Download "Итоги года. Быль о правах / 28.12.23"
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FDJqPSO2C2mk%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
Similar videos from our catalog
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F6uLVo9wYk9s%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F7ud_7tiYnJY%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FBJe-uUzvUlQ%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FHk-ZdFqY7CA%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FVHiN8F5Psss%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FaU_YIBwVgBo%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252Fgglk1TwFlEQ%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FlYRhowo43NI%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FyIguI7Oe1W8%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
Video tags
Subtitles
Russian
00:01:06
[music]00:01:32
165 minutes in Moscow on the YouTube channel00:01:35
live nail the program was about the rights00:01:37
Koloy hel gov Alexey Kuznetsov Andrey00:01:39
Melikov is our sound and video director and00:01:42
today we are summing up the00:01:44
legal results of the year according to our00:01:46
program. Well, probably there will be some00:01:48
news because some00:01:50
news continued to happen in the outgoing week.00:01:53
But in fact, we will try to00:01:56
look at the outgoing year with such an eagle eye00:01:58
from this narrowly00:02:00
professional point of view. What is he the00:02:03
Prince of what’s new in Domestic00:02:05
jurisprudence, both in theory and in practice,00:02:08
and accordingly, my first question to my00:02:11
dear friend00:02:18
co-host Lgov Koloy What do you think00:02:21
is most significant in the legal field00:02:24
in the past year in our00:02:26
country? Yes, greetings00:02:28
Alexey, I really remember00:02:32
this00:02:34
famous song by Slepakov. It was a difficult year,00:02:38
and the most important thing.00:02:41
Probably, if we look at the00:02:44
past 12 months so globally, then probably the most00:02:47
important thing - this is00:02:49
that certain trends have appeared. And00:02:52
of course, we are naturally talking about00:02:55
trends in legislation related to the00:02:59
military part of what is happening, and trends00:03:02
related to00:03:04
legislation related to00:03:05
foreign agents and that’s all that00:03:08
is connected, let’s call it in a general00:03:11
word, undesirable for the state.00:03:14
And before it was called enemies of the people00:03:16
now it’s00:03:18
called a little more civilly But the00:03:21
trends there are of course trends00:03:24
towards the bonds and values so00:03:28
called00:03:30
there yes Family values00:03:34
values associated00:03:37
there with traditional relationships00:03:41
non-traditional relationships this is00:03:43
like another part of what we are00:03:47
seeing In the current In the current00:03:50
agenda and, of00:03:53
course, we are talking00:03:55
about such a trend aimed at00:03:59
the safety00:04:02
of a certain circle of people. Yes, from the00:04:06
managers of the state, this is00:04:08
certainly connected with the events that now you00:04:11
look at it as something that happened in a00:04:13
past life and this was only 5-600:04:16
months ago and Well, you can look back00:04:19
and see how much everything00:04:22
has changed since that time. It would seem that00:04:24
it was in June Yes, the month of June and,00:04:27
accordingly, the00:04:30
death or crash of a plane in00:04:32
which00:04:35
there was a Prigo-like00:04:39
Let's legally establish his death00:04:41
because it was launched, so00:04:43
we can speak without fear there are some00:04:47
consequences that, as it were, legally00:04:49
he is recognized as dead. Let’s say that while00:04:54
the inheritance is already flat,00:04:58
I would have sold it. It’s quite recent,00:05:03
but we understand how00:05:05
fleeting everything is, how quickly00:05:09
news dies. And of course, there’s another important00:05:14
trend that I’m talking about did not say this is a trend00:05:16
associated00:05:18
with,00:05:21
say,00:05:23
leveling the influence of international00:05:26
law on national law Yes, this is00:05:28
what we are talking about the termination of00:05:31
international treaties related to the00:05:33
Council of Europe and everything that concerns Europe00:05:35
and so on, this is the Convention for the Protection of00:05:39
Human Rights, this is the Convention on the00:05:41
Suppression of terrorism, this and the charter on00:05:44
local self-government, there is a00:05:46
European social charter and so00:05:48
on. That is, several international00:05:51
documents we are essentially e00:05:59
And thereby we are separating ourselves from the rest of00:06:03
Europe by saying that we are not ready to00:06:05
continue to exist in the same space with you, the right00:06:08
to exist Well, first of all turn is, of00:06:10
course, the ECHR, which for us was for00:06:13
lawyers, first of all, a kind of00:06:15
outlet because00:06:18
few of the lawyers reached00:06:21
this instance, but many of the lawyers00:06:24
used certain positions of the ECHR in00:06:28
certain cases in practice and it00:06:31
was impossible not to take them into account Although It is clear00:06:33
that the courts there of the first there of the first00:06:35
second instance did not particularly pay00:06:38
attention to all this, but nevertheless, for00:06:40
example, on the website of the Supreme Court at one00:06:42
time there appeared not only the practice of the00:06:45
ECtHR, but even some00:06:48
reviews of practitioners that the Supreme Court itself appeared00:06:52
on its own behalf publishes Yes, not just a00:06:54
link to, but precisely what the Supreme Court00:06:57
says. Pay attention to00:06:58
such and such a practice, to such and such a practice, I00:07:00
will confirm your words by the fact that00:07:03
literally in a couple of years Before the twenty-00:07:05
second year, I00:07:06
had to be a00:07:08
history teacher several times advocacy at00:07:10
various bar studies in the regions And00:07:13
twice I witnessed the00:07:16
speech of Nikolai Matveevich Kipnis, a00:07:18
famous Moscow lawyer and00:07:21
probably an even more famous00:07:23
law teacher, and he was just giving lectures to colleagues00:07:28
at the ECHR and because Russian cases are being00:07:32
considered there, respectively. What00:07:34
decisions have been made and so these speeches00:07:37
met with the legal community with00:07:40
great interest, they asked him a00:07:42
lot of questions, that is, it was clear that00:07:44
Russian lawyers see this as a00:07:47
really practical00:07:49
tool that is important for them, yes,00:07:53
yes, I’ll give you a very00:07:56
interesting example. In my opinion, an example is one of00:07:58
my colleagues00:08:00
every once when the court00:08:02
hearing on a criminal case began and when her00:08:04
client was sitting in a cage, she, referring00:08:06
to the practice of the Supreme Court, filed a00:08:08
petition to allow him00:08:10
to sit next to her because it degrades her00:08:12
dignity and so on and so on and there, well, I don’t00:08:15
know. In one of the places cases00:08:18
this did not work out Well, this is also good, yes, that00:08:21
is, the very fact of the possibility of citing the00:08:25
practice of the European Court00:08:28
from the practice of Russian courts, this00:08:33
was already a good opportunity00:08:36
to justify one way or another your00:08:38
position, but this is how we remember00:08:42
this opportunity in March deprived and today we00:08:45
cannot be more precise, we can refer But00:08:48
the courts do not perceive this In any way00:08:51
and therefore naturally I have already00:08:58
changed Documents no longer00:09:05
refer to all this And of course for them it does not00:09:09
matter at all, but I wanted to00:09:11
remember and I really00:09:14
wanted to Remind to start with such a fun,00:09:18
fun00:09:20
reminder that we have in January of this00:09:22
year, I just specifically looked at what the00:09:24
funniest news was. T the00:09:28
funniest news is that passengers in the00:09:30
upper berths on long-distance [ __ ] trains were00:09:34
given the right to sit on the lower00:09:37
berths while eating, this is right for me00:09:42
It seems like the news from Saltykov00:09:45
Shchedrin is like this.00:09:47
You know, it characterizes our00:09:49
time and what is allowed and the fact that00:09:54
people on long-00:09:58
distance trains are in the lower berths.00:10:04
speaking at one time in my00:10:06
youth I traveled a lot by00:10:08
trains. I love trains and I was00:10:10
absolutely sure that00:10:13
passengers in the upper berths always had this right. It was00:10:15
somehow so self-evident00:10:17
that a person should be given the opportunity to00:10:19
eat there three times a day in comfortable00:10:22
conditions. that when I found out that00:10:24
now it turns out that this right has finally been00:10:27
officially suppressed, so to speak.00:10:30
What a pity that I no longer00:10:33
teach at school because I00:10:35
used to have a problem. How to explain in00:10:37
practice to show what a legal00:10:39
custom is. Is there such a topic as sources of00:10:40
law and legal custom? now00:10:43
I would have an example I say00:10:46
look guys it turns out before this00:10:49
Before January of this year, the fact is that00:10:52
passengers in the lower bunks should move three times a00:10:54
day and let passengers from the00:10:56
upper bunks eat normally, it turns out it00:10:58
would have been a legal custom and00:11:00
only now so to speak, it was introduced to the institute and00:11:05
the right was entered if we talk today about certain00:11:10
changes for the year in the form of certain00:11:15
nominations, then the nomination is the incident of the year. I00:11:17
think it will be Just this one, this00:11:21
news. But the nomination, in my opinion, the00:11:24
nomination of the year is an increase of a young00:11:27
age This is for just a00:11:29
fantastic story Well, yes, when the00:11:31
lower one is lower immediately and the upper one Yes, it00:11:34
will be more accurate the other way around. Uh-huh00:11:37
Yes, first they00:11:40
had to immediately raise it to 30 years old, and from 18 to00:11:45
21 they should have raised it every next00:11:48
year, one year at a time, but00:11:50
in the end they did it how they raised it to 30 And00:11:54
they said we won’t raise it from 18, let the00:11:57
people ask Yes, let it remain00:12:00
Yes, well, that is, in my opinion, this is a00:12:02
clean scam, yes, that is, First we00:12:05
will say this and then like this and in the end00:12:07
now we have00:12:09
conscripts under 30 years old from 18 to 30 years old00:12:13
And it should have been there, for example,00:12:17
that the conscription age is increasing from 1800:12:20
to00:12:21
21, and then from 27 the age limit is up to 30 and00:12:26
it turned out that00:12:27
we have increased it to riti But from 18 they didn’t raise it00:12:32
and are not going to understand Uh-huh This00:12:35
concerns the nomination wiring of the year, and00:12:39
probably the nominations,00:12:41
well, this is probably the sadness of the year - this is00:12:44
precisely Russia’s withdrawal from all sorts of00:12:47
international00:12:48
treaties. Well, in the end, this all led to something,00:12:51
yes, to the fact that we can now,00:12:53
without turning to Europe. Well, formally,00:12:57
the position has already been designated00:12:59
and constitutional court and the President of00:13:01
Russia, but we know that this is such a very00:13:05
fragile matter. Yes, the stated position is why00:13:09
we now have the formal00:13:11
right, without looking at the convention,00:13:13
for example, to cancel the moratorium on the00:13:15
death00:13:17
penalty, we can, for example,00:13:23
make Well, those decisions that are essentially00:13:26
being made now and we do not have are possible00:13:29
apply to the ECHR because we know00:13:33
that in recent years before this00:13:37
decision, this bill was adopted00:13:40
stating that we are ending the validity of00:13:42
international00:13:43
treaties of the Council of00:13:45
Europe on the territory of Russia, 25% of the total number of applications to the00:13:50
ECHR were from Russia, that is,00:13:52
imagine how many countries00:13:55
Yes, it is included in the Council of Europe How many countries are00:14:02
included? Yes And 25%, that is, a quarter of the complaints00:14:06
were from Russia, this is a lot and00:14:09
imagine now that all these00:14:12
25% of the00:14:14
complaints that are received by the ECHR do not00:14:17
go there naturally, this will greatly00:14:19
facilitate the work itself ECtHR but judicial00:14:23
practice in our country Unfortunately, the00:14:27
ability to refer00:14:30
to these00:14:32
very positions of the European Court of00:14:35
Human Rights will suffer greatly from this, and if we talk about the00:14:39
military about all these changes, then it’s00:14:42
probably important here, among other00:14:44
things, to talk about insults that00:14:47
may be there yes And we have new00:14:50
articles00:14:51
discrediting and so-called fakes Yes00:14:55
unreliable information And in relation to the00:14:57
Armed Forces but there were none in00:14:59
relation to Volunteers and remember Yes,00:15:02
when Prigozhin turned to Volodin they say00:15:04
that this is there telegram bloggers there are00:15:07
my prisoners the combatants are insulted Yes00:15:10
Think Maybe those00:15:12
who help the enemies of the state should prohibit00:15:14
any criticism and so on and so on and of00:15:17
course there it was all received with a00:15:20
bang and accordingly a rule was adopted to00:15:25
discredit participants in00:15:26
hostilities regardless of what00:15:29
status they are in Yes in including00:15:31
former prisoners and Volodin, so to speak,00:15:34
took it all under the hood then00:15:36
Imagine, what kind of dissonance is00:15:38
happening in our heads now00:15:40
when we say that Volodin urgently00:15:42
ordered to study the issue at the00:15:45
request of Prigozhin Yes, it’s amazing And how00:15:49
everything changes I I mean00:15:52
this story, too. This is about00:15:56
the trend that we talked about00:15:57
initially, you know, there is00:16:00
such a version that one of the reasons for such00:16:03
very zealous service to his cause00:16:06
on the part of the Terrible prosecutor Andrei00:16:09
Yanuarivich Vyshinsky was00:16:11
that in the party archives a document was kept00:16:13
where his signature at that time of the00:16:17
responsible employee of the Petrograd00:16:19
Council of Workers' Soldiers' Deputies00:16:21
was on the arrest warrant for00:16:24
Vladimir Ich Ulyanov, and this fact of the00:16:27
presence of such compromising evidence, I fully00:16:30
admit that Vladimirovich Putin00:16:32
also appreciates Volodin for the fact that he can always be00:16:35
reminded like this to say in front of whom he00:16:45
deflected the state of the value of00:16:48
the frame, I will remind you that this was not in a00:16:51
past life, but precisely this year when, for00:16:55
example, we were suing the same Prigo Yes, I am00:16:59
representing Alexey Alekseevich00:17:01
Venediktov, whom the authorities00:17:03
are forcing us to call a foreign agent,00:17:06
we were suing there and now a year ago And in00:17:10
February we served there. Well, that is, there was a00:17:12
meeting on newly opened ones, and so00:17:14
on and so on, then, in00:17:16
fact, Prigozhin said his00:17:19
famous phrase That I didn’t have and there was no00:17:23
need for secrecy Yes,00:17:25
something like that He said very beautiful, that00:17:31
’s why it seems to me that this can also be identified as one of the00:17:35
notable events of the year.00:17:37
And of course, the important thing00:17:40
is the legally important one. In my opinion,00:17:43
we cannot help but touch upon the topic of when00:17:46
suspected accused and even00:17:48
administratively00:17:50
arrested people are now00:17:52
required to submit a00:17:54
report on this matter. and00:17:57
today we are discussing it, we have it and on the00:18:01
YouTube channel a living nail, each of00:18:03
these topics was discussed there. In a separate00:18:05
program, well, if not the entire program, then at00:18:08
least a significant part of it00:18:10
was discussed in detail. Therefore,00:18:12
our viewers, if any of the00:18:15
topics discussed today are of interest we can00:18:17
look in more detail Well, I want00:18:19
to say that our program is not that00:18:21
old Yes, it has been on the air for 5 years But at the very00:18:24
beginning I remember we also discussed00:18:26
fingerprints In what cases00:18:29
can they be demanded In what cases00:18:31
can they be refused And now before the obligation00:18:34
we started with this Well, in one of the00:18:36
very first programs there was somewhere at one00:18:38
time Yes, you can retrieve the archives I hope00:18:40
that it is possible By the way, there may00:18:43
be problems with this Although our colleagues are00:18:47
doing a lot to00:18:48
restore the archives I hope before us00:18:51
someday it will come, it means they will get their00:18:54
hands on it, so this is a short path from00:18:57
fingerprints, which were known00:18:59
back in the 10th century, to DNA analysis, which in00:19:01
general is more or less the frontier of DD pergo00:19:06
yes Well, I think that this is important to know for00:19:10
our viewers because you and I are00:19:13
still00:19:14
one thing When, for example, DNA is taken from the00:19:18
accused Yes, those I don’t know are in pre-trial detention center00:19:20
Well, God be with them there, somehow00:19:22
this can be understood, but for administratively00:19:25
arrested people who have been arrested for 15 days00:19:27
or00:19:29
whose suspicions can be lifted after00:19:31
10 days00:19:32
yes If some kind of charge has not been brought,00:19:34
then in this sense I think00:19:37
this is an unnecessary measure,00:19:38
especially for administratively arrested people.00:19:42
Well, it00:19:44
seems to me as they say, young people say.00:19:47
And this year, by the way, a00:19:51
decision was made00:19:55
not to label foreign agents for the00:19:58
first time. It happened this year That is, the00:20:00
law itself on foreign agents has already been00:20:03
almost 13 years old, and it’s been like that for00:20:07
more than 12 years. Yes, but for00:20:12
the first time this year, a case was considered00:20:15
for not being00:20:16
labeled in the Criminal Code, as in the00:20:19
administrative code, I call it00:20:23
Polystay, which is connected00:20:27
with00:20:30
activity on statements I think00:20:32
this is to politicize the Armed Forces00:20:34
and here is Article 330 in the Criminal00:20:38
Code, it provides for00:20:39
liability for failure to provide00:20:42
documents for inclusion in the register, and so on00:20:44
and so forth, but it provides for the so-00:20:47
called administrative action,00:20:50
which we also talked about00:20:52
there. The00:20:57
article is the article of the same name. Yes, no00:21:00
marking, no provision of documents,00:21:02
if under this article00:21:04
they are brought to administrative responsibility twice within a year,00:21:06
then automatically the third00:21:08
time they are already charged with criminal00:21:10
liability, and it was on this00:21:13
basis that a case was opened00:21:17
against Artyom00:21:19
Vankov, this is such00:21:21
an activist, he was recognized as a foreign00:21:23
agent and relations in this year, throughout the00:21:28
history of this norm, a00:21:30
criminal case was opened00:21:33
against, more precisely, in fact, non-compliance with the00:21:37
requirements of the law, a foreign agent.00:21:39
And in the same00:21:41
year, in the outgoing 2023, it was00:21:46
decided that Rosreestr will not00:21:49
publish information about the owners of the00:21:52
USR extract if it was ordered by third00:21:55
parties, remember we this was also discussed, that00:21:57
is,00:21:58
the data will be such data from will be00:22:01
available only if the owner gives00:22:03
his consent to this, that is, if for00:22:06
example I want to find out what00:22:08
real estate property belongs to Alexey00:22:11
Kuznetsov, then I will not be able to do this as00:22:14
before by ordering an extract from the Unified State Register. But I00:22:17
need to this will be Alexey’s consent, I00:22:20
think Alexey will never refuse me this00:22:22
if00:22:29
everything that is connected is necessary again. This is what I call00:22:32
ideological protection because00:22:36
Propaganda of symbols, after all, it00:22:38
seems to me that this is ideological protection,00:22:43
and this00:22:45
year they adopted such a design Yes, I have it00:22:48
I call it exactly that, that00:22:51
is, the ban on Propaganda of Nazi00:22:54
paraphernalia was in fact00:22:56
equated00:22:58
to the ban on the propaganda of paraphernalia similar00:23:01
to Nazis,00:23:02
respectively, this was equated to the00:23:05
paraphernalia of extremist organizations00:23:07
that were recognized by the court as extremist and00:23:10
this was equated to the paraphernalia of00:23:12
banned organizations.00:23:14
And if you look at this whole logic,00:23:17
a series of these Here is an organization that00:23:21
turns out to be such that00:23:24
we recognize organizations as extremist,00:23:27
the court00:23:28
means the court can equate any organization00:23:31
to a Nazi organization, relatively speaking,00:23:34
by recognizing it as extremist, and that00:23:36
is,00:23:45
equating for Propaganda, for example,00:23:48
Nazi paraphernalia, putting it on a par with the00:23:52
demonstration of paraphernalia of an extremist00:23:54
organization. That is, this is one and the same00:23:56
Pack turns out that And this year we,00:24:01
well, we can state the fact that00:24:05
the state has00:24:07
established such a structure. So00:24:11
there is a political structure, this00:24:13
structure is recognized as extremist Yes,00:24:16
for obvious reasons, and00:24:20
accordingly, everything connected with this00:24:22
extremist paraphernalia is00:24:26
recognized as equivalent,00:24:29
accordingly Well, it is prohibited Yes,00:24:31
such a conclusion is prohibited for demonstration, that is,00:24:35
relatively speaking,00:24:37
there is a political figure Ivan Ivanovich,00:24:40
I’m not specifically naming anyone now, a00:24:43
political figure Ivan Ivanovich,00:24:45
he has an organization there that is00:24:47
engaged in political activities,00:24:48
there is a logo, there are flags there, and so00:24:51
on,00:24:52
commodity goods00:24:56
Iva Iva and the organization are recognized00:24:59
extremists,00:25:01
then all this paraphernalia is00:25:04
automatically prohibited as attributes of an00:25:07
extremist organization, and this00:25:09
design is actually like this,00:25:12
like the blockchain Yes, one after another,00:25:14
it closes behind itself these00:25:22
gaps that are necessary for the state. But speaking of this, there is00:25:28
no need to further recognize00:25:30
through the court It is precisely his attributes of some kind of00:25:32
extremist that are00:25:34
automatically, you yourself at the beginning of00:25:36
the program compared, although in00:25:39
favor of the current times, but the current00:25:41
times are with those when it00:25:44
was all called the enemy of the people, and then, too,00:25:46
automatically, if a person was declared an00:25:48
enemy of the people, then members of the family of the enemy of the00:25:51
people, respectively already in00:25:53
court and so on, the same thing is happening, thank00:25:55
God.00:25:56
Well, for now, yes, I00:25:59
agree. Our times00:26:01
have not yet reached such a level; this is00:26:04
still happening with trademarks and not with00:26:06
family members. Although there is always room to grow in00:26:09
the middle of the hour and literally by a few00:26:12
tens of seconds we are distracted We remind you about the00:26:14
existence of our breadwinner shd00:26:18
Media Speaking of the breadwinner, today at00:26:22
22:05 the final Live Nail Stream begins,00:26:26
which is planned for 4 hours00:26:29
Irina Vorobyova Alexey Venediktov will lead there00:26:31
will be many interesting guests and00:26:33
employees of the Living Nail and regular00:26:36
guests of our channel So come00:26:39
this also has to do with your00:26:42
selfless help to us. Well, as00:26:44
for our shd Media, there are now00:26:48
a lot of different gifts that you can00:26:53
give for the New Year or00:26:55
Orthodox Christmas or some other00:26:58
holidays, these include antique books, and00:27:01
books for gift editions. Well, of these00:27:04
from the mass literature of historical00:27:07
literature, which is a00:27:08
specialization of our online store,00:27:11
this is the book we have already advertised. The00:27:14
Great Chronicle of Poland, the Rus and their00:27:17
neighbors in the 19th and 1st centuries, this is one of the00:27:20
fundamental medieval chronicles of00:27:22
Europe. You can say this is a Polish00:27:25
Tale of Bygone Years, remarkably00:27:28
published, equipped maps supplied with00:27:30
reference material edited by an00:27:33
outstanding Soviet Russian00:27:35
historian one of the largest Russian00:27:38
archaeologists Unfortunately,00:27:40
Valentina Lavrentievich00:27:42
Yanina Koloy, who has already left this world, here at the beginning of our00:27:47
program in the chat there was a small00:27:49
discussion about what year DD is the00:27:54
second or twenty Trey from the point00:27:56
from the point of view of law was more Well, to put it mildly,00:27:59
more turning point, I understand that we are talking00:28:02
about such a very evaluative concept of00:28:05
worse is better, and it is clear that the twenty-00:28:08
third is now00:28:10
ending before our eyes, and the twenty-second was a year00:28:12
ago, so Yes, it’s difficult00:28:15
to compare them enough human memory00:28:17
interferes with this, but still, at the level of00:28:19
sensation, would you say it’s more00:28:22
shocking or something from the point of view of Changes00:28:24
in the law twenty-second or twenty-three,00:28:29
of course And look,00:28:32
and when something happens that00:28:36
happened in February twenty-two,00:28:40
and this the very00:28:42
turning point after which00:28:46
everything is bad. What can happen00:28:48
no longer seems so bad because one00:28:51
gets used to it and, of course, from the point00:28:54
of view of the00:28:56
radicality of the decisions made,00:28:59
let’s call it that, and it00:29:01
was much more difficult. It’s possible00:29:04
that in 23 the ones taken, let’s say, are much more00:29:10
complex from the point of view from the point of view of the law there and the00:29:14
right00:29:16
of construction, but what happened in the00:29:18
twenty-second year in the form of a pledge for00:29:23
criticism00:29:26
and00:29:27
speeches and everything that happened as a result,00:29:30
plus then the mobilization and everything that00:29:33
happened after the mobilization,00:29:36
naturally the twenty-second year was00:29:38
more difficult in this sense. Well, I have exactly the00:29:41
same feeling that what we00:29:43
are raking up Well, more precisely, we still have to00:29:45
rake it in rake it up until00:29:48
we rake it in the twenty-third year - these are the00:29:50
consequences of the twenty-second everything00:29:53
nothing radically new happened in the twenty-third00:29:55
this is all the development of00:29:58
that turning point that00:30:00
happened in d00:30:02
second Yes Absolutely true because everything00:30:06
that is adopted after And we also00:30:08
forget about the sentences that are passed00:30:11
Yes on one or another article to politicize00:30:12
and because these sentences they00:30:17
will say you know how they create an atmosphere00:30:20
in society they create an atmosphere and an00:30:24
understanding of where Aa where we are moving00:30:29
specifically on the verdict and on those cases00:30:33
that are being initiated. Because when00:30:35
they are sentenced to 8 years for there are some kind of00:30:39
price tags or something else. Well, people immediately,00:30:42
well, or whatever. Or like today, six for00:30:45
reading00:30:46
poetry, yes, dadada, yes, that is you see, yes,00:30:50
that is, there are 9 years for going to a00:30:52
rally, 8 years for changing the price tags, 600:30:55
years for reading poetry, and in society,00:30:59
of course, this is created like, well, if00:31:02
that’s the case, then probably no, we won’t00:31:05
do anything else, and in general the purpose of00:31:07
all this is this, yes And also against the00:31:10
backdrop of this changing legislation,00:31:13
which essentially prohibits you from00:31:16
speaking out under threat00:31:17
of prison,00:31:20
then of course in this sense the second was much00:31:24
more difficult, much more difficult, and because00:31:28
you know how, after a turning00:31:31
point, everything else is already is taken for00:31:34
granted, yes.00:31:38
Let’s imagine using the example of the media.00:31:41
Yes, they closed Echo just like that00:31:45
with a click and closed it and that’s it. And then everyone00:31:48
realized that there would be no more free00:31:51
media, at least one with a00:31:54
license, it wouldn’t be the same00:31:58
now. Everyone understood everything. in addition to the new newspaper,00:32:01
after which they also closed the new New newspaper00:32:04
closed the rain closed the Echo closed00:32:07
until before first the rain then Echo then the00:32:11
new everything Well, that00:32:14
is, using the same example, you can Well, how00:32:17
can you00:32:18
project all this to the right, yes, that is, you00:32:22
first get00:32:24
some kind of huge on the head and then everything that00:32:29
follows there on the legs On the arms On the00:32:31
torso it is no longer perceived as00:32:33
painful as what was on the head Yes00:32:36
And here the same thing, that is, we suddenly00:32:39
received some kind of fracture and then00:32:43
everything is in the context of this fracture is00:32:44
already taken for00:32:46
granted and in this, of course, the00:32:50
twenty-second year was more difficult than the twenty-00:32:51
third; it took me so long to answer the question00:32:54
regarding what was more difficult, but00:32:57
naturally we cannot ignore the00:33:00
decision of the international criminal court,00:33:03
which was also It would seem that it will00:33:05
turn out in March that this was a long, long time ago00:33:07
many years ago, but let me remind you00:33:11
that the International Criminal Court announced the00:33:13
issuance of an arrest warrant for President00:33:15
Vladimir Putin and the Commissioner for00:33:17
Children's Rights Maria Lvova Belova00:33:21
Yes, and they are accused of crimes00:33:24
related to the forced transfer of00:33:27
children from Ukraine to Russia00:33:29
Well, What can we say, yes, this is an00:33:32
extraordinary event for our country. I00:33:35
mean that never in my life has there been such a thing00:33:37
that the international criminal court in general, in00:33:39
general, in any of the developed countries as we00:33:42
position ourselves, attracted anyone there00:33:44
or issued warrants, I will remind you that these00:33:47
were countries such as cat divoir00:33:50
Kenya Sudan And who else did we have?00:33:55
According to the International Criminal Court,00:33:57
Muammar Gaddafi, as far as I remember, was also00:33:59
Well, in short, in general00:34:03
there were seven people in total00:34:06
who fell under this story00:34:08
But this is infrequent history and it must be said00:34:11
that not a single guilty verdict has00:34:14
yet been passed00:34:16
Yes by the international criminal court But00:34:19
why Because two were acquitted,00:34:23
strangely enough That’s just in my opinion00:34:26
Mr. Bakbo President Cat Divoir was00:34:29
acquitted in the nineteenth year and00:34:32
then two did not live to see the verdicts and there, in00:34:37
my opinion, If I’m not00:34:40
mistaken, someone from the international So00:34:43
now I’ll say in my opinion,00:34:47
either the President of Kenya, I’m not ready00:34:49
to say now, someone in general is waiting for00:34:52
their extradition And in my opinion,00:34:55
the President of Liberia is the first of those00:34:58
convicted, I can’t say yes yes, but I think00:35:05
someone from the neighboring country is waiting for his extradition, I think Sudan If I’m00:35:08
not mistaken, an African country Yes, in00:35:10
my opinion, someone from Sudan, the president00:35:12
of Sudan is waiting for00:35:15
extradition nice, as we know, he was arrested00:35:19
but died in prison Well, actually00:35:23
speaking: If only00:35:27
someone was detained there, someone was00:35:29
acquitted, someone is awaiting00:35:31
extradition in general, the decision of the international00:35:34
criminal court is probably00:35:38
no longer a legal one, but rather a00:35:41
symbolic00:35:43
gesture by which the international criminal court00:35:45
says00:35:46
that A a crime is being committed in Ukraine00:35:49
and B00:35:52
that they should00:35:55
be investigated00:35:57
submitted now, well, in addition to the symbolic00:36:00
meaning, we observe, so to speak,00:36:02
certain slightly00:36:05
nervous notes leaking out about When00:36:07
the question arises: Should I go? Yes, on departure, yes, can00:36:12
the state? Let us remember the case of SA, and so00:36:14
on. Can the state guarantee,00:36:17
so to speak, the non-application of this decision of the00:36:21
international criminal court? So that I00:36:24
will remind you that 123 countries are parties to00:36:28
the statute, they have all00:36:32
the grounds for arrest, that is, they00:36:34
signed it there, and so00:36:36
on. What else, well, remember the story with00:36:39
Armenia? And also that they ratified00:36:41
the statute, this was also an element of the00:36:45
deterioration of Relations between Russia and00:36:49
Armenia Well, actually speaking of the countries00:36:53
participating in the Rome Statute, they00:36:55
can take such measures, but in general, I do00:36:59
n’t think that00:37:01
now we’ll say it’s safe00:37:03
Putin’s security service And Putin himself is unlikely to00:37:07
trust someone in this way to go somewhere and00:37:11
where he’s not00:37:12
sure further again but covid00:37:16
is coming back covid Yes, by the way, well,00:37:19
thank God I00:37:22
see a little in my surroundings, but I hear that many are sick00:37:23
yes yes What I mean is that we know more00:37:27
for the security service there are no grounds for anything00:37:29
What is00:37:30
more important I would really like to actually00:37:33
touch on another a little bit of the topic, again00:37:35
returning to the military topic because we00:37:37
somehow missed it,00:37:39
but it’s very important. In my00:37:43
opinion, the case is when the Supreme Court00:37:47
outlined What surrender is, remember00:37:51
Yes, the Supreme Court said that surrender00:37:55
when there is an00:37:57
opportunity, quote, to provide00:37:59
decisive00:38:00
resistance then This is a crime, that00:38:03
is, you need to somehow00:38:06
resist more resolutely, and we know that if you00:38:09
resolutely resist, then00:38:10
chances are you no longer need yes yes yes captivity to00:38:15
surrender It’s no longer necessary Yes, but00:38:18
nevertheless, the Supreme Court said that this00:38:20
will happen if you resolutely not showing00:38:22
resistance, then this is Voluntary surrender,00:38:24
captivity implies up to 1000:38:28
years of imprisonment,00:38:29
and at the same time, if you surrendered and00:38:33
then went over to the side of the enemy, then the00:38:36
article of treason is already applied to him and not00:38:38
just Voluntary surrender And00:38:40
treason like us we know there are 20 years of00:38:43
imprisonment as far as I remember Yes, well, he00:38:46
went over to the side of the enemy, that’s understandable, yes,00:38:48
it’s really one of the00:38:51
main elements of high00:38:53
treason there, it’s00:38:55
also clear from the military theme. I00:38:58
think it’s important00:39:00
to understand this whole cycle of00:39:02
prisoners in nature. Yes, I think so I call it00:39:05
when ZK goes to war from prison00:39:10
from the war, he has fought for six months,00:39:16
returns to his home already a free00:39:21
person, so to speak, without a criminal record, after a couple of months he commits a00:39:24
new crime and again goes to prison00:39:27
from prison again, so to speak.00:39:28
You know, this is the cycle that stole drank00:39:30
in prison as in that Absolutely right Yes,00:39:33
romance, about the same story is00:39:35
happening now Yes, this romance,00:39:37
unfortunately, romance can only be00:39:39
for the00:39:40
prisoners themselves who are mobilized00:39:43
in this way But in general00:39:46
there is no romance for those who are around them00:39:47
Because when they00:39:49
return they commit the same grave00:39:52
Particularly grave crimes, for example, there are00:39:54
many cases when prisoners who have00:39:58
served, so to speak, their allotted sentence00:40:00
for their 6 months and returned to their00:40:04
home after 6 months, they00:40:06
commit the same murders, the same00:40:09
violent crimes,00:40:11
crimes of a sexual nature,00:40:13
crimes and go back to prison to these00:40:15
prisons and again right there we remember00:40:20
the right of the Ministry of Defense Yes,00:40:23
let’s recruit such people00:40:26
under a contract and send them there again,00:40:30
we know that quite recently a law was passed00:40:33
giving the right to the National Guard to have00:40:37
corresponding volunteer00:40:39
units, this is also part of00:40:42
this whole story, plus I I think it wouldn’t be amiss to00:40:45
remind you what benefits were00:40:46
accepted for those who went on their Yes, I00:40:49
mean under the contract for mobilization00:40:52
and so on, yes for obtaining higher00:40:53
education,00:40:55
yes Yes, there is a lot of everything there, from e00:41:00
payments to employment or00:41:04
placement of children in education or00:41:07
Some people themselves, that is, they actually00:41:10
adopted a lot of different00:41:15
benefits in favor of these00:41:18
same servicemen. Let’s call them00:41:21
that, but let me remind you at the same time. Yes,00:41:23
those who were mobilized00:41:26
in September October last year. They are00:41:28
still fighting, that is, for more than a year.00:41:31
they do not return home And those who00:41:36
were convicted and served their sentence They00:41:39
still return after six months This is a very00:41:43
strange moment, in my opinion, given00:41:46
that, of course, the mobilized00:41:48
are released on vacation there for, in my opinion, 2 or00:41:51
weeks, they are released home Then they00:41:53
come back. Here it must be said that there00:41:55
is00:41:56
some truth in this, but in any case they are not00:42:00
released without ends, as is done,00:42:02
for example,00:42:03
with prisoners who were involved in a00:42:07
military operation. And it must be said that00:42:10
this story is about a pardon mechanism,00:42:13
which we have also talked about many times on00:42:16
the air he’s also a kind of event.00:42:20
That is, everyone who00:42:22
participated in the commission of crimes00:42:26
doesn’t matter there, but it happened. I had00:42:29
one case, if you remember the high-profile murder00:42:31
in Vladikavkaz when the ex-husband killed00:42:35
his ex-wife with a knife and stabbed her to death.00:42:38
Yes, I participated in the case when this same00:42:42
man even earlier had staged a stabbing there,00:42:45
I represented the interests of the00:42:47
victims there, respectively. This00:42:49
man was pardoned by Putin. He is going to his place,00:42:54
committing another crime. Yes, of a00:42:57
narcotic nature, and still,00:43:00
nevertheless, he won everything, he came to00:43:05
his place and now, well, I don’t know what his00:43:08
Fate is. but what I mean is00:43:11
that this story with the shortage of00:43:15
military personnel, it00:43:17
provoked an increase in these00:43:20
crimes that are committed by the same00:43:22
people who were released and sent to their00:43:26
own, and naturally this same Prigogine came up with it.00:43:29
Well, at least00:43:32
they implemented it, at least yes00:43:35
yes I think that’s all- it’s00:43:38
such an important point that, well, before it00:43:41
was unacceptable for us, that is, it didn’t00:43:44
fit into our heads. How can you00:43:46
drag prisoners to war and then00:43:49
return them and let them go? Can you imagine they gave a00:43:52
man 20 years, they gave him 15 years? There, for00:43:55
murder, for rape, they are simply00:43:58
taken there for six months. they00:44:00
won back and please You are not00:44:02
judged You are free and moreover you still00:44:06
have some kind of authority in society00:44:09
Because you came with yours, so to speak,00:44:12
but these are not just incomprehensible things,00:44:16
but nevertheless they happen here,00:44:19
nevertheless they happen e important trend Alesya,00:44:22
we00:44:23
talked to you and they said about an important00:44:27
trend related to the deprivation of citizenship,00:44:31
that is, this year there are a lot of00:44:35
bills that have00:44:37
been adopted aimed at depriving00:44:41
citizenship for one reason or another.00:44:43
Thank God that the Constitution00:44:46
states that it is impossible to deprive00:44:48
the citizenship of those people who have received00:44:50
it by right of birth, so-called, that00:44:52
is, those who were born00:44:53
Russians. But those who are gendered by right00:44:56
of birth are now, in my opinion, yesterday00:44:59
or the day before yesterday, the Ministry of Internal Affairs announced that in the00:45:03
Tver region in the Moscow region,00:45:06
in a couple of regions, somewhere in five00:45:08
regions of00:45:10
Moscow, they were deprived citizenship of people for the fact00:45:14
that they were brought to criminal00:45:15
liability under some articles. That00:45:17
is, this citizenship was00:45:19
acquired in the process of living in Russia and00:45:22
this is an acquired citizenship, it can00:45:25
be, that is, a person can be deprived of00:45:27
this citizenship only because he00:45:30
committed some category crimes00:45:32
Although in the Constitution, if I'm not mistaken, there are00:45:33
no conditions under which a person can00:45:36
be deprived of citizenship No, it says00:45:39
categorically Yes, yes, yes, it says there, that00:45:43
is, in fact, if we interpret the norm00:45:46
of the Constitution, it says00:45:48
that acquired citizenship by right00:45:51
of birth there are no differences, respectively, it00:45:55
just means citizenship Anyone who00:45:57
receives citizenship has the right to this,00:45:59
but now the legislator interprets this as00:46:03
meaning that the acquired citizenship is00:46:05
still second-class citizenship. Well,00:46:09
that’s it. Yes, Alexey said very precisely that this00:46:11
is second-class citizenship00:46:13
that can be given and can be taken away. Uh-huh00:46:15
Well, that’s not even citizenship is00:46:17
more like some kind of residence permit Yes, yes, of00:46:20
course it is he who was deprived of citizenship,00:46:23
you know someone who received citizenship00:46:25
and did not register with the military Well,00:46:28
yes, but in the new law that came into00:46:32
force in00:46:34
October, if you read it carefully,00:46:37
Alexey is there there is no difference at all00:46:40
between what is acquired, that is, when a00:46:44
person is deprived of citizenship for00:46:47
committing a crime, there is no this00:46:50
division between acquired by00:46:53
birthright and acquired by right, I00:46:56
don’t know life there, or what is it called00:46:58
if we speak to a simple person Well, in00:47:00
general, acquired00:47:02
citizenship, that is, there There is no such division at all,00:47:04
and my colleague who00:47:07
deals with migration matters00:47:09
recently discussed this and thought that00:47:11
if we come across such a case, we00:47:14
will need to appeal to the Constitutional00:47:16
Court to00:47:17
clarify this particular norm that is00:47:20
included in the new law, yes,00:47:23
because if this put everything that way, then tomorrow00:47:26
they will go and deprive those who, by right of00:47:30
birth, have citizenship in essence,00:47:32
that is, no, well, relatively speaking.00:47:35
It might look like if you are a citizen of00:47:37
Russia, but you did such and such and00:47:40
such and such and you too they can deprive you even00:47:42
if you have it by right of birth. Well, that’s00:47:45
the norm, but it seems very likely that everything is00:47:49
heading towards this, and in00:47:52
general, in00:47:54
general, this trend towards deprivation of00:47:57
citizenship is, unfortunately,00:48:01
very00:48:03
obvious, understandable and most likely this00:48:06
trend We will see in the next year00:48:08
Very witty in a chat with SFA with Fais called00:48:13
it, you know, as you remember, again, this is not the00:48:15
first time this year I have turned to00:48:17
Roman private law. Although God knows00:48:20
this is my only C for the entire course of00:48:22
the institute, it’s true. I then retook it,00:48:24
so I wrote citizenship or Latin00:48:28
citizenship is defective in comparison with the00:48:30
Roman one, remember, indeed, the status in00:48:32
Ancient Rome was determined by the status of libertas,00:48:35
free or slave, the status of a civilian Tati with a00:48:38
Roman, er, Latin or a foreigner. Well, the00:48:42
status is the surname and there is family, and so00:48:44
on, really Latin00:48:47
second-class citizenship, additional responsibilities per00:48:50
person, and so on and so forth further, a00:48:52
wonderful historical00:48:54
analogy ae Well, probably the main00:48:58
bill, which is more precisely the law00:49:00
that was adopted this year, is the00:49:02
law on electronic subpoenas. I00:49:04
think it made the most noise00:49:06
this year because it really00:49:09
concerns many people and this is the story00:49:13
that we saw in the period of00:49:15
mobilization in the twenty-second year, when00:49:17
these summonses were dumped into the hands of people there,00:49:21
it became Well, the need for it,00:49:24
let’s say, disappeared,00:49:26
and now so-called00:49:29
electronic summonses appear that are sent in00:49:30
parallel with the same00:49:32
written summons, many began to00:49:35
try to delete their public services, thinking00:49:37
that00:49:39
everything was fine in fact, no, well, as if00:49:42
the legislator is not a fool either Yes, he, too,00:49:45
can come up with another story, he can00:49:47
say Here’s the register, come in if you want to00:49:50
look, if you want, no, well, it’s the same thing00:49:52
as Sing a Yaik Yes, they threw me a sing and00:49:56
look there Open it if you want, don’t open it00:49:58
But we they threw it in Yes, it’s the same thing with00:50:01
the registry, whether you want to see it or not,00:50:03
we notified you accordingly, and00:50:08
then, in accordance with these new00:50:11
laws on electronic summonses, the police00:50:15
received the right to serve summonses; the police00:50:17
received the right to detain and deliver00:50:19
citizens to departments, and as we see, they successfully00:50:22
use this right Yes, we00:50:26
recently saw that they were talking about this, including that00:50:30
the police are just looking at young00:50:33
people, he is eligible00:50:35
for military service, his age means00:50:39
Let's go check. Yes, if you are not00:50:42
registered, then you are going one day, it00:50:45
means to00:50:47
serve. They quite enjoy this00:50:50
right, in addition to this, all the government agencies there are00:50:53
connected from the00:50:54
tax point tax Ministry of Internal Affairs Central00:50:58
Election Commission Ministry of Education pension fund Universities00:51:02
employers bodies there subjects any00:51:05
various bodies they now00:51:08
provide00:51:10
information in electronic00:51:13
form what you have00:51:15
there from a tax point of view what you have there in the Legislative Office00:51:18
what you have there in the Pension00:51:20
Fund what you have there in university that00:51:23
you have a criminal record there, no criminal record,00:51:26
no cases are being conducted, and so on. In00:51:28
short, all the information in accordance with00:51:30
this law is provided. Of course,00:51:33
it caused a lot of noise this year and we00:51:36
accompanied it for quite a long time in the background for a00:51:38
couple of months after the adoption of this00:51:40
law according to - I think at the end of April it was00:51:43
accepted, we talked about it and continue00:51:45
to talk about it, it seems to me until the end of00:51:48
the year00:51:50
that employers comply with this00:51:54
law, including in electronic form to their00:51:57
employees00:51:58
further.00:52:06
as a00:52:09
self-employed individual entrepreneur, real estate registration00:52:11
rights are canceled00:52:14
immediately, yes, you can’t00:52:17
register a car in your name, you can’t00:52:19
use banking products. Well,00:52:22
that is, they took and limited everything that was possible00:52:26
for these00:52:29
same military personnel who are obliged to00:52:32
serve, what else is important? Yes, if we are00:52:35
talking about trends Well, let’s not say that00:52:38
so obvious, but nevertheless, we see that00:52:42
our brother lawyer is now also starting to be00:52:46
regulated quite strictly. Yes, and00:52:50
the law has taken a lot of different initiatives00:52:53
this year, including a lawyer in00:52:54
relation to lawyers, for00:52:58
example, there are Well, let’s say there are three00:53:01
fundamentally important innovations:00:53:04
access they want to00:53:06
give out secret information in a special manner for lawyers00:53:08
yes And if a lawyer has gained access to this00:53:11
state secret which is contained in the00:53:13
case materials, then his movement, that00:53:17
is, his travel abroad may be00:53:19
limited00:53:20
Yes, in addition, if the lawyer00:53:24
has, that is, a second00:53:27
citizenship, he does not has the ability00:53:29
to protect clients in a case in which00:53:31
there is a state secret, it’s also strange, yes, that00:53:34
is, if I have a passport. Well, I’m00:53:36
exaggerating, yes, I don’t have it, but suddenly I have a00:53:40
passport, for example, of a citizen of00:53:43
Kazakhstan.00:53:45
Yes, that I don’t have the right00:53:47
to protect00:53:49
someone in Russia. It seems to me that this is some kind of... then it’s an00:53:52
illogical00:53:54
story if there is a state secret00:53:56
because we remember the constitutional court, in00:53:58
my opinion,00:53:59
back in 1996 and in00:54:04
2021 noted that the participation of00:54:08
lawyers in cases related to state secrets00:54:11
guarantees not only the right of the accused00:54:14
to receive qualified assistance but00:54:16
also the safety of secrets00:54:19
information Yes, what does this mean? This suggests that there is00:54:22
no need for additional guarantees in00:54:24
order for this state secret to be preserved,00:54:26
because the lawyer himself00:54:29
preserves it by the fact that he has this00:54:31
status of a00:54:32
lawyer. Therefore, here we can also00:54:35
say that00:54:36
the initiative regarding lawyers is also00:54:39
quite drastic. Well and the travel ban00:54:42
is actually a violation of the00:54:43
constitutional00:54:45
right in Russia to travel00:54:48
from probably, let’s say, what’s important is that00:54:52
there are still a lot of bills that we haven’t00:54:55
discussed, but they were generally00:54:58
touched upon by us during the year in one way or another, but it00:55:01
seems to me that this is important. This is what we’re talking about we00:55:04
talked today And of course,00:55:06
these monstrous sentences Vladimir Komuz00:55:09
25 years old there from the knee what 8 years00:55:13
in my opinion or 7 years00:55:16
Yes, well, in general there is Ilya Yashin and so on00:55:19
and so on We have00:55:24
a question in print Just in case, we’ll say00:55:26
that it’s recognized00:55:28
Let's not be recognized, so it will be00:55:30
sure to just show it, make sure I'm00:55:32
not recognized, but he did00:55:35
n't submit any reports, so the case was there.00:55:37
Yes, of course it was recognized. Well, here I am, that is,00:55:41
against the backdrop of all this, and these sentences,00:55:44
of course, nothing at all. There is no00:55:46
positive here.00:55:50
K Unfortunately, I don’t expect even a year from now, but on00:55:52
the contrary. I’m afraid that00:55:56
after March of 2400:55:59
it will be even worse, to put it mildly. Well,00:56:03
let’s see, as they say, we’ll00:56:05
observe our transmission of00:56:12
pumping in the best rodeo, we’ll00:56:15
test it experimentally with you00:56:17
within of this whole year, in fact, for00:56:19
5 years already there have been Cola Akhilgov Alexey00:56:22
Kuznetsov our program congratulates you on the00:56:25
upcoming New Year, we sincerely00:56:28
hope that it will still be00:56:30
better than the previous one in the near future00:56:33
you have a free hour you00:56:35
can have a snack smokers take a smoke break everyone00:56:39
else as they say in army rewind00:56:41
footcloths 1805 on air program not so00:56:45
trial of linguist Ivan badum do00:56:48
kurte on charges of publishing an00:56:51
outrageous00:56:53
essay in 1914 110 years ago Ivan00:56:57
Aleksandrovich wrote the current00:56:59
legislators and rulers of Russia would like to00:57:02
destroy the slightest traces of local00:57:04
originality of00:57:06
individuality and at the same time make it00:57:09
impossible all sorts of attempts at social00:57:11
activity in times were 110 years00:57:14
ago yes That's how he came to live like this00:57:16
we will deal with the rebel00:57:18
in 1905 in a dissenting opinion00:57:22
freshly made on the Agent theologian Adre00:57:24
Kuraev will talk to him Anton nut00:57:28
2105 on Pastukhov's Thursdays00:57:30
classic composition two foreign agents00:57:32
Vladimir Pastukhov and Oh, excuse me, not a00:57:35
classic with him, not a foreign agent Liza00:57:37
Anikina pah-pah But foreign agent Alexey00:57:40
Venediktov will appear after00:57:43
2205 presenters Along with Irina Vorobyova, the00:57:47
final stream in support of the channel00:57:49
live gvost Amateur All the best to you00:58:03
NDescription:
Поддержать Живой гвоздь: с карт российских банков https://pay.cloudtips.ru/p/7edd7c0e с карт иностранных банков https://www.donationalerts.com/r/zhivgvozd Boosty: https://boosty.to/zhivoygvozd Криптокошелёк: bc1qmdt96xvsun9a8qxvgakfx9gqy4x72penx5rm2p Trust Wallet: https://link.trustwallet.com/send?address=bc1qmdt96xvsun9a8qxvgakfx9gqy4x72penx5rm2p&asset=c0 Главные юридические события года выбирают, а их текущее состояние и перспективы - анализируют Калой Ахильгов @ahikaloy и Алексей Кузнецов. Телеграм-канал Калоя Ахильгова: https://t.me/akaloy Новый — пятый том комикса в серии «Спасти» уже в продаже! На этот раз авторы попытались вызволить из Тауэра наследников внезапно скончавшегося английского короля Эдуарда IV. Купить: https://diletant.shop/tproduct/596598185-351029717571-kniga-spasti-printsev-iz-tauera-tom-5 📌 Живой гвоздь в аудиоформате: https://podcast.ru/1616175210 🔔 Последние новости и анонсы программ с YouTube-канала «Живой гвоздь», а также контент от наших постоянных гостей и экспертов на официальном телеграм-канале: https://t.me/livegvozd Мобильное приложение "Эха": любимые программы в формате радиоприёмника. Простой интерфейс. Работа в фоновом режиме. Расписание эфиров. Скачать: в AppStore: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/%D1%8D%D1%85%D0%BE-online/id1639907671 в PlayMarket: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=online.echofm.app Сайт "Эха": https://echofm.online/ (если не открывается – ссылка на рабочую версию сайта всегда есть в тг-канале ЭХО FM https://telegram.org/ Подписаться на Youtube-канал Дилетант: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuIE7-5QzeAR6EdZXwDRwuQ?sub_confirmation=1 Магазин Дилетант: https://diletant.shop/ По вопросам взаимодействия: [email protected]
Preparing download options
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players
Questions about downloading video
How can I download "Итоги года. Быль о правах / 28.12.23" video?
http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.
Which format of "Итоги года. Быль о правах / 28.12.23" video should I choose?
The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.
Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Итоги года. Быль о правах / 28.12.23" video?
The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.
How can I download "Итоги года. Быль о правах / 28.12.23" video to my phone?
You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.
How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Итоги года. Быль о правах / 28.12.23"?
The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.
How can I save a frame from a video "Итоги года. Быль о правах / 28.12.23"?
This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.
What's the price of all this stuff?
It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.