Download "«Холодная гражданская война» в России. Евгений Чичваркин*: Особое мнение @totsamychichvarkin"
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FutbVQthcBck%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
Please wait. We're preparing links for easy ad-free video watching and downloading.
Table of contents
Similar videos from our catalog
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252Fvb3YGxvL_rQ%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FAkaXr_GWqRg%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
Video tags
Subtitles
Russian
00:00:23
[music]00:00:32
Hello This is a Youtube channel live00:00:34
nail microphone Lisa Anikino on the air00:00:36
program Special Opinion with his own special00:00:39
opinion guest today Evgeny00:00:40
Chichvarkin Hello Hello00:00:43
Evgeny You, even when Alexey Navalny00:00:46
made the decision to return to Russia, you00:00:49
dissuaded him, as far as I know, you00:00:50
even flew and met with him in Berlin00:00:52
in order to dissuade him from00:00:54
returning to his homeland why it’s bad,00:00:58
erase why then you thought that this was the00:01:01
only correct00:01:06
decision of history, I read a lot00:01:12
of all kinds of00:01:15
Russian state from the00:01:18
Russian state that we were lucky we had00:01:21
late Gorbachev Yeltsin and very early00:01:26
Putin,00:01:28
that’s00:01:30
all of us the mistakes of a survivor are00:01:34
simple. That is, you think that such an00:01:36
outcome, the death of Alexei Navalny, was00:01:41
inevitable. Why if Putin had died00:01:44
earlier, Putin’s00:01:46
trumpet would have really come off00:01:49
and some new government, roughly speaking,00:01:53
would have decided to flirt with the West for the sake of00:01:56
lifting sanctions, then maybe it didn’t00:01:58
happen00:02:01
Would it be clear to Putin himself that the chances00:02:03
had deteriorated greatly? When a00:02:05
full-scale war began, since00:02:09
everything that the West could use00:02:11
against Russia was what to exchange for and How to00:02:16
scare00:02:19
and how to rein in all the cartridges were used00:02:26
[music]00:02:28
Clearly, they turned out to be00:02:34
training pseudo thirteen packages of00:02:37
sanctions00:02:39
for which Putin and his entourage has fun00:02:42
wiping their asses when they go to their00:02:46
suitcases. But what about the conversation about the exchange00:02:49
that supposedly almost00:02:53
took place, look, I’m making you00:02:58
an offer, I like you very much.00:03:00
Let’s sleep, I’m a very good00:03:04
lover, I’m so clever,00:03:08
so experienced, so gentle, attentive00:03:12
I’m all this And you don’t00:03:14
answer And so the grin itself does00:03:20
n’t mean that we are in00:03:24
negotiations well and Putin After all, he himself00:03:26
said that I’m sorry for such mezot Well,00:03:30
that’s the very thing, but I don’t know how else to explain it,00:03:32
that is, it doesn’t mean that we’re in00:03:36
negotiations doesn’t mean anything at all00:03:39
And the fact that I’ve been sending hearts and love notes there for 2 years does00:03:44
n’t mean at all that00:03:46
we’re in negotiations00:03:48
at all because00:03:51
you’re generally in love with another person and00:03:56
And in general a different orientation, for example,00:03:59
and I’m not interesting in any way Well, that doesn’t00:04:05
mean that we are in negotiations But it00:04:07
seems to me that we are in negotiations and I’m about to be00:04:09
on friendly terms But this is not true at all and I00:04:13
certainly understand that if a team00:04:16
wants to succeed, the team must00:04:20
convince itself that this success00:04:23
is possible for me, a tired old man00:04:26
and00:04:28
grammatically,00:04:30
if they had asked the question00:04:32
there in November, is it possible to exchange Alexei00:04:36
Navalny, I would say that it is certainly00:04:37
not, but Putin made such a mistake00:04:43
by giving00:04:45
people to the West twice, this is Khodorkovsky and00:04:48
Navalny, when he was in a coma,00:04:51
of course the third time he will not00:04:54
come to the same place by creating for himself simply a monster00:04:58
who will immediately go00:05:00
and communicate differently with all00:05:02
world politicians, God forbid, and00:05:06
finish his studies with the advice of wise men who00:05:10
help with sanctions and, roughly00:05:15
speaking, with extensive political experience in the00:05:18
pre-election00:05:21
year, Aleksey Navalny, speaking00:05:26
in the00:05:28
British Parliament at the State Department00:05:31
and what we00:05:35
recommended00:05:37
doing00:05:39
would certainly be a huge,00:05:42
incomparable problem for00:05:44
Putin, why would this be a problem? It00:05:47
seems to me that the West has already spent00:05:49
quite a lot of resources, maybe00:05:51
imaginary resources, but nevertheless we have not produced00:05:54
any results on putting pressure on Russia We00:05:56
are seeing all these sanctions, all these00:05:58
threats,00:06:00
with the exception of some specific00:06:02
assistance to Ukraine. Well, if only there was a person who00:06:06
could correct them with00:06:17
support and followers, and so00:06:21
on, Navalny’s article Voskozhy00:06:28
de00:06:31
knew phenomenally well about Navalny00:06:33
because there was a lot of great great interest in this figure00:06:39
and the impact could00:06:43
have been on a fundamentally different00:06:47
scale, we will probably see this with00:06:51
Yulia. That is, you think that00:06:53
the question here, in the absence of some competent00:06:58
leadership, is that Western countries00:07:00
simply do not want to come to radical00:07:04
measures. Well, they at least should see an00:07:07
alternative, who if not Putin is who and00:07:11
here the alternative is absolutely clear00:07:14
a person about00:07:17
the West who respects Western00:07:19
legislation international00:07:22
law Why00:07:25
not Will he sell oil00:07:28
yoke of00:07:30
conditions Nava00:07:32
will Will Western companies00:07:35
work in Russia well successful profits00:07:38
will they be robbed No00:07:41
will there be wars No, it won’t Why00:07:46
not, it’s all a show, it would line up a00:07:51
fairly clear00:07:58
picture, pause for advertising, this is00:08:00
Evgeny Chichvarkin on the YouTube channel, a00:08:02
living nail, we’ll be back in a few00:08:05
[music]00:08:07
minutes Anton Pavlovich Chekhov was a man of00:08:10
great sense of humor, loved to joke and00:08:13
laugh. Here’s an example of dialogue from his00:08:16
play a wedding and in Greece you have tigers and00:08:20
there are lions and lions. In00:08:25
Russia there is nothing but in Greece there is everything and there are00:08:30
sperm whales in Greece there is everything and there are00:08:35
amaras in Greece there is everything there and there is a00:08:40
collegiate registrar Well, jokes00:08:44
aside and today in Greece there is even a00:08:46
golden visa, this is the most affordable00:08:48
program today. For the purchase of00:08:51
real estate in Europe, in order to obtain a00:08:53
residence permit for 5 years with the right of00:08:55
extension, you need to purchase real estate00:08:57
costing from00:08:59
euros, this can be an apartment in the00:09:02
city center on the seashore or even a small00:09:04
house on the islands, together with a residence permit, the investor00:09:07
receives huge opportunities that are so00:09:10
valuable in a period of geopolitical00:09:12
upheaval, this is the opportunity to move to00:09:15
sunny Greece or at least00:09:17
use the property as a00:09:19
summer residence, rent it out and earn00:09:21
income. Moreover, the status of a resident of Greece gives the00:09:25
right to travel around without restrictions For00:09:27
Schengen countries, the status of a00:09:29
residence permit in an EU country makes it00:09:32
possible to open accounts in00:09:33
European banks, unfreeze assets and00:09:36
overcome most international00:09:38
restrictions and prohibitions, among other things,00:09:40
Greece has a wonderful climate, sincerity and00:09:43
openness of the local population,00:09:45
cordiality, excellent higher education,00:09:48
universities and schools, medicine,00:09:51
infrastructure, rich culture and00:09:54
Heritage but at the same time, it is not at all necessary to live in00:09:56
Greece all the time;00:09:59
you can only enjoy the benefits of00:10:01
resident status and feel like a00:10:03
person of the world, wherever you are,00:10:06
there are two but but they can also be00:10:09
overcome; first over the past year, the00:10:12
golden visa program has attracted00:10:14
record investments into the country of about 700 million euros, the00:10:18
colossal demand has changed and the trends00:10:20
in the market the government has decided to00:10:23
change the program and very soon the threshold00:10:25
for purchasing real estate will not be00:10:27
250,000 euros but 500,000 or even00:10:31
800,000 now the increased tariff is already in00:10:34
effect in the largest00:10:35
municipalities Although there00:10:38
are still small but colorful00:10:39
ports near Athens cities by the sea where the entry threshold00:10:42
has remained the same date of change has not yet been00:10:44
established, which means there is still time to00:10:47
take advantage of attractive00:10:49
conditions; the program also has00:10:51
restrictions for participation; the main00:10:53
applicant, that is, the investor must have an00:10:55
additional passport in addition to the00:10:57
Russian one, for example, Armenia Israel00:11:00
Vanuatu Turkey does not matter now and this can00:11:03
be overcome obstacle And regarding this00:11:06
and other questions, contact Kans00:11:09
company, which has been00:11:12
engaged in residence permit and citizenship00:11:14
by investment programs around the world for more than 30 years, specialists will00:11:17
answer all questions and guide you from00:11:20
choosing real estate to obtaining00:11:22
documents link as usual in00:11:25
[music]00:11:27
description of a living nail you talked about an00:11:30
alternative to Putin, do you think that Yulia00:11:33
Navalnaya can become such an00:11:34
alternative in the eyes of the Western part00:11:37
of the world, you know, in 1918, 600:11:42
years00:11:44
ago, I wrote that this is in open00:11:47
sources, that if her name is on00:11:50
the ballot, then she will support Putin even00:11:56
then I’m like that like this is a very very strong00:12:00
woman Very charismatic very00:12:03
consistent for00:12:05
many woman she is absolutely she is more of a00:12:09
role model than even00:12:13
Alexey Well, it’s really simple I don’t even00:12:18
see him over not00:12:23
Sometimes I treat her very well00:12:25
pain Uva ve she’s a wife even if00:12:31
you’re not into me please aggression in00:12:33
Russia It seems to me that society, especially in00:12:36
recent years, has slipped into these very00:12:38
traditional values, a significant00:12:40
part of it is going to vote for a woman who00:12:42
will lead00:12:44
the country. Well, they tried it on, but they were scared,00:12:49
they took it off. And for a woman, there are just00:12:52
more women. Thank you to Putin for00:12:57
this, uh, I’ll say so gloomily that because00:13:03
someone00:13:04
remained in the land of Donbass, someone is00:13:07
relocating00:13:09
and someone will have nothing to even00:13:13
check00:13:14
a box with, so women00:13:17
would come to vote and they would come00:13:20
disciplined all together from small to00:13:22
large and their majority is even if by00:13:25
gender sign of division, she would00:13:28
have won.00:13:30
Well, the question is, were you ready00:13:32
because peace, calm, creation is what00:13:36
Russia needs because Russia is tired of00:13:41
tanks of missiles and the constant inflation of00:13:43
cheeks and waving a nuclear rod 24 by 700:13:49
from any00:13:52
iron, probably in order to become such a00:13:55
single leader00:13:57
of the opposition in the West you need to offer00:14:00
some specific ideas, some00:14:02
specific program or to catch your breath,00:14:06
he will suggest, what do you think, is it possible that the fakes00:14:08
that we have now seen concerning Yulia00:14:10
Navalnaya, including those concerning you,00:14:13
too, should be considered a sign of fear in the00:14:17
Kremlin? Well, they will try, since the pain is trying to show her00:14:21
absolutely nothing00:14:24
to stain it with what they00:14:27
themselves are wearing,00:14:31
returning to the exchange of Krasik,00:14:33
isn’t Krasik a figure whom00:14:35
Putin would like to return to Russia enough in the world00:14:38
to offer one00:14:40
of the political prisoners in return Putin certainly wants to00:14:43
return him, he00:14:45
told00:14:48
Carlson about this until Carlson flew away but00:14:51
promised00:14:53
return most likely American sweat00:14:56
someone from00:14:57
behind will get someone from his own00:15:00
Natasha Closer to the body therefore Why00:15:03
imprison Rossi Well, there are also watered00:15:07
prisoners with citizenship of Western00:15:09
countries Well, this is no one Coke if there is00:15:13
also a00:15:14
Russian one convicted in the original00:15:18
country00:15:20
if These people00:15:24
surrendered their00:15:27
citizenship,00:15:29
that would be one thing, but it doesn’t work in00:15:32
this00:15:33
direction, why do you think they allowed an00:15:36
open funeral for Alexei Navalny and00:15:38
even allowed them to come to this funeral and00:15:41
lay flowers at this00:15:43
funeral because they were sure that00:15:47
they were so intimidated that few people would come and00:15:51
we saw that00:15:53
in the city where the city lives and around 15 million00:16:00
Moscow in the rubber city, a00:16:03
number of people came who, after00:16:06
all, the cemetery was able to accept, albeit for many00:16:09
hours, but somehow relatively speaking00:16:13
Well, for several days a huge number of00:16:16
people were afraid to come, but it was not00:16:20
similar to I don’t know 200,000 on Bolotnaya00:16:23
Despite the fact that this required a completely different00:16:26
degree of courage from people than00:16:30
going out to Bolotnaya And00:16:33
then they grazed on Bolotnaya What a great fellow and brave he is,00:16:36
how he looks to the west,00:16:39
thinks alternatively And this is all cool and great and00:16:42
then let’s go drink a pumpkin lot or whatever00:16:46
they drink in Moscow,00:16:48
and here,00:16:51
uh, these same people will be slowly00:16:55
imprisoned and kicked out of work who were there,00:16:59
who got caught, and people will be Well, there will simply00:17:02
be a department that will consistently00:17:06
deal with repressions against these00:17:08
people and then those who voted for00:17:13
collected signatures for hopes, too And those00:17:17
who will come to the elections at00:17:20
noon, too, if someone is active,00:17:23
someone in favor will definitely be removed,00:17:27
well, they can then simply postpone it and until00:17:31
everyone gets their hands on it, it just looked like the00:17:34
most active ones then less00:17:38
active, it looked very surprising.00:17:40
On the one hand, a00:17:42
lot of people really came, this is a gigantic00:17:44
queue, a very dense crowd, and on the other00:17:46
hand, people shouted slogans; they weren’t hit by00:17:49
valves; they weren’t taken away; that day,00:17:52
as far as I remember, there were only a few00:17:53
arrests; just people from the queue00:17:56
no one should00:17:57
pull it out.00:17:59
This is some kind of oxymoron for our times. Yes,00:18:02
yes, there is a certain kind of fear of God00:18:07
among a certain kind of strange variety among00:18:12
the authorities. If you remember the uncoordinated00:18:15
march around the Kremlin of 60,000 people when00:18:19
Nemtsov was killed, don’t pull it out either;00:18:22
snipers were sitting, calling, smoking on the roof of00:18:27
the Kremlin.00:18:29
That is, you think this is connected with00:18:30
some kind of superstitious fear of00:18:32
funerals before00:18:34
death. It seems to me that well, apart from completely00:18:38
frostbitten people in the Kremlin, there are many00:18:40
quite God-fearing people and for many00:18:43
these rituals have a sacred00:18:47
meaning;00:18:49
unexpectedly, I will assume00:18:57
because the relationship with death and00:19:01
with the veneration of the00:19:05
dead of most people certainly00:19:08
works Orthodox00:19:11
doctrines And you don’t connect this with the upcoming elections,00:19:17
no,00:19:19
but the choice doesn’t00:19:23
affect anything if they were the first to beat Delhi,00:19:27
several times fewer people would have come,00:19:32
but they probably weren’t here, there was probably00:19:37
more fear of the Western press because00:19:40
Navalny’s coffin was absolutely everywhere in00:19:43
every newspaper in all the news And if00:19:46
the authorities there showed cruelty,00:19:50
then they would rinse again00:19:55
and and probably To avoid this, they00:20:00
still live in a picture when the pictures00:20:03
No, they don’t give away the body Well, there’s no picture, but00:20:07
here there is a00:20:08
picture I think this is one of00:20:12
those in including a pragmatic00:20:15
relationship, well, plus00:20:18
probably the cops who are happy to00:20:21
beat and00:20:24
[music]00:20:27
PTA00:20:33
money no matter what the price is. A00:20:36
person who has gone down the drain. He is also the Armed Forces, and in the same environment00:20:41
he understands that from him, the lower your00:20:44
education, the more understanding that you are00:20:46
in a tough environment where nothing depends on you,00:20:48
it’s a direct path to piety,00:20:57
go get things done, and here, it’s like00:21:01
a cemetery, it’s kind of bad And when they00:21:06
wash the girls’ hands00:21:09
Nigo Well, there was no order Yes, I00:21:12
think that’s the main thing, not that they have00:21:13
something there... then it seems they still have00:21:15
piety and00:21:16
humanity. I think that they didn’t want the00:21:21
West to have this picture again00:21:27
showing everything00:21:28
good, the Armed Forces, it00:21:32
seems to me that there are some other Armed Forces there,00:21:35
often I don’t00:21:38
know, I don’t know, it’s hard to get into Putin’s00:21:42
head, it’s better to do it with the help of a00:21:45
hammer I and not so Umari I just00:21:49
can’t imagine that after the start of00:21:51
the war it wouldn’t be attack by00:21:53
Atan of course Thanks for the clarification I00:21:57
can’t imagine00:22:00
Poti we see from Ukraine and nie for retin with00:22:04
Navalny the West is already all the West is far away his00:22:06
opinion doesn’t00:22:10
matter and yes and suddenly no00:22:13
convoy that they’ve been vegetable for so many years Well,00:22:17
I don’t know, they’ll come up with really00:22:19
real sanctions And not this Armed Forces Well, in00:22:22
a year they haven’t come up with it, it will sound very much neither the00:22:25
maximum00:22:26
nor00:22:28
the life of one Russian oppositionist00:22:30
against the heap of life of civilians in00:22:32
Ukraine00:22:34
nothing nothing but it is one way or another00:22:38
influenced and the news background was absolutely00:22:43
overwhelmed by the number of people00:22:45
who00:22:48
expressed condolences to me,00:22:52
I was simply absolutely amazed, absolutely00:22:55
amazed by the number of Ukrainians and the00:22:59
number of Englishmen, I don’t even know what00:23:00
struck me00:23:04
more Vladimir Pastukhov called what00:23:06
was happening in Russia queues for Boris00:23:08
Nadezhdin queues to Navalny’s grave00:23:12
people who bring flowers to a00:23:14
memorial to the victims of political00:23:15
repression during the Cold Civil War00:23:17
How far do you agree with this00:23:22
definition? Well,00:23:26
probably.00:23:29
Probably it can be interpreted this way. I00:23:32
said that this is the last legal00:23:37
protest as far as there is; there will be no00:23:40
more of them;00:23:46
that it will be possible00:23:49
legally in the amount of dozens of items00:23:54
[music]00:23:56
forehead to publicly demonstrate unity00:24:00
against the general line of the party I can’t00:24:03
imagine such an event Well, also00:24:08
the names of some very famous people I00:24:11
just don’t want to make a rumor00:24:14
because Well, somehow00:24:17
I just don’t know if there is this is an acute, albeit00:24:21
hidden, confrontation, there is a feeling that00:24:24
some kind of global feeling of00:24:26
hopelessness has gripped those who live in Russia,00:24:29
we can talk about a civil war where there is00:24:35
apathy As long as there is something to eat,00:24:39
no as long as the refrigerator is full No, of course, just00:24:42
like the Civil War, a civil00:24:45
war on a full stomach00:24:51
There are no nations, they did00:24:56
nothing,00:24:58
nations were against the Russians in many ways, but00:25:01
they were against those Russians who did00:25:03
n’t like it there and00:25:06
left,00:25:08
but against it, I felt a bunch of crap on myself,00:25:14
at some point I’ll00:25:16
just sit down with good lawyers and write00:25:19
about this in00:25:21
English so that it would be good00:25:26
ANS00:25:28
and those who live there, well, BC is cool for them00:25:33
On the contrary No Ikea you can make furniture00:25:37
Netch you can fry burgers There is nothing else00:25:41
Flax is still there00:25:44
by the way,00:25:46
no there is not yet I don’t00:25:49
know something can be done no films,00:25:52
you can00:25:56
pack00:25:58
or that ordinary people feel good,00:26:01
very entrepreneurs What does it mean to00:26:03
feel good financially comfortable Yes,00:26:07
many entrepreneurs are financially00:26:09
comfortable If you are not connected with Western00:26:12
contracts Well, even those who are connected with00:26:15
Western contracts have slowly00:26:16
moved to Eastern contracts,00:26:23
too near death, in any00:26:27
case, some of my00:26:30
friends, to varying degrees, some have the00:26:33
best 2 years of their entire00:26:37
career, some have the worst,00:26:39
but all their assets00:26:43
are alive Yes, but there is also a constant feeling00:26:46
that your business can be squeezed out of your business at any00:26:48
moment if it becomes enough00:26:50
interesting And every entrepreneur has had this feeling for a very00:26:53
long time,00:26:56
even the same security officer who sits00:26:59
in his liver of whim and extorts that this00:27:03
will save Him. It’s good if this feeling has been there00:27:06
for many years, if people00:27:09
Yes, it’s good for them. Still a plus- minus00:27:11
full refrigerators, but the refrigerators are getting00:27:14
thinner and thinner because the prices are00:27:15
growing and rising No, the refrigerators are not00:27:18
losing weight, there was stress there in the spring of twenty-00:27:22
two there was stress when the exchange rate went up,00:27:25
something else happened now, everything00:27:29
seems to me plus or minus nothing Well, eggs have become more expensive00:27:31
Well listen I go to stores I00:27:33
really don’t like the prices But I can’t00:27:35
say that my salary is like that of00:27:37
some nurse from Chelyabinsk00:27:41
7,000 I think that there are no such salaries,00:27:44
let’s not00:27:46
be like her, if her salary is 7,00000:27:49
then there is a lot more of everything and this and that00:27:52
there is still less than 20 something. It00:27:55
seems to me that there is no and and If you go to00:27:59
all sorts of hard00:28:00
discount stores00:28:04
you eat and00:28:08
get dressed 2 years have passed since the beginning of the war,00:28:11
more than two years have passed What are the feelings from00:28:14
these two past years in in terms of00:28:16
changes inside Russia and probably00:28:19
outside Russia, but in relation to what00:28:21
is happening in00:28:26
Ukraine,00:28:28
the feeling is00:28:31
that the chance that Ukraine00:28:35
has lost these territories for at least a long time,00:28:38
unfortunately, is increasing because Ukraine is00:28:42
not being helped as promised,00:28:45
and the Russian army is00:28:52
paying with the lives of soldiers with the lives of00:28:56
st. is gradually learning to00:29:00
fight Why don’t they help to the required00:29:04
extent? Out of fear, everyone is afraid00:29:09
to anger Putin, he’s waving a nuclear00:29:13
club, so they’re trying to calm him down on00:29:17
the line that there00:29:21
are Russian oppositionists00:29:23
abroad, how much more00:29:25
effective has their work become? It’s00:29:27
more effective in general, what can be00:29:28
done00:29:30
now? You know, It all depends on the words00:29:34
he uttered were00:29:38
picked up like I don’t know by Lenin. But00:29:43
can all this be thrown into emptiness, in any case,00:29:47
you can read here write to speak00:29:49
if someone00:29:52
needs you in Russia you can’t already be an00:29:55
oppositionist or Roma in prison Even those00:29:58
who now go uh and continue to00:30:02
support the memorial Nemtsova at some00:30:04
point will either squeeze them out or transplant00:30:08
nothing, it seems to me that these are just the00:30:11
last months when it’s all00:30:14
relatively somehow legal Do you have00:30:17
an understanding of why00:30:19
neither Lenin nor Trotsky has yet emerged among the00:30:21
Russian00:30:23
oppositionists, you know uh 900 uh00:30:28
second third fourth fifth sixth00:30:32
other years Well, maybe fifth or sixth,00:30:34
no, but before the revolution and after,00:30:39
absolutely no one knew who they were,00:30:44
and they sat,00:30:47
corresponded, studied meanings,00:30:51
went to party congresses, argued, wrote, wrote, wrote, wrote,00:30:58
selected meanings, selected00:31:01
words, wrote a lot read a lot, argued a lot,00:31:07
discussed a lot, they jumped out like a Royal00:31:10
art at the last moment,00:31:13
practically well, historically, it was the00:31:15
last moment, so maybe there is, it00:31:19
means we just don’t know with00:31:22
you,00:31:26
maybe it’s broadcasting,00:31:28
does this mean that until00:31:30
some necessary moment comes, changes will not00:31:32
happen, as it were they didn’t try to be00:31:34
in opposition, definitely definitely, the00:31:37
military defeat of 904 or the military00:31:42
failures of00:31:43
96 definitely created a revolutionary00:31:48
situation. It’s just that I see the military defeat in00:31:55
Afghanistan, it seems to me that it’s been a00:31:57
year since posts on social networks on00:32:00
March 5, everyone is hoping for whose nay Stokes already00:32:04
now in our time, as if00:32:06
there is no hope for anything else anymore, as if00:32:08
only the Lord’s will can00:32:10
change the situation in Russia. I’ve [ __ ] everyone up and have00:32:13
n’t00:32:16
forgotten myself. Can we say that Putin00:32:23
at this stage has achieved his goal? Yes At this stage, Putin has certainly00:32:26
achieved his goal. He wanted to achieve more,00:32:29
but he achieved absolutely enough more00:32:32
than enough That selling for00:32:36
victory is what exactly Putin wanted to achieve00:32:38
You have such an00:32:42
understanding It’s clear that it’s not00:32:45
denazification of00:32:47
Nikolaev00:32:49
Odessa, that is, purely Dnieper,00:32:54
and I admit that Kiev too, that is, with00:32:58
such a fat crescent, half00:33:02
the country is gone. That’s00:33:04
what clean territory cannot be brought in Chaos in00:33:09
world politics does not elevate Russia,00:33:11
raise it from its knees, just wring out00:33:13
territories for itself, wring out territories, get00:33:17
people's love forever as a strong00:33:21
leader of the00:33:25
Russians. At the beginning of the war, this is not the first time they organized a00:33:28
charity dinner.00:33:31
How much was collected and is it possible00:33:32
to trace how these fees change over time00:33:36
in last year00:33:39
470,000 this year For 2 seconds of conditional00:33:43
lunch 13000:33:46
And since there were several more00:33:49
emotional payments, the00:33:51
end result looks like the following 90-00:33:55
odd thousand00:33:59
euros, medicines will arrive in Ukraine in a few00:34:02
days and I hope I’ll be driving00:34:05
this little00:34:07
truck in a couple weeks, a00:34:12
very complex apparatus will be installed in the Lviv perinatal center00:34:15
to detect pathology and00:34:18
save the smallest little00:34:21
babies. And they can take on00:34:27
childbirth when a person is too small, well,00:34:31
literally conditionally, 500-something grams00:34:37
can become for00:34:39
Lviv a kind of survival rate for a00:34:45
newborn here such two00:34:48
initiatives have all gone away in our00:34:51
last00:34:57
month, 10 times less than last year, and00:35:00
I wouldn’t like to say that these are00:35:04
the last. But apparently everything is going to a00:35:08
logical conclusion, since I have00:35:10
mostly Russians00:35:12
and00:35:13
no one has already gone bankrupt who were finished off by00:35:19
these idiots in the banks and00:35:25
regs,00:35:29
who thought that the Mission was accomplished, and so00:35:31
on. That00:35:35
is, maybe our trip, which00:35:40
will take place the other day, will00:35:44
somehow encourage more people to do good00:35:48
deeds,00:35:50
but I’m already somehow especially00:35:55
Nest from the fact that it has been reduced so much00:36:00
help disappointment in someone disappointment00:36:04
in some kind of social wave if00:36:06
at first everyone was burning with enthusiasm Everyone00:36:08
wanted to help then everyone has waves,00:36:11
absolutely all waves are subject to the wave00:36:15
theory Well, that is, you think that this is00:36:18
just a natural stage of chaos00:36:23
is if we talk about states, rates00:36:27
from states too far from being as00:36:31
spectacular and effective as they were at the beginning of00:36:34
the war, as if everything had not been00:36:37
won quickly, but now we will do it00:36:38
little by little because we cannot refuse00:36:40
But we don’t want to invest too much in it00:36:43
Well, you00:36:45
answered it yourself, you yourself in the end I have nothing to00:36:48
add so it00:36:50
is, but isn’t there a feeling that the00:36:54
Western elites wouldn’t mind00:36:55
continuing and then they looked when00:36:58
Prigozhin went to Moscow and they imagined that00:37:01
that’s all there was still a civil war and00:37:05
some fainting people were going around and someone00:37:10
would seize some a nuclear power plant00:37:12
or a missile launcher and [ __ ]00:37:16
it, let this Putin be00:37:19
better than anyone else. Clearly evil and he is00:37:22
incomprehensibly evil because he is a changing00:37:25
evil. And so he is temporary and looks at everything00:37:29
absolutely in such a slice of time in how00:37:34
I don’t know, a00:37:38
Polaroid photo, then he It seems to them that he is understandably00:37:42
evil. Because when he is already in a big00:37:45
war, they will no longer be taken over and they will already have00:37:50
them. The cycle will00:37:53
end. The other side of democracy, do you00:37:57
think they would now like to00:37:59
make peace with Putin, leave him00:38:02
what he has already captured in Ukraine and just00:38:04
more than everyone else? many people shouldn’t00:38:06
do this, yes00:38:08
many many people, yes, it seems to me that it00:38:12
would be calmer for everyone,00:38:15
many people. They don’t understand that Putin00:38:18
cannot stay. Putin can00:38:20
exist in the regime of a00:38:23
free00:38:25
state only by transferring00:38:29
everything to a war footing, and00:38:32
under this sauce, stealing freedom from00:38:36
property is all that they ca00:38:39
n’t switch to a peaceful mode anyway,00:38:42
and they will never be able to again as long as00:38:45
Putin is alive, there will be00:38:47
war, and why don’t they understand this?00:38:49
Are there really no people who can00:38:51
explain this to them? You never know, there are people from Russia, and that00:38:55
is, this is how it works, you00:38:57
don’t need to think that here in the West,00:39:00
some intellectuals are going into politics. Well,00:39:03
somehow they are00:39:05
elected. Well, they are chosen if they choose from you,00:39:09
roughly speaking, if 20% of the00:39:12
population there in some country do not work,00:39:14
they live on begging for help and other things,00:39:18
who they choose, who will be next for them00:39:20
promise that they will have social00:39:23
payments for nothing And in case of Covid, there00:39:27
will be nothing to do, nothing will be done,00:39:29
it will just be00:39:30
helicopter00:39:32
money that will fly in,00:39:37
they have no will, and in the elections, they are most afraid of00:39:41
responsibility00:39:44
anno does not00:39:45
come what kind of responsibility will there be a00:39:48
big war, it is his fault and if they00:39:53
give ses or I don’t know something else,00:40:01
and like the entrance prayer from the Crimean bridge, a00:40:06
bus with children falls, here they will00:40:09
certainly show it and fly for00:40:13
it here00:40:16
somewhere in the west Well, you mean from00:40:19
citizens or maybe to be from colleagues00:40:22
and blow it away once again00:40:30
weak-willed people are not very smart00:40:33
weak-willed with short thoughts like00:40:38
Pinocchio that there is a00:40:41
phenomenal here This is the Form of democracy that00:40:44
you can have different opinions that you can00:40:47
look whatever you like marry even three of you00:40:50
even on a stool this is00:40:55
also populism populism00:40:58
basically Well somewhere then there are smart00:41:01
politicians or is it an00:41:03
oxymoron there is in the Emirates Sheikh Mohammed00:41:06
Bin Rashid00:41:08
al-Maktoum it seems they didn’t00:41:10
choose him Yes,00:41:13
he’s just lucky in this country with his family00:41:17
like no one else00:41:19
I want more about the presidential elections00:41:22
in Russia You said that it doesn’t00:41:24
matter at all But then it’s not clear00:41:26
why so much effort is directed at them00:41:28
and Putin somehow started showing off his uniform in front of the camera00:41:30
and showing off the00:41:32
exhibition - this is unfortunate Russia and00:41:34
this dregs with candidates who will00:41:38
compete in the ballot Why if it does00:41:41
n’t matter at all Well,00:41:43
in the Potemkin village, they really love00:41:46
these rituals,00:41:52
uh, that’s00:41:55
How00:41:59
to say Well, I’ve already said it many times,00:42:03
here’s how they came to shoot you in three past seven,00:42:06
you should have the Armed Forces according to the00:42:09
recording form, the commas are correct everywhere, all the columns00:42:12
must be filled in, they made a mistake in the00:42:15
surname and rewrite it they can’t, it’s not on00:42:18
this day that they’ll shoot you,00:42:27
people left, they found00:42:29
mistakes in the documents, they left in their hearts, they00:42:33
never came again. And00:42:35
if they took them away, they’d shoot them; the plan is that the00:42:39
Chekists’ passion for some kind of fulfillment00:42:43
of formal, these legal requirements is00:42:47
such that it’s all within the bounds of00:42:55
the law they have this kind of00:42:58
strange feature of the security service, which is why,00:43:01
as it seems to them, in the eyes of the whole00:43:05
world, these will be00:43:06
legal elections,00:43:08
absolutely00:43:11
legitimate, for this, for this, there are00:43:13
these all sorts of00:43:19
davankovs, this whole00:43:22
performance00:43:25
is being played out, but they themselves are constantly00:43:27
bypassing laws and constantly don’t even00:43:29
try to formally comply with them00:43:31
during various trials,00:43:33
for example,00:43:35
they try, they just00:43:38
quickly change this law to suit themselves, but it didn’t00:43:41
work. They robbed Akunin, so00:43:44
they changed the law in order to rob them. Well, why don’t00:43:47
they have enough money? No, it’s not about the00:43:50
money, it’s00:43:53
in order to get more money,00:43:56
he also wants to be on the bright side and00:44:02
continue to earn money in Russia that00:44:04
he changed his mind and didn’t do that anymore00:44:08
in public, they punished him so that others would be00:44:11
disgraced, it00:44:12
seems to me that those who are serious00:44:15
Fun because, according to the new law of00:44:19
foreign agents, it was lower in Russia, it00:44:25
was possible to receive income00:44:28
then you can no longer receive income now you00:44:32
can’t print, they will continue to burn books,00:44:34
they will continue to burn authors, we are still on the00:44:38
third step, but the fight against foreign agents00:44:41
turns out to be quite pointless00:44:43
in Russia, they stayed and continue to receive00:44:46
income, closed the canal, she already said that she00:44:49
will continue to work, but that’s not the00:44:52
point here. ma00:44:58
mug with some kind of00:45:00
smear and they are just very careful It00:45:04
seems to me, well, firstly, there will be more of them00:45:07
every Friday, only the sun sets,00:45:11
and secondly, it seems to me that they will be deprived of them. They will00:45:15
continue to deprive everyone of all opportunities00:45:18
so that people will be afraid that00:45:24
they are00:45:27
needed by this engage in your00:45:29
opinion Out of respect00:45:31
for the last will of Alexei Yes, this needs to be00:45:36
done one last time, there is no need to00:45:38
play anything legally with this state anymore.00:45:40
I have always been00:45:44
very careful about smart00:45:47
voting for many, many years, but once a three-hour00:45:50
whitening of the woks was lost after00:45:54
a certain mathematician and God forgive00:45:58
the communist, well, we know that Labano00:46:04
ruined his career, broke his house, I don’t00:46:07
know where and how he is now, but it seems to me00:46:11
that00:46:12
this was a smart vote, and once again00:46:17
showed many who were00:46:20
watching this, the authorities00:46:24
are [ __ ]. Well, again, I do00:46:30
n’t know what will this00:46:33
lead to, that is, it’s worth it and we00:46:37
need to leave? Yes, it seems we already came to this00:46:40
in our last conversation with you on a00:46:42
living nail. But you will see00:46:45
after the inauguration that I was right in00:46:48
relation to very bright people with a conscience, and00:46:52
even roughly00:46:54
speaking, just from a different position you and I00:46:58
will be witnesses when the state00:47:02
makes the next round and no one will00:47:04
see it or understand it, but quietly this corkscrew00:47:10
is screwing deeper into the swamp00:47:14
And people don’t always understand that00:47:18
they wake up on the00:47:20
next step, not even on the next one,00:47:24
but levels of hell, but just on the next one00:47:27
steps and what was possible yesterday is00:47:30
no longer possible today, and the fact that it cannot be00:47:33
understood by the first arrests or bans00:47:36
or something else00:47:38
We, it seems, without any elections We walk along00:47:41
this ladder and find ourselves constantly on the00:47:43
next step Well, what will change00:47:45
then after the inauguration Let's forecast00:47:47
our inauguration will be very soon00:47:49
how much time should pass after the elections00:47:51
elections on March 17 I don’t remember what the00:47:54
date is but the inauguration will be soon00:47:55
Let’s check Let’s check it00:47:59
will be quiet in the summer I don’t know my expectation00:48:03
that many people whom we know00:48:06
as decent and cool ones will either leave00:48:10
or go to prison No one who can00:48:14
go so calmly to Chechnya00:48:17
to deal with the problem of gays or00:48:21
the kidnapping of relatives or blood00:48:23
feud No one who, whether00:48:27
you have a Nobel Prize or twenty-00:48:31
eight years of00:48:33
experience working for00:48:36
Gazprommedia, nothing will00:48:39
help, nothing will help, the choice will be00:48:44
jail or leave and now he’s00:48:47
standing there, if you’re an MR of a big city, behold,00:48:57
if you’re a great writer or singer00:49:01
who only00:49:04
gave hints to understand00:49:06
that it will be necessary, either you sit down,00:49:10
everything goes further into fascism, into deep00:49:14
terry fascism, it will accelerate00:49:20
if it00:49:24
accelerates00:49:27
if00:49:29
economic greetings will fly in.00:49:32
What eggs will become more expensive, it will also00:49:35
accelerate if00:49:37
the West increases pressure,00:49:42
and it won’t be so fast if Putin00:49:46
continues to00:49:48
take away village after village and learns to00:49:53
drive tankers in even faster and with a00:49:56
smaller00:49:57
discount Well, this is how it goes I just don’t00:50:00
understand What does the inauguration have to do with it this is all00:50:02
tied absolutely not to the presidential00:50:04
elections but to the processes that already00:50:06
exist. But nevertheless, the picture is00:50:10
the picture. It’s good if everyone comes out at00:50:13
noon against Putin, votes against00:50:15
Putin and the elite. Well, good, a lot of people. Well,00:50:19
people can’t condemn people; they’ll be00:50:22
beaten if there will be00:50:24
a lot of them, if anything, and they will shoot, people00:50:28
understand this, they feel00:50:30
it with optimism, and through the00:50:33
screen I’m talking about something else. It’s good to see in the00:50:36
ballots that many people, not at noon00:50:38
at other times, do not vote for Putin, for00:50:40
other people, there won’t be any here00:50:43
-won’t the elites say change? Putin, you’re00:50:45
doing something wrong. Which elites? Well, who’s00:50:48
there besides Putin? Are there some00:50:50
influential people with00:50:52
money? All the elites. All the elites were at the00:50:55
congress on agents in the00:50:59
world, with the exception of a few people at the00:51:02
congress. the agents were all the elites, the elites were00:51:05
all scattered, they left. Like in the00:51:08
seventeenth, it’s not the elites, it’s a swarm around the00:51:12
queen bee, that is, Putin rules, Putin00:51:14
makes a decision, Putin makes a decision, and no one00:51:16
orders him, there can’t be any coalitions.00:51:19
Why can he advise? I don’t know,00:51:21
Patrushev,00:51:22
or00:51:24
probably00:51:26
there’s a conditional one there. Naryshkin00:51:28
probably00:51:29
can if there is00:51:33
some significant advice, probably the00:51:36
Kovalchuks can advise him or00:51:39
influence the decision in some way,00:51:41
maybe the00:51:45
confessor can say Don’t be afraid of the00:51:47
bombs,00:51:56
but maybe they’re not elites, they’re just a pack of00:51:59
old dogs. this00:52:02
is a pack of all these confessors of00:52:06
Patrushev, they cannot unite and00:52:11
cannot unite with anyone, he00:52:12
carries out orders, he just00:52:15
cannot advise anything, he receives an order00:52:17
and tries00:52:19
to follow him like his00:52:26
elders, these are ghouls, and for them00:52:30
isolation is a special way to00:52:34
threaten to the Swedes00:52:37
and show the mother to the [ __ ]00:52:41
and wave a nuclear00:52:45
dick because00:52:54
no one needs their own anymore. Fence them with a fence because of the00:52:58
fence. They will throw wads of money at us00:53:00
for oil and gas. We will carry this oil and gas through a hole in the fence.00:53:03
And here00:53:05
we will do what we want And if00:53:08
we like the neighboring Earth, we’ll take it00:53:11
because it’s historically ours, like the00:53:14
whole Baltic, like Kazakhstan, like everyone else,00:53:18
if you don’t stop him, he’ll go further00:53:20
Poland was also ours, such a country was00:53:24
screwed up. It was a very positive broadcast, a00:53:27
very positive Special opinion from00:53:29
Evgenia Chichvarkina Subscribe,00:53:31
like and don’t go far yet00:53:33
firstly, I want to tell you about the00:53:35
book that is on shd Media, this is00:53:38
military rhetoric of the Second World War, what00:53:41
language was used by different countries during00:53:43
this period, how they communicated with their00:53:45
citizens, how they spoke about their00:53:47
enemies, how in principle, this00:53:49
speech institute worked. It’s quite interesting,00:53:51
I’ve already ordered one for myself. And I advise you too.00:53:54
And of course, the comic book to save00:53:56
Princess Cockroach, definitely don’t00:53:58
pass it by by March 8th, it will be a wonderful00:54:00
gift, it’s more life-affirming than00:54:03
talking about modernity, because the00:54:05
Cockroach’s book is all- they do save And00:54:07
how exactly they save You can find out from this00:54:09
comic, well, after our broadcast there00:54:11
will be a program with Sergei Aleksashenko00:54:13
the price of the issue so I’ll stay with you00:54:15
for another hour and at 900 a program of 6900:54:19
minutes with Oleg Kashin and Lisa Lazerson00:54:22
Youtube channel living00:54:24
nail copper and Telegram channel living00:54:27
nail - these are the places where you can00:54:28
find our broadcasts, find information, find00:54:31
products through which you can00:54:32
support our work and Thank you very much00:54:34
for being with us. All the best, forgot that00:54:37
same00:54:38
Chichvarkin, my Instagram and for00:54:42
some reason you are on the Telegram channel you haven’t written anything for a long time00:54:43
Well somehow the Telegram channel00:54:46
turned out to be not mine I operate with visual images00:54:50
on00:54:54
Instagram Subscribe and Well00:54:58
maybe Aleksashenko will make you laugh now00:55:00
e Instagram is considered00:55:03
extremist banned in Russia and that’s00:55:06
all But you still go and00:55:08
Subscribe everyoneDescription:
Сегодня в прямом эфире своё Особое мнение представляет предприниматель Евгений Чичваркин* @totsamychichvarkin. Ведущая: Лиза Аникина. Узнайте больше о «золотой визе» Греции у экспертов Astons: https://www.astons.com/ru/residency-by-investment/greece/ Поддержать Живой гвоздь: с карт российских банков https://pay.cloudtips.ru/p/7edd7c0e с карт иностранных банков https://www.donationalerts.com/r/zhivgvozd Boosty: https://boosty.to/zhivoygvozd Криптокошелёк: bc1qmdt96xvsun9a8qxvgakfx9gqy4x72penx5rm2p Trust Wallet: https://link.trustwallet.com/send?address=bc1qmdt96xvsun9a8qxvgakfx9gqy4x72penx5rm2p&asset=c0 0:00 — Начало эфира 0:45 — Можно ли осуждать решение Алексея Навального** вернуться в Россию? 8:00 — Реклама 11:30 — Юлия Навальная — альтернатива нынешней власти? 15:45 — Будут ли силовики преследовать тех, кто пришел на прощание с Навальным**? 23:10 — «Холодная гражданская война» в России 28:10 — 2 года с начала СВО. Что изменилось? 29:23 — Стала ли эффективнее работа российских оппозиционеров за рубежом? 32:20 — Чего хотел добиться Путин? 33:25 — Благотворительный обед Чичваркина*. Результаты сборов 35:50 — Сокращение помощи Украине — естественный этап? 40:00 — На Западе боятся Путина? 41:20 — Подготовка к выборам в России. Зачем это нужно? 44:45 — Борьба с иноагентами в России 45:28 — Акция «Полдень против Путина» Телеграм-канал Евгения Чичваркина*: https://t.me/EvgenyChichvarkin Телеграм-канал Лизы Аникиной: https://t.me/echo_episod * — Евгений Чичваркин признан российскими властями иностранным агентом * * — Алексей Навальный признан российскими властями террористом и экстремистом Княжна Тараканова — героиня шестого тома комикса серии «Спасти». Княжна, чьё происхождение, да и имя, остаются тайной, выдавала себя за княгиню Елизавету Владимирскую — незаконнорождённую дочь императрицы Елизаветы Петровны. Оформляйте заказ на сайте diletant.shop! А ещё на сайте теперь можно оформить подписку на печатную версию журнала Дилетант! Попробуйте: https://diletant.shop/ 📌 Живой гвоздь в аудиоформате: https://podcast.ru/1616175210 🔔 Последние новости и анонсы программ с YouTube-канала «Живой гвоздь», а также контент от наших постоянных гостей и экспертов на официальном телеграм-канале: https://t.me/livegvozd Мобильное приложение "Эха": любимые программы в формате радиоприёмника. Простой интерфейс. Работа в фоновом режиме. Расписание эфиров. Скачать: в AppStore: https://apps.apple.com/us/app/%D1%8D%D1%85%D0%BE-online/id1639907671 в PlayMarket: https://play.google.com/store/apps/details?id=online.echofm.app Сайт "Эха": https://echofm.online/ (если не открывается – ссылка на рабочую версию сайта всегда есть в тг-канале ЭХО FM https://telegram.org/ Подписаться на Youtube-канал Дилетант: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuIE7-5QzeAR6EdZXwDRwuQ?sub_confirmation=1 Магазин Дилетант: https://diletant.shop/ По вопросам взаимодействия: [email protected]
Preparing download options
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players
Questions about downloading video
How can I download "«Холодная гражданская война» в России. Евгений Чичваркин*: Особое мнение @totsamychichvarkin" video?
http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.
Which format of "«Холодная гражданская война» в России. Евгений Чичваркин*: Особое мнение @totsamychichvarkin" video should I choose?
The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.
Why does my computer freeze when loading a "«Холодная гражданская война» в России. Евгений Чичваркин*: Особое мнение @totsamychichvarkin" video?
The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.
How can I download "«Холодная гражданская война» в России. Евгений Чичваркин*: Особое мнение @totsamychichvarkin" video to my phone?
You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.
How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "«Холодная гражданская война» в России. Евгений Чичваркин*: Особое мнение @totsamychichvarkin"?
The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.
How can I save a frame from a video "«Холодная гражданская война» в России. Евгений Чичваркин*: Особое мнение @totsamychichvarkin"?
This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.
What's the price of all this stuff?
It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.