Download "Константин Ремчуков / Персонально ваш // 16.05.2022"

"videoThumbnail Константин Ремчуков / Персонально ваш // 16.05.2022

Личный приём / @user-lj9pp2mx5b // 16.05.2022

Личный приём / @user-lj9pp2mx5b // 16.05.2022

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Белковский + Бунтман / 15 февраля 2024 @BelkovskiyS #белковский #новости #политика #belkovskiy

Белковский + Бунтман / 15 февраля 2024 @BelkovskiyS #белковский #новости #политика #belkovskiy

Channel: Белковский

Атаки на Москву, поджоги военкоматов, арест Кагарлицкого*. Дубнов: Утренний разворот / 02.08.23

Атаки на Москву, поджоги военкоматов, арест Кагарлицкого*. Дубнов: Утренний разворот / 02.08.23

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Московские СИЗО переполнены. Дело Беркович и Петрийчук. Ева Меркачёва: Персонально ваш / 10.01.24

Московские СИЗО переполнены. Дело Беркович и Петрийчук. Ева Меркачёва: Персонально ваш / 10.01.24

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Регистрация Надеждина. Что с Залужным? Дмитрий Стратиевский: Особое мнение / 06.02.24

Регистрация Надеждина. Что с Залужным? Дмитрий Стратиевский: Особое мнение / 06.02.24

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

В Человеческом измерении. Неделя с Леонидом Гозманом* и Ириной Баблоян // 02.07.2023

В Человеческом измерении. Неделя с Леонидом Гозманом* и Ириной Баблоян // 02.07.2023

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

Владислав Иноземцев*: Особое мнение / 23.05.24

Владислав Иноземцев*: Особое мнение / 23.05.24

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

МУС уравнял Нетаньяху и Путина. Гибель президента Ирана. Шевченко: Особое мнение @MaximShevchenko

МУС уравнял Нетаньяху и Путина. Гибель президента Ирана. Шевченко: Особое мнение @MaximShevchenko

Channel: Живой Гвоздь

венедиктов

пастухов

живой гвоздь

политика

00:00:00

[music]

00:00:13

[music]

00:00:32

15 o’clock exactly in our capital this

00:00:35

drift in the parade of unfamiliarity always

00:00:37

says time something else, although here on

00:00:39

YouTube it’s not so important how much

00:00:40

time, mostly then you’ll look

00:00:42

at the recordings to watch interesting conversations with

00:00:45

interesting people Konstantin Remchukov,

00:00:47

we are not all personal, your editor-in-chief,

00:00:49

general director and

00:00:50

independent newspaper, Konstantin Vadim,

00:00:52

now I welcome you, I have risen, well,

00:00:56

let’s start with serious topics because

00:00:58

then, of course, there will be universally

00:01:00

delicious all sorts of McDonald’s Muscovites,

00:01:02

so I’ll try you a little with such

00:01:04

questions, but here they serve

00:01:06

Sweden and Finland are applying for membership in NATO,

00:01:09

and thus there

00:01:11

is a prospect that seems not of the past, the

00:01:14

border of Russia is right here what is called

00:01:16

within walking distance from St. Petersburg, how can

00:01:20

this situation be assessed there,

00:01:24

you know in politics and there are

00:01:29

vague

00:01:30

intentions, assurance promises of achievements

00:01:35

so difficult measurable but emotionally

00:01:39

charged there is very specific, easy

00:01:41

to verify, here is the entry of Finland and

00:01:45

Sweden into NATO, this is the concrete and tangible

00:01:49

consequences of a special

00:01:52

military operation in Ukraine on the part of Russia,

00:01:56

which was directly and unequivocally stated by all the

00:02:00

current politicians of Sweden and

00:02:02

Finland, Finland and the president and

00:02:05

prime minister named after Sweden traveled the

00:02:08

Prime Minister of Strange Affairs and you

00:02:10

can’t argue with this, and so I

00:02:13

perceive it as everything that has

00:02:17

a lace of words twisted on as goals, the

00:02:20

intention to achieve it is difficult to measure,

00:02:24

here most often it’s about who

00:02:27

believes whom, that is, some element of this or

00:02:30

logically,

00:02:33

here everything is specific, here is what

00:02:36

day of conspiracy 80 is today, one can

00:02:40

say that as a result, NATO has

00:02:43

moved closer to our borders,

00:02:46

although Sweden sounds like it

00:02:50

will not deploy nuclear forces

00:02:54

on its territory, but that’s what for the

00:02:57

time being today The main thing will not be that there

00:02:59

will be

00:03:00

unified elements of infrastructure

00:03:03

so that

00:03:05

all

00:03:07

NATO members and organizations in general can

00:03:10

use this

00:03:11

infrastructure, that is, this is

00:03:13

strategic planning,

00:03:15

and in general, in a military sense, the entry of

00:03:19

these countries is more significant than at one

00:03:21

time the entry of countries the Baltic because the

00:03:23

Finns have quite a serious army, they have

00:03:26

not only an education system that is one of the

00:03:27

best in Europe, but also a military

00:03:29

training system that is known to be one of the best in

00:03:31

Europe, and the Swedes, as far as I remember, until

00:03:34

recently they even made

00:03:35

combat aircraft themselves, which is generally

00:03:38

quite rare now a phenomenon that is

00:03:39

not in many countries, you know

00:03:42

how the brain is, I don’t belong to the typical

00:03:46

class of experts, but I

00:03:50

think that since Russia is a nuclear

00:03:54

power, it’s better for it

00:03:58

to be like such a

00:04:01

silent symbol of a possible answer,

00:04:04

so I don’t see any military risks for

00:04:08

Russia,

00:04:10

not from Sweden, no, Finland, not from Poland

00:04:13

and

00:04:14

even strangely enough it sounds from Germany,

00:04:19

so Germany really

00:04:21

loves our leadership, Putin in particular, in

00:04:24

some completely mystical way for me,

00:04:26

he believes the

00:04:29

Germans, he never spoke out against the

00:04:32

Germans,

00:04:33

not how bad at that time he absolutely does not

00:04:38

like America and and

00:04:41

trusts the Anglo-Saxons and

00:04:45

blames them for everything in the world, but serge

00:04:49

had the best relations with

00:04:51

gas supplies with giant infrastructure

00:04:54

projects in Germany, one of the key members of

00:04:56

NATO, which means membership in NATO itself

00:04:59

is never, well, at least until

00:05:03

recently, I know that what now

00:05:05

will not be an obstacle for our

00:05:08

country to develop exactly normal

00:05:10

relations of friendly

00:05:12

partnership, what is happening now

00:05:14

is

00:05:15

such a deviation from many decades,

00:05:20

but look, maybe

00:05:22

personal experience is also reflected here because, after

00:05:24

all, Putin lived in Germany for several years

00:05:27

and worked somehow for him, the Germans are simply

00:05:29

also on an everyday human

00:05:31

level, maybe closer in America, he didn’t want to, did

00:05:33

n’t work and knows about it, maybe, but

00:05:36

not only, but in layman’s terms, a little

00:05:38

more than the majority of people, something

00:05:41

so distant, an obvious thing, of course,

00:05:43

also the very first thing it comes to mind,

00:05:45

that is, directly transferring your empirical

00:05:48

everyday experience to

00:05:50

politics and geopolitics, foreign policy,

00:05:53

this can be allowed, of course, I don’t want to

00:05:55

release it because politics is more

00:05:57

than your personal experience and it is in the

00:06:00

feelings of precisely such systemic trust and

00:06:03

mistrust,

00:06:05

but China no longer lived in China but

00:06:09

we also don’t hear anything about China,

00:06:11

while many people

00:06:14

treat China with suspicion and I want to

00:06:16

remind you here of the context of international

00:06:19

relations on the eve of a special military

00:06:21

operation that would have been absolutely clearly and

00:06:23

unequivocally stated, confirmed by

00:06:25

Biden, his Vice President Harris and

00:06:29

Blinky to us this is an American line beer

00:06:33

tank not scary not FRG Jones

00:06:36

Prime Minister of Great Britain and all this lasted

00:06:39

almost until

00:06:41

February 24 when they said that today the

00:06:44

most important confrontation in the world is the

00:06:47

confrontation between Western

00:06:49

democracies and the

00:06:50

author Kiyame China, Russia, that is,

00:06:55

such a border was drawn and that means we

00:06:59

related to the number of countries with which the West

00:07:02

will confront, I think that

00:07:04

psychologically this can influence

00:07:07

Putin, you know that he is still hostile, it doesn’t matter

00:07:09

yes or no, he still

00:07:11

believes that we are on the side of evil and not on the

00:07:14

side of good, he puts forward

00:07:16

opposite narratives, especially in

00:07:18

his first speeches, what is it or to the

00:07:20

West, fake, not credible on the

00:07:24

side of evil, immoral in the extreme, that’s why,

00:07:27

but these are again words words

00:07:31

words yes, but there is a sofa, and what I’m

00:07:33

suspicious about is that I’ve never seen a single

00:07:36

thing that I

00:07:39

could soberly evaluate in China, what’s

00:07:43

happening there and the model that is

00:07:46

used there and the

00:07:49

consequences of excessive convergence or

00:07:52

dependence on the Chinese market, an analysis of

00:07:55

how all other countries and companies

00:07:58

feel in the Chinese market, a very

00:08:00

tough market like this, it may be

00:08:03

possible to find it difficult to get out with virtually no

00:08:06

losses, impossible, that’s

00:08:08

what supplier monopolies are, but

00:08:11

when we are there we leave the gas on VGA and that

00:08:13

Europe wants to get rid of the monopoly, what

00:08:15

is a monopoly, the importer is installing this

00:08:18

pipe to the entire 7th row and everything begins to dictate to you and you

00:08:22

at what price you

00:08:24

will sell this gas there, it

00:08:27

cannot be found 1 slam the door and leave,

00:08:29

where are these multi-billion dollar investments in

00:08:31

this pipeline, so there are a

00:08:33

huge number of substantive

00:08:35

issues related to partnership with

00:08:37

China with the practice of this partnership, what

00:08:40

it shares, what it doesn’t share, how it

00:08:42

uses countries in its own interests,

00:08:45

China is a very

00:08:47

self-centered system that

00:08:50

takes into account few people, and that’s when you analyze

00:08:54

the risks for countries and then it turned out that the

00:08:57

biggest risks come from the Anglo-Saxons of

00:09:00

Germany, no from China, no from them,

00:09:04

so I don’t fully

00:09:05

understand this one, and that’s why I’m at a loss, and the

00:09:10

consequence of this attitude, such as a way of

00:09:14

looking at things, was that we are in a

00:09:18

decent month we get

00:09:21

Sweden and Finland into

00:09:24

NATO, Christmas trees,

00:09:27

what is childhood planning like, we’re

00:09:30

just seconds, well, for the last few years,

00:09:33

maybe even a decade and a half there, they’ve been

00:09:34

constantly talking about the danger of the

00:09:37

inadmissibility of the undesirability of

00:09:39

NATO’s advance to the east, and these are the

00:09:41

last months before the start of

00:09:42

the special operation in Russia in 2 goals,

00:09:45

ultimatums, but they were already talking about almost

00:09:48

returning to the borders of 97, they demanded

00:09:51

security guarantees, in fact, everything turned out

00:09:53

exactly the opposite, that is, we need

00:09:55

to move even further, and this is what

00:09:57

we are talking about, it’s not very clear from

00:09:58

whom the threat comes, not from the Swedes, pigs

00:10:00

The Ministry of Justice to me comes from the Poles, as you

00:10:02

say, does not come from the Germans, does not come from

00:10:04

the Anglo-Saxons, in general, quite far from

00:10:06

our borders, so what would seem to be the

00:10:08

difference where NATO will advance if

00:10:10

the threat is still from those states that are

00:10:12

thousands of kilometers from our border, well,

00:10:15

yes, that’s okay use as a tor

00:10:17

for which in negotiations someone is always

00:10:19

moving

00:10:21

somewhere, someone on this basis demands that

00:10:25

something happen this is the diplomacy

00:10:28

of the given here we are yesterday, in my opinion, the

00:10:30

editorial articles name came out in the newspaper, it

00:10:32

just talks about

00:10:35

diplomacy as an art impossible from

00:10:39

politicians in the sedan class obligations

00:10:42

perhaps perhaps war is a continuation of

00:10:45

politics by other means to diplomacy

00:10:48

as a separate type of activity art

00:10:51

and the most important tool for

00:10:54

managing the

00:10:56

interests of any state, even a very

00:10:59

small one as long as there is some manat and

00:11:02

let’s assume Russia, which is a multi-

00:11:04

regional power in which

00:11:06

diplomacy should be at the highest

00:11:09

level It is the specific actions that I

00:11:14

designate as art that are impossible, and now

00:11:16

we see that this art, from my point of

00:11:18

view, has faded; we have not

00:11:20

achieved a single impossible solution; very

00:11:23

often diplomats or people representing

00:11:25

diplomats speak the language of

00:11:30

politicians,

00:11:31

while it is necessary to accurately record what

00:11:37

happened in the West penetration into the

00:11:40

diplomatic positions of politicians, well,

00:11:42

that is, the leader of the allied party of

00:11:45

Germany, Burbank, yes, she becomes not a

00:11:46

wandering on the bodies or there are

00:11:49

not the strangest things in Great Britain, from

00:11:52

our point of view, she has the skills of a

00:11:54

diplomat, so they say rudely

00:11:57

directly, politically engaged and

00:11:59

biased, and against this background we began

00:12:02

as to emulate this style and

00:12:05

it turned out that diplomacy disappeared and that’s

00:12:08

what you’re saying there is an attack there

00:12:12

or an expansion, well, yes of course, but again the

00:12:17

ultimatum nature of our proposals is

00:12:20

how we need to quickly consider our

00:12:23

proposal to return it became bios 7 or year

00:12:26

it all looked like an excuse for Moreover,

00:12:30

clearly understanding that no West has the

00:12:33

allotted time frame from the end of December, it

00:12:36

turns out that the end of February will not have time to

00:12:39

evaluate any

00:12:41

of our documents, and then

00:12:44

we will say, we wash our hands with soap, we

00:12:46

gave ours a chance, I won’t take advantage of it, so

00:12:48

now we will solve this issue in our own way and

00:12:52

began to decide, and apparently like my

00:12:56

feeling, a lot of time

00:12:58

had already passed, no one was counting on such a

00:13:01

scenario so that they wouldn’t say that everything

00:13:02

was going according to plan, because it’s

00:13:05

absolutely clear that in the first weeks,

00:13:08

probably a week and a half, the West generally believed

00:13:11

that Zelensky would soon everyone

00:13:14

strove to transfer their personal plane

00:13:16

so that the moisture is not there the government in

00:13:18

exile created our politicians with all sorts of

00:13:21

statements such that

00:13:23

Zelensky left them soon he won’t be there the

00:13:25

West the first sanctions the first reaction but the

00:13:30

speed machine came out there

00:13:32

everything will take over but there is a riot to think what to do

00:13:35

and even the way sanctions are deployed in

00:13:38

waves suggests that every day

00:13:41

or every week there are

00:13:43

special operations within the time frame that

00:13:46

experts thought about back and that everything will

00:13:49

end very quickly, they say that

00:13:53

colossal miscalculations were made on all

00:13:55

sides, an

00:13:59

error in assessing all situations in general, both

00:14:02

in the West, but for them, these opinions are

00:14:05

essential, and for us and I

00:14:08

was preparing for our broadcast today, I think

00:14:10

Anton and I haven’t seen each other for a long time, suddenly he

00:14:13

wants to talk about everything, but in general

00:14:17

terms, not specifically what happened yesterday

00:14:19

or the day before yesterday, well, that’s me and in general I’m

00:14:21

like that as you wanted, the date we

00:14:23

saw each other between 3 Turunda nights, in

00:14:25

my opinion, so I began to think there, what

00:14:29

are the

00:14:30

miscalculations of

00:14:32

our leadership in assessing the

00:14:35

international consequences of their decision on a

00:14:38

special military operation?

00:14:42

What is obvious to me at the

00:14:44

moment on May 16,

00:14:47

2022, the first is an error in

00:14:51

determining the

00:14:52

quality of the armed forces of Ukraine,

00:14:55

the ability and desire of the Ukrainian military

00:14:59

to resist Russia, this is a

00:15:01

fundamental error, the fact that everyone with whom

00:15:03

I talked there in January-February on these

00:15:07

topics that are related there to the

00:15:09

Ministry of Defense or in one form or another

00:15:11

to people who are something then to hear about

00:15:13

this time everyone said that there is nothing

00:15:15

like that, no

00:15:17

one will resist anyone because there in general the

00:15:21

armies are like coins when you listen to the game and

00:15:23

here there he pulled out his hair and wrote that

00:15:25

they seem to have 250,000 armies, also just a

00:15:28

quantity or days nothing

00:15:30

prepared and so on today we

00:15:31

see 200 all thousand seemed to be a serious

00:15:35

backbone that has not fled anywhere, is

00:15:37

highly motivated

00:15:39

to resist, and despite the fact that now, but

00:15:43

various buildings are solid back and do not write

00:15:46

about retraining camps and the level of

00:15:50

mobilization, and as I understand it, the

00:15:54

Ukrainian army is able to increase

00:15:59

it’s easy to grow your armed forces up to a million people, if they don’t already grow, but

00:16:01

they talk about it in any case, that

00:16:02

trained reservists can be

00:16:04

deployed, two more drivers, now it all

00:16:07

just depends on the supply of

00:16:10

appropriate weapons; the second

00:16:12

absolutely seems to me that there was a

00:16:15

serious mistake in assessing the

00:16:17

unity of the West in support Ukraine

00:16:20

no cracks no alternative

00:16:23

assessments ira is also very significant you

00:16:25

are planning an operation like any other there is

00:16:27

nowhere to go they will

00:16:29

never play with us on the contradictions hd

00:16:32

someone up to

00:16:34

3 the

00:16:35

scale and variety of sanctions no one

00:16:39

foresaw this

00:16:41

closure of

00:16:43

air traffic

00:16:45

by the West

00:16:47

the suspension of supplies of spare parts and

00:16:50

components as for our planes,

00:16:53

and for the last 24 hours they have

00:16:56

been telling us about Siemens trains,

00:16:58

so the peregrine falcon is written, swallows

00:17:01

will be, and these are for parts, and so on,

00:17:04

further

00:17:07

arrest and actual confiscation of more than

00:17:11

300 billion dollars of

00:17:12

cb reserves, well, that is, you are preparing, you still have to,

00:17:17

any scenario must because

00:17:19

that we never know what will be given

00:17:22

when you are preparing, you write, then as a

00:17:24

rule 3 four scenarios are needed,

00:17:26

what will happen if this happens, if at

00:17:30

least one scenario was written that

00:17:31

the West will take and confiscate 320 350

00:17:34

billion of our dollars there, no one

00:17:37

can have this ever no, everyone was

00:17:38

talking about Swifty, no, cover this

00:17:41

in our first scenario, but here is scenario number 4, I’ll

00:17:44

arrest you, who will take

00:17:47

responsibility to say yes, no, this

00:17:49

cannot be, and if there is no such person, then

00:17:52

you must first be smarter before pulling out

00:17:55

this money in the center 350 billion is

00:17:57

not a lot of money, it’s a gigantic

00:18:02

accumulation of our people and the deferred

00:18:05

consumption of our people. Let me remind you that

00:18:07

money that

00:18:10

the state did not give for current expenses went into these reserves,

00:18:13

be it pensions, be it roads, be it

00:18:16

bridges, as if the hospital had a budget

00:18:18

limit, but that’s what we like we should

00:18:21

put it aside like an airbag,

00:18:23

which means it turns out that this

00:18:25

scenario was not described, it

00:18:27

says something about the fact that in general there is not such a

00:18:29

level of

00:18:32

readiness then

00:18:34

absolutely no one foresaw this, from my

00:18:38

point of view, a

00:18:39

completely new high-quality reaction this

00:18:41

company consul rush this It’s just that this did

00:18:45

n’t happen because no matter what the system was there,

00:18:47

cultural figures went and

00:18:50

exchanged, theater and ballet had a

00:18:53

big tour in New York, and so on,

00:18:56

now this has covered the spheres of the science of

00:18:59

education, Jones’s dispute with you beloved

00:19:02

exchange, and yes, it turns out that joint

00:19:05

projects are also a measurement, and

00:19:09

what is

00:19:11

loss, even

00:19:15

loss, but the assets of private individuals, yachts, villas,

00:19:19

airplanes, yes, this is several tens

00:19:21

of billions; this is also a way of life for our

00:19:23

citizens and our individuals, why should this be

00:19:26

hooted and damn it, they took him away, these

00:19:29

cute ones, they took these yachts, it also seems to me

00:19:31

that this loss of resources for

00:19:33

the country from the effective

00:19:35

elimination of dependence on our

00:19:38

oil and gas supplies actually indicates that they did

00:19:41

not foresee

00:19:44

Russia’s ability to preserve key

00:19:48

assets that went to the

00:19:51

well-being of our country if there are no

00:19:55

oil and gas supplies there until we

00:19:56

reconfigure that there will inevitably be

00:20:01

another problem moment here I just

00:20:04

want to say more about it, maybe more

00:20:08

emotionally, maybe more simply

00:20:10

expressively and expressively, from my point of

00:20:13

view, there has been an actual elimination,

00:20:15

at least at this moment, of such a

00:20:18

phenomenon as the soft power of

00:20:21

Russia, not only in the near and far

00:20:24

abroad, this is a very important thing

00:20:26

because after all, when hard power is not

00:20:29

used, everyone knows that soft power

00:20:32

is the force that advances the country,

00:20:37

promotes the country of their people, culture,

00:20:41

influence through education through contacts,

00:20:44

and this is the soft power that, but I just

00:20:46

don’t know how many in 20 years, a fund was created

00:20:48

in the development center and progress

00:20:50

now you will come somewhere and you will

00:20:53

tell something within the framework of soft power why

00:20:55

people should come to us right now at the

00:20:57

moment the most serious Chris I know that everything

00:21:00

will be like that there as always comes to life in

00:21:02

some forms for the fact that today it is

00:21:05

actually the paralysis of soft power in Russia

00:21:07

is considered to be the most serious consequences

00:21:10

of this operation, then I, as an economist,

00:21:13

say no one foresaw it because

00:21:16

otherwise you would have to prepare for what would be an

00:21:19

immediate shock within the shock

00:21:23

surgery of the Russian rope, the need to

00:21:26

rebuild all industries, new

00:21:28

budget restrictions, new incomes, new

00:21:30

markets, and I’m amazed because the whole

00:21:35

discourse about the dashing 90s by a

00:21:38

huge number of experts, both

00:21:41

armchair and serious politicians,

00:21:43

who spoke boiled down to the fact that

00:21:47

almost the main fault of the 90s and the

00:21:50

country’s leadership at that moment was that they

00:21:53

subjected the population to shock therapy,

00:21:57

why it was impossible to do it like China

00:22:00

everyone said to slowly follow

00:22:03

first then first this and this

00:22:06

means it was written down as the main

00:22:09

fault and the price of Gaidar and other people

00:22:12

now I say again shock therapy

00:22:15

in my opinion I gave the definition is a

00:22:19

form of fitting the Russian economy into the

00:22:23

world economy on new

00:22:26

market conditions when

00:22:30

marginal costs are a factor that

00:22:33

predetermines the decision to invest or

00:22:35

develop this or that

00:22:37

production, and now we

00:22:39

are faced with shock surgery, that is,

00:22:42

not fitting into the global coneco, but

00:22:44

being cut out of the global economy of Russia

00:22:47

and everyone should immediately start

00:22:49

doing this with all income courses

00:22:53

opportunities to travel somewhere

00:22:56

use your savings,

00:22:59

rising prices so that Rosstat doesn’t say anything, I’m

00:23:03

under the flood of everything that

00:23:06

we don’t consume, I go even alcohol, I see how many

00:23:08

prices have risen, although there

00:23:11

were no new imports, but some

00:23:13

whiskey there cost that much

00:23:15

now it costs, say, three times more expensive

00:23:19

why but because there will be a situation like this,

00:23:22

we now all proceed from the fact that

00:23:24

this product is not because it is so expensive

00:23:26

that it came to us so expensive, but

00:23:28

then it is so expensive that we simply do not

00:23:31

expect that we will have it in the near future; we are

00:23:33

mortgaging our future

00:23:35

the risks have not been received for the time being, the mission has not been received and

00:23:37

its pages are nourished in this sense,

00:23:39

someone in China is fighting and the period they forgot about

00:23:42

China, no one says to listen, but in

00:23:44

China there is also no show, China just like

00:23:46

in the 90s, Deng Xiaoping followed his own path

00:23:49

like that I now Xi Jinping does not allow

00:23:52

this to expose citizens

00:23:55

and the economy and industries and

00:23:58

enterprises and unemployment and closures to such a shock, this is a

00:24:02

colossal level, they are

00:24:06

uncertainty and indeterminacy,

00:24:08

as we know, as Kafka Dostoevsky taught us, it

00:24:10

still drives us crazy

00:24:14

only uncertainty, cause causes a

00:24:17

person why - during interrogation, I never

00:24:19

say what he is poor in; he keeps

00:24:22

thinking about what

00:24:24

happens next;

00:24:28

when we analyzed the consequences, including, in

00:24:32

my opinion, it may be with you on this air,

00:24:34

which shortly before the operation, I say

00:24:36

that there are three motives for which we need to

00:24:39

investigate

00:24:40

is it possible is it impossible military operations the

00:24:42

first motive will there be an economic

00:24:45

benefit from this we said no there won’t be

00:24:48

because there will be sanctions there will be deterioration of the

00:24:50

stone actually this came true then it comes

00:24:52

down politically

00:24:55

foreign policy no it will be

00:24:56

isolation was refused in the

00:24:58

national sense no what could

00:25:00

be internal political what is internal

00:25:01

political the ruling group

00:25:04

consolidates power politics

00:25:07

begins to change the

00:25:10

criteria for whether you are needed here or not

00:25:14

needed here but it’s possible I said this

00:25:17

before but it seemed redundant to me and

00:25:20

so the politicians are under control we see how

00:25:22

the constitution has changed we see how the

00:25:24

choice is made why is there such a price

00:25:26

Now I see that internally the political

00:25:29

consequences are already obvious: the desire to

00:25:32

straighten the

00:25:34

political agenda

00:25:37

for Putin or against Putin at all

00:25:40

levels, this is not only at the level of, say, the

00:25:43

presidential elections, Mironov here

00:25:45

put forward the idea of help Thursday there will be a date

00:25:48

here at night this week,

00:25:50

why do we need these elections I think

00:25:53

it’s at least a single voting day

00:25:56

if all the parties that are in the house already

00:25:59

support the path, why waste

00:26:02

money and people’s energy, go for

00:26:04

someone’s eye father, there is no

00:26:06

fundamental difference between us, therefore, according to

00:26:08

Mironov, he is not the last person on the

00:26:11

political map Russia, he

00:26:13

conveys the idea to his friends and no

00:26:16

politics in any region,

00:26:18

no political question: will

00:26:21

we build roads or kindergartens, will

00:26:23

we help pensioners or will we

00:26:26

do something, there is no key question

00:26:28

for Putin or against Putin, if you are for

00:26:30

Putin, you don’t care

00:26:32

and hold some kind of

00:26:35

company elections and everything else seems to be

00:26:38

secondary, so the sublimation

00:26:40

takes place of feelings of only one thing: that

00:26:43

Putin we are voting for him, and all

00:26:45

other issues if we call for a

00:26:46

vote will somehow be

00:26:48

resolved, this is a serious turn in

00:26:50

internal politics, yes we are having a serious

00:26:52

conversation was when I was a non-systemic

00:26:54

opposition from here looked strange, but

00:26:56

now it turns out that the systemic

00:26:58

opposition doesn’t interest anyone what

00:27:00

they think, but a person

00:27:02

consists of nothing but

00:27:04

thoughts about Putin, it consists of

00:27:07

banal, hard everyday life, people

00:27:10

want to know about

00:27:12

healthcare education for their children and the

00:27:14

housing issue about roads about

00:27:17

crime and rest homes and so on, it

00:27:23

seems to me that now

00:27:27

Medvedev is helping me a lot,

00:27:33

helping that it would seem that

00:27:36

his posts are not so chaotic in nature,

00:27:41

induced by some sharp

00:27:44

thoughts, but in fact, since

00:27:47

he is everything - after all, the person included, he is the

00:27:48

deputy chairman of the

00:27:49

deputy secretary of the council, it is safer than the

00:27:51

deputy chairman of the stems of the launch, he himself is

00:27:54

Putin, but he still puts

00:27:59

things in there that allow me, again, to

00:28:02

return to my hypothesis,

00:28:04

initially them immediately after the military price

00:28:09

only confirms that Putin’s original motive

00:28:11

was, as it were, him did not look strange

00:28:14

with all those disadvantages of which I said he

00:28:16

would be strategic in his

00:28:19

coordinate system, Perry was taught to create a world

00:28:23

international political order not to

00:28:27

wait for the war that someone would

00:28:30

start against us because of the Crimea in his hypothesis

00:28:34

these were the Ukrainians over and then once upon a time, but

00:28:37

now

00:28:40

what the security council probably gave him was extinguishing

00:28:42

the show and not the tag with

00:28:45

which we are connected

00:28:48

with the world economy,

00:28:51

regardless of how a

00:28:55

particular relationship develops and now

00:28:57

we see grain, food prices rise,

00:29:01

which reshuffle in the world begins from these

00:29:05

shake-ups in the world because of these price increases,

00:29:09

what in the future are food riots and

00:29:13

political upheavals and regime changes,

00:29:16

well, gas and oil will also lead to a

00:29:21

cessation of supplies from here and the

00:29:23

readjustment of new supply routes to

00:29:27

key markets will also lead to because there

00:29:29

will be an increase in prices and an increase in prices means an increase in

00:29:32

costs It’s just a check, the lack of

00:29:34

profit, the lack of profit often leads to

00:29:37

bankruptcies, unemployment, and so on, and

00:29:39

now when Medvedev

00:29:41

blurts out this motive, you begin

00:29:43

to understand that Putin, in the end, did

00:29:45

n’t think everything through, but decided to

00:29:48

aggravate the situation so that in the end,

00:29:52

when people get tired, the bidan will lose

00:29:56

congress for the

00:29:58

midterm elections

00:30:00

let's assume and the

00:30:02

election campaign begins trump

00:30:05

returns he says that in general you did

00:30:08

not know how to negotiate with Putin

00:30:09

let's come to an agreement with him here China is

00:30:13

on the heat and stands on the one hand

00:30:15

Harrison for the territorial integrity of

00:30:17

Ukraine on the other hand he accuses

00:30:19

America of not taking into account the interests of

00:30:21

Russia, and I think it was Taiwan who recruited

00:30:24

him to maintain some plans for

00:30:26

the integration of Taiwan using such methods and there is

00:30:28

no need for it, and it seems to me that in these

00:30:30

conditions Putin may seem onion then,

00:30:33

well, let’s not have a month-long operation, but

00:30:36

let’s give it a year, let’s 2 here’s the world in

00:30:38

We’ll keep him in this state and when he starts,

00:30:40

someone will definitely call macron

00:30:43

now we know that he likes to call

00:30:44

Moscow macron to look for sushi, I’ll fly you

00:30:47

but not a single lieutenant, let’s

00:30:49

meet somewhere, we’ll talk, we need to

00:30:50

live somehow for a year, we’ll live but As a consequence

00:30:53

of this, the reorganization of

00:30:55

international relations, I don’t fully

00:30:58

understand how we can defend our relations, in

00:31:00

particular economic ones,

00:31:04

because economic relations,

00:31:07

well, in international markets, they are still

00:31:10

determined by your productivity,

00:31:12

competitiveness, no one

00:31:17

gives anyone any privileges, and it may seem because

00:31:20

we are everywhere they scrub it off so it does

00:31:23

n’t like us and that’s why we want

00:31:26

something Perry to establish in the economy you

00:31:27

won’t move anything because the power in the

00:31:30

world of capital by capital than you have is

00:31:32

stronger capital topics you have more of it

00:31:34

than it is more technologically advanced than it is

00:31:37

innovative who you have everything the

00:31:39

cards are in your hands and you will have to play

00:31:42

to this tune and fight for

00:31:44

what we are actually fighting for, we are fighting for

00:31:47

sovereignty, people who quite possibly do

00:31:50

not fully understand this. you sell

00:31:52

your oil and gas and you depend on dollars

00:31:54

and euros, it’s definitely sovereign you do it by

00:31:56

depending on them and the cats what do you spend on are

00:31:59

you burning no, we don’t want anyone to

00:32:01

interfere in anything, impose some

00:32:03

standards on us, including

00:32:05

environmental other no, we are a sovereign

00:32:07

country, we want to pollute, we will

00:32:09

pollute, and when we decide that we will not

00:32:11

pollute, we will go first, I need it, that

00:32:13

is, falling out of these global

00:32:16

agreements

00:32:18

as a sign of what kind of sovereignty

00:32:21

does not look convincing to me, especially since the

00:32:26

world economy has changed, I have already

00:32:28

said that

00:32:30

85 percent of world trade, this is within

00:32:34

transnational corporations, this is

00:32:36

actually between workshops or between

00:32:39

divisions of the same company,

00:32:41

hence the requirements of globalization, the removal of

00:32:43

barriers to finished products, few people

00:32:46

trade yet at least intermediate

00:32:48

goods in English intermediate goods,

00:32:50

they make up 65 70 percent there already in

00:32:53

the structure of trade, this is exactly what is needed

00:32:55

cooperation and people raise their level of

00:32:58

industrialization exclusively at the beginning

00:33:01

so a link in some chain calculate

00:33:04

something right away you will create some chain but

00:33:07

it’s funny but yesterday the strain of hearties

00:33:09

as far as let’s drive through the TV

00:33:11

better than

00:33:13

it is produced by sonido or we’ll produce a

00:33:16

car that’s better by the way

00:33:19

conversations machine news that

00:33:21

amused someone so much to this piece I made

00:33:23

myself happy in the morning about the fact that but this is not

00:33:26

nationalization in such a classical

00:33:27

sense, but the nationalization of

00:33:30

AvtoVAZ assets, that is, the Moscow plant

00:33:33

will now be one hundred percent owned by

00:33:35

the state, the

00:33:36

Togliatti plant will be two-thirds there,

00:33:38

one-third there will be a tour of success, but here,

00:33:40

in fact, it will still be a

00:33:41

state company that will

00:33:42

revive the production of Muscovites, the

00:33:45

Muscovite car, which has

00:33:47

not existed for 20 years, there is not even a museum for

00:33:50

elco, suddenly they will start

00:33:53

producing and

00:33:54

people will start producing soft rice of irony that all the

00:33:57

information is being listened to, and that’s what we

00:34:01

We really hope to make a car from scratch

00:34:03

when no one in the world

00:34:04

does this, but we’re trying to try our luck, that’s who

00:34:08

they were at the concert, the phrase was said that we

00:34:10

will do and electro, well, right away

00:34:13

the lecturer, of course, that is, separately nine

00:34:15

in the eighty-fifth year when Gorbachev

00:34:19

came to power at the March captured, then

00:34:22

he went to AvtoVAZ somewhere in June 85,

00:34:26

met with the workers, everyone was jubilant,

00:34:29

Gorbachev was a good hammer, he was

00:34:32

optimistic, and based on the results of

00:34:36

Gorbachev’s visit to AvtoVAZ,

00:34:39

meetings with the staff, they decided that

00:34:41

in 5 years in Russia, the Soviet Union

00:34:43

would become a trendsetter in

00:34:44

the automotive industry, we have this here is the phrase

00:34:47

to become for Canada, it’s not easy to do there,

00:34:50

improve the quality,

00:34:52

become a trendsetter of fashion, this is

00:34:55

our traditional,

00:34:58

our maximalism, but that is, we tits are

00:35:02

not content with this, not when we immediately

00:35:03

follow the crane, well, and a

00:35:05

trendsetter, but I always

00:35:08

recommend the book

00:35:10

likers yes Toyota, for example, where is one

00:35:14

of the best books and is well translated into Russian,

00:35:16

where

00:35:19

this first book is composed, then there

00:35:21

was a lot and it sells how and in principle it can be

00:35:24

transferred to the service sector,

00:35:26

which is very important, but for production

00:35:30

these are 14 principles, these are the

00:35:34

Toyota production system, this is

00:35:37

long-term philosophy is a description of

00:35:40

the process and the management of the entire process,

00:35:43

this organization of the rhythm of work at

00:35:46

all stages so that people are not driven there and so

00:35:48

on and

00:35:50

without this you cannot achieve quality, the

00:35:53

actual meaning of the entire production

00:35:55

system, modern forays are the same thing

00:35:58

I studied in

00:36:01

Germany and even once two ago I

00:36:05

was and I

00:36:06

say the Germans and the Germans of this is Harry the

00:36:11

production system of Toyota he so

00:36:13

why does it give this is our

00:36:15

production system with its

00:36:17

culture with its

00:36:19

approach to this quality as a consequence of the

00:36:23

organization of the process procedures practices

00:36:27

plans long-term cash philosophies it is

00:36:30

extremely important to have a philosophy in

00:36:34

this in fact, long-term when you

00:36:36

sacrifice

00:36:38

current productivity, tell

00:36:40

the master to rebuild, yes, in the name of

00:36:43

strategic quality improvement, this is very

00:36:45

serious science, this is not a matter of

00:36:47

lecture, this is science, practice, you

00:36:50

go and you must eliminate all

00:36:53

losses according to the Japanese code, this is called

00:36:56

this mudra, you are literally cutting out

00:36:59

claims two are you taking one step at a time or three

00:37:01

steps away from it, that’s how we do everything, that is, we will pour

00:37:03

full concentrate into creating that is,

00:37:06

the cost or value for the

00:37:08

consumer, that’s why I

00:37:10

support the desire for software to become the

00:37:15

world’s legislative body, but as it didn’t work out in 80 90,

00:37:18

I think it’s also

00:37:20

unlikely that it will be possible to become

00:37:22

the legislator may have such a goal and it is worth it,

00:37:24

maybe the goal is worth producing just

00:37:26

some cars of acceptable quality in

00:37:28

some inexpensive segment, but in order to

00:37:32

produce this, this also requires approaches, I

00:37:35

know, for example, on gas,

00:37:37

Oleg Deripaska, on gas, I watched how the

00:37:40

Japanese management system was applied

00:37:43

from I remember they started producing the Volga with the Americans,

00:37:46

someone wanted a

00:37:48

seagull there, some other something, gas 69, and then

00:37:52

it turns out that from the point of view of the

00:37:55

quality market and the price-quality ratio, the

00:37:58

gazelle is the best car on the market

00:38:02

because they take it and they have become in this niche

00:38:05

the best thing is that we are generally not only in Russia, we do

00:38:07

n’t deliver everywhere and everything goes away

00:38:09

because how much money did you pay for

00:38:10

this car with such qualities and for

00:38:13

these purposes a small truck that

00:38:15

will transport cargo for small

00:38:17

businesses or for a crooked store there

00:38:19

because in two- three years, you can

00:38:21

easily write off this car and you

00:38:23

have all the value of which

00:38:25

instead of why you got it with

00:38:27

minimal costs, I saw how to

00:38:29

move to this from the only

00:38:31

car that meets the needs of

00:38:33

the market was this one, so it was necessary, as it

00:38:35

were, for the image of especially a veteran to the factory didn’t

00:38:37

want to give up the wolf, this is the glorious

00:38:41

name of the site, I remembered Cyber for with the

00:38:43

red stadiums that at this price and with

00:38:46

this quality you will not compete with

00:38:48

this question and how difficult it was to

00:38:51

set it up and they had it written everywhere there was a

00:38:54

combo they had everywhere there it’s written

00:38:57

I’ll be there these Japanese workers

00:38:59

immersed themselves in this process created

00:39:00

some crumbs quality some kind of

00:39:03

bonuses they have if they find one hook so that

00:39:06

all four different types of engines can be

00:39:08

lifted and lowered into this machine that

00:39:11

there were four different strengths it was a

00:39:13

waste of time while you belong even

00:39:15

before they stepped over to set up I saw I

00:39:17

just walked around these workshops I looked I

00:39:19

was simply amazed this is really a

00:39:21

breakthrough on so difficult to organize from

00:39:25

such there must be

00:39:26

dedication and specific knowledge of the

00:39:29

experts who teach the team teaches

00:39:32

this when he learned Oleg this then he

00:39:37

told when you It was true a long time ago, about

00:39:39

10 years ago, that the

00:39:42

governor of one of the regions came to him, who

00:39:45

had concluded agreements with foreigners, and

00:39:47

assembling the machines here, the foreigners found out

00:39:50

that the labor force did not even meet the

00:39:52

needs of assembling from these Western

00:39:55

parts, and this governor came and

00:39:58

said to his

00:39:59

colleague, you won’t mind if I

00:40:02

’ll transport 1000 of your workers with their families

00:40:04

to my region, but we

00:40:07

’ll put cottages for them because otherwise our

00:40:09

enterprise means they won’t

00:40:12

make money, but the governor saw

00:40:16

that just raising even such a

00:40:18

person is a big problem, so I

00:40:20

’ll say again what we

00:40:21

’ll do now we have no other

00:40:24

alternative since we have taken the path

00:40:26

to diverge from the whole world because of sick

00:40:29

value chains with markets that have led to an

00:40:33

attitude towards an economic

00:40:36

trade financial war, this is what we

00:40:40

can say about a war about a

00:40:42

financial and economic trade war,

00:40:44

and of

00:40:46

course we have to survive and such a country how

00:40:49

ours should survive, so there will be

00:40:52

enthusiasm, but I want to say that this is a

00:40:54

very difficult, serious scientific

00:40:58

management project for something to travel, for

00:41:02

something to fly, for something to

00:41:04

spin where it needs to be, if we

00:41:07

look at another area there, let’s say there are

00:41:09

TV models there hp tablets

00:41:13

microchips we see what a colossal

00:41:16

gap this is a gap, it is both scientific and

00:41:18

technological, but you just do

00:41:20

n’t have to think about when we will do everything

00:41:22

while you start to understand the details and

00:41:24

where you will get it, this obliges

00:41:27

the route, it’s how good it can’t be taken for you,

00:41:29

we can develop it and who comes

00:41:32

such tadpoles before in fact they are

00:41:34

all in yesterday they have no skills

00:41:37

they have so I look at the coming years

00:41:39

as quite difficult to be

00:41:44

honest and

00:41:49

God who will demand the complete

00:41:52

mobilization of society

00:41:55

but society does not mean mobilization

00:41:59

centralized centralized

00:42:00

mobilization in the 21st century is nothing will give, and this

00:42:04

mobilization for survival, it seems to me, is

00:42:07

through the forms of private initiative,

00:42:10

because

00:42:13

only private capital with its

00:42:16

selfish interests continues to

00:42:19

claim that it is a much more

00:42:21

effective and diverse agent of

00:42:24

transformation in the country than the state,

00:42:26

the state can take one two three

00:42:29

maximum spheres, concentrates everything

00:42:32

resources are really bad at calculating costs,

00:42:36

how much money they spent,

00:42:40

how effective they are, the state doesn’t

00:42:43

like something from the critics, so it often

00:42:44

keeps all these things closed and

00:42:48

moving is such a speculative

00:42:50

wish because, on the contrary, we

00:42:52

still live on the contrary,

00:42:54

concentrate easy to

00:42:55

schematize

00:42:58

character traits there, Putin and the

00:43:02

Russian authorities as a whole, as a

00:43:05

geopolitical reality,

00:43:08

geopolitical reality understands

00:43:10

a reality that depends very little

00:43:11

on whether we are there or not,

00:43:14

it must be taken into account and it is a reality that

00:43:17

leads to certain consequences

00:43:18

that most of us may

00:43:21

not want to see, which means the first

00:43:24

feature is extreme secrecy,

00:43:27

secrecy, non-publicity, opacity,

00:43:32

narrow circle of access to information in the

00:43:36

decision-making process,

00:43:39

suspicion and

00:43:43

the desire to carry out a lot of things in the

00:43:46

mode of some unexpected decisions,

00:43:48

not even to report that

00:43:51

but why not remove gold and foreign exchange reserves of

00:43:55

300 billion so that the enemy does not

00:43:57

suspect that this is a sign that

00:43:59

Russia is preparing for something, even

00:44:03

this one seems to me, I cannot admit that

00:44:06

such a risk was not on the table, but

00:44:09

do not inform these do not give or very

00:44:11

Nabiullina the right to quickly somehow

00:44:15

save these assets, our gold and foreign exchange and

00:44:18

only then start the operation, probably

00:44:20

someone said no, you know the

00:44:23

scale of the operation; withdrawal of such an amount to other less

00:44:26

risky assets for Russia, such an

00:44:29

amount will not go unnoticed on the

00:44:31

world market and the CIA will know about it; to a certain

00:44:36

extent, this

00:44:38

feature disappears somewhere, but in order

00:44:41

to be able to count on what will happen, that

00:44:43

another second

00:44:44

absolutization of particular damage to the understanding of

00:44:48

the most typological from the typical

00:44:50

basic and essentially, it seems to me that this is a

00:44:54

very important feature, we take some

00:44:56

separate feature, for example, Nazism, and

00:44:59

begin to absolutize the fact of the presence of

00:45:01

some -that group of a certain percentage there

00:45:04

among voters

00:45:05

to a level that characterizes all

00:45:08

Ukrainians and their entire political system,

00:45:10

this is the absolutization of particulars to the detriment of a

00:45:14

common understanding of the

00:45:16

essential, poking around is also a

00:45:19

stylistic feature at the time of

00:45:22

decision-making, who through the same pretext

00:45:24

in order to develop all this therefore

00:45:27

we say that one and a half percent of the Nazis,

00:45:29

let’s say that there are those 100 percent,

00:45:33

that’s a

00:45:35

methodological mess in the head outside of it

00:45:37

remains, say they would start to carry out the affairs of Poland, a

00:45:39

visa until the main enemy in the

00:45:43

articles is declared to be Lenin who

00:45:45

came up with this idea to spend Ukraine does not

00:45:46

exist and the first thing that people do

00:45:50

was shown to what -that settlement

00:45:52

SBN restored the monument to Lenin and on the

00:45:55

central ones it was a mess, so you

00:45:57

guys and the red flag are big risks,

00:46:01

we are Lenin red flag 11 fications where there are

00:46:05

absolutely big tions and there’s a

00:46:08

feeling that communication is going on, it’s worth beating for

00:46:10

which these categories have no

00:46:14

no meaningful sense further,

00:46:16

the line is absolute from my point of view, a

00:46:18

serious negative attitude towards

00:46:21

the Internet,

00:46:22

social networks, not using these

00:46:25

gadgets,

00:46:27

inability to Google the necessary information,

00:46:30

trust in these daddies,

00:46:34

lack of understanding of cloud technologies,

00:46:38

she leads her point of view as

00:46:41

ideological backwardness

00:46:44

and not understanding the specifics of today's

00:46:47

society, its needs and

00:46:51

probably after all, the dominant methods of

00:46:54

communication in modern society, the

00:46:57

dominant methods of communication

00:46:59

are all these

00:47:02

Internet technologies, all the gadgets that are

00:47:04

connected with this,

00:47:06

if you don’t understand this, do you think

00:47:08

that the loudspeaker will announce to you and

00:47:11

you will listen like that, well, yes, some

00:47:13

part of the population, but is it part

00:47:15

of the population has the energy and drive for

00:47:19

change development mood desire

00:47:22

passion to change the country for the

00:47:25

better what follows from this is no repentance

00:47:27

generational confrontation along the lines of

00:47:30

values because

00:47:32

if you don’t love the Internet so much and we

00:47:35

saw it even not long ago and a pinch of the

00:47:37

Klim nozzle of social studies

00:47:40

sounded naive that here this society

00:47:42

will replace knowledge in the future, I’m saying this,

00:47:45

but it’s just funny, I

00:47:47

go there every day on the website of Harvard

00:47:49

University or Stanford,

00:47:51

the amount of materials on these sites and the

00:47:54

knowledge embodied in real scientific,

00:47:58

quite advanced knowledge, it is

00:48:00

immeasurably more than ever

00:48:01

social studies on the code in the coming years

00:48:04

dare you just assured because it is a

00:48:06

completely different mechanism for maintaining a wide

00:48:08

variety of cheeses in science, simply

00:48:11

because it is science and, in fact, all the

00:48:13

high-quality universities there are actor kim britzka

00:48:15

mouth stand-up they all exist

00:48:18

because they have created a large

00:48:22

endowment and with this large house you

00:48:24

sign them the last time when there were 35

00:48:27

billion dollars there 28 these are

00:48:31

donations then very smart people

00:48:33

tadpoles place these 35 billion a

00:48:36

good tool gives, say, 11

00:48:39

percent per annum, which means you get somewhere around 3 4

00:48:42

billion dollars and the money goes not these

00:48:45

studies, for example, features of the

00:48:48

culture of service during lunch in the 4th

00:48:54

century BC somewhere it would seem that this is

00:48:56

not and what does this have to do with practical technology,

00:48:58

but this is how the pyramid of knowledge is built, it seems that they are

00:49:02

not needed, in fact there are

00:49:03

scientific methods of expedition, followed by

00:49:06

archaeological excavations and that’s how

00:49:09

knowledge and so on in every sphere and

00:49:11

when you come

00:49:14

into conflict with a new generation for whom the

00:49:17

Internet is an integral value of their

00:49:20

life and

00:49:22

quite possibly this is a form of

00:49:25

existence,

00:49:27

even if we are skeptical about it,

00:49:30

why replace

00:49:34

our real existence with the Internet,

00:49:36

this is how it is, so come into conflict with

00:49:39

these people and think that the things

00:49:42

you are doing for which you are quite possibly, if you are not

00:49:46

worried, will be handed over to reliable

00:49:48

hands, but in a generation I

00:49:51

would not say that this is good, further

00:49:55

solving problems, we have all learned over the last

00:49:58

20 years a good term and there is a

00:50:00

road map for solving all problems,

00:50:02

whatever the conflict, whatever

00:50:04

the problem, but it is quite obvious that

00:50:06

road maps are not a tool for

00:50:08

solving problems for us, we do not know how not to

00:50:12

draw up and road maps are not

00:50:13

used all the conflicts that were

00:50:15

in the space of the former USSR,

00:50:18

be it Transnistria or Abkhazia and

00:50:21

South Ossetia, here is Donetsk Lugansk

00:50:24

all this turns out that it’s

00:50:31

not even of course what the

00:50:33

desired result is, because the road map is

00:50:35

to order and the goal is clear, it feels like the

00:50:37

goal that someone understands who

00:50:39

you are is not quite familiar with

00:50:41

decently, they want to publicly name it,

00:50:45

so the process itself is some kind of negotiations

00:50:47

there I command 5 + 2 or 2 plus 5 so they

00:50:51

can go go go and then we see in

00:50:53

Nagorno-Karabakh the broads

00:50:56

turn around military until they fly to

00:50:58

Moscow to Moscow sounds like war, you will never

00:51:01

solve more than one political problem,

00:51:03

sit down at the negotiating table,

00:51:04

but we were the most important panel

00:51:07

returned Karabakh even with the decision that

00:51:10

we should solve the pulp and this is also a very

00:51:14

significant flaw, what is

00:51:17

the toolkit as a road map for

00:51:20

solving complex problems is not being developed,

00:51:23

is not used and we do not have

00:51:25

people who

00:51:29

could promote the interests of

00:51:33

Russia through these road maps

00:51:36

beyond communication, a serious problem

00:51:40

remains, and now, with such a concentration

00:51:42

of power in domestic politics,

00:51:45

I don’t fully understand the exclusive

00:51:49

nature of power; a

00:51:51

closed number of people connected with

00:51:54

the special services or loyal to the web

00:51:56

or friends enter into power; this is how in the country there

00:52:01

is a political lift and

00:52:05

you can’t actually party you

00:52:07

can’t create a movement, you can’t write a tweet, you can’t without the

00:52:10

risk of getting

00:52:11

a slap on the head at best, actually,

00:52:14

maybe you’ll be sent to prison, but if you

00:52:17

block political elevators for

00:52:20

young people and even for people who are not young and are

00:52:22

interested in politics, I think

00:52:25

that power is

00:52:27

closed in a narrow way circle

00:52:30

thing, you inevitably begin to think that

00:52:33

maybe it was good at the beginning

00:52:35

when you are just coming to the class to

00:52:37

consolidate in order to

00:52:38

implement some projects, but now

00:52:41

you see that this is simply the preservation of

00:52:44

power there, access to wealth in this

00:52:47

power by a simplified method should not be

00:52:49

wasted Even though this doesn’t

00:52:51

seem well-reasoned, this is a very

00:52:52

serious problem, as it were, in the life of the

00:52:56

ability of the political system,

00:53:02

nothing has changed in the rhetoric of punishment,

00:53:05

you follow the responsible people in

00:53:07

relation to the West without the

00:53:09

West, this is a

00:53:13

jackal tobacco with shure honey in the vocabulary of

00:53:18

Mowgli the West of Western Europe, and it’s

00:53:22

added there Australia

00:53:25

it’s hard for the Saxons for the countries and Zealand at the

00:53:29

cordon in general who will support yes this is a

00:53:33

state that does not have

00:53:37

international legal personality they do

00:53:40

not have their own interests that they could

00:53:43

oppose to the interests of the USA they will sing along with the

00:53:45

Americans if that’s the case then there is

00:53:48

nothing to talk about with them but the Americans and I do

00:53:51

n’t we talk very much, but it’s not very good to talk to these people either,

00:53:54

therefore,

00:53:56

now, after 80 days of the

00:53:59

conflict of this bloody katz, a

00:54:02

picture of the

00:54:06

prospects for our life emerges, essentially a battle

00:54:10

for an isolated regime than we could have

00:54:13

imagined there three months ago,

00:54:15

although there were already many trends after

00:54:18

these,

00:54:20

our ideas

00:54:22

options for a treaty on guarantees of our

00:54:25

security, we are moving very much because

00:54:28

I say again, none of these

00:54:30

countries has subjectivity, will,

00:54:33

sovereignty, and America has everything.

00:54:36

Touch talking to them is such a

00:54:38

risky step because in this logic we

00:54:41

all understand that within the country,

00:54:43

subjectivity has one way is a secret

00:54:46

then talk to Lavrov or Shoigu, they

00:54:49

also don’t decide anything, the east decides

00:54:51

the president and this extends to a

00:54:53

large community of very influential

00:54:54

states now that they have all

00:54:57

left and when everyone

00:54:59

opposes Russia even more than they

00:55:01

spoke out rhetorically I mean than yes

00:55:05

this is a conflict the fact that Putin, in her

00:55:07

first address, noted that even

00:55:09

small satellite countries of the United States allow

00:55:11

themselves such harshness that large countries do not allow,

00:55:16

and finally, the last thoughts for

00:55:21

Anton Orek are the

00:55:26

existence of Russia as a state, to

00:55:29

what extent is it

00:55:32

compatible with those norms of the constitution

00:55:35

that guarantees rights and freedom

00:55:38

tolerance

00:55:41

discord and

00:55:45

we hear now among many of those who

00:55:48

are engaged in propaganda that these are

00:55:50

redundant articles in our constitution they

00:55:53

must be removed no freedom there should

00:55:55

be not a word not an assembly at all

00:55:57

democracy of the Western Anglo-Saxon

00:55:59

types is not for us then the question arises

00:56:03

whether it is possible to preserve Russia without rights and

00:56:05

freedoms,

00:56:06

what kind of government

00:56:08

system this should be, what is its

00:56:11

attractiveness for society, this is also

00:56:14

very important for the society of various

00:56:16

social groups within this society, who

00:56:20

will tell everything, our country is so special,

00:56:22

we are not tolerant, what is the mechanism of

00:56:25

social and political lift in

00:56:27

which country then

00:56:30

what will it be? there will be a managed democracy

00:56:32

democracy from above

00:56:35

controlled by some officials

00:56:37

who are considered as the fathers of the nation who

00:56:41

will guide unreasonable people and

00:56:43

here I see unlikely risks for the

00:56:48

existence of statehood,

00:56:58

refusal cannot pass without a trace from

00:57:01

my point of view for the strength of the

00:57:03

state because you cannot

00:57:05

tie

00:57:07

148 million people

00:57:10

into one idea of the matter, their

00:57:13

idea does not exist, there is this idea that they are not

00:57:16

tolerant, it certainly does not cover

00:57:20

everyone, but since very many people

00:57:22

who think about the reef, fixing and writing have a

00:57:25

different point of view, then in the short

00:57:27

term they will tactically lose today

00:57:29

to those who do not think about simply supporting,

00:57:31

but in the long term when they

00:57:33

write their memoirs,

00:57:34

nicknames will give assessments, then the

00:57:36

assessment of

00:57:39

those who do not think that this will certainly prevail in the long term right in

00:57:41

relation to Russia and the Russian people,

00:57:43

by the way, let's get chinnaswamy in a couple of minutes, there is

00:57:45

a book left, yes, our traditional

00:57:49

section is to recommend an excellent

00:57:51

book by

00:57:53

Archip Zhid Bannerjee and Esther Duflo,

00:57:57

economic science in difficult times,

00:57:59

this is an application with Gregory, or a husband and wife

00:58:05

who wrote an excellent book and

00:58:08

they talked about the fact that Murphy writes how books

00:58:11

economists write to explain and which no

00:58:13

one reads there so that a scientific article from the

00:58:15

form and and here we decided to write that in

00:58:18

the worth of days and I Katz and and

00:58:21

all members of the government of

00:58:23

all levels should definitely read the government but the

00:58:26

academic community youth

00:58:28

any phrase John maynard keynes an idea

00:58:31

that transformed macroeconomic

00:58:33

policy written by practical people who

00:58:36

consider themselves completely immune to

00:58:38

intellectual influence

00:58:40

are usually slaves to some economist of

00:58:42

the past madmen in power

00:58:45

who hear voices from the sky extract

00:58:48

their crazy ideas from the works of

00:58:50

some academic write and

00:58:52

compose shaya several years ago, both

00:58:54

active and active directs changes and

00:58:59

they appeal to the need for a good

00:59:02

economic theory underlying

00:59:04

economic policy to the headquarters to solve the most

00:59:06

complex problems

00:59:09

faced not only by the poor, these are

00:59:10

specialists in poor countries, but also by

00:59:12

rich countries, all rich countries, this is the

00:59:15

growth of inequality and poverty how

00:59:17

to overcome ecology, so I highly

00:59:20

recommend economics in difficult

00:59:22

times archi jint bannerdzhi and ester

00:59:25

duflo thank you very much Konstantin

00:59:29

Remchukov was on our air today,

00:59:31

personally yours, I thank everyone who

00:59:34

watched us and literally 5 minutes later

00:59:36

Lazerson and Maxim Shevchenko climbed in

00:59:39

there will be an attack from the flanks, but

00:59:41

Nikita Vasilenko will also conduct this broadcast, thanks

00:59:42

again to everyone

Description:

В эфире главный редактор и генеральный директор «Независимой газеты» Константин Ремчуков. Ведущий: Антон Орехъ. Подписывайтесь на Антона Ореха в Телеграме: https://t.me/orex62 🔔 Последние новости и анонсы программ с YouTube-канала «Живой гвоздь», а также контент от наших постоянных гостей и экспертов на официальном телеграм-канале: https://t.me/livegvozd Подписаться на Youtube-канал Дилетант: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuIE7-5QzeAR6EdZXwDRwuQ?sub_confirmation=1 📌 Живой гвоздь в аудиоформате: SoundCloud: https://soundcloud.com/user-524451485 Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/4c85mLayKb5oPlpXptWQ5y Яндекс.Музыка: https://music.yandex.ru/album/22141653?dir=desc Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/%D0%B6%D0%B8%D0%B2%D0%BE%D0%B9-%D0%B3%D0%B2%D0%BE%D0%B7%D0%B4%D1%8C/id1616175210 Google Подкасты: https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9mZWVkcy5zb3VuZGNsb3VkLmNvbS91c2Vycy9zb3VuZGNsb3VkOnVzZXJzOjEwOTk2NzA5MDUvc291bmRzLnJzcw?sa=X&ved=0CAIQ4aUDahcKEwigxO3Eweb2AhUAAAAAHQAAAAAQEQ Магазин "Дилетант": https://diletant.shop/

Preparing download options

Popular

HD video

Only sound

All

* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."

** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players

Questions about downloading video

How can I download "Константин Ремчуков / Персонально ваш // 16.05.2022" video?

http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.

Which format of "Константин Ремчуков / Персонально ваш // 16.05.2022" video should I choose?

The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.

Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Константин Ремчуков / Персонально ваш // 16.05.2022" video?

The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.

How can I download "Константин Ремчуков / Персонально ваш // 16.05.2022" video to my phone?

You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.

How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Константин Ремчуков / Персонально ваш // 16.05.2022"?

The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.

How can I save a frame from a video "Константин Ремчуков / Персонально ваш // 16.05.2022"?

This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.

What's the price of all this stuff?

It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.