Download "Правда Сноудена Фильм - Информационная безопасность.- Защита в интернете."
Please wait. We're preparing links for easy ad-free video watching and downloading.
Similar videos from our catalog
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252F0bwcmD5-4HE%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252F9780pqBRnqg%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F9l4T_7ipQ90%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FI8x5bl1Ww5U%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FLPjRQVG8z-k%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FUl0JAeRrzEE%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FaF1K-pdJc0c%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FaPon7WliM9k%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FyiTIy9Fqtbk%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FTDDsiegOq2M%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
Video tags
Subtitles
Russian
00:00:14
[music]00:00:47
at this stage you will have to take my00:00:50
word for it I work for the government and am00:00:53
connected with intelligence I hope you understand the00:00:56
risk I am running by communicating with00:00:59
you and agree to take all the00:01:00
precautions I have suggested00:01:03
believe me this is not a waste of time it is not00:01:07
difficult for someone familiar with the technique00:01:09
will take a couple of minutes, I want to make sure00:01:13
in non-email correspondence that the key00:01:14
we exchanged will not be00:01:17
intercepted or replaced, I'm00:01:19
waiting for confirmation that no one has a00:01:21
copy of your personal leverage, choose a strong00:01:24
password, your opponent is guessing00:01:27
passwords at a speed of 1 trillion options00:01:29
per second if the device on which00:01:31
the keys are stored where you enter the password00:01:33
will be hacked deciphering our00:01:35
correspondence will not be difficult these measures do not00:01:38
guarantee one hundred percent protection but gives00:01:41
us some room for maneuver and00:01:43
finally if the source materials are00:01:45
made public suspicion will immediately fall on00:01:47
me but this should not deter you from00:01:50
publishing the provided00:01:51
thank you for my information and be careful00:01:54
zenfone networks00:01:59
all these zenfone the truth of Snowden00:02:12
[music]00:02:16
and now let me sum up some00:02:18
only00:02:19
according to your words the snowball gives us the00:02:20
opportunity to check those facts we get Nastya00:02:22
which we doubt we eliminate00:02:24
surveillance from we are destroyed the chance00:02:27
to establish that this or that baht is not fabricated00:02:29
the authorities are right we are talking about00:02:32
creating an objective source for me00:02:34
it all comes down to the issue of independent00:02:36
control over the activities of the government00:02:38
so I come back to the problem00:02:41
again and again we will continue the conversation with00:02:46
David Orphans news release00:02:48
weather forecast estimates on the radio what types of00:02:50
dinnerbone00:02:57
hello can you hear me that I'm David, as00:03:01
you wish, well, from the very beginning, I want to00:03:07
remind you that Barack Obama himself touched on00:03:09
these issues when he was elected to the position00:03:12
he now holds in December of the00:03:14
seventh year, he said that the president00:03:16
does not have the authority to unilaterally00:03:19
authorize a military offensive in a00:03:21
situation where we are not talking about00:03:23
actual00:03:24
or an imminent threat to the nation,00:03:27
thus, according to Obama himself, according to00:03:28
the constitution, the president has no right to00:03:30
what he is doing now,00:03:31
why is this so important, on August 1, 2007,00:03:35
when he told why he decided to00:03:38
run for this position and00:03:39
why it is so important to change the existing00:03:41
structure, he said this that we cannot00:03:44
ignore the law just because00:03:46
it is inconvenient to us,00:03:47
we must again demonstrate to the world00:03:49
that the law is not subject to the whims of00:03:51
capricious rulers so00:03:54
that the president00:03:59
[music]00:04:10
[music]00:04:22
you ask why I chose you I didn’t00:04:25
choose you did it00:04:27
surveillance installed on you means00:04:29
that you have been selected and this term00:04:31
will become clearer when you learn how the00:04:33
modern system works, sits00:04:36
you know that every time you cross00:04:39
a border, make purchases, dial00:04:41
a number, drive past a cell tower,00:04:43
communicate with friends, write an article,00:04:46
visit a website and write00:04:48
emails or send the data you are00:04:50
controlled by the sister of the matches the coverage is00:04:52
unlimited because the protection is not00:04:54
flawless since you became a victim of the00:04:57
nb system then you are one of those few who00:05:00
are aware and can talk about the threat00:05:02
that the00:05:05
secret police unlimited in their means poses to democracy00:05:13
[music]00:05:25
[music]00:05:54
[music ]00:06:02
thank you for the invitation and for the00:06:04
opportunity to share00:06:06
my story,00:06:07
to begin with, having served myself a little for about00:06:11
four years in the armed forces, I00:06:13
almost immediately entered the MB00:06:16
and in general the complexity of my service00:06:18
is about 37 years, in general it was00:06:21
interesting and believe me, I liked00:06:23
solving puzzles and solving problems00:06:25
stuff like that and that’s what I was doing there,00:06:28
my work was related to data, I00:06:30
studied how the information00:06:31
system works and worked on the concept of00:06:34
analysis in which data00:06:35
is distributed in such a way that it00:06:37
can be encoded and processed00:06:39
electronically, that is, to00:06:40
automate the analysis process, we’re talking about00:06:43
metadata and the study of the relationship and00:06:46
approximately this was the scope of my00:06:48
VNB activities, I00:06:50
eventually came to this and I was the only one you were00:06:52
doing this one way or another,00:06:55
the terrorist attack of September 11 happened and and after it00:06:59
almost immediately two days later it may be00:07:02
a week after the events and they decided00:07:04
that they would start spying on everyone who00:07:06
lives in our country and they wanted the00:07:09
spying to be carried out by specialists from00:07:12
our program, so yes, that’s what they00:07:17
did,00:07:18
then they started collecting00:07:20
telecommunications data and went further00:07:22
to take at least these companies to go, which00:07:26
provided them with 320 million records a00:07:28
day, every 45 days, the program was re00:07:31
-approved as I called it by the00:07:34
committee, which included Aiden, mint, and00:07:37
our Department of Justice,00:07:39
this program was called stellar wind,00:07:42
first I turned to my friend from the00:07:45
House Intelligence Committee00:07:46
and she spoke with the00:07:49
chairman of the committee, Nancy Pelosi,00:07:50
the leader of the minority caucus00:07:53
they were all instructed on00:07:56
this program by the way and on everything00:07:58
else including various cr programs00:08:01
I was supported by four other members and00:08:05
we and all these years we worked in the00:08:07
government trying to convince them not to00:08:08
deviate from constitutional principles in00:08:12
particular to bring loans into the case by00:08:13
ensuring judicial oversight and we all00:08:17
naively believed that00:08:19
this was possible, but we were mistaken,00:08:23
moreover, after all our00:08:26
numerous efforts, they began to put pressure on us, shut00:08:29
our mouths and threaten us, all of our00:08:32
four were pursued at the same time, they00:08:35
didn’t come to me personally with weapons, I don’t know00:08:37
why they needed it00:08:42
[music]00:08:57
[music]00:08:59
Laura I’ll try to answer those of your00:09:02
questions that I can remember,00:09:04
forgive me for the confusion, I’m not a writer,00:09:06
besides, the letter was compiled in great00:09:08
haste, the stellar wind project00:09:12
is developing with the expanded nb group00:09:16
for operations with special sources,00:09:18
picking up the shaya of the stellar00:09:20
wind’s activities spread throughout around the world,00:09:23
covering almost all the territories of the United States,00:09:26
it is alarming that the range of00:09:28
American communication means00:09:30
controlled by ANB continues to00:09:32
expand. We complain that the crisis is00:09:34
growing. We ourselves continue to increase00:09:37
our access to personal information throughout00:09:40
our history, ANB has collected data in such volumes00:09:43
as Now I know the location of00:09:47
most data interception points,00:09:49
I have proof that the00:09:51
largest telecommunications companies00:09:53
in the United States are deceiving the trust of their customers, we are00:09:57
building the most powerful weapon of oppression in the00:09:59
history of mankind, its creators00:10:02
absolve themselves of all responsibility,00:10:05
nb director Keith Alexander00:10:08
lied to Congress and I can prove it to00:10:11
billions of communications connections in00:10:14
the USA are being intercepted, I collected00:10:17
primarily facts about violations of the rights of American00:10:19
citizens, but believe me, compared to00:10:22
what we do in other countries,00:10:23
Americans are in a privileged00:10:25
position,00:10:27
this I can also prove, the government00:10:31
claims that we still00:10:33
lack rules to regulate cyber00:10:35
operations, yet another yours we have a00:10:38
detailed policy of sorts of a00:10:40
marshal plan for cyber operations developed by the00:10:42
white house it is called presidential00:10:45
directive number twenty and was completed00:10:48
at the end of last year the00:10:49
evidence I also have is00:10:52
grateful to you for caring about my00:10:54
security nose I know how this00:10:57
will end for me and I am ready take a risk and if00:11:00
I'm lucky and you're careful you'll00:11:02
get everything you need I00:11:04
ask one thing for this information to00:11:05
reach the American public00:11:09
does a n b intercept electronic00:11:12
correspondence of American citizens no does00:11:17
pleo rb intercept telephone conversations00:11:22
of Americans no search queries no00:11:26
sms messages no orders on amazon.com00:11:31
no banking information no what00:11:35
legal permissions are required from AN00:11:38
to intercept communication00:11:40
connections and information relating to00:11:42
American citizens in the00:11:45
states, this requires requests from the FBI if00:11:48
we are talking about foreigners located in the00:11:49
USA, you also need a request from the FBI, which00:11:52
can work together with a nb or00:11:54
another intelligence agency, but in00:11:57
order to begin collecting data,00:12:00
we need the consent of the court and the court must00:12:04
approve the decision, we do not have such power,00:12:06
we do not do this, the us court of appeals,00:12:15
everyone stand up, the meeting of the00:12:19
court of appeals from the 9th circuit of the us begins, I00:12:22
ask everyone to sit down00:12:33
welcome to the Ninth Circuit and00:12:36
today our first case is Juan v.00:12:40
National Security Agency,00:12:41
you can proceed,00:12:46
honorable court, I am Kevin Paxton00:12:48
representing Carolyn Joel and ISO00:12:51
plaintiffs in this case, your honor, so our00:12:55
plaintiffs claim that the government00:12:58
received information about their00:12:59
communications connections, according to the00:13:02
district court, we could not bring00:13:05
facts indicating that our plaintiffs00:13:07
suffered damage of a00:13:08
different nature than all other00:13:10
clients and shades, and through the connection the00:13:13
records were intercepted,00:13:15
concluding that since everyone00:13:18
was subjected to surveillance, no one should00:13:20
sue, however, the refusal of the victims on00:13:23
such grounds means in general that the00:13:26
most harmful and massive00:13:28
government actions cannot be challenged00:13:30
if you have evidence that00:13:33
specifically your client’s connection00:13:37
was intercepted, we have00:13:40
evidence that all00:13:42
connections between the network and TNT and other00:13:45
networks in the north and the California communications center were intercepted,00:13:48
this respectively includes the00:13:50
Internet connection of our plaintiffs from00:13:52
northern California so they 100:13:55
thanks to you your part00:14:03
dear court I'll get rid of00:14:05
the Department of Justice here I represent00:14:07
the interests of the defendant we believe that this00:14:10
lawsuit should not be heard in00:14:12
federal court due to the fact that00:14:14
control of the political branches of government by the00:14:16
executive and legislative00:14:19
provides the optimal opportunity for00:14:23
successful resolution of issues related00:14:26
to the national policy of alleged00:14:28
surveillance that00:14:32
concerns the plaintiffs even if it is00:14:34
established that the interception of correspondence or00:14:37
telephone conversations of our plaintiffs is in no way00:14:40
related to national security in00:14:43
your honor, I do not00:14:44
know of cases where anyone has made00:14:46
claims how similar you are to the00:14:48
requirements of these two plaintiffs, we00:14:50
believe that it would be more effective to consider such claims00:14:53
brought against this defendant00:14:55
under the00:14:57
supervision of representatives of our00:14:59
government to prove and I wonder00:15:02
what role with such an approach you00:15:06
assign the judicial body to the court at00:15:09
gerson and I think they are not false to get in the way,00:15:11
the correct one, I understood the judge jump00:15:15
and I believe that there is a narrow00:15:17
category of cases in which the court00:15:19
can really, let’s say, step aside00:15:22
only when considering these cases,00:15:24
but you do not dispute the role of the courts in any00:15:28
case, yours than in our honor to the greater00:15:30
part, that is, we thought you were asking us to00:15:34
refuse this role00:15:36
is not your honor, the question of whether to consider00:15:39
this case remains at the discretion of the court, but00:15:42
we do believe that as00:15:43
this process continues, a00:15:46
number of issues will inevitably be raised involving00:15:48
classified information, which, as the00:15:51
director of national intelligence has already explained,00:15:53
can cause exceptional harm to00:15:55
national security,00:16:01
thank you for inviting if00:16:04
anyone - Do you have any questions, please00:16:06
just raise your hand and I will contact00:16:08
you as soon as I can,00:16:09
and so who has the feeling that he00:16:12
is being monitored and constantly, I00:16:16
probably have everyone here, I understood from00:16:19
almost everyone present how00:16:20
many of you were arrested and your phones were taken away00:16:22
back room on the day of the trial00:16:24
who had their iris scanned wow00:16:29
guys you are all here are kind of00:16:32
canaries in the mine because they are all qi00:16:34
ati you are directed against you saw00:16:37
advertisements in the subway attach a card to the00:16:39
metro credit cards to for auto replenishment00:16:41
so this is the concept that we00:16:44
will talk about today the so-called linking,00:16:46
we take one set of data and link00:16:48
it to another, for example, you have a00:16:51
metro card and a payment card and you can00:16:54
draw a line between them, so it00:16:55
would seem no big deal, but00:16:59
your bank card is linked to everything00:17:01
you do, now they know where you are00:17:03
you go to do some shopping, they are00:17:05
interested in you, they can00:17:07
recreate your every step using00:17:09
your metro card and credit card,00:17:11
they know where you went and what you bought and,00:17:13
in principle, by comparing this with the data of00:17:16
other people with a similar route, they00:17:19
can determine who you00:17:20
met, we take the data your cell phone00:17:22
which tracks your location00:17:24
and links it to your purchases,00:17:27
subway rides and your payments and00:17:29
receives so-called metadata00:17:32
covering a person’s entire life in00:17:34
total; this is a kind of00:17:36
content; they tell your story,00:17:38
which consists of facts but is not always00:17:41
truthful, here’s an example: you were on the corner00:17:44
streets where a crime was committed but this does00:17:46
not mean that you are a criminal here it is important00:17:48
to note that if someone considers you00:17:50
guilty of anything it will haunt00:17:53
you for the rest of your life so remember00:17:56
everything that is now being applied to you take00:17:58
fingerprints and iris scans00:18:00
photographs that's all will be used00:18:03
in the future to suppress people who are00:18:05
trying to resist changes and00:18:06
protest in a constitutional way and00:18:09
again a question for you Director Clapper00:18:12
about surveillance I hope we will limit ourselves to00:18:14
yes and no answers since Senator00:18:16
Feinstein wants to continue and is it true00:18:19
that A N B is collecting data on that or of00:18:22
any other nature about millions or hundreds of00:18:25
millions of Americans the king does not lead00:18:32
intentionally no except in some00:18:35
cases unintentionally perhaps led but00:18:40
intentionally not strictly00:18:55
[music] the00:19:07
encrypted archive will be in your00:19:09
hands within 7 days00:19:10
the key will be transferred when00:19:12
everything else is done analyze the00:19:16
provided it is beyond the00:19:20
power of one person to conduct the necessary investigation recommending that00:19:22
Glenn Greenwald be involved in the case,00:19:24
assuming you are familiar,00:19:28
outside the encrypted text00:19:30
my real name will be indicated, I will let you00:19:34
decide for yourself whether to report my00:19:37
participation in this case,00:19:38
personally, I would like all00:19:40
responsibility to be entrusted to me00:19:42
alone, no one, even the people closest to me,00:19:46
knows about my intentions,00:19:48
it will be dishonest if they come under00:19:50
suspicion from my actions,00:19:54
this can only be provided by you immediately pointing to00:19:57
me without trying to maintain my00:19:58
anonymity,00:20:03
now about the time of our meeting in00:20:05
Hong Kong, the first attempt to make sure00:20:08
will take place on Monday at ten in the morning00:20:10
local time we will meet in the lobby at the00:20:13
entrance to the restaurant in the hotel of the world00:20:17
you will recognize me I will solve a00:20:20
Rubik's cube come up to me and ask00:20:23
what time the restaurant opens and I will answer00:20:26
that I don’t know for sure I will advise you to ask at00:20:28
the reception and I will offer to conduct for you, this00:20:33
means that we recognized each other, all you00:20:35
have to do is follow me,00:21:15
how best to position yourself, you probably00:21:17
have a shooting plan, yes, I’ll move00:21:19
there, this lighting is better, okay, so00:21:28
this is where we can start, so we received00:21:34
from you only shocking materials,00:21:37
each of which is enough for reporting00:21:39
to us, even these materials on a number of00:21:43
specific documents can become00:21:45
a sensation, I want to try to break them00:21:47
into groups today, as soon as I woke up, I have already00:21:50
started preparing articles and I would like to00:21:53
tell them to include them in a day00:21:55
or two,00:21:56
yes, if this suits you, good as00:22:00
for topics that we need to discuss,00:22:03
I would divide them into two categories00:22:06
because there are things that I would like to00:22:10
talk about documents of their contents and00:22:13
Laura also has a number of questions about how to00:22:15
work with documents there are points00:22:17
that you can help us understand00:22:20
plus we have there is your story of which you were under00:22:23
such pressure, why did you do this,00:22:26
yes, I would start well with this, partly00:22:30
because only you can tell about it,00:22:32
yes, I suggest starting with this00:22:35
part of this part also because you00:22:38
shouldn’t delay with this, since there’s so much to everything00:22:42
reasons to start with this what are yours00:22:45
tell me how you came to this there00:22:47
is and there is one important point I already00:22:50
mentioned this in correspondence that00:22:52
modern media pay too much00:22:55
attention to the individual I agree and I am afraid00:22:58
that if we go down this path they00:23:02
will use it in my goals and I00:23:06
would not want this to happen and I00:23:08
continue to insist that this story is not00:23:10
about me00:23:12
you are worried about their poison they are useless00:23:15
cheap hands00:23:16
starladder.tv hands how it broke00:23:18
continue to me00:23:20
yes and I am ready to do everything for00:23:23
this to come out I don’t really know how the00:23:29
media works,00:23:30
what’s what, so I’ll have to00:23:34
learn on the go, and I would like to00:23:38
understand why you decided to do what you00:23:40
did for me, this is the question of00:23:43
whether the state can violate the rights of people,00:23:45
actively resist its power, I’m00:23:49
coming to the office every day and I get paid to00:23:52
develop methods00:23:54
that will strengthen the power of this state00:23:58
and I understand that if the election00:24:01
guarantees, the only thing that limits this power, are00:24:04
violated, then you have no00:24:07
means to resist unless you are the00:24:10
most sophisticated technical00:24:13
specialist in history world, I00:24:15
fear that no one, even the most00:24:18
talented, will00:24:19
have the strength alone to cope with00:24:23
brilliant minds and even the most00:24:25
mediocre employees00:24:27
who have such tools and00:24:29
means, so when I saw that the00:24:31
promises of the Obama administration were being violated,00:24:34
that its actions actually lead rather00:24:37
to strengthening00:24:38
the system that it promised everyone eradicate00:24:41
with forces reduce contain00:24:45
that everything has worsened take at least00:24:47
the drones that I learned about in the vnb where00:24:50
we watched video from their cameras on work00:24:52
monitors what I saw and formed00:24:58
my decision in real time in00:25:00
real time, that is, a low-quality video stream00:25:03
is sent directly to the desktop00:25:06
usually this was observational data, but00:25:08
there are also killer drones that00:25:11
fly out to bomb a drone00:25:13
can follow something at home for00:25:16
many hours and you don’t know someone’s house00:25:18
because you don’t have complete00:25:20
information in front of you is a page that00:25:23
lists data from drones in00:25:25
various countries with different code00:25:27
names and you click on any and00:25:30
watch the video00:25:33
clearly so you are sincerely interested in00:25:37
living in a world where the right to00:25:38
privacy is00:25:39
strictly respected but at the same time00:25:42
your actions threaten you with prison where this00:25:44
right will be completely negated how00:25:47
you came to in order to sacrifice00:25:48
personal comfort for the sake of publicity, I remember00:25:52
what the Internet was like before it began to be00:25:54
controlled, this is a unique period in the00:25:56
history of mankind,00:25:57
let's say the most ordinary children from one part of00:26:02
the world could have an equal discussion in00:26:05
which they could firmly count on00:26:09
respect for their ideas and expression with00:26:12
leading experts from another part of the00:26:14
world on any topic wherever and however they want,00:26:17
whenever they want,00:26:20
freely, no restrictions, and we saw00:26:23
how all this began to fade away, how00:26:26
the model changed to the side of self-restraint of00:26:29
their opinion, people began to joke00:26:32
that they could be included in the list because of their00:26:35
statements on political topics or00:26:37
harsh remarks on forums, it has become common for us to00:26:40
suspect that we are being watched;00:26:43
many of my friends said that00:26:46
they think about it before typing a query00:26:48
in the search bar, I know that it will be00:26:50
saved, which narrows the00:26:52
scope of their intellectual research and00:26:57
I would rather take the risk of00:27:04
conclusion or others negative00:27:07
consequences for me personally than I agree to00:27:11
put at risk00:27:13
my own intellectual freedom and the00:27:16
freedom of those around me whose lives are00:27:19
no less important to me than my own00:27:23
and once again I want to emphasize that I am not00:27:25
sacrificing myself,00:27:27
I feel satisfaction from the knowledge00:27:31
that I can make a contribution in the common good,00:27:51
let's talk about this in more detail, yes, I don’t know00:27:56
how aware you are about the programs as00:27:59
well as about their real technical00:28:00
capabilities, but there is an00:28:02
infrastructure both in the USA and throughout the00:28:04
world00:28:05
that nb created in cooperation with00:28:10
other countries,00:28:12
it intercepts almost all00:28:18
digital connections, all radios connections00:28:21
all analog connections that00:28:25
its equipment can record and with00:28:30
such capabilities, in fact, the entire huge00:28:34
variety of00:28:35
connections based on computer00:28:39
communications and between different devices, that00:28:42
is, informal communication between people are00:28:45
tracked automatically without00:28:48
targeting, and this allows you to00:28:51
retroactively search for your00:28:54
connections based on the most confirmations,00:28:57
for example, if I want to know the contents of00:29:01
your correspondence or I don’t know00:29:05
your wife’s telephone conversations, and so on, I can00:29:08
use the so-called00:29:10
selector, that is, any element of the00:29:15
communication chain00:29:17
that can accurately or almost accurately00:29:20
identify your identity, this could00:29:22
be email addresses and IP00:29:25
addresses, telephone numbers credit cards, even00:29:29
passwords that no00:29:31
one except you uses, I can enter this00:29:35
data into the system and it will not only00:29:37
look through the entire database and tell you where I could have00:29:40
met this data before, but essentially00:29:44
conducts an additional level of surveillance00:29:46
that covers the future, that is,00:29:49
if it is a fact will be discovered now or in the00:29:52
future information must be transmitted00:29:54
to me immediately in real00:29:56
time00:29:57
information that you are communicating with someone00:30:03
I know practically nothing about you00:30:07
for I work for Guzal in Hamilton00:30:12
this is a defense contractor for the KNB I am attached00:30:16
temporarily but I am not I communicate with the management of00:30:19
bu zalim does not receive any assignment, everything comes from00:30:21
n.b. sorry didn't catch your name and00:30:24
forgive me my name is edward snowden00:30:27
can you stand edward joseph snowden00:30:31
full of them from where are you from so that00:30:37
means you were born in north00:30:40
carolina in the small town of elizabeth city00:30:43
there is a coast guard station there i'm00:30:46
from the family military but I spent most of my00:30:48
childhood driving a Ford I won’t give it to the state of00:30:50
Maryland your family how this will turn out00:30:56
for her this is perhaps the most00:31:01
painful moment my family doesn’t know00:31:03
what’s going on I didn’t tell them I don’t00:31:08
think I can maintain the family00:31:13
ties that I I managed to acquire it, I don’t00:31:19
want them to be somehow connected with all00:31:21
this, I leave it to you to decide what00:31:25
to publish and what data to keep, I00:31:27
count on your responsibility,00:31:30
but I assume that the closer I am to00:31:34
my family,00:31:35
the more likely it is that they will be00:31:37
pressured, that is, I should not be published, of00:31:39
course, of course, we will do everything in00:31:41
our power not to put ourselves at00:31:44
risk in Asia, yes, of course, yes, I understand everything,00:31:47
forgive me, but I suggest we pause for a moment to00:31:50
sort out the documents and then00:31:52
we will continue, of course, what I need00:31:55
will need an email address or00:31:57
but since since you have encrypted00:32:00
the letter, you can send it from wherever00:32:03
you want, the most important thing is to00:32:05
encapsulate the data in such a way00:32:08
that they cannot be decrypted and00:32:09
read during the transfer of the settlement00:32:12
or reception at one of the two endpoints,00:32:15
you should know that these documents will be00:32:17
downloaded before 72 understand how to use00:32:21
this process for different purposes it seems00:32:24
that it is difficult I am not so then I am00:32:27
waiting for your instructions and00:32:30
show me the current folder structure00:32:32
where the files are stored00:32:36
how many documents you said there are only00:32:39
7 while you are with them ultra tough if you want00:32:42
we can how many documents are we00:32:47
talking about when garden worked with wikileaks,00:32:49
our technicians created a system thanks to00:32:51
which access to the data was open to everyone00:32:53
and I’m thinking about whether we can do the00:32:57
same; this, of course, would be an ideal option,00:33:00
but since some of these00:33:05
documents are officially classified, their00:33:08
disclosure threatens the safety of people and00:33:10
technology, I’m quite sure your00:33:13
technical ability to protect them, that is,00:33:16
you can threaten not to shoot or00:33:18
torture me, I won’t be able to reveal the password even00:33:20
if I wanted to, well, yes, I have enough skills for this, a00:33:24
number of journalists are also capable of this,00:33:28
but their circle is very limited,00:33:31
and that’s the main question: can00:33:34
organization to protect such information in00:33:38
such a way as not to be at00:33:41
risk of uncontrolled leakage00:33:43
but he but I’m ready to come to terms with it seriously I don’t00:33:46
want to be the one who decides00:33:49
what can be talked about and what can’t be talked about that’s why00:33:51
I don’t publish the material I myself don’t00:33:55
speak openly00:33:56
but act through journalists so that00:33:59
my opinion so that my position, since00:34:02
I have a strong conviction,00:34:04
are left out of brackets and public00:34:07
interests are represented with00:34:09
maximum objectivity, and by the way,00:34:12
given your awareness of00:34:18
the situation in the UK,00:34:20
I will say that the government communications center00:34:24
has created00:34:26
perhaps the most aggressive program for00:34:31
intercepting network data in world and I00:34:35
name tempor a t e m p o and this is the00:34:39
world’s first full coverage, which means00:34:42
collecting information that complements the data00:34:44
on all articles, this is how I would like to00:34:49
structure the further conversation if you don’t00:34:51
mind,00:34:52
you’ve already found out what you’re waiting for00:34:55
then I would like to go back00:34:59
to finish the articles00:35:00
and we also have a lot of documents not00:35:03
related to the first stories, I would like to00:35:06
discuss them, of course, so that then I can move on to I do00:35:08
n’t have a couple of minutes, I can check00:35:12
from the diary for you, I’ll look at the whole00:35:15
schedule for you don’t mind, the raven00:35:17
can’t do it if you want00:35:29
come00:35:33
hello, yes, everything was very tasty,00:35:39
thank you very much, no, I still have some left, perhaps00:35:46
we’ll give it later, so I do00:35:47
n’t need anything else, yes, great, thank you very much,00:35:52
goodbye, now we’ll fix it, it00:35:58
won’t take long, it’s interesting, I told00:36:04
Laura on the phone and00:36:06
these built-in protocols work not computers from which a00:36:09
microphone can be recorded, even00:36:10
when the handset is down, even if it’s just00:36:13
plugged into the network,00:36:14
you could be wiretapped, I don’t understand how00:36:16
I didn’t think about this before, there are00:36:18
many ways in which everything00:36:21
that happens here can end up in the00:36:23
public domain like this that we have to00:36:25
take this into account because yes, I think you are right,00:36:28
you have a computer with air balloons,00:36:30
you can get it by00:36:35
the way, you decided when the00:36:38
printing of 1 article will be handed over, they will be published in London00:36:41
at seven eight in the morning, well,00:36:47
look at your00:36:56
nails, here’s another one, let’s00:37:00
never leave again identical sd cards00:37:02
in laptops for the future at least you knew that00:37:11
it’s still in yours in your laptop00:37:15
and everything is clear okay I just in00:37:17
case I understood yes here’s a treasure ok00:37:21
thank you you will have a new archive that00:37:23
looks exactly the same as the old one for you it00:37:25
will be necessary to mark it somehow, you can00:37:29
pass me my invisibility cloak00:37:32
now, otherwise00:37:40
this is in case of possible filming before it’s about00:37:44
video surveillance, I think at this stage you00:37:53
can’t do anything in the USA Kerry,00:37:55
we’ve all become a little you in today00:37:59
told me something like I’ll00:38:01
never leave a single device in my room again in my life,00:38:03
and I’ve got it, you’ve become00:38:05
infected with paranoia, it happened to00:38:06
all of us, he said that again, I wo00:38:11
n’t leave a single device in my room00:38:13
without a press, and I can barely carry mine, shine in00:38:19
it, all the gadgets00:38:20
are all yours bad influence so I00:38:22
need you to see the00:38:23
administrator password because I don’t know it00:38:28
if you want to throw on a cloak please don’t be00:38:30
shy no I go in your passwords00:38:33
only four characters00:38:34
should I use sometimes clay but this is00:38:37
for one time yes everything is correct before he00:38:40
was longer but when I found out that it was00:38:42
needed for one session I chose the password00:38:44
in short it's wrong but actually no00:38:47
I already tried to explain this to Laura before that's the00:38:50
point because your00:38:51
computer has a mac address if anyone00:38:54
can identify your device00:38:56
but I couldn’t, considering that your material00:38:59
will upset them very much,00:39:00
so you can become a priority for them.00:39:15
so the fire alarm00:39:21
is clear, it looks like it’s a regular00:39:25
three-second one, and check it out, or maybe00:39:29
call the reception to find out, well, I don’t00:39:33
think it’s anything serious at all,00:39:35
although it’s interesting that this has already happened,00:39:37
maybe they’re angry that they00:39:39
can’t listen to us through the phone anymore, and00:39:44
they used to they turned on the alarm,00:39:45
no, this happened the first time,00:39:47
but just in case, we need to check if00:39:50
they have something connected to all this unusually,00:39:57
maybe we need it, so much the better00:40:00
and ignore it, then we need it00:40:04
before it was turned off,00:40:06
I meant if it turns on again00:40:13
now we let's go down to tell us they00:40:15
beat us, yeah, so let's00:40:21
forget about it for a while, let's finish things up,00:40:35
they're unlikely to answer them now00:40:38
7,000 people are calling, hello, there's00:40:44
something ringing on the tenth floor, can00:40:45
you tell me what happened, it's clear and clear,00:40:51
great, thank you, goodbye,00:40:54
check the fire alarm,00:40:57
yes yes yes, well that’s what we wanted, how nice00:41:00
of them that they didn’t forget00:41:02
to warn us, I’ll give you a little00:41:10
tour when the ENT saw this, her00:41:13
mouth started watering and she couldn’t tear herself away00:41:15
from these gifts, we’ll try to control ourselves, I’m00:41:18
sure it will work out, okay, for starters00:41:21
some explanations, a00:41:22
short overview of how all this is00:41:23
organized, here are a couple of interesting00:41:25
documents, the main goal of the 2nd archive is00:41:29
to draw attention to s o as00:41:31
opposed to00:41:32
prism, generally speaking, the sensor00:41:35
works from a spoke with sources, it00:41:37
passively collects data from networks around the00:41:39
world,00:41:40
that is both American and00:41:42
foreign, various methods are used for this,00:41:45
but one of the main ones is00:41:48
cooperation with corporations, both00:41:50
local and international companies00:41:52
with a base in the USA, they can be forced to00:41:55
cooperate or simply pay them,00:41:57
they can also offer00:41:59
mutually beneficial deals to the authorities of other00:42:01
countries on approximately the following conditions we00:42:03
install a system for you, you give us00:42:06
access to all the data, you see here we have00:42:10
much more data here than00:42:13
one person or team could collect exquise00:42:17
cardiff dive or just x [ __ ] and here00:42:20
we have a huge folder with documents on its00:42:22
work,00:42:23
this system allows the analyst to00:42:27
navigate in the boundless ocean of00:42:29
raw data, the segment here has everything00:42:32
you need for searching in retrospect but00:42:34
also in real time for marking00:42:36
objects exquise corr interface for00:42:38
all this I want to show you one slide00:42:41
that00:42:43
ENT and it turned out to be very important, I talked00:42:45
about the fact that these tools become more and more over time00:42:49
more and more powerful,00:42:52
very clearly in fiscal year 2011,00:42:55
they were able to monitor 1 billion00:42:57
telephone Internet connections00:42:59
simultaneously on each of these00:43:02
devices and they collected data at a00:43:05
speed of about 100 25 gigabytes per00:43:07
second, which is you robits of each00:43:10
of these devices of each of the devices00:43:12
on and how many devices were there at that00:43:16
time? There were 20 points00:43:18
10 at the bases of the Ministry of Defense, but this00:43:22
data is outdated, we00:43:24
are developing rapidly, but even 20 points are already 2000:43:29
billion, as you can see, all this needs to be00:43:31
published at least so that people00:43:33
can imagine their capabilities, this is00:43:37
obvious don’t let them be science fiction, all00:43:40
this is happening in reality, no, I’m talking00:43:42
rather about the scale of all this, and00:43:44
although this is an absolutely inaccessible00:43:47
technical document,00:43:48
even in this form it’s deafening,00:43:52
you know what I’m talking about00:43:53
at this point, it would be worth it to have a00:43:55
debate about whether we want we want the authorities to say that00:43:58
all this is so unusual, such a scale, it’s00:44:01
amazing for even if you know it,00:44:03
you know what happens when you see all00:44:06
these schemes in reality, so to speak in00:44:09
technical terms, it00:44:10
just makes an indelible00:44:12
impression, this is what it needs00:44:20
on the air, news prices, new sensational00:44:24
report again brings back concerns that the00:44:26
right to privacy is being violated for00:44:29
security reasons a00:44:30
court order has been made public00:44:33
giving a n b full access to the00:44:35
data of millions of We00:44:37
Raise customers on a daily basis I was00:44:39
lucky enough to record the first00:44:41
television interview with the reporter who brought00:44:44
this story to the world Glenn Greenwald from garden00:44:48
congratulations on the sensation explain to our00:44:50
viewers why this is so important is because00:44:54
people have realized that the law under which this is00:44:57
done, the Patriot Act, passed00:44:59
after 9/11,00:45:00
gives the government extremely broad00:45:02
powers to collect data on people without00:45:05
reasonable grounds for suspicion00:45:07
required by traditional00:45:09
standards00:45:10
under the Patriot Act00:45:12
if there is suspicion that you are involved00:45:14
in Is it a crime of terrorism that the authorities00:45:16
can collect information on you? Why are00:45:19
we so alarmed by this00:45:21
court decision? It is aimed not only at those00:45:23
people who are suspected of00:45:25
crimes or participation in00:45:26
terrorist activities. It00:45:28
allows the recording of calls from each of00:45:31
Verizon's clients, as well as00:45:34
wiretapping of conversations, both00:45:36
international and local. covering00:45:38
everyone indiscriminately, in fact, this program00:45:41
is aimed at collecting data about all00:45:42
Americans00:45:43
and not just those who have reason to00:45:45
suspect00:46:46
of something; it is very difficult to find out that the00:46:51
person you love with whom you00:46:53
lived together for 10 years may not return00:47:00
why didn’t they ask00:47:04
when we last saw each other where00:47:07
now00:47:08
what am I doing and what does she know about my00:47:12
illness in this regard, yes, so they are00:47:20
quite knowledgeable00:47:22
since I’m definitely not on sick leave00:47:48
hello good afternoon hello00:47:51
whiner now I’ll leave the Internet but00:47:57
as it is news00:48:01
and news and what kind of truth we had00:48:04
guests today, it seems just a couple of hours00:48:07
ago that someone came to your house and00:48:13
women from the personnel department design b it’s00:48:15
unlikely she’s from she’s not from the hut Zolin because there00:48:19
was a policeman with her, he’s clearly from the00:48:21
police n. b.00:48:22
regular police wouldn't try to00:48:24
break into my house your girlfriend lives there00:48:28
yes she lives there I told the genius00:48:30
to cooperate with them00:48:32
one second I can't find the phone and do00:48:35
n't worry about anything now wait I'll00:48:37
get everything we need okay00:48:40
listen well it's you it was worth expecting,00:48:42
yes, I was preparing for it, you just know00:48:45
when a blow falls on your loved ones and you00:48:47
find out about it, it’s another winter, and of course,00:48:50
maybe they just noticed that you00:48:53
disappeared, I know the probability is not too00:48:56
likely, yes, but they’re unlikely to00:49:03
go, you’re lying,00:49:08
forgive me today somehow she didn’t care about00:49:10
her appearance, how she00:49:15
reacted relatively calmly,00:49:17
relatively calmly, the weight is what you are00:49:20
doing and the page doesn’t know anything and00:49:23
therefore, although I feel very unpleasant, this is the only way00:49:28
I can at 9 and they didn’t00:49:31
order anything, something like I need to leave00:49:33
I can’t explain the reason to you or you00:49:35
just disappeared waiting until she went00:49:37
on vacation I left her a note that I00:49:41
need to leave for a while in my work00:49:43
this happens no no clearly these are the00:49:45
things00:49:46
I can ask you a couple of questions they00:49:49
can check your things to find out what00:49:51
you took it, but they may generally00:49:59
suspect something, but it’s doubtful00:50:02
what exactly, yes, because I cast00:50:04
such a big net that if they00:50:06
guess you, they will inevitably have a00:50:08
heart attack, they will decide the guy had00:50:10
access to everything and they are unlikely to understand that00:50:12
it was me I did, I think that they will experience00:50:16
relief, although all this still will00:50:21
not cause them great joy when they00:50:23
saw that my revelations reflect00:50:24
trends, that I do not give any00:50:26
lists indicating names and positions,00:50:28
it is true, and yet I think that they will probably00:50:31
have enough paranoia and that they will00:50:34
prepare for the worst and this may well00:50:37
force them to turn to methods that are not entirely, let’s00:50:40
say, rational. I agree,00:50:44
but at the same time it seems to me that now00:50:47
their hands are tied, yes, I agree, I00:50:50
had time to prepare everything in such a way00:50:52
that we would all be at least at least00:50:54
minimally protected regardless of00:50:56
who will be involved all this let's say you00:50:59
magazine virgo a kind of immunity so00:51:01
we have time to play on00:51:03
this before they become dangerous for us it will00:51:05
take weeks before their lawyers,00:51:07
as always, lead their song this is a00:51:09
special situation how can we turn it00:51:11
to our advantage, we00:51:13
have already seen more than once how they do this, be00:51:15
it drones or wiretapping and so00:51:17
on, as the law of 1840 states,00:51:20
nature is such and such,00:51:22
but it takes time and it requires00:51:25
effort and and besides, I believe that the00:51:27
more publicly we behave as00:51:30
journalists, the more we will be protected.00:51:33
You have already thought about when you are ready00:51:36
to speak, I am ready as soon as I can honestly00:51:41
say, I believe that this should in no way00:51:43
prevent the publication of my materials for00:51:45
me this is the most important point, I would not00:51:47
want to draw attention to myself00:51:50
before it is necessary based on the00:51:52
development of the situation from the publications00:52:14
[music]00:52:27
[music]00:52:33
we are talking about tens of millions of00:52:35
Americans who were not00:52:37
suspected of anything but who were00:52:39
monitored00:52:48
on air news cnn published a new00:52:53
scandalous article, this time in the00:52:55
washington post newspaper, a sensational report00:52:57
exposes another large-scale00:52:59
secret government program,00:53:01
both the washington post and garden in00:53:04
london report that the nb fbi has00:53:07
direct access to the central server of 900:53:09
leading internet companies including00:53:12
microsoft00:53:13
yahoo google facebook and wahl skype00:53:16
youtube and00:53:17
apple, as the author claims, they transmit00:53:20
audio-video00:53:21
photographs letters, log documents by00:53:23
an analyst to track00:53:26
proposals and a person’s circle of contacts,00:53:28
let’s discuss the latest revelation,00:53:30
we are little by little starting to get used to them00:53:32
bilby is not a former employee of a n b who00:53:34
quit in 2001 due to the fact that00:53:37
what happened there now you are known as a00:53:39
whistleblower beat what can you say00:53:41
about the article in the washington post00:53:43
I believe this is just a continuation of a long-standing00:53:46
course of action that is, you are not surprised, but do00:53:48
you think through whom00:53:51
the leak could have occurred I don’t know who00:53:53
did it but I have no doubt that00:53:54
the administration will launch an investigation not00:53:57
against the people who established the program,00:53:59
but against those who leaked the information.00:54:01
I’m not surprised that the companies are00:54:04
denying everything. I won’t say that there00:54:06
may be some technical00:54:08
basis that allows them to say that they are00:54:11
not actively cooperating with the authorities or00:54:13
that in their understanding the government is not00:54:15
has direct access to servers, but I have00:54:18
had to talk more than once with different00:54:20
people who, sitting at a table through a web00:54:23
portal, typed commands and00:54:25
accessed servers remotely, so whatever you00:54:29
call it, the fact remains a fact, I00:54:31
can call this the most blatant00:54:33
violation of the civil rights of Americans00:54:35
for the whole story here's00:54:36
what's interesting today the New York Times00:54:39
wrote that the administration has lost the00:54:41
trust of citizens the New York Times00:54:42
attacked President Obama this is00:54:45
nothing new they attacked Bush00:54:47
and when he tried to protect the country we00:54:49
must not let our guard down or we00:54:51
will be attacked again we already saw00:54:54
in boston remember people were ready to00:54:56
sacrifice their freedoms they needed to00:54:58
escape to a little play00:55:00
devil's advocate how to live and believe in00:55:02
freedom if we have secret courts and00:55:04
secret operations such as prism00:55:06
secret investigations recording00:55:09
every sneeze every spit of every00:55:10
American00:55:11
without putting the public is aware of00:55:13
this, in your opinion, this freedom in 2008 was00:55:16
taken from us and canceled warrants for00:55:18
wiretapping conversations, with the exception of00:55:20
those with Americans in the00:55:22
United States, that is, now they do not00:55:24
need permission to wiretap those00:55:27
who are outside the country or00:55:30
for Americans on territories of the00:55:31
United States who00:55:32
negotiate with people located in00:55:35
other countries and again emphasize the00:55:37
fact that no one checks or00:55:39
controls the activities of nb means00:55:41
that they can do whatever they00:55:43
want and since their work is surrounded by a00:55:45
veil of secrecy and those who are ready00:55:47
to reveal their secrets are intimidated even when00:55:50
they break the law we have no chance of00:55:51
knowing until we00:55:53
begin to investigate and00:55:55
provide absolute transparency with00:55:56
our government Glenn00:55:58
Greenwald congratulations again on this00:56:00
scoop thank you for your comment00:56:38
and I have heard from lenses and She's00:56:54
already been alive for a long time and is free. Apparently, the rent for the00:56:57
apartment doesn't reach00:56:59
the landlords. We were told that if we don't00:57:04
pay within five days, we'll be evicted.00:57:06
It's strange, because I have an automatic00:57:08
payment transfer system set up;00:57:13
there are also construction vehicles across the street from my house.00:57:15
so that it means I00:57:21
wonder what I’m not looking for00:58:04
mixed feelings, it’s00:58:09
hard for me to describe or express them in00:58:13
words because you don’t know what will happen00:58:17
tomorrow in an hour in a week you feel00:58:21
fear and some strange freedom you00:58:23
understand me the planning stage was00:58:27
easier I didn’t have to take into account00:58:29
just different factors, just take one more step00:58:31
after it, calls00:58:35
are recorded through digital channels, not00:58:37
content, only data about where and00:58:39
where the call was made, as it turned out, the authorities00:58:42
have direct access to the servers of large00:58:44
Internet companies,00:58:45
as the government proves that this is00:58:47
necessary for national00:58:49
security purposes and is not a violation of00:58:51
privacy is a00:58:54
difficult question because, as Pete00:58:56
mentioned, yesterday around midnight the00:58:58
director of00:59:00
national intelligence announced a00:59:02
leak of information about them, there is panic00:59:05
in the intelligence committee,00:59:06
leaders of both parties have already announced00:59:09
support for the administration, the00:59:11
government communications center has its own00:59:12
Wikipedia on the most closed most00:59:15
classified level00:59:16
where every intelligence officer can00:59:18
find everything he needs,00:59:20
I’m sharing with you this information, it’s your business00:59:22
to decide what you need and what you don’t, it00:59:25
contains documents of different types,00:59:27
pictures, documents, powerpoint word, and so00:59:29
on, forgive the necessary squat, yes,00:59:34
sorry for interrupting,00:59:36
that means these documents show there00:59:40
are documents on our topic in one00:59:42
of the sections of, say, the tempor document and a number of other00:59:44
issues, this is a separate Wikipedia article, it00:59:46
also talks about an original00:59:49
tool called you dug yu dak is a00:59:52
mechanism for searching data across the entire00:59:55
array of material in surveillance then00:59:57
troubleshooting page projects00:59:59
for certain tools can be described01:00:01
thank you01:00:03
what is our next step when you are thinking of01:00:06
making yourself known and are you I think now01:00:09
soon events will unfold01:00:11
truly rapidly as soon as they01:00:13
begin to shift attention to us01:00:15
which can happen at any minute I01:00:19
will open up to tell them and guys this is01:00:22
not a question from which you can01:00:25
hide in the shadows this is a public matter01:00:27
not my personal01:00:29
this is the business of each of us and I am not afraid of you01:00:32
you will not make me silent like you could01:00:35
make everyone else and since everyone01:00:38
continues to remain silent I will say I believe that01:00:40
after me, no matter what you do to me,01:00:42
someone will appear who will do the same on01:00:45
the Internet, this principle is called hydra,01:00:48
as soon as you run over one of us,01:00:50
7 new roads will immediately appear and yet you01:00:56
are worried, actually no, I think that01:01:02
this stress does not scare me to a greater01:01:07
extent because I knew what I was going into before,01:01:10
since I voluntarily went for it, I have01:01:16
already gotten01:01:18
used to this idea, it doesn’t scare me,01:01:21
if we break down the door, I’ll probably be01:01:23
scared, but until this happens,01:01:26
I’m holding on less began to eat that's all that that's01:01:31
all that has changed01:01:39
let's discuss the timing of when you will reveal the01:01:41
secret of your identity yes we must01:01:45
discuss everything because this01:01:48
question worries me yes I'm listening to you the thing is that01:01:52
if we reveal the cards I know that you are01:01:56
sure that you will figure out in any case01:01:59
and that this will happen very soon today01:02:02
in the New York Times, Charlie Savage, our01:02:05
charming Sherlock Holmes of political01:02:07
reporting, concluded by deduction that a01:02:10
continuous series of leaks indicates that there is01:02:12
one person behind all this,01:02:14
otherwise he quoted you as saying that it is one from01:02:16
your reader before or and others01:02:17
assume that overall this is good I01:02:20
want people I want people to know that01:02:22
this is one person I want to01:02:25
prepare our public for the idea that this is a01:02:27
person with a certain set of01:02:29
political beliefs who wants the01:02:32
world to know about what happens at the same time,01:02:34
I maintain your complete anonymity01:02:36
and I want to start introducing people to you, so01:02:39
to speak, gradually, but what01:02:41
worries me is that if we just01:02:44
come out and say here is the person who01:02:46
did everything that we talked about in01:02:48
essence, we will do it for the government01:02:51
his work, that is, it turns out that we01:02:53
will give them your confession and help01:02:57
them establish the source of the leak, that is,01:02:59
maybe you are right, maybe they will quickly find you and01:03:01
be able to find out everything, but what if01:03:03
we fail, then it turns out that we are01:03:06
giving them all the trump cards or or and everyone already01:03:10
knows it’s hiding it because they don’t01:03:12
want to or don’t know and we’ll tell them everything01:03:14
so if the likelihood is that it would take them01:03:16
two or three months of work and we’ll solve01:03:19
this problem for them or let me01:03:22
finish, maybe it’s not important for you maybe that's what01:03:25
you want,01:03:26
maybe you want to open up not because01:03:29
you're going to get caught and you need to get ahead of01:03:32
them, you're opening up because you want to be01:03:34
heard clearly, that's what it's01:03:37
all about, I don't want to hide or01:03:39
hide, I don't have to do that, there01:03:42
's certainly a reason for it but I01:03:44
think it’s a sign of strength to come out and tell01:03:47
them and I’m not afraid of you and others01:03:50
shouldn’t have you either01:03:51
just a week ago I was sitting in the office next01:03:53
to you, we’re all interested in this, this is01:03:56
our country,01:03:57
but now the balance of power between citizens01:03:59
and the government has become balanced between the01:04:02
managers and the governed, instead of a01:04:04
balance between01:04:05
electing them and the voters, it’s clear that’s what I01:04:09
wanted to hear, that is, that’s not the point at all,01:04:12
no, I want to finish, I don’t think that01:04:15
there is a possibility that I01:04:16
will never be discovered at all, it’s just a matter of01:04:18
time, maybe it will take a lot of time01:04:21
although I doubt it, I didn’t even try to01:04:24
cover my tracks since from the very beginning01:04:25
I intended to come out in the open, well01:04:27
today I’m publishing a general article on the defense of the01:04:31
Rochon whistleblowers in it I’ll mention01:04:33
you and without breaking your identity01:04:36
I’ll deal with it as soon as I return and at the same time01:04:38
I intend to send it away to all those who01:04:40
insist on the need for investigations, I01:04:42
want this to be an01:04:43
apologia for fearlessness in the face of intimidation tactics,01:04:46
so that everything we do will be carried out01:04:49
under this sign, this is wonderful,01:04:51
I like your principles and I fully01:04:53
support we are turning inside out the01:04:56
model imposed on us by the government01:04:58
when the person who wants to speak01:05:00
the truth must hide hide in the01:05:03
shadows speak anonymously and so on I01:05:05
agree that’s what the plan will be I’ll sum it01:05:10
up since we all here believe that this is exactly how it01:05:12
should be under this matter you yourself01:05:15
feel the power of your chosen one understand01:05:17
me01:05:18
yes I want everyone to feel this power01:05:20
I'm asleep and01:05:21
this is a real challenge, a bold challenge has been thrown01:05:24
and in their face I won't hide for01:05:27
a single second, I won't, I'll tell01:05:30
you everything in your eyes, yes, I need01:05:31
an investigation, investigate nothing here,01:05:34
I'm facing war and the truth, and I think that01:05:37
this is a very strong position and01:05:39
only one question arises: how can we achieve the01:05:42
maximum effect, yes, but this is my01:05:44
task and I will complete it,01:05:46
so this morning I am publishing my article,01:05:49
unless the garden backs down, then01:05:52
the article comes out in the morning to01:05:54
maintain the momentum to prepare the public for a01:05:56
new revelation, a new article in the evening01:05:58
and in with it we are preparing everyone for the01:06:01
biggest leak and tomorrow when we01:06:03
publish what we are going to publish the01:06:05
question will arise what kind of leak it is and who the01:06:08
source is and I guarantee you01:06:19
in a second I will check01:06:21
move it a little I just move01:06:23
and I can cross all seven I just01:06:25
need to do this everything can be removed01:06:31
first some general biographical01:06:33
information01:06:34
state your name tell us about your01:06:36
position in the intelligence community01:06:38
and how long you worked in it well I don’t01:06:42
know how much detail you need to01:06:44
tell just in general in general I’m an01:06:46
infrastructure analyst at booz01:06:48
allen hamilton01:06:49
without delving into my background ok something01:06:52
like your resume ok mine have01:06:55
snowden01:06:56
im 29 years old i work at booz allen01:07:00
hamilton as an infrastructure analyst for01:07:02
nb in the state of hawaii before this have you held01:07:07
any positions in the intelligence01:07:09
community i was with a systems engineer system01:07:12
administrator senior consultant01:07:16
this is in central intelligence01:07:19
management methodological consultant and01:07:22
administrators of telecommunications01:07:24
information systems and01:07:26
what level of clearance to classified01:07:28
information did you have top secret01:07:36
people with my level of access to system01:07:39
administration or to01:07:41
infrastructures us analysis usually have01:07:45
higher levels of access than ordinary01:07:47
employees mb01:07:48
usually nb uses such levels of01:07:51
clearance like shh ai si kay and gamma, that01:07:57
is, top secret signal markings,01:08:00
admission by talent and gamma, each of them01:08:03
touches on certain key aspects of the01:08:04
activity of the n.b.01:08:06
if you are a system administrator, you are01:08:09
entitled to special access, private01:08:11
privileged access, it allows you to01:08:14
operate information at any level,01:08:16
regardless of what you need for01:08:19
your work,01:08:54
we will continue to remind you of the main news,01:08:58
former technical employee n.b.01:09:00
Edward Snowden takes01:09:02
responsibility for the leak of information01:09:04
that the US government is intercepting01:09:06
data from telephone Internet connections, not01:09:09
all US politicians have confirmed the VPO, a01:09:11
criminal case will be opened, it’s better to01:09:15
put it this way, or in short,01:09:16
people have already seen me on video so that it’s01:09:19
easier to recognize me shave look, it wo01:09:21
n’t work out completely anyway, the stubble will01:09:23
remain, I don’t have a blade in the room, are you01:09:29
planning to discuss this topic with01:09:31
other publications today, of course, yes, you01:09:34
’ll look into the office, and Sasha has this press, we01:09:36
would like to ask about where he is01:09:37
alone now and what are his plans, but for01:09:39
similar I won’t answer questions01:09:41
tournament if you ask anything else in01:09:42
the interview there is no point in you your plans you01:09:45
will stay in Hong Kong for some time for01:09:46
some time are you going to continue01:09:49
covering this story or are we not expecting01:09:51
new reports from you01:09:52
no I will continue write about this01:09:54
whether the US authorities tried to force you to01:09:57
abandon this topic do01:10:00
you know how the Hong Kong authorities feel about this matter01:10:03
did they try to contact you01:10:05
to find out the whereabouts of Snowden to find out01:10:09
some information I was not contacted by01:10:12
representatives of any authorities what do01:10:15
you think they will do events will develop for01:10:18
you, of course, for sleep I have for the01:10:20
American media of the01:10:21
American administration as a whole, but01:10:24
I can say for myself that I will continue to01:10:26
write articles about what our01:10:28
government is doing and about what01:10:30
my readers should know, that no one can know this before him01:10:33
They could have sent01:10:34
their people after me or brought in intermediaries to the case,01:10:36
but they work01:10:38
closely with the governments of other01:10:40
countries, or they could pay the local 3 hells,01:10:42
they have plenty of funds and01:10:44
opportunities, the officer is located across the01:10:47
street at the American consulate in01:10:49
Hong Kong, representatives of the Ministry01:10:51
of Justice continue to insist on that01:10:54
all the statements made by their01:10:56
representatives of the world are01:10:57
not true,01:10:59
stay on our channel, we will01:11:01
closely monitor how01:11:03
events develop01:11:13
[music]01:11:15
on the air of Daniil Retort from the main01:11:18
news of the hour, despite the threat of criminal01:11:20
prosecution, the whistleblower who told the01:11:23
interception of data by the American authorities01:11:25
decided to speak publicly.01:11:28
security in Afghanistan,01:11:29
Topol rebels are reported to have01:11:32
attacked the airport in Kabul,01:11:34
now a press review awaits you, you will find out the01:11:37
weaning is written by newspapers around the world,01:11:39
let's start with the garden and our main news, the01:11:42
identity of a former CIA employee has been revealed,01:11:45
we give the floor information about a cell of01:11:47
incredible proportions that the British are01:11:49
conducting on the Internet, Edward Snowden, an01:11:53
exciting story01:11:54
I’m listening to her, first of all, this is an01:11:57
absolutely fantastic story, it’s01:11:59
like they took it from a John le Carré novel,01:12:01
think about it, first he got01:12:03
the materials, then he decided to go to01:12:05
where, in his opinion, America was an hour away from01:12:08
getting to Hong Kong because,01:12:10
purely technically, in China with his policy of01:12:12
one country, two systems, he can01:12:14
count on a certain protection, everything is01:12:17
carefully planned, just like a01:12:19
real spy novel,01:12:21
but do we know the details, judging by the01:12:26
latest, it doesn’t look very good, but it also looks like we’ll01:12:29
soon find out much better hide I don’t01:12:32
know, only the lower part is visible faces of01:12:41
mobile phone providers01:12:43
find out all about air miles and01:12:45
travel companies at our station01:12:48
if you are going on the road01:12:50
join me every weekend01:12:51
you before if you want to keep up to date with01:12:59
international events listen to01:13:02
BBC world news01:13:04
well now we are back again with the01:13:05
main news of the day,01:13:07
Snowden claims that he was horrified by the01:13:11
speed at which nb was growing its01:13:14
influence, so he decided to release01:13:16
documents that prove that this01:13:18
organization not only wiretapped01:13:20
millions of telephone conversations but had01:13:22
direct access to the period of the world's largest01:13:25
and how I feel, how can I01:13:26
comment, well, what will01:13:30
happen we talked about this I knew that I was01:13:33
taking a risk01:13:35
no, is it worth it to me, it means he will arrest us, we01:13:39
managed to publish information that01:13:42
needed to be published, it was revealed that you can01:13:47
continue writing01:13:48
regardless of what happens to me,01:13:52
29-year-old Edward Snowden said that the01:13:55
US authorities or the foundation will have information about01:13:58
mobile calls of Americans, as well as01:14:00
data from the Internet, the Guardian newspaper01:14:02
claims that he revealed his appearance at01:14:04
his request,01:14:05
we have David visa and raise in touch and who is01:14:08
it, I’m01:14:11
afraid that you got to the wrong place, I’m01:14:27
listening, can you repeat it, no01:14:37
thanks, no calls, probably not01:14:39
a mistake number yes and not from anyone thank01:14:43
you I'm sorry if it's two men from01:14:47
the lobby let them call except them01:14:50
no one just let them through as you said01:14:59
so commented yes wait you're a01:15:10
lawyer no no no those who asked about me01:15:15
find out they're not lawyers no01:15:24
tell her what she was mistaken and Mr.01:15:27
Snowden does not live here01:15:37
hello Robert and you can01:15:38
talk now and I managed to get into the room01:15:41
I am now safe with the01:15:45
client well we could now01:15:47
discuss further actions is this01:15:49
resolution already in force or not yet01:15:51
formally yes but that is formally she it's01:15:58
not working yet, do you mind01:16:10
if I put it on speakerphone, excuse me,01:16:14
yes, we're here, Robert, hello, client,01:16:18
I'm fine, I'm not complaining, I01:16:25
met with a representative of the UN High01:16:27
Commissioner for Refugees in Hong Kong,01:16:29
they know that you are applying for protection as01:16:33
provided for in the statute of their department, they01:16:36
they want us to go now, we will get to the01:16:42
lunch break, clearly the building has01:16:48
several separate exits, so if01:16:52
someone and journalists are waiting for you,01:16:57
that’s great, I can take01:17:00
the equipment with me01:17:01
if necessary, perhaps I will01:17:03
have to leave somewhere and I will01:17:05
never return to the hotel ok I'm ready01:17:18
thank you thank you very much thank you very much the01:17:21
air is about what steps he01:17:24
should take next and where he01:17:26
will live will they give him a private01:17:28
apartment in which he can hide01:17:29
from the police everything is clear I'll call01:17:37
before we go out okay yes see you01:17:42
okay then01:17:44
so we don’t have a car, so I think01:17:48
we can either ask the concierge to call a01:17:52
car or go down and catch a taxi, but there01:17:56
will be such traffic in this area01:18:00
that catching a taxi will01:18:01
not be easy, yes, I know, tell me, have there been01:18:05
precedents when01:18:06
Hong Kong has extradited someone for01:18:08
political reasons no, I01:18:12
haven’t heard that, if we report torture or01:18:14
ask for asylum, by law you should be01:18:18
given the right to continue to01:18:21
stay in Hong Kong since they don’t01:18:23
know where to send you while01:19:08
we can go,01:19:18
the president definitely does not welcome the01:19:20
increased attention that01:19:21
this debate has attracted last week there was a leak of01:19:24
classified information about programs01:19:25
designed to fight terrorists whose01:19:27
activities can harm01:19:28
American citizens, this is a big01:19:30
problem, but the debate is quite legitimate,01:19:32
which means it should be continued01:19:41
[music]01:19:54
[music]01:21:01
[music]01:21:17
chronicle was hounded01:21:18
[music]01:21:19
I need to go to the unofficial The United States01:21:22
is intercepting millions of01:21:24
emails and telephone conversations of Brazilians,01:21:26
so I want to show you a new document01:21:30
on the diagram, you can see it all01:21:33
very clearly. This map shows the01:21:36
cables01:21:37
used in collecting data within the01:21:39
Prism program,01:21:41
here you can see the volume of01:21:44
information being collected, look here01:21:46
here the thicker the line the more data01:21:48
they collect here you can see these lines01:21:51
indicating cables in the south of Brazil01:21:53
they are quite bold and here in the01:21:56
north along the coast01:21:57
we see the same thing that is, as part of the01:22:00
prism program they collect a01:22:02
lot of data here that in my opinion the view is extremely01:22:04
important because prisms then Facebook is01:22:06
skype youtube yahoo hotmail and here you can see01:22:09
how much data is intercepted from01:22:11
Brazil, but we cannot say whether the01:22:15
Brazilian government knows about this or01:22:17
does not cooperate only with Brazilian01:22:20
companies, but I am sure that sooner or01:22:22
later we will we will find out until one day we01:22:24
will find out all or almost all of01:23:25
which of them we can insert01:23:28
operational data here we cannot01:23:30
publish this we can edit you can01:23:32
scroll to the top we could01:23:34
quote Alexander Orda01:23:36
tarmac folder why not conduct a continuous01:23:38
interception of all signals here is your01:23:41
homework for the base bear hill01:23:43
Keith Alexander director nb01:23:45
will go during a visit to the UK yes this is a01:23:48
secret document so a secret01:23:51
document we have the ability to put01:23:53
text on only three separate slides if01:23:56
we insert more than three the whole layout will fly01:24:01
so yes well this is very dangerous material01:24:06
for the Guardians you understand if you make01:24:09
a mistake at the very end, given that we01:24:11
kept everything secret, who knows how it will01:24:14
end, they can break in and seal01:24:17
everything here if we are in front of him, he01:24:19
said that the Prime Minister is extremely01:24:22
worried, everyone is saying that the wave is coming from the01:24:24
very top01:25:07
[music]01:25:19
[music]01:25:36
how you can see on the map the plane on board01:25:39
there is Snowdon supposed to01:25:41
land in Moscow in just01:25:43
a few minutes she01:25:44
must have heard about this CIA agent01:25:50
who revealed a bunch of their secrets and so it01:25:53
turned out that he was stuck at the Moscow01:25:57
airport01:25:58
we managed to get him out of Hong Kong but01:26:00
when his plane landed at the01:26:02
airport in Moscow, the01:26:03
American government revoked01:26:05
his passport, that is, formally he did not01:26:08
enter Russian territory, he is in the01:26:10
transit zone at the airport, he01:26:13
is accompanied by one of our people, we01:26:16
are trying to find him a private plane to01:26:21
take him out of Moscow,01:26:26
to Ecuador, or maybe better to Venezuela01:26:30
perhaps to Iceland01:26:32
where he will be safe I01:26:47
ask you there is no time01:26:50
limit for speaking thank you I welcome everyone01:26:53
present I want to start with the fact that after the01:26:56
attacks of September 11 the Americans01:26:59
justify all their actions as the fight against01:27:02
terrorism01:27:03
everything is done in the name of national01:27:04
security in the name of protecting our01:27:07
population on in fact, everything is completely different; the01:27:10
vast majority of documents01:27:13
have nothing to do with the fight01:27:16
against terrorism or national01:27:19
security; they are related either to01:27:21
rivalry between countries or to01:27:24
industrial financial or01:27:26
economic issues; I will also mention the01:27:29
Oka score program01:27:31
when we just started publishing 1 of01:27:34
our articles, the government of the United States01:27:36
justified itself by the fact that it does not01:27:39
intercept the content of conversations but01:27:40
only collects metadata, that is, the names of01:27:43
those who call their interlocutors, the time and01:27:46
duration of their conversation, the01:27:48
place from where the call was made, the place to01:27:50
which it was made, and so on and so01:27:52
forth, but if I know for sure with01:27:55
what kind of people you communicate with and if01:27:58
I know about everyone with whom they communicate,01:28:00
if I know where and when your communication took place, the01:28:03
duration and place of your01:28:06
conversations, then I can find out a01:28:08
lot of your personality about your01:28:10
activities about your life, that is, there is an01:28:13
obvious invasion of personal01:28:15
life but in fact this argument01:28:17
to the government is absolutely false01:28:20
since the American government has the01:28:21
ability to collect not only01:28:23
your metadata but also the contents of01:28:26
letters that you send by01:28:28
e-mail or listen to your01:28:30
phone conversations,01:28:31
they know the queries that you enter into the01:28:34
search bar of your Internet browser,01:28:36
they know what Internet sites you have01:28:39
recently visited, what documents you01:28:42
send to your colleagues at work, this01:28:44
system is capable of tracking almost01:28:47
everything that you, that any person does,01:28:49
this is during Internet sessions, if you01:28:53
work,01:28:54
tell journalists and investigate the01:28:56
actions of the American authorities,01:28:58
or if you got a job at a01:29:00
company that competes with01:29:02
American corporations, if you01:29:04
work in the field of human rights protection01:29:06
and your activities affect the interests of01:29:09
the authorities, in general, whatever you do,01:29:11
you know that any of your negotiations01:29:14
can easily be intercepted and if01:29:17
you are an American and live in the United01:29:19
States then they need to obtain01:29:21
court permission to intercept your01:29:23
data and they always get it, but01:29:25
if you are not an American,01:29:27
then for this they do not need anything, no01:29:30
permission, no special01:29:32
documents. I think that the consequences of01:29:34
such an invasion of people’s privacy at01:29:37
this stage are very difficult to predict, but01:29:40
we must understand that one way or another this is a01:29:42
huge blow for all of us because the01:29:46
ability of citizens to protest,01:29:47
organize demonstrations or, say,01:29:49
organize some kind of political01:29:51
demonstrations is sharply reduced when we are01:29:54
deprived of our right to privacy,01:30:04
please give me your phone numbers like this01:30:13
please, I put everything in bag,01:30:16
but hide their refrigerator, let's01:30:29
start, and as you know, in June,01:30:35
again, the Duma was charged with01:30:39
3 serious crimes based on the law of the01:30:43
First World War, which01:30:45
is called the Espionage Act, the01:30:49
Espionage Act provides for01:30:51
criminal prosecution for the dissemination of01:30:54
any information related to the defense01:30:56
of the country it is only used to01:31:00
prosecute people accused of01:31:04
collaborating with foreign countries,01:31:06
spies, not whistleblowers, and this is a very01:31:09
unusual case, not only for all of01:31:12
you, but for me too, this law01:31:15
does not distinguish between whistleblowing in the01:31:19
public interest and selling secrets to an01:31:21
enemy of the country01:31:22
for personal gain that is,01:31:24
I can be justified by the fact that the01:31:26
information released01:31:28
should not have been kept at all or01:31:30
classified as secret01:31:32
information, that its distribution was01:31:34
done in the interests of society and for01:31:37
its benefit, and even if the court concludes that the01:31:40
program in question violates01:31:43
the law or Constitution, this will not serve as a01:31:45
justification within the framework of this law,01:31:47
the government is not obliged to explain01:31:49
the secrecy or demonstrate the01:31:51
harm caused by the leak, this is not01:31:54
relevant, therefore they say that the process01:31:57
will not be fair, we mean not01:31:59
exactly what01:32:02
human rights activists usually mean, but we also say that the law01:32:04
itself excludes any possibility of being counted01:32:07
that Snowdon could count on01:32:09
and actually equates him to01:32:12
spies and these 3 charges can easily be01:32:15
turned into one hundred and two hundred or even 300 and01:32:17
he can be tried separately for each01:32:19
document that was published by01:32:21
journalists and I think that we all01:32:24
understand even though we meet here as01:32:26
lawyers01:32:27
at a bar meeting that the outcome of this01:32:30
case will, alas, be determined by politics and01:32:33
not by law 95 percent01:32:58
[music]01:33:09
Mr. Snowden is accused of serious01:33:11
crimes, he should be returned to the01:33:14
United States where he will be given a fair trial and01:33:17
will be given all the rights due to a01:33:19
US citizen in accordance with the01:33:22
constitution of our country01:33:31
[music]01:33:38
[music]01:33:49
[music]01:34:15
no I do not consider Mr. Snowden a01:34:16
patriot I have asked for a01:34:19
comprehensive review of our01:34:22
surveillance operations before these01:34:24
leaks occurred for me it is a priority and I think01:34:29
for the entire American people it01:34:32
is rightful and methodical to01:34:35
study of these laws and thoughtful,01:34:40
objective debate that will help01:34:44
make our lives better01:34:48
[music]01:35:21
[music]01:35:23
as soon as David01:35:27
[music]01:35:30
and friend tell me01:35:32
everything is okay01:35:35
[music]01:35:39
I want yes okay okay let's go don't pay01:35:42
attention01:35:50
but you when I'm okay01:35:52
I just couldn’t sleep all night, it’s clear that01:35:54
Brazil is demanding an explanation from the01:35:56
British government,01:36:17
according to the latest data, and Nb had access to01:36:20
encryption keys and paid01:36:21
technology companies to introduce01:36:24
loopholes into encrypted protocols.01:36:26
Today we are gathered to talk about01:36:28
methods by which you can01:36:29
protect yourself from government01:36:31
spying.01:36:32
Jacob Apple Baum journalist and01:36:35
developer of encryption and security01:36:37
programs Ladar Levinson creator of a01:36:39
secure electronic messaging service01:36:42
lava bit which Edward01:36:44
Snowden used the words thank you lava bits you01:36:48
postal service which I hope one day01:36:50
will become known to everyone and in itself and not01:36:53
just in connection with the name Snowden I01:36:56
created this service so that01:36:58
no one could force me into violating01:37:03
privacy, let's say my idea was01:37:06
to exclude the service provider from the equation;01:37:09
I do not keep logs on the server and do not have01:37:13
access to the user's mail on disk,01:37:15
which of course does not exclude the possibility01:37:18
surveillance for that excludes me from01:37:21
this equation where surveillance can01:37:24
be established on any party,01:37:26
both the sender and the recipient of01:37:29
the message, but not so long ago an01:37:32
FBI agent contacted me who said that01:37:35
since I could not give him information about01:37:38
any specific user then I01:37:40
will have to give them the protocol keys with s l01:37:42
and allow their people to secretly collect01:37:44
data from all correspondence taking place on01:37:46
my network, of course I was very01:37:52
pleased with this, to put it mildly, even more01:37:55
alarming to me was that I couldn’t tell anyone about01:37:57
it, so I decided that if01:38:01
I will not be able to make this situation public01:38:04
if I do not have the opportunity01:38:06
to tell people what is happening,01:38:09
the only ethically correct choice is to01:38:11
close the network, think about it, I believe in the01:38:18
rule of law, I believe in the need01:38:20
to conduct an investigation, but for any01:38:23
investigation there must be a serious01:38:25
reason for the violation of the right to privacy01:38:28
and should be a01:38:29
matter of concern because it is an act of01:38:32
aggression because it is an act of destruction01:38:35
if we have no right to privacy01:38:38
so how can we have a free open01:38:40
discussion what is the use of the right to freedom of01:38:44
speech if it is not protected if you do01:38:50
not have the opportunity have a private discussion01:38:52
with another person about something you01:38:54
disagree with think about what destructive01:38:57
effect this will have what destructive01:38:59
effect it will have on countries where there is already no01:39:01
right to privacy01:39:03
I would like to draw your attention to one01:39:05
interesting point - what used to be01:39:07
called freedom we we call the01:39:09
right to privacy and we are immediately01:39:12
ready to admit that we are deprived of this right, which is01:39:15
why I am seriously worried about01:39:17
my generation, especially when we talk01:39:19
about the fact that nothing can surprise us anymore, we01:39:21
must understand that without the right to privacy01:39:24
we are deprived of the ability to act,01:39:25
we lose freedom itself because we01:39:28
cannot freely express our thoughts,01:39:29
there is a myth about the passive01:39:32
surveillance machine, but what is any surveillance01:39:34
if not control and all these statements about01:39:36
passivity are simply nonsense,01:39:39
they act very actively in relation to01:39:41
Europeans and Americans, too, essentially01:39:43
in relation to anyone, if we are01:39:45
required,01:40:00
here a whole paragraph is devoted to the fact01:40:03
that they are intercepting data from the01:40:06
mobile communication device of01:40:08
Chancellor Angela Merkel, look here there01:40:11
is a number, but I think01:40:34
no, it’s necessary, but of01:40:36
course not01:40:45
[music]01:41:21
on you hello, what are you going to01:41:27
tell the people of Germany I came01:41:30
as a consultant and what do you intend to01:41:33
tell but all I know is01:41:35
the truth what will you talk to them about01:41:39
it depends on their questions01:41:42
I think yes yes well01:41:45
thank you01:41:51
good afternoon Mr. Bell hello how are01:41:54
you how are you01:41:55
galant 8 2 1 articles and I’m very glad01:41:58
to see you,01:42:08
I’m glad that I was called here because in01:42:11
my opinion it is extremely important for us to talk about the01:42:13
secret activities of intelligence01:42:15
communities around the world and not only01:42:18
nb all those programs that01:42:21
Edward Snowden spoke about and these are essentially01:42:23
tools for collecting information such01:42:26
tools have been used by every01:42:28
dictatorial regime in history, one of the most01:42:30
important tasks for them is to know as01:42:32
much as possible about their people,01:42:33
for this they create such programs,01:42:36
personally, I see them as the greatest threat to01:42:39
democracy throughout the world01:42:42
[music]01:43:05
[music]01:43:29
what do you think they do journalists01:43:32
with those of us who work with01:43:34
Snowden's documents, what do you think is the approach01:43:37
they take towards such people you01:43:39
are on the list of priority01:43:41
targets this means that any01:43:43
electronic device you01:43:46
use will be tapped all the01:43:48
data will be recorded and what they do with01:43:50
this data they are trying to find out on what01:43:52
we work on partly01:43:54
including this but first of all01:43:56
they will seek to identify your01:43:59
sources of information that is, let's say01:44:00
that I have a confidential01:44:02
source supplying me with information01:44:04
who works in the US government and01:44:06
he believes that there is some kind of01:44:09
violation of the constitution01:44:10
and he gets in touch with me, what01:44:14
next they will establish surveillance, they will01:44:16
monitor his every move, and if he01:44:19
starts transmitting information, he can be01:44:20
captured right on the street, the most01:44:22
correct thing to do here would be to do01:44:24
as deep throat did01:44:26
during the time of Nixon, meet in person in01:44:29
underground parking lots01:44:48
[ music]01:45:12
let's separate our metadata for the last time01:45:14
so that01:45:16
your real name does not remain in the chain of our correspondence. Of01:45:19
course, this will not give you the opportunity to01:45:21
deny your involvement in this01:45:23
story, but I am sure that it will be much better01:45:25
if the revelations happen on your01:45:28
terms and thanks again for everything what01:45:33
did you do and once again forgive me for the01:45:35
numerous delays we arrived in the01:45:38
developed territory where we01:45:40
had no one to take as a model and if everything01:45:42
ends well, maybe our success01:45:45
will inspire courage in the hearts of other people on the01:45:47
network for01:45:54
I wanted to share with you the news of a01:45:56
new01:46:00
source with which which we are on,01:46:09
this is the person who does01:46:12
most of it, you do most of the work, the place,01:46:18
but actually01:46:20
what happened and this is actually very01:46:27
dangerous for the source, I hope he knows01:46:33
what needs to be done so as not to get caught and01:46:35
worry, he did it all01:46:37
with the help of this quite well and01:46:43
they talk so well, and01:46:48
by the way, this is still a big question: where should they turn the01:46:51
clutch? no, they are01:46:53
extremely careful, yes, there is also this is good,01:46:56
and this is where it is, they01:47:10
already seriously01:47:29
knew about it,01:47:37
this is not a real airplane, you01:47:41
mean the control system here the whole process01:47:43
sends them to hell who is there there is01:47:46
a graph on it the whole arrangement for each01:47:49
element is very brave it’s a01:47:51
very risky business but the most important thing is01:47:53
that no one comes in and this is what01:47:55
this graph looks like01:47:56
on it you can see how a decision is made it’s01:47:59
something like this and here01:48:08
look at this decision-making scheme for01:48:13
each of them the policy was given for sure01:48:21
this is simply amazing01:48:28
this is simply ridiculous01:48:31
this is shocking and this is you you are the01:48:43
population of the whole country and I what is this what01:48:49
we are working on now01:49:04
this man is it really scary I don’t01:49:08
know, at the same time, he’s not bad at all, but01:49:10
I just hope that01:49:12
you’re right to him, his courage may shock,01:49:14
but there is no doubt on the other side that he01:49:16
was inspired by what you did, it01:49:19
could, it could, it could01:49:22
bring this whole political situation with01:49:25
revelations01:49:26
completely new level because this is01:49:28
exactly how it will be, I don’t know, I think01:49:32
it’s great that people will see what was01:49:35
hidden from them once again, and01:49:38
this time by a different branch of government01:52:05
[music]Description:
-------------- TELEGRAM COLLECTION--------------------- БАЗА КРЕАТИВА - https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCksG6P7r0gDkLK8TAm3Uolw Музыка Для Избранных - https://tele.gg/MuzWod Музыка - https://t.me/MuzWod Поддержать Мир Открытой Двери --- https://qiwi.com/n/CREATIVMOOD -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- В январе 2013 года Лора Пойтрас стала получать анонимные зашифрованные электронные письма от человека по имени «CITIZENFOUR», который утверждал, что у него есть доказательства существования нелегальных программ скрытого наблюдения, которое ведет АНБ в сотрудничестве с другими спецслужбами по всему миру. Музыка √ https://tglink.ru/muzwod ------------------------------------------------------------------ Ещё видео 1.Креативный взгляд --- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w5vdxEHfVNU 2.ИТОГИ креативных стараний - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1ZIsJGmDVgo 3.Обращение искусственного интеллекта https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=F4wRepUi-BQ 4СЧАСТЬЕ --- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jCSBmraj3pw 5.Мир Открытых Изменений --- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VmCU5SXzi6Q 6.Волк и Овцы --- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yxtMMmy3vYM 7.Последний снимок --- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kb4V7ED7lbo 8.Квантовый феномен --- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3fHRTyjPGIQ 9.Крипта и блокчейн вся правда --- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uNv6B3rR3k4 10.Самый добрый мультик --- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=kqQbds83g0g 11.MAGASHOW --- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2lynNEQJXbs 12.Скамейка - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8qMuv_wWcQU 13..Хакеры пользуются -- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lVyFX... 14 .Лила --- https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=atStekV17-4
Preparing download options
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players
Questions about downloading video
How can I download "Правда Сноудена Фильм - Информационная безопасность.- Защита в интернете." video?
http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.
Which format of "Правда Сноудена Фильм - Информационная безопасность.- Защита в интернете." video should I choose?
The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.
Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Правда Сноудена Фильм - Информационная безопасность.- Защита в интернете." video?
The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.
How can I download "Правда Сноудена Фильм - Информационная безопасность.- Защита в интернете." video to my phone?
You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.
How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Правда Сноудена Фильм - Информационная безопасность.- Защита в интернете."?
The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.
How can I save a frame from a video "Правда Сноудена Фильм - Информационная безопасность.- Защита в интернете."?
This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.
What's the price of all this stuff?
It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.