Download "Сложность израильского конфликта, атака по больнице, выборы/Венедиктов**: Будем Наблюдать //21.10.23"
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FFr3fkbdAI6I%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
Please wait. We're preparing links for easy ad-free video watching and downloading.
Table of contents
Similar videos from our catalog
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F4difTJZrGio%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F3lJebV6bcjc%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F4TZdP-q6YaA%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FBG9XKS-nQJY%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FG9y9HfB9TBU%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FS2mBHCIMAQk%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252Fh-4KzY17WA0%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FkZkiMIXMh3U%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252Fqpv6RCLd5Qk%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FtAfZoT6S4qg%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
Video tags
Subtitles
Russian
00:00:49
[music]00:01:12
Good afternoon, let's start our today00:01:14
We will watch for 2 hours until 14:0000:01:19
Yes, not everyone, not everyone, Maslenitsa, not everyone00:01:24
since we have Grigory Alekseevich Yavlinsky00:01:26
the question piles up to him how interesting00:01:29
will00:01:30
next time November 11 something like this 1100:01:34
November Yes on the day of the armistice after the Second00:01:36
peace after the First World War and there we have00:01:39
It’s almost like an anniversary. Yes, we have 10500:01:42
yo my friends here are the organizational ones00:01:45
question We still have Stream Yes00:01:47
now Yes we continue Stream you see00:01:50
those who are now watching in support of the living00:01:53
nail If you want you can00:01:55
list some donations you see00:01:57
what is there for this minute and you see00:02:01
in the upper left corner you can use the QR code00:02:03
foreign cards Or you can use Russian ones00:02:06
cards any donations any amounts small00:02:09
not very small not very small A00:02:12
we will continue collecting now because00:02:14
Yesterday in the night stream here are the ladies00:02:16
collected as much as we collected00:02:20
we will be grateful to you and I am already grateful00:02:22
to those who actively donated Stream yesterday00:02:26
so that at least maybe the end00:02:28
years to close our holes00:02:30
in any currency we accept it Thank you00:02:33
big Yes, of course we are not such young ladies00:02:36
how how we don’t count that much Yes00:02:39
Well, my friends, Well, we still have several00:02:43
how to subscribe to Dilettant because00:02:45
Russian Post doesn't accept something?00:02:47
does not accept yet We work with the Post Office00:02:49
Russia, we are trying to come to an agreement with it00:02:54
clear yes for now Well there is so Amateur Media00:02:56
You can buy anything there00:02:58
case and we always offer you all sorts of00:03:01
interesting things happen, interesting things happen00:03:05
soup interesting others We in general are not00:03:08
hold on Well let's start let's start here00:03:13
a lot has happened and it seems00:03:18
released00:03:20
hostage several or one two Yes00:03:23
two Well, this is a story with hostages who00:03:27
A hostage and American citizenship is00:03:32
that means US Secretary of State Blinken went to00:03:35
Qatar acted as a mediator, we know00:03:37
that Qatr is the main financier00:03:40
Hamas terrorist movement00:03:43
Hamas movement and as a result quite00:03:45
difficult negotiations00:03:48
which was reminded how he was saved in00:03:52
Iraqi time00:03:54
there was an attack00:04:00
memory for today00:04:02
day were00:04:11
pulled out by his American Israeli A00:04:15
Mom only has American citizenship00:04:17
in my opinion this is how it is somehow yes how is it00:04:19
the process is underway, I know that the French too00:04:21
they are trying to negotiate through the boat00:04:24
to get out the hostages who have00:04:27
and French citizenship then NPO00:04:30
citizenship I will remind you that this festival00:04:32
which was attacked where00:04:34
was 26000:04:36
young people from different countries were killed00:04:39
not necessarily with Israeli00:04:41
citizenship therefore many countries have them00:04:44
in my opinion about 30 Whose citizens are in00:04:47
hostages of Hamas and are in00:04:49
gas sector they are trying to00:04:51
hostages00:04:52
pull out00:04:54
so there are not only hostages there00:04:58
Hamas as I read and some others00:05:02
terrorist affiliates or00:05:04
independent organizations is true00:05:06
or how it is firstly I don’t know but00:05:09
secondly, you need to understand that the hostages are00:05:11
this is a product Yes and00:05:13
goods for sale resell00:05:17
and trades exchanges00:05:21
A00:05:22
forwarded yes and00:05:25
so maybe there is an Islamic one there00:05:28
jihad there are many different organizations Well00:05:32
they have some kind of offset Excuse me00:05:34
for this reason I don’t even doubt00:05:37
what could it be but specifically of course00:05:40
I don’t know there are hostages. And many00:05:44
are apparently in gas inside these00:05:47
endless tunnels, 130 of them00:05:50
I think today00:05:52
Israel estimates approximately00:05:53
Concreting tunnels Deep underground00:05:56
perhaps some have already been removed from00:05:59
Gas in order to00:06:01
bargaining is so very difficult00:06:03
delicate00:06:04
question but how do we see the process after all00:06:08
somehow went somehow but00:06:13
let's go00:06:15
Biden is or rather the White House there00:06:19
refuted the wishes of the United00:06:22
States as if expressed by Biden00:06:25
postpone the wish00:06:28
postpone ground operation in gas00:06:32
Well, I haven’t worked in Bely for a long time00:06:35
home so we see that the operation is not00:06:37
has begun Yes, we see the operation is not00:06:39
began and then what was there to refute?00:06:41
They say he didn't hear the question00:06:44
that of course carrying out ground00:06:48
the operation involves a huge00:06:49
number of victims as among terrorists00:06:53
both among the Israeli army and among00:06:56
the civilian population of gas is very raft00:06:59
development in cities, in particular the city00:07:01
Gaza There are very dense buildings and here00:07:04
this is a displacement of almost one and a half million00:07:07
residents yesterday the official figure was 100:07:10
400 and it indicates that people00:07:13
they are afraid of this ground operation Yes they are00:07:16
move south beyond the line that00:07:18
was drawn by the Israeli army all00:07:21
the issue of efficiency must be resolved00:07:24
military during the release of hostages00:07:27
destruction of Hamaz infrastructure and00:07:29
the destruction of those terrorists and bandits00:07:32
who attacked00:07:33
civilians How to save lives00:07:36
their soldiers, the life of hostages and the lives00:07:39
This problem does not concern civilians00:07:42
there is no good solution00:07:45
decisions00:07:46
guys and we will wait, I say absolutely00:07:49
cynically new victims yesterday's hit00:07:53
Izraq missiles00:07:58
this is Yes her in next to the Orthodox facade00:08:02
churches Yes where00:08:04
18 people died, as they say, yes, but00:08:09
there will be a lot of these things, but it’s necessary00:08:12
remember something else, you need to remember that00:08:14
that both Hamas and Hezbollah did not stop00:08:16
shell Israeli cities and every00:08:20
day every day again hundreds of missiles more00:08:23
times hundreds of missiles are flying at Israeli00:08:25
cities too Why are there no casualties because00:08:28
iron dome because these are all 2000:08:30
years Israel has invested as a state00:08:33
budget money in air defense00:08:35
defense of Hamas which was00:08:38
the state is practically not in gas00:08:39
invested money in protecting his00:08:41
population therefore reflect these missiles from00:08:45
and Hamas among the residents of Gaza I do not put up a sign00:08:48
equality but nevertheless it is one00:08:50
territory there is no way00:08:53
you also need to understand, I want to remind you that00:08:55
Stream continues and they go a little00:08:58
yes yes00:09:09
Thank you all this is there and all this is on the board00:09:12
collected yesterday00:09:13
spa weddings pla yesterday collected 25 mil00:09:18
for this second I see on my00:09:20
thank you is reflected on the screen00:09:23
great we continue during these00:09:26
one and a half hours for those who want it easy and00:09:29
just see the QR code on the left00:09:32
support this00:09:34
donation donation echo of Moscow donation00:09:37
living nail please join00:09:40
we are very grateful to you about the different00:09:42
aspects they write here in the chat Thank you for00:09:44
you write to us on business writes in chat about00:09:48
different aspects of difficulties00:09:51
related to Israel and the gas sector here00:09:56
starting is dangerous for many reasons not00:09:58
start Nope the situation is like this00:10:03
this consideration relates to the question of collective00:10:05
responsibility by the way, Hamas00:10:08
which declares as the main goal00:10:10
extermination of the Jews and Israel took power00:10:14
and got power in gas for 18 years who didn’t00:10:18
wanted goals left and who wanted came to00:10:21
during these 18 years what is absolutely00:10:24
not true, because if you talk about that00:10:27
Who came and left in Gaza? Nobody from Gaza.00:10:30
didn’t leave and couldn’t leave there was gas00:10:33
in the blockade from the outside first of all00:10:36
Arab countries because in many00:10:38
Arab countries Egypt00:10:41
Saudi Arabia Hamas is considered00:10:43
terrorist00:10:44
officially recognized by the organization00:10:46
terrorist organization where he went00:10:49
where did anyone want to go?00:10:53
where is where you know about whatever00:10:56
one Arabic00:10:58
wound00:11:01
actually European countries00:11:04
accept Ukrainians00:11:06
Arab countries do not accept refugees00:11:08
refugees from gas is also a fact00:11:12
will have to be taken into account00:11:16
everyone Because I repeat here again00:11:20
Hamas said it very carefully00:11:21
Hamas came to power came to power00:11:23
first in the elections and then as a result00:11:25
coup d'etat where were00:11:27
his opponents were destroyed, I remind you that00:11:29
Hamas received 44 votes in the elections and it00:11:32
political opponents of fatah 41 about it00:11:36
not too big a gap Yes but00:11:38
The Hamaz armed forces committed00:11:40
seventh year coup d'état00:11:42
killed Palestinian officials00:11:45
national administration of arafa tosp00:11:48
who managed to leave, who didn’t, their hands were cut off00:11:50
the legs were cooler, you can talk about them00:11:53
to say that who managed to leave, yes this is about00:11:55
them Yes absolutely true, let's do it anyway00:11:57
We at least paid more attention there00:12:00
To the events but I repeat once again00:12:03
divide Hamas and the Palestinian people of Gaza00:12:07
so I’m just as I was and remain00:12:10
opponent of collective responsibility00:12:12
but when military operations occur or00:12:14
Counter military operation civilian00:12:17
there have been and will be victims and the whole question00:12:20
proportionality of the response by whom is measured00:12:25
proportionality00:12:27
prona00:12:30
about beliefs please tell me in00:12:32
to what extent can we talk about that and00:12:35
somehow this is what can be calculated B00:12:37
Which00:12:38
to a degree, the inhabitants of Gaza are hostages of themselves00:12:42
Hamas Well the residents of the gas Propaganda00:12:45
education and so on Next, this is about anyone00:12:48
the state can be said this way00:12:50
Let me remind you once again that Hamas as a result00:12:53
adj as a result of government00:12:56
coup coup destroying00:12:59
their political Arab opponents00:13:01
and when00:13:03
Let me remind you once again that he is 18 years old00:13:07
back Israel unilaterally00:13:10
left the gas territory, not just left00:13:13
military Yes, they took the settlement with them00:13:15
not a centimeter00:13:17
And in the gas sector there is no land under00:13:21
occupation settlements or whatever00:13:24
there’s no way to tie anything down here, yes it is00:13:27
first story and second story all all00:13:30
all the latest events detonated with00:13:33
terrorist attack by Hamas and00:13:35
terrorist attack approximately00:13:37
Now it’s clear that it was about 3,00000:13:39
not a bad person, but at the same time breaking through00:13:42
in twenty-two places it means the border00:13:45
between Gaza and Israel and had00:13:50
instructions once again having instructions00:13:52
once again having instructions to kill00:13:55
civilians and take them hostage then00:13:58
there is no way to recapture some city there00:14:00
which is occupied by Sderot00:14:02
which Maxim Shevchenko is here for us00:14:04
said that this is ancient Arabic00:14:05
city but they didn’t enter it or rather00:14:07
they entered it and shot civilians00:14:10
they cut up the women and children and took them away00:14:12
hostages and00:14:13
gone yes Even if we follow Shevchenko’s logic00:14:17
I don’t walk on it, but nevertheless, but you00:14:19
wanted to liberate the city or cut00:14:21
there Who Well that's all00:14:23
And we also need to remember this, but good00:14:26
there will be no way out here and 15 years ago00:14:29
back Ehud Barak former prime minister00:14:33
there is also a person with whom I had to00:14:36
communicate about what is needed in order to00:14:39
gas might have been created00:14:43
administration from representatives of different00:14:45
Arabic00:14:46
states It was a proposal then00:14:49
Arafat and the Palestinian Authority00:14:51
hoping to regain control of the gas00:14:54
they refused, now there is talk again and00:14:58
USA Nasko I know suggests that in gas00:15:02
became the Civil Administration00:15:04
administration military administration of00:15:06
representatives of border states00:15:08
Jordan and Egypt they don't want00:15:12
understand what they get they don't want00:15:14
not Jordan nor Egypt this is actually00:15:18
really big problem How to be there00:15:21
we need to build a right of way right there00:15:23
The question arises: On whose territory?00:15:26
Ilida territory already has some military00:15:29
they say let's do it00:15:35
two-acid, that is, the children there are not children00:15:37
Do not cross this line Yes question B00:15:40
which direction now then if in00:15:42
towards gas is occupation aside00:15:44
Israel I will remind you that when they say00:15:46
on the evacuation of gas residents from the North00:15:49
northern part I will remind you that Israel00:15:51
evacuates its citizens in the same way00:15:53
way from the border00:15:56
cities in the north where shelling is taking place00:15:59
hils from the territory of Lebanon and here in the south00:16:02
where there are shelling from gas, there too00:16:04
approximately 400,000 have moved00:16:07
people in total were forced from the North00:16:09
and move from the south because of the shelling Well, that’s it00:16:12
400,000 is still not one and a half00:16:14
Milna or there Absolutely right. How are you?00:16:17
you will assume that we have processes00:16:21
I want you to understand that this is a whole00:16:23
I see the process was very00:16:26
big donation I mean you're 5000:16:29
yes I'm very grateful I don't see whose but I00:16:31
grateful Thank you very much I'm there00:16:34
Thank you very much to everyone who writes here00:16:36
there's someone there00:16:38
5,000 sent for someone and someone for coffee00:16:42
for coffee yes that's good too thanks coffee00:16:45
also needed especially by our producers00:16:47
we're talking about our people here00:16:49
He's probably young and deeply mistaken.00:16:51
says there are no Sergeevs except me00:16:54
We didn’t have Sergeev, but that’s somehow00:16:57
yes Korzun00:17:00
through four Sergei they created Echo of Moscow00:17:03
Sergei Korzun Sergei rebel Sergei00:17:05
fanton and Sergei Ignatov chief00:17:07
sound engineer00:17:30
murders of Hamam Russians and captured people00:17:33
Russians So Vladimi I don’t know where00:17:38
view Vladimir Vladimirovich in00:17:41
in a conversation with Netanyahu expressed00:17:43
condolences and sympathies to the Israeli00:17:46
there was a telephone call to the people and the Prime Minister00:17:48
conversation official message What about00:17:51
look, I don’t remember that I said this separately00:17:54
pro-Russian citizens00:17:57
I know that negotiations are underway about00:18:00
liberation this I know are underway Yes00:18:02
are underway Yes, I know they are underway and00:18:06
directly and again through00:18:08
intermediaries Well, all this talk is what00:18:11
don't talk to terrorists00:18:13
Of course, complete [ __ ] always happens through00:18:16
negotiations between intermediaries and sometimes directly00:18:20
and we saw how Americans who did not00:18:22
talking to terrorists now00:18:24
through intermediaries Kara and they are no longer00:18:27
hide00:18:29
this is very00:18:30
roo were able to00:18:33
release two hostages from 203 but00:18:37
In general, it seems to me that now it is very00:18:39
highly emotional00:18:43
the death of Israeli civilians is like00:18:47
I would say it passes and hardens Yes00:18:51
c Here comes high nationality from death00:18:55
civilians in Gaza00:18:57
also means high emotionality00:18:59
remain00:19:01
hostages00:19:03
and this is this I think that now now00:19:06
maybe tomorrow it will be different00:19:09
the knot should begin to untie precisely from00:19:12
hostage release knot I have in00:19:14
type of escalation is not a relationship node but a node00:19:16
escalation then we can talk00:19:19
otherwise there people hold each other there by00:19:21
throat yes00:19:23
and it’s quite difficult to talk then00:19:27
compress00:19:30
sickness How it is now lined up according to00:19:33
analysis of what happened and how00:19:35
it is covered and how materials are presented00:19:39
What is the picture now emerging? Well, I00:19:42
I’ll repeat what I said yesterday at Ira’s and00:19:46
Max look Yes there are all kinds00:19:51
statements koto can be trusted neri question00:19:54
beliefs00:19:57
ladies responded with a statement such and such But this00:20:01
crime killed people00:20:05
Let's record this as a crime story00:20:07
people died in criminal history00:20:09
there must be material evidence in addition to00:20:12
statements beyond analysis Yes there should be00:20:15
material evidence we see e evidence00:20:17
direct well material material we00:20:21
we see these material evidence in place00:20:23
crimes that are going on we see00:20:25
very small00:20:27
funnel 3000:20:29
see We see that the hospital has walls00:20:33
are standing roofs are standing ceilings are standing00:20:35
Some windows are broken, it's bad, everything's bad00:20:39
nevertheless00:20:40
And we We don’t see neither presented nor00:20:43
one rocket fragment, not one part00:20:47
to even determine what kind of rocket it is00:20:49
where are they all they are not there I am watching We00:20:52
we see that they are roaming around the crime scene00:20:54
people just like that, that is, she doesn’t even00:20:56
fenced off, that is, everything is flooded there. What00:20:59
It's not called traces of people, but traces00:21:02
so all those00:21:04
the charges that were brought00:21:06
They are not confirmed to Israel by anything00:21:11
just nothing material statement yes00:21:13
statement these are people who believe Let and00:21:15
they believe and of course here00:21:18
surprise Doctors Without Borders who00:21:21
today the organization said yes00:21:24
that we were too quick to blame Israel00:21:27
but what does it mean to find out that this is not Israel?00:21:31
Wait, do you have any00:21:33
Evidence00:21:35
Evidence is a criminal act that00:21:38
accuse Israel of any00:21:40
There is no evidence, well, that is, an accusation00:21:44
was Israel if you are any lawyer there00:21:47
these people would be blown apart in one second00:21:49
present There is no evidence as of today00:21:55
de00:21:57
pov if they really died there00:21:59
civilians Yes and according to the assessment00:22:03
American and French intelligence services there00:22:06
a hundred people died, could have died00:22:09
could have died, I’ll say it again because00:22:12
not a single name is given if in00:22:15
Israel I can give you everything by name00:22:17
a number that few people know means00:22:20
death toll estimate00:22:21
More than 144,800 have already been identified00:22:25
hard work00:22:28
more than 800 dead established00:22:31
dead through00:22:33
DNA00:22:34
special at a military camp yes00:22:37
laboratories are open, drove there where it goes00:22:40
this is where volunteers work and so on00:22:43
once again if we treat it like00:22:45
crime must be00:22:47
It is proven not only what is stated, but also00:22:50
It has been proven and unfortunately such cases00:22:52
will be repeated regarding00:22:55
information It seems to me that00:22:59
this shift in focus is not well illuminated00:23:01
again the lighting is wrong And today in our00:23:04
the morning spread was about Seryozha very much00:23:06
interesting I listened to him Maxim Ira00:23:10
arranged, should we consider what if00:23:14
people if the media explain why Hamas is like this00:23:18
comes then it gets sided00:23:21
Hamas meaning is it necessary?00:23:24
explain motives00:23:26
motives are approximately as I hear00:23:30
I say And here's to you00:23:33
61% of our viewers disagree with this00:23:36
positions a 39 nevertheless counting 4000:23:39
agree with this00:23:43
position Yes more than a third Yes 2/5 therefore on00:23:48
actually people are different again00:23:50
I repeat that the main role here is played00:23:52
beliefs, not facts, the story is00:23:56
in my opinion, what if before the facts00:23:59
Yes, you collected the facts to accept00:24:01
solution Yes, create a solution now00:24:03
accepted first and the facts you are looking for00:24:07
confirm already existing beliefs00:24:10
this is very bad and I don't like it at all00:24:14
I agree with these different kinds00:24:17
statements to understand means to forgive it00:24:19
the whole declaration is all [ __ ] Yes, if you00:24:22
don't understand why this happens00:24:26
disease00:24:28
besides the fact that this is a crime00:24:30
disease Well, they study the motives of serial00:24:34
the crime must be studied the disease must be treated00:24:38
choose methods to treat00:24:40
treatment where surgically And where00:24:43
therapeutically And where it seems that00:24:45
This is a disease. Yes, we need to study what it causes.00:24:48
took it Well, yes, if the maniac was unhappy00:24:51
there's a boy in the family and you know it's not00:24:54
means that00:24:56
you shoot and you can put it in00:24:59
a psychiatric clinic is two different things00:25:02
with criminals So that means we need to study00:25:05
There is no place to put this question. But the question is for00:25:07
to what needs to be studied, let me remind you that we have00:25:10
Stream continues Thank you very much00:25:12
you participate in it, you see it on your00:25:15
screens tape like we already have there00:25:18
growing up we're moving towards 3 million00:25:21
which we have set a task and ask you00:25:25
support us see the code on the left00:25:28
If you point you can with Russian00:25:30
cards from a foreign card, send any00:25:32
amount again any amount and for any00:25:35
amount thank you00:25:37
Yes, try again with someone's shadows00:25:40
doesn’t read the QR code Well look, they send it00:25:44
send carefully wipe the window I00:25:47
I would say wipe the window or if you have00:25:49
God forbid there is a VPN, in this case it00:25:52
maybe not reading happens and so I would now00:25:56
paused for a second00:25:58
We have a video there and after that I00:26:01
one of the simply very important books00:26:06
I wish you an important person once again00:26:08
introduced let's talk about it and then00:26:10
let's continue I even know where we started00:26:16
let's start with a live guest staying in Moscow and00:26:19
brings you daily news00:26:21
we collect the agenda for00:26:26
cast you could always see the situation00:26:29
in the world from different sides, support us in00:26:31
this is a difficult time for us to00:26:33
develop and further how to do it00:26:35
follow the link below the broadcast or00:26:37
Use the code to leave your00:26:41
Donat We have a paradoxical00:26:45
situation It's not just because00:26:48
will remain in history Well Vladimir00:26:50
Borisovich You are just like a child00:26:52
there are better means of defense00:26:56
There is not00:26:57
[music]00:27:00
we don’t live in Russia just like that forever00:27:03
there must be some mission for which00:27:06
you can die this is who00:27:08
proved00:27:11
[music]00:27:13
female I want to offer you a book00:27:16
which author which is just my very00:27:19
a good friend and in general our friend00:27:21
Alexander golts is a wonderful specialist00:27:25
military construction analyst00:27:27
situation and he survived the cold war00:27:32
this is a very important book because it is very00:27:35
a lot of muti has been written about cold00:27:38
the war was and of course touching00:27:41
intelligent Alexander Golts wrote00:27:44
you a postcard to everyone who purchases this00:27:47
book from the author extremely touched by the00:27:50
that you found the book interesting00:27:53
and signed by Alexander Golts Yes, we have it00:27:58
The book costs 2500 rubles shop Dilettant00:28:01
Media but don't forget what's in it00:28:05
meaning and Sasha Golts also with her00:28:08
with pleasure and conveys it to us because00:28:11
he understands that this also helps Eh00:28:14
to a living nail here00:28:15
and we will be very grateful to you for00:28:19
pleasure and intellectual you00:28:22
gain a lot of experience in diplomacy00:28:25
By the way, the experience here is negative and00:28:28
positive I'm sorry it took me so long00:28:31
I advertise the wonderful Sasha Golts00:28:34
plus here you are00:28:36
you see there is also an endless duplicate00:28:39
mirror corridor where it is duplicated00:28:41
cover of Amateur just released00:28:45
The Iron Chancellor is00:28:49
Bismarck I remind you from myself this is Bismarck00:28:53
this is a very interesting story But besides00:28:58
topics as always main I by the way00:29:01
I always rush to read what’s around me00:29:05
what's around? For example, was there an Anschluss?00:29:08
GDR Here it is Yes, this is what it is00:29:13
authors scatter00:29:16
the notorious textbook here, let's00:29:19
there are a lot of friends here00:29:21
relevant around except the topic which00:29:24
always deep and interesting except00:29:27
main topic A I would like to start00:29:31
continuing here00:29:33
talk talk about talk here00:29:37
a man who called himself an aristarch00:29:39
Iosifovich00:29:40
nagla 26 years old we already know everything and how00:29:44
talk to relatives who are convinced00:29:46
is that Israel00:29:48
oppress talking is no less difficult00:29:51
What about theirs who are also them00:29:54
supported Well, according to the facts, it’s not necessary00:29:57
generally oppress who when whom what00:30:01
oppress with the hospital Here's this story00:30:05
And00:30:06
you understand there is a story with00:30:08
terrorist attack Here you are00:30:12
look at how many wars there are00:30:15
was carried out and who attacked the year forty-eight00:30:20
who attacked soro nine attacked00:30:22
Israel or Israel attacked its own00:30:25
his neighbors attacked him00:30:27
next war and this year who00:30:32
Israel attacked its neighbors or five00:30:35
Arab countries attacked Israel00:30:38
next war sede year three war00:30:41
Doomsday who attacked whom in the year00:30:44
Israel attacks Lebanon What?00:30:46
something happened specifically for this purpose00:30:51
prepare for back talk00:30:56
relatives they sincerely believe that00:30:58
they say they are not relatives00:31:00
propagandists are you sitting at lunch?00:31:04
were there war crimes with00:31:07
Israeli side killing peaceful00:31:09
Of course there were populations. This is war.00:31:13
war is impossible without the military00:31:15
crimes in00:31:17
in terms of how war crimes have already00:31:20
interpreted by the Geneva Conventions with XX00:31:23
century because before the 20th century what is now00:31:27
called war crimes00:31:29
in custom Yes, in custom, that was the story in00:31:33
during the Hundred Years' War when A English00:31:37
king or rather black prince00:31:40
The heir was the customs of war means00:31:43
capture of knights enemies hostages and00:31:47
compulsory ransom ransom - it was00:31:49
rule and here is the black prince after one00:31:52
from battles or Henry V I don't remember this00:31:54
Henry V after before anku00:31:58
interrupted00:31:59
captives and from the point of view of those centuries this00:32:04
was a war crime Well there you go00:32:06
concept of war crime in XX and XX00:32:09
century - this is the Geneva Convention00:32:10
porono Because before If it was00:32:13
concept and sort of such a custom by the way and00:32:17
now there is a violation of the customs of war too00:32:21
the Geneva ones are now codified00:32:23
conventions which by the way00:32:26
signed00:32:27
most states Yes, they recognize00:32:30
this is a violation yes, they said that00:32:33
this is it00:32:36
violation of the customs of war rules of war00:32:39
crimes based on this00:32:42
talk like that in my opinion yes00:32:46
by the way, here about how to talk you00:32:49
must be able to have capable00:32:52
have information to answer00:32:56
call00:32:57
Well, you should know this well00:33:00
examples of frequently asked questions I00:33:03
just now I see in our00:33:08
chat means isn't it00:33:11
it's about00:33:14
liberation of occupied territories00:33:17
contrary to UN decisions, isn’t it just easier00:33:20
liberate the territory Don't go because00:33:24
here is the territory that was designated00:33:27
for the Palestinian state in particular00:33:29
Sector00:33:30
Gaza which was in soro PTO after the war00:33:34
captured since 201000:33:36
by whom00:33:38
Egypt Egypt and 21 years it was under00:33:43
Egypt then really after the war00:33:46
six of this year she was captured00:33:50
Israel is correct. Then speak to00:33:53
within 10 years past the Yom Kippur War00:33:57
the process between Egypt and Israel has begun00:34:01
Egypt recognized Israel's right to00:34:03
existence within the boundaries of 484 years Yes00:34:07
and then Israel leaves in the fifth year if00:34:10
we are talking about this from these territories00:34:12
Yes, live there and do Hamas00:34:15
health care system of air defense because00:34:18
Your neighbor is crazy Israel like us00:34:21
iron dome they say from their post00:34:25
Kupo left the territory once again left and00:34:29
this is a very long process because00:34:32
let's say from the west coast not quite yet00:34:34
gone there is still there00:34:36
settlements Yes there are colonies there00:34:41
bases But this is a gradual process and so00:34:44
this terrorist attack is not for00:34:46
liberation of lands and the west bank00:34:48
after all, I was near Jordan, near Jordan, yes00:34:51
near Jordan but also after sixty00:34:53
seventh year Yes but nevertheless00:34:57
agreement between Israel and Arafah00:35:00
Volume between terrorist and terrorist00:35:03
you know when begin prime minister00:35:05
Israel who was also a terrorist00:35:07
committed attack A before release00:35:09
Israel to English posts which Yes and00:35:12
when they told Him but you are the same00:35:13
terrorist like Arafat Begin answered yes I am00:35:16
a terrorist and he's a bandit Well, yes Well, here we go00:35:19
but nevertheless we agreed for a second00:35:22
agreed and were km David00:35:24
there really was an agreement there and Perez was there00:35:27
the process proceeded and began to transmit00:35:29
Palestinian Authority00:35:31
autonomy Yes, and they began to give weapons00:35:35
Palestinian police and began to withdraw00:35:38
some colonies are a process and then in00:35:41
the Arab countries responded to this00:35:43
recognize the right00:35:46
Israel on the existence of the boundaries of the case00:35:49
then in principle he has the right00:35:51
the existence of a Jewish state00:35:52
these territories or not about the border00:35:54
let's talk about Egypt and Jordan and Bahrain00:35:59
Yes United Arab Emirates Yes Morocco Yes and00:36:02
there should have been Saudi Arabia more00:36:05
there was an agreement between the Palestinian00:36:08
administration between Araf Tom and then00:36:11
Mahmud Abbasov and Israel's Hamas when00:36:13
came to power and said we are not00:36:15
we admit Israel must be destroyed00:36:17
not a single Jew should remain00:36:19
our land That is, it actually tore00:36:24
Well Hamas Yes he did not recognize yes yes yes00:36:27
tore Yes, here are the historical facts00:36:30
look through Wikipedia if nothing else00:36:32
you can’t look through it on different00:36:36
languages Yes, and be prepared to often00:36:39
asked like this00:36:43
questions about the territory of Israel all00:36:45
increased this is also a frequently asked question00:36:47
question but this is how it decreases00:36:49
if they left the gas that's all Well00:36:53
let's take a ruler and see where it comes from00:36:55
Israel leaves00:36:57
They left Sinai, I will remind you that in this00:37:01
year the Israeli army repelling the attack Yes00:37:05
captured00:37:06
Sinai and then gradually thanks00:37:09
agreements with Egypt signing00:37:11
peace agreement, Israel withdraws from00:37:14
Sinaia leaves with00:37:17
Sinai liberates occupied territories00:37:20
given this do it howl am00:37:24
agreements in00:37:27
one of the frequently asked questions is why00:37:30
it didn't work out in 4 years it didn't work out00:37:33
Palestinian state Well because00:37:35
they didn't want to because there was no00:37:37
Palestinian state Arab00:37:39
the countries didn't want them. They didn't want them there either.00:37:42
Israel They wanted there they wanted00:37:44
he did not allow them to divide this territory and00:37:48
they went to conquer this territory00:37:50
Palestine Israel which by resolution00:37:53
should have been stripped since it's Arab00:37:57
states Yes without recognizing the UN resolution00:38:01
let's go conquer these lands00:38:04
Palestinian state what00:38:06
a Palestinian state they said00:38:08
Arab countries we are all Palestinians we are in00:38:11
Palestine what other state00:38:14
why the extra Israel and the extra00:38:17
a Palestinian state won't help00:38:19
it worked out and then one came who00:38:24
To you our chat visitor from Vladivostok00:38:28
but you will have to answer at sixty00:38:30
in the seventh year Israel itself attacked00:38:35
No00:38:38
no it was on political information00:38:41
There is no Soviet school, read What00:38:46
it happened like this00:38:49
Ah, look, now00:38:54
oh well00:38:59
and here00:39:02
Is it true that a candidate like00:39:05
Venediktova will be Remchukov I mean, well00:39:09
yeah, that's who this Vedik guy is00:39:12
Venediktov is not a candidate anywhere00:39:15
so like Venediktov is going nowhere00:39:17
where from Please forgive me00:39:22
for comparison from chemistry lessons yeast in00:39:25
toilet00:39:26
well two From the point it was first00:39:29
presidential administration through the newspaper00:39:34
statements reported that they00:39:36
they are considering the possibility there in the Kremlin00:39:38
propose to me as a foreigner00:39:40
Excellent for the agent, but in order to mean00:39:43
become a candidate for00:39:45
candidates So this is not the case with me00:39:47
discussed and I publicly When it was00:39:50
it says I'm not interested00:39:52
That was all, then Alexey00:39:54
Anatolyevich Navalny Or those who inserted00:39:56
my last name in the description Yes put me00:40:01
to vote Although even before that I00:40:03
said I'm not interested00:40:04
meaningless story That's where the trembling comes from00:40:10
they asked in the toilet did you see00:40:13
How many Palestinian children have been killed?00:40:17
conflict first00:40:20
saw00:40:22
saw and they will continue to die00:40:25
as well as00:40:27
precisely because Hamas chose the military00:40:32
point00:40:33
conflict Hamas chose a military point00:40:38
conflict00:40:40
how many civilians00:40:43
people of Nazi Germany00:40:47
died How many from00:40:50
bombing during the Red advance00:40:52
Armies from one Rhône of the Allies00:40:55
sgo00:40:58
Hitler chose a point00:41:00
conflict is not England00:41:03
attacked this is not the Soviet Union attacked this00:41:06
Shiya Germany00:41:08
attacked Although as they wrote and that’s why I00:41:12
I say00:41:13
what's in charge00:41:17
beneficiary of the death of the Hitler regime00:41:20
It's German00:41:22
Khoi people00:41:25
we see the cue00:41:27
people Yes, I say this, yes this is the main one00:41:31
beneficiary and at the same time00:41:34
also, of course, if00:41:37
read German and Soviet newspapers00:41:41
thirty-nine then this is England and00:41:44
France announced something else about this00:41:46
Now they were asking about Mirnoe about the death00:41:49
civilians And what different people write00:41:52
people then at the moment it's completely different00:41:55
story00:41:57
Denis, 23 years old, history teacher, you know00:42:00
his00:42:01
yes yes Satanovsky said that Zakharova is in00:42:05
basically doesn’t particularly like Jews and Israel00:42:07
can't stand it and doesn't particularly like it00:42:09
hides it like he had a fight with him for this00:42:12
Solovyov when I talked with Maria00:42:15
Zakharova I’m not behind her00:42:18
noticed but our mit in00:42:24
in general the VM saves00:42:27
continuity of the Soviet Foreign Ministry which00:42:31
I didn’t really like Israel at first00:42:33
sixty this00:42:34
years and in this sense in this sense00:42:38
probably Satanovsky00:42:40
rights00:42:44
always Soviet power then Russian00:42:46
power Well in a very short period no00:42:49
made a bet on the Arab states and00:42:53
Now00:42:55
attention00:42:57
struggle in Africa in the Middle East in00:43:00
Latin America it was logic against00:43:03
traditional states of the Soviet Union00:43:06
relied on what he called00:43:08
national liberation war00:43:10
within this national liberation00:43:12
struggle and we saw this during the CPSU process00:43:15
where did you read the documents Yes in deno deno VM00:43:19
years we have seen support for individual00:43:23
there are not many terrorist movements00:43:26
only in the Middle East and not only in00:43:28
Africa But00:43:29
say the Irish Republican Army00:43:32
Documents are money given00:43:34
A00:43:37
let's say Red00:43:39
army in Germany to the red brigades in00:43:43
Italy to the red front in Japan was00:43:47
special department of the Central Committee of the PSS Yes Soviet00:43:50
The Union believed that in this way it was00:43:53
imperialist countries which and00:43:56
supported naturally this00:43:57
anti-colonial and terrorist00:44:00
domestic movement00:44:01
and terrorist movements within00:44:05
And the imperialist countries themselves00:44:07
believes that this strengthens and weakens them00:44:10
means it strengthens it and this is Heritage00:44:13
it hasn't gone anywhere it hasn't gone anywhere I00:44:16
I mean ideologically, but it’s nowhere00:44:19
nothing happened, false passports were printed00:44:22
it's all in the documents it's there00:44:23
represented at the trial against the CPSU00:44:26
brought money in suitcases through00:44:28
diplomatic channels yes exactly00:44:33
terrorist organization in any way00:44:34
case, I remember very well what I read00:44:36
everything related to terrorist00:44:38
organizations in Western Europe and Japan00:44:42
so it’s not surprising that Maria00:44:46
Vladimirovna Zakharova and Russian mit00:44:48
inherited this hereditary disease00:44:51
considering that something that weakens means00:44:53
it's good for us yes it's true it's00:44:57
so true and personal Elizabeth00:45:02
insult00:45:04
which Satanovsky expressed to00:45:07
Zakharova So you ask why I don’t00:45:10
I bring them because I don’t bring them00:45:13
in general And what does this add? We’re talking about00:45:17
We're talking about politics00:45:20
policy And that Lavrov is pursuing a different one00:45:23
what does Zakharova say about politics?00:45:28
and that Rekov is pursuing a different policy00:45:30
No, what are we going to do with weight gain?00:45:37
habits00:45:41
Rafaela asks What if suddenly00:45:44
will be handed over00:45:45
personal request from Supreme Venediktov00:45:50
sit on the throne00:45:54
Here's Teach's answer as they say no00:45:58
interested That's it00:46:02
pragmatic answer And by the way exactly like this00:46:05
Dmitry Muratov did not give the same answer00:46:08
interested where it was written Who is who00:46:10
Yes and who is there not quite Yes and so on00:46:13
This is not all00:46:15
listen with interest00:46:17
always when you are given personal information00:46:21
a request from someone yes you should ask a00:46:26
what kind do I have00:46:27
tools that's when they asked to accept00:46:31
participation in the exchange of Ukrainian sailors00:46:35
Ukrainian sailors in 191900:46:38
And I said, I can do this00:46:41
if only I have the fullest possible00:46:44
and no one will interfere, neither the Foreign Ministry nor the FSB00:46:47
neither the SVR nor the presidential administration Yes00:46:50
I myself know how to do it00:46:52
it will work out maybe not with me then00:46:54
agreed00:46:55
and then we00:46:57
changed You see, this is always like this00:47:01
Because if they offered me now00:47:02
relatively speaking, deal with hostages00:47:04
told me what tools I would have00:47:06
What powers do I have, otherwise you’re walking around like00:47:09
impostor Yes impostor, how are you?00:47:12
people should talk00:47:14
understand what you have00:47:16
powers00:47:17
therefore not00:47:22
interested A00:47:24
V00:47:27
yesterday agreements were concluded between00:47:30
government00:47:32
Izi is completely sl so it is a whole00:47:36
ruler but you see Let's go back to00:47:38
how to conquer this place00:47:41
look we have a situation today00:47:43
which exists today it certainly has00:47:46
there's a tail behind you, but it's all the same00:47:49
what can you say, you are now repeating Putin00:47:52
these are Russians00:47:54
territories00:47:56
this is Yerevan, Azerbaijani city of Serzha00:47:58
Receive and sign Yes, what are you doing?00:48:01
no signature where and where wait and where and where00:48:06
English King Charles II who should00:48:08
claim rights00:48:10
to the North American colonies And where00:48:13
French macron which is on Luzina00:48:15
must present listen Well stop it00:48:17
this is what we have today we have today00:48:19
hot phase of the conflict Yes we are today00:48:22
we have a sharp shift00:48:24
temperatures today we can have00:48:26
fatal outcome today we need this00:48:30
treat and then you are calm00:48:33
sit down at the table and talk00:48:36
about the status of people about the citizenship of people as00:48:41
Hong Kong was remember how Hong Kong was and then00:48:45
not the best story but still00:48:47
but nevertheless 99 years yes And they thought that00:48:51
will resolve, will not resolve, well, that means it needs to00:48:53
was concluded at 19900:48:56
What a story, now remember00:48:59
there is the kingdom of David and the construction of the temple00:49:02
Solomon On the one hand and there and on the other00:49:04
I don’t know the other side there tita00:49:08
Emperor's destruction of the temple Yes, well, well00:49:10
listen, it's true, it's true00:49:13
Leave it to the historians and tell me00:49:16
please who is the legal successor now00:49:19
Nebuchadnezzar Iraq Yes no there no no00:49:24
such a people00:49:27
Well, there are Assyrians, but there are a lot of them00:49:31
there are few of them00:49:33
no it happens in history they can’t be removed00:49:36
their00:49:38
name00:49:41
speak fell00:49:43
asks here and note what’s wrong with the camp00:49:48
Arab world of Palestine territory00:49:50
admitted00:49:52
resolution00:49:54
SPON Palestine is needed less by the West or00:49:58
Arabs What is Palestine? Where is Palestine?00:50:02
the authorities are terrorist00:50:03
organizations that attack and kill00:50:06
leaders of the Palestinian national00:50:08
administration Yes Muslim Brothers They00:50:12
those who attack the Egyptian00:50:14
President Yes, what is Palestine? What is it?00:50:17
Palestine now But then in the World Cup00:50:22
The World Cup itself00:50:24
strategists00:50:28
political interest00:50:30
sponsors Hamas In my opinion00:50:32
is that they shouldn't00:50:35
allow for a new balancing of forces when00:50:38
Saudi Arabia first Yes00:50:41
together with the USA and Israel constitute00:50:44
triangle of stability in the Middle00:50:46
East then their role is reduced to zero00:50:50
and we see00:50:54
SPON of the Hamas consul who see that00:50:57
they will simply lose both influence and money00:51:00
who will invest in others00:51:03
water supply and not00:51:05
rockets I will repeat again no one mine00:51:08
Version not yet verified Moreover00:51:10
some are even respected Arab leaders00:51:14
she was supported for example00:51:17
brother of the Saudi king, former head00:51:20
intelligence00:51:21
the tour said it right He said it was00:51:25
aimed at disrupting the Saudi agreement00:51:28
Arabia is a terrorist attack00:51:30
was politically aimed at disrupting00:51:32
Saudi Arabia's agreement with Israel00:51:34
and the USA, this is what the former boss said00:51:37
Saudi Arabian intelligence brother of the king00:51:40
Prince's uncle Bin Salman And this is already00:51:42
strategic goal to disrupt disrupt00:51:44
these negotiations because00:51:46
will change the picture Yes, I think that in00:51:48
this Listen, I’ll say it again now00:51:50
now again now you will explode there00:51:52
chat Yes I have00:51:54
payment planners who are political00:51:57
did this Hamas attack they couldn't help but00:52:00
understand how Israel will respond first00:52:03
pushed Hamas to plan this attack00:52:05
these young people00:52:07
Yes fanatical young people and knew that00:52:10
they will00:52:12
destroyed I speak by Hamas00:52:15
young terrorists fell on the territory00:52:18
Israel It's not in Gaza yet, it's right in00:52:21
now it continues but they dragged in and00:52:24
wow00:52:26
they know that the government is right00:52:29
Netanyahu can only answer this way00:52:32
only by mass bombing only00:52:35
destruction of Hamas as an infrastructure and00:52:38
then it discards All agreements 2100:52:41
of the Arab countries condemned Israel 2100:52:45
from 2 yes So this discards Mirny00:52:51
the process it makes a ditch on the ladies wok go you00:52:56
you have no right to say they are brilliant00:52:57
They00:52:58
Evil can be ingenious It is ingenious00:53:01
pure chemical evil was sacrificed00:53:04
Hamas is not a tear00:53:06
fell, sacrificing more or less stable00:53:10
relationships process process00:53:13
stabilization in the Middle East But00:53:15
We maintain the key role of Iran and Qatar00:53:19
where did Damn rush when he got into the car?00:53:22
where does macron call in car00:53:27
returns his00:53:28
the role of these guys is very serious00:53:33
ve In the sense that this is the redistribution of the Middle00:53:36
East and that means the world and that means the world00:53:39
because both the Saudis and the boat are a long time ago00:53:42
European American players Iran00:53:46
natural00:53:47
That's why horses00:53:54
planning goals have so far been achieved as00:53:58
there are brilliant robbers with a plan00:54:00
their genius is the word brilliant00:54:02
usually have a positive connotation I want00:54:04
just say these are terrorists no00:54:06
Professor Moriarty was with me by the way00:54:08
once a collection from the BBC When Echo still existed00:54:13
a Therefore00:54:16
there was a dispute over the naming00:54:18
terrorists, I understand why they are not00:54:21
called terrorists00:54:24
and until a certain time Irish00:54:27
the republican army which blew up00:54:29
their own English soldiers and00:54:33
civilians died Lord Mouton00:54:35
And their logic was that the word00:54:39
terrorist negatively colored our00:54:42
smart listeners will figure it out themselves, it’s us00:54:45
we can’t name but our guests call00:54:48
Our guests call but editorial00:54:49
politics but journalists shouldn't00:54:52
call Yes because they are emotional00:54:54
militants Yes, separatists but not terrorists00:54:58
I said that Guys, please explain to me00:55:00
terrorist attack is legal legal00:55:03
thing is a conscious choice of victims like00:55:07
civil yes When you00:55:10
attacks talking militants in my opinion00:55:13
Well we discussed Yes we discussed freely00:55:16
but when they attack the maternity hospital00:55:18
these are terrorists but here are the borders00:55:20
Well, roughly speaking, they disagreed here00:55:22
and now it has turned into a scandal00:55:25
again but I know that it’s literally in00:55:28
they have already begun to call the latter Eto00:55:30
terrorists because my logic and00:55:32
the logic of the journalists of the echo of Moscow there Volodya00:55:34
Varfolomeeva Yes, in particular, she was in that00:55:37
which by the way was an argument between me and Valeria00:55:40
Novodvorskaya00:55:41
When00:55:43
Budenovsk And when I said this00:55:46
they are terrorists, you can call them00:55:49
freedom fighters until the moment when00:55:53
they attack the barracks00:55:55
and not a maternity hospital, a terrorist can00:55:58
Kalyaev was called a freedom fighter00:56:01
he was already called a terrorist00:56:03
comrade means here I am saying How00:56:07
a journalist and not a comrade. Yes, there are a lot of them00:56:11
people and a lot of people a lot00:56:16
of people00:56:18
which means they sympathized00:56:22
the Chechens their liberator whose struggle00:56:26
Bombed by the Russian army I was in Grozny00:56:28
At ninety four I saw what was destroyed00:56:30
that's all, and a huge number died there00:56:33
civilians but no one could00:56:36
sympathize with the people who then00:56:38
sympathized after Budyonov after00:56:41
capture of the maternity hospital Yes, they offered themselves in00:56:45
hostages to these terrorists once again00:56:48
I emphasize00:56:50
terrorist in order for them to release00:56:52
they were called terrorists00:56:56
ri because terror is00:57:01
the way was Ours00:57:03
the dispute is quite so serious with00:57:06
head of the BBC when I'm there somewhere in00:57:10
in the middle I told them you know when00:57:12
it was I remembered it was after the explosion in00:57:14
the metro in the fifth year, in my opinion, is brilliant Well, this is00:57:17
Well, what kind of terrorists are they? We know who they are00:57:20
that's it then00:57:21
Noni was hit by peace00:57:25
They just hit00:57:28
citizens This is not military action This is00:57:32
it’s not the minds that arrived unintentionally00:57:35
a rocket is also very bad this is also00:57:39
the dead need sympathy but they00:57:42
were not selected00:57:44
purpose, I always talk about their intent00:57:48
terrorists who were not targeted00:57:50
came to Israel and chose the goal00:57:52
civilians are terrorists who00:57:54
bombed the London Underground or00:57:57
station in Spain or September 11th they00:58:02
they chose civilian00:58:05
the population is the civilian population00:58:07
that's not collateral damage that's exactly what it's not00:58:10
side effects therefore to the question of00:58:12
terms to the question about the term Tell me00:58:15
please story from BBC While we are00:58:16
talked about the story from the BBC and the sick series00:58:21
also a big scandal Well, that's what I'm talking about00:58:23
said00:58:25
was there before the story already started there00:58:28
it’s even worse Seryozha the story is00:58:30
is that we, no matter how strange it sounds00:58:32
we are00:58:33
discussed with the information director00:58:36
services to Volodya flame before before before00:58:39
just on them because the appearance00:58:42
social networks it simply covered traditional00:58:46
Media with their verification with their conservatism00:58:49
with our check with our conservatism00:58:52
with ours00:58:53
then I remember the clarifications and you’re there00:58:56
participated we argued with Volodya What00:58:58
Speed or accuracy is more important and we00:59:00
still came to the conclusion that accuracy00:59:01
more important for reputation than Let us00:59:03
we'll lose in speed but we're looking for a second one00:59:06
We are looking for confirmation from an independent source00:59:08
and so on A00:59:11
and then Ekha began to lose in the rankings00:59:15
What kind of news do you have that everyone00:59:18
know but00:59:19
and we all agreed that accuracy00:59:23
more important and and now it’s already social networks It’s00:59:29
threat to the information field00:59:31
continue to cover traditional media00:59:34
every person and every a politician every00:59:40
a private person is a mass media00:59:42
information and which can00:59:45
spread inaccurate information00:59:47
incomplete but necessary00:59:49
get ahead somewhere heard something yes00:59:52
I heard something somewhere00:59:55
I ran into it myself these days, I can help you00:59:58
say in the World Cup I saw I saw that01:00:02
a person named Sinclair wrote that01:00:04
French Channel 1 apologizes for01:00:06
what he wrote about the attack on the hospital01:00:09
I translate this in French, I know what it is01:00:12
Sinclair is one of the leading01:00:14
quickly translated and posted and then became01:00:16
I thought it was important to check and01:00:18
It turned out that this is her namesake01:00:20
deputy ini what am I this page through 301:00:23
minutes but less01:00:25
this is Woe from Wit because we know01:00:28
anle this is Woe from Wit Yes, I ran into it too01:00:31
and I will continue to struggle, I want more01:00:35
thank you again Sorry, we're streaming here01:00:37
continues at the beginning of the hour01:00:39
I would like yes please We thank you here01:00:43
do you have any data there 276201:00:48
yeah, donations continue to come from us01:00:52
there is an hour maybe this hour you can01:00:55
catch up to 301:00:57
million see the amount put there We are very01:01:00
thanks to everyone on the left side of the screen QR code and01:01:04
you can use a foreign card through this01:01:07
QR code or send from a Russian card01:01:09
any amount to us This is necessary in order01:01:12
to continue to function01:01:14
close our budget deficit which01:01:16
unfortunately there is, you know, here's the paper01:01:19
increased in price by01:01:22
30% and paint01:01:25
30 books become more expensive accordingly01:01:27
magazines become more expensive, you buy less01:01:30
I get it, I get it. More forwarding01:01:34
so we say thank you to you01:01:36
great even if you send very01:01:38
a small amount anyway you see that01:01:40
it adds up to a large sum and01:01:45
It allows us to01:01:46
function So send shi01:01:49
donations you have 5001:01:51
minutes last from e asks which one01:01:56
real perspective What about Palestine01:01:59
I've already lost here that the Palestinians01:02:02
these territories will be under01:02:04
international control or what?01:02:07
writes Tanya E, the world will be saved by common efforts01:02:11
Hamas from total destruction I don't think so01:02:14
that the world will be saved by Hamas because01:02:16
Israel's allies and Arab countries01:02:19
many view Hamas as01:02:22
but as a threat01:02:26
creation of an international administration or01:02:28
Return of Gaza01:02:30
under the control of the Palestinian Authority01:02:34
which is ready to negotiate with everyone01:02:37
this is of course a way out this is of course a way out but01:02:41
we must remember that Hamas is deeply01:02:45
has taken root in gas for its 15 years01:02:48
reign for 18 years of reign, which is very01:02:50
many residents of Gaza T here come help01:02:54
humanitarian aid was distributed by officials01:02:57
from01:02:58
Hamas and the people were grateful to them and01:03:00
remain so01:03:02
grateful they act01:03:05
distributors of the benefits of defenders and people to them01:03:09
they believe and this is also a fact. This is also not necessary.01:03:13
forgetting it requires01:03:15
treatment in a broad social sense Well01:03:18
Let's see what we can agree on Yes, I think01:03:20
that the key figure here is01:03:22
Palestinian National Authority01:03:24
Mahmoud Abbas and the Jordanian King01:03:29
and the king of Egypt and plus now Saudi01:03:32
king of egypt king of egypt president01:03:35
Egypt and the King of the Saudis Sorry for the sake of01:03:38
God I already Yes01:03:39
of course in this Middle East01:03:42
I look at the boiler carefully because01:03:44
explosion then it can go further in waves01:03:46
it has already affected as we see01:03:50
Ukraine very strongly we see that01:03:55
the weapons that were supposed to01:03:57
sent to be sent to Ukraine sent01:03:59
those same shells in Israel01:04:04
so pay attention to this01:04:07
attention Here Hasan writes Yes, I noticed that01:04:11
The media are actually turning into social networks01:04:14
makes its own agenda Yes places it01:04:17
biased information unsubscribed from everyone01:04:19
newspapers what to do about it Well, it's happening01:04:25
it happens to me the other way around Hasan Although I don't01:04:27
I'm coping01:04:28
I subscribe additionally every crisis01:04:31
makes me turn my01:04:33
attention to media that seems to me to be01:04:36
comparison with others Yes, you are comparing01:04:39
information Yes may affect your01:04:42
perception of the world Well, for example, until recently01:04:45
time I was not subscribed to Ukrainian01:04:49
the truth is that I subscribed to the publication because01:04:52
that I seemed to neglect the fact that01:04:54
happens inside Ukraine and probably01:04:57
in vain here is the Ukrainian truth for me01:04:59
now it seems the most balanced01:05:04
skeptical media is very difficult during01:05:07
wars find skeptical Media Yes which01:05:09
checks double checks investigates not01:05:12
looking at the shoulder straps there What is called me01:05:14
subscribed added and I feel like peace01:05:17
got rich so it's not a matter of trust01:05:19
But this is a matter of checking sources I see01:05:22
as we say the investigation of the Truth later01:05:25
have a continuation Yes expressed there in01:05:27
resignation for example that is power01:05:30
acknowledges that these investigations are01:05:33
these are serious media Well, there is media01:05:36
where are you reading for the sake of there01:05:40
opinions not for the sake of facts but for the sake of opinion there01:05:43
speakers are people whose opinions you are interested in01:05:46
you are completely optional with this01:05:47
agree01:05:49
This is completely optional, but it’s for you01:05:53
Interesting01:05:54
What could it be? Here I am very good01:05:56
I understand Hasan too, that’s what people who01:06:01
I need information and fact first of all here01:06:04
what to do Where is it01:06:05
search need to collect01:06:08
several sources that don’t suck and01:06:12
you see that they don't screw up, it's theirs01:06:14
story behind them subscribe to them01:06:16
create a separate01:06:18
tape and watch them there01:06:21
Not all01:06:23
semi01:06:24
it works, but take it anyway01:06:27
sources on01:06:30
Dmitry sets reputation01:06:35
question: your view on the double standard01:06:38
as he formulates Dmitry Russian01:06:41
liberals on01:06:43
leaving what Jews in Palestine can do01:06:46
Russians are not allowed in Ukraine Just a story01:06:50
I think this is it01:06:53
vz correct I've never done anything at all01:06:55
I don’t compare it to what I compare it to itself01:06:58
it happened and I advise you so and conflicts01:07:02
in the Middle East and the war in Ukraine01:07:06
the history of Karabakh the history of Kosovo is everything01:07:09
different stories and you need to watch them01:07:12
movement and not compare and then do01:07:15
conclusions, if this is possible, then this is possible No01:07:18
This is not how every story happens01:07:20
I’ll tell everyone now that we’ll blow up the thing too01:07:23
chat history of each crime01:07:27
The history of every war is different01:07:30
history of each cause of war and reasons for01:07:33
war is different and01:07:36
so my advice to you is you can't01:07:38
I give it to you for free because01:07:41
And so they send us donations now01:07:44
Thank you very much my advice to you01:07:47
monitor the development of the conflict and01:07:49
count possible exits from each01:07:51
I will give you a specific conflict01:07:54
We saw example A with hostage taking01:07:58
There have been three major hostage situations in Russia.01:08:01
Budenovsk Dubrovka01:08:03
Beslan they are different01:08:07
were01:08:09
embroidered and terrorists in different ways01:08:13
and now tell me which one was correct01:08:16
impossible I'll give you an example I ska01:08:19
impossible in a historical sense not for01:08:21
specific deceased hostage01:08:23
families01:08:24
An Israeli soldier was freed01:08:27
plays pranks A in exchange for01:08:29
102701:08:31
prisoners convicted Palestinians one01:08:36
of which Al Qadi was the organizer and01:08:40
leader of the attack 701:08:43
October01:08:45
to Israel And then the question was asked01:08:49
Well, of course, we then break them01:08:52
everyone01:08:54
and here is an example for you and on the other hand a01:08:57
what if this Alka didn’t exist01:08:59
some other01:09:00
Alma headed it wouldn't be like this01:09:03
attacks01:09:05
you see, this is a very complicated story and01:09:08
Of course, emotionally we all choose how01:09:11
in Budenovsk when people suggested instead01:09:14
themselves hostages hostages And thereby01:09:17
rescued other hostages and reached Rome01:09:22
wow01:09:24
hostages died during the assault but01:09:27
the terrorists were all destroyed and more01:09:29
as the president told us, look01:09:31
more terrorist attacks No since the fourth year01:09:33
hostage taking no no but they know01:09:35
let's destroy everyone, what a bad story01:09:39
there are no good stories with01:09:41
terrorism knows no good stories01:09:44
knows good results and we haven't yet01:09:47
Let's forget that in Budenovka First there was01:09:49
unsuccessful assault on hospitals during which01:09:52
The hostages also died, that's what01:09:55
also applies to War when you compare That01:09:57
what is happening in Ukraine and Israel01:09:59
Now yes, they are incomparable things01:10:01
different means hotter and green with mine01:10:05
point of view that's why I prefer01:10:07
always You don't give me much for this01:10:10
love Atomy Zro events Da Laga01:10:13
decompose them into atoms But each01:10:15
separately just like every crime01:10:18
Let's all read Agatha Christie Poirot01:10:21
Poirot's crimes are one and all01:10:23
the crimes are different and the evidence is different and01:10:26
different reasons and different consequences01:10:29
when all crimes count01:10:31
the same here the bad appears01:10:33
consequence01:10:35
and both fast and wrong with Yes, here with01:10:38
Sergey agrees yes A and I just01:10:41
it seems like we don't have enough attention01:10:44
attentiveness but because you know01:10:47
why am I not at all interested in you01:10:49
I'm attacking, we don't have enough time and social networks01:10:52
created this story It's a threat again01:10:55
this is a threat to perception Yes they are01:10:59
brought a lot of good but they created01:11:02
threat to information perception Faster01:11:04
Hurry up, let's finish it later later01:11:07
finishes printing and that’s it01:11:10
remains and also consumption goes on01:11:12
I read the title then I'll read it here01:11:14
remembered here switched to this brains not01:11:17
works about the World Cup there are very interesting01:11:19
research Well here we are I'm basically01:11:22
I think that then it’s not war, it’s not war01:11:26
That means, by the way, Vladimir Vladimirovich is here01:11:28
Putin said about Ukraine there is a war01:11:31
war so that's why I say the word01:11:33
war like Vladimir Vladimi means me01:11:37
I just want to draw your attention to that01:11:40
what if there was no plague and then war I01:11:41
I think that the world media would sit and01:11:43
It would be better if people's minds were in the back of their heads, how is this going?01:11:46
after all01:11:52
SMT fights with the European Commission over Twitter01:11:56
because of X Yes, and there should Freedom01:12:01
word What is more important Well, this is the story01:12:04
it needs a public discussion01:12:06
public discussion but now there is no time01:12:09
that one was blown up here and they ran01:12:13
it was stolen here Well then01:12:15
bad 2800 2.800 000 we have guys Thank you01:12:20
Thank you very much Yes, 200,000 left, come on01:12:25
Well, I’ll say it seriously even if there aren’t any01:12:27
There will be a huge thank you to everyone who sent01:12:30
I saw there 50 rubles 10 rubles Thanks01:12:32
your help is great anyway01:12:34
priceless and I'm not saying this as a joke. Well01:12:37
Of course, buy a new magazine01:12:40
our Amateur Media book by Sasha Golts01:12:43
books on Israel now cost A01:12:45
next week I want to tell you Seryozha01:12:48
was found in different publishing houses01:12:49
book01:12:51
Olenberg I think that we have hired more01:12:55
lit monuments of the academy publishing house01:12:57
meeting01:12:58
essays two autograph books01:13:01
I will exhibit Yevtushenko and Valery Zolotukhin01:13:05
for lovers And this is also what you buy01:13:08
you are providing assistance and now I am sending it01:13:10
we're 300 a thousand each, I see Yes, I'm rubles01:13:14
I see the ruler moving01:13:16
Well, let's see it turns out semi01:13:22
semi on the elections of twenty-four01:13:25
is there any hope for01:13:27
appearance of the candidate Whose position will be01:13:31
fundamentally different from Putin’s and not01:13:34
so not a joke, but it’s clear who isn’t01:13:38
it’s clear who isn’t, well how01:13:40
that's great From Putin's but not these01:13:44
state parties such as Well they are01:13:47
not different From Putin's Listen, yes, well01:13:52
this question is really hard to understand01:13:54
that this question will be in the hands01:13:56
presidential administration of Sergei01:13:58
Kiriyenko who will offer Putin his01:14:01
election option Maybe most likely01:14:04
I agree with Alexey Navalny here01:14:07
what will it be according to the Moscow scheme When01:14:09
there will be Putin and representatives01:14:11
parliamentary pseudo parties and then01:14:15
the question will arise for those who go01:14:18
Can I vote for01:14:20
Zyuganov is there01:14:22
Slutsky01:14:23
the same position that Putin holds, yes01:14:26
war and this is the main thing for those who are talking about it01:14:29
thinks01:14:30
which means it's possible01:14:34
there will be some noname that01:14:37
declares01:14:39
anti-war Boris Nadezhdin in one01:14:41
the word is easier with this one Well because he01:14:44
initially occupied this position from February 2401:14:49
anti-war History is what he stated01:14:54
these years, which in Russia is not at all01:14:57
really01:14:58
safer accordingly there are more01:15:01
organized candidate Gregory01:15:03
Yavlinsky I think he’s not01:15:06
will be allowed If you want my point of view I01:15:09
I think they won’t let him in. Well, which one is good?01:15:12
Apple declares anti-war position01:15:14
accepts an obligation01:15:16
stop the war01:15:18
someone immediately01:15:22
cm at 80 it will be that's a plus01:15:27
conditional Boris01:15:30
Nadezhdin But conditional01:15:34
conditional hypothetical Boris to Nadezhda Yes01:15:37
conditional hypothetical Boris Nadezhda01:15:39
which takes anti-war declares01:15:41
anti-war position since February 2401:15:45
here for those who occupy a similar position01:15:49
position Is there any point in it01:15:53
I would01:15:54
I even voted for Pink Bobblehead01:15:57
which initially occupies a non-contour01:16:00
here before the elections Yes, why And count01:16:03
voices who01:16:05
decide to count the votes because there01:16:10
red will pass01:16:12
line but I can't call like01:16:14
foreign agent Or vice versa I01:16:16
I explain the position regarding hypothetically01:16:20
sing naked for the candidate01:16:23
This is a kind of statement to yourself that yes the sun01:16:27
dangerous But this is not dangerous and here I am01:16:29
solidarity01:16:34
Boris Nadezhdino or Grigory Yavlinsky01:16:37
yes, but from this position if we see01:16:39
candidate who occupies another01:16:41
position of an unrealistic candidate01:16:45
unreal here by the way01:16:47
the discussion was very interesting01:16:49
I was reminded in01:16:52
Twitter01:16:53
in the fourteenth year in March immediately after01:16:57
Crimea FBK held01:17:00
poll How do you feel about the fact that Crimea01:17:02
may become Russian, the process was underway01:17:04
only FBK conducted Navalny 85% thought01:17:08
that yes, rather yes, or yes, or rather yes01:17:11
a total of 85% of the Russian population is FBK01:17:15
I thought that I thought that I would like to01:17:18
they didn’t explain why Crimea was Russian01:17:20
Why What happened01:17:22
grief was explained as a general mood yes01:17:25
mood belief is simple01:17:28
that's it01:17:30
Why did it go down in history, did it go down in politics?01:17:34
Crimean expression01:17:35
consensus because Crimean consensus01:17:38
Was Is there now?01:17:41
consensus This is a big question and therefore01:17:43
it is very important to understand the voices behind the01:17:47
vote01:17:49
against And then it arises01:17:51
some kind of pink01:17:53
[ __ ] where you can stick your name01:17:57
and say Well, yes, yes, yes, in general, this is the sun for me01:18:00
my position is known your position01:18:02
known but there are a lot of people who cannot01:18:06
doesn't want to be shy afraid doubts01:18:11
yes And suddenly it appears in this sense that01:18:15
even I would say the Kremlin candidate01:18:17
there will be no others only the consent of the Kremlin but01:18:20
who declares a position01:18:23
may be the subject of my vote01:18:26
mine personally without any calls, but tell me01:18:30
please, why does the Kremlin need this?01:18:32
candidate in general01:18:34
produce a increase turnout b show01:18:37
how marginalized he is already01:18:40
Yes Lyudmila from01:18:43
Dnieper Ukraine naturally why are you01:18:47
you think it doesn’t evoke any emotions01:18:50
murder of civilians in Ukraine is you01:18:53
why do you think so and where am I?01:18:55
said I don’t know, where did I say that?01:18:58
Lyudmila It's because we talked about01:19:03
events in the Middle East or what?01:19:05
now no I didn't say that of course01:19:08
evokes emotions but Lyudmila I will answer you01:19:10
Seriously, are you seriously asking this?01:19:13
addictive When they tell you01:19:15
that 14,400 civilians died on one Saturday01:19:19
October 7, and not with a rocket, but with knives01:19:25
cut out or shot at point-blank range with bullets01:19:28
with knives, your level of horror is more than that01:19:33
that the rest doesn’t seem to be horror anymore01:19:35
what I meant is what I meant01:19:38
this is a defensive reaction of the psyche, this is for you01:19:42
any psychiatrist will explain This is already Horror01:19:45
and this is no longer horror but addiction01:19:51
ballito there01:19:54
so many died so many died so many died01:19:57
thousands died thousands thousands not tens01:20:00
Because when everyone can have ten01:20:02
show And when thousands are01:20:05
statistics This is very important to understand01:20:09
and this is wrong from the point of view01:20:13
morality But this is correct from the point of view01:20:17
That is, it is objective from the point of view01:20:20
psychiatry That's what I meant people01:20:28
so here it was01:20:32
it turns out that we are on the air now01:20:35
we call on someone political01:20:37
suicide suicide declare01:20:40
anti-war in the elections as a candidate is01:20:43
are you asking or is it someone from there?01:20:45
someone immediately deleted it from there01:20:47
nothing happens, look nothing01:20:49
I urge you to explain my position01:20:53
and only I understand for sure that01:20:56
call on no one, and even more so01:20:58
You can’t nominate because it’s dangerous01:21:01
so I was categorically against it01:21:04
so that Muratov and Roizman were included in01:21:09
these lists without without them01:21:11
consent I was categorically against01:21:14
this is so that you can understand me01:21:16
I categorically do not approve of this because01:21:19
it's like drawing a target on your back people01:21:23
inside01:21:24
Russian people are foreign agents and Roizman01:21:28
still under criminal prosecution for01:21:31
discredit is actually a sentence there01:21:33
there are courts if you forgot Yes01:21:36
fine and01:21:39
what if he said yes, ask the question01:21:43
no That's why I don't name any01:21:46
another surname Except those who already01:21:48
were not named by me but who were themselves01:21:51
named such a story question also by01:21:55
elections and following our last conversation01:21:58
Saturday Oleg asks 10 million01:22:02
Yavlinsky This is how he says signatures Yes01:22:05
this is a drain through blocking requirements 4501:22:08
years old Oleg from Moscow I don’t think I think01:22:11
that the mere fact of a meeting01:22:15
somehow for some reason01:22:18
what parameters of these signatures01:22:21
I don’t know the parameters change org or what01:22:23
you must also understand that of course01:22:25
The Kremlin will prevent this and01:22:27
appearance there 10 million 3 million 2 million 5 million01:22:33
Human01:22:35
and this in itself is a political fact And01:22:38
Yavlinsky is now thinking about exactly this01:22:40
in my opinion he will tell you himself Probably01:22:42
I think but nevertheless he thinks about01:22:46
processes Yes, this is not only received01:22:49
registration but also collecting signatures01:22:52
this is a political challenge to the Kremlin and Any01:22:55
the person who leaves the signature is01:22:58
a single political challenge to the Kremlin01:23:01
will be regarded in the Kremlin Well then01:23:06
it's actually your business01:23:11
And I think that of course I signed ten01:23:15
impossible and will destroy sites like01:23:17
sites were destroyed during Navalny's time there01:23:20
everything was blocked during the smart holo01:23:23
this one talks about it We live in the century Yes01:23:28
Well, I’m answering Here is Oleg who is on01:23:30
my opinion is serious01:23:32
The question is a serious question Well, I understand01:23:36
psychology in this case tactics01:23:39
Grigory Yavlinsky01:23:41
This is what he collected in the last elections01:23:43
I think 700,00001:23:45
Human01:23:47
731 Maybe I'm wrong Well01:23:51
people leave signatures01:23:54
leaving personal information is clear01:23:57
that the secret police will have access to them01:24:00
it’s clear that people should understand And those01:24:03
people who left Yes, they are Russian01:24:06
citizens can leave signatures01:24:07
Naturally, those people who are here01:24:10
will01:24:12
take risks, they must also understand this and01:24:15
apple should say so01:24:21
public01:24:23
for on the internet it can't be me01:24:25
I always say and it doesn’t matter who makes them Well01:24:28
maybe this is where people become public01:24:30
declare their disagreement with01:24:35
politics another policy Dmitry01:24:37
Asks why01:24:40
Legitimism involving Dmitry word01:24:44
legitimize you wrong it01:24:45
you use legitimate president - this is01:24:48
the one that is recognized by the majority01:24:51
countries you mean apparently01:24:55
Legality So it’s necessary here01:24:58
choose Either you are trying to raise01:25:05
anti-war but as you say01:25:15
legitimism nele01:25:18
pinky01:25:21
stench of Rocher There is no good choice There is no choice01:25:26
Well, this is the choice everyone will make01:25:29
his01:25:30
on your own Mikhail Sorry with us01:25:33
We have half an hour left01:25:36
2890,000 and we will collect another 110,000 We are for01:25:40
half an hour to 3 million or not, but it’s already01:25:43
sport went to the chat there is a call to get01:25:46
Yes thank you very much and don't forget the likes01:25:49
only bet too if there is no money01:25:51
like this guy has no money like this01:25:53
But of course it would be nice to call it01:25:57
this word if these 108 are already thousands01:26:02
will get there in the remaining 29 minutes of Mikhail01:26:07
and Stalin can anyone immediately 10001:26:09
will close and that’s it. And I’ll tell Lisa Lazerson01:26:13
that someone loves her very much And yes, someone01:26:16
loves her very much or Lick on Neva or01:26:19
both yes Or strongly dislikes strongly dislikes01:26:22
loves therefore 200,000 the main thing is that01:26:24
the main thing is to have a strong feeling01:26:26
strong feeling the feeling you have01:26:28
strong feelings for one of the persons or for01:26:31
both at once and Mikhail from Stalin01:26:34
ask Alexey Alekseevich And you01:26:36
ever donated to some media01:26:38
or YouTube channel01:26:40
a Media A01:26:44
Yes, I donated and continue to donate to the Department of Internal Affairs01:26:49
info I donated and I donated you know who01:26:53
I think it's a lawyer's01:26:55
on the street I'm like this01:26:58
human rights channel or society I01:27:01
donated monthly And the day before yesterday I01:27:05
donated on Twitter at the request of Evgeniya01:27:10
Markov, who was on duty at Nemtsov01:27:14
bridge and now in the pre-trial detention center they broke him there01:27:17
ribs and it was necessary I was there yesterday01:27:20
call to close there for a certain amount for01:27:24
medicines and to pay the rent I do this01:27:27
Donatil Well, in general, yes, it’s more difficult now01:27:32
because I repeat there are no salaries and in01:27:35
in general Now I have basically everything01:27:37
consumable But nevertheless, yes01:27:40
I donated and I think I did01:27:45
Right01:27:47
So that means it will remain with us, he says01:27:50
extend for the whole weekend01:27:52
No it will be extended No look01:27:55
fees will be extended throughout the weekend01:27:58
It will just be quite hard to find there01:27:59
You will need to go to the archive and there and01:28:03
we will have it, it will be possible to replenish it from01:28:05
us for the night that's when the girls finished01:28:07
and until the morning I'll tell you now01:28:11
how much have we added 150,00001:28:13
in my opinion 130,000 rubles per night so they01:28:17
will be extended here it seems IT vi 00 I tell you01:28:22
I'll tell you when there are 100,000 left but for now01:28:25
there are still more than 100,000 here about the strong01:28:28
feelings just lydeya 67 years old01:28:31
Netherlands I miss Tonya Samsonova01:28:34
Why is she not there? I met her myself01:28:37
quite recently in London she01:28:38
own01:28:39
you can see the project at01:28:42
Instagram Lydia once you are in the Netherlands01:28:45
you don't need a VPN, it's your own01:28:48
she's very busy with the project01:28:51
The truth is that the girl was always very01:28:53
independent therefore01:28:56
But well, we are in correspondence with her, we are her01:29:01
love naturally01:29:05
Yes, and I’ll pass your question on to her 2.900 00001:29:09
100,000 left Of course we love her Well01:29:11
gently Yes 26 minutes left 100,00001:29:14
Ruslan from Saratov asks a serious question01:29:18
the question Although he formulates it, he does it01:29:22
countries in my opinion you are engaged01:29:25
the return of Ukrainian children what do you mean?01:29:27
is more motivated by helping children or01:29:29
opportunity to get some01:29:31
Nobel01:29:34
the award is my personal apology to01:29:37
Ukraine This is my personal01:29:40
restitution restitution Literally01:29:43
words Before Ukraine and those colleagues are friends01:29:47
and the enemies I do this to01:29:50
mm combined01:29:53
and one Nobel laureate We have01:29:56
Therefore we have enough01:29:58
Well, and of course in life the inner01:30:02
satisfaction is also important, it raises01:30:05
me in my eyes and my eyes01:30:10
friends, a complicated story, here's a question01:30:14
no yes like when did this happen what01:30:17
it became possible Well it became01:30:20
possible for me It is quite obvious And01:30:23
the most important thing is that besides everything01:30:27
big but back01:30:30
home boy or girl01:30:33
when I come back it’s already kind of small01:30:36
at least a sigh of relief Well, you can01:30:41
you can say that, but once again01:30:45
I repeat the case, very fragile I would say01:30:48
that's why I say but not01:30:53
for donations please for donations01:30:56
Yes, a request from Yulia Well, that’s them01:31:01
said hello to sister Valeria from America01:31:05
we if this is not this you know Do you remember how01:31:08
London radio broadcast to France01:31:11
grandfather Pierre went for01:31:14
bread Yes Julia, just don’t let us down01:31:17
stones Well Valerie Hello big yes we are for01:31:20
donations for good donations for we can01:31:24
transfer here in the remaining time01:31:26
send greetings Yes 10.000 and Hello B01:31:30
Valeria live from America01:31:33
Hello, they are asking how to develop01:31:36
oratorical01:31:40
abilities for this you need first01:31:42
study the audience I have to tell you01:31:44
that when I went to work as a teacher01:31:47
I had several lessons in a row01:31:48
which generally led01:31:50
schizophrenia01:31:52
feature When it was necessary to talk about01:31:54
the battle of Stalingrad in fourth grade01:31:56
and in dem or rather in o terminology01:32:00
choice you study the audience you first01:32:03
you need to understand what audience you are for01:32:06
applying This is the first step Yes Before you01:32:09
crowd here's one for me01:32:11
from Shumen01:32:14
musicians told w you don’t understand01:32:16
you go on stage and speak01:32:20
hi and hall or there with01:32:24
field and you are thrown onto the platform And you01:32:28
I just said hi and that’s all for you01:32:32
this is really in many ways01:32:34
so that’s why I’m like Yuri Petrovich beloved01:32:38
said it is important to be heard in01:32:40
fifth row not first not twentieth in01:32:43
fifth, the rest will pass and gestures should01:32:46
be like that Yes, but in reality it is necessary01:32:49
understand why you are going out what are you doing01:32:52
and the second thing you can say to someone is01:32:55
go out to the audience that is for you01:32:57
so hostile01:32:59
came out here01:33:02
and don't break it01:33:06
to an audience that listens to you like How01:33:10
Apostle is actually the only thing I would01:33:13
I wanted to add that of course it is necessary and01:33:17
study theory, rhetoric, and so on there01:33:19
then it happens01:33:22
but one cannot overestimate the formal ones01:33:25
primo overestimate without that01:33:28
you will feel the audience and what you are with01:33:34
on the one hand you prepare for the audience and on the other hand01:33:36
on the other hand you must all the time01:33:39
leave a little space for01:33:43
surprises never break A01:33:46
sorry citizens, according to my theory you are not01:33:49
must make noise here That's how many people01:33:52
this is by the way on this and ru here should01:33:55
be Applause Yes applaud me01:33:57
written Yes good These were the questions for01:34:01
Degi So let's One day Leonid Ilch01:34:04
He said, why doesn’t he applaud me?01:34:08
it says applause yes it's true01:34:10
there was why a living nail light01:34:12
Merkulova writes not to collect Yes you01:34:16
dupe she called I would I would01:34:19
offended but on the other hand Question01:34:22
normal good make a live project01:34:24
nail and place it on the platform01:34:26
for example Je assign a percentage to investors01:34:29
and collect money there is a question for investors01:34:32
- this is a very serious question, especially with01:34:35
taking into account, on the one hand, Russian01:34:38
investors who don't want to deal with01:34:40
foreign agents it is toxic and with01:34:43
on the other hand, you know that YouTube01:34:45
disabled monetization for Russian media01:34:48
Russian channels including ours01:34:51
and on the third side a foreign investor01:34:54
this means turning all journalists01:34:56
who work here in foreign01:34:58
agents I01:35:01
one person answered, wrote Oleg01:35:05
failed artist they say great01:35:07
he was very skilled in oratory01:35:11
I was very prepared Yes, I listened to his speech Yes01:35:14
he was very prepared If you look01:35:17
film Mikhail Rom ordinary fascism then01:35:19
what's available so you'll see how he's in front01:35:23
trained with a mirror there is a lot01:35:26
photos of how he practiced gestures Here01:35:29
that is, he was also choleric from the inside01:35:31
hysteria and an asteroid Yes, that helps01:35:33
get the crowd going but he trained before01:35:36
mirror this is true absolutely everything is true01:35:40
What you say is true, but such01:35:44
there are a lot of people who start a crowd01:35:47
and here it is very important that there are people who01:35:50
go to Tol to turn it into01:35:53
herd Yes this is the goal again the goal What are you01:35:57
come out Yes to be a speaker you01:36:00
come out so that this story is very01:36:02
important and one guy here buddy here01:36:06
this is 10,000 maybe the question will be No yes01:36:10
just sent but also01:36:12
spa01:36:14
friend and associate of this artist01:36:17
failed01:36:19
Speak here01:36:21
The less meaning, the faster the heart beats01:36:24
he said well there is a lot in this01:36:26
sense Goebbels Of course the person who01:36:29
built a Nazi propaganda system01:36:32
very seriously01:36:34
Do you know what I was in the museum in01:36:39
Berlin A 3 million Hurray 3 million someone gave 5001:36:44
now I see right away Thank you very much01:36:50
continue with 3 ml I didn’t understand right away01:36:54
thank you very much you are very much01:36:56
help, if only I had this01:36:58
Here's the opportunity to send you a heart01:37:01
I would check maybe there is a question there01:37:03
some because I saw 50,000 at once01:37:05
jumped And thank you, it means a lot01:37:08
the story is01:37:09
what really01:37:12
actually returning to the crowd and01:37:16
herd goal is also very important for your01:37:19
rhetoric and awaken as we see in01:37:22
a person has the darkest thing in him01:37:25
animal beginning is much easier than01:37:29
introduce restraining fuses01:37:31
cultural institutions01:37:33
education surrounded by normal people01:37:36
Yes it is very hard work and01:37:38
it costs nothing to turn into a beast01:37:40
tell him you are above everyone else01:37:42
because your dad and mom are so and so01:37:45
nation You are higher than everyone else because01:37:47
you are oppressed for 50 years, you are above everything01:37:51
the rest because you get less01:37:53
they stole everything from you easily and simply or01:37:56
a person believes in it easily and simply01:37:58
my friends you01:38:00
you know recently in one of the universities I am01:38:04
I know for sure in one of01:38:07
Universities01:38:08
the teacher who said that01:38:12
Hitler had extraordinary strength01:38:15
influences developed by him and led01:38:18
quote from01:38:20
gebel01:38:21
student Well yes but it's the same question01:38:24
because then you don't have it01:38:26
justification of Nazism This is the same as01:38:28
there is an excuse for others Quite Seryozha01:38:32
the question apparently came for no question No01:38:34
And what is this? What is this? Why01:38:38
top so from Krasnoyarsk Maxim Alexey01:38:42
Alekseevich you are very awkward01:38:45
answered terrorism or drones in Moscow01:38:49
City Mall there are no victims but an assassination attempt01:38:52
it can be considered a terrorist attack01:38:55
you can qualify Why is it awkward01:38:57
answered I answered as I understand and you01:39:00
qualification dexterous or not dexterous - This01:39:02
Your qualifications and not mine can be considered01:39:05
attempted terrorist attack A any selected01:39:09
deliberately civilian population Yes how01:39:14
goal regardless of Maxim from rcha outside01:39:18
depending on the rightness of the case01:39:21
regardless of whether it's right, it can be done this way01:39:24
qualify from hair01:39:26
question 38 years old this is our Nikolai 38 years old01:39:32
vologist is our Nikolai who is the only one01:39:35
man, well, 38 years old, I only know Nikolai01:39:38
he had a lot of girls yesterday01:39:41
donati donati devi this is not harassment01:39:50
you don’t feel like a peaceful inhabitant of gas01:39:52
may be called a vak or worse, accomplices01:39:55
terrorist that's what's wrong with it01:39:58
do explain Nikolai explain I01:40:01
I can tell you a terrible thing Nikolai I01:40:03
I sympathize with the civilians01:40:06
gas, I sympathize with the families of the victims01:40:09
civilian children of residents01:40:12
gas and it doesn’t give me any01:40:15
difficulties because I know inside myself01:40:19
exactly yes, those people who created this01:40:24
situation that resulted in death01:40:27
these particular residents of gas are01:40:30
terrorists01:40:31
Hamas who went to Israel were killed01:40:35
masses of civilians were taken to01:40:37
hostages and called fire on you Well on01:40:40
them I them01:40:42
Sorry01:40:43
of course no difficult no moral01:40:49
torment01:40:51
thank God for the religious01:40:53
no because again I came up with it01:40:56
rebel I don't have two for you01:40:59
texts it's not about ethnicity01:41:01
belongings And it's about sympathy and01:41:05
it's a matter of understanding who caused this tragedy01:41:08
it's a tragedy what's happening in gas01:41:10
listen this is a tragedy and what01:41:12
what is happening in Israel is also a tragedy01:41:14
but there is01:41:16
nuance As they say01:41:18
Yes, terrorists did civilian things01:41:22
population as their goal and wanted to cause01:41:25
this Tragedy both in Israeli society and01:41:28
Palestinian for peace01:41:31
rebelled against Israel That was their goal01:41:34
and I continue with the consciousness of this goal01:41:37
sympathize with the families of those killed in the gas and01:41:42
of course first of all first01:41:45
queue01:41:49
no problem telling you this01:41:53
Nikolay and if you are as it seems to me01:41:56
you won't have a reasonable person either01:41:58
no difficulty in saying this because01:42:01
that there is an impossibility it seems to me for01:42:03
a normal person is indifferent01:42:07
indifferently and even more so with gloating01:42:10
See or see the body of a murdered child01:42:15
deceased no matter what no matter from what01:42:18
and generally see a dead person and01:42:21
look at how the president approaches this hem01:42:25
Biden I said yesterday I want again No01:42:27
miss it because that means to me01:42:31
Vladimir Bori Pastukhov said that he is01:42:32
he missed he missed he missed a lot he01:42:36
said netanyahu he said don't let rage01:42:40
absorb01:42:41
don't make the mistakes we did01:42:44
committed on September 11 after 1101:42:49
September01:42:51
Afghanistan is in ruins, what's there?01:42:54
Taliban Iraq collapsed So what?01:42:56
civil war in Syria and Libya01:42:59
ruined what's there01:43:01
civil yes, that is, previous experience Yes01:43:05
we don't know we don't I don't want to be on them01:43:07
I don't want to be in Netanyahu's place01:43:09
I didn't want to be in George Bush's shoes Yes01:43:11
this is the hardest decision that doesn't have01:43:14
good continuation which are associated with01:43:17
victims So you estimate, why not01:43:20
presidential livs and that’s why though01:43:25
it would be necessary to make a decision to kill01:43:28
peaceful people who can01:43:30
be collateral damage and I'm weak01:43:34
I don't01:43:36
ready this is what I replied to Nikolay Sorry01:43:38
Yes, but strong passions and strong ones are terrifying01:43:44
after 9/11 and and hate01:43:49
which01:43:51
Well look here01:43:52
then how much01:43:55
screwed up the Patriot Act when he01:43:58
accepted quickly in America, well quickly01:44:02
quickly as it was multiplied by the way01:44:06
number of people are absolutely peaceful01:44:09
caught up in distribution and and probably and01:44:12
probably how much was saved by A And how much by C and01:44:15
this one and this one01:44:18
take this and this is the truth01:44:21
so Nikolai I repeat01:44:24
I have absolutely none01:44:27
moral difficulties with this simply01:44:29
no Kostya asks how much for01:44:33
yours01:44:35
Ukrainian children returned to participate01:44:39
well look at me01:44:42
Chimney sweep, my job was to clean the chimney01:44:45
I didn't deal with almost any individual cases01:44:47
And it's not just me, it's a small group01:44:50
of people01:44:52
that's why the children returned besides everyone else01:44:56
statistics besides01:44:58
participation of the state and one and the other AND01:45:02
third so I would I would not figure01:45:07
called a lot01:45:09
a lot more than me01:45:13
I thought I was just afraid to talk about it01:45:16
because here within the country there is01:45:17
weight01:45:18
people have power who don't want01:45:22
this return and who tell me and01:45:27
my drinking buddy says wait they01:45:30
Russian citizens their parents are now01:45:31
Russian citizens because01:45:33
most of the kids there are okay01:45:36
would be from Ukraine - these are people from Zaporozhye01:45:41
Kherson Donetsk Lugansk regions01:45:44
Do you want to give away Russian citizens?01:45:46
or children of Russian citizens Are you what?01:45:49
what are you doing you are enemies of the people like us01:45:51
they sell Russian citizens01:45:53
They say it's completely frank01:45:55
They say this even when they are at the very top01:45:58
I am convinced of this and generally overcome01:46:01
this being an Ino agent and with my other01:46:05
friends who don't have We01:46:08
impostors01:46:09
we are impostors and do not have any01:46:13
other possibilities Well, except01:46:15
lobbyist let's say01:46:19
So01:46:21
because the scheme I was invented01:46:24
give you the diagram01:46:26
I will call it was invented and carried out in01:46:29
life and there is not a single refusal when01:46:32
parents mother grandmother or person with01:46:36
comes to Russia with a power of attorney01:46:38
Ukraine, she takes this child and01:46:41
leaves freely Yes with01:46:45
failure obstacles01:46:49
uh01:46:51
proposed to lobby01:47:20
either through01:47:23
Belarus either through01:47:25
Finland or via01:47:28
Estonia, what we have with whom we have there01:47:31
border A from Kaliningrad through01:47:34
There is not as much Lithuania as we would like01:47:38
the problem remains serious01:47:42
But But this is this pipe which01:47:45
was Forgiven a year ago started in01:47:49
November She works too01:47:53
slowed down by different circumstances But01:47:56
works well well they work well well well01:47:58
works like it works like it works though01:48:00
If this pipe works, the other doesn't work01:48:02
That's why01:48:03
when Ukrainians say we are Ukrainian01:48:07
colleagues say we liberated there01:48:10
so many children Well01:48:11
great but it was like you01:48:14
guess not military01:48:17
raid to the Far East or Lipetsk01:48:20
region beyond liberation01:48:23
children How do you guess This is probably01:48:26
Russian volunteers01:48:28
Russian citizens pay attention01:48:33
volunteers under threats from local authorities01:48:35
you give away Russian children, they do it and01:48:40
there are a lot of them01:48:42
a lot of01:48:45
a lot but so that it’s not all01:48:49
slowed down at speed01:48:51
VM needs to continue working there big01:48:55
pain orphanages because they seem to01:48:56
Russian now from the point of view of power01:48:59
where to return them Where to Donetsk01:49:01
you will return the orphanage to bombs somewhere01:49:03
The front line is going now Where to Kherson01:49:06
return there Front line Now where01:49:10
all the relatives of these children are there01:49:14
part of control Ukra01:49:19
no nationality01:49:21
Ukrainian is not01:49:23
Russian are family members01:49:26
It's a big problem. Well, I must admit that01:49:30
interfere but not like that01:49:32
so that it’s critical, I mean a reason for children01:49:35
parents have everything there01:49:37
it’s going but now it’s frozen, that’s also true Well01:49:41
that is, not What do traffic jams mean not not01:49:43
let's not say not burgundy color but like this01:49:47
no red movement yes red01:49:49
red red that's especially the sun01:49:51
intensified when it means they took Moskalkova01:49:53
under European sanctions01:49:56
on time the only Russian Bureaucrat01:50:01
who did this very effectively01:50:05
together with the Ukrainian side they took under01:50:08
sanctions European mediators and then01:50:10
there are intermediaries everywhere so that they understand01:50:14
they start to say this01:50:19
Zhano Brom who are not under sanctions but01:50:22
It's a different matter with a Russian bureaucrat01:50:24
member of the administration who are under01:50:27
children did not benefit from sanctions01:50:29
exactly, well, it’s their right, please tell me01:50:33
can you answer briefly, simply not at all01:50:35
I don't question this01:50:45
shoved01:50:47
Tatarstan does not like that Kadyrov01:50:50
declares the seva head of all Muslims01:50:52
Russia was shown to him a little like this and then01:50:55
So it means hitting departure hitting back01:50:59
Yes the East did01:51:01
subtly Andrey now it’s all donations01:51:04
donations donations yes01:51:08
10.000 Say hello to Nizhny01:51:11
Novgorod with pleasure01:51:14
Yurchuk and drive away from Masya01:51:18
Maksyuk go and gona Yurich Mikhailovich gona01:51:23
hello to you yes and thank you for01:51:27
10,000 yes we can sell it and01:51:29
I remind you that now Nathan01:51:32
me the number that came out yesterday about01:51:35
Bismarck means this is answering chat this is not01:51:40
Medvedev with a mustache is Bismarck Yes because01:51:46
what are you guys tired of? Yes, I understand01:51:52
this is this01:51:54
from01:51:56
a long time ago in general How many donations were collected01:52:01
Sergey, we have already collected three and a half Yes01:52:04
now for 3 ml small one like this01:52:06
pig tail Well, nothing but I want01:52:08
just tell everyone that we really01:52:11
We'll be here for a few more days Saturday01:52:13
Sunday and Monday and take01:52:15
donations You will need to go either to01:52:18
watch the stream which girls will be there01:52:20
QR code or to our Seryozha broadcast and then01:52:24
it will be possible to add because even01:52:27
after after the end it will be possible01:52:28
add to those who later join us01:52:31
joined We are very grateful to everyone01:52:34
who even the smallest amounts even 10 rubles01:52:38
the smallest amount helps us continue01:52:42
work and the last thing I'm very sad01:52:47
I'll read it here from01:52:48
Oleg01:52:51
who scolds the light at the World Cup01:52:53
is Russian and so on of this type01:52:57
benefactors save Ukrainians01:52:59
children it's like bandits first we do it01:53:03
the problem and then we solve it like this Ole you01:53:05
save you can I can and you or let me01:53:09
let them die let them die01:53:18
probably said one lawyer we are sofa01:53:22
I’ll sell without you. By the way, about lawyers. Here01:53:26
this is completely different in my opinion01:53:29
suicide on a colleague01:53:32
lawyers about that01:53:34
that the lawyer is here to stay01:53:37
left01:53:42
the bill is forfeited this is the bill01:53:45
government M does not betray A's memory01:53:48
maybe it's someone from the same01:53:50
it's understandable, yes, because lawyers01:53:52
those who left continue to fulfill their01:53:54
lawyer's duties and opportunities01:53:57
them like that01:53:58
there is this continuation of the same01:54:02
stories about tightening the screws on the solution01:54:04
legal assistance, well, it’s not about01:54:07
it's about lawyers01:54:10
client's point of view about lawyers01:54:13
too but wow01:54:18
next01:54:21
writes yes, and I’m very glad that Ukrainian01:54:25
Children have the opportunity to study even in01:54:28
people like this can be learned everywhere and in different ways01:54:31
ways But he studies and these are priorities01:54:35
we understand this correctly absolutely because01:54:38
that no no no she's just just01:54:40
says it's not a question Valentina says01:54:43
and I understand this perfectly because01:54:46
in any conditions, normal people01:54:48
children are taught and saved, and so on and01:54:52
their own and others, or are they sitting like Oleg and01:54:56
Nadya, come Oleg, I’ll find you here01:54:58
work on evacuating children, come01:55:01
so honest and noble all in white01:55:04
Let's01:55:05
We don't have enough hands here, but will you01:55:09
communicate with governors and generals01:55:12
border guards Let's01:55:15
go ahead and I can answer this01:55:18
great for you msv and who is protecting your01:55:23
nail this is the very last thing you don't01:55:26
You were talking. So you collected donations and01:55:30
gave us the opportunity to continue working 201:55:32
months, almost these 3 million give01:55:35
we have the opportunity to work for 2 months and01:55:38
I’ll even tell you I’m scared to open a pair01:55:40
new programs which was very important to me01:55:43
important I said What is this money for?01:55:45
new programs So embroider on01:55:48
indeed, and I encourage you to continue01:55:51
protect despite the fact that now01:55:53
the broadcast will end nevertheless we will01:55:56
continue collecting these donations for another 3 days01:55:59
who can who is looking at the recordings now01:56:01
many will join now watching there01:56:03
about 17000 Yes, this broadcast in general01:56:06
watches about a quarter of a million and01:56:10
reconsidering I just encourage you01:56:12
even the smallest donations will help us01:56:15
then plan01:56:18
January around New Year somewhere around New Year01:56:21
the year is not the New Year itself Agu Well, I don’t know01:56:24
Let's see, who knows, oh well01:56:26
thank you to everyone Many thanks to everyone who01:56:29
listened to everyone who watched, especially those who01:56:33
helps us financially Thank you01:56:35
great friends 15 o'clock Olga Zhuravleva01:56:38
od bottom will be her program this is the nearest01:56:41
what can you hear? Well, at 14 what not01:56:44
we will have a bookstore, yes, why?01:56:48
no one but I have and a book casino01:56:51
everything is great01:56:58
AllDescription:
Поддержать Живой гвоздь: https://www.donationalerts.com/r/zhivgvozd 00:00 В прямом эфире Живого гвоздя еженедельная программа «Будем Наблюдать» с Алексеем Венедиктовым** и Сергеем Бунтманом 01:12 — Вы все еще можете поддержать «Живой гвоздь»! 03:13 — Освобождение заложников из Израиля 06:16 — Байден ответил утвердительно на вопрос, следует ли Израилю отложить наземную операцию в секторе Газа 09:45 — В чем сложность израильского конфликта? 17:25 — Переговоры Израиля и ХАМАС ведутся через посредников? 19:30 — Атака по больнице. Можно ли сейчас сделать какие-то выводы? 26:00 — Реклама 27:21 — Покупайте книги в магазине «Дилетант»! 32:20 — Как сейчас нарушаются конвенции ведения войны? 33:00 — Освобождение территорий Палестины могут разрешить конфликт? 37:35 — Почему в 47-48 гг. не получилось образовать Палестинское государство? 39:00 — Слухи о кандидатуре Венедиктова*. Откуда они взялись? 40:17 — Потери гражданского населения Палестине 42:05 — Позиция МИДа России по поводу израильского конфликта 49:45 — Кому Палестина нужна меньше: Западу или арабам? 59:25 — Соцсети и традиционные СМИ 1:01:55 — Что будет с палестинскими территориями после завершения конфликта? 1:13:25 — Какими будут президентские выборы? 1:19:25 — Нормализация войны 1:20:30 — Будет ли на выборах кто-нибудь с антивоенной позицией? 1:26:20 — Венедиктов* донатил СМИ или правозащитным организациям? 1:29:25 — Что мотивирует Венедиктова* заниматься возвратом украинских детей? 1:34:15 — Почему «Живой гвоздь» не сотрудничает с инвесторами? 1:39:40 — Сочувствие мирным жителям Газы 1:44:30 — Как обстоит ситуация с возвращением украинских детей? * * — власти РФ считают иностранным агентом, а ФБК*** — разжигателем войны * * * — организация внесена в список иностранных агентов, признана экстремистской и запрещена в РФ Новый — пятый том комикса в серии «Спасти» уже в продаже! На этот раз авторы попытались вызволить из Тауэра наследников внезапно скончавшегося английского короля Эдуарда IV. Купить: https://diletant.shop/tproduct/596598185-351029717571-kniga-spasti-printsev-iz-tauera-tom-5 🔔 Последние новости и анонсы программ с YouTube-канала «Живой гвоздь», а также контент от наших постоянных гостей и экспертов на официальном телеграм-канале: https://t.me/livegvozd Мобильное приложение "Эха": любимые программы в формате радиоприёмника. Простой интерфейс. Работа в фоновом режиме. Расписание эфиров. Скачать: в AppStore: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/%D1%8D%D1%85%D0%BE-online/id1639907671 в PlayMarket: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=online.echofm.app Сайт "Эха": https://echofm.online/ (если не открывается – ссылка на рабочую версию сайта всегда есть в тг-канале ЭХО FM https://telegram.org/ Подписаться на Youtube-канал Дилетант: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuIE7-5QzeAR6EdZXwDRwuQ?sub_confirmation=1 📌 Живой гвоздь в аудиоформате: Яндекс.Музыка: https://music.yandex.ru/album/22141653?dir=desc Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/%D0%B6%D0%B8%D0%B2%D0%BE%D0%B9-%D0%B3%D0%B2%D0%BE%D0%B7%D0%B4%D1%8C/id1616175210 Google Подкасты: https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9mZWVkcy5zb3VuZGNsb3VkLmNvbS91c2Vycy9zb3VuZGNsb3VkOnVzZXJzOjEwOTk2NzA5MDUvc291bmRzLnJzcw?sa=X&ved=0CAIQ4aUDahcKEwigxO3Eweb2AhUAAAAAHQAAAAAQEQ Магазин "Дилетант": https://diletant.shop/ По вопросам взаимодействия: [email protected]й
Preparing download options
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players
Questions about downloading video
How can I download "Сложность израильского конфликта, атака по больнице, выборы/Венедиктов**: Будем Наблюдать //21.10.23" video?
http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.
Which format of "Сложность израильского конфликта, атака по больнице, выборы/Венедиктов**: Будем Наблюдать //21.10.23" video should I choose?
The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.
Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Сложность израильского конфликта, атака по больнице, выборы/Венедиктов**: Будем Наблюдать //21.10.23" video?
The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.
How can I download "Сложность израильского конфликта, атака по больнице, выборы/Венедиктов**: Будем Наблюдать //21.10.23" video to my phone?
You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.
How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Сложность израильского конфликта, атака по больнице, выборы/Венедиктов**: Будем Наблюдать //21.10.23"?
The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.
How can I save a frame from a video "Сложность израильского конфликта, атака по больнице, выборы/Венедиктов**: Будем Наблюдать //21.10.23"?
This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.
What's the price of all this stuff?
It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.