Download "Статус. Екатерина Шульман* и Максим Курников / 19.12.2023 @Ekaterina_Schulmann"
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FkUQuvC9eQtY%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
Similar videos from our catalog
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252F38HH2S49Tf0%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F46G2I1tFJEs%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FIkNTXGoIXSg%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FNPrA-Dq8lYk%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FOi2gnQKQEeU%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F_mJKbN-jDQA%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FqR2PFH5vCQ0%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252Fv9vVCBFco0s%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252Fvcp5ZsK-NMY%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252Fyee8dEu_ZuI%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
Video tags
Subtitles
Russian
00:00:27
[music]00:00:58
at00:01:01
[music]00:01:28
and00:01:31
[music]00:01:38
on air Ekaterina Shulman's program00:01:44
status Hello on air program00:01:46
status and in the studio really00:01:48
Ekaterina Shulman Good evening00:01:50
Hello to Eva in person not via remote00:01:54
communication yes And this is among other channels00:01:57
Ekaterina Shulman's channel channel on Russian00:01:59
and the living nail channel That is, three channels00:02:02
Which means three possible likes Well, with us, as I00:02:06
understand it, today all the headings should00:02:08
be in place. Which means we’ll move on00:02:11
to the first00:02:12
heading, a few words about our own00:02:15
schedules but events Now now let’s00:02:18
say a couple words about that and everything about00:02:20
schedules, planting calendars, electoral00:02:23
and so on, we need to tell you00:02:24
a little about us too, we00:02:25
really are today. What a joy it is to be00:02:29
together from Berlin already next00:02:31
Tuesday we will be separated again but00:02:35
the status will come out in due time we00:02:37
will be online and then On January 2,00:02:41
we will miss one Tuesday, we will still give00:02:44
it a rest and the fountain will hope that the00:02:46
surrounding reality will somehow00:02:47
support us in this decision. Still,00:02:49
at least for one week we will be able not to00:02:52
carry out the status, but already on the 6th. But on January we00:02:55
will have a meeting here in Berlin, together with00:02:58
Armen Zakharyan, you and me as00:03:00
a moderator about 1000 one night about 100000:03:03
one night tickets there is a link in the description00:03:05
there, more than half have already been sold. So00:03:06
hurry up if you haven’t already and you know00:03:09
what else I’ll say and we’ll try to make sure00:03:12
that there will be a link too in the description00:03:14
so that you can watch it online00:03:17
via boost there in the description there are two00:03:20
ways how you can connect00:03:22
live to watch this very00:03:25
broadcast from Berlin Yes, but already on January 9,00:03:31
Tuesday, I hope that again in00:03:33
person in the studio we will resume our00:03:35
releases which are like We hope they will continue to00:03:38
go out throughout the coming00:03:40
year 2024, wherever we find ourselves during this year.00:03:42
So, returning to our00:03:46
events. And the first thing I would like to00:03:48
say is that there is indeed some00:03:51
innovation in our political legal00:03:54
practice, the inclusion of the writer Boris00:03:56
Akunin in the list of extremists and00:03:58
terrorists, it is00:04:00
simultaneously reported that a00:04:03
criminal case has been initiated against him under, as far as I00:04:04
understand, two articles of the Criminal Code,00:04:06
one of them is justification of terrorism and00:04:08
the other is the dissemination of false information00:04:10
about the armed forces of the Russian Federation,00:04:13
which means that this is a list of terrorists and00:04:15
extremists, and that’s what it’s called00:04:17
with I would say revolutionary A directness00:04:20
- this is a list that00:04:23
Rosfinmonitoring maintains, citizens are included there00:04:25
against whom00:04:28
criminal charges are initiated under articles of a terrorist00:04:31
or extremist nature,00:04:32
amazingly, it was this00:04:34
wonderful list that I spoke about at that00:04:36
only meeting of the Human Rights Council00:04:38
with the President at which I00:04:39
had the pleasure of attending, I00:04:41
then spoke about that that of the several00:04:43
hundred citizens included there, almost00:04:47
2/3 are, so to speak, persecuted for00:04:50
religious reasons of00:04:53
Jehovah's Witnesses, then the president promised to00:04:55
look into it, said that why are we00:04:56
persecuting them here, the nonsense that was sorted out00:04:59
became much much worse, so00:05:01
maybe it wasn’t even worth this topic and raise00:05:04
What is inclusion in the list, what does it00:05:05
mean, inclusion occurs As you can see,00:05:07
out of court, this is an initiative of00:05:09
Rosfinmonitoring, the consequences are00:05:11
that the person added to the list is blocked,00:05:13
all his accounts are blocked, he cannot use00:05:16
banking services on the territory of the00:05:18
Russian Federation, he cannot have00:05:19
access to his money, he can withdraw00:05:22
10,000 rubles in cash for each member of00:05:25
his family, including himself, and00:05:27
live luxuriously on this money, that is, this is00:05:29
really such a thing. I would say that00:05:31
disabled people have no measure. If you are00:05:33
inside Russia and if00:05:35
you actually live on some00:05:39
money. What this means in the case of Boris00:05:43
Akunin, it is important to make a distinction00:05:46
which, as I see, many do not make00:05:48
between this list of terrorist00:05:49
extremists where individuals are included and00:05:52
the list of extremist materials00:05:55
that Roskomnadzor maintains in the Lists of00:05:57
extremist materials, this is our00:05:59
kind of list of banned books as it00:06:01
once was from the Catholic Church, some texts are included in it00:06:04
by court decision,00:06:07
Roskomnadzor enters some texts and then00:06:11
their00:06:12
distribution is prohibited to the00:06:14
works of the writer Akunin or the00:06:16
writer Bykov or some00:06:17
other writer who are not included in00:06:20
this list this does not apply in any way00:06:22
maybe it will happen maybe we will see00:06:24
there Roman Azazel And what else is there Pelageya00:06:27
and the Black Monk recognized with these00:06:29
very extremist materials, so far00:06:31
this is not happening, which means for those who00:06:34
keep books at home buys them in a store00:06:37
buys them online reads gives them to00:06:40
a friend to read there is no legal threat00:06:42
yet concerns the threat of a00:06:48
potential threat for publishers and for00:06:50
sellers, so what could be the00:06:53
ambush, so to speak, the ambush could be00:06:55
the following means And if the author is00:07:00
convicted by the court as a terrorist or00:07:03
extremist, then the00:07:07
payment of royalties to him can be considered as00:07:09
financing of extremist or00:07:11
terrorist activities, but for00:07:13
this I repeat once again, a00:07:16
separate court decision will be necessary each time. It’s00:07:18
easy to imagine that this case00:07:20
will not be a court decision; it’s a quick matter,00:07:22
but nevertheless, I will still draw00:07:24
attention to the fact that those publishing houses,00:07:27
retail chains and00:07:29
marketplaces that are now withdrawing from00:07:32
sale and removing texts But these00:07:35
authors who are being persecuted00:07:37
act in a proactive00:07:39
manner, so to speak, they are not fulfilling any law,00:07:42
let's take a00:07:44
short break here, let's watch a meaningful00:07:46
advertisement And after that, let's return to the00:07:50
[music]00:07:56
studio I remember the Wrath of Achilles and his Scream00:08:00
at the walls of the city when he was gone so we00:08:03
lost hope for a fair victory then00:08:06
we had to use a trick we00:08:09
prepared a gift for the Trojans that they are00:08:13
unlikely to forget the time inside this00:08:16
wooden hell lasted an00:08:18
eternity it was stuffy my eyes stung with sweat00:08:22
and my lips were dry with thirst in this00:08:25
pitch darkness I completely lost track of00:08:28
time but My friend heard the joyful cries of00:08:31
the crowd, they bought into our00:08:34
trick when we found ourselves in the city and everything around00:08:37
became quiet, I opened the door slightly and00:08:40
looked around, there were only drunken00:08:43
bodies lying behind me. For the Glory of Zeus, I shouted and00:08:50
with fifty of the best warriors we took the00:08:54
city on the path for O00:08:58
de we will conquer Troy And let us remind you that this is00:09:01
the territory of modern Turkey; it is not at all00:09:03
necessary to climb into a wooden00:09:05
horse, because Turkey is one of the two countries00:09:08
that still provides00:09:09
citizenship by investment; Russians00:09:14
can obtain a passport of the Turkish Republic for the purchase of real estate in the country00:09:16
from $ 400,000 in just a period of 800:09:20
to 12 months acquisition real estate00:09:23
in Turkey is a clear and logical way00:09:26
to preserve capital and transfer it to00:09:28
Nera00:09:30
jurisdiction. In addition, this is your second home00:09:33
and an alternate airfield where you can always00:09:35
fly during geopolitical00:09:37
frosts. Interest in Turkey is only growing00:09:41
today; it is a hub for international00:09:43
air traffic and its position is at the00:09:45
crossroads of Europe and Asia makes the00:09:47
Republic a key destination for00:09:50
conducting international business; a00:09:53
Turkish passport opens entry to more than 11000:09:56
countries of the world, including Japan.00:10:00
But the main thing today, of course, is00:10:02
the opportunity to reduce political risks00:10:05
where Russians are denied entry simply00:10:07
because of the wrong passport; a00:10:09
green light for newly issued Turkish citizens. This00:10:13
also applies visas and business and opening00:10:16
accounts in foreign banks and access to the00:10:18
international financial system, exchanges00:10:21
and financial instruments And also00:10:23
obtaining foreign residence permits, especially in00:10:26
Europe. However, you should hurry up.00:10:29
Turkey plans to raise the00:10:31
investment threshold for citizenship to00:10:33
$600,000 in the coming months, so it00:10:36
remains wrong a lot of time to00:10:38
have time to enter the program so that the purchase of00:10:41
foreign real estate and all00:10:42
legal and bureaucratic procedures00:10:45
do not become an obstacle, we recommend00:10:47
contacting the international company00:10:49
Astons, which has been dealing with00:10:53
citizenship and VN for investments around the00:10:56
world for more than 30 years.00:10:58
For the WTO, a passport or residence permit00:11:01
can become even more Popular with the00:11:03
promotional code "living nail" which you00:11:05
must inform your00:11:07
consultant. You can get a00:11:10
$5,000 discount on the company's legal services00:11:12
and to always be aware of00:11:15
events and the latest immigration00:11:17
opportunities, subscribe to their00:11:19
telegram channel about immigration. On the mat, we00:11:23
leave contacts in00:11:26
the description. Well, we continue program00:11:29
What other events? Yes, besides the fight against00:11:33
fiction, recognized as00:11:35
extremism. And we still continue to00:11:37
have, so to speak, ordinary00:11:39
election events. Let's look at them00:11:41
a little. By the way, speaking00:11:44
about fiction, as00:11:47
was said some time ago,00:11:49
Yes, election campaigns are thought of in00:11:50
some way as a series of holidays,00:11:53
exhibitions of achievements, all kinds of00:11:55
competitions and other things, all of this00:11:57
should be united according to the organizers by the theme of family00:12:00
and nepotism, and almost every time you00:12:02
look at, let’s say, the design of00:12:05
these events,00:12:06
something quite strange breaks through, well, for example.00:12:08
Remember, there00:12:09
was a competition not it actually00:12:12
takes place in which it was necessary to show00:12:14
what you do good as a whole family and00:12:16
it was called it’s a00:12:19
wonderful family name again You understand00:12:21
what’s going on Yes so They usually talk about00:12:22
some kind of disease Yes you know It’s a00:12:24
family thing for us there I don’t know we are so far the00:12:26
most00:12:27
ironic maybe yes or something else00:12:30
So last weekend in Moscow00:12:32
there was a forum Relatives Beloved, also00:12:33
nicely held by the movement of the first00:12:35
movement of the first - this is this is the new00:12:38
new pioneer for the opening means the slogan of00:12:40
this event is next I am Russian I am00:12:42
special Oh this you also somehow know00:12:46
this Remember about this extra chromosome of the00:12:48
Russian people yes yes How do you understand this is a00:12:50
special femis way of saying about a00:12:54
child what he has Well, in fact, the00:12:55
development of this is positive in the00:12:59
end it really can be a00:13:00
stigmatization of all this And among00:13:02
philologists this is called00:13:04
uncontrollable subtext And when you00:13:08
say something you want to say one thing and00:13:09
something else comes out of you because00:13:11
there is this very subtext that you do00:13:13
n’t even realize. Well, for example, there is00:13:15
deputy Slutsky, about whom we will also now00:13:17
say a few words at some event00:13:20
in the past year passionately means said00:13:22
one country one people one president he00:13:25
didn’t mean anything like that he didn’t want to00:13:26
quote Hitler But somehow it just00:13:28
creeps in. This is such a00:13:30
philological phenomenon, you can say00:13:32
that the organizers of this kind of events00:13:33
consider their clients, so to speak, and the00:13:35
potential audience is all sick, but00:13:37
we will not say this with all00:13:39
certainty, just what is called,00:13:40
let’s pay attention to this kind of00:13:42
specific family style00:13:43
that all the time slides into something00:13:46
pathological, it’s difficult to say why00:13:48
further What else is happening in00:13:50
our poor election scene is not00:13:52
I can’t help but note the successful00:13:55
meeting of the initiative group meeting for the00:13:57
nomination of the independent candidate00:13:59
Ekaterina Ntso for the President of the Russian00:14:01
Federation, they gathered in Moscow, there00:14:03
were about 500 people there and they00:14:07
turned off the lights as expected, which can00:14:09
of course be considered, so to speak, some00:14:11
elements of the design of this event00:14:13
as independent and even in some way00:14:15
anti-government, so to speak, and another00:14:18
of the same kind of signs, one of the00:14:22
participants, upon returning from Moscow to00:14:25
Krasnoyarsk, was detained at the airport on00:14:29
suspicion of committing a crime under a00:14:31
rather rare article: false denunciation00:14:34
false denunciation against an employee of the Ministry of Internal Affairs So00:14:37
she wrote some time ago a00:14:40
statement against a policeman who, according to her,00:14:42
attacked her, now00:14:43
qualifies as a false denunciation, with the00:14:45
exception of these two incidents00:14:47
that we noted, everything generally went00:14:49
quite smoothly. Judging by the videos and00:14:51
photographs that were available in large quantities00:14:53
there, the participants showed00:14:57
enthusiasm, let’s say as Galina said00:14:59
Yusifovich, apparently the unspoken slogan of this00:15:01
company, we won’t catch up, at least we’ll bask in the00:15:03
general It’s clear But it’s natural that00:15:05
people want to take part in something like that. Well, at least I’ll00:15:06
remind you that in order for a00:15:08
nominee to be registered00:15:10
or, more precisely, to apply for registration00:15:12
as a presidential candidate, it00:15:13
is necessary to collect 300,000 signatures. This00:15:16
The congress itself is quite a big event. By00:15:19
the way, the meeting of the initiative00:15:21
group itself, preventing the question of where the money comes from,00:15:24
it’s not very expensive, and judging by the way00:15:26
it was formalized, there00:15:28
wasn’t a lot of money spent, I don’t think that it’s such a00:15:30
big problem to find a certain00:15:33
amount of funds for something like this a one-time00:15:35
event because, well, this is00:15:37
still not support for extremism so00:15:40
far, but there are hunters to do something so good00:15:43
And at the same time not to be exposed to00:15:44
too much danger in Russia00:15:46
is enough, so here I would not look for00:15:48
any secret powerful sponsors at all,00:15:51
distracting I’ll say for a moment that00:15:53
these conversations about the fact that behind every body00:15:54
movement there is a huge amount of money, they are00:15:57
very typical for people who themselves00:15:58
have never done anything in their lives. You00:16:00
understand how much it costs, a large00:16:03
number of things don’t cost anything special,00:16:05
so you sit down and do it. I00:16:07
understand that this sounds like a call to eat00:16:10
cakes in the absence of bread, but00:16:12
nevertheless, these estimates, which you quite00:16:15
often see, how much it costs there, I don’t know,00:16:17
again, promote the video on00:16:20
YouTube, a meeting for such and such a number of00:16:22
people is quite often compiled by00:16:24
truly professional00:16:25
technologists who have their own ideas00:16:27
about the price, everything is the same, if there are a00:16:30
sufficient number of Enthusiasts, it can be00:16:32
done much cheaper, but00:16:36
unlike a one-time event in the hall,00:16:38
which is really accessible to many00:16:40
people, collecting 300,000 signatures is already a00:16:43
company, this is a company that requires00:16:46
volunteers. Even if we assume, we00:16:48
can assume that the need for00:16:51
meaningful political action in00:16:54
some sense of one’s helplessness is00:16:56
so great that you have Booth volunteers, that00:16:59
is, people who will work00:17:00
for free, this is possible, this is00:17:03
not fantasy, it happens, someone should00:17:06
still work with them, who should00:17:08
work with them, who -it should be00:17:09
organized by 300,000 signatures, that’s00:17:11
a lot. I still think the00:17:15
likelihood of this candidate appearing on the00:17:17
ballot is extremely low. I don’t think00:17:20
our political managers can show such frivolity.00:17:22
Therefore, I think00:17:25
that she won’t be registered; the00:17:27
easiest way to00:17:28
do this is not to she didn’t get these00:17:30
300,000 signatures. It’s quite easy00:17:32
to do, and by threatening with a local collector,00:17:36
even if I repeat again, they will be there and they00:17:38
will be people ready to work. Even there,00:17:41
for some small or symbolic00:17:42
money, nevertheless, they too can00:17:45
naturally be intimidated. In general, we continue to00:17:47
monitor behind this plot, I confess to00:17:49
you, there really is something so00:17:50
cute that warms the soul, I think that00:17:52
this whole Festival of Disobedience00:17:54
will not last long, but while it lasts, we are00:17:56
watching it on the Telegram channel, she has00:17:59
250,000 subscribers, which is00:18:02
a lot for a Russian political telegram, a lot00:18:05
more What else with the participants in the00:18:07
electoral process, which means the congress of00:18:09
United Russia took place here without surprises.00:18:12
Last time you and I read the schedule of congresses, the00:18:16
LDPR deputy Slutsky,00:18:19
mentioned above, was nominated as a00:18:21
presidential candidate, also known as00:18:23
Zay Chutka. But we have no doubt that we00:18:26
will see him on the ballot, which means that he is, so00:18:28
to speak, the Heir representative of00:18:30
Zhirinovsky on the ground, then tomorrow,00:18:33
December 20, the Council of Legislators is meeting with us;00:18:35
this is a joint00:18:37
venture of the two chambers of Parliament; the00:18:39
leaders of the00:18:41
State Duma and the Federation Council, respectively, will00:18:43
attend there. And the topic is the00:18:46
thirtieth anniversary of the Constitution and,00:18:47
accordingly, the thirtieth anniversary of00:18:49
parliamentarism in Russia. What could00:18:51
be interesting here? interesting there may be00:18:53
some discussions of constitutional00:18:54
changes change do not change the ideology00:18:56
introduce do not introduce a new Constitution00:18:57
accept not do not accept something00:18:59
like that tomorrow we’ll see What’s there And they will00:19:02
tell us what else we are00:19:04
waiting for right with bated breath in the00:19:06
party schedule 23 December on Saturday and the00:19:09
Communist Party of the Russian Federation is convening a congress of A Just Russia00:19:12
and the Civil Initiative party and on00:19:14
December 24, just before Christmas, the00:19:16
New People party means that all these congresses, we00:19:18
repeat once again, are necessary in order to00:19:20
nominate candidates for the presidential00:19:23
elections from the party. We remind you once again that00:19:25
parliamentary parties have00:19:26
parliamentary privileges, they should not00:19:28
collect any signatures That is, their00:19:30
candidates with a high degree of probability00:19:32
such ballots will appear further and by the00:19:36
Supreme Court also not How this is not00:19:41
far from discussing election00:19:43
issues means what happened there I00:19:45
will pay attention to this now00:19:47
because there were different Messages about this00:19:48
like the Supreme Court banned citizens from00:19:50
campaigning on the Internet, this is not exactly00:19:52
what happened. The Plenum of the Supreme Court00:19:54
discussed sent for revision its00:19:56
own explanations on cases of00:19:59
offenses related to00:20:00
information support of elections. That00:20:01
is, they have a certain document that00:20:04
they create and which should explain00:20:06
the practice in this region, they didn’t send it00:20:09
for revision, perhaps before the end of the year, which00:20:11
would be logical, we will see it already00:20:13
finalized and accepted if they have time, if they do00:20:16
n’t have time, we’ll tell about it in January, which00:20:17
means in the draft this is the one00:20:20
that needs to be finalized, in this draft00:20:21
clarification it says that00:20:24
violations of campaigning can be00:20:26
admitted not only by the media but also by any00:20:29
other persons who, without speaking on00:20:32
behalf of the candidate, produce00:20:35
campaign materials at their own expense or00:20:37
from improvised means, that is, look at00:20:39
what they want to say, at least while the00:20:41
Supreme Court is trying to say what they are00:20:43
trying to say about the following If you00:20:45
something- you do it for money, they campaign00:20:49
during the campaign, then you are breaking the00:20:52
law because any campaign00:20:55
work during the pre-election period must be00:20:57
paid for from the election fund. And00:21:00
if I do it for free,00:21:02
I think that during the finalization I00:21:05
hope this will be clarified somehow So, that00:21:07
means you are a citizen, you are not speaking on00:21:09
behalf of the candidate, but you yourself00:21:12
are encouraging a poster from scrap materials00:21:16
and I don’t know, you shot with it, for example.00:21:19
And this is wrong, but if you do this00:21:23
for free, you can00:21:25
participate in the dissemination of campaigning00:21:27
from money from the election fund for free, this is00:21:31
all extremely murky That is, if I00:21:33
say on my channel, vote everyone for00:21:36
Slutsky or for Nzo, for example, but it00:21:40
turns out that I’m campaigning and it’s00:21:44
not paid for from the election fund,00:21:46
which means, generally speaking,00:21:48
the opportunity to campaign or00:21:50
speak out on selected issues is00:21:53
part of our active electoral00:21:54
rights, I have the right to vote, I have the00:21:55
right to discuss this, so to speak.00:21:59
But really, if we say I hire a00:22:01
film crew and, on my own00:22:02
initiative, shoot a video glorifying00:22:04
Deputy Slutsky and show it, then it would00:22:07
seem that Deputy Slutsky00:22:09
has advertising campaign00:22:11
material that he did not pay for, and this00:22:13
wrong In general, if you00:22:15
didn’t understand it before, then my explanations00:22:17
will make it even more incomprehensible to you. But this is a00:22:18
deliberate effect. It’s intended00:22:20
because that’s how much I’ve read this00:22:23
very explanation; it does00:22:25
n’t explain anything at all, which means it’s more00:22:28
understandable, and they00:22:29
can’t be involved in the production of propaganda materials00:22:30
foreign agents Unless they themselves00:22:32
are candidates, and if, for example, a00:22:34
foreign agent is the orderer of the campaign, then00:22:37
this is also a violation and he is held00:22:39
accountable and the executor of the order00:22:41
is held accountable. That is,00:22:42
if I go to the printing house, I order00:22:44
leaflets, again with the image of00:22:45
Deputy Slutsky, from whom I am in no way00:22:47
I can’t get rid of it, otherwise it will be a00:22:50
violation. Let’s see how there will be00:22:54
a desire to somehow tie the hands of citizens00:22:56
so that they don’t campaign on their YouTube channel in their00:22:58
Telegram channel. What00:23:01
is campaigning, what is free00:23:03
campaigning, what is paid campaigning?00:23:05
Let the FSB experts figure it out in court Well,00:23:07
by the way, regarding the court, after all,00:23:09
we are talking00:23:10
about administrative offenses, these are00:23:13
all articles, in particular article 5 1200:23:16
illegal production of placement of00:23:18
materials That is, this is not a criminal offense, this is an00:23:20
administrative law in our times, in general,00:23:23
childish measures, however, we will00:23:25
continue to monitor behind these developments of00:23:28
events, what is there? I want what I want to00:23:30
tighten up so that the00:23:32
election campaign is completely quiet and00:23:34
beautiful, which means the State Duma00:23:36
has completed its session, which it00:23:37
has been shortened many times, apparently people’s00:23:39
eyes and not to interfere with them enjoying the00:23:42
direct line of the president. What have they managed to00:23:45
accept from what about we must have00:23:47
time to tell you, which means firstly And00:23:49
such, so to speak,00:23:56
biopolitics means in three readings already in the00:23:59
third reading a law has been adopted according to which,00:24:01
from January 1, 2024,00:24:03
maternity capital can00:24:05
only be received for children who00:24:08
are citizens of Russia by birth. What does this00:24:10
mean That is, either both parents are00:24:12
citizens or one of the parents. The00:24:15
other citizen may not be a citizen, but the00:24:16
child was born on the territory of Russia.00:24:18
So let me remind you that in relation to citizenship00:24:20
there are two principles: the principle of blood; the principle of00:24:21
soil; Who was born on our land, is our00:24:23
citizen; or Who was born from our00:24:25
citizens; is our citizen; mixed00:24:26
forms here po there is a mixed form00:24:29
But basically we predominantly00:24:31
apply the principle of blood, that is, the children00:24:34
of citizens are citizens, why was this00:24:37
done, by the way, it was an initiative of the00:24:40
LDPR faction, it is a rather infrequent case00:24:42
when a factional initiative not00:24:43
introduced by the parliamentary majority is00:24:46
adopted and becomes law if the00:24:48
Federation Council everything this would00:24:50
be approved by the argument that00:24:54
migrants take advantage of a loophole in the law,00:24:56
come and give birth to many, many, many children00:24:58
and receive maternity capital for them.00:25:01
We were just told that giving birth to00:25:02
many, many children is extremely in the00:25:04
interests of the Russian Federation because00:25:05
we will quickly grant citizenship to these children00:25:07
and then he will ask what’s00:25:09
wrong with that, for your small amount of00:25:11
maternity capital you will then get,00:25:13
so to speak, a reservist contract serviceman,00:25:15
but no, but no, that means if00:25:18
all this again goes through the Federation Council and the00:25:19
President, then from January 100:25:21
such a norm will be adopted further. So We00:25:23
will remember with you that we had such a00:25:25
strange fight against abortion, about which they00:25:27
cautiously said that it seems perhaps00:25:30
it will more likely come down to conversations and00:25:32
initiatives of local initiatives than00:25:35
some kind of legislative prohibition, we remember00:25:37
the framework of what is happening Yes, that means the Russian Orthodox Church wants to00:25:40
at least remove abortion from compulsory medical insurance from00:25:42
system of compulsory health00:25:44
insurance, as a maximum, to achieve00:25:45
their ban altogether; the intermediate idea is to00:25:47
prohibit private clinics from performing abortions.00:25:51
Well, some regions ran there, we’ll tell you00:25:53
a little bit about it;00:25:54
some regions ran ahead of00:25:56
the locomotive and, on their own initiative,00:25:58
banned private clinics from providing these services,00:26:00
which means that We are coming up with00:26:02
bills in the Duma00:26:06
that would prohibit non-00:26:08
state clinics from providing this00:26:10
medical service. We have one00:26:11
bill introduced by the Nizhny Novgorod00:26:13
Regional Duma, at least from00:26:15
what I found further, the Vedomosti newspaper00:26:18
did not publish a letter, but00:26:20
published news that the committee is00:26:22
specialized The health committee sent a00:26:24
letter to Speaker Volodin saying that there was00:26:28
no need to ban abortions in private clinics.00:26:29
After that, something went wrong.00:26:31
Different members of the committee began to say00:26:33
different things. They said that some were for00:26:35
some against, but00:26:37
there was no general position of the committee. Who says there was no letter?00:26:39
Who says there was a letter If there is no00:26:41
joint position of the committee, I00:26:42
don’t understand why you should write a letter to the speaker. What are00:26:44
you writing to him about, dear Vyacheslav00:26:45
Viktorovich, we are all in doubt. What is00:26:47
the point, if the committee writes to the chairman,00:26:51
then he writes to him. It’s clear that Yes,00:26:54
the position of the committee is that it is not00:26:56
necessary now so to speak, to muddy the waters,00:26:58
it’s clear that after the president on a00:27:00
straight line said something about00:27:02
women’s rights and what a ban is in general. This is not00:27:03
our method, all this extraordinary00:27:05
activity should go back a little.00:27:08
I’ll remind you that even before the straight line of phases, the00:27:12
Federal Antimonopoly Service went to00:27:14
check those regions that have banned00:27:17
private clinics from performing abortions, which00:27:20
confirms our repeatedly00:27:22
expressed idea, initiative is not00:27:24
encouraged in autocracy, dear citizens and00:27:27
leaders of organizations, employees of00:27:29
budgetary structures, please do not run00:27:32
ahead of the locomotive. Do not cross the path of the00:27:33
father in the Inferno, these wise00:27:35
folk expressions should somehow help you00:27:37
warn00:27:40
your bosses about this when necessary They will tell you it’s not your business to00:27:43
raise or lower the birth rate in Russia00:27:45
they will say to lower you will lower00:27:47
they will say to increase you will increase But for now there has00:27:49
been no instructions Stop00:27:51
doing this, a phaser will come to you and say00:27:53
that you are violating the competition law yet they00:27:55
will charge you some kind of fine. And all00:27:56
because, instead of00:27:58
looking at the title documents,00:27:59
you listened to someone unknown on the Internet, on the00:28:01
Internet they will tell you a lot of things.00:28:03
So, we have spoken here00:28:05
many times, except for00:28:07
the call, so to speak, not to show enthusiasm, which00:28:09
never is rewarded in no00:28:11
area, this is the principle of the functioning of00:28:13
our regime, and00:28:15
specifically regarding abortions. We talked about the fact00:28:17
that there will be terrorization of gays00:28:19
because here, so to speak, the00:28:22
opinion of our elderly authorities00:28:24
coincides more or less with the opinion of the00:28:25
majority. Homophobia is00:28:27
widespread in Russia for a number of reasons, but abortions like00:28:31
divorces - these are two pillars of Russian00:28:34
family life and no one will touch them, there00:28:36
were arguments that it was00:28:39
possible to talk like that before, but now00:28:41
everyone would go crazy and they00:28:43
shouldn’t talk like that, but as00:28:46
unkind people said about one00:28:47
Soviet writer, I call her00:28:48
crazy in her favor, this is00:28:50
all the madness, it’s in her favor, a fool, a00:28:52
fool, doesn’t eat, I’m watching just on the00:28:55
Telegram channel FM 67 Russians00:28:58
would not support the ban on abortion in the country,00:29:00
rfi source means dear citizens And then there’s00:29:03
one side note And when they00:29:06
call you with a desire to find out your opinion, they00:29:09
interview them,00:29:12
our administration is obsessed with surveys, they are simply obsessed,00:29:15
they order00:29:16
many, many surveys for any reason and then, based on00:29:18
this, they judge it, it seems to you that there,00:29:20
again, there are some people who went there, you know?00:29:23
tyrants who run around naked and00:29:25
enjoy their everything00:29:27
And impunity is nothing like it,00:29:29
as autocracy was, it still00:29:31
works by touch where you can00:29:32
push where you can’t crawl away 1000:29:36
times ready to change your mind today00:29:37
Says one thing tomorrow another the day after tomorrow the00:29:39
third why haven’t you seen them what did you think00:29:40
before or did you think that they hit the00:29:42
floor and transformed into some of00:29:43
these most amazing monsters? No, it does00:29:45
n’t happen like that, but00:29:49
deeper it happens in the same vein as the00:29:51
previous activity, which means the last thing. Let’s00:29:54
talk about liqueurs.00:29:56
Let’s00:29:58
briefly talk about this. This is important because that the00:30:00
alcoholization of the population attracts not00:30:02
only our attention but also the attention of the00:30:03
legislator. This00:30:04
means that only in the00:30:07
first reading we managed to pass the so-00:30:09
called bill on nalivayka, what is it?00:30:11
These are amendments to the law on00:30:13
state regulation of the production and circulation of00:30:15
ethyl00:30:16
alcohol, a big beautiful bill with00:30:19
United Russia members with a deputy topiliny00:30:21
chairman of the committee on economic00:30:22
policy with the vice-speaker00:30:26
status What are we talking about and it00:30:30
is prohibited to sell alcohol on tap00:30:32
after, in my opinion, 23 hours But this depends00:30:36
on the region Yes, but these restrictions do not00:30:38
apply to beer and00:30:41
low-alcohol drinks such as00:30:43
Poiret cider and mead You know what00:30:45
Poiret is, I didn’t drink I don’t know either, Niko I00:30:47
haven’t heard of it, but that means the so-00:30:50
called liqueurs are stations for00:30:53
bottling some kind of alcohol in stores. That00:30:57
is, it’s like you have a store here and on the side you have00:30:59
a buffet, you call it a buffet and00:31:01
then you bottle, for example, beer,00:31:03
since in general our legislation is00:31:04
extremely liberal in this area,00:31:06
then stores selling alcohol00:31:07
are located, including in residential buildings,00:31:11
of course, if you have00:31:12
this very pouring, pouring, bottling going on there around the clock,00:31:15
then the residents, as they say, complain00:31:19
and are dissatisfied with this, which means that in fact,00:31:21
they adopted this, advertised as a law00:31:23
generally banning everything and everyone, in00:31:24
fact, this is still the same our perversion,00:31:27
federalization of delegation00:31:29
of responsibility to the localities means it00:31:31
is proposed to the regions to determine how they00:31:34
want or do not want to00:31:38
allow these same liqueurs at all as an00:31:40
additional incentive to this00:31:41
lawmaking was, of course, a terrible00:31:43
story with cider poisoning when00:31:46
several dozen people died from00:31:48
some amazing drink00:31:50
that apparently contained methyl00:31:52
alcohol. Apparently this00:31:54
means that the fight is not very radical,00:31:58
but nevertheless, what is called paid00:32:00
attention to the problem. Here Boshe is also00:32:01
interesting, it means as it turned out,00:32:04
some time ago,00:32:07
Vladimir Kolokoltsev, the Minister of Internal00:32:10
Affairs, also wrote a letter to Speaker Volodin,00:32:13
everyone writes letters to Volodin, complaining about00:32:15
deputies who organize raids on00:32:18
alcohol spill points at night and00:32:20
involve journalists in this. Why is00:32:22
Kolokoltsev indignant about this because,00:32:24
firstly, he says that there is a moratorium on00:32:27
scheduled inspections of legal entities And00:32:29
besides, such a fuss creates a false00:32:32
impression of the inaction of the police, although00:32:34
supervision of trade is not within its00:32:35
competence, that is, you understand, yes, the00:32:37
deputies who came there to some00:32:39
night cafe are compromising the police,00:32:41
thereby perhaps even discrediting them00:32:43
to me somehow it seemed funny00:32:45
to be honest that the Minister of Internal Affairs was00:32:47
serious like this. Well, firstly,00:32:49
somehow he decided to support this business and00:32:52
secondly they complain and secondly they complain to00:32:54
the speaker about the deputies who are00:32:57
organizing raids and honest people suffer from this00:32:59
entrepreneurs and also00:33:01
innocent police officers who,00:33:03
in principle, have nothing to do with it at all, and what00:33:06
names do these liqueurs come up with for themselves?00:33:08
Wow, in the regions there, yes yes, this must be00:33:11
given due credit there naming creative00:33:14
naming very very very well,00:33:16
let’s move on to the next A that00:33:18
Venezuela and Guyana decided not to fight as00:33:20
we told last time is good Novo00:33:22
excellent this is really good00:33:23
news yes then let us00:33:25
say now A few words about different merch00:33:27
that you can buy From the links in00:33:30
the description and I must say that not00:33:31
only our merch will be there this time yes there00:33:33
will be not only our merch there will also00:33:36
be links to all sorts of valuable00:33:39
works and products and books and books The00:33:43
book is a work, strictly00:33:45
speaking, illuminated by the name of Evgeniy00:33:46
Vadimovich Roizman, firstly, you can00:33:48
buy his book, you can buy his00:33:49
book with an autograph, you can buy a00:33:52
beautiful one it's called a Power bank00:33:54
on which it says everything will be fine that00:33:56
I have one, he gave it to me and you00:33:58
know what he's good at. It's black and that's why00:34:00
when you turn it on, then00:34:02
this inscription everything will be fine, it00:34:04
kind of glows white on this general black And00:34:06
I have to be honest, I have a keychain00:34:08
just from00:34:11
Roizman’s Dark Times book, too.00:34:14
I also have an autographed book, like some people00:34:17
get everything for free, and a book with00:34:19
stories about the basics, mostly about00:34:20
animals, I’ve almost already read it, it’s00:34:22
small and very soul-warming00:34:25
dear friends, in fact, merch is something00:34:27
that helps a lot now for different different00:34:30
different grooming yes, especially for those people00:34:32
who are inside Russia, so00:34:33
they don’t have many opportunities, but00:34:35
you can buy a book Well, we move on00:34:38
to the next00:34:39
[music]00:34:42
section on the concepts of What the concept we have00:34:46
today, the concept of us is unfortunately00:34:49
more relevant than we would like and00:34:51
we remembered about it due to the fact that a number of00:34:54
political prisoners in Russia do not00:34:57
make themselves known and people know nothing about them00:34:59
Navalny unknown where Alexey00:35:01
Gorinov unknown where all this00:35:02
continues already for days and weeks and is00:35:04
causing generally justified00:35:06
concern. So this practice00:35:08
has a name; moreover, this name is00:35:11
enshrined in international law; this is00:35:14
not so widely known, so we decided to00:35:15
tell you what forced disappearance is from the point of view of00:35:17
international law;00:35:19
dis means00:35:22
enforced disappearance - This is something00:35:24
different from kidnapping from kidnapping from00:35:28
kidnapping for ransom or there by the groom,00:35:31
so to speak, within the framework of a traditional marriage,00:35:33
this is a specific phenomenon, what is it?00:35:36
So this is the arrest, detention,00:35:39
kidnapping or Deprivation of freedom of someone by00:35:42
representatives of the state or individuals and00:35:45
groups of individuals acting with permission00:35:47
from support or with the consent of the state00:35:50
with the subsequent refusal of the authorities00:35:52
to recognize the fact of deprivation of liberty or00:35:54
concealment of information about the fate or00:35:56
location of the disappeared person, as a result of00:35:59
which this person remains without the protection of00:36:02
the law, often unfortunately, forced00:36:05
disappearance is a precursor to00:36:07
murder. So this is the disappearance of a person00:36:12
through the state or groups00:36:15
delegated by the state for00:36:18
this purpose or are they allowed to act00:36:21
what is called in Russian the00:36:23
connivance of the 200th Assembly00:36:26
adopted an international convention to00:36:29
protect all persons from enforced00:36:31
disappearances since this practice is00:36:33
quite common where exactly is it00:36:35
widespread it is mainly00:36:36
associated with the military00:36:38
junta why are they doing this means00:36:42
Military juntas, by their nature, are forced to00:36:45
position themselves as some such00:36:47
temporary phenomena, we are saving the Fatherland00:36:49
from the chaos of the collapse of the Civil War of00:36:51
something. Now we will restore order and00:36:53
leave, so they very often apply00:36:56
all sorts of emergency legislation00:36:59
or due to this political00:37:01
nature of theirs, as well as tell the nature of their00:37:03
military They don’t like long judicial00:37:06
procedures,00:37:08
so they can, for example, arrest people00:37:11
like How legal Yes, citizens come in a00:37:13
uniform there, they give you two They say you00:37:14
are arrested in the name of00:37:19
caudillism, they can find it, God forbid,00:37:22
bones After a few decades,00:37:25
that is, this is the Rhone’s way of taking00:37:27
advantage as if legal violence00:37:30
Well, that is, people will not resist.00:37:31
Yes, but on the other hand, not being subjected to00:37:35
all the shortcomings of the legal procedure, so to speak,00:37:37
is actually a way to kill00:37:40
or at least neutralize your00:37:42
mainly political opponents.00:37:43
Taking advantage of the fact that you are posing as a00:37:46
state between us you are00:37:48
not fully present because the whole00:37:50
point of the trial, just like the whole00:37:52
point of the penitentiary system in its00:37:54
publicity, is that it operates according to00:37:57
the regulations, the regulations are accessible,00:37:59
known, all these stages can be tracked,00:38:02
information about a person can be obtained, this does00:38:04
not make the fate, so to speak, of a00:38:05
detained person arrested and convicted00:38:07
somehow it’s especially easier But this protects00:38:11
him to some extent from extreme degrees of00:38:14
arbitrariness So this convention This00:38:17
international convention says that00:38:19
disappearance naturally brings00:38:21
suffering and paralyzes the victim of those close to her.00:38:24
They are in a situation of constant00:38:26
uncertainty, they don’t know, that is, they are at00:38:28
the worst situation than the people who00:38:30
were told, you know, your national00:38:31
traitor there was shot Well, that’s how he is, that00:38:33
is, people continue to search, they don’t know what’s00:38:36
really going on, they can’t in00:38:37
any form continue their lives in a00:38:39
normal way, which means they are subjected to00:38:42
such forced disappearance of00:38:44
men and women and children, which means00:38:47
he commission on human rights created a00:38:48
special working group that has been working since 000:38:50
until now, often wives,00:38:53
mothers, other female relatives of the00:38:55
abducted ledges, the00:38:57
main actors, let’s say, the main00:39:00
figures in their search and in00:39:02
making these stories public, we are now00:39:05
with you one such one such Let us00:39:07
tell you this case, unfortunately, it is a fairly00:39:09
common phenomenon, again00:39:11
mainly in military juntas in00:39:13
countries where the military is in power,00:39:15
but also in situations of civil wars,00:39:17
civil conflicts in which there is00:39:19
one power in one territory on00:39:20
another, which means that this very00:39:24
convention is international, by the way,00:39:27
protection of all persons relative00:39:28
disappearances was just adopted on00:39:30
December 20, 2006. So tomorrow it will be00:39:33
her anniversary, I must tell you right away00:39:36
that these two countries are the main00:39:39
lovers of international law, the USA and the00:39:41
Russian Federation have not00:39:42
ratified it, but in the European Union00:39:44
it has been ratified in Kazakhstan By00:39:46
the way, the Day of Victims of Enforced00:39:49
Disappearances is also celebrated on August 30th. I’m00:39:50
informing you about this. By the way, speaking00:39:53
about the practical consequences, so to speak,00:39:55
this is the very same thing. The working00:39:57
group, I repeat, is functioning00:39:59
and you can write to it, for example, because00:40:02
this definition00:40:04
fits perfectly well as a native one to what you and I are00:40:07
seeing everyone understands what it is What is00:40:09
its validity effectiveness and00:40:11
so on But at least this is in their00:40:14
part in some way they will have to00:40:16
react in general, so to speak, in00:40:18
general activity such as writing posts on00:40:20
social networks this It would be useful to have a little00:40:23
recommendation, but we can00:40:25
move on today again, it will not be00:40:28
fathers, but mothers, mothers, fathers, great00:40:32
theorists and00:40:35
practitioners. So, for the second time we are addressing00:40:37
you to the topic of women's political00:40:40
activism, women's protest activity,00:40:42
and we remember that we had wives in00:40:44
Rosenstrasse the year before if I I00:40:46
’m not mistaken, the release of a participant in almost00:40:49
the only and certainly the only00:40:51
successful protest in Nazi Germany00:40:54
Anti-anti-fascist protest at this00:40:57
time, today’s our heroines, we00:40:59
will also have such a Collective entity00:41:01
- these are the mothers of May Square and the grandmothers of00:41:05
May Square, what is this, this00:41:08
social movement that arose in00:41:09
Argentina in the second half of00:41:12
the seventies, when power there00:41:15
was in the hands of the military junta,00:41:18
Argentina in general is a rather00:41:20
unhappy country historically, in some ways it strongly00:41:23
resembles the Russian Federation and00:41:26
historical Russia, that is, you understand, a00:41:28
large fertile country rich in00:41:30
natural resources, songs, beautiful00:41:34
Nobel Prizes in literature00:41:35
received periods00:41:38
this country was experiencing rapid economic growth, was00:41:40
already preparing and was practically the hegemon on its00:41:42
Continent and the continent is healthy, and00:41:45
then time after time some bad luck00:41:48
happens and they will choose someone strange.00:41:50
Well, now they have also chosen a slightly00:41:51
strange comrade, but maybe00:41:52
something... he’ll do something to them there. But in the 20th00:41:55
century, it’s really some kind of series00:41:57
of dictatorships. One is more amazing than the other.00:42:00
Some of them look more romantic about00:42:01
them, then they won’t shoot various musicals00:42:03
until we point fingers, and00:42:05
some are completely ugly, which means this is what this00:42:07
wonderful00:42:09
junta of ours was doing. by the fact that in their language it00:42:11
was called national00:42:15
reorganization, a more00:42:17
common name for this00:42:18
historical period, let’s say. The Dirty War, what00:42:21
they had there, they really had00:42:24
practically the beginning of a civil war00:42:26
between the left and the right, as happens on the00:42:29
South American continent and in00:42:31
Central America, which means the military00:42:33
that captured the authorities saw themselves as the00:42:35
Savior of the Fatherland from the Red threat and00:42:38
from these very00:42:41
civil civil wars, so to speak, they had to,00:42:44
according to their own plan,00:42:46
prevent the revolution that was00:42:48
about to happen How to prevent00:42:50
a revolution Well, of course, killing more00:42:52
people who can00:42:54
carry out this revolution accordingly means means00:42:57
in time while in power, it is00:42:58
believed that about 30,000 people were00:43:01
killed by them, which means that they did these00:43:03
very forced disappearances, they directly00:43:05
used them extremely, in addition, they00:43:07
invented a wonderful technology, but they00:43:08
say that they did not invent it. And as00:43:10
always happens, everything bad was taught by the00:43:11
Europeans, they say that they did this in00:43:13
Algeria, the French, what is it? These are the so-00:43:16
called death flights, they take people on a00:43:18
plane and throw them into the sea and sometimes not00:43:20
into the sea, in general, how will it work out in order00:43:22
to avoid unpleasant prices on the plane,00:43:24
they were pumped up by pirates so that they would00:43:27
fall asleep there and that’s how it ends they00:43:30
literally hid in the water,00:43:32
which means it was a00:43:36
wonderful junta who said that not00:43:38
today, tomorrow we will establish a legitimate00:43:40
government here. But it hasn’t worked out yet00:43:41
because the Revolutionary danger00:43:43
has not passed and they kidnapped people, men, women,00:43:47
civil activists, journalists,00:43:50
some kind of artistic figures In00:43:52
general all those who seemed to them to be some kind of00:43:53
potentially leftist with this very dirty thing,00:43:56
as00:43:57
usual there is a lot of dirt, both inside and00:44:00
outside it is believed that the American00:44:03
government somehow treated them00:44:04
neni, go within the framework of politics son of a [ __ ]00:44:07
US our son of a [ __ ] the late Kissinger00:44:10
who was with here, too, in our fathers, in00:44:12
connection with his recent death, it was00:44:14
believed that he supported this cause and00:44:17
somehow looked at them positively because they were00:44:18
not communists. Yes, it’s clear that he believed that00:44:22
France That’s why I remembered about Algeria00:44:24
Well, I remembered about Algeria because That’s00:44:25
about this technology But in general it was believed00:44:27
that France also somehow favored them, so to00:44:28
speak, it seemed like it even00:44:30
helped them, then when all this was over,00:44:32
they dug up all the bones, then they tried to serve Kiser with00:44:34
some kind of court summons00:44:35
when he came to various00:44:37
South American countries and to the French00:44:39
retired government officials also00:44:41
had complaints, which means that as for00:44:44
our mothers, So this means that what is happening is00:44:46
people are taken away, they disappear irrevocably00:44:49
in a country of terror, everyone is afraid to speak out, the00:44:51
press is no independent, there is nothing,00:44:54
there is nothing, what to do means the00:44:56
women decided More precisely, at first it00:44:58
was a small group of women, 14 people,00:45:00
this is then they began, so to speak, the00:45:01
founder of these mothers, the square of May, the00:45:04
square of May, the Central Square in Buenos00:45:05
Aires. They wanted to get to the president.00:45:08
Well, he was not the president, he was, as it were, the00:45:09
de facto president. Jorja Rafael saw00:45:12
they wanted to get an appointment with him with00:45:14
their pain, so to speak. How you understand,00:45:16
women in these situations always want to get to the00:45:19
first person somehow, thinking that they are00:45:22
hiding the rights from him, of course00:45:23
he himself is a good person. Therefore, if they00:45:25
complain to him, then he will probably help them somehow,00:45:26
they came there, they are no one,00:45:28
of course no, he didn’t receive some00:45:31
kind of secretary, they talked there and00:45:34
that means they realized that no one wants to listen to them,00:45:37
they decided that they would stand00:45:39
on this square so that the president would00:45:40
see them, that he would look at them from the window00:45:42
or he would go out there and00:45:44
come and somehow they will attract his00:45:45
attention, the police came up to them and said00:45:47
that it is impossible to gather more than three and, in00:45:48
my opinion, even three people cannot gather together, and00:45:50
told them to move from here, what did00:45:53
they begin to do, they began to walk around the00:45:56
central obelisk in this square,00:45:58
this is called the May Pyramid holding00:46:00
hands in twos, like, we’re not three of us, we’re walking00:46:02
together, we’re walking around, they walked around like that,00:46:05
then they left and said that00:46:07
they would come in a week and then they chose a00:46:10
time of half an hour every day every week00:46:13
on a certain day, which means that they will be00:46:16
on Thursdays from 153 to 16 :00 walk and they00:46:20
began to become more more more00:46:22
more in order to recognize each other,00:46:23
they began to wear white scarves,00:46:25
initially they were made from00:46:26
diapers. That is, it was like a sign00:46:28
that they were looking for their missing children,00:46:31
of course, no press wrote anything about it00:46:32
all this was, so to speak,00:46:34
hushed up, but nevertheless00:46:39
the earth is full of rumors and they began to be recognized about them, they00:46:41
began to become more numerous, it means they00:46:44
wrote in Pirin, they wrote to UNICEF, but00:46:47
no one answered them, it means how long it00:46:50
all took, how long it all lasted, it means00:46:52
look, it started at seventy in the00:46:54
seventh year, and only from April 30,00:46:58
1978 to August00:47:00
1978, they went on like this for more than a year,00:47:02
and only in August00:47:03
1978, one Argentine newspaper published00:47:06
their appeal, then there was an international00:47:09
outcry, which means, again, they did not00:47:13
overthrow the regime.00:47:14
But this is hype. and the fact that the international00:47:19
community somehow began to say to these00:47:20
Argentines that you behave more decently00:47:22
yourself there made it easier to find these people,00:47:26
which means then they admitted a little later00:47:28
they admitted the kidnapping of the authorities admitted that00:47:30
they kidnapped 99,000 people for a minute,00:47:32
and this organization itself is the mother of00:47:34
May Square and then a little later appeared00:47:36
grandmothers of May Square and grandmothers, by the way,00:47:38
why grandmothers kidnapped women,00:47:40
including women, some of00:47:42
them gave birth to children in custody, were taken away,00:47:45
given to the right families for00:47:47
patriotic education, in this way, it is00:47:49
believed that more than 500 babies00:47:51
were lost and did not know who they were00:47:53
later when the junta ended it all in the eighties, a00:47:55
big search process began,00:47:57
these grandmothers are the mothers of these00:47:59
women who are looking for their daughters and00:48:01
their unknown grandchildren about whom it is00:48:03
generally unknown whether they exist or not, which00:48:05
means that regarding the effectiveness of00:48:07
peaceful protest, it means 14 people,00:48:10
14 women founded this organization00:48:13
it means that out of these leaders, five were00:48:15
killed, including two nuns, wow,00:48:18
but this rather00:48:21
central character, so to speak, who was one00:48:24
of the founders, just as we00:48:26
said, was thrown into an airplane and after00:48:30
several decades a group was found, there is a00:48:32
group in Argentina that is looking for a00:48:34
burial place and trying to identify them, which00:48:36
means they found her, they found her, by the way,00:48:42
and identified this chagi Vara, so they found00:48:44
this woman and thus managed to00:48:46
bury her. That is, it was not a00:48:49
completely unsafe00:48:51
movement, let’s say, nevertheless, this00:48:53
duration is so visible humanitarian00:48:56
mission It led to the fact that at least00:48:58
some kind of conversation about00:49:00
where where people are at least Tell us where they are00:49:02
Yes, it still00:49:05
began since then There are00:49:08
many songs about this, films have been made,00:49:11
this organization has been nominated for the Nobel Prize00:49:13
peace prize True, they didn’t receive it, but00:49:15
nevertheless, So this is such a00:49:17
story. I don’t know how00:49:19
inspiring it is. Because after all, a lot of00:49:21
sacrifices, so to speak, a lot of sacrifices were made and it took a00:49:25
very, very long time for it to give at least00:49:27
some result, but nevertheless, they00:49:29
became famous If you Google it, so to speak,00:49:30
then you can watch a lot of00:49:32
documentaries on this topic,00:49:34
but we move on to questions Yeah,00:49:39
questions from listeners Before00:49:43
moving on to questions, I’ll say about the SH store00:49:45
Amateur Media world of engineer Shukhov, such a00:49:47
book is there today and how the brain of00:49:50
an inventor works, if you wanted to know00:49:52
how this brain works, then please, well,00:49:55
now to the questions, I’ll start with this.00:49:59
Unfortunately, the set of letters here00:50:02
is displayed as a name quality. Therefore,00:50:05
[music]00:50:08
excuse me, let’s do it like this, that’s where I’m coming from I’ll00:50:11
start from the other side, this00:50:13
time00:50:16
RV in May followed the link you provided and00:50:20
joined the ranks of the members with the right to cast a decisive00:50:24
vote. The more often I think about00:50:27
whether some kind of trouble will happen to me if I00:50:30
fulfill my duties in good faith,00:50:32
how to behave in the fatal March days00:50:35
I’m studying in medicine, I’m sure that I’ll00:50:36
bring more benefit to society If before I study and00:50:39
for participation in rallies we’ve already00:50:41
expelled00:50:43
Uh, horses, then look, this is not a rally,00:50:47
this is the most legal of all legal activities,00:50:50
you are a member of the precinct election00:50:52
commission with the right of a decider, soate of the00:50:56
decider, you are the power there in general - then speaking00:50:59
So, therefore, do not be overly alarmed by00:51:02
what can happen, it means that if you00:51:05
start recording falsified00:51:08
violations and somehow energetically argue with00:51:11
your00:51:13
falsifiers, accuse them of00:51:15
hitting one of them, curse them with obscenities,00:51:17
something like that, they will call the police like00:51:19
that you are here Buta and they need to take you to the00:51:21
police station, so the task will not be to00:51:24
throw you out of the university again and repress you in some other00:51:26
way, but to make sure that00:51:28
you do not interfere with this work of theirs.00:51:31
Therefore, see yourself as00:51:33
correctly as possible, this advice is always useful00:51:35
if it provokes you don’t tear it down don’t00:51:37
scream don’t throw ballots on the floor under00:51:39
any circumstances record everything now you’re00:51:42
studying medicine, maybe you00:51:43
know some secrets How to go00:51:44
without sleep for three days I00:51:46
don’t know them, but the main virtue of an00:51:49
observer and a member of the election00:51:51
commission is vigilance vigilance00:51:54
and once again, vigilance, therefore,00:51:56
record everything, if you cannot or00:52:01
are afraid to express your dissatisfaction00:52:03
or your complaints right there, so to speak,00:52:05
in people’s faces, then at least when you leave the police00:52:07
station you can make it all00:52:09
public once again your status00:52:11
protects you and Read everything carefully00:52:14
legal acts that relate to your00:52:17
position remember you if I'm not mistaken00:52:20
you cannot be detained in administrative00:52:22
detention and administrative arrest you00:52:24
cannot be subjected to without some kind of00:52:26
separate sanction of the prosecutor That is, I00:52:27
will repeat this again, quite well, in00:52:30
general this is the status Yes you not the protesters Yes,00:52:33
and not even the one who signed for the00:52:37
candidate, although no one has ever00:52:38
been punished for this, so don’t be fooled by provocations, write00:52:41
everything down,00:52:45
watch everything, don’t be afraid of something that won’t00:52:48
happen, because well, without00:52:51
election commissions,00:52:52
elections cannot take place process, as00:52:55
someone who has some experience00:52:57
in the commission as a voting member,00:53:00
I can say that00:53:02
be sure to go to all the00:53:05
orientation events that00:53:07
will be there, get to know other members of00:53:08
the commission, it’s quite possible you will00:53:10
meet like-minded people there who,00:53:13
and not at first glance, you see them maybe he will00:53:16
recognize who will help you,00:53:18
including somehow sharing responsibilities00:53:20
for this very vigilance, well, take00:53:24
this advice,00:53:25
in fact, there are people there who, just00:53:27
like you, want everything to pass, at00:53:29
least it was calculated. Honestly, Vlad00:53:33
Grace asks you if it is possible scientist00:53:37
to be responsible for actions00:53:39
committed by others under the banner of the00:53:41
ideas he puts forward, I ask In connection with the00:53:45
recent death of the philosopher Antonio Negri,00:53:47
who in the past There was a sentence on00:53:49
charges of moral responsibility for00:53:51
leftist radical terror in00:53:54
Italy, but a good00:53:57
vos Well, look, it’s not him as it’s not him00:54:00
first Neon last00:54:02
Carl Schmitt tells us something, for example, the00:54:04
famous German philosopher, the author of the thesis00:54:07
of the will, the Fuhrer forms the law, also served00:54:10
his sentence, not exactly for life, but00:54:12
he served it,00:54:14
and the criminalization of intellectual00:54:16
activity, of course, does not cause much enthusiasm among people engaged in00:54:18
intellectual activity,00:54:19
we might00:54:21
like to live in such an ideal00:54:24
universe protected by the first amendment,00:54:25
although we see that even in the country in which the00:54:27
first amendment applies, it’s not that00:54:28
some kind of ideal universe is located,00:54:30
but nevertheless, nevertheless, of course, in the00:54:35
legislation of almost all countries of the00:54:38
Eurasian continent there are00:54:40
certain sanctions for words You don’t have to00:54:42
be a scientist, you can be a person00:54:43
without any education at all in order to00:54:45
be accused and convicted of00:54:47
Propaganda, justifying the spread of00:54:50
extremist terrorist and other00:54:53
ideas means about responsibility, I00:54:56
would still like it if we are not talking00:54:58
about criminal responsibility,00:54:59
let’s say moral responsibility. But00:55:01
for me I would like people to distinguish00:55:04
reasoning from00:55:06
calls, of course, the creation of an idea which00:55:09
then, mastering the masses, becomes a00:55:11
material force; this is great power and,00:55:14
accordingly, Great responsibility, on the00:55:16
other hand, as you know, I am00:55:18
responsible for what I write. But I am not00:55:20
responsible for the fact that you00:55:22
read a complex question, but really00:55:26
Before each, so to speak, each00:55:28
mass terror is preceded by00:55:30
some extremely peaceful person,00:55:33
often even a vegetarian who, in the quiet of00:55:35
his office, comes up with some idea,00:55:38
eugenic, geopolitical, or the idea of00:55:42
universal equality, the idea of liberation from00:55:45
exploitation and other such00:55:47
wonderful things to forbid people00:55:49
to think, check every philosophical00:55:52
treatise on the possible consequences of how this is an00:55:54
assessment regulating Through the gpt chat you know the00:55:57
chat Please tell me Will there be00:55:59
trouble from this philosopher or will there be big trouble?00:56:01
Call an FSB expert to00:56:04
determine the degree of extremist, so to speak,00:56:07
difficult and difficult to resolve00:56:10
questions We can Answer00:56:12
by and large, only for ourselves, yes. We must00:56:15
think about who, so to speak, will seduce one00:56:17
of these little ones. Who would be better off not being00:56:20
born, as roughly stated in the00:56:21
gospel, we need to think about it, but all the consequences of00:56:24
any of our actions are actually unknown to us,00:56:26
therefore, excuse me, this00:56:28
question seems to be I don’t have an answer for00:56:30
you Victor Vilov asks00:56:34
whether a vague nomination and, in00:56:37
general, an attempt to conduct elections as quietly as possible, does not contradict the00:56:38
main goal of the00:56:41
electoral procedure, confirmation of00:56:43
legitimacy, listen to what kind of00:56:46
listeners we have, where do they come from, they are00:56:48
so wonderful, look, there is a00:56:51
difference between how you conduct a00:56:53
campaign and what you then after don’t00:56:54
say re-confirmation of legitimacy00:56:57
will consist in the fact that firstly00:56:59
the company will take place extremely quietly peacefully,00:57:02
which can be interpreted as a sign of00:57:04
national unity and universal consent00:57:06
no one objected No one made a scandal everything00:57:08
was wonderful Yes good man00:57:12
besides there will be a result that the company00:57:16
will also recite00:57:25
loud, noisy and attracting00:57:27
attention, and sometimes you need to crawl on the00:57:28
roof with a simple one without attracting the attention00:57:31
of the orderlies right up to the00:57:34
ballot box. I think this is my00:57:35
working hypothesis. And so far it is, at the very00:57:37
least, confirmed. Let's see what00:57:39
happens next. It seems to me that our case is00:57:40
more likely the second one. now to arrange00:57:43
some kind of fireworks and enchant the00:57:46
Voters with intrigue or loud00:57:48
promises or tell him that after00:57:49
the elections everything will change there is no need, the voter00:57:52
twitches so much from loud sounds Ravi00:57:54
filled the table and life is not nice to him, that’s us00:57:56
too In general, we see quite well based on00:57:59
sociological data Therefore, it is necessary00:58:01
pretend as if nothing special is00:58:04
happening, you know, like at the beginning of00:58:06
Chekhov’s story, Anna ours, where there she00:58:08
says that the wedding took place without special00:58:10
celebrations, yes And it’s boring to have fun when an Eighteen-year-00:58:12
old girl marries a00:58:13
fifty-year-old official, it’s boring to have00:58:15
fun when a seventy-year-old00:58:16
official goes to the same wedding for the fifth time00:58:18
position that excites you here00:58:20
you accept Why is this person here00:58:22
Even with the strangest inclinations00:58:24
can torture some kind of upsurge of feelings00:58:26
Therefore, it must be said that Well,00:58:29
again, horses at the crossing. Let's00:58:32
talk 125 times about the horses and about this00:58:34
unknown crossing, that is,00:58:36
invisibility is a means for00:58:38
the best or at least the least00:58:40
expensive00:58:43
overheard00:58:48
and I have time for one more question If for a moment Here is the00:58:52
same set of letters that I00:58:54
cannot read00:58:55
dear Ena Milona your colleague on the echo00:59:00
and on joint YouTube broadcasts Yulia00:59:02
Latynina is actively promoting the idea of the00:59:05
depravity of universal suffrage00:59:07
right, she believes that there must00:59:08
be an NS in different programs, she talks about00:59:11
different property in the army service, and00:59:13
so on. She is very consistent and00:59:15
logical in this. What, in your opinion, is the00:59:17
fallacy of the00:59:26
time given under the guts? There is no big chain; you can’t00:59:30
mince this stuff back; universal00:59:33
suffrage was with achieved by battles00:59:35
by humanity by the beginning of the00:59:37
10th century in most countries of the world00:59:39
it was introduced to cancel it00:59:41
will not work it is de facto and so limited by the fact00:59:44
that not everyone votes and in00:59:46
most elections not the00:59:48
majority of the list votes at all,00:59:52
not always and not so exceeds00:59:56
50% therefore the price exists and so this00:59:59
price is an educational de facto person is not01:00:01
able to understand what is happening there01:00:04
this price let’s say social01:00:06
certain social circles are interested in01:00:08
all this movement and others are not01:00:09
interested in it it is extremely far from them01:00:12
so there is no need for artificial qualifications01:00:13
conduct election campaigns in01:00:15
such a way as to attract the01:00:16
electorate that you need and you can,01:00:19
if you have01:00:21
state power, moderate01:00:22
your election legislation so01:00:24
as not to allow candidates or, more01:00:27
precisely, methods of running a company that are01:00:30
destructive for your political01:00:32
system; the political system already has01:00:34
enough tools in order to01:00:35
protect yourself, you don’t need to deprive people of their rights,01:00:38
especially since this is impossible, you won’t01:00:40
sell it, you understand this elephant, how can we01:00:42
now say that we know people without01:00:44
those who haven’t passed some test, we won’t01:00:46
let them vote Who are you01:00:48
Sorry for in order for this01:00:50
fundamental right to be01:00:51
taken away from a person on the basis of something, that is, my01:00:54
argument here is generally simple01:00:57
political in the most literal sense,01:00:59
it is impossible because this stage of01:01:01
social development has been passed, it is01:01:03
difficult to roll it back Well, we have already01:01:06
talked about the good news I asked in the01:01:08
Telegram channel Echo news from the editors01:01:11
that they consider the good news01:01:12
last week, everyone said that01:01:14
the war between Gaia did not take place. You see, this01:01:16
means that not only I really, again,01:01:18
let’s not renounce the countries behave01:01:22
differently, but these01:01:23
two wonderful01:01:25
states signed a joint01:01:27
declaration in which they oblige to01:01:29
refrain from violent actions01:01:31
against each other. At the same time, we must keep01:01:32
in mind that some time before01:01:34
this,01:01:37
American sanctions regarding its oil were partially lifted from Venezuela.01:01:41
Therefore, yes. Therefore, something is01:01:43
happening with our wonderful01:01:45
Venezuelan regime, which, as you01:01:46
wonderfully noted, is a fool, a fool but he01:01:49
doesn’t eat soap. Or rather, he eats soap01:01:51
exclusively for his own benefit, which01:01:53
means continuing to declare the difference in01:01:56
their positions in relation to this region and01:01:58
Sikib, nevertheless,01:02:00
they signed such a declaration together with the neighboring01:02:02
country, that is, really01:02:04
remember last time, I was still surprised01:02:05
how is it so Why do experts in the region01:02:07
say that there is no war There won’t be anyone and01:02:09
it’s just Madura doing PR, so to speak,01:02:11
we saw such PR I’m01:02:13
naturally scared by our own unfortunate01:02:15
experience But it seems we need to listen to01:02:17
regional experts, they really01:02:19
held a referendum, 95% got it,01:02:21
where did they get it from these 95 % is the01:02:23
secret of every autocracy,01:02:24
but nevertheless, and now there is no need to fight,01:02:26
that is, here is the best possible option.01:02:28
If, between us, our Russian01:02:30
leaders were a little01:02:32
smarter, they could also01:02:35
win people’s love in such01:02:38
non-invasive ways, but we have a01:02:41
program ends, this means it's01:02:42
time to put a like or even three likes01:02:45
on different three channels Thank you for01:02:47
watching, goodbye Thank you this was01:02:50
Ekaterina Shulman's program statusDescription:
Поддержать Живой гвоздь: с карт российских банков https://pay.cloudtips.ru/p/7edd7c0e с карт иностранных банков https://www.donationalerts.com/r/zhivgvozd Boosty: https://boosty.to/zhivoygvozd Криптокошелёк: bc1qmdt96xvsun9a8qxvgakfx9gqy4x72penx5rm2p Trust Wallet: https://link.trustwallet.com/send?address=bc1qmdt96xvsun9a8qxvgakfx9gqy4x72penx5rm2p&asset=c0 В эфире еженедельная авторская политико-просветительская программа Екатерины Шульман* @Ekaterina_Schulmann. Ведущий: Максим Курников. Архив записей и расшифровок программы «Статус» с 2017 по 2022 год: https://echofm.online//archive Ищите «Эхо» на Бусти и Патреоне. Оформите ежемесячную подписку — получите доступ к эксклюзивному контенту, общайтесь с друзьями «Эха» в нашем закрытом телеграм-чате и смотрите онлайн-трансляции Встреч «Эха». Бусти (для российских и международных карт) https://boosty.to/echofm Патреон (для международных карт) https://www.patreon.com/ECHOFM Мерч Евгения Ройзмана*: https://www.wildberries.ru/brands/2754267-royzman-ev Заказывайте мерч «Эха»: Российский магазин: https://echofm.myspreadshop.de/ÑÑо+бÑла+ÑÑжелаÑ+неделÑ?idea=64997b592bb2e40cb21749b4 Европейский магазин: https://echofm.myspreadshop.de/азбÑка?idea=651bea2bc116fd0fca27b5d6 Наборы стикеров теперь доступны и в России. Бесплатная доставка по стране! https://merchmag.ru/echofm/nakleyki-listovye/?page=1 «Тысяча и одна ночь». Встреча с Екатериной Шульман* и Арменом Захаряном 6 января в Берлине. Билеты: http://tinyurl.com/2p88mrwu , доступ к онлайн-трансляции https://boosty.to/echofm/posts/737e05d5-519a-47f9-8bab-57b5347a7bba?share=post_link Екатерина Шульман* в Телеграме: https://t.me/eschulmann Максим Курников в социальных сетях: https://t.me/kournikov https://twitter.com/kmvir * — Екатерина Шульман и Евгений Ройзман признаны российскими властями иностранными агентами Новый — пятый том комикса в серии «Спасти» уже в продаже! На этот раз авторы попытались вызволить из Тауэра наследников внезапно скончавшегося английского короля Эдуарда IV. Купить: https://diletant.shop/tproduct/596598185-351029717571-kniga-spasti-printsev-iz-tauera-tom-5 📌 Живой гвоздь в аудиоформате: https://podcast.ru/1616175210 🔔 Последние новости и анонсы программ с YouTube-канала «Живой гвоздь», а также контент от наших постоянных гостей и экспертов на официальном телеграм-канале: https://t.me/livegvozd Мобильное приложение "Эха": любимые программы в формате радиоприёмника. Простой интерфейс. Работа в фоновом режиме. Расписание эфиров. Скачать: в AppStore: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/%D1%8D%D1%85%D0%BE-online/id1639907671 в PlayMarket: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=online.echofm.app Сайт "Эха": https://echofm.online (если не открывается – ссылка на рабочую версию сайта всегда есть в тг-канале ЭХО FM https://telegram.org/ Подписаться на Youtube-канал Дилетант: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuIE7-5QzeAR6EdZXwDRwuQ?sub_confirmation=1 Магазин Дилетант: https://diletant.shop/ По вопросам взаимодействия: [email protected]
Preparing download options
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players
Questions about downloading video
How can I download "Статус. Екатерина Шульман* и Максим Курников / 19.12.2023 @Ekaterina_Schulmann" video?
http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.
Which format of "Статус. Екатерина Шульман* и Максим Курников / 19.12.2023 @Ekaterina_Schulmann" video should I choose?
The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.
Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Статус. Екатерина Шульман* и Максим Курников / 19.12.2023 @Ekaterina_Schulmann" video?
The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.
How can I download "Статус. Екатерина Шульман* и Максим Курников / 19.12.2023 @Ekaterina_Schulmann" video to my phone?
You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.
How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Статус. Екатерина Шульман* и Максим Курников / 19.12.2023 @Ekaterina_Schulmann"?
The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.
How can I save a frame from a video "Статус. Екатерина Шульман* и Максим Курников / 19.12.2023 @Ekaterina_Schulmann"?
This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.
What's the price of all this stuff?
It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.