Download "Телеканал Зал суда. Прямой эфир"
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FeA9hmpzKWpI%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
Please wait. We're preparing links for easy ad-free video watching and downloading.
Similar videos from our catalog
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252Fa_ruMFAOd34%252Fsddefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FefI0T7xpF7E%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252Fg8v51aPQbXQ%252Fsddefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FrL6x6wypytU%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252Fwpj6rHNao-U%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FzSfo6SyBTfs%252Fsddefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FziyWqHmBtB4%252Fsddefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FYM_iz2M545I%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
Video tags
Subtitles
Russian
00:00:00
not only but also seven chickens 10 ducks and00:00:03
one little pig here00:00:06
they will divide everything fairly, look00:00:10
carefully And now let's go back to the hall00:00:14
[music]00:00:15
court, plaintiff Ivan Kurnosov sues00:00:19
on compensation for damage to health and moral00:00:21
damages for trying to bury him alive00:00:24
defendants Lina and Mikhail Kashki claim no00:00:27
admit and claim that they tried00:00:29
save a life I was fine00:00:31
until I met these00:00:33
the defendants with their relatives I00:00:35
was a middle class entrepreneur Well00:00:38
at that moment in our city there was00:00:41
folk song competition Here at the competition00:00:43
a very beautiful girl won, it's theirs00:00:46
relative Well, we started having an affair00:00:48
we tried together for a couple of weeks00:00:50
Well, we decided to get married, she says00:00:54
only with the blessing of the parents Well then00:00:56
blessing so blessing let's go00:00:59
but I had to go to the dark village of Vyselki00:01:02
there 3 hours by train several hours by00:01:04
by bus and 8 km on foot May month of the road00:01:08
blurry Well, Siberia what can I say00:01:11
a tractor will pass well than a Hummer is not a tractor00:01:13
Well, we got into my Hummer and got a treat there00:01:16
everything from the city of whiskey there, well, red caviar00:01:19
there's this and that, that is, and the bride00:01:22
I also asked you to take a bag of sugar there00:01:25
a bag of buckwheat and 20 kg of pasta Well then00:01:27
asked for it and did it as if let's go00:01:30
the ride was terrible, of course, but we got there00:01:33
we arrived and it was only 13 in the village00:01:36
houses Well, that’s an interesting figure and00:01:39
39 residents Well, they came to get the bride drunk00:01:42
of course the whole village Well, when did they start00:01:45
let's get acquainted everyone introduces themselves as porridge00:01:47
porridge porridge I say you are relatives00:01:50
that's all, no, he says00:01:52
namesake Yes, almost all namesakes00:01:56
this happens in small villages00:01:58
it happens Well, they set the table, I have mine there00:02:02
they also supplied the hotels with their first00:02:06
they put on Well, everything was fine, they sang00:02:09
the songs there are all beautiful the bride in general00:02:11
I was dazzling and I cleaned up the trash00:02:17
first-time drinker just got in the way, woke up00:02:21
it's like something out of a horror movie. Excuse me, but what?00:02:23
you said that you left, I don’t understand00:02:28
like in a horror movie I'm lying in a grave00:02:32
half-buried stream of ice water00:02:35
these are all around me in dim light00:02:37
kerosene lamps faces of these porridges00:02:39
twisted with rage with shovels standing00:02:42
and dig me further What are you talking about00:02:45
dear Spasa defendant defendant00:02:49
defendant Well, what was the strength, I don’t know00:02:53
how he broke out Well, to the hummer to his00:02:57
Hummer is not yellow but black00:02:59
all burnt out I don’t know where I’m going00:03:03
I ran to the taiga, I just don’t remember how long00:03:05
days as if I was there, well it’s all weak00:03:09
I remember how everything was in a terrible dream00:03:12
drank water from the swamp there and ticked me and00:03:14
mosquitoes ate me, I don’t know how to live00:03:16
stayed at all I just remember00:03:18
the last birch under00:03:20
her mug is worth collecting juice apparently Well00:03:24
a sip did everything and switched off and woke up in00:03:27
hospitals00:03:28
already00:03:30
I look like00:03:32
Everything seems to be fine Yes, in the hospital already00:03:35
The nightmare is already over Well, I started00:03:38
call the police so that these00:03:40
punish the ghouls, but no one will00:03:43
believes I was lying in this mental hospital Yes in00:03:48
in this madhouse all the doctors are some kind00:03:50
they're all sick idiots I don't know about me00:03:52
the man was lying normally just saying how00:03:54
Well, I would tell the doctors that every night00:03:57
come to me vlat blood I just00:04:01
they're drinking blood00:04:02
they come every night they say take it00:04:05
they say build the Ark, build the Ark00:04:08
put the money from the ghouls there and by and00:04:12
send the toadstool down. That's when they00:04:14
will move away from you and what are there 39 of them00:04:16
ghouls then they charge 75,000 s00:04:19
everyone I lost, how much I lost00:04:20
dove00:04:22
became, that is, you in the form of messes00:04:26
they come exactly00:04:27
defendants of course00:04:30
and how long, excuse me, did we lie in00:04:32
mental hospital Well me first00:04:35
it seemed like he lay there for 2 weeks, but that’s until00:04:38
when my leg jumped out it broke me00:04:39
transferred to the regional office, I explained to them that I00:04:42
I was saving myself from them, they came to me00:04:44
I thought I'd be completely killed off, although00:04:47
the window jumped out thank God second floor00:04:48
I only broke my leg but I was in the regional00:04:51
transferred00:04:54
Well what?00:04:58
suicide sabist end his life from00:05:01
I ran away, please forgive me00:05:04
there is an extract from history00:05:06
illness please pass it on00:05:08
bailiff So I realized that I00:05:11
the truth is not what is a toadstool00:05:13
which needs00:05:14
let down Well, there’s a river like this, and here’s a river00:05:17
please tell me yours00:05:21
a friend who determined what was needed00:05:24
let the river down exactly 3 ml or is it you00:05:29
not that 3 mil is needed for the Ark00:05:32
build and put the money there and00:05:34
spell to write Here I have it written down00:05:37
lies here then just as if all this00:05:40
It will be fine What about business? Everything00:05:42
In general, I’ve lost it. Well, what about Hamer?00:05:45
only osaga00:05:47
there was nothing left at all, that's what00:05:50
what's left of him is clear, so please00:05:54
who of you00:05:58
beginning Yes, I don’t agree with the fact that he’s here00:06:01
said Your Honor, we saved lives00:06:04
they saved his life, why is he like that here?00:06:07
he says how it was then00:06:10
my daughter arrived with him in a yellow tank Well00:06:14
we were happy my daughter came as a guest00:06:17
I came to meet you and how are we doing?00:06:19
in the village it’s customary if it’s a holiday00:06:21
we walk around the whole village if God forbid00:06:24
we see off the funeral on our last journey too00:06:27
the whole village but everyone was gathered00:06:30
I of course put my female on00:06:33
you want to poison me teli Excuse me at the World Cup00:06:37
the infusion itself00:06:39
fly agaric Yes, well, it’s harmful for the fortress00:06:43
does not bring only for the fortress here00:06:46
means what? Maybe it’s not my fault00:06:48
I noticed that he liked our guest00:06:51
my moonshine Well, I drank it00:06:55
isra00:06:58
my grandfather and I have a small house in one00:07:02
Mashenka's room in the other bedroom we yes00:07:05
the kitchen is small. Well, where is he?00:07:07
the car is like our hut, well we are in it00:07:09
they put the car down Well, we sat some more00:07:12
the guests have spoken00:07:14
separated, it's dark, I don't look outside the window00:07:17
just like my soul is sick of something I think how00:07:19
he's lying there in the car alone, maybe in00:07:22
please move it and then it started to rain00:07:26
a thunderstorm began and how they say Well, just like00:07:31
hit the car and the whole car00:07:33
when it caught fire it was yellow like yes00:07:36
now the car is still on fire00:07:38
the lightning was yellow like a chicken on00:07:41
car And then I turned all black00:07:43
I got scared, my father got scared too, faster00:07:46
ran to call neighbors to knock on the rail00:07:50
that's how it was. Well, when the neighbors00:07:53
came running and who were already gathering people for the World Cup00:07:55
who went to bed even in00:07:58
They covered the fire under the car with earth00:08:00
it seemed like they had put out the fire and started opening the doors00:08:04
snuggled up somehow with an ax there00:08:06
pick it out Got him out of Sat and he has no memory00:08:09
wow, what should we do? Let’s bury it with earth00:08:12
Well, dig it in, look at his eyes00:08:16
opens treated treated Well, we think00:08:19
it helped Thank God and he jumped up and finished00:08:23
and ran into the forest, we say where are you00:08:25
ran then And Where to run then was and already00:08:28
it's dark and raining00:08:29
and he disappeared in one second, but we00:08:31
they ran with lanterns00:08:36
look and then Masha woke up all in00:08:39
tears Where did the groom go Where did he disappear How00:08:42
sank into the water And the next day our Mash00:08:45
she got sick and caught a cold while we were running around00:08:48
agta she kept calling him, screaming under00:08:50
cold rain then her temperature00:08:54
got up, let's go to the hospital00:08:56
lucky And she has pneumonia And also00:08:59
Your Honor turns out she's pregnant00:09:01
after all, this is a guest on the fortieth00:09:05
it will work out, well spoiled girl00:09:08
it turns out she's pregnant with us now00:09:10
lies on the preservation of almost a child00:09:12
lost and to this day lies here00:09:14
hospital so far here is a certificate that she00:09:16
I'm pregnant, I don't just say we00:09:20
that same spring the site is all00:09:22
they said he came and inspected the car but00:09:26
no documents00:09:28
Nothing00:09:29
We don’t know any documents or last names00:09:32
came and got drunk00:09:34
right away Well, what should we do? And in a month we00:09:37
the district policeman says that yours has been found00:09:40
the fiancé of a mental hospital for you, and even with him00:09:43
He has some kind of nonsense, but we think, well, Vki00:09:46
after all, almost a relative decided00:09:48
they brought guests to visit him yes00:09:51
we went to the hospital and he didn’t see how00:09:54
second floor glory00:09:58
to God00:09:59
Of course, we decided to stay out of harm's way00:10:01
don't show your face anymore00:10:02
they came to visit me and visit me00:10:04
they are Barge Haulers Damned I think maybe00:10:08
Okay, we’ll raise our grandson ourselves. But what about him?00:10:12
makes a claim for a million rubles00:10:14
Don't know00:10:15
I saw more of what was there00:10:18
Dene the car is still parked there00:10:20
True, the tires were flat and the car was burned00:10:23
here they wrote lightning oud What kind of lightning00:10:25
good luck fight a little Well of course he will get better00:10:28
no good, all this will be fixed Well, in general00:10:31
Of course, Isa’s diagnosis is not very good00:10:33
comforting and I have to disappoint you00:10:36
that he's not a doctor00:10:38
not at all, but most likely this is due to00:10:42
fly agaric Well, I would probably even do that00:10:45
she said not just with fly agarics, but with00:10:47
amount drunk with fly agarics00:10:50
Wow, we all drink and don’t poison anyone00:10:52
lay on00:10:55
The court understands the position of the parties00:10:58
succeeds Decision making stay with00:11:02
[music]00:11:07
us, do you know how to correctly express your00:11:11
claims This is just for you00:11:13
clear calculations I didn’t understand That is00:11:15
you put what you put together I put what I'm on00:11:17
beat 10,000 and my claim for 15,000 from p00:11:20
subtract 10 p 5.000 she owes me00:11:23
10,000 I forgive her for the fact that I caused00:11:26
they constitute your claims00:11:29
5,000 rubles 15 15,000 rubles 15,000 do you know00:11:33
how to defend your position00:11:36
Wait, crystal vase, its fate00:11:39
Let's start from the beginning00:11:41
the crystal vase broke No, I understand00:11:43
the answer does not deny that it crashed00:11:45
You just say that the defendant came and00:11:46
it was broken, the defendant claims that you00:11:49
They threw a vase at him, you know there’s one like that00:11:51
there was a bombing that someone threw what I no longer00:11:53
I remember actually I don’t remember who did what00:11:55
threw Why in court you need to control00:11:57
your emotions You offered me this one00:12:00
that's crap the defendant the defendant please00:12:03
I'm sorry, I'm sorry, it's you specifically00:12:05
sorry, by accident, here's judge Elena00:12:08
Dmitrieva will help you find a way out00:12:10
difficult00:12:12
provisions Now let's go back to the courtroom and00:12:15
we'll find out the solution00:12:17
judges the court announces the decision made on00:12:20
case, the court heard claims from00:12:23
the defendants' objection to the claims00:12:25
claims and also having considered00:12:27
all submitted documents you claim about00:12:29
recovery of material and moral00:12:31
harm due to harm00:12:33
health is considered necessary to deny00:12:36
the court refuses to satisfy the requests00:12:38
claims because in case00:12:40
causing harm to health, material and00:12:43
moral damage is compensated by the person00:12:45
guilty of causing this harm in00:12:47
in accordance with the rules of Article 106400:12:50
Russian Civil Code00:12:52
The Federation is at fault in this case00:12:54
defendant in causing personal injury00:12:56
law enforcement agencies do not00:12:59
established therefore claims00:13:02
cannot be satisfied, that is, in00:13:04
in this case, naturally00:13:06
of course, according to everything you stated00:13:07
circumstances needed00:13:09
contact law enforcement agencies00:13:12
Because now the court cannot00:13:14
establish a cause-and-effect relationship00:13:16
between the conduct of the defendant and00:13:18
resulting harm to health, as well as00:13:21
plaintiff causing you moral damage00:13:24
and the defendants the court announced its decision00:13:26
case00:13:27
the court decision in the claims was closed00:13:31
requirements00:13:33
refuse Well, the Ghouls are gone again00:13:36
with impunity and my whole plan went up in flames00:13:38
there is nothing left, neither business nor00:13:40
everything is healthy when a person gets hit00:13:43
lightning it needs to be buried in the ground00:13:45
everyone should know and I’ll tell my daughter00:13:48
better to be a groom00:13:50
[music]00:13:57
figured it out00:13:59
m more when it comes to family00:14:01
relationship Why did I write to the newspaper00:14:04
because we filed a complaint with the police00:14:07
police but the police did not react there00:14:10
such males sit like my son-in-law when00:14:14
family fire goes into courthouse00:14:16
It's getting really hot in here I00:14:19
by the way, this weirdo as a witness00:14:21
invited he comes00:14:27
race calmed down defendant00:14:30
[music]00:14:40
Yes today at00:14:45
program He gets into the car00:14:47
unwraps the sandwich and I'm horrified00:14:50
I see that this sandwich00:14:57
wrapped by VDM Dmitry Kozlov after00:15:00
divorce left everything to his ex-wife00:15:02
including heirlooms from the late 10th century00:15:06
library and antique set00:15:09
the library is damaged and the service is sold out00:15:11
according to the contract, I promised to give you a00:15:15
I promised for a year but that doesn’t mean00:15:18
that I already gave it to you. What if you00:15:20
in 5 years I would change my mind and come00:15:22
took Anna Kozina helped the unemployed00:15:25
sister get a job for female drivers00:15:27
taxi e work your own car00:15:30
sister stole her husband and now she wants00:15:32
pick her up00:15:34
car as much as possible as your own person00:15:37
just take your own husband and00:15:40
put in my bed for money00:15:43
the wife decided to pay off her debts00:15:45
in an interesting way her neighbor00:15:47
agreed to accept debt repayment00:15:49
in kind of her husband That's just the husband after00:15:51
nights of love I preferred to stay with00:15:54
[music]00:15:56
neighbors stay with us00:15:59
[music]00:16:02
plaintiff Dmitry Kozlovsky demands that00:16:05
his ex-wife returned the Famil to him00:16:07
the library she illegally owns00:16:10
and paid 8,000 rubles for damaging books00:16:13
defendant Iraida Kozlovskaya states that00:16:15
the library was bequeathed to her and her child00:16:18
we're talking about00:16:27
unique00:16:29
and about00:16:36
earthenware back we wife00:16:39
divorced, I left, what was left for her00:16:46
apartment furniture furnishings and also our00:16:50
the son also stayed with00:16:53
her Java with new00:16:57
seven00:16:59
New Man and suddenly I recently found out00:17:03
What00:17:05
Iraida is starting to start selling out00:17:10
this tea set is my sister for me00:17:14
says that she sold two of hers00:17:19
pairs two tea pairs of my neighbor I00:17:23
I'm looking for this neighbor, I'm begging her to ransom her00:17:27
these00:17:28
this couple here is the receipt it is fortunately00:17:31
turned out to be a good woman We are right00:17:35
f Hungry We were hungry, he was still00:17:39
took away What00:17:41
you are asking for the property to be withdrawn from00:17:44
unlawful possession of the defendant I request00:17:46
seize00:17:49
library00:17:50
belonged to father Here you are first00:17:54
service and then you’ll talk about the library00:17:57
speak magazines you are ours Tell me00:18:01
yelled00:18:02
us Tell the bit Return the responder00:18:05
Please tell me the claims00:18:07
requirements are formulated If you00:18:09
noticed from00:18:12
illegal possession of someone else Yes of course00:18:17
why do you think that your ex00:18:20
the wife owns a tea set and books00:18:24
illegal from your point of view00:18:26
Why Because it's This library and00:18:29
this set is our heirloom00:18:32
she belonged to our family00:18:35
the parents are the plaintiff but at the moment when you00:18:37
began to dissolve the marriage Why don't you00:18:39
filed a claim if it00:18:41
your property that was transferred to you by00:18:43
inheritance it is your personal00:18:45
it does not belong to property00:18:47
jointly acquired property Why are you in00:18:50
this moment when dividing property is not00:18:53
made demands that it is yours00:18:55
personal property and not simply taken away00:18:57
was00:18:59
years old 2 years old not before not yet00:19:02
there was no talk about it, there was no talk about it00:19:04
Your Honor, this all already happened before he00:19:06
before the death of our parents we had it all in00:19:09
we lived in my apartment together, it’s all mine00:19:12
our In general in general in our common home00:19:15
there was this library and there was this service00:19:18
So please be kind to me00:19:20
you need evidence that you00:19:22
you can00:19:23
provide what we are talking about00:19:26
library which includes certain00:19:29
number of books do you have?00:19:32
bibliography catalog which was composed00:19:35
here completely completely Yes and about00:19:37
tea service then I am he which one are you from?00:19:41
number of items is 1200:19:43
items00:19:45
prove it exists00:19:49
prove prove Sorry, well00:19:51
Prove that this A service exists and that it00:19:53
consists of DTI items it is located in00:19:57
at the moment he stole it from my house00:19:59
off as after please please00:20:02
divorced from the defendant00:20:05
divorce certificate and00:20:07
documents confirming that there is a speech at all00:20:09
it's about the library and not about two books00:20:11
through the bailiff hand over00:20:13
please, please answer, I'm listening to you00:20:16
please your honor no library00:20:18
he won't get it. Let the service return it to him.00:20:20
the service stole me, I went to the store, he00:20:23
waited until the child was home like that00:20:26
the last thief and Ukra, you understand this00:20:29
I understand he still requires 80,000 where did I get it from?00:20:32
80,000 Your Honor I have a salary00:20:35
only enough for bread only enough for00:20:38
payment for housing And this one00:20:43
magazine considerations of nature and the defendant in00:20:46
there is no room for deliberations in court00:20:49
there is space for performances and00:20:50
presentation of evidence defendant00:20:53
respondent Please tell me which one00:20:56
service comes into question when00:20:58
you talk to each other00:21:00
you see, I don’t, it’s very expensive00:21:03
service prices for him00:21:07
no the defendant is not accepted by the court00:21:10
because none of the parties are judicial00:21:12
any evidence00:21:14
availability of service is not represented by the00:21:17
defendant Your Honor is still with us00:21:20
time of the defendant's appearance on the books00:21:23
books please, I'm listening to you on00:21:26
books00:21:27
so the books are fine, I don’t tell him00:21:30
I'll give it back00:21:32
library Why Because let him00:21:34
the service will be returned to me first by the defendant, we will not00:21:37
we can discuss with you what is not in00:21:39
this court hearing is not for you00:21:41
presented is a photograph of his service00:21:45
description of his assessment Here you are talking about00:21:49
some service and I’m with you on this topic00:21:51
I can't talk because I'm for00:21:53
I don't have it Your Honor so I have it00:21:55
was home00:21:57
What00:21:59
respondent Let's go to the books Tell me00:22:01
please these books belonged00:22:05
who they belonged to my grandfather my father00:22:09
husband yes00:22:11
and before the death of his grandfather the entire library00:22:15
moved into my house, that is, into mine00:22:17
apartment and all this belonged to us to me00:22:21
to my husband and grandfather by my inheritance00:22:24
I conveyed all this to my son, what it is00:22:26
inheritance passed on to your son wanted00:22:28
to see a grandson like mine00:22:31
grandfather is a professor, that is, he is his grandfather00:22:33
professor philologist So I wanted a grandson00:22:35
see also the same professor00:22:37
philologists gave him this library and after00:22:40
death I have this library00:22:44
at home Your Honor Let me continue God00:22:48
with him with00:22:52
sets at home this set is my ex00:22:56
wife became malicious00:23:02
I'm picking up our son from school He00:23:07
gets into the car turns around00:23:10
A sausage sandwich and me, to my horror00:23:14
I see that this sandwich00:23:22
my mother's wrapped books00:23:25
keeps the warmth of her hands and the book on which00:23:28
I grew up in 2 days I'm coming for00:23:33
Slavik take him to the circus and I see how00:23:36
he and his friend let in00:23:37
airplanes What kind of airplanes are these from?00:23:40
pages of the lifetime edition00:23:44
Dostoevsky, you understand what is going on00:23:46
speech Well, you didn’t leave us anything00:23:49
no money, child, further on00:23:52
I had fun, my wife writes notes00:23:56
on the pages00:23:59
antique edition ipso you00:24:03
understand Meme at home00:24:06
Moscow architecture album pages00:24:10
1931 edition of which there are 50 pieces in total00:24:14
Let's get her00:24:18
let's come back Sorry I didn't say the main thing I00:24:21
received a birthday present this one00:24:23
lazy box in which00:24:26
from the cutting of painting reproductions this is what I am00:24:32
received a gift from his ex-wife00:24:34
understand, it’s very difficult for me now, but I00:24:37
need to be saved need to be saved00:24:40
Heritage is national00:24:43
there are no traces of this here00:24:48
persuasion defendant Let's get to the point00:24:51
after all ok please tell me for that00:24:54
so that this can be answered00:24:58
to one very important question indicated00:25:01
whose library is ours?00:25:04
is00:25:06
whose property is ours00:25:11
family I'm sorry you don't have a family00:25:13
the marriage is over she is mine00:25:15
the property of the defendant's son Tell me00:25:17
please the plaintiff pays alimony on00:25:19
child support No he left us00:25:22
hungry fathers don't pay any child support00:25:25
nothing left threw questions at me Answer00:25:28
please what what you told me00:25:31
You are repeating this for the eighth time already because00:25:33
that we will soon be eating toilet paper00:25:35
why do you work somewhere? I work at00:25:38
I'm very small for you in court Claim00:25:42
demand you go to court to court or rather with a claim00:25:45
applied for payment of alimony from00:25:46
side with and he left he left so I00:25:51
Finding him is not the answer Well stop it00:25:53
tell fairy tales Well, fairy tales00:25:55
Stop telling us it works00:25:57
court case, I asked him to buy it00:25:59
groceries and pay for his son's pool00:26:01
the answer was sent to me by the respondent, I am asking you00:26:04
Question: Have you gone to court? Why?00:26:08
because this is how it happened and what00:26:10
you think that you are not defending your own00:26:13
interests a To protect the interests of your00:26:15
the child is not able to go to court00:26:18
claim for alimony00:26:21
do you think the best way out?00:26:23
provisions for taking books and writing on them00:26:26
your notes00:26:29
Barbarians Barbarians in Ira and Napoleon in00:26:32
Russia and Hitler are not in the squares00:26:35
did ec plaintiff I ask you please00:26:38
let's go without yours let's go without yours00:26:41
Please no comments please00:26:43
comments you think you know00:26:47
where should you write a note in the margins of a book?00:26:50
you know how to take it to your husband but you will00:26:52
claim that where is the husband? No one00:26:54
doesn't know No, he told me don't give it to me00:26:56
for alimony00:26:58
I will later educate my son, he is00:27:00
Your Honor told me 2 years have already passed00:27:04
By the time he said there00:27:07
Dear set, I sold two cups00:27:09
from this service00:27:12
neighbors about mine00:27:19
income is the only thing I want00:27:21
understand there must be some logic in00:27:23
your position00:27:26
you know, not just to talk00:27:29
One for all for me for itza you for all00:27:33
you're talking, I should be the answer00:27:35
I forbid you to speak at all now00:27:38
there must be logic00:27:40
some kind of it lies in the fact that you00:27:43
must object to the claims00:27:45
claims level Let it not00:27:48
will give away the service And I books - this is for00:27:51
benches are not for trial, it’s on a bench like that00:27:54
talking court is not for this level00:27:56
conversations00:27:58
you 200:27:59
for years they did absolutely nothing for that00:28:02
to collect alimony you sell00:28:05
How are you00:28:06
approve cups that have no price now00:28:10
you demand the service back Well, what is the logic in00:28:12
what do you do when I cup00:28:15
I also sold the service and had it later00:28:17
stole That is, if you return the service you00:28:20
you'll sell cups if he didn't00:28:23
stole I would sell this service Yes00:28:25
because he doesn't have a price, he does have a price00:28:28
No, well, what should we do?00:28:31
slanderer you are witnesses00:28:33
stated Please00:28:36
please invite me to the hall00:28:38
witnesses00:28:40
defendant's witnesses00:28:48
Pass Hello Your Honor Me00:28:51
name is Rima Timofeevna Berezkina I00:28:54
I am a mother the answer but I want to say00:28:59
that I'm not here so much as a witness to my daughter00:29:02
I speak for my grandson00:29:05
stand up for my little blood00:29:07
Slavika is only 9 years old, several years old00:29:11
back at the birthday party of grandson Slavik00:29:13
my00:29:14
uh, the father of my ex-son-in-law Dmitry00:29:18
Alexey Dmitrievich Dear person00:29:21
Professor, by the way, a good person00:29:24
like that and He raised a glass of wine oh00:29:27
Forgive me a glass of wine for your health00:29:31
everyone present for my grandson00:29:33
Slavika and he in the presence of all the guests00:29:38
announced to everyone that he had his own library00:29:41
expensive library which is right now00:29:43
they try to divide and00:29:46
the service is very expensive, also the service How00:29:49
well we have a third person00:29:51
who saw this Servi Yes saw Servi00:29:54
good Servi very good00:30:02
witness I understood the sun What do you want00:30:04
say I understand the sun you know everything you00:30:07
say it has Well, you know that one too00:30:11
translation into legal language Well actually00:30:14
really all you want to say is00:30:16
translated into legal language00:30:19
you are the plaintiff00:30:22
prove prove00:30:26
Yara00:30:28
prove that you are the owner00:30:31
libraries you can't How do I00:30:33
I can prove it. Well, for example, you can00:30:36
prove this by the fact that you will00:30:39
justify the position that after death00:30:42
your father you actually entered into00:30:45
rights to follow the biblio because this is it00:30:47
of course00:30:49
Why Isn't that right Your Honor May I00:30:52
I'll interrupt the things they're doing right now00:30:57
publicly in front of all guests officially00:31:00
presented by Your Honor by grandfather to his grandson00:31:04
There is a will for the only grandson00:31:07
that there is a will What will00:31:09
my father's will in which00:31:13
apartment and everything movable00:31:17
the property is inherited by me00:31:21
as a direct heir Well, you will stand it00:31:23
can be considered no wait you00:31:25
came into inheritance00:31:29
how many years ago did you join00:31:32
inheritance Well, in a few months00:31:35
after my death00:31:37
father Okay then tell me this is me to you00:31:40
now I’ll say this 2 years 2 and a half years00:31:43
ago you inherited from me00:31:45
then a question for you if you consider yourself00:31:49
heir and according to the will entered into00:31:51
the right to follow all movable and00:31:54
real estate depending on00:31:56
where she was at the time of her death00:31:59
testator question why indicated00:32:02
the library was not local to you00:32:06
your residence if you consider yourself00:32:08
heir I explain to you the question here00:32:12
lies not in legal but in ethical00:32:14
in the field of natural science, please excuse me, let's talk about ethics00:32:18
the court has nothing to do with me and I lived00:32:21
wife and with my son in our common home00:32:24
and in the same house was our00:32:26
library once upon a time But he's your dad00:32:29
gave it to my grandson to continue00:32:32
the Kozlovsky family gave00:32:37
libraries plaintiff plaintiff and defendant and00:32:40
the court witness is removed for acceptance00:32:43
solutions Next in the program under the contract I00:32:47
promised to give it to you within a year00:32:50
I promised but that doesn’t mean that I give it to you00:32:52
gave already And if you are in 5 years00:32:54
I changed my mind, my sister would come and pick me up00:32:57
Alexandra promised to give her hers00:32:59
car but not for free but for 240,00000:33:02
rubles in the end all the money was paid but00:33:05
Alexandra's car is never00:33:07
gave as much as possible his person00:33:11
just take your own husband and00:33:14
put in my bed for money00:33:17
The couple fell into a debt trap00:33:19
neighbors helped them for a long time00:33:21
money and then demanded it urgently00:33:23
return the full amount with an alternative00:33:25
refund money She with00:33:28
at my husband's00:33:30
neighbors stay with00:33:34
us and now let's go back to the hall00:33:38
I ask everyone to judge00:33:42
sit down the court announces the decision made00:33:45
in the case the court heard the claims00:33:48
the defendant's objection to the stated00:33:50
claims by asking a witness with00:33:52
The defendant also considered everything00:33:54
submitted documents and00:33:55
evidence in a writ of certiorari00:33:58
property from someone else's illegal possession00:34:00
on payment of monetary compensation for00:34:02
The court considers part of the damaged property00:34:05
necessary to refuse the court refuses00:34:08
satisfaction of this claim because00:34:10
the plaintiff has not presented relevant00:34:13
evidence that the service00:34:15
belonged to him as a personal00:34:17
property is also not represented00:34:19
any evidence of existence at all00:34:22
this service and it was not produced00:34:24
assessment therefore claimed00:34:27
claims for monetary compensation00:34:29
in the amount of 80,000 scar in this judicial00:34:32
meeting, the amount of claims filed00:34:34
the claims were not proven, the plaintiff also could not00:34:38
present at this court hearing00:34:40
any evidence that is controversial00:34:42
the library belongs to him as his00:34:44
personal property or has been transferred00:34:47
him on the Right of Inheritance because00:34:50
After divorce and after00:34:52
entry into the hereditary00:34:56
the plaintiff's property actually ceased00:34:58
use the specified hereditary00:35:00
property leaving the controversial library in00:35:03
at the disposal of his ex-wife from00:35:05
what the court concludes based on that00:35:08
including testimony about00:35:10
that this property is property00:35:13
of a minor, the court explains00:35:15
issu and the defendant that the parents do not have00:35:18
rights to their property00:35:20
minors Thus,00:35:22
the court has no grounds to reclaim the property00:35:25
from someone else's illegal possession00:35:27
since actual ownership is debatable00:35:29
library is a minor00:35:31
the child is natural, the defendant the court announced its00:35:34
solution case closed please everyone00:35:38
stand up for a court decision in a lawsuit00:35:42
[music]00:35:43
refuse, I'm just discouraged by the decision00:35:46
court is just a license for vandalism I00:35:48
I will definitely protest because00:35:50
if my ex-wife can’t be stopped then00:35:53
what will be left to my heir from00:35:55
our property familial I think00:35:58
My husband and I will agree without court, I'll tell him00:36:02
his books and not mine00:36:07
cups, can you express yourself correctly?00:36:10
your claims This is only for you00:36:12
clear calculation I didn’t understand That is00:36:15
you added what you are Yes, I will add what I am on00:36:17
beat 10,000 and my claim for 15,000 from p00:36:20
subtract 10 five 5.000 she owes me00:36:23
I forgive her 10,000 due to the fact that I00:36:25
caused her sha demands they are with you00:36:27
amount to 5,000 rubles 15 15,000 rubles you know00:36:33
how should you defend your position?00:36:35
Wait crystal00:36:37
vase its fate Let's start from the very beginning00:36:40
began the crystal vase broke No I00:36:42
I understand that it was the defendant who crashed00:36:44
denies You're just saying that the defendant00:36:45
came and broke it, the defendant claims00:36:48
that you threw a vase at him, you know there00:36:50
there was such a bombing What who threw I already00:36:52
I don't remember on00:36:55
Sachet control your emotions You tell me00:36:58
suggested this crap answer answer00:37:02
I'm sorry, I'm sorry, it's you specifically00:37:04
Sorry00:37:05
accidentally judge Elena Dmitrieva will help00:37:09
find a way out of a difficult situation00:37:12
look at family matters and now let's go back00:37:15
to the courtroom00:37:17
plaintiff Alexandra Tarina files a claim for00:37:20
execution of a car donation agreement00:37:22
defendant Anna Kozina does not recognize the claim and00:37:25
claims that you eat00:37:27
change for the worse therefore no00:37:29
what a gift speech cannot go on00:37:33
years ago My sister and I made a deal00:37:36
an agreement under which her car is in a year00:37:39
becomes my property but my sister00:37:42
refuses to fulfill these now00:37:44
terms of the obligation00:37:47
contract the car she bought for00:37:50
husband's money What do you care about?00:37:53
I bought the money, it's mine00:37:55
the car is the crux of the matter, I bring in the judge and she00:37:59
She registered the car in her name but she drives it00:38:03
didn't become more accurate, she tried but she had00:38:05
it didn't work out how she put it she didn't00:38:08
feels the size, but you are the size00:38:10
you feel especially strange men00:38:13
Anh I'll say00:38:15
Yes, I was unemployed at that time.00:38:20
In general, two hobbies in life are horses00:38:22
and cars Wait, let's eat00:38:24
let's not get carried away, I beg you very much00:38:26
Yes, I can't help it00:38:30
No idea What do you want to say if I00:38:33
I understand correctly that a contract was concluded00:38:35
donation he was imprisoned under00:38:38
conditions precedent yes After a year00:38:41
the car becomes my property then00:38:44
there is a year within a year it turned out like this00:38:47
that my sister called me and said I00:38:50
I'm generally very passionate about cars.00:38:52
so I couldn’t even read what I had00:38:53
my job will be driving a car00:38:55
And then the owner of the company called00:38:58
the taxi in which her husband Pasha works00:39:01
hires chalky women00:39:04
taxi and yato is a fool00:39:06
[music]00:39:09
and I didn’t have a car and Anya00:39:11
offered and says take my car00:39:13
get a job 30% of salary00:39:16
monthly you will give me A through00:39:19
year The car will be yours Well, I agreed00:39:23
first of all cars this is me00:39:27
and in a year the car will be my salary00:39:29
I had00:39:30
big I agreed I agreed00:39:34
I transferred 12 months of the year to her as00:39:38
supposed to be 240,00000:39:43
RUB I gave her this money and waited for what00:39:46
she will fulfill her obligations but she00:39:48
it's still been more than a year she hasn't00:39:50
register the car in my name As it should00:39:52
I have the contract, everything is drawn up00:39:54
I have it notarized here00:39:57
donation there is a certificate of income from my00:40:00
work and I00:40:03
pay money but now she00:40:05
refuses, I have to go through court00:40:07
ask you to fulfill it00:40:11
obligations because we can't00:40:14
find a common language on this issue Yes I00:40:16
I refuse And I have everything arranged00:40:19
I refuse I want to counter00:40:21
The claim and why I refuse because00:40:23
a year ago financial situation and00:40:26
I had a marital status00:40:28
stable my dear sister we00:40:30
Divorcing my husband Thanks to my00:40:32
to my beloved sister who has everything now00:40:35
it took me away from me, we don't really have it now00:40:39
we share the car, I just have no health00:40:42
Help from the clinic, please be quiet00:40:46
Anya, well, I didn’t take him away from you, he’s00:40:48
not a car so I can have it with you Sorry00:40:51
that she changed my mind because00:40:56
her00:40:58
husband In general, he and I love each other00:41:02
that's why she's an insult, we don't like her00:41:04
wants to take this car back although I00:41:07
performed correctly for a whole year, I paid00:41:09
no money, you can tell me more00:41:11
tell me how much money you paid But00:41:14
then I recognize the deed of gift00:41:16
void as a contradiction00:41:17
current legislation and00:41:19
car on your budget00:41:22
honor If I understand the contract correctly00:41:26
will come into force exactly in a year Yes, not me00:41:29
I don’t see the contract yet, I have to now00:41:30
see what kind of gift agreement this is yes00:41:32
Please pass it through the judicial00:41:34
bailiff under the gift agreement plaintiff plaintiff00:41:37
Please tell me this is the situation yes00:41:40
because the fact is that the defendant can00:41:42
give00:41:44
just how to dispose of the property00:41:46
of which she is the owner00:41:49
a civil case has now been initiated00:41:53
legal proceedings in which this00:41:55
the car is considered controversial00:41:58
I promised to donate property under the contract00:42:02
I promised you for a year but it’s not00:42:05
it means that I already gave it to you A00:42:07
if you changed your mind in 5 years I would come00:42:09
took the plaintiff the plaintiff the plaintiff00:42:12
You see, there is a difference in this00:42:15
because what you have named00:42:18
contract promise donation from us00:42:21
is preliminary with you00:42:23
the contract then needed another one Yes00:42:27
of course not he could automatically00:42:29
turn into the main contract if00:42:32
the necessary conditions have arrived in this00:42:35
situations You have a contract promise of donation00:42:38
in which the main thing is If you00:42:40
looked at the subject of the contract it was there00:42:42
the defendant is clearly stated to be00:42:47
she is not the owner00:42:49
property Disputed her property So far00:42:52
not failed at the moment when it expired00:42:53
for the duration of the contract she remained her own00:42:56
that is, they only recently No, not00:42:59
not sure plaintiff this is not the subject of this00:43:01
claim but I’m also not sure00:43:04
because in general if this00:43:07
treated as joint property00:43:10
property then the defendant could not00:43:12
dispose of Even when imprisoned00:43:14
preliminary contract of property without00:43:18
written consent of your spouse00:43:20
You can’t give something that’s complete to you00:43:22
volume does not belong to me your judicial00:43:25
summons from whom statement through00:43:26
bailiff please pass it on00:43:28
can I hear my witness?00:43:31
can confirm that what I conveyed00:43:34
she got all the money, plaintiff Well, first of all, I00:43:37
if it weren't for that, I won't listen to your00:43:39
witness for two00:43:42
the first basis is monetary00:43:45
testimonial obligations00:43:48
Not00:43:49
monetary obligations are confirmed00:43:52
are always confirmed only in writing00:43:55
evidence that is, I am the Doge00:44:01
would be rasma as a remunerative agreement and not00:44:07
may be considered remunerative00:44:09
agreement because gift agreement dash00:44:12
free transaction understand00:44:14
gratuitous therefore yours00:44:16
evidence of what you conveyed00:44:18
money based on testimony00:44:21
testimony cannot be considered by the court00:44:24
as admissible relevant evidence00:44:27
they don't confirm anything at all00:44:29
except one at the discretion of the court to admit00:44:33
contract promise donation void00:44:35
deal and want to take everything into the budget00:44:38
witness no no court expelled Acceptance00:44:43
solutions Next in the program How to00:44:47
a man of his own00:44:54
Husband pays off debts interesting00:44:57
way her neighbor agreed to accept00:44:59
repayment of the debt in kind to her husband00:45:02
only the husband preferred love after the night00:45:04
stay with00:45:07
neighbors stay with00:45:12
us and now let's go back to the hall00:45:16
court the court announces the decision taken on00:45:19
court case having earned claims00:45:22
the defendant's objection to the stated00:45:24
claims from also having considered00:45:27
counterclaims filed00:45:29
defendant in this lawsuit00:45:31
meeting declared counterclaim court00:45:34
considers it necessary to satisfy and00:45:37
makes a decision to terminate the contract00:45:40
containing a promise to donate itza00:45:44
car in the original claim00:45:46
obligations00:45:48
execute the gift agreement the court considers00:45:51
necessary to refuse the court dissolves00:45:54
agreement concluded between the city and00:45:56
defendant which contains a promise00:46:00
donate a car to the plaintiff because00:46:03
that after the conclusion of this agreement00:46:06
property status of the defendant and her00:46:08
health status has changed so much00:46:11
that the execution of the contract is currently00:46:13
time will lead to a significant reduction00:46:16
her standard of living is appropriate00:46:18
evidence and documents by the defendant00:46:20
court hearings were presented and00:46:23
no matter00:46:24
also disputed this essential00:46:28
change in property status00:46:30
is confirmed by documents about00:46:32
divorce proceedings and certificates of00:46:35
medical condition00:46:38
the presence of divorce proceedings and00:46:40
stated claims in the section00:46:43
jointly pressing this property also in00:46:45
did not challenge this court hearing00:46:48
satisfy the counterclaim00:46:50
accordingly refuses00:46:51
initial and does not make a decision on00:46:53
obligation answer transfer gift controversial00:46:56
car in the property of justice00:46:59
This judgment was made in00:47:01
in accordance with the rules of part one00:47:03
articles00:47:04
577 and part two of Article 57200:47:07
Russian Civil Code00:47:09
Federation plaintiff is clear Yes I hope so00:47:13
you understand the court decision, I understand that00:47:15
I bought her husband for 240,000 Well you can00:47:17
consider the situation this way, the answer is to you00:47:20
I understand the answer, you understand the decision00:47:23
court the court announced its decision the case was closed00:47:27
court decision to dismiss the claim00:47:30
satisfy the counter00:47:32
lawsuit I certainly feel guilty before00:47:35
sister for the fact that Pasha is now with me, well00:47:39
Let's assume that I bought it for 24,00000:47:42
the car that I dreamed about my husband not in00:47:46
the car was happy I just lost it00:47:48
the people closest to me and00:47:52
[music]00:47:54
Mu Zhdan is that they all be00:47:58
equally subject to laws separately00:48:02
once again the court specifically explains to you00:48:05
responder to you specifically If you00:48:08
went to court, study wisely00:48:10
defend your position Well, I'm not interested00:48:13
what we sang, what songs we sang00:48:15
we divide apartments and cars we divide apartments00:48:18
cars money and more and also seven00:48:22
chickens 10 ducks and one small00:48:24
the pig here will be divided according to everything00:48:27
justice look00:48:30
carefully And now let's go back to the hall00:48:35
plaintiff Maria Glotova demands from the court00:48:39
the defendant to return the debt in the amount of 20,00000:48:41
rub defendant Zinaida Khvostova claim not00:48:44
admits makes a counterclaim for00:48:46
repayment of the debt according to the receipt in the amount00:48:49
10,000 rubles, well, we had a normal one00:48:53
good strong family like Russia and us00:48:56
lived on credit took money on credit00:48:59
gave it away And then the crisis struck00:49:02
I worked as a manager for the company I worked for.00:49:04
I worked, I went broke, I was fired and00:49:07
Husband was not paid any money upon dismissal00:49:10
I also worked in commerce and it worked out00:49:13
the situation is that he also has a salary00:49:16
detained for several months He didn't00:49:18
receives a salary and we have a loan00:49:21
which we didn’t take a month to repair00:49:23
we can pay another month00:49:25
pay off Well, this is from the zid00:49:29
Romanovna is your defendant00:49:31
honor In general, the defendant says service00:49:34
security are you interested in a loan00:49:36
need to repay, but there’s no money. Where am I?00:49:38
I can take the money And we are friends00:49:40
were she lives on the floor above but she told me00:49:42
so it seems like he says in a friendly way come on00:49:44
says I'll lend you money against00:49:46
receipt Well, we borrowed money from her00:49:49
and there’s nothing else to give the loan from00:49:52
once they took two they took these receipts and00:49:54
Accumulated in general One day she me00:49:56
somehow meets you at the entrance and says00:49:58
Listen says Mash Your honor even to me00:50:00
It’s inconvenient to tell says Mash at your place00:50:03
says the guy says cute00:50:05
says the prominent lend him to me for00:50:08
night and I'm for you00:50:10
everything up to the head of the receipt00:50:13
I'm sorry, I was in shock, can you imagine?00:50:16
something the blonde came up with I'm just shocked00:50:18
I'm in tears, my husband is back, he's there00:50:21
posters for 100 rubles pecked I returned to him00:50:23
I posted all this and said: Well then00:50:26
say do says I realize that I00:50:28
the man is the head of the family so to speak00:50:31
financial problems for the family are mine00:50:33
problems says I'll go work on this00:50:37
the debt was returned in the morning, laundered, swore to me00:50:41
in eternal love and fidelity says Yes I00:50:43
speaks to this one only when necessary00:50:46
to say I say again says again00:50:48
and that's all00:50:54
such00:50:58
money In general, Zinka tells me what00:51:00
says let's say that's what he says00:51:03
under00:51:04
receipt Well, in general, he’s there again00:51:08
went again went and did not return and so00:51:12
in the end what happens is I was left without00:51:14
money without a husband and so I want her00:51:17
now here is the receipt Here it is in her hand00:51:19
this document is written I want her00:51:21
I got these money back for rendering00:51:24
services00:51:26
Beth doesn't have it, let her Vert me00:51:29
rub That is, if I understood you correctly00:51:32
that you are providing services yourself00:51:35
admit, well, you say custom00:51:38
services provided provided by the investigator00:51:42
the fact of the provision of services you00:51:45
admit And this is that the services that are in00:51:48
the loan was provided here's how00:51:50
there is a defendant m writing a receipt that she00:51:52
I owe you00:51:54
where to sign from it Well, how could it be otherwise yours00:51:57
honor is by mutual consent00:51:59
agreement for the provision of Please ask00:52:02
you have already repaid the loan that was taken00:52:04
loan Yes, we paid it off. Well, let's get a receipt00:52:07
Then through the bailiff00:52:09
Please Yes Please answer me00:52:11
I'm listening I want to say that I'm not going to00:52:16
pay off any debt in the amount of 20,000 rubles00:52:19
my ex00:52:21
girlfriends, not only how long have I had her00:52:24
borrowed it incomprehensibly and00:52:27
ran to me less at home than00:52:28
I have how much I gave her without00:52:32
you would know all sorts of receipts and here on00:52:35
she please don't do any good to you00:52:37
you'll get evil, she's still pushing now00:52:40
a lawsuit against me in the amount of 20,000 rubles00:52:42
Well, I also found her receipts00:52:45
outstanding in the amount of 10,000 rubles here00:52:48
let her, let me put forward a counterclaim00:52:51
she will pay me off, my dear friend00:52:53
claim for 10,00000:52:56
First you repay the debt to me and I will give you00:52:57
10,000 of this money will be nothing00:53:00
repayments all this is her contract this00:53:03
nothing more than a filkin’s letter, what is it00:53:06
before Filkina there is a letter there with your hand00:53:09
written You were hoarding in your mind00:53:11
please answerer Well first of all it's not00:53:13
the contract is what is presented by the person00:53:15
receipt I undertake to pay Titova00:53:18
Maria Mikhailov, this is for you until September 2200:53:23
20,000 rubles in brackets00:53:26
rubles for intimate services provided to me00:53:29
good husband but this receipt does not have00:53:32
this has no legal value00:53:35
the receipt is contrary to all norms and00:53:38
moral rules and00:53:39
morality00:53:41
Riya You sold your husband You're from00:53:44
him a prostitute00:53:47
did you think00:53:49
yours Please tell me00:53:54
slashing00:53:56
now her ex husband lives with me00:53:58
husband He is now my favorite man00:54:01
in the world living with men like you00:54:04
speak communication with whom contradicted00:54:07
standards of morality and morality do not00:54:08
confuses Well, the thing is that she herself00:54:11
sold for money you understand for money00:54:14
how can you be your own person?00:54:17
it’s so easy to take a husband and put him under00:54:19
into my bed for money, you understand00:54:24
slashing00:54:26
here there is enough strict decree for intimate00:54:28
the services provided to me and my husband were good00:54:30
intimate services were really but you00:54:32
you see, this is her initiative00:54:35
I wanted you to suggest00:54:38
she is the plaintiff you asked for your witness00:54:41
parties Invite fasting want your husband00:54:45
respondent respondent No, of course you can00:54:47
invite your beloved man but not00:54:49
court here the court invites the retinue from the Rhone00:54:54
please answer in the witness room with00:54:56
the defendant's side is not even00:55:00
figure me out00:55:07
humiliate please I listen to you Me00:55:09
name is Lotov Valery Nikolaevich I want00:55:12
say that we have a relationship with the night00:55:14
were mutual and no receipts here00:55:17
should not be attributed what money00:55:19
Mine demands00:55:22
the same with no new one left I left00:55:26
apartments in Turkish home nothing00:55:28
took almost he came empty nothing00:55:30
wasn't enough What are you even talking about00:55:32
man or whoever is just in the apartment00:55:34
Zina I understand what true love is00:55:37
what is care what is attention00:55:40
Excuse me please witness And you are00:55:42
understood the moment you were paid00:55:44
First00:55:45
money no money I wasn't paid I just00:55:48
understood the relationship difference when I lived with00:55:50
Mashenka we had completely different00:55:52
relationship Excuse me please witness00:55:55
but the thing is that naturally the question00:55:57
the court showed whether the loan was repaid00:56:00
what yes The loan is fully repaid from what00:56:02
I must conclude that the defendant00:56:05
the defendant did not deny that she00:56:07
paid for the relevant services00:56:10
which you provided to the defendant in response00:56:13
that I worked, the money I spent on00:56:16
repairs to equipment, all this was left to her00:56:18
fool Yes, she bought you from head to toe00:56:20
she's fed up with you00:56:23
and understand your logic. That is, what are you saying? Well00:56:29
I left everything because why Well, here I am00:56:33
I left everything to my wife for a reason because00:56:34
it was in this family in her apartment that I00:56:36
I understand what true love is00:56:39
such understanding I understood my relationship00:56:41
exactly in this apartment, that is, not in00:56:43
corridor, namely in the apartment with Masha00:56:45
it was completely different, you know she00:56:48
she didn't consider me a person00:56:49
I didn't say the words correctly00:56:52
the court retires to make a decision00:56:56
Now let's go back to the courtroom and find out00:56:59
solution00:57:01
judges the court announces the decision made on00:57:04
case the court has earned the plaintiff's claims00:57:07
the defendant's objection to the stated00:57:08
claims and also having considered00:57:11
counterclaims filed00:57:13
defendant in this court hearing00:57:15
interviewed a witness on behalf of the defendant and00:57:17
having considered all the submitted00:57:19
evidence in the original claim00:57:21
collection of funds00:57:23
provided for by the conditions00:57:26
the court considers the provision of services00:57:28
necessary to refuse and makes a decision on00:57:31
recovery of advisers for state income00:57:34
the amount stipulated by the contract in00:57:36
in the amount of 20 rubles counterclaims00:57:39
the claim satisfies and00:57:41
collects a claim in favor of the defendant00:57:44
a sum of money in the amount of 10 rubles court00:57:48
denies satisfaction of the main claim00:57:50
because he finds a contract00:57:53
honey contrary to morality00:57:56
moral and ethical standards and00:57:58
relationships between people that is00:58:00
violating the rules of Article 16900:58:03
Russian Civil Code00:58:04
Federation treaty contradictory00:58:07
morality is insignificant That is, he is not00:58:09
gives rise to no legal consequences00:58:11
therefore satisfaction of your stated00:58:13
claims rejected, the court considers00:58:16
necessary to apply the rules of Article 16900:58:19
Russian Civil Code00:58:21
Federation as a conflicting deal00:58:24
Rav00:58:25
namely, the consequences of the transaction according to the characteristics00:58:28
her insignificance and seeks advisers in00:58:32
income of the Russian Federation cash00:58:34
means that the plaintiffs would read in00:58:37
in the amount of 20,000 rubles, the court satisfies00:58:40
counterclaim and collects the claim in00:58:43
in favor of the defendant 10,000 rubles because00:58:46
the court was presented with written00:58:48
proof of debt00:58:50
relations is personally written and00:58:53
signing a receipt for her00:58:57
specified amount of money to be borrowed by the court00:59:00
I'd like to clarify00:59:03
that of course you are the one I’m addressing to you00:59:07
You have the right to demand in order00:59:10
presentation of the so-called recourse00:59:13
claim for half of that amount00:59:15
directly from your spouse00:59:17
since your marriage is not currently00:59:19
dissolved and the spouses bear joint and several00:59:22
liability for the debts of one00:59:24
spouses That is, if you consider00:59:26
you need then 5,000 rubles you are ok00:59:29
regress, that is, turning to another00:59:31
person you have the right to recover from your00:59:33
your spouse is responsible for your income00:59:36
state 20,000 rubles plaintiff you00:59:40
defendant 10,000 rubles because00:59:43
written evidence provided00:59:45
plus You have the opportunity to collect from00:59:47
your spouse 5,000 rubles plaintiff defendant00:59:51
the court announced its decision in the case00:59:53
The court's decision to deny the claim was closed00:59:57
satisfy the counter00:59:59
lawsuit I think that Valerka still comes to me01:00:02
this Zinka will return to him for now01:00:05
the new product is being played and will come to me01:00:07
home men are now very big01:00:10
there is a shortage so we need them01:00:13
[music]01:00:23
take care01:00:26
Do you know what to do if your child01:00:28
committed a crime in their place01:00:30
rattles grenade toy machine you01:00:34
want to receive alimony even if you01:00:36
the father of the child has no income01:00:38
a penny I haven’t seen you Well maybe a day01:00:40
it turns out that the law has changed01:00:43
surrogacy is important I01:00:46
gave birth I'm the mother I didn't feed him for 2 days01:00:48
It’s important what’s in this damn contract01:00:50
written This is my child Especially for01:00:53
free legal services work for you01:00:56
consultation I bequeath my son01:00:58
Got it We will protect yours01:01:01
[music]01:01:21
children watch the courtroom01:01:25
Her mother and daughter are the first in Russia01:01:29
judicial TV channel01:01:31
divorce proceedings tomorrow and without01:01:33
all sorts of beautiful dates01:01:36
the greediest every day01:01:40
They are the most deceitful01:01:43
the defendants are right here, we need this money01:01:46
the fairest01:01:48
judges learn to protect their rights01:01:52
see Deme Elena Dmitrieva judicial01:01:56
passions with Nikolai Burdelov01:01:59
Hour of judgment with Pavel Astakhov Battle for01:02:02
money with Dmitry01:02:05
Agris new stories with Elena01:02:11
[music]01:02:23
Kutina01:02:26
[music]01:02:31
hot showdowns right in the courtroom You01:02:34
came and went, you swore your love to me01:02:37
undeserved dousing01:02:40
dirt01:02:42
you won't answer for tea01:02:45
do you think small tragedies are due to01:02:48
big nonsense sun That's what I'm saying01:02:50
family life and career and everything in general01:02:52
The sun collapsed at one moment, you didn’t01:02:55
never seen Your Honor 11 years husband01:03:00
no, all this is in the judicial program01:03:03
passions with Nikolai Burdelov01:03:06
[music]01:03:18
[applause]01:03:23
[applause] [music]01:03:25
beats our men and then takes them away01:03:27
they plow his plot A to us01:03:29
comes then takes eggs then doesn't suck01:03:32
let's say he takes out a gun and shoots01:03:34
shoots Roman Karavaev acquired01:03:36
country house for family01:03:38
enjoy the peace and quiet but dream01:03:40
it was not destined to come true because behind the fence01:03:43
lived the local policeman who opened01:03:45
shooting at new neighbors01:03:48
the new Russians arrived and made a finger01:03:51
and Dava was demolished, Dey was carried by cars01:03:55
we need to put some kind of kindergartens nearby01:03:58
HOA members also wanted to close it01:04:01
arrange a parking lot in the yard but for01:04:03
the old dovecote should have been demolished01:04:05
unexpectedly found near this building01:04:08
they are the defenders of the yard boys01:04:10
declared a real war on the HOA. She believes01:04:14
that she bought me, signed a contract and01:04:16
I bought it with whoever I want and live with it01:04:21
Want01:04:23
the agreement was brutally destroyed01:04:26
the groom did not finish building her barn and the street to live in01:04:29
Lavila demands return to another woman01:04:31
Ben for the saw And Gvozdeva claims that01:04:34
saw compensation for broken01:04:37
[music]01:04:41
plaintiff Roman Karavaev presents his heart01:04:44
claim for compensation for material damage01:04:46
in the amount of 3500 rubles for the treatment of a dog01:04:49
which the defendant injured and compensation01:04:51
moral damage in the amount of 100,000 rubles01:05:00
Hello please01:05:02
sit down hearing01:05:05
open Your honor my name is Karavaev01:05:09
Roman Alexandrovich 3 months ago I01:05:11
bought a plot of land with a house for a summer cottage on01:05:14
where I spend summer time with my01:05:18
family answer01:05:23
only at the end01:05:26
weeks I work as a journalist in Moscow and01:05:29
I spend all my summer time and vacation on01:05:33
I like to do housework in my dacha01:05:35
affairs01:05:36
on one's own01:05:38
so a week ago I built a summer one myself01:05:42
water supply which was one of01:05:44
reasons for our01:05:46
conflict on Friday night I heard01:05:50
unexpectedly the shooting was completely01:05:52
shocking fact that there was no shooting01:05:55
no shooting that you are a hundred loud01:05:57
claps shot from a pistol I went out01:05:59
street and saw that there were picket fences01:06:01
Empty cans placed on the fence01:06:04
from under the beer and on them Your honor neighbor01:06:07
mine fires accurately in honor01:06:10
Yes, there was no such thing. He’s lying, it’s all me.01:06:12
did the citizen give you his word?01:06:15
Major No not01:06:18
I gave the hem to the fence and asked01:06:21
urgently01:06:23
stop, resolve this issue peacefully01:06:25
by the way I determined that my neighbor is01:06:27
drunk because he is, first of all, very drunk01:06:29
swearing and screaming as he ran up to the fence01:06:32
he accused me of being01:06:35
the destroyer of this fence and what I01:06:38
I reinforced the plastic pipe myself01:06:40
that I’m nobody here at all and he’s an old-timer and01:06:43
basically I should just keep quiet01:06:45
his01:06:47
performance I tried it again01:06:49
calm down but he just started threatening Yes01:06:51
you threaten me with a dog with a weapon01:06:54
weapons, namely weapons, Your Honor, so A01:06:56
did you know that this was a police officer?01:06:59
I couldn't imagine this The only thing01:07:01
what have you that you haven't seen him in before01:07:04
I've never seen him in uniform01:07:06
just this time on this day on this evening01:07:09
I saw he was wearing police trousers and01:07:12
gave out But you already said that yes yes And01:07:14
this is in confirmation and so I started for you01:07:16
threaten with a weapon started threatening with a weapon01:07:18
happened and happened the following lives with me01:07:21
fighting rotwell named Fox he he01:07:24
popped up completely naturally01:07:26
into the yard and started barking loudly at01:07:28
directly my neighbor your what is he01:07:30
poisoned him on me it caused01:07:33
completely inadequate01:07:35
nation neighbor, he pulled out a gun and01:07:37
told me to urgently shut my mouth01:07:40
and started shooting at the dog. And you told me01:07:42
tell me01:07:48
fence shop01:07:51
seeing him is elementary and easy one and a half01:07:54
meter fence this fence can dog01:07:57
overcome on my own and imagined01:08:00
Is your Rottweiler a danger to your dog?01:08:03
a citizen who, although with a weapon,01:08:05
after all, there is a fence behind the fence. Well, answering01:08:08
to your first question yes my dog01:08:10
Elementary can jump over this01:08:12
fence but only if she doesn’t01:08:14
tied to a chain in this case through01:08:17
the entire territory of my site passes01:08:19
a specially tensioned cable on which01:08:21
my dog is wearing a collar but being01:08:24
Of course he rushed like a fighting dog01:08:26
to protect his master he jumped on01:08:28
the fence but he couldn't jump over it01:08:30
outraged my neighbor he started01:08:32
literally shoot him01:08:35
the neighbor saw that the dog couldn't01:08:38
overcome this fence of course because01:08:41
my dog tried with his claws the king01:08:45
so So the neighbor is convinced And what next01:08:47
he yelled the next thing that he himself was zant01:08:52
the mouth of my PSU arrows but at the same time01:08:55
incident As they say, it only went into01:08:57
another stage my neighbor pointed at me01:08:58
the gun said that the next victim01:09:00
I will be moreover after this he will burn01:09:03
my01:09:04
a house so that everyone doesn’t behave01:09:07
to do as I did it I naturally sue Iz01:09:10
what does your claim consist of?01:09:12
the next claim is 35,500 rubles for treatment and01:09:17
dog care all documents01:09:19
confirming that it was carried out01:09:21
surgery and treatment at the veterinary clinic01:09:24
I can attach and also since my dog01:09:27
was unfortunately a medalist of many01:09:30
there are more international competitions now01:09:32
cannot participate in these victorious01:09:35
tournaments and that's why I'm bringing a claim in01:09:38
in the amount of 100,000 rubles for moral damage01:09:41
So01:09:42
I'm so worried about the fact that I'm not01:09:45
I will do more Have you consulted a doctor?01:09:48
can you prove that in fact01:09:50
as a result of these01:09:52
your neighbor you were treated for01:09:56
What01:09:58
did you have any health problems?01:10:01
Yes of course yes Thank you please pass it on01:10:03
please give me all the documents01:10:06
will let you know what you have to say01:10:09
lawsuit Your Honor I am a district police officer01:10:12
in this area as usual in this01:10:13
site Yes on this site I am01:10:15
district police officer myself, I live in village A on01:10:18
they only come to the dacha on weekends01:10:19
usually on Friday evening I arrived with01:10:21
work at the dacha rest look at mine01:10:24
the fence that I personally built with my own01:10:26
hands some kind of pipe01:10:28
screwed through the fence I saw a neighbor01:10:30
who stood on the ring of his house I01:10:32
I called him and said get yours out of here01:10:33
Pipe and this pipe was on your side01:10:36
No it was a pipe on his part but she01:10:38
there was a key on my fence which I01:10:39
built with his own money Well, it stings01:10:42
me a little Well That side That side01:10:44
which overlooks the neighbor's street01:10:47
Prim's neighbor's plot here is yours01:10:50
some right not a fence my your honor01:10:54
fence regardless of who it is01:10:57
built it is common property01:11:01
if there is no contract agreement and on01:11:04
is there any fence01:11:09
exchange of property your mais what next01:11:13
what happened next I explained to him01:11:15
ok, get the pipe out of here, he01:11:18
started telling me that I won’t do anything01:11:20
take away01:11:22
and sgo n who ran Oh so said Fox01:11:25
take this scum01:11:26
red What does rudd mean scum Well I01:11:29
I don’t know, maybe in his terms01:11:32
police officers are bad01:11:34
people Why are redfins so good?01:11:37
some Zonovian concepts are probably not01:11:39
I know, well, what happened next, so I look at the dog01:11:43
rushes towards me and the drool is already flowing onto the fence01:11:45
climbed accordingly I got it correctly01:11:47
weapon and used weapon First01:11:49
productive shot in the air and then01:11:52
already to defeat l understandable That is, I don’t01:11:55
I deny that I shot the dog but this01:11:57
it was purely self-defense because01:11:59
that the dog could close my throat01:12:01
saw that the dog was on a leash Yes01:12:03
he wasn't on a leash Your Honor he wasn't01:12:05
was on a leash. What is the height of the fence?01:12:07
one and a half meters about one and a half meters On01:12:09
how far from the fence was the dog01:12:13
When01:12:14
you fired a shot, how long has it been01:12:17
he was ready to jump over the fence01:12:19
his Your Honor Let me say a couple01:12:22
words mean everything my respondent said01:12:24
is completely opposite01:12:26
history of what happened and in addition to01:12:29
because the truth was behind me I have01:12:31
another witness is our neighbor too01:12:34
which I would like to invite01:12:38
please invite me for a certificate01:12:40
Itza witnesses Itza witnesses01:12:49
Pass01:12:50
Hello, before I add witnesses01:12:54
I would like to ask a question to the respondent You01:12:58
sent a report on the use of weapons in01:13:01
in due course of course you are there01:13:03
sent sent a report you wrote01:13:05
statement of what was applied01:13:06
weapons including threatening weapons to you01:13:09
Absolutely true and also carried out01:13:12
independent ballistic examination01:13:14
which confirmed that the bullets were fired from01:13:16
pistol is registered for01:13:19
directly I do not deny that I01:13:21
shot a dog but it was exclusively01:13:22
self-defense was a criminal case01:13:24
initiated No the case was hushed up after01:13:27
why I decided to go to court that is01:13:29
a decision was made to refuse01:13:31
initiation of a criminal case Absolutely01:13:33
that's right, the thing is that, uh, my area01:13:36
it's nearby so I heard01:13:39
shots uh from afar saw uh what's up01:13:44
It's like a dog fell but it's close to me01:13:49
there was no time, but I can do the most important thing01:13:52
talk about moral character in general01:13:54
he does this endlessly01:13:56
shooting01:13:59
Are you reading? Shut up there. Stand up.01:14:01
please introduce yourself Your Honor I am01:14:04
I also live in the country and I can say this01:14:06
lawless man is not power, it's not at all01:14:08
shame they used to charge you know how01:14:11
He can’t take any bribes like that01:14:13
with money he means what he does, drinks with01:14:15
our men then take them away from01:14:17
him plows at the site And comes to us01:14:20
either he takes the eggs or we don’t give him the chickens01:14:22
pulls a gun at a chicken01:14:27
shoots me alone in this area01:14:29
collection I have nothing I have them01:14:31
good list for the ambassador01:14:34
oh give me01:14:36
I'll tell you the actual track record01:14:39
The thing is that about Every Friday This is it01:14:43
Grandma said it right, she’s coming to01:14:45
area and starts firing from his01:14:48
the pistol fires somewhere it misses01:14:51
hit the dog with someone yes Here are my pigeons01:14:55
here take you look at what he is01:14:59
I created a Dovecote I01:15:01
raised purebred pigeons on which01:15:04
the whole village came running and what did he do with01:15:07
he turned pigeons into living targets01:15:10
You see, these are live pigeons01:15:14
who are so handsome, show me01:15:17
what a beauty they are, oh well, don’t, it’s not01:15:19
is relevant to the case as it is not A01:15:21
this is the dead body that I cashed01:15:26
elu chickens photographed themselves in addition01:15:31
What kind of board do you have next to you?01:15:34
the board is evidence01:15:36
The fact is that I ran to the station to01:15:39
we took my neighbor a loaf of bread together01:15:43
several boards were taken for examination and01:15:46
these holes were installed there01:15:50
traces of01:15:52
bullets01:16:00
part That is, this is the sun And how long ago is it01:16:03
continues in your garden01:16:06
we have all been in partnership for several years now01:16:09
Why were they discharged?01:16:22
statements01:16:27
militsi bundi ska when you protect01:16:30
keep quiet and now he has appeared01:16:33
the hero leaves to make a decision01:16:36
I ask everyone01:16:39
stand up Next in the program we've arrived01:16:42
the new Russians made their fingers like a fan and01:16:45
Let's demolish everything, there was a children's playground01:16:47
SS cars should be some kind of children's01:16:50
the gardens nearby were also closed by the old Dovecote01:16:54
went to the pensioner by inheritance, he and01:16:56
as boys he took care of birds and even01:16:59
opened a small pigeon business01:17:01
released at weddings in honor of the groom and01:17:03
bride but the neighbors planned to deprive him01:17:06
this joy She thinks she bought me01:17:08
signed the contract and01:17:10
I bought with whomever I want and live with whomever01:17:14
I want to fulfill the contract I fulfilled Roman01:17:17
the carav cruelly deceived Irina's expectations01:17:19
Nail not only her barn was not completed01:17:21
but e and st01:17:23
grief, the groom dreams of returning at least his01:17:25
chainsaw but Gvozdeva considers it01:17:28
compensation for what was spent on it01:17:33
time the court decision is announced I want01:17:37
tell you that that evidence01:17:39
which I received in court01:17:41
meeting01:17:44
Absolutely sufficient to01:17:47
satisfy your01:17:48
demands of the person who causes harm01:17:52
obliged in full therefore I01:17:56
satisfying the claim, I believe that you caused01:17:59
guilty actions owe their harm01:18:03
reimburse in full the declared01:18:07
requirements including compensation01:18:09
moral damage because01:18:11
the plaintiff proved to me that he suffered01:18:14
experienced moral and physical01:18:17
suffering for this amount is now what01:18:20
concerns your offense the court rules01:18:24
private definition and sends it to your01:18:28
management is a particular definition for01:18:31
taking the necessary measures if I am in01:18:34
within a month as planned01:18:36
Article 226 of civil procedure01:18:39
code I will not receive a response from your01:18:41
management I will take all necessary measures01:18:45
for that01:18:46
to hold you accountable for01:18:49
shooting in the wrong place for01:18:51
The use of weapons for what you01:18:53
pointing weapons at civilians01:18:56
persons being a police officer being01:19:01
representative01:19:04
authorities I believe that in your actions01:19:08
there is also an administrative composition01:19:10
offenses and maybe01:19:12
corpus delicti But this01:19:15
the investigative committee will decide01:19:18
at01:19:19
[music]01:19:21
prosecutor's office01:19:26
court decision claim01:19:29
[music]01:19:32
satisfy the plaintiff chairman of the HOA01:19:35
demands to oblige the defendant to demolish01:19:37
unauthorized erected structure defendant01:19:40
Mikhail Frolov does not recognize the claim and01:19:42
makes a counterclaim for recognition for01:19:44
him ownership rights to01:19:47
[music]01:19:49
pigeons listening01:19:51
I am honored to be Matitsa Galina Borisovna01:19:54
chairman of the owners' association01:19:56
housing house number 15 I came to court01:20:00
protect the interests of our members01:20:03
partnership a year ago01:20:06
and we organized a Partnership01:20:08
homeowners in multi-apartment buildings01:20:10
house built on the territory of an old01:20:15
in the courtyard of old five-story buildings01:20:18
new building01:20:20
means built in this yard01:20:24
our new building is quite populated01:20:27
rich people are decent01:20:30
And we would like on our territory01:20:32
arrange a yard01:20:35
parking lot for this purpose we01:20:38
privatized the territory of our yard01:20:41
Yes, you didn’t privatize it, you just01:20:44
received this in accordance with the law01:20:47
land ownership Yes I have01:20:50
agreement confirming this fact01:20:52
property only there maybe two01:20:54
ways to own or rent01:20:56
we own this01:20:58
territory I have documents01:21:01
confirming ownership rights and01:21:03
land and apartments for all residents I understand01:21:08
So01:21:10
means when we01:21:12
privatized when we privatized01:21:14
this land took quite a lot01:21:18
time period around 901:21:20
months unexpectedly01:21:23
there was one problem on site01:21:27
this courtyard was built a long time ago01:21:31
I don’t know 100 years ago probably01:21:33
The dovecote is the owner of this dovecote01:21:37
didn't show up, we invited the Builders01:21:39
which should have been demolished01:21:41
this dovecote was never announced but the pigeons01:21:43
there were pigeons, yes they were there01:21:46
there were pigeons but no owner Yes he is01:21:48
somehow didn’t figure in principle We01:21:50
practically didn’t know his name Well01:21:53
the residents of Kone didn't want to know you01:21:55
you know the inhabitants of these houses - This is old01:21:57
building five-story buildings they probably01:21:59
knew each other We have everything in common01:22:01
decent people who came to live in01:22:03
new building we have a high-rise building is interesting01:22:06
that is, people who lived in these old01:22:09
houses Yes, these are indecent people and you01:22:12
who came to the new building are decent01:22:14
We bought apartments where people lived01:22:17
I don't know much there for a long time01:22:21
I've accumulated decades there01:22:26
you are the Duma, then everything is allowed to them and people01:22:29
we already live there01:22:31
a lot of catches, shut up, I say give me01:22:35
The treaties are facing a big problem01:22:38
it was Mr. Frolov who just stood up with his chest01:22:40
to protect this01:22:43
depths found out found out about that that about that that01:22:48
the head of this dovecote or owner01:22:50
dovecotes there is a certain Frolov, he’s just01:22:53
stood up for the breasts That's how we saw him01:22:55
In general, he showed up and was known to be like this01:22:58
no way with him at all01:23:01
unexpectedly I decided to solve this somehow01:23:03
controversial issue contacted the district01:23:05
council means in the district council to me01:23:07
told me before you tell me01:23:10
about government in which there are many questions01:23:13
can be solved I understand that you tell me01:23:16
tell me when did you build this house01:23:19
The dovecote stood. Yes, it stood there for a hundred years.01:23:22
This is the old Dovecote but not01:23:24
gly01:23:26
new She was always updated and painted01:23:28
and she cleaned up completely01:23:31
ownerless Let me ask a question01:23:33
absolutely ownerless Give me a question01:23:35
ask Yes, I want to know when you01:23:39
started the process of land registration in01:23:42
property this Dovecote also stood01:23:44
Yes, she was there when you started01:23:47
registration you had to invite01:23:50
surveyor and BTI Yes, chewing in general01:23:55
yes please tell me everything01:23:58
documents confirming me everything01:24:00
documentation01:24:02
since the measurement of the Earth was01:24:04
everything was done was done within the law01:24:08
right they told me that of course two01:24:11
there cannot be owners of the same land01:24:13
I don't need to know what you were told I01:24:16
Somehow I'll figure it out from the documents like this01:24:19
here in accordance with the documents01:24:22
floor in b here here here it is applied01:24:26
some kind of building It’s really not indicated01:24:29
like pigeons but this building is indicated01:24:33
now the registration certificate01:24:35
your his01:24:36
absolutely strange there are no rights01:24:41
encumbrances, these are the issues you solved01:24:44
V01:24:51
municipal Galina Borisovna answer01:24:53
to the questions that I ask you specifically01:24:56
did you resolve these issues in the council yes yes01:25:01
I was reassured that I was the only one01:25:03
The owner of the land is our Partnership01:25:05
homeowners is01:25:07
the owner of his ilk and this land on01:25:10
territory of the yard I am absolutely calm01:25:14
naturally invited workers who01:25:16
should have demolished this junk which01:25:18
we needed this fishing to appear01:25:24
who invited some other guys01:25:26
boys but naturally against children01:25:28
of course we are not natural with ours01:25:30
We do not use excavators and large equipment01:25:34
Of course, naturally, children should be respected01:25:37
love them01:25:38
you know the homeowners too01:25:42
must be respected We bought apartments that01:25:45
it's not cheap, you know there in the yard01:25:47
Mal play Nede's only hobby01:25:50
pigeons spotting was carried out in01:25:53
a high-rise building was built legally01:25:56
your house is these five-story buildings and you01:25:59
We're used to living there like in a barn. Sorry.01:26:01
we paid a lot of money and we want01:26:04
We all01:26:06
car owners are the owners of this01:26:08
apartment building are01:26:11
car owner So we wanted01:26:14
organize the hidden car you need01:26:17
this Earth to organize01:26:18
parking lot and you want to admit it this01:26:21
goal01:26:27
[music]01:26:30
I'm listening to you Your Honor Hello lo01:26:34
Michael01:26:35
Gavrilovich Your honor these comrades01:26:38
we have gathered a dove we will build a comrade they01:26:43
your comrades were called comrades01:26:46
Togo01:26:51
measles01:26:52
but when they already started to carry01:26:55
the dovecote that was built was mine01:26:57
my grandfather, my father, it was all01:27:01
kept in good condition I like01:27:04
already the heir to this business there are unique01:27:09
pigeons are unique so they burst in01:27:13
they broke into this dovecote01:27:15
You01:27:18
Lida in some01:27:21
They didn’t give us the yaks, we had to apply01:27:24
to the police for help only with help01:27:27
the police drew up a report with the help01:27:29
we were able to take the police from01:27:32
them document which is01:27:36
most PWM01:27:38
doku pigeons01:27:44
sagra01:27:47
when the residents of your house relate to this01:27:51
the structure includes them and children with great01:27:55
enjoy visiting this dovecote and A01:27:57
these new Russians arrived and did01:28:00
fingers fanned out and let everything be demolished01:28:02
children's playground demolished and parked cars01:28:05
we need some kindergartens nearby too01:28:08
they closed it and they still have it, I understand yours01:28:11
indignation but however if this is for real01:28:14
in fact it is an unauthorized building01:28:16
subject to demolition you have no requirements01:28:19
Va There is paper from BTI, it’s the same01:28:23
the document is an official document from the BTI01:28:26
I pay for all this and membership fees01:28:29
That's why01:28:31
I'm counter-claiming these owners01:28:36
who want me then come to me but I01:28:39
I read your statement in which you01:28:42
request recognition of ownership of01:28:44
this building is behind you Yes, if possible, here01:28:48
I am a boy who has been since childhood01:28:51
sono01:28:53
was busy with these pigeons01:28:57
interrogate him as a witness Yes01:28:58
please if possible as a witness01:29:01
please invite the boy to the hall01:29:03
defendant's witness01:29:08
Pass you know your part I have01:29:10
there is also a witness and we will listen to him01:29:12
we'll listen and what's your name Popov01:29:16
Anton01:29:17
Mikhailovich Please tell me here01:29:19
parents are yours yes my mom yeah01:29:24
understandable Tell me you know about that01:29:27
The dovecote is located in your house then01:29:29
next to before Yes I know I'm looking after her01:29:32
my friends and I, my friends are all behind her01:29:34
they look after us like everyone has their own01:29:36
there is a pigeon there, we look after them and01:29:38
a lot of people are busy with this dovecote01:29:41
Yes a lot of all my friends we are there We are there01:29:45
how we walk through this depth we walk there01:29:47
we are building, as if we are updating E What is it in?01:29:50
condition there she is well maintained Yes she is01:29:52
well maintained, recently renovated there01:29:55
cheeks Your Honor by How do you think this01:29:58
The dovecote must be demolished01:30:00
the requirements of the residents of the new house which01:30:03
built near you or not no Yes01:30:06
she's been there for a long time now everyone01:30:08
to all the boys in the yard to all my friends01:30:10
the pigeons don't like it all for that01:30:13
so that it is not demolished A A The car where01:30:17
you can put them there in the Big Yard01:30:19
everywhere01:30:20
put01:30:24
rdx goal suffered mega nasty yours then01:30:30
that I ask to be questioned by Your Honor01:30:34
Let's interrogate We'll interrogate everyone Your Honor Irina01:30:38
Vadimovna I live in this house no.01:30:41
15 and am still a member of the partnership01:30:44
own01:30:50
housing01:30:53
here opposite the dovecote on my second01:30:55
floor apartment and balcony just goes out01:30:57
not only do I wash my balcony every week01:31:05
not washed01:31:07
don't bother me 2 months ago01:31:11
changed the furniture for some reason 301:31:13
a month ago I went to the dacha, that is, to01:31:15
vacation and how can pigeons appear there01:31:18
I will now remove you from the court01:31:20
meetings 3 months ago I left for01:31:23
I even come on vacation to the dacha01:31:26
twisted01:31:27
nest01:31:31
Vanya, as you know, doesn’t make nests about the World Cup, you01:31:38
say if you want again01:31:50
tearing up the balcony01:31:52
I had to go to my housekeeper01:31:54
pay extra 200 rubles so that she can01:31:57
removed all this extra work This01:31:59
my expenses were but since I returned01:32:02
I really have a problem01:32:04
catastrophic property damage court01:32:06
not only does I sympathize with you01:32:08
dirty the whole apartment So I am the house01:32:11
female workers I pay much more but01:32:13
not only do I have a car Yes01:32:15
I understood everything about they spoiled everything for me01:32:17
the car that I had to01:32:19
paint and you paint01:32:25
caviar court once again sympathizes with you and01:32:28
removed to accept01:32:30
solution Next in the program She believes01:32:33
that she bought me, signed a contract and01:32:36
I bought with whomever I want and live with whomever01:32:40
I want a contract Make Irina's dreams come true01:32:43
the nail turned out to be brutally dismembered by the groom01:32:46
Nestro barn Izhi01:32:50
kgo chainsaw And Gvozdeva claims that01:32:54
saw compensation for broken01:32:59
the court has considered your application and01:33:03
established that in fact the construction is a01:33:07
it is the pigeons that do not have the characteristics01:33:10
unauthorized construction However, in01:33:13
according to law right01:33:15
ownership of unauthorized construction01:33:18
may be recognized as a person if01:33:22
preserving this building does not violate01:33:24
rights and interests protected by law01:33:26
other persons, the court found that Dovecote01:33:31
does not violate anyone's rights or any rights01:33:34
there are no third parties with this building01:33:37
Moreover, this building is being violated01:33:40
is a public place that01:33:43
attractive also for young people01:33:45
of our generation so I meet01:33:49
your statement01:33:52
Thank you this building is now recognized01:33:56
after the entry of the court decision there will be01:33:58
your property and the main claim01:34:01
of course not01:34:03
[music] [applause]01:34:07
the court's decision in the claim is satisfied01:34:10
refuse to satisfy the counter01:34:16
claim ic Roman Karav is suing for01:34:19
recovery of property from illegal01:34:22
possession defendant Irina Gvozdeva with a claim01:34:24
does not agree puts forward a counterclaim about01:34:26
refund in the amount of 501:34:29
rubles for repairs01:34:32
chainsaws Hello please01:34:36
sit down hearing the case is open yours01:34:39
honor I came to court for my property01:34:40
I want my saw back Your Honor01:34:43
the court saw your saw No, I want the defendant01:34:46
returned my saw But that's another question01:34:49
Katya's friendship washed down Friendship in general01:34:53
we agreed with the defendant that I01:34:55
I quickly do light work for 1 day and she01:34:57
pays me good money in general01:34:59
I'm repairing her shed and she gives me 12,00001:35:03
I come to her house and what do I see there?01:35:06
instead of a barn there is just a pile of rotten wood01:35:09
there is nothing to repair, everything needs to be repaired01:35:11
to build again, in general, I worked for her01:35:14
Week week like an ox from dawn until01:35:16
sunset I plowed built Well, not completely01:35:20
built here But I'll tell you more01:35:23
contract She promised to feed me01:35:25
promised But she got me on bread and water01:35:27
held as if not fed, did not feed empty01:35:30
pasta three times a day Well, so what?01:35:32
you were working then, of course it’s impossible01:35:34
work01:35:36
I carried all sorts of pickles from the market01:35:39
I did it. I didn’t cook it like that for myself.01:35:41
pickles how I fed him how could you not01:35:44
It’s a shame to lie, it’s good to stand here01:35:45
what happened with the saw Okay let's talk01:35:47
then about food Well, in general, let's talk about the saw01:35:50
I bring to01:35:52
Don’t lie to the court, yes, this is correct01:35:55
remark there is no need to lie to the court And you01:35:58
By the way, he also forced me to work01:36:01
As for the spoils in bags, I carried them01:36:04
every day and day and night forced well01:36:07
you know what I'm talking about here and then01:36:10
she left, that's the thing, she left without01:36:12
she threw me money with a saw, no, with a saw01:36:15
Yes left me with a saw without food without mute01:36:19
ended up in a barn with no money and no food01:36:22
defendant Well, my neighbor came, I'm without money01:36:25
I'm sitting without food She says, look01:36:27
the barn fence could be fixed01:36:29
something, well, go fix it, feed it01:36:33
me as a person and not as a beast Well, I01:36:35
I’ll tell you there was borscht and cutlets01:36:40
domestic ones, well, according to your build01:36:43
it's clear that you like to eat Well, I'm telling you01:36:46
with nature purely on spiritual food and01:36:48
work is fresh air so to speak, well01:36:52
I was placed with her at her neighbor's at Anya's01:36:56
still feeds well and there is work01:36:58
it was left as if it was completely different Well, yes01:37:03
stayed completely Yes I see01:37:05
The defendant returned and wanted a scandal for me01:37:07
my mom didn't throw all my things away01:37:10
the street didn't pay me a penny01:37:13
To hell with the money, she didn’t drink mine01:37:14
gives it away She thinks she bought me01:37:17
I signed a contract and bought a tie with whom01:37:20
I want and live with whom01:37:23
I want the contract I fulfilled the contract I fulfilled01:37:26
in the obligations in which we01:37:28
signed I completed I did more I01:37:30
erected01:37:32
the palace renovated the barn let's01:37:36
I’ll read this contract to me and that’s it01:37:39
the rest of the documents, by the way, are documents on01:37:41
chainsaw too01:37:44
Let's go So well, I heard you01:37:48
Let's go01:37:50
Let's talk until Thank you, I answer Gvozdeva01:37:55
Irina Yurievna with the claim categorically I do not01:37:59
I agree, that means the point is01:38:02
that I'm worried Just a second01:38:06
please let him return my money for01:38:08
repair the chainsaw and then I’ll return it to him01:38:11
saw here The thing is that you what01:38:13
We repaired a chainsaw, I want to tell you01:38:15
how it was means it was so he01:38:18
stood on Yaroslavka That's the job01:38:21
I met him there as a builder01:38:24
brought there, migrant workers usually stand there01:38:27
So I offered him a job, he took it01:38:30
agreed, brought it, showed mine01:38:33
he looked at the barn, we agreed on01:38:35
everyone signed an employment contract01:38:38
agreement So we agreed that he01:38:41
will be with his instrument he came with01:38:43
chainsaw by the way, not a penny in your pocket01:38:46
I didn’t even have my things with me, like a sweatshirt01:38:48
which he got stuck in. I gave it to him01:38:50
for work01:38:51
that naked01:38:53
came, the whole thing was full of holes01:38:56
It’s impossible for him to work, that means01:38:59
he started working by the way this01:39:00
chainsaw which immediately started01:39:03
break he has no money he applies01:39:07
to me so that I say let you be01:39:10
pay for saw repairs so here's my account01:39:15
payment01:39:20
yazh01:39:22
on the crab here is the receipt from the repair aka01:39:25
I was told how much the repair cost01:39:28
I have already given 3200. That is only 5200 in total01:39:31
5200 and the chainsaw costs 8 So01:39:33
Do the math Whose chainsaw is this now 520001:39:37
I paid for the repair, and it was already repaired01:39:39
I drank baked goods Ponya Well, give me these01:39:42
all the documents And what did we get now?01:39:45
By the way, the barn he built01:39:46
Look show show it costs two01:39:50
brsh left no roof, no walls, nothing01:39:53
Look there's just no roof Yeah yeah01:39:56
material then you provided the material01:39:59
provided only material material01:40:01
listen to this, this is what you built in01:40:03
alone yes But this is a work01:40:05
architectural art I am also for this01:40:07
you're laughing Your Honor Why am I laughing?01:40:10
I say this in all seriousness Brick Brick01:40:13
there lay he did carpenters01:40:16
there is only one area of this barn01:40:19
at first glance I'm on it01:40:21
I didn’t put him on a chain, I didn’t put him on a chain01:40:24
forced did not collect showed the volume01:40:26
work He agreed we signed01:40:29
signed the job done I'm crying01:40:31
money means the thing is that I left for01:40:34
a few days on business01:40:36
I’m coming, it means Karaseva is not there, the barn is not01:40:39
completed, I worked on this chainsaw01:40:43
the contract was not fulfilled and Anti has it01:40:47
although now su should sit smot G what01:40:51
whatever you want, I want him to return it to me01:40:53
money in what amount 52 for repairs then01:40:57
what did I spend on it01:40:58
Ben I'm not even talking about the fact that everything01:41:01
materials are now rotting that he is not01:41:02
painted the roof, no more01:41:05
fills them with an agreement that01:41:09
that he must do all the work A01:41:10
now what he did is all rotting because01:41:13
that six months have passed, it’s all flooded01:41:16
understand understandable in other words you01:41:18
do you want for01:41:19
the work was not paid for01:41:22
agreement and for the repair of the saw to recover from01:41:27
money correctness Let01:41:30
he tre That is, you have filed a counterclaim about01:41:35
collection of 5200 rubles Your Honor I am not asking01:41:39
already with her money I found my happiness I01:41:42
please just return the pelo I have it01:41:43
witness that she took it I want01:41:45
to listen to the witness. Okay, let's01:41:47
Let's listen to your witness Invite01:41:49
witnesses witnesses sa01:41:59
Go through What is your name Veresova Anna01:42:02
Tarasovna Anna Tarasovna Something for you01:42:05
we know about this incident which in01:42:07
your locality occurred in01:42:10
in relation to the defendant Irka is, as it were, mine01:42:13
neighbor I heard all this Romka work at01:42:17
not from morning until01:42:19
but the noise is day and night, as day and night say01:42:22
the night is already a headache That's the noise from the saw01:42:25
shugo So, well, how would I go? How01:42:30
they say I need a fence01:42:37
take a metal nap with pasta like01:42:41
I left the dogs for him. Well, here I am with him01:42:45
invited as if she regretted it and took it to01:42:48
I can’t live for myself Well, first, it’s time to fence01:42:51
installed, fed and watered01:42:54
man man needs attention How01:42:56
says Well, what next? Well, so what?01:43:00
So we began to live little by little. And what about01:43:03
you brought the document from me01:43:05
marriage certificate with whom with Roma To01:43:09
you are now spouses, what do you have there?01:43:13
show me what you have there show me show me01:43:17
legal01:43:18
Legitimate wife I am the wife01:43:21
take your hands off01:43:23
you went too far there, I don’t know he01:43:26
did you act mentally01:43:29
sick man shows you01:43:32
marriage certificate she is happy and you01:43:34
throw like a tigress Let him ride01:43:36
Yaroslavka chooses anyone there01:43:39
listen now what to talk about01:43:41
now these are the spouses I chose01:43:44
employee and chose the one who me01:43:46
satisfied, now let him give it away either01:43:48
money or a man or something01:43:51
Yeah, it's okay to have a gun in your head01:43:55
set it up myself01:43:57
spun and what words he sang and what he said01:44:02
Remember what you want to say, what you have01:44:05
there were some personal relationships with the central01:44:09
everything was fine with him. Why not?01:44:12
feed it then feed it all01:44:15
And what kind of love is this? I left whole01:44:17
the refrigerator costs food he couldn't01:44:19
open the refrigerator Explain explain01:44:22
I think women are fighting, what they divided01:44:25
was like this, slept with someone, found happiness01:44:28
married someone else but everything happens in life01:44:30
now here we are, sirs, listen maybe01:44:33
enter into a settlement agreement refuse01:44:36
according to your requirements and everything will happen right away01:44:38
explained But women fight, let them01:44:41
they agree I don’t care Yes really01:44:43
the male created the situation himself and would not have run01:44:47
then no one should have fought oh01:44:50
Give me back the saw Give me back01:44:53
you'll be a saw01:44:56
sleep, make a decision, I ask everyone01:45:04
stand up the decision is announced01:45:07
court I cannot return the defendant to you01:45:11
man but I'll try to resolve the matter, sorry01:45:15
By01:45:17
essentially01:45:19
Naturally your claim should be satisfied01:45:23
because01:45:24
the defendant holds this very01:45:27
chainsaw in someone else's illegal possession01:45:30
therefore you will be obliged to return this01:45:33
chainsaw itsu And you will be obliged to the plaintiff01:45:37
return 5,200 rubles which were01:45:42
spent by the defendant on repairing this01:45:45
chainsaw, the defendant proved that she01:45:47
incurred expenses for the maintenance of your01:45:50
property due to other requirements01:45:53
you are not available for01:45:55
the court considers its own exception01:45:59
the mission is over; the court's decision is clear01:46:01
yes Vano hearing of the case01:46:08
the decision of the main court is completed and01:46:12
counterclaims01:46:14
[music]01:46:19
to satisfy01:46:30
[music]01:46:37
look dated June it is for01:46:42
received it and didn’t tell me anything about it01:46:43
and I continued to repair it until the summer01:46:46
until the longest time Rosa Sorokina01:46:48
did renovations in the house with and then in one01:46:51
the moment she found herself in the street Poor woman01:46:54
wants her money back any cougar but e01:46:57
ex-mother-in-law is sure that Sorokina01:46:59
cunning swindler 5 years old01:47:02
England Well, how can this be? Why me?01:47:05
she needs a collapse England Karina Korneeva01:47:08
dreamed of marrying a foreigner and01:47:10
leave Russia but her lover does not01:47:12
lived up to expectations and kicked Karina out onto the street01:47:14
indignant girl b for property a01:47:17
failed groom01:47:19
believes If you dare again01:47:22
to deceive or attempt to deceive the court01:47:25
I will make a personal determination and send01:47:27
this is a determination to the City Duma and I01:47:29
I think that the City Duma will accept01:47:31
appropriate decision on this01:47:34
question This is your right I know what it is01:47:37
my right and this right was given to me by the people01:47:39
when the parliamentary mandate becomes01:47:41
cover for illegal activities01:47:43
government officials are turning a blind eye to this01:47:45
eyes the angry proletariat enters into01:47:48
battle armed with plastic01:47:58
Ved plaintiff Roza Sorokina goes to court01:48:02
with a claim for the return of funds to01:48:04
in the amount of 120,000 rubles spent on01:48:07
home improvement defendant Anna01:48:10
Sorokina against the claim01:48:14
objects01:48:15
Hello please01:48:18
sit down hearing de01:48:21
open to you01:48:23
the word hello Hello again I01:48:27
Sorokina Rosa Pavlovna You know I01:48:29
came to court with a claim for the return of money01:48:32
amount of 120,000 rubles per01:48:34
inseparable home improvement here01:48:36
in particular, the defendant's home, but the thing is01:48:39
that this is my ex-mother-in-law and you know01:48:41
after I got her whole dilapidated house01:48:43
ennobled that is, and invested in it01:48:45
She restored and made good repairs01:48:47
I sold it and it turns out I'm on the side01:48:49
remained somewhere, that is, not sideways01:48:51
This didn’t affect me selling the house, well01:48:53
I'll start in order Everything Let's Yes the point is01:48:56
the fact that with her son Victor01:48:59
Well, our life together didn’t work out01:49:02
yes we lived but it so happened that well in01:49:04
every family has its own thing, we then converged01:49:06
then we separated and at one point we01:49:07
they took it like that and got divorced just like that01:49:09
they waved their hand but we know we01:49:11
planned to live together children are joint01:49:14
yes yes we have a daughter together01:49:16
joint daughter Yes husband pays01:49:19
Do you know child support?01:49:23
no, I haven’t applied for alimony yet01:49:24
because we basically had everything01:49:25
ok but not touched on this yet but I01:49:26
I'll probably do it anyway01:49:29
it's just that I work in01:49:30
basically I have a good job I work01:49:32
waitress in a cafe Well, decent01:49:33
I’ve been earning money for two years now01:49:35
whom we lived in this house I01:49:37
rebuild this house01:49:39
I bought all the building materials for this amount01:49:41
I have 120,000 rubles here and all the receipts01:49:43
receipts That is, I also bought slate01:49:46
bought door frames bought paint then01:49:48
there are all the building materials Well, how could I01:49:51
I tried my best, I did it, and it worked01:49:54
that one fine moment when well01:49:56
another divorce with my husband, yes01:49:58
happened my ex-mother-in-law she01:50:03
find it in our cafe and not only that01:50:06
Your honor that they are even having a wedding01:50:08
we played in this cafe just for that reason01:50:19
I'd like to apply more She's sold01:50:22
this house a Originally this house She01:50:25
promised my granddaughter, that is, my daughter01:50:28
ended the marriage, what did you plan in01:50:31
Should I continue to live in this house? Well, of course01:50:33
we planned to live together further, well01:50:35
it’s just that this doesn’t happen in families01:50:37
your honor Well, that's how it happened01:50:38
We got divorced and then we didn’t formalize the relationship01:50:40
Well, then we just continued to live as civilians01:50:42
b that such a family is normal01:50:44
got divorced and then registered their marriage01:50:46
then it happened again Well, it happened01:50:48
Your Honor, in principle, I wanted01:50:51
and the daughter's father was And we lived if01:50:53
if she had not interfered we would have lived and01:50:55
further normal You divorced but01:50:58
continued to live together and continued01:51:00
live together Well, just another grind01:51:02
as if I were gone and my absence01:51:04
it turned out that while his wife was alive, the husband01:51:06
got married and it turned out that she huh01:51:10
I found it and it turned out that the mother-in-law is joining the family01:51:12
destroyed my husband married someone else01:51:14
woman and she is also in a rebuilt house in01:51:16
Ahli remained good who found himself01:51:20
I'll eat, let's live and go to the hostel now01:51:24
registered in the hostel We are now with01:51:26
daughter in the hostel We live as if and that is01:51:29
I didn’t have the documents Show me that01:51:31
what are you saying, I have all the documents01:51:33
you invested money, give it to me here01:51:35
all my receipts are here, well01:51:37
certificate of termination That is, you01:51:38
claim that you are 120,000 rubles01:51:42
spent on over 2 years from01:51:44
2008 2010 yes yes I bought01:51:47
building materials and made repairs there in01:51:49
this house01:51:51
I understand your requirements are clear01:51:54
I answered Anna Tarasovna Sorokina with a claim01:52:00
my ex-daughter-in-law I don't agree01:52:03
Moreover, I affirm that there is no01:52:07
we did not use building materials01:52:09
but everything is so difficult, that is, you01:52:13
claim that from the moment you came to your01:52:17
your daughter-in-law's family01:52:20
participated in home renovations did not invest01:52:23
money for home improvement and nothing01:52:26
the deadbolt has nothing to do with improvement01:52:29
was and moreover I want to say She01:52:32
I got myself a haha it’s standing here like this01:52:35
hack man stro material in the store01:52:38
who advised Nya Odna01:52:41
just a second What specific jobs were01:52:43
carried out by you and on your day01:52:45
the roof itself was covered01:52:48
separately left in this house that is01:52:52
directly these window frames01:52:53
there it was done it matches01:52:55
no reality She says that01:52:58
the roof was covered with slate, look at that01:53:01
what slate what slate01:53:04
iron photo of not our house house01:53:08
absolute home that's right this is my home and01:53:10
you have nothing to do with him01:53:12
her hacker kicked her out. That is, it’s not that, that’s not01:53:16
I don’t know where this house is from, probably from where01:53:19
downloaded this is not the internet this is the house that01:53:23
we built it my son built it Yes, but01:53:26
these checks that she gave you are her [ __ ]01:53:30
he gave receipts to the market for construction materials01:53:32
what a hell of a toast I came up with another one01:53:35
I figured it's about money now01:53:38
which the plaintiff allegedly invested in improving01:53:42
your home Where is this house located where01:53:46
I inherited this one01:53:49
the house needs to be rebuilt so badly01:53:53
he is yours exists01:53:56
Yes you don't01:53:58
sold no sell We sold you01:54:01
tell me how I can01:54:04
damn I received an advance payment for the house and here it is01:54:08
Look at all these checks of hers already01:54:11
dated June she is for01:54:15
received it and didn’t tell me anything about it01:54:16
and I continued to repair it until the summer01:54:19
until the very end, and what about the deposit for the house?01:54:22
given Here you go, why did you continue01:54:25
invest when01:54:27
So that means your daughter-in-law is lying01:54:31
Of course he's lying Of course he's lying and then the checks01:54:34
what is it also to cut in the month of June Really01:54:37
in general he will be a normal person01:54:40
invest money in what you already have01:54:43
almost sold out so I didn’t know who it was01:54:45
he told me about this and the doors01:54:48
were then I will sell and the checks are hers01:54:53
Somehow you can prove your position01:54:56
Yes, I have checks and I have more01:54:58
witness Give me documents and witness01:55:00
there is and there is a witness Let's witness01:55:03
to whom I bought01:55:05
building material this is it01:55:09
certificate I bought building materials01:55:11
within 2 years it is clear and witnesses01:55:15
invite me and I'll throw this money into the air01:55:18
I throw it away I don’t know where01:55:22
whom01:55:24
Teri because I think ST will sue01:55:28
enough for me Introduce yourself Ayvaz01:55:32
Mikhail Arturovich Well Mikhail What is it01:55:37
what happened what are you talking about here01:55:40
will be the owner's entrepreneur01:55:43
home goods stores01:55:47
here is an Tarasovna01:55:50
built this house in 200801:55:52
I've been building this for a year01:55:57
his son built this house and his assistant01:56:00
she often came to me and bought01:56:03
construction material paints there01:56:06
board nails didn't take receipts01:56:10
I took it, but you know how mechanically01:56:13
threw it away01:56:15
receipts it is clear that Human receipts01:56:18
you see, so I brought the receipts01:56:22
these are the ones here I am here 32,000 are the boards01:56:26
and 12,000 is still paint, taking this into account I01:56:30
I also registered what I have01:56:32
in 2008 she spent01:56:37
only about 200 Yes, 240,000 rubles Yes, that’s it01:56:43
here is the girl these are the documents01:56:45
these are not documents01:56:47
document, that's all I have01:56:50
They brought some kind of document, they say01:56:52
documents with I saw I saw that this01:56:55
a piece of paper fell that was torn out, pass it on01:56:58
to me him through the bailiff through the bailiff here01:57:02
please draw this all in 2 year01:57:05
there they wrote the documents by hand, they say01:57:08
printing nothing this is a log book I am like that01:57:11
Understand01:57:12
date Absolutely correct plaintiff tell me01:57:17
please tell me any01:57:20
lease agreements or any other01:57:23
agreement on the right of use01:57:26
you with this house you have a defendant in01:57:28
that's the point, everything is related01:57:30
wanted to do something verbally Of course01:57:33
because she said that she was home01:57:34
granddaughter01:57:38
balance of registration01:57:42
what are you talking about01:57:44
I bought it so I bought it with money01:57:48
gave01:57:50
because it's yours that has already driven me out01:57:52
honor because no documents, nothing01:57:53
no evidence, she's already starting01:57:55
come up with I don't know what01:57:56
This document you decided to destroy it01:58:00
Well, maybe I got excited, sorry01:58:02
Your Honor Well, there won't be a trial01:58:04
get excited and leaves to accept01:58:06
balanced and legal01:58:10
decisions Who01:58:14
such in the program you are in your English01:58:18
Can01:58:21
don't need love she needs young England01:58:23
the girl lived with an elderly foreigner and01:58:25
I was sure that I had arranged my life, but01:58:28
in the end, Karina's dreams turned out to be cruel01:58:30
destroyed and her common-law husband is sure01:58:33
that he himself was a gift for the girl If01:58:36
do you dare to deceive again or01:58:39
try to deceive the court I will endure01:58:41
private definition and will direct it01:58:43
determination to the City Duma and I think01:58:45
what the City Duma will accept01:58:47
appropriate solution to this issue01:58:50
This is your right. I know that this is my right.01:58:53
and this right was given to me by the people's deputy01:58:55
City Duma was in a hurry on important matters01:58:57
government affairs by car with01:58:59
suddenly the official's car flashes01:59:02
attacked by a guy with a blue bucket on his head01:59:04
and tragedy cannot be avoided01:59:08
[music]01:59:12
The plaintiff's court decision was announced01:59:16
appealed to the response with a demand for01:59:20
RUB for inseparable housing improvement01:59:22
which she produced at her own expense01:59:25
the concept of inseparable improvements refers01:59:27
to leasing agreements and related01:59:29
their relationship in this case with the court01:59:32
there are no grounds for satisfaction01:59:34
claims due to lack of01:59:37
any agreements between and Som and01:59:39
respondent I asked you a question There are01:59:42
did the contracts you say that we did sun01:59:44
by kinship and family you01:59:47
acted no01:59:49
no court unreasonably you could present01:59:53
requirements for the ex-spouse and not for01:59:55
mother-in-law but ex-husband what follows01:59:58
is not from the case materials02:00:00
the owner of this property is why I02:00:03
I refuse to satisfy your02:00:06
requirements and encourage you in the future02:00:09
act wisely and02:00:11
in good faith as intended02:00:14
civilian02:00:16
[music]02:00:18
legislation02:00:22
court decision in claims02:00:25
[music]02:00:28
refuse plaintiff Karina Korneeva02:00:31
applies to the court for division02:00:33
jointly on living property and cash02:00:35
funds in the amount of 150 rubles defendant02:00:38
Paul Barton does not agree with the claim and02:00:40
claims that the disputed property02:00:42
purchased with his personal02:00:44
money hello please02:00:48
sit down02:00:50
hearing02:00:51
openly Hello your honor I request02:00:54
consider the claim for division jointly02:00:56
acquired property in court I02:00:58
lived with a British citizen02:01:00
Hollow Bart 5 years civilian02:01:03
married 2 years ago when we were dating02:01:05
joint household and lived together he02:01:07
bought and registered a one-room apartment02:01:10
an apartment 57 km away for 3 million rubles is02:01:15
time02:01:18
uh02:01:19
put a vacuum cleaner there, a TV washing machine02:01:22
dishwasher02:01:23
car Well, small ones, some kind of kitchen02:01:26
harvester iron in general everything is there and now02:01:30
that’s when we started living with him02:01:32
together he was 49 years old at that time02:01:34
there was an active foreigner with02:01:36
his prestigious job was as a designer02:01:38
the last 5 years he has become pathetic02:01:40
drunkard02:01:43
actually impotent Roma This is from02:01:46
not good for a long time02:01:48
words ago I quit my job because02:01:50
that he promised that we would go with him to live in02:01:52
England And now it turns out that I02:01:54
I'm broke, I'm without a job, without money02:01:56
because I fed him for a long time02:01:58
didn't work, was lying on our sofa, so02:02:01
in fact, I want him to return02:02:03
me 150,000 which I added to him02:02:05
your time to buy an apartment and02:02:08
divided with me the property for which02:02:10
I've been spending money all this time I see02:02:13
So I need your documents in that02:02:16
including marriage registration certificate02:02:19
We had a marriage02:02:21
for civilians there is a copy02:02:24
apartment certificates issued in02:02:28
he has a certificate of my income02:02:31
an extract from my account indicating that I02:02:33
I withdrew money before buying an apartment02:02:35
literally on the eve of the completion of the transaction and02:02:37
there are a whole bunch of documents for household02:02:38
technique means then to me If you’re not there02:02:42
marriage registration certificate for me02:02:44
we need proof that this02:02:47
bought an apartment02:02:50
and these electronic devices too02:02:54
you bought it in these maybe02:02:56
confirm My mother as a witness we02:02:58
we can only call her as a witness02:03:01
testimony is only testimony and that's it02:03:02
what I conveyed to you There are no others02:03:05
It’s clear that marriage is not02:03:06
registered Well, he’s already 5 of me02:03:08
years, in fact, fed with promises02:03:10
that now he will stand on Angi now02:03:12
he has to straighten out the situation now02:03:14
things will get better now we will register with him02:03:16
Now we'll leave Well, that's it02:03:18
speaking until the very last02:03:19
Well, why did you give him money then?02:03:21
to purchase an apartment We lived02:03:23
together I hoped for something and02:03:25
again, I perceived him as02:03:26
my husband, how can I not I will02:03:28
buy a product for yourself But he doesn’t give it to me02:03:30
the look of a man who every day with02:03:33
the law can only be perceived02:03:35
real husband if he is one02:03:38
And in our country, in accordance with the law, marriage02:03:41
admits02:03:43
only registered marriage in the zaksa02:03:47
civil authorities02:03:50
condition And now what should I do?02:03:52
BC I understand now what should I do now02:03:54
we'll figure out what to do, the answer is yours02:03:58
word I don't02:04:00
I agree first02:04:02
Introduce yourself, I'm Paul Barn02:04:05
designer va I do not agree the claim I02:04:09
I affirm that all things are my property02:04:17
bought the company received only 20,000 rubles02:04:22
per month, the best time I had an income of 602:04:26
until 10 am is your best time02:04:28
ended 4 years ago you 4 years02:04:31
you lie and wait for some mythical02:04:32
orders yours Yes, let me talk02:04:37
I give the best time I my income was from 6 to02:04:43
10 dollars in02:04:47
a month I don’t need anything I didn’t take02:04:50
I don't need anything from these pathetic little ones.02:04:54
150,000 rubles but nevertheless you are theirs02:04:58
took it when I met Karina02:05:02
there were a lot of orders, they were big for me02:05:06
money I02:05:07
saved for 2 years no fashion designer02:05:12
foreign no work me because because02:05:18
there was an edge02:05:20
Lude You know what, let's talk02:05:23
about property So02:05:26
first, you’ve already been living for several years02:05:29
actually one family with the plaintiff Why02:05:33
you didn't legitimize02:05:36
attitude that02:05:39
hindered at the beginning we lived together02:05:42
but then they started quarreling because02:05:47
only talks about England She doesn't laugh02:05:52
live with02:05:54
me02:05:57
when but if you when did you understand this02:06:01
By the way I am02:06:04
I realized when I decided to live and02:06:08
work Russia Why don’t they live here02:06:12
What kind of work are you LG and you lie to yourself, I understand02:06:14
that no one takes it Well, how long ago is that02:06:17
it was it was 2 years ago So what02:06:21
you are 2 years old02:06:24
actually02:06:25
deceived02:06:27
telling a woman that you will be a husband02:06:31
someday that you will go to England Here's more02:06:34
a month ago the plaintiff wanted to go to England02:06:37
to leave with you and hoped for it02:06:41
it turns out that you cheated02:06:44
person despite the fact that02:06:47
you seem decent Doro02:06:50
look like that's what he looks like here02:06:52
respectable Duma, he's quite himself02:06:54
leads differently but I want to live and work02:06:59
Rush I love this one02:07:02
country That's why I decided to buy an apartment02:07:05
Moscow Let's tour this apartment02:07:08
Let's talk, you bought this apartment with your own money02:07:11
money or whatever02:07:13
the plaintiff invested some money in this02:07:16
I bought the apartment, the apartment is my money02:07:20
where as I say I received 6,00002:07:24
dollars a month just like that02:07:27
she said that she invested 150,000 rubles in this02:07:31
apartment correctly I understood you Correctly02:07:33
Let's invite invite invite and02:07:36
documentation02:07:37
Introduced I don't need these pathetic02:07:42
150,000 I bought this apartment myself02:07:46
money regarding household appliances I02:07:50
gave02:07:51
She buys money for Karina I was very02:07:56
busy uh raft what were you doing some02:07:59
Could you give me money? Where could you get it from?02:08:01
no one brought them to the sofa02:08:02
Once I understand the answer is one more question02:08:05
Why didn’t you settle this peacefully before the trial?02:08:08
question If the woman you are with02:08:11
you have been living for many years, there are some02:08:13
property claims why don't you02:08:16
resolve these issues peacefully02:08:19
as men usually do when I02:08:22
I understand I will live and work02:08:25
Russia02:08:26
Karina understand, I won’t take her02:08:30
England started making trouble, I didn't think so02:08:34
Russian girl is so scandalous02:08:37
screamed, threw dishes, demanded to take them02:08:41
her England why does she think I'm going02:08:46
England Why am I 5 years old? You are 5 years old. My brain is 5 years old.02:08:49
listens to his England Well, how can it be02:08:51
maybe why did you deceive me02:08:53
then she needs love so much England02:08:56
I'm her ticket02:08:58
England ticket Yeah, so you think02:09:03
not a person and a citizen, but a ticket02:09:07
to England for02:09:09
Itza I bought everything I gave her money I took you02:09:15
got it enough thanks, let's go02:09:17
Now we are listening to your witness02:09:18
Invite02:09:20
May I have witnesses, Your Honor? I will tell her.02:09:24
I bought only Kuum Klina with my own money02:09:27
I don't need a vacuum cleaner, take it no02:09:30
the vacuum cleaner is good, but everything else is okay02:09:32
that would carry a TV and a dishwasher then02:09:35
and the washing machine and everything in the world you took mine02:09:37
I saved money until I could save up for02:09:41
you return it on the couch even without a hose02:09:44
witnesses02:09:47
Pass02:09:52
Hello your honor my name is Koeva02:09:54
Tatyana Yurievna I am a mother02:09:57
Karina In general, from the very beginning I02:10:00
initially did not believe in the relationship between02:10:02
my daughter and the overseas guy who02:10:06
ohmuri e actually introduced himself02:10:08
ruined everything for her02:10:10
life02:10:13
rob02:10:17
years old man Paul said that he was buying02:10:21
apartment Well, for me he is a young man02:10:23
of course from the point of view of my age I02:10:25
I say when he said that he was buying02:10:27
he misses an apartment just a little02:10:30
150,000 Karina and I went, she’s Karinochka02:10:34
worked in a good prestigious02:10:35
organizations somewhere their salary is up to 30,00002:10:38
plus she also had a bonus in her account02:10:41
small money 150,000 there we were02:10:43
went with her to the savings bank and took out02:10:46
they even went together to pay for the money02:10:49
apartment I am a witness, you understand this02:10:52
the second time then for some reason he had02:10:55
orders are prestigious then they02:10:57
died somehow suddenly, no work he02:11:00
everything says I'm lying here waiting for a good report02:11:03
little continue Everything happens and there is a crisis but02:11:07
Karinochka continued to work. In short, she02:11:10
so to speak Well, God reproached him but weakly02:11:12
with him Says nothing Mom it’s me of course02:11:14
was indignant How do you work? And he02:11:16
You're lying Lazy on the couch, nothing Mom02:11:18
we are one family In short, like hers02:11:20
appeared so to speak salary Mommy02:11:23
we need to buy something and something and so and so and so and so02:11:25
We walked together with her. Well, how can we do without an adviser?02:11:27
That's right, I went with her and chose02:11:29
home appliances, that is, so to speak02:11:32
I bought a decent vacuum cleaner there02:11:33
please go and buy then02:11:35
there is also a dishwasher for dishes02:11:38
so that my son-in-law has a clean one02:11:41
always a decent washing machine02:11:43
bought because he needs to wash his pants How02:11:46
it says all sorts of kitchen units so that02:11:48
rubbed everything for him Well, in short, that's all02:11:51
Tatyana Yurievna bought with her money02:11:54
I understand you came here with a passport. Why?02:11:56
You know, yes And then he constantly02:11:58
said Mommy, you and I will go soon02:12:01
to England with you I have a mansion there02:12:03
you will be so wonderful there02:12:05
room So I think, Finally02:12:07
I'll leave my filthy place, I'll even02:12:10
issued02:12:11
pass what is needed according to Manly Oh, I have so much02:12:17
I went not only did I ruin my life02:12:20
ruined my girl Yes he ruined02:12:22
threw away 5 years and robbed her and more02:12:26
you really need to eat agli Stand on me02:12:30
place Stand up idiot Fool overseas bastard02:12:34
they release such people here and to us in Russia02:12:36
Then they ruin our girls' lives02:12:38
You will somehow take action in the end02:12:41
after all, well, but of course if they are girls02:12:45
together with moms02:12:47
hoya02:12:53
iram02:12:54
old, I was even planning to go to England. And I02:12:57
more years nothing English Duma02:13:00
Queen How old02:13:03
years live there long live the court is removed02:13:06
for adoption02:13:07
solutions Next in the program If you02:13:10
dare to deceive again or02:13:13
try to deceive the court I am very often02:13:16
ode02:13:20
city with an appropriate decision on02:13:23
dan wow It's your right I know what it is02:13:26
my right and this right was given to me by the people02:13:29
when the parliamentary mandate becomes02:13:31
cover for illegal activities02:13:33
government officials are turning a blind eye to this02:13:35
eyes the angry proletariat enters into02:13:38
fight armed with plastic blue02:13:41
[music]02:13:46
bucket02:13:49
for recognition02:13:51
the property you declared common02:13:54
joint property because it is common02:13:57
joint property may arise02:13:59
only if the marriage is official02:14:01
registered in02:14:04
civil registration authorities02:14:06
state now what concerns02:14:09
directly your requirements A02:14:11
return you 150 and the equipment for which you02:14:16
paid the money02:14:18
having studied the ones you presented02:14:20
evidence, the court came to the conclusion that02:14:23
in fact, this equipment was purchased02:14:25
at your expense the court is critical02:14:29
refers to the defendant's statements that02:14:32
that he did not receive 150 rubles in payment02:14:35
the cost of the entire apartment, on the contrary, the court02:14:39
believes your testimony and testimony02:14:43
witness and documents presented and02:14:45
collects the defendant 15002:14:48
rub in favor of itza and also make a decision02:14:55
about returning from someone else's illegal02:14:58
ownership of property specified in02:15:01
list transmitted02:15:03
[music] [applause]02:15:07
court decision to satisfy the claim in02:15:11
counterclaim02:15:16
refuse claimant insurance representative02:15:20
the company is filing a recourse claim for02:15:22
compensation to the defendants for the amount of insurance02:15:24
compensation in the amount02:15:26
216,500 rubles defendant Pavel Tarasov with02:15:30
no claim02:15:31
[music]02:15:33
I agree Hello, have a seat02:15:39
It’s not entirely convenient for you. But for you, of course.02:15:46
I'm comfortable next to you02:15:49
I'll put it this way I think you will02:15:54
It’s better to listen to you, of course I imagine02:15:57
the interests of the insurance company so I02:16:06
claim illegal actions02:16:10
two of our cars were damaged in an accident02:16:13
clients insured under helmet policies02:16:19
The fact is that the defendant grossly violated02:16:22
traffic rules He jumped out02:16:25
on the road in front of a Mercedes car02:16:28
whose driver is saving the defendant's life02:16:31
was forced to use emergency02:16:33
braking resulting in Mercedes02:16:36
the security car crashed into the following one02:16:39
from behind So it all happened before our eyes02:16:43
many witnesses in the presence02:16:45
traffic police officer02:16:48
the defendant tried to flee the place02:16:51
incident but he was detained but02:16:53
our valiant police work well02:16:56
luckily it’s impossible to hide from her02:16:59
so yours02:17:00
honor upon accident I'm not finished02:17:03
honest02:17:05
citizens continue unconditionally02:17:08
Thank you Your Honor so in fact02:17:12
this accident was compiled02:17:16
about an accident from which it follows that02:17:20
The cause of the accident was a pedestrian crossing the street02:17:24
in the wrong place and causing interference02:17:27
traffic02:17:29
there were further funds for the defendant02:17:33
an administrative protocol has been drawn up02:17:35
a receipt was also issued02:17:38
imposing on him a fine of 30002:17:41
rub according to Article 1230 Well, that’s right for02:17:44
violation of traffic rules by a pedestrian02:17:47
movement02:17:48
Well, I understand what the rule is the amount of the claim02:17:50
Which02:17:51
[music]02:17:52
[applause]02:17:54
respondent I just wanted to point out that02:17:56
these documents confirm02:17:58
direct guilt of the defendant amount02:18:01
lawsuit So02:18:03
because the insurance company is forced02:18:07
was to make insurance payments in02:18:12
size02:18:16
rub02:18:19
ru she suffered losses due to the fault of the defendant02:18:23
for a total amount of 216,500 rubles we are asking the court02:18:28
recover this amount from the co-defendant So02:18:31
The plaintiff wants to recover 216,500 rubles from you02:18:35
defendant How do you feel about the declared02:18:38
requirements And you Bye Give me everything02:18:40
documents yours I am02:18:43
I protest against02:18:46
why does he say that I am something02:18:48
violated these morons, they did it themselves02:18:50
They don’t know how to drive What kind of morons Yes what02:18:52
morons driver damn I'm sorry Do you have02:18:56
copy of the fine receipt copy of the receipt02:18:59
Yes, she was discharged for violating it02:19:01
issued for a violation, you know why02:19:03
to me02:19:04
they wrote forced me to write you understand02:19:06
they simply wouldn’t let me go Pavel Sergeevich02:19:10
let's tell you your story in02:19:12
free story well your honor and02:19:15
explain why you came with buckets to02:19:18
head to court and brought friends with them02:19:21
the three of us came your part The thing is that02:19:24
we are with the guys, we are activists, we are against02:19:27
flashing lights we fight against flashing lights because02:19:29
that it’s becoming impossible to live. Well, of course02:19:32
operational machines must have02:19:34
priority passage operational I02:19:36
I think that ambulances are cars02:19:39
police and let's say if a person is being transported02:19:42
there with intensive care, yes, but why is that02:19:44
These [ __ ] drive around with flashing lights02:19:46
want what02:19:48
goats know whose they were transporting whom02:19:53
Deputy So you broke the rules02:19:56
traffic resulting in02:19:58
there was an accident your part I am not02:20:01
violated no rules and the matter is that02:20:03
I was crossing the road I stood in the middle02:20:06
stripes and02:20:08
waited out of the bus That's how it was when02:20:11
I was crossing and then I heard the knock of a car02:20:15
the other one just crashed into the back and here02:20:18
healthy big guys like wild boars run out and02:20:21
on me well I had nothing to do I02:20:23
just retreated and started running away02:20:25
you were wearing a bucket Yes, a bucket02:20:28
was Of course Oh, that's definitely clear02:20:31
That is, you completely accidentally left02:20:34
the bus was decided completely by accident02:20:37
cross the road completely by accident02:20:39
it turned out to be a bucket on my head and completely02:20:42
by chance these people with flashing lights in02:20:45
at this moment we were driving along this road like this02:20:48
yes even judging02:20:51
according to these documents according to the plan02:20:55
which was compiled by the inspector02:20:58
DPS it all happened outside the zone02:21:01
pedestrian crossing your part you02:21:04
you understand that I literally work all day02:21:06
day and evening I study I need02:21:08
finish college I go out and sit down02:21:12
trolleybus I work on Kutuzovsky02:21:16
the avenue is constantly because of them02:21:18
there are traffic jams, I have no other way02:21:20
I can get there I get on the trolleybus02:21:22
the trolleybus stops, I'm always late02:21:24
is he standing why yes why and because02:21:27
they all drive with flashing lights and the road02:21:29
block the fact that the road02:21:31
is constantly blocked at this very moment02:21:33
time period traffic cops constantly02:21:36
block the road to give02:21:39
travel It is clear your position is clear Your02:21:43
honor I am absolutely not involved in the accident in02:21:47
the fact that I was crossing the road yes On me02:21:49
a blue bucket was worn and perhaps02:21:51
the driver stared at me in the bucket yes02:21:54
Well, maybe in a bucket, I don’t know what it is02:21:55
currently attracted attention02:21:57
you touched the car No, I didn’t at all02:21:59
touched the car absolutely nothing02:22:02
what I ask you to call02:22:05
Mercedes car owner witness02:22:08
Jeep that was on site02:22:10
incident and interrogate him he will tell you02:22:12
will explain how it really happened02:22:14
Well, let's interrogate the witnesses02:22:18
Invite FSA witnesses FSA witnesses02:22:23
Pass Hello servants of the people with02:22:26
flashing lights02:22:27
[applause]02:22:28
freaks, bring order to the courtroom02:22:32
these02:22:33
I don’t know people They would care02:22:38
place for buckets And so Vladimir Andreevich02:22:40
calmly introduce yourself Osipov Vladimir02:22:44
Andreevich I am a deputy of the city duma02:22:48
the car is actually registered02:22:51
me and the car have a flashing light02:22:55
quite officially approved beacon Here02:22:59
By the way, you have all the permits02:23:01
were in the car when it happened02:23:04
Road accident Find Yes, I was in a car in02:23:06
that day I was driving to work I was late for02:23:09
the meeting although there was little movement02:23:11
current but nevertheless I was late02:23:14
the beacon was on, they were late, young02:23:17
man wait, listen, I give it to the judge02:23:19
now explanation Dear Sir02:23:23
witness Please tell me A in02:23:26
what direction were you moving in?02:23:30
side of the City Duma How is it possible02:23:34
plan drawn up by traffic police officers02:23:37
you were moving from a city I don't know which one02:23:41
plan02:23:42
created by traffic police officers but we02:23:45
we were going exactly in that direction. I demand that02:23:48
you explained to the court in which direction you are02:23:51
moved Why did you have them turned on?02:23:53
flashing lights and what event02:23:58
and What time was it for?02:24:00
appointed Your Honor if I arrived here02:24:04
giving evidence is not02:24:07
means I have to tell everything02:24:09
Excuse me but sometimes there is information02:24:12
which is generally closed to the wider public02:24:16
public02:24:21
fulfilling your request I answer02:24:23
Dear yours02:24:26
honor we were going to a city meeting02:24:29
thoughts on which route Excuse me, can I02:24:33
probably choose which one02:24:36
you wanted to get to the center using the Mosk route02:24:39
In Moscow I still had urgent matters02:24:41
which to do02:24:45
By02:24:47
Absolutely right, I would have had time, so here I am02:24:51
I warn you Dear Witness02:24:54
cheaper on criminal liability for02:24:57
knowingly giving false testimony and if you02:25:00
dare to deceive again or02:25:03
try to deceive the court I will endure02:25:05
private definition and will direct it02:25:07
determination to the City Duma and I think02:25:09
what the City Duma will accept02:25:12
appropriate02:25:14
the decision on this issue is yours02:25:17
right I know that this is my right and this02:25:20
the people gave me the right. What happened on02:25:22
road on the road Unexpectedly, like the devil from02:25:26
a figure jumped out of the snuff box02:25:28
men from the oncoming lane02:25:31
traffic due to the bus as later02:25:33
it turned out it was the defendant02:25:36
so seeing that the accident happened on his02:25:41
it's your fault, young man,02:25:44
leaked, I thought back then Probably this02:25:46
followers movement This is in the fight02:25:48
for an accident Well, of course two points came out02:25:51
cars I will stand Yes hello how are you02:25:53
la buckets You could use a little brain and brain02:25:56
Here in these buckets Yes, witness, I understand02:26:01
that probably Sitting in the bureaucracy02:26:05
in offices you consider everyone not very smart02:26:08
and precautionary towards02:26:11
officials but still behave02:26:13
that's correct, firstly, and secondly,02:26:14
I have a question for you okay, did you move on02:26:17
meeting of the Duma which was02:26:20
appointed And who was driving in the second car?02:26:23
in the second car, as always, behind me02:26:25
a jeep was driving My car is a Jeep with02:26:29
the security only arranged for you, you didn’t02:26:32
state protection is required Well, this is02:26:35
my what's your internal affairs Sorry02:26:38
then then yes you have the right to hire02:26:41
security but this security that you02:26:44
you are hiring has no right to travel02:26:46
flashing02:26:49
beacon th02:26:52
the car crashed into him, Your Honor02:26:54
ask me to interrupt my driver was at02:26:57
him02:27:01
driver I didn't ask you02:27:04
questions if you break the rules again02:27:08
behavior in court proceedings order02:27:11
court hearing I you02:27:15
will be fined, that means I have one more for you02:27:19
question How did it happen that your02:27:22
the security car collided with yours02:27:25
cars Well, my driver who drove02:27:27
the car I was driving in, of course02:27:30
already proven by experience, it instantly02:27:33
reacted and suddenly I felt02:27:35
really hit from behind there I was recently02:27:38
took the young guy driver Of course I did02:27:40
I won’t tolerate him for being an amateur02:27:43
later, but nevertheless he entered02:27:46
then they set off on us and you are familiar02:27:50
traffic rules in which02:27:52
it says he was driving, but maybe not02:27:55
absolutely so what needs to be observed02:27:57
distance and not move bumper to bumper02:28:00
how these people often move02:28:02
car bumper for which he was punished02:28:05
Please note, Your Honor, that I am guilty02:28:08
the defendant was recognized as having passed the DDP. I am this02:28:12
noticed a long time ago the court is leaving for02:28:15
decision making02:28:17
[music]02:28:25
the decision is announced02:28:35
court fact of violation of traffic rules02:28:38
motions by the defendant in this case02:28:41
is not a basis for recognizing it02:28:43
guilt in material damage which causes02:28:47
in accordance with road rules02:28:49
the driver must comply with traffic02:28:51
safe distance from the person in front02:28:53
transport from case materials02:28:56
seen by the way from those documents02:28:59
which you presented Dear old man02:29:01
that this point of traffic rules02:29:04
ignored by car drivers02:29:07
who were moving away from Moscow02:29:10
Despite02:29:12
that the administrative building is located in02:29:15
in the center of Moscow naturally has not been proven02:29:18
cause and effect relationship between02:29:20
violation of traffic rules by the defendant02:29:22
traffic and road transport02:29:24
an incident which, in the opinion of the court02:29:26
occurred due to the fault of drivers who02:29:30
driving evidence02:29:32
There is no contrary in the case materials02:29:35
that's why I refuse you satisfaction02:29:38
your requirement and collection of an adviser02:29:42
the amount you declared But that's not all02:29:46
the court sends a private ruling to02:29:49
address of the organization where you are Dear02:29:53
witness you work because in02:29:55
in accordance with Federal Law, you do not02:29:58
you have the right to use flashing lights02:30:02
beacons you are not one of those people02:30:06
which are included in the Resolution02:30:09
Government of the Russian Federation02:30:11
do you use these flashing lights?02:30:13
beacons without permission therefore02:30:17
the administration will find out why02:30:19
there were these beacons on your roof and02:30:22
how and who will bear02:30:24
responsibility for this02:30:27
offense you have a court decision I understand02:30:30
parties Yes Your Honor hearing02:30:33
[applause]02:30:39
the court's decision in the lawsuit has been completed02:30:45
refuse02:30:47
We'll figure it out one more time e Got it02:30:51
You02:30:52
I'm sorry, the matter is not finished yet, we'll be there02:30:59
just come here02:31:02
[music]02:31:10
said the courtroom Battle for money from wages02:31:14
the horses didn’t take me until dawn, I need to think first02:31:18
It's all about people, that's what you're made for02:31:21
this job is for you02:31:24
free legal advice02:31:26
what are you doing now is called02:31:28
legal blackmail you won't lose anymore02:31:31
not a penny satisfied with your IR Yes I am not02:31:35
agree with02:31:36
[applause]02:31:39
[music]02:31:45
this02:31:49
[music]02:31:53
watch further on the hall channel02:31:59
court I ask everyone to stand up ignorance of the law02:32:03
does not relieve you of responsibility02:32:05
Now we understand what I said naturally02:32:07
we will do it all, turn it on and02:32:09
protect your right look at cases02:32:12
family so as not to commit a fatal02:32:14
mistakes stits what do you really want on it02:32:17
get married really Listen, it seems to me that02:32:20
you exist very harmoniously. Maybe you02:32:22
You won’t get a divorce Judge Elena02:32:24
Kutyina won't return your love, I'm not your mother02:32:28
Yes, of course, I understand you, don’t continue02:32:31
but will restore02:32:33
justice on the wedding night She02:32:35
she deceived me, you deceived her too, she02:32:38
I expected it to be a wedding night and her02:32:40
Not02:32:45
was02:32:46
[music]02:33:00
today at02:33:01
program we are the former matchmaker Slava those02:33:04
Lord, our former children were02:33:07
married grandson02:33:09
Slava Can ex-matchmakers live peacefully?02:33:13
in general02:33:15
area until it came to02:33:17
assault must be divided up02:33:19
pennies and put up a three-meter fence02:33:22
from sin02:33:23
[music]02:33:24
away under the influence of this woman02:33:27
predator I just can’t do it any other way02:33:29
name he says the wrong words02:33:32
he thinks it's all he says the wrong words02:33:34
which you want to hear to me so02:33:37
it seems that it can force a man02:33:39
introduce your wife to your mistress and why02:33:42
the woman is sure that the presence of a rival is not02:33:45
the reason for divorce will be sorted out02:33:47
[music]02:33:49
court you were on the train and what02:33:52
happened this devi threw at me02:33:55
the only thing I02:33:57
By the way, the train is going merrily and02:34:00
Someone's life is going on in the compartment to the sound of wheels02:34:03
someone is drinking tea, someone is playing cards and someone is02:34:05
meets his one and only02:34:06
a wonderful and unique man02:34:08
to whom you really want to give02:34:15
heir02:34:19
plaintiff Inna Lisina files a claim for02:34:22
reimbursement of the difference between received02:34:24
funds and actual expenses02:34:27
defendant Elizaveta Konovalova vs.02:34:29
the claim objects and states that no one02:34:32
nothing is02:34:37
the case must be heard02:34:45
compensation02:34:46
Sergeevna plaintiff I'm listening to you Your Honor02:34:51
I'm filing a lawsuit against my neighbor02:34:54
citizen Konovalova for compensation to me02:34:57
differences in costs02:35:00
for the installation of a septic tank and artesian02:35:03
wells we are talking about an amount of 165,000 rubles02:35:07
That is, you are asking to recover the amount of 16502:35:10
exactly We02:35:12
bought summer cottages and built them nearby02:35:15
we are at home there02:35:17
We were friends even the fence between us02:35:21
they did not build houses in order to save money02:35:25
We decided that we would make one septic tank and02:35:29
one well for two, we have a septic tank02:35:32
built on the territory means citizens02:35:35
Konovalova and they built a well on mine02:35:39
territory here is all the construction for us02:35:42
It cost us 430,000 rubles, both the septic tank and02:35:48
septic tank and well 100,000 septic tank and 33002:35:51
well you tell the truth to the court that's all02:35:53
as it is and not what you think it is02:35:55
you make it up, I always tell the truth02:35:58
Yes, you don't always tell the truth02:36:00
flooded everything, talked to each other or02:36:03
give you more02:36:04
no thanks time02:36:06
I shouldn't talk to her at all02:36:08
I want to stop then02:36:10
keep quiet your honor means when I02:36:14
kva came up02:36:16
and said he announced the amount to her and that’s it02:36:20
needed This amount is 215,000 from it02:36:23
she she says she agreed, but she said02:36:26
50 I only have02:36:28
50,000 now I have no other money02:36:31
La you 50 Yes 50,000 she paid02:36:35
was there any preliminary love between you?02:36:37
agreement that we will build02:36:40
septic tank and well We will be like this02:36:43
choosing a model for this company is common to us02:36:46
about this amount02:36:49
reprimanding Yes we are these conditions02:36:53
stipulates that you will do the installation02:36:56
you know what happened there is what it is02:36:59
offered me to make a cheap septic tank and02:37:03
cheap well for 20 m and you are cheap02:37:07
A septic tank is essentially a cesspool02:37:10
flies from the stench and as for the well02:37:13
she offered me well 2002:37:16
like everyone in the village does supposedly she02:37:19
before that I offended half the village, I found out02:37:21
20-25 m but this is not clean water, this is swill02:37:24
you see, this is the swill I offered her02:37:27
make an artesian well at 80 m02:37:30
clean good crystal clear water02:37:33
the respondent agreed she agreed02:37:35
agreed but she said that she had02:37:37
now there is no money yet she said02:37:40
that she has no money now Or she02:37:41
said as she said she would later02:37:44
surcharges for the rest she knew about the amount02:37:47
I'm talking about you warned her in advance02:37:49
of course, but then we started to disagree02:37:53
we quarreled and now she doesn't02:37:56
wants no contact with me02:37:59
what kind of money does she not laugh at all?02:38:01
she doesn't want to listen to me, I already02:38:04
this way and that and in a good way and in a bad way02:38:07
I ended up having to go to court02:38:09
you see, I'm a non-conflict person02:38:12
person is not conflicted conflicted everything02:38:14
this is an idea, it is not a conflict02:38:17
I understand your stets, our defendant is eager02:38:20
V02:38:22
fight say the word say the word first02:38:27
Do you agree with the claim No, of course I don’t02:38:29
I agree with this and am going to file a lawsuit02:38:31
pay the children02:38:33
objection is good Your honor she is between02:38:36
otherwise misleads the court The case in02:38:38
the fact that we are not just neighbors02:38:41
how she describes us here as exes02:38:43
relatives, that is, we are former matchmakers02:38:45
Lord, what are your exes?02:38:47
in general our children were married married and02:38:50
grandchildren are mine before grandchildren are there are no grandchildren02:38:53
thank you there is no state, that is, children02:38:56
there are such relatives My daughter and her02:38:59
son, okay, we really bought it02:39:03
when our children got married we were in02:39:05
wonderful friendly relations we02:39:07
we bought two plots of land next to each other and we didn't02:39:10
we put it together we rested we did it02:39:12
kebabs fixed all the holidays02:39:14
it was just flat. We're not talking about any money.02:39:17
I didn't walk at all when I didn't speak02:39:20
over these two years we mean when02:39:23
already really equipped both of them02:39:25
plot We decided accordingly02:39:28
really put a septic tank on mine02:39:30
territory and make a well on it02:39:33
territory, well, I kind of even though I02:39:35
blonde But I'm not completely stupid02:39:37
I actually studied all the papers here02:39:40
I have estimates for installation and septic tank and02:39:43
everyone in the village makes wells, so do I02:39:51
advised to do this, that is, I02:39:53
she promised her 50,000 and agreed with02:39:56
you here, the following happened to us02:39:59
situation The thing is that we don’t have02:40:01
completely different financial situation02:40:03
I've lived modestly all my life, and she's from here.02:40:07
cohorts of rich people, that is, money02:40:09
I never thought she had chickens02:40:11
they peck and as she said she doesn’t want to drink02:40:13
this is slop and this is not02:40:16
She decided to install an imported septic tank and02:40:18
respectively artesian well02:40:20
ok please tell me you agreed02:40:22
the plaintiff warned you about02:40:25
that she wants to install a septic tank and02:40:29
a well is more expensive Yes of course02:40:32
We discussed this issue with her, but I02:40:34
immediately no I immediately told her that I didn’t02:40:37
I can afford that kind of money, I have this02:40:41
possibilities conditionally she is all this02:40:43
she knew very well she told me no02:40:44
worry, I'll take it all on you02:40:46
We warned you how much you are willing to pay02:40:49
pay Yes, I told her that I could02:40:52
Yes, she agreed. What are we doing with her?02:40:53
before signing please She agreed02:40:56
a hundred documents and here are the calculations02:41:00
on the construction of a septic tank and well, you have it02:41:02
we didn’t build it Well, we built it, that’s the point02:41:05
the fact that in our village everything is being built02:41:06
It is for this reason that I02:41:08
accordingly I agreed with these02:41:10
50,000 which we agreed upon02:41:14
you have documents02:41:16
the main requirements are cost02:41:19
construction of wells and septic tanks Yes, that's it02:41:22
there are agreements there are all agreements on the company02:41:26
still here you are Please pay attention to02:41:28
about our financial situation02:41:30
This is the house that I built on02:41:32
in your own area It’s only 40 metro02:41:34
a modest country house and this is it02:41:42
rebuild my financial situation02:41:46
Sorry guys, why do I need this?02:41:48
show Well, in order for you02:41:50
show that I really couldn't02:41:52
afford such a septic tank and such chickpeas02:41:55
without these photos02:41:58
It's understandable to be jealous because Glu when02:42:00
conflicts have started, here are the conflicts02:42:03
started after our children02:42:05
divorced, that is, not because of the septic tank02:42:07
Because of the [ __ ], of course you still think about money02:42:09
she needs mine she doesn't need my money she02:42:11
I just followed the principle of keeping us together02:42:13
crush my son completely if only02:42:15
not her daughter if it weren't for your daughter yours02:42:19
Dasha there would be nothing at all02:42:22
no ships Leshe, no money02:42:25
she didn’t demand such agricultural information from me as02:42:27
my Dasha, you should have prayed for no02:42:30
of course pray This is your Dashenka02:42:32
hahala walks there and looks for where she can02:42:35
But he loved your daughter and yours went02:42:37
twisted her tail and chose Wherever she wanted02:42:39
It’s more profitable to settle yourself in. So02:42:41
attached And now we have to02:42:43
I would like to answer for yours in general to you02:42:46
the question was in vain I didn’t answer02:42:49
EU you built the fence Yes she did02:42:52
she put a fence between us she02:42:55
put a fence between us02:42:57
there is no way to install the vessels right now02:42:59
there is no fence between you, but02:43:02
I have the opportunity to fine you for02:43:05
what is it that you are disturbing the order in02:43:07
courtroom I am you part02:43:11
you gave me the floor02:43:14
give you a hundred opportunities to argue and02:43:18
organize a market here Excuse me wa chi02:43:20
I beg02:43:21
Sorry, what else can you add? Here02:43:25
I want to say in the sense that she02:43:27
Basically, she doesn’t need money, she just02:43:30
she wants to squeeze this area from me02:43:32
about this several times already But the thing is02:43:35
what did she tell me if you don't want to02:43:36
give money give me land I'm so02:43:39
just curious02:43:41
how much land does she want to take from me?02:43:43
from my station she showed me02:43:46
claim for 10 acres it's you it's you you02:43:49
you understand 165,000 10 acres of land02:43:52
the defendant, well, such claims are not02:43:54
declared your honor and here you are02:43:56
understand If you make a decision now02:43:58
in her favor I will remain absolutely nothing02:44:00
I bought this land exactly the same way02:44:03
built her house on this land and she02:44:05
it's all just a raider02:44:07
grip She just squeezes me all the way02:44:09
what about 165,000 that she doesn’t care about at all?02:44:12
she needs a house there that costs millions and this02:44:15
No luck02:44:17
how much is removed to make a decision02:44:19
I ask everyone to stand up, your business, your business02:44:22
just to annoy as much as possible02:44:24
if your Yes on studied that so Yes what are you02:44:27
you say, what about your Dasha, you went out02:44:29
marry my who Who studied what02:44:31
if it weren't for her none of this would have happened02:44:33
you don't need my money, you see02:44:35
she is principled, it should have been yes02:44:37
dissuade you from your wok Nothing you from02:44:39
You won't get me attacked of course02:44:41
kvass look at yours ko hvo kru Yes02:44:45
Here, hold your candle, I don’t know where it is02:44:47
there's someone you're sleeping with now Next in02:44:51
program under the influence of this woman02:44:54
predator I just can’t do it any other way02:44:56
name he says the wrong words02:44:58
he thinks that's all that burns those words02:45:01
which you want to hear to me so02:45:03
it seems Can the power of tradition and opinion02:45:06
older relatives stop the man02:45:08
will the person who made the decision to divorce understand?02:45:11
wife02:45:14
spell02:45:16
you were on the train and what02:45:20
happened this girl attacked me02:45:22
the only thing I managed to do was keep it between02:45:26
other places you can meet your love02:45:28
anywhere in the park in a cafe on the train What if02:45:31
The train takes a long time, so you can catch it02:45:33
fall in love fall out of love fall in love with someone else02:45:35
the main thing is not to get confused which one02:45:37
beloved ones to you02:45:41
[music]02:45:44
expensive02:45:46
there is no money for bidding at the market, the court announces02:45:49
decision the court decided the claim about02:45:52
recovery of funds in the amount of up to02:45:55
half of the actual expenses incurred for02:45:57
Leave the septic tank and well equipment02:45:59
without satisfaction the court accepts this02:46:02
decision Due to the fact that the property02:46:05
what you built is not yours02:46:09
as if there is no common property between you02:46:11
there was an agreement that Dan possessed02:46:15
you build with funds that02:46:19
contribute in proportion to what you incurred02:46:22
expenses or divide them in half That is02:46:24
there are no written agreements between you02:46:26
it wasn't02:46:29
the first since the septic tank is located on02:46:33
the defendant's plot and it costs 100,000 then02:46:37
actually paid for it paid02:46:40
half the cost that is 50,00002:46:42
how correctly it was installed in02:46:45
court at the same time well more02:46:48
expensive property is located on the site02:46:52
which which belongs to itsu That is02:46:55
it's your property that is02:46:57
it turns out that due to the fact that you02:46:59
ruined relationships for each of you02:47:02
there is property left on your site02:47:05
a well on your site, a septic tank and then02:47:08
it turns out that I can't02:47:09
use its water Well, not yet02:47:12
it turns out because you have something in common02:47:14
water supply and I can't say how02:47:17
events will develop further If you02:47:19
you will block each other's access to02:47:22
wa to this property then it can02:47:24
lead to further presentation02:47:27
e other claims for failure to obstruct02:47:30
enjoyment of recognition there it is02:47:33
property in common, that is, to fantasize02:47:35
as many possibilities as you like02:47:37
a few Yes a lot in the end everyone02:47:40
you can build a new one02:47:43
equipment on site you well you02:47:46
septi if if you don't agree but02:47:50
reasons to satisfy this02:47:52
the court does not have a claim therefore the claims02:47:56
case denied02:47:58
closed solution02:48:00
[music]02:48:01
sudas02:48:04
Of course, I shouldn’t refuse my daughter02:48:07
allowed her son to marry02:48:10
This is something02:48:13
I won't have any more words02:48:16
[music]02:48:18
I can't see these anymore02:48:20
ex-relatives will most likely give me a dacha02:48:22
I'll sell it and then let her do it herself02:48:24
deals with these new owners with02:48:26
this well with this septic tank for me02:48:28
it won't happen anymore02:48:30
touch if trouble comes to your house02:48:33
daughters have diphtheria, you know, she almost02:48:35
died you have pain if love02:48:38
turned into hatred you didn't spend02:48:40
not a penny for maintenance until you02:48:43
found the money, please keep quiet if02:48:46
you need to understand how to protect yourself and your loved ones02:48:49
Well, how can I my own son02:48:52
put in jail see the program02:48:56
affairs02:48:57
[music]02:49:01
family02:49:02
plaintiff Aizat Kasanov sues02:49:06
termination02:49:08
marriage defendant Liya Kasanova with the claim is not02:49:11
I agree, I’m sure it’s possible to have a family02:49:14
save02:49:18
plaintiff's divorce case is being heard02:49:21
Kasanov Aizat Batyrovich defendant02:49:24
Kasanova Aliya Bulatovna plaintiff I you02:49:27
I'm listening Your Honor I ask you to separate us02:49:32
since our marriage is practically on paper02:49:35
We don’t live together and have a family. Well, we can’t help but02:49:38
it turns out Save Please tell me02:49:40
when was the marriage registered?02:49:43
registered 6 years ago 6 years02:49:45
ago and you haven’t lived all 6 years02:49:48
together No we lived together for 2 years Yeah02:49:51
Well, re years It’s practically not, but where02:49:54
you lived together and you lived together02:49:58
here in Moscow then after a certain02:50:00
time with us She became pregnant and left for02:50:04
city02:50:05
shtau and son was born Son was born Yes Son 402:50:09
years, yes, that is, you have a common child And02:50:12
that Well, she left for Kakta and that And you I02:50:17
continued to work here, well initially I02:50:20
in general, I’ll tell you how I’ve been doing this for 10 years02:50:24
business opened a network in his hometown02:50:28
retail stores your hometown02:50:30
where is the same in costa02:50:33
so I opened it and then decided to expand the business02:50:36
went to Moscow02:50:38
Yeah 8 years ago I went to Moscow02:50:41
I tried and created my own network here Yeah02:50:45
7 years ago I applied for citizenship and received it02:50:49
began to develop it further throughout02:50:52
4 years it’s like my wife lived there I02:50:56
always went there went there went there02:50:59
yes, that is, they were engaged in a breakup02:51:01
Yes, I was raising my son02:51:04
raising a son Well, in principle, how02:51:06
I wish I had this, sometimes I even go crazy02:51:10
like this02:51:13
make two states Why doesn’t the wife02:51:17
wants to return to Moscow or cannot02:51:19
return to Moscow First she02:51:21
reasoned that she will go02:51:24
only there to give birth is the best environmentalists are all02:51:28
our acquaintances know us all, as if everyone02:51:31
her own mother will help there, so to speak02:51:34
ok left you agreed left02:51:37
To give birth02:51:38
child so that the mother is nearby02:51:40
safely carried the child to birth02:51:42
wonderful son Uh huh02:51:45
after the birth of her son, she announced that02:51:48
Absolutely does not want to return to02:51:50
Moscow because Moscow has a bad environment02:51:52
it's true there are a lot of people everyone is in a hurry02:51:55
everyone is in a hurry, people are not in each other's02:51:58
she is respected even when she is with her child02:52:00
went somewhere in the transport no one told her02:52:03
not inferior02:52:06
place Well, what’s wrong with you?02:52:10
wife Well, maybe she’s wrong in that02:52:15
there is a life really in02:52:18
Moscow is difficult I agree that02:52:22
difficult but still here anyway02:52:24
city of prospects let's say it02:52:27
prospects for you or you now02:52:29
talk about the prospects for your02:52:31
family In general I take it as a business02:52:34
created for his family in no way02:52:36
case not only for02:52:39
That's how divorce works02:52:43
what places Well, you say What are you02:52:47
Constantly travel to your hometown02:52:50
visits02:52:51
you participate in raising your family02:52:54
your wife is involved in supporting your son02:52:56
support also wife works teaching wife02:52:59
No, my wife doesn't work, I don't work02:53:00
I provide for her completely and I do not02:53:02
I understand the reason for the divorce02:53:04
Well, is that your latest fatigue?02:53:07
for the last 2 years I have been living with his other friend02:53:11
just befuddled by another woman that's why02:53:13
This is the reason for your appeal02:53:16
going to court for divorce is not like you02:53:19
tired of traveling to visit your family and02:53:21
exactly what you live with another02:53:24
woman Yes, yeah, the answer is about it02:53:27
knows or just now found out know about02:53:30
this she knows so the answer is listening to you02:53:33
agree with the claim no Your Honor I02:53:35
I completely disagree with the claim because02:53:37
I believe that our family can and should02:53:40
save How do you just understand02:53:43
Jan a little at first when I got pregnant I02:53:46
considered it necessary and necessary to go02:53:48
to give birth in Kokshetau, in principle, Aizat is for you02:53:51
everything was confirmed for some reason, that is, you02:53:54
really left to be a mother02:53:56
so that because it’s easier there, relatives02:53:58
ecologists dear ecology everything is clear A02:54:01
why didn't you come back well you know02:54:03
it all depends on our son I02:54:06
came a couple of times with my son Azat us02:54:08
I actually met him and he bought it02:54:10
It's a very good apartment for us, that's it02:54:13
It’s very difficult for the child here02:54:15
some kind of allergic reaction begins02:54:17
reaction started asthma Well I can't02:54:21
torture your child if he is here02:54:23
uncomfortable and Isa it’s all great02:54:25
knows that we went through a bunch of doctors02:54:27
a consultation was held, that is, according to02:54:30
there are no medical indications for your child02:54:34
can live in Moscow When you02:54:36
you go back there, everything goes away02:54:39
everything passes through the passage because it’s clean there02:54:41
the air is a mountainous area on the coast02:54:43
lakes understood you well then tell me02:54:46
please how do you think02:54:49
save the family I want my husband02:54:52
returned to our hometown because02:54:54
when I left to give birth he had02:54:56
completely different plans he wanted02:54:59
build us a house on the lake02:55:01
so that we can live there together so that I can give birth02:55:03
he still has children but you know with everyone02:55:06
for a month he has his opinion constantly02:55:09
changing, I understand, well, the answerer, well, you02:55:12
wasn't around at all02:55:16
left He is a young man you him02:55:18
basically left alone in Moscow02:55:20
there are a lot of people here who want to get married I02:55:24
I agree with you I understand that now02:55:26
he came under the influence but Kohl Soon02:55:30
your husband has had someone else for a long time02:55:33
woman, don't you think that your02:55:35
the relationship has exhausted itself, I think that he02:55:38
just fell under her influence she told him02:55:41
powder your brains and this is only temporary02:55:44
is your intention serious and do you think02:55:47
possible to save the family with the defendant02:55:49
Your Honor this is a deliberate decision I do not02:55:54
one day and even more than one year persuaded02:55:57
my wife to come back to02:56:00
lived in Moscow, explained everything to her02:56:02
Well, you see there is a situation02:56:06
objective reasons why she does not02:56:08
Maybe02:56:10
return I'm in basically the same state now02:56:12
buy a whole council of all the same02:56:15
doctors let’s create all the conditions02:56:18
what do my children need to live?02:56:20
clear the smoke over Moscow I am able02:56:23
buy a house outside the city not in Moscow in02:56:27
environmentally friendly02:56:29
area to build it create all the conditions02:56:32
Yeah for the child for the child for the family02:56:35
what was it but wife category02:56:38
build a house where there will be no such thing02:56:41
the child won't have any smoke either02:56:44
allergic reactions yes Of course for the sake of02:56:47
what is this yes absolutely of course she is not in02:56:52
at least he doesn’t want to move02:56:54
here because there are relatives there02:56:57
parents and how would she get used to02:56:59
certain environment But this is the only02:57:01
is there a reason or are there any other reasons?02:57:03
after the birth of the child she lost02:57:07
practically interesting Aizat, what are you talking about02:57:09
you say, what nonsense I like you02:57:10
I loved you before, I still love you, well I do02:57:13
as a man, a young man, everything to me02:57:15
I also need a woman nearby02:57:17
So let's say someone met me. Well,02:57:20
in the end, nobody is just a physiologist02:57:22
Not02:57:23
canceled How can you say that02:57:25
after what I did, what should my son do?02:57:29
very well maybe the defendant Well, you02:57:31
explains the old man. It’s strange what’s in your head02:57:33
it doesn’t happen that a man starts a family02:57:36
to have a wife nearby02:57:41
and married life consists of02:57:44
many aspects and almost everything is natural02:57:47
he listed them as far as I understand02:57:49
I fulfilled my responsibilities as a husband02:57:54
I think that we need to go to Kokshetau02:57:57
I'll try it there02:57:59
bring me to my senses, I understand what a man has02:58:01
who lives without his wife may be02:58:05
some affairs on the side Well, I'm ready02:58:08
forgive him because I am also him02:58:10
I love you but it’s just that no one ever02:58:13
divorced in the family you understand this02:58:14
it will be a shame for the family. What can I say?02:58:16
to our child what will I tell Donat what02:58:20
his dad found another woman and left and02:58:23
your dad thinks so and so do my parents02:58:25
they think it will be a shame Aizat Well02:58:27
finally come to your senses because here under02:58:30
the influence of this predatory woman is just me02:58:33
I can’t call her anything else, he says02:58:35
not the words he thinks that's all02:58:37
what about he says the wrong words that you02:58:39
want to hear me like that02:58:42
It seems that the case has been stated please02:58:45
witness Yes my witness is your witness02:58:48
please invite a witness02:58:50
parties witness witness02:58:52
Come on now you will see this cougar02:58:55
Hello02:58:58
Hello02:59:00
Hello, please introduce yourself Romanova02:59:03
Olga Yuryevna What do you want to explain on02:59:06
protoko you don't understand anything02:59:08
don't know anything about02:59:10
witness's father listening to the witness02:59:15
for 4 years I helped02:59:18
I worked together with Azat, I managed his affairs02:59:24
I was the manager of his stores and02:59:27
for the last 2 years we have been living together as02:59:29
common-law husband and wife Well, what kind of wife are you?02:59:31
You are just a lover who is a lover02:59:34
got into someone else's way that we live together And02:59:37
we are making general plans, we have some kind of02:59:39
we already have a joint farm02:59:40
we live together in my Moscow02:59:42
apartment Why are you02:59:45
vate please answer the answerer It is necessary02:59:49
listen02:59:50
Now the testimony of witnesses The point is02:59:53
that's what you just said, these are these02:59:55
here are the titles What are you telling us02:59:57
absolutely not necessary You don’t know anymore02:59:59
his ex-husband he has tastes03:00:01
interests changed03:00:02
changed the witness I dare to remind you03:00:05
that the plaintiff is not yet the ex-husband03:00:08
answer yes wrong03:00:10
said the fact is that he is very strong03:00:14
this is VM Moscow changing people, he is engaged03:00:17
business affairs he strives to achieve03:00:19
to develop so that the business can be03:00:20
successful what I strive for together we03:00:22
we do this03:00:29
we help the defendant question to the witness you03:00:33
do you think that03:00:35
ic doesn't want03:00:38
return to03:00:41
city03:00:42
Gori03:00:44
the most important thing is that he03:00:48
m for removal03:00:51
solutions Next in the program you are on the train03:00:55
we were driving and what happened this girl on03:00:58
I was attacked by the only thing I03:01:02
the train was moving happily and to the sound of the wheels03:01:05
compartment life goes on someone drinks tea someone03:01:08
someone is playing03:01:12
I really want to give it to you03:01:15
[music]03:01:22
the heir's decision is announced to the court03:01:26
decided to file a claim to satisfy the marriage03:01:29
between spouses between the plaintiff and03:01:31
defendant dissolve the court dissolves03:01:34
marriage between spouses as in judicial03:01:37
meeting it was established that further03:01:39
living together between spouses and03:01:42
saving the family is absolutely impossible03:01:46
it is obvious that things have developed between itso and03:01:49
defendant such relationships When families03:01:52
no longer has itza almost formed03:01:56
the new family the defendant did not come for a long time03:02:00
to meet my husband to save the family03:02:04
Therefore, in this case, the period for03:02:06
grant reconciliation according to the opinion of the court03:02:09
unreasonable case closed please everyone stand up03:02:15
solution03:02:16
court claim03:02:19
satisfy I will always help and03:02:23
Donat but I think that there is no happiness built in03:02:26
my happiness is in Moscow03:02:30
I didn't expect that we would be divorced and03:02:33
I just can’t imagine how I’ll survive this03:02:35
shame what should I do alone with03:02:38
[music]03:02:42
as a child, hatred as you loved at first03:02:45
then you loved me, I didn’t love you03:02:47
loved your mother We are for children03:02:50
laughed and didn't cry when they took me away03:02:52
a child from the family lay without03:02:55
food without drinking near the mothers who were in03:02:57
breaking point, we collected it on the edge of life and03:02:59
death We are for your property not03:03:02
divided and multiplied as soon as03:03:05
the defendant became aware that I have03:03:09
son, she immediately ran to sell everything03:03:11
property so that this child has nothing03:03:12
got it03:03:14
if something threatens your well-being03:03:16
call our free legal03:03:19
consultation with professional lawyers03:03:22
will help you with their03:03:25
[music]03:03:30
council plaintiff Victoria Kotikova03:03:34
brings a claim to establish03:03:36
paternity regarding his period03:03:42
no child03:03:46
[music]03:03:49
admits the case is being heard to establish03:03:52
paternity of a minor03:03:55
child plaintiff Kotikova Victoria03:03:57
Alekseevna defendant Pushkarev Leonid03:04:00
Kirillovich, plaintiff, please state03:04:03
your claims Your Honor I03:04:05
Want03:04:07
establish the paternity of my child and03:04:10
this young man is the defendant Yes03:04:13
this respondent to my Danya, more precisely03:04:15
Our 3 month old was conceived on a train03:04:18
So how it was03:04:21
and I've been meaning to go to my place for a long time03:04:24
to a friend in salihat And actually money03:04:28
there was no time for both03:04:31
That's how circumstances coincided03:04:33
divorced her husband and03:04:35
it contributed to my trip I bought03:04:39
ticket dolan there not far from Salekhard03:04:42
So I bought a ticket and went03:04:45
Actually, how was it all the company that03:04:48
there was a student in the next compartment03:04:51
This young man at that moment told me03:04:54
was very interesting nice cool03:04:56
the guy is actually me in the next compartment03:04:59
next compartment Yes, here they are right away03:05:02
invited because well03:05:04
would have started a conversation and we continued03:05:08
communication was fun We sang a lot03:05:11
danced and in ku here and in Kup Well there it was03:05:15
You know the place a little, but here you go03:05:18
in general, how love began frankly03:05:21
It was love at first sight here03:05:23
100% he told me sincerely you know03:05:27
sincere words and Moscow trains03:05:30
Labytnangi03:05:32
Ngi da Uh-huh03:05:35
These are the sincere words I spoke to him03:05:38
The only love is truly03:05:40
Love at first sight is such a spark03:05:42
such a storm of emotions In general Well, of course we03:05:44
we slept together we had sex wait here03:05:48
dawn We woke up, I see he is collecting03:05:50
things think that you woke up03:05:52
sounds just very romantic03:05:56
wait please ok excuse me03:05:57
honor I think he's doing what what03:06:00
happens says things collect I say03:06:02
Where wait? We haven't arrived yet.03:06:04
says my Pechora station, that’s it for now and03:06:06
I will call you, I will write to you, but03:06:09
Do you know, Your Honor, what is most interesting?03:06:10
he didn't take my phone number he says03:06:12
love love like that but didn't take the number03:06:14
phone Love eclipsed consciousness and forgot03:06:16
take the phone I was shocked I I I I don't03:06:19
knew what to do, you understand with your husband03:06:21
divorced, lived together for 5 years with my husband03:06:24
divorced, abandoned, just found the real one03:06:25
love is true love03:06:28
Nala you understand all men are [ __ ]03:06:30
I'm convinced of this, you hear03:06:33
her Please excuse me Yes, well, in general03:06:37
Of course I came to my friend. She me03:06:39
How did you find him on social networks?03:06:41
of course I wonder how you make me feel03:06:43
found it look It's enough03:06:46
the network just needs to be more careful03:06:49
defendant especially your friends are several03:06:51
since they said that you study at polytechnic03:06:54
everything is very simple03:06:55
and then a month later I realize that I03:06:59
pregnant Well, who was it from?03:07:02
the last person is my love, I understand03:07:04
that you fell in love Well, because you are the father03:07:07
who e That's actually now Why03:07:12
where we stand is that I want him to admit it03:07:14
his paternity if he doesn't intend to03:07:16
build a family with me, that is, even though03:07:18
if he proves that he is the father, let him pay03:07:21
elements in general I want you03:07:24
specifically admitted that you are our father03:07:26
Dani that you specifically here me03:07:29
I used it differently then I won’t say03:07:31
you said such beautiful words yes03:07:33
I spoke beautiful words I spoke to you03:07:35
I love You are the only one Yeah And in the end what03:07:38
Here you go, baby, I’m not here03:07:40
what does it have to do with Yes plaintiff plaintiff Let's RM to03:07:44
your claim Please tell me you are the plaintiff03:07:48
met after all these events03:07:50
after the birth of the child with the defendant after03:07:53
how he was found on social media03:07:54
networks yes I met we met03:07:56
especially in order to03:07:58
establish paternity so that he can hand over his03:08:01
materials but at the moment I now03:08:03
it is unknown whether or not it is03:08:06
there is an examination carried out and the court will03:08:10
presented clearly That is, voluntarily03:08:13
surrender to the mother yes He claims that it’s just03:08:15
he is not the child's father so he agreed03:08:18
Of course I understand, we are listening to you, respondent Well03:08:21
in fact, everything is simple here of course03:08:24
everything, this girl is on her first night in03:08:27
I was second on the train by the way03:08:29
spent with Mikhail You know who he is03:08:33
Mikhail Mikha Mikhail this is your neighbor shopping03:08:35
cancer stories and at some point apparently03:08:38
it so happened that they decided apparently03:08:40
privacy and grandmother and grandson who03:08:42
we were traveling with them and came to us in the compartment03:08:44
And we had neighboring compartments. Well, supposedly on03:08:46
tea from now on that's all03:08:48
started before grandma came for teaDescription:
Ищите первый в России телеканал судебных разбирательств «Зал суда» в пакетах: Ростелеком (кнопка 418) Каналов «Единый» от Триколора (кнопка 392 в общем списке), а также в мобильном приложении «Триколор Кино и ТВ» Телекарта (Horisons 2: кнопка 132, экспресс ам5: кнопка 52) По просьбам подписчиков нашего ЮТЮБ канала "Зал Суда" — с 16 ноября до 14 декабря 2020 года вы сможете смотреть прямые трансляции первого в РФ телеканала судебных разбирательств "Зал Суда". Лучшие судебные практики, скандалы и истории из реальной жизни нон-стоп 24 часа 7 дней в неделю не только на ЮТЮБе, но и на больших экранах ваших ТВ! На канале Зал Суда телезрители увидят полюбившиеся программы: - «Дела семейные. Битва за будущее» с Е. Дмитриевой - «Дела Семейные. Новые истории» с Е. Кутьиной - «Битва за деньги» с Дмитрием Агрисом - «Судебные страсти» с Николаем Бурделовым Смотрите, комментируйте, делитесь и подписывайтесь на наш канал Зал Суда https://www.youtube.com/user/CourtHour...
Preparing download options
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players
Questions about downloading video
How can I download "Телеканал Зал суда. Прямой эфир" video?
http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.
Which format of "Телеканал Зал суда. Прямой эфир" video should I choose?
The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.
Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Телеканал Зал суда. Прямой эфир" video?
The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.
How can I download "Телеканал Зал суда. Прямой эфир" video to my phone?
You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.
How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Телеканал Зал суда. Прямой эфир"?
The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.
How can I save a frame from a video "Телеканал Зал суда. Прямой эфир"?
This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.
What's the price of all this stuff?
It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.