Download "Андрей КУРАЕВ: Поезжайте в Москву с цветами / ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ"
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FQnxevn8dFKQ%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
Please wait. We're preparing links for easy ad-free video watching and downloading.
Table of contents
Similar videos from our catalog
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252F1J_fyP19Q98%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252F3UI7W9hHZQU%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FtdO0mI5CgwY%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FxmZbx0L7wHI%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
Video tags
Subtitles
Russian
00:00:00
[music]00:00:15
Good evening dear friends This is an00:00:17
inhale-exhale program My name is Stas00:00:19
Kryuchkov And I am glad to meet you on our00:00:22
channel and approximately Subscribe is a00:00:25
guarantee that from now on we will be able to see00:00:28
new interesting guests and00:00:30
ask important questions to the best of our ability Well, of course00:00:33
it is condition that together there will00:00:35
be more of us, leave your00:00:37
comments in the chat of this broadcast,00:00:39
share the link to this video with your00:00:42
friends, family and acquaintances and00:00:45
subscribe to my telegram channel00:00:47
camera film of course to the resources of our00:00:50
guests we are recording this conversation on00:00:52
Epiphany evening with us today00:00:54
theologian Andrey Kuraev00:00:57
[music]00:01:01
I’m now Andrey, good afternoon. Hello,00:01:03
good afternoon. What permission do I have00:01:06
today to alternate between private questions,00:01:09
some theological things and a number of00:01:13
news stories, if you agree, a00:01:16
few more personal questions and,00:01:20
in fact, I guess I’ll start with this about00:01:22
two weeks ago00:01:25
in yours blog I saw a link to the00:01:29
answers that the00:01:33
now retired Bishop of Kastanay,00:01:36
Father Anatoly Aksyonov, gave to his interlocutor00:01:40
and they concerned you personally and one of the00:01:43
important thoughts that I drew00:01:46
attention to With all that polites piet00:01:48
that he observed and with all that00:01:51
ambiguous and rather let’s say a00:01:54
tough position in your address,00:01:58
directly condemning Yes, he said that00:02:02
there is a time for multiple rights, he cited00:02:06
the story of00:02:08
Metropolitan Nicodemus,00:02:10
saying that in one audience00:02:12
there is such a truth, but in another audience00:02:16
this truth sounds inappropriate. In this00:02:21
regard, for you personally, how you define00:02:24
yourself the time of presence of this or that00:02:27
truth in life and the time of00:02:30
readiness to sacrifice it, this is00:02:34
somehow00:02:37
with your life logic mission in the00:02:41
form in which it is now present in00:02:44
this life correlates or This is a00:02:46
completely alien story because there00:02:48
was a reference to theology on church people00:02:53
Let him and I be friends during the years of studying at the00:02:57
academy00:02:58
and for me it was a very00:03:01
important experience of communication Friendship The fact is00:03:05
that I am a Moscow major, a00:03:08
kind of such a World of communication and so00:03:10
on I practically never00:03:13
left Moscow anywhere and the so-called00:03:15
deep people in general, I tried00:03:17
not to have any contact with him and especially contacts,00:03:21
and therefore joining the circle of the seminary00:03:23
for me was an acquaintance with guys00:03:26
who came from completely different social countries.00:03:29
I remember who was delighted with some00:03:31
tragic stories of Ukrainian guys about00:03:33
how they slaughter pigs for Christmas00:03:35
there before Christmas they prepare so on00:03:38
Moscow boys will hear such00:03:40
stories as how to properly hold a pig00:03:42
How to implement and so on00:03:44
yes it was some kind of New planet for00:03:46
me and one of these aliens in the00:03:51
good sense of the word I was00:03:52
interested in opening these games Volodya00:03:55
his story is so00:03:58
ordinary. A working-class family, the father drinks00:04:02
and when he drinks, he beats up the mother.00:04:05
One day I wrote home, grabbed a shotgun00:04:09
and the shot hit the mother. The00:04:11
pellets actually got into her eyes,00:04:15
no, but there were just00:04:18
five pellets at 11, these are the numbers of her00:04:21
vision.00:04:23
One day she was00:04:26
lying in her bed00:04:29
and suddenly sees the Mother of God in a dream00:04:31
coming out of the icon that was with the bed, a00:04:35
ritual icon that was not particularly00:04:37
treated in this family, comes up to her,00:04:39
takes her hand00:04:40
and says you will see, you will00:04:42
recover00:04:43
by the morning, she began to scream in the colors of darkness And a00:04:47
few days later she it meant a00:04:49
consultation with a00:04:50
Moscow doctor who volunteered to treat the fact00:04:54
that they were from the provinces, but that’s00:04:58
because the eyes didn’t leak Yes, and he gathered a00:05:00
consultation, they brought her in00:05:02
and when, accordingly, He told00:05:05
the backstory then asked the assistants00:05:07
to lead the patient again to the meeting, she00:05:11
wanted these patients’ hands when I got there myself00:05:13
and she walked between the chairs and everyone00:05:16
was in shock, it was clear what she saw00:05:18
after that. This woman never00:05:22
missed a single service, she went to churches00:05:25
and why not, he told me because00:05:28
I was surprised when I was at his00:05:30
monastic tonsure, the second Sergius’s00:05:33
mother was present. What rarely00:05:35
happens when children have their sons' hair cut?00:05:37
Here the mother is present and she was happy.00:05:40
Usually mothers in such cases cry00:05:42
because the hope for their grandchildren is cut off.00:05:47
Why How can she be happy? He did00:05:50
n't tell that story there, he has a00:05:52
beautiful voice. Volodya went with the00:05:55
Lavsky choir of Father Matthew just- As soon as00:05:58
the borders opened, there were some tours in00:05:59
Germany, there were now trips, he brought00:06:02
some kind of radio transistor especially for his00:06:04
mother, all sorts of small money00:06:06
that he spent for his mother, he brought it to her00:06:09
and then he never caved in to his00:06:11
superiors, he was an honest man, he was00:06:13
regularly driven away from the pulpit. Well then there is00:06:17
therefore for me this is, well, such a very00:06:20
bright name, a bright image has always been And the00:06:24
first kind of crack arose00:06:27
just when on my visit to00:06:29
him in his Kazakh party which was00:06:31
reminiscent of the00:06:32
matter in general that he did not say What was the00:06:34
reason for my scandalous scandal The Vladyka did00:06:38
not tell said that a00:06:40
new temple was built there just now,00:06:43
if its illumination I was invited as00:06:46
such an additional cultural00:06:48
program and in this Temple the00:06:50
local governor Akim of the00:06:53
Kostanay region of the Kazakhs was depicted on the fresco00:06:57
met people inside this temple frescoes00:07:00
I I wrote about this in my00:07:03
journal and, as it were, began to say about it that00:07:06
somehow it was wrong, yes. And of course00:07:08
there was a scandal because00:07:09
Kazakhstan was born. Well, it’s impossible for such a00:07:12
big sponsor and benefactors to somehow00:07:14
be surprised that something wrong00:07:16
happened00:07:18
Yes, so the fact is that later this fresco00:07:20
was redrawn after I said about it,00:07:24
that when the Vodokan went00:07:27
And now I want to tell one00:07:30
poem that over the years00:07:33
has become autobiographical for me Although00:07:35
it was written a long time ago In 192900:07:39
I sit alone in the evenings and look in one00:07:43
portrait, a young boy with big00:07:46
eyes with a clear gaze looks at the light, the00:07:49
longer I look, the more pity the tears burn with00:07:52
hot fire, this affectionate little white00:07:55
boy has turned into me, alas,00:07:59
this is Nikolai Solodovnikov, a wonderful00:08:02
Orthodox, such a semi-underground poet of00:08:04
the Soviet era,00:08:07
and now you know for me this is one of00:08:09
the most important00:08:12
experiences or something. In my already00:08:16
many ten years of church life,00:08:18
I have rarely seen a person in the church00:08:20
establish themselves better. Especially with career00:08:24
growth,00:08:25
unfortunately I have seen the opposite more than once00:08:27
when such wonderful boys,00:08:29
seminarians, Russian boys according to00:08:31
Dostoevsky Yes, they suddenly turned into00:08:35
despots of people deprived cat empathy of00:08:39
people who care about everything00:08:43
and what’s even worse is that this00:08:46
system actually instills omnivorousness in the city for the00:08:49
sake of the good of the church, that is, some00:08:52
kind of abstract good Yes, but it is very00:08:54
great and the church serves the salvation of people00:08:56
for eternity, next to this Great goal00:09:00
all landmarks begin to disappear any00:09:04
means seem to be But if this Great00:09:07
goal helps, then it’s good00:09:09
The greatness of the goal justifies the means00:09:12
It is when the goal is great that the00:09:17
dimension with the means is lost00:09:19
was also in the Bolshevik ideology00:09:21
Bolshevik practice of the early 20th century,00:09:23
therefore you can follow the path of terror and so on00:09:26
at the end of the 19th century it was stated that it is possible00:09:30
kill half of humanity for the sake of the happiness of00:09:32
future generations,00:09:35
but on the contrary, all other parties lost00:09:37
because they could set such00:09:39
global tasks as the happiness of future00:09:41
humanity for its entire endless00:09:44
future of all humanity, since then the00:09:46
scale of means allowed by them00:09:49
was also somehow more00:09:52
foreseeable and more limited The Bolsheviks00:09:55
did not have such a restriction And today00:09:58
we see that in essence, speaking in this00:10:00
attitude of Bolshevism, this is also the existence of00:10:04
such a church corporatism,00:10:06
I won’t say Orthodox Catholics The same garbage00:10:08
here in any such corporate religion00:10:12
where there is a clear corporation of Shvetsov who00:10:16
naturally consider themselves salt the lands00:10:18
identify themselves with this entire Faith as00:10:21
the object of their worship.00:10:23
And in this case, it turns out that00:10:26
you can go to all this, it’s not scary, it’s00:10:30
considered a feat. In a certain sense, I even seem to00:10:33
sacrifice my reputation00:10:35
a little because some people there00:10:37
will not scold him But I00:10:39
do this for the sake of saving my neighbors and so00:10:42
on, of course00:10:43
this is extremely reflected in the00:10:46
discussion around the experience of Metropolitan00:10:48
Sergei of Staraya Gorodsky. I myself have more than once00:10:50
told a fairy tale about the fact that allegedly at the00:10:52
end of the 20s the security officers showed a list of00:10:57
bishops of the Russian Church whom they00:10:59
arrested, they said Sergi, we00:11:01
will shoot everyone. If you don’t sign00:11:03
the document we need, you won’t cooperate,00:11:05
then you cried all night, she signed the00:11:09
path in history in the morning, the church00:11:13
is a beautiful fairy tale, not a single00:11:15
confirmation of it has been00:11:17
found anywhere over the00:11:19
past decade, and earrings are not00:11:22
produced by such a metro Ogorodsky00:11:24
has the impression of such a sentimental00:11:26
person, he always tried to rely on00:11:28
power, even managed to do this with the00:11:30
provisional government in00:11:32
1977, so it is unlikely that there was such a00:11:34
serious and terrible choice,00:11:37
but the point is not even that, but the fact is that in the00:11:39
end We remember Patriarch Kiril his00:11:41
monument to Sergius he said the words to the Staraya Gorodsky00:11:43
that he called him a holy hierarch and00:11:46
so on.00:11:47
That is, this is a certain attitude especially00:11:50
seemed to Patriarch Alexey 2, yes,00:11:53
partly under my conviction and my00:11:54
pressure, he renounced politics.00:11:59
So00:12:01
I understand that this is organic for this structure00:12:04
But Kirill is one thing00:12:08
Gundyaev Yes, everything in his life is somehow00:12:11
twisted too dashingly from the very00:12:13
beginning, but another thing is Volodya00:12:16
Aksyon and therefore it was not very bitter to00:12:18
hear from him this00:12:21
declaration,00:12:23
such a moral many options. Is it00:12:27
nevertheless possible to oppose a corporation of liars?00:12:32
this fixation of small00:12:35
ulcers, after all, they are like water off a duck’s back, and in this00:12:39
sense you yourself become. But in some00:12:42
way, a00:12:44
corporation of liars is a thorn on the body. With all this,00:12:48
nominally sharing those00:12:51
formal values that for them are00:12:53
not formal for you.00:12:55
Well, first of all, for me this is a matter of my00:12:58
personal hygiene,00:13:00
but I have to brush my teeth regardless of00:13:02
who has any problems with his00:13:04
dentist, if my boss does00:13:07
n’t even know which Dentist and never00:13:09
goes there, it doesn’t mean that I should also00:13:11
follow the example.00:13:13
Secondly, there is hope that00:13:16
what -then today's Russian boys00:13:18
who study in modern seminaries00:13:20
and at the same time, let's say, sometimes listen to you and me.00:13:25
Maybe somehow something00:13:28
will enter their matrix and their understanding of the fact that the00:13:33
Gospel commandments is not just about00:13:35
relationships with00:13:37
neighbors,00:13:40
what else is it and it also concerns00:13:44
life, it also00:13:45
concerns something that you preach00:13:49
that you can allow yourself the00:13:52
personal benefit of the corporate one, maybe00:13:54
somehow they will think about it, that’s why I do00:13:58
n’t think it’s useless. Well,00:14:02
especially since we are in Russia in which00:14:04
everyone- Still, with all that, in recent00:14:06
centuries there has been a heightened demand for,00:14:12
essentially00:14:14
speaking, to approach everyday life,00:14:19
everyday details of both court life and the00:14:22
life of a peasant hut, with some kind of ultimate joint standard of the Gospel.00:14:25
Therefore, sometimes I don’t say that00:14:29
now, of course, it’s difficult to say in general,00:14:30
this is how it led to it Yes00:14:33
It seems that Russia has become a00:14:35
historical state in it that has fallen out of00:14:37
history when I now read the Diaries of00:14:39
tsarist officials of the 19th century, to be honest, in the00:14:50
60s of the 19th century he is considered a00:14:53
terrible obscurantist, not at all like that, he00:14:57
gives extremely harsh assessments because he00:15:00
sees in the country00:15:08
of the Russian region there00:15:12
were no military problems, the uprising00:15:15
had already been suppressed by the ants00:15:25
somewhere in Siberia, the Polish nobility,00:15:28
clear out and so on, it’s natural to00:15:30
convert everyone to Orthodoxy, that is, it’s00:15:33
like those commissions in which Valuev was a member00:15:35
Yes, they solved those problems00:15:37
which the Kremlin cabinet wants to set for itself has00:15:39
not yet set00:15:41
for now the main thing for them would be something there somewhere00:15:44
else to get to, and then the question of00:15:47
putting things in order, so-called one00:15:48
certification, everything was very similar, but00:15:51
you know, I’m afraid that modern ones I can even00:15:53
try to find read out Let's pay00:15:57
attention to the diaries, you still have a00:16:00
powerful list of such films offered on00:16:03
New Year's holidays for00:16:05
the films reviewed after you find this00:16:07
status about the film about one thing I ask you, it is00:16:09
definitely00:16:11
scary that our government does not00:16:13
rely on any moral principles00:16:15
and does not act on any moral00:16:17
strength, respect for freedom of conscience for personal00:16:19
freedom of property rights, a sense00:16:21
of decency is completely alien to us. We only00:16:23
preach moral themes that00:16:25
we consider useful for ourselves, but we are00:16:27
not at all embarrassed to engage with them in practice.00:16:29
As soon as they recognize that something00:16:31
is profitable, we take away the temple, confiscate00:16:34
the property, systematically ruin what00:16:36
not by confiscation, we exile tens of thousands of00:16:38
people, we allow the00:16:41
manifestation of human feeling to be cast as treason,00:16:43
as today00:16:46
it is called a traitor when a person00:16:49
is indignant at the death of children,00:16:53
instead of correcting the mixture of ottoman-00:16:56
mindedness by the Dukes of Alba, we00:16:59
must reduce the feeling of disgust towards00:17:01
us throughout Europe And we talk about the Greatness00:17:03
of Russia and Orthodoxy00:17:05
Trouble in the fact that I think that today’s00:17:08
ministers do not keep such diaries00:17:11
and therefore we have little chance historically of the future to00:17:15
find out what, how00:17:18
discussions go, how decisions are made at00:17:21
Putin’s long long table, an00:17:23
instructive story in Valuev’s diary,00:17:26
but today’s Russians have a very00:17:29
interesting note, he says being to00:17:31
my readers diaries That is, he00:17:34
assumed in advance that over time00:17:35
after his death this would be read,00:17:37
there is one more episode, now I don’t00:17:41
remember who, but one of the highest officials with00:17:44
direct access to the sovereign brought00:17:47
his diary to the emperor and showed it to Your00:17:52
Majesty.00:17:54
That’s what he wrote about you and your family that00:17:57
emperor, give me a couple of days more00:18:00
important,00:18:01
leafed through it Yes, thanked him Yes, there are00:18:04
high words in the diary about the emperor,00:18:06
his dignity, his family, but there00:18:08
were negative reviews about his competitor00:18:10
about another general,00:18:12
so returning to the conversation about00:18:15
cinema and today's Russian00:18:17
boys, you brought it in relation to00:18:21
Bishop Anatoly a story from his00:18:25
youth from his childhood and00:18:30
during the Christmas holidays I myself00:18:32
watched the film Man of God by Elena00:18:35
Popovich, I don’t know how this kind of00:18:37
popularization relates, this is also in00:18:39
some way a film about a miracle00:18:42
in the Russian episcopate today there are00:18:47
people about whom this kind of film can be00:18:51
remove Let it be partly deep00:18:53
Let it be partly generalizations so00:18:56
justified that with this Russian00:18:58
boy you are talking about00:19:00
it will lie on the soul so that it00:19:05
really00:19:07
tells and tells some kind of story,00:19:11
popularization is important, something of this kind00:19:15
can be told by any believer00:19:17
probably in life almost every one of us00:19:19
had miracles of an unusual meeting and00:19:21
so on the result the result Yes, I don’t know anymore, like00:19:27
another generation I don’t know00:19:31
Who they are and how, but knowing the selection criteria for00:19:38
selection, we can assume that this is a00:19:42
systemic installation,00:19:44
here Russian boys don’t need people00:19:46
who are capable00:19:49
are capable of not drowning out this00:19:52
But using ours to00:19:58
turn at least to the regional00:20:00
authorities at the local level yes So what does it have to00:20:03
do with raising your voice not in defense of00:20:06
corporate interests00:20:09
but in defense we simply offend, well, let’s say the00:20:13
same sectarians, for example,00:20:15
if I can’t imagine this,00:20:18
continue the conversation about Kirill, I was on the eve of00:20:22
Epiphany In the morning I went to the00:20:24
Patriarchate website and for a very long time tried to find the00:20:27
published text of the00:20:30
Epiphany sermon, there was a00:20:34
news note about who was nearby00:20:36
there, who held the arm, who accompanied00:20:39
which choirs sang, what it says, it00:20:42
turned out that00:20:45
I had to wait until 5 o’clock in the evening to get to the sermon. When a00:20:51
link to this sermon was published on the Telegram channel of the Patriarchate and00:20:54
then it was already distributed on news00:20:57
sites, they paid attention to a very00:21:00
specific phrase, I will quote it00:21:03
in full with your permission, I will ask00:21:05
you to give it comments, the desire00:21:08
to defeat Russia today has become, as we00:21:10
know, very dangerous forms, we pray00:21:12
to the Lord to enlighten those and help them00:21:16
understand that any desire to destroy00:21:18
Russia will mean the end of the world, but not00:21:22
only about this we need to pray that00:21:24
instead of such madness, the00:21:26
human race will gain some kind of new consciousness,00:21:30
that is, the patriarch says that someone00:21:32
wants to destroy Russia and this will lead00:21:35
to the end of the world and further he writes We believe00:21:37
that the Lord will not abandon the Russian land, they00:21:40
will not abandon our authorities, I don’t feel in00:21:42
these words, by and large, anything00:21:44
other than calculations; there is no good in them; there is00:21:46
some kind of00:21:48
purely rationality in them that you from the00:21:51
patriarch, by and large,00:21:53
good. Not from the patriarch, not from a specific00:21:55
person, from the past in general. Well, why00:21:58
were these words said because in a different and00:22:01
more harsh configuration, these words We00:22:04
seem to have heard from the person whom00:22:06
we discussed with you in October, in my opinion Yes,00:22:10
he knew the concept here is desantanization00:22:13
Medvedev said the same kind of words00:22:17
After all, it would be possible to00:22:19
speak out in the abstract Yes, the pastor's00:22:21
baptismal sermon No, there is no need to pour grist into this00:22:26
mill, this is the00:22:27
bishop's church, church pas Who are now00:22:31
put in such a situation or is it coming00:22:33
from one head, here is your answer to this00:22:36
question, what is it?00:22:38
first, in any case, no one could00:22:41
force the Patriarch to00:22:42
start discussing this topic on the feast of Epiphany.00:22:46
Moreover, in this way, that is, this is00:22:48
clearly his personal desire, what is00:22:51
it connected with? It’s just the desire of an00:22:54
opportunist to once00:22:56
again say something that00:22:59
will be pleasant00:23:01
But this is soft option, what00:23:04
if it really is that he has already reformatted himself like this00:23:11
and this is some kind of real picture of the world00:23:13
that lives in his head, that is,00:23:19
such a Globe of the world is already inlaid into his skull. So we are00:23:22
enemies,00:23:25
it is clear that he is constantly hinting at this But it does00:23:28
n’t burn that the problem is that there are00:23:29
all people around you understand00:23:31
Yes, people have nutritional sexual00:23:34
orientation And we say the last00:23:37
line of resistance began soon and00:23:40
we will be forced to be like this, try it00:23:42
about this about00:23:43
nothing else, so to00:23:46
prevent this from happening, let’s00:23:48
remember accordingly that we have a powerful weapon00:23:50
that can destroy the whole world,00:23:53
pull out the patriarch Of course, there are speculations,00:23:56
firstly,00:23:57
the desire to reformat Russia in00:24:01
Russia just now, right now, it is00:24:05
making an attempt to reformat the00:24:06
neighboring country,00:24:09
women's countries, double standards, it00:24:11
was quite frankly stated that the00:24:14
goal of this is that00:24:16
reformatting another country00:24:19
called genocification and so on.00:24:22
That is, bringing another00:24:24
government there, changing some kind of00:24:25
ideological cultural matrix, and so00:24:28
on and so forth,00:24:29
this is possible in relation to us, this is supposedly00:24:33
impossible, the00:24:35
second thing is that the00:24:37
defeat of a certain country in some00:24:41
conflict is completely ambiguous00:24:43
the destruction of this country,00:24:46
generally speaking, this is a very dangerous thing,00:24:49
this is one of the consequences of Victory, the beast00:24:51
has been occulted in recent decades,00:24:53
this idea that Victory can00:24:56
only be the same as it was on May 9, 1945,00:25:00
that is, unconditional coatulation,00:25:02
occupation of a00:25:04
hostile power and on its surface00:25:07
unconditional surrender is signed00:25:10
and Our troops remain there for decades00:25:13
and forever arbitrary borders00:25:16
establish a social system and so00:25:17
on,00:25:18
but it is extremely rare in history00:25:22
as a rule that wars end in a00:25:26
completely different way the signing of the Tilsit00:25:29
peace, for example the00:25:30
Fur agreement,00:25:33
yes That is, there were hostilities, there was00:25:35
a war and then the horse Count Vita signs the00:25:38
treaty where the floor of Sakhalin is left behind.00:25:41
That is, even a lost war does not00:25:44
always mean a00:25:46
fatal ulcer;00:25:48
mortal losses for the losing country do00:25:52
not always mean a lost war00:25:55
means a change of government,00:25:56
only all the more extremely rarely. It means00:25:59
some kind of serious vital threat to the00:26:01
population of this country.00:26:04
Because it is far from all the00:26:07
warring parties, not all of them are00:26:09
Hitlerites,00:26:11
this is the point that Hitler is00:26:14
unique because he is like some kind of00:26:16
absolute evil because He00:26:18
also set the goal00:26:19
absolutely in relation to some nations,00:26:23
but such Madmen are rare, fortunately00:26:26
in history00:26:27
and no there is no reason to believe that00:26:29
the leaders of the modern Western world are,00:26:32
as it were, from this number,00:26:34
so that’s why before us Here is a certain00:26:37
attempt mother I’m still here the same concept of00:26:40
demonizing the enemy And extremely scaling00:26:42
oneself there are demons, our war is sacred,00:26:46
our goal is absolutely but again why is this being00:26:48
done Because that when I say something about00:26:50
absolutes, then again all sorts of00:26:52
relative small means are lost, since the fight00:26:55
against absolute evil means everything is possible, since00:26:57
the fight for absolute good, then00:27:00
again Well, what can you do? Yes, we must00:27:02
do this because otherwise it will be00:27:04
very bad00:27:06
Well and of course it’s impossible not to notice that the00:27:09
same00:27:12
80s00:27:14
made a whole suitcase of speeches with the00:27:17
opposite meaning when we lived in the fact00:27:20
that there can be no winner in a nuclear war,00:27:23
that nuclear weapons can’t be abolished,00:27:27
that there must be moral00:27:29
awareness among politicians who00:27:31
they master the atomic button and so on. That00:27:34
is, this is the rhetoric of the era before Tanta, and00:27:38
even more so perestroika, he was good at it,00:27:41
he reproduced it several times,00:27:44
but now you see he got sick differently. Yes,00:27:47
of course, it happens that a person00:27:49
changes his views over the years, maybe that’s what00:27:52
happened But this is again to the question of00:27:54
how without changing one thing. That is,00:27:58
he always wavered from the party line. That00:28:00
is, when Soviet Propaganda00:28:02
was so in words of peace-loving.00:28:04
Then the church leaders said the00:28:06
same thing when you read now,00:28:08
it feels like what Revolutionary is,00:28:13
they just talked a lot about the fact that00:28:16
the people have the right to revolt to fight00:28:18
imperialism, only everything was of course,00:28:30
and now accordingly. That is,00:28:33
what seemed to be the theology of the revolution was00:28:35
called the theology of the revolution00:28:37
of the October theology Red00:28:39
theology was in fact a forum00:28:42
opportunism the same00:28:44
Sergianism also today this the00:28:47
constant has not changed,00:28:51
just this kind of ability, or00:28:54
is it an internal mutation of a person who00:28:57
felt the taste of higher power00:29:00
and for the sake of expanding this power of his out of00:29:03
resentment from the fact that some part of the00:29:06
Ukrainian case is leaving at least00:29:09
his nominal control, and so on, and00:29:11
he from -for this I’m ready to talk about the00:29:13
destruction of the whole world, the destruction of00:29:15
Russia,00:29:16
but maybe these are internal mutations00:29:19
he has, I don’t know for a long time I haven’t talked to him00:29:21
about this, part of Ukrainian00:29:24
society is leaving power, there is no feeling that the00:29:27
party line has begun to waver somewhere00:29:31
in that direction because00:29:32
you can’t figure it out with your head without standing with anything else.00:29:35
Profit from the fact that Caesar will be00:29:38
pleased if the00:29:40
Ukrainian government introduces to the Rada00:29:42
a bill banning the UOC of the Moscow00:29:46
Patriarchate, which they shied away from00:29:47
until last year, but nevertheless as a00:29:50
ban on reality some but how to ban00:29:53
this reality is good activity00:29:56
what to deal with in Ukraine I am surprised00:30:01
here by only one thing Why did they delay this for so long back00:30:04
in 14 I spoke about the era of such still00:30:07
disguised proxy warriors when00:30:09
they said that polite people about ours00:30:11
are not there and so then they are not there, I say that00:30:13
as soon as the Russian table is needed, the00:30:15
first hub of the second Ukraine will be the00:30:17
end for the opc of the Moscow Patriarchate,00:30:20
and now frankly, without any hesitation,00:30:25
many Russian soldiers entered the land of00:30:28
Ukraine on February 24 of last year, and that’s00:30:33
what happened next for a whole year and they are still00:30:36
going on about this. Conversations about such00:30:39
clear measures of social hygiene were not00:30:43
surprising, some kind of Ukrainian atmosphere,00:30:48
and note that Russia bans00:30:51
religious organizations, simply,00:30:53
again, due to the fact that the center is located, the United States00:30:56
is00:31:02
almost invented by terrorists, so let’s say00:31:06
I’m in principle against the state, the00:31:09
relationship of religion. But when00:31:14
all sorts of Media start talking about this,00:31:19
you in your country would first play00:31:21
a role for people with real00:31:23
freedom of conscience, and then all over00:31:27
the world you would start not to intercede; the00:31:30
main question, of course, is what is happening in00:31:33
Ukrainian church life, why00:31:36
give I understand, maybe for Christ.00:31:38
But why create problems for yourself because of00:31:42
that dubious pleasure00:31:45
of being included in the pasta of Patriarch Kirill,00:31:51
it is not clear what is the reason for suffering for the sake of00:31:54
which people are persecuted not because they00:31:57
believe in Christ, not because they pray,00:31:59
so some people can become them troubles,00:32:02
then this is a very problem, very problematic00:32:04
because00:32:05
according to the Ukrainian behind the00:32:08
structure is dissipative,00:32:10
each church as a whole does not have the rights of a00:32:13
legal entity as a general corporation,00:32:16
but each parish is completely00:32:17
independently legal00:32:19
and at the university and any parish. Maybe, although00:32:21
we have established that they took that Moscow U00:32:24
we have a control center in our00:32:26
parish, we have a control center in Poltava and00:32:29
nothing more has been said, which is00:32:32
why a high-profile law will most likely be a00:32:35
PR campaign, but of course Ukraine is a country00:32:41
at war and therefore, of course,00:32:44
it is a mass of shell-shocked people.00:32:47
What is worth just the other day the admission that it00:32:51
turns out00:32:56
that banker He00:33:00
gave information to the SBU And the upcoming riddles of00:33:05
February 24 and at the same time00:33:11
the head of Ukrainian intelligence declares accordingly, of00:33:15
course you can’t help but marry what kind of00:33:18
people are you like? Yes, what can you do there00:33:21
without trial or investigation of a person, even there00:33:24
he is your ally, a client of someone who is00:33:25
moderated00:33:27
we are so therefore, there will00:33:31
certainly be incidents, but the question here is who00:33:35
brought this to his knees,00:33:38
but for now, for now, this is more of a kind of operation,00:33:43
but nevertheless, towards the final00:33:46
demarcation between the opc and the OC under the leadership of00:33:50
Dumenko, the epiphany of the Metropolitan, we are close to the00:33:55
Moscow Patriarchate, well, not even00:33:57
the patriarchy, here is the Russian churchliness It00:34:00
has a chance to maintain its influence on00:34:04
Orthodoxy in Ukraine after everything00:34:06
that happened because I see that in00:34:09
all countries there is a demarcation there,00:34:11
the Old Believers of the Belokrininsky consent00:34:13
also do not shy away from Moscow, they00:34:17
create their own ancient Orthodox00:34:18
Church and so on and so on And so00:34:20
on00:34:21
in Ultimately, what today is the00:34:26
basis of Orthodoxy in Ukraine is that the00:34:28
parties are not an observer as a person in the subject,00:34:31
but nevertheless located on the other00:34:35
side of the border of00:34:39
the worldview mentality at the turn of the00:34:42
millennium of simple Russia, Ukraine, it was00:34:45
customary to expect the end of the world and they were afraid that the00:34:47
quiet00:34:49
kingdom of total electronic control had come00:34:51
and so on, I then talk to him,00:34:53
the arguments were like this: Wait, be afraid00:34:55
if all this digital00:34:58
narcotic kingdom is contrary to00:35:01
God’s plan. It’s easy for the Lord to destroy all this,00:35:04
just send a meteorite Swarm00:35:07
towards the Earth from small piles of small00:35:09
meteorites, these meteorites will be knocked down by the00:35:12
orbital constellation of satellites sorbitol00:35:15
and we will find ourselves again maybe cellular00:35:18
communications without any surveillance and so on,00:35:21
but this has happened in history. Well, for example, we00:35:24
really like to talk about the Battle of Kulikovo, the00:35:27
door in Donskoy, and usually I forget00:35:30
to put a poll Why did this00:35:33
battle actually take place? Why did it end in00:35:35
victory and the answer will not be in the moral00:35:38
qualities of Dmitry Noskov and Russian00:35:40
warriors, but simply that the Great Plague came,00:35:44
this great plague swept through Europe and00:35:47
Asia and led to the death of the Great00:35:51
Silk Road, respectively, the00:35:55
cities in Central Asia00:35:57
that were the backbone of the00:36:00
Mongol Empire died out00:36:02
and therefore it disintegrated, the trade00:36:06
route disappeared, it disappeared, it is necessary to compress together00:36:07
the Horde plunged into infighting, and with00:36:10
this small piece of the Mongol00:36:12
Empire, the Golden Horde. This is a small00:36:14
piece against the backdrop of this huge empire,00:36:16
the largest in the history of mankind,00:36:17
perhaps00:36:19
where there was infighting, respectively, mother00:36:23
and against00:36:24
Tamtamysh, and therefore from this00:36:27
impostor who has very00:36:29
little power he succeeded to overcome00:36:31
on the Kulikovo field this is what that never is00:36:36
and it would seem that today the configuration is like this00:36:39
tomorrow What if something happens and00:36:42
it turns out that Russia has a00:36:44
common enemy, Ukraine, this happened many times, it’s00:36:45
true And when the Cossacks go here and there,00:36:49
they are together with the Tatars and Turks against00:36:51
Moscow then vice versa and so on, that’s00:36:54
why such turns are possible in00:36:56
the future, that’s why they never penetrate,00:37:00
as for the people, they won’t forget not to00:37:03
say goodbye. Well, fortunately, the Europeans were able to00:37:06
erase the traumatic experience of two00:37:08
world wars within the terrible European wars.00:37:11
And somehow today there is no particular hostility00:37:14
between the French and Germans and even00:37:16
the Belgian who00:37:17
passed back and forth through the passage yard,00:37:19
violating all the agreements, also seems to be not particularly00:37:22
offended today with his neighbors,00:37:25
so therefore I would not say that all this is00:37:27
definitely something that will last forever, yes, but the fact is that00:37:30
certainly the00:37:32
current generation of Ukrainian people00:37:34
will not to live in the Moscow Patriarchate is00:37:37
for sure, and the Cossacks, by the way, this morning I saw you00:37:40
a story from Stavropol from the local00:37:42
gymnasium named after00:37:44
Ermol General about what Izhevsk00:37:47
was prescribed for a student and the parents apparently00:37:49
saw it, such morals can00:37:53
take root or the modern world is not00:37:55
allowed because I just didn’t00:37:59
become there to register other subsequent00:38:02
details, the first father became a boy who has already00:38:05
stood up for this teacher, the00:38:09
second the parents of this entire school are demanding that00:38:11
we also love this officer. Let him00:38:13
continue to teach. The parent meeting of00:38:15
Stavropol also voted and started a00:38:17
petition that we are all fine for this,00:38:22
that is, it must be said that00:38:29
Minister Kravtsov is somehow becoming stronger, by the way, yesterday the Minister00:38:32
of Education is saying that people who returned00:38:34
from Ukraine and have gone through this school of life00:38:39
can now teach life safety with full right,00:38:42
you admit that everything that happened is that00:38:46
this is a plague that came to us00:38:47
because Putin did not dive into the00:38:51
Epiphany compartment 2022 And now I dived in and00:38:55
it will all go away, I00:38:58
suggest you take up such folk Orthodoxy00:39:01
because yesterday I saw a funny statistic.00:39:02
Every third Russian went00:39:06
to church this year, 36 percent00:39:09
and then there are many, many, many such things. The00:39:12
Epiphany tradition of shining the water is00:39:16
generally a00:39:17
canonical tradition or so00:39:20
they came up with a little bit00:39:23
no to distinguish between diving and just taking00:39:28
illuminated water from the temple Well, firstly,00:39:31
this is the deepest religious style of00:39:33
humanity, such is something00:39:37
sacred to consume to00:39:40
let in your World to take out of the altar00:39:43
That is, a certain distribution of illuminated00:39:45
Gifts But this is in any religion, that is we'll00:39:48
say there we take inside the Old Testament, a00:39:52
sacrifice is made, let's say while the00:39:55
calf is being sacrificed,00:39:57
well, the priest cut his breast in the00:40:01
temple in Jerusalem, a dedication and then00:40:04
the priest, let's say, is left with a cutting And00:40:08
everything else is taken by the donors and00:40:10
shared among themselves such a communal world00:40:12
is in the order of things, so that's why it a00:40:15
very deep religious instinct it00:40:18
is, it is justified and it should be noted that there is00:40:21
pandemonium in our churches. It is precisely00:40:22
when something consecrated can be carried away,00:40:25
illuminated honey, consecrated apples00:40:28
for Easter and now illuminated water,00:40:33
therefore,00:40:35
for the fact that practically nothing indicates anything00:40:40
if it were also to promote some kind of00:40:42
there is also no distribution of illuminated Hare Krishna food,00:40:44
either00:40:46
hundreds of thousands of people either went there and00:40:49
also went there. Year after year on TV,00:40:51
the number of this is absolutely wonderful,00:40:52
this is a very ancient tradition,00:40:55
this will bring joy to your home and so on, and let us00:40:57
remember, Lord, how00:40:59
Chumak just recently charged this water00:41:02
negatonic00:41:04
with the help of the same television and so00:41:06
on and the Soviet self-proclaimed mouth in the00:41:08
world I ate it calmly and was very00:41:10
happy,00:41:12
it comes to the point that at00:41:16
Epiphany all the sacred water cannot even be washed00:41:19
at night00:41:21
And this is some of our Theological problem The00:41:24
fact is that the truth is00:41:26
not00:41:28
today's day then on that day the decision00:41:32
was illuminated by the watery nature, but to00:41:36
understand this one must switch to the language of myth00:41:38
because in archaic ancient00:41:42
philosophies the world is a plexus of the four00:41:44
main elements water air fire Earth00:41:48
and respectively these elements, that is, the00:41:52
very00:41:53
meaning of the Ivangar plot is that the creator00:41:55
who created these elements, by the way, is the creator of the00:41:58
Parisian poet, the word elements is the same00:42:01
word as the verse, here the train lays down the verse,00:42:04
you understand exactly. Very beautiful. Very00:42:06
accurately, and now the creator enters00:42:09
his damaged creation00:42:11
to reassemble it again. Here’s how to00:42:15
clean it, filter it, rebuild it,00:42:17
clean it. Let’s say there was a time when a00:42:19
mechanic was rebuilding the engine to00:42:21
clean all the injectors there and so on,00:42:23
clean the carburetor This is what00:42:26
Christ does, he at the Transfiguration transforms00:42:28
the light the holiday of transfiguration, burying let's00:42:31
say the earth transforms water crucifying00:42:34
in the air illuminates the airy nature And00:42:38
plunging into the rivers of the Jordan illuminates the00:42:40
aquatic nature00:42:42
water in the archaic consciousness in the language of00:42:45
myths is a synonym for death00:42:48
You can’t breathe in water, water00:42:51
dissolves everything, erases mountains, and so on. That’s00:42:55
why the00:42:57
immersion of Christ in water is a00:43:00
prototype of the world of death and the exodus00:43:03
from there, that is, now death is not scary for us,00:43:05
this is all connected with the Easter00:43:07
theme of Christianity, but all this00:43:10
was too difficult to explain people00:43:12
Therefore, in the end, you see Orskaya is degrading,00:43:14
just00:43:16
buy a candle, leave a pretty penny and some00:43:19
holy water will be good to come out,00:43:22
why illuminate it if it has already been00:43:25
illuminated by Christ, this Theological00:43:27
question remains unclear Why baptize00:43:31
children if the parents are already baptized, which means00:43:33
natural sin is already affecting this00:43:34
I stopped,00:43:35
there are such serious preparation00:43:37
questions, and have you noticed any00:43:40
significant transformations in the00:43:43
People’s Orthodoxy of the period since you00:43:46
noticed any,00:43:48
but it hasn’t really revealed itself as the current reality?00:43:55
I now have very little communication with00:44:00
this contingent, so00:44:04
you can only judge this on the Internet on00:44:06
TV, partly at the00:44:08
ritual level, hardly at the level of mass00:44:11
sentiment. Yes, of course the people want to fight,00:44:13
thirst for Victory,00:44:16
it’s true00:44:19
today I watched the Epiphany00:44:24
commentary myself, I understand it is filtered and so00:44:27
on, but still their abundance of sincerity does not00:44:30
raise any doubts,00:44:33
it will strengthen this desire for the presence of00:44:36
the patriarch at the so-called00:44:38
Christmas meetings that the day before00:44:41
If you saw the announcement, Vyacheslav00:44:43
Volodin was called to church, apparently there will be a00:44:46
dialogue00:44:48
directly from the podium of the State Duma, you00:44:51
will have to speak or in the sidelines of00:44:53
some offices No, do this Every00:44:55
year, deputies who mean nothing to the event00:44:58
usually ignore it That is, this is a00:45:01
day off for at home That's when they What00:45:04
is called simply presents their hall00:45:05
interior,00:45:07
you will see a lot of people wearing white hats,00:45:12
participants in Christmas readings00:45:15
who will convince that we must00:45:17
save Russia00:45:21
according to the format, this has been going on for 20 25 years already,00:45:25
but the format in which the president celebrated00:45:28
Christmas alone seems00:45:31
somewhat new then there has never00:45:34
been anything like this before, he usually either stood there with00:45:37
Sobyanin for the time being with his wife And00:45:40
now the loneliness of you00:45:42
somehow resonated in your heart in a00:45:45
special way, or does it stand and stand for00:45:50
only one thing: that it was a staged00:45:53
recording,00:45:55
that is, it was filmed somewhere in advance00:45:59
and then it was pasted into the broadcast,00:46:06
I can’t00:46:08
diary this, I don’t know anymore00:46:11
now Andrey, I can’t help but00:46:13
translate this conversation into some serious plane,00:46:15
you’re the only one who mentioned it at the edge, but00:46:19
nevertheless, I saw that you paid00:46:21
attention to a00:46:25
number of photographs that after00:46:28
after they began to dismantle the rubble of this00:46:31
house, they published this yellow kitchen, this is a00:46:34
girl who00:46:37
published a video on Facebook extinguishing candles there for00:46:42
birthdays.00:46:46
Here you are writing in your home in connection with the death of00:46:50
dozens of people in the Dnieper,00:46:53
they wanted another rushing roll with a teardrop00:46:56
of a child or beaten to death by bots I I would00:46:59
like to hear your answer to this00:47:01
question, Russian culture is filled with these00:47:05
gestures, as you know, gestures, death rockets,00:47:15
that is, this is the attitude that we are00:47:18
always right.00:47:20
This is very sad, that00:47:23
part of Russian culture that came00:47:27
through Chadayev, partly Dostoevsky through00:47:29
Tolstoy, first of all, of course, it clogged with00:47:32
boots, clogged with nightingales, and so on00:47:35
That is, the manifestation of elementary empathy00:47:37
like Valuev, by the way, is considered a00:47:40
betrayal, the manifestation of windy00:47:43
sympathy is00:47:44
sadly00:47:49
somewhat private Try to Remind00:47:53
once in the 90th year in the 90th September of the00:47:57
ninetieth year00:47:59
one of my first experiences As a00:48:02
speechwriter's work in Alexey's patterns00:48:04
they will compose speeches for the creation of the00:48:08
Supreme USSR00:48:09
on the topic of the perceived law of Saturday of00:48:11
conscience, a new one, I inserted the idea00:48:15
that00:48:16
all people have a conscience; freedom of00:48:19
conscience is also always there under any00:48:20
regime.00:48:22
And the question of the social level on00:48:25
the public goes away when the00:48:27
consequences of an00:48:29
act of conscience for this a person,00:48:32
society and the state take revenge on him for this00:48:35
or support him, there is a certain general00:48:39
law, not one good deed goes00:48:41
unpunished, we all know this, especially00:48:44
love, the00:48:46
question is that society can00:48:48
soften its own morals and00:48:51
extinguish these possible00:48:54
consequences, yes Or maybe, on the contrary,00:48:57
to strengthen the00:48:59
administrative police’s arguments The trump card in the00:49:01
hands of those who are00:49:02
engaged in this00:49:05
preaches hatred of investment and so00:49:08
on, it humiliates someone,00:49:09
this is the problem, and today it is00:49:12
undoubtedly that this is the part of Russian00:49:15
culture that is faithful to cry for the little00:49:19
man These are the ones00:49:24
this part of culture She is00:49:27
rejected today Because when she wants a gun, you00:49:31
can be silent00:49:34
and then maybe something will change, I00:49:37
hope that this is not forever00:49:39
and we will again feel sorry for Mumu, a00:49:44
small branch in this00:49:46
conversation is a compromise with conscience, it makes00:49:49
you completely unscrupulous because00:49:51
that, by and large, you are conducting00:49:53
this dialogue with yourself, but here you are telling00:49:56
yourself this is the situation that has developed00:49:58
here, you need to hold the end here and keep00:50:01
silent But this is dishonesty in its00:50:05
purest form Yes, in my personal00:50:08
understanding of what it is This is a general00:50:10
absence of this kind dialogue So is it00:50:12
better the absence of this dialogue or00:50:15
small compromises somewhere you say to yourself00:50:18
Well, I’ll give up a little,00:50:21
I’ll find some other way,00:50:24
is there such a clear one or is it somehow pointless00:50:29
No, well, with my conscience everything is more complicated,00:50:32
first of all,00:50:35
my conscience This is my thing wherever I want, there00:50:38
and I put00:50:40
people are very good at coming to terms with00:50:42
their conscience,00:50:44
so let’s say the monastic tradition has00:50:47
such a wonderful Maxim00:50:49
when one Saint said I don’t know any00:50:51
other downfall for a monk except to00:50:53
trust the voice of his conscience00:50:57
That is, the apostle has the expression of00:51:00
people with a burned conscience.00:51:02
And then Well, it is known that under00:51:05
any conditions00:51:07
a person needs crutches to walk, but with a00:51:09
certain form of destruction of the body,00:51:11
disability, that is, also with a00:51:13
certain form of mental disability,00:51:15
external castolettes are needed, called a canon, a00:51:17
canon, a stick, literally00:51:21
a stick on which you can lean, which00:51:24
externally limits you, it allows you to00:51:26
move in the right direction00:51:29
and only somewhere at the top,00:51:32
another understanding already appears00:51:35
to become a saint and do what you want, the00:51:40
highest purpose of a teacher leader is00:51:43
to make yourself, it is not necessary00:51:45
for a person to already learn00:51:48
to distinguish between good and evil, and in00:51:50
24/7 mode in everyday life,00:51:54
this always requires some kind of work00:51:57
on proper nutrition of your conscience,00:52:00
in particular, such a technical measure,00:52:03
of course, for this you need to00:52:04
read books correctly00:52:07
Well, and then watch the telegram channel00:52:09
correctly00:52:13
And at least sometimes intercede for someone,00:52:18
flowers to the monument is a conscientious00:52:20
gesture Because here in the same00:52:22
telegram -channels and YouTube channels, a00:52:24
discussion broke out about the fact that, well,00:52:26
dedicating a flashlight there in a turning corner and00:52:29
bringing flowers to the monument is the same thing,00:52:32
but why not dedicate it to flashlights in the00:52:35
gateway? Why Do00:52:41
n’t I condemn? Andrey Desnitsky said best on the topic:00:52:44
those who left Russia, what is00:52:52
it? flowers are good00:52:57
Go to Moscow00:52:59
Let's Repeat this or do something even00:53:02
better, something even more serious, but rather than00:53:05
condemn those who live there in Moscow00:53:07
do this, but you come from your people there, the00:53:10
accent is these bouquets, they are indignant at00:53:15
that Oh, how little you understand them00:53:18
with Andrey a little at the end of this00:53:21
conversation, such private stories, I saw00:53:25
you that you mentioned in connection with the death of00:53:28
Mikhail Churikova that in00:53:30
your youth you had a chance to visit her00:53:34
house, can you tell your memories00:53:37
about this time in general to this actress?00:53:41
No, I was a teenager, I was more00:53:43
interested in her daughter than Inna00:53:46
Churikova herself, that’s why00:53:49
a lot. By the way, I’m a stupid lustful00:53:53
calf. Yes, today I understand that00:53:56
otherwise00:53:57
Akhedzhakova are these two amazingly00:54:01
beautiful ugly women of Soviet00:54:03
cinema00:54:04
who are beautiful precisely because of the unusualness of their00:54:07
faces, and so on, in addition to all other00:54:09
character, and so on And then it00:54:12
seemed if against the backdrop of some other00:54:14
cinematic ones00:54:18
and I honestly was still such an00:54:24
actress then, even then00:54:30
they are not there, I wasn’t with her at all, but00:54:33
this is a boy,00:54:39
so there’s just00:54:43
nothing. I didn’t start adding anything to the portrait myself.00:54:46
I can yes00:54:49
Okay innovative innovative censer00:54:53
was developed in the Novosibirsk00:54:55
Akademgorodok does not lose let’s00:54:59
say00:55:01
the use of such tools is00:55:05
pathos or something It’s funny the modern00:55:08
world Modern technologies come to the00:55:11
service of Orthodoxy00:55:12
saw this news it made you laugh00:55:15
pleased made00:55:17
you laugh Of course I think the00:55:21
engineers are unlikely to have a government order00:55:32
yet the plot It seems to me that from the ethical00:55:35
side it can be sorted out.00:55:40
But it was innovative and they were proud,00:55:43
they talked a lot before an innovative00:55:45
lamp for transportation was developed.00:55:50
This is what comrades00:55:53
Kunin, the head of Russian Railways, was very proud of at one time. Yes, here is00:55:56
some kind of cunning lamp with an eternal00:55:58
flame. And the main thing is that without a threat to00:56:01
opinions on the plane,00:56:02
so sometimes we work in this direction00:56:05
because the social order comes00:56:07
and fulfills something Soviet science00:56:11
cemetery plot engineer Bula00:56:14
French cemetery Russian cemetery and00:56:17
now alarmist sentiments suddenly00:56:19
arose in a number of telegrams How is it possible for00:56:22
Russian culture without feeding the Russian00:56:25
power of the Russians The French don’t want money and00:56:28
in fact the graves there will be desolate,00:56:30
you can provide your information on this matter to our00:56:35
audience, that nothing will00:56:37
come, that everything will be fine, Everyone there00:56:40
will be well-groomed in the end,00:56:45
this is an ordinary propaganda company00:56:49
showing, let’s say that the cemetery in00:56:53
which we will be buried there, you00:56:55
see Now his grave is directly00:56:56
threatened by everything, and in fact there are 15,000 burials there.00:57:01
Naturally, burial in any00:57:04
cemetery is different; one thing is somewhere,00:57:06
I read graves that have a name00:57:10
that have been preserved for generations; there are those that have00:57:13
no eternal memory left on earth; it00:57:15
didn’t work out;00:57:19
this is a common story00:57:22
even cases00:57:24
in France They have their own laws that for a certain00:57:28
number of years if you00:57:30
don’t take care of the grave there is no payment there,00:57:33
let’s say a payment to the local gardener then00:57:36
you think that a new burial is possible there before00:57:39
storage; the00:57:42
usual laws I think that in Russia they00:57:44
have00:57:46
50 some kind of rights actually this the land is00:57:49
lost from the family, especially if it does00:57:51
n’t confirm them.00:57:53
So the usual story is nothing00:57:56
Russophobic there, the municipality just00:57:58
refused when A few ago,00:58:00
Russia just said let’s do this memorial00:58:01
cemetery, let’s take care of its00:58:04
part, take care of its preservation then00:58:07
France agreed00:58:09
from the service Well, that after this, too, we will00:58:13
talk about this at our own expense out of only 1500:58:16
thousand from 22 graves whose leases have expired00:58:20
2215 thousand I think that the00:58:24
city municipality will find these kopecks, he has already00:58:26
announced this So there is no reason to00:58:29
make a fuss here about the00:58:31
question to talk about how is it that00:58:34
suddenly Russia has become so many men who00:58:39
don’t shake hands that even for a good deed,00:58:42
people refuse to take a small amount of money00:58:46
for the sake of the Russian good? It00:58:49
seems to me that life I think we are talking about this00:58:52
and there is a lot more to be said about this for a long time,00:58:54
how did we get to this point? life00:58:56
is like that And we have so much time,00:58:59
unfortunately, another plot is not even a plot00:59:03
Yes,00:59:05
Josef Rasenger Papa Bendik left 16 The00:59:07
Western world said goodbye to Papa in retirement00:59:10
Papa is now left alone That is, he does not00:59:12
write music albums but washes the00:59:15
feet of the homeless,00:59:18
but in short, yes in the regime such a00:59:22
digest, according to the feeling, the world of Western00:59:25
Christianity turned out to be cleaner and healthier than the00:59:30
world of orthodoxy today, or this00:59:33
kind of generalization will be too rough and00:59:35
orthodoxy today is different,00:59:38
you can answer that the world of the Vatican00:59:43
turned out to be more professional than the world of St.00:59:46
Danilov Monastery Well, it’s quite00:59:47
obvious That is, I cannot compare00:59:51
degree of grace or ethics and00:59:54
so on Well, at least the way, let’s00:59:59
say the01:00:03
very presentation of01:00:05
PR, let’s say then it’s definitely the Vatican01:00:09
much higher, they clearly understand What a01:00:12
church can be like in the 21st century, a church with a01:00:15
huge and sad imperialist01:00:17
past with a lot of negative01:00:20
baggage and historical partly01:00:22
modern and in this sense, Catholics01:00:26
know how, if necessary, to identify themselves and01:00:31
Christ of one01:00:32
or another of their figures, and01:00:36
Pope Benedict also knows how to Christ. He knew how to01:00:39
pronounce the words Repentance of01:00:40
corporate repentance.01:00:42
But we can’t do this; we have a01:00:46
bag of love on earth’s heads. As01:00:51
they say among Catholics They are01:00:53
every squeak, this is the01:00:56
difference of course. That is, we are01:00:59
just bad people who don’t even01:01:02
know how to be hypocrites, that is, let’s say at least01:01:06
the scandal of 12, it’s01:01:10
so difficult to say in words that01:01:14
we are against punishment,01:01:31
in this sense,01:01:33
I can’t evaluate what’s inside that of Pope01:01:37
Francis or his cardinals Yes,01:01:38
how deep is there from the feelings of01:01:40
suffering Francis probably has it,01:01:43
moreover, when the French one must01:01:46
remember that he had a traumatic01:01:49
experience of betrayal01:01:50
when he betrayed his subordinate01:01:53
monks, the appropriate general01:01:57
essentially agreed to the execution,01:02:00
he himself talked about it very much01:02:03
painfully remained01:02:05
silent did not intercede, and so on. So I01:02:09
think that there is such01:02:10
a burn that does01:02:14
not allow him to take seriously the01:02:17
doxology that he is in his position01:02:19
to hear his address, the01:02:21
last question will take a long time to01:02:24
formulate during the conversation, now01:02:27
this thought has arisen about the movie,01:02:29
I asked you there is such a frequent plot here A01:02:31
man disappeared there due to one or01:02:34
another circumstance, everyone accepted that he01:02:36
disappeared and died. Here is an empty grave, people01:02:38
come to an empty grave, bring flowers,01:02:41
and here arose in recent years in the field of01:02:46
public discussion. And in reality and in01:02:49
life, such an abbreviation is an abbreviation01:02:51
like PMC01:02:52
And today I see the news on tapes01:02:56
[music]01:02:57
empty coffins come for funerals with those01:03:01
killed from Ukraine, gives01:03:04
pacifiers to people, in Russian Orthodoxy, in01:03:09
my opinion, there is no tradition of burying01:03:12
deceptions like this.01:03:14
Why not? There is such a01:03:17
grave for an unknown soldier And01:03:21
there are many memorial monuments under01:03:23
which there is no real storage there is01:03:24
a pyramid with with an asterisk then01:03:27
put together a soldier or a grieving mother and01:03:31
people really come01:03:34
flowers if there are any01:03:38
Agree that the memorial to the Unknown01:03:40
Soldier is not a completely Christian01:03:43
memorial nevertheless, that is,01:03:46
the state01:03:49
But why not Christian And what01:03:51
contradicts Christianity here, we have01:03:54
such a grave at the university in the01:03:56
Peter and Paul Cathedral in St. Petersburg01:03:58
when the formal church denies that01:04:00
this is the last Russian Tsar lies and01:04:03
just at the funeral service burial in the01:04:06
presence of Yeltsin until there01:04:08
Accordingly, the Lord has peace everywhere01:04:10
lying and at the same time not hatred they01:04:13
were called but01:04:16
someone thinks that this is the royal family of01:04:18
someone that no Well, such a symbolic01:04:20
burial01:04:22
and still, as it were, the church is01:04:24
just like not to bring up there were hints of the01:04:26
metropolitan country quietly that it’s still01:04:28
time to recognize something as the real remains01:04:30
it was back in the era of Doc, look, but wait, it’s01:04:34
somehow a trick public attention has01:04:36
greatly moved away from this matter.01:04:38
So no, for the Christian edge of01:04:41
consciousness, the fate of the dead flesh is not as important01:04:44
as prayer is important. Therefore, if this01:04:49
can be the focus where a person’s personal prayer will awaken,01:04:51
even if it’s an empty01:04:52
grave, so be it. I promised that this01:04:56
question would be the last, but I am now01:04:58
continued it a little As soon as the PMCs started01:05:00
talking and this is the thought you01:05:04
just brought me to, after all, a pardon and for01:05:07
Consent to aggravate your guilt, that is, to01:05:09
go kill for your homeland, if you01:05:13
figure out the dogmatic ones, you are sitting in01:05:16
hard labor Yes, you have a set of01:05:18
articles there, you stole there, you used drugs01:05:20
traded there, maybe you beat your wife, then you01:05:23
did another fifth out of ten bad things and they01:05:27
tell you01:05:28
to go and everything will be redeemed, redeemed. So on01:05:32
such a formal plane in the plane of01:05:34
state life You agree and01:05:37
go And then you are free and go and01:05:42
Bogoslovsky Here you are in this sense With01:05:45
what kind of soul you leave when you were sitting then01:05:48
killed and then the mercy came back to you01:05:51
walk Vasya in the ancient church of such people01:05:54
if they were Christians they01:05:57
would definitely celebrate this is a01:05:59
person who could avoid the war and01:06:02
voluntarily went to01:06:04
kill Yes, somehow this is poorly connected with the gospel01:06:07
on the other hand Yes Of course,01:06:10
you can remember01:06:13
this mobilization by zones during the Great01:06:16
Patriotic War, when it was,01:06:19
we have to constantly compare,01:06:21
they impose this on the special operations of the01:06:23
Great Patriotic War, and here there is a contradiction.01:06:25
If you even consider war to refuse, then01:06:27
who has the right to compare the tour of the01:06:29
holy war, the network to the sacred,01:06:31
maybe yes, the Great Patriotic War with what01:06:33
you are doing today, but anyway, by the way, let me01:06:36
remind you, it has nothing to do with the result of01:06:39
those mobilizations of prisoners were the01:06:42
subsequent so-called in the gulag01:06:45
when thieves in law they considered01:06:49
traitors those who went to the front01:06:56
because their enemy laws01:06:58
assumed that you cannot01:07:00
cooperate with the authorities in anything01:07:03
even like this, when we are talking about such a stinking01:07:06
Great Patriotic War, but this is their01:07:08
problem, it has nothing to do if01:07:11
this decision was not inspired by01:07:14
the gospel01:07:15
and is completely outside the brackets. I promised01:07:18
the last. It was the penultimate one. You01:07:20
said about mobilizations by zone and I01:07:22
remembered the TV series Shtrafbat where the role of01:07:25
the priest was played by Dmitry Nazarov, People's Artist, who has now been retired from the Moscow Art Theater, and01:07:30
this film was shot by01:07:31
Nikolai, who left so far this week, I01:07:36
know that before steel was also somehow present in your life, it01:07:42
all came together, you will agree, and the doctor01:07:46
and Nazarov left two departures Yes one01:07:51
functional care other final care01:07:55
Both are sad, but if01:07:58
Nazarov’s first departure is sad, it’s not for a01:08:01
person, he’s practically01:08:05
I think that he himself is becoming more deeply01:08:08
interesting than his future role at home, they01:08:11
will be maybe only roles They01:08:14
will be more interesting01:08:16
I hope that Great great01:08:19
human professional future01:08:21
But as for01:08:23
his former employer, yes,01:08:27
on this occasion, the network sarcastically remarked that01:08:31
he played a prisoner of the Khabensky concentration camp, but01:08:34
in fact turned out to be banal Kapu01:08:38
Father Andrey I thank you for this01:08:40
conversation Take care of yourself and be healthy01:08:43
thank you All the best01:08:46
[music]01:08:51
dear friends the guest of inhalation-exhalation01:08:53
today was father Andrey Kuraev Exactly01:08:55
now If you haven’t done this for some01:08:57
reason, urgently subscribe to01:09:00
our channel Like this broadcast,01:09:02
subscribe to my telegram to communicate01:09:04
via Direct and share your01:09:07
thoughts on what you heard, I01:09:10
say goodbye Stas Kryuchkov with you Take care01:09:12
and good luck01:09:14
[music]Description:
Стоит ли приходить в нынешнюю церковь. Раскол в церкви. Реализуема ли инициатива правительства Украины о полном запрете УПЦ (МП)? Стала ли Православная церковь Украины @church-ua @duh_propovedy полном смысле самостоятельной? Нависла ли угроза над старообрядцами? Крещенская и рождественские проповеди Патриарха Кирилла, ночные купания Владимира Путина. Генерал Герасимов запретил бороды в зоне СВО. Разделяет ли Дмитрий Медведев традицию юродивых на Руси? Дмитрий Назаров уволен из МХТ @mxatchekhova Умер Николай Досталь, режиссер сериала «Раскол» и фильма «Штрафбат», роль попа в котором сыграл Дмитрий Назаров. Уход Инны Чуриковой. Крещенские традиции. Что такое совесть? Поможет ли патриархии инновационное кадило? Прощены ли наемники ЧВК в в вечности? Удар по Днепру. Цветы к памятникам в память о жертвах удара по Днепру. Кто будет ухаживать за русскими могилами? Западное христианство после ухода папы на покое Бенедикта XVI @VaticanNews В пятницу 20 января на в 17-00 на канале @khodorkovskylive 00:00 Начало. Гость — Андрей Кураев 01:01 Правда у каждого своя? История об исцелении 06:36 Фреска с губернатором — нормально или нет? 12:28 Об ответсвенности за собственное здравомыслие 18:13 О кинематографе и религии 20:18 О воинственной крещенской проповеди патриарха Кирилла 29:22 О судьбе УПЦ и религиозной жизни в Украине 33:43 Что сейчас база православия в Украине? 37:39 «Скрепность крепчает». Телесные наказания в школах 38:30 Зачем святить воду? Откуда пошла эта традиция 43:38 Как война повлияла на «народное» православие? 45:25 Почему Путин встретил Рождество наедине с самим собой? 46:11 В каком состоянии сейчас русская культура? 49:44 О компромиссах с совестью 53:18 Воспоминания о встречах с Чуриковой 54:49 Для РПЦ разработали инновационное кадило 56:11 Французы не хотят русских денег. Кладбище в Сент-Женевьев-де-Буа 58:58 О западном христианстве 01:02:22 Хоронить пустые гробы — по-христиански? 1:04:52 О «помиловании» через убийства 1:07:19 О Назарове, Хабенском и Достале 1:08:51 Конец ============================= Телеграм-канал Станислава Крючкова https://t.me/photoplenka ============================= Писатель Михаил ВЕЛЛЕР в программе «ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ»: Путин как пустота и что ждет впереди? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BeZioFR2b0s ============================= Писатель Дмитрий БЫКОВ в программе «НАВИГАТОР»: Цветы у памятника Леси, Кучера у Дудя, Арестович, Чурикова и Кикабидзе https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ap_aM08aRPg ============================= Историк и социолог Борис КАГАРЛИЦКИЙ в программе «ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ» ============================= Драматург Иван ВЫРЫПАЕВ в программе «ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ» https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1fnU39HXUKU ============================= Группа «БЕЛАЯ ГВАРДИЯ» и ЗОЯ ЯЩЕНКО в программе «ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ» https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KBWk6lfZfYU ============================= Писатель Станислав БЕЛКОВСКИЙ в программе «ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ» https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PsyJ7JmfHwA ============================= Адвокат Илья НОВИКОВ в программе «ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ» https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OzumJcxSdu8 ============================= Музыкант Константин АРБЕНИН в программе «ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ» https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7_143oZVFMw ============================= Блог Михаила Ходорковского: https://www.youtube.com/user/khodorkovskyru ============================ Плейлисты: ► Блог Ходорковского: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G7kI1pJUZbs&list=PLUpN6Si0hGl4Grv-wza2qAaE322NcoK0c ► Ответы на вопросы: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=asGc56bUvs8&list=PLUpN6Si0hGl7VIGZSi0O6vmqGTNKnqb9Y ► Интервью с Ходорковским: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLUpN6Si0hGl6NhQa9nhFk3E6bwAgml7yM ► Правозащита: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h4WjEvgt0tg&list=PLUpN6Si0hGl7aRDjrl1vICk3jXAjFtNtG Социальные сети: ► Twitter: http://bit.ly/MBK-Twitter ► Instagram: https://www.facebook.com/unsupportedbrowser ► Telegram: https://t.me/khodorkovski ► Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/unsupportedbrowser ► ВКонтакте: http://bit.ly/MBK-VKontakte =============================
Preparing download options
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players
Questions about downloading video
How can I download "Андрей КУРАЕВ: Поезжайте в Москву с цветами / ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ" video?
http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.
Which format of "Андрей КУРАЕВ: Поезжайте в Москву с цветами / ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ" video should I choose?
The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.
Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Андрей КУРАЕВ: Поезжайте в Москву с цветами / ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ" video?
The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.
How can I download "Андрей КУРАЕВ: Поезжайте в Москву с цветами / ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ" video to my phone?
You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.
How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Андрей КУРАЕВ: Поезжайте в Москву с цветами / ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ"?
The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.
How can I save a frame from a video "Андрей КУРАЕВ: Поезжайте в Москву с цветами / ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ"?
This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.
What's the price of all this stuff?
It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.