Download "Анна Наринская, Сергей Смирнов | Обзор от BILD"

"videoThumbnail Анна Наринская, Сергей Смирнов | Обзор от BILD

Любовь по кадыровски. Филология по путински. Взрывы домов. Утренний разворот @BelkovskiyS

Любовь по кадыровски. Филология по путински. Взрывы домов. Утренний разворот @BelkovskiyS

Channel: Белковский

Кто сделал пут*на бандитом, когда придут Атакамсы, тайна Эрдогана #НАБЕЛО @BelkovskiyS

Кто сделал пут*на бандитом, когда придут Атакамсы, тайна Эрдогана #НАБЕЛО @BelkovskiyS

Channel: Белковский

Арестович: Изменит ли Навальный Россию? @SobolLyubov

Арестович: Изменит ли Навальный Россию? @SobolLyubov

Channel: Alexey Arestovych

🎭Как НЕ ПОТЕРЯТЬ СЕБЯ в ЭПОХУ ПЕРЕМЕН / Дмитрий Назаров и Ольга Васильева / Хочу Сказать. Ларина

🎭Как НЕ ПОТЕРЯТЬ СЕБЯ в ЭПОХУ ПЕРЕМЕН / Дмитрий Назаров и Ольга Васильева / Хочу Сказать. Ларина

Channel: Ксения Ларина

Ордер на арест Путина / Путин не избежит Гааги / Что ждёт Лукашенко

Ордер на арест Путина / Путин не избежит Гааги / Что ждёт Лукашенко

Channel: Реальная Беларусь

Арестович @FeyginLive Россия довоевалась до расширения НАТО

Арестович @FeyginLive Россия довоевалась до расширения НАТО

Channel: Alexey Arestovych

Штирлиц против Путина; Навальный обвиняет; музыка пропаганды // Человек без телевизора

Штирлиц против Путина; Навальный обвиняет; музыка пропаганды // Человек без телевизора

Channel: Ксения Ларина

⚡️ 31 ТРУП В ЧАСОВОМ ЯРУ | ПОВАР ПУТИНА ПРЯЧЕТСЯ | КАК ВЕРБУЕТ ФСБ

⚡️ 31 ТРУП В ЧАСОВОМ ЯРУ | ПОВАР ПУТИНА ПРЯЧЕТСЯ | КАК ВЕРБУЕТ ФСБ

Channel: Популярная политика

bild

BILD на русском

бильд на русском

бильд

обзор от бильд

bild russian

новости

политика

россия

russia

украина

смирнов

наринская

смирнов медиазона

кара-мурза

театр

культура

якутское кино

якутский фильм запретили

роскомпозор

эритрея

беларусь

путин антисемит

антисемитизм

зеленский

война в украине

война на украине

00:00:18

[music]

00:00:28

Hello Live review from

00:00:31

Belt, Vladimir Karamurza, sentenced to 25 years in

00:00:33

prison, was taken to a

00:00:35

maximum security colony in Omsk and

00:00:38

immediately placed in solitary confinement. We will talk more about this

00:00:40

with the editor-in-chief of the media zone,

00:00:42

Sergei Smirnov. Hello Sergei,

00:00:43

good afternoon, why about the transfer stage a

00:00:48

prisoner from one point to another is

00:00:49

always spoken of as the most dangerous

00:00:52

dangerous time of his imprisonment Well, for

00:00:56

several reasons, the first thing is that he is

00:00:58

lost from sight, we cannot come to him at

00:01:00

some point Yes, the lawyer

00:01:02

cannot go in, he cannot find out what’s wrong with him

00:01:04

is happening And so this is the main thing that we

00:01:07

don’t know where a specific person is when we

00:01:09

didn’t know where we could for how long we

00:01:11

didn’t know where the feed was but for a couple of weeks Yes,

00:01:13

he was only able to tell after a couple of weeks

00:01:15

where he was this is the main

00:01:17

reason of course and the second is a very

00:01:19

tiring trip in any case,

00:01:21

because

00:01:23

the transfer of a new cell there and new

00:01:27

conditions is always a very tiring

00:01:29

stage in Russia, it’s always very tiring And

00:01:32

somehow this procedure

00:01:35

is done consciously Judging by the information, he visited pre-trial

00:01:37

detention centers in several cities, he visited

00:01:39

Samara somewhere else before he got to

00:01:41

Omsk, this is an absolutely standard

00:01:43

procedure and logistical decisions that are so strange from our point of

00:01:46

view are simply a

00:01:48

feature of the FSIN system and for non-

00:01:51

political matters they often transport prisoners in approximately the

00:01:54

same way, the fact

00:01:55

that he immediately

00:01:58

ended up in the shed, which tells us

00:02:01

it’s difficult to say that O what does this say

00:02:03

right away because we don’t know the reason, but

00:02:06

we can only speculate here, we do

00:02:08

n’t even know the specific reason, well,

00:02:10

how is it all built, but this

00:02:13

rather indicates increased

00:02:14

attention? And we understand that

00:02:16

people are prisoners in the solitary confinement when it is

00:02:20

really necessary to the authorities of the colony, if

00:02:23

the authorities of the colony need this, there is a

00:02:25

reason, they will find absolutely any

00:02:27

button turned incorrectly 2

00:02:30

minutes earlier, stood up for the fact that in ordinary

00:02:32

life they do not pay attention, but I

00:02:33

suspect that this is due to the fact that

00:02:36

they received a signal from Moscow, we saw this

00:02:40

as it happened with Alexey Navalny received

00:02:42

a signal to create special conditions that are not the

00:02:45

most comfortable, so we are

00:02:49

waiting for the first time. Does this mean that his

00:02:52

conditions will automatically be more

00:02:54

lenient than, for example, those of Alexei

00:02:56

Navalny? Well, I wouldn’t even talk about the

00:02:59

soft conditions of a maximum security prison for

00:03:02

25 years, I wouldn’t like to use the word

00:03:04

soft, but talk about the difference is the first time

00:03:08

there or the third time and the special regime

00:03:10

that Alexei Navalny will have soon,

00:03:11

yes, but we understand that it is unlikely that an appeal will

00:03:13

cancel his special regime. There, the difference is not

00:03:17

so significant in the conditions of

00:03:20

detention to talk about a softer

00:03:22

regime, the wrong regime is strict, very

00:03:25

tough, just Alexey Navalny will have

00:03:26

even more restrictions,

00:03:28

formally these restrictions. A little less of

00:03:30

a problem is that, like

00:03:32

Alexei Navalny, if

00:03:37

the head of the colony wants to create additional restrictions, it will not be

00:03:39

difficult for him; if he needs to create a

00:03:41

special, maximum uncomfortable regime,

00:03:44

they will create it. Vladimir Karamurza

00:03:47

Apparently, he was also poisoned and Judging by the

00:03:50

information that we have, perhaps

00:03:52

even more than once, the

00:03:53

state of his health, as reported by

00:03:56

relatives and lawyers, is quite difficult.

00:03:58

Does this matter for the system; it

00:04:01

will somehow

00:04:03

take care that he does not get worse;

00:04:06

this is also a question. It’s not entirely clear. what is

00:04:09

in their head and in general, to be honest,

00:04:11

talking about Karamurz should be done in the context of the

00:04:14

term that they gave the yoke for 25 years, it

00:04:18

looks like I’m just sorry, but even against the

00:04:21

background of Alexei Navalny, you have numerous

00:04:23

criminal cases that are somehow completely

00:04:25

limitless, the first time you give 25 years

00:04:28

under the state article changes, this

00:04:31

looks like some kind of special direct control

00:04:33

and a special decision in this regard. I don’t

00:04:37

think that health will become

00:04:40

some kind of important factor for them. It’s another question, but

00:04:43

on the other hand, I’m not sure that

00:04:45

the authorities there will want to deliberately worsen their

00:04:47

health status and will not pay

00:04:51

attention It seems to me

00:04:54

they just had a lot of opportunities

00:04:56

to demonstrate this before, but they do

00:04:58

n’t provide help, they help me, they let me

00:05:00

go, but it

00:05:01

seems to me that they won’t deliberately make things worse

00:05:04

right away, that’s another matter. Maybe they

00:05:06

just mean the conditions are difficult. The

00:05:08

Omsk colony is very far away; you won’t be able to

00:05:11

go to see him on a date. Yes and

00:05:14

you convey you convey Everything will be normal,

00:05:17

but that means there is still

00:05:19

less control than in closer colonies. Well, they

00:05:23

mean that it will get worse and

00:05:24

will get worse. I just don’t think that

00:05:26

health is something for them. This is a topic

00:05:28

that they are very actively discussing.

00:05:30

By the way, we see this Alexei Navalny,

00:05:31

too, in the sense that Yes, there was a hunger strike

00:05:34

then he fought for a long time. Well, fortunately,

00:05:37

lately Despite all

00:05:38

the fears, We don’t see any deterioration.

00:05:40

So I don’t think that the issue of

00:05:42

health will become the key one. Sergei When you

00:05:45

hear about the

00:05:47

supposed negotiations about exchange and so on,

00:05:50

how seriously do you take this

00:05:53

information,

00:05:54

but I’ll probably be an optimist here in the

00:05:56

sense that it’s quite strange for me

00:05:59

because I always look rather gloomily,

00:06:02

but it seems to me that in any case, the very

00:06:05

fact of such conversations personally makes me happy,

00:06:10

I’ll be honest because that well, in the conditions of

00:06:13

19-25 years old it looks completely hopeless

00:06:15

and when

00:06:17

there are potentially some contacts and the

00:06:19

possibility of exchange, then I think this is a

00:06:22

good sign that Despite all

00:06:25

the denials and so on, that there are some

00:06:28

contacts, at least

00:06:30

the options for which they are being considered

00:06:33

they will sit for 25 years because it

00:06:35

looks like an absolutely monster 25 years yes And

00:06:39

when you have no hope of

00:06:41

release This I think is also

00:06:43

very depressing in addition And

00:06:45

these negotiations information about some

00:06:47

negotiations and contacts still gives

00:06:50

some hope and of course I’m here

00:06:52

if there was some kind of exchange, something else, I

00:06:55

would be very happy. Let's now move on to the

00:06:57

specific names of the masses

00:06:59

of political prisoners who, apparently,

00:07:01

are now in Russia, if you believe

00:07:03

media reports, if you just do the math, it

00:07:07

turns out that several hundred people

00:07:10

will now be convicted there openly

00:07:15

criminal cases regarding some kind of

00:07:17

Let's call it Guerrilla

00:07:19

activity Is it really on such a

00:07:22

scale or are law enforcement

00:07:24

agencies here too What is called drawing statistics for themselves,

00:07:27

this is not the easiest question, including

00:07:30

because we don’t have a lot of information

00:07:31

about this, but from what we can

00:07:34

know Let's start with the fact that the authorities have

00:07:36

a large Yes, some kind of partisan

00:07:39

activity. They combine different

00:07:41

actions, which is also important, and in us this

00:07:44

evokes an attitude as some kind of single

00:07:47

activity. There are stories of sabotage on

00:07:50

railways. Yes, first of all, arson of

00:07:54

relay cabinets, there are attacks on military registration and enlistment offices,

00:07:58

which were still a little earlier now, to

00:08:00

a lesser extent, there are other

00:08:03

related articles that the authorities combine under the

00:08:05

article terrorism, sometimes the

00:08:07

impression is created of some kind of terrorist

00:08:09

threat, but more often than not these matters of

00:08:11

capitalism are not related to a

00:08:12

specific example, these are military registration and enlistment offices, but not

00:08:15

only for words for commentary, if

00:08:18

we talk specifically about the most radical

00:08:21

actions regarding

00:08:23

real cabinets and arson, I think that

00:08:26

Despite the fact that the case is not so

00:08:28

many, but at one time we counted 60

00:08:30

cases, now there are more of them, but it’s probably up to

00:08:33

100 cases, probably no more, I think there’s

00:08:36

different information inside even these cases

00:08:39

I think some groups

00:08:41

act Quite

00:08:43

sincerely This I think By the way this is a

00:08:46

minority, a completely radical

00:08:48

minority of the most radical views

00:08:50

from the extreme left is the extreme right But

00:08:51

this is just a completely minority even within

00:08:53

these cases I think in several cases

00:08:56

some people do it for money this is

00:09:00

also quite important in in the sense that yes,

00:09:02

and they name different reasons,

00:09:05

I completely know the case, according to one of the versions, a large

00:09:08

group told them, well, they explained that

00:09:12

this is paid for by a company that

00:09:13

deals with lines of cabinets in order to

00:09:15

get insurance.

00:09:17

Well, that is, I am sure that the authorities, of course, will

00:09:19

not say that this is not so, they will

00:09:21

prove to the court But this looks

00:09:23

like it has

00:09:24

some explanations, and the third option,

00:09:27

which we don’t yet know how

00:09:30

many of these options there are, all the cases are closed, we do

00:09:32

n’t know anything, these are unknown people. I won’t

00:09:34

name a single name of people who are

00:09:35

imprisoned under the article of sabotage because they are

00:09:38

public affairs, they are not in contact

00:09:40

I think some of the journalists did these

00:09:42

things that are

00:09:45

called provocations when some

00:09:47

person comes out and offers money and

00:09:49

says what needs to be done, while this is an

00:09:52

employee of the special services, he records all this

00:09:54

and

00:09:56

Yes, they detain you in place When

00:09:59

they detain you in place This is the first

00:10:00

sign that you are too lazy to detain the closet on

00:10:03

the spot This is very suspicious, there are still

00:10:05

some cases that I also have

00:10:07

great doubts about their connection with

00:10:11

provocations, these are cases

00:10:12

Also on terrorism but related, for

00:10:15

example, to the region of free Russia

00:10:17

Freedom of Russia and some person writes to

00:10:19

someone in Russia that I represent

00:10:21

The Legion needs some kind of help there,

00:10:24

people don’t enter into correspondence, that’s

00:10:27

enough for an article about participation in a

00:10:30

terrorist organization, even

00:10:32

replying exactly to the message, well, in general, it’s

00:10:34

important to look at who’s writing, if

00:10:37

it’s written by representatives of a real

00:10:38

organization, then it’s not enough. But if it’s an

00:10:42

operative officer, he’s of course

00:10:44

initially lays down all the communication and all the

00:10:47

answers so that later this criminal case will be

00:10:49

more convenient for him.

00:10:51

Yes, and send it to

00:10:55

court. Well, seriously, we have seen this in various

00:10:57

cases before. Yes, we can remember the new

00:11:00

Greatness, the classic story of how it all

00:11:02

happened, but now it’s just less well-

00:11:05

known cases

00:11:07

We know about these cases, there are many less repressions

00:11:09

and others are not the most famous

00:11:11

people, this is very sad. In addition,

00:11:13

the last thing I want to say is this is a

00:11:16

large and huge group of cases, and the

00:11:19

cases of the gods of change stand out separately,

00:11:21

we talked about Vladimir Kormurza,

00:11:23

but the case of high treason is much more more, there are a

00:11:26

lot of

00:11:28

criminal cases, well, a lot on the scale of

00:11:31

treason. Although a few a week is a

00:11:34

very, very large amount of donations from the Ukrainian

00:11:37

army, and I honestly have no doubt

00:11:39

that there is a lot of room here. They have a lot of space

00:11:42

because I have no doubt that they will

00:11:45

prove nothing at all. know

00:11:46

because the case in the area of change is closed

00:11:48

We won’t even know the details and

00:11:51

some kind of donation is enough. I

00:11:52

suspect that the fund will be used by someone else to

00:11:55

initiate a criminal case for high

00:11:57

treason, this is a separate topic, these cases are also

00:12:00

enough and we are sure that not all of the

00:12:03

defendants are involved I know Sergey, we saw

00:12:07

several messages, sometimes even

00:12:08

recorded on video, from pensioners

00:12:11

or pensioners or other gullible

00:12:13

people who were called by people who

00:12:15

usually introduce themselves there to the

00:12:17

Sberbank security service and then they

00:12:21

went and set something on fire. What are these

00:12:23

cases, what do I know about them, we we know

00:12:26

quite a bit about them And we can only

00:12:27

make assumptions here We don’t know who

00:12:29

these people are Why are they calling we can too

00:12:32

Judging terrorism then it’s more interesting, but

00:12:35

it’s interesting that to what extent We checked

00:12:38

the information on one of the cases Terrorism

00:12:40

is

00:12:42

always a local question, just questions about

00:12:46

federalism, federalism in such things

00:12:48

sometimes works, the center has not yet given a

00:12:50

clear order Under what article to

00:12:52

incriminate Yes, these actions and

00:12:55

articles are different somewhere, as a rule, this is

00:12:58

hooliganism,

00:12:59

admission of guilt and all the others, not the

00:13:02

longest term, somewhere

00:13:03

damage to property in some options and

00:13:07

terrorism Maybe it depends on which

00:13:09

employees And what department

00:13:10

is considering it There is also a dispute between the

00:13:13

department because hooliganism is the

00:13:15

Ministry of Internal Affairs

00:13:17

Terrorism is the vision of the FSB Yes And by the way,

00:13:20

maybe both here and there

00:13:23

and as far as I understand There was a case when a

00:13:25

criminal case was not initiated Then

00:13:27

there is this too Looks quite normal

00:13:30

Logical, but as far as I understand orders

00:13:32

from Moscow There are no orders on these matters

00:13:35

There is no practice, so each region

00:13:37

interprets its side after all I

00:13:40

think there the issue of terrorism is less than

00:13:42

hooliganism, damage to property, recently

00:13:45

there was a special report on Russia which was

00:13:48

presented at the UN, to what extent do you

00:13:51

think this speleological report reflects the

00:13:54

situation with depressions in Russia, to

00:13:57

what extent is the report objective? Well, the report

00:14:00

is objective if we say because the

00:14:02

main problems recorded there are

00:14:05

certainly the problem reported and in large

00:14:07

international reports, in any case, you are

00:14:08

unlikely to include everything in it what

00:14:10

is happening you will get a general

00:14:12

idea it is not necessary to do a report

00:14:15

and write a big book after all, the format of

00:14:17

the report is a little different but the main

00:14:19

position was recorded there it was said

00:14:22

that repressions in Russia have intensified it was

00:14:24

said that repressions in Russia, which is

00:14:26

quite important for international

00:14:27

organizations, began a long time ago before the war

00:14:29

This is a rather important emphasis because it is

00:14:32

not clear to everyone That there were mass

00:14:35

anti-war protests of repression against

00:14:37

mass repression What kind of memes are there

00:14:41

repressions against anti-accident activists? There are

00:14:44

many articles of the Criminal Code, that is, the

00:14:46

main points are stated absolutely

00:14:47

correct. It’s quite difficult to argue here;

00:14:50

another thing is that we You can always

00:14:53

add something to develop any idea from this

00:14:55

report and simply explain what

00:14:58

torture is, how it happens, how many cases

00:15:00

of torture are a separate problem, that there

00:15:02

have been more of them lately, people

00:15:05

have had their ribs broken already in Moscow, well, that is,

00:15:07

something that didn’t happen before in cases

00:15:10

related to politics That is, everything here is getting

00:15:13

much worse how

00:15:16

influential this report is, what after it, what does it

00:15:19

influence, but it’s hard for me to judge here honestly

00:15:21

about He and I think whoever is watching

00:15:24

presents himself as a kind of attitude towards

00:15:28

international structures, international

00:15:29

organizations, we understand that this is not very

00:15:31

good it works honestly and openly and it’s unlikely that it’s

00:15:36

worth hoping that it will have any significant impact. But this is rather

00:15:38

educational information for the whole world

00:15:41

for people who diplomats diplomats

00:15:45

bring their governments to some

00:15:47

form because, after all, I’m sure

00:15:50

not everyone understands what’s going on in Russia,

00:15:52

that these are actually some distant

00:15:55

positions, he always blames everyone when you

00:15:58

still have a neutral report, he

00:16:01

didn’t let the special representative into Russia,

00:16:03

yes, this is a report to collect on the spot. This of

00:16:07

course causes a reaction. I think the reaction is just a

00:16:11

greater understanding of what is happening in

00:16:13

Russia. in my opinion, it’s quite

00:16:14

useful; another thing is to hope that the report

00:16:17

There are also recommendations in the report;

00:16:20

they end with a treasure approximately

00:16:22

the same; you need to improve the judicial

00:16:24

system; end with repression; cancel

00:16:26

repressive legislation;

00:16:28

this is the same form as any

00:16:31

official statement of international

00:16:33

structures; We don’t hope for this; you

00:16:37

know in fact, Sergei If

00:16:39

we talk about the Committee against Torture,

00:16:40

for example, and

00:16:42

such recommendations that

00:16:45

are given to countries every five years, countries try to

00:16:47

implement, for example, at one time it was

00:16:50

this committee that recommended separating the

00:16:52

investigative committee of the Prosecutor's Office of

00:16:53

the Russian Federation, this was done, that

00:16:56

is, some time ago Russia

00:16:57

listened to such reports,

00:16:58

of course, and here the influence of the

00:17:01

ECHR from which Russia withdrew is very important and now

00:17:03

it remains literally the only

00:17:05

organization where Russia continues to

00:17:07

cooperate and listens or

00:17:10

pretends to listen, but there is a

00:17:12

return to the HRC that had a very

00:17:14

serious impact

00:17:17

on, for example, the conditions of detention in prison,

00:17:20

they are all compared to the 90s, they

00:17:22

have improved again, it’s hard to say we

00:17:25

only understand that we are talking about

00:17:26

schizo, but globally there are changes,

00:17:29

including the relative transparency of the

00:17:31

judicial system, in this regard, I have an

00:17:33

example of a country that was not in the ECHR and did

00:17:36

not follow the recommendations of Belarus Yes, that’s

00:17:39

there everything is much worse there is complete

00:17:41

opacity if we say here that a

00:17:43

prisoner has been traveling for several weeks and we do

00:17:46

n’t know about him, in Belarus we

00:17:49

may not know what’s going on for months or even years,

00:17:51

a person.

00:17:53

Let’s have time to talk a little more

00:17:56

about history. Moreover, in Russia I’m not

00:18:00

I know how you noticed that after the

00:18:01

war, crimes against

00:18:03

monuments began. It’s surprising, but for some reason the

00:18:06

regime suddenly focused on several

00:18:09

nationalities. It’s probably the Poles that

00:18:12

somehow lead in this regard. But

00:18:15

now there is a message

00:18:17

from others there in Athens and so on.

00:18:18

Why is it

00:18:20

important for the state to fight monuments

00:18:24

I think again We are considering this, we don’t

00:18:27

know the answer clearly and clearly about

00:18:30

the state, there is no doubt that this is done by

00:18:32

state structures, but here it is

00:18:34

quite important to understand that if there was an order

00:18:37

at the level of Moscow and Vladimir

00:18:38

Putin personally, then this happened all over the country

00:18:41

Within a week

00:18:43

then there is most likely I suspect that

00:18:46

this is rather an initiative on the ground, perhaps of

00:18:49

local intelligence services which the disease

00:18:52

relates to in some regions Yes, to the

00:18:54

memory they believe that these monuments are a

00:18:57

direct accusation of us by the intelligence services and here is another

00:19:01

convenient excuse Yes, the countries that are

00:19:03

now against us are their own

00:19:04

they are fighting against us with monuments, let us

00:19:07

do something with them.

00:19:09

Well, it seems to me that this is a common story for a

00:19:12

totalitarian state in the sense

00:19:14

that it is trying to rewrite this history

00:19:16

and remove inconvenient moments.

00:19:18

I think we will see a lot more of this

00:19:21

kind in the history of monuments, that is

00:19:24

Well, we just watched a discussion on history

00:19:28

this weekend, Magomed

00:19:30

Daudov, nicknamed Lord, spoke out against the

00:19:33

textbook that Medinsky wrote, the

00:19:36

miracle really had some kind of reaction, but

00:19:38

then the moment Daudov deleted a

00:19:40

fragment of his supply, he said that

00:19:42

the circulation of textbooks would be confiscated, apparently it was

00:19:44

not confiscated after all what kind of

00:19:46

historical discussion is this? I wouldn’t call it

00:19:49

historical in the literal sense

00:19:51

of the word, but it’s such a thing that

00:19:54

modern Russia is such an

00:19:56

eclecticism from different states and to make a

00:20:01

textbook that absolutely everyone would like,

00:20:03

even today’s Seemingly complete

00:20:07

monolithic Russia is quite a difficult

00:20:09

task

00:20:10

and Medinsky I made

00:20:13

some mistake with my textbook because you ca

00:20:16

n’t keep track of everything. Yes And at the moment of

00:20:20

repression, the repressed peoples

00:20:22

made a not very correct

00:20:23

formulation and this caused a reaction. I

00:20:26

think such a topic is such a thing that it is very

00:20:28

difficult to write a textbook in athletics.

00:20:30

We still have some kind of controversy probably

00:20:33

about the 19th century about the revolution, then there will be

00:20:36

something else because there the Putin

00:20:39

state likes to use Yes,

00:20:41

some moments in its favor and

00:20:44

sometimes it’s just the opposite Well,

00:20:46

I don’t know, to be for Lenin or the Tsar, it’s

00:20:50

not so easy to formalize in the textbook,

00:20:51

so as not to cause a contradiction, the groups

00:20:53

that support the Ukrainian

00:20:55

state, on the one hand, created the

00:20:57

Ukrainian state, on the other hand,

00:20:59

preserved Yes, preserved the

00:21:02

very one that was disintegrating with Russia. Well, that

00:21:04

is, I mean that you can’t please everyone here;

00:21:07

another point, I have no doubt

00:21:09

that such influential people I’m

00:21:13

afraid that most

00:21:16

likely there won’t be any more opponents and defenders, but we’re just seeing something like

00:21:18

this. It seems to me that the

00:21:20

characteristic picture is that this textbook is

00:21:22

cobbled together from pieces, not everyone likes it, and some

00:21:25

people don’t like it; they sit and are

00:21:28

silent.

00:21:29

Sergei’s last topic, which I want to

00:21:31

have time to talk about. You are the editor-in-chief

00:21:32

of the media zone and Just together with the BBC, you are

00:21:36

counting messages about the dead

00:21:40

Russians in the war with Ukraine and your

00:21:44

calculations show that this is at least

00:21:48

36 38 thousand Well, yes, in this category,

00:21:53

tell us what conclusions can be drawn from

00:21:56

this count, what do you see How

00:22:00

the information of the dead is changing

00:22:02

How it is changing in the end, the contingent of

00:22:04

dead Yes, well, you just need to understand

00:22:07

that the big problem with the numbers is in any

00:22:10

case, since the state of these numbers does

00:22:13

not provide any alternative

00:22:15

Normal calculations We do not see estimates,

00:22:18

for example, yes Or Ukrainian countries and

00:22:20

Western intelligence services this is not the most frequent

00:22:22

information

00:22:23

is not the same there this is still an estimate.

00:22:28

We decided to monitor the losses from

00:22:31

open messages, literally, so we

00:22:33

know the names of the dead, more than 30 thousand

00:22:36

dead, and from them we can determine

00:22:39

where people are from. Which regions. That is, this is

00:22:43

information useful for understanding where

00:22:45

more people are fighting, how many are dying

00:22:48

now from those mobilized from Volunteers,

00:22:51

some people are not always possible to determine

00:22:53

who yes We understood exactly how many

00:22:56

prisoners began to die Yes, when it became

00:23:00

noticeable by the way, it’s harder for them to deal with them

00:23:02

because there is no doubt that they are

00:23:04

less social

00:23:06

and they have fewer social connections and

00:23:08

we’re just talking about the deaths of prisoners we will

00:23:10

learn less social networks than

00:23:12

about people other than others who have

00:23:14

more social connections left, that

00:23:17

is, we can make such a general assessment

00:23:19

How the number of deaths is changing,

00:23:22

approximate dynamics Yes, when it’s one thing but the

00:23:25

names we see how many names we see

00:23:27

in a month we understand more fierce

00:23:29

battles are not fierce this is not the number of

00:23:31

real losses, this is the number of people who

00:23:35

we have determined that he definitely died and

00:23:37

there is a message about this,

00:23:39

however, from these numbers we can draw many

00:23:41

conclusions

00:23:43

regions age royal composition and so

00:23:48

on Thank you very much Sergei for coming

00:23:50

to the studio and answering questions goodbye the

00:23:53

European and American press

00:23:55

regularly publish articles about Russian

00:23:57

culture and its so-called black

00:23:59

spots, do the waves of these

00:24:02

discussions reach Russia? We’ll ask

00:24:04

journalist and exhibition curator Anna

00:24:06

Narinskaya Hello Anna Hello

00:24:08

How much do these articles really

00:24:11

provoke discussion both in the West and

00:24:14

in Russia?

00:24:15

indeed, two in the West in Russia,

00:24:19

these are two such different questions in general. And

00:24:22

unfortunately, now

00:24:24

we still always forget that, by

00:24:27

the way, Facebook is where the reflection of the

00:24:30

mirror of these discussions is, even if they were there

00:24:33

in some German in New York there was a

00:24:37

famous article about this or even in

00:24:40

some Russian-speaking but banned

00:24:43

buildings in Russia, we still say that

00:24:44

Facebook is in Russia under VPN And in

00:24:47

fact, it’s not like people know this is just one

00:24:49

Happy family or an

00:24:50

unhappy family that sits on

00:24:53

Facebook and there he swears or, on the contrary,

00:24:55

agrees about this Well, frankly

00:24:57

speaking, even before VPN it was such a

00:24:59

unique social network,

00:25:02

not Odnoklassniki not VKontakte, that’s why

00:25:05

these are completely two different

00:25:07

stories, roughly speaking, I feel

00:25:10

scary, I don’t know, again I’m tired of

00:25:13

saying the word guilty, well somehow

00:25:16

involved in all this because

00:25:19

Having arrived

00:25:21

in Germany in particular there after the

00:25:24

start of a full-time invasion, I

00:25:28

believed that this tragedy, everything that

00:25:30

happens should really push us, but I do

00:25:32

n’t know, let’s call

00:25:34

humanities intellectuals and so on, to

00:25:36

push us to this reflection

00:25:39

about Russian literature in particular not

00:25:42

only Well, I remember your article and I remember

00:25:45

this image of Pushkin

00:25:48

in Kherson in my opinion What kind of banner is this

00:25:51

that pushes the name of Pushkin in general, in essence,

00:25:54

this territory of

00:25:56

the article was captured was that it was mine

00:25:58

I didn’t defend Pushkin I didn’t defend I gave it

00:26:01

conditionally Mine generation are those people

00:26:05

whose conscious life occurred in a

00:26:08

short moment Okay Freedom of speech,

00:26:11

let’s say freedom of speech in this

00:26:13

regard in Russia Even if not more fully Well, you

00:26:16

could say anything about culture

00:26:17

in the late 90s and early 2000 and

00:26:22

we don’t seem to have any there is

00:26:25

no time for a colonial, non-gender

00:26:28

analysis of Russian canonical

00:26:33

texts, which are terribly important in

00:26:36

Russia because they have this same

00:26:38

mirror called the school

00:26:40

curriculum and we must understand that the

00:26:42

school curriculum that

00:26:44

My mother, who just died, was

00:26:47

born in 1936, studied with. me

00:26:50

and according to which they studied My children are

00:26:51

almost the same Well, they

00:26:55

brought up the Solzhenitsa, in my opinion The story about a real

00:26:57

person was brought out when my children are

00:26:59

now probably leading everything back,

00:27:03

that is, it’s really directly cast in

00:27:07

some kind of bronze, this canon Yes, and the

00:27:10

Great is a terrible word Russian literature

00:27:13

and we are still and yes My generation

00:27:17

has done nothing about the fact that Putin, with the

00:27:21

full applause of everyone and without any

00:27:24

doubt, can put Pushkin on a

00:27:28

billboard in Kherson, maybe they can be classics

00:27:30

in which Gogol will be included, which means

00:27:33

decorating the ruins of theaters in Mariupol

00:27:37

is not the study of my generation, I am

00:27:41

absolutely sure of this, that is, it is clear

00:27:43

that it’s not that we could influence

00:27:45

Putin like that and he would say, well, he wrote in Rimskoe

00:27:48

Now, of course, I won’t do this,

00:27:49

but there’s simply not even any

00:27:54

parallel discussion of this And when

00:27:57

my schoolchildren children went through Poltava in a

00:28:01

class without any historical In the

00:28:04

commentary During the most wonderful years in the

00:28:06

most beautiful Moscow school,

00:28:09

of course it’s, well, let’s say it’s the fault of the

00:28:11

humanities students, so I should have

00:28:13

done this, I didn’t do this about this

00:28:15

was the article that you remembered So

00:28:18

I think to this day Since then, there has been

00:28:22

talk about the fact that Russian culture is

00:28:24

somehow different from, if Divided by

00:28:28

historical periods Yes, from the French

00:28:32

incredible imperial And if you

00:28:36

say the position of women,

00:28:39

gender violence, and so on, they will give a head

00:28:42

start to the cruising ranks of a lot of things,

00:28:45

for example, French authors, that’s where no

00:28:49

means yes will be described very strongly. That

00:28:52

is, this is Now a very

00:28:56

conscious refusal of historicism in the criticism of

00:29:00

Russian culture when, for example, I

00:29:02

spoke with the author of One of the

00:29:04

harshest articles about this and asked the question

00:29:08

you are writing. Write it out in a German newspaper

00:29:11

and do not compare it in any way with the views

00:29:14

of German classics And the German

00:29:17

romantics who glorified the war And

00:29:19

in general, military feats were One of the

00:29:22

main themes Yes, a man, a lone knight,

00:29:25

capture, storm and stress, it

00:29:28

was actually called yes. Well, somehow here the eyes drop so much

00:29:33

and it turns out that all this is

00:29:35

not important, although in fact, Yes, we

00:29:37

understand that

00:29:39

everything in the case is in the European context, and the

00:29:42

Russian culture that we are talking about is at

00:29:45

least these important economic

00:29:48

texts. Yes, they are in the European

00:29:49

context. Well, it’s like a

00:29:58

crime divided throughout Europe. Or what should we call it and

00:30:01

say a sign of history? Yes, here’s the Empire

00:30:05

expanded, glorified These people

00:30:07

who go there to India in England and the

00:30:11

time of the white man, the

00:30:12

question is, what was the attitude towards Kipling

00:30:16

who wrote About the time of the white

00:30:18

man

00:30:19

in England Yes, now any schoolchild, even

00:30:22

too much, can be kickbacks from the teeth,

00:30:25

which means it bounces off what Kipling is a

00:30:28

terrible imperialist and so on And we

00:30:31

have not brought such work, which means

00:30:34

that Russian culture is somehow especially

00:30:37

characterized by the

00:30:39

justification of violence, the

00:30:42

attraction to death or something

00:30:46

else that is accused of this is simply not scientific Anna

00:30:50

So you gave an example of the British experience and the

00:30:53

German experience now if you read

00:30:56

again on social networks, you often see the position

00:30:59

that you speak for yourself, there is no need to speak

00:31:02

for other countries,

00:31:06

I discussed this, yes, I think it’s terrible, I

00:31:10

can’t say anything. I never You

00:31:13

can, I understand that I probably many

00:31:15

viewers are now condemning me, I absolutely I don’t

00:31:18

understand, I was involved in sugar at

00:31:21

some point, I did a big

00:31:23

exhibition Well, as a member of a large team

00:31:26

together with Sergei Lukashevsky and I don’t want to

00:31:29

pull the blanket on myself and the

00:31:31

Sakharov center they were already

00:31:34

agents. Of course, we did a big

00:31:37

exhibition dedicated to Sakharov’s centenary in the

00:31:40

twenty-first year and so to

00:31:43

speak, his ideas are very close to me And

00:31:46

I believe that the

00:31:49

ideas of justice should be

00:31:51

national Of course, I cannot call

00:31:55

for the fact that it is clear that they should

00:32:01

take into account all sorts of

00:32:04

national characteristics of tradition and so

00:32:07

on, but still, yes, human rights are

00:32:10

rights I

00:32:12

won’t talk about a person now Well, they are

00:32:15

human rights everywhere Yes and

00:32:17

Well, if you don’t treat it like that, then I just don’t

00:32:20

know what to do, but then we have to accept

00:32:22

that

00:32:26

female circumcision is for this culture and let’s

00:32:28

live with it, so to speak. Well, I’m probably a very

00:32:30

outdated person, I’m like that I can’t live, I

00:32:32

think that no, a woman cannot be

00:32:34

stoned anywhere, no matter how

00:32:37

autoctonal it is, some cultures speak

00:32:39

only for myself, you can disagree with me.

00:32:42

So

00:32:45

I think that it was the duty of my generation

00:32:49

and the

00:32:51

Russians within

00:32:53

their

00:32:55

culture, let’s say their language, to

00:32:59

how to say to look critically at

00:33:04

various texts of Russian literature We are

00:33:06

still talking mainly about Russian literature

00:33:08

Well, or there are some works of

00:33:11

painting and what is that Although this does not have such an

00:33:15

impact and we had to somehow

00:33:18

say

00:33:20

stop talking about it like about something

00:33:23

absolutely beyond

00:33:25

the jurisdiction of what if

00:33:28

Lermontov wrote a terrible

00:33:30

lullaby text which I just can’t repeat now

00:33:34

means on the air And what did he write that

00:33:38

even the Russian court now

00:33:40

prohibits further just how to say it’s not so

00:33:43

popular Well, here’s Lermontov’s

00:33:44

lullaby text my baby is sleeping a wonderful

00:33:47

story this is

00:33:49

read by every seven Well, probably yes, it

00:33:52

was necessary to work with it somehow

00:33:54

and this work has been carried out there, for example, in

00:33:57

America This is work with incredible By

00:34:00

the way, I think there are overlaps But there is a

00:34:02

lot going on there, I

00:34:05

repeat, I will say again Yes, and in this sense,

00:34:08

Probably it is necessary as It would be for the Russians,

00:34:12

so as not to tell the Russians or the Jews

00:34:15

like me, but at the same time born in Russian

00:34:19

culture and working there with it, they

00:34:21

had to think about it. So that then

00:34:24

other people wouldn’t think for us, wouldn’t write

00:34:26

articles in the New Yorker about how they

00:34:28

Tolstoy was disappointed, but

00:34:30

to say that being in some

00:34:34

country you cannot be indignant at

00:34:36

lawlessness if we are not talking about culture right now.

00:34:38

Yes, just lawlessness in another

00:34:40

country, in my opinion. This is nonsense. Well, you

00:34:43

addressed your audience with just such a question,

00:34:46

as they say some kind of

00:34:47

teaser the answer killed, yes, that is, the

00:34:50

answer

00:34:52

is for me. I don’t even understand that, for

00:34:55

example, a resident of

00:34:58

Hitler’s Germany. He couldn’t

00:35:00

condemn racism in America, which

00:35:03

was a monster then.

00:35:05

I can even just not have Facebook and

00:35:07

then they would have sent him some- then the

00:35:09

planters who had already done something to the

00:35:13

slaves and would say, well, you actually have

00:35:16

consorts. Sit quietly,

00:35:18

this is some level of conversation, I absolutely do

00:35:22

n’t know. Firstly, it kind of

00:35:25

kills any idea of conversation that

00:35:29

experience is something important, so people

00:35:32

can bring one experience into another experience

00:35:35

In addition, I repeat that there are

00:35:37

some humanitarian standards that,

00:35:39

well,

00:35:41

for places where we are told that there is

00:35:45

democracy and civilization, they

00:35:50

are more or less strongholds, so

00:35:55

I don’t want to give examples now.

00:35:57

I just think that really,

00:36:01

how to say

00:36:03

I think it’s outdated that thought blows wherever it

00:36:07

wants and therefore people can think about

00:36:09

everything talk

00:36:12

question like the author of the film Find the Jews

00:36:15

When you hear a joke from Vladimir Putin

00:36:17

about the detergent Israeli, what do you think,

00:36:20

what do you feel

00:36:22

Oh, I personally don’t feel anything,

00:36:27

just put it this way, I also wrote about it,

00:36:32

so I can literally I never

00:36:35

had any doubts that, like a stage in

00:36:40

Russian xenophobia, the stage

00:36:42

of anti-Semitism, it will return or can

00:36:46

say It will come again. This is an eternal

00:36:48

saying. Well, at least Putin is not an anti-Semite,

00:36:51

which of course was very popular in Jewish circles and

00:36:53

right in Israel, and that

00:36:56

means in Israel it was It’s a really important

00:36:58

quality of Putin that at least he’s not an

00:37:00

anti-Semite, you know, we Jews

00:37:04

tend to treat ourselves as the chosen

00:37:06

people, and that’s why many people

00:37:09

believe that there is xenophobia in general and

00:37:12

national intolerance, and these are all these

00:37:15

things, but there is Emitism, which is somehow something

00:37:18

else and there is racism And there is This is

00:37:21

some completely different thing

00:37:23

Unfortunately or fortunately this is not so And

00:37:26

if xenophobia flourishes in the country and

00:37:28

if in general it is said that some

00:37:30

people there are not like that and should know their

00:37:32

place as they say And in general

00:37:35

it is considered that languages are not equal and

00:37:38

cultures are just not

00:37:40

equal to Putin, then this will also affect Jews,

00:37:43

especially keeping in mind that there really

00:37:46

is a great tradition in Russia, if for

00:37:50

example

00:37:51

this is another question that was which we wo

00:37:54

n’t

00:37:56

talk about today, but probably that’s how one

00:38:00

of Putin’s main enemies

00:38:03

representatives of LGBT people have become But this is just the way it

00:38:07

is It’s amazing how much

00:38:10

attention is paid to this group of people in general,

00:38:12

and now, for example, even recently

00:38:17

some funny comedy film was released where

00:38:19

the main one

00:38:20

How cross-racing works there, or whether the

00:38:23

main character overheats in

00:38:27

Yakut women film Let's pay attention, they

00:38:31

took away his license because it's

00:38:35

LGBT Propaganda

00:38:36

and Hello, am I your aunt, is it a banned

00:38:40

film or not How was it shown in every club here, it

00:38:42

all means Hello It's like Nikitich

00:38:46

Yes, the main thing is that somehow I

00:38:51

was sitting on every TV, that is, this is worse

00:38:53

than the Soviet regime in this sense Yes, and

00:38:55

in many ways we will not hide So and In

00:38:59

addition, it is clear There are some moments of their own,

00:39:03

but it is also obvious that this is a kind of

00:39:07

platform on which Propaganda can unite with a certain

00:39:09

part of the population, well,

00:39:15

because there is and in of all peoples Let's not

00:39:18

deceive ourselves that this is

00:39:19

somehow characteristic of the Russian people or Russian

00:39:21

Russia, rejection of the other is a very

00:39:24

important thing, and

00:39:26

so to speak, and racism in many different

00:39:30

countries is based on this. Rejection of the

00:39:32

other is a very strong thing. A Jew is an

00:39:36

absolutely

00:39:37

typical ideal other, in addition to

00:39:42

Russia has a huge tradition of not loving

00:39:45

this other

00:39:47

state anti-Semitism of

00:39:50

caricatures where with such noses it means that

00:39:53

this is an

00:39:54

absolute faith that has not gone anywhere, an

00:39:58

all-onist conspiracy and what that means is that they are

00:40:00

sitting somewhere behind the scenes since until

00:40:04

recently I went to Moscow from

00:40:06

Moscow I

00:40:07

left on August 10 for the last time I must

00:40:10

tell you that it is considered indecent

00:40:13

to judge by taxi drivers what it is in general.

00:40:16

But still, I’ll tell you that the number of

00:40:21

taxi drivers who told me that it was the

00:40:23

Zionists who started the war, they generally move

00:40:26

puppets and even Putin is all of

00:40:30

them are proteges. More than five

00:40:34

taxi drivers, they drove so often, that’s why the

00:40:38

fact that the

00:40:40

development of Russia as it is developing

00:40:43

now will also lead to anti-Semitism. What kind of it

00:40:48

will it be? Is it possible to repeat the structure of

00:40:50

state anti-Semitism? I don’t

00:40:54

know how it was in the Soviet Union. Well,

00:40:58

maybe it’s possible because it’s a long

00:41:01

conversation, I’m afraid. We don’t have time because

00:41:03

it’s just because until now Since

00:41:05

there are Israeli laws

00:41:08

of return and any potential Jews

00:41:10

can leave for Israel, then I would not be

00:41:12

surprised at all. I don’t know about some kind of ban on

00:41:14

education, I croak this does

00:41:17

n’t foretell anything, well, almost nothing

00:41:20

foretells anything, but quite such a

00:41:24

technical explanation Why Jews

00:41:28

for example, you don’t need to enter technical

00:41:30

universities, you can find it because they will go to

00:41:33

Israel and will use this

00:41:34

education against us or our

00:41:37

allies or our allies, this was

00:41:40

one of the main explanations for

00:41:42

state anti-seatism in the

00:41:44

seventies and the exclusion of this

00:41:47

black list of universities where Jews could not

00:41:49

to do which, uh, since I did

00:41:52

the film, the research was shared by

00:41:55

many people whom we are accustomed to

00:41:58

consider decent.

00:42:00

We mentioned one Yakut film

00:42:02

Let's talk about another Yes, the film And this

00:42:04

was the one that was removed, I also did

00:42:06

not see the film Unfortunately, but the most important thing is

00:42:09

that we can’t watch it

00:42:10

because it was removed from streaming

00:42:12

platforms And why, in your

00:42:16

opinion, in principle did the state react so nervously

00:42:18

to a film that, in

00:42:20

general, It would seem that it was calmly shown

00:42:23

at various festivals And did

00:42:25

not cause any problems on the national agenda,

00:42:28

you know, I don’t want to to talk about what you don’t

00:42:31

know, of course I just read about it,

00:42:33

so I understand that after all, the idea is going well,

00:42:36

and in some national conflicts, that there is

00:42:41

some kind of tension shown in this

00:42:44

film between the

00:42:46

Yakut population and the Russian

00:42:49

policeman, I wanted to say the policeman

00:42:51

Yes, it seems to me that this is also becomes

00:42:54

absolute, firstly, there are two things here,

00:42:57

firstly because such tension is

00:43:00

rising now in different regions

00:43:02

and this is one hundred percent too. I have

00:43:04

personal experience, in my opinion, even in the studio I talked about it using the

00:43:06

example of the truth of

00:43:08

people from Kalmykia, it’s correct to say

00:43:13

Yes, where there is certainly this, well, there

00:43:17

is such tension. This is a new thing, people,

00:43:19

how to say it, suddenly realized Yes, and

00:43:22

they remembered the suppression that was and,

00:43:25

for example, they consider the situation with a

00:43:28

large number of conscription there in

00:43:30

Ukraine as unfair. That is,

00:43:34

this is rising Yes, and this is certainly true

00:43:36

there is a reaction. And besides, there is

00:43:39

this idea. Sergei also said

00:43:42

that the state is eclectic and

00:43:45

[music]

00:43:47

according to Medinsky’s textbook, and the reaction

00:43:50

to it is clear that this is starting to interfere, this must be taken

00:43:52

into account, it is very difficult to

00:43:55

take into account. Therefore, this needs to be leveled out,

00:43:58

what is this no, how can I cut off any hints about

00:44:01

this? Thank you very much Anna for

00:44:05

coming to the studio, answering questions,

00:44:07

goodbye

00:44:08

Valentina Matvienko said Valery

00:44:10

Zorka is not the Chairman of the Constitutional

00:44:12

Court, otherwise she said that he skillfully

00:44:15

weaves beads, well, I must admit that there is

00:44:18

no better way to say what he does

00:44:20

constitutional court is Like

00:44:23

this video and Subscribe to our

00:44:24

channel

00:44:25

goodbye

00:44:29

[music]

Description:

Анна Наринская, журналистка и куратор выставок и Сергей Смирнов, главный редактор «Медиазоны» — гости нового Oбзора от BILD. Подписывайтесь на наш Telegram: https://t.me/BILD_Russian

Preparing download options

Popular

HD video

Only sound

All

* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."

** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players

Questions about downloading video

How can I download "Анна Наринская, Сергей Смирнов | Обзор от BILD" video?

http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.

Which format of "Анна Наринская, Сергей Смирнов | Обзор от BILD" video should I choose?

The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.

Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Анна Наринская, Сергей Смирнов | Обзор от BILD" video?

The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.

How can I download "Анна Наринская, Сергей Смирнов | Обзор от BILD" video to my phone?

You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.

How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Анна Наринская, Сергей Смирнов | Обзор от BILD"?

The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.

How can I save a frame from a video "Анна Наринская, Сергей Смирнов | Обзор от BILD"?

This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.

What's the price of all this stuff?

It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.