Download "Почему военная помощь США — не то, что надо. ФБК и мэр Орска. Плющев. Дунцова | Пастухов, Еловский"
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FMyJ7IgDTFWM%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
Please wait. We're preparing links for easy ad-free video watching and downloading.
Table of contents
Similar videos from our catalog
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FEvNruHSQ2bQ%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FHmtAAfRrwL0%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FhGG897AcfeQ%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252Fi0ee76QOrQU%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252Fj0oi6ifAb9o%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252Foa9MblUM-jk%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252Fz7UnbmrWNhE%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FzaJMsFW0rsQ%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252F25JotH9lOew%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FhlZc6c7mbWA%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
Video tags
Subtitles
Russian
00:00:04
[music]00:00:09
Good afternoon, purely concrete politics00:00:12
comes out this week on Sunday as00:00:14
usual My name is Dmitry Yalovsky I00:00:17
welcome our viewers and listeners00:00:20
to the Khodorkovsky Live channel Well, as00:00:23
usual, we will understand the intricacies of00:00:25
the world00:00:27
behind the scenes processes together with00:00:30
Vladimir Pastukhov Vladimir Borisovich00:00:32
Greetings Hello Dmitry00:00:35
Vladimir Borisovich, I’ll start with a little00:00:39
story about our internal kitchen.00:00:42
In fact, the day before we discussed with the designers the00:00:45
cover for our00:00:47
today’s issue, I asked them,00:00:50
so besides you and me, there to00:00:53
depict Biden Macron and Scholz00:00:56
who00:00:57
doubt it was somewhere during the day, which means00:01:00
the designer the cover was provided to us, everything00:01:02
is good, it means I liked it,00:01:05
events happen in the evening after which00:01:08
I write again to the designers, colleagues, the situation00:01:11
has changed, we need self-confident people,00:01:14
which means Biden and and and European00:01:19
world leaders, but what happened is what everyone00:01:22
so many were waiting for on Saturday evening, the00:01:26
Americans accepted the package assistance for 6100:01:29
billion until several months later they could not00:01:31
sign it Well, it seems that now everything00:01:35
has been agreed upon, there will be several00:01:37
bureaucratic procedures,00:01:39
after which, in an amicable way, as I understand it,00:01:41
this week the tranche will already go to the00:01:45
needs of Ukraine and, as far as I understand, the00:01:48
Pentagon already has everything ready, the00:01:50
American military is expecting from Mashka Well,00:01:52
in fact, it will continue to help00:01:55
Ukraine. This hasn’t happened since about the end of00:01:59
last year.00:02:01
Help us assess the importance of this moment,00:02:03
how much it can now make00:02:06
some changes in the course of the war,00:02:09
because over the past few weeks the situation has00:02:11
been, if not stalemate, then critical and00:02:14
more and more often we heard the alarming word00:02:16
combination front00:02:19
poses Well, if I were you, probably00:02:22
guys, I wouldn’t00:02:23
waste money, I would leave the original00:02:26
cover face00:02:30
for nothing to spoil the paper,00:02:33
you know, because in my00:02:35
opinion, this is the doubt, it00:02:38
remained as it was And I would00:02:42
still be there behind I would just add a00:02:46
photo of Trump, absolutely00:02:48
pleased with himself, and he has a thumbs up like,00:02:51
well, let him live for a while. Well, then this00:02:54
cover would be completely consistent with the00:02:57
situation we are in, that is,00:03:01
Biden is still doubtful and Trump00:03:04
with a thumbs up, like, we’re not00:03:06
finishing off Yeah but this is relatively00:03:11
good news, that is, in any case,00:03:12
that is, this relatively good news is00:03:14
that radical brutal00:03:18
and very difficult decisions are postponed,00:03:20
let’s say, for several months.00:03:23
And yet, in absolute terms,00:03:28
this is nothing. Decisive news00:03:32
because help has been given in00:03:35
format in00:03:38
volumes of mechanics such that it is absolutely00:03:42
insufficient not only for00:03:45
Ukraine’s military victory in this war, but also in00:03:48
order to provide stable and00:03:51
long-term resistance to Russia under the00:03:53
existing circumstances. That is, I00:03:57
would say such a supporting00:03:59
dropper00:04:01
is the whole problem, that is, I’m already in00:04:03
the morning there, well, active users00:04:07
wrote00:04:08
comments Well, you said that there would be00:04:10
no help. Isn’t it time to apologize? Well,00:04:13
how come we have people who are00:04:15
direct here, two points? I never00:04:19
said that there would be no help, I always00:04:21
said00:04:23
that help is late and that it will not be00:04:27
provided in the00:04:30
VM And that it will only be provided in a00:04:34
situation when it becomes extremely00:04:39
critical, so I should apologize here Not00:04:42
for anything, what I predicted, what00:04:44
happened, that is, the very fact that this00:04:47
help has now been given This is rather a00:04:49
frightening fact for me Unfortunately, a frightening fact00:04:53
that is a whistle Tom for now those fux Groups00:04:56
in Washington who mebo00:04:59
[music]00:05:00
for from Ukraine and on the Blood of00:05:03
Ukraine, there was a feeling that the situation was00:05:06
really critical and it’s00:05:09
dangerous to continue playing this game, why is it dangerous00:05:13
because in fact Ukraine has become,00:05:16
well, some kind of bargaining chip in the00:05:20
election campaign and in this00:05:24
electoral trump,00:05:29
trying to make the00:05:31
situation for Biden The worse the better00:05:35
for Trump and the worse for Biden If,00:05:38
as it were, the crisis in Ukraine00:05:41
is not resolved by Biden and Trump00:05:45
played this game and approximately apparently Well,00:05:50
within two weeks he began to receive00:05:52
signals of what could happen it is exactly00:05:55
the opposite that he can take one00:05:57
extra card from the deck and the front can00:06:01
crumble and00:06:02
then Trump will not win but lose.00:06:05
Why Because Biden will say that00:06:08
look, we lost Ukraine because of someone00:06:10
because of Trump, that is, we, we had a00:06:14
strategy, it couldn’t be said that00:06:18
she was someone will check we were ready for anything00:06:21
our guns would be00:06:25
Dawn tram00:06:28
more than once the sun it collapsed the front broke through00:06:32
who is responsible Trump and the00:06:34
Republicans00:06:36
To avoid a similar situation00:06:38
about a week ago Trump gives00:06:41
the go-ahead which by the way for me shows00:06:43
that after all the Republican Party they are00:06:46
quite powerfully controlled and the position of the00:06:50
Republicans is warming up and00:06:53
they are carrying out this aid package which00:06:59
is carrying out the aid package. I think that you and I00:07:02
will look at it later, which in fact turns00:07:04
out to be00:07:07
minimalist like00:07:10
this00:07:12
Arvo, well, it seems like there is00:07:14
no help, it seems as if there is it00:07:23
I have an anxious expectation, that00:07:27
is, in essence, Further in moss performances00:07:30
from 3-4 months to six months00:07:34
and00:07:35
life on a00:07:39
diet and beyond We find ourselves in the same00:07:43
situation Let's really00:07:45
look at this package in more detail before that I will address00:07:48
our viewers, friends, do not forget00:07:50
to like I suggest doing this at the00:07:52
moment when you are interested or you00:07:54
like some idea question judgment00:07:57
Well, check if you are subscribed to Narvsky,00:07:59
we have a lot of useful and interesting things Well, of00:08:01
course, we also read all the comments, Honestly, a00:08:04
package of 60 billion,00:08:08
as far as I understand, somewhere half of00:08:10
it is00:08:13
replenishment of the Arsenal that00:08:16
was spent directly by the00:08:17
Americans, plus expenses for their00:08:21
activities in Europe, including NATO,00:08:25
small fragments segments Yes, this00:08:28
pie is going So to help Israel for00:08:32
humanitarian purposes, don’t look00:08:35
Dmitry Yes, the packages are divided there Why00:08:39
Because As far as I understand, 60 is00:08:42
still00:08:43
only for Ukraine, as it were, only for00:08:46
Ukraine now let’s go back to this, the overall00:08:48
package there, in my opinion, was00:08:52
voted and Taiwan Well, in general, this is00:08:57
Indo and the00:09:00
Pacific region is allocated separately00:09:03
Israel, as it were, is also allocated separately, that00:09:05
is Now, let's discuss Ukraine. There, in00:09:07
my opinion, there are 61 billion somewhere. But then this is a00:09:10
classic story with all sorts of00:09:12
American assistance, which is well00:09:14
known to those who lived in these controversial00:09:17
nineties, when a Grant is issued there,00:09:21
they say what kind of Grant. Well, they didn’t00:09:23
write me out, but I watched how for those00:09:27
who are lucky and that there is a significant00:09:31
part of this Grant, it immediately00:09:33
goes to serve those people who are00:09:36
engaged in issuing00:09:39
grants, that is, in general, this00:09:42
assistance is considered00:09:46
very specific by the Americans, that is, they immediately00:09:49
put all the accounting expenses into the assistance,00:09:53
let’s say so global00:09:57
accounting, so then it turns out00:09:59
that out of these six billion, well, you can00:10:02
argue there, you have to figure it out with a magnifying glass, but it00:10:05
turns out that00:10:08
about 13 14 billion are spent simply on00:10:13
stupidly00:10:14
replenishing their own warehouses, which were00:10:17
slightly emptied when Ukraine00:10:19
was given weapons in the program, then 7 billion00:10:23
is spent on routine financing the00:10:26
activities of the American contingent in00:10:29
Europe Well, they are, as it were, there and00:10:31
they are flying spiolto satellites,00:10:36
additional patrolling, all00:10:38
this is all taken into account, that is, it seems like00:10:40
assistance from Ukraine, but Ukraine will not00:10:43
see it further from the rest,00:10:46
and there are not quite clear to me, but00:10:50
two categories that is, one00:10:52
somewhere around 14 billion, this is understandable, just00:10:56
what goes into the supply of weapons. As I00:10:58
understand it, this is shells and 14 billion for the00:11:03
purchase of high-tech weapons. I do00:11:05
n’t quite understand these 14 billion, is this00:11:08
also for Ukraine or not, well, I’ll assume00:11:10
the best that it is also for Ukraine we00:11:12
will be talking about high-tech00:11:15
assistance, that is, if this is so, then relatively00:11:18
speaking, to help Ukraine, well, somewhere around 28-3000:11:22
billion, that’s the actual assistance allocated,00:11:24
plus there00:11:27
is help,00:11:30
strictly speaking financially, because00:11:31
Ukraine somehow needs to00:11:35
balance the budget there Civil00:11:37
life does not stop and00:11:40
7.5 billion are given for this.00:11:42
Now we don’t see exactly how these,00:11:46
relatively speaking, 13 and 13 billion will be00:11:49
distributed over00:11:51
time, there is an assumption I00:11:54
heard from experts who00:11:57
understand this, that from the very the beginning00:12:00
will be divided in such a way that a00:12:01
significant part of it, say a third, will be00:12:05
reserved for the next year and it00:12:09
will be like a kind of reserve that Ukraine00:12:12
can use in the event that00:12:13
another administration comes and then the00:12:16
funding will be completely00:12:18
blocked, but one way or another it will be00:12:21
extended in time, that is, here and00:12:23
now, it will be possible to use a much00:12:24
smaller amount, and now, the00:12:28
accompanying conditions, in general, I would00:12:31
say that there is a whole complex. Well, not00:12:35
that humiliating, but00:12:38
such signal conditions that did00:12:41
not exist before. That is, the first thing is that all this00:12:43
help is provided in form of00:12:45
a loan, that is, it is no longer00:12:47
gratuitous assistance, and in this sense, there is00:12:50
Kremlin Propaganda,00:12:52
which00:12:56
has been lying to itself all these 2 years now. Because Yes,00:13:00
indeed, this will now00:13:02
accumulate as Ukraine’s debt, it is an00:13:06
irrevocable debt. That is, it is absolutely00:13:08
clear, an irrecoverable debt because the00:13:10
state It will be quite difficult for Ukraine for a decade00:13:12
to pay off00:13:14
these debts, it’s00:13:17
like Soviet debts to African countries,00:13:20
that is, they do not exist to00:13:22
get money back in order00:13:24
to have a constant subject of00:13:27
conversation,00:13:29
that is, I don’t think that anyone who made00:13:32
these changes they They are counting on the fact that00:13:35
this money will someday be returned. But00:13:37
they make it clear that we will00:13:40
talk to you on the principle that for every00:13:42
vitamin we feed you, we will ask for a lot of00:13:46
small services. That is, this is such a signal, and00:13:49
at the same time, as if this signal was not00:13:52
considered necessary to00:13:54
send for Ukraine And they considered it00:13:57
necessary to send him for the00:14:00
electorate, which, apparently, is00:14:02
also already beginning to lean towards the fact that00:14:03
he was too00:14:05
generous, this is also such a signal that00:14:08
indicates a change in00:14:11
the situation; second, there are a lot of words,00:14:14
it is not clear how all this00:14:16
will be implemented about strengthening00:14:20
personal control of targeted00:14:22
control over the use of all this00:14:24
assistance Apparently, this is00:14:27
the mythology that the00:14:29
country is a very corrupt country and therefore00:14:32
everything is lost there, it begins00:14:35
to work on the capitalist hill and there are obvious ones there are00:14:41
such bookmarks, I would say that do00:14:44
not directly talk about corruption but suggest00:14:48
its existence00:14:50
therefore everywhere conditions the00:14:52
provision of00:14:53
assistance with very strict control. What does this00:14:56
mean? This means that there are bookmarks in order to00:14:59
put any moment on Hold, that is,00:15:02
to slow down, that is, the pretext, you know00:15:06
Anishchenko is not the first of our former sanitary00:15:09
doctor was born in the world, that is, you can always00:15:12
find what -the pretext is some kind of00:15:14
suspicion00:15:15
that can be used to00:15:18
slow down the process, and finally00:15:20
the third such transitory element is00:15:22
essential: this is also such a00:15:26
bookmark that allows you to twirl this00:15:29
bill like a drawbar, that it includes00:15:34
demands that this assistance is00:15:36
provided on the terms that the00:15:38
US partners the alliance00:15:40
is provided with an agreed00:15:42
proportional amount of their assistance. Well, that is,00:15:45
as if we gave 60 billion, then we have00:15:47
some kind of scattering of it00:15:50
all over our heads, which means Germany is00:15:53
so much, France is so much, Holland is00:15:55
so much, well, and there Greece is very little00:15:59
everything- at least something there is conditional, and00:16:02
then, well, imagine that someone does00:16:04
n’t give it. That is, this is a constant reason for00:16:06
someone to raise the question that00:16:08
look,00:16:09
the conditions for financing the pledged00:16:12
bill are not met, which means00:16:13
they can slow it down, that is, there are a lot of00:16:16
bookmarks that makes this00:16:18
bill so instrumental00:16:20
that it can be used as a lever in a00:16:23
certain sense of certain pressure.00:16:25
That is, this is very different from the00:16:28
conditions00:16:30
under which military financial assistance to00:16:33
Ukraine was00:16:36
initially provided to the basic conclusion that I draw.00:16:40
Unfortunately, Zelensky and his team00:16:43
have lost a lot in their authority in those00:16:45
opportunities that they had since the beginning of00:16:47
the war and to provide vital00:16:52
assistance. From the West, Ukraine in this00:16:55
war is often unable to do so.00:16:57
That is, they do not have enough00:16:59
lobbying capabilities to do this at the00:17:03
level that Ukraine00:17:04
needs today, then I can’t help but ask00:17:07
Was there any chance at all of getting00:17:11
everything that was needed, everything that was needed, not00:17:13
just these homeopathic and00:17:16
teaspoons, but a really large volume with00:17:20
everything that the Ukrainians needed, including all these00:17:22
types of weapons that the Ukrainians needed?00:17:25
For a speedy victory over Putin,00:17:27
you know, we00:17:29
will find out after many years about what00:17:32
happened and where the cat ran, but it is00:17:35
completely clear that the situation began to00:17:37
worsen00:17:38
approximately Since the end of last summer,00:17:43
when something like this happened with the00:17:47
Ukrainian00:17:49
offensive, which was perceived by the West00:17:52
as the collapse of its hope,00:17:55
illusion. What happened, you understand, we have a00:17:59
huge number of rumors going on there00:18:01
is a version that00:18:06
the West gave incorrect00:18:09
advice which, in general, if00:18:14
implemented, would have led to a00:18:16
catastrophic defeat of the Ukrainian00:18:18
army Well, because it was forced to00:18:21
attack00:18:24
And without aviation cover, which the West did not00:18:27
provide, and00:18:29
with still not00:18:32
enough weapons for an offensive,00:18:35
let not the same as now00:18:37
shell famine, but still there were00:18:39
few of them And they had to attack head-on00:18:44
through the positions that Russia was preparing00:18:47
precisely for Such a scenario over the00:18:51
previous year and as a result a00:18:57
decision was made Well, in fact,00:19:00
to minimize these risks, just00:19:04
take it and it’s00:19:05
stupid to lose the army and he acted like such a00:19:09
kutuzov who seems to be saying to00:19:12
lose Moscow there to lose the offensive00:19:14
but save the army Well, it’s like this is00:19:17
one version of events there, another version00:19:20
says that, in fact,00:19:23
the American and Western advisers00:19:25
advised something completely different. That is, they00:19:29
just put all the eggs in one00:19:32
basket hit with a narrow wedge in one00:19:35
place Throw everything you have in one00:19:37
second and then there would be a chance to00:19:39
really break through But if you00:19:41
smear it all with00:19:43
a fine smear, spread it in a thin layer on bread,00:19:48
then nothing would come of it initially,00:19:49
but I have it here such a question Well,00:19:52
yes, that is, there are00:19:55
situations in life and when00:19:58
you can take responsibility.00:20:01
Let's put it all down. Well, that is, I, in principle,00:20:04
understand the military leadership of Ukraine,00:20:07
which was not ready to play the game.00:20:11
We have 1500:20:13
chances out of 100 to win. Let's go for00:20:18
these 15 let’s put the whole army in Well, we’ll see00:20:20
what happens, but nevertheless there is a version00:20:22
that the plan was different I’m not a military expert00:20:25
I don’t know, something went wrong, that is,00:20:28
after,00:20:29
but nevertheless, this is how00:20:33
Ukrainian policy was built that all relations with00:20:37
the West are were tied to a certain00:20:41
legend, the inevitable Victory of Ukraine in00:20:44
this00:20:45
offensive, and when you rely so heavily00:20:47
on this and when this00:20:50
event does not happen, then there is00:20:53
definitely a rollback, that is, a00:20:56
new paradigm is being formed00:20:59
that sounded So a military00:21:03
Victory in this war on the part of Ukraine is00:21:06
not achieved00:21:08
But this is probably the main00:21:12
reason why,00:21:14
in principle, the attitude00:21:18
towards00:21:19
support has changed, that is, something happened00:21:22
at the turn of the summer-autumn of last year that is in the00:21:26
minds of not only00:21:28
decision-makers, but also in00:21:32
reality, since the West is a00:21:35
mostly democratic environment that is, in all00:21:37
these00:21:38
numerous public institutions00:21:41
there was a feeling that military Victory in the00:21:45
foreseeable future was unattainable,00:21:48
that we would throw everything into the pattern of a00:21:52
resource war for survival, where00:21:55
the winner is the one who will simply remain alive for a long time00:21:58
and the enemy will die. Well, roughly speaking,00:22:02
the trust will burst from internal tension00:22:05
that is, in fact, it looks like the00:22:07
truth and, in fact, the same person00:22:10
wrote this in his sensational00:22:13
article in economics. Which I think00:22:15
ultimately led to00:22:18
his resignation And then the next question is that00:22:22
we have such a game00:22:25
that essentially its goal is a00:22:30
revolution either in Russia or in00:22:33
Ukraine, that is, the war itself is00:22:35
not waged in order to break through the00:22:39
front to occupy territory and so on. It is00:22:41
waged in order to look for00:22:43
enemy forces and ultimately so that the00:22:45
rear, that is, the front of the grater, collapses. at00:22:50
the front they exist in order to pull down the00:22:53
poles from the shackle,00:22:59
in fact, in this case, it’s no longer with Russia,00:23:01
but with00:23:02
China, because00:23:05
the situation is clear. Russia can, of course,00:23:07
wage a war a little longer than Ukraine,00:23:09
but it also00:23:12
cannot wage a war there on its own indefinitely,00:23:16
and Ukraine can now wage a war on00:23:19
its own without external support it00:23:21
cannot, in00:23:23
principle. Thus, the West has a00:23:26
New00:23:27
reality: if in the first so-00:23:30
called heroic segment of the war they00:23:33
understood that they were fighting Russia through00:23:38
Ukraine, then in the second section of the war00:23:41
there was a firm understanding that they were00:23:43
fighting China through Russia and00:23:46
Ukraine And this is a slightly different situation,00:23:49
you understand that you are already starting to consider that you are00:23:52
ready to compete with China in the years to come, so to speak,00:23:54
when the Chinese00:23:57
money, not the Russian one, cracks and China00:24:01
says that no more, it can no longer supply through00:24:04
its proxies North Korea and00:24:07
Iran through a partial proxy there00:24:11
the components necessary for Russia,00:24:13
weapons and everything00:24:15
else,00:24:18
plus added to this is the clear00:24:22
feeling00:24:23
that it is not public opinion or the economy that00:24:29
the world is not ready for and is not able to00:24:32
carry out the complete isolation of Russia, that00:24:35
is, Russia continues to00:24:37
receive colossal windfall profits from00:24:41
the sale of energy resources. Yes, it now00:24:44
sells oil to there are basins there that at any00:24:48
moment threaten to capsize and create00:24:51
dozens of environmental disasters in the00:24:53
Baltic Sea anywhere, but00:24:56
nevertheless I found a way.00:24:59
All this led to the fact that the00:25:03
approach changed. You see, there wasn’t something there, the00:25:06
approach changed and this approach became00:25:10
cynically00:25:11
pragmatic that is, they began to consider not00:25:14
so much justice as money in the00:25:17
pocket, and counting this money in the pocket,00:25:21
they came to the conclusion00:25:22
that the war was becoming too00:25:27
expensive an invoice and the main thing is that it is not a00:25:30
reason to fit in00:25:33
completely, this is very important. That is, this is what the00:25:37
situation always reminded me of00:25:39
cat00:25:40
house I called Not forever and today is not00:25:45
Wednesday, and therefore it suddenly turned out00:25:50
that both public opinion and the00:25:57
decision-making center reacting accordingly to this public opinion say that there is a certain00:26:00
limited limit of what they can00:26:03
give; this limited limit is in00:26:05
space, that is, in terms of volume and00:26:07
time.00:26:09
And therefore, I would not say that all these,00:26:12
that is, of course, were influenced by the00:26:16
election campaign in the United States with all the00:26:22
attendant additional complications,00:26:24
but this is not the main thing, you understand. The main thing is that the00:26:26
approach has changed,00:26:29
the approach has changed and when it changed It has already become00:26:31
clear that there is no motivation and00:26:36
courage to provide00:26:38
assistance to Ukraine in the required volumes,00:26:41
that is, the question then became not about00:26:44
the assistance that is necessary in order to00:26:46
adequately end this war, but about00:26:50
the assistance that is necessary so00:26:53
that Ukraine does not lose00:26:55
defeat here and there it is necessary Well, some00:26:59
conditions must be met and now the dispute has already become that00:27:02
is, Dmitry, in principle it turns out00:27:05
that they went down to another floor, went down to the00:27:08
floor below from the discussion of what needs to be given00:27:12
in order to adequately end the war of00:27:15
victories for Ukraine, went down to the00:27:18
floor What needs to be given as a minimum in order to00:27:21
Ukraine has not suffered00:27:23
defeat in the near future. Uh-huh. And00:27:26
when the discussion went in this direction00:27:30
and then it was00:27:32
dragged out and then it was dragged out for six months, that00:27:35
is, making the situation critical, making the00:27:38
situation critical, exposing Zelensky00:27:41
very much, forcing00:27:43
Zelensky to come out with this law of00:27:45
mobilization, which causes a lot00:27:48
complaints and such rejection of the Ukrainian00:27:52
society, forcing them to go through this00:27:55
difficult situation00:27:58
when the front is rolling back, created out of00:28:01
nowhere a real threat00:28:04
that in such conditions it is already really00:28:07
possible to attack Kharkov and lose00:28:11
territory on a much larger scale00:28:13
than what happened and without doing00:28:16
anything is changing That is, this means00:28:18
that Zelensky is being squeezed out for something00:28:20
Zelensky is being squeezed out for something That's00:28:23
why this department has made a00:28:26
conversational decision and no one is00:28:31
going to throw him a Lifebuoy00:28:34
To give them decisions00:28:37
to avoid so I don't have any00:28:39
euphoria00:28:41
about this one Now voted for00:28:45
help is natural after Trump's change of00:28:47
position.00:28:49
I had no doubt that it would be given00:28:53
naturally recently after the00:28:59
attack on Kharkov had already been formed. I had no doubt that00:29:02
Trump, with his intuition, would change his00:29:04
position because00:29:07
it was too risky, it was already quite a00:29:10
casino because he risked becoming like00:29:14
if he were the main culprit for the defeat of Ukraine,00:29:17
he doesn’t need this, that is, he needs to00:29:19
hold out this situation too by some kind of00:29:27
exchange, but it gives the00:29:30
opportunity to not even exhale just a00:29:32
little, just breathe and not00:29:35
exhale, let’s say for a few00:29:37
months further on, it’s unclear what00:29:40
will happen because either something will happen00:29:42
within a few months, or we00:29:44
will find ourselves in a situation where there is no money but00:29:46
you hold on vavich Well, just for00:29:49
context, here is the amount since the beginning of00:29:52
Russia’s full-scale invasion of00:29:55
Ukraine, the Americans have allocated00:29:59
113 billion dollars for the war and assistance to Ukraine, this is00:30:03
data from the Institute for the Study of War00:30:07
75 billion was sent directly to00:30:10
Ukraine 38 Well, approximately, that is, we can00:30:13
count half Yes, this is what the00:30:17
United States of America themselves spent,00:30:19
just to understand the level of00:30:21
figures, it is said that for an unlimited00:30:25
future, that is, for a year. Select the amount00:30:28
that we are counting Well about 2500:30:31
billion is plus or minus what00:30:34
realistically will go towards that is, you know,00:30:37
it’s simply not comparable and at the same time there is00:30:41
such a feeling you know flr such that the00:30:44
last money Yes Last autumn the00:30:46
last money this is this, this is00:30:49
actually a very good comparison00:30:51
then there is another comparison in a00:30:53
simpler way, I looked for this figure, I think that it is00:30:55
underestimated, but what is00:30:59
there, Reznikov, in my opinion, in his interview00:31:02
last fall, said that a day of00:31:05
war costs 100 million dollars in Ukraine,00:31:07
I think that it costs more,00:31:09
significantly more, but since this the00:31:12
official figure is announced Well, we00:31:15
take 100 million dollars. This means that a month of00:31:18
war costs 3 billion, at least this does not00:31:22
count everything else. But this00:31:25
means00:31:26
that Ukraine needs to receive a minimum of direct expenses00:31:30
from somewhere, well, 36 billion a year,00:31:37
you know. I think that in reality That00:31:41
is,00:31:43
taking into account the economy, that is, we are00:31:45
now talking here from 2025, that is,00:31:48
in a much worse situation,00:31:51
that is, paving, as I said, this is00:31:54
several months of six months of conducting a session,00:31:58
we are in a situation where let’s say this00:32:00
help will begin to arrive In a week Well,00:32:03
let’s go there relatively speaking, from May 1 Well, from00:32:06
May 1, 600:32:08
months Well, until November, and00:32:11
then we have elections. Well, actually,00:32:13
look how interesting they are. And00:32:16
then the elections,00:32:17
therefore, made it00:32:19
possible, in00:32:21
principle, not to collapse the front while they00:32:25
sort it out among themselves. Well, how It00:32:28
seems to me that different types of military operations,00:32:31
different operations require different00:32:33
budgeting, and some somewhere,00:32:36
sometime you can spend less money, but I00:32:39
believe that if you are not just00:32:42
in deep defense Yes, you try00:32:45
somehow and try to hold back the front, and then00:32:47
intense military operations require00:32:49
you to inject more money, well, look,00:32:53
you yourself practically00:32:56
laid down the answer in the question, that is, with00:32:58
the funding that we see. I think00:33:01
that the talk about a possible new00:33:08
strategic offensive by Ukraine They are baseless, that00:33:10
is, I think that this type of assistance is00:33:15
aimed at to help Ukraine00:33:18
Organizing a strategic00:33:21
[music]00:33:22
defense is good, but here’s a thesis for you that00:33:25
means the lack of progress is a regression00:33:28
for America and Ukraine Now it seems like00:33:32
some kind of small impulse has emerged. Even if it’s00:33:34
weak. Even if it’s00:33:37
insufficient, but still let’s go back to the00:33:39
beginning of our conversation This is good00:33:41
news, but for Russia that Russia can00:33:45
now respond with something in this regard,00:33:48
does it have any contacts? I don’t00:33:51
know. Apart from North Korea, there is no00:33:54
surge in mobilization. That is, it00:33:57
could really be against the background of that00:33:58
that Putin’s troops, Putin’s officials00:34:02
and the military are not doing anything now,00:34:05
this American tranche may be00:34:09
more successful than if there were00:34:12
some parallel processes going on in Russia00:34:14
that could be compared in volume and00:34:15
scale with American assistance.00:34:17
Sorry, that’s enough, because Iva put it but00:34:21
then, in principle, you may be00:34:23
right Why Because Moreover,00:34:26
Ukrainian society continues00:34:28
to remain much more open and,00:34:30
accordingly, there its problems we have00:34:33
the opportunity to openly discuss and see, which00:34:36
means Russian society is becoming00:34:39
more and more closed and there are opportunities to00:34:42
receive adequate objective00:34:43
information about the state there is less and less business in the army at00:34:47
the front and in the rear, that00:34:49
is, we can only see00:34:53
some kind of propaganda picture there. Well,00:34:58
experts receive some fragmentary indirect data, that is, the general00:35:00
impression is00:35:02
that Russia is on some kind of Plateau00:35:06
of Stability, but at this is also not00:35:09
infinite We just don’t see We We00:35:11
really don’t see these problems We really do00:35:14
n’t see these problems nevertheless,00:35:16
first of all, we don’t see the real00:35:18
state of the army We don’t understand what’s00:35:23
happening in the army today We saw it when Prigozhinsky was00:35:28
here one flux opened up and from there pus00:35:31
flowed out in such a full volume, sometimes00:35:35
small pimples open up. Well,00:35:37
we remember this dismissal of00:35:41
Spartak, the commander p8 and then Spartak00:35:44
was there and a lot of00:35:47
pus spilled around it, that is, it became clear that00:35:49
in general they were fighting like 150 years ago. That is, to00:35:54
me it was more reminiscent of the stories about the Ruhr at the00:35:58
end of the century, when more people died00:36:03
from disease than directly in battle, that00:36:06
is, I can assume that the situation00:36:09
in fact is also not so hot00:36:14
and that Ukraine will receive a certain00:36:18
respite and the shell00:36:21
hunger will be the same from my point of view00:36:28
saying this will aggravate this situation is an00:36:31
indirect sign that the situation00:36:35
is not ideal and that even00:36:39
this help is00:36:40
not useful, let’s say for the Kremlin00:36:44
is that the Kremlin is now actively00:36:46
playing the game by sending a rather00:36:50
unequivocal message00:36:56
at the moment, I’m not talking about whether it is ready00:37:00
actually stop it, but obviously he00:37:02
wants to play this game and he wants00:37:04
to play this game not because of a good life,00:37:06
that is, we see that Russia in this00:37:09
situation is playing cat and mouse with00:37:15
Europe, perhaps with America too, but in00:37:18
Europe This is good visible and sends a signal00:37:20
that she is ready to end the war on00:37:23
the terms if a piece remains for her,00:37:27
this piece00:37:41
was snatched from Medvedev, but in general it00:37:44
is not so00:37:46
popular now. Therefore, yes, we can00:37:49
see in principle that this00:37:52
injection here may, under certain00:37:55
circumstances, turn out to be the00:38:00
Putin clan I’m inclined to think that00:38:03
he00:38:06
needs a break, relatively speaking, now00:38:10
it turns into something, that is. Let’s say,00:38:12
let’s say they know something that we don’t know,00:38:15
they better count their bins and00:38:18
understand that for them this is also a00:38:28
break. Well, you see, there’s no break00:38:33
at all in our area there is nothing more00:38:37
permanent than temporary, you know, that is,00:38:39
as soon as it goes, the respite00:38:42
may end instantly, or it may00:38:44
drag on for decades. Well, in a00:38:47
sense, Russia and Japan still have00:38:51
a respite. Well, let’s be so objective, we are00:38:54
de facto in a sense00:38:58
there is no state of war mirato, but as it were, well, everything is already as if there was a00:39:03
respite from the Baltic, no one00:39:06
recognized it, it was an occupation, but it lasted00:39:10
almost 50 years there,00:39:14
and then when the system collapsed, everything00:39:17
won back. That is, while we are talking about some kind of00:39:20
respite, and it may be inclined00:39:26
he can pretend that he is leaning toward this,00:39:28
and then when he pulls00:39:32
Zelensky into negotiations, he can say, and00:39:36
now we want this, this00:39:39
complete disarmament, the withdrawal of all00:39:41
foreign troops, the arrest of all Nazis, and00:39:45
this is the case, and so on. All the negotiations are at a00:39:49
dead end, maybe like this to behave quite well, this00:39:51
will discredit Zelensky. And maybe he can00:39:54
really say well, we’re on the00:39:55
same day, he00:39:57
makes it clear there under the conditions of the Istanbul00:40:00
agreement, plus or minus something. They are ready to00:40:02
gain a foothold along this line on00:40:04
certain conditions. Well, that’s how00:40:06
the war is moving And into this format on the00:40:09
fourteenth 'twenty-two,00:40:13
that is, there will be a shootout there will be00:40:15
tension, but in general, as if00:40:18
intense, this will allow some kind of maneuver00:40:21
with those mobilized on both sides to make00:40:24
some part of the population there, bring00:40:26
back00:40:28
some social problems to start00:40:31
Raskino, then the question arises Well,00:40:33
okay and Zelensky can00:40:35
afford it Well, let’s say, yes, with Zelensky00:40:39
I think it’s more difficult now than with the Kremlin00:40:41
because,00:40:43
paradoxically, in principle, tactically00:40:46
Putin can00:40:47
afford it; another question is that the00:40:51
strategic consequences for the regime of transition to00:40:54
peacetime will be catastrophic.00:40:57
Well, that’s how they are they will feel it later,00:41:00
we can00:41:02
predict it like this,00:41:04
you had accidents, there were no settings,00:41:08
you had00:41:10
serious internal political problems, no, they will be in00:41:13
peaceful conditions, but they may00:41:16
believe us, they may not believe us, but for00:41:19
Zelensky, there is exactly the opposite00:41:22
situation, there is no fortune teller here it must00:41:24
be clear that for him, in00:41:27
fact, the phrase itself is good. I am00:41:30
entering into a negotiation process with00:41:32
Putin. Well, this is already00:41:35
Polukhina becoming a00:41:39
DB. This is the problem. I don’t understand how00:41:43
I think that he realizes this. And this is00:41:45
his movement now back and forth all the00:41:48
time they remind me more of this00:41:51
very complex00:41:53
humanitarian00:41:56
preparation for what is possible. Well, in00:41:59
a sense,00:42:00
a maneuver. Well, I’ll probably add one more thing,00:42:04
knowing Putin as a tactician who00:42:09
is trying00:42:10
to respond to the current situation. Yes,00:42:14
you can expect some kind of in the near future, probably in the00:42:16
next few days or weeks.00:42:20
then there is a massive00:42:22
Russian offensive at the front to take advantage of00:42:24
this00:42:26
[music]00:42:28
like the00:42:29
American law was signed Yes, help00:42:31
was allocated but nothing has arrived yet And00:42:34
now there is such a small window of00:42:36
opportunity for Putin’s troops What do you00:42:39
think, will you agree or not Well, I00:42:42
just don’t have the competence for this00:42:44
because an offensive is Possible when there are00:42:46
appropriate00:42:48
strategic reserves for this, that is, an00:42:51
offensive is an offensive00:42:53
itno00:42:54
after the fact,00:42:57
but it does not lead to the00:43:01
results that Moscow00:43:02
was counting on, that is, there is no00:43:04
strategic breakthrough, that is, they00:43:06
have advanced there by 10-15 km, they00:43:09
occupy this village that village, but they00:43:12
cannot enter the operational space in00:43:14
this sense, despite the shell hunger00:43:16
and everything else, they are holding their00:43:19
positions, so it cannot be said that00:43:21
they did not advance, they will00:43:24
attack, it is already more difficult to implement00:43:26
what you said, but they are already advancing and00:43:28
you need to understand And that’s why they didn’t00:43:31
succeed yesterday. So they want to break through this00:43:33
front line there for several months, you’ve been00:43:36
saying. Now they’re going to launch an00:43:37
offensive. Well, what were you waiting for, waiting for00:43:39
Congress to vote? I think it’s not00:43:42
that simple, that is, my00:43:43
feeling00:43:46
is, you know, remember how the dragon was killed, he says00:43:49
he wanted to kill me, he says if he00:43:51
wanted to kill you, he would have already killed you if00:43:54
they could attack, they would have already00:43:55
attacked, you understand, there00:43:57
are no benefits for them to wait00:44:02
until Congress votes, I think that the00:44:04
lack of offensive was due to the fact00:44:06
that there were no resources for such an offensive00:44:09
now the answer then will there be an00:44:14
offensive? The answer to this question is00:44:15
not connected with the fact that00:44:18
American help will not come. But with whether,00:44:21
relatively speaking, they have managed to accumulate enough operational reserves over the last month and a half00:44:27
and whether they will risk throwing them into battle, you00:44:30
understand, after all, an offensive is an offensive00:44:33
this is always a double-edged sword. With all00:44:36
that, in such a serious offensive you00:44:39
open up and here, in general, there00:44:45
is always a chance that you will launch an offensive and00:44:48
then the attack will come and they will cut you up,00:44:52
so I’m not so sure How are00:44:56
you that in the near future This is an offensive00:44:59
will take place I would rather say that if00:45:02
nothing changes, Russia00:45:04
will try to organize a summer00:45:06
offensive. Well, having prepared for00:45:09
this for a few more months, the standard00:45:12
time for these latitudes is June July, so I did00:45:15
n’t immediately understand, offering questions00:45:20
from the audience to discuss, there remains about a00:45:23
quarter of our Sunday service, let me00:45:26
remind you that00:45:27
viewers can Send their wishes and00:45:30
questions to me on the Telegram channel link in the00:45:33
description also in the description link to00:45:34
Pastukhov’s kitchens This is00:45:37
Vladimir Borisovich’s program with Boris00:45:39
Vladimirovich and Pastukhov’s Telegram channel is00:45:42
also in00:45:44
the description so the question is our viewer or00:45:48
viewer from Bashkiria, it’s not very00:45:50
clear A if the front still waits until a00:45:54
miracle occurs, what will the West do, run00:45:57
with bulging eyes or line up00:45:59
in Moscow to bow Thank you from00:46:02
Bashkiria, your latest kitchen release is00:46:04
again a very00:46:08
task, well, if the front sleeps,00:46:11
then it will have to be patched up Well, such a simple00:46:15
answer I I don’t think that the West is00:46:20
ready to abandon the idea of supporting00:46:24
Ukraine, preserving Ukraine as a00:46:26
sovereign00:46:27
independent and00:46:37
orienting additional00:46:40
resources have been found from Europe and for the supply of00:46:44
additional weapons. And then everything00:46:47
will depend on00:46:50
Zelensky’s ability not to delay mobilization00:46:54
but to form00:46:57
new brigades and quickly arm and00:47:00
abandon them them going into battle, this will00:47:02
of course be associated with very large00:47:03
casualties,00:47:05
since quite a lot of00:47:07
poorly trained people will be forced, well,00:47:10
in the00:47:12
defense regime of Kiev in 1941,00:47:16
to go into battle and then, as it were, at the third00:47:19
level, this will be a kind of test of00:47:21
Ukrainian society00:47:24
for the readiness of everything - it’s real to go to00:47:27
the end. So we don’t know. Now,00:47:30
this is the situation of what kind of pause there was. And it’s like,00:47:33
well, all00:47:35
sorts of images, and this, too, will00:47:40
once again put people in front of the mirror, and00:47:43
this is the patriotic feeling00:47:45
that seems to us to have dulled anyway00:47:49
For these 2 years and that people there are already tired,00:47:52
but this fatigue can pass, you understand,00:47:54
and a breakthrough of the front may turn out to be three00:47:58
in one direction or the other, but00:48:00
it may also turn out to be a trigger for the00:48:03
resumption of a new session of passionarity,00:48:06
that is, therefore, I think00:48:09
that simply if this happens,00:48:13
then the next stabilization will occur in a00:48:16
much worse situation, that is, let’s00:48:20
say there. If today Moscow is conducting00:48:24
separate peace negotiations with the West00:48:28
along the lines of a00:48:31
piece of the Zaporozhye and Kherson00:48:34
regions, a00:48:35
piece of the Donetsk region and almost the entire00:48:40
Lugansk region, then relatively speaking at the00:48:43
next level we will be talking about00:48:47
approximately territories in twice00:48:50
as much as the current one Well, yes, this00:48:53
will be a problem, I think that the line of those00:48:57
who want to talk to Moscow is already00:48:59
standing and will not get any longer. Whoever wants it is00:49:02
talking over there. We see that00:49:07
Orban not only feels great,00:49:10
but most likely even takes money there00:49:12
Moscow for the purchase of Eurovision, as it now00:49:16
turns out, so everything is00:49:18
fine there. People have already decided, you00:49:20
know, they have already formed,00:49:22
whoever wants00:49:24
the library is in the audience, Catherine from00:49:29
Pskov, if the West is ready to sell Ukraine,00:49:32
then why is everyone looking for a million shells on the initiative of the Czech Republic?00:49:34
Why is Macron00:49:36
launching a weapons factory that00:49:38
should be operating by the twenty-fifth year or are00:49:40
they already doing it for themselves?00:49:42
Well, the correct answer is they are already00:49:45
doing it for themselves, yes. That is, in principle, it is00:49:48
necessary to separate two completely unrelated00:49:53
questions: has the West realized00:49:56
that Russia is00:49:59
such a natural enemy And in00:50:03
relation to which you need to keep your ear to00:50:05
the ground. That is, this is the Bear Shatun in00:50:07
the den. Well, yes, I realized whether it’s fair or00:50:10
not. It seems that this will have to be decided by the00:50:13
next generation of Russians who00:50:15
will have to break this idea of themselves,00:50:17
but it has now formed and therefore, in00:50:22
general, this is the course for a return to the Cold00:50:26
War,00:50:27
from my point of view, it is considered00:50:31
a consensus, that is, no matter00:50:33
what happens to00:50:35
Ukraine, I can predict that00:50:39
Europe will not live as it lived,00:50:42
relatively speaking, well, after the collapse of the00:50:45
Berlin Wall and before this war, that00:50:48
is, it will be it means that the military00:50:50
component, that00:50:53
is, in the euro,00:50:57
will be in00:51:00
vogue again, this means an increase, well, from my point of00:51:04
view, military spending there is up by00:51:08
one and a half to two percent00:51:09
per GDP,00:51:13
this00:51:15
means a return to the00:51:17
arms race, this means00:51:20
if00:51:22
the Americans go further with isolationism00:51:25
in the sky00:51:27
Well, as it were, the creation of a whole -then the00:51:28
European army will not be able to escape here.00:51:31
Although I doubt that in the end00:51:34
isolationism will win in full00:51:37
force in America, that is, it is one thing to frighten and another thing to00:51:40
put it into practice because it is00:51:42
not00:51:44
beneficial for ourselves and in this sense00:51:50
everything has nothing to do with because they are far from00:51:54
ready to support Ukraine, I would00:51:56
say that they are aimed at a cold00:51:59
war, but at the same time, they would like to00:52:01
end the hot war and00:52:05
the risks associated with it as soon as possible because00:52:07
they know how to behave in a cold war, they have a00:52:09
lot of experience. oh, and in pandan, our00:52:12
viewer of Anastasia from Poland00:52:14
asks about the likelihood of00:52:16
Putin’s attack on this country, she says that the local00:52:20
Inform space is filled with00:52:22
discussions of this probability. Some00:52:24
say that it definitely won’t happen, but there are those00:52:26
who say that it will, but in a year and a00:52:29
half or two, Anastasia asks you to evaluate00:52:33
the likelihood of such a00:52:36
conflict Well,00:52:38
unfortunately, from the moment when Putin00:52:41
came to power in Russia, the only00:52:44
working formula is the formula00:52:46
Never say00:52:47
never, that is, things that seem00:52:51
unthinkable to us are completely00:52:53
irrational. After some time, they00:52:56
are formed00:52:58
into practical plans, that is, at the00:53:01
moment here and now there are00:53:04
no prerequisites for an attack on Poland,00:53:07
that is, if the question of an00:53:09
attack on Poland, some00:53:12
other Baltic countries is a question, let’s say00:53:15
there for the next few months. But00:53:18
obviously there is no further situation, it can00:53:21
go in three directions, in principle, not00:53:27
in Russia right now apart from war, this is the time.00:53:31
That is, as soon as they now try to00:53:33
abandon the war, they will be faced with a00:53:35
heap of social problems, an increase in00:53:37
internal tension, essentially the threat of00:53:40
plunging into such a serious civil00:53:43
war, that is, they will have to sooner or00:53:45
later return to the idea of war again and00:53:47
again as something that the splat of00:53:55
society is psychologically dependent on00:53:58
this sect. Well, the most striking00:54:02
spokesman there is Dugin00:54:04
Prokhanov Malofeev and all the rest, this is an00:54:07
absolutely religious and philosophical00:54:10
movement of00:54:13
sectarians with a philosophy and ideology00:54:17
reminiscent of00:54:19
Christ Marie in reality, these00:54:21
suicidal00:54:23
sects are predictable to what extent00:54:27
right Eli will fall Step by step, it is00:54:32
very difficult for me to understand these suicidal philosophies,00:54:35
but I do not exclude that it is possible, that00:54:37
is, at some stage at some stage the00:54:40
question may arise that00:54:43
the only way to save the regime is to00:54:46
get involved in a gigantic catastrophic00:54:49
suicide00:54:51
war,00:54:57
what are they just threatening? Well, if00:55:00
Ukraine, let’s say, the deadline will really expire.00:55:02
But then, well, will France00:55:06
fit in with00:55:08
Poland?00:55:10
Well, it’s like a dinosaur girl,00:55:13
maybe it’s spelled, maybe not, so they00:55:16
will try, if00:55:18
possible, to taste it,00:55:25
there’s mo Wow regime that He00:55:29
will try to do something like that, it’s00:55:34
impossible for dessert, I left a couple of topics,00:55:37
I suggest you allocate literally 2 minutes for00:55:39
each00:55:40
I sent you a00:55:44
post from Alexander Plyushchev this morning, which concerns the00:55:47
sensational film of the Anti-00:55:50
Corruption Foundation, but not the one about00:55:53
the nineties And that which about the family I will00:55:56
remind our viewers and listeners00:55:59
who are probably aware of history. In00:56:00
general, the background of the fight against corruption has learned that the00:56:03
children of the mayor of Orsk, Mr. Kazoo, live00:56:07
somewhere in the Middle East in some00:56:09
kind of rich oil country, they don’t00:56:12
particularly worry about the floods there00:56:14
Beth Orenburg and so on and so forth00:56:16
Well, in general, a typical picture is00:56:17
drawn. Yes, it means that the local KZK sent00:56:21
his children, his family00:56:23
to resort towns and tried to enjoy00:56:27
life there. But Plyushchev, our colleague00:56:29
found out that it seems that the Son of the Kazoo is quite an00:56:34
independent person who is not only00:56:36
like I would have00:56:39
worked in oil all my life, graduated from the Faculty of Geography,00:56:42
apparently was a decent specialist and00:56:45
got a job in the huge00:56:56
Sado Aravi, I don’t remember exactly now Well,00:56:59
in general, somewhere somewhere, your00:57:02
attitude to this story To the consequences00:57:05
and to the actual00:57:07
investigation itself about the family Governor of00:57:11
Orsk Well, I don’t have anything to do with the investigation itself00:57:15
Because I didn’t delve into it, I just00:57:19
looked at it, but it’s such an interesting00:57:22
fact00:57:24
[music] that00:57:25
’s why I don’t even know what to say. But00:57:28
in relation to how the VBK treats00:57:31
working with information, well, you can say00:57:33
the first thing is that this is an absolutely standard00:57:36
practice of the WBK,00:57:38
they are actually talking about Propaganda and00:57:41
not about investigation, and they00:57:43
actually didn’t fit in anywhere that they00:57:45
are a mass media00:57:47
that is obliged to comply with the standard of00:57:50
objectively professionally honest00:57:52
journalism, this is not about them, a00:57:56
political machine of goodness. Well, what is00:58:01
goodness everyone understands in its own way,00:58:03
which is busy Not with investigation, but00:58:06
with propaganda, investigation is for00:58:08
them a format of propaganda,00:58:11
they are absolutely cool. The guys in00:58:15
terms of the ability to obtain00:58:18
information00:58:20
and in this00:58:23
sense, in the ability to pump it out from a00:58:27
variety of sources, use leaks00:58:30
Well, they have almost no equal But then they continue to00:58:34
work the most00:58:36
interesting part of the investigation begins, that00:58:38
is, for the general public it seems that00:58:42
the investigation ends when the00:58:46
information was leaked to you; in reality, the00:58:48
investigation is just beginning at this moment.00:58:49
Because you begin to check this00:58:52
information, firstly, check the technical characteristics, and00:58:56
compare it with other versions. In00:59:00
general, this colossal work00:59:02
which, well, I can say that for00:59:06
me there are two teams and they are interconnected00:59:09
with each other and00:59:11
are00:59:12
indicators of compliance with always the00:59:14
highest standards. I mean, if00:59:17
we are talking about Russia, the race of journalism00:59:20
is a traditional team of a new newspaper, that00:59:23
is, it is also a created sneeze,00:59:27
actually working under the leadership of00:59:30
Serge Sokolov and this is a separate team that emerged from this lodgment of00:59:33
important stories of00:59:36
the novel by Anin, who, from my point of view,00:59:38
is an incredibly scrupulous and very00:59:41
careful person, and therefore for00:59:44
these teams, the moment of receiving00:59:46
information before the material is released usually00:59:50
takes Well a month if not a year Because00:59:53
it’s00:59:55
very important that you check all the time00:59:57
whether what you see00:59:59
really means what you think, this is the01:00:01
biggest01:00:03
problem of ubk, otherwise it is in the morning in the01:00:08
newspaper in the evening in the verse and,01:00:10
accordingly, there is no01:00:13
serious processing of information here and there cannot be,01:00:15
because the result is what they are doing01:00:17
this for they want to use the information01:00:18
in advance for Propaganda and that’s why they01:00:21
cut corners very EASILY so what’s with it is natural01:00:26
for me. Logical I don’t see01:00:28
anything new in this, this is normal01:00:31
practice when FBK cut01:00:35
corners to order. That is, if they need01:00:38
it to look like this then they won’t01:00:41
particularly print with the fact that there may be01:00:43
15 other versions01:00:51
being interpreted right now in01:00:54
Yekaterinburg there is a meeting between01:00:56
Ekaterina and her supporters. Well, the meeting01:01:00
was actually disrupted by representatives of01:01:02
the police, security forces are checking for01:01:04
signs of extremism, checking everyone’s01:01:07
passport documents Don Sola said that the01:01:10
meeting will definitely continue as01:01:12
soon as the police are convinced that there is no01:01:16
threat to them in general, with01:01:20
such, of course, a little irony,01:01:22
sarcasm, but to comment on the actions01:01:26
of the security forces and why is this necessary, strictly01:01:29
speaking, Or can the system no longer01:01:31
become the system, the elections ended before they did01:01:34
n’t allow any there's a type of01:01:36
danger there She clearly doesn't doesn't look like an01:01:39
extremist Doesn't look like,01:01:41
well, you never01:01:44
know what size the mushrooms will grow in01:01:46
the area What if they01:01:50
grow up from Chernobyl01:01:52
Suri, in01:01:55
general, they seem to be going about their01:01:58
usual business, mowing the lawn, but for01:02:01
some reason they need to, but that's another question in general, I’m01:02:03
not very interested in this because01:02:05
instinctively it seems to me that the PKO is due01:02:08
to evolution due to01:02:11
some specific01:02:13
situation created by this pseudo election01:02:16
campaign that we had. I will be01:02:18
very glad if I’m wrong, it turns out that I01:02:20
misunderstood you. Thank you very much, Vadimir01:02:24
Borisovich We seem to have managed to discuss everything about the01:02:27
main topics Thank you friends for being01:02:29
with us don’t leave without liking without subscribing01:02:32
without commenting this is all very important and01:02:34
useful Vadim Borevich Glad to see you in the01:02:37
usual duty interiors it’s good that01:02:39
you will return I’ve finally become closer to the events01:02:41
the signal reaches faster Yes and the pulse of01:02:45
the event is also felt It seems to me more01:02:47
brightly and clearly See you in a week01:02:49
Thank you very much See you01:02:51
All the best Thank you01:02:54
Happy NDescription:
Палата представителей Конгресса США наконец одобрила пакет военной помощи Украине на сумму более 60 миллиардов долларов. Законопроект, застрявший в нижней палате американского парламента с осени прошлого года, наконец принят — теперь его должен одобрить Сенат, а после этого он поступит на подпись к президенту страны Джо Байдену. Президент Украины Владимир Зеленский уже поблагодарил американских конгрессменов. Как долгожданная помощь изменит расстановку сил в войне Украины против армии Путина? Политолог Владимир Пастухов и журналист Дмитрий Еловский обсуждают эту и другие главные новости недели в программе «Чисто конкретная политика». И, как всегда, отвечают на вопросы зрителей. Смотрите «Чисто конкретную политику» каждое воскресенье в 15-00 по Москве, Киеву и Вильнюсу на @khodorkovskylive и не забывайте подписываться на канал, чтобы получать больше объективной информации о происходящем в России. Таймкоды: 00:00 Начало 00:35 США одобрили помощь Украине на $61 млрд. Что дальше? 05:44 Почему Трамп пошел на попятную 08:05 Сколько из 61 миллиарда дойдет до Украины 17:06 Что испортилось в отношениях Украины и США. Версии 24:20 Россию оказалось невозможно изолировать 29:49 Украина воюет с Путиным на последние деньги? 33:25 Пойдет ли Россия в наступление? 42:02 «Кому в мавзолей, кому в библиотеку». Форточка возможностей для Путина 49:25 Мир взял курс на возвращение к холодной войне 52:11 Нападет ли Путин на Польшу 55:35 Плющев и расследование ФБК о мэре Орска 1:00:50 Полиция сорвала встречу Дунцовой с избирателями Ютуб-канал «Пастуховская Кухня»: @pastukhov_kitchen Телеграм-канал Владимира Пастухова: https://t.me/v_pastukhov Телеграм-канал Дмитрия Еловского: https://t.me/delovsky СМОТРИТЕ ТАКЖЕ НА ХОДОРКОВСКИЙ LIVE ⚡️НОВОСТИ | КОРАБЛЬ РФ АТАКОВАН РАКЕТОЙ | США ОДОБРИЛИ ПОМОЩЬ УКРАИНЕ | НАВОДНЕНИЕ ПОД ТЮМЕНЬЮ https://youtu.be/yTqVlQgIJXA БЫКОВ: Символ РФ — Пугачева. Прислуга Путина Памфилова. Мелкий палач Симоньян. Садист из Росгвардии. Ивлеева и Хинштейн. Гоголь придумал Украину https://youtu.be/tiEKl9bznlY ХОДОРКОВСКИЙ и ПАСТУХОВ: Наводнение как проверка власти. Мобилизация? После смерти Путина полыхнет https://youtu.be/3G89MY-tNLU ШЕНДЕРОВИЧ: Фейковый Шойгу. Менты и полиция. Путин и народные вилы. Пугачева. Чардаш под Оренбургом https://youtu.be/tvaQYcZ_pOY ОРЕШКИН: Цена потопа – день войны. Шойгу vs экс-охранник Путина. Казахстан побеждает Россию https://youtu.be/Xr2zhgr_sJI АСЛАНЯН: Россияне заплатят по долгам АвтоВАЗа. ГАИ проболталась. Citroen вернулся в Россию https://youtu.be/ChwKdIlNeOI Нина ХРУЩЕВА: У Путина большие проблемы. Почему ИГИЛ устроил теракт в «Крокусе». Как Крым отошел Украине https://youtu.be/9qM8Hr0r2gw НЕМЦОВ: От преемника Ельцина — до врага Путина. Предсказание о войне с Украиной. Сахаров, Тэтчер https://youtu.be/AmUYMuAqvcI Шахерезада Кабаева. Наложница Путина, но не первая леди. Тело государственной важности / КЛИНИКА https://youtu.be/ZEhQ9-0n4d8 АСЛАНЯН: Теракт в «Крокусе»: как к нему готовились. Оружие и снаряжение. Анализ https://youtu.be/eN2iWA73jUo НЕВЗОРОВ: Кому выгоден теракт в «Крокусе»? Только Кремлю. Жизни людей — для Путина пустяк https://youtu.be/7nuA3OfO4lM ЛЕВА БИ-2: Тюрьма в Таиланде. Не сойти с ума. Впереди гражданская война. Путин. Земфира, БГ, Брат-2 https://youtu.be/paSWT7njeDI Блог Михаила Ходорковского: https://www.youtube.com/user/khodorkovskyru #США #война #Россия
Preparing download options
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players
Questions about downloading video
How can I download "Почему военная помощь США — не то, что надо. ФБК и мэр Орска. Плющев. Дунцова | Пастухов, Еловский" video?
http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.
Which format of "Почему военная помощь США — не то, что надо. ФБК и мэр Орска. Плющев. Дунцова | Пастухов, Еловский" video should I choose?
The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.
Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Почему военная помощь США — не то, что надо. ФБК и мэр Орска. Плющев. Дунцова | Пастухов, Еловский" video?
The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.
How can I download "Почему военная помощь США — не то, что надо. ФБК и мэр Орска. Плющев. Дунцова | Пастухов, Еловский" video to my phone?
You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.
How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Почему военная помощь США — не то, что надо. ФБК и мэр Орска. Плющев. Дунцова | Пастухов, Еловский"?
The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.
How can I save a frame from a video "Почему военная помощь США — не то, что надо. ФБК и мэр Орска. Плющев. Дунцова | Пастухов, Еловский"?
This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.
What's the price of all this stuff?
It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.