Download "Что вчера случилось с государством? Домашний стрим (Борис Кагарлицкий, кот Степан)"
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FSo7BZfTCeiQ%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
Please wait. We're preparing links for easy ad-free video watching and downloading.
Similar videos from our catalog
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FOf7jP4X_GQ8%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FWm-k2Uu1R3A%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FbBwfNmVG7KA%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FfhgVUit55BE%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FhzXy4GzzaTo%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FtDtqZx6E5og%252Fsddefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FwhHT3d7QfmI%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252Fyl1s5PsCrb0%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
Video tags
Subtitles
Russian
00:00:42
[music]00:01:11
[music]00:01:33
Here00:01:35
good evening here is Stepan, here I am Boris00:01:39
Kogorlitsky editor-in-chief of the channel and00:01:41
rapcore site and we are here together on00:01:45
channel rabkor00:01:47
and today we are broadcasting change and00:01:50
we'll talk about one thing00:01:52
the only topic I think is more correct00:01:54
we will talk about what you want00:01:56
talk about what you will ask me00:01:57
we will talk about questions00:01:59
the main topic which In general is now already00:02:02
since last night and in my opinion all00:02:05
today is probably still some time00:02:07
time haunts a huge number of00:02:10
people and even all over the world not only00:02:12
in Russia, what happened yesterday?00:02:15
it turns out it’s possible, let’s arrange it00:02:18
such a small rebellion there are thousands under it00:02:22
people to Moscow on the road with a volume of then00:02:26
either three or 5 or even more00:02:27
helicopter in the army00:02:29
let's capture a couple of cities and approach00:02:32
Moscow00:02:34
and then we’ll say that yes, well, everything00:02:39
ok We have nothing like that00:02:41
let's go our separate ways, well, a little more00:02:45
the president declared these people terrorists00:02:49
extremists, traitors to the Motherland, and00:02:52
generally enemies and so on and so forth Well00:02:57
then but again, well, they opened it00:02:59
criminal case closed criminal case on00:03:02
article00:03:03
rebellion coup d'etat There and so on and so on00:03:06
further but then the criminal case was closed Well00:03:09
what problems and00:03:11
let's say we took a Gazelle there00:03:16
Wagner center with four I think five00:03:19
billions of rubles Well, they just lay there00:03:22
money but there are some pistols there00:03:24
it is unclear who designed some00:03:26
fake passports for00:03:29
Evgeniy Viktorovich Prigozhin only with00:03:31
other names Well, some other00:03:34
strange white powder, probably dental00:03:36
powder And then they took it all away00:03:39
then we'll return it then we'll return it Well, of course everything00:03:42
things are over in general Is that so?00:03:45
is it possible and what was it? If it wasn't00:03:48
coup It was like the British00:03:51
American say prectical joke Yes00:03:54
like this00:03:55
practical joke prank like we have00:03:57
there was a prank Well, let's prank00:04:00
let's arrange something like this Well then ha-ha-ha after all00:04:03
it was really fun all day00:04:04
intensified It's true 15 or 20 people00:04:08
killed on the way. Well, what's the difference between us?00:04:10
seems like this is being read today If you00:04:13
there are 15,000 or even 15 people - This is generally00:04:15
especially since they say that Prigozhin00:04:18
people or will you return them to their families now00:04:20
some very large compensations00:04:23
paid or at least promised00:04:25
almost up to 50 million rubles for each00:04:28
lost head Well, there are many here00:04:30
families will even say Oh yes00:04:33
good job guys, that's it in general00:04:37
what was that00:04:40
and I think that00:04:43
the most in my opinion00:04:46
convincing and00:04:48
still gave a well-thought-out explanation00:04:51
Anatoly Nesmeyan is also by the way00:04:53
curious irony of the situation that Anatoly00:04:56
I was on the air of Rabkor just the day before yesterday and00:05:00
we just finished broadcasting with him00:05:02
discussed including Prigozhin and much more00:05:04
the other ended the broadcast in about00:05:07
15-20 minutes maybe half an hour before00:05:10
this is where it all started, that is, of course00:05:12
if it all started right now00:05:14
on air It would be more fun for us too, but not00:05:16
came out But yesterday we had Stream How are you00:05:19
remember, yes, it was 9 o’clock in the evening00:05:23
and just live we were able to00:05:25
discover that Prigozhin is almost entering00:05:27
Moscow turned around and said yes, well, what about00:05:31
goodbye guys while we're home here00:05:34
Well, what makes such a guy00:05:40
after passing about three00:05:44
350-400 km What is called without00:05:47
resistance in general without much knocking down00:05:50
helicopters and other things captured I say00:05:52
a couple of cities in one day right on00:05:56
threshold What is called at the gate wall00:05:58
Moscow turn around and wave your hand Oh00:06:01
and we are very afraid to shed blood Guys00:06:04
you shot at the helicopter and at you too00:06:07
By the way, it looked like they were shooting from a helicopter and00:06:10
somehow they didn’t really care00:06:12
that this is such a bad story even00:06:15
boasted that they shot down everything and00:06:17
so many00:06:18
broken Here the plane crashed on this00:06:22
shot down military transport plane here00:06:24
the helicopter crashed, the tracks are so cool00:06:28
We are so great00:06:30
and then it seems like everyone else Grigorievich00:06:33
Lukashenko called and we were like00:06:34
agreed but now let's get back to that00:06:37
what Ne Laughing wrote, I’m expressing my opinion00:06:40
version based on the fact that he is not daring00:06:42
wrote That is, the version is not quite00:06:44
original but based on it00:06:47
information on its version also look00:06:51
roughly what this whole policy is all about00:06:53
all these00:06:55
patriotic state stories00:06:57
cover it all up it's all [ __ ], just00:06:59
at least somehow explain to outsiders00:07:03
observer what is really happening00:07:05
purely commercial disassembly because in00:07:07
Africa Wagner controls Well, conditionally00:07:10
speaking common fund00:07:11
controls huge funds I'm there00:07:14
I think it’s not just billions, but00:07:17
many billions of dollars and which are there00:07:21
somewhere they store it somewhere they exploit it00:07:24
because it can be said00:07:25
diamond mines gold mines and so on00:07:28
Further00:07:29
Well, in general, all this is kept under00:07:33
control00:07:35
Wagnerians but00:07:37
myself00:07:38
Evgeniy Viktorovich Prigozhin was not00:07:41
owner of even a significant share of everything00:07:45
from this wonderful property well00:07:47
Accordingly, it’s still unpleasant here00:07:49
the story is that after Lavrov’s trip to00:07:52
black continent after it00:07:55
wonderful communication with African00:07:56
rulers00:07:57
suddenly there is another conversation that Russia00:08:00
will create a military base in Africa A00:08:03
What does this mean? What does this mean?00:08:05
The Ministry of Defense is directly involved00:08:08
in this work and is a competitor for00:08:11
Prigogine, that is, Can just squeeze it out00:08:13
part of his security business00:08:16
Well, it’s clear that this is very serious00:08:18
conversation very serious conflict00:08:20
situation and then suddenly we find out that00:08:23
Prigogine is dissatisfied with how disgusting00:08:26
SRO is being conducted here we find out that00:08:30
Shoigu, generally speaking, is a bastard and so00:08:33
on and on and on and in general where are the shells00:08:35
but Gerasimov is also for one thing00:08:37
Gerasimov where is the ammunition and why?00:08:40
so bad you command more00:08:43
because00:08:44
Apparently there is no reaction. Needed00:08:47
it was possible to put the squeeze on the fact that00:08:51
Putin can simply be persuaded by threats00:08:53
so that he removes these people or00:08:55
at least this whole story with the military00:08:57
closed base in Africa00:08:59
the truth does not close History is not00:09:02
ends and then we see that everything00:09:06
after all this is the beginning of a rebellion, and there is00:09:10
another trigger to this rebellion This is00:09:12
the story is that from the first00:09:15
July all00:09:18
volunteer formations and hired00:09:21
formations must sign a contract00:09:23
from the Ministry of Defense, that is, like00:09:25
Prigozhin you are now not just technically00:09:27
subordination to the military, but you also00:09:31
employee They are your employers and so00:09:34
accordingly they can give you00:09:35
instructions of the order and accordingly00:09:36
the main thing I think is more important is you in front of00:09:39
they must report to report to00:09:42
including quite possibly in their own00:09:43
operations in Africa about how you are where00:09:45
What things did you put where did you put them? Well,00:09:48
in general a lot of other things00:09:49
then the specific disassembly begins00:09:52
it's more like a classic00:09:55
mafia skirmish when two gangs say00:09:58
doing business in the same territory00:10:00
they had about all these threads00:10:04
resources and income and the territory itself00:10:07
distributed but then some arise00:10:09
What is called misunderstandings they cannot00:10:12
come to an agreement and the shooting begins00:10:14
Are there any armed conflicts?00:10:16
but then they still sit down somewhere and find00:10:20
some neutral place was rubbed00:10:24
decided agreed and redistributed00:10:27
possible resources someone had to00:10:29
share who had to give in and that’s it00:10:32
everything went fine and then again Friendship00:10:34
happiness together and common business A00:10:38
and it is clear that in conditions of rebellion00:10:40
I even made one like this00:10:42
a significant logical error I think00:10:44
Well, since he might rebel, he might00:10:46
he can take the entire common fund for himself00:10:48
assign it and then everything will be fine00:10:52
But00:10:54
then I already understood00:10:57
Nesmeyan In general, this is more correct00:10:59
analyzed it, you know, of course00:11:02
control everything with your guys00:11:04
maybe, but it’s one thing to control on the spot00:11:07
and another thing is using all this goodness00:11:09
because even if somewhere there are some00:11:11
terrible African mines lie00:11:13
some huge boxes00:11:16
with dollars there are tens of millions00:11:20
million 100 dollar bills which00:11:22
By the way, they were withdrawn from the world economy00:11:24
Sterilizes cash very well00:11:26
somewhere in America, that is, else00:11:28
American imperialism must00:11:30
thank you to say that he is struggling with00:11:31
inflation in the USA Well, I think not only00:11:34
he alone and not only Ours and There00:11:36
probably the Colombian guys are the same00:11:38
capable of fighting American inflation00:11:40
But who else is like this?00:11:43
oh well, it’s all there but00:11:46
you know, in order for all this00:11:47
especially not to be used there00:11:49
only ingots of paper lie there completely00:11:52
maybe working mines somewhere00:11:55
gold is mined00:11:56
Well, and all sorts of other interesting things to00:11:59
it all worked I need it all00:12:01
move wash00:12:03
legalize00:12:05
again logistics for security guards00:12:08
no one canceled the divisions either00:12:10
this means that this also needs to be supported00:12:12
there is just the Ministry of Defense here00:12:14
and by the way, the Russian Foreign Ministry is also very00:12:18
may be useful, but if that’s the case00:12:22
it is no longer controlled by one00:12:24
a person of even one private company00:12:27
it’s clear that there are law firms there too00:12:30
all kinds of fakes should be included00:12:32
companies through which something00:12:33
scroll and well, a lot of other things00:12:37
In short, well, so that passports are00:12:39
in any case they were real and in general00:12:42
in short00:12:44
in general, the other side has00:12:50
relatively speaking, Ministry of Defense00:12:52
governments and so on they have00:12:55
also have their trump cards in what is objective00:12:58
not even a military character Well, here you are00:13:02
blackmail this entire company military00:13:04
coup00:13:06
We've almost reached the capital and here comes00:13:11
message that Well, let's negotiate00:13:13
we will give up how many billions of dollars00:13:15
you need moreover if you are already standing at00:13:18
gates of the capital if the government has already00:13:20
began to flee the capital and move to00:13:22
Petersburg if everyone ran if they were already at00:13:25
private planes bosses in different00:13:28
on the other hand, it’s actually possible here00:13:31
taking power is another matter, what's wrong with it?00:13:33
do and then have a nice topic in general00:13:35
not the slightest units, but the main thing is that in this00:13:39
moment the compensation amount should not be00:13:43
it's just very very big even00:13:46
astronomical that is, what we are with00:13:49
With all your hard work we can get it for ourselves00:13:51
imagine That is, I think that there00:13:54
in general people are not poor I think that00:13:56
generally mountainous Now maybe00:13:57
will the mask objectively displace Elon or00:14:00
at least get close to him there00:14:02
Bill Gates Well, who else is Warren Buffett00:14:05
there is also one for these guys00:14:07
will join Well, there is also the Sultan of Brunei00:14:09
so to speak in this category Well I00:14:11
I understand that our officials are there too00:14:16
I suspect that our most important thing00:14:19
the boss is there on this list just00:14:21
list of peoples of reality Well, in general it is00:14:25
or else00:14:27
Prigogine will have to be raised00:14:29
very, very, very high I think that's it00:14:31
They probably gave him some kind of guarantee00:14:34
negotiations also took place during the day and00:14:37
as a result, the outgrowing is canceled00:14:40
Let's unwind the dance of the little swans00:14:43
backwards and everything, that is, with one00:14:46
looks like it almost happened00:14:48
coup d'etat but the coup d'etat was needed00:14:51
As a cover for00:14:53
commercial showdowns in order to00:14:56
negotiate with competitors for more00:14:59
favorable conditions00:15:00
they achieved their goals in this sense00:15:03
a coup or rebellion turned out to be just00:15:06
on the contrary, quite successful00:15:08
but things just went a little too far00:15:10
far away I think that if Putin in 1100:15:14
hours after the start I wouldn’t have performed at all00:15:16
then it was even easier to come to an agreement But with00:15:19
on the other hand, this led to the fact that00:15:22
Prigogine raised the stakes in fact00:15:25
ultimately because00:15:26
so I had to spend extra00:15:29
billion other dollars00:15:31
But00:15:33
in general Well what can I say we are all a little bit00:15:36
we take these people too seriously00:15:39
we perceive them as political00:15:41
figures including even changing trying to do00:15:44
some political forecasts where00:15:45
there is no smell of politics there, it’s pure commerce00:15:47
And00:15:49
I wrote that this is not political00:15:51
Well, I wrote yesterday morning that00:15:55
no political prospects But precisely with00:15:59
point of view of what if proposed00:16:00
will even take Moscow and declare himself00:16:02
ruler of Russia and what about this Russia00:16:04
will make it unclear if there is no00:16:07
directions no idea program00:16:09
there is no HR strategy, that’s all00:16:12
it is doomed politically But it turned out00:16:14
that this is political doom00:16:16
Of course I calculated correctly, however there00:16:19
there was no politics at all, that is, this00:16:21
political doom was not explained00:16:24
so they didn't count something00:16:26
out of control to a greater extent00:16:28
Well, there was no politics at all, there was00:16:32
so that's about me for today00:16:36
I see00:16:37
again tomorrow we will publish on rabkor00:16:40
column by Anatoly Nesmeyan where is it00:16:43
the vision is described in detail There is00:16:45
some nuances00:16:47
Well, does he just know or does he explore00:16:50
question I No, I rely on the fact that he00:16:52
writes Well let's see the last thing00:16:56
interesting that it seems to be attached00:17:00
they won’t touch those bloggers00:17:03
Prigozhinsky who wrote that yeah00:17:06
Putin is finished and so on now we all00:17:09
we'll smear you all, we'll hang these guys00:17:12
bloggers seem to be gathering somehow00:17:14
squeeze it will really happen00:17:17
or not but that's a different story we00:17:18
We'll keep an eye on it anyway00:17:20
it turns out that some military officers too00:17:23
will have to tight now no schadenfreude00:17:27
because in general there is repression if00:17:29
repression and00:17:32
Now I think I can take it easy00:17:34
moving on to questions questions means about00:17:36
this is what they will be like, I think for some00:17:38
The questions were even partially answered. So00:17:41
introductory remarks but let's see what00:17:43
will happen next Yes Boris you can only00:17:45
microphone to the left or right in some way00:17:48
move the side and you can probably hear it00:17:50
No, it just takes up most of it00:17:52
frame and the camera focuses on it Yes00:17:54
like this it will be much better on this00:17:57
so Well, it’s also necessary to mention that00:18:01
today is the same as at last home00:18:03
one book will be played on the side00:18:06
by what00:18:09
everyone I already understand the system00:18:13
book is played00:18:15
long introduction my book New We00:18:19
discussed the option of what would happen00:18:21
play out two books but just now00:18:24
this situation is not enough00:18:26
number of copies we will00:18:28
gradually00:18:29
get more and more00:18:32
but that's why we're playing only one for now00:18:34
Let's see how things go. You know next00:18:37
there because we want to improve this00:18:39
sense systematically00:18:41
stream of instances but00:18:45
the drawing scheme remains exactly the same00:18:47
that is, well in general00:18:51
Maxim will explain this now00:18:54
funny roulette turns out the more00:18:57
the person donated the more he has00:18:59
the chances are 100%00:19:01
doesn’t give because it’s in the past anyway00:19:05
since it's not the biggest donor to donate00:19:09
I received the book, yes, that is, here it is, as it were00:19:12
the chances of money and pure luck are equalized00:19:16
at least comparable00:19:19
Well, that's right, I say Maxim Yes yes00:19:23
you can participate with a donation of 50000:19:26
rubles above To participate00:19:29
you still need to not only drive it, but also00:19:32
send a link to one of yours00:19:34
contacts00:19:35
phone number or VKontakte link or00:19:39
Telegram account so that we can communicate with you00:19:42
contact here if you donate a few00:19:44
since the donations themselves are summed up in00:19:47
in the end it doesn't matter00:19:50
Well, the percentage chance increases the more you00:19:54
donate in total, the more you will have00:19:57
chance Well, but the chance changes in00:19:59
depending on00:20:01
total pool of donations on this stream here00:20:04
I repeat 500 rubles Donat minimum for00:20:08
participation and00:20:09
link or phone contact with you any00:20:13
mail possible00:20:15
to contact00:20:20
Well, I think we can start already00:20:23
with questions Yes, so the first question is from me00:20:27
just an ordinary Proletarian 2000 rubles00:20:30
So Boris Yulevich yesterday's Experience showed00:20:34
that in our realities the strong one is the one00:20:37
who has strength in the form of soldiers, machine guns and00:20:40
so on, can he create his own PMC00:20:43
RK A00:20:45
the idea is beautiful, you just understand that it’s not enough00:20:49
the fact that no one is this dude00:20:51
will most likely register it the other way around00:20:53
will register very quickly somehow00:20:55
realistic extremist or else00:20:57
some organization what do we have in common00:20:59
no need another thing is that some people00:21:02
who wear shoulder straps may be us00:21:04
listen and generally get into our00:21:06
ideas but that's something else00:21:10
So00:21:12
next Donat A and those who write that Dan00:21:16
This trick on the microphone Most likely he00:21:20
fixed probably not possible00:21:22
laptop change focus again00:21:27
Yes no If possible in the same direction00:21:30
it was not visible at all to move it any further00:21:33
Well, do you have enough table?00:21:36
difficult to move by yourself00:21:41
laptop00:21:48
second question00:21:50
invite us00:21:52
at the beginning then of course of course00:22:14
So00:22:16
Hello Boris Yulich00:22:18
I was unpleasantly surprised by the reaction00:22:21
subscribers of the work correspondent group to news about00:22:24
these skafe all the commentators are hyenas00:22:27
rejoiced at the death of people Bastards and00:22:30
scum with no empathy for other people00:22:33
there are open psychopaths with such left00:22:37
like you and the fascists don’t need your own00:22:40
there are plenty of cannibals00:22:44
I think that not everyone who writes comments00:22:48
after all, fascists and villains are cannibals and with00:22:52
on the other hand, the majority of viewers00:22:54
readers write no comments00:22:56
but the story is very short I understand00:23:01
where does all this come from Yes of course00:23:03
some00:23:05
social outrage was because00:23:08
main Who were there00:23:13
board of the company which itself00:23:15
built and was00:23:19
Pakistani billionaire who paid00:23:21
250 thousand dollars this descent to00:23:24
do the Titanic look at it00:23:27
at the bottom of the sea naturally before this man00:23:29
flew into space, not small either00:23:33
but you understand what a thing00:23:37
the team were the same hired workers00:23:42
highly paid on the Proletarian was the Son00:23:45
The 19-year-old son of this billionaire who00:23:49
A good and a bad person, but in any case00:23:51
case00:23:52
It’s not clear what’s there to gloat about, well00:23:56
and indeed in general completely death00:23:59
not very worth the people but it’s clear where it comes from00:24:02
such a social issue has arisen that00:24:04
something a millionaire sympathizes with or00:24:07
a billionaire all the more, but one more00:24:10
nuances is that00:24:13
batisk was made by a company that00:24:15
selected employees for the panel Well in00:24:17
Soviet times would have selected people from00:24:19
workers of Christian origin in00:24:22
The USSR built something like this, but I think that00:24:25
there would be much more control00:24:28
but although here is a well-known story that00:24:31
many believed that treatment in00:24:33
the Kremlin hospital of that time was worse than00:24:37
to ordinary areas Why and because in00:24:40
Kremlin hospital doctors were selected according to00:24:42
questionnaire But there’s no way to the districts, how will it work out?00:24:48
And00:24:50
here they were also selected based on a questionnaire so that they were00:24:52
people preferably not relevant00:24:55
the standard that it’s not about the eyes00:24:58
non-white, preferably non-male, female00:25:02
at least men, it is desirable00:25:05
so that they are not traditional00:25:07
orientation and this is accordingly needed00:25:09
recruited personnel, but again this is not00:25:13
it means that they selected bad personnel Well00:25:15
just when00:25:17
the staff is selected in a package, let’s say00:25:19
chance to get a good professional he00:25:22
it doesn't matter because it might coincide00:25:25
good profile good professional00:25:26
this happens often it happens But maybe00:25:29
don't match up to getting very bad00:25:31
professional Well, when someone is there00:25:34
started complaining that something was being violated00:25:36
some rules were broken00:25:38
the representative office of the retelling said that00:25:40
what are these white men all about?00:25:42
they don’t understand anything we need to have00:25:46
All00:25:47
right but on the other hand00:25:50
someone is sick of political correctness and00:25:52
someone like hatred of Anglo-Saxons00:25:54
is sick Who has what yes And so00:25:58
for example, he says that it is not necessary00:26:02
reckon with the invented eyes of theory00:26:06
gravity00:26:07
If I get you right00:26:10
these guys just don't count either00:26:14
it worked out in the end00:26:18
so the next Donut is all abbreviations and00:26:22
no spaces So if something00:26:24
I read it wrong, it’s better to correct it right away00:26:27
so I read Frankfursach and noticed00:26:32
and it’s bad with the team Apparently with00:26:36
returned to Germany spoke openly00:26:38
about the responsibility of the Germans for coming to00:26:41
Nazi rule and World War II00:26:43
no account, still considered necessary00:26:47
for the nation, working on oneself00:26:50
parallels with the current one I agree00:26:52
without universal repentance it is impossible00:26:56
uh rebirth of the people00:26:59
Well, you know the corresponding quote adorda00:27:02
I don't know specifically00:27:04
it was possible and it was said that they really want00:27:07
it is important to understand what was the emphasis of the work on00:27:10
yourself or repentance are not the same thing00:27:12
Moreover, they are completely different00:27:14
opposite things That's because00:27:16
Repentance is a kind of public action on00:27:20
self-humiliation is aimed at the most00:27:23
discredit or devaluation itself00:27:27
which not only does not imply00:27:29
positive work on yourself but really00:27:30
in fact excludes even the possibility of such00:27:32
work00:27:33
that is, I’m not sure what exactly is repentance00:27:37
this may be something you need to think about But00:27:42
this is for any person00:27:44
if he did something bad or even00:27:47
participated in something bad allowed something to happen00:27:50
disgusting, it’s a very bad job for him00:27:52
over myself Why did I allow this to happen00:27:56
happened to me what is my personal share00:27:59
what is our fault? Collective share of blame and00:28:02
so on, but this is not Repentance, this is exactly00:28:04
quite psychoanalytic00:28:06
psychological spirit work on oneself00:28:08
This is a completely different story but again00:28:11
I repeat00:28:13
I don’t know the exact quote, so I00:28:17
What is called interpreted go00:28:19
maybe I didn't catch something00:28:24
so next question00:28:29
Denis so khvatulin 500 rubles without00:28:32
any message Here I donated00:28:34
Thank you00:28:37
So00:28:39
cat Frosya Hello yesterday alone00:28:42
the cook showed what to present at least00:28:45
some requirement is needed at a minimum00:28:48
have a concert00:28:50
orchestra on00:28:52
it is now00:28:56
but what I found does not give any indication of the fact that00:29:00
a lot of people support this whole thing00:29:02
terrible time for self-organization is lost00:29:05
any initiative is irrevocably suppressed00:29:07
what to do accept it00:29:09
I think it's time to organize ourselves00:29:11
lost forever, you understand that00:29:13
self-organization is not a matter of time00:29:15
question of conditions00:29:17
time even if there are no real conditions you00:29:22
you can take as long as you like there00:29:24
at least 10 Although 150 years will not give conditions00:29:27
will ripen therefore during this time anyway00:29:29
do nothing it doesn't work like that00:29:33
first second what00:29:37
tell you I think that these are just the conditions00:29:41
it is quite possible for self-organization00:29:42
starts right now And00:29:46
By the way, these are the last events00:29:49
time has shown how necessary it is00:29:52
showed This is not like you and I00:29:54
showed00:29:55
that the mass public because quite00:29:59
number of people are somewhat terrified and00:30:01
says someone supports adoption00:30:03
supports that supports that Oh this00:30:05
now it's all over. These people aren't00:30:08
delve into what does Prigozhin want in this case?00:30:12
what did you want why this whole story is about00:30:15
what are we talking about here No just Oh00:30:18
Well, something like this is happening and it’s great that00:30:21
something happened here But even more so00:30:23
interesting some guys with machine guns00:30:26
tales on the streets00:30:28
some Tanks you can climb on them00:30:30
take a selfie take a photo with00:30:33
girl Well, a lot of interesting, that's why I00:30:36
I think that people perceive it as00:30:38
such a created political position and00:30:41
on the contrary, here we also need to take into account00:30:44
the important fact is that after all00:30:49
there are a number of these00:30:52
frostbitten Patriots who00:30:54
supported anxiously What does this mean00:30:56
the patriot camp split Well, approximately00:30:59
equally And this is good and moreover these00:31:02
people quite possibly will begin00:31:04
some kind of breakdown of some kind00:31:08
kind of cognitive dissonance How fashionable00:31:10
now talk some internal00:31:12
thoughts will go on and some even00:31:16
clear00:31:21
So00:31:22
next donation00:31:25
student from Moscow So good afternoon Donat00:31:30
from two parts and yes I see it from above00:31:33
one Donat And about did Prigozhin lose00:31:36
situation whether he wanted power survived went to00:31:40
Belarus00:31:41
Wagner does not sign contracts counting00:31:46
respect from the population because civilians are not00:31:48
touched and showed that the authorities are all cowards00:31:52
so the second Donat is the second part and he00:31:54
opened Pandora's Box can be active and dashing00:31:58
wielding weapons in their hands on trucks in00:32:00
side of the Capital and nothing will happen to you00:32:02
even cities can be taken without shots00:32:05
it turned out that the population was not at all00:32:06
loyal to Putin according to scripts Yesterday00:32:08
sent Donat for 1000 rubles so with this00:32:12
no one Yes, I checked and we yesterday00:32:15
answered Donat, I only asked a question00:32:17
abbreviated00:32:18
about what00:32:20
about political society00:32:25
I’ll say it right away first of all00:32:28
Yes, he didn’t lose another case that he has00:32:30
there were commercial problems, he solved them00:32:32
do you understand what will happen to that part now?00:32:35
Wagner which remained inside Russia00:32:37
By the way, it’s not clear if Prigozhin and00:32:39
Russia dumped00:32:41
at least officially in Belarus and00:32:44
It’s quite possible Belarus has had it for a long time too00:32:45
no longer, he's probably somewhere already00:32:47
Central Africa Well at least00:32:49
this is probably the first thing we're talking about00:32:52
I just didn’t even hear anymore And even00:32:54
if he won and lost in00:32:56
political or ideological or00:32:57
in some other sense this is for him00:32:59
no longer important And by and large for00:33:01
us too so this is for the moment00:33:05
history but what he showed first00:33:07
weakness secondly cowardice of power in00:33:10
thirdly, the ease of which everything is possible00:33:12
collapse And fourthly, the complete absence00:33:15
real grassroots support for the authorities00:33:18
it's obvious Well, a lot of people watched00:33:21
Now guys like this will fix it here00:33:23
Well okay like that00:33:25
if he later went on TV and00:33:28
would announce that he is now the president I will00:33:30
I assure you that well, 95 percent of Putin00:33:32
loyal electorate really loyal00:33:34
they just said oh well and right there00:33:38
They completely forgot that Putin was, you know00:33:40
By the way, this is accurate. We checked with this00:33:44
Here00:33:46
retired staff Well, at least it’s impossible00:33:50
a pensioner can be very different00:33:52
reasonable and even there people are 80 years old books00:33:54
they write but or there is something else to do very00:33:57
valuable She has such a massive this00:34:00
Here00:34:01
elderly television audience people00:34:04
who are zombied by TV here with00:34:09
they have such a problem that if you forgive00:34:10
person to retell the program that he00:34:13
I literally heard him there five minutes ago00:34:15
can't predict what it was about00:34:17
if let's say they ask so that they just don't00:34:21
remember that's what it is00:34:23
the main base of such stable support00:34:25
so this will be the base of any power00:34:27
the power changes tomorrow and they just00:34:30
forgot that yesterday they supported each other00:34:34
The next question is00:34:38
I follow the leftist agenda, I say that we have00:34:41
quite correct capitalism but friends00:34:44
especially after yesterday they say00:34:47
feudalism Boris Yulich has already degraded00:34:49
before feudalism or not yet00:34:51
I’m now saying you need something to insult00:34:54
feudalism then why offend feudalism?00:34:57
another system with very logical00:35:01
system established by clear rules00:35:04
by the way, in many ways much more00:35:06
fairly and in one's own way or at least00:35:08
much more00:35:09
logical even than in general in principle00:35:11
capitalism because00:35:15
peripheral type Why Because they00:35:18
it's just very bad everything is bad there00:35:21
it doesn't work, everything works great00:35:23
If this is real feudalism00:35:26
The first is an agrarian society, point00:35:29
agricultural if you have an industrial00:35:31
society cannot be feudalism because00:35:33
that is not even built on property00:35:36
on the ground and in touch00:35:38
like and ground, that is, we won’t say00:35:41
the estate belongs to the feudal lord00:35:43
between the estate, that is, the feudal lord and00:35:46
the peasant are equally00:35:48
part of the estate they can't easily00:35:50
leave they are attached to him and this00:35:54
not serfdom of the Russian type because00:35:55
that serfdom of the Russian type is the same00:35:57
capitalist relations when people00:35:59
can trade sell as a product00:36:03
Well, what about American slavery? Yes, which00:36:06
only the conditions appear00:36:08
capitalism and fedorism is assumed00:36:11
simple and peasant feudal lord tied to00:36:13
their estate and tied to each other00:36:14
they cannot exist without each other00:36:16
they have a system of mutual obligations00:36:19
which they must perform well00:36:21
actually when the feudal lord begins to fail00:36:22
fulfill obligations, riots begin00:36:24
When is it usually burned, especially in the early00:36:27
catalism burning castles is very similar00:36:30
the system also works well so how00:36:33
as a rule they don't do that, so00:36:35
accordingly further00:36:37
system of feudal relations built00:36:41
on what the overlord has00:36:42
certain obligations to00:36:44
rebelled with her vassals00:36:46
reassignment00:36:48
Yes, every life cycle these00:36:51
obligations are confirmed and00:36:54
are respected accordingly00:36:57
important again is the point that the key00:36:59
the principle of feudalism is not law00:37:01
this is really different from capitalism00:37:04
unwritten law and custom but partly00:37:07
customs is honor honor you understand00:37:09
that's where the honor of Russian officials was00:37:12
among00:37:13
Russian armed formations00:37:17
admitted, it’s hard for me to imagine A00:37:21
if you take the honor factor that is00:37:24
knightly part Yes Noble part00:37:26
it will just fall apart, it will never happen again00:37:29
honor is the regulative principle00:37:32
regulating ethical and even on this00:37:34
sense, the political principles of the system are00:37:37
Yes, of course the principle is violated, but00:37:40
they are violated by capitalism and you are afraid about00:37:43
Socialism will be violated by individuals00:37:45
people Yes, but as a principle it is00:37:47
regulating factors therefore Well of course00:37:50
saying that in Russia federalism is00:37:51
certainly a vile insult to00:37:52
feudalism in Russia feudalism is close00:37:54
not even those examples that are given00:37:58
they are mainly associated with the era00:38:00
the decay of feudalism that is00:38:02
a decayed society when the system is not00:38:05
works when relationships don't rule00:38:07
work like everyone else breaks them when no one00:38:10
doesn't trust anyone when00:38:12
no agreements are being respected00:38:15
the laws are respected in principle, this is again00:38:18
the same feature of the decomposition of any society is00:38:20
there is any decaying society any00:38:22
decaying system or system00:38:24
unstable she is affected by this00:38:26
from here they say Game of Thrones00:38:29
Yes This is not about feudalism As such it is00:38:32
more about the decay of society and00:38:35
decomposition of the state00:38:37
Fine00:38:40
don’t you think that Putin is only00:38:42
strengthened his power and reputation because he00:38:45
smog without blood and loud statements00:38:47
suppress a rebellion that has every chance of00:38:49
success thereby showing its00:38:52
capacity of both rhythm and west00:38:54
Why has he been lucky for so long?00:38:57
didn’t say that he suppressed the rebellion, he paid off00:39:00
from the rebels, we understand that he suppressed00:39:04
if loyal troops came because of two00:39:08
hours in 20 minutes in two days they demolished00:39:13
to smithereens to smithereens these so that they00:39:16
there they all ran away and said hello00:39:18
so that they beg for mercy00:39:21
mercy And then he gave a rebellion or another00:39:25
option that he turned that I am against00:39:28
of this rebellion you are rebels you are a traitor and00:39:31
Immediately the Wagnerites said Oh, what a horror00:39:33
we give up and give him Prigozhin00:39:36
head and00:39:38
Well, someone called the FSB00:39:42
called for Prigozhin to be handed over to us and that’s it00:39:45
Fine00:39:46
Now, if it happened like this00:39:48
script Yes suppressed And so nothing00:39:51
suppressed the opposite00:39:53
Prigogine joyfully having fun with songs00:39:58
jokes turned around and went home but00:40:01
another thing is that I think that part00:40:02
Prigozhinsky staff who are serious00:40:05
the wrong people perceived what was happening00:40:08
closest assistants who00:40:10
participate in the deal will probably also receive00:40:12
their share of the production This is because00:40:15
Essentially, I was ashore. Yes, these are the privates00:40:19
mercenaries privates00:40:21
they're probably dudes now00:40:23
some are perplexed because they too00:40:25
tried to motivate with some ideas00:40:27
like we are for Russia and so on and then00:40:30
they said what Russia is like there, this is what they turned out to be00:40:33
and besides, maybe they are some kind of00:40:35
the additional bank did not receive therefore00:40:37
I think it’s just among the PMC personnel00:40:39
there are a lot of dissatisfied people and in this sense Yes00:40:42
they failed the story but i think man00:40:47
maybe a person will actually be someone00:40:49
transferred to another00:41:02
are you young or not?00:41:05
Do you agree that Marxism is not00:41:08
complete knowledge and just an attempt00:41:11
interpretations by an imperfect mind00:41:13
real processes and also transmitted00:41:17
through such a distorting instrument as00:41:19
the language, which means the Marxists just invented it00:41:23
his explanation of society and it00:41:25
equivalent to other explanations00:41:28
from the first half I agree with the second00:41:30
no because the thesis is that Marxism is00:41:33
an attempt to explain society, especially on00:41:36
in some human language it is00:41:39
it's true and it can be said at all00:41:42
about any text in general about00:41:45
any text written by Man simply00:41:46
in general love and since Marxist00:41:49
the texts are written by people they are supermind00:41:52
and it’s not God that means it’s probably true00:41:56
than they agree that this is equivalence00:41:59
any other way of interpretation No00:42:01
not equivalent, but because there is scientific00:42:04
again they have their own interpretations00:42:07
boundaries are your problems, well00:42:10
ideological or just don’t know00:42:13
some non-scientific interpretations00:42:15
Marcism is a scientific interpretation00:42:17
having a certain methodology00:42:19
another question is that any scientific00:42:22
interpretation also has its limits00:42:24
boundaries are what scientists call00:42:27
validity00:42:31
applicability yes, that is, simply put00:42:33
if we assume about feudalism too00:42:37
and capitalism if we have any knowledge00:42:40
which we possess feudalism will00:42:43
mechanically transfer to capitalism then00:42:46
it turns out that it all doesn't work well00:42:48
under feudalism people behave like this00:42:50
we mean they will behave like this00:42:53
it would be wrong it is by the way Marx00:42:55
it was he who wrote about this that he00:42:57
the study is limited to certain00:43:00
historical and geographical reality00:43:03
there is this primarily Western Europe And00:43:04
in general the so-called Western world and this00:43:06
period somewhere here, relatively speaking, there with00:43:09
fifteenth-sixteenth to nine Yes00:43:11
standing there There they are What is it called00:43:13
currency and not critically mechanical00:43:17
transfer to another Well, this is at least00:43:20
raises questions at a minimum00:43:22
check how well it will work00:43:24
I believe that the dialectical method is everything00:43:27
works the same but every time you have to00:43:30
conduct the research again00:43:32
many Marxists are simply mechanical00:43:35
carry over what you just said00:43:37
mechanical leads from one to another00:43:39
That is, they do not understand boundaries00:43:41
disability00:43:42
Well, then just do dogmatic00:43:45
wrong conclusions though00:43:48
we need to understand that research is needed00:43:50
every social phenomenon00:43:55
next donation00:43:58
and from the same donator why Marxists00:44:01
social sciences are underestimated and considered00:44:03
they are, if not bourgeois, then very00:44:05
engaged00:44:07
what kind of Marxists are we talking about? It seems to me00:44:11
the person is simply very unfamiliar with00:44:12
Marxist texts or his00:44:14
some neighbors are very familiar00:44:17
limited guys who Why00:44:19
read by all Marxists because in general00:44:21
Marxism is based entirely on00:44:23
social sciences himself is00:44:26
organic part00:44:28
moreover, outside of Marxism in general00:44:31
modern social sciences will00:44:33
sociology economics political science00:44:35
Imagine it’s impossible that everyone00:44:38
Marxists are not involved, but even00:44:41
when let's say you have something in common00:44:44
quite hostile paroxysm of school00:44:46
you still have to at least answer00:44:48
the questions that Marxism posed therefore00:44:50
Marxism is an organic part00:44:52
social sciences therefore tell someone00:44:53
neglect No at all00:44:55
unity about bourgeoisness here if00:44:57
we have experience because00:45:00
the first generation spoke about this00:45:04
Marxists based already on Marx that00:45:07
social position ideological00:45:09
class position naturally distorts00:45:11
distorts the view yes that is if we00:45:14
we are engaged, we look from the position00:45:16
of a certain class we are respectively00:45:18
tendentious and therefore Marx is precisely in00:45:22
difference from bourgeois in quotes00:45:24
researchers directly says I'm becoming00:45:25
positions of the proletariat and bourgeois00:45:27
the researcher says I am looking from the position00:45:30
common good from the perspective of common interest00:45:33
actually use the police00:45:34
parasites therefore Mark in his00:45:36
shows and acknowledges commitment00:45:37
honestly and this is precisely his scientific strength00:45:40
that he immediately corrects himself in00:45:43
in this sense shows its00:45:44
limitations and demonstratively they00:45:46
declares a00:45:48
liberal different researchers are very00:45:51
often hide and in this sense just00:45:54
exhibits scientific dishonesty00:46:03
also from the young one from the Alliance00:46:06
invitational interviews with Victor00:46:09
Altsk nesvisa apparently00:46:18
why wasn't he more radical in his00:46:22
trying to save the USSR00:46:24
Why was he so radical?00:46:27
I remember him very well in those years he00:46:30
was00:46:32
how was he so radical?00:46:35
as far as I could let's say so you understand Well then00:46:37
there is something from any person can give00:46:38
what can you expect, what, who is he?00:46:40
By the way, he has a colonel of the engineering troops00:46:43
didn't have any of my own00:46:45
powerful political organization00:46:47
participated quite actively00:46:50
in events Well, I could do something else00:46:53
Well, how right was he of all his00:46:56
actions because it is often00:46:58
the attempt to preserve the USSR relied on00:47:00
the idea that anything is possible00:47:02
leave it the same anyway00:47:04
was doomed but00:47:07
I don’t see any lack of radicalism in him00:47:09
Volgograd radically and many others00:47:13
[music]00:47:19
so how do you like that Georgy Fedorov00:47:22
is in the upset Patriots club00:47:26
Well, I don’t really feel sorry for Georgiy, I sincerely tell him00:47:30
My condolences because this is of course a dead end00:47:32
and this significantly negates that00:47:35
what he used to do and what he00:47:38
did for most of my life00:47:40
previous life therefore the club in general00:47:43
unpromising And even more so positions00:47:47
Fedorov in this club In general, he has no00:47:49
especially of political significance because00:47:53
what are people initially trying to solve?00:47:57
an unsolvable task, that is, to maintain00:47:59
authorities and Putin while condemning them00:48:01
as absolutely criminal and at the same time00:48:03
Means00:48:04
either one or the other or you're on the side00:48:07
criminals00:48:08
I must say we condemn these people as00:48:11
criminals as enemies of Russia and we will00:48:13
support Hello Hello00:48:17
and they also ask how you feel about00:48:19
because he drowns for fighting And00:48:22
will you continue to collaborate with him?00:48:25
unfortunately it's impossible now00:48:36
Donat00:48:38
Schrödinger fur seal trade union00:48:42
so everything should be decided in the interests00:48:45
worker How to understand workers or00:48:49
exploiter00:48:51
Well, you see, first of all, let's start with the fact that00:48:54
after all, we are talking precisely about the fact that00:48:57
Workers organize and their interests00:49:00
formulate understand there is always00:49:03
the problem that we have00:49:04
political Marxism is what we are trying to00:49:07
speak on behalf of the Workers and we00:49:11
in fact, we don’t just appropriate00:49:13
this knowledge Yes we assume we00:49:16
We investigate the issue We analyze interests00:49:19
we analyze the structure of interests00:49:20
analyze the social process during00:49:23
of this analysis we do certain00:49:25
conclusions about00:49:26
what is in the interests of the Workers and what is not00:49:29
Accordingly, we insist on this00:49:33
we are fighting but00:49:36
on the other hand, you know there is00:49:39
the danger is that we will simply arrogate rights00:49:42
speak on their behalf on behalf of the huge00:49:45
the masses of people will not ask Who00:49:48
said that we are right in everything who said00:49:50
that ours is impeccable who said that people00:49:54
even having objective interests00:49:57
are fully aware of them and therefore00:50:01
create them in the same formulations like this00:50:04
how we formulate them, that is00:50:06
accordingly, without the participation of the mass itself00:50:09
people without the participation of the masses themselves00:50:11
decision making and in formulating00:50:15
policy or political course00:50:18
nothing good will come of it00:50:21
sooner or later we'll get it instead00:50:24
authoritarian system where00:50:27
a small group will impose on the people00:50:29
the idea that it was popular00:50:32
so there should be some dialogue here00:50:35
people may not understand themselves00:50:37
our own interests are also true, but we don’t00:50:40
we have the right to make unambiguous decisions for people00:50:43
where is their interest not to ask it like00:50:46
the problem of the entire Soviet system in general00:50:49
there was a system00:50:51
knows better than you yourself Who makes up00:50:54
there seem to be supports for this system, but there are00:50:58
the other side of this00:51:00
case It is that00:51:04
in general, when there is overwhelming00:51:07
majority of the people00:51:09
who earns by his labor00:51:13
then it is not possible to discern the interests of the Workers00:51:17
very difficult, that is, we are great00:51:19
understand who actually composes00:51:22
this also gives an exploitative elite00:51:25
sociological analysis we see interest00:51:27
these are the tops, she is quite clearly her own00:51:30
interests cannot be realized00:51:32
society is much less human00:51:35
And there are intermediate phases from00:51:38
intermediate state there is a person00:51:40
which is acceptable00:51:41
It works best to own it00:51:44
some small company somewhere else00:51:46
there are two employees Who is he00:51:48
exploiter of electric ten this and that00:51:51
That's why it's a contradictory interest00:51:53
objectively contradictory But further00:51:56
that's how he identifies himself00:51:59
who is he ready to go with?00:52:22
No, I'm not confused by the microphone yet00:52:27
once I read what was heard at the meeting00:52:29
I heard it fine yes And on stream00:52:32
couldn't be heard00:52:35
if you seem to be hired by someone somewhere but00:52:39
you get funds that have little correlation00:52:42
means that have little correlation with what you are00:52:46
you do it AND at the same time you order00:52:47
house cleaning and food delivery00:52:51
If you order house cleaning or00:52:56
food saver you pay for the service you00:53:00
buy00:53:02
an exploiter who earns00:53:05
you understand money through someone else's labor00:53:08
that is, it’s not like someone came to me00:53:11
let's say fixed the toilet00:53:13
I paid I don't use it I don't00:53:17
received money from what he received00:53:18
the toilet wasted money therefore00:53:21
there is no exploitation here00:53:22
organization is when someone else's work is mine00:53:25
brings money that's the point00:53:27
operation00:53:29
I didn’t earn any money, which means I didn’t have anyone00:53:31
exploited But another question00:53:33
some idiot is paying me money00:53:35
which I didn’t earn Well, be glad that00:53:38
there are idiots who pay you00:53:39
money that you didn't earn. Well00:53:41
they say you are lucky and the last one is still00:53:44
the question is in this donation00:53:46
they ask And how to understand what’s wrong00:53:50
public00:53:51
Which one is not?00:53:53
The Society itself must make a decision00:53:56
we can analyze it and evaluate it00:53:58
again, how does this correlate with interest?00:54:01
society they can be calculated but there are00:54:03
necessary conditions for reproduction00:54:06
social organism That is, for example00:54:07
we understand that if there are diseases there are00:54:11
healthcare that fights them00:54:13
then probably health care will work00:54:16
Logical00:54:18
But00:54:20
nevertheless of course00:54:22
society members of society must00:54:25
participate make a decision00:54:27
socialism00:54:36
next Donation from anonymous Good evening00:54:38
the right of a nation to self-determination is one00:54:41
from the basic principles of Marxism why00:54:42
then on the past aspiration with a suit00:54:45
you said that Karabakh should be00:54:47
Is Azerbaijan recognized by its residents?00:54:50
Karabakh should not have the right to00:54:53
self-determination and shouldn't it00:54:56
defend Marxists00:54:58
here everything is immediately confused, first of all, I’m not00:55:01
said that Karabakh should be recognized00:55:03
Azerbaijan is just Kostyuk00:55:07
they said that as a result of the war00:55:14
it turns out that by force00:55:16
Azerbaijan resolved the issue in its favor and00:55:19
By the way, how did you decide before this in Armenia?00:55:22
that is, not that side, not the other, not00:55:25
held a referendum as we know And thus00:55:29
more referendum on certain00:55:30
you understand the rules they say here00:55:32
they don’t trust the referendum, let’s say here it is00:55:34
held by the winners held by the winner00:55:37
a referendum involves a number of00:55:39
requirements firstly that there00:55:41
at least 51 percent of00:55:43
registered voters and on00:55:45
that moment when the conflict is only00:55:47
started because if one group00:55:49
people kicked out another group from00:55:51
territories and then didn’t count them00:55:53
votes But what kind of referendum is this?00:55:56
violates the rules, both parties must00:55:58
have equal chances equal rights to00:56:00
campaigning all television airtime00:56:03
which is at least publicly available00:56:05
should be divided exactly 50/5000:56:07
that means both parties must have the right00:56:10
fully express your Arguments and so00:56:12
then there's surveillance and control00:56:16
counting votes other other and then00:56:19
be surprised if this is not observed then00:56:20
why does someone not believe it?00:56:22
result because it is not respected00:56:24
Elementary rules that actually00:56:26
do it vote directly00:56:28
referendum This is the first thing I do now00:56:32
I emphasize that no one said that Karabakh00:56:35
must be Azerbaijani00:56:36
we just said that Azerbaijan00:56:39
I decided just like before I decided00:56:43
his Armenia, the Armenian side is more precisely in00:56:46
in principle of course00:56:48
[music]00:56:52
won't they don't want it or they're different00:56:55
side00:56:56
Here00:56:58
Well, we need to negotiate in an amicable way00:57:03
the definition is not the most obvious00:57:06
Marxist position is true00:57:08
Lenin's position is unconditional00:57:10
it was there that Lenin had a very important00:57:13
reservations, but in principle there is Rosa’s position00:57:15
Luxembourg which says that just00:57:18
It's not about self-determination of rights00:57:21
The workers and we should not00:57:24
care about national interests even00:57:25
care about your interests00:57:28
workers00:57:29
working Proletarian class and so on00:57:32
further, therefore, all national games -00:57:35
it's all from the evil one, it's terrible, it's00:57:37
Roslisselburg position00:57:39
there is a position of auto Marxists who tell me00:57:42
closest to those who talked about what00:57:44
national cultural rights are necessary00:57:46
observe protect but they cannot be reduced and00:57:50
should not be limited to the formation00:57:52
own state That is, if we00:57:55
actually we can state00:57:59
multinational empire state00:58:02
protect national rights this way and that00:58:04
and be it better than if every nation00:58:07
every people actually must00:58:09
the state because firstly, well, even00:58:12
you know how the formula we don't want to be00:58:14
national minority in your00:58:16
state We want you to be00:58:18
national that in our state we00:58:20
drew the line just an oppressor00:58:22
oppressed have changed places everything is here00:58:25
this is not a solution is that everything00:58:27
the rights of all people of all nationalities00:58:30
ethnic religious groups were in00:58:32
equally protected00:58:35
in 201200:58:39
I'm from Rostov opposite its southwest00:58:43
south-eastern district00:58:45
located00:58:48
city police department what are they talking about00:58:51
were engaged in video capture of the southeastern00:58:53
districts00:58:58
we need the military district of Moscow00:59:28
Well then00:59:31
what the police were doing the police were protecting00:59:33
by the way, all this seemed00:59:36
the story of the Prigozhinsky rebellion what00:59:39
the police are not a factor at all if00:59:42
that it’s not just Armed at all, even00:59:44
political struggle that is the police00:59:46
automatically obeys the one who has00:59:50
whom the tanks relatively speaking00:59:52
the police won't just be great00:59:54
resist university no weapons00:59:56
to resist but she will give us00:59:58
obey01:00:01
Well, basically the plan is a fortress01:00:03
assumed that the police were hiding in their01:00:07
institutions in police departments in01:00:10
some of his other offices are locked01:00:13
there she protects herself, but on the street01:00:17
go to the city to do whatever you want01:00:23
I think there is some order too01:00:26
Supported them They didn’t need to01:00:28
the city began to collect what young people01:00:30
bad images By the way, I understand that01:00:33
the species took care of it, I don’t know01:00:36
we've been thinking about this, yeah So01:00:40
the police were always kept period So here too01:00:43
one more question and why not01:00:45
took advantage of the rebellion01:00:47
so, well, there was a question about the tank, yes01:00:50
that the tank is not stuck, pointed the muzzle at Well01:00:53
Yes01:00:54
well, I don’t know, I wasn’t there01:00:57
it still seems very grotesque01:00:58
story: When a tank gets stuck in a gate01:01:01
circus01:01:02
This seems very symbolic to me01:01:05
the situation is funny Yes, I would honestly01:01:08
I would leave it there later as a monument01:01:09
all this heavy and generally all this01:01:11
era But01:01:14
as for the whole thing, well, first of all, we don’t01:01:17
we know whether we will use it or not01:01:19
because there is very little data out there01:01:22
everything is happening at the front, they stopped talking about01:01:24
Ukrainians also write this and report01:01:27
but I think that firstly they are several01:01:30
we were just blown away by what we saw01:01:33
there's something going on with the Russians. They weren't there.01:01:35
ready for this rebellion01:01:38
use it but needed how01:01:39
at least there for a few days01:01:41
figure out what's going on with the other one01:01:43
sides perhaps partially somewhere and01:01:45
using such areas is another matter01:01:48
that now the long-term situation is playing01:01:50
that is, it is quite possible that part01:01:52
Russian troops are very strong01:01:53
demotivated after they01:01:54
observed in the rear and this may01:01:57
seem like a very serious factor01:01:58
it doesn’t even matter how everything goes01:02:00
Ukrainian side Well, we'll see later01:02:02
what's going on downstream?01:02:04
Dnieper because the water has almost gone there01:02:07
everything dried up and it seemed like it was all over again01:02:11
No one like Prigozhin allegedly claimed01:02:14
Ukrainian some Armed groups01:02:16
quite a lot are transported if they01:02:19
they crossed there in large numbers01:02:20
already Yes there will be problems01:02:25
[music]01:02:30
here is anonymous 200 rubles Good evening01:02:34
Invite Elena Agafonova to Stream01:02:37
Youtube channel People's control of Tula01:02:40
area you know, I don’t know, but again01:02:43
[music]01:02:45
we will keep this in mind, I will write to you Yes01:02:49
now and here addition01:02:51
woman01:02:58
recognized as an agent, she is invited to her place01:03:02
liberal media but not very accepting01:03:05
about Elena's Soviet slogans01:03:07
important to remove to improve relations left01:03:10
Fine01:03:13
Please write out01:03:17
again it would be desirable for us to find01:03:29
3,400 rubles Good evening interesting01:03:32
Could this all be a performance for01:03:35
Russian citizens for the West or else01:03:38
someone is missing01:03:48
[music]01:03:55
So01:04:00
so will the authorities learn their lesson and will01:04:03
strive to avoid repetition01:04:05
similar01:04:06
to some extent Yes probably But these are there01:04:10
every such situation is enough01:04:13
unique because01:04:16
how can I tell you later just because01:04:24
next time if someone rebels01:04:27
completely different then it will be again01:04:28
another story another plot another01:04:31
another drama because reasons everyone01:04:33
times will be unique What can01:04:36
happen01:04:37
will be real not in the sense that in01:04:41
the first time there was no riot or anything01:04:43
there was a performance that he had the wrong ones01:04:46
the goals that were announced are not the same01:04:49
that we knew01:04:50
next time something might happen01:04:52
taken seriously and arrange another01:04:54
the rebellion was already where the goals did not hold01:04:57
correspond01:04:59
proclaimed then by the way01:05:02
I think that the authorities will not be at all01:05:03
capable because this is the method01:05:07
which was not used but simply01:05:08
agree on money it won't work01:05:17
[music]01:05:19
Next question from this donation: How01:05:22
public trust will change and01:05:26
army to this structure01:05:29
but what kind of dude Wagner is there Probably01:05:34
I think that on the one hand they are for01:05:38
some part of the population was not raised01:05:39
your authority or some other way around01:05:41
dropped that is, those who have nothing at all01:05:44
knew and suddenly saw that these people01:05:47
rebelled and almost bet on01:05:50
knees of power01:05:52
probably rushing with great interest as01:05:55
minimum and even sympathy And those who talk about them01:05:58
knew and believed in them and really01:06:01
took slogans seriously01:06:04
Everyone will probably be extremely01:06:06
they won't be very disappointed01:06:08
relate01:06:11
the next thing seems to be weakening the dude01:06:15
beneficial for the future protest01:06:17
movement01:06:21
so they saw that Fedorov was with the angry01:06:26
Patriots is now sitting01:06:28
coal was already a question, I already answered yes01:06:31
very sad, sorry Georgi so much01:06:35
[music]01:06:37
so hope you're close frankly01:06:41
dubious people in brackets Mironov and01:06:44
especially by people with cannibalistic views01:06:46
in arrow brackets01:06:48
We won't see Gubarev01:06:53
when myron and I talked01:06:58
moreover, here recently One of my common01:07:02
an acquaintance with him said that well, what’s so01:07:06
to Sergei Mikhailovich, he’s not01:07:08
believes what he says, it's all make-believe I01:07:11
I say maybe she's talking for fun but we01:07:13
are you really listening here?01:07:16
concerning01:07:21
there were not fundamentally different views01:07:23
Moreover, he once said about me that01:07:26
Boriska This is my most respected enemy01:07:30
I also treat him with the same respect, but01:07:33
we are fundamentally01:07:37
can be treated01:07:39
just unlike Prigogine sincerely01:07:42
thinks what he says, I like it01:07:45
like it Strongly dislike it01:07:49
other people who are just brazen01:07:52
every minute01:07:55
So01:07:56
[music]01:07:58
next Donat Briz Yurievich are you serious01:08:02
discussing this Nesmeyan conspiracy theory01:08:05
this is a standard story from him and no01:08:08
no facts and what happened yesterday01:08:11
Rybin It was a very strange Stream01:08:14
firstly, what happened yesterday from Rybnoye01:08:17
Rybina listened to the questions, answered them and01:08:21
gave some comments and no01:08:26
problems01:08:28
really very Well yes due to fatigue01:08:33
Here01:08:36
how will you describe the plot?01:08:39
the thing is you see a social process01:08:41
some kind of mass action01:08:44
people and here you see a rebellion conspiracy01:08:48
it is clear that a conspiracy for rebellion is needed01:08:51
the conspiracy must be said first01:08:54
start some actions that are01:08:57
outside the legal rule01:09:00
conspiracy probably needs to be studied01:09:03
it wasn't because we don't believe conspiracies01:09:06
What was it then?01:09:09
you want to give a different explanation but01:09:11
Which Give another explanation01:09:14
because that's all absolutely01:09:15
I explain unconvincingly that Prigozhin01:09:17
I just suddenly changed my mind because01:09:20
I was afraid to shed blood if this01:09:23
believe me, well, I sympathize with you01:09:28
next Donat Describe typical01:09:32
Trotskyist and Stalinist01:09:36
This is a good psychological test01:09:40
But01:09:44
Trotskyists are more fundamentally the rest01:09:47
more pragmatic01:09:49
Stalinists01:09:51
people usually01:09:54
smaller range, say theoretical01:09:58
it’s even interesting for political ones that is01:10:00
typically steel01:10:02
usually focuses on01:10:06
What is called a sinless leader01:10:13
steel yes Or some kind of replacement for Stalin01:10:16
current01:10:18
which replaces Stalin's local point01:10:22
and focus on this person01:10:25
which seems to express the principle01:10:30
socialist revolutionary01:10:32
action and thinking01:10:34
critical assessment is underdeveloped here01:10:38
Trotskyist focuses on the absolute01:10:41
idea yes, that is, he does not focus on01:10:45
absolute leader absolutely idea01:10:47
Therefore, transcrists actually all the time01:10:50
quarrel, quarrel and split what01:10:52
everyone has their own idea absolutely01:10:54
ideas01:10:55
absolutely socialist01:10:57
Communist idea01:10:58
At the same time, it must be said that, like Stalin,01:11:01
was a soloist in the narrow sense of the word01:11:04
plan what was01:11:08
no longer just political pragmatism01:11:11
being Stalin should not navigate01:11:13
at least He set the settings like this01:11:18
Trotsky if he wasn’t01:11:22
But there is one more thing very important for01:11:26
Stalinism which is more likely01:11:30
Well very often reproduced by Turkish01:11:32
organizations that the apparatus begins01:11:35
make political decisions that is01:11:37
the device is created to perform01:11:39
political decisions And after some01:11:41
you start assigning time01:11:43
opportunities the right to make political01:11:46
decisions and accordingly begins01:11:47
accept01:11:48
subordinating politics to oneself and not vice versa01:11:51
that is, well, Lenin wrote about this by the way01:11:54
a good apparatus for politics and not01:11:55
policies for the apparatus are Stalin's01:11:58
the approach is that the policy was01:12:00
for the device the device itself receives01:12:03
solution01:12:04
And in this sense, Trotsky of the party or01:12:08
the group usually denies this01:12:09
categorically she very often01:12:11
practice repeats01:12:13
so next donation01:12:16
anonyma finished reading your book from01:12:19
I was surprised to learn about sympathy01:12:22
to others and from the barn to the socialism of the barn01:12:27
zombart And zombar then01:12:31
funny story because he was like that01:12:34
a completely convinced socialist and even01:12:39
assessed Marxism very positively01:12:43
towards the end of his life he began to lean towards B01:12:47
in general, even fascism is already like this01:12:49
sad story but there is truth here01:12:53
subtleties that the fascists never existed01:12:55
became as far as I know01:12:58
didn't, but there's some interest in01:13:01
began to show some kind of fascism, that is01:13:03
in general, his views have evolved01:13:05
but how can I figure out the work of an early zombard01:13:08
which relates quite directly to his01:13:11
sympathy with socialism there in this right01:13:13
writes as for others, yes he was01:13:17
a person of leftist views simply never01:13:19
he had no revolutionary views01:13:21
time emphasized what he was for01:13:23
socialist reforms he wrote a book01:13:25
socialism, it was close enough01:13:29
to the Zhirussian wing01:13:31
Socialist Party of France and what01:13:34
very interesting very many almost all01:13:35
his main students turned out to be precisely01:13:38
there that is, among the French01:13:40
specialists01:13:41
As for there's another character here01:13:44
It's quite interesting in this sense01:13:46
Max buckets which precisely emphasized that01:13:50
that's anything, just not a socialist but with01:13:52
this emphasized that he in no way01:13:54
antisocialism is socialism is simple01:13:56
that's the problem Yes, theoretical01:13:59
which can be completed one way in01:14:02
another well the same young man01:14:04
Of course, although some thought he was like that01:14:07
pretty red in my youth I suspect01:14:10
what is his later work where is he01:14:13
Marx criticizes this as a way01:14:14
justify yourself01:14:16
too leftist views in youth But01:14:19
again curious who the students were01:14:23
best students01:14:25
Weber But there was definitely one01:14:28
one of the leaders of the Bavarian Republic01:14:29
Soviet and diodlukhach the most outstanding in01:14:33
in general, one of Weber's students and certainly01:14:37
one of the most interesting Marxist01:14:40
theorists of the 20th century That is, probably also01:14:42
It’s not entirely by chance that they studied01:14:43
exactly01:14:44
Uber Although by the way01:14:47
Lukovich began the land in the land then01:14:51
sharply disagreed, but with the choice01:14:53
that there was no unity of views01:14:55
in general, well, negative01:15:00
there was no complete break01:15:04
So01:15:09
but you write and told on01:15:13
streams About the controversy you Maxim your viewers01:15:17
specifically asks you to say Stream not01:15:18
streams about streams Well, really, viewers01:15:21
they are offended Yes, you write so well and01:15:25
talked about on streams01:15:26
controversy between Vaber and his students01:15:30
realpolitik and Weber's new book01:15:34
about politics but how does a vaper feel about01:15:37
socialism to the Bolsheviks as just scientists01:15:39
from the outside No, not really to anyone else01:15:42
he was quite negative01:15:45
even in some01:15:47
later texts of the letter01:15:50
quite a lot in German01:16:00
[music]01:16:08
I'm by no means one of them01:16:11
That is, that is, he distanced01:16:15
saved But let's just say he to01:16:18
moderate social democrats belonged to01:16:21
this can be seen quite positively01:16:24
developmentburg was treated poorly01:16:26
Of course, it’s also bad for the Bolsheviks01:16:28
because it seemed to him that here they were01:16:30
destroy with violence01:16:32
society and01:16:35
clubs drive people to heaven this is very01:16:37
bad, but except for Luxembourg, I’m not there01:16:40
I know the details01:16:42
relationship or rather his attitude towards her but01:16:45
in general, he also thought that there was no need01:16:47
no need for extreme sports, no need for it01:16:50
revolutionary struggles Let's somehow01:16:52
be careful more careful that is in01:16:55
in this case he was more like this01:16:58
but he was never a socialist01:17:01
literally but he's like01:17:02
sympathized with moderate socialist01:17:04
which were01:17:07
democrats practically01:17:12
So where do you get optimism and interest in01:17:15
life is another Donat from the trade union01:17:18
cats named after Schrödinger01:17:21
somehow there is everything but maybe together01:17:25
charging there is also an addition for me01:17:28
do you feel like you've been lately01:17:31
became a monopolist of both01:17:32
productive forces01:17:35
but it would be a pity if I was left alone like this01:17:38
the only last optimist at least01:17:40
someone must be so do you think01:17:44
them essential for the creation of the New01:17:46
Mira01:17:48
If so, how should the human masses be deprived01:17:53
both01:17:56
Well, you know how to enjoy life but not01:17:59
I know how to live without enjoying life01:18:01
there are so many good things in life in general Sun01:18:04
the grass shines brighter01:18:07
speak platitudes, speak nonsense, but nevertheless01:18:10
less but it's true I think so01:18:14
By the way, Yudin recently published a very01:18:18
interesting text in the insider where he says01:18:22
what do you think that people first01:18:24
there will be some opinion and then they will start01:18:26
act but actually do the opposite01:18:29
People get carried away so differently01:18:31
actions and thanks to this they01:18:33
there is a certain opinion about this01:18:35
very accurate observation Grigory Yudina01:18:37
I like her very much I am very close01:18:39
he also said very similar things01:18:41
that is, people will begin to act01:18:45
then they will be more involved01:18:46
optimism because optimism with01:18:49
readiness to act01:18:52
so the last question in this donation01:18:54
the bioreactor of history awaits the dull and boring01:19:08
so on, the limiter added 1000 rubles01:19:12
You can’t buy a book by message without VPN01:19:18
well, I do not know01:19:21
All in all01:19:23
maybe the problem here is that01:19:26
someone is abroad Well, I don’t know01:19:29
So we really can't01:19:31
send a book abroad now01:19:33
at least until it worked out they01:19:35
made some attempts Kazakhstan01:19:37
We’ll help you send it. That’s basically it01:19:40
I don’t know what to do next, but01:19:43
if anyone is watching01:19:46
Our channel is accordingly some01:19:48
pennies will fall monetization We are quietly01:19:51
we extract all sorts of things, it happens01:19:55
so Andrey 300 rubles message Thank you01:20:01
next Donat Yakutsk 1800 rubles01:20:07
Russia seems upset by01:20:10
unfulfilled unfulfilled shift01:20:13
Do you think the authorities forced this01:20:16
rebellion to believe people that there is a change01:20:18
power is possible01:20:20
until longer Well, I think that some part01:20:23
people yes01:20:24
all the people Well, it’s probably hard to say01:20:27
as they say for the whole people could someone01:20:29
maybe yes01:20:32
so with the same donation 1800 rubles01:20:36
it’s also written I want an autographed book and01:20:39
Contact01:20:40
but there are two options He wanted to participate01:20:44
in the drawing or he wanted to buy for 180001:20:46
the book is good So if he wants01:20:49
we can participate in the drawing01:20:51
put in the drawing01:20:53
if he loses but he01:20:56
we will start sending out gradually01:20:59
book01:21:00
those people who want to buy it01:21:03
Therefore, we have already sent several people01:21:08
and through us it will be a dragon01:21:13
make it cheaper than01:21:15
But then you can do this. What to write01:21:18
PM me that this is such a book01:21:21
needed and we cash on delivery We are out01:21:26
just probably not in the next few days01:21:28
because we're just running out01:21:32
more or they will print it then it will be possible to do more01:21:37
Well, in general, if something If you don’t01:21:39
If you can win today, you can win it01:21:42
order like this01:21:45
so it’s signed naturally01:21:49
so there are candles Donat Hello Boris01:21:53
Ievich Question: what are the prospects?01:21:55
formation of a unified in basic ideas01:21:58
leftist organization01:22:01
by the way01:22:03
We will have Stream three soon01:22:06
I think the agent is scheduled for Tuesday01:22:10
Lobanov stuping is planned for Tuesday01:22:14
Kagarlitsky By the way, here If we step on something01:22:17
was planned for today there technically01:22:19
there were glitches and we couldn’t do it, but here we go01:22:23
he will appear and here are three on Agent in one01:22:26
in the bottle here01:22:28
in the afternoon at three o'clock on Tuesday we have01:22:31
stream and then by the way on Wednesday01:22:35
there will be a speech by Grigory Yudin That is everything01:22:38
more or less but not all01:22:41
Many more or less famous popular01:22:44
influential social left01:22:48
our figures appear01:22:54
not just possible in fact01:22:57
is happening01:22:58
So01:23:01
Well, in addition, the next question is this01:23:04
Donate, what do we need for this, ordinary people?01:23:08
observers can do other than study01:23:10
there is no theory and participation in various events01:23:13
desire to be helpless in conditions01:23:16
like yesterday01:23:19
posed this question at least01:23:21
build connections with like-minded people01:23:25
supporters there01:23:28
interested and so on this time01:23:31
second if a vacuum may occur01:23:34
power he's real Maybe people should01:23:37
immediately begin to organize yourself somehow01:23:39
we simply form some structures01:23:41
to solve even everyday issues01:23:45
Well, you need to actively participate in this01:23:48
form some kind of bodies like Soviets01:23:52
committees and so on and again in them01:23:56
gather together left because they will01:23:59
come01:24:00
Who01:24:02
the other one also looks like you01:24:05
hold similar views01:24:10
and again build bridges of communication with01:24:14
other regions other houses01:24:18
show the situation becomes open A01:24:20
now is the time to create a party01:24:23
almost impossible legally Yes01:24:25
illegally you will be pressed This01:24:27
just an opportunity to substitute very01:24:30
many people so you have to be here very01:24:33
careful and for now you can watch01:24:36
The storm harbinger of others resembles simple ones01:24:39
donate numbers and likes are mandatory01:24:42
subscribe here dear viewers01:24:44
Be sure to subscribe if you don't01:24:46
subscribed and be sure to like01:24:47
because then more people will see and01:24:49
it will spread more like this01:24:51
more so please like01:24:52
Subscribe and donate01:24:55
only us please other channels and01:24:58
this is already too serious do you think01:25:00
This is true, but I’m sitting on the couch and I pressed the button.01:25:03
but this is also help, this is real help01:25:05
specifically01:25:07
I see that there are a lot of donations here01:25:10
Here comes another 1000 rubles from the limiter01:25:13
This is already the second Donat of such songs Peter01:25:17
500 rubles without indicating your contacts01:25:20
or people didn't hear, I'll repeat it better01:25:23
Once again we have giveaways for donations from01:25:26
500 rubles above can be accompanied by your01:25:30
contacts you will actually participate01:25:31
in a drawing for an autographed book Yes uh01:25:35
either I don’t know or they want01:25:38
participate01:25:42
But pay attention, yes, if you still want01:25:51
[music]01:25:55
said from a liter 1000 rubles I think01:25:58
people have two misconceptions: first01:26:02
consider the authorities smart who suits01:26:04
performances second consider power01:26:07
excessively stupid I think, or rather what they are01:26:11
all entrepreneurs and not politicians01:26:29
[music]01:26:31
so the next Donat from Peter is 555 rubles01:26:35
so yesterday on the stream you and the guests said01:26:38
that Prigogine's rebellion is causing01:26:40
Putin's regime receives a severe blow01:26:43
opinions can be heard from many01:26:45
oppositionists but don't you think that01:26:48
this might look like a giveaway01:26:51
wishful thinking and what mode01:26:54
Putin, on the contrary, is now capable01:26:57
strengthen01:26:59
Let's see if we were wrong then01:27:02
you'll see it pretty soon but when01:27:05
someone is showing that he can let01:27:08
and without any ideological or worthy01:27:12
respect the motives but make such a shooter01:27:15
in a day and a half and almost reach Moscow01:27:17
does not occur Well of course it is01:27:20
undermines any regime, as does understanding01:27:22
the fact that there are no laws in this state01:27:25
I don't have any because I have to announce01:27:31
day as a villain and just a criminal01:27:34
which you need01:27:47
[music]01:27:51
so the next Donat from Razin is 100001:27:55
rubles01:27:56
How do you think Brusselsevich is for us?01:27:59
it happened for the democrats last night01:28:03
result A formed last night01:28:05
the result was the best possible01:28:08
Well, you know, it's hard to say he wasn't01:28:12
the worst although for one reason because01:28:14
if the authorities really turned out to be01:28:17
Prigogine with some others01:28:20
friends but they repeated the power not01:28:23
held back and didn’t know what to do but how01:28:26
at least it would be no way no01:28:29
Democrats are not progressives at all.01:28:32
people are at least completely dishonest01:28:34
and Prigogine exposed this very well01:28:37
great on the other hand if only01:28:39
power just fell apart yesterday01:28:41
some possibilities would open up01:28:43
which should have been used01:28:47
we were given a reprieve by everyone and the authorities and01:28:50
society and the left in general will be removed by everyone01:28:52
line01:28:57
so the next donation is Mikhail Fromsa01:29:01
Iberia 500 rubles Hello Boris01:29:04
yulich ass patriot krp guards All01:29:07
they talk about civil war but not but me01:29:10
I don’t see a specific civil conflict01:29:12
in society in the majority in brackets yesterday01:29:15
cardinal hlang lansknech01:29:21
passed without resistance along the central01:29:24
Even the security forces did not help Russia01:29:27
resistance01:29:29
Well, it's not a civil war yet, it's01:29:32
definitely not a civil conflict either01:29:34
Civil interests civil01:29:36
principles are not involved at all01:29:42
I agree that this is categorically01:29:44
civil war But this01:29:48
replacement of public policy01:29:51
Bandit showdown is enough01:29:53
serious story01:29:56
So01:29:58
young Losolian another Donat what01:30:01
spoke USSR propaganda about the Uprising in01:30:04
What is Novocherkassk anyway?01:30:07
Novocherkassk Uprising Well, that's why01:30:11
there is a fairly large book about this01:30:15
my name is mass unrest in01:30:17
USSR in the era of Khrushchev I don’t remember the author01:30:19
you will have to type it into Google in Yandex01:30:23
what Soviet Propaganda said nothing01:30:26
you know, it was nothing at all, it was all01:30:29
the essence is that the Soviet official01:30:31
Propaganda hid the very fact of the uprising in01:30:35
Novocherkassk and01:30:37
it was possible under the conditions01:30:39
information policy01:30:40
which was carried out in those days01:30:44
there were different versions then Peter came here01:30:47
such a surviving participant in the events01:30:50
who collected01:30:52
maybe he was trying to get data01:30:55
later rehabilitation of participants01:30:57
uprisings and so on, but then there was01:31:00
the film is let's say weak01:31:07
well, it’s just, well, it’s very well shot, but01:31:11
weak in concept there is no01:31:14
no concept that's why I would like it01:31:17
I suggested watching it only01:31:18
solely from the point of view of the fact that01:31:20
well shot their filmed movie black and white in01:31:25
in the spirit of that time, here's the material01:31:28
seuda they are interesting01:31:35
Michelle 66 Sobol and Khodorkovsky, it seems01:31:39
supported Prigozhin somehow01:31:41
characterizes our liberals01:31:43
this characterizes their despair01:31:45
helplessness In my opinion By the way yes01:31:51
they simply01:31:53
they look everywhere because I don’t know01:31:56
where to look01:32:00
[music]01:32:01
limiter sent another 487 rubles 70 kopecks01:32:05
despite the fact that before that there were two donations01:32:07
1000 rubles If I remember correctly and01:32:09
wrote Donat to round up the total01:32:11
amount but you still haven’t sent the limiter01:32:14
Send your own contact for 20001:32:16
rubles contact need even more money01:32:23
if you want to win you must01:32:25
send Contact How will we know01:32:27
that it was you who won it, how do you like it01:32:30
we will send this book as soon as we contact you01:32:32
it is unclear therefore please01:32:35
sorry no one so we can survive for you money01:32:37
there's just no other way01:32:41
So I get ahead of myself and see that01:32:44
the limiter sent another 570 rubles01:32:48
message was in a hurry and poorly rounded01:32:51
sorry sent 570 rubles01:32:56
the next one more meter a thousand rubles and01:32:59
These donations are entered into a book drawing01:33:03
participates just send your contacts01:33:05
please because you are already succeeding01:33:07
4000 in total Well, even a little more01:33:10
came01:33:13
[music]01:33:19
[music]01:33:21
did Prigozhin set the goal of removing him from his posts?01:33:24
Shoigu Shoigu and Gerasimov01:33:28
ok Write to the cart I just don't01:33:32
I wanted to leave my contacts here Yes, well he is01:33:36
where in Donat wrote or where to you01:33:38
wrote01:33:41
great good so here you go01:33:45
Prigozhin's goal is the removal of Shoigu and Gerasimov01:33:50
If so, then we reached from them suspiciously01:33:54
I don't hear anything and what will happen next?01:33:57
I think this was one of the options01:33:59
resolve the conflict I think for him01:34:01
it was important not to take it off01:34:04
African business I believe it01:34:07
the main thing is01:34:11
African business is a fact of murder01:34:15
Archana Dzhemal while trying to investigate01:34:21
no imagination, concrete facts yes01:34:24
quite a lot of publications on Africa01:34:25
publication in the dark business there we are not01:34:28
we know how much money01:34:29
[music]01:34:31
hidden What specific assets but judging01:34:35
because they kill journalists01:34:37
probably big especially because this01:34:39
very serious people are engaged in01:34:40
the state level is probably huge01:34:42
you understand So of course all this is there01:34:44
So I think that now he is a program01:34:48
fulfilled the minimum, that is, he most likely01:34:50
suspended these guys from Africa and they will be fired01:34:53
or not I think not most likely But01:34:55
here if I’m not laughing I don’t agree01:34:58
says that most likely they are except01:34:59
Shoigulyat I'm not sure that they will fire because01:35:02
that someone should be appointed any new01:35:04
appoint it will become politically dangerous01:35:05
and the puck is definitely safe in a situation in01:35:09
any moment01:35:12
Yes, so the next donation01:35:17
[music]01:35:19
but yes, 200 rubles is so kind Than01:35:24
different mercenary hired workers01:35:28
The state and the private wage worker01:35:31
enterprises nothing01:35:41
now I'll take some Question from the chat01:35:45
how are things going with buying a book outside?01:35:48
Russia is asked in chat whether things are bad01:35:51
things I even discussed creating there while we01:35:54
haven't come up with an option, although some may01:35:56
there will be options through Kazakhstan01:35:58
do something, that is, send01:36:00
Kazakhstan needs some quantity01:36:02
find partners in Kazakhstan or similar01:36:04
another country and through this later01:36:06
launch sales of books in countries where01:36:11
you can read the money but this is it01:36:13
quite a complex scheme Not yet01:36:14
it turns out01:36:16
So come back Magic Arrow 50001:36:19
rubles without your Contact again there is01:36:22
the opinion that everything is already in Russia01:36:24
privatized and there is nothing to privatize01:36:26
Is it so01:36:27
Well01:36:29
to a large extent the most delicious morsels01:36:31
the most interesting thing is already long ago01:36:33
privatized01:36:35
[music]01:36:38
large by large yes01:36:45
[music]01:36:46
O01:36:48
Hello, thanks for the broadcast Boris Yulich01:36:51
if the expected event occurs if01:36:55
you have a specific plan for the reforms that are needed01:36:57
will produce in Russia very01:37:00
Interesting01:37:01
workers' correspondent's party program as01:37:04
Of course the program is not on purpose01:37:06
we write in the program writes a specific one01:37:08
situation but of course it is partly01:37:11
read books again for a long time01:37:14
retreat I had a book01:37:16
political science of the Revolution where there is very01:37:18
detailed section about the new public01:37:21
sector01:37:22
social states and so on01:37:25
yes Well, at least First you need01:37:28
analyze oligarchic corporations01:37:32
Use for public interest01:37:35
You can even specifically stream about this01:37:37
do discuss even with someone01:37:43
in general, yes, in short, the answer is yes, and that’s it01:37:48
including in my books by some colleagues this01:37:50
in general one way or another it may not be in01:37:52
one text in one document01:37:59
next donation01:38:02
limitr writes 200 rubles01:38:05
as long as these donations are not read we can01:38:09
You can organize a luxury chat here01:38:12
so meter with another guinea white01:38:17
from YouTube chat chat with leftists01:38:20
free as an entrepreneur01:38:25
I invite him to this luxury chat01:38:29
gorgeous by the way01:38:31
there is a chat of Agent Stepan, it is linked to01:38:35
boost this is very important I decided something01:38:37
day advertising went Stepan's agents01:38:41
connected with buste she buste laid out with mine01:38:45
lectures on political science on Marxism and01:38:49
history of Eastern Europe That is, someone01:38:52
will now subscribe to boosters before01:38:53
not signed it will work out right away01:38:55
there are more or less ready-made courses in this01:38:57
real meaning and recommend01:39:10
[music]01:39:15
what do you think about Lukashenko’s role in politics01:39:18
Russia and yesterday's situation in particular01:39:21
Well, I think that Lukashenko was attracted01:39:24
because Putin did not want to communicate personally01:39:26
with Prigozhin I think that’s how it has aged01:39:29
increase Degrees increase the status of these01:39:32
negotiations01:39:33
plus01:39:35
suggested it was necessary to convince him that he was not01:39:37
throw I think Lukashenko is needed for this01:39:39
Is it true that yours can also be thrown But01:39:41
after all, the president gave commitments01:39:43
at least it's something01:39:51
sidius already donated 2500 rubles at once01:39:56
Boris Yurievich Good evening How are you?01:39:59
Do you think the chef could go further if01:40:01
I would see support from the people of Vo01:40:04
authorities on which it is possible01:40:07
lean politically01:40:09
I wouldn't rule it out completely, let's say01:40:12
so this is01:40:13
[music]01:40:15
he hesitated suddenly when he saw that01:40:18
he suffered and suffered much more than01:40:22
he asked, maybe he had an issue01:40:24
Temptation but you understand01:40:30
money is much more important than power01:40:33
a way to earn or steal money01:40:35
So I think that it’s still here too01:40:39
the amount of money for power is impossible01:40:43
say just the opposite01:40:50
Well, there are 20 minutes left until the end of the stream for me01:40:54
I still need to read all this, let me do more01:40:56
do with questions01:40:58
is that there are a lot of them today Well we I01:41:02
I think no one doubts that we are very01:41:03
we answer them quickly today Yes01:41:05
what will we do then I won’t answer questions01:41:08
we'll collect them, I'll try to answer them in01:41:11
VK on your page in text form01:41:15
in text form Yes, well, because to do01:41:17
new Stream then new questions very much01:41:20
a lot of questions and we Well, objectively very01:41:22
responded quickly01:41:23
no longer possible01:41:37
I will respond in writing at uh01:41:41
on the VK page here is such an option01:41:43
suggests let me do it quickly then01:41:45
a few questions and more01:41:48
count01:41:50
these are the ones Peter sent Contact Yes I01:41:53
I'll look through it again and write down all the donations01:41:55
total amounts everything01:42:00
sent donations and then I’ll look at it01:42:05
yes And this will be to the highest degree01:42:08
Fair we don't want this01:42:12
Well, what else can we say, let's for now01:42:16
there Maxim is working on01:42:25
[music]01:42:30
maybe I watched all day and then01:42:33
decided not to jump in the draw01:42:35
I already have the book Thank you01:42:37
big01:42:41
I miss Anna Ochkina so much01:42:45
when we hear it01:42:54
they also write that the limiter is still overcharged01:42:58
writes something We are long overdue01:43:01
abandoning Soviet rhetoric is not01:43:02
speak out against small business Well, so01:43:05
further agree01:43:14
Okay, let's do it then01:43:17
I'm counting maybe at the end01:43:19
I'll ask a few questions, but let's go for now01:43:22
you are doing calculations, we are kind of01:43:25
We're closing the giveaway, but if anyone wants01:43:27
send Donat then we will anyway01:43:29
grateful That's But it means about01:43:34
regarding current things I wanted two things01:43:37
announce So today I repeat already01:43:39
said we planned today01:43:42
performance01:43:45
the wonderful Evgeniy Stupino This is it01:43:48
it didn’t work out but we have it on Tuesday01:43:51
what is planned01:43:54
Lobanov Stupino, the three of us will discuss01:43:57
Firstly01:43:58
and that's what to do left established01:44:01
situation, that is, well, in the long term, then01:44:04
there are still three characters when there are three01:44:06
left01:44:07
left faction on agents whatever01:44:10
you name it, we're going there01:44:12
together and try to formulate01:44:15
there are some general positions01:44:18
again it will be three o'clock in the afternoon there is01:44:21
some everyday reasons01:44:24
That's why you just need to pay attention01:44:28
on the other hand someone is watching us let's say01:44:30
from Yakutia there from the Far East of Siberia01:44:32
then 3 pm is a very convenient time and01:44:35
you can watch it online01:44:37
they don't drown because we are great01:44:40
we understand that many in the east simply01:44:42
should sleep at this time tomorrow works01:44:45
so on, that means this is the first time again01:44:49
I remind you that we agreed with Yudin on01:44:52
Wednesday, that is, on Tuesday we have three on01:44:54
Agent is like three teners yes01:44:58
was famous yes01:45:00
trio three tenders Here she is old Agent01:45:04
so and also Yudin01:45:08
briefly, so to speak, on tour in01:45:11
Moscow because I understand that01:45:13
then he will go somewhere again. Here we are with him01:45:16
We agreed that we will have it on Wednesday at01:45:18
19:30 I also pay attention if the first01:45:21
the case on the contrary is ahead of time, usually01:45:24
second case later Usually the time is01:45:27
193001:45:30
nothing will happen yet and this same01:45:33
evening then transfer for each person01:45:37
audience Well maybe someone all01:45:39
evening put the computer on and01:45:42
Yudina will just listen first01:45:44
Kagorlitsky will listen to him later01:45:47
Archagov with one of his lovely01:45:50
interlocutors I don’t remember who will be in01:45:52
this time that's why they're just so small01:45:55
announcements now I say that we still have01:45:58
I plan to open it soon01:46:01
we have01:46:02
Media planning so to speak grass01:46:06
Let's see what we have next. This means01:46:09
tomorrow we will have a psychopath too Sobchak01:46:14
and in the evening by the way the same evening when01:46:17
here are three Inna Agents will be next01:46:19
Historical Stream of Maxim Bronberg I01:46:22
I don’t know yet what it will be about. I want it.01:46:25
talk if not next time01:46:27
what can I say about history01:46:29
coups d'etat Teach01:46:32
riots, he loves such comparisons01:46:34
this is how it happened in different countries01:46:36
in different stories on different occasions here I am01:46:40
thought that would be enough01:46:41
interesting, then again we have 2901:46:45
will be another book Stream Lina reading01:46:49
Lina will read with Nikita Savin01:46:52
say this01:46:54
[music]01:46:57
Lena I’m reading is just starting hers with us01:47:00
cycle01:47:01
I’ll just ask her to love and favor her too01:47:05
So far I've only held one Stream or rather01:47:07
two there separately were together I’m mistaken01:47:14
the second one is a stream on the book series01:47:17
book01:47:20
bookshelves Yes I think so I hope so01:47:24
this will be interesting and useful and this one01:47:26
the cycle continues who what she me too01:47:28
helped make01:47:30
video bookshelf made from phalantra we01:47:34
removed and there will be new bookshelves made of01:47:37
Fallaster was also removed But for now it’s here01:47:39
There is no such video, you just need to make it here01:47:41
Zhenya Rodionova will be there again01:47:45
perform on June 30 with the team01:47:48
I also recommend the podcast - this is Basis01:47:51
means these are our plans and uh for01:47:56
June in general is getting further and further into July01:47:59
for July is not yet fully realized Well then01:48:02
we are starting it slowly01:48:05
shape and in general I hope01:48:08
something interesting will turn out that is01:48:10
We01:48:11
We are not going on vacation. As you can see, we are working.01:48:15
moreover, you see some days even01:48:18
23 we can do01:48:20
this prospect arises because01:48:23
those who want to come to the Stream Cortex Cancer01:48:26
It’s advisable to watch the slave’s streams just01:48:28
more and more it is very important but01:48:31
so again, dear viewers01:48:32
I remind you, that is, firstly, after all,01:48:35
us01:48:36
There is01:48:38
Bushi is there01:48:40
agents of Stepan Chan where are also some01:48:43
things are discussed it is tied to boost01:48:45
But01:48:47
subscribe to the channel and like01:48:53
You can even help somehow01:48:56
without spending any of my money and spending01:49:01
only01:49:02
spent on the contrary pumping up the resource01:49:04
time and attention, that is, time Of course01:49:06
you spend01:49:07
attention I think this is a resource that01:49:10
it's pumping up and I think it's next01:49:14
still an important task to increasingly actively01:49:16
ensure the cooperation of all leftists01:49:18
information projects01:49:20
I don’t know everyone. Of course I have personal ambitions.01:49:25
some sectarian moments but overall B01:49:28
in general this is how it is01:49:30
spontaneous to the operation in general after all01:49:32
there is cooperation in content01:49:35
mutual assistance at least mutually01:49:38
mutual promotion advertising is01:49:40
is happening We are in general again Therefore01:49:43
we always say subscribe to01:49:46
prime numbers Subscribe not only01:49:48
subscribe to us01:49:50
Vestnik Bore subscribe to Vestnik01:49:53
more Originals here and a number of others01:49:56
professionals can also find common things in01:49:58
us recommended channel and so on That01:50:01
eating is also very important because01:50:04
in general, this is also part of the current work01:50:06
you know, we often think that it is necessary or with01:50:10
rifle to the barricade or already sit on01:50:12
sofa, that is, there is a lot01:50:15
intermediate fastovskiy intermediate01:50:17
stages and01:50:18
intermediate states I hope more01:50:21
that in general we can do all these01:50:24
states pass and let's talk01:50:27
honestly yes we are preparing we are preparing we01:50:29
we are not waiting, we are preparing, but there are opportunities01:50:31
getting ready is also limited, that’s the question01:50:34
resources It is a matter of time conditions and01:50:37
so on therefore even just when she01:50:40
watches and likes Subscribe01:50:41
further you are not just having fun Yes01:50:45
you somehow participate in the common cause even01:50:48
if you don't think about it yourself01:50:50
Maxim what we have now01:50:53
I've read the total so far01:50:57
donations and everyone has a total number01:50:59
donations to us in total with participation in01:51:02
in the drawing they donated 10,700 rubles01:51:07
yes so let's give you more now01:51:10
I'll find some question anyway01:51:12
because I still need01:51:14
count01:51:17
so still there01:51:20
Is it possible to assume that the following01:51:23
capitalism formation will not be feudalism01:51:27
you know this is very similar to scientific01:51:30
fiction very curious something01:51:32
pay attention to the night of fiction01:51:36
I’m not talking fantasy, but the name is Science Fiction01:51:40
around 70 80s01:51:44
there was such a tendency to show either01:51:46
feudal future01:51:49
often just01:51:51
apocalyptic or some other01:51:53
planets or even this01:51:57
feudal society like some01:52:00
alien feudal society with01:52:03
who have to, one way or another, already01:52:04
people of the future have to deal with well lines01:52:08
they say we can come to similar ones01:52:10
it’s natural for the Strugatskys’ plot01:52:14
famous01:52:16
book It's Hard to Be God classic01:52:19
Strugatsky01:52:21
But01:52:23
The Strugatskys were not talking about01:52:26
feudalism01:52:27
made this representation of feudalism as01:52:30
Oh like a metaphor, like a metaphor it's too01:52:34
it is very important that we are talking about feudalism01:52:36
exactly how about a metaphor it’s a metaphor01:52:39
historical analytical ones are very dangerous01:52:42
as I already said, that is what01:52:45
feudal society is a society01:52:47
a significant part of production is associated01:52:50
with subsistence farming with simple farming01:52:52
production I said to the ground with01:52:54
nature, by the way, is in this01:52:56
strong side That is, this is a society where01:52:59
The connection between people and nature is much greater01:53:01
than in modern society01:53:04
It’s just a passed stage And so01:53:07
actually I have to say that01:53:09
this period was not the worst in01:53:13
history of mankind itself01:53:14
endless wars01:53:16
epidemics and so on are also the period01:53:18
late feudalism when it begins01:53:21
gradually outgrow capitalism or01:53:24
at least the market is developing01:53:26
commodity money01:53:27
while01:53:30
some period of the dark ages 7 801:53:35
9 of course these are very dark times but in01:53:39
in what sense there is very little from them01:53:40
for example, there are written monuments left01:53:42
there is very little document information on01:53:46
God knows about them, but for example from01:53:49
all sorts of warriors There are massacres and so on01:53:51
much less, that is, it’s all in the village01:53:55
grow01:53:56
rye or wheat there to feed their01:54:00
feudal lords grazing cattle01:54:03
they can’t read and write and eat for that01:54:05
there is only one priest who alone can01:54:07
for the whole village read write feudal lord too01:54:10
who doesn't know how to write a letter?01:54:11
let's go to our priest and priest01:54:14
will write him a letter under dictation, sent from01:54:17
another feudal lord who is his01:54:19
a priest who is also already for him01:54:22
read the letter or write a response under01:54:24
dictation That is, there is such a continuous01:54:27
system01:54:28
intellectual connections in the form01:54:30
catholic church01:54:32
in the east it is partly Orthodox01:54:34
the church also played a role maybe01:54:36
less clearly but also fulfilled, that is01:54:39
very simple functions very simple01:54:42
tasks01:54:43
he is very simple Well, of course primitive01:54:46
society, we probably wouldn’t live in it01:54:48
I wanted to but01:54:50
it was a society with its own rules01:54:53
order and01:54:55
so there is no need to criticize fedolism simply01:54:58
fedolism we understand some kind of savagery there01:55:00
backwardness depravity dirt Well it was [ __ ]01:55:05
only this is just human01:55:06
if it died out I wouldn't worry01:55:09
this topic these dark ages so she them01:55:12
survived and now the striking strength began01:55:15
gradually create new technologies01:55:18
technologies that are being restored01:55:19
were in the ancient world and in the end01:55:22
it turned out to be a new time so no01:55:26
swear so the Middle Ages are not the same01:55:28
it was a terrible time and the idea itself01:55:32
The Middle Ages in general is a judgment This01:55:34
the idea is just from intelligent people themselves01:55:37
there are these Italian humanists of the 14th century01:55:40
came up with the idea to understand it yourself01:55:44
antiquity then the Middle Ages01:55:47
very such a bad dark time and01:55:49
Renaissance is coming, that is, here are ours01:55:51
relatively speaking, time as they counted01:55:54
when culture and civilization are revived01:55:55
knowledge art is truly progress01:55:59
art is huge, but not a single one01:56:01
terribly offended and upset and01:56:04
we were surprised if we found out that through01:56:06
several centuries of them themselves01:56:08
belonged to the Middle Ages what is it01:56:10
late Middle Ages because they are like01:56:12
times always opposed01:56:15
and the very concept of the Middle Ages They are just01:56:18
and came up with a way to separate themselves from him01:56:20
Well, you see how it happens that some01:56:24
concepts become purely common nouns01:56:26
and vice versa stops01:56:28
In the Middle Ages this was a concept01:56:31
the negative then became clear01:56:33
historical and vice versa, feudalism is01:56:36
such a purely negative concept01:56:38
a certain method of production01:56:41
now feudalism is ready, this is when it’s simple01:56:43
different people cut each other's laws01:56:46
or when everyone is there for themselves, what in general01:56:49
Fedorism is not typical, that’s what Maxim01:56:52
us us I just finished01:56:54
I have today because I don't have01:56:58
phone I'll be on the computer via01:57:01
Random orc through a simple generator01:57:04
random number generator from one01:57:07
up to 100 will now be displayed on my screen then01:57:11
there are all the gaps01:57:14
from one to five, for example, Peter will win01:57:17
And this limiter has, for example, from 19 to01:57:22
6901:57:24
big percentage for big01:57:49
and the man who won was very lucky01:57:52
That is, he has01:57:54
the chance of Victory was four and a half01:57:57
percent01:57:59
10 percent of people had edema01:58:02
which was 50 percent did not win K01:58:04
unfortunately, or to the happiness that was01:58:06
50 percent is who Well this is limitr01:58:10
sad01:58:12
listen but we promise that soon01:58:16
time we will play two books one01:58:18
for the biggest donor another01:58:24
we will play for the one who wants more01:58:28
lucky01:58:29
What happens if a person01:58:33
[music]01:58:35
nationalize one01:58:37
that is, one book will remain I think01:58:41
if he just wins01:58:43
In any case, we will send one and the other01:58:46
this is the one on the wheel of fortune01:58:48
determined we will replay it, twist it01:58:50
wheel I think this will be best01:58:54
we are simply the largest Donat01:58:57
we won't choose01:58:59
eat the largest one and twist it with a wheel01:59:02
we can sort of chances01:59:18
Well, you can do that, no, it’s just logical, I01:59:22
I understand, yes, in fact, yes, well, that is, well01:59:28
okay, let's decide what to do about it, but dears01:59:30
viewers just warn us right away01:59:32
We don't have any extra books right now01:59:35
only for now01:59:37
Unfortunately, here's one book at a time for now01:59:40
we are playing until soon01:59:42
I hope that I remember more to play01:59:44
these two books then this01:59:46
natural injustice it will be01:59:48
we have overcome and this will be the model01:59:52
such01:59:53
Random justice a la rabkor here01:59:56
Dear viewers Let's sum it up01:59:58
first of all thank you very much and02:00:01
I remind you that there were a lot of questions now02:00:04
those not answered to me will be collected at all and I02:00:07
I’ll post them with the answers to my02:00:12
page02:00:14
VK VKontakte and I think what we will do02:00:18
further because it looks like the shaft02:00:20
the question is growing very well but we will02:00:23
try not to offend anyone and therefore02:00:26
means according to such publications02:00:29
there will be more and more done02:00:31
regular practice02:00:32
requires some time from me well02:00:36
as they say, it’s not a pity for good people02:00:38
and most importantly no one was offended. This is the first02:00:41
Second again, I would say plans for02:00:43
future02:00:45
and the third02:00:47
As always02:00:51
Thank you very much subscribe to the channel02:00:54
like02:00:57
watch subscribe to boost and02:01:00
the main thing is just don’t forget us, you tell us02:01:05
you help us a lot, we make this channel02:01:07
togetherDescription:
НАСТОЯЩИЙ МАТЕРИАЛ (ИНФОРМАЦИЯ) ПРОИЗВЕДЕН, РАСПРОСТРАНЕН И (ИЛИ) НАПРАВЛЕН ИНОСТРАННЫМ АГЕНТОМ КАГАРЛИЦКИМ БОРИСОМ ЮЛЬЕВИЧЕМ, ЛИБО КАСАЕТСЯ ДЕЯТЕЛЬНОСТИ ИНОСТРАННОГО АГЕНТА КАГАРЛИЦКОГО БОРИСА ЮЛЬЕВИЧА. ✅Поддержать работу канала «Рабкор» и освещение дела Кагарлицкого можно по реквизитам: 2200 7004 3856 6977 (Тинькофф) Поддержать нас на Бусти на постоянной основе: https://boosty.to/rabkorleft Карта для международных переводов: 4165 9816 0119 6631 Отправить пожертвование через криптокошелёк: https://taplink.cc/rabkor Вышла новая книга Бориса Кагарлицкого “Долгое отступление”. Можно приобрести напрямую в издательстве со скидкой. Промокод: РАБКОР2023 https://www.directmedia.ru/book-697767-dolgoe-otstuplenie/ Вакансии Рабкора тут - https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1Imzv3OB54s4BYEhNmFxZcbC2i25nLn5wi15xC_VZBW0/edit?usp=sharing Рабкор на других площадках: • https://rabkor.ru/ • https://t.me/rabkor • https://t.me/kagarlitsky • https://vk.com/rabkor_ru • https://dzen.ru/rabkor_ru • https://discord.com/invite/3eZyrkUZD7
Preparing download options
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players
Questions about downloading video
How can I download "Что вчера случилось с государством? Домашний стрим (Борис Кагарлицкий, кот Степан)" video?
http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.
Which format of "Что вчера случилось с государством? Домашний стрим (Борис Кагарлицкий, кот Степан)" video should I choose?
The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.
Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Что вчера случилось с государством? Домашний стрим (Борис Кагарлицкий, кот Степан)" video?
The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.
How can I download "Что вчера случилось с государством? Домашний стрим (Борис Кагарлицкий, кот Степан)" video to my phone?
You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.
How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Что вчера случилось с государством? Домашний стрим (Борис Кагарлицкий, кот Степан)"?
The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.
How can I save a frame from a video "Что вчера случилось с государством? Домашний стрим (Борис Кагарлицкий, кот Степан)"?
This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.
What's the price of all this stuff?
It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.