Download "Служили два товарища. Фильмы о гражданской войне."
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FoB1-Q2--ZBE%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
Similar videos from our catalog
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F4n18c5dULXQ%252Fsddefault.jpg%253Fv%253D6426c66a&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FEGnyLhOJ39Y%252Fsd2.jpg%253Fsqp%253D-oaymwEoCIAFEOAD8quKqQMcGADwAQH4AYAEgALQBYoCDAgAEAEYEyATKH8wDw%253D%253D%2526rs%253DAOn4CLA-16fNyVxhJQdW9OnEMxpV4EGHpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FN1-kP9D1GXE%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FbRn6pEtQoYQ%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FcgSArC1B94A%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FukUA1wzeBuw%252Fsddefault.jpg%253Fv%253D63e247dc&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252Fx7oPBVOjCeE%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
Video tags
Subtitles
Russian
00:00:03
lead, I don’t know, well, now we’ll throw in00:00:07
and the women will give birth to new00:00:08
zagato squad in the person of one person00:00:11
[music]00:00:19
hello Gleb, welcome, but we’ve00:00:23
already sorted out a lot of films and now00:00:25
we have the last one in line, these00:00:29
two comrades served absolutely right to the requests of00:00:31
our viewers and listeners, how they00:00:34
voted, it took third place and00:00:37
that’s when we came to it, but00:00:40
this film raised a lot of direct00:00:43
questions for me, it’s just in my opinion an00:00:46
anti-Soviet Soviet film, as you00:00:48
said then, that means there are Soviet00:00:51
Soviet films, it’s anti-Soviet a00:00:53
Soviet film in my opinion, well, in00:00:55
any case, a Soviet film with a00:00:58
large number of elements, these are00:01:00
Soviet, that’s for sure and it’s not just00:01:03
because if we look at who00:01:05
wrote the script and who filmed it, everything will fall00:01:08
into place, but let’s not00:01:11
rush, let’s start as always since00:01:13
some year00:01:15
we have had an ideological basis00:01:17
throughout the entire analysis until00:01:19
we’ll talk about what mistakes and mistakes there are,00:01:23
and they are there, I noticed00:01:26
a lot of them, anachronisms, and so on and so forth,00:01:28
let’s get down to00:01:31
the analysis, let’s start since the year 1968, by the way, we00:01:35
touched on it when we were talking about reviewing the00:01:39
film, the new adventures of the elusive,00:01:41
by the way, what a coincidence that00:01:45
two comrades served in the new adventures of the00:01:47
elusive, the place of action is in the rank of the00:01:50
Levsky Crimea, in essence, well, in the00:01:54
Avengers it is presented in a few strokes00:01:56
and already directly in00:02:00
two comrades served there, everything revolves around, well,00:02:03
basically, a few weeks in November00:02:06
1920, we have already said that 1968 was a00:02:10
very difficult year,00:02:11
a lot of different events happened there, at the00:02:13
height of the war in Vietnam, it was00:02:15
in this year that the00:02:18
famous Sankney massacre took place00:02:20
Paris negotiations began between the north and00:02:23
south and, accordingly, the United00:02:25
States of America, the00:02:26
Cold War was in full swing and the00:02:29
assassinations of Robert Kennedy and the height of the00:02:33
Civil War and many other00:02:35
events actually show that the00:02:38
Cold War was really developing into such a very, well,00:02:42
not hot stage, of course, but in the stage is00:02:44
very difficult and the confrontation between the two00:02:46
systems socialist and00:02:48
capitalist, we have already00:02:49
talked about this, it entered such a very tough00:02:52
stage and therefore it is logical that the films00:02:55
that were shot in the Soviet Union during this00:02:57
period from 1968, especially dedicated to the00:03:01
Great Patriotic War dedicated to00:03:04
the civil war, they should have been00:03:06
because again, we have a planned00:03:08
economy, total state control over the film00:03:11
industry, they should have these00:03:13
films reflect a certain00:03:15
ideological component, that is,00:03:17
serve the cause of the information war before the00:03:20
Western world, if you like, and here00:03:23
two comrades served just here, this is one of those00:03:26
films that is very controversial and how I know00:03:30
people who00:03:32
watched it in the eighth year, they00:03:36
also had the feeling that the film was00:03:38
extremely controversial, but I just talked with00:03:41
various representatives of00:03:43
that age, let’s say I was interested,00:03:47
asked if there was time to talk, and00:03:50
accordingly, everyone as one said that the00:03:53
film was extremely controversial.00:03:56
there was a lot and then they were just talking about00:03:59
how the film was so strange, very00:04:02
strange and it was difficult to say that it00:04:05
expressed the official ideology that00:04:08
was not in the Soviet Union at that time;00:04:16
about00:04:20
Soviet power about its birth about the00:04:23
role of the Communist Party of the00:04:28
Bolshevik Party and the role of commissars and about many00:04:30
other things very controversial opinions a very00:04:34
controversial opinion we no longer take the fact that00:04:36
Vysotsky brilliantly played the role of the white00:04:39
officer Brusentsov, who00:04:43
then evoked sympathy among some people of a00:04:45
very character I Of course, the character is00:04:48
in fact extremely antipathetic, but00:04:51
nevertheless it was all presented in such a way00:04:53
that both the script and the production,00:04:56
at least for the viewer, gave rise to00:05:00
several questions as to whether00:05:02
maybe not everything was so smooth with the00:05:05
establishment of Soviet power with the00:05:07
civil war, maybe not everything is so00:05:09
simple, and by the way, many of the00:05:13
cliches that were created in this film, including00:05:15
the cliche regarding00:05:18
the fact that the Soviet Red Army00:05:21
subsequently fought both the00:05:23
Civil War and the Great00:05:26
Patriotic War, were led by absolutely00:05:28
mediocre00:05:30
commanders, as a rule, in the workshop, but00:05:33
I’m talking about this cliche now and00:05:35
mostly there was one line with the help of00:05:39
which the soldiers were motivated, this is the line of the00:05:41
whip, you can’t do it, there will be a tribunal in the film,00:05:44
all this is very clearly shown, but we’ll get to the00:05:48
question of how the censorship missed this, well, this is00:05:52
68, after all, when the consequences of the00:05:56
so-called thaw were still felt and00:05:59
let’s not forget that if I may00:06:02
say so, the corporation of the film of the affairs of00:06:06
the cinematographer, the scriptwriters, it also00:06:08
acted according to certain internal00:06:11
laws and who should be supported who00:06:13
should be pushed and well, about all this00:06:16
in order, I think now we should00:06:18
smoothly move on to who actually00:06:21
created this film, to the director and00:06:23
a screenwriter, and that’s right,00:06:25
in my opinion, it’s especially important to show00:06:28
who those directors were and what they had, let’s00:06:32
say who played behind them,00:06:35
there was a director of the film, Evgeniy00:06:38
Karelov, he didn’t live such a long life, but00:06:41
he made a decent number of worthy00:06:44
films, and this is a wonderful film 200:06:47
capitalism of the 50s and the film is very00:06:50
popular children Don Quixote comedy seven00:06:53
old men and one girl00:06:55
and that’s exactly what he00:06:56
became famous for as the author of the film two comrades served,00:07:00
but about him I can’t say that this was00:07:04
some kind of person who was charged00:07:06
anti-Soviet and I can’t say anything about00:07:08
this about the director as a00:07:10
director, but about two00:07:13
screenwriters who, in my opinion, for a very long time,00:07:16
almost until the end of the eighties,00:07:19
acted in tandem and wrote00:07:22
scripts for a huge number of films,00:07:23
many of which are very controversial, I would00:07:26
go into detail and probably we00:07:28
we’ll take 10 minutes from the audience, but believe me, it’s00:07:30
worth it; by the way, this is the first time in a00:07:33
long time that we’ve touched upon the scriptwriters; they’re the00:07:35
directors; well, in general, maybe this is not00:07:38
right on our part, since00:07:40
after all, the script’s basis is the axis around00:07:43
which the whole film revolves, but here,00:07:46
believe me there are two screenwriters,00:07:49
Duma Yuli Teodorovich and Frit Valery00:07:54
Semyonovich, they were friends almost from school, they00:07:57
entered VGIK together00:08:00
in the screenwriting department, and throughout their00:08:04
lives, right up to Pawn until the end of the00:08:06
80s, they were the authors of scripts for a00:08:08
huge number of films, many of them00:08:10
which were controversial,00:08:12
they had such a kind of author’s tandem, and it must be00:08:15
said that they belonged to the so-00:08:17
called Soviet golden youth00:08:19
because they grew up in families where00:08:21
their fathers occupied a very high position00:08:25
in the Soviet leadership, in00:08:27
particular with the Duma’s Yuli Teodorovich, and00:08:30
his father was Teodor Lvovich Duma was00:08:34
one of the high officials of the Supreme Council of00:08:37
the National Economy,00:08:39
that is, he was specifically involved in issues of00:08:42
state planning,00:08:44
of course, this is a very high post, and Frid00:08:48
Valery Semyonovich’s father Semyon Markovich00:08:50
Frith was a professor of microbiology and00:08:53
occupied several00:08:55
departments at both Moscow University and00:08:59
Minsk University, and I must say Do you remember00:09:02
the image of the paramedic who in the film00:09:05
reads a poem to the Red Army soldiers about00:09:08
lice soup? Yes, by the way, I really liked the00:09:11
interesting image, well, the man is00:09:13
really passionate about his work and he is00:09:16
in a visual form through poetry, here00:09:18
by the way we also remember the windows of00:09:20
Mayakovsky’s growth, which also00:09:22
conveyed certain information00:09:24
propaganda in verse in this case, the paramedic00:09:27
reads poems about hygiene to the Red Army soldiers in a00:09:30
visual form, shows why they need to00:09:32
fight and take care of their00:09:34
appearance, and this is the way of life taken00:09:37
because it was precisely the men’s when he00:09:41
was still very young and when he joined the00:09:43
Red Army as a paramedic he just00:09:46
wrote such poems and read them as00:09:47
Red Army soldiers, that is, this image from00:09:50
life,00:09:51
that is, both of these snare 100 future ones, they00:09:55
were actually from the golden youth and,00:09:58
by the way, by age they should have00:10:00
gone to the front, but since they00:10:02
entered the 1st pom. in 1944, 1941,00:10:04
they studied calmly at VGIK,00:10:08
but suddenly the following00:10:10
situation happened in 1944, it would seem like00:10:13
three years, they both waited as00:10:15
volunteers to go to the front, somehow took the current00:10:18
early exams, went to the front, why do00:10:21
you think it was in00:10:22
1944? but 44 this offensive00:10:27
is not going on at all, well, just like that, usually we00:10:29
know many were filming themselves here, the so-00:10:31
called armor, dropped out of school and went for 4100:10:34
years because this is the most difficult moment,00:10:37
massively besieged, all the recruiting centers00:10:41
wanted to go to the front, but then somehow, well,00:10:43
42 but why 44 when the war is00:10:45
already gradually00:10:48
declining and, moreover, various00:10:51
decrees of the Soviet government are issued about00:10:53
strengthening this armor00:10:55
because it is clear that the war has already00:10:57
gradually reached a turning point and we00:11:00
need to take care of personnel, and then suddenly they00:11:02
quit their studies precisely in00:11:04
1944 they volunteered for the front, to00:11:08
say that they did not go to the front as00:11:10
volunteers, in fact, they escaped, escaped00:11:13
from specific criminal prosecution,00:11:16
because in 1943, at the00:11:19
end, a certain group of young people was discovered, the00:11:23
so-called youth group, they were00:11:25
then in the NKVD bodies in their affairs00:11:28
took place which were accused of00:11:32
anti-Soviet agitation during the war years,00:11:35
by the way, and in particular, well, at00:11:38
least this is open sources that I00:11:40
don’t know to trust on the Internet here or not,00:11:42
of course, doing it in my hands, I didn’t hold them,00:11:43
they accuse him of preparing an attempt00:11:46
on Stalin’s life, this is very serious, this is00:11:48
serious, here you can always of course00:11:50
say what is this, well, the organs00:11:54
were just drawing the unfortunate people with sticks, these00:11:58
students were taken from the student bench00:12:00
in order to get an extra extra thing to00:12:03
do, they had nothing else to do than to draw00:12:05
sticks for themselves under such a far-fetched00:12:07
pretext, expressed as a serious00:12:09
pretext in my opinion in the midst of a war,00:12:11
especially but let’s assume that this the disk00:12:13
is such a strange thing, it would be00:12:16
strange and by the way,00:12:19
Lansky 13 people passed through it and all the representatives of00:12:21
this very00:12:23
golden youth, and it’s interesting who00:12:26
entered there before the youth, but who, for example, is the00:12:28
daughter and Maria Goga of Diamonds, who was repressed in the 30s,00:12:34
representatives too there is a00:12:37
creative elite, let’s say,00:12:39
or medical children, golden youth00:12:43
who actually lived comfortably in Moscow,00:12:44
that is, escaping from the front, and so00:12:47
chopped up such conversations, well, maybe this is00:12:50
a fiction, if in forty-three there would00:12:55
not have been such a thing that00:12:57
seems to me that it is somehow connected and that it was00:13:00
made according to which the Duma ifrit was held00:13:02
and the case of the so-called00:13:06
Fourth Reich, you probably have00:13:08
n’t heard about this rain, the meaning of 4 years, there00:13:12
really was some sort of Fourth00:13:14
Reich, well, this is an organization, the work of an organization00:13:17
called 4 as some kind of itself - then the00:13:21
organization was passed by those who were members of it,00:13:23
which means the following story happened in00:13:27
my forty-third year until in forty-00:13:29
third the son of the Minister of Aviation00:13:32
Industry Shakhurin on the lips was00:13:36
either 16-17 years old shot his love, the daughter of an00:13:41
Uman diplomat, and shot him in the00:13:44
center of Moscow on a stone bridge and then he00:13:46
shot himself, well, it seems like it’s something00:13:49
similar to unrequited love,00:13:51
the weapon is understandable in the military,00:13:54
it was possible to purchase a desecrated one, and besides, they were00:13:56
part of the elite of the elite, the authorities somehow00:13:59
began to promote this case and00:14:01
promoted that it turns out there is a certain00:14:04
organization of children People's Commissars,00:14:08
well then, for example, there were 3 from I'm very00:14:11
sorry, two sons of Mikoyan who00:14:13
called their organization the Fourth00:14:14
Reich,00:14:15
the ideology was essentially00:14:17
National Socialist, but they didn’t00:14:20
call themselves and addressed each other as00:14:22
Gruppenführer and Reichsführer, and so on,00:14:24
well, officially it seems like they were played00:14:28
officially, well, this was such a00:14:32
kind of mockery towards the00:14:35
authorities, but let's see who was part00:14:38
of this so-called Shakhurin group, the00:14:40
Fourth Reich, it included the children of00:14:42
very high-ranking officials, well, in00:14:46
particular, as I said, two sons of Mikoyan,00:14:49
Sergei Ivanov, son of raiden By00:14:53
the way, the state security commissioner in00:14:56
which he was married for 30 years to00:14:57
Alliluyeva’s sister, who was the wife of Steel, well,00:15:00
that is, essentially a relative of Steel, but but00:15:02
he was repressed for 30 years during the00:15:04
Great Terror, there was a son and an assistant to the son of the00:15:08
price of Voroshilov’s assistant, General00:15:10
Khmelnitsky, there was a son of the surgeon Pakulov and00:15:14
so on, and by the way, there was, remember, we00:15:16
touched on this personality of the nephew of00:15:19
Armand Hammer, the same00:15:22
entrepreneur who very actively00:15:25
traded in Soviet Russia, well, let’s say, he did00:15:28
n’t just trade, he even helped, well, in00:15:30
fact, well, not for free, of course, but00:15:33
nevertheless, that is, this is really an elite of00:15:36
elites children who are directly00:15:38
involved in the propaganda of Nazism, even if only to00:15:41
their own circle,00:15:43
but this says a lot, and plus00:15:45
how the case ended in murder and it is00:15:48
still not clear whether this was jealousy or whether00:15:50
someone covered their tracks, it is not clear about00:15:55
this, by the way, not so a long time ago in00:15:57
2010, a book by Alexander Terekhov,00:16:00
Stone Bridge, was published, I can’t00:16:03
recommend it because I simply have00:16:05
n’t read it, but judging by the annotation, he00:16:07
examines this case from an artistic00:16:09
point of view, but it seems to be based on00:16:11
archival data, but this case00:16:13
was really helpful00:16:15
they treated this elite very gently when, by the way,00:16:17
Stalin found out that what was00:16:20
happening right next to him in Moscow, almost00:16:22
where he lives, he only said one word,00:16:24
but this is apocryphal they will keep silent,00:16:26
but but about Mikoyan of I can00:16:29
say that Mikoyan children, of course, they00:16:32
later formed such a00:16:34
kind of anti-Soviet vanguard, and00:16:37
Stepan Mikoyan, who was a pilot,00:16:41
of course, was not in this case for an hour, they00:16:42
were not a participant in it, so he even helped in00:16:45
such a transfer to the court of time00:16:47
and he was there, by the way, on the side of00:16:49
Mlechin, well then there are opponents of the00:16:51
Soviet Union, he directly says that the00:16:53
cash register collapsed and well, all empires should00:16:56
collapse like this, the Soviet Union, as00:16:59
always, the empire, the empire of the entire empire, will00:17:02
collapse and it’s good that it happened in the00:17:04
ninety-first year, well, that is, the00:17:06
elite children were so unique, well, here’s00:17:10
the question about how to educate the elite, well,00:17:13
in general, it’s strange that they were treated00:17:15
quite gently, as you say, so I00:17:17
would like to explain in a nutshell how00:17:20
gently, but I want to note00:17:22
why these guys were treated so gently,00:17:25
so you’re playing Nazism, you’re00:17:28
playing it’s all clear, but at the same00:17:32
time Nazism is killing your brothers00:17:36
because specifically Stepanov00:17:38
was a pilot there, yes, yes, exactly what00:17:41
if we talk about Mikoyan, well, they00:17:43
probably somehow managed to convince the authorities and,00:17:47
again, I’m not aware of the matter, I didn’t00:17:49
read that this was of course a game, but in00:17:53
the case of minus and freedom organs00:17:56
could not be convinced so, by the way, they00:17:58
escaped to the front, and at the front, their00:18:01
black raven walked through the window and they went00:18:05
to the colony in the north, in my opinion,00:18:08
where you sent them, and frith then00:18:10
wrote a book, it’s called 8000:18:13
half the story of the camp idiot I00:18:16
I remind you that the fire over there at that time will00:18:18
come to the floor until now, this jargon00:18:20
has been buried up to 100 by an idiot, it00:18:22
actually begins with a person who cooperates with00:18:24
the administration and for this you the00:18:27
administration provides such00:18:29
fairly warm places, that is, there is00:18:31
a librarian there, a bathhouse attendant, a bread-cutter, and so on, it00:18:34
seems like he’s fritting as he himself said, he00:18:37
refused, he did not cooperate, but for some reason,00:18:40
when he was imprisoned before he was00:18:42
engaged in amateur performances, to00:18:44
participate in the filming of some films was00:18:46
being a prisoner of that same00:18:48
terrible gulag and they both served until00:18:53
56-57. By the way, for some reason they didn’t got into the00:18:57
famous Belev amnesty for 53 years, well, they spent time there,00:19:00
were rehabilitated, returned00:19:03
to Moscow, and since they won’t lie, in00:19:07
my opinion, they learned them from their00:19:09
student days, in fact, they took them away, they00:19:11
learned them at VGIK and they were assigned to the00:19:14
place of screenwriters and they wrote scripts00:19:17
for films as I said, it’s very, very00:19:19
controversial and it was already filmed in the eighth year, they just00:19:22
received an order to create it,00:19:25
well, we won’t worry about the eighth00:19:26
year, 67, this is the anniversary of the revolution,00:19:30
films are being made from this commission by00:19:32
the state and the civil one, not the00:19:33
revolution, well, how to bypass such a top00:19:37
civil wars like the liquidation of the monitor lizard of the00:19:39
Kiev Crimea, which many, by the way,00:19:43
say that this was precisely the finale of the00:19:45
civil war, we talked so that00:19:48
you remember the reasons and chronology of the civil00:19:51
war, that it essentially ended later00:19:53
in the twenty-second year, when the00:19:54
White Army stronghold in00:19:57
Primorye was liquidated, I also more Let me note that we00:20:01
discussed, if you remember the00:20:03
state border, red sand,00:20:05
that in fact the civil war not00:20:08
only continued until00:20:11
they fought with the Basmachi even before the 30s, but it00:20:14
continued and then simply was no longer00:20:16
considered specifically as episodes of the00:20:18
civil war, well, just a00:20:20
stronghold of the White Guard in in the Crimea, this00:20:26
was precisely the claim against Tanya, the enemies00:20:29
in general say that even if we don’t00:20:31
succeed in attacking Moscow, we00:20:33
will create our own Russian state in the Crimea,00:20:35
well, something like how Chiang00:20:38
Kai-shek became the consequences of creating their own00:20:41
Chinese state in Taiwan, which is00:20:43
still We don’t know an unrecognized00:20:45
state that has no relation to the00:20:48
People’s Republic of China, it00:20:50
looks like they wanted to do something and the liquidation of00:20:52
Crimea is really essentially the00:20:54
end of the civil war in the sense00:20:56
that the last serious enemy00:20:58
was eliminated, well, at least00:21:01
that’s what many people thought,00:21:04
this opinion was shared and so the film begins with the fact00:21:07
that he helped the stereoscopic view of the00:21:09
fortifications at Perekop, which in00:21:11
fact, of course, filming was not carried out there00:21:14
because these fortifications at Perekop itself are the00:21:17
very isthmus that connects the00:21:18
Crimea and the mainland, he survived the00:21:22
Great Patriotic Civil War, everything was00:21:25
swept away there back in forty in the fourth year, when00:21:28
ours liberated the Crimea, there was a00:21:31
maximum concentration of gun00:21:33
barrels per00:21:34
square kilometer, maybe00:21:37
a meter, it was simply plowed up and,00:21:39
of course, there was no fortification left; they00:21:41
actually removed it in the famous Arabat00:21:43
fortress, which is located right on the00:21:46
Arabat spit, well, they just picked it up, more or00:21:49
less similar to00:21:52
Perekopsk fortifications of the area and00:21:54
fortifications that were simply stored, but this is00:21:56
normal and00:21:59
these fortifications are viewed through a stereo tube, rows of barbed00:22:01
wire, some kind of explosions and a song is sung,00:22:05
two comrades served, illiterate, by the way,00:22:08
in the same regiment and so on, it00:22:11
immediately surprises me why such a00:22:13
song they came up with you, it didn’t00:22:16
bother you in any way, but I actually thought00:22:18
this song existed, either our00:22:21
grandfathers and great-grandfathers or not, but it’s generally00:22:24
kind of strange and again illiterate,00:22:26
our great-grandfathers and grandfathers were not so00:22:29
illiterate as to replicate it, well,00:22:31
well, someone illiterate composed it on a00:22:33
song in the same regiment, but then00:22:36
some kind of polishing still happens and in the00:22:38
end we get a competent version, but here’s00:22:41
how it’s kind of strange, but it00:22:42
shows that look what00:22:44
illiterate people made the revolution, the00:22:46
civil war, on the one hand, on00:22:49
the other hand, the song then this is actually a00:22:51
paraphrase of a German soldier’s song,00:22:55
just because my friend had a couple of phrases both00:22:58
in content and in some moments,00:23:00
well, this song was sung, including during the00:23:03
Great Patriotic War, by Nazi00:23:05
soldiers, and although the song is not a combination00:23:08
composed in the Third Reich, it was composed00:23:10
long ago during the Napoleonic wars in00:23:13
Prussia in 1809, but here are some00:23:17
words from there, I will still allow you to00:23:18
quote that they are directly repeated,00:23:20
in particular there are such lines of the Ainu00:23:23
book for us gif login Hitler Adolf Hitler he was00:23:26
hit by a bullet why not me well00:23:31
as in the song he sings why exactly a00:23:33
German song, the question is, what a00:23:38
charm it turns out to be, well, we can00:23:41
say that this is, well, this is a German00:23:43
soldier from the time of the Napoleonic wars, but00:23:46
why did they take it, but nevertheless,00:23:48
the film already begins with the fact that we hear a00:23:50
song that has essentially German roots00:23:54
again, this song was popular,00:23:57
and they sang it was a drill song of the00:24:00
Nazi troops during the Great00:24:02
Patriotic War, but nevertheless00:24:04
these fortifications are observed and we learn00:24:08
that the Red troops are accumulating in front of00:24:11
the dig to break into the Crimea and are00:24:15
just00:24:17
looking for an adjutant like then it turns out that the hero’s00:24:21
dad is new from the regiment commander, no one is00:24:24
beautiful, he jumps and asks Nekrasov’s00:24:27
attention, he is handsome, and00:24:30
the Red Army soldiers who teach in such a field00:24:32
school also joke about him, and00:24:35
mom remember by the words, this is by the way, by the way, it00:24:38
was like that and about the school and the00:24:40
truth is that red is red the world,00:24:42
including this is00:24:43
a school that taught illiterate00:24:46
peasants to read and write, but00:24:49
later the00:24:50
curriculum became more complicated, they were00:24:53
taught there and the basics of astronomy, that,00:24:57
relatively speaking, the earth is round, the earth00:24:58
revolves around the sun, some00:25:01
biological concepts, that is, such00:25:04
serious preparation already I was walking and now they are00:25:06
joking, just Nekrasova is not mother,00:25:09
but Nekrasov’s dogs find Nekrasov,00:25:12
by the way,00:25:13
in some strange trousers sewn from00:25:16
some kind of bear on which there are even some00:25:19
remnants of some kind of00:25:20
advertising inscription before00:25:23
this in the advertising inscription of me to be00:25:26
honest, it surprised me, it even made me laugh,00:25:28
I think it’s generally like this, why, well,00:25:31
of course, the00:25:32
Red Army soldiers, like the White Guards,00:25:34
were equipped with00:25:36
uniforms differently, but still, this is the twentieth00:25:40
year and these are units that have been fighting for a long time00:25:42
and are going against the enemies of the Russian Crimea,00:25:44
well, let’s assume that this is possible, okay,00:25:47
let’s assume in general, Nekrasov is called by the00:25:49
headquarters and at the headquarters there is a meeting of commanders00:25:53
and the issue of the further capture of the00:25:56
Crimea and Papanov is being decided, which is clear that00:25:59
he is a simple man himself, in my opinion, he says00:26:00
that he spent his life before he began00:26:03
commanding Kyle, that is,00:26:05
most likely he was some kind of miner but00:26:08
this is typical because00:26:11
some of the units that went to00:26:13
war in Ukraine on the Don were in00:26:16
many ways formed by the miners of the Donbass,00:26:18
that is, it is quite likely that a miner could00:26:21
become a commander, and I’ll tell you right00:26:23
here that you paid attention to their00:26:26
uniform. some kind of strange one is more00:26:29
reminiscent of the form of the Great Patriotic00:26:32
War than the Civil War, there is00:26:35
such a thing, but I would even concentrate on something else00:26:37
on the speech of this Papanov,00:26:40
but in principle the speech is00:26:42
correct, here the Crimea is a pimpochka, and00:26:45
the palm closed it is not there, but you need to take it, but00:26:49
notice what wording our screenwriter00:26:51
is they write how we will take Crimea, I don’t know, but00:26:56
we will take it on the one hand, remember,00:26:59
remember our review of the border, the first00:27:04
episode, we will learn on the one hand, on the other00:27:07
hand, I don’t know, but I’ll drive00:27:10
people to this very dig anyway, I’ll00:27:13
take it anyway, well, this creates a strange00:27:16
impression and this impression00:27:17
is further strengthened by his brother as a hint like00:27:20
this, well, now we’ll throw in and the women will give birth to new ones,00:27:23
well, because what to expect from this00:27:25
miner, yes, there are white officers there00:27:28
later, although it shows that there are red00:27:31
commanders who are present at all meetings00:27:34
there, of course there are different ones00:27:37
characters, but in general they don’t00:27:38
shine with such operational tactical00:27:41
art and Lieutenant Brusentsov, yes, he is a00:27:44
drunkard, and he is an officer who00:27:47
is disappointed in many ways, but he immediately arrives, so00:27:50
these will go after yours,00:27:52
here you need to strengthen it, that is, you can immediately00:27:54
see the white bone that knows how to00:27:56
fight not the fact that these blue-legged men are making00:27:59
this impression just like that00:28:01
is intensified and how are these commanders00:28:04
going to lead their units, how to00:28:08
motivate Nekrasov, they just00:28:10
call him to entrust him with00:28:13
aero video shooting of the area and why00:28:17
because Nekrasov worked as an assistant to a photographer before the war,00:28:21
well it would seem that a camera, a movie camera,00:28:25
are slightly different things, and Nekrasov is00:28:27
immediately told to change it, I don’t know what this00:28:29
system is immediately sent to,00:28:32
but I think I immediately began to command, but it’s00:28:35
also such stupidity, some people are one thing to00:28:37
command people, and another00:28:39
thing is to work with the equipment that you00:28:41
I’ve never seen this before, but this is00:28:44
nothing else, Papanov’s hero actually00:28:47
expresses himself, and judging by his chief of staff, judging by his00:28:51
bearing, most likely this is in special terms, he00:28:55
spoke directly, he says, if you don’t comply with00:28:57
the tribunal, that is, it’s only00:29:00
with a whip that you can lead the Red Army soldiers,00:29:03
but this, of course, is not to00:29:05
say directly like modern films, but as00:29:07
they say, sediment remains and Nekrasov,00:29:10
well, what to do, he takes this device00:29:13
outside the headquarters and meets with00:29:16
another hero whom he will go through the00:29:18
whole film, these are the heroes of Bykov, he00:29:21
plays the bulls perfectly, in general, this is one00:29:23
of my favorite actors,00:29:24
he plays a simple one too00:29:27
Red commander against Karyakin, he immediately00:29:30
says that he is actually a commander, but00:29:32
since he hotly shot wines 500, then00:29:36
he was a traitor, he was demoted in00:29:38
rank, his command decided,00:29:40
look, he’s some kind of loudmouth,00:29:42
poorly educated, who mainly00:29:45
relies on a certain revolutionary00:29:47
consciousness is00:29:48
also being mocked by the ugly hero, it’s00:29:51
clear that he’s more intelligent, after all, the00:29:54
son of a priest worked as a photographer, he’s00:29:57
educated, he00:29:58
even speaks as intelligent, unlike the00:30:00
same to the river, he directly speaks00:30:04
about whether he shot or00:30:07
not, he immediately doubts yes you probably00:30:09
you weren’t the one who shot him in vain and00:30:11
he’s just talking about Nikolka’s eyes,00:30:15
Nikolka’s eyes are too squinty, one problem is that00:30:18
the loan is in the wrong place, but it’s cool, he says there and00:30:20
there, I immediately have a conflict there is also00:30:24
a conflict about the fact that Nekrasov00:30:25
says Popova that you volunteered00:30:28
being a popovich, when you know00:30:31
that Lenin is actually a nobleman and they also00:30:33
show just such an00:30:35
uneducated, blue-legged Karyakin,00:30:37
then stop naledi talking about such things as a00:30:40
conflict, educated educated people, and00:30:43
these are essentially rednecks who are00:30:46
in command, but it is clear that all this00:30:47
lends itself to masks, but they are direct here they are visible00:30:50
and then there is this Karyakin, he00:30:54
pulls bulls, so it’s still a positive00:30:56
character, when I watched the00:30:57
film, despite all the questions, I00:30:59
watched it when I was little, it’s definitely a00:31:02
positive character, but at the same time,00:31:05
look there are several points by00:31:08
which we can say that this an00:31:09
illiterate person from whom everyone00:31:12
suffers because he is such an00:31:13
illiterate loudmouth and he suffers from him and00:31:16
his troops are ugly there later at the end, well,00:31:19
in fact, he expresses this expression,00:31:22
essentially with corpses, how he threw00:31:24
at the White Guards, but we will return to this, but00:31:27
not even that illiterate also00:31:29
dishonest, he seems to be for his00:31:32
comrade, and then he00:31:35
begins to speak out against him world of an00:31:37
episode very interesting but looking00:31:40
ahead, but by the way, when I00:31:41
watched very little, there were no questions,00:31:44
well, it still shows that Nekrasov but00:31:46
he did something wrong, well, maybe it’s not right, and by the00:31:49
way, he honestly said that I honestly00:31:51
didn’t bother that I was drying, but we’ll come back to this,00:31:54
we’ll come back to this, the accents are00:31:56
anti-Soviet, it’s definitely in general that they are given a00:31:59
task using an airplane, by the way,00:32:03
the airplane of the Forman system is formal new00:32:05
couple these were the most common00:32:07
aircraft of00:32:09
the Civil War, everything here is very well00:32:10
selected, the camera by the way is00:32:13
well selected, this is a de Brie camera, I’ll tear it up,00:32:16
most likely the model of D.N. but you know, it’s00:32:20
not true, what’s the matter is that I00:32:22
re-read a lot of documents while I was00:32:24
preparing, well, different ones, of course, on00:32:27
the Internet that I found about aero00:32:30
videography during the civil period of the First00:32:32
World War, to be honest, I did00:32:34
n’t find anything, moreover, when I studied00:32:37
aero videography during the Great00:32:39
Patriotic War,00:32:41
I found a lot during the first, but in particular00:32:44
there was a00:32:46
cinematographer, Theodore Buki Moi Vich, who00:32:58
spent one of the very first videos filming in a front-line situation in the late autumn of forty-one during the battle of Moscow, so he was there, he00:33:00
managed to film there literally 30 seconds,00:33:02
how00:33:04
inconvenient it was to film many of the layers, these are even00:33:07
more advanced cameras, after all, he was 4100:33:11
years old, by the way, he received an award for this, and00:33:13
here such high-quality shooting, well, at00:33:15
least00:33:17
they are given the task of filming and no one00:33:20
doubts whether it will work or not00:33:22
and00:33:23
indeed, the prototype of this kind of00:33:27
aerial photography was Nikolai00:33:29
Vasilchenko, who really00:33:30
did an avi reconnaissance of the dig, but what kind of00:33:34
aeroflot reconnaissance he did, it was00:33:37
by the way, if you remember our video00:33:39
dedicated to military topography during the00:33:42
Civil War, I think there will be00:33:44
a link here, we are just right We’re talking about00:33:46
aerial photography in detail enough,00:33:48
but aero video filming in that00:33:51
period is unlikely, so such a task is00:33:54
somewhat strange and the country that the chief of staff,00:33:56
okay, Papanov, he’s really still00:33:59
there, like our filming, the arrival of Poincaré in00:34:02
Algeria,00:34:03
art, but as if00:34:06
the chief of staff, well, obviously he should have00:34:09
known that aero video filming was then00:34:11
practically impossible, it was00:34:13
unlike aerial photography, and this is precisely00:34:16
to confirm not from the myth that they did00:34:19
everything in defiance of the command, the command00:34:21
ordered it was littered with corpses, and so on and so00:34:24
forth, and so unfortunate Nekrasov,00:34:27
contrary to logic, contrary to technical00:34:30
development, was able to do more there is a suburb with a00:34:33
detachment of 1 it turns out to be a gondola of this00:34:37
very plane because it’s just the00:34:40
hero of the bull to get you talking no wallpaper00:34:42
we’ll fly all of me and he’s not just to the whites and00:34:46
the odometer won’t let him go, well, that is,00:34:48
it’s clear that he’s not so much his comrades,00:34:50
although he’s there he says, well, for the sake of conversation,00:34:53
but first of all, he is in the countryside,00:34:56
by the way, a zagato detachment in the person of one00:34:58
person, so by the way, it’s no wonder00:35:01
why they Nekrasov, or rather, didn’t try to00:35:03
at least literally shoot something for a few seconds there00:35:06
to see why he00:35:08
immediately just takes this device and flies00:35:11
with him, well, nevertheless, they fly over the00:35:14
enemy’s positions, they shoot at them, the00:35:19
nekras tries to shoot, but then they00:35:21
find out that they can’t and00:35:23
ultimately their plane is shot down; it00:35:26
falls somewhere in the reeds, well, on Soviet00:35:30
territory, that is, not on the territory00:35:31
occupied by the Whites, but the territory is occupied by the00:35:33
Reds and well, how do they think that the00:35:35
Reds and at this interesting moment, also00:35:38
completely anti-historical, they fall00:35:41
into the hands of00:35:43
free rebels, well, then Karyakin00:35:46
says so and they would have said that the Makhnovists00:35:47
who sentenced them to execution are00:35:50
logically they are flying from the white00:35:52
territory and They00:35:55
don’t have any documents to the point, and they confirm that they are00:35:57
Makhnovists and there is a conversation going on: we’re friends, we’re not00:36:01
friends, we’ll see about that later, although this is00:36:04
complete nonsense, because then, of00:36:06
course, Makhno, by the way, we talked about this00:36:08
in the first review of the film Not Lime’s The00:36:11
Avengers So, yes,00:36:14
the Makhnovists, yes, during the twentieth00:36:16
year they were either for the Red Army or against them,00:36:20
but at this moment00:36:21
Makhno units are specifically taking part00:36:24
in preparing the assault on the Crimea, and this is precisely the00:36:27
digging area, all the scenes of action00:36:30
are clear that these Makhnovists know perfectly well00:36:32
that the Red Army is theirs allies and here00:36:36
the dialogue begins, you sold00:36:40
your revolution to Russia, well, we sold it,00:36:43
and to whomever needed it, we sold it, by00:36:45
the way, the characters are cool, all00:36:47
these Makhnovists there, they are not very00:36:49
well written, the actors00:36:51
play well, the staging is gorgeous, they00:36:54
are sentenced to execution, but they manage to00:36:57
escape and here, look, they escaped from the Makhnovists00:37:00
to get to where the00:37:03
subras trefl is already red and here and without00:37:07
the way, note this is the stomach prototype of00:37:09
modern films about the Great00:37:11
Patriotic War where is this stamp you escaped from the Germans00:37:14
and somewhere there was against the wall00:37:16
listening to him but when I watched this,00:37:19
Commissar Scheele, I don’t know the end of twill,00:37:22
Commissar music, I laughed, the thought occurred to me that00:37:25
these two00:37:28
comrades served in a certain00:37:29
penal battalion on minimum wages, well, actually, yes,00:37:34
because she immediately starts to get hysterical, of00:37:37
course, she’s not as beautiful as the films in the00:37:40
style the Mikhalkovs without these screams is an00:37:43
omission, well, even then they haven’t learned how to00:37:46
make a proper movie where everyone screams so much00:37:48
that it’s behind the ears and she doesn’t need to be00:37:51
hysterical, she says to talk a lot and and00:37:53
all this right here, it just cuts off00:37:57
everything, we start to have such an image of just the same00:38:00
countrymen on who is hanged as usual,00:38:02
this red terror after the00:38:05
liberation of the Crimea, we will not00:38:07
take this character historically completely,00:38:10
but the image is that this is probably a separate00:38:13
topic dedicated and the civilian is not in the Crimea,00:38:15
but the image is so obvious, such a00:38:18
hysterical one, especially who does not scream at00:38:20
which how did she do this from a nekrasu I00:38:23
recognized you, you are a White Guard who tortured me,00:38:26
that is, something is clearly wrong with her head,00:38:28
the only one is then she00:38:31
heroically dies during the storming of a dig00:38:33
and then it seems like she is being filmed with us, which is00:38:35
usually shown if there is a00:38:38
representative state security organs00:38:40
or the party, then he is a bastard or a psychopath, but00:38:44
when there is some kind of battle, he is somewhere00:38:46
far away in this regard, I remember00:38:49
what fierce indignation there was about the00:38:52
images of the NKVD in the Belarusian film00:38:55
Brest Fortress renders the zinc00:38:57
sinner not just catching spies there, he00:38:59
actually has them they catch a saboteur, he also00:39:02
dies in battle, what is this, what kind of00:39:04
historical injustice,00:39:05
especially in the film Brest Fortress - the hero of00:39:09
Pavel Derevianko, in the end he00:39:13
admits that he is not just a commissar to a00:39:15
Jew, Jews,00:39:17
but it is a joy to go to be shot, this00:39:19
was by the way, historical truth,00:39:21
well here, at least as shown, to00:39:24
brush off the first from the whites, they fled,00:39:27
almost killed, waved, almost killed, and00:39:30
it’s like they’re our own, but they’re not our own,00:39:32
like a mountain, they came here to shoot, here00:39:36
they came to shoot the skinny peasant00:39:38
to give in, and now they’re being put up against the wall, just a00:39:42
private by chance00:39:44
the chief of staff was passing by and just what are you doing here,00:39:46
they’re shooting us, notice00:39:49
the wording, what is the wording of the chief of staff, the00:39:51
representative of the Red command,00:39:53
the execution00:39:55
is postponed is not canceled postponed00:39:58
well, you see how many of these00:40:00
details there are, this is actually anti-Soviet and00:40:02
by the way there are just Latvian riflemen we00:40:05
not against the type00:40:07
go away okay over anyway they get to00:40:11
the headquarters then it turns out that Nekrasov did00:40:13
n’t film anything and it’s so interesting for him00:40:16
when he wanted to film the positions00:40:19
he didn’t succeed, but when he didn’t00:40:21
want to he pretended to have this camera that supposedly00:40:24
it’s some kind of hellish when a machine00:40:26
wave can put everyone down, remember, yes, and00:40:28
it turns out that the Makhnovists00:40:31
laughed, like they’re not00:40:33
educated at all, but this is this beloved headquarters00:40:36
that the Makhnovists were not only that, since00:40:39
Kristan and the taxi is not prepared at all, it’s00:40:41
not a Red Army soldier at all, disheveled00:40:44
to look, but to wave is just a cross and00:40:46
still in the cube, how did he, how did they manage00:40:48
to be white, these are all of them more than once of Christ,00:40:51
also in spite of, but this is this Makhnovist,00:40:54
in spite of this, it’s a little different, but they are00:40:56
genre artists, and they don’t recognize00:40:58
military laws, so I win, as well as00:41:01
physical laws, we know this, the laws of00:41:03
time, namely We recommend reconsidering00:41:06
the review, but not the film, of course, Bender started00:41:10
there in huge quantities of these time movements,00:41:12
yes, but it turns out that they00:41:15
kind of failed the task, and here00:41:18
Bykov’s hero shows his rotten00:41:22
insides, in fact, what’s rotten, here I was00:41:23
little, watching, that is, a person with00:41:26
such absolutely where and it’s a matter of Giza Ravan’s00:41:28
consciousness, but in the sense that I00:41:29
simply didn’t have him yet and that he failed while you were00:41:32
going on a mission, but00:41:35
I have doubts that I know this person for00:41:37
how long, two or three days they’ve known each other,00:41:40
how do I know it will be possible and he00:41:41
really specially assigned the task,00:41:44
who knows, he says directly and I understood that00:41:46
someone and Popovich and also his dads are so00:41:49
chilling that you got excited about all00:41:52
sorts of things, but then find out that Nekrasov is00:41:55
honestly a Red Army soldier because he,00:41:57
having a phenomenal memory, is00:41:59
an accident, by the way, a piano in the bushes,00:42:02
or God from the machine in this case00:42:05
God from Nekrasov’s head who helps00:42:07
him00:42:09
sketch out the positions which00:42:12
some random coincidence00:42:14
is confirmed by reports from the00:42:17
census takers and it turns out that Nekrasov00:42:19
actually confirmed the intelligence data00:42:22
and it is possible to storm these positions, but00:42:25
again the person who00:42:27
was able to carefully watches this film, they find out that00:42:29
this data, in fact, Nekrasov did00:42:32
not help in any way because the positions were00:42:35
taken away from the front and a huge bunch of00:42:38
people were killed, it is clear in the film, it turns out that it00:42:40
is like an attentive viewer, especially00:42:43
one who was initially anti-Soviet,00:42:45
all this was in vain, the pilot died in vain00:42:48
they went through all the00:42:50
adventures there because they still drove them00:42:52
head-on, by the way, there was also a stamp from the Red00:42:55
Army, they only attacked in the head, both00:42:57
civilian and the Great Patriotic War, we’ll00:42:59
get to that yet, it’s not a sin here, it’s00:43:03
a little bit wrong, in my opinion,00:43:05
they went through sivash, that is, they were00:43:08
initially like Nissans through sivash and00:43:10
through outbid, they also00:43:12
stormed, and they stormed from the00:43:14
point of view that it was necessary to distract the whites00:43:17
from sivash, this film is said00:43:20
well, it would be good, but at least it remains outside the00:43:23
brackets like this since this is the00:43:25
attitude, but nevertheless, Nekrasov is00:43:28
really his example, in my opinion it’s a00:43:30
Mauser, if I don’t confuse anything, and he’s00:43:34
happy and it turns out, by the way, there’s such a00:43:36
touching scene when they00:43:39
help the legless commander get00:43:41
on his horse, well, Katya, I didn’t find such a00:43:45
prototype, well I think that probably there00:43:47
were such disabled people who fought, people were00:43:51
highly motivated in that civil00:43:53
war, very many after that Nekrasov00:43:57
looks at the00:43:59
award weapons of the00:44:01
bulls, he says, let me see, yes, go, well, and the00:44:03
hero of Bykov begins to explain00:44:06
why he did this, I didn’t00:44:08
start shu shu shu I told you to your face00:44:10
now I admit my mistake, this is such a00:44:13
person, but from the point of view of psychology, everything is00:44:16
explainable from the point of view of war, everything is00:44:18
explainable, well, the man was mistaken, he directly00:44:20
said that I, well, lost my temper, was wrong,00:44:23
but how it’s all presented, that’s how he’s like00:44:26
the fool says, too, a stroke so00:44:29
characteristic enough that it will show,00:44:32
look at these loudmouths and these00:44:34
loudmouths then stamped things in00:44:36
the thirties and forties like the screenwriters and I,00:44:40
and by the way, we digressed a little from00:44:43
more precisely, we didn’t tell you anything00:44:45
about the second line of this film, because the lines are on the00:44:48
2nd floor civilian film they are00:44:50
a collision of two worlds00:44:52
about the red world we talked about the Soviet00:44:55
now gaps so exactly about this00:44:58
very00:44:59
lieutenant gave a turn to Brusentsov by the way about00:45:03
Brusentsov you’re actually not just00:45:05
such a surname taken from somewhere from the ceiling00:45:08
you want to say that there was something real00:45:09
prototype not I’m talking about this when00:45:13
these heroes of ours were sitting in the gulag, in my opinion, the00:45:15
mint had a friend there, a former officer of the00:45:19
Soviet army as the Red Army,00:45:21
who was imprisoned, I don’t know why they became00:45:24
friends, and then fate separated them,00:45:26
this Brusentsov Brusentsov, his name,00:45:28
disappeared somewhere and just with this00:45:31
film it was such a signal from the Brusents,00:45:33
where did you respond to such a roll call,00:45:36
kind of wow, that is, they00:45:39
used the whole February to00:45:42
find a person in this way, well, they00:45:44
used it to get money to00:45:46
push their own ideology,00:45:49
they used naturally bypassing all00:45:51
possible00:45:53
By the way, you bypassed the censorship institution,00:45:56
but also for this, for personal00:45:58
purposes, this is it, but this is me, again, mensa00:46:01
memories, that is,00:46:03
there is real confirmation of all this, this fact,00:46:06
yes, well, at least this is the statement of the00:46:07
screenwriter himself on this subject, Brusentsev,00:46:11
what is this for the brilliant white officer,00:46:14
by the way, it’s also interesting that the Reds are00:46:16
preparing for the invasion of Crimea and, in00:46:18
principle, they are in the mood for the flight, you remember, it’s00:46:20
quite optimistic, well, it’s difficult, but00:46:23
we don’t know him, but we’ll take it, but what about the00:46:26
Whites and the Whites, some hotel in Paris00:46:29
Sevastopol huddled together these00:46:32
leaves, like the wind blown by the wind, all these00:46:34
representatives of old Russia don’t discuss00:46:38
how bad everything is, some quartermaster is cooking00:46:40
40,000 tunics, where will I get them? I do00:46:44
n’t have family diamonds, something like that,00:46:46
he says, everyone complains about their fate and someone00:46:49
passes by them - a drunken00:46:51
young officer who climbs with a lighter00:46:55
in my pistol shape just into00:46:58
Brusentsov’s room in which he sleeps in the00:47:00
same bed with a prostitute00:47:02
wanted to00:47:03
joke Brusentsov, who has a00:47:06
pistol under his pillow, by the way, an astra pistol, a00:47:09
Spanish pistol, the pistol00:47:12
was first produced in the twenty-second year, too00:47:15
that is, also astral00:47:17
time travel, that is, how did you get it, but00:47:20
okay, the twins are killed by this young00:47:23
officer,00:47:24
Brusentsov is arrested, naturally00:47:26
some kind of investigation begins, it’s clear, and00:47:30
in the room there is a certain nurse00:47:32
Sasha, who is played by a wonderful00:47:34
Soviet actress and who00:47:38
Brusentsova themselves begins to express It’s00:47:40
because of people like you that the00:47:41
white movement is dying, although I’m a participant, why did00:47:44
this happen? I slept with a prostitute00:47:46
and therefore the white00:47:49
movement died or shot some fool00:47:51
who bursts into a dark room00:47:53
shouting his hands up and with a pistol in his hand,00:47:55
I want this logic, no caught it00:47:58
by the way, throwing it doesn’t catch it either and it00:48:01
starts to burn God, look at00:48:03
you, there’s a dead man lying there for you to cry for00:48:05
him, what are you talking about in a month, not00:48:08
me, not you, no one will be here, how is he00:48:10
there, by the way, he’s looking00:48:12
at things sensibly in a month all the generals and00:48:15
colonels will be janitors and all the ladies00:48:17
on the panel to those present, this of course does00:48:20
not apply, that is,00:48:22
enough people can get such a network of education, but00:48:25
the image of Vysotsky is clear what a00:48:28
hardened officer he is, a front-line soldier00:48:30
who is used to saying everything to his face00:48:32
when, due to the fact that he00:48:35
they take away his abrek horse with which he00:48:38
went through the entire First World War, he00:48:40
raises his voice at the boss from his00:48:43
warm body, sends him straight to the dig, and00:48:45
at the dig he naturally00:48:48
comes with a professional and starts00:48:50
talking, here we are sitting here and the red00:48:52
means they can pass through the Sivash, go00:48:55
rest, lieutenant cool bet here with the00:48:58
businessman, when I watched this moment of the00:49:01
lieutenant’s conversation and 2, unfortunately I don’t00:49:04
remember the novel by the colonel, this colonel,00:49:07
yes, I look at their uniform and I00:49:11
laugh, I see that this is a Soviet uniform00:49:15
on them, having given it from the times of the Great00:49:18
Patriotic War, that is, certain00:49:20
collars are definitely buttons, but that is,00:49:24
in this regard, they didn’t do any work at all, didn’t00:49:28
bend a little, embellished them, made them00:49:30
look like00:49:32
yes, I’ll tell you more, if Brusentsov, then00:49:35
he obviously should have come on00:49:36
secondment, dressed, no, here’s00:49:39
the colonel, he should have been there00:49:42
Kornilov consisted of carneys narrow regiments regiment00:49:45
more precisely, the uniform should be black,00:49:47
well, in any case, they had a uniform like this,00:49:49
sitting here in a field uniform,00:49:52
okay, okay, let’s assume these are little things,00:49:55
well, I like the other thing better, that00:49:58
of course he lets you send this colonel,00:50:00
Napoleon the essay knows everything perfectly well,00:50:04
but you just in case a case in00:50:07
Sevastopol, the light is transmitted by phone to00:50:09
someone in my opinion, according to my ensign,00:50:12
if I’m not mistaken, and just the same,00:50:14
Sivash is pointing these searchlights, the00:50:16
searchlights were of course they were00:50:18
used mainly as00:50:20
anti-aircraft weapons to00:50:23
detect a balloon or an airplane there, but00:50:26
they could have been used in order to see who is00:50:29
approaching and just at the very00:50:32
last moment the spotlight illuminates the00:50:34
Reds who are already right on the bank00:50:37
of this Sivash, here again we need to00:50:40
make an insert of how the Reds crossed with what00:50:43
faces they didn’t cross, we’ll come back,00:50:46
what are we talking about about the whip, well,00:50:49
in general of course00:50:51
they didn’t cross, he won’t say that they were walking through00:50:54
icy water, although the water was of course, to put it00:50:56
mildly, cold,00:50:58
what’s interesting is that they didn’t walk on water all the time,00:51:01
most often they walked through places00:51:04
where you can cross knee-deep to waist-deep00:51:07
why because that’s exactly what00:51:10
I’m planning the operation and They understand perfectly well00:51:12
that it will be difficult and suicidal to storm these well-00:51:14
fortified positions head-on on the Turkish Luna00:51:16
dig,00:51:18
although it will still be necessary just to00:51:21
pin down the enemy troops, it00:51:24
was necessary to undertake some kind of roundabout maneuver,00:51:25
and just like yours in the00:51:28
rotten sea, so-called rotten00:51:31
because at00:51:35
certain times of the year it00:51:38
turns into what kind of semi-swamp they00:51:40
found a local peasant who00:51:43
knew very well the ways in just in00:51:46
November through this force and he led the00:51:49
red units right to00:51:52
that same Lithuanian peninsula and00:51:54
now The most interesting thing is that during the00:51:56
Great Patriotic War,00:51:57
the same peasant already led parts of the00:52:01
Red Army in April of forty-four00:52:04
during the liberation of the Crimea in almost the00:52:07
same places, and by the way, it’s00:52:10
interesting that the assault on the Crimea and the first assault on the00:52:13
Crimea by the Germans in the forty-first year stormed00:52:17
and00:52:18
took her liberation of the Crimea in00:52:20
the year forty-four, everything is repeated when00:52:22
this outbid is taken further, the troops00:52:25
starting from rolling back and the Soviet00:52:27
troops from rolling back to Sevastopol and the00:52:29
German troops in the year forty-four00:52:30
rolled back to Sevastopol, Sevastopol is the00:52:33
last such last line of00:52:35
defense of Sevastopol surrounding the00:52:37
area, so it all repeated three00:52:39
times, this is what happened in the twentieth00:52:41
year, it was repeated two more times in00:52:44
history, the military, as a result of the battle,00:52:48
takes the White fortification on the Lithuanian peninsula, and the battle scene itself is00:52:52
shown very cinematically, that00:52:54
is, here is the scene when the camera from below00:52:57
looks at the hero Bykov who is running,00:53:02
jumping over, respectively some00:53:05
heaps of00:53:06
fortifications there are barbed wire, rows of00:53:09
barbed wire as he runs over the corpse00:53:11
that is hanging on this barbed wire, well,00:53:13
you know, the00:53:15
red one drives his troops straight onto the00:53:18
barbed wire or they get entangled there, they are00:53:20
shot, they don’t know how to00:53:23
lead and command in any way,00:53:25
you know, that’s all. the battles for Lithuania00:53:28
are a factor of surprise; they haven’t yet had time to00:53:31
cut the wire, it’s good to go on the attack,00:53:34
but this is all repeated in00:53:36
the scene with the digging that the red one is driving00:53:39
people onto this barbed wire, and what’s00:53:41
interesting is how they00:53:44
throw00:53:46
some special ladders over this barbed wire00:53:49
but this is complete nonsense because00:53:51
during the assault specifically on the outbid there were00:53:54
special teams with wire cutters who00:53:57
just cut through this wire00:53:59
and it was nothing00:54:01
extraordinary, it was a common00:54:03
tactic of the First World War when the00:54:05
troops went on the attack and when they had no00:54:08
there are enough artillery pieces so that00:54:10
first of all what they used it for was to00:54:12
break this wire, if there00:54:14
were no special teams of sappers00:54:17
who cut through this wire and00:54:20
here and there some homemade means,00:54:22
almost corpses to each other on the railing00:54:24
I throw over this barbed wire00:54:26
but also such a residue seems to have remained,00:54:29
perhaps overlooked by the military00:54:31
historian who advised the film, but it is00:54:35
also shown as very rude that the00:54:38
Reds don’t know how to fight at all, daurada00:54:40
of enthusiasm go on the attack,00:54:42
nevertheless, by the way, they meet00:54:46
just in the trench, now it’s Bykov’s hero, and the00:54:50
commander meets Nekrasov gives him00:54:52
the task back, which means through the icy00:54:54
sivash reports that00:54:58
reinforcements are needed, which then comes00:55:00
in the form of cavalry, by the way, a very beautiful00:55:02
scene when a cavalryman appears and00:55:05
begins to play the trumpet of the offensive and the00:55:07
bulls where where and our red cavalry is00:55:10
just driving the whites but at the same time00:55:12
at perekop what is happening where by the way the00:55:15
Nekrasovs are taking part in the assault it is00:55:17
shown fundamentally correct there were00:55:20
two assaults the first assault was unsuccessful00:55:23
for the red army 40 to 50 percent of the00:55:27
personnel were killed because well such a00:55:30
perekop is a bottleneck00:55:33
very well fortified there even the00:55:36
trenches of the whites were concreted they were helped by00:55:39
French engineers and although there were00:55:41
few whites, well, I have data, of course they are00:55:43
very approximate. 10,00000:55:46
reds advanced against about three00:55:49
thousand whites who were located in00:55:52
these fortifications, but the whites had00:55:54
machine guns and artillery pieces,00:55:57
they again adapted well to the terrain, the00:55:59
fortifications were and00:56:02
just 50 percent of losses and this is quite00:56:03
understandable considering that the Reds did not have so00:56:05
many artillery pieces00:56:08
because when in 194400:56:09
when the Germans even more fortified that00:56:12
same dig there was an offensive there it was00:56:14
all just grinding then how00:56:17
many artillery pieces were there there, in00:56:19
my opinion, if I’m not mistaken, there were either 50 or 6000:56:22
artillery pieces per 30000:56:25
square meters, that is, everything was00:56:26
plowed up there, and therefore it’s understandable why00:56:28
the digging was not taken with such heavy00:56:30
losses, it’s still an attack on a00:56:32
well-fortified area, which00:56:35
was absolutely impossible by the00:56:37
way, there was a Kornilov00:56:40
regiment there, it was a floor that was very00:56:42
motivated there, as by the way,00:56:44
Papanov’s hero says at the beginning of the film,00:56:46
shoulder straps on the water, that is, there are almost purely00:56:48
officer units, and by the way,00:56:51
here is the scene when a lot of00:56:54
Reds died during the attack, it is00:56:56
fundamentally this correct, but how it is00:56:59
shown how it is shown that these are some00:57:01
someone is carrying some kind of [ __ ]00:57:02
of brushwood, someone saw carrying00:57:05
some of these here on a00:57:07
ladder to throw them over00:57:09
the wire, but this, of course, does not00:57:12
relate to historical truth00:57:15
because there were detachments that were just supposed to00:57:17
cut the wire; there were detachments00:57:19
that were supposed to protect the area;00:57:21
well, it didn’t work out; this was the first attack, but the00:57:24
second one worked; they fed; the00:57:28
commander and the Shuya fortifications began to retreat;00:57:36
so on, what00:57:38
is shown in the film, and during the capture of Shunia,00:57:41
two armies meet somehow: 1 which is00:57:44
advancing Sivash of the Lithuanian peninsula,00:57:47
the other which is coming from a00:57:48
digging site, and now Sivash is marching a detachment under the00:57:52
leadership of whoever Nekrasov is coming here,00:57:55
they meet full in some kind of00:57:57
dugout or in a trench and here I am, here you are,00:57:59
my dear friend, you’re so kind, what an00:58:02
interesting scene, the hero Bykova says, and00:58:05
I’ll probably be with you again00:58:07
because my squad was killed here, too, you00:58:10
can do it in two ways, this was a cunning bypass of censorship on the00:58:13
part of the scriptwriters, on the one00:58:14
hand,00:58:15
it’s like if it had been done, well, look,00:58:19
they died heroically, it was very00:58:21
fierce battles, but on the other hand, under the00:58:24
leadership of this, Vanka Karyakin and00:58:26
it’s not surprising that they put the bourgeoisie down;00:58:39
the world didn’t hear such a thing for this,00:58:42
but if he carried the cartridges, he didn’t finish, didn’t00:58:45
hear, well, my family knows him00:58:47
very well, a film that they also wrote a script for,00:58:49
it’s a film like, say, a00:58:51
production drama about a00:58:54
person who is looking for himself in some00:58:57
team, that’s not what we’re talking about there would be heroes00:58:59
who he plays a cameo role in00:59:01
general the situation is such that the main character did00:59:03
not fulfill something something is not accepted your I do00:59:06
n’t even remember that the hero is Bykov and if00:59:08
I had no cartridges, well, that is, stupidity00:59:12
Kailash would be a person here or he00:59:14
didn’t bring pasta or potatoes, but what if00:59:17
he had carried a cartridge? This is a spit00:59:19
about where there is and a spit about the fact00:59:22
that in relation to say that00:59:24
every person in his place is00:59:27
actually like in battle because building00:59:29
socialism is a dove 100 what if he00:59:31
was carrying cartridges and here are the bulls here, too, the00:59:35
same image playing such a loudmouth who00:59:37
also kills his people, also such a00:59:40
peculiar00:59:41
moment, by the way, Nekrasov is also a man00:59:45
who is smart to understand that there00:59:47
will be prisons later for someone, he is a fool it’s00:59:49
not he who thinks that he will abolish prisons00:59:51
except for one where we all00:59:52
put counter-revolutionaries in prison there will be prisons00:59:55
some joyless person is also00:59:57
humane because they are meeting with01:00:00
Bruce Sentsov he is together with the baron01:00:01
somewhere like a show to the cucumber he goes he01:00:03
goes and he01:00:05
wants bulls he should be shot Nekrasov,01:00:08
it may be his own, look, he looks like an01:00:10
officer will leave, he holds his hand as if he were holding a01:00:13
saber prisma pack, they explained and left, that is,01:00:16
he is still Nekrasov, such a humane01:00:18
Brusentsov, then he is not humane, he is01:00:21
hiding with the baron in some kind of beam,01:00:24
the baron has a01:00:26
rifle with an optical sight from the 30s,01:00:29
this is also a complete anachronism,01:00:32
the Brazilians ask why you need the01:00:35
last cartridge, it burns especially to shoot yourself, a01:00:37
good joke, an optical sight, why01:00:40
not miss, funny, he has a better bullet for01:00:43
you, the Baron of the Reds will find a better one,01:00:45
let’s use it in the business and begin to01:00:49
join in by zhanna for shooting, the baron is on fire01:00:50
and don’t don’t need no need Brusentsov01:00:54
takes aim at a random Red Army soldier01:00:57
who turns out to be01:00:58
Nekrasov who shoots hits him on the back01:01:01
Nekrasov settles on the01:01:03
floor of the bulls begins to shoot in the direction01:01:07
where the shot came from the baron by the way01:01:09
Brusentsov set up the baron for the baron01:01:11
kills himself he manages to escape01:01:14
into this is the time, by the way, that same01:01:16
colonel is pressed to the shore, married on01:01:19
the to a beautiful cinematic scene of01:01:21
how they go into the sea, these white01:01:24
white unfinished ones, that there is no land01:01:27
here, cinematically beautiful, and01:01:29
at this time Brusentsov01:01:32
is running like everyone else in Sevastopol, the01:01:35
last steamers are already leaving there shows01:01:38
once again his essence of such an01:01:41
alpha male, as they would say, who01:01:43
forces you to01:01:45
crown him at gunpoint quickly, otherwise I will kill you in01:01:48
God's temple, Vysotsky plays great, they01:01:50
are going to take this Sasha with them, Sasha does01:01:53
n’t want to go anywhere, she’s watching that chips on TV,01:01:56
semi-crazy people they are storming01:01:58
just these01:01:59
suitable steamships, everything is shown in general01:02:03
quite truthfully, there were such cases01:02:05
especially in Yalta in Alushta when the01:02:07
last steamships were leaving and after them they fired01:02:10
from cannons, they fired, well, the01:02:13
last scene seems like it01:02:14
should be a pity for this lieutenant because the abrek is not01:02:16
allowed in an abrek swims after him and he01:02:20
shoots himself under us, we should play01:02:23
this anti-Soviet hit of the 90s and soul01:02:26
ii soul that you abandoned the horse, I don’t know, in01:02:29
general, the heroes die and here is also the image of01:02:31
such an honest white officer, although according to01:02:35
the plot he is a01:02:36
bad person, this bar of Germans is very01:02:39
bad rude01:02:41
not not to look for what is ideological but nevertheless01:02:45
but let's think carefully respond to01:02:47
the film what he did positively well and01:02:50
except if we analyze the moment that01:02:53
he suggested that the Reds01:02:55
could pass through Sivash and we will deliver this is a question of a01:02:58
good or bad deed he is simply a01:03:01
professional professional Yes, well, what01:03:03
good did he do throughout the01:03:06
entire film, he01:03:08
violated the chain of command, was01:03:11
rude to higher ranks, was rude01:03:14
to prostitutes, slept, I01:03:17
can’t do anything positive, no, well,01:03:20
he fell in love with this Sasha, again, I also don’t01:03:24
understand that she found a lot of us, that this01:03:26
guy is so good, so strong01:03:28
who knows how to suppress him, he also01:03:30
suppressed him in the end, although not01:03:32
completely, she left him for him anyway,01:03:34
it turns out on this pier, that is, the01:03:36
actor of the Vysotsky high-rise just plays01:03:40
beautifully that he seems to evoke01:03:42
sympathy, but in fact he did01:03:44
nothing good for the film and let’s take01:03:47
Nekrasov’s hero Yankovsky, he seems to be01:03:52
more of a source of regret,01:03:55
but let’s see what01:03:57
good he did in the film, firstly, he is01:04:00
clearly educated and intelligent and01:04:03
really serves the cause of the revolution01:04:05
because, in addition to01:04:07
fulfilling his duty, I remember he01:04:09
also films Red Army soldiers also01:04:13
one of the lines of the film to capture my01:04:15
personality is a photographer, that is, he is an ideological01:04:19
person and in fact, all he01:04:21
does is he heroically fights01:04:24
heroically performs tasks, well, the hero is01:04:27
his partner Karyakin, of course, but we01:04:31
talked that this was specially introduced to him by the01:04:33
foulbrood specially specially then01:04:36
he told that and the hero would have been01:04:39
more positive, he also did a lot of01:04:41
good, you know, since the film was shot01:04:43
for thin councils where the intellectuals were sitting,01:04:46
many of these intellectuals remembered how01:04:50
they were set on the01:04:52
path of truth by such commissars when it means they talked about what01:04:54
they wrote about, I sometimes01:04:57
read when a memory of our01:04:59
creative intelligentsia, how they01:05:01
behaved in the thirties, when there was01:05:05
such a writer Fedin, when he was entrusted by01:05:07
Alexey Tolstoy, Alexei Tolstoy, this is a01:05:10
classic, in fact, he was entrusted with what UN report,01:05:12
well, it’s really on fire, and the smart guy, [ __ ] off,01:05:15
even in the expression jackpot, I’ll do it,01:05:18
that is I’m a01:05:19
creator, you all owe me some kind of01:05:22
commissar to appear here, so what did you01:05:23
write here, no change it, it’s clear that this01:05:26
is some kind of disgust and it01:05:29
was necessary to show that these01:05:30
commissars are people’s people and01:05:33
some kind of foulbrood It’s01:05:36
just that Bykov’s heroes invested this rotten thing,01:05:38
but again, when I01:05:40
watched it, he did01:05:43
n’t give me any negative emotions at all to01:05:45
the tanker, crying, fighting, fighting, saying something, something,01:05:48
something he wants, he says, he doesn’t01:05:51
hide, he’s honestly open while Brusentsov01:05:54
and the whole White Guard Wrangel's army01:05:57
drop towards the steamer01:05:59
departing at that time Nekrasov when he was01:06:05
also as quickly as possible the hero Bykov the01:06:08
whole hospital was still there with them the dialogue01:06:11
remember how they hijacked the Makhnovists01:06:14
it was silent and silent but he did not take him in the01:06:16
end Nekrasov died on the way and01:06:20
the last shots this is when01:06:23
Sevastopol has already been taken, the red troops come and01:06:26
are met by children who joyfully01:06:30
greet the liberator, and because01:06:33
by the way, when we spoke without a line about the01:06:35
review of the film again, elusive new01:06:38
adventures perceptible about the01:06:40
evangelical Crimea, what did01:06:42
Crimea imagine itself to be even through the eyes of a child01:06:45
when children go to school? there the dead01:06:47
are hanging with their tongues hanging out, what01:06:50
Crimea represented itself as and how the local01:06:51
population was robbed there, they say that we01:06:54
killed him, robbed him because he is not a01:06:56
Bolshevik,01:06:58
a Bolshevik, and okay, to hell with him, so01:07:01
it is clear that a significant part of Crimea01:07:03
met the Red Army as a liberator,01:07:06
no matter from such White Guard01:07:07
lawlessness, let's say it frankly, but by the way,01:07:10
they also sing a01:07:12
very strange song if they hurt you painfully01:07:15
separated from you, also illiterately say01:07:18
it would seem you were hurt painfully, what say01:07:20
their company commanders you give machine guns you give batteries01:07:24
that it was fun but also kind of01:07:26
strange the song is01:07:28
off topic, well, it’s kind of01:07:32
stupid, but nevertheless, here01:07:35
they are entering Sevastopol, where the01:07:37
Soviet government is already creating some kind of01:07:39
headquarters, they’re starting to01:07:43
establish some kind of peaceful life, and just the01:07:45
hero Bykov comes, handing over the film equipment,01:07:49
he tells about the fact that this song is a01:07:51
dachshund song that is constantly01:07:53
humming, a bullet flew by and a.a.01:07:56
and she keeps01:07:58
calling you, stop calling on you, she says, unfortunately, I01:08:00
died,01:08:01
and here, by the way, is the moment that I think01:08:04
the censorship was deliberately true wella, I have01:08:07
this feeling because the ending is01:08:09
just anti-Soviet, which01:08:12
they tested like this, they were honored, they were introduced, they01:08:14
introduced her neutralizes because01:08:17
there was still such an image, do you remember the orchestra01:08:21
that was such a team, they started and they did01:08:24
n’t know how to play, there was some old man,01:08:27
some kid who was always out of tune, so01:08:30
they start playing very01:08:32
poorly, they succeed in the end, you01:08:34
remember how well it was done, that’s it01:08:36
they just show these footage that01:08:39
supposedly this Nekrasov shot, those who died, he01:08:42
also filmed himself there, and just footage of those01:08:45
revolutionary years that was filmed by01:08:47
Red Army cameramen, so he01:08:50
shows them and the music is playing louder and01:08:52
louder and it plays as01:08:56
harmoniously as possible because everything is a01:08:59
victory and just the same and well, Soviet01:09:03
power was established, the sacrifices were not01:09:04
in vain,01:09:05
although you know the 80s, I came across01:09:08
several articles that just01:09:09
showed that yes, this ending,01:09:12
when these shots show it, it’s all01:09:14
very motivating, but this is exactly for the01:09:17
Soviet power, and the ending with the fact that01:09:20
this grief-stricken01:09:22
hero is standing on the pavement past01:09:27
him, they are transporting just the same cart where01:09:30
these tools lie, it was01:09:33
just said that that filter had to be01:09:35
finished because the whole revolution01:09:38
is over, the holiday is over now the01:09:41
harsh Stalin-Leninist everyday01:09:45
life is coming all the music is over no01:09:48
amateur performances now all is now the01:09:51
kingdom that’s how you remember we said in01:09:53
the video dedicated to the second congress01:09:56
of Soviets and decrees about peace like the Bolsheviks01:09:59
Arakcheev Schena in the labor movement01:10:02
is coming, that is, such a fig, then in01:10:04
the end it is also shown in this film by Zaka01:10:07
but still I I considered01:10:09
the ending, it evoked only positive01:10:12
emotions, the sacrifices were not in vain, the01:10:14
Brusents and all the rest, let’s say, the01:10:17
evil spirits were driven out, they won and managed to01:10:21
create a real state of01:10:23
workers and peasants, no matter how you01:10:25
treat it, the film ends here,01:10:27
but what about the mushroom, let’s briefly sum it up01:10:33
it’s difficult to summarize, but nevertheless, I01:10:36
need to say a few words, the film was not01:10:41
interesting to re-watch it,01:10:42
to work through and review it because01:10:45
films about the01:10:47
elusive on the network or the white sun of the01:10:49
desert, which is also the same, we also01:10:51
talked about such a rather controversial film,01:10:53
and films about the01:10:56
state border and we recently01:11:00
reviewed Lenin in October, these are different01:11:02
civilian films, although they01:11:04
were all filmed in the Soviet Union and each company01:11:07
should be studied as an interesting example of01:11:11
class struggle, well, if, again,01:11:15
a person understands that in any society01:11:18
except some primitive community01:11:21
there is a class struggle, she finds01:11:24
embodiment in all manifestations of01:11:27
human activity, including in01:11:29
culture, and each example is precisely the01:11:32
product of this culture, but still cinema01:11:36
is a synthetic art, so we can01:11:38
say the position on this, he wrote a01:11:40
poem, this is his position, the opposition of the01:11:43
censor which year, we all do not01:11:45
allow this it’s clear, but here, look,01:11:47
screenwriter, director, sound engineer,01:11:50
cameraman, and so on, a huge01:11:52
number of people create a synthetic01:11:54
product, and even in the conditions of Soviet01:11:56
society, all this had to be approved by a01:11:58
certain censorship commission, and01:12:01
at each stage there was also its own01:12:03
specific political struggle, and in01:12:06
such a sample of the Soviet art,01:12:08
we can do this very class01:12:10
struggle among cultural and01:12:13
artistic figures who occupied an01:12:15
exceptional place in Soviet society01:12:17
throughout its history, this01:12:19
was very interesting for me to see how it01:12:21
was built, who the people who wrote the01:12:25
script are, how they treated the Soviet01:12:27
regime, why and so on, well, not to01:12:29
put it mildly, and they didn’t like it, at least because they01:12:32
had to spend a significant part of01:12:34
their lives in camps, at01:12:37
least, and again, in relation to01:12:40
censorship, how for some reason they01:12:41
missed it for some reason01:12:43
by the way, I didn’t miss 6 from the eighth year01:12:46
another film with Vysotsky was supposed to be released on the screens,01:12:47
also an intervention that was directly clearly01:12:51
cut down and they said that this was generally an01:12:54
alien idea and simply wasted money from01:12:58
the state on the shooting of this film,01:12:59
it also has a certain01:13:02
artistic value,01:13:03
some points are unconditional I love it very much from there,01:13:05
but of course this film has a big01:13:09
anti-Soviet fig in its pocket, it’s not for nothing that they did01:13:11
n’t let it in, and here in this film I’m also01:13:13
watching and well, intuitively I feel it01:13:16
here, the censorship said to remove it, so01:13:18
Zura backed down here, here the01:13:22
censorship increased, here it is could, that is,01:13:25
again, in the conditions of the Soviet creative01:13:27
intelligentsia, there was just the same01:13:30
continuation, one might say, of the01:13:31
civil war that we are talking about01:13:34
and it was very interesting, just you know, there were01:13:37
its battles to observe them, dissect them, and01:13:40
I hope the listeners were also interested in01:13:42
everything with us this is to dissect and01:13:44
study the gleb and I want to say look01:13:47
how great we are, these figs in your01:13:49
pocket now apparently have an excellent01:13:51
class sense of what we want and all01:13:56
our listeners and viewers have a01:13:58
class 4 understand perfectly well these are01:14:01
our class interests but this is not01:14:04
quite but this is in general not our mailing list of01:14:06
interests and not only in art and01:14:08
culture but also in everyday life at01:14:10
every step01:14:14
[music]01:14:16
chop doesn’t work out okay01:14:22
here I’m slowing down and what is this simple well no no I01:14:27
like alone no but I think I’ll go back to01:14:31
what point01:14:32
well okay I’ll start and then you’ll01:14:35
look there, well, I’m looking for a good one, say, the01:14:38
seam is like a rock, okay, it’s funny to the point of pain,01:14:41
you’re more accurately hit by a bullet, then said01:14:45
the baron of steel,01:14:47
a reservation, okay,01:14:49
why didn’t you run away, it’s necessary to drop it doesn’t drop, it’s01:14:52
not very drop removed completely, let’s call it a day,01:14:56
we’ll wrap it up already at the end but okay01:14:59
yes everything is fine01:15:03
[music]01:15:09
[music]Description:
Служили два товарища - противоречивый фильм. В этом обзоре мы с Глебом Таргонским осветили замысел сценаристов, поговорили об игре актёров, разобрали исторический контекст. Новые видео появляются, благодаря вашей поддержке! Donationalerts: https://www.donationalerts.com/r/krasnoetv Карта Сбербанка: 4274320053142660 Яндекс.Деньги: 100115761035574 PayPal: paypal.me/krasnoetv2020 Webmoney: 158698007489 Для удобства платежа, настройте шаблон платежей в вашем онлайн банке, и помогайте проекту на постоянной основе. Аудиоверсия: https://files.krasnoe.tv/files/audio/CivilWar/Sluzhili_dva_tovarisha.mp3 Канал Революционная Инициатива: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCzrFjkzu4i10l48vstsgrnQ Мнения авторов не всегда совпадают с точкой зрения редакции. Мы в ВК: https://vk.com/ktv_ru Мы в ФБ: https://www.facebook.com/unsupportedbrowser
Preparing download options
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players
Questions about downloading video
How can I download "Служили два товарища. Фильмы о гражданской войне." video?
http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.
Which format of "Служили два товарища. Фильмы о гражданской войне." video should I choose?
The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.
Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Служили два товарища. Фильмы о гражданской войне." video?
The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.
How can I download "Служили два товарища. Фильмы о гражданской войне." video to my phone?
You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.
How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Служили два товарища. Фильмы о гражданской войне."?
The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.
How can I save a frame from a video "Служили два товарища. Фильмы о гражданской войне."?
This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.
What's the price of all this stuff?
It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.