Download "Белковский — Рязанский сахар, Путин в девяностые и главные кланы в России 🎙 Честное слово"
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FxlPVEMu7xZ0%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
Please wait. We're preparing links for easy ad-free video watching and downloading.
Table of contents
Similar videos from our catalog
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F-YodeSwpZDw%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F1gzM_dLv6Ww%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FDppDdMg83Ik%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FHfT_yr3GlDE%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FZPMLKpuTP9s%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FblG3PdjNdk0%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FggbFIybLY7E%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FshXr2p82Bv0%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252F25JotH9lOew%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FhlZc6c7mbWA%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
Video tags
Subtitles
Russian
00:00:15
Good morning friends have turned on the channel00:00:17
popular politics program00:00:19
Honesty in which we meet with00:00:21
interesting guests we discuss all the most00:00:23
important things that are happening around us all the00:00:25
most important things that are happening in Russian00:00:27
politics My name is Ruslan Shavinov I00:00:29
welcome you, please press your fingers up and00:00:31
write your comments carefully00:00:33
On YouTube, send questions to the super chat,00:00:36
comment actively and help this00:00:38
broadcast spread. And in general, we will have fun00:00:40
with you on the next broadcast.00:00:43
Therefore, be active in the chat, please,00:00:45
once again I encourage everyone to do this. Today00:00:48
we will have a conversation in this program00:00:50
live with Stanislav Belkovsky,00:00:51
writer, political scientist, political strategist a00:00:53
man whose many merits we00:00:56
will talk to him today Stanislav Good00:00:57
morning00:00:58
Good morning everyone I was thinking where to start and I00:01:03
probably still can’t help but ask00:01:05
you about just such a topic, a topic00:01:08
related to the explosion of houses in 99,00:01:11
for sure Yesterday everyone was tortured00:01:13
trying to get your comment aren’t you00:01:16
the initiator of these terrible events, as00:01:19
they write in a report on the website of one00:01:22
American fintech, which says00:01:25
that Berezovsky, together with Putin,00:01:28
came up with all this and carried it out as the00:01:30
author of the idea And who suggested it all to them00:01:33
was none other than Stanislav Belkovsky,00:01:35
what is your answer to this how did you feel00:01:38
about this publication And you and what did you00:01:40
do in 199900:01:43
Where were you all these 24 years00:01:47
along the way I firstly00:01:50
take this opportunity to remember how on the00:01:53
Field of Miracles I enjoy very much I say00:01:55
hello to distant relatives there00:01:56
I urge you to subscribe to my channel00:01:59
Belkovsky where Yesterday in the Good00:02:01
Night Malyshit program, the question was00:02:03
discussed quite a bit, now let’s move on to the meaning of what00:02:06
is happening is that this is an article by analyst00:02:09
Robert, who remains an00:02:11
official employee of the US State Department,00:02:13
this is perhaps the only thing that00:02:15
makes it really discussed00:02:18
until 2017, he was the deputy director of the00:02:22
US Intelligence Department, the00:02:43
bombing of houses in Moscow, Volgodonsk00:02:46
Buynaksky in September 1999.00:02:51
According to one version, these explosions00:02:54
became the reason for the second Chechen war,00:02:56
which was led by Vladimir Putin, and according to the00:02:59
author of the text, the sources, in00:03:02
particular of the late00:03:04
Alexander Litvinenko, a former employee killed in 2006,00:03:07
could have been organized by Boris00:03:09
Berezovsky and the then Minister of00:03:11
Internal Affairs of the Russian Federation Vladimir00:03:14
do not help Vladimir Putin00:03:17
create the00:03:20
elections of 2000 because00:03:24
Berezovsky does not want to00:03:25
see Vladimir Putin at all, they wanted to take00:03:28
a timeout for this and the Kremlin is a00:03:38
bunch of Bibles for me because with the reference of the00:03:42
same Alexander of Lithuania in00:03:44
2005 with American scientists00:03:47
it is stated that I was an ideologist this is an00:03:49
operation with explosions This00:03:52
good already for the films of the Coen brothers and00:03:55
Everyone goes crazy in their own way there Seimar00:03:58
Kharj with his northern ranks in their own way to00:04:02
type almost the whole story we00:04:05
can say the following I remember quite well00:04:06
that in ninety-nine I00:04:08
actually collaborated with Boris00:04:10
Berezovsky in the project of creating a00:04:12
unity bloc he same bear bear So00:04:15
I have a regional movement, unity,00:04:17
presidential elections, I have no00:04:18
relation at all00:04:20
to the unity bloc, also very00:04:22
relatively, but nevertheless I am passionate and00:04:25
but I often communicated then with the Berezovskys and00:04:27
some other people, and therefore I00:04:30
remember how everything was really like that in00:04:32
early September there was no confidence that00:04:35
Vladimir Putin would be able to win the00:04:36
presidential elections, although he was the00:04:37
absolute favorite, certainly at the bet of the00:04:41
Kremlin,00:04:43
therefore the very idea of postponing the00:04:46
presidential elections was discussed, I do not00:04:48
exclude the Chechen war, respectively, the00:04:50
previous explosions if they were00:04:52
not carried out because officially the consequences of00:04:57
one of its possible goals was the postponement00:04:59
but then, by the middle of the second half,00:05:02
so that it became00:05:04
completely clear that Putin might have00:05:06
elections, there was a sharp jump in his00:05:08
popularity of the women’s war, as well as a00:05:11
big contrast between the young00:05:12
active similar Putin and, on the one00:05:15
hand, the sick Boris Yeltsin, on00:05:17
the other hand, also not young, apparently not00:05:19
very healthy00:05:22
propaganda that Boris Berezovsky played a00:05:24
significant role in making sure that00:05:32
Putin is also old and sick, so00:05:36
you can’t bet on him, and many liked this, the00:05:40
sick president who personally00:05:42
works with documents and balances00:05:44
on the brink of life and death,00:05:47
all the key decisions On these issues were made by00:05:49
Boris Nikolaevich’s family Yeltsin in00:05:50
the person of Valentin Borisovich Yumashev,00:05:52
Yeltsin’s informal son and his own00:05:54
formal daughter, in fact, Tatyana00:05:57
Borisovna Dyachenko Boris Berezovsky was00:05:59
in the wings, he was important, but still rather a00:06:00
political strategist of this project, not a00:06:03
person who determines its00:06:05
outline, so who to bet on,00:06:07
what is the scenario of Putin’s behavior towards power00:06:10
in which the Chechen war00:06:11
certainly played a key decisive role, all00:06:13
this was decided by the Yeltsin family and maybe00:06:15
today, when the question arises about the00:06:17
responsibility of these people for Vladimir00:06:19
Putin, he organized the fourth world00:06:21
war, well, I’m inclined to classify this00:06:24
as exactly how the00:06:25
Yeltsin family wants to get a little00:06:27
excuse for all this and show00:06:28
that no, in general there are some gloomy things going on00:06:31
with Russian history that are not00:06:33
connected in any way, just an assumption, they00:06:36
rule out the initiative which00:06:44
Well, you are a little flattered as a human being,00:06:47
like Poly, a technopathic Media player, that00:06:52
you are being brought into this story and called00:06:53
not just what - an ordinary00:06:55
participant, an ideologist of these terrible00:06:57
events, is a little bit like Orel00:06:59
putting omnipotence on Stanislav00:07:02
Belkovsky, or do you treat this with00:07:04
hostility because the topic is still00:07:06
quite serious and not very pleasant,00:07:09
I treat it indifferently since00:07:12
no one will believe it anyway, seriously00:07:15
analysts like the minimum of those who00:07:17
really know the situation as it00:07:19
was in the late 90s and how Vladimir00:07:21
Putin came to power,00:07:23
maybe someone will believe it, but it is unlikely that00:07:25
the point of view of such people can be00:07:27
significant in this context,00:07:29
then this is all00:07:32
Alexander’s version Valternatinenko from my00:07:34
involvement if you believe Robert his00:07:37
sources uh which was set out in00:07:39
2005 2005 another context is00:07:43
immediately after the Orange Revolution in00:07:46
Ukraine where Berezovsky’s muses also00:07:47
took some part Not decisive,00:07:49
well Berezovsky is more significant and the exchange is00:07:51
significant but somehow took and00:07:54
when there were quite a few people willing to come forward,00:07:59
then this version arose, that is, then00:08:02
someone wanted to slap Berezovsky with the hands of the Anglo-Saxon00:08:04
justice and a bunch of00:08:07
me too. Although a much less00:08:08
significant00:08:09
interesting character, nevertheless, this is why00:08:11
this is a00:08:13
projection of the events of those years, but I am00:08:16
not at all happy with the omnipotence As00:08:18
you say, because And if you are00:08:20
suspected of gang rape, this00:08:22
too, rejoice at this version that everyone,00:08:25
so to speak, is thus emphasized00:08:27
in sexual potential No, hardly yes And00:08:30
especially since I have long moved away from00:08:31
political technology, I am more busy with issues of00:08:33
religion and philosophy and that’s all contexts are of00:08:36
little interest to me, they are interesting to me00:08:37
only from one point of view, but how it00:08:39
really was in the late nineties,00:08:41
where I was just petty, because00:08:44
nothing special is connected with me.00:08:46
But remember who brought Putin to power,00:08:48
why did Putin fulfill his00:08:50
obligations to those who, according to his00:08:51
authority, in my opinion, did it, and so00:08:53
on. This, of course, from the historical point00:08:55
of view of the state of my father’s point of view, is00:08:56
very important, including for answering the00:08:59
question: was the current00:09:01
big war inevitable? In my opinion, yes it was00:09:03
inevitable from the very beginning from the point of view of the00:09:05
most logic the birth and formation of the00:09:07
Putin regime,00:09:08
continuing for the Yeltsin regime, it00:09:12
became clear about something Stanislav00:09:13
when it became clear that yes Putin This is00:09:16
war. I understand that now we are00:09:18
doing it in hindsight. The conclusion is that it has always been. And00:09:21
when you began to become a reality,00:09:24
not only a Russian person, but also people00:09:26
In general, this is00:09:28
not just an everyday truth00:09:31
corresponding to00:09:34
Belkovsky, according to which00:09:36
banality is bad for everyone except one. It is00:09:38
usually true00:09:39
historical00:09:42
prophets. Clairvoyants who can understand00:09:45
where history will go, most00:09:47
people, including the vast00:09:50
majority of official status00:09:52
titular analysts, are00:09:54
not endowed with such abilities, they can only00:09:56
understand trends and to retrospectively evaluate00:09:58
how it would have been my confidence00:10:00
that Putin is obliged to build a big war00:10:02
happened in 2016, I published00:10:05
Putin’s article on this topic quite nervously in the00:10:07
publication, I00:10:09
tried to remove it from this site00:10:12
because Putin was obliged to00:10:13
lead to the destruction of the system that00:10:16
Seriously serves or at the level of the00:10:18
psychology of the unconscious, this always00:10:20
led to great success, the collapse of the00:10:23
Soviet Union because he became the00:10:25
second person in the city of St. Petersburg, a00:10:27
wealthy influential person, the00:10:28
collapse of the administration of Anatoly Sobchak00:10:31
in St. Petersburg because he became00:10:32
the President of Russia, and so on,00:10:33
respectively, the collapse of the Russian00:10:35
Federation in that the form in which it is00:10:38
Boris Yeltsin, that is, a democratic00:10:41
country with reservations00:10:42
in the American-centric world, should also00:10:45
bring Putin, in his opinion, to new00:10:47
even according to the unconscious00:10:48
idea of the world to new00:10:50
energy levels should become00:10:51
great as never before, he will be00:10:52
seen today as he is being killed by the isolation of00:10:55
the Russian Federation by the fact that the country is00:10:57
not becoming at all what00:10:59
Yeltsin ordered to protect it on December 31,00:11:03
1999, now00:11:05
lethal isolated states00:11:07
that seem to have nothing in common00:11:09
with the West and refuse to be part of the00:11:12
Americans’ personal world, but there are also00:11:14
considerations of a00:11:15
simpler pragmatic order. The fact is00:11:18
that Putin was brought to power00:11:20
as the expressive energy of the people00:11:21
and sentiment together and revenge for the00:11:24
90s, he was the spokesman for those who lost00:11:27
those Russians, these are tens of millions of people00:11:30
who were angry at the 90s of the twentieth century, the00:11:33
costs of their social capital, as00:11:37
founder Yuri Shevchuk brilliantly said in this DDT group yesterday you were the00:11:39
master of the empire And now Putin’s orphan00:11:42
the leader of the party of those who yesterday was the00:11:44
master of the empire is now an orphan the people00:11:46
who led him to power supported him00:11:47
for many years, including the Russian system00:11:49
liberals, believed that all this was a sham, a00:11:52
decoration Well, to keep people00:11:54
everywhere in fact nothing like that will00:11:57
happen, there will be a movement in the real00:11:59
direction of totalitarianism and war,00:12:00
because totalitarianism and war are00:12:02
revenge for the nineties, this happened00:12:05
a mask of growth to the face of those dark energies00:12:07
on which Putin came to power, they00:12:09
ultimately took over and he became an00:12:11
exponent of the very in fact, and not only in the00:12:13
propaganda PR plane, and in this00:12:16
sense, of course, the00:12:17
apotheosis of revenge is00:12:20
concentrated Energy and sentiment, a00:12:22
big war was inevitable00:12:24
and sometimes Stanislav your permission to00:12:27
today to today I will lead00:12:28
to a discussion of what is happening now00:12:30
in Russian politics I would like to hear00:12:32
your assessment of all this the madness of00:12:35
what is happening in particular around the figure of00:12:37
Ramzan Kadyrov, the head of the Chechen00:12:40
Republic, a man who was previously00:12:42
considered00:12:45
untouchable by many and who plays by his own00:12:47
rules, which only he is allowed to00:12:49
now, there is a lot of talk around his00:12:52
state of health, a lot of speculation on00:12:53
this topic Well, the whole Putin was pulled out in00:12:56
order to refute the theory about the poor00:12:59
condition of Ramzan Kadyrov, Ksenia Sobchak00:13:01
was involved in everything, I want to00:13:03
ask you what is happening now with00:13:06
Ramzan, not only with his health00:13:07
in general with the figure of Ramzan Kadyrov with the00:13:09
political player with the Personality of Ramzan00:13:12
Kadyrov, what are we now seeing, what00:13:14
assessment can we give00:13:18
of Ramzan Kadyrov as killed recently,00:13:22
Yevgeny Prigozhin has always been an important00:13:24
part of Putin’s power machine00:13:26
as a bad guy Bad Guy, that is, a00:13:28
person who can informally carry out the00:13:31
Kremlin’s tasks, including very dirty ones, instead of00:13:34
Vladimir Putin being officially00:13:36
involved in this from the order, there is no00:13:40
need for the person to just pick up and disappear or was killed,00:13:42
so to speak, than even in the center of Moscow,00:13:43
but Putin had nothing to do with it, and Ramzan00:13:47
Kadyrov certainly00:13:50
took an exclusive place in00:13:52
Vladimir Putin’s entourage. In addition, it is also00:13:54
associated with the pacification of Chechnya. In00:13:56
principle, Putin loves geis, but he already00:13:58
loved Evgeniy fit trusted him in the house of00:14:00
Kizha this it’s just that everything changed on June 24,00:14:03
according to them, it was possible the same and the sledgehammer00:14:06
was allowed Prigogine correctly, everyone was00:14:08
terribly indignant about him, they could00:14:10
n’t care less and let him support him in this00:14:11
Because Putin really likes to00:14:14
use it to troll00:14:16
his opponents00:14:17
And in general, if something- then he demands from him that he00:14:20
must do exactly the opposite00:14:23
under pressure Yes, just like when, after the events00:14:26
on Bolotnaya Square and Sakharov Avenue, the00:14:28
activists of these events demanded00:14:31
vertical social mobility in the00:14:32
movement of new people to government00:14:34
positions. Putin responded with this appointment of the00:14:36
head of the Ural wagon workshop of the Igor Kholmanskikh plant00:14:40
in the Poluprinsky federal district. that00:14:42
same Mr. Kholmansky was going to00:14:45
gather a team of workers from the Ural carriage00:14:47
of the plant and beat people on the square of00:14:50
So and Kadyrov Avenue which he would present to the00:14:52
public and Western partners and00:14:55
tell them not to say that00:14:57
this is mine Live What is called this is a00:14:59
very Putin style this is the style of00:15:02
Gangster Petersburg which Vladimir00:15:03
with his team they brought big00:15:06
Russian politics not so much to the00:15:07
USSR as many suspect, since00:15:09
Putin is a product of a much greater00:15:11
degree of Gangster Petersburg than00:15:13
later Soviet intelligence services, the very00:15:16
fact that the whole Putin acted00:15:19
to refute rumors of death,00:15:21
the state of Ramzan Kadyrov’s match00:15:23
suggests that with whose health00:15:25
everything is not simple, to put it mildly, otherwise you00:15:27
Putin didn’t need it didn’t need to00:15:29
follow up on a PR company and00:15:31
the publication of a scandalous video with the00:15:33
shooting down of Nikita Zhuravel by Kadyrov’s 15-year-old00:15:35
son Adam Ramzach, which was00:15:38
recognized. Divert attention from the00:15:39
health issues of the head of Chechnya to show that the head of00:15:42
Chechnya as before, everything is possible in the Russian00:15:44
Federation, he is absolutely untouchable, his00:15:46
power is unlimited. Therefore, if someone00:15:48
talks too much about this, the00:15:49
same thing will happen to him as to Nikita00:15:52
Zhuravel or Boris Nemtsov. That’s the point of00:15:55
this whole company. Besides, as we00:15:56
know, Vladimir Vladimirovich the bill00:15:58
promised a new mosque in Moscow in South00:16:00
Butovo, which Ramzan Kadyrov presents00:16:02
to his people as a victory because00:16:04
Ramzan of whom was very much this whole00:16:07
company is very largely00:16:08
oriented neither to the West nor to you and00:16:10
me, not to Putin’s opponents Anna the00:16:12
Chechen people in which there are many00:16:14
ill-wishers during the Ramzan matches, any00:16:16
weakening of it could be a signal for00:16:19
large-scale destabilization, which00:16:21
Kadyrov himself understands, what his patron00:16:22
Vladimir Vladimirovich Putin understands, therefore00:16:24
Kadyrov always needs to bring Gifts00:16:26
in his teeth to his People so as not to00:16:29
show, thereby I have no00:16:31
alternative, only I can kill00:16:33
that kind of money from Moscow only I can, only I00:16:36
can wipe the feet of the capital’s elite,00:16:37
only I can call Putin on the carpet,00:16:40
in fact, when I need it, if I’m00:16:42
not there, then what will happen here is an00:16:45
action in the Kremlin that ended with the promise of a00:16:47
new mosque, this link in the same chain,00:16:50
right now the news has come that00:16:52
Grozny has been appointed the cultural capital of00:16:55
Russia in 2025, that is, also separated by a00:16:58
comma after the story with the South00:17:00
Butovo mosque, the hero city of Grozny will also be the cultural capital of Russia00:17:03
in the near future.00:17:05
Then, continuing the topic00:17:08
with Kadyr, I want to ask what will happen if,00:17:10
well, hypothetically, tomorrow Ramzan00:17:12
will not be What what will happen to the Chechen Republic00:17:15
next after excommunication from00:17:19
power for various reasons,00:17:20
health status or maybe suddenly some00:17:22
political decision of Vladimir Putin and00:17:24
Ramzan Kadyrov does not become What will happen00:17:25
to the republic00:17:28
based on Putin’s political decision00:17:30
Ramzan will not disappear anywhere00:17:31
since he is the most important element of the Putin00:17:33
system authorities, Putin is holding on to him,00:17:35
what he showed at yesterday’s meeting from the00:17:37
Kremlin, which was marked by a kind of00:17:39
iconic and symbolic triumph of the head of00:17:41
Chechnya, he is not only alive and well, but00:17:44
it turns out that he is also a mosque, the00:17:45
cultural capital of Russia 2025, which we00:17:49
just said, and so on, but for all00:17:51
other reasons both natural and00:17:53
unnatural Ramzan Akhmat00:17:55
can naturally disappear, understand the official00:17:57
successors for today. This is Adam00:17:58
Sultan Dilemkhanov, deputy of the00:18:00
State Duma and Magomed Daudov,00:18:02
against forgiveness, forgot his speaker of the00:18:04
Chechen parliament, who, however, must00:18:06
hold power until they are00:18:08
fully mature for the first to put his00:18:10
sons in First of all, those who became Akhmat,00:18:12
we can also remember that at the wedding of00:18:15
Akhmat Ramzanovich Kadyrov, who is00:18:17
now 18 years old, Putin personally met with him,00:18:20
that is, this is a wedding00:18:21
gift for his father, a meeting with the President of00:18:24
the Russian Federation,00:18:29
and00:18:31
this whole structure can only stand00:18:34
if Kadyrov is00:18:37
completely restored control the situation in00:18:38
Chechnya where, again, there are many dissatisfied00:18:40
among those families and clans that were00:18:42
infringed upon by Kadyrov’s rule, where00:18:44
a lot of people died. These people are00:18:47
partly in Russia and partly outside. But00:18:49
this will lead one way or another00:18:51
to destabilization, not the fact that the formal00:18:52
successor of which keeps the situation00:18:54
under control00:18:56
I have question,00:18:58
continue the topic of these Untouchables, a00:19:00
question for you as a person who, it00:19:03
seems to me, sees the big picture and00:19:05
can00:19:07
determine who is who on the political map of Russia. And00:19:09
who is now in 2023, wartime, that00:19:12
is, there is a difference between Russia before February 24 and00:19:16
Russia the current Putin's Russia, its00:19:18
political map, who is now the most00:19:21
influential and the strongest and00:19:23
controls all of us, somehow it was generally accepted00:19:26
that there is Kiriyenko, who00:19:28
controls and leads the whole game; it was generally00:19:30
accepted that there are00:19:31
security forces who can do a little more than the00:19:34
rest, but well, after February 24,00:19:37
2023 who passes the rules of the game Who is the leader00:19:41
in this race who is worth following and00:19:45
evaluating every step The00:19:47
rules of the game are created by Putin himself because00:19:50
in his fundamental philosophy the strategy00:19:53
is not to put your eggs in one basket00:19:56
tell the00:19:58
key clans several, none of them is00:20:00
total and not one hundred percent on the one00:20:04
hand from the clan that00:20:05
directly conducts the special operation Z. This is00:20:07
Sergei Shoigu and Valery Gerasimov, all of them00:20:09
are large businessmen, they are00:20:11
closed on the one hand by the family of Boris00:20:13
Yeltsin on the other hand by Gennady00:20:15
Timchenko, a long-time and key business00:20:17
partner of Vladimir Putin, there is the00:20:20
Kovalchuk clan to which, in fact,00:20:22
belongs to Sergei Kiriyenko, he00:20:24
is not a separate independent00:20:25
player and an integral part of the Kovalchuk plan00:20:27
Mikhail Kovalchuk, by the way,00:20:29
Mikhail Kovalchuk has just been led by the Kruchatsky00:20:31
Institute called on Putin to resume00:20:34
nuclear tests to say nuclear00:20:37
Blackmail was this means it will be and will remain an00:20:40
important element of Vladimir Putin’s bargaining00:20:43
with the West regarding00:20:45
his satisfaction conditions, the00:20:46
Kolchuks are responsible for internal politics,00:20:49
media science and technology, here they are the00:20:52
undivided rulers, it was necessary to00:20:54
actually multiply the Russian00:20:56
Academy of Sciences by zero,00:20:57
and so on, almost all major00:21:00
Smiths to that extent are today00:21:03
under their direct or skeletal control, with the00:21:04
rare exception of00:21:10
large construction infrastructure00:21:12
projects, just remember the Crimean00:21:15
bridge00:21:16
there are several FSB clans at once.00:21:19
In addition, I have any any group of00:21:21
influence in modern Russia, any plan00:21:23
close to Vladimir Putin, he00:21:25
has an extensive network00:21:27
of his own bureaucrats00:21:29
controlled by this particular clan and00:21:31
law enforcement agencies and in civilian00:21:33
ministries, this is the only thing the00:21:35
stability of this type of clan can do Well, by the way,00:21:38
Roman Abramovich remains an important figure00:21:40
as the embodiment of Boris Yeltsin’s family,00:21:42
together they have not gone anywhere. Yes, their00:21:45
influence is not the same as more than a few years ago00:21:47
when they brought Putin to power and,00:21:49
say, controlled 60 percent of the00:21:51
first government of the first Putin00:21:53
government by Mikhail Kasyanov, but00:21:55
Roman Akach remains Abramovich remains00:21:57
not only an important window to the world for Putin, a00:22:00
negotiator on sensitive00:22:02
issues with various external players,00:22:04
allegedly from such a pseudo-liberal position, he has00:22:09
forgotten almost no one, but in any case,00:22:12
the moderator of this whole story remains00:22:13
personally. Well, there is a Russian Guard00:22:15
there in the form of director Vasilyevich00:22:17
snatching gold a game that is in a00:22:20
loyal relationship with Ramzan matches00:22:22
Kadyrov, they can be considered to a00:22:24
certain extent partners,00:22:25
both political and economic, so one way00:22:27
or another, the moderator of all these00:22:28
stories remains Vladimir Putin and00:22:30
to say that he is a Hostage of00:22:32
one of the clans or at least part of it I00:22:35
forgot to mention, of course, the clan of Nikolai00:22:37
Platonovich Patrusha, the son of Dmitry00:22:39
Nikolaevich Patrushev, who deals with a00:22:40
variety of issues from geopolitics00:22:43
to agriculture, now completely00:22:44
given over, and agriculture00:22:46
is the whole Universe and fertilizer. The deal00:22:49
is also a lot, a lot of things that concern00:22:52
Vladimir Putin in the first place, but00:22:53
Putin remains key anyway for the00:22:55
feat of the scammer is called the key00:22:57
moderator of this system00:22:59
to assume that he is some kind of passive00:23:02
instrument In whose hands nothing has changed00:23:04
and nothing has changed, that is, from the point of view of00:23:07
the role of Putin, before we00:23:09
called him arn, it was generally accepted that00:23:11
Putin is the arbiter between these clans are00:23:12
inferior and specifically control00:23:14
the situation So that one of the others does not gobble up00:23:16
and there is some kind of stability after the war00:23:19
after the start of a full-scale invasion00:23:21
of Ukraine, the situation has not changed Vladimir00:23:23
Putin is still a deterrent00:23:25
for all groups and how they behave We have00:23:28
not heard that alone for a long time somehow00:23:30
watered down others, some kind of squabble under the00:23:32
carpet of all this, as if there00:23:34
is no reason now why Putin said Quietly,00:23:38
during the war, everyone needs to show loyalty or are00:23:39
we simply not noticing something,00:23:47
absolutely? Back in the spring of last year,00:23:49
a big one began00:23:51
with the failures of the Russian armed forces00:23:54
in Ukraine it was sold then,00:23:56
of course, Evgeniy Prigozhin became the main one and it’s00:23:59
unlikely that anyone would have dealt with it better than him. After Prigozhin’s00:24:01
death, the company went down,00:24:04
no, we don’t see it on that scale, but mutual00:24:09
hatred exists and the struggle00:24:10
continues permanently. Moreover, it00:24:12
cannot stop because for some reason00:24:13
clan directly if some plan stops00:24:16
fighting with others, he will simply be eaten00:24:17
not destroyed Unfortunately, but00:24:21
fundamentally the role of the path has not changed in00:24:22
this sense, the key players in his00:24:23
environment are interested in him The legend is00:24:26
that they want to remove him And thereby00:24:28
draw a line under uh, a big war00:24:31
has no basis; if they remove him, they00:24:33
will shoot each other, and the war in any00:24:35
case is the priority area of00:24:37
responsibility of him, those around him00:24:39
proceed from the fact that as long as Putin is alive, everything00:24:41
will be as now we have to00:24:43
put up with it, since00:24:45
these plans will exist outside this system of power they can’t00:24:47
Even those people who are seeking the lifting of00:24:49
sanctions from themselves in the European Union are not ready to00:24:51
completely dissociate themselves publicly from00:24:53
Vladimir Putin to discuss the war, this00:24:55
can be done by individual people like Oleg00:24:57
Tinkov, who is not actually connected with the Kremlin,00:24:58
or Arkady Volzh, who was00:25:01
closely connected with the Kremlin, repented of the00:25:03
sanctions against him for some reason the sanctions were lifted from00:25:05
Grigory Berezkin, who did not00:25:06
repent of anything and was a partner for many years,00:25:08
including Kovalchuk, well,00:25:10
that is, we know why all the00:25:12
intense lobbying in Hungary where00:25:14
Berezkin is busy with energy00:25:15
construction, but how do we see all these00:25:18
arguments everyone is Beyond the00:25:19
politics of morality War and Peace and so on,00:25:21
these are again some kind of behind-the-scenes00:25:23
behind-the-scenes deals that the clans00:25:26
around Vladimir Putin are counting on00:25:27
and henceforth they believe that thanks to these00:25:29
deals they will somehow be able to crawl out of00:25:31
sanctions in the coming years Or maybe00:25:33
then and then if everything is found for00:25:35
natural reasons, then they, like the00:25:36
Heirs of Joseph Stalin, will negotiate with the West,00:25:38
but today they have neither00:25:41
the motive00:25:42
nor the opportunity to remove Vladimir Putin, and00:25:45
therefore I understand that for many this00:25:46
came out as a sentinel, so I would like to think that00:25:48
now Putin has been overthrown, but I don’t see any pre-00:25:50
real material prerequisites for00:25:52
this, I didn’t give us hope00:25:55
Stanislav Belkovskiy Okay, we ourselves00:25:57
are moving on, friends, I remind you of the00:25:59
popular politics channel, support00:26:01
this broadcast with likes Stanislav I have a00:26:02
rather unexpected question, have you read00:26:05
Vladislav Surkov’s column, his idea of the00:26:09
concept of uniting Russia, Europe,00:26:11
America into a single North, if you read00:26:15
what you think about this, what comment00:26:17
can you get on this issue?00:26:20
I read it certainly because I generally00:26:22
pay attention to the text of Vladislav00:26:24
Yuryevich Surkov, since in all these00:26:26
texts they do not appear often, but00:26:29
always at significant moments in history00:26:32
there is only one reader, the addressee00:26:35
Vladimirovich Putin and always Vladislav00:26:38
Yuryevich Sharkov is trying to express in his own words00:26:40
how he is considered to be00:26:42
Putin’s inner thoughts, so these texts are already00:26:44
interesting, like what the church thinks, like how00:26:47
Putin thinks, once upon a time Sokolov00:26:49
wrote articles on the loneliness of the half-breed, where00:26:52
he set out a completely Putin-like view of the00:26:54
Russian world that only loneliness only00:26:56
isolation will save Russia, roughly speaking, this is what is00:26:58
happening before our eyes, then00:27:00
he wrote shortly before the special operation that00:27:02
Russia is doomed to expansion, that it is00:27:04
expanding Yes, this was a prerequisite for the00:27:07
fact that Ukraine and now Surkov are00:27:11
actually transfers that Putin wants to00:27:12
negotiate with the West and is not at all00:27:14
in the Vedic alliance secrets of00:27:16
India to go to Africa and all that, all these00:27:19
Alter alliances. This is only a way,00:27:21
again, to force the smell of negotiations in the alliance,00:27:23
that Putin sees himself as part of the north and not the00:27:26
global south, and times will pass,00:27:28
Italians will become possible until00:27:30
they have to bargain with the West, including00:27:32
military methods and methods of nuclear00:27:33
blackmail is what you want to say Vladislav00:27:36
Yuryevich Surkov, or rather, how he sets out00:27:38
his understanding of the ideas of the strategic ideas of00:27:42
the plans of the main patron, while00:27:44
naturally Surkov solves his00:27:46
own problems, he wants to attract all00:27:47
the attention and return to power, but that’s00:27:50
another question for me interesting for us,00:27:52
Vladimir Putin00:27:53
[music]00:27:56
reacts to such publications. That is, he00:27:58
perceives them, uh, and they find a response,00:28:02
such publications are made by00:28:04
Surkov. Putin listens to this. Do00:28:07
you think00:28:09
Putin should not listen to this00:28:11
because he thinks so himself the00:28:13
battle his thoughts Okay, I understand you, and he00:28:16
correctly understands the thoughts of the leader. Therefore,00:28:19
if someone table Vladimir in00:28:22
Vladislav Yuryevich’s article, then Vladimir00:28:24
should be glad that Yuryevich00:28:26
remains an intelligent, subtle and delicate00:28:28
comrade-in-arms until Vladislav Yuryevich was00:28:31
returned to power, Despite the fact that he00:28:33
appears in these articles a smart, subtle00:28:35
comrade-in-arms, but let's see that it will be clear00:28:37
that he has reached their heights of the church, it is unlikely that he will be00:28:39
able to rise when he was the curator of00:28:41
Russian domestic policy; he had the00:28:43
post of head of the00:28:44
presidential administration; in many ways, his00:28:46
public ambitions let him down;00:28:51
where Everyone should downplay00:28:53
their influence and sit generally quietly in the00:28:55
shadow of the leader who should be00:28:57
the only public developer in this00:29:00
system, but perhaps some will00:29:03
return to mid-level positions and succeed.00:29:04
The main thing here is not Surkov himself, I’m saying00:29:06
what is still confirmed by me a00:29:08
long-term hypothesis that Putin does not00:29:10
intend to do business with the West at all. He just wants to00:29:12
renegotiate the deal with the West on his own00:29:14
terms. I00:29:16
continue to ask questions, including00:29:18
those sent by our viewers. The question00:29:20
about the figure of Ruben Vardanyan00:29:22
was quite an important person for the Russian00:29:24
political elite. Because despite the fact00:29:26
that they are not public, but a man00:29:28
who served the interests of many00:29:31
oligarchs and officials, including the well-00:29:33
known cellist Sergei Aldugin,00:29:35
passed large sums of money through voltramate,00:29:38
which were then deposited into an account with the00:29:40
Russian elite, and now he00:29:42
is actually in captivity of the00:29:45
Azerbaijani government under the Aliyev regime. We do not see00:29:48
any actions on the part of Russia00:29:51
to somehow get him out of00:29:55
this captivity,00:29:57
official Yerevan announced that it is00:29:59
demanding his release, the00:30:01
European Court is submitting some documents,00:30:03
but there are no documents from Russia, and this came as00:30:06
a surprise to many because there are some00:30:07
personal the same agreements between00:30:10
people are personal sympathies and personal00:30:12
relationships because well, it seems like he00:30:15
acted in your interests and there is00:30:17
no reaction there are no demands00:30:18
for complications, it surprises you in general00:30:20
what do you think about the whole situation around00:30:22
Vardanyan there00:30:24
can be no public reaction00:30:26
since 202200:30:28
turned out to be from Russian citizenship,00:30:31
it seems like the Kremlin is completely inconvenient to00:30:33
protect him. Why protect a person00:30:35
who00:30:36
demonstratively refuses a00:30:38
Russian passport, this does not mean that there will not be some00:30:40
informal efforts to facilitate it. Teach00:30:43
because he is really connected with00:30:45
some prominent important figures of the00:30:47
Putin establishment. Although I do not00:30:49
trust the theory according to which it was00:30:51
Moscow and the Kremlin who sent Vardanyan to00:30:54
Armenia Karabakh No, of course this is the same thing00:30:55
It was the idea of the word bank glynych at the00:30:57
junction of two trends, firstly, it became00:30:59
clear that someone in the foreseeable00:31:01
historical future should00:31:02
replace Nikolayevich Pushinyan and his00:31:06
team And why not Weben Korolen and00:31:08
his team are clear that00:31:11
Pashinyan’s predecessors will not be able to do this00:31:13
because on the one hand they were00:31:15
the sources and organizers of large-scale00:31:17
corruption on the other hand and brought00:31:20
the situation to the inevitability of a military00:31:22
defeat of the Ar00:31:24
together with Azerbaijan. But what is the00:31:28
next generation after Pashinyan? Yes And00:31:30
that’s when they could well claim00:31:32
what they can now claim that00:31:34
he will be the leader of Armenia at the00:31:35
next historical turn, another00:31:37
country wanted, on the contrary, to distance itself from the00:31:38
Kremlin from a big war. To avoid00:31:41
sanctions, which they succeeded in as a result of00:31:43
moving to Armenia, they00:31:45
simply underestimated00:31:47
Azerbaijan’s desire to get it. Azerbaijan is00:31:50
of course possible now someday he00:31:52
faces up to 14 years in prison he has been00:31:55
charged under the article of financing00:31:57
terrorism of a00:31:58
tourist organization, here00:32:00
we mean the Nagorno-00:32:02
Karabakh Republic itself, which, as we00:32:03
know, will officially come into00:32:04
existence on January 1, 2024 on00:32:07
the basis of a decree of its last president00:32:09
Samvel Roman, but some kind of big jackpot00:32:13
perhaps Azerbaijan when they release00:32:14
what this course will be connected with, who will00:32:17
offer it to Armenia or Russia, we will00:32:19
look at Armenia Can offer00:32:21
some political conditions, maybe00:32:24
Nikol Shpina can lobby for some00:32:28
interests of Azerbaijani businessmen00:32:29
businessmen of Azerbaijani00:32:31
origin who are under sanctions from the USA and00:32:34
France on the other On the other hand, if Bender00:32:36
leaves the pre-trial detention center, then he will fly away; he will become a00:32:39
figure of another political class00:32:41
in Armenia itself. But on the other hand, we00:32:43
don’t know how00:32:44
much Pashinyan is really interested in the00:32:46
speedy release of the VVB for Vardanyan,00:32:48
who, in general, has been in conflict with him00:32:50
lately and took an00:32:51
excellent, radically opposite00:32:53
position to Pashinyan’s position on Karabakh when00:32:56
they called for recognizing the shares as an00:32:58
independent state and entering the00:33:00
war, which Pashinyan00:33:01
categorically did not want to do. Therefore,00:33:03
here only shadow efforts can be00:33:05
successful in the public sphere, now00:33:08
Azerbaijan is over-determined to00:33:09
arrange a show trial of those00:33:11
who support the key figures who00:33:13
supported Karaban independence in the mountains00:33:15
recently and to00:33:17
extract from this means dividends.00:33:19
However, I admit that a deal is quite00:33:21
possible. And a turnaround of Armenia from Russia is expected00:33:25
subsequently because00:33:27
Moscow did not provide any official assistance during00:33:30
this00:33:31
short-term war which ended with the00:33:33
military defeat of official Yerevan.00:33:35
And we are waiting for Nikolai Pashinyan to take a00:33:38
course towards euro integration and more00:33:40
honest ties with the United States. Well, in general, with the00:33:42
collective West, or is everything much more00:33:45
subtle and impossible? Such a reversal is all the00:33:47
same and Yerevans are officially very00:33:49
dependent on Moscow, and where00:33:53
this reversal is happening before our eyes in the00:33:55
fall of 2020, during the Second00:33:58
Karabakh War,00:34:00
Karabakh and Armenia ended in defeat when most of00:34:02
Nagorno-Karabakh was occupied by00:34:04
Azerbaijani troops, let me remind you all00:34:06
this from the point of view of international law,00:34:08
the territory of Azerbaijan, that is,00:34:09
Azerbaijan acted on its00:34:11
territory, therefore their there00:34:13
could be no external claims against him on this issue,00:34:14
that once again the question arises that if00:34:16
you really want to defend the territories, you00:34:18
must legally recognize How this was00:34:20
done by Vladimir Putin with Abkhazia South00:34:22
Ossetia Armenia for all the years did not00:34:24
do this did not recognize Nagorno-Karabakh00:34:26
then already it was clear that the Kremlin stands on the00:34:29
side of Azerbaijan and all of00:34:31
Vladimir Putin’s certain obligations to the00:34:33
sacrificial Taipei Erdogan, the President of00:34:34
Turkey, to the patrons of Azerbaijan, with00:34:37
whom he has absolutely no intention of meeting And00:34:39
due to the influence of the Azerbaijani lobby in00:34:41
Russia itself, which is largely tied to00:34:43
Elgam Ibragimov, Vladimir00:34:45
Putin’s classmate at the Leningrad University00:34:47
Zhdanov, and that is, for the last three00:34:50
years, Armenia could not count on being00:34:53
on its side in this conflict, but tried to maneuver00:34:55
now that the Russian Federation had already completely surrendered00:34:57
Armenia and outlined its priorities00:34:59
openly. Of course, Pashinyan will move00:35:01
towards the United States and France, this is a very00:35:02
difficult complex process now in first00:35:05
of all, Armenia needs to resolve the00:35:07
issue of the inviolability of its00:35:09
state border to avoid00:35:10
raising the issue of the Excel00:35:12
extraterritorial corridor between00:35:14
Azerbaijan and the Nakhichevan region00:35:17
through the Zangiz Sinim region of Armenia,00:35:20
that same legendary ezangi00:35:22
zombiz corridor and will the USA and00:35:26
France be effective as international00:35:28
mediators00:35:29
in resolving the situation taking into account00:35:32
interests Armenia is not eating yet Clearly, but00:35:33
this is a different situation, a question from the00:35:36
point of view of international law in Karabakh,00:35:38
Azerbaijan liberated its own00:35:39
territories and formal legally And00:35:41
here the Zangizon corridors are also the00:35:43
canonical territory of Armenia, therefore the00:35:45
International community can be00:35:46
involved in protecting interests00:35:48
less actively, but00:35:50
all the construction of its policy in in the field of00:35:53
international relations and security,00:35:54
Armenia has to start from scratch,00:35:56
since the Armenian elite’s bet was made00:35:58
back in the early nineties of the twentieth00:36:01
century after the first Karabakh war on00:36:03
Russia, the main guarantor of security00:36:04
failed,00:36:08
and we ourselves are moving on, friends.00:36:11
We’ve been on air for 35 minutes. Send questions to the00:36:13
chat. I remind you that we are live on air with00:36:15
Stanislav Belkovsky We talk about the main00:36:17
political events and listen to his00:36:20
opinion here on popular politics00:36:23
live on air first a question that was00:36:25
sent to us as soon as we announced that there00:36:27
would be a broadcast with you,00:36:29
what do you think about such a media phenomenon and00:36:33
such luck Ksenia Anatolyevna Sobchak00:36:35
how so it turns out that during00:36:38
crisis situations, be it speculation about the00:36:42
state of health and freedom and freedom of00:36:46
Surikin, be it a story with a00:36:49
refutation through her of00:36:52
information about the health problems of00:36:54
Ramzan Kadyrov, every time it turns out00:36:56
that it is Ksenia Anatolyevna who publishes the00:36:57
footage and they contact her as she00:37:00
says and00:37:02
Reliable sources convey footage that is very00:37:04
beneficial to the authorities with this your your00:37:07
relationship to this What do you think is this00:37:09
plum Ksenia Anatolyevna is playing along00:37:11
because the reach of the clique or she00:37:14
generally plays such a role for the Kremlin00:37:16
now in 2004 the person through whom00:37:18
you can throw the necessary information00:37:22
the necessary information can be through00:37:24
many people, not only00:37:26
on the left, it happens. I understand that you do not have a00:37:29
special relationship, that’s why she is mentioned.00:37:32
I, too, have not been involved00:37:34
in this relationship for many years, so I00:37:36
would not like to engage in criticism of her, but00:37:38
of course the00:37:39
communications person is the ruling persons who are00:37:41
often treated with this type00:37:45
but When At the same time, he00:37:47
continues to build the image of a00:37:50
person who does not support the war;00:37:53
the image of a person who, well, at00:37:55
least publicly, is00:37:57
exactly the kind of person00:37:59
who is still critical00:38:01
of the authorities. And somehow this doesn’t00:38:03
really fit in with the political strategist, tell me, is00:38:05
n’t there such a thing? - contradictions and00:38:08
Cry that this is a deception when on the one00:38:11
hand a person plays the role of such I am00:38:13
against everything and then do it as it is00:38:15
beneficial for those against someone allegedly against00:38:24
published data about his conversation with the00:38:26
youngest of whom I don’t know00:38:29
how reliable this whole story is00:38:32
in the wake of his harsh criticism for00:38:34
publishing a video with Nikita Zhuravel,00:38:36
it is clear that perhaps there was a two-way00:38:39
combination, but in Russian Lida there are many00:38:41
people who would like, on the one hand,00:38:43
to maintain relations with Vladimir Putin,00:38:45
on the other hand, they are against the war; this00:38:47
includes all system liberals in the end00:38:50
[music]00:38:52
finally, who was not by chance00:38:54
re-acted and the Accounts Chamber in Yandex00:38:56
really didn’t help him avoid sanctions. And00:38:59
what did we count on00:39:00
Nabiullina, the chairman of the Central Bank, exactly the same00:39:03
people? They are used to working, they00:39:05
respect him, they see a lot of00:39:08
good things from him, together they are against war,00:39:11
trade, the difficult fate of the systemic00:39:14
liberals of modern times00:39:16
connected about systemic liberals has always00:39:18
been considered to be, again, this is00:39:19
just some kind of00:39:21
definition that many have used,00:39:23
that Putin is the systemic liberal who00:39:26
gives the economic bloc. So you00:39:27
figure it out and pick around the rest of everything else for00:39:30
other political groups during the00:39:32
war, after a year and a half, many expected00:39:35
some kind of then the purge of all system00:39:36
liberals, that now he will put the economy on a00:39:38
war footing and, in general,00:39:40
he no longer needs them because00:39:42
they demonstrate it to the outside world, but00:39:45
everyone understands that they do not support what is00:39:47
happening now because they are00:39:49
somehow stylistic. Or maybe00:39:51
ideologically, it’s not close to understanding such a00:39:53
war as a whole. Why didn’t this00:39:55
purge of system liberals happen and should we00:39:57
expect it? I don’t know in the near future, as you00:40:00
see it.00:40:01
I just didn’t expect any purge of00:40:03
system liberals from the point of view of the00:40:06
financial sphere. Putin himself is a00:40:08
system liberal, he’s completely00:40:11
like-minded. Codrina Nabiullina and so00:40:12
on, and therefore continues to occupy00:40:16
key positions in the economic bloc will00:40:17
remain in them; the economy is switching to00:40:20
military, one way or another this is indicated,00:40:21
although the military budget which in 202400:40:24
will be 70% more than this year and the00:40:27
second more than in 2021 but00:40:30
Putin has the same views. In particular,00:40:35
the question of how to fight00:40:36
inflation, why not give money00:40:37
to the people,00:40:39
save money, create money boxes, these are all00:40:42
general views on the subject of a market economy to a certain00:40:45
extent,00:40:47
they are planned, all00:40:50
kinds of socialist methods,00:40:51
experiments are deeply alien to him, he is an00:40:54
ultra-right politician in his views In00:40:56
addition, systemic liberalism is associated with00:40:58
Putin not only00:40:59
with views on the economy, but also with the general idea00:41:03
that a Russian person cannot be allowed to00:41:04
roam, he cannot be given democracy,00:41:06
which is that in the 90s, when Vladimir00:41:09
Putin as a political figure, we did not00:41:11
know that democracy in Russia is extremely00:41:14
harmful because the people will definitely00:41:15
bring to power fascists or00:41:17
some kind of fascists and communists00:41:19
combined, no red-brown00:41:21
coalition, so Russia needs some kind of00:41:23
enlightened authorites, these are systemic00:41:25
liberals. Putin for many years was a symbol of00:41:27
enlightened authoritarianism and partly00:41:30
remains because Yes, they are against war,00:41:33
but they not against their own cooperation with Putin and have absolutely no00:41:35
plans to leave the system because00:41:37
the phrase systemic liberal00:41:39
systemic means more than a liberal00:41:41
systemic person of the system who cannot00:41:43
express themselves and realize themselves outside the system.00:41:47
I finally want to ask you a question00:41:49
related to Ukraine, you worked a lot there00:41:52
they talked about this in00:41:54
their numerous interviews, now00:41:57
around Ukraine the issue is not related to you,00:42:00
only one is being discussed. Should00:42:03
Zelensky not need to go discuss the00:42:05
media on00:42:07
the Internet, too, everyone is joining in these00:42:09
discussions, I’m rather00:42:13
asking a broader question, that’s what is possible now00:42:15
describe now the political structure of00:42:17
Ukraine how much it has changed both in00:42:21
connection with the war and in connection with the past00:42:22
past tense to your last00:42:25
working moments associated with this00:42:28
beautiful country. What do you00:42:29
see now as the political component of00:42:32
Ukraine00:42:34
and the quality has not changed anything Ukraine00:42:37
remains a democratic free00:42:38
country during00:42:39
the war during the war, a lot changes00:42:43
towards the consolidation of power and the emergence of00:42:45
certain authoritarian tendencies,00:42:46
which, however, appeared before the war00:42:50
during the reign of Zelensky and00:42:52
caused significant opposition both in the00:42:54
Ukrainian elites and among the people,00:42:56
let’s not forget that Zelensky’s rating00:42:58
before the start of the special operation was00:43:00
only 23% then it soared to 91 percent00:43:03
somewhere At these heights it is00:43:05
located approximately and now Zelensky’s undermining has become00:43:07
Ukrainian and gives up power. In my00:43:09
opinion, Zelensky is not going to ask another00:43:11
question how his00:43:13
Dear American partners will react to this, what will they00:43:15
say about this since from their00:43:17
a lot depends on opinions, because American00:43:19
military economic support is a00:43:21
necessary condition for the survival and00:43:22
subsequent prosperity of Ukraine at00:43:25
this historical stage; simply00:43:26
survival without the support of Ukraine00:43:28
cannot be maintained and will be exposed in the war00:43:31
and among the elites, many are still00:43:35
dissatisfied with his team, now in00:43:37
Ukraine in Zelensky’s team00:43:39
conversations have begun about the transition to a presidential00:43:40
republic. Vadim Zelensky himself will appear.00:43:44
Apparently, he strives not to hold00:43:46
presidential elections in 2024 since00:43:49
elections are formally impossible under martial law.00:43:50
But they are difficult to00:43:52
conduct and in fact, in conditions of war, it is00:43:54
technologically unclear how to do this00:43:56
when hostilities are of sufficiently00:43:59
high intensity this means one way or00:44:01
another Whoever intends or wants anything, a00:44:03
subjectively objective choice can00:44:05
only be made under conditions of a truce, and00:44:07
for this The truce now has no00:44:08
conceptual basis, but Ukraine00:44:10
will remain a Democratic country, it is not at all a00:44:12
fact that Vladimir Zelensky will retain00:44:14
power after the war, and this is perhaps the00:44:16
key to the00:44:17
country's own prosperity; the main00:44:19
problems; the main two problems of Ukraine00:44:21
are large-scale corruption;00:44:23
inefficiency of management; and, among other things,00:44:24
external players constantly raise questions00:44:27
about this and link the further00:44:28
continuation of support for Ukraine with the fight00:44:30
against corruption; optimization of management; and00:44:32
it cannot be said that Vladimir Zelensky00:44:34
has made a qualitative breakthrough; No, he has become00:44:37
but the quality was not accomplished, but in a different way No matter how00:44:41
ambiguous it may sound, the war00:44:43
opens up completely new prospects00:44:45
for destroying, so to speak, the00:44:48
corrupt system and the rule of power. A00:44:50
new generation of specialists who better00:44:52
understand what modern00:44:54
management is. What are global trends with the00:44:56
Eastern European testing ground00:44:58
Ukraine may well become, but when00:45:00
they talk about Ukraine, they often, in addition to00:45:02
what they have listed, also talk about the fact00:45:04
that this is a country that was divided00:45:05
between various oligarchs, where they00:45:07
had their own TV channels, their parties, their own00:45:09
media, but00:45:11
now it is precisely this Aspect that many00:45:13
are talking about that it was just because of the war that it00:45:14
stopped, someone escaped, someone was00:45:16
imprisoned, like in the story with Kolomoisky, and in00:45:18
general, this is where they managed to break this00:45:21
vicious Circle, uh, don’t you think that the00:45:24
oligarchs no longer have such influence00:45:27
until the Kolomoisky case ended,00:45:30
it was indicative, demonstrative,00:45:31
since it was he who was the head of the United States,00:45:34
expressively, he is wanted by the00:45:36
Federal Bureau of Investigation,00:45:37
Kolomoisky’s lawyer, the United States, where he would be00:45:40
prosecuting him for laundering proceeds from00:45:42
crime, they always00:45:44
argued that the formulation of the question00:45:46
is absurd, since00:45:47
no income was recorded in Ukraine obtained00:45:49
by criminal means, what could Kolomoisky00:45:51
launder00:45:52
now, therefore, Zelensky has an important00:45:55
quality00:45:57
and this was an important sign before00:46:00
Vladimir Zelensky’s recent visit to the United States,00:46:01
which was no longer as00:46:03
triumphant as a year ago, that is, there00:46:05
was a lot of roughness in00:46:06
interaction with American00:46:08
partners, but the oligarchs are nowhere yet don’t00:46:10
share, they will disappear when the00:46:12
economic base is completely destroyed,00:46:14
their power is that the war and is doing this by the00:46:16
end of the war, apparently the ligraphic plans00:46:18
have weakened, they will continue to cling to00:46:20
power now she says that00:46:22
they no longer exist, but the general trend is there00:46:25
she and Actually, the positive00:46:27
consequences of the war will certainly be00:46:28
that there will most likely no longer be an oligarchy in the old sense in Ukraine.00:46:32
Well, since we talked about the elections in Ukraine and00:46:34
so on, I ask about the elections in Russia in00:46:37
March 24 and now. There is a wide discussion00:46:39
around this with uh. there is00:46:41
a discussion literally Internet warriors00:46:43
are taking place on this topic, I want to ask you,00:46:46
what position do you take about the twenty-00:46:49
fourth year and00:46:51
Putin’s elections, and in your opinion, that’s what’s00:46:54
important, it will be stress with the test.00:46:55
For Vladimir Putin, in general, in general, the00:46:57
voting procedure that will be in00:46:59
March is 24 years old,00:47:01
but Putin definitely doesn’t consider the00:47:04
technical point for him, he is absolutely convinced that00:47:08
his percentage is closer to 80. The general00:47:11
attitude is that Putin should00:47:12
receive00:47:13
more than in 2018 with a total turnout00:47:17
higher than 2018,00:47:20
thereby confirming that the decision is starting to be big The00:47:21
multinational people of the Russian Federation like war and00:47:25
they simply view it as a00:47:26
chaotic procedure that will00:47:29
go through completely calmly. But will the Russian oppositionists be able to00:47:31
oppose something? I00:47:34
don’t know, but what I know for sure is that personally,00:47:36
as an opposition voter, I’m an opponent of00:47:39
the Kremlin, the main thing is that I’m tired of the00:47:41
constant analysis among Russians00:47:42
oppositionists who accuse each00:47:44
other more harshly than with the common enemy00:47:47
the Kremlin and would like to live to see00:47:49
this showdown and want to see some kind of00:47:52
consolidation of the opposition, including in the00:47:53
face of the 2024 elections,00:47:57
well noted And who are we waiting for00:48:01
as opponents was I published in00:48:03
Domosti and Medusa link to sources00:48:05
that this is an installation that should not be like this00:48:09
supposedly Vladimir Putin should not seem to be00:48:11
the oldest on the ballot and therefore00:48:13
the participation of Zyuganov is in question and so on00:48:16
in your opinion who will be selected00:48:18
as opponents Should we wait for a00:48:19
liberal candidate there as they write the same00:48:22
statements hinting at the Egyptian and00:48:24
conditional Muratov,00:48:27
first of all, I don’t trust this theory About00:48:30
the fact that there should be only00:48:32
old people to choose from because Vladimir00:48:34
Putin cannot be posed like that, no00:48:37
kirienta can pose a00:48:39
question to Putin like that because then it00:48:40
turns out that Putin looks an old man and00:48:43
Putin doesn’t look like an old man objectively. In00:48:45
my opinion, he is00:48:47
in good physical shape, especially since he does00:48:50
n’t look like an old man in subjective00:48:52
eyes, so look for those Putin’s,00:48:54
let’s make old00:48:56
candidates so that you look young00:48:57
now, how to beat the Russian president.00:48:59
No one from his circle is such an insult00:49:01
it will go, therefore, it seems to me that the theory is that00:49:03
you are on stage and won’t you go to sleep? Will Gennady00:49:05
Andreevich Zyuganov go excellently? Not because00:49:06
he should set off the young Putin, but00:49:08
because he is simply not yet ready to00:49:10
transfer the power of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation to another generation,00:49:13
he still wants to transfer it to his00:49:14
grandson Leonid Leonid we are not ready for this00:49:16
And if we transfer now we need to00:49:18
transfer a figure like Andreichkov, she00:49:20
said the governor who is objectively the00:49:22
brightest among the politicians of this party But00:49:26
Zyuganov is not ready for this I don’t want to00:49:27
leave the party to the family Could00:49:29
they be Slutsk from the LDPR Alexey Nechaev from00:49:31
new people then there are people who are quite young00:49:33
and who do not understand the theory that there00:49:36
should be only decrepit grandfathers, setting00:49:39
the path for which Alexey Alekseevich00:49:40
Venediktov will become a candidate, I have a00:49:41
hard time believing But I want to pinch, as far00:49:44
as I know this man, he will00:49:45
never go like this Although who knows him to00:49:47
everyone everything in life anything can happen00:49:48
Of course, but of course there will be no real00:49:52
liberal candidate, no real00:49:53
candidate not controlled by the Kremlin in these00:49:55
elections. Therefore, if the00:49:57
candidate is not going to be under00:49:59
control, he will not be registered, so to speak.00:50:03
Well, I’m more likely talking about who will00:50:05
play the dummy candidate from00:50:06
liberal opposition of such a systemic00:50:08
kind of conditional00:50:10
half-Yabloko but at the same time00:50:13
criticize the war as it was.00:50:15
For this there are New people00:50:18
leader Alexei Nechaev actually00:50:21
mother model in the elections in Moscow what does00:50:23
not suit you In Moscow as a model for00:50:26
subsequent federal elections It00:50:27
seems to me so- then everything will be approximately and will go away like00:50:29
a conspiracy Moscow is not Russia in Moscow everything00:50:32
went well00:50:33
79% The rest little by little because00:50:37
approximately not yet according to the Kremlin’s plan00:50:39
should take place in the spring of 202400:50:42
Will the real position be able to put something I wanted to00:50:44
put I don’t know, well, how would it be00:50:46
possible to oppose it though It would be nice to have00:50:47
a consultation and giving up an endless00:50:50
life would be a good idea00:50:53
Thank you very much We have a political scientist on00:50:55
the air today of the program Honest Word00:50:59
subscribe to Youtube channel00:51:01
Stanislav Belinsky's telegram channel00:51:03
links in the description subscribe to the00:51:06
guests who come to us different00:51:07
opinions here there are different positions well00:51:09
the topic this is a wonderful program here you can00:51:11
hear everything My name is Ruslan00:51:14
Shaginov I thank you for00:51:16
being with us this morning00:51:18
popular politics is only00:51:20
starting to air today we00:51:22
will also have news today and an evening broadcast and an00:51:26
evening Honest to Dmitry Bykov00:51:28
Dmitry Bykov today too will be 17:0000:51:30
here so don’t miss anything I’ll00:51:34
just say a big thank you at the end00:51:35
not just to those who watch and like but00:51:37
to those who financially support through the00:51:39
website patreon.com or through sponsorship00:51:42
on YouTube You see the QR code on your00:51:44
screens also in description link00:51:46
please support the release of new00:51:49
episodes of your favorite programs on the channel00:51:52
popular politics00:51:54
nicknames of those who have already signed up for00:51:56
regular sponsorship of this particular00:51:59
program Honestly, you see on your00:52:00
screens all these people00:52:03
donate a00:52:04
fixed amount every month that they have chosen00:52:08
so that we can continue to00:52:09
work Thank you very much exists Only00:52:11
thanks to you, thank you for watching,00:52:13
liking and supporting No war and00:52:16
freedom to AlexeyDescription:
В гостях «Честного слова» — публицист Станислав Белковский. Как всегда, обсуждаем главные новости последних дней. Задавайте свои вопросы в чате! И подписывайтесь на канал @BelkovskiyS С экстренным выпуском шоу ДОБРОЙ. НОЧИ. МАЛЫШИ — о взрывах домов в РФ (1999), за которыми последовала вторая чеченская война. Гость: Станислав Белковский: @BelkovskiyS Ведущий: Руслан Шаведдинов https://www.facebook.com/unsupportedbrowser Канал БЕЛКОВСКИЙ: @BelkovskiyS Экстренный выпуск шоу ДОБРОЙ. НОЧИ. МАЛЫШИ – о взрывах домов в РФ (1999), за которыми последовала вторая чеченская война Избирательная кампания против кандидата «Война»: https://navalny.com/p/6642/ Присоединяйтесь. Пишите нам на [email protected] 🔹 Подписывайтесь на канал «Самое важное» с Иваном Ждановым! https://www.youtube.com/@samoe_vazhnoe/featured Наш мерч Navalny Shop: https://navalny.shop/ Слушайте нас в формате подкастов: https://band.link/PopularPolitics Важные ссылки: 🔹 Штабы Алексея Навального возобновляют свою работу! Заполните нашу анкету: https://shtab.navalny.com/ (из России доступ с VPN) 🔹 Наш Patreon, где вы можете поддержать любимую передачу: https://www.patreon.com/Popularpolitics 🔹 Помощь юристов и ответы на главные вопрос о мобилизации. Наш телеграм-канал: https://t.me/mobilizationnews 🔹 Станьте спонсором канала, и вы получите доступ к эксклюзивным бонусам: https://www.youtube.com/c/Popularpolitics/join 🔹 Приложение «Самиздат», где собраны все расследования про путинских жуликов. Для iOS — https://apps.apple.com/us/app/samizdat/id1609390951 Для Android — https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=com.unieditorsmobile&pli=1 🔹 Новости без цензуры: телеграм-канал «Сирена» https://t.me/news_sirena 🔹 Наш список разжигателей войны: https://acf.international/ru/list-of-war-enablers 🔹 Наш проект «Цены сегодня»: https://pricing.day/ 🔹 Отправьте в эфир стикер и задайте свой вопрос: https://friends.politica.media/ 🔹 Telegram-канал профсоюза «Промзона»: https://t.me/industrial_zone Бот для связи: https://t.me/zajava_bot Поддержите нашу работу! 🔸 Наш Patreon: https://www.patreon.com/Popularpolitics 🔸 Другие способы есть на сайте (в России открывается через VPN): https://donate.acf.international/ru ИНСТРУКЦИЯ, КАК ПОЛЬЗОВАТЬСЯ КРИПТОВАЛЮТОЙ. ВИДЕОВЕРСИЯ: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wX9Mu9lmL54 Текстовая инструкция: https://storage.googleapis.com/teamnavalny/btc-instruction.pdf 🔻 Bitcoin 3QzYvaRFY6bakFBW4YBRrzmwzTnfZcaA6E 🔻 Ethereum 0x314aC71aEB2feC4D60Cc50Eb46e64980a27F2680 🔻 Monero 42e1hkdsTHUUWSM24jVgLTH4MDJPMbNS1XDt7rK36dTBSKweohz9FSWKAAoqHLN9nSVgocnSnkR2AaLMWtsrmAoQGPdWSE1 🔻 Zcash (Z-адрес) zs1x0f6ccg9njmkahy03kup0fujdgp5pthv2nug7mwe0luj54mxal60ttym4aex3fnmj900yqtqcl5 🔻 USDT 0x9A4B20a7909Af03dd8B4f28A419840F9715E1F73 Подписывайтесь на нас в соцсетях! Телеграм: https://t.me/politica_media Инстаграм: https://www.facebook.com/unsupportedbrowser Твиттер: https://twitter.com/politica_media Пишите письма политзаключённым, чтобы поддержать их! — Юрий Жданов. 165115, Архангельская область, Вельский район, д. Горка-Муравьёвская, Спецгородок д.1 «А» ФКУ ИК-14 УФСИН России по Архангельской области, Жданову Юрию Павловичу, 1954 г.р. — Яшин Илья Валерьевич, 1983 г.р. Написать можно с помощью сервиса «ФСИН Письмо»: ФКУ СИЗО-2 УФСИН России по г. Москве. — Даниэль Холодный. 600020, ул. Большая Нижегородская д. 67, Владимирская область, г. Владимир, ФКУ Т-2 УФСИН, Холодному Даниэлю, 1997 г. р. — Лилия Чанышева. Адрес: 450015, г. Уфа, ул. Достоевского 39, ФКУ СИЗО-1 УФСИН России по РБ. Чанышева Лилия Айратовна, 1982 г.р. — Вадим Останин — экс-координатор Штаба Навального в Барнауле (Алтайский край) ФКУ Следственный изолятор №1 УФСИН России по Алтайскому краю; Адрес: 656021 г.Барнаул, пр-д Канатный, 81, Останину Вадиму Валерьевичу, 1976 г.р. Ещё больше адресов: https://rosuznik.org/#mail Таймкоды 00:00 Начало 01:00 Что делал Станислав Белковский в 1999 году? 06:45 Как Станислав Белковский относится к заявлениям о его причастности к взрывам домов в 1999-м? 09:11 Когда стало понятно, что Путин — это война? 12:24 Что происходит с Кадыровым? 16:51 Что будет с Чечнёй, если Кадыров умрёт? 18:56 Кто сейчас самый влиятельный в России? 23:04 Изменилась ли роль Путина после начала войны? 25:57 Про концепцию объединения Европы, США и России в «Единый Север» 27:53 Реагирует ли Путин на публикации Суркова? 29:15 О ситуации вокруг Варданяна 33:22 Отвернётся ли Армения от России? 36:07 Про связь Собчак и Кадырова 41:47 Как можно охарактеризовать Украину с политической точки зрения? 44:59 Освободилась ли Украина от влияния олигархов? 46:32 Про выборы в России в 2024 году
Preparing download options
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players
Questions about downloading video
How can I download "Белковский — Рязанский сахар, Путин в девяностые и главные кланы в России 🎙 Честное слово" video?
http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.
Which format of "Белковский — Рязанский сахар, Путин в девяностые и главные кланы в России 🎙 Честное слово" video should I choose?
The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.
Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Белковский — Рязанский сахар, Путин в девяностые и главные кланы в России 🎙 Честное слово" video?
The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.
How can I download "Белковский — Рязанский сахар, Путин в девяностые и главные кланы в России 🎙 Честное слово" video to my phone?
You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.
How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Белковский — Рязанский сахар, Путин в девяностые и главные кланы в России 🎙 Честное слово"?
The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.
How can I save a frame from a video "Белковский — Рязанский сахар, Путин в девяностые и главные кланы в России 🎙 Честное слово"?
This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.
What's the price of all this stuff?
It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.