Download "Потоп в Орске и Оренбурге. Дело Олега Орлова*. Венедиктов*, Колесников*, Аникина и Журавлёва"
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FTSmgpwRnSGE%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
Table of contents
Similar videos from our catalog
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F7RiHqMGzgu0%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F9Fsa7Gyp7lE%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FG0DRXvAiwlA%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FILAD6SNXVhY%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FqTOXhUV4fe0%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FwgC3_0g520M%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FxAliAjVVrNM%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
Video tags
Subtitles
Russian
00:00:47
Good morning everyone00:00:49
855 minutes in Moscow This is the program00:00:51
morning spread on YouTube channel00:00:53
living nail Olga Zhuravleva or Anikina00:00:56
Hello everyone, how are you doing?00:00:58
Let's tell you, yours has passed00:01:01
week What mood are you in? How are you00:01:03
get ready for the coming weekend00:01:05
are you having this very weekend because00:01:06
we won’t be given examples Well, or rather Olya00:01:09
there will still be one day off yes yes00:01:11
I will be possible on Sunday00:01:13
I have two more wonderful days ahead of me00:01:15
with morning turns I hope that we00:01:17
Let's all enjoy them to the fullest. What do we have?00:01:19
today in the program Today in our00:01:21
program, firstly we will talk about00:01:23
situation in the Orenburg region to us00:01:25
ecologist Sergei Simok will join00:01:27
Chairman of the Russian Green Board00:01:29
League candidate of biological sciences and he00:01:31
will talk about the flooding in Orsk and00:01:33
Orenburg will explain what this will have00:01:36
consequences And in general how they work00:01:38
similar tragedies And then we have00:01:40
material of the week from the new newspaper We are with00:01:41
Let's talk about Andrey Kolesnikov00:01:44
material and not only its material in00:01:45
magazine hump, that's how beautiful he is00:01:47
we already enjoyed the new one today yes00:01:50
Before the broadcast, they honored the real live00:01:52
paper magazine and there really00:01:54
many many topics that can be discussed00:01:57
with Andrey Kolesnikov in addition to chapters from00:01:59
his books that are published there are00:02:03
many more interesting twists00:02:06
concerning history and today00:02:08
I'll say this And today we'll talk with00:02:11
Alexandra Baeva about refusal00:02:14
human rights activist Oleg Orlov in his00:02:17
request to personally participate in the trial00:02:19
Oleg Orlov's meeting worsened00:02:22
his health condition, his hearing has deteriorated00:02:24
because of this it is difficult for him to remotely00:02:25
participate in court hearings because00:02:28
that the video connection is because it’s bad00:02:30
sound quality nevertheless despite00:02:32
his request to be personally present at00:02:34
court hearings, the court refused him00:02:37
lawyer Alexandra Baeva and I are talking about this00:02:39
OVD info let's talk about today's topic00:02:42
- the State Duma approved this in the third reading00:02:44
the bill on legal profession is a series00:02:48
restrictions for lawyers this may00:02:50
negatively affect the general legal00:02:52
situation in Russia which is already in00:02:54
generally deplorable but you can do even more00:02:57
bad impact not so much on lawyers00:02:58
how much on their protective ones right away00:03:01
this will directly affect00:03:05
for all people who in one way or another00:03:06
may be faced with the need to have00:03:09
lawyer Yes, with Dmitry we are talking about capture00:03:11
Let's talk about this Well, at 11 o'clock00:03:13
usually with us Alexey Venediktov nothing00:03:15
our new schedule is stable with00:03:18
11:00 to 12:00 He’s on our air I think00:03:21
that everyone is waiting for him to come here the most00:03:24
we will discuss important topics of the week. Well00:03:26
Let's talk about his interview with00:03:27
former Israeli minister who00:03:30
came out yesterday Thursday evening on00:03:33
YouTube channel living nail Well, in general00:03:36
details A And thanks and details we00:03:39
Today we’ll discuss more. Well, what do we have here?00:03:43
here we already have greetings from everywhere00:03:47
probably soon soon soon it will be necessary already00:03:51
uh we have news in Rivne Yes we have news00:03:54
exactly at zero So we have 2 more minutes00:03:56
there will be greetings from Dortmund00:03:59
to Greetings from Balashikha from Shchukin00:04:03
from the Moscow region Orekhova Zueva Morning00:04:06
Andrey from00:04:08
Orekhova Zueva and Mikhail Bashkirtsev writes00:04:11
Everything goes according to plan sadomy debauchery00:04:13
rodents floods arson explosions from 1200:04:15
April you Hello By the way yes day00:04:18
Cosmonautics is also a World Holiday00:04:22
It's under different names at someone's place00:04:25
It's science day, someone's day00:04:29
that's exactly what it's called00:04:32
This is our day for space explorers00:04:34
astronautics naturally on the territory00:04:37
former Soviet Union Closer closer to00:04:39
the cosmonautics holiday, by the way00:04:41
also refers us a little to the magazine00:04:43
gorby when the central publication is there00:04:46
concerns just disintegration or attempts not00:04:50
allow the collapse of the Soviet Union00:04:52
the consequences of this collapse, including00:04:54
on holidays it appears if Belarus00:04:57
Kazakhstan and Russia are celebrating something00:04:59
something similar00:05:02
then in Ukraine already with some nuances A00:05:06
in there00:05:07
let's say Asian Republics in some00:05:10
cases coincide And in some cases00:05:12
diverge from Armenia there or Georgia00:05:14
I suggest some of my own holidays00:05:16
release a geopolitical study00:05:19
situations based on holidays Yes yes yes00:05:22
public holidays like how like00:05:26
a sign of belonging to the Soviet00:05:29
the former Soviet Union is very00:05:31
interestingly someone writes to us from the world of Jean00:05:33
Good morning from Orsk If you are really from00:05:35
Orska Please write how you are doing00:05:37
And what's going on with you? We're leaving now.00:05:40
for the news and then we'll come back00:05:41
let's begin our discussion of the main00:05:44
and, of course, to communicate with guests. And I00:05:47
as the author of the program take a day00:05:49
endless Well, you are also the author, come on, day00:05:51
but I continue this is our hopeless00:05:53
I fully support the event00:05:55
Sophie's comment from the Russian invasion00:05:58
to Ukraine began exactly 10 years ago 1200:06:00
April fourteenth separatists00:06:02
DPR in quotes, that is, pro-Russian00:06:06
forces captured Slavyansk Yes indeed00:06:09
When did I do this selection?00:06:13
a day for these days Yes, the capture of the Slavs00:06:16
times the fourteenth year We by the way We00:06:17
By the way, we talked about this yesterday with00:06:19
Alexander Stefanov in a dissenting opinion00:06:20
you might be interested in listening00:06:22
about how propagandists are now shifting00:06:25
the date of the beginning of this conflict Oh well00:06:27
first the news and then everything else00:06:37
so not yet, not everything we have yet00:06:40
prepared00:06:42
[music]00:06:45
Hurray 900 in the morning in Moscow at the microphone Lisa00:06:48
Anikina is news about a live nail00:06:50
the main thing by this time last night00:06:52
air defense system destroyed a drone in00:06:54
Rostov region and one in Belgorod region00:06:57
salt00:06:58
Ministry of Defense several groups of Shaheeds00:07:00
the goal was Energy infrastructure00:07:02
Vladimir Putin previously stated that Russia00:07:05
forced to respond to attacks by the armed forces00:07:07
Russian energy facility FSB reports about00:07:10
preventing a terrorist attack in Moscow00:07:12
synagogue, according to intelligence services, explosion00:07:14
planned by a native of one of the countries00:07:16
Central Asia he resisted00:07:18
during the arrest and was killed they convey the00:07:20
news FSB distributed video from00:07:23
apartments of the alleged terrorist00:07:24
only a knife is visible next to the body00:07:26
improvised explosive device Judging by00:07:28
cameras were stored under00:07:30
detained with a mattress in the Tver region00:07:33
suspect in the murder of a police officer00:07:35
The Moscow region is the thirties Vasily00:07:37
Buryak according to the Investigative Committee He gave00:07:39
confessions from security forces00:07:41
they claim that Buryakov’s house is up to no good00:07:43
found weapons, ammunition and drugs00:07:45
substances from the Tver region00:07:47
the suspect was taken to Moscow for00:07:50
helicopter water level in the Ural River00:07:53
Orenburg exceeded 11 m near the administration00:07:56
cities warned that there is a risk00:07:57
flooding of energy facilities and in some00:08:00
areas possible short-term00:08:01
power outage peak flood expected00:08:04
out of the danger zone this afternoon00:08:05
more than 10,000 evacuated00:08:09
people in Kazakhstan, a law on00:08:12
criminalization of domestic violence still00:08:14
por for Assault and Intentional00:08:16
causing minor harm to health00:08:18
provided only00:08:19
administrative punishment is now00:08:21
will become a criminal offense00:08:24
the document must be signed by the president00:08:26
Kasym Zhumar Takaev00:08:29
and 100 Russian military arrived in Niger00:08:32
they delivered instructors to the military00:08:34
equipment for the air defense system of the latter00:08:36
generation of equipment purchased from Russia00:08:39
reported local government00:08:40
Artin TV channel previously transitional00:08:43
the nigerian government refused two00:08:45
defense agreements with the European Union and00:08:47
broke the military agreement00:08:50
USA in the Kansky competition program00:08:53
film festival included Kirill's film00:08:55
Serebrennikov Lemons ballad main00:08:57
hero writers politician lemons him00:09:00
played by British actor Ben Whishaw in00:09:03
The world premiere of the film will take place00:09:05
The film festival will be held from May 14 to May 25.00:09:09
there was news on a live nail and we00:09:12
let's continue00:09:13
[music]00:09:16
spread So Olga Zhuravleva Lisa00:09:19
Anikina Youtube channel living nail00:09:21
morning spread I hope everything is already00:09:24
Woke up and everyone already cheer up with us00:09:25
There are a lot of topics today, I think it’s possible already00:09:27
let's start with the first one we want to talk about00:09:29
what is happening in Orenburgskaya00:09:31
areas what will be the consequences00:09:33
what's happening? Yes, but what? And what do we already have00:09:36
they write that the water is running out, but we can’t get through00:09:38
home yet not just I think that00:09:40
this is a report from the field. But they write something else00:09:43
actually the peak is expected today at00:09:45
anyway in my news today00:09:47
was written but let's look at it in more detail00:09:49
Sergey Tima joins us00:09:51
Chairman of the Russian Green Board00:09:53
League Candidate of Biological Sciences Dobroe00:09:56
morning and we can't hear you00:09:59
so once again I was afraid of just everything00:10:03
I can hear yes Everything is fine And Sergey if00:10:07
okay Let's start over because00:10:12
people who don't worry regularly00:10:15
these are the floods in principle00:10:17
guess what When is spring What00:10:20
called friendly A00:10:23
when it gets warm very quickly00:10:26
naturally the water rises in the rivers Well00:10:28
This is how forecasts work in principle00:10:32
were probably yes, that is, in principle00:10:34
these too should have expected the flood00:10:37
regions naturally should also00:10:40
expect this to happen this year00:10:43
which came as a surprise to everyone.00:10:46
whether00:10:47
say Well, it’s a tradition with us and it’s winter00:10:50
it always comes unexpectedly yes00:10:53
the flood comes unexpectedly therefore00:10:55
nothing new here, everything is perfect00:10:57
normal and familiar00:10:59
The question is why does this happen and how often?00:11:03
and will this happen further Yes I00:11:06
I think this is the most interesting question00:11:09
of course there are two parts00:11:11
the answer is the first part in which I cannot00:11:14
boast big00:11:16
competence how the dam was built Were00:11:19
Are there any violations? How much was stolen there? Well00:11:21
actually I have this topic00:11:24
the information is the same as everyone else's so I00:11:27
I prefer not to talk about this topic but00:11:30
listen to those who are more competent00:11:33
I can talk about00:11:34
friend00:11:36
Why is the load on dams increasing?00:11:40
to river beds. The fact is that this00:11:43
directly related to change00:11:46
Klima that now I’m already on mine00:11:50
memory about 20 years old, probably Russian00:11:58
ST says doubts about climate change00:12:00
they say it's the sun00:12:02
normal cycles that were supposedly00:12:05
always generally relax and receive00:12:07
pleasure really is00:12:09
Not at all like climate change00:12:12
modern climate change is completely00:12:15
man-made with absolute00:12:19
irresponsibility of humanity as a whole00:12:21
Well, over the past ten years, zero00:12:26
2030 This is especially related00:12:29
irresponsibility of some of the most00:12:32
interesting representatives of this00:12:34
humanity well represented by states00:12:37
some primarily those who00:12:39
live off the sale of hydrocarbons00:12:41
oil and gas, which themselves are not particularly00:12:45
do something to mitigate the change00:12:48
climate and others interfere with block00:12:52
joint00:12:54
SDO actions00:12:59
it cannot be00:13:01
to some extent slow down so that's what00:13:04
his00:13:06
the consequences of the consequences actually00:13:08
there’s a lot I won’t list everything00:13:10
only what has to do with floods00:13:13
and floods in00:13:15
Russia The fact is that one of the consequences00:13:18
overall climate change overall00:13:20
warming is increasing00:13:23
intensification of the polar mystery00:13:26
ice climate of Europe00:13:29
almost 90% is not determined00:13:33
just geographical location00:13:36
Western transfer so-called00:13:39
Atlantic cyclones which00:13:41
west to east bring moisture and00:13:44
moderate soft00:13:48
they bring this moisture both in the form of snow and00:13:52
like rain00:13:59
this is a slow current that goes from the south to00:14:01
north along the coast of Western Europe and00:14:06
This is a stove that heats everything00:14:08
Europe up to the Urals and including the basin00:14:11
The Ural River also heats and supplies00:14:14
moisture so00:14:16
here is a warm current Warm water flows along00:14:20
surface cold water should00:14:22
actually go down and down under00:14:25
The Gulf Stream is actually cold00:14:27
countercurrent cat00:14:31
there is one such physical feature00:14:33
fresh water has a lower density than00:14:37
therefore the cold water that is formed00:14:40
as a result of the polar ice mystery00:14:42
desalinated and it does not sink down but00:14:45
goes along the surface of the Gulf Stream00:14:48
Gostream is weakening as a result of00:14:51
some00:14:58
percentage of cyclones that generate00:15:00
Gulf Stream00:15:01
weakened and our climate is determined here00:15:04
such a confrontation between00:15:06
cyclones that come from the West with00:15:09
Atlantic and anticyclones which00:15:11
are formed in the center of the continent That's who00:15:13
who is where the border will be established there00:15:16
where the border spills out or pours out00:15:19
precipitation there is heavy, snowfall is heavy00:15:21
there is also enough rain where the west is00:15:25
a lot of precipitation and most of the precipitation is later00:15:29
they arrive and this is exactly what happens over00:15:32
European territory of Russia and how00:15:34
the further east it becomes more and more pronounced00:15:37
That is, it turns out that this one is00:15:39
the unusually snowy winter we00:15:40
seen this year This is a consequence00:15:42
global warming If00:15:44
simplify, yes, but the mechanisms here are a little bit00:15:47
others Now I’ll explain it like this probably00:15:49
everyone paid attention00:15:52
that approximately during the last00:15:54
15-2 years, frosts begin and00:15:58
then the snow falls, those who00:16:01
older people remember that well, back in00:16:03
the eighties and nineties were well00:16:05
it's about the same time and that's why00:16:07
The ground did not have time to freeze now00:16:10
At first the Earth freezes and then00:16:13
frozen ground lies down00:16:15
snow Why and because cyclones don't00:16:18
can reach the anticyclone carries cold00:16:21
frosty weather at the beginning already in November00:16:23
December Frost and only then on on00:16:25
the ground is frozen and snow falls in the spring00:16:28
begins00:16:30
water cannot be absorbed into the soil because00:16:33
she she can't keep up and she00:16:36
quickly rolls into00:16:39
reservoir into river beds as a result00:16:43
a stormy flood occurs once and00:16:45
soil drought two because the soil is not00:16:48
saturates with water and against the backdrop of the fact that everything00:16:51
more and more extreme heat00:16:54
gradually nonlinear process and BC more often00:16:57
and more often00:16:59
extreme heat in summer00:17:02
sharply worsens living conditions and00:17:03
agriculture this process is only00:17:05
it starts to get much worse, but00:17:07
this is such a small digression so here it is00:17:09
this is one factor that the water is fast and friendly00:17:12
reservoirs roll down Well, of course it00:17:14
there's a lot at once the second one00:17:16
factor is also very significant and also00:17:20
noticeable to those who are a little older and could00:17:23
watch what's happening during the course of00:17:25
years old00:17:27
30 We're Almost Reversing Climate Change00:17:30
lost such a season of the year as spring if00:17:34
30-40 years ago and before, spring occupied00:17:37
we have about a month and a half, that is00:17:39
snowmelt began in March and00:17:42
ended in early May back in May00:17:43
Somewhere the snowdrifts lay there for a month and a half00:17:46
gradually the water melted melted melted00:17:48
absorb into the soil as a result and in the soil00:17:50
there were groundwaters that fed later00:17:53
the river Oz gradually and finally00:17:57
therefore it was extended for a month and a half00:18:00
It's spring now, it's cold, it's cold here00:18:03
cold cold cold Then once again00:18:05
Summer is coming in just a week or two00:18:09
Yes, I just felt this today when I00:18:12
I don’t remember the beginning of April like this00:18:15
Well, it's all already summer summer clothes00:18:17
years earlier By the way, yes this is also very00:18:20
characteristic thing by displacement displacement00:18:22
season occurred for about a month in00:18:26
the eighties when I was00:18:27
student was the commander of the security squad00:18:29
nature university and every year I00:18:32
organized expeditions to the border on00:18:35
junction of Samara Orenburg Saratov00:18:37
and Ural regions00:18:39
Kazakhstan, well, they conducted research there00:18:42
and we designed natural monuments00:18:44
always went for 5 years in a row and we00:18:47
left at the very end of May00:18:49
usually on Friday for May00:18:51
holidays get in not to break away especially from00:18:54
do not miss many days of school and00:18:55
returned May 10-111 always at the same time00:18:58
same time strictly like this every year00:19:02
when we left the trees were still bare00:19:04
when we returned on May 10 they were in00:19:07
light haze Yeah now Pay attention00:19:09
attention the same thing happens for a month00:19:11
before, well, in Moscow, at least already00:19:14
not just a slight haze, but directly visible00:19:16
primrose leaves are already just everywhere there00:19:18
bumblebees everything that should be Month Month00:19:21
everything shifted for at least a month and00:19:23
shrunk from a month and a half to a week or two00:19:26
Yeah, of course the snowmelt is stormy00:19:29
friendly water cannot be absorbed00:19:32
of course this leads to stormy00:19:34
floods and then the water quickly00:19:35
rolls down in the summer when strong00:19:39
heat water shortage drought and the soil is dry00:19:44
These are the consequences of climate change00:19:45
which only00:19:47
this process will begin00:19:50
further at least 100-150 years Sergei is here in00:19:54
in the chat, many write from conspiracy theorists on the air00:19:56
come where is the proof that this is00:19:58
man-made processes00:20:02
and the proof that this00:20:04
this is a man-made process for a minute00:20:08
numerous models and climatic00:20:12
which are built by specialists and not00:20:15
those comrades who write on air00:20:18
about conspiracy theorists, unlike those00:20:21
by the way, conspiracy theorists who are usually those00:20:23
the same people love it when they talk about00:20:25
vaccination there vaccinations everything else00:20:27
that's where these people usually love00:20:29
conspiracy theorists And when they are told about00:20:32
scientifically based models that00:20:36
have a consensus of experts in everything00:20:39
world they begin to talk about00:20:41
conspiracy theorists are a very curious phenomenon00:20:43
By the way, here's the evidence00:20:47
simple ones I could show now and00:20:50
graphics and what00:20:53
happens how high the correlation is00:20:55
between changes in carbon dioxide content00:20:58
gas in the atmosphere and average00:21:00
temperatures and this happens00:21:02
this mechanism always works like this00:21:05
clocks throughout Earth's history00:21:08
the higher the carbon dioxide concentration00:21:10
one of the greenhouse gases the higher00:21:13
temperature on the planet00:21:15
always now starting from00:21:19
eighties from sixties00:21:21
years of the 10th century when industrialization began00:21:24
the revolution has begun quite a bit00:21:26
rapid increase in greenhouse gas emissions00:21:29
carbon dioxide from combustion00:21:31
organic fuel and00:21:34
the correlation is clear Well, simple00:21:36
it's fantastic how noticeable it is00:21:38
This has especially happened over the last 20000:21:41
years and especially over the last 50 years in all00:21:44
years when it was found out it became00:21:46
absolutely clearly obviously clearly00:21:50
noticeably00:21:52
Why was this not noticeable at first?00:21:55
so much because the biosphere has00:21:57
mechanism00:22:00
compen initially more carbon dioxide00:22:03
more ocean vegetation00:22:05
sucks in00:22:07
learns but at some point the mechanisms00:22:10
broken they are no longer able to assimilate00:22:13
this amount of acid gas and heat00:22:16
absorbs the heat of the world very well00:22:19
the ocean but now it's too much00:22:24
knowledge of the temperature of the world ocean00:22:29
phytoplankton absorption capacity00:22:32
carbon dioxide increases temperature00:22:35
therefore these mechanisms are gradually00:22:38
gradually gradually break into00:22:40
as a result of the same process nature00:22:42
struggling but she can't cope00:22:44
progressive increase in concentration00:22:48
carbon dioxide plus K carbon dioxide00:22:50
methane is also added, this is already00:22:53
process00:22:54
Follow the Domino principle when00:22:56
temperature rise00:22:58
on the planet due to carbon dioxide emissions00:23:00
gases begin to melt permafrost and00:23:03
permafrost - What is it?00:23:05
a frozen swamp is essentially where there is water00:23:08
about half water half organics00:23:10
plus or minus I'm sorry Russia00:23:13
Russia is the same country that has00:23:16
permafrost has a lot of things 68%00:23:21
Russian territory is permafrost00:23:25
68% more than any other country in the world00:23:27
and so00:23:28
Ghanaian area from Tai permafrost begins00:23:33
so-called swamp gas is released00:23:36
When organic matter is under anaerobic conditions without00:23:38
oxygen in the swamp it decomposes00:23:41
turns not into carbon dioxide but into00:23:44
methane main main component00:23:48
Swamp gas is methane so methane00:23:51
has00:23:52
ability e00:23:55
what about00:23:57
conditions, that is, further the process becomes00:24:00
automatic but started it00:24:02
human activity launched it00:24:06
it was triggered by carbon dioxide emissions00:24:08
when burning organic fuel A00:24:11
you can do something about it here00:24:13
people started and stop stop00:24:15
It's impossible. It's impossible already.00:24:18
no need to relax it's not worth it00:24:21
the process is now possible00:24:24
slow down, but Greta Thunberg tells us00:24:27
I said this and laughed00:24:30
by the way, she’s talking about exactly this and00:24:32
said of course And by the way, experts00:24:35
confirmed that she didn’t lie about anything00:24:40
Of course we don't have anything good right now00:24:42
option We have an option between bad00:24:45
choice between bad and very bad between00:24:47
rapid and severe climate change and00:24:51
softer And against the background of this it is necessary00:24:54
talk about00:24:55
adaptation is the same00:24:59
in principle ROSI has accepted in principle to think about00:25:02
future even 5 years VD Not to mention00:25:06
already perspective 10050 adaptation00:25:09
agriculture adaptation ladies00:25:12
adaptation of housing and communal services00:25:15
Why think? Let the children figure it out.00:25:17
This is unfortunately the Russian approach00:25:27
and at least slow down climate change00:25:30
minimize the continuation of the emission00:25:33
greenhouse gas and secondly necessary00:25:36
think about how to adapt the farm00:25:38
adapt life to what's happening00:25:41
What will be the consequences of the current ones?00:25:44
floods in the current floods as in00:25:47
it's called us if it's possible00:25:48
Let's have us here just us yes00:25:51
I’m just correcting us here, don’t confuse us00:25:53
flood with flood what's happening00:25:56
flood is something that happens every time00:25:57
the year is correct and the flood is00:26:01
something less Both happens00:26:04
every year is catastrophic00:26:07
there is a flood, there is a normal flood here00:26:10
now we are talking about catastrophic00:26:13
flood flood it's essentially two00:26:18
terms that mean approximately one thing00:26:20
and the same phenomenon slightly different00:26:22
sides flood is the flood of rivers in00:26:26
as a result of a large00:26:28
the amount of meltwater flood is00:26:31
economic problem associated with this00:26:35
Uh-huh So these are the ones like this00:26:37
what catastrophic events will happen?00:26:39
environmental consequences That's what00:26:42
we are now seeing here about cattle and00:26:44
burial grounds told about flooded00:26:47
cemeteries are besides the fact that00:26:49
apparently there are people on boats trying00:26:51
somehow00:26:53
save yourself everything that happens changes00:26:56
the ecosystem as a whole, what now00:26:59
told00:27:00
changes the dried soil Of course changes in00:27:03
in principle the essence of the landscape is00:27:06
ecosystems advancing deserts semi-deserts00:27:09
natural zones are shifting north in those00:27:12
places where00:27:13
is happening00:27:15
floods especially when it floods00:27:17
large areas are fundamental00:27:20
the ecosystem doesn't change because00:27:22
great dress vivre becoming00:27:29
you're sick They can't stand it anymore00:27:32
Of course, a huge number die00:27:34
animals especially terrestrial00:27:37
birds rodents those animals that live00:27:41
in the floodplain and those who have not yet woken up00:27:43
can leave quickly the big ones just leave00:27:45
coming back is not a big problem00:27:48
but the ecosystem as a whole is changing00:27:50
earth ecosystem00:27:57
the desert changes there or00:27:59
semi-desert where there was a steppe00:28:01
becomes the dry steppe comes therefore00:28:05
natural areas are shifting greatly00:28:07
moving north very quickly00:28:09
quickly and borders secondly as a result00:28:12
of this, a large number of people are penetrating to the north00:28:14
number of animal and plant species00:28:17
more southern and including pathogens00:28:20
diseases are very active now00:28:23
the last 15-20 years to the north00:28:25
Western fever, for example, penetrates00:28:27
Nila00:28:29
the sun penetrates further and further to the north00:28:31
malaria mosquito and where puddles remain00:28:37
warm places are ideal00:28:39
after the flood when they flood00:28:41
large areas then the water goes into00:28:43
puddles remain in the depressions, they don’t last long00:28:46
they dry out00:28:47
But in order for the mosquito to mosquito larvae00:28:50
fight and turn into a cop00:28:59
behind00:29:01
it appears more00:29:03
mosquitoes there are conditions for00:29:06
a more southern mosquito of the genus Anolis appeared00:29:10
which is a carrier00:29:12
malarial plasma, for example, huge00:29:15
number of other animals animals00:29:18
pathogens advance on00:29:20
north00:29:33
then in South Central Asia at the expense00:29:38
In practice, water supply is provided00:29:41
large rivers that originate in00:29:43
mountain range himalayan soul ingan00:29:47
bakhmara are all the rivers that flow from00:29:49
glaciers glaciers are also fast00:29:57
disappearing provide water to the region where00:29:59
life is sweet00:30:02
man milda man and for a moment this00:30:06
three nuclear powers India Pakistan and00:30:09
China and when there are hundreds of billions of people there00:30:12
at least millions of people it turns out00:30:14
troubles to existence arise Of course00:30:16
tension socially00:30:18
political threads appear00:30:20
climate refugees who are in00:30:34
for at00:30:37
Assad00:30:39
which the Turks first built on the ef00:30:42
platinums which have reduced access00:30:44
water, why did they build it because there is no00:30:47
enough because the climate00:30:50
changes to00:30:58
for irrigation of large areas received00:31:02
several harvests and then it passed00:31:04
soil salinization and they have lost enormous00:31:06
amount of farmland peasants00:31:09
the ruined fellahs went to the cities00:31:11
the cities were filled with millions00:31:14
disadvantaged Of course social00:31:16
the tension resulted in us00:31:17
now we see in Syria and what happened00:31:20
in Syria, the war has given millions of migrants to00:31:23
Turkey Europe tensions in Europe00:31:25
terrorist attacks and the same thing is happening all over00:31:28
to the world and I repeat once again this is just the beginning00:31:31
it happens that armed conflicts00:31:33
e arise due to environmental factors including00:31:36
number of changes and natural changes But00:31:40
on the other hand, armed conflicts00:31:42
also affect the environment because00:31:45
because here's the Kakhovskaya hydroelectric power station for you00:31:48
much more and again it only gets worse00:31:53
we make no way out of the absolute smooth00:31:56
We're approaching the apocalypse00:31:59
nom00:32:01
etzi fighting missile launch00:32:05
daily is actually gigantic00:32:09
risk is not enough00:32:15
Chernobyl what00:32:26
we had a candidate of biological sciences00:32:29
on air Thank you for joining us00:32:31
so early in the morning00:32:32
Thank you have a nice day Well let's continue00:32:35
our spread please like and subscribe00:32:38
By the way, there are many many specialists here too00:32:40
connects a variety of things you need00:32:42
clean river beds need to be done what needs to be done00:32:45
would have done something else, it was built incorrectly00:32:48
the dam was repaired incorrectly00:32:51
something else It's great if someone00:32:53
specialist engineer00:32:55
hydrogeologist or something else00:32:58
a specialist dealing with these very things00:33:00
hydraulic engineering00:33:01
structures then let you write00:33:04
detailed work on this topic Explain00:33:07
Who was wrong because here's one00:33:10
in a short phrase somehow no one has me yet00:33:12
not convinced Let's ban the cultivation00:33:14
cows is easier than minimizing damage00:33:16
from large corporations by the way00:33:18
do you remember how Or do you not remember00:33:20
she was small00:33:22
what about methane was scary00:33:26
scary world shoo that's a cow00:33:28
they forge methane and this changes the climate00:33:31
they sinned on cows, but in general, of course00:33:34
the cow is to blame, this is undeniable, and the mice00:33:37
mice about gnawing Yes Koro destroys our00:33:40
ecology everything is all logical00:33:43
us meanwhile How00:33:46
say it's not raining outside00:33:49
on the contrary, the sun is shining and we are going00:33:52
concert Yes, believe me, it’s shining outside00:33:55
the sun is there, the birds are singing00:33:58
I'm sorry, you're just here so soon00:34:00
and you won’t understand Yes, we can already by the next one00:34:01
go to our topic but first with us00:34:03
there must be a die yes yes please and00:34:05
please give me a magazine and I will00:34:56
Victor Eroshenko00:34:58
Yeah, we're already on the air Andrey Kolesnikov00:35:01
Expert of the Carnegie Foundation and Tubers magazine00:35:03
The New Times Good morning Good morning00:35:07
And we want to talk to you about the new number00:35:12
magazine of new thinking hump ours00:35:16
the audience knows very well you have already seen00:35:18
We probably even showed the cover00:35:20
fully, but now I’m showing it already00:35:22
like like a real magazine and Andrey00:35:25
Kolesnikov is also one of00:35:28
permanent00:35:29
authors So here he is too00:35:31
present but so00:35:34
there's not much to say here00:35:36
publication of how many fragments of the book00:35:39
Andrey recently recently released recently00:35:43
written like this you can say yes00:35:45
Correctly written and00:35:48
above are fresh In general, fresh books00:35:52
But besides this there are many more topics00:35:55
which it seems to me is possible with Andrey00:35:59
it would be nice to discuss when I saw it00:36:01
magazine I saw that there are a lot of them here00:36:03
those who Well, how can I say they00:36:07
very much this is what we all talk about regularly00:36:10
we think that's why there is, for example00:36:12
wonderful publication by Lev Gudkov00:36:15
Lent and traditional values00:36:18
sociological view of Orthodoxy00:36:20
this is incredibly interesting Listen, come on00:36:22
nm from the article which in general00:36:25
does not concern00:36:28
from Sai book I would like about the book00:36:30
can you talk about this World Cup?00:36:33
book and for whom00:36:35
she is a book published by Elena00:36:39
get into the fur coat00:36:41
Fri selected places from home00:36:45
libraries She tells unconditionally00:36:47
about the feelings of today about how00:36:52
homemade00:36:53
library zat00:36:58
[music]00:36:59
Not because this because this is some00:37:02
accumulated like a family00:37:04
internal protective power and00:37:06
intellectual and cultural strength00:37:10
which allows you to cope with00:37:12
horror, the permanent horror in which we00:37:15
we are00:37:17
now this is something to say00:37:20
intersection00:37:22
history of Nigo SSA is something00:37:28
continuation of one of these books by the way00:37:29
Elena also went out with Shubina a few times00:37:31
years ago the intersection of these, as it were,00:37:35
family stories00:37:36
with exactly this analysis of our00:37:40
cultural baggage first of all00:37:42
literary and cinematic00:37:45
And now is just the time when it’s worth00:37:49
pay attention to our00:37:52
roots on our culture which is on my00:37:55
look completely unfairly blaming00:37:56
in what led to what it led to00:37:58
this is not She brought there are more specific00:38:01
characters who are themselves00:38:04
cancel this culture Well, so to speak and00:38:08
either this way or this way they transform it so that it doesn’t00:38:11
find out let's say it's used as00:38:14
alive about protection Sorry, I wanted to00:38:17
I wanted to clarify a little you are talking about00:38:20
what it is00:38:22
this has some kind of protective function00:38:25
family library and family history00:38:28
And00:38:30
Russian literature first00:38:32
queue but on the other hand even those00:38:36
books mentioned in these00:38:38
fragments published in the magazine00:38:41
all these humpbacks seem to be old family ones00:38:46
the books are terribly relevant00:38:48
And here you can’t really escape from00:38:51
everyday life because at every point00:38:55
can you find a parallel00:38:57
dm and this also protects This suggests that00:39:01
that this too can be experienced Or it can00:39:04
disturb and even00:39:06
frighten and so and so on the one hand as00:39:10
It is said in Ecclesiastes that everything has already happened and not00:39:13
nothing new On the other hand, after all00:39:17
today's situation is unprecedented00:39:20
as much as one movement can00:39:23
bring down a giant variety00:39:28
the history of the country is not only the last 3000:39:30
years but I don’t know the achievement there00:39:32
Gorbachev's time of the same00:39:34
because the magazine is like00:39:35
Gorbachev's achievement of those people who00:39:39
in general they tried to do something before00:39:41
Gorbachev is surprisingly anti-risk00:39:47
[music]00:39:53
[music]00:39:57
about military culture Yes, that's it00:39:59
must establish Russian messianism00:40:01
which returns to the most primitive00:40:04
ideas of Russian Russian nationalism00:40:07
imperialism is an incredible simplification00:40:09
happened in this too00:40:11
meaning the question is overcoming this00:40:14
just due to that layer of culture00:40:17
layer of culture that has been accumulated But this00:40:20
It won't be easy, I'll ask anyway00:40:23
this00:40:26
why politicians let's call it so delicately00:40:31
will go away but not00:40:33
less rehabilitation of this culture00:40:36
perhaps there is one of the fragments there by the way00:40:38
which is published it is dedicated to letters00:40:41
Thomas Man00:40:42
Yeah, which discusses exactly those problems00:40:45
within which we find ourselves today and about00:40:47
of whom we are passionately arguing about our00:40:49
collective responsibility for00:40:50
what is happening collectively00:40:51
responsibility of the intellectual class for00:40:54
what's happening is that these veves00:40:58
Germany can overcome them00:41:01
I overcame it, but it was very difficult00:41:05
the process according to the letters of Thomas Man is00:41:08
you can see but really the parallels are simple00:41:11
fantastically accurate right down to the words00:41:15
which we ourselves use in our00:41:17
discussion we are not the first here we are not here00:41:20
unique to00:41:21
unfortunately00:41:24
this is a consolation00:41:27
Well, people passed by and that’s by the way00:41:31
one topic that is relevant to many00:41:34
maybe spectators and even00:41:37
listeners to our conversation00:41:41
this is a home library topic like00:41:44
lost paradise for those who left and did not00:41:49
I could take this library with me00:41:52
By the way, it was also relevant at the beginning of the 20th century00:41:55
centuries and God knows when else ah-ah but now00:41:58
the generation for which has still left00:42:02
the home library had something like this00:42:04
meaning Do you think this could be00:42:07
the last people who value paper00:42:10
home00:42:12
there could be more library like this00:42:14
there won't be a problem, it depends00:42:17
internal family culture from traditions00:42:21
they are not the real ones they talk about00:42:23
our our leaders uh00:42:26
[music]00:42:27
yes Definitely now00:42:31
[music]00:42:42
[music]00:42:45
paperless that's the nerve at the end00:42:49
after all, paper books are important for00:42:51
generations that are still more or less00:42:54
generations that are more or less00:42:56
able00:42:57
even if they are 708 years old 60 years old 50 years old 4000:43:01
years, these people are generally still in the field00:43:04
they are doing something else they are suffering00:43:07
trying to cope with the current situation00:43:09
it matters to them as well00:43:12
inside00:43:13
family introduction to this publication00:43:15
Boris00:43:16
Minaev is a good wonderful writer00:43:19
my co-author on another biography book00:43:27
suffer intellectually from the fact that they00:43:29
can't get in touch with their00:43:31
paper left abandoned in Russia00:43:36
library this is this is very important00:43:39
moment Well, for those who left00:43:42
children, which is also extremely important for00:43:46
very many inside, so to speak00:43:48
educated class which is still in00:43:50
Russia is present, this is also part00:43:53
At home, this is some kind of home, that is00:43:57
there are a lot of them here00:43:59
emotional moments after all00:44:02
here, well, the truth is that the educated hasn’t died yet00:44:05
cool if you go there I know the store00:44:09
Moscow or to the flan store or to00:44:11
Amateur00:44:14
copper you will see a lot of people standing00:44:18
delving into books and among them very00:44:20
a lot of00:44:21
young people, which makes you extremely happy00:44:24
vice versa00:44:27
Because now she’s not so active00:44:29
intellectual life club life00:44:30
lecture life people people cling to00:44:33
any kind of reason to come on00:44:36
somehow saturate your own brain and that00:44:39
including understanding what is happening to us00:44:41
now it's impossible to understand no no00:44:44
plunging into the search again, here's how00:44:48
the roots of what is happening and in search00:44:51
actually some kind of intellectual00:44:53
say or Anti intellectual00:44:55
impulses to what happened00:44:57
and how to deal with it is in the magazine00:45:01
the hump we are talking about now is00:45:04
and several literatures Well, we in general00:45:07
literature centrina country therefore very00:45:09
a lot is connected with literature and about00:45:11
literature and publications, including00:45:14
this is how you can see it yes Good And in00:45:17
this number concerns and e00:45:20
intellectual and literary life00:45:22
also because it's connected and that's it00:45:26
publication about the New World and00:45:29
Sergei Zalygin and his new world to me00:45:31
seems to be in the same place in the same place00:45:34
I'll take a clip because00:45:36
yes, the magazine room of perestroika is the same00:45:40
this is absolutely amazing00:45:44
some Yes very recent past00:45:47
Perestroika How how also like this00:45:51
intellectual intellectual club00:45:54
to whom the writers of perestroika there00:45:57
journalists of politics perestroika00:45:59
perestroika children perestroika all this00:46:01
adjoins00:46:03
there are some other publications on which00:46:06
maybe you should pay attention to00:46:08
By the way, I noticed this magazine00:46:11
on the portrait of Dugin and the newly-minted00:46:14
Slavophiles attack the institute00:46:17
philosophy Well, in my opinion, the Russian State University for the Humanities is still very00:46:21
the strong one was taken under his wing00:46:24
yes Tell me please00:46:28
How do you look at this as a sign?00:46:31
what and what are the consequences of this00:46:36
suggests let's say so you know I'll start with that00:46:39
that there is of course a lot in the magazine00:46:42
Gorbachev's own lens through00:46:44
which in general an attempt is made to look00:46:47
on history on what is happening00:46:50
now because here we are right now00:46:53
agreed that there is a lot in history00:46:55
Let's take a look at the fact that there are a lot of repetitions going on00:46:58
and dealing with this story, including00:47:00
with the history of perestroika It would seem, well00:47:03
passed and passed nothing like all these00:47:05
discussions00:47:06
all the conversations come back00:47:09
are returning Not to mention the fact that00:47:11
It would be nice to go back to that point when00:47:13
Perestroika began and return00:47:15
actually to some democratic00:47:18
conquest in the literal sense of it00:47:20
words otherwise we are all here actually00:47:24
there would be something like this inside00:47:27
live and it’s terribly important to talk about00:47:30
what happened and how it happened and who00:47:34
what was said and who wrote what? Otherwise we00:47:36
we find ourselves in a situation of absolute00:47:39
obscurantism This is exactly this article00:47:41
quite curious about Attacks on the Institute00:47:43
philosophy that has been going on for more than one year00:47:47
and it must be said that the institute00:47:48
philosophy of the Academy of the Russian Academy00:47:50
science is not a liberal institution like00:47:53
we are the widow of the famous Great Philosopher00:47:58
turned into quite weak00:48:00
publicist at the end of my life I have in00:48:02
mind00:48:03
zino00:48:05
there are people there who actually00:48:08
doing what they're doing00:48:09
philosophers call for such zenos Dugin00:48:12
sky type, that is, to the classes themselves00:48:15
Russian philosophy but at the institute00:48:18
philosophies are engaged in Russian philosophy00:48:20
do it00:48:21
professionally moreover Russian00:48:23
philosophy cannot be understood without00:48:26
context of Western European philosophy00:48:28
this is part of European philosophy that we00:48:30
they didn’t talk about it and did it00:48:32
European people with philosophy00:48:35
educated at that level of education00:48:38
which we don’t really need right now00:48:41
I dreamed about the text you mentioned00:48:45
about Zalygin's new world this is very00:48:48
interesting story this is Victor Afana00:48:50
Eroshenko [music]00:48:57
nsm new world Prim on the front lines00:49:00
positions he would be a member of the league head00:49:02
department00:49:04
journalism this small one wrote00:49:06
memoir is really small two00:49:09
rooms00:49:12
where he talks about his00:49:15
impressions here we come, as it were, to00:49:17
another story that seems to break00:49:20
cliche00:49:25
[music]00:49:26
communist publication it was one00:49:28
from sa also worked in a magazine00:49:30
communist If I'm correct Poroshenko -00:49:32
this is Yegor Gaidar's closest friend00:49:35
well, as if in human relations and00:49:39
they met exactly in the communist and00:49:42
here is a completely unexpected look at00:49:43
new world zalygin which then how would we00:49:46
everyone rated it as the most advanced00:49:49
edition that was printed00:49:51
already the impression arises00:49:55
such a diary00:49:57
that he's in some kind of stagnant swamp00:49:59
because in the communist there was real00:50:01
the struggle for perestroika published articles00:50:04
against various costly projects00:50:07
it was interesting and lively there and suddenly he00:50:10
falls dreaming of getting naturally in00:50:12
the new world with its glory Tvardovsky and so on00:50:14
then a friend gets into something like this00:50:16
a little bit like a foreign space where00:50:18
everything is happening very slowly00:50:22
[music]00:50:25
where it was naturally terribly important00:50:28
in every sense of the word and there too00:50:30
there is some kind of struggle and he this struggle00:50:32
describes not everything was so simple and also00:50:35
Solzhenitsyn was pushed through Gorbachev00:50:38
publications and with great difficulty between00:50:41
other things, but also this Paradox00:50:45
Eroshenko points out some00:50:47
progressive articles by leading publicists00:50:50
which were terribly important back then00:50:52
figures of the ruler of thoughts coexisted with00:50:55
something very strange, so to speak00:50:57
articles For example, Eroshenko had00:50:59
conflict with Zaly Zalygin pointed to00:51:01
publication of an article by Igor Shafarevich00:51:03
which was absolute at that time already00:51:07
Russian nationalist00:51:13
imperialists00:51:16
and Zalygin simply ordered this article00:51:20
print this as if it were within the framework00:51:22
Zagin had quite a pluralism of opinions00:51:25
broad-minded he was not a liberal00:51:27
by the way, absolutely but within the limits00:51:30
understanding that there are various00:51:34
like positions, different opinions00:51:36
it was worth it00:51:37
Shenko should publish such an article00:51:40
remembers what the halls said, this is not new00:51:42
Mirov's article that Zalygin is scary00:51:46
corroded and said that it’s not up to you to decide00:51:49
my magazine when utvo zhuu00:51:56
for financial difficulties then00:51:59
you will decide what to print like this00:52:00
things00:52:01
happened that didn’t interfere Then00:52:03
Zalygin in the new world has already begun, as it were00:52:06
so to speak, new Russia and at the beginning00:52:08
reforms to give huge space00:52:10
Yaroshenko when he no longer worked there00:52:12
publish a work diary00:52:16
Gaidar's wide gesture for Lygin00:52:19
as a person, as if not narrowly liberal00:52:21
look so very curious00:52:24
passed00:52:26
we have so much to talk about books today00:52:28
we talk so much about literature like you00:52:31
explain what people who read like00:52:33
how the same books grew on the same00:52:35
the same books suddenly turn out to be00:52:37
different sides of the Barricades I mean00:52:39
this rift that is now inside00:52:40
Russia for the war against the war for Putin00:52:43
against Putin Why are books like this?00:52:46
seems to be a universal way of education00:52:48
Why don't they work?00:52:51
the eternal theme is still working in some way00:52:55
degrees00:52:57
you are European educated people00:53:00
there are European philosophers00:53:02
there are no educated philosophers there00:53:05
I know Putin’s favorite philosopher Ilyin00:53:07
for example, that he is an uneducated person00:53:09
that I read some other books Well,00:53:11
he's like Dugin, he probably read books too00:53:15
gin read very specific books and he00:53:18
somehow very specific to them00:53:19
interpret00:53:26
the damage to Russian education is00:53:30
what's happening to him now what's wrong with him00:53:31
give a whole structure inside00:53:33
RSUH is the same in general so to speak00:53:36
a number of young people will graduate00:53:38
people completely filled with nonsense00:53:41
literally exchanging brains with nonsense00:53:43
there they will be able to read some00:53:45
books but they will not understand at all what00:53:48
they actually read it because00:53:50
teach the same Russian00:53:52
Russian conservative philosophy00:53:54
the philosophy of harvesting would be professional00:53:57
not as part of the indoctrination of brains into00:54:01
benefit there of the war of Great Russia Missy00:54:03
Russian idea and so on00:54:06
further, education is not a guarantee against00:54:10
let's say about the military00:54:12
views are not always a guarantee00:54:14
from in order00:54:17
the person did not simplify his own thinking00:54:20
before some kind of propagandist to me with this00:54:23
I encounter among obva here in Moscow00:54:27
it happens, but this is rather an exception00:54:30
rules because rather this one that one00:54:33
environment or community or whatever it is00:54:36
say in French it's called lieu00:54:38
where educated people exist00:54:41
those who left remained, well, these are people after all00:54:44
who understand that peace is better than war00:54:47
at least that universal human values00:54:51
And philanthropy than values00:54:55
called traditional00:54:57
By the way, here in the article you mentioned by Lev00:54:59
What Gudkova said here is very interesting00:55:03
very accurate cape man very deep00:55:07
he writes about the fact that traditions00:55:10
values incompatible things tradition -00:55:13
this is something frozen in granite00:55:16
As said00:55:18
one and value is something00:55:25
[music]00:55:26
works in the genre means cult00:55:30
death for someone there for some reason00:55:32
abstract means the idea of00:55:35
How huge your homeland must be00:55:38
but this is not a value, this is an anti-censor00:55:42
[music]00:55:52
[music]00:55:56
passed this stage of glorification of death and00:55:59
glorification of war and for some reason under Putin00:56:02
we failed again here are some00:56:05
almost medieval concepts or00:56:06
concepts of totalitarian regimes of the 20th century Well00:56:09
just when00:56:11
Homeland with His Excellency00:56:14
absolutely merge. This is also not pure.00:56:16
Russian experience Frankly speaking, because00:56:19
Death for the Motherland and death for the leader is00:56:22
well, it’s also a kind of tradition00:56:31
Yes, of course, this is actually our00:56:34
our today00:56:35
[music]00:56:36
the problem is that the value00:56:39
become very archaic wild and00:56:42
antiloch ideas about the world and00:56:46
man I apologize in what00:56:48
there were times when young people were filled with nonsense00:56:52
brains Well, that’s just about young people I00:56:54
I wanted to ask, I somehow see two00:56:57
point of view on the one hand here00:56:59
Youth are our future, they are those who00:57:01
will not keep the Soviet Union in mind00:57:04
and follow some old ideals00:57:06
dream of a strong leader about imperial and with00:57:10
on the other hand, the point of view is that00:57:12
youth, those who grew up under Putin will00:57:15
much more susceptible to Putin's ideas00:57:16
because they haven’t seen any other life00:57:18
Which country do you like?00:57:20
closer here remembering the Marxist00:57:23
the term dialectics is very different00:57:27
There have been attempts to generalize the idea00:57:30
Even before the war, young people are like this00:57:33
progressive what is now just for00:57:36
shift account00:57:37
generations we00:57:42
normalizes not yet00:57:44
happened well, you see sociologically00:57:47
it is clear that young people are less likely to00:57:49
keep the war young to a lesser extent00:57:53
program is susceptible00:57:58
firstly, within complex cohorts it is very00:58:01
a lot of people are simply absolutely indifferent00:58:03
Moreover, within these cohorts there is00:58:06
careerist who perceive simply00:58:08
external reality Well00:58:10
a reality that needs to be adapted00:58:11
and which ones you need00:58:13
there was a lot of talk00:58:15
again this is pre-war nazm so the period that00:58:18
actually the main aspiration00:58:20
a significant part of getting a job00:58:23
in MTO it’s like Gazpro00:58:26
[music]00:58:30
the tiny thing was hammered quickly00:58:33
career thanks to death for00:58:36
There was no such thing in the homeland, this is this demand00:58:40
if he existed he had to be woken up00:58:42
artificially partly he is awakened now00:58:45
and for some it’s like a career00:58:51
elevator rise00:58:57
Putin says about the sun, he proposes00:59:00
personnel programs why not00:59:02
not passing through the crucible means combat00:59:06
action Do not make a career later This00:59:09
terrible for sure but for everyone00:59:12
authoritarian totalitarian regimes in00:59:14
in principle, young people are extremely00:59:16
the young spirit of the floss is important00:59:21
[music]00:59:25
I remembered the totalitarian movement00:59:28
one more one more Sorry I just remembered00:59:30
my favorite book on this topic is Umberto00:59:34
Eco firstly he had a wonderful00:59:36
book Don't try to get rid of books00:59:39
the dialogue is just about that00:59:41
Why are books needed and what concerns this00:59:45
this youth in the novel00:59:49
his queens doe flame queens Lana there00:59:52
there is this moment and they are given00:59:55
even00:59:57
illustrations these are the eyes of Duchi which01:00:00
see a doctor delivering a baby01:00:04
and all these young people there01:00:06
small movements uh01:00:10
little fighters there blacks and01:00:13
Jews are little defenders there, Duchi and01:00:17
that's all, these are the fiery youth01:00:19
who just sacrifices everything01:00:22
But nothing changes in this rhetoric01:00:26
how it was done with floss and with01:00:28
Hitler, in my opinion, is also okay with the sun01:00:37
this is a new property of this type of mode01:00:40
By the way, this is one of the characteristics01:00:42
allowing us to evaluate today's01:00:44
Putin's regime is almost totalitarian01:00:47
NM does not have the totality that it had01:00:50
mode01:00:52
ideologically even from the point of view01:00:54
political strategists absolutely repeats this01:00:57
this very experience you mentioned If we01:00:59
let's take mu soline VSS Italy Yes starting01:01:03
since kindergarten then that that that kind of like01:01:06
since Eka has pictures, this is the movement01:01:08
de children's literature so to speak01:01:10
children's literature with all sorts of stitches01:01:13
all this happened and we know from01:01:15
Let's take new rifles based on Soviet experience01:01:17
they have flags from them with rifle songs01:01:20
let's go mugs this is the one01:01:23
here's Balila01:01:24
Italian here01:01:27
I'm proud that in 2000 I01:01:29
I already mentioned this somewhere01:01:32
article entitled tea with Putin01:01:35
hinting that this person is me01:01:38
it was visible in 2000 will be built01:01:40
This is the kind of corporate state01:01:42
Musovsky type we are here abstract01:01:45
from various bad words so as not to01:01:47
get some so to speak01:01:49
claims But it was obvious that01:01:53
a man with such a brain will build01:01:56
something similar not only to Soviet01:01:59
Union for what he understands is controlled01:02:02
controlled society broken different01:02:04
corporations different structures starting from01:02:06
kindergarten They are not now01:02:07
are embarrassed to say that they need to go to01:02:09
kindergartens movement01:02:11
the first movement of the first - this is ours01:02:14
combining Pioneer and Komsomol in one01:02:18
Yuna bottle01:02:20
the army is even cooler than in the past01:02:23
Soviet period in the late Soviet period01:02:25
Well, they played lightning, but very formally01:02:27
And here everything is still quite serious01:02:30
taxpayers' money is there for that01:02:31
to buy them all sorts of suits01:02:33
and take a natural question with01:02:37
your literary and journalistic and01:02:42
all sorts of other sociological and even01:02:43
legal01:02:45
experience Well, it can’t work Well, we01:02:49
we saw how it was done and it doesn’t work01:02:52
still 100% result01:02:55
impossible, kindergarten endocrine here01:02:59
these all grow up to be absolute tins01:03:03
Solon with soldiers01:03:05
eyes from the point of view of the big story with01:03:08
point of view of historical optimism01:03:10
you can be kind of political today01:03:13
pessimist but at the same time historical01:03:15
optimistic that we are still out of this hole01:03:18
let's get out and still do this kind of regime01:03:22
really become ineffective01:03:23
maximum people can think01:03:27
double consciousness in people and experience01:03:29
Soviet Union which is just in01:03:31
the magazine is described there as if the main01:03:33
history historical historical section01:03:36
this means the process of the collapse of the Soviet01:03:40
Union for example with a very curious01:03:42
interview with Baturin who talks about01:03:45
that if it weren’t for the State Emergency Committee it would have been possible01:03:47
to achieve something so to speak01:03:48
truncated format of the Soviet Union and in01:03:51
such a truncated several columns01:03:54
confederacy as part of the former01:03:56
I could have survived the Soviet Union01:03:59
I don’t really agree with this idea But the idea01:04:00
interesting but the State Emergency Committee certainly buried01:04:04
all hope that such things can01:04:07
save Just started01:04:09
centrifugal01:04:10
processes This is also experience showing01:04:14
that nothing lasts forever under the moon and such01:04:17
kind of constructions are authoritarian01:04:18
totalitarian01:04:25
they were sometimes launched by the same pioneers01:04:29
young Octobers and grandchildren of Ilyich and all sorts of01:04:33
other interesting people What don't they01:04:35
got in the way Then01:04:36
become heroes heroes and perestroika and01:04:41
tons of other interesting things01:04:43
that there is still Historical optimism01:04:46
I would like that01:04:47
said there is pessimism because those01:04:50
more pioneers Komsomol VS rest I01:04:52
party means career they find themselves01:04:55
in power01:04:56
Yes, experience didn’t teach them anything. They01:05:00
think they are attractive to01:05:02
Some people are actually repelled by them01:05:04
the same CIS countries that politely01:05:06
they shy away from Putin and say dadada We01:05:07
of course very interested in01:05:09
economic cooperation But the same01:05:12
the most Central Asian leaders with01:05:15
with pleasure they hug not only01:05:16
Putin but also with Macron and with anyone01:05:18
also because they want it to be normal01:05:22
somehow exist to maintain one's01:05:24
power is no longer soft01:05:27
attractive power too much01:05:28
he demonstrated hard power and this01:05:31
a person who has not learned from experience01:05:33
own length including01:05:34
Soviet life K01:05:36
unfortunately Thank you very much We and01:05:40
magazine Discussed with a good person01:05:42
let's talk again yes it was01:05:44
Andrey Kolesnikov is on our air Expert01:05:46
Carnegie Foundation Thank you for coming to us01:05:48
Let's show the magazine again Before01:05:50
as we will understand further Yes maybe Ivan01:05:52
Ivan will help us show it to us01:05:54
will show it as expected Thank you very much01:05:57
uh, keep in mind that here he is, just here01:06:00
Not many copies came out and so01:06:03
that please everyone is interested in this01:06:06
really beautiful well published and01:06:08
very interesting magazine 999 copies01:06:11
now there is Well, I don’t know probably already01:06:13
less left but you can still buy01:06:16
If I were you, I would hurry because01:06:18
Gorby magazine comes out limited01:06:20
circulation due to these difficulties with01:06:23
license we move on to the news then01:06:25
let's continue our01:06:30
[music]01:06:40
9 am reversal in Moscow at the microphone01:06:42
Lisa Anikina this is news on a live nail01:06:45
Russian Orthodox Church in Estonia01:06:47
may be considered terrorist01:06:49
organizations with such initiative01:06:50
made by the Ministry of Internal Affairs, reported by the national01:06:53
broadcasting company01:06:55
Orthodox Church has about 100,000 parishioners01:06:58
according to the authorities, the subordination of the church in01:07:00
Moscow poses a security threat01:07:03
Estonia01:07:05
seventeen-year-old love Lizunovo01:07:07
transferred from house arrest to pre-trial detention center01:07:09
Lizunov and her friend Alexander Snezhkov01:07:11
detained in 2022 due to graffiti01:07:14
death to the regime, criminal case against young people01:07:17
people were charged immediately under three articles in that01:07:19
including calls for terrorist01:07:21
activities and extremism reminds01:07:24
BB great-granddaughter of the legendary Soviet01:07:26
Pilot Valery Chkalov Daria Bogdanova01:07:29
faces 7 years in prison under article01:07:30
calls for terrorism in Russia against01:07:32
she was charged with criminal charges because of01:07:34
posts on social networks and interviews with Ukrainian01:07:37
the channel writes pcs Bogdanov has01:07:39
Israeli citizenship, she left Russia01:07:42
after the start01:07:43
its in the Kharkov region announced01:07:46
forced evacuation of families with children01:07:48
from 47 settlements in the border01:07:51
areas this does not apply to Kharkov01:07:53
according to authorities in border areas01:07:58
exchange01:07:59
[music]01:08:02
the European Parliament decided to remove it from the agenda01:08:05
of the day the question of EU council funding01:08:07
until Ukraine receives a new system01:08:09
Air defense is a proposal from the VNS MEP01:08:12
former prime minister of Belgium bi top01:08:15
stood up According to him, European countries have01:08:18
about 100 trio systems01:08:22
[music]01:08:25
June 15 to allocate funds for development01:08:27
space nuclear power01:08:29
reported on the Kremlin website to do this01:08:32
Roscosmos and Rusatom should question01:08:34
the exact amount is not01:08:36
called the assets of the largest01:08:38
wine producer in Russia Kuban wine01:08:40
transferred to the state change of owner01:08:42
occurred within the framework of the Arbitration Court decision01:08:44
court of the Chelyabinsk region dated April 501:08:47
trip of the Prosecutor General's Office to the former01:08:49
owners of Chelyabinsk01:08:50
electrometallurgical plant01:08:52
the defendants appealed to the Supreme Court01:08:54
for violation under Rani01:08:57
and United Russia deputy Alexander Khinshtein01:09:00
accused Samarsky of LGBT propaganda01:09:02
Minister of Youth Policy Sergei01:09:04
Burtseva Khinshtein reported that01:09:06
informed all authorities that01:09:08
including Governor Dmitry Azarov Burtsev01:09:11
denied the accusation but resigned01:09:15
this was the news on live gvo we01:09:17
let's continue01:09:18
[music]01:09:24
U-turn is not U-turn in Moscow 10 am and01:09:27
3 minutes Subscribe, like and01:09:30
keep watching us and even us01:09:32
write I'm here with interest with interest01:09:35
I read your comments, including about01:09:38
how wretchedly wretched the woman looks01:09:41
over 40 when they try01:09:44
Well done really really01:09:47
guys, I'm sorry, I didn't mean to, I swear01:09:49
Not01:09:52
come on special01:09:55
If you don't mind, especially since we01:09:58
OVD lawyer is already waiting for Alexander Baev info01:10:00
Alexandra Dobroe01:10:02
morning Good morning I'm not working anymore really01:10:05
SD info I am a privately practicing lawyer01:10:08
ok Sorry then in the credits we are01:10:10
we will correct the lawyer Alexander Baev in our01:10:13
morning spread on a live nail we01:10:15
wanted to talk to you about the situation with01:10:17
Oleg Orlov for details01:10:19
as far as we understand, the court refused to give01:10:22
him the opportunity to personally attend01:10:24
meeting Despite the fact that problems with01:10:26
rumors prevent him from participating in01:10:28
meeting01:10:29
remotely Yes, we submitted a petition01:10:32
about the personal appearance of Oleg Petrovich and Oleg himself01:10:35
Petrovich also petitioned that01:10:38
he wants to personally participate in this01:10:39
during the process, we explained to the judge that in01:10:42
as a result of these grueling01:10:44
trips for almost a month01:10:47
Oleg Petrovich went to01:10:49
Lavinsky District Court to01:10:51
familiarize yourself with your materials01:10:52
criminal case and as a result he has yes01:10:55
he has a cold his hearing is deteriorating we01:10:57
explained this to the judge explained the situation01:11:01
that only personal participation can01:11:03
fully provide01:11:05
and to protect the rights of Oleg Petrovich and he01:11:08
could examine all the evidence01:11:10
be present to hear what is happening01:11:12
answer questions reasonably01:11:15
Ministry of Justice more precisely01:11:17
representative of the Ministry of Justice and so on01:11:18
further but the judge for us in this part01:11:21
refused the application but said that01:11:24
video conferencing can be provided01:11:26
on the next01:11:27
meeting Why did she refuse to eat?01:11:30
some kind01:11:31
motivation the judge said at the meeting that01:11:34
she doesn't01:11:35
can personally What exactly is she can’t01:11:38
ensure the appearance of Oleg Petrovich of some01:11:41
details of the reasons why01:11:43
happens no that is su the judge they are on01:11:46
the meeting were not announced Wait here01:11:50
that is, I already have here01:11:52
If you have any questions, please introduce Him01:11:55
had to personally and came to01:11:57
Golovinsky court is correct Yes it is01:12:01
delivered organized its delivery01:12:04
Right01:12:06
Yes means But delivery to court01:12:10
there’s no one to organize it, that’s how it turns out01:12:13
Yes I understand all yours01:12:15
indignation I don't even have01:12:17
perplexed because we have heard a lot about01:12:20
that there are traffic jams in Moscow, that’s why there01:12:22
in some situations or somewhere else01:12:25
difficult means with delivery, river floods or01:12:28
it means anything, well, I mean01:12:31
convicted suspect not involved01:12:33
participates via video link there01:12:35
is somewhere at this time and it’s us01:12:38
we know, but here it’s just like experience01:12:42
Is there delivery? What's it like?01:12:45
happened besides the judge who else is in this01:12:48
may take part in01:12:50
decisions formally tro for Golovin Random01:12:55
consideration in the first instance01:12:57
criminal case, that is, and his claim about that01:13:01
to be removed from the register for01:13:02
agent countries it occurs in already01:13:04
Moskvoretsky District Court that is01:13:06
Zamoskvoretsky District Court must01:13:08
obtain permission from Golovinsky01:13:09
district court for them to write out01:13:12
means permission for him to come from the SZ01:13:15
number five Vodnik has already left for01:13:17
Zamoskvoretsky District Court That is, this01:13:19
The procedure itself is quite complicated.01:13:21
and moreover, she is not uncomfortable, that is01:13:25
there aren't any really good ones01:13:27
rules in order to01:13:29
deliver people held in pre-trial detention centers to01:13:32
courts As you know, they are also taken away before01:13:36
breakfast and then there's enough01:13:37
a useless procedure that is quite01:13:39
takes a long time to get to the court where he is supposed to01:13:41
sit in a room with guards not immediately01:13:45
Provides an opportunity to become familiar with01:13:46
documents are taken away only late, late01:13:48
in the evening to pick it up early in the morning01:13:51
that is, the procedure itself is arranged01:13:53
quite inhuman in this way She01:13:56
quite complex And despite the fact that with01:13:58
On the one hand there is experience on the other hand01:14:00
It's actually quite a complicated procedure though01:14:02
the judge of the Zamoskvoretsky court, of course01:14:04
nothing stood in the way of ensuring personal appearance01:14:07
In my opinion, yes, ensure personal appearance01:14:08
Oleg Petrovich in this judicial01:14:10
the meeting is just still important I think01:14:12
remind you that to get acquainted with the case01:14:14
he was driven around every day, it seems01:14:16
to his requests to give some breaks01:14:18
it was not possible for him to be normal01:14:19
eat take care of your health01:14:21
just relax for a bit01:14:24
come though it seemed01:14:27
yes it is quite very complex01:14:30
schedule when before breakfast there 6:00 am01:14:33
They're lifting you up, they're already taking you somewhere.01:14:35
They only deliver late at night and they don’t give it to me01:14:37
no opportunity to wash or eat or01:14:39
sleep or see a doctor early01:14:41
in the morning at 6:00 am the next day again01:14:44
pick up a person again through this one01:14:46
carry out an inhuman procedure01:14:48
there is this and for a young body it was01:14:50
would be quite a difficult test for Ole01:14:53
We remember Salenko These are the stories with01:14:56
taken to court with inability to eat01:14:59
and and Yes yes this is generally familiar but01:15:04
there is a feeling that this is it01:15:07
delivery in this mode is just like that01:15:10
element Well, torture in a good way01:15:12
bullying and not delivery to court - This is01:15:16
the next stage of torture Well, it's true01:15:19
somehow very01:15:20
strange, who can I appeal to?01:15:24
if the judge says I can't01:15:26
provide someone to contact. That's how you do it01:15:29
Who else can you contact a lawyer?01:15:32
connection with the organization of the trial01:15:36
Well, here the judge is in his right01:15:38
there is no formal restriction on participation01:15:41
Oleg Petrovich That is, he can01:15:43
to participate in VKS is that she remained01:15:45
deaf to01:15:47
our to our stories about how01:15:49
Oleg Petrovich's current condition is01:15:51
this is another question, that is, formally01:15:53
Oleg Petrovich will have the opportunity01:15:55
read the materials and at least01:15:58
participate via video conferencing01:15:59
in this process Of course we are more01:16:02
they were afraid of everything with a defense lawyer01:16:04
Oleg Petrovich that they won’t give us any01:16:07
personal appearance or video conference01:16:09
will be considered in one day, but at least in01:16:11
in this format the judge satisfied01:16:13
petition Why is it so important for Oleg01:16:16
Petrovich to personally participate in01:16:19
the court just needs to say it because01:16:22
Well, it’s clear that this is a court, such a court01:16:25
everyone will say that Lord, what should we do there?01:16:26
I will give him this judgment. Why is this for him?01:16:29
important Well, let's start with the fact that this is a status about01:16:32
foreign agents Yes, that's enough01:16:35
discriminatory illegal law01:16:37
limiting a huge amount01:16:39
constitutional rights and express your01:16:41
disagreement personally disagreement with what01:16:43
this status has been assigned this is so01:16:45
civic duty, taking into account the fact that Oleg01:16:48
Petrovich citizen Yes with a capital letter01:16:52
a person who has his own opinion01:16:54
this issue, which has spoken a lot and01:16:56
at its meetings about01:16:57
TV discrediting of the Armed Forces01:17:00
Russian Federation, that is, for Oleg01:17:02
It is extremely important for Petrovich personally to participate01:17:04
in this process and the most important thing is that01:17:08
you need to argue your own reasons01:17:12
Yes, bring your arguments against those01:17:14
arguments it uses01:17:15
The Ministry of Justice has already given us01:17:18
get acquainted with the representative's objections01:17:20
The Ministry of Justice is quite01:17:22
many interesting points on which01:17:25
Oleg Petrovich would be interested01:17:27
speak01:17:28
independently not only through01:17:30
representatives, as far as I understand01:17:32
conditions have now changed01:17:33
content and seems to be even better01:17:35
side Yes, first he got into the season01:17:39
The procedure number is as follows01:17:41
way that first a person for some01:17:43
quarantine time falls into one season01:17:46
then he gets it on a permanent basis01:17:48
transferred to another and as far as I01:17:50
it is known Oleg Petrovich is pleased with how01:17:53
He was transferred to the conditions now in a pre-trial detention center01:17:55
that is, that is, they don’t smoke there, for example, yes01:17:58
which already greatly affects Comfort Yes01:18:03
stay in this season that is this01:18:05
the translation was better than this01:18:08
quarantine season in which he sat until01:18:10
this Uh-huh And Anna Borisova writes to us here01:18:14
that Chalenko's board is always this way01:18:16
treated all the suspects you01:18:18
it didn't bother me, but in fact yes01:18:21
all suspects were treated this way and01:18:23
all this has been known for a long time and always01:18:28
lawyers talked about how difficult it is01:18:32
sometimes it’s easy to comply, I don’t even know01:18:36
physical rights01:18:40
people precisely because of difficulties01:18:43
delivery to court of contents there in this01:18:45
the court is blowing somewhere, someone is sick there01:18:48
something else Yes, it's a long time ago01:18:51
known but just uh01:18:55
these are these bright bright stories They are just01:18:59
remind us that all these01:19:01
rules lately it seems to me01:19:03
only getting tougher, no easing01:19:07
I don’t know for the last 15 20 years there01:19:13
this area has not arrived we just01:19:15
we see these stories more often, but in fact01:19:18
really nothing for the better, not everything for me01:19:20
the same cells BC the same01:19:23
the number of people we have in handcuffs01:19:27
the same conditions are delivered there with01:19:31
inability to eat and being in01:19:34
these special rooms with security and01:19:36
so on Because I I I understand01:19:40
that there is no difference01:19:42
in or correct01:19:45
me what the person is suspected of or for01:19:48
what he01:19:49
convicted everyone looks like extremists01:19:52
terrorists and ours in flight there and in01:19:56
some kind of violence or it's not so Or is it01:19:59
some are softer01:20:03
cases, first of all I would say that01:20:05
Of course there were changes. That is, for example01:20:07
there was a pilot regulation of the European01:20:09
human rights court on the conditions01:20:11
keeping prisoners and there for the better01:20:14
side changed the moment But about that01:20:17
how many square meters does a person need01:20:19
Of course, that's all for staying in a cell01:20:23
still continues to be non-human01:20:25
conditions That is, these are quite complex01:20:27
harsh conditions and they spread01:20:30
not only on political prisoners but01:20:33
the memorial believes that Olik Petrovich01:20:34
political prisoner But also on ordinary01:20:37
prisoners That is, this is such a general01:20:39
Practice is not specifically against Oleg01:20:42
Petrovich they carry him like this in the morning, yes01:20:45
until there late at night in court this practice01:20:48
maybe on what01:20:50
any example just like you are correct01:20:52
They said yes, there are some cases that01:20:55
are discussed about which they talk about01:20:56
they give examples but this is practice01:20:59
general And unfortunately she can01:21:01
be subjected to absolutely any01:21:03
the prisoner is just a system this way01:21:06
arranged Yes, what is this?01:21:07
additional punishment and conditions01:21:10
and transportation and01:21:13
I don’t know the attitude of the bailiffs01:21:15
escorts to the person whose01:21:18
they deliver this Well yes, it’s negative01:21:20
attitude too, many with this often01:21:22
are faced with some unreasonable01:21:23
rudeness this is how it works01:21:25
system And unfortunately it's pretty deaf01:21:27
to complaints about this kind of thing That is01:21:30
when lawyers try to appeal against such01:21:33
inhuman conditions yes or torture01:21:35
even the conditions are unfortunately the only one01:21:38
the authority that was here was not deaf01:21:41
This is unfortunately the European Court of Justice01:21:42
human rights to which we are no longer01:21:44
we can contact you because we left01:21:46
from under its jurisdiction here is Russian01:21:48
The system unfortunately remains deaf to01:21:50
complaints from lawyers against such01:21:53
appeals I just don’t know if everyone01:21:55
noticed that for these01:22:00
conditions of detention and delivery to court and01:22:03
doesn’t have all these events01:22:05
meaning violent or01:22:07
nonviolent01:22:08
a crime is charged to a person, that is01:22:13
accountant or I don't know which one01:22:16
some kind of financial fraud attracts01:22:18
or political defendants01:22:21
or I don't know, bribe taker01:22:24
just like everyone else too01:22:26
is in a cage There and so on or01:22:30
there this is in the glass here in01:22:33
Well, it would be wrong to do this01:22:36
some difference Yes there are some01:22:39
delivery rules contents and so on01:22:41
further And here the difference between these conditions is not01:22:44
should depend on what01:22:46
committed a crime even if it01:22:48
some kind of violent crime01:22:49
equals to torture a person01:22:52
imprisoned01:22:55
not for that01:22:56
the criminal system is aimed01:22:58
persecution Well, they just tell us01:23:00
what about the danger? We remember the stories01:23:02
when in court the gang members seized01:23:05
their guards were snatched from them there01:23:07
weapons and fled from the courthouse that is01:23:11
in theory, some measures should be taken01:23:13
Well, not applied to suspects yet01:23:17
convicted but on the other hand the same01:23:20
the most measures apply to01:23:22
everyone so are you with01:23:25
tighter control definitely yes Well01:23:27
of course when the gang was accompanied by g01:23:30
there's one there01:23:31
the woman was guarded and they snatched it from her01:23:34
that means the weapon she has on her is there01:23:37
parallel to some political01:23:38
a process in which 10 con warriors01:23:40
accompany some one Yes peaceful01:23:43
absolutely intelligent political01:23:45
prisoner But it certainly looks01:23:47
pretty funny of course some measures01:23:50
or the number of convoys at least in01:23:51
depending on the situation it should01:23:53
change and how is Oleg’s mood01:23:56
Petrovich How01:23:58
attitude He remains optimistic01:24:01
incredibly better than those who01:24:04
even lawyers who work with him01:24:07
affairs In my opinion That is, he is cheerful01:24:09
cheerful continues to radiate optimism01:24:12
which he had throughout01:24:14
processes If you followed them, he01:24:16
answers emails to the best of his ability01:24:18
maybe somewhere it also shares some01:24:20
interesting moments that happen01:24:22
in his life For example, he recently told me01:24:24
wrote that he participated in the Championship01:24:27
backgammon and learned to play backgammon for the first time01:24:30
it is in the season that life continues01:24:35
explore what's happening to him01:24:37
Therefore, if you also want to01:24:40
see this optimism and talk to01:24:42
Oleg Petrovich You can write to him01:24:44
letter via the VN system letter01:24:47
works in season works in Sin letter yes01:24:50
Uh-huh Yes it works well it all depends01:24:53
of course from the addressee himself, that is, to01:24:55
during this month while Oleg01:24:57
Petrovich was not taken01:24:59
opportunities to respond to that number01:25:01
letters that he receives but he01:25:02
gradually it does answers therefore01:25:05
shipping and paper physical letters and01:25:08
here is the letter through the VN system01:25:10
happens regularly Uh-huh I'm just for01:25:13
our viewers listeners If anyone01:25:15
I haven’t tried it yet, please note that01:25:17
It is enough to know the full name of the place where01:25:21
contains the person and the year of his birth and01:25:23
a letter is enough01:25:25
you can easily send a letter and it arrives01:25:28
it is there after censorship the answer comes01:25:30
also quite quickly so I’ll turn it in01:25:33
Your attention Well, in general and inexpensive if01:25:36
if pus is very important for a person01:25:39
which is located in a certain01:25:40
information isolation of social01:25:42
isolation I think that any communication in this01:25:46
situation very, very cheer up Thank you01:25:49
huge Alexandra Baeva lawyer was in01:25:52
our broadcast Thank you for joining us01:25:53
joined Thank you for being01:25:55
continue your work this is very good now01:25:57
important Yes Thank you Thank you very much I01:26:02
just while we were talking with Alexandra01:26:05
I remembered my Well, not very rich experience01:26:07
we once went to court01:26:09
for example, to the court of Nikita Bely01:26:12
to the governor who is also dangerous01:26:14
criminal01:26:15
everything was usually listed there and there01:26:19
security and dogs and everything like him there with01:26:22
a special griller is about to pounce01:26:25
same for us It's obvious01:26:27
absolutely Well, this is of course 000 years ago01:26:29
already01:26:31
was it it was it really and and so01:26:34
it's always like that, that's how it's supposed to be01:26:36
be at least like01:26:37
I wish there were trials that are allowed there01:26:41
the public there are journalists and relatively B01:26:44
in general it’s comfortable everything happens in that01:26:46
sense that the judge does not threaten every01:26:50
second, kick everyone out to He's not there either01:26:53
calls the bailiffs but still uh01:26:55
actually that's all01:26:58
it's not normal I told you about m01:27:01
what I've been reading here for the last few days01:27:04
stories of the condemnation of the Decembrists and there, well01:27:09
there too And they weren’t allowed either01:27:11
attend the trial Uh-huh Well because01:27:13
in general it was such a very01:27:14
special01:27:16
And they couldn’t defend themselves either01:27:19
some of them being European01:27:21
somehow educated there are also several of them01:27:23
I was confused by the fact itself. Wait, what about them?01:27:26
it turns out there were no lawyers01:27:28
lawyers no I mean they couldn't01:27:29
come out yourself at least to present your01:27:31
position Lisa dear these are those01:27:34
blessed times before before reform01:27:37
When everything was very difficult for us01:27:40
court but it's No there wasn't, not to mention not01:27:43
there were ships as such, they were just01:27:45
some documents from the village, some commission01:27:48
I read it from the papers, it means that01:27:50
known about this and about the other01:27:52
them by category each category01:27:54
punishment was imposed and sent to the sovereign01:27:57
the sovereign means he pardoned as best he could because01:27:59
what was possible at that time01:28:01
legislation could in principle01:28:03
for example sentence01:28:05
to Well, I don’t know about boiling because01:28:09
were still operating there Alexei01:28:11
Mikhailovich there Peter I and so on01:28:14
all sorts of decrees and01:28:16
so those we know are five01:28:19
hanged they were sentenced to01:28:23
fourth and there were others then01:28:25
sentenced to death in lieu of01:28:27
this was given the following first category01:28:31
the so-called Yes they were sentenced01:28:34
already to death but she too, it’s like01:28:37
here are the next ones dada yes but this is a mercy01:28:40
just like all the sentences were like this01:28:42
amendment to the fact that later the sovereign01:28:45
will do because actually he judged personally01:28:47
Nikolai, by and large, that’s it01:28:49
returning to the staging01:28:54
put on leg shackles01:28:57
leg shackles01:28:59
would be there usually Pete ex-prince ex01:29:02
former second lieutenant There and so on and so on01:29:06
that's when on former princes and non-princes01:29:08
put on leg shackles Many of them01:29:10
then in their memoirs they wrote that actually01:29:12
actually according to the law01:29:15
Russian in shackles and drowns only01:29:18
those who have committed a repeat crime01:29:22
or tried to escape01:29:24
This doesn’t apply to us, comrades. Why01:29:27
shackles01:29:28
Well, for beauty, I mean it’s tradition01:29:32
tradition is a great thing, it's a matter of01:29:35
traditions and values there was still01:29:38
giant break in mortals01:29:41
executions here between the last mortal01:29:44
execution before the Decembrists and the execution itself01:29:46
there are a lot of these five Decembrists there01:29:49
nuances in general in Russia, but there is Eliza01:29:52
Petrovna, for example, didn’t love, that is, she01:29:54
all death penalties are done through oneself01:29:56
missed it and they say she canceled01:29:58
death penalty No she just asked01:30:00
so that everything is sent to her for the performance01:30:03
death sentences and she doesn't not like them01:30:06
is not01:30:24
Well, of course not about the noble01:30:25
hero but01:30:26
so really harsh and even01:30:31
public reprisal execution but when people01:30:36
They drove me through the gauntlet. They think01:30:39
after that the living Healthy ones went to themselves01:30:42
to distant01:30:43
their garrisons sometimes assigned them this01:30:46
the number of spitzrutens or sticks that they are01:30:48
died before reaching the end01:30:50
building in terrible torment, but this is not01:30:54
damn it's so simple01:30:56
corporal punishment yes that's why there is01:31:00
in the history of Russia there are all sorts of amazing01:31:03
nuances By the way, regarding the Decembrists case01:31:04
The soldiers are also very big and01:31:07
uprising of the Chernigov regiment and those who01:31:10
went to the Senate although there were of course01:31:14
significantly less than those opposing them01:31:17
But nevertheless, there were Soldiers there too01:31:19
who were attracted to01:31:20
responsibility of this or that someone01:31:22
just disbanded someone got it01:31:24
Quite corporal punishment01:31:28
what’s scary to remember Well, it seems01:31:32
it seems like there are just mortals there01:31:34
there were no verdicts but nevertheless it was so01:31:37
Well, in general, yes, we are talking about the return01:31:40
traditional values we'll talk01:31:42
today just literally in 5 minutes01:31:44
with Dmitry capture about what new01:31:47
restrictions will be imposed against lawyers01:31:49
specifically against lawyers because01:31:51
There is no other way to call this bill01:31:53
It turns out that the State Duma is already in the third reading01:31:55
accepted this new norm And of course with01:31:58
Alexey Venediktov, we are this too01:31:59
Let's discuss at 11:00 he will join us A01:32:02
as long as you can give us likes You01:32:04
you can subscribe to us if you haven’t already01:32:06
subscribed And of course you can come in01:32:08
on01:32:24
populist No, it seems scientific to me01:32:27
popular it's called populist01:32:29
I suddenly thought what are you talking about who are you01:32:32
wanted01:32:35
swore yes scientifically popular Yes yes yes01:32:41
and of course our magazines too. Listen01:32:43
newspapers have already been sorted out for Cosmonautics Day01:32:46
we had we had copies01:32:48
newspapers Just last Saturday I01:32:52
I held it in my hands and there were copies01:32:56
authentic authentic newspaper issues from01:32:59
April sixty-one01:33:02
publications about human space flight01:33:05
about further greetings there01:33:08
awards of all sorts of delight and that’s it01:33:11
It’s possible that someone has already cut everything apart. I01:33:14
I don’t see, I went to different sections and it’s unlikely01:33:16
did she manage to go down somehow very01:33:19
far away No this is a Saransk wall newspaper01:33:22
oo coma01:33:24
but nevertheless it was like that A01:33:26
something else I wanted to draw your attention to01:33:28
shop Amateur T-shirts can be turned01:33:30
pay attention to the T-shirts we have01:33:32
sold with our designs with our Above01:33:35
and a hoodie and even with your portrait there, Well01:33:38
I mean you are in this SF T-shirt I am for you01:33:40
I’ll say more there and with your portrait01:33:42
there, look, yes, me too01:33:43
Yes, I took pictures with the cat. I took ours01:33:46
So yes, you can also look at01:33:48
us Olya not only in the video but also in the photo01:33:50
and on a T-shirt that shows how young we are there01:33:53
Oh yes actively diligently just everything01:33:56
In general, I’m already looking younger, I’m still young01:33:58
And who knows, the younger ones would have turned out to be yes01:34:01
Eh yes hoodies vests Choose what you like01:34:04
you will like it when we have something01:34:06
you order you support us01:34:08
you pay for our work and for yourself too01:34:09
do it nicely and if you don't want to01:34:11
Only we can make you feel good01:34:13
support us via QR codes which01:34:15
there is here oh I can even see myself01:34:17
So that's near Lisa who's near01:34:20
Lisa No, it’s just that now I finally see01:34:21
how I look on screen so I can01:34:24
regulate where exactly mine is01:34:26
hand and where I show you and under the video01:34:29
You can also support us using the links01:34:31
bring some amount that will not01:34:33
for you it is possible with Russian01:34:34
cards is possible from foreign cards is possible01:34:37
subscribe to boost and you can01:34:39
transfer cryptocurrency to us If you01:34:41
you know how to use such high technologies01:34:43
use it because I don't01:34:44
I've learned so far, maybe for the better01:34:46
you know, maybe you haven’t already brought Lizo, maybe01:34:49
no need What What teach just just Ales01:34:53
wondering who the next guest is to leave01:34:55
or not Alex Don't leave Alex We have01:34:58
There is a description under the video, everything is written there01:35:00
No, not everything is there01:35:03
written yes maybe just a person is not01:35:05
expanded the description under the video Yes we will01:35:08
The State Duma approved talking about lawyers01:35:10
in the third reading the bill on01:35:12
it seems to you that this concerns the legal profession01:35:14
only some people who are engaged01:35:17
the practice of law is still really01:35:20
in fact this concerns everyone because01:35:22
the bill on legal profession concerns01:35:25
what can you count on01:35:28
When you need a lawyer what is he01:35:31
can physically do it for you01:35:33
physically and not only and morally Why?01:35:36
cannot and this will be described in01:35:40
Law on Advocacy which is for now01:35:42
It's still just a draft law, but that's the deal01:35:45
in the third reading so what in the third01:35:47
reading, it’s a matter of little things and that’s what we’re talking about01:35:49
Let's talk to Dmitry with a seizure lawyer and01:35:52
human rights activist01:35:54
but whatever the case is, I still don’t get tired01:36:00
to say that unfortunately the lawyer -01:36:03
This is something that concerns everyone01:36:06
because anything can happen Yes to me01:36:09
it seems that the position is what you are telling us01:36:11
here they report a flood in Orsk and Orenburg01:36:14
15 regions were flooded, all villages drowned01:36:18
in the water And here they tell all sorts of [ __ ]01:36:21
What are you saying is true Orsk flood oh01:36:26
I didn’t see anything anywhere, the man woke up01:36:28
dear Sheriff We are already talking about this01:36:31
Let's be honest, it's not the first day, but01:36:34
today we started right from this with from that01:36:36
why do floods actually happen?01:36:39
By the way, I remembered there is such a definition01:36:41
these are what meteorologists call it01:36:44
especially dangerous natural phenomena01:36:49
oh yes oh oh I’m right there is such a term01:36:55
punish punish these01:36:58
those who are weather forecasters01:37:01
punished if they did not indicate the presence01:37:04
a particularly dangerous phenomenon And here's why01:37:07
These mailings will be coming all the time01:37:09
terrible storm, be careful out there01:37:11
just be quiet, honey, because if01:37:14
You didn’t say in the forecast that there would be a thunderstorm01:37:18
Hail with stones, strong gusts of wind and01:37:22
God forbid anyone else was hurt or there in connection01:37:25
with this something went wrong there somewhere01:37:27
suffered, someone drowned and so on01:37:32
they will also get to those who did01:37:35
forecasts if the forecast did not indicate01:37:37
what's there01:37:38
flood and all sorts of floods01:37:42
can cross all sorts of boundaries then they can01:37:45
have complaints against those who made the forecast01:37:48
Although something tells me that in general01:37:50
everyone assumed and the story is exactly with01:37:54
this unfortunate dam which is either01:37:56
the mice ate it or people took it apart, well01:38:00
really, it looks funny, well, well01:38:02
It's a shame to say such things. Listen, well01:38:04
you don't know what kind of mice there are maybe01:38:06
there are such mice that wow, just like everyone else01:38:08
ladies might know Maxim Kurnikov He01:38:11
practically from these places he is all there01:38:13
traveled and climbed and from the side01:38:15
Kazakhstan and from Orenburg he was01:38:18
even in my opinion the editor-in-chief of the echo01:38:19
Orenburg at one time and now I don’t remember01:38:22
main01:38:29
con01:38:30
Izu So it seems to me that01:38:32
here Masima yes you will meet Max If01:38:36
you will talk to him, keep in mind01:38:38
that he knows exactly what size01:38:40
mice in the Orenburg region, I'm sure01:38:42
absolutely, well, well, really, it's terrible And01:38:46
By the way, it just so happened that01:38:48
the day before that's what we were talking about01:38:52
I'll give it to you, we're not in any danger there01:38:55
That's all01:38:57
And who pulled his tongue? No, he01:39:00
went and checked everyone was worried he was there01:39:08
trampled and warmed up But it’s not his fault01:39:11
he's not a mouse expert after all.01:39:14
he he the head of the city is not really for me01:39:18
I think I just read it01:39:22
material from journalists who visited01:39:24
these flooded flooded houses and01:39:27
places, but on the cedar this is exactly what01:39:31
Ira Vorobyova gave us a lot to read01:39:34
very interesting and says a lot01:39:37
Well, first of all, there are people who say01:39:39
what if our mayor was Vladimir01:39:41
Vladimirovich, of course we would have something like this01:39:43
it wasn’t Oh yes, he’s delving into it01:39:47
he always checks everything himself01:39:50
I'll include the details, but the mayor and I don't01:39:52
I was lucky and this is how it turned out in reality01:39:55
many said that this year there is no01:39:58
it will be so pompous Well, that’s quite enough01:40:01
strange considering how snowy it was01:40:03
winter Well, that is, it’s clear that these01:40:04
the processes are much more complicated but it seems to me01:40:07
straight logic when you think sharply01:40:10
it got warmer there was a lot of snow then it01:40:13
It's getting warmer Therefore it will all start01:40:15
to melt somewhere Well, here you and I live01:40:17
in not01:40:19
floods it seems that somehow everything01:40:22
I foretold that by the way, even I live in01:40:26
in general, on seven hills, roughly speaking, that’s all01:40:29
I still thought there was so much snow01:40:31
there was so much snow and I thought that now01:40:33
everything will melt, you won’t be able to go outside at all01:40:34
there will be just waist-deep water Well, yes, but01:40:36
somehow it went away very quickly and there was no water01:40:39
everything just evaporated and vice versa01:40:41
sandstorms started because all01:40:43
this ice was covered in layers of sand01:40:46
methodically with salt and grated with this01:40:49
now it’s marble or something like that01:40:51
baby And when I and01:40:57
All01:40:59
ew so my predictions are perfect01:41:04
did not come true And in the meantime we01:41:07
finally finally we see already01:41:09
our next01:41:10
guest we were just waiting to meet him Yes to01:41:14
Dmitry Zakhvatov joins us01:41:16
Dmitry good morning01:41:18
zra We represent you as a lawyer and01:41:21
human rights activist there is nothing Yes everything01:41:24
ok good And then as a lawyer and01:41:26
human rights activist we would like to ask you01:41:29
What could the bill entail?01:41:30
which is now in the third reading of the State Duma01:41:33
approved the bill on01:41:35
Bar you know this bill -01:41:37
this is just a continuation of the series so to speak01:41:40
to the Bar01:41:43
and the ongoing attempt is completely01:41:46
shackled completely put under01:41:48
control of the Ministry of Justice to deprive her01:41:51
all sorts of beginnings01:41:53
independence01:41:56
actually how much it will be01:41:57
different from what we already see01:41:59
now this is a statement of some new01:42:02
norms or are these the same norms that01:42:04
we see at the moment that01:42:06
they will just be legally01:42:07
fixed just needed01:42:09
make more efforts to get a lawyer01:42:11
remove from work to create01:42:12
there is no problem for the lawyer, there are a number of01:42:16
quite suspicious01:42:18
alarming innovations in particular01:42:21
one additional term is introduced01:42:23
qualification commissions, let me remind you that01:42:24
qualification commissions are01:42:26
commissions that decide on issues01:42:29
suitability of the candidate to receive01:42:32
status of a lawyer, reception of him01:42:33
qualifying exam01:42:35
disciplinary proceedings01:42:38
Yes in case including in relation01:42:40
unwanted lawyers if current in01:42:44
The old or rather now version of the law01:42:46
it was envisaged that the composition01:42:48
qualification commissions include 1301:42:51
people of which seven are lawyers and01:42:54
the remaining six people are two judges01:42:56
two representatives of the Ministry of Justice and two01:42:59
representatives of the legislative branch01:43:01
subject of the Federation then now to these01:43:04
six more votes can be added01:43:08
it would be more accurate to add one more Voice from01:43:10
representative quoting the bill01:43:12
scientific community what is it01:43:14
completely understandable but apparently we are talking about01:43:16
representatives of any01:43:21
Universities are now bending the line01:43:24
humanitarian you all know well yes it is01:43:27
that's how crazy Marco is01:43:29
history talked about exactly this today01:43:32
Yes Yes01:43:34
Accordingly, the issue is now resolved01:43:37
about deprivation, for example, of the status of an objectionable01:43:40
lawyer in case this happens01:43:42
it will be much easier to01:43:44
compared to how it happens on01:43:47
current moment what if before01:43:48
after all, all the votes exceeded six then01:43:51
now it will be at least01:43:54
And here you need to understand that the following01:43:56
bill because they are always fierce01:43:58
you know we have the power to cook this or01:44:00
another frog is always on low heat01:44:02
when they don't make moves next01:44:04
with the bill they can easily introduce01:44:07
composition of the commission one more person for01:44:10
in order to outweigh these lawyers01:44:12
votes and thus deprive the commission01:44:22
these squats are funny01:44:25
Well, the truth is here 6 na se let's01:44:28
let's do it one on one and do it all or01:44:32
I’ll just sign everything, I don’t know there01:44:34
Head of the Supreme Court Well, how is it Modus01:44:38
You understand this modus operandi Yes it is01:44:42
everyone has this way of doing things01:44:46
the criminal has criminal handwriting Yes01:44:48
if he serially commits certain01:44:50
crimes But our Russian01:44:52
the authorities are here, the modus operandi is here01:44:54
they never do something like this01:44:56
sudden movements after rare rare rare01:44:58
a rare exception when it becomes01:45:00
They are completely scared and prefer to make do01:45:02
with one or another public organization01:45:06
or with any protest group yes01:45:10
Or with some institute like this01:45:13
very neat01:45:18
courtesy is gradually depriving him01:45:21
independence right so on just01:45:24
Well, this is how they work01:45:26
accepted and therefore no need to search here01:45:27
no logic in this you are absolutely01:45:30
right in that at the moment01:45:33
disbar any lawyer01:45:35
does not represent any status at all01:45:37
There is absolutely no need for labor for this.01:45:39
interact with no chamber01:45:41
the lawyer's office is just a crypt01:45:44
I apologize for it being political01:45:47
criminal case as it happened with01:45:49
Navalny's defenders, for example, yes Or01:45:51
there with Dmitry the talented01:45:53
this is done in 5 seconds01:45:55
no special knowledge or skills for this01:45:58
no skills required and through criminal prosecution01:46:01
conviction in fact the status of a lawyer01:46:03
there is no problem in selecting a person01:46:07
this I have I apologize for these01:46:11
as far as I understand there are more changes01:46:13
such a cute thing, like deprivation of status01:46:16
lawyer for the absence of m within01:46:20
Russian Federation let's say this if01:46:23
the person is, as far as I understand, behind01:46:25
outside Russia he is deprived01:46:27
lawyer status automatically Well01:46:29
this is what I don’t understand at all why they are01:46:31
to be honest, they introduced it because, well, that’s it01:46:35
famous lawyers who are forced01:46:37
were to leave Russia anyway01:46:39
they continue to work one way or another01:46:41
they still keep writing01:46:43
procedural documents organize01:46:45
their human rights ka01:46:47
organizations didn’t organize01:46:50
That's why01:46:53
Apparently for this purpose, well, you know, the absence01:46:56
lawyer's license or01:46:57
lack of status does not hinder you01:47:00
opportunities to write procedural01:47:02
documents and organize work with01:47:04
any person can be selected01:47:06
the certificate can be revoked by anyone01:47:08
titles and positions and even possible01:47:10
cancel his diploma01:47:11
for example about higher education because01:47:13
courts are controlled by the state and suddenly01:47:16
maybe it will turn out that in fact01:47:18
this law degree was obtained there01:47:19
in some illegal way two01:47:21
the person didn't pass the exam01:47:23
Uh-huh Yes, after 25 years this can happen01:47:26
can be easily found out given01:47:28
features of our judicial system01:47:30
which is entirely in01:47:31
dependent on the state but you are not01:47:33
you can't take away a person's knowledge01:47:35
you can take away a person's experience01:47:37
you can take it from a person01:47:38
organizational skills and therefore01:47:42
this norm Well, she's just stupid honestly01:47:44
saying because well they will deprive01:47:47
status of those who left, lawyer, what does this mean?01:47:50
nothing will change from this at all01:47:52
will change01:47:53
no way01:47:54
will prevent lawyers who have left from continuing01:47:58
work as they work while in01:48:01
exile to advise people who01:48:05
are also located on the territory01:48:07
Russia may not be able to help the defenders01:48:11
so experienced and directly01:48:14
work on the land, go to court and01:48:17
the investigation is preparing legal proceedings for them01:48:18
positions Well Next01:48:21
under scares Yes but but actually if01:48:26
look at exactly this part uh01:48:29
law01:48:31
in such a sober Yes look with a homie01:48:34
the rest We will very quickly understand what it is01:48:36
just some stupidity, well maybe01:48:39
to be just the goal This is such a scarecrow for01:48:41
so that lawyers who are considering01:48:43
about what they weren’t doing01:48:45
did not leave for political affairs01:48:47
just in case from Russia and behaved01:48:50
decency01:48:53
don't interfere, don't bother, don't01:48:55
defended I'm afraid that those lawyers who01:48:57
were forced to leave Russia due to01:49:00
threats01:49:01
persecution are special people01:49:04
sort of yes It’s like, for example, journalists01:49:07
who also left Russia because of the threat01:49:09
persecution is just business in general01:49:11
whole life And therefore it would be enough01:49:14
it's weird to scare them like that01:49:17
stupidity01:49:18
deprivation of status on the grounds01:49:21
criticized the law, including01:49:24
by the international community Well, we're talking01:49:26
not only about such special lawyers01:49:28
who decided absolutely radically01:49:31
I'm doing everything right If I have to, I'll leave01:49:33
If necessary, I will sacrifice everything And for sure01:49:35
there are some people, some lawyers01:49:37
who Well doubt whether they want to be01:49:39
such desperate human rights activists or01:49:41
after all, work is more expensive and important to them01:49:44
Well, once again those people who left and01:49:48
engage in human rights protection from abroad01:49:50
they left for a reason and those lawyers01:49:53
who left just like that I think that they01:49:56
normal Oddly enough, it won’t affect me at all01:49:58
I also read that now lawyers01:50:00
chambers will be required to initiate01:50:02
disciplinary proceedings against01:50:04
lawyers for any representation01:50:07
Ministry of Justice, this is how serious it is01:50:11
the limitation is just coming back01:50:14
to the first part of my01:50:19
[music]01:50:23
pressure on independent human rights defenders01:50:25
Russian if it was possible before01:50:27
refuse this or that body01:50:30
consideration of his submission to01:50:33
consideration of his complaint about behavior01:50:37
defender simply because01:50:41
this statement Well actually or in this01:50:42
the complaint contains no basis for01:50:44
response of the legal authorities01:50:46
self-government then in the present01:50:49
moment the law directly says that01:50:52
now it’s territorial01:50:54
federal division of the Ministry of Justice if01:50:56
makes such a complaint then the council01:50:58
the chamber is obliged, strictly speaking,01:51:00
react transfer it all to01:51:03
consideration of the coalition commission I01:51:06
Dmitry wanted to contact you with01:51:09
asking citizens to tell01:51:13
citizens what do they need now including01:51:16
and in the light of all sorts of recent ideas01:51:20
concerning01:51:21
lawyers can count on what01:51:23
after all, the lawyer has the right. Here we sit01:51:26
Lisa and I are steaming somewhere01:51:29
preceding01:51:52
touch any person caught in Well01:51:55
in different circumstances according to the current01:51:57
people don’t know the rules at all01:51:59
why do you need a lawyer and he is needed for01:52:02
some very specific actions from01:52:05
to protect your rights, they tell us01:52:07
for example, what after being detained at01:52:09
rally Yes at such and such01:52:11
Internal Affairs Directorate does not allow lawyer in, announces plan01:52:14
interception But the lawyer has this01:52:17
right fortress yes yes interception is01:52:20
other Yes and01:52:23
something changes in this situation or in01:52:26
this area is still the rights of lawyers01:52:28
remain01:52:29
unshakable if your question sounds like01:52:32
in the context of this bill Yes01:52:34
which was adopted in the third reading01:52:37
then of course01:52:40
it's long overdue01:52:42
issue of protection of professional rights01:52:45
lawyers because Advocacy in Russia01:52:49
this is such a very weak weak link01:52:52
justice system, a lawyer has enough01:52:55
few01:52:59
powers can be ignored01:53:01
it’s easy not to respond to a lawyer’s request01:53:02
on01:53:03
him01:53:06
you can for this Despite the fact that01:53:08
responsibility is provided but history01:53:09
I know quite a few cases when someone01:53:11
whatever this responsibility01:53:12
firstly they attracted and secondly there01:53:15
absolutely ridiculous amount of traffic for01:53:17
failure to comply with a lawyer's request01:53:19
the lawyer's request is very important01:53:24
protect a person, for example, or search01:53:28
person if01:53:32
M not guaranteed the right to a lawyer How do you01:53:35
Right01:53:36
noticed on access to your principal01:53:39
According to the Constitution, everyone has the right to01:53:41
defender from the moment of actual01:53:44
detention is a constitutional norm01:53:47
systematically01:53:50
she is ignored by Rita and investigated by the police01:53:54
cases by operational services are not uncommon01:53:57
the use of physical violence simply01:53:59
attitude towards a lawyer you can remember01:54:01
the history of covid times was and is01:54:06
lawyer Diana Pinova who was beaten and01:54:10
a fabricated case just in connection with01:54:14
because she was trying to get to her01:54:17
client also lawyer01:54:20
to the world later01:54:22
of course they justified that it was enough01:54:24
an unprecedented case but nevertheless she01:54:26
I just went through all the circles of hell and some01:54:30
time was even under such measures01:54:32
suppression as a ban on certain01:54:36
action adversarial in our courts01:54:39
As you know01:54:40
she is absent01:54:42
in fact you can offer huge01:54:48
quantity01:54:49
analytics evidence01:54:52
ven if they are involved in the case then01:54:55
They don't necessarily have to be01:54:57
taken into account by the court and even in judicial01:54:59
sentences01:55:01
It’s not a fact that they will be addressed01:55:05
attention Although the law requires it and01:55:10
so what can we say here?01:55:13
Because the judiciary is very weak01:55:16
You see, the problem is independent01:55:19
court fun lawyer01:55:22
so weak enough Well, that is, she is in01:55:25
law01:55:26
spelled out more how to say more sensibly01:55:29
still than in reality01:55:33
fulfilled Yes of course and and these are01:55:36
the changes do not concern just these01:55:38
Advocacy does not concern defense issues01:55:41
lawyers' rights does not concern the issue01:55:43
which long ago Nara but at01:55:46
This bill is aimed at the opposite01:55:50
then to deprive yourself of01:55:52
lawyer self-government which01:55:54
as a matter of fact, they should by and large01:55:56
happy to deal with issues01:55:59
professional rights protection of professional rights01:56:02
lawyers Although in reality We01:56:04
we see that they are dealing with these issues01:56:06
also weak in different ways01:56:08
reasons basically now When a person01:56:11
gets caught in a political case for01:56:15
comparing the grille with the pre-military ones01:56:17
years01:56:19
him01:56:22
legs lawyers left many lawyers01:56:24
they are afraid of persecution because we01:56:27
saw examples when the lawyers themselves01:56:29
when the lawyers themselves became01:56:30
persons involved in criminal cases It’s clear01:56:33
that now everyone is much more unprotected01:56:35
But how much If you're talking about01:56:38
human rights activists, of course, not all01:56:40
enough01:56:43
for that totality of criminal cases01:56:46
political ones today01:56:55
I had a search and detained a man01:56:59
dawn and so on Sometimes it just passes01:57:02
several times a day and those01:57:05
human rights lawyers who01:57:07
have been doing this for a long time and collaborate with01:57:22
no less Well01:57:25
to every citizen in respect of whom01:57:28
a criminal case has been initiated against him in any01:57:31
in case will be provided free of charge01:57:32
defender But how good will he be01:57:34
work of course it's very big01:57:35
question This is a very clear state01:57:39
poorly finances this part of the work in01:57:43
justice system there who01:57:46
works in the state system He01:57:50
I feel like this year's defender01:57:53
This is how I felt it in connection with the courts01:57:57
little law enforcement activity01:57:59
has general protection of rights01:58:01
citizens it functions a little according to01:58:03
other templates and I'm just kidding01:58:07
by and large they do not01:58:09
law enforcement activities they01:58:10
they do statistics, that is, they01:58:12
customize01:58:13
indicators01:58:15
through administrative01:58:18
manipulation detection rates01:58:22
initiated criminal cases solved01:58:25
for the same period last year yes01:58:29
and thus receive an assessment of their01:58:32
activity is generally a disaster for anyone01:58:34
centralized police system A01:58:36
our police system is01:58:39
centralized, well, here’s the totality01:58:41
all these problems, that is, the absence01:58:43
independent01:58:45
court centralized police officer01:58:47
apparatus is weak Advocacy they bring01:58:51
actually to the results that we01:58:53
today we see that you are not01:58:55
you can actually achieve01:58:57
Justice in court And if you can01:58:59
it happens once there in01:59:01
five-year plan and then, as a rule, only in01:59:04
jury trials Yes01:59:07
political compositions they are not01:59:10
provide for the possibility of considering01:59:13
jury trials therefore those01:59:16
100% of them end in accuser01:59:19
sentence to one degree or another01:59:23
severity01:59:25
And01:59:26
we have, I wanted to ask in conclusion01:59:29
you Dmitry if01:59:31
Maybe01:59:32
Remind citizens that they should01:59:35
It’s nice to have your own rights too01:59:37
know That's how it is with lawyers, yes with01:59:40
For human rights activists, everything is complicated, but with rights01:59:42
everything means the same with rights, everything too01:59:44
It’s not easy But here’s an example01:59:47
stories about these door-to-door visits01:59:50
in order to find out if anyone should join the army01:59:54
Well I'm being rude01:59:57
formulate What for example02:00:00
a district police officer is not the same as a Group02:00:03
capture and that the district police officer is completely02:00:05
it is not necessary to open the Doors wide for him02:00:07
he can't break down the door now or anything02:00:09
nothing terrible will happen Well, some more02:00:11
these are the things you would pay attention to02:00:13
pay attention to what people are called Well02:00:17
I pierce and act against themselves02:00:22
enough that it's very big02:00:23
extensive topic and put it down02:00:26
E 5 minutes is impossible But the most general things02:00:30
if you are afraid of mobilization and you02:00:32
you are afraid that the local police officer will come to you or02:00:34
police officer or if you or if02:00:37
you hear a knock on the door and you like02:00:39
You'll see through the door peephole what's there02:00:42
a man who introduces himself02:00:43
police officer and he asks you02:00:46
open the door but you can you must02:00:49
understand that you simply don’t have to02:00:50
do unless we are talking about02:00:55
You will not be searched for this at all02:00:58
it's okay if you don't take this door02:01:03
open if you don't know If02:01:05
police officer on the street or in the department02:01:08
the police or anywhere else asks02:01:10
you have a lot of awkward questions, yes02:01:12
you must understand what you may have02:01:15
you have every right not to answer these questions02:01:17
if you are detained and demanded of you02:01:19
unlock Leo's mobile and understand02:01:22
that you are not obligated to unlock your02:01:24
mobile phone and nothing will happen to you02:01:26
in case of refusal, unlock it and02:01:30
Moreover, you need to be very careful02:01:32
take care of your own safety02:01:36
set a two-factor password everywhere02:01:39
authentication in order to02:01:41
strangers, including02:01:44
employees did not have access to this02:01:50
information do not answer anything you can02:01:53
to be honest and say that I don’t know what02:01:56
tell you because I'm afraid of you and I02:01:59
it's uncomfortable to be around you02:02:01
so I won't tell you anything and and02:02:03
we will only talk02:02:04
presence of a lawyer What if you don’t tell me02:02:06
introduce him So we won't02:02:07
talk to you at all And this sounds like02:02:10
There's only a little time left of us02:02:12
for a couple of minutes it sounds very good but02:02:14
in theory, when your doorbell rings02:02:17
you are policemen02:02:18
you say adults, no one is home I02:02:21
no one02:02:23
so in practice there is a feeling that02:02:24
it will only make them angry and no02:02:26
legal norms won't work here you are02:02:28
if you show off, I won't let you02:02:30
see what's good on my phone02:02:32
resisting the police with their muzzle to the floor02:02:34
a criminal case and, by the way, they can02:02:36
just start02:02:38
beat Well, you see, we live unfortunately in02:02:42
so historical02:02:44
reality that I can't help you as a person02:02:48
with experience I can say that it’s perfect02:02:52
problems associated with violence Yes with02:02:54
to the police, but I can say absolutely02:02:57
definitely just for refusing to unlock02:02:58
telephone You are absolutely according to the law02:03:01
will not receive any persecution because02:03:04
that this is your privacy and for02:03:09
in order to extract information from you02:03:11
By and large, the phone is needed judicially02:03:15
some kind of ruling But Priya despite02:03:18
on the totem02:03:22
country that we have02:03:24
the security forces are all strong, but here's how it's not02:03:27
paradoxically some certain ones Oh02:03:29
I'm sorry, he's finally here02:03:32
appeared And then we are all tail Yes tail02:03:34
we see yes yes this is Lucia apparently she is to me02:03:39
will help you tell what02:03:41
something happens despite this02:03:44
standards of decency are still forced02:03:47
Well, for some reason they are not forced02:03:49
in particular no one will comply02:03:50
break down the door02:03:52
a search warrant is not in question there02:03:55
detaining someone really02:03:57
armed criminal who entered02:04:00
give you an apartment and take you02:04:02
Hostage and these things They02:04:07
of course, nevertheless it is fulfilled02:04:10
in general, citizens, this is not the same, don’t try02:04:14
be more law-abiding02:04:17
assumes02:04:20
say Thank you for meeting Luke or02:04:24
like like Lucia Yes with02:04:27
lucius and this is where we'll probably end02:04:33
our legal department02:04:36
Thank you for being with us, and by the way02:04:38
I draw the attention of all our listeners02:04:40
spectators you wanted to leave And then you would02:04:43
didn’t see so much beauty and didn’t02:04:44
heard so many useful things Dmitry02:04:47
We had a lawyer on the air and02:04:49
human rights activist, thank you for coming to us02:04:51
We continue our turn, we have 1 left02:04:54
an hour before the end of this morning02:04:56
broadcast and we will spend this hour with Alexey02:04:59
Venediktov will have more after this02:05:02
many programs we have02:05:03
traditionally come out every day at my place02:05:05
I don't have a schedule at hand right now02:05:08
I'll read it to you again today Friday02:05:10
there are announcements there and yours personally there02:05:13
there is and of course a real colonel02:05:14
traditional Friday broadcast, and02:05:18
tomorrow we also have a morning spread02:05:19
tomorrow the day after tomorrow Tomorrow I'm with02:05:22
Bolshakova the day after tomorrow with Vasily02:05:23
Polonskiy as always variety So02:05:25
that tomorrow is also a must come02:05:28
i.n. Media don't pass by02:05:31
look at the light, scroll through our02:05:34
virtual books to choose02:05:36
what do you like best and buy there02:05:38
there are old ones there are also new ones02:05:40
We sell all different editions02:05:42
interesting all useful all cool Well02:05:45
and we move on to the news and then to02:05:47
Alexey Venediktov02:06:00
11:00 in Moscow at the microphone Lisa Anikina02:06:03
this is news on a live nail, the air defense was shot down02:06:06
five more drones on the territory02:06:07
Belgorod region earlier this morning02:06:10
The Ministry of Defense reported the destruction02:06:11
four Drones in the Rostov region02:06:14
Astro's sources claim that02:06:16
Novoshakhtinsk oil refinery plant attacked02:06:18
confirmations yet02:06:20
no The Ministry of Transport ordered to strengthen protection02:06:23
airports from drones, RBC found out02:06:25
the department confirmed this without specifying02:06:27
what measures are we talking about according to the information02:06:30
building protection should be strengthened to02:06:31
airfields classified as the first and second02:06:34
categories of transport objects02:06:35
infrastructure among them Vnukov02:06:37
Sheremetyev and02:06:39
Domodedov in Dagestan FSB and Ministry of Internal Affairs02:06:42
detained former and current02:06:44
Rosseti Severny employees02:06:46
Caucasus they are suspected of stealing about 302:06:49
billion rubles from the budget02:06:52
arrest Soviet court of Makhachkala They02:06:54
are in season02:06:56
Pyatigorsk journalist Maria Ponomarenko02:06:59
went on a hunger strike after her02:07:01
sent to solitary confinement by colony officers02:07:04
threatened her with a phone ban02:07:05
conversations with my mother were forced to write02:07:07
explanatory During lunch and picked up02:07:10
things and products were told by the lawyer02:07:12
Ponomarenko was sentenced to 6 years02:07:14
distribution case02:07:16
fakes naha doubled in rosni02:07:21
under the article on voluntary surrender02:07:23
it provides for up to 10 years in prison02:07:26
the military man is also accused of desertion in02:07:28
mobilization period case details02:07:30
including the name of the accused02:07:32
the court's press service02:07:34
reveal Russia ignored more02:07:36
2.5 thousand decisions of the European Court on02:07:39
human rights follows from the report02:07:41
Committee of Ministers of the Council of Europe general02:07:43
the amount of unpaid compensation for these02:07:45
cases exceed 2 billion euros law on02:07:48
non-execution of ECtHR decisions was adopted in02:07:50
Russia in June 202202:07:53
Switzerland will hold a referendum on02:07:56
the issue of preserving traditional02:07:58
Swiss neutrality initiative02:08:00
people's party has collected the necessary02:08:02
number of votes neutrality02:08:03
assumes non-participation in military alliances02:08:06
as well as the rejection of non-military02:08:07
coercive measures including sanctions writes02:08:10
financial Times date02:08:12
no referendum yet02:08:13
designated Stalin's estate near Moscow02:08:16
Lipka Alekseevskaya bought in Mytishchi02:08:18
company associated with the ex's family02:08:20
Krasnodar02:08:21
Alexandra Tkacheva reports RBC estate02:08:24
was in an abandoned state experts02:08:26
estimate the cost of the complex at 400-50002:08:29
million rubles it was live news02:08:32
let's continue02:08:35
broadcast and before Alexey Venediktov02:08:38
will join our morning02:08:40
U-turn Need to lower the die02:09:26
and drum roll Alexey Venediktov02:09:29
finally joins the morning02:09:31
Good morning Hello02:09:33
Alexey Alekseevich good immediately02:09:35
subdued02:09:37
still can't see it02:09:41
Well I hope they fix it now02:09:44
somehow but I think we can02:09:46
for now start without a picture I think that02:09:48
viewers listeners and va02:09:52
SLT everyone continues to be in02:09:54
some tension about02:09:56
Iranian-Iraqi prospects02:10:12
but what did you take away from this conversation?02:10:15
how serious are these02:10:18
fears No, it’s clear that there are fears02:10:22
In general, attacks are taken seriously here02:10:25
this is not the first day and not the first year, but02:10:28
point from where Iran will launch if02:10:31
will run a big question and in addition02:10:34
no matter what this has to do with it02:10:36
seriously it has always been like that but we02:10:38
We know, for example, that yesterday the minister02:10:41
foreign affairs of the countries of the European Union02:10:45
large countries Germany France called02:10:48
to the Iranian Foreign Minister02:10:52
prevent escalation and do the same thing02:10:55
ministers of saudi arabia egypt02:10:57
In Jordan, everyone understands that Israel02:10:59
will answer02:11:01
Yes, and of course this is a big escalation02:11:05
regarding the events here, I have02:11:07
today we taught how to behave when02:11:09
rocket fire where to go how to run A02:11:12
if there is nowhere to run how to sit what02:11:15
cover parts of the body If suddenly on the street02:11:18
turned out to be Nothing so everything is all right here02:11:21
this is not taken seriously here02:11:31
giggles02:11:34
They also reminded me of that02:11:38
how to behave look around Wherever02:11:40
shelter Here and so on Uh-huh But by the way02:11:43
I wanted to ask you about this, here you are02:11:46
directly see for yourself How it is02:11:49
It may not even be working for the first time02:11:50
once02:11:53
a Do you think in Russia no one02:11:56
it occurred to me that these are the ones02:11:59
skills that exist in Israel02:12:02
of the entire population And for part of the Russian02:12:05
population in general would be useful02:12:08
somehow give instructions to people there02:12:12
I don't know what to do there02:12:14
master classes Sorry to conduct something02:12:16
this needs to be done in addition to some things02:12:19
I don’t know about evacuations, there are sirens and everything02:12:23
other things No, well, look, first of all02:12:27
this is the sun, these are all very protocols02:12:29
traumatic for ordinary people02:12:32
interrupt their usual activities and their02:12:36
ordinary life and find yourself in a situation02:12:39
exceptionally crisis with a threat to02:12:41
life in Israel, shelling occurs every02:12:44
day again I was not mistaken every day or02:12:47
another city02:12:51
you get confused a lot but there are tacos there02:12:54
feature of the fragments falling from the sun is equal to02:12:57
of course, that’s why this is already a certain image02:13:00
life who was brought up Excuse me 7502:13:04
years of existence of the State of Israel02:13:06
and people there understand that this is necessary02:13:09
You can behave like this, but not like this, I’ll remind you02:13:11
that when we were trolleybus explosions02:13:14
Moscow at one time had special02:13:17
protocols do not touch packets Yes call02:13:19
if anything02:13:24
and after02:13:26
these people just forgot about them because02:13:28
nothing was repeated because it was not02:13:30
has become a way of life somewhere in02:13:34
Belgorod region probably really02:13:36
we need to do this now or Kursk02:13:39
region or Voronezh region where02:13:41
every day anyway02:13:43
Belgorodskaya02:13:46
areas of that02:13:52
this is absolutely02:13:55
impossible I remembered by the way About02:13:58
About these02:13:59
our traditional aggravation02:14:02
security that occurs after02:14:04
some kind of disaster after02:14:07
some after a terrorist attack and so on02:14:10
Crocus passes there literally a day or two a day02:14:14
public transport in02:14:16
metro starts more carefully02:14:18
I don't have to look through backpacks02:14:22
look at the mogu02:14:24
nothing The usual story is what happens in02:14:27
France02:14:30
there would be a daily threat all this is there02:14:34
exceptional understand yes but here it is not02:14:38
this is a bond02:14:40
this is the norm in life, so I want to understand you02:14:43
would like it to be, well, what?02:14:46
It’s safer to introduce this as a norm, here I am02:14:50
Don't know02:14:53
ve in our country or is it still02:14:56
too traumatizing really and only02:14:59
unnerving02:15:01
people once again I repeat to lead now to02:15:05
Belgorod probably needs a02:15:08
in the region it’s probably not necessary and in Kharkov02:15:11
Kharkovskaya what am I telling Kharkovskaya02:15:13
region this is already Vedeno ukra02:15:22
empty I see, but just about02:15:26
no need, obviously now02:15:28
Russian authorities continue their tactics02:15:31
this rear life which is Central02:15:33
the war is somewhere far away, life is with us02:15:36
nothing goes on everyone02:15:38
changes as much as you think02:15:40
justifies itself from the point of view02:15:42
mood You just looked at02:15:44
Israel Where is the shelling where is it hard where02:15:46
scary and you're basically watching02:15:48
what is happening in Russia What02:15:49
more effective in terms of02:15:51
society For example02:15:54
I don't even really understand your question02:15:58
in fact, it means once again in Israel - this02:16:01
image02:16:02
this won't surprise anyone in life02:16:05
sirens will not surprise anyone with the presence02:16:08
fortified rooms will not surprise anyone02:16:10
the presence of bomb shelters is of no concern to anyone02:16:14
you will surprise anyone with rules of behavior02:16:16
no surprise, and it continues02:16:18
I repeat many ten02:16:22
People were already born with these protocols02:16:25
Russian Federation this02:16:28
no consolidation of society How does it know02:16:31
occurs during a crisis during02:16:34
crises it arises around either02:16:36
certain ideas or certain02:16:39
people we see public surveys02:16:41
opinions regarding the so-called02:16:44
special military02:16:51
slaughter begin to fight for the youth02:16:53
statements were written with reference to their02:16:54
sources that are going to create02:16:56
a special Ministry that will02:16:58
actively develop among Russians02:17:00
patriotic feelings in general we and02:17:02
we are already seeing such a struggle for02:17:04
patriotism within the Russian Federation02:17:06
but now apparently it will be for this02:17:07
special department This is how much02:17:10
effective Is it possible not to02:17:14
effective none effective02:17:16
Ministry02:17:21
can cultivate patriotic feelings02:17:23
Yes, this is another story with a cut02:17:25
budget Yes with the appointment of new02:17:28
officials who will report on02:17:30
number of pioneer ties and02:17:32
Komsomol badges issued and this02:17:35
everything That's why power02:17:39
who is used to solving problems without02:17:41
political, that is, not compromise02:17:44
stories And bureaucratic yes02:17:47
with orders we lower from below from above to below02:17:50
from bottom to top with reports and this is all done02:17:54
For show, for point of view02:17:57
efficiency wears I would say wrong02:17:59
that is zero And as history shows02:18:01
The Soviet Union and its collapse minus02:18:03
character but they don't teach anything02:18:07
It's not just bourbons I wanted, I wanted02:18:10
I also need to ask about efficiency because02:18:13
what the heck02:18:15
that's when it comes to safety02:18:19
the effectiveness of our our people in terms of02:18:22
our structures02:18:24
I see, this is what's happening now02:18:29
flooding Wait, I don’t understand What?02:18:32
Means02:18:33
understandable What do you understand? Well02:18:35
efficiency is this is to report that we02:18:39
we strengthened it, which means we started checking there02:18:43
something else, well, that’s enough too02:18:45
bureaucratic reaction That's how they02:18:49
we also prove their effectiveness02:18:50
we know exactly the same as with the pioneers or02:18:52
there they are Komsomol members02:18:55
list numbers there are numbers of people02:18:58
whom they involved in it there, what in02:19:01
reality is happening, it's already different02:19:02
the question is with the flood Well we02:19:05
I know God But we know, for example, what's wrong02:19:08
the moment the missile hit the02:19:12
Senate dome in the Kremlin no more02:19:16
rockets up02:19:17
Moscow, they all get lost on the leakage of Moscow02:19:21
we know that the airports that used to be02:19:23
closed at night Yes, as if they weren’t flying02:19:26
because drones and missiles were flying in or02:19:28
there's something there that doesn't close now02:19:30
This is the question02:19:31
efficiency yes yes that is a question02:19:36
efficiency, that is, there is bureaucracy02:19:38
times Yes, you can judge by reading that02:19:43
this is actually happening02:19:45
complex movement complex Ministry of Energy02:19:51
Not so02:19:52
is being done Why do you think this02:19:54
initially02:19:56
ineffective because it is ineffective02:19:58
Because it's not achieved02:20:06
bureaucratic decisions02:20:10
OBZh I answer with public discussions02:20:14
discussion talking about what it is02:20:17
patriotism02:20:21
this sun is born in competition in02:20:23
this is not a public field02:20:25
exists and therefore it is natural02:20:28
takes on the character of carrion, that is02:20:31
instructions02:20:33
instructions02:20:35
Well, how is a modern young man02:20:39
whose hand there is opportunity02:20:42
via iPhone or something else02:20:44
go into the world will perceive02:20:46
instruction You must Love your Motherland02:20:48
must love someone there Well, Sami02:20:51
think about it, well, there are other ways02:20:54
Bota farms are there. Propaganda is also there.02:20:57
For example02:20:58
the arrival of new people in places like02:21:02
RSUH there are all sorts of institutes and so on02:21:05
when they come there the philosopher Dugin02:21:09
when some of his lectures are given there02:21:12
let's say02:21:13
supporters It works Stop it02:21:16
stop being scared stop being scared02:21:19
shake acts don't understand02:21:23
We have philosophers of the arc in PM there02:21:27
sat in every office for a year02:21:31
and there were no other philosophers in each02:21:34
What's called02:21:37
and we have a Komsomol organization02:21:40
Youth Yes there was what it was 12 million 1502:21:43
million people and and whom02:21:48
philosopher and all races and everything fell apart because02:21:51
that young people accepted it as02:21:54
carrion as feeding02:21:57
doh it will be so And what is living and this is what02:22:00
living You see what can attract02:22:04
for real02:22:05
uh Why02:22:07
strives the most02:22:09
such a lively and young part of Russia and it02:22:14
I like to shoot and kill there02:22:18
work I don't I don't know actually thought02:22:22
yes You need to do scientific work on this K02:22:25
what the young part of Russia strives for no02:22:27
no young part of Russia yes02:22:29
there are completely different people with02:22:31
different02:22:32
we see interests in surveys, for example02:22:35
according to all-Russian polls from different02:22:39
social services people there02:22:42
1824 in its absolute majority 2 p02:22:46
advocate peace and peaceful02:22:48
negotiation02:22:50
people 60 plus are in favor of the majority02:22:55
continuation of hostilities against02:22:57
Ukraine no matter how it was02:22:58
formulated we see a generation gap02:23:02
young people want to live in peace, we are not now02:23:04
discuss On what conditions in the world Not02:23:06
shoot not kill how02:23:09
once yes, but completely different Well, here you go02:23:12
please because modern02:23:15
opportunities for moji technologically they02:23:17
it's like killing people02:23:22
live in small towns and villages and02:23:25
leveled the odds and opened the world to them02:23:27
Of course they want to live in peace in one02:23:30
sense in the world and in another sense in the world02:23:33
Yes, and this is evident from the survey, that’s what he wants02:23:37
youth Well, this is natural Probably02:23:40
after all02:23:42
it's natural02:23:44
the movement of the young wants to live and live by02:23:48
the possibilities are interesting02:23:50
and this cannot be reversed, as you think02:23:54
this is natural02:23:56
motion suggest something else02:24:00
I know this can’t be reversed. Suggest02:24:04
this is not possible02:24:05
I want to change the subject a little and02:24:08
go to what is happening in Orenburgskaya02:24:10
areas You communicate a lot with people02:24:14
who have access to Putin, for example02:24:16
who have access to senior officials02:24:19
Or yourself02:24:21
that we see rudeness on the part of the head02:24:23
region in relation to local residents02:24:25
who lost their homes as a result02:24:27
flood in the Kremlin to this as02:24:31
relate Well, I think that Putin02:24:34
weighs the effectiveness of the governor02:24:37
paslera it's you who bashfully doesn't02:24:44
mentions02:24:46
this fu02:24:52
more important than his is this phrase, in my opinion02:24:56
it was Peskov who answered something I no longer02:24:58
I remember in02:24:59
trip Well, yes, there are bureaucrats like that02:25:04
people are different people are among them02:25:09
is the efficiency that costs02:25:11
higher than normal communication with02:25:14
people Well, efficiency probably02:25:17
governor is now saving people02:25:21
providing assistance to victims02:25:24
compensation systems are work02:25:26
we don’t have a normal manager from here02:25:29
we see, but there is, for example, a question: How much?02:25:32
died during this flood in02:25:34
Orenburg region in Kazakhstan nearby02:25:37
And how much02:25:39
people are evacuated safely02:25:42
a decision is made quickly02:25:44
compensation We see that in Orsk it is02:25:46
was02:25:47
Sumy was given slowly02:25:51
Uh-huh Yes yes yes yes this is a question in general02:25:54
like this Imagine being there02:25:56
governor or mayor you have this02:25:58
natural history and you have limited02:26:00
resource How will you distribute it to them and02:26:02
will02:26:03
efficiency How do you use this resource02:26:06
dispose of it in a limited manner This will be02:26:10
efficiency but apparently they calculated it02:26:12
that it is quite effective02:26:14
act there02:26:17
no tah s02:26:21
in m with these words the fact that in principle02:26:24
the dam broke isn't it enough02:26:26
tragic event to hit02:26:28
to the governor in the hat Well, he should02:26:30
be responsible for making sure everything is fine or02:26:32
no or not02:26:34
must Lisa if it breaks under you02:26:37
I have to serve you the table02:26:40
Posha I don’t know, you’re just like Putin02:26:44
Hitting the hat solves the problem02:26:47
This is how our bureaucracy works02:26:50
you are confident that this is the one02:26:53
effective way Well, no No, yes, well02:26:56
wait if the chair breaks02:26:59
there must be people watching02:27:00
to ensure that the chair under me is in good order02:27:02
if it is not working then we have Yes02:27:06
we don't have people like that we don't have but but by02:27:10
about the flood here with me02:27:13
My questions may be naive Maybe02:27:15
maybe I don't understand something about this at all02:27:17
So we talked there with people who02:27:19
understand what's going on there02:27:20
spill warming everything this is this02:27:24
But from the news that we see from02:27:27
statements there from all sorts of officials and that02:27:30
but the mayor is insipidly memorable, we understand that02:27:33
no one expected no one expected that02:27:35
warming02:27:37
and will lead to such a flood that02:27:40
the level will be exactly like this What exactly02:27:42
that the dam does not protect this02:27:45
no one expected this to say02:27:48
that were admitted02:27:53
of course Initially you need to force02:27:56
officials so that they save people and02:27:58
then give them goodies. The time will come.02:28:01
debriefing but no need to put02:28:04
horse muzzle to02:28:05
cart for officials02:28:09
stop now When you need their help This is02:28:12
mismanagement and so on02:28:19
ndi in France There are mayors, everything is there too02:28:24
We didn’t expect that the first thing was to save people02:28:27
help people yes provide02:28:30
compensation and everything else02:28:32
then they can then these02:28:35
officials cannot be chosen simply from02:28:38
There are a few of them self-government there02:28:39
differently02:28:41
arranged. What does self-government have to do with it?02:28:44
it's arranged differently again02:28:46
priorities When disaster strikes02:28:48
disaster02:28:53
People A is interested02:28:56
ra effectively saves people and then02:29:00
figure out who's there Overlooked the dam C02:29:02
which side did you overlook the dam? Why in02:29:04
Same thing in Kazakhstan02:29:06
they did it nearby in this dam Yes, of course02:29:10
We need to figure it out, but the first step is help.02:29:12
people but it's obvious02:29:14
[music]02:29:20
there would be no way to help people if02:29:22
the chair didn't break If people had deliberately02:29:25
trained people walked and looked for mice02:29:27
didn’t chew the chair Yes, that means natural02:29:31
things to prevent the dam from bursting02:29:33
so that the volcano does not erupt so that02:29:36
there were no earthquakes, we are everything02:29:38
we understand Well, for example, so that it doesn’t happen02:29:41
arson of grass burning can be monitored then02:29:45
there will be fewer natural fires every year02:29:48
talk raw yes yes yes yes she does it02:29:52
does a lot02:29:53
years This is nonsense Well, that is, nothing02:29:57
it works, well, yes, it’s just that you seem to02:30:00
relieve responsibility from those who02:30:01
had to ensure security and02:30:04
this dam and in principle02:30:06
region I'm telling you how02:30:08
little Putin Now I blame you02:30:11
raised like this And you are brilliant at this02:30:16
Listen to the beginning, help me later02:30:20
responsibility only in this order02:30:23
By the way, it’s interesting, I read it in02:30:24
report from Orsk just oh well02:30:28
correspondent there on boats02:30:30
traveled there with people talked to everything02:30:34
the cats were rescued, everything was done as expected and02:30:36
very often people said that02:30:38
if only we had one like this02:30:40
he's such a real mayor, like Vladimir02:30:44
Vladimirovich who delves into everything02:30:46
which is about here02:30:50
was02:30:51
ok listen how is it how is it for him02:30:53
succeeds I would like to02:30:56
learn to be so perfect I have in02:30:59
like Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin02:31:01
manages to be like this in people's opinion02:31:04
here is the ideal ruler despite the fact that he02:31:07
subordinates often fail02:31:09
for some reason he will punish them because02:31:12
what Vladimir Vladimirovich chose long ago02:31:14
imagine a form like this02:31:18
Batman was putting up a Christmas tree02:31:21
request and flew away and02:31:24
flew away it really is like this02:31:26
patriarchal autocratic is built02:31:34
created the image very02:31:38
it was like this for a long time why with this image02:31:41
he has not arrived in Orenburg now02:31:43
area never02:31:47
flies just in case it’s new if you remember02:31:50
Kemerovo Winter cherry he didn’t arrive02:31:54
straightaway02:31:55
Yes, he explains it like this if I arrive02:31:59
everyone is focused on me and not liquidation02:32:04
consequences That's it02:32:06
explanation by the way considering very often02:32:10
the sycophancy of our officials is02:32:12
fair than the price02:32:15
cat deputy02:32:24
this is the beginning you know when from the Kursk shelf02:32:27
If you do, it hasn't changed anything in a while02:32:30
these 24 years he was then for us journalists02:32:33
Pula explained: I would have flown and everything would have been02:32:37
me Admirals stood instead02:32:39
engage in search and rescue02:32:41
works Yes maybe it's not true Maybe it's02:32:45
is it true that Amira02:32:51
this is known as for isn’t Putin02:32:53
resource to force admirals02:32:55
engage in rescue work and not02:32:56
stand side by side and don't look at02:32:59
mouth02:33:01
no Question removed, everything is correct02:33:05
he has nothing to do with arriving in the Oryol region02:33:06
distract people from work Dava Orlovskaya02:33:10
immediately Oh Orenburg excuse me please02:33:12
to Orenburg Let's forget Ridna again02:33:15
Let's finally talk about progress02:33:18
what about the sanctions that were02:33:21
aimed at Friedman and Aven you about02:33:23
this is what02:33:25
think02:33:27
Well my point of view hasn't changed02:33:30
channel viewers know my point very well02:33:32
I think that02:33:34
administering such personal sanctions02:33:37
was, as it now turns out, illegal02:33:40
this part of the sanctions Yes, because the court02:33:43
it determines the relation to the law it was02:33:45
nekon I came from know the law02:33:50
European Commission rules I proceeded from that02:33:52
that this is wrong and ineffective02:33:54
so I have nothing except this02:33:56
the correct decision of the court is firstly02:33:59
the court corrected the lawful decision of the court02:34:02
governments European Commission governments02:34:04
Yes, the court corrected the government, wasn’t it bad?02:34:06
it's good second story If you02:34:10
look at the actual thing02:34:12
changed exactly to02:34:15
this name he is from02:34:18
points in the article that Putin is good02:34:22
attention is paid to the article of the fifth year02:34:24
2005 good attitude means02:34:27
the leader of the alpha groups is really a02:34:30
also there it's in fact everything also there02:34:33
several tweets were attracted02:34:36
attention to tweets from journalists who02:34:38
claimed that Putin is helping Alpha02:34:41
they just didn’t even approve the tweet, but so well02:34:43
Putin helps Alpha I tweeted Yes02:34:46
Putin helps Alpha get there02:34:48
such-and-such an asset I wrote a tweet Here it is in02:34:50
actual level02:34:52
This means that the European Commission’s arguments were02:34:55
this is what the court said Wait your02:34:57
argument Yes02:35:00
not soft enough European and this one02:35:03
part of the sanctions is part of the sanctions02:35:06
which they were in March02:35:09
second year until November twenty, I think02:35:13
third year declared illegal there02:35:16
there are other sanctions they continue02:35:17
remain under the sanctions that were02:35:20
later but this opens the way to many02:35:24
countries have case law02:35:26
opens the way for others not only02:35:29
only to Russian entrepreneurs and02:35:32
just for private citizens to apply02:35:34
European Court to challenge02:35:36
European sanctions are not the first02:35:37
I will remind you that the court decision02:35:39
they canceled the previous court hearing02:35:41
sanctions from Evgeniy's mother02:35:45
prigo Yes she was under sanctions were not02:35:48
recording some of his assets in Europe yes but02:35:51
the European Commission is here again immediately02:35:52
introduced new sanctions against her but in02:35:54
In principle, this proves that judicial02:35:56
the system works and I apologize They02:36:00
they constantly review sanctions or02:36:02
or it seems to me once every six months02:36:05
six months is just a procedure it should be02:36:07
be yes, that is, it’s not some kind of straight02:36:09
special They led This question can be02:36:12
challenge the procedure, but the story is that02:36:14
Now the race begins, we've taken it off you02:36:17
sanctions for this and we are giving you sanctions02:36:20
six months later again so the last ones02:36:23
sanctions that were imposed against02:36:25
Ridna in the European Union they are action02:36:28
every six months they seem to02:36:30
resume maybe someone02:36:33
I will once again repeat the imposition of sanctions on02:36:36
my02:36:38
look absolutely ineffective it's already02:36:41
Proven Well then02:36:45
here you go02:36:50
carry out his policies this led to this02:36:52
sanctions people lived in Europe02:36:54
minding their own business Yes they were02:36:56
returned to the country with their02:36:58
money that is now working for02:37:00
government on military-industrial02:37:02
the complex is the result of these sanctions Well02:37:06
here is the European Court Despite all these02:37:09
he took the troubles purely legal02:37:11
solution your arguments are not convincing02:37:15
the words of the European Commission are insufficient for this02:37:17
to impose sanctions against private02:37:20
property, which is very important, that is02:37:22
practically froze private02:37:23
property, that is, this base02:37:26
European about what is private02:37:27
property is inviolable Yes it is02:37:29
these sanctions, if it doesn’t break then02:37:31
undermined the court said just a second This02:37:34
illegal It was illegally canceled That's it02:37:37
this part Well, there will be more and more02:37:39
continue And by the way it will continue02:37:41
as if some of the sanctions were lifted from02:37:46
personal with these specific people they02:37:48
that now they will fly back the free world and02:37:53
will stop whatever it is02:37:56
to help02:37:58
I won't tell you anything about love02:38:02
how about02:38:03
patriotism is important02:38:07
justice restoration02:38:09
there is only one justice02:38:11
of important02:38:16
restoration for what02:38:20
By the way, this is clearly stated in the court decision02:38:22
what if people were silent and did not speak out02:38:24
about yours in no way about02:38:28
politicians it doesn't make them guilty02:38:31
they cannot be asked to sit down02:38:34
for some kind of political02:38:37
said the line02:38:40
court they were silent and you cannot them02:38:42
blame02:38:51
this is their sovereign right, each individual02:38:53
the right of every person is a very important cla02:38:57
court decisions This does not apply to many02:39:00
only to02:39:02
businessmen Yes, this applies to everyone, but02:39:05
I'm telling you about the trial that took place02:39:08
such an important decision so it seems that02:39:11
restoration of justice is not02:39:13
less important than whether they love someone02:39:15
fly02:39:19
were ineffective and even vice versa02:39:21
worked So02:39:23
now it's it's it's not that important but how02:39:26
they will02:39:28
now what will be the effect I have on Po02:39:31
about the fact that a person should not02:39:33
swear in love or not love for one's there02:39:37
Putin and so on But what about the athletes?02:39:40
what about cultural figures whose different02:39:43
situations just for this feat02:39:51
this doesn't mean that if we're talking about02:39:53
The Olympic Committee is right there02:39:55
non-admission of those who supported their so A02:40:00
if the athlete fared02:40:05
allowed that is there actually02:40:08
again no one forces a person02:40:10
take an oath02:40:12
some kind and this is normal European02:40:16
another look up02:40:19
abnormal no There you are Bring it02:40:21
take the oath here now, take it02:40:23
oath and then we will give you your property02:40:26
let's return Well then these people should give02:40:29
before the same European Court and02:40:33
try not to do this to them02:40:37
did they do it and is there any work being done now?02:40:39
discussion do you know02:40:42
you a new system of imposing sanctions so that02:40:45
they didn’t impose sanctions and then you need to go to court02:40:47
prove that you are not Vert first02:40:50
I don’t know about some court hearings02:40:52
in water02:40:54
sanctions No, not carried out because02:40:57
sanctions are being introduced and this is one of the problems02:41:00
Out of court, not even in02:41:02
out of court and in order without02:41:05
discussions with someone accused of something02:41:07
they accuse him and don't give him a chance02:41:10
defend themselves and immediately introduce punishment02:41:14
what is my complaint about the sanctions regime02:41:16
Yes, you declare a person like that02:41:20
and immediately introduce punishment not just02:41:22
announce the punishment there02:41:23
freezing bans and depriving you of Rights without02:41:27
court decision you are limited to it02:41:30
rights without discussion, this is how we see it02:41:33
the court corrected02:41:35
by the way it has now passed since March Yes02:41:38
for 2 years already, for 2 years people have been deprived02:41:40
rights defined in relation to02:41:43
own number02:41:45
property and court re but unfortunately himself02:41:50
the sanctions regime is being introduced outside02:41:52
discussion out of court and this02:41:56
big lack but just not very02:41:59
I understand why this situation still exists02:42:00
didn’t move in any direction although02:42:02
at least considering the large number02:42:04
Russian opposition politicians02:42:06
who communicate with the European Parliament02:42:07
who are trying to explain what it is02:42:09
ineffective that's not how it works02:42:11
a huge number of experts say02:42:13
about what it is02:42:15
ineffective answer Look at02:42:18
statement02:42:20
op watering by02:42:23
regarding the lifting of sanctions02:42:26
with with words What a nightmare, what a shame02:42:31
shame this is such a part of the opposition02:42:36
policy02:42:39
Absolutely a nightmare so ask them02:42:43
Nya ask ute02:42:53
someone should be competitive02:42:56
the procedure is not necessarily judicial but02:42:59
Necessarily02:43:02
adversarial is not done officials02:43:05
can lift sanctions can impose02:43:07
sanctions for this is not the case procedure is not visible02:43:10
there is no evidence, here is the evidence02:43:18
journals of the European Commission or some website02:43:20
where everyone can write something and02:43:23
based on the fact that everyone is someone02:43:24
wrote something, tweeted or spread02:43:27
You can introduce sanctions Well, fear God02:43:30
But on the other hand, many people do not02:43:32
paid attention to this, this is what02:43:34
did you notice that this is02:43:36
unfair and somehow very clumsy02:43:39
ineffective because inside Russia02:43:41
in general everything is like that02:43:43
works zat can be semi02:43:50
under absolutely Putin's approaches first02:43:55
what Lisa shows us first02:43:57
punish then figure it out Well, that’s it02:43:59
I see, well, thanks, I'm in charge now02:44:02
us and this Lord is an example of the regime02:44:06
acting yes yes Well you are you02:44:10
put02:44:11
Bach yes And you are young, you are Putin02:44:15
raised correctly Well, in general it’s logical02:44:16
everything is fair, that's it02:44:18
efficiency02:44:19
I don’t remember I don’t know Propaganda Here she is02:44:21
here Yes, probably so why are they mocking02:44:26
above Oleg Orlov right now we see02:44:28
that after it every day02:44:30
took him to get acquainted with the case in court02:44:32
for some reason they refuse to bring02:44:34
so that he can participate in the meeting remotely02:44:36
he says that because of spoiling the gos02:44:38
he heard it02:44:42
hard listen this is a working machine yes02:44:47
a machine that has no mercy02:44:50
and is devoid of even any signs of that02:44:52
what needs to be demonstrated somehow02:44:54
respect for a person Because if you02:45:04
she doesn't show you anything02:45:06
will bring you more than a headache02:45:08
boss why did he let him in, he’s an enemy02:45:11
people why are you02:45:19
that's why What do you want to say by this You02:45:22
you want to say that you are on his side and02:45:24
so people inside this system02:45:26
absolutely ruthless and unmerciful02:45:29
demonstrate02:45:30
ruthlessness02:45:34
life is merciless for bureaucrats Yes02:45:38
You can't show mercy02:45:40
the bosses will understand, the bosses will not understand02:45:49
with demonstrative no mercy I02:45:51
I remembered the story Sorry with the cut off02:45:55
ear and detention of terrorists and with02:45:59
discussion especially discussion of this02:46:01
video we remember it all there and02:46:04
uh, all sorts of things were naturally expressed02:46:07
words that And how they should have behaved02:46:09
news if there is a terrible one in front of them02:46:11
criminal Well okay Yes this argument02:46:13
also understandable, although I can’t understand it02:46:16
admit a02:46:19
video of a man being detained appears02:46:23
who killed the police because they02:46:26
caught him looking for bookmarks or something02:46:30
something like that he was hiding there02:46:33
in the Tver region There is another one first02:46:35
a man was accidentally detained with the same02:46:37
motorcycle Well, in general, [ __ ] him02:46:40
absolutely the same Well how can I say good02:46:42
looking calm its very calm02:46:46
they ask he answers Well, you killed you killed02:46:50
I killed Yes why there what are you there02:46:52
you admit that you did it, you did it calmly02:46:55
a sitting man whom no one pokes02:46:57
and by the way he killed the police and he02:47:00
by the way drugs means02:47:03
sold drugs and here he is02:47:05
good one should be treated with humanity02:47:08
and the law Why so what does it say A02:47:12
you wanted an ear I don't remember No I wanted I02:47:15
I wanted to understand why the ear02:47:21
and here it is02:47:24
that's how criminals should02:47:27
detain and say yes yes so them and02:47:28
must be detained and then we02:47:30
show the criminal too. In general, not02:47:32
the most beautiful person in the world02:47:34
It turns out that it is possible, it turns out that it is possible02:47:36
was for whom for whom02:47:40
acceptable to whom acceptable to viewers02:47:45
I don't know there's a talk show02:47:49
easy to explain to viewers02:47:51
a terrorist act was committed02:47:54
it was directed specifically against these02:47:56
spectators against civilians and people02:48:00
they understand this - solidarity02:48:04
this is any social psychologist for you02:48:08
will explain Yes because every person02:48:10
could put himself in the place of the victim in02:48:13
hall of the cropus center and therefore no02:48:16
mercy and that's why it was about02:48:19
Yes, they sold quite successfully02:48:22
tell the police they are strangers to them02:48:26
treat the population poorly02:48:30
not good They are strangers they are different and this is what it is02:48:35
If we talk about the audience, this is what it is02:48:37
indifference to Well, that was their job02:48:39
detain They are armed They are not02:48:41
civilians They could shoot back02:48:44
this is the perception If we talk about those02:48:47
who understands this, therefore, what if we talk02:48:50
about those who detained Well02:48:52
listen terrorists or suspects02:48:54
in terrorism were detained on the trail02:48:57
here it is immediately Yes, it hasn’t cooled down02:49:00
bye02:49:02
besides it also worked, you know this02:49:05
called fear times rage02:49:07
Adrenaline and such a chase it was02:49:11
to take revenge is the basis was to take revenge here02:49:16
take revenge here02:49:19
why 5 days? Well, we were looking for the code02:49:21
passions have subsided Uh-huh Well, they detained In addition02:49:25
I would like to remind you that the previous02:49:27
when they detained it later it turned out that it was02:49:29
the court that this is a mistake that it’s not him but yes and02:49:33
so that means they are more careful, what if02:49:35
it's not him either, although he is something there02:49:37
says so there can be a lot02:49:39
different times different from imagine02:49:43
what kind of people what kind Well, conditionally02:49:47
criminals or whatever02:49:49
announced02:49:51
criminals The broad masses want02:49:53
lynching immediately And which one is enough02:49:56
I'm indifferent02:49:59
I was amazed I was amazed02:50:01
that there is a message there about incidents in02:50:04
In Moscow, the child was throwing something02:50:06
burning paper from the window and as a result02:50:09
set fire02:50:10
the neighbor's balcony was big02:50:13
serious02:50:14
fire calls to lynch a child send02:50:19
because it's really easy for yourself02:50:21
imagine how you burned completely02:50:23
apartment and need to be executed02:50:26
baby these are people who associate themselves02:50:29
victims because that's how it is02:50:31
opportunity to associate yourself02:50:34
victims with armed police02:50:36
people in uniform who02:50:39
there02:50:41
would people02:50:49
the fact of the death of Aley Navalny on the 10th day02:50:53
Do you think they are there?02:50:55
check, wait, it's there, he's not02:51:00
extended he canceled the waiver02:51:03
extension, the court overturned the refusal to extend02:51:07
and returned it to the investigative committee. Well02:51:10
there are procedural things that means02:51:21
unsubscribed02:51:24
Yes, they know they are still checking something there02:51:27
how can you tell what they check in02:51:29
sugar probably interview those who were02:51:31
nearby looks at the diet there02:51:34
temperature regime as it was observed in02:51:36
regarding Alexei Navalny Well then02:51:39
investigators doing their usual work02:51:41
those investigators who do their work there02:51:43
regular work02:51:49
documentation02:51:53
conversation with people with witnesses02:51:56
Yes, but this is a procedural work if02:51:58
there is a complaint This is how it should be02:52:00
be investigated and everyday life should not be given02:52:02
just an unsubscribe but a reasoned answer02:52:04
Well, apparently they took another 10 days but just02:52:08
Alexei Navalny This is not ordinary02:52:09
prisoner there must be some02:52:12
special instructions special attention02:52:14
some special conditions02:52:19
it's all about checking these orders02:52:21
Were they preserved in written form?02:52:23
documents or these orders as if02:52:26
there weren't because they don't exist02:52:28
documents so I don’t really understand02:52:31
your objection no it’s not like that02:52:33
the objection is02:52:35
clarification Well, for them it’s normal02:52:37
a prisoner here for the investigator there02:52:39
who came to this place from somewhere02:52:41
unhappy02:52:44
Solikha ZAZ02:52:48
it is claimed by his loved ones that he died02:52:51
violent death must be checked well02:52:53
that is, with any prisoner in similar02:52:56
circumstances would still be carried out02:52:57
Here is the same rather long check02:53:00
Right02:53:01
but a man dies and it’s unclear Well, if02:53:05
have a complaint for example exactly the same yes02:53:07
there is a complaint received02:53:10
Yeah absolutely And by the way, about Alexey02:53:15
Navalny because she appeared02:53:16
information that he wrote a memoir02:53:20
that they will be published02:53:23
And for some reason this also caused a strange02:53:26
reaction in some places he couldn't he02:53:29
I couldn’t write it myself and you have something else02:53:33
about this Which one02:53:37
opinion what we know firstly we know02:53:40
that this book he is writing the word to write02:53:43
wrong left dictating about this too02:53:46
speaks02:53:48
e02:53:49
Who after the poisoning when he was in02:53:53
Berlin it was 2 months later02:53:55
poisoning means it started in November02:53:59
from November to December to January he wrote in02:54:02
Berlin dictated02:54:06
then he was in prison and from there too02:54:10
I wrote and conveyed it once and now it’s like02:54:14
Knop Koto publishing house approves02:54:17
belongs to Bertelsmann it's very02:54:19
serious reputable publishing house02:54:22
I assure you it will be checked there 100 times by lawyers02:54:25
so that Flo doesn't come out they will check 100 times02:54:28
Is it really Navalny here 10002:54:30
once they check because otherwise he will be sued02:54:32
they'll throw it in, which means it's like now02:54:36
the publishing house says it means Julia02:54:39
Navalnaya is working with editors02:54:41
by the editors of this02:54:42
manuscripts Well, let's read it, I'm not at all02:54:45
ready to discuss there how it is there yes E we02:54:50
we know that it was difficult to convey02:54:52
read the interview with Olga Mikhailova02:54:55
lawyer, which is very common and they generally have02:54:58
there was no contact they were behind glass02:55:00
so it was even bad to hear something02:55:02
somehow he conveyed Oh well, these are legal02:55:05
questions actually but let's02:55:07
Let's wait for the book, it will be released on October 2202:55:10
I say again this is very serious02:55:11
publishing house new life bertelsmann02:55:13
which just like that and which they won’t02:55:16
make them look solid02:55:19
I just saw maybe you have02:55:21
there is an answer that the book will be translated into02:55:23
many languages including Russian02:55:25
I have a question: what language is it in?02:55:28
written Maybe you have something about this02:55:31
you know maybe this could be this02:55:34
there was a crooked wording I didn't02:55:36
formulated02:55:40
Izya I think yes I think who02:55:44
no rusm02:55:48
It is true that in the World Cup the first edition will not be02:55:50
in Russian it is done for02:55:52
Western listener for commercial02:55:55
success because Alexey's book02:55:57
Navalny Patriot to distribute in02:55:59
Russia will be And since He is still in02:56:02
lists of extremists and terrorists will02:56:04
it's impossible for you02:56:06
understood therefore maybe02:56:08
initially the publishing house lets on02:56:11
English or German was available in02:56:14
virus edition will come later02:56:17
[music]02:56:18
ask the authorities or Yulia Well, of course02:56:22
he wrote and dictated in Russian, but02:56:25
By the way, about the list of extremists and02:56:27
the ring does not intend to exclude terrorists02:56:30
Alexei Navalny because they are nothing02:56:32
don't know about his death it's like02:56:35
in general it’s the same as about02:56:38
Oleg this should also come02:56:41
indication of the first02:56:44
faces yes exclude02:56:48
Navalny concerns both Putin and neither02:56:51
the official will not take it upon himself02:56:53
the courage to cross out from somewhere02:56:55
Alexey02:56:57
naval Well that's why it's just this02:57:00
like this Well, this is of course some kind of paradox02:57:03
on the one hand, this is a person who is not02:57:05
there is a political02:57:09
death from another02:57:11
hand yes genius02:57:16
Another paradox about the lion How do you like his recent02:57:19
speech first leaked negotiations Well02:57:22
or rather leaked audio messages and then him02:57:25
videos What is this02:57:27
was corrected Well, I'll guess of course02:57:31
corrected of course, but I'll assume that02:57:34
Mr. Rulev he is like02:57:36
would behave quite a lot and often02:57:39
they let him do it cheekily02:57:41
parliamentary status and general rank02:57:44
how he thinks and at some point such02:57:47
people hot that line02:57:50
which the bosses don't approve of, but they02:57:53
move into a tighter line, mind you02:57:55
again the line there is calmer Yes02:57:58
reducing the escalation of mercy or not02:58:01
increasing escalation of violence, that's it02:58:04
it just caused a really big02:58:06
international ska what is heaven who02:58:08
State Duma deputy from the party02:58:10
United Russia02:58:11
General This is not some guy02:58:14
propagandist who is on the channel02:58:15
somewhere out there for little money02:58:18
it says and a representation has been made02:58:21
as far as I know informal up to02:58:24
that it seemed like even Takayev was going to02:58:28
talk about this with Putin02:58:30
the president of the president and decided this matter02:58:32
stop and say you're a guy say what02:58:34
this is not Rosseti and Ukrainians, he is like that02:58:36
approximately and said Uh-huh But it’s true02:58:41
what what else02:58:44
since Ukrainians are not Russia, well this is02:58:49
Is it true that helmsmen are no longer allowed?02:58:52
on federal TV channels in various02:58:54
show that the ban was given to him Lisa I didn’t02:58:58
I watch TV channels so much02:59:01
insides, these are my insides about02:59:04
several people several with a big I and02:59:08
occupy higher positions I can’t02:59:11
have inside information about all the deputies from02:59:18
you know how much Putin loves hockey players02:59:20
play hockey Yes the hockey player there 302:59:22
minutes fine and he has a 2 week fine02:59:24
Well, it's good not to do anything else02:59:27
said maybe maybe doesn't have02:59:30
don't gossip02:59:32
in general just something for02:59:38
this is what they write that recruiters are from the Ministry of Defense02:59:41
are now actively visiting women's colonies02:59:43
important stories are written about this, it’s possible02:59:46
consider another whining rush that many well02:59:50
quite famous women for a long time02:59:52
asked to be sent from02:59:55
prisons on their own, including this one here02:59:58
Crimean03:00:00
official x they still don’t03:00:04
they answered nothing, this is a serious way out03:00:10
colonies of people who are convicted of03:00:12
number for long periods03:00:19
there is an appeal from the wives of those convicted because of03:00:22
murders due to fraud in large03:00:25
sizes which were sentenced there to 10-12 years03:00:28
colonies that we are ready to work there for03:00:31
FSO there you want a cook you want Swami there03:00:35
Babarikh's women, well, let's do this and03:00:39
I know that this is being discussed Yes too03:00:41
right03:00:43
Tori is so surprised03:00:51
what is missing03:00:53
liu is not enough pori this is03:00:57
character of what is happening in the colonies03:01:01
How in what way the people who committed03:01:03
serious crimes by court decision03:01:05
Russian Yes they can go free03:01:08
and this is already 2 and a half years or so03:01:13
more me again03:01:15
in the form of news information about what allegedly03:01:20
Strelkov Girkin everything is very very very03:01:23
really wants to go and seems to have already03:01:26
they’ll even send it, but it seems like03:01:29
impossible because of the article under which His03:01:33
accused Well, the article can always be changed03:01:37
as you know Yes, think about replacing there03:01:40
first and foremost it doesn't last long it all depends on03:01:43
The prosecutor's office may change the investigator03:01:46
accusation but specifically gerkin I don’t have03:01:49
no information about what awaits him03:01:52
changes I just don’t have it, I don’t know03:01:54
No, it’s even possible for Girkina03:01:57
they let me go to the front again, it won't be03:02:00
very good from some point of view03:02:02
politics or03:02:05
no, I hear Putin’s intonations again03:02:09
means who03:02:13
I tell you03:02:18
It’s just that Strelkova Girkin was decided03:02:20
Going to jail is probably for this03:02:22
some reason he's probably very up to03:02:26
sat down hard03:02:32
to annoy accept not those whom he03:02:34
insulted And to whom he imprisoned I will answer you03:02:38
that's it, that is, he doesn't03:02:42
you want it, I don't have it03:02:46
insider03:02:48
ok it's not mine ok then tell me about it03:02:52
we literally have 2 minutes left03:02:54
tell me what you have about03:02:57
Insight What if you found out something like this?03:03:00
latest03:03:02
day that's simple03:03:05
not yet03:03:08
continues03:03:11
hard work continues03:03:14
promoting the exchange of prisoners of war for all03:03:17
everyone about03:03:19
and it’s just important that people03:03:22
knew that no one was holding hands03:03:25
omitted the second story I met here03:03:28
with the family of one of the Russian hostages03:03:31
in Israel which is captured03:03:33
Coma Yes, I'm in Israel There are only three and A03:03:40
Of course it’s surprising that it’s Russian03:03:43
public opinion as opposed to03:03:45
Israeli public opinion is not03:03:46
stands up for these03:03:48
three people, it’s as if they don’t exist03:03:51
And the Society doesn’t know about this at all03:03:54
Hamas is holding Russian citizens in03:03:56
hostages03:03:57
And there were five or six of them there03:04:01
released either two or three three03:04:04
three were released a long time ago. It was03:04:06
in the fall And these three They are in03:04:11
hostages and We hope they are alive03:04:15
no information at all03:04:20
let's say no reliable information03:04:23
so actually formally 13403:04:27
the hostage is still there, hesitating all the time03:04:29
Yes but how many of them are alive from different03:04:32
countries but how many of them are alive No one03:04:35
knows and therefore when is the last03:04:38
round of negotiations the number arose: 4003:04:40
we change hostages 8 0003:04:48
why is everyone here because that is everyone03:04:51
people started asking if they were alive and03:04:53
here, among other things, there are mass03:04:55
manifestations with the participation of parents03:04:57
hostages addressed to the Prime Minister03:05:00
netanyahu03:05:01
you but how many of ours are still alive no one03:05:05
Not03:05:06
I know Alexey Venediktov was in our03:05:09
morning spread Before we03:05:11
let's finish the story03:05:16
gu be different william bulette trying03:05:19
change 20th century William Boulet is an ambassador03:05:22
United States in the Soviet Union and03:05:24
France is a very famous person author03:05:26
two novels an expert on American03:05:28
politics and Russian history and book03:05:31
based on his history on his03:05:33
documents you can read you can03:05:35
order it from us at03:05:37
shd Media and support us in this way03:05:40
we will be very grateful to you for this03:05:43
We still have support at 15:00 and even03:05:46
signed if if you ask forDescription:
Поддержать Живой гвоздь: с карт российских банков https://pay.cloudtips.ru/p/7edd7c0e с карт иностранных банков https://www.donationalerts.com/r/zhivgvozd Boosty: https://boosty.to/zhivoygvozd Криптокошелёк: bc1qmdt96xvsun9a8qxvgakfx9gqy4x72penx5rm2p Trust Wallet: https://link.trustwallet.com/send?address=bc1qmdt96xvsun9a8qxvgakfx9gqy4x72penx5rm2p&asset=c0 Пятница на Живом гвозде начинается с Утреннего разворота! Ведущие: Ольга Журавлёва и Лиза Аникина. 0:00:00 — Начало эфира 0:00:47 — В эфире Утренний разворот с Лизой Аникиной и Ольгой Журавлёвой 0:06:30 — Выпуск новостей 0:09:17 — Эколог Сергей Симак, председатель Совета Российской Зеленой Лиги, кандидат биологических наук о затоплении в Орске и Оренбурге 0:34:55 — Материал недели от «Новой газеты». Журнал «Горби». Представляет Андрей Колесников*, эксперт фонда Карнеги* 1:06:30 — Выпуск новостей 1:09:20 — Замоскворецкий суд Москвы отказал правозащитнику Олегу Орлову* в его просьбе лично участвовать в заседании по его делу. Рассказывает юрист Александра Баева 1:41:14 — Госдума утвердила в третьем чтении законопроект об адвокатуре. Рассказывает юрист, правозащитник Дмитрий Захватов 2:05:50 — Выпуск новостей 2:09:25 — Специальный гость — Алексей Венедиктов* 3:05:08 — Не забудьте купить книгу в магазине Дилетант! 3:05:50 — До завтра! Сайт журнала «Горби»: https://gorby.media/ Купить бумажный журнал Горби: https://novaya.shop/catalog/knigi/periodika/gorby-6/ Новый выпуск «Той самой Новой Газеты»: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1GpoWGwa_nEf8U_SgLIJCl6K6_GYh5G19/view?usp=sharing Подписывайтесь на телеграм-канал Лизы Аникиной: https://t.me/echo_episod Подписывайтесь на телеграм-канал Ольги Журавлёвой: https://t.me/juravleva_romanovna Подписывайтесь на Алексея Венедиктова** в соцсетях: https://t.me/aavst2022 https://twitter.com/aavst20551?s=11 * — Олег Орлов, Андрей Колесников, фонд Карнеги за международный мир и проект ОВД-инфо признаны российскими властями иностранными агентами * * — власти РФ считают иностранным агентом, а ФБК*** — разжигателем войны *** — организация внесена в список иностранных агентов, признана экстремистской и запрещена в России Княжна Тараканова — героиня шестого тома комикса серии «Спасти». Княжна, чьё происхождение, да и имя, остаются тайной, выдавала себя за княгиню Елизавету Владимирскую — незаконнорождённую дочь императрицы Елизаветы Петровны. Оформляйте заказ на сайте diletant.shop! А ещё на сайте теперь можно оформить подписку на печатную версию журнала Дилетант! Попробуйте: https://diletant.shop/ 📌 Живой гвоздь в аудиоформате: https://podcast.ru/1616175210 🔔 Последние новости и анонсы программ с YouTube-канала «Живой гвоздь», а также контент от наших постоянных гостей и экспертов на официальном телеграм-канале: https://t.me/livegvozd Мобильное приложение "Эха": любимые программы в формате радиоприёмника. Простой интерфейс. Работа в фоновом режиме. Расписание эфиров. Скачать: в AppStore: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/%D1%8D%D1%85%D0%BE-online/id1639907671 в PlayMarket: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=online.echofm.app Сайт "Эха": https://echofm.online/ (если не открывается – ссылка на рабочую версию сайта всегда есть в тг-канале ЭХО FM https://telegram.org/ Подписаться на Youtube-канал Дилетант: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuIE7-5QzeAR6EdZXwDRwuQ?sub_confirmation=1 Магазин Дилетант: https://diletant.shop/ По вопросам взаимодействия: [email protected]
Preparing download options
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players
Questions about downloading video
How can I download "Потоп в Орске и Оренбурге. Дело Олега Орлова*. Венедиктов*, Колесников*, Аникина и Журавлёва" video?
http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.
Which format of "Потоп в Орске и Оренбурге. Дело Олега Орлова*. Венедиктов*, Колесников*, Аникина и Журавлёва" video should I choose?
The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.
Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Потоп в Орске и Оренбурге. Дело Олега Орлова*. Венедиктов*, Колесников*, Аникина и Журавлёва" video?
The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.
How can I download "Потоп в Орске и Оренбурге. Дело Олега Орлова*. Венедиктов*, Колесников*, Аникина и Журавлёва" video to my phone?
You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.
How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Потоп в Орске и Оренбурге. Дело Олега Орлова*. Венедиктов*, Колесников*, Аникина и Журавлёва"?
The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.
How can I save a frame from a video "Потоп в Орске и Оренбурге. Дело Олега Орлова*. Венедиктов*, Колесников*, Аникина и Журавлёва"?
This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.
What's the price of all this stuff?
It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.