Download "Михаил Бонч-Бруевич: дважды генерал. Дело N @SMOTRIM_KULTURA"

"videoThumbnail Михаил Бонч-Бруевич: дважды генерал. Дело N @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

Абсолютный слух // Эфир 24.02.2021 @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

Абсолютный слух // Эфир 24.02.2021 @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

Channel: Телеканал Культура

Михаил Плетнев и Российский национальный оркестр. М. Мусоргский. "Картинки с выставки"

Михаил Плетнев и Российский национальный оркестр. М. Мусоргский. "Картинки с выставки"

Channel: Телеканал Культура

Эдуард Назаров // Острова @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

Эдуард Назаров // Острова @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

Channel: Телеканал Культура

"Предел возможного" 1-я серия. Художественный фильм (Экран, 1984) @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

"Предел возможного" 1-я серия. Художественный фильм (Экран, 1984) @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

Channel: Телеканал Культура

Хакасия. Загадки Долины царей // Запечатленное время @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

Хакасия. Загадки Долины царей // Запечатленное время @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

Channel: Телеканал Культура

Резо Чхеидзе // Острова @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

Резо Чхеидзе // Острова @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

Channel: Телеканал Культура

Письма из провинции. Шуя (Ивановская область) @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

Письма из провинции. Шуя (Ивановская область) @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

Channel: Телеканал Культура

Абсолютный слух // Эфир 10.10.2021 @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

Абсолютный слух // Эфир 10.10.2021 @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

Channel: Телеканал Культура

Гении и злодеи // Николай Склифосовский @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

Гении и злодеи // Николай Склифосовский @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

Channel: Телеканал Культура

Абсолютный слух // Эфир 31.03.2021 @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

Абсолютный слух // Эфир 31.03.2021 @SMOTRIM_KULTURA

Channel: Телеканал Культура

Культура

канал культура

телеканал культура

Дело N

Документальный сериал

Дело N культура

документалистика

передача

история

СССР

Михаил Бонч-Бруевич

Бонч-Бруевич

дважды генерал

00:00:00

[music]

00:00:12

brother of the Bolshevik, assistant to Lenin,

00:00:16

major general of the Russian imperial

00:00:18

army, one of the founders of the Red Army,

00:00:21

military leader of the Supreme Military

00:00:24

Council and chief of the field headquarters of the

00:00:26

revolutionary military council of the Soviet

00:00:29

Republic, paradoxically, this is one

00:00:32

person, Mikhail Dmitrich Bonch-Bruevich, a

00:00:35

graduate of the Konstantinovsky Land Survey

00:00:37

Institute and the Nikolaev State University Academy of the

00:00:39

General Staff

00:00:40

[music]

00:00:56

[music]

00:01:28

dear friends, we are in the

00:01:31

state military archive and on

00:01:35

our table today there are unique

00:01:38

documents they are connected with the personality of

00:01:41

General Borscht Bruevich and there are names

00:01:45

in our history that seem to be

00:01:48

well-known, but we know little about them what we know, but

00:01:51

before we talk on this

00:01:54

topic, I want to introduce the

00:01:56

guest and expert of our program, Igor

00:02:00

Mikhailovich

00:02:01

Nagaev, hello, hello,

00:02:04

General More Bruevich, basically these

00:02:08

documents date back to the Soviet era,

00:02:11

but to understand what and how happened

00:02:15

at that time, you still need some background

00:02:19

our hero,

00:02:22

Boy Bruevich, he was a participant in the First

00:02:24

World War, how would you rate his

00:02:30

participation in this war in which roles in the first

00:02:33

roles in the second in general what did he do

00:02:36

you know there is such an expression as a paradox man

00:02:40

I think Mikhail Dmitrich applies to our hero to the

00:02:43

fullest because he had

00:02:46

already entered the period of the First World War

00:02:48

as a rather large military man, he

00:02:51

grew up very quickly in Taiwan because

00:02:53

he started as a lieutenant colonel and ended up, as

00:02:56

you know, as a major general.

00:03:05

ranks about the officer

00:03:08

corps second,

00:03:09

paradoxically, entering the war

00:03:12

there was such an expression, he was

00:03:15

terribly devoted to tsarism, he was even

00:03:18

called somewhere a revolutionary monarchist, he

00:03:21

began to publish very early, and to publish

00:03:23

as a military journalist, that is, you understand the

00:03:25

paradoxical nature of man and

00:03:27

will always emphasize it on this side, on the

00:03:29

one hand, cocaine begins to be printed

00:03:31

and the journalist, a well-known task at that time, a

00:03:32

Russian disabled intelligence magazine, and

00:03:35

many such places are

00:03:37

not built then, as he sleeps on the site, he

00:03:39

served in the Kiev military district and

00:03:41

at the same time,

00:03:42

his teacher Dragomirova, everyone known,

00:03:45

instructs him to compose very interesting

00:03:48

things interesting things collect all the training

00:03:51

manuals it is known that this is our

00:03:53

documents and is also reflected in one

00:03:55

letter, the Russian chief

00:03:58

organizer of the Red Army of that period succeeded, he writes that

00:04:00

the testament of Dragomir and left and life

00:04:03

before the start of the First World War, he

00:04:05

instructs him

00:04:06

to finish the training manuals on

00:04:09

Russian tactics army, if Dragomir especially

00:04:11

described such a Russian army of the Eastern

00:04:14

War, the leg of the Russian-Turkish war of 1778

00:04:17

1888, then he adds here the experience of

00:04:21

1, as they used to say, of the shameful war, then the

00:04:24

Russian-Japanese war, the quality of 4 thousand of the

00:04:26

fifth year in the First World War,

00:04:30

General Bonch-Bruevich ranks senior

00:04:33

command and staff positions in the Russian

00:04:35

army is in charge of intelligence, counterintelligence,

00:04:38

awarded the

00:04:39

St. George weapon after the February

00:04:43

revolution, actively collaborates with the

00:04:45

councils of workers' and soldiers' deputies,

00:04:47

being the head of the Pskov garrison,

00:04:49

even sits on the executive committee of the local council,

00:04:54

but here you are talking about his monarchical

00:04:58

beliefs and nevertheless, as

00:05:01

the empress knows she was dissatisfied with him, the

00:05:04

fact is that the tsarina’s entourage

00:05:07

was, so to speak, panicking about the

00:05:09

German park bonjour evich characteristic

00:05:12

of him administratively so good good

00:05:14

you sincerity he did not love those whom he

00:05:16

loved the empress and if you allow me I’ll

00:05:18

just quote you things that, for

00:05:21

example, she wrote to Tsar Nicholas 2

00:05:24

Nicholas

00:05:26

what a joy it will be for the novel when you get rid

00:05:28

of br br

00:05:30

I can’t write his name but first

00:05:33

he needs to be made to understand this, he is doing

00:05:35

evil to serve the brothel and to you you are too

00:05:38

kind,

00:05:39

my luminous angel, it seems to me that there is

00:05:43

some kind of courtly and plaintive here m3

00:05:48

m3

00:05:50

well because of course I absolutely agree with you in

00:05:55

this interview, but not only did

00:05:57

he have an unkind, very

00:05:59

large number of well-wishers after

00:06:01

February, he is inserted and so to

00:06:05

speak is those who, even under the

00:06:07

provisional government under Alex,

00:06:09

we will still say to Kerensky, let the

00:06:11

Kornilovich rebellion influence but again I say

00:06:13

when they study the document, it is felt

00:06:16

all the time that it has some

00:06:18

kind of minus that many do not understand the

00:06:21

fact that in the seventeenth year among the

00:06:23

senior staff it becomes not a hand

00:06:25

shake, how to choose for officers, it

00:06:27

was not just like that, but first let’s a

00:06:30

few more words about his role in the army of the

00:06:34

seventeenth year after the February

00:06:36

coup,

00:06:37

that is,

00:06:39

during the provisional government, he

00:06:42

begins to actively cooperate with those

00:06:44

soldier committees

00:06:46

that appear before after his

00:06:48

February coup and essentially

00:06:50

this is the source of the collapse of the army, the main

00:06:53

source is doubtless

00:06:54

not himself, here it is itself collapsed

00:06:59

or and and collapsed I think that this in

00:07:02

this process went parallel and

00:07:04

naturally to weaving the agitation and

00:07:06

propaganda of the Bolsheviks who are striving

00:07:08

to make, as you remember from the metal

00:07:10

war, a

00:07:11

civil war and wanting the defeat of their

00:07:13

own government before the second

00:07:15

moment but the people who were their own

00:07:18

constituted the main force of the army he tired and

00:07:21

four years of war at the end of the 17th 18th

00:07:27

year and what are we fighting for,

00:07:29

well, you know when this question

00:07:31

is asked what are we fighting for there some kind of

00:07:34

miracle hero will suit Alexander

00:07:37

Vasilich a pack of

00:07:39

numbers in general what are we fighting for

00:07:41

boozled Switzerland until we will cook

00:07:44

about this then it was common again

00:07:46

for the tsar for the homeland for the faith of the tsar there was no longer

00:07:52

from February 17 until faith during the period of the

00:07:58

provisional government was also probably

00:08:00

not at its best and and 3 and the fatherland by

00:08:03

force of dragging along the TPO these are the concepts of both

00:08:06

Russian and not only the Russian kingdom for

00:08:09

1 for the role in they fought many

00:08:10

nationalities then the Russian empire in those

00:08:12

states here in that period it

00:08:15

eventually simply dried up there is such an understanding

00:08:17

and fatigue the person is tired, well,

00:08:20

especially positional war is

00:08:22

psychologically difficult they are generally for no

00:08:25

and not sitting in a trench I was there winter-spring then

00:08:29

water snow and sitting then what a

00:08:32

process of fraternization began fraternization with enemies

00:08:36

the most amazing thing that means from these

00:08:39

committees there is such an anti-officer and

00:08:43

such a wave they resisted

00:08:46

and this discipline and

00:08:49

imagine he got a situation like this

00:08:51

moment on 17, a robot that can be

00:08:53

expressed in a well-known phrase, a stranger among

00:08:56

his own among the nobles among the highest upper circles,

00:08:59

the goal of the aristocracy and his own among strangers

00:09:02

who are just a crowd of bows they

00:09:05

could not be close to him and he writes that he was drawn to Lenin and

00:09:08

instinctively he would give until the end of

00:09:11

his you had a clear life, he was 86 years old, he doesn’t

00:09:14

bear it, he didn’t join the party, of course,

00:09:16

dad says a lot of things, the paradox is a paradox, but

00:09:20

in general,

00:09:21

let’s say two words about his character, he

00:09:24

was such a quarrelsome person, he was a

00:09:27

reserved person, I would say that to myself,

00:09:30

but at the same time I didn’t hurt what again, this

00:09:32

everything arose, he really was a

00:09:34

good specialist, like any

00:09:37

specialist, at first he did not try

00:09:39

to admire, did not try to accommodate the

00:09:41

poet, the poet is designated as a poet,

00:09:42

and he always had his own point of view, he

00:09:45

expressed those considerations that, for

00:09:46

example, already working from documents

00:09:48

directly from our military archive,

00:09:50

she showed that some things and he

00:09:52

simply foresaw a lot of such

00:09:54

events that then happened in the

00:09:58

fall of 1917,

00:10:00

Mikhail Bonch-Bruevich becomes the first

00:10:03

general of the Russian army who went over

00:10:05

to the Bolsheviks, his brother Vladimir

00:10:08

heads the administration of the Council of

00:10:10

People's Commissars, the

00:10:12

new government even offers him, 47 years old,

00:10:15

Mikhail Boch Breivik the post of supreme

00:10:17

commander in chief,

00:10:21

he would would have been the first commander-in-chief and

00:10:24

only the first general, but he personally

00:10:25

refused in favor of Nikolai Vasiliev

00:10:27

Krivenko,

00:10:28

there were three of them, Krylenko Dybenko and

00:10:31

Antonova-Ovseenko, well, yes, the first composition of the

00:10:36

people of the People's Commissariat for the

00:10:38

Navy no, but since there was

00:10:40

a coup, since the Bolsheviks came to power,

00:10:42

but it’s understandable that this post is

00:10:45

undoubtedly a political one for the military,

00:10:48

but in general he acted wisely, and it’s even

00:10:52

another thing that accepting even these

00:10:56

responsibilities, that is, well, taking

00:10:58

responsibility for the army at the moment

00:11:01

when all that was left of it was just

00:11:04

some disorganized and units

00:11:06

leaving the army army crumbling here

00:11:09

we can drink and kill many of this

00:11:11

talk about how to say it will fall apart

00:11:13

army army which has no longer become a practice, now

00:11:16

finding itself essentially the second

00:11:20

person in the dying Russian army, it

00:11:24

means that he is participating, he is beginning to participate in the

00:11:27

creation of such a new yes, this

00:11:30

worker-peasant effect like the people

00:11:33

who surrounded him, the ranks of his brother

00:11:35

gave his hand when it all started, I

00:11:38

think that the brother was the very

00:11:40

bridge of refusal, so it was the brother who was

00:11:43

killed by the convinced, as we said, a

00:11:45

Bolshevik, what a humanist and enemy by

00:11:48

deeds, the Central Committee, well, yes, that’s what God Bruevich

00:11:53

and Lenin calls for Petrograd in order

00:11:56

to organize resistance to the

00:12:00

defense of Petrograd in general in a hawaii

00:12:03

situation this is somehow connected with the fact that the

00:12:05

brother is no doubt in the

00:12:09

Bolshevik apparatus there is an interesting

00:12:12

monograph so to speak

00:12:14

Alexander Kavtaradze these are heroes more often came out in 580 of the

00:12:17

war as a specialist in the service of the Soviet

00:12:19

Republic a little more 1000 and he

00:12:22

is the first general knew and of course are

00:12:25

n’t we probably carrying the brother

00:12:28

advised systems that the

00:12:30

generals will roll down especially the generals are the generals

00:12:32

who know how to use gunpowder and

00:12:35

most importantly the enemy remains the same February

00:12:40

1918 Germany breaks the truce with

00:12:43

Soviet Russia a

00:12:45

massive offensive begins German

00:12:48

troops occupy Minsk Pskov

00:12:50

Petrograd is under threat, the former

00:12:52

capital of the empire and the seat of the Council of People's Commissars, the Treaty of

00:12:55

Brest-Litovsk has not yet been signed, which

00:13:00

means Lenin is calling him to Petrograd and

00:13:03

they meet, how would you assess

00:13:05

the situation more? the

00:13:17

Soviet government,

00:13:19

which began to create its main

00:13:22

weapon, was brought in, ended up in place on the

00:13:24

spot absolutely, yes, I can even repent of

00:13:26

saying again, I’m saying that I

00:13:28

may have archival influence that I’m

00:13:30

trying, but in that era because well, that’s the

00:13:32

level of work if you

00:13:34

start all the time give some kind of assessments,

00:13:36

you have already turned into such a historian

00:13:39

who mentally you before the court of

00:13:41

history from such a gait, a shaky

00:13:43

phrase from

00:13:44

an archivist, he must be absolutely

00:13:47

impartial,

00:13:48

absolutely that’s what it is about that, he

00:13:51

speaks closely like any person to

00:13:52

someone you have sympathy for someone - in

00:13:54

this we carry, I think that Lenin was

00:13:56

very lucky,

00:13:57

who became this first person, namely

00:14:00

Michal Dmitrich bones Bruevich, a man

00:14:02

who was an outcast among his own people,

00:14:07

well then let’s remember how this

00:14:09

senior general in red, he solved the

00:14:14

issue with defense, that is, the army

00:14:18

decayed, it’s clear that the workers detachments

00:14:22

to resist even such already very

00:14:25

battered German troops,

00:14:27

they cannot what was the decision, the decision

00:14:33

was to stick with those who can

00:14:35

hold on, there is a very interesting

00:14:36

memory of Gurevich’s bonus with the famous

00:14:39

General Barsky when he suggested

00:14:41

he couldn’t be the only one,

00:14:43

he had to select and someone, so to

00:14:45

speak, not only he alone then switched

00:14:47

to transfer moved the majority

00:14:49

of the generals of the tsarist army just

00:14:50

transferred to the service, well, for various

00:14:52

reasons and Cypriot speaking, I don’t

00:14:55

sympathize with the Bolsheviks, so to speak,

00:14:57

they didn’t her not very not very pleasant

00:15:00

but here and homeland

00:15:01

again the Germans if the Germans take the

00:15:04

spots Petrograd on for the Bolsheviks it

00:15:06

was the cradle of the revolution for most

00:15:07

Russian people it was the city of Petra in the

00:15:10

capital of the empire

00:15:11

the capital of the cute moment usually know everything

00:15:13

as soon as it surrenders the capital of the state

00:15:16

no longer exists for this letter set about

00:15:19

HIV and Lenin we enter the key and

00:15:21

yes, with an assessment of the situation in the

00:15:25

spring of 18, it’s interesting that he

00:15:29

pays attention,

00:15:30

which means I’d better quote the time, it

00:15:33

will be more interesting, the Supreme Military Council

00:15:35

approved on March 4, 2010, he himself began

00:15:39

to have two main tasks

00:15:40

to control the field forces operating

00:15:42

on the western and southern border of the Soviet

00:15:44

Republic against the Germans, the second is

00:15:46

to develop and carry out life through

00:15:49

the filler and from the organs of the main

00:15:51

provisions of the entire military system,

00:15:52

in other words, to create this system, and

00:15:54

here is the paradox of this letter that

00:15:58

he would call today an army reform,

00:16:00

you understand, he proposes to reform an

00:16:02

army of a new type of new like, here he

00:16:06

writes a list of reforms, reforms and

00:16:08

orders that precede the

00:16:10

establishment of the position of

00:16:11

chief of staff from the General Staff, that

00:16:14

is, he already defines himself as the Messi of

00:16:15

Minsk, the job responsibilities of that very

00:16:18

army that, well, there was a decree

00:16:20

from this decree, how long has passed, see the

00:16:24

first phrase, of course she was able to

00:16:26

It sounds murderous to disband the

00:16:29

revolutionary military council;

00:16:31

relations with the party bodies have always been

00:16:33

very peculiar;

00:16:36

he always tried to push the party aside; maybe that’s

00:16:38

why the party responded in kind; it was

00:16:40

bon gu ri that moved;

00:16:41

well, this is actually the main spring that was

00:16:45

red down;

00:16:50

whom he writes and writes to Lenin, this is not

00:16:52

just some kind of conversation among his

00:16:54

circle until

00:16:56

the spring of 1918, at the suggestion and under the leadership of

00:17:01

Mikhail Bonch-Bruevich, combat

00:17:03

units were formed to resist the German army, the

00:17:06

curtain troops, when the enemy attacked, the

00:17:10

curtain troops had to retreat,

00:17:12

pinning down the enemy’s forces and destroying

00:17:15

communications

00:17:17

in the fall of the same year, the veil detachments

00:17:19

became parts of the Red Army leading the

00:17:22

civil war,

00:17:23

by this time Bonch-Bruevich was already

00:17:26

retired, he headed above and

00:17:29

geodetic management of the product that

00:17:34

he sought to do the best from his

00:17:37

point of view, he was either not understood or

00:17:40

his aspirations were read

00:17:41

because he wants to make a career, that he

00:17:43

just wants us Tibet, I haven’t found a single

00:17:46

document so that bonjour 9 wrote to someone,

00:17:48

he always circled his relationships,

00:17:52

so the conversation goes oddeleni

00:17:54

roll back unpleasant, although he has a

00:17:57

memory of the same and by whom who what what

00:17:58

tse ti si where he writes as a very rude

00:18:00

person to a person who doesn’t

00:18:02

like anything Russian because he was a father

00:18:04

like that person, in general, he loved

00:18:06

to drink and it

00:18:09

was difficult to find among among the Bolsheviks a person who loved

00:18:11

Russian that period it was it was Well,

00:18:16

look, yes, it means that despite all the

00:18:18

conflicts that existed in the

00:18:20

political and military leadership of the

00:18:24

Soviet republic, even the conflict

00:18:26

between the Russian and Stalin, between the Russian and

00:18:30

Voroshilov, that is, everything was not smooth there either,

00:18:32

but for some reason, Voroshilov

00:18:35

remained in his place and you after all from

00:18:38

remained in his place there Kamenev and so

00:18:41

on they became and our hero of the generals

00:18:45

shaving had to do

00:18:48

cartographic work, well, you know,

00:18:50

firstly it was his specialization, the

00:18:52

first were enough before he

00:18:54

began to carry over there, the determining one graduated from

00:18:56

youtube cadets at the path of the school, I think

00:18:59

that it was too image of an

00:19:02

educated person

00:19:03

looking too ahead of the site

00:19:06

[music]

00:19:17

and my

00:19:24

husband with me handwriting was false on restart

00:19:29

himself when he wrote the network in ink and

00:19:31

not a single blot, not a single blot

00:19:38

the other day, it means that the

00:19:41

resolution of the revan council was read out, releasing

00:19:44

me from the post of field chief

00:19:46

spar of the headquarters,

00:19:48

deserving deserving until the last days in

00:19:51

this position, I will

00:19:53

also finish with the study of our fronts with the fact that

00:19:56

always yes with the fact that today we see on the southern

00:19:59

and western on the eastern fronts to

00:20:01

inspect the matter on the spot by us on the spot in

00:20:05

this we relate well, here we mean that

00:20:06

what we we say that you are

00:20:08

fighting on dota there, Gusev is remembered by

00:20:11

Sergei Ivanovich,

00:20:13

well, that is, in fact, when he leaves, he at least

00:20:17

leaves a will, what needs to be done without

00:20:19

him directly premium,

00:20:21

this is basically not a

00:20:23

good thing in the army, and for the

00:20:27

benefit of the matter, I ask for your help in this

00:20:30

in fact, since he himself, from the position of

00:20:34

the chief, that the chief of staff is not able to do

00:20:38

absolutely anything,

00:20:42

this position, under modern conditions, has

00:20:45

turned into a purely clerical one; he

00:20:48

had more than 50 years;

00:20:56

gave service to the ladies, that is, he was such a

00:20:59

decorative figure, well, let’s say

00:21:02

Brusilov, but he didn’t want to be, didn’t want to be,

00:21:05

you understand that’s the point, in principle, Jed

00:21:09

was a man of science, by that time he had already

00:21:11

matured as a great scientist, the work of the wine

00:21:15

historical commission to study the experience of

00:21:17

1 empirical war that’s the attitude she

00:21:20

worked from the heart,

00:21:22

yes, he was really where he

00:21:24

knew everything, the founder of our aerial photography,

00:21:27

this is how homeless people live, I shave in unity, for all

00:21:29

this he will ask that year he receives

00:21:32

only gratitude from the left and the council for 35

00:21:36

years, not work for the benefit of military affairs, but

00:21:40

this gratitude preceded by the arrest in

00:21:44

1923,

00:21:46

Bonch-Bruevich was accused of sabotage,

00:21:48

from here the personal intervention of

00:21:50

Felix Dzerzhinsky saved him

00:21:53

in the thirty-first, Bonch-Bruevich was again

00:21:55

taken away in the case of a counter-revolutionary

00:21:57

conspiracy, but the

00:22:00

crime was not found in the thirty-

00:22:04

seventh, former general major of the Russian

00:22:06

army Mikhail Bonch-Bruevich received a new

00:22:08

Soviet rank at almost 70 years old, he is given the

00:22:13

title of Komkom Dima and sent forever

00:22:16

into the reserves by the

00:22:18

Workers 'and Peasants' Red Army, they

00:22:20

simply removed it, they say,

00:22:23

they gave the call to the division commander, although

00:22:25

as you understand, he did not command any girls in the piles

00:22:27

and quietly slept -1 this

00:22:30

can be called a reserve with the word

00:22:33

lucky or indeed again

00:22:37

use the term paradox maybe from

00:22:40

not here it seems to still be carrying in

00:22:42

parallel they safir climate in the form of

00:22:43

women until 26 years before the death of

00:22:45

Dzerzhinsky Dzerzhinsky worked

00:22:47

together and maybe there is an axis for systems what

00:22:49

authority to say with the answer levels

00:22:51

female that the NKVD would be ready, he was

00:22:54

very very tall, perhaps it was this

00:22:56

shadow that saved him somewhere, so to speak,

00:22:58

and perhaps there was the fact that all his

00:23:03

charges were later dropped against him, as in the

00:23:05

twenty-first year, the prosecutor’s office

00:23:06

dragged him from him all the accusations and about

00:23:09

31 years, I’m not even talking about when he took the

00:23:11

side of the investigation and testified against someone

00:23:13

that also carrying clouds was

00:23:15

taken into account on the good side, and then he

00:23:17

was 67 years old, he attributed there was nothing to the product

00:23:21

of another, all the white migration they write

00:23:24

everything these years of being there, so to speak,

00:23:27

for this abroad,

00:23:28

but as we said, white Russia and

00:23:30

abroad, she writes only negatively, no matter

00:23:33

how many times I saw somewhere Yana your pet, it’s

00:23:35

clear where everything is only negative, so

00:23:37

blame him for what years that he and the

00:23:38

careerists then that he

00:23:41

pretends to be nothing, it’s

00:23:43

easy to explain, of course, these

00:23:46

were two irreconcilable camps,

00:23:51

Russian life here was split, that is,

00:23:55

it was split into Russian and utopian

00:23:59

fargo ringing, of course, belonged to those who,

00:24:03

so to speak, either by conviction or simply

00:24:07

by professional affiliation,

00:24:10

he tried this utopia carried out in 1944,

00:24:17

Mikhail Bonch-Bruevich was awarded the

00:24:20

last rank of lieutenant general,

00:24:22

reserve, doctor of military and technical sciences,

00:24:26

one of the creators of the red army

00:24:28

died in 1956, a year later,

00:24:33

Bonch-Bruevich’s memoirs were published,

00:24:35

the book was called all power to the soviets,

00:24:40

well, in general, my friends, you see that

00:24:43

our history of the beginning of the twentieth century, it is

00:24:47

not tragic at all, but it is still

00:24:55

really interesting and you can think about it,

00:24:58

but that’s all for today, thank you

00:25:01

very much, thank you very much and see you again

00:25:04

in the archive where our history is stored

00:25:10

[music]

Description:

🔥 ПРЕМЬЕРА // СМОТРИМ ВСЕ СЕРИИ МЕЛОДРАМЫ «НЕСМОТРЯ НИ НА ЧТО» В HD КАЧЕСТВЕ👉 https://smotrim.ru/brand/66257 СМОТРИМ ВСЁ В HD КАЧЕСТВЕ ТУТ 👉https://smotrim.ru/cinema 🔹Подписаться на канал Культура: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCik7MxUtSXXfT-f_78cQRfQ?sub_confirmation=1 🔹Все видео:https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedoFdLYYzIM01HdxSVXnndKa Михаил Бонч-Бруевич в 1898 году окончил Николаевскую академию Генерального штаба и до 1908 года служил при штабах различных военных округов. С началом Первой мировой войны в августе 1914 года стал генерал-квартирмейстером штаба 3-й армии Юго-Западного фронта. 10 сентября 1914 года произведен в генерал-майоры. Во время нахождения на должности генерал-квартирмейстера штаба 3-й армии Юго-Западного фронта ведал разведкой и контрразведкой. В марте 1915 года Бонч-Бруевич стал начальником штаба Северо-Западного фронта. При Временном правительстве сначала занял должность начальника Псковского гарнизона, где находился штаб Северного фронта, затем некоторое время командовал Северным фронтом, и, наконец, был назначен начальником Могилёвского гарнизона. Во время Октябрьской революции М. Д. Бонч-Бруевич стал первым генералом, перешедшим на сторону большевиков. Его родной брат — Владимир Дмитриевич, большевик с 1895 года — стал управляющим делами Совнаркома. В 1919 Михаил Бонч-Бруевич возглавил Полевой штаб Реввоенсовета. В 1944-м генерал-майор Русской Армии Бонч-Бруевич получил звание генерал-лейтенанта Красной Армии. Редактор Н.Марченко. Режиссер П.Виноградов. 🔹 🔹 🔹 Другие передачи телеканала: ▫️ XX век https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedpwcru7SevkLM5V61jeSyJP ▫️ 2 Верник 2 https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedpMmSrBnBIzMCg7YpTl97MN ▫️ Агора https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedoTZjKax2Fr17xho09ugY_Q ▫️ Белая студия https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedouaL0HYtkFhzP68wfrWVJ0 ▫️ Власть факта https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedoi329KxXh7r-2xZp7h_RMw ▫️ Главная роль https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedpxXdMXXiOBrdF3OOFMk_He ▫️ Диалоги о животных https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedrxBAsgsVLP6UocdiuDiRAW ▫️ Документальные фильмы https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedoIohTkfmfVFCXxUIX_2qQk ▫️ Запечатлённое время https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedrOcVcDyE8zfSqKgpToMOeM ▫️ Игра в бисер https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedq6S9AoaC5yTG3ZHcI4cwxP ▫️ Концерты https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedqJ5zHy4FMYRFEez9ejuse6 ▫️ Легенды мирового кино https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedqPqZGs0SYwMHtMfI3DKP08 ▫️ Линия жизни https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedpYptAQS7f5RZKNpUzQ6G52 ▫️ Мы - грамотеи! https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedpJDBbaD2knwM9d3yd2QNbO ▫️ Наблюдатель https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedqZHvAD146yYV5Fj_JbHy41 ▫️ Новости культуры https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedqKHOK2FY3ODnjVEjpsFO0d ▫️ Пешком... https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedpZljXE6XIyEusIZheJDjbZ ▫️ Полиглот https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedpPPa_Vet4KhyyYHdsEE7ku ▫️ Правила жизни https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedo7TxLE4xEZws_qD_9GQzrM ▫️ Романтика романса https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedpClWHzBVX5a5DHmAj3VwTw ▫️ Россия, любовь моя! https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedqT2RceHB-h6n1SNp1X7uIc ▫️ Рэгтайм, или Разорванное время https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedrOZXHZbF1m87lMw43q4L0p ▫️ Сати. Нескучная классика https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedrNlKpNxD48yhCB_g65R-MR ▫️ Смехоностальгия https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedphHWj1sSKlFFew9-AphqTX ▫️ Спектакли https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedr5f2Ewm2u-A-dji9rDJeIv ▫️ Художественные фильмы https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedo2KZOi56SRTjBVLLBy-Sdi ▫️ Цвет времени https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedqFzngqeiQVJZaifu0rde08 ▫️ Энигма https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedoZpreN1KF3axtyleml81F_ ▫️ Энциклопедия загадок https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PL66DIGaegedpTJtjzpQ8iBzr5Y8x9f8HI

Preparing download options

Popular

HD video

Only sound

All

* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."

** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players

Questions about downloading video

How can I download "Михаил Бонч-Бруевич: дважды генерал. Дело N @SMOTRIM_KULTURA" video?

http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.

Which format of "Михаил Бонч-Бруевич: дважды генерал. Дело N @SMOTRIM_KULTURA" video should I choose?

The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.

Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Михаил Бонч-Бруевич: дважды генерал. Дело N @SMOTRIM_KULTURA" video?

The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.

How can I download "Михаил Бонч-Бруевич: дважды генерал. Дело N @SMOTRIM_KULTURA" video to my phone?

You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.

How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Михаил Бонч-Бруевич: дважды генерал. Дело N @SMOTRIM_KULTURA"?

The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.

How can I save a frame from a video "Михаил Бонч-Бруевич: дважды генерал. Дело N @SMOTRIM_KULTURA"?

This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.

What's the price of all this stuff?

It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.