:07

point of view, I repeat,

00:16:09

he is like this, therefore, there is not only a

00:16:13

war crime. If you look at the

00:16:16

international tribunals in the former

00:16:18

Yugoslavia in Ireland, you see strains of

00:16:21

mass murder, I have already

00:16:23

talked about this. Yes, and a crime against

00:16:25

humanity and genocide there there are many

00:16:27

elements of crimes, but from the point of view of

00:16:30

the UN, the tribunal creates today's

00:16:33

Security Council Well, that's how

00:16:43

20 went, in your opinion, you know

00:16:45

Yaropolk Nikita Nikita, 22 years old from Moscow,

00:16:48

you know, and this missile

00:16:50

eclipsed everything Yes, I even wanted to watch I did

00:16:53

n’t even look at the declaration To be honest,

00:16:57

which they adopted Well, they accepted and accepted,

00:17:01

you know, They also make

00:17:03

mandatory decisions on horseback for understanding this is

00:17:05

very important what is interesting from this I

00:17:08

managed to watch uh Hmm

00:17:10

macron’s press conference a question was asked

00:17:13

uh Russia Ukraine he says that there is

00:17:15

more and more consensus towards my position

00:17:17

What is the position of macron you

00:17:19

know check This I can’t do now

00:17:24

but how is it done to ask the master the count of

00:17:27

dead military personnel as

00:17:30

follows, according to the decree, in my opinion, from the

00:17:32

year ninety-four, if

00:17:35

military personnel die during a military operation,

00:17:38

it must be established the fact of death through a

00:17:40

Rostov laboratory that

00:17:43

determines DNA

00:17:45

After which it is entered into the registry,

00:17:49

accounting begins,

00:17:51

payments begin and the family is informed before that, but the

00:17:55

person is not considered dead,

00:17:58

missing, he could have been wounded

00:18:01

in the hospital, he could have deserted, he could have surrendered, but they say that’s

00:18:03

it anything,

00:18:06

so this is an indication - This is mandatory for the military

00:18:08

prosecutor’s office. History is,

00:18:10

in fact, this is how the calculation is carried out

00:18:12

uh, a special table for ah,

00:18:18

how do you like the crown today I watched episode 6 of

00:18:21

season 5.

00:18:23

I’m just talking about Russia about the

00:18:26

reburial of

00:18:28

Nicholas II’s family because there in some

00:18:32

way I have historically participated in this,

00:18:34

yes, well, the crown well recommend

00:18:43

Fegen says Feigin again, I thought that

00:18:47

you had 15 million

00:18:49

Swiss dollars, where did you get so many

00:18:51

Boomerangs, but I don’t have it

00:18:54

Well, let him show

00:18:57

my Swiss account is declared in the

00:18:59

Russian Federation It’s

00:19:01

been a long time since I officially paid taxes on all the

00:19:06

money that went somewhere,

00:19:09

but he was wrong a

00:19:11

thousand times Fedya this time

00:19:16

If I came correctly again, that’s why he’s

00:19:18

lying and it’s clear why, look,

00:19:21

he’s trying to discredit the opposition,

00:19:24

find out what happened with this Warsaw

00:19:25

congress, he’s discrediting himself and specifically he’s

00:19:29

silent, you know, he’s giving credit, he’s putting on a

00:19:32

show It’s clear Who he’s discrediting with,

00:19:34

trying to discredit me Well, okay,

00:19:36

let him try, but he’s doing a bad job,

00:19:39

someone believes him, let him believe him, and

00:19:41

then it will be interesting,

00:19:43

it will be extremely interesting for you,

00:19:46

Zheki Mikheev from Kamchatka Hello

00:19:49

Kamchatka is always with us

00:19:52

Kamchatka with us and every time I have

00:19:55

some spectators in Kamchatka from Kamchatka Well,

00:19:58

those who have been at sea especially haven’t been there for a long time

00:20:01

Hello,

00:20:03

not 15 but 15,000, yes something a little more

00:20:06

probably,

00:20:09

why didn’t they start promoting the situation with

00:20:11

missiles in Poland? where are three

00:20:13

Boris shader and because

00:20:16

because people work there who

00:20:19

saw Oh my God This is a rocket these are pieces of a

00:20:22

rocket test 300 S300 is air defense this is a

00:20:25

Defense story

00:20:28

from whom Russia is defending itself on the Polish

00:20:31

border and taking into account the fact that, in my opinion, the 31st

00:20:34

division of Ukraine is with -300 from those

00:20:37

times and yes and isonite yes but also what listen Well

00:20:42

everything is a draw isolated case As

00:20:44

President Duda says Can I join the

00:20:46

Polish president once again I will

00:20:49

only express my condolences that civilians died

00:20:52

Sakhalin is also with us look how good it is ST

00:20:55

- This is older Yes, there is a younger

00:20:59

line of contact will now move

00:21:02

deeper into Russia, probably maybe

00:21:05

I don’t know what it is yet I don’t see

00:21:12

Nikolay Smirnov Great Britain you

00:21:14

apologized as a peldaren for that broadcast,

00:21:16

why should you apologize, he was right, he was

00:21:18

wrong, then he should apologize in my opinion

00:21:19

that he became and from He left you He left you

00:21:23

He didn’t leave me He owed you an

00:21:26

apology, he didn’t apologize, he delayed

00:21:30

why then there were fragments of two missiles, two

00:21:32

S-300 missiles, it’s not clear Katya, yes, that

00:21:35

is, we understand for sure that one missile is

00:21:37

most likely exactly what we know from

00:21:39

the Poles that one is most likely a

00:21:41

Ukrainian missile out of 300 And the second may

00:21:44

be part of a downed Russian missile,

00:21:46

just

00:21:48

maybe

00:21:51

Well, let’s wait for something to change,

00:21:53

we will find out tomorrow I do

00:21:59

n’t have time for long questions from Ukraine

00:22:01

serves Thank you Kostya Bakun

00:22:06

and something for missiles you have too

00:22:08

many you probably Yuri specialist

00:22:11

There are two missiles hear what I say two

00:22:14

again two I will show two two well two well

00:22:19

Tell me the recent meeting with Shevchuk in

00:22:22

St. Petersburg Well why did I come to St. Petersburg just

00:22:26

with Yuri Galich Kabaladze we came just

00:22:28

you know to sit with friends to relax

00:22:30

and I suddenly saw that

00:22:33

somewhere on Instagram, in my opinion, it is prohibited

00:22:36

in Russia, that a-a

00:22:38

Lev Shlosberg is photographed by Shevchuk and

00:22:41

there is a stamp. I wrote to Yuri that you and

00:22:45

you are here and you and you are in St. Petersburg Well and then

00:22:49

Opanka Well come on I’ll come Yes, I’ll come, we arrived, we sat

00:22:51

and talked, by the way,

00:22:54

we agreed that when he will make

00:22:56

vinyl now We are through our shop point Amateur

00:22:59

Media vinyl strips with

00:23:02

Shevchuk’s autograph are new and we will sell you

00:23:05

too, because well, the concert, you yourself

00:23:07

know it is not trustworthy, as they

00:23:10

say now Oh, by the way, about the shock dot

00:23:13

Amateur Media according to your requests but

00:23:15

hurry up, we're raking up everything that's left for

00:23:18

the monsters to move Yes, we already offered you something about this book

00:23:21

and it flew away in one

00:23:23

day seam dot Amateur Media love and

00:23:27

terror in Hitler's Berlin and I received

00:23:30

a lot of good messages from you about

00:23:34

this book I liked it I read it myself, uh,

00:23:37

now we put it up, oh, there are

00:23:40

only 100 copies of it. Well, maybe there

00:23:42

will be more before the end of the program, maybe there

00:23:43

will be more today, but just in case,

00:23:45

tell yourself that dot leitan dot

00:23:47

the world, by the way, there’s a good book

00:23:49

about Freemasonry, uh, we put it quite a

00:23:53

few more new interesting books Well,

00:23:55

for the sake of one, I won’t like the pack right away,

00:23:57

they gave it as a

00:23:59

good gift and by the way,

00:24:02

today Admiral gift books

00:24:04

told me that let’s New Year is coming soon, so

00:24:06

I think that in a week or

00:24:08

next week there are expensive 10-15 and

00:24:11

took away the collected essays But now there

00:24:12

and with us We guys, I congratulate you all,

00:24:15

Sergei Riot and I Zhenya Bychakova and

00:24:18

Katya Kovrev completed the cycle My district, the

00:24:22

last four magazines Here they are, the

00:24:24

last 123 issue

00:24:27

Arbat, I don’t know, it’s already on display at the

00:24:31

Tochka dilettante shop.media But if not, then it

00:24:33

will appear soon. That means Arbat and

00:24:36

Ryazansky and Gagarinsky and Davydkovo fillet

00:24:40

123 districts in Moscow 123 magazines As

00:24:44

they say, the two horsemen of the Apocalypse

00:24:46

could not prevent this, nothing war

00:24:48

non-stop for 35 issues a year for 24

00:24:53

years, we did this for you

00:24:59

Yes signed the magazine If you indicate

00:25:04

what needs to be there Sign or something

00:25:07

pre-order Shevchuk's records to open you

00:25:09

know Kirill when I understand Which

00:25:11

record then I will open Yes, we will open

00:25:13

the pre-order that it is difficult or not

00:25:16

difficult at all yes I remember Sergei On the

00:25:19

Western Front without a variable Remarque

00:25:21

yes I I remember Yuliano through the spectrum, of course, do

00:25:26

n’t you think that comparing Azov and

00:25:29

dude Wagner is at least unethical,

00:25:30

firstly, respected Alexander is a journalist,

00:25:34

in general, the surname is unethical with a sledgehammer, also

00:25:36

smashing your head is not very unethical, and

00:25:38

secondly, I didn’t compare again, I’m

00:25:42

talking about relationships, different relationships in

00:25:44

different structures,

00:25:46

of course,

00:25:48

dude Wagner is one half-case, he has a

00:25:52

different story, dude, probably a different

00:25:54

story. And we talked about that and I’m talking about

00:25:57

that, I’ll repeat and don’t compare that from the

00:26:00

point of view of Russia

00:26:01

there are no prisoners of war because there are wars. No,

00:26:04

what kind of prisoners of war? what is

00:26:06

And what is what is it called

00:26:09

hostages what is it called all this there is no war

00:26:12

What to call it Russia is transferring fighters

00:26:16

from the Azov regiment to the leader of Azov

00:26:18

to Ukraine and who is this Well, a prisoner of war there

00:26:21

is no war, you understand, yes, in this story there is a

00:26:23

lot of hypocrisy on the part of Russia,

00:26:25

of course,

00:26:26

but we can call it Whatever you want

00:26:29

But We remember that Zelensky said all

00:26:34

those All those who fight against Russia if

00:26:37

they surrender we promise them This is what he

00:26:40

promises Find for yourself he didn’t say

00:26:42

what the guy Wagner is talking about And

00:26:45

this doesn’t concern the Chechen battalions

00:26:46

this does not concern the Russian Guard, this

00:26:49

only concerns the armed forces, and the DPR LPR - this does

00:26:51

not concern Ukrainian citizens from the

00:26:53

point of view

00:26:54

that you are being a hypocrite here, this is everyone

00:26:59

who fights with weapons in their hands or not everyone, that’s

00:27:02

all

00:27:03

Let me speak honestly Well, by God we

00:27:06

will be here this is where we

00:27:08

don’t need a lot of imagination around the

00:27:11

history of the rocket, Alexander

00:27:13

showed us that as soon as we start

00:27:16

to fantasize, then disappointment sets in.

00:27:18

I am against

00:27:20

fantasizing, we don’t know when I say I don’t

00:27:22

know, it means I don’t know.

00:27:25

Yes,

00:27:26

we saw how many

00:27:29

self-confident people last night shouting about NATO

00:27:31

about the fifth article about closed skies there won’t

00:27:35

be closed skies there

00:27:38

won’t be closed skies because I’ll

00:27:41

tell you why Because I meet with

00:27:43

diplomats and talk to Westerners they

00:27:46

say then NATO planes should

00:27:48

patrol this airspace

00:27:50

if we declare the skies closed, that is,

00:27:52

collide directly with Russian

00:27:54

planes from the Russian air

00:27:57

defense we will not do this, although

00:27:59

it was a month ago, however, it

00:28:01

will not happen because the NATO side is avoiding a direct conflict in every possible way,

00:28:08

you can see for yourself it is public, therefore there

00:28:10

was no closed sky, you can’t say Give us a

00:28:13

closed sky

00:28:15

again Zelensky has right, that is,

00:28:18

Ukrainians have the right, but when others scream about it

00:28:20

on Twitter, others don’t understand

00:28:25

how this happens

00:28:27

[music]

00:28:30

and

00:28:33

so

00:28:35

Ivano-Frankovsk Egor,

00:28:38

who will you root for at the

00:28:40

World Cup? I’m not going to root, I’m going to be

00:28:43

healthy.

00:28:45

Vladimir, 32 years old, Nizhny Yavlinsky

00:28:48

received an invitation living nail Yes,

00:28:49

of course, they haven’t heard him or what,

00:28:55

Pelevin hasn’t read the last book yet

00:28:57

Sorry for God’s sake, there’s almost no

00:28:59

time at all

00:29:01

Pavel 3 how to finish your non-Freud we

00:29:04

Pavel here we were asking my opinion

00:29:07

correctly my opinion I didn’t have to

00:29:09

wait for the

00:29:10

Kherson operation

00:29:13

or raisins I’m on February 24, I’m repeating I

00:29:17

probably said that Russia has already lost

00:29:19

by starting this special military they’ve already

00:29:21

lost

00:29:23

no matter how it ends in the military

00:29:25

sense

00:29:27

isolation reputation economy

00:29:32

and within the country What’s most important is the split

00:29:36

in families

00:29:38

you understand we’ve already lost in this sense this is the point

00:29:41

of me by the way military

00:29:44

I understand that now the military is on the cutting edge, but

00:29:47

from this point of view I care much less,

00:29:51

so Well, actually, I answered

00:29:55

the interview. I am planning on so far there is no agreement

00:30:03

where the pro-Russian administration of

00:30:06

Kherson has disappeared. Valentin is not following the disguises.

00:30:09

As I understand it, they are in the city of Genichesk, in

00:30:12

my opinion it

00:30:14

seems

00:30:19

Nail writes there I bought Marat’s pamphlets in your store and

00:30:22

opened them on a random

00:30:25

page and there Marat writes about warring

00:30:27

Russia, how did he know such people from

00:30:31

the province, I told him no when

00:30:36

the Inhabited Island Boris Anatolyevich

00:30:38

Strugatsky, we met him now,

00:30:40

by the way, don’t forget Strugatsky, but we

00:30:43

met him, I told him I’m talking about the towers

00:30:46

Remember, I’m saying How did they know all this,

00:30:48

Alexey said, But it’s obvious, and

00:30:53

Marat said all this obviously,

00:31:00

that from the fourth he knew that Echo

00:31:03

would close, she only said about it in April,

00:31:04

but I told you in April, and I told my people

00:31:08

24 Strugatsky means in 20-22 on Friday the

00:31:13

day after tomorrow, Vitaly Dymarsky will have

00:31:16

Boris Vishnevsky talking about the Strugatskys

00:31:18

as visionaries. Please don’t miss the

00:31:21

evening broadcast

00:31:23

Alex Filipenko Who refuses to change

00:31:26

everyone

00:31:27

Alex is right sick, so look

00:31:30

firstly, these are lists that

00:31:33

need to be compiled, secondly, as we

00:31:35

see from stories with your husband you need to agree

00:31:39

or disagree, thirdly, these people

00:31:43

whom we call prisoners of war are in

00:31:45

different places

00:31:47

in different places in Russia and different places in

00:31:50

Ukraine

00:31:51

in general, this is very very dreary

00:31:55

hard work. Believe me, I

00:31:58

know, I’ve been doing it before that's why there's

00:32:02

no such refusal no Let's change it but

00:32:05

she's also grabbing Both of them every

00:32:09

moment it's moving towards this someone died someone

00:32:12

escaped and someone was taken prisoner Let's also call

00:32:14

it prisoner

00:32:16

and this is the list it's like

00:32:23

Where to watch old episodes Echoes from the

00:32:27

embassies of different countries I don’t know honestly I

00:32:30

understand what you’re asking What

00:32:31

Naryshkin did and I

00:32:34

’ll find out we’ll take it to us probably now

00:32:37

I’ll ask

00:32:39

Viktor Shesterov What’s heard from Rosem nothing yet

00:32:43

[music]

00:32:46

and Shevchuk’s vinyl will be listened to a number of times This is a

00:32:49

question for Yura, that’s what it will be like I’ll

00:32:52

imagine what it will be like.

00:32:55

Yes, a criminal case was opened against the gubar from Kherson.

00:32:58

Well, yes, the economic

00:33:00

article is true. Yes, there is such a case,

00:33:03

they report it. Well, I don’t follow this,

00:33:07

honestly, there are more serious

00:33:10

people who need to be followed.

00:33:13

Yes, I love biathlon, really status of

00:33:16

the case on the downed Boeing tomorrow there will be a verdict

00:33:18

on the first four accused and

00:33:21

the prosecutor's office has asked for four for life, I

00:33:25

will remind you that now the planet in the Planet

00:33:27

is ordering this book, I am showing you

00:33:30

which one And unfortunately you can’t buy it from us on

00:33:33

shop.eletant Media

00:33:35

because they don’t give us they gave it not only

00:33:38

so many orders they printed, I bought it

00:33:41

and accordingly now it’s worth this

00:33:44

book that you all wanted love and

00:33:47

terror in Hitler’s Berlin and

00:33:49

look there there’s still a little bit

00:33:53

left, you

00:33:55

just need to jump off now and buy it

00:33:57

because

00:33:59

[music]

00:34:01

epidemic You can and so

00:34:07

Hello, today I’m proud in my

00:34:09

telegram I wrote about Rosina Well, well

00:34:11

written

00:34:13

Echo interviews from embassies are on the artery

00:34:16

And you mean what I did for

00:34:19

RTVi Yes, indeed there are some there,

00:34:21

and the Ambassador of Latvia is the Ambassador of the EU, but that’s if

00:34:25

we have to my on in ours too, not only

00:34:27

here Look no we were talking about

00:34:30

mansions if I understand but We

00:34:32

will do this of course

00:34:33

about the Armenian Embassy here Yulia Yes

00:34:36

thank you

00:34:40

Nikolay Beketov Hello Alexey

00:34:42

Alekseevich Why are you so animated today What

00:34:46

about those Moldova how about those Ukraine also launched S-300s

00:34:51

that fell on Nikolaev.

00:34:54

This is a question to whom they

00:34:57

asked me about those missiles that

00:35:01

fell on the territory of Poland, I told you what

00:35:04

President Baydan said, the American

00:35:06

President was up to Polish,

00:35:09

you hear a little, you listen no, Or do you

00:35:13

live in your own information bubble and

00:35:15

yourself you talk to yourself

00:35:21

like this

00:35:22

Will the early issues of my

00:35:25

regional ones be posted? Mikhail Makarov unfortunately they are

00:35:28

not

00:35:30

so Vadim Will there be a hearing Echo with

00:35:32

Vladimir Borisovich Zhen

00:35:35

when the

00:35:37

21st is Monday? Yes, if my memory serves me right, the

00:35:43

21st is shorter than the 21st for this week at 17:00

00:35:50

hearing Echo with Vladimir Pastukhov

00:35:54

who sponsors the rain I somehow don’t really

00:35:59

pay attention to this, to be honest, I do

00:36:01

n’t care much so on and so

00:36:04

forth

00:36:10

Alexander Ruzanov and the missiles fell on

00:36:12

Nikolaev Why won’t he answer Well, probably

00:36:14

Russian I don’t know I didn’t study

00:36:17

Nikolaev separately I I was now dealing with

00:36:20

Poland because this is a new phenomenon and the

00:36:23

fact that Russia has been firing missiles at Ukraine for

00:36:25

a long time Yes, these are Russian missiles

00:36:30

and President Putin said about it and you

00:36:33

know this or you are not only some This

00:36:36

is Alexander Alexander Ruzanova is not

00:36:39

only deaf but also blind

00:36:42

What is it about? to ask that and I answer

00:36:46

Well, all sorts of nonsense, I Allow me to

00:36:51

Mr. Movchan yesterday gave a general analysis of the

00:36:54

economy Iran is essentially a mirror of the future

00:36:56

of Russia and you know, I haven’t looked yet, I

00:36:58

watch it all the time with a delay, but if

00:37:01

we talk In general, the volume of sanctions

00:37:04

is approaching Iranian sanctions is

00:37:06

it’s true that

00:37:07

Gleb Pavlovsky is seriously ill with Moses too

00:37:13

Elena Zotova there is an opportunity to invite

00:37:16

Kiriyenko on the air but he won’t come

00:37:21

answer honestly the correct policy

00:37:23

Russia has been pursuing since 2014 as if it was

00:37:26

the first time I came to this studio I,

00:37:28

as a citizen of Russia, do not

00:37:30

share this policy I criticize it starting since the age of 14,

00:37:34

in fact, much earlier,

00:37:37

and this, by the way, in my public conversations

00:37:41

with the same Putin, I publicly criticized in

00:37:43

the eyes, not only behind the eyes, I had

00:37:45

such an opportunity Yes, you can find and look at this,

00:37:51

and the rain has taken over the genre of hearing from you Eh This

00:37:54

good So we are creating a genre, we are creating

00:37:58

as usual, they are conscious of fashion and you are

00:38:01

participants in this creation, put likes,

00:38:03

don’t forget likes Not enough Well, by the way,

00:38:05

how many likes are watching us, 20 probably,

00:38:07

somewhere around

00:38:09

22,000 likes, so many

00:38:14

drinks in advance with Kiriyenko,

00:38:18

even when he was prime minister -minister and before

00:38:20

that, too, after that I don’t remember, but with the

00:38:24

prime minister exactly

00:38:28

Well, the truth is, I write more to the Chernomyrdins,

00:38:30

this of course was a difficult test, in

00:38:32

fact, if we talk about

00:38:34

prime ministers, of course I drank,

00:38:37

I can list a large list of people

00:38:44

Georgy, where does such a negative

00:38:46

attitude towards Yekaterinburg come from? center

00:38:48

I have a completely positive attitude towards the

00:38:50

Yekaterinburg Yeltsin center, a

00:38:51

negative attitude from Solovyov

00:38:53

Mikhalkov, I’ll tell you, by and large, the

00:38:56

Yeltsin center is the center of competition for

00:39:00

Mikhalkov Solovyov because he

00:39:04

creates And such a vision is

00:39:08

pure, they create a dirty one, all the difference

00:39:11

They see competitors

00:39:17

When will the secret police officers be drained in the

00:39:20

ranks of Navalny there won’t be a meat eater in this,

00:39:23

just like during the Revolution before the

00:39:26

revolution of 17, in the course after the revolution you

00:39:29

have to dig into it and look for it sometimes they

00:39:33

themselves get caught sometimes they themselves admit sometimes they

00:39:35

get caught sometimes the wrong ones are

00:39:37

announced

00:39:39

Yes, not only in the ranks of Navalny

00:39:43

Navalny’s team Well so in other ranks they are

00:39:46

Eves, these are professional working

00:39:48

people or an institution Yes, and we see how the

00:39:52

security worked in the first Russian

00:39:54

revolution, the second Russian revolution, members of the

00:39:56

Central Committee were, it turns out, agents of the secret police

00:40:03

more than Lithuania in all spheres, and in all

00:40:07

opposition parties, let’s say,

00:40:11

agents were infiltrated at the top this is how

00:40:16

it works look What happened

00:40:18

when the Stasi archives began to be opened

00:40:22

look what happened in Latvia

00:40:24

when the KGB archives began to be opened

00:40:27

Quite interesting

00:40:31

I want to say one important thing

00:40:34

so that you understand

00:40:35

those who are banned here, they cannot

00:40:39

participate in our other streams, we

00:40:41

ban and I then look, now I have

00:40:45

no time, then I look and everyone who is

00:40:49

engaged in insults here is

00:40:51

rude to everyone I send bananas you then Opa

00:40:55

and you No, keep this in mind, you just

00:40:58

think who didn’t notice to me when

00:41:00

to click and then eat at home I

00:41:02

always always listen to myself there catch

00:41:05

your own mistakes and then

00:41:06

correct them Well, at the same time I watched So

00:41:09

just keep in mind Therefore, it’s better

00:41:10

Delete yourself

00:41:18

a I wonder who was infiltrated Kadyrova about Boris, look at the

00:41:23

root actually at the root

00:41:26

the viewer

00:41:28

with which of the chicks Who are the chicks

00:41:33

And you drank best I was the one

00:41:36

I can’t even say that I drank the best, I

00:41:37

don’t understand what you’re writing,

00:41:43

where is everything going downhill so far,

00:41:48

and he’s asking about Dorenko, they killed him,

00:41:52

I don’t have any information about that,

00:41:55

and in general

00:41:58

Yes, and in general, there was probably nothing for it

00:42:01

If you mean security probably he

00:42:04

was not for anything, well, anything can be allowed,

00:42:08

but I don’t have such data,

00:42:10

excuse me, are

00:42:15

you satisfied with the time in which you live?

00:42:33

happy with the family,

00:42:36

happy with the son in this sense Satisfied, but

00:42:40

in general life is a series of tragedies of

00:42:41

separations

00:42:43

And this is also

00:42:48

to crab your relationship with the lawyer

00:42:52

Ilya Novik Vadim I have a good

00:42:55

relationship with the lawyer Ilya Novikov,

00:42:57

first of all as a lawyer but also as a

00:43:00

person who

00:43:06

sometimes does not promote legal approaches in general, yes,

00:43:09

I treat him very well and I know that he

00:43:13

acted outside the public zone. I know how

00:43:16

he

00:43:18

organized the release of Hope

00:43:21

Savchenko, it was not at all easy. And

00:43:24

then

00:43:25

Fedyan declared him an agent of the Kremlin and a

00:43:29

person

00:43:32

specifically about Savchenko after she

00:43:35

was released,

00:43:37

I immediately thought then I’ll ask when

00:43:39

it’s still here then and wait, handsome,

00:43:42

I know very well

00:43:44

how it went,

00:43:46

how it was seriously

00:43:48

painful because just like that, at a

00:43:52

distance of two outstretched arms,

00:43:56

I talked about it, the presence of other

00:43:59

main handsome guys

00:44:01

with Putin

00:44:03

and Ilya armed me with Novikov then with

00:44:07

the materials of the case I spoke to Vladimir

00:44:10

Vladimirovich said Well, look,

00:44:11

you say that, or rather,

00:44:14

the prosecutor’s office says that she climbed

00:44:17

onto this table Gladky, which is four and a

00:44:20

half meters now I don’t remember exactly, Yes,

00:44:22

time has passed, well, you Well, you and she are

00:44:25

wounded and you, well, Vladimir Well it’s impossible,

00:44:28

she couldn’t correct it Well, Vladimir

00:44:30

Vladimirovich Well, this is clearly not

00:44:32

Show me

00:44:36

So, in fact,

00:44:40

this is the story

00:44:45

[music]

00:44:48

Rodion Stepanova agrees that Propaganda

00:44:51

kills and listen to Counter-propaganda Well,

00:44:54

this says philosophical things, I’m a little

00:44:56

more earthly words in general there are

00:44:59

people kill because of this they commit

00:45:01

suicide they are pushed to

00:45:03

lethal decisions Yes, this is not

00:45:05

necessarily propaganda Counter-propaganda

00:45:07

really kills and lies kill

00:45:11

Well, that’s what we’re going to philosophize on this topic

00:45:22

why he doesn’t decide anything Nikita 28 years old

00:45:25

Moscow he’s creating

00:45:28

Such a field, I’ve been following behind the

00:45:32

international tribunals According to the former

00:45:33

Yugoslavia Provandi Well, what do they decide,

00:45:36

solves a lot, a lot of legal matters,

00:45:38

there is a maritime Arbitration

00:45:42

UN institution is very important

00:45:45

when the Security Council sends

00:45:47

peacekeepers when everyone has agreed Yes, and

00:45:50

separates the

00:45:51

warring parties. Yes, no, you can’t say

00:45:54

that it doesn’t solve anything, just now in the

00:45:57

conditions of this conflict, one of the parties is

00:45:59

constantly a member of this security with

00:46:01

the right of the century and here, of course, there is

00:46:04

complete powerlessness in this matter

00:46:12

[music]

00:46:15

3700 likes something is not enough Let's

00:46:18

catch up to four at least Putin has

00:46:21

a lot of personal things in the decisions of this they

00:46:23

answered him you know Just when you are sitting

00:46:27

You can save people at such meetings,

00:46:30

now I’ll tell you a

00:46:32

broader story, in fact, Dima

00:46:35

Murat Dmitry Muratov once again

00:46:37

I confirm I spoke with him yesterday after

00:46:40

his interview with Yuri Duddy comes out.

00:46:43

He will come to the studio and answer your

00:46:45

questions, it may be more than one hour we’ll be with him

00:46:48

let's decide how to do it But he will come

00:46:50

That's when these same medicines for

00:46:54

children that were banned in the

00:46:56

Russian Federation and when they were

00:46:58

given to us We were lobbyists for all the

00:47:02

parents' doctors

00:47:04

Well, Vladimir Vladimirovich Well, the law does

00:47:07

n't allow Well, let's change it,

00:47:09

ask,

00:47:11

but children are dying Vladimir’s wife and Yes, it

00:47:15

was possible and we know that it was

00:47:18

such things also happened. And once it was

00:47:21

impossible to get a person out. Well,

00:47:25

listen, let Putin report on Golunov.

00:47:30

Yes, we have an authoritarian system. By the way, we were

00:47:32

recently

00:47:34

given the financial Times last year

00:47:38

interview such a lunch with war show times

00:47:41

gave a great interview to Surkov

00:47:43

Unfortunately it doesn’t open for me because I

00:47:45

can’t subscribe my cards don’t

00:47:47

work naturally Russian Here uh

00:47:50

And there in the title that Putin is a

00:47:53

modern Octavian August what what

00:47:56

did I say I we in the twentieth year they did

00:47:59

Amateur that according to Octavian this is Putin

00:48:03

ancient in Ancient Rome So we are Surkov,

00:48:06

he knows what he said and that’s when

00:48:10

you understand who is in front of you if you

00:48:12

can pull out a person

00:48:14

but how not to take advantage of this no Let him

00:48:16

die better so that we can do it again they shouted

00:48:18

and the Bloody Tyrant, but you can

00:48:21

shout like that and of course they used it,

00:48:23

of course and of course

00:48:26

I already said. If now there was

00:48:28

an opportunity, I would use it

00:48:30

without batting an eye, don’t pay attention to the

00:48:33

screams of those. How can we do this

00:48:36

because we pulled out one person and already well

00:48:39

and a hundred And here’s a thousand

00:48:46

Marie 2D If the advantages are that these are on the

00:48:49

agent Maybe there are, I don’t see them, to be

00:48:50

honest Maria I’m glad to see you in the

00:48:53

chat, I don’t see them, first of all, it’s

00:48:55

offensive, it’s disgusting and

00:48:58

insulting, I don’t know each other there

00:49:00

Congratulations there, with the

00:49:01

advent of the glorious system, you were insulted,

00:49:05

maybe you weren’t offended, you were

00:49:07

insulted Well, there are a lot of

00:49:10

things that interfere there, but for example,

00:49:13

it interferes with me, ah, meeting some

00:49:16

people who are not not me, sorry, you’re

00:49:18

toxic, they’re probably following

00:49:21

you, probably listen But this means

00:49:24

I can’t get an opinion of the information

00:49:26

to tell you Well, it’s not useful

00:49:29

Well, well, I’m not talking about reports there

00:49:33

about what is needed, all

00:49:35

this is not a second citizenship, I’m not planning

00:49:38

But I’m not planning a second citizenship

00:49:41

Why we should give this country to

00:49:43

others

00:49:45

Why so that

00:49:49

I don’t plan

00:49:53

Lavrov I feel sorry for Dima from Bobruisk some

00:49:57

Dima is the right person no

00:50:00

you know why

00:50:01

He is a grown boy I am Sergei

00:50:05

Viktorovich well acquainted with you

00:50:08

at one time

00:50:12

I think he had a choice

00:50:15

I think I don’t know I I think he had a choice,

00:50:19

he made this choice

00:50:23

and

00:50:25

this means that he chose the Consequences himself

00:50:28

because he could not help but understand the

00:50:30

consequences for himself in the future Now

00:50:33

everything is in the future

00:50:38

and I feel sorry that he made such a choice That’s what

00:50:41

I would say and it’s a shame

00:50:49

Boomerang You are ready to fight to the end, you are a

00:50:52

Patriot, you can see how I am a patriot, but I am not

00:50:54

fighting,

00:50:55

you can say that I am fighting. Well,

00:50:59

in the understanding of many people, I am not fighting,

00:51:00

but you are right. I am fighting for the Russia

00:51:03

that I consider correct. But the policy

00:51:05

that I consider correct is for talking with

00:51:06

people who think it’s right, but you’re

00:51:08

probably doing the same thing,

00:51:14

and Dmitry Samsung visited Crimea since

00:51:16

14, no,

00:51:22

we’re waiting for Shevchuk’s new disc. I’ll tell him

00:51:25

your attitude towards Latin. You know, I’ve made

00:51:28

it a rule

00:51:29

not to comment,

00:51:32

try not to comment on journalists

00:51:35

who once worked for Echo can only be

00:51:37

praised when there is something to praise for, and

00:51:40

what I like is because, well, there is

00:51:41

a certain journalistic school, Echo, and the rules of the

00:51:44

Echo journalistic school, and when

00:51:46

journalists deviate from this school, it’s

00:51:49

their choice, well, I won’t comment on that, I won’t be

00:51:52

here, okay,

00:51:56

but I’ll be with Kournikova to praise for the film Hunger,

00:51:58

I watched it,

00:52:00

this is the scoundrel that the

00:52:03

hunger companies have committed now, you know, this is

00:52:06

scoundrel

00:52:08

Yes, this film that you must watch

00:52:10

is a consequence of the revolution,

00:52:15

including that everyone will find a lot of things for

00:52:18

themselves and they close it But I

00:52:21

hope that it will appear on YouTube in December,

00:52:23

we will inform you in every possible way where you

00:52:26

can watch it,

00:52:29

and why do you think that you are not mistaken, I

00:52:32

don’t really understand

00:52:35

what, of course, I could be wrong, just like you,

00:52:38

however, but when I say I’m

00:52:41

sure of it, that’s what I I’m telling you I

00:52:44

know this I experienced this, that

00:52:47

’s why I’m saying it’s

00:52:52

like watching the film Olya Shorina’s Hunger

00:52:54

Well, we’ll tell you when it appears live

00:52:58

Live Yes, I see your request, I’ll say we’ll

00:53:01

write it, we’ll publish it in our

00:53:03

telegram channel, we’ll say everything here

00:53:11

[music]

00:53:14

so

00:53:15

on do you still trust the results of

00:53:18

electronic voting now of course

00:53:20

no one has proven it back

00:53:23

no one has proven it back all the fantasies are not

00:53:27

very erotic

00:53:30

and Kurnikov has a lot of respect separately for

00:53:32

this work this is true brand this is true It’s

00:53:34

just simple truth August is

00:53:38

cooler than Caesar Yes Vovan is tolerant Why did

00:53:43

Russia attack Ukraine Because

00:53:45

Russia If we talk about those who made

00:53:47

this decision, they

00:53:49

ban you here, but they also do the right thing for the

00:53:52

ban, But I’m addressing this to the equan But

00:53:56

we talked about this many times, but

00:53:59

the team that made the decision

00:54:01

believed that the territory of Ukraine, firstly, is

00:54:04

partly the territory of Russia, secondly,

00:54:06

that current Ukraine is a threat to a

00:54:09

springboard

00:54:10

for Counter-Russian actions, then

00:54:13

it attacked

00:54:18

Peskov, do you even have the right to your own

00:54:21

voice or only to the voice of the president,

00:54:22

you know Svetlana, the last question, I’m

00:54:25

Dmitry Sergeevich, I became president there a long time ago,

00:54:27

I talked about this I

00:54:28

told you, you can’t hear,

00:54:31

he told me then Listen to everything I

00:54:33

say unless I stipulate that this is my

00:54:35

opinion Yes, this is all agreed upon

00:54:38

at the top, I’m a mouthpiece that’s why

00:54:43

When you hear it Yes, this is the

00:54:46

opinion of the president

00:54:49

and the

00:54:51

video about you was collected on the popular

00:54:53

politics channel you know a lot of likes, your

00:54:55

support, Thank you, of course, for

00:54:58

your support, of course I didn’t watch the video, I really

00:55:01

didn’t. So they wrote me

00:55:04

some 15 million there, well, even if it’s not at all

00:55:07

erotic from the point of view of fantasy, But

00:55:10

let them show you the famous

00:55:11

investigators there. Well, show me all the bills. it’s

00:55:15

clear that it’s an attempt at discretion, it’s

00:55:19

clear, it’s not interesting, apparently I hit a

00:55:23

sore spot

00:55:25

when I started my investigation, I’ve already started.

00:55:30

Well, that’s their difficulties. Thank you

00:55:32

very much, I’ll remind you that I found an amateur.media There

00:55:35

’s also love and terror in the garden of monsters in

00:55:39

Hitler’s Berlin, a book that we

00:55:40

already had and which you quickly snapped up

00:55:43

now Go to

00:55:44

shop.atan.media I’ll remind you that the

00:55:47

last 4 issues have been published uh My district

00:55:51

including Arbat Gagarinsky Ryazansky

00:55:53

ryadydovo see you tomorrow we are at

00:55:57

Vladimir Borisovich Pastukhov And now

00:56:01

18 hours in the price of Victory

00:56:04

Boris Kovalev doctor historical sciences

00:56:08

Vitaly Damarsky Bye everyone

Description:

В прямом эфире на ваши вопросы ответит Алексей Венедиктов*. Поддержать Живой Гвоздь: https://pay.cloudtips.ru/p/7edd7c0e Мобильное приложение "Эха": любимые программы в формате радиоприёмника. Простой интерфейс. Работа в фоновом режиме. Расписание эфиров. Скачать: в AppStore: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/%D1%8D%D1%85%D0%BE-online/id1639907671 в PlayMarket: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=online.echofm.app Подписывайтесь на Алексея Венедиктова* в соцсетях: https://t.me/aavst2022 https://twitter.com/aavst20551?s=11 * — власти РФ считают иностранным агентом, а ФБК** — разжигателем войны ** — организация внесена в список иностранных агентов, признана экстремистской и запрещена в России 🔔 Последние новости и анонсы программ с YouTube-канала «Живой гвоздь», а также контент от наших постоянных гостей и экспертов на официальном телеграм-канале: https://t.me/livegvozd Подписаться на Youtube-канал Дилетант: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuIE7-5QzeAR6EdZXwDRwuQ?sub_confirmation=1 📌 Живой гвоздь в аудиоформате: Яндекс.Музыка: https://music.yandex.ru/album/22141653?dir=desc Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/%D0%B6%D0%B8%D0%B2%D0%BE%D0%B9-%D0%B3%D0%B2%D0%BE%D0%B7%D0%B4%D1%8C/id1616175210 Google Подкасты: https://clck.ru/ehYPw Магазин "Дилетант": https://diletant.shop/

Preparing download options

Popular

HD video

Only sound

All

* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."

** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players

Questions about downloading video

How can I download "Алексей Венедиктов* / #СлухайЭхо // 16.11.2022" video?

http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.

Which format of "Алексей Венедиктов* / #СлухайЭхо // 16.11.2022" video should I choose?

The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.

Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Алексей Венедиктов* / #СлухайЭхо // 16.11.2022" video?

The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.

How can I download "Алексей Венедиктов* / #СлухайЭхо // 16.11.2022" video to my phone?

You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.

How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Алексей Венедиктов* / #СлухайЭхо // 16.11.2022"?

The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.

How can I save a frame from a video "Алексей Венедиктов* / #СлухайЭхо // 16.11.2022"?

This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.

What's the price of all this stuff?

It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.