background top icon
background center wave icon
background filled rhombus icon
background two lines icon
background stroke rhombus icon

Download "Лев ГУДКОВ: Пустые представления, бюрократия перед выбором и поворот в Азию / ВДОХ- ВЫДОХ"

input logo icon
"videoThumbnail Лев ГУДКОВ: Пустые представления, бюрократия перед выбором и поворот в Азию / ВДОХ- ВЫДОХ
Table of contents
|

Table of contents

0:00
Начало. Гость — Лев Гудков
0:55
Выжидание и пессимизм - господствующие социальные настроения
1:36
Динамика отношения к войне
2:20
Отношение к политическому классу
4:00
Нагнетание выдуманной угрозы
5:05
Доступ к информации
6:25
О чем думает молодежь?
7:24
Тон задает консервативное большинство
10:50
Что такое тоталитарный социум?
13:11
Почему продолжает работать телевизор?
18:20
Отношение респондентов к действиям российских сил в Украине
18:50
Патернализм и отождествление себя с государством
19:46
Половина россиян желает прекращения войны. Люди не хотят слышать того, что не соответствует их представлениям
21:00
Нереалистичность переговоров
24:25
Кто такие «университетские попугаи»?
25:30
Что такое социологическое интервью
28:20
Власть уничтожает активное меньшинство
30:20
Контроль за частной жизнью
32:20
Принуждение бюрократии к репрессиям
34:30
Силовики и их роль
36:40
Система лишена страховых механизмов
38:26
Горизонт планирования в два месяца опрокидывает «стабильность»
40:20
Сокращение запросов и новые стандарты жизни
42:30
Тревожность как фоновый режим существования
44:23
Ощущение беспомощности
45:10
Михаил Жванецкий - лучший социолог
46:45
Азиатский поворот и «недружественные страны»
48:50
Гаага и доверие к международным правовым институтам
50:49
Миграционные настроения
52:00
Скрытая мобилизация
53:30
Возможность влияния на ситуацию
55:38
Разорвана социальная ткань. Страх перед возвратом массовых репрессий
57:00
Враждебность большинства к оппонентам и вторичная агрессия
59:00
Жизненная стратегия обывателя
1:01:00
Логика лояльности к Путину
1:02:34
Конец
Video tags
|

Video tags

ходорковский лайф
ходорковский live
мбх
khodorkovsky
Россия
Украина
война
путин
политика
мобилизация
ходорковский
СВО
спецоперация
наступление
Гудков
опрос Левада-центра
Лев Гудков
Арсений Левинсон
Юрий Левада
ВЦИОМ
ФОМ
Гудков последнее
Лев Гудков интервью
Гаага
Международный уголовный суд
Медведев
Си Цзинпин
визит
КНР
рейтинг Путина
Китай
бюрократия
опросы
РПЦ
Киево-Печерская лавра
репрессии
задержания
аресты
дискредитация
протест
ООН
Львова-Белова
суд
дети
Мишустин
гудков
левгудков
левадацентр
Subtitles
|

Subtitles

subtitles menu arrow
  • ruRussian
Download
00:00:00
selfish greedy stupid
00:00:02
incompetent this is a very unstable
00:00:05
track there is continuous hammering dominates
00:00:08
that it is the most conservative groups of
00:00:10
the population primitivization forced into
00:00:13
moronicity sincere and not sincere This is
00:00:16
completely unimportant They do not solve
00:00:18
real problems
00:00:19
[music]
00:00:34
Good evening dear friends This is
00:00:36
the program inhale exhale My name is Stas
00:00:38
Kryuchkov I am glad to meet you on the
00:00:40
Khodorkovsky Life channel Subscribe,
00:00:42
leave your comments, like and
00:00:46
share this link among your friends,
00:00:48
family and acquaintances, this helps in
00:00:51
distributing this video today
00:00:53
sociologist Lev Gudkov is with us
00:00:56
[music]
00:01:00
Lev Dmitrievich Hello Good evening
00:01:02
Glad to see you
00:01:04
Good evening,
00:01:07
you know this may be an extremely general
00:01:10
question, but nevertheless, how would you describe the
00:01:12
prevailing mood in society at the moment, the
00:01:15
social mood,
00:01:21
but
00:01:22
in anticipation of hope
00:01:26
and some pessimism, such a
00:01:30
combination of
00:01:31
hopes, illusions and the expectation of uncertainty
00:01:37
and the expectation of the worst, something
00:01:39
like this, speaking
00:01:43
in principle over the year, in relation to what is
00:01:49
called a
00:01:50
special military operation,
00:01:54
almost nothing has changed,
00:01:58
except for some slight
00:02:01
increase in support for military actions,
00:02:05
general consolidation
00:02:07
in relation to the authorities, approval,
00:02:12
all ratings have gone up, the
00:02:15
perception of the authorities about politicians has become
00:02:18
much more favorable, which
00:02:21
amazes me Simply
00:02:22
I would say that even the assessments turned upside down a
00:02:25
year ago, the relationship in
00:02:30
principle with the
00:02:32
political class was very
00:02:34
critical,
00:02:37
the majority believed that we
00:02:41
were arriving in such a mafia-like,
00:02:43
corrupt state that
00:02:45
officials and politicians put themselves above
00:02:48
the law,
00:02:51
they are selfish, greedy, not smart,
00:02:54
incompetent,
00:02:57
immoral, and so on, today
00:03:01
the situation has changed
00:03:04
political the class is perceived as
00:03:06
patriots, competent believers, some
00:03:10
stylish, etc., this is the result,
00:03:14
firstly, of information isolation
00:03:17
practically
00:03:20
in the public field for the majority of
00:03:23
any authoritative critical
00:03:27
opinions, assessments, because everything is squeezed
00:03:31
out of the borders or into Telegram channels, that’s
00:03:40
why
00:03:45
[music]
00:03:46
growth,
00:03:48
say, of Putin’s rating but it rose to 83
00:03:53
percent,
00:03:55
this is high, this is not the maximum value, but it is
00:03:58
close to them and
00:04:01
[music]
00:04:02
popularity approval of the activities of the Duma of the
00:04:06
deputy corps, the government all
00:04:09
rose a little, not much, but this is a
00:04:12
very steady
00:04:15
buildup of this threat from the outside,
00:04:19
it forces people to put aside all
00:04:23
claims to power and unite for
00:04:27
protection, the fact that this is a fictitious defense is a
00:04:31
fictitious threat, but it’s not
00:04:36
perceived because there is a
00:04:38
continuous chattering like this
00:04:40
on television and Propaganda in this
00:04:43
sense. It turns out to be very
00:04:45
effective,
00:04:47
this is the second time, I already said that
00:04:51
almost all information channels are blocked,
00:04:55
although in a year the number of people who
00:04:58
they are able to bypass the
00:05:00
blocking of
00:05:02
Roskomnadzor has increased slightly But
00:05:05
still this is
00:05:07
no more than 20 percent more these are
00:05:12
younger groups more
00:05:13
educated these are mainly large
00:05:16
cities but young people although they have access
00:05:21
to information they distance themselves from what is
00:05:24
happening much less
00:05:27
included in what is happening in Ukraine in
00:05:31
political
00:05:32
events She is trying to do
00:05:36
their own business, therefore,
00:05:39
it dominates the most conservative groups of the population,
00:05:42
these are
00:05:44
older people, they make up And the
00:05:48
majority is simply purely in
00:05:51
demographic terms, the majority of
00:05:53
young people are few now
00:05:55
and
00:05:57
they their opinion, their ideas
00:06:00
turn out to be more important, more significant
00:06:04
than the opinion of opponents of the war, I can
00:06:08
clarify about the youth This is
00:06:11
conscious a conformist life
00:06:13
position or is it an inevitability that you
00:06:17
accept if there is segmentation in the circle of
00:06:21
generations less than 40 on this matter
00:06:26
Well,
00:06:28
there is but it is small on the continuum
00:06:31
there is no There is a clear differentiation but
00:06:35
there are some continuum more
00:06:38
[music]
00:06:41
people are concerned About 25 years 25
00:06:45
about 30 years this is exactly the age
00:06:50
when people start families, they
00:06:53
no longer have
00:06:54
that youthful romanticism of idealism,
00:06:57
they have gained a lot of money and begin to understand
00:07:01
what’s what. They begin to take
00:07:04
responsibility for the family; children appear
00:07:06
and they are much more critical; they are
00:07:11
skeptical about propaganda. They were
00:07:14
more worried, but this is to say
00:07:17
I’ll say it again about young people: up to 30 years old, the
00:07:22
population structure
00:07:26
under 30 years old is only 15 percent of the
00:07:28
population.
00:07:30
Very little, the
00:07:32
bulk are still older people who
00:07:37
identify themselves with the state,
00:07:39
rely on the state and
00:07:43
reproduce all the complexes of the Soviet
00:07:46
era,
00:07:48
disappointed in the course of reforms,
00:07:51
democracy. Although this they don’t really
00:07:55
understand what democracy is, but rather
00:07:59
it is combined with this some protection
00:08:02
from the arbitrariness of officials and the
00:08:07
idea of ​​a customized state that
00:08:10
takes care of people,
00:08:13
well, plus Propaganda has really
00:08:16
raised a very strong anti-Western
00:08:18
mood. I propose for each of
00:08:22
the points Propaganda Putin illusions of hope,
00:08:25
expectations of tomorrow day to walk
00:08:28
separately And now, purely
00:08:30
methodologically, determine the
00:08:32
possibilities with the current possibilities of
00:08:35
sociology because for me a significant
00:08:38
presumption is that we proceed from the
00:08:40
possibility of sociology to exist in the
00:08:44
circumstances offered to it, but
00:08:48
nevertheless based on the fact that it has
00:08:51
the resource to give answers to the
00:08:53
question of this or that dynamics talk about
00:08:56
social trends and, to a certain
00:08:58
extent, from numbers, that is, you
00:09:01
will agree if I propose to
00:09:02
fix we are dealing with something
00:09:06
not to pay attention to, which would be a
00:09:09
sacrilege, that is, sociology is important and
00:09:11
essential And talk about what the data of
00:09:15
sociologists
00:09:17
during the war are
00:09:19
untenable deceptive or false,
00:09:22
well, at least it’s neglect Well,
00:09:26
sociology works as a certain given thing
00:09:29
No, I don’t agree, nothing fundamental
00:09:33
happened during the year of the war in this sense,
00:09:37
people answered the same way and answer many
00:09:40
times, they checked this and the point is not that
00:09:44
how asserts that people are afraid
00:09:48
to answer something else, they simply do not
00:09:51
have other ideas, and this is
00:09:54
the most important thing that the idea
00:09:56
arises in response to
00:09:59
Especially if it does not
00:10:01
directly concern their experience of their everyday
00:10:05
life But it concerns some abstract
00:10:07
things that are shown on television,
00:10:11
this is
00:10:12
extremely important people do not have their
00:10:15
own resources there are no means for
00:10:18
analysis
00:10:21
this can only be done by
00:10:24
specialists and accordingly
00:10:27
this is what is needed for
00:10:31
public intellectuals professors
00:10:34
journalists commentators who could
00:10:38
rationalize and critically
00:10:40
present the consequences of certain
00:10:42
events based on the
00:10:45
analytical data they have means of
00:10:48
intellectual means The masses of
00:10:50
the population, deprived of this, do not have such
00:10:54
means, therefore this decision did not
00:10:57
happen in the last year;
00:10:59
we have already been living in such an intensifying
00:11:04
totalitarian society for about 15 years,
00:11:07
if not more;
00:11:09
repression did not begin today or yesterday,
00:11:14
approximately almost 20 years ago no longer
00:11:18
it just intensified during this time, a
00:11:21
generation
00:11:23
formed under the Putin
00:11:25
regime entered into thinking in this way, having
00:11:28
internalized all the rhetoric and all the demagoguery of
00:11:31
the authorities and it is
00:11:33
quite difficult to change this situation,
00:11:36
therefore all this talk about how something is different
00:11:39
during the war.
00:11:41
No, generally speaking,
00:11:46
the war does not concern the main the masses of
00:11:50
the population
00:11:51
this is extremely important when we
00:11:54
ask How are you in the mood today the
00:11:58
usual mood is calm everything is fine
00:12:02
young people and officials are more
00:12:05
optimistic about pensioners
00:12:07
because
00:12:09
diseases fears poverty
00:12:21
seems to hardly affect them they do not
00:12:25
understand the connection that their
00:12:27
purchasing power is decreasing that
00:12:32
they are not they can get medicine there,
00:12:34
medical services, it’s like each
00:12:38
specific case, it’s in this
00:12:40
hospital, it’s not generally bad with medicine in
00:12:43
Russia, it’s this opinion that
00:12:47
you get, it’s always partial
00:12:50
knowledge, it’s another matter for doctors who can
00:12:53
look at it a little more broadly, so
00:12:56
doctors like that, you know, run from Russia or
00:13:00
flow from the provinces to Moscow, where
00:13:03
salaries are higher. Especially a
00:13:09
large number of doctors,
00:13:13
people are not able to
00:13:16
establish a connection between certain
00:13:19
events and to a very large extent, an
00:13:23
explanation of what is happening is offered to them, as
00:13:25
before, by television,
00:13:27
television, dolberg, this very
00:13:30
primitive explanations. But
00:13:35
the more primitive the
00:13:38
easier it is to assimilate
00:13:47
intellectually if I return to
00:13:50
sociology and still to the dynamics of
00:13:53
refusals or interruptions in communication, the past
00:13:56
year has shown me that there are more of them,
00:13:59
that is, it is clear that people’s readiness to communicate is
00:14:02
accompanied by
00:14:04
methodologically and in a certain way,
00:14:06
but nevertheless has not increased
00:14:10
no
00:14:14
no How did you How was
00:14:19
what is called response rate, it
00:14:21
has not changed and it is at the level of
00:14:24
approximately the European
00:14:26
surveyed services, it is higher than in France
00:14:30
and a little bit lower than, say, West
00:14:33
Germany, we have approximately 25
00:14:39
in France 16 West Germany 28
00:14:45
this is the actual achievability
00:14:49
of it determined not by fear by the fact that people
00:14:53
are not at home in the first place, but we conduct personal
00:14:57
interviews at their place of residence, they are at
00:15:00
work, they are busy feeding a child there
00:15:03
or something else, there are a lot of
00:15:07
reasons why, purely
00:15:10
technically, they are not achievable, this is
00:15:14
very important
00:15:18
respondent I am also a very frequent important they are
00:15:25
afraid to open the doors because there are
00:15:29
scammers, speculators and so on if
00:15:34
we talk about the stated
00:15:36
reasons for refusal, then they What is the
00:15:45
proportion of refusals higher for those who
00:15:48
[music]
00:15:53
and This varies very much
00:15:56
among loyal groups of the population the
00:16:01
number of refusals is about 8 times higher than for
00:16:06
people who are critical anti-war
00:16:08
sentiments
00:16:10
According to the latter, I considered this based
00:16:14
on the materials of the February survey, this
00:16:18
is important, you understand,
00:16:21
if we talk about fear, it is fear that
00:16:25
determines both conformism and loyalty, and that is why it is
00:16:29
there that the percentage of
00:16:32
refusals is higher, who refuses, who officials
00:16:36
speak on sensitive topics, although
00:16:39
of course they are extremely
00:16:42
conformist,
00:16:45
older women do not refuse very educated,
00:16:48
just in case, because they don’t really
00:16:51
understand this, but they are not the only ones who are scared,
00:16:54
but their parents are from
00:16:57
Soviet times, so
00:17:00
they have no other ideas. But
00:17:04
approximately,
00:17:06
if we use Bolgakov’s expression
00:17:08
from the theatrical novel, we do
00:17:11
not rebel against the authorities, we are supported, but
00:17:15
is this a marker? the insincerity of
00:17:19
this loyalty which they talk about
00:17:22
then
00:17:23
forgive me. Is this a marker of the
00:17:27
insincerity of this
00:17:30
demonstrated loyalty
00:17:35
from the point of view it makes absolutely no difference.
00:17:37
What difference does it make to you sincerely if they
00:17:41
behave like this
00:17:43
if they Our Madhouse vote for Putin
00:17:46
as he sang
00:17:47
in one song but they they vote they
00:17:52
approve it they support it but sincerely not
00:17:56
sincerely This is not at all important
00:17:59
from the point of view of the
00:18:01
consequences of this they can keep
00:18:04
figures in their pocket and other things probably
00:18:07
some part
00:18:12
answers insincerely But this absolutely does not
00:18:16
matter because what is
00:18:18
important is precisely this symbolic
00:18:22
support for the actions of the authorities if 77
00:18:25
percent
00:18:27
approve of the actions of
00:18:30
Russian troops in Ukraine and do not want to
00:18:34
hear anything about the negative sides of the
00:18:38
death of people,
00:18:40
the destruction of infrastructure, etc., then
00:18:43
this is a fact, they are pushing out
00:18:46
[music]
00:18:47
unpleasant events, defending themselves, defending
00:18:51
their conformism, and so on, this is one
00:18:53
side of the
00:18:54
other side of
00:18:57
this,
00:19:01
they feel it Here are some of
00:19:06
their identification with the state, they
00:19:10
perceive themselves as
00:19:14
subjects of this great power and are
00:19:18
ready to see
00:19:21
this construction of reality precisely as a
00:19:25
confrontation between the West and Russia, therefore the
00:19:28
heroic Putin does
00:19:32
not need to confront the Americans and others who
00:19:35
want to destroy Russia, take away something there,
00:19:39
weaken, humiliate and so on it works
00:19:43
everything else all the other arguments are
00:19:46
facts they are crowded out and are
00:19:50
not considered significant they don’t want to hear
00:19:54
what doesn’t correspond to their
00:19:57
ideas this time on the other hand I’ll
00:20:00
play along with you a little 50 percent
00:20:04
want an end to the war
00:20:09
the beginning of peace negotiations
00:20:13
you understand that these are almost the same
00:20:16
people, if 77 percent, then two thirds of
00:20:19
these 77 percent would like an immediate
00:20:22
end to the war, but on what conditions
00:20:24
the first
00:20:27
exchange of prisoners the
00:20:30
second
00:20:32
refusal of Ukraine from those territories
00:20:37
captured by Russian troops
00:20:39
refusal of Crimea and so on, that is,
00:20:44
agreement to all the
00:20:48
goals that
00:20:53
the policy
00:20:55
starting this war from Ukraine
00:20:59
and of course 76 percent believe that
00:21:04
one of the most important conditions for such peace
00:21:08
negotiations was Ukraine’s refusal
00:21:10
to retreat to NATO, which makes absolutely,
00:21:14
you understand, the negotiations themselves are not realistic,
00:21:23
that is, in reality, these are
00:21:28
negotiations or a cessation of
00:21:31
hostilities, this means the capitulation of
00:21:33
Ukraine and surrender completely, just well then
00:21:38
that he declared his own at the very
00:21:40
beginning of
00:21:41
the war
00:21:43
and the activation of the critical apparatus does not
00:21:47
occur in principle on the subject that
00:21:50
Sweden,
00:21:51
Finland is already on the threshold of NATO, Ukraine
00:21:56
is suffering those sacrifices that are
00:22:00
not actually comparable to the goals
00:22:03
that were proclaimed on the 24th,
00:22:07
this is a completely
00:22:09
blocked logic of reasoning and
00:22:12
is it really possible that the TV is capable of
00:22:15
acting exactly like that, yes exactly like that,
00:22:21
I say again, a
00:22:30
strong process of degradation of society,
00:22:34
there is a lack of authoritative opinions, a
00:22:36
lack of public discussions and goals
00:22:40
about the purpose of the policies being pursued,
00:22:43
if so, then people do not have a
00:22:47
mass of the population, they do not have their own means.
00:22:51
You understand, when
00:22:54
I hear this all the time,
00:22:57
distrust of sociology, other,
00:23:00
etc. speakers’ own consciousness it
00:23:04
replaces
00:23:06
knowledge
00:23:08
of consciousness
00:23:11
there is a projection of attribution of one’s own
00:23:14
characteristics of thinking skills to the population
00:23:17
as a whole
00:23:19
this is a big mistake and generally speaking it’s not
00:23:23
just a mistake it’s the
00:23:26
lack of development of our intellectual
00:23:29
public there
00:23:31
is no mechanism for
00:23:34
introducing scientific
00:23:37
interpretations of scientific analyzes firstly the
00:23:42
eight-day environment and accordingly this
00:23:45
transmission in me of extremely primitive
00:23:49
ideas about the structure of society about the
00:23:51
composition of society and the
00:23:54
phobias that are within the
00:23:56
prejudices of Russia and so on, the
00:24:01
educated community has risen a little,
00:24:04
comparison with the Soviet level,
00:24:07
it has risen a little but has lost
00:24:10
the top the most
00:24:12
refined layer of intellectuals
00:24:15
that we
00:24:17
knew there in
00:24:19
the seventies,
00:24:27
Mordashvili
00:24:29
and other things like that
00:24:40
compilers that bring everything together,
00:24:55
if I return to the conversation about the dynamics of the
00:24:58
idea of ​​​​what is happening and who
00:25:01
finally changed their attitude towards the war, and
00:25:05
various sociological services show
00:25:07
that such a group
00:25:10
still appears among the respondents. Yes, how correct from a
00:25:13
methodological point of view is it not to
00:25:16
imitate, so observe some
00:25:19
scientific frequency to ask a question so that
00:25:22
you can make a sociologically
00:25:25
significant conclusion about uh in what
00:25:28
plane
00:25:29
this attitude is changing and, in fact,
00:25:32
what you can work with somewhere a
00:25:36
population group that can be
00:25:37
addressed somewhere a population group
00:25:40
that is ready to
00:25:42
critically engage in the conversation is
00:25:45
critical This is fundamental
00:25:48
Well, look
00:25:49
What is sociological
00:25:54
Solidarity is this understanding that my
00:25:58
opinion
00:26:01
I see in this actually a manifestation of one’s
00:26:04
own dignity therefore those who
00:26:07
speak
00:26:09
openly speak differently, those who
00:26:20
think differently with a different resource of
00:26:23
intellectual resources, cultural and
00:26:26
informational resources and a completely different
00:26:29
own consciousness of
00:26:31
their dignity there are few of them about there, from 6 to 12
00:26:37
percent,
00:26:39
it is also
00:26:42
clear that this is more educated, these are,
00:26:45
as a rule, highly educated people, these are
00:26:49
families in which there are at least two or three
00:26:53
generations, people, parents with higher
00:26:55
education,
00:26:56
certain cultural
00:26:59
social, reflexive capital,
00:27:02
analytical capital have developed,
00:27:04
and there are also adjacent layers. But this
00:27:08
up to about 20 there are 25 percent who are
00:27:13
less educated but quite
00:27:16
[music]
00:27:18
radically thinking, radically in the
00:27:21
sense that
00:27:22
they are trying to think out some of their
00:27:25
thoughts, their
00:27:27
ideas. Trying to think out what,
00:27:30
generally speaking, it is very difficult to think,
00:27:33
especially for people who are not very educated,
00:27:37
so
00:27:38
to think out this, generally speaking, is a lot of
00:27:40
work and complexity is necessary to come into
00:27:44
conflict with the environment of such
00:27:47
people, I say again In general,
00:27:51
this is approximately 20 percent of the population,
00:27:56
say this number in different ways Yes, from 6
00:28:00
to 20 we will count it so, to some
00:28:04
extent, in its position it turns out to be important
00:28:08
and significant for people actually making
00:28:12
decisions, that is, looking at the position of less
00:28:16
than a quarter of the country's population,
00:28:19
perhaps it is needed, is it being demonstrated and has it
00:28:23
ever been demonstrated?
00:28:27
Well, a
00:28:28
number of 20 30 ago It was significant it
00:28:35
was It was very important and the authorities
00:28:37
took into account the mood, opinion, interests
00:28:41
of these people relied on them because,
00:28:44
generally speaking, perestroika was done from my
00:28:47
point of view by bureaucracy
00:28:50
bureaucracy these are people with education
00:28:54
with a certain horizon a
00:28:59
higher sense of responsibility
00:29:02
for what is happening because they are
00:29:05
bureaucracies middle management bureaucracy
00:29:07
It deals with real problems and
00:29:11
all
00:29:13
horizons they better understood the situation
00:29:16
had access
00:29:18
official information classified information
00:29:22
understood the real problems,
00:29:27
today the authorities
00:29:31
do not just
00:29:33
ignore opinion. They destroy
00:29:36
that layer or that environment that actually
00:29:42
has the potential to not only act critically, but
00:29:47
even think that what we see today is
00:29:52
no longer just closing there, blocking
00:29:55
information channels, but destroying
00:29:58
owl memorial and other organizations
00:30:03
coercion of
00:30:05
informationism intimidation
00:30:09
intimidation of the public both
00:30:14
judicial practice and Roskomnadzor are aimed at this, in
00:30:18
principle
00:30:19
the state has been
00:30:21
behaving for several years like a
00:30:24
typical totalitarian regime, trying
00:30:27
to control not even external
00:30:29
loyalty, but
00:30:31
what people think, what people can even
00:30:36
think is
00:30:38
extremely important extending its
00:30:41
influence to all areas Where before,
00:30:47
family life, moral art,
00:30:49
culture, religion, science, etc. are the
00:30:53
result of this long-term
00:30:57
influence, this and I say again This is a
00:31:01
slow but irreversible process and
00:31:03
gradation of society during snowstorming,
00:31:06
lack of development
00:31:08
and Unification that at least seems to be
00:31:12
not yet felt
00:31:14
Since the transformation, in any
00:31:18
case, as you say during the period of
00:31:19
perestroika, began with shifts in the
00:31:23
mentality and ideas of
00:31:25
the bureaucracy, then apparently attempts to understand what
00:31:29
is the determining motivation of the
00:31:32
current bureaucracy are being made and
00:31:36
now this kind of abandonment Yes,
00:31:39
this kind of
00:31:41
research can be hidden, maybe
00:31:44
indirectly. They demonstrate
00:31:46
what the general mood of the bureaucratic
00:31:50
class is really not in the readiness
00:31:53
to act, yes, but in the structure
00:31:57
of thinking, yes, in the structure of understanding
00:31:59
what is happening,
00:32:04
I am not talking about the entire bureaucracy, but the
00:32:07
middle echelons, because above this is an
00:32:11
absolutely corrupt layer, that is, a
00:32:15
fixed one of those who contribute to
00:32:17
the functioning of the state apparatus itself,
00:32:20
those who are connected with the real
00:32:23
problems of
00:32:24
managing medicine, providing transport there,
00:32:29
social spheres, roads, it’s all
00:32:33
bureaucracy,
00:32:38
control
00:32:42
over this layer is really being tightened and there is strong
00:32:46
coercion, including repression, we believe
00:32:50
that repression is only against the opposition.
00:32:52
But generally speaking, they don’t go to
00:32:56
the highest and middle levels, they are
00:32:59
constantly
00:33:01
carried out like this at the highest level is
00:33:03
simply noticeable and there are
00:33:06
foundation centers that monitor this, let’s
00:33:10
say the foundation of a St. Petersburg politician,
00:33:13
all these cases every year, according to the data
00:33:16
there from the foundation of a St. Petersburg
00:33:19
politician or there Nikolai Petrov,
00:33:22
professor Nikolai Petrov,
00:33:23
2% above the nomenclature are arrested
00:33:28
for 5 years for 5-6 years - this means
00:33:32
10-12% higher than the management team Well, we’re
00:33:36
flying away well,
00:33:38
all these big names,
00:33:43
we perceive this as a
00:33:46
manifestation of corruption, in fact, in
00:33:47
reality this is coercion of loyalty,
00:33:52
intimidation of precisely this top layer and
00:33:57
coercion of some loyalty,
00:34:00
including to the business of the largest business
00:34:05
at the middle level it’s not so noticeable, but it’s
00:34:08
just all
00:34:10
the multiplicity of this word, but it goes there
00:34:13
if the security forces are in power,
00:34:18
representatives of the political police
00:34:20
who
00:34:22
initially act outside the legal ones,
00:34:25
so this is its status,
00:34:29
special secret police, special
00:34:33
department. What does special police department mean? This means
00:34:36
this department is removed from the usual
00:34:38
official regulation; it is subject to
00:34:41
other rules. behavior and the entire
00:34:45
system is an action outside the legal framework with
00:34:49
special statuses they control the
00:34:52
judiciary, administrative authorities, etc., but the
00:34:55
security forces themselves are specialists in
00:35:00
violence, coercion, control, but
00:35:03
they are not competent leaders, they do not
00:35:06
solve real problems, you understand,
00:35:08
so this is also one of the factors
00:35:12
[music]
00:35:14
degradation
00:35:15
of society
00:35:17
primitivization of coercion for such imbecility
00:35:22
is compensated for and of course the
00:35:28
security forces cannot think differently in
00:35:32
these categories;
00:35:37
this is a
00:35:38
narrowing or reduction of
00:35:42
managerial bureaucratic competence; of course, it
00:35:47
has only one outcome; this is
00:35:51
the perspective of the
00:35:53
system;
00:35:54
accumulation of dysfunction and collapse of the
00:35:58
fear of the system; it cannot
00:36:02
exist because the only
00:36:05
tool is violence, coercion, this is
00:36:09
not a solution to real problems, but the
00:36:12
system cannot help but be aware of
00:36:15
the prospects of its collapse and obviously
00:36:18
it must, in any case,
00:36:20
undertake
00:36:22
some real responses to the challenges
00:36:25
coming from this middle area,
00:36:29
where everyday issues are resolved
00:36:31
or
00:36:34
else how can it be,
00:36:37
how can it be
00:36:39
exactly the way it is if you remove the
00:36:42
block of systemic, so to speak, liberals,
00:36:45
economists,
00:36:47
cautious and attentive people who
00:36:50
understand what certain steps can lead to,
00:36:54
of course
00:36:56
the system is deprived
00:37:02
Well, generally speaking, the situation in which
00:37:06
Russia finds itself today
00:37:09
is a
00:37:11
pre-catastrophic situation,
00:37:18
they oppose Russia if the country
00:37:23
finds itself among a small group of
00:37:26
outcast countries Well, if
00:37:30
investment is reduced Flight of capital technology
00:37:34
if
00:37:36
the building of the East is being driven by tanks from the Second
00:37:40
World War
00:37:41
Tell me, does society share this
00:37:45
optimism that
00:37:47
Putin demonstrates every time when he says that
00:37:49
more than half of humanity is with us before
00:37:51
China plus India this is already 2.8 billion
00:37:54
or Mishustin, who the day before, speaking
00:37:57
before the Duma in his report,
00:38:00
showed
00:38:02
such optimism that he demonstrates some kind of unreliable
00:38:06
strength. What does
00:38:09
today's ideas of a Russian look like about
00:38:12
tomorrow and the horizon of his
00:38:15
planning because it is clear that the
00:38:17
state
00:38:18
everyone lives in some kind of private life
00:38:20
and tries to build it in accordance with
00:38:24
what is available and obviously Yes, he has
00:38:28
some internal resources in the stash, so this is
00:38:32
what the Russian thinks now
00:38:35
about what his tomorrow will be like,
00:38:39
again I think a very small part is
00:38:43
really just these 20 percent 20
00:38:47
30 percent maximum in general The
00:38:51
planning horizon has been reduced to
00:38:54
two months,
00:38:58
which the average family has in order to
00:39:03
live with it so much accumulation so much
00:39:07
savings there
00:39:12
are more there are 10 percent of the population the
00:39:17
top
00:39:20
large savings and
00:39:23
it binds its future namely
00:39:27
preservation in any way the preservation of the
00:39:30
current regime
00:39:32
is one
00:39:34
one Planning calculation horizon one
00:39:38
strategy of rationality but the bulk
00:39:45
of our questions is to answer I don’t know
00:39:48
what will happen in the near world for two months
00:39:51
what will happen to me people are very alarmed
00:39:55
in this sense This is a completely different
00:39:57
Horizon of existence people are worried about the
00:40:02
deterioration of medical care
00:40:05
the threat of unemployment not to mention the
00:40:10
consequences of their own war
00:40:12
of mobilization and so on, therefore
00:40:17
there is no future Well, or
00:40:19
if we talk about the actual country, then
00:40:22
this is roughly
00:40:23
the hope that it will be no worse.
00:40:27
And so on according to the formula, and so on,
00:40:30
repetition of what we have today, this is a
00:40:33
very important mechanism for adapting to
00:40:36
the situation,
00:40:38
minor reduction, slow
00:40:40
slight reduction in requests,
00:40:43
savings on this, which allows us to somehow
00:40:46
maintain that way of life, the
00:40:48
standard of living that has developed there in
00:40:51
recent years, but not
00:40:55
this, on the one hand, on the other hand, without the
00:40:59
main hope that somehow
00:41:01
maybe the situation will improve.
00:41:05
And these are also very important things because
00:41:11
more than half there, about 50 there, 3 to
00:41:17
60 percent say that
00:41:21
in a year in five years everything will be the same
00:41:24
as today.
00:41:27
But somewhere else, about 15-20
00:41:30
percent hope that somehow,
00:41:33
miraculously,
00:41:35
we will live better;
00:41:37
young people are more optimistic and look at
00:41:40
these are older people
00:41:47
[music]
00:41:53
declining quality of life
00:41:56
Dmitrich Well, the consequences can be
00:41:58
not only expressed
00:42:01
financially but also in terms of living
00:42:05
better. Yes, one cannot ignore the factor of
00:42:09
mental well-being when they say
00:42:11
answering the question about how the
00:42:14
military confrontation affected their lives
00:42:16
Many say a deterioration in mental
00:42:19
well-being. But in general, society
00:42:21
considers
00:42:23
its peace of mind, let’s say, as
00:42:26
some value or is it a peripheral
00:42:30
thing that is disturbing
00:42:33
insofar as they
00:42:35
prefer not to talk about it,
00:42:38
but
00:42:40
psychology, of course, is
00:42:52
in illusion and in hope,
00:42:56
so there is uncertainty here,
00:43:06
irritation of the fact
00:43:16
that
00:43:20
being it will be better
00:43:25
this is the most stable material of
00:43:29
social construction in repressive
00:43:31
regimes,
00:43:33
firstly, the
00:43:34
very own insecurity, lack of
00:43:38
security, anxiety,
00:43:40
complexes or sentiment, they
00:43:43
are transferred to the government,
00:43:50
hopes are transferred to it and, accordingly,
00:43:53
this creates conditions for stability
00:43:59
if we identify the dominant
00:44:03
phobia that contributes to
00:44:07
this the paternalistic logic
00:44:09
was self-reproducing, this is the
00:44:12
fear, first of all, of
00:44:14
physical survival, the preservation of the family
00:44:18
or something higher, and here is a whole
00:44:22
complex, a conglomerate, a
00:44:24
whole complex, this is the lack of
00:44:27
trust,
00:44:28
constitutional trust,
00:44:31
fear of violence from the police, fear of
00:44:35
being deceived, this feeling of
00:44:38
helplessness in life because a person
00:44:42
comes
00:44:43
to the hospital and they expect that the doctors
00:44:55
will treat him like candles, so this is the best thing, well,
00:44:58
what do you want?
00:45:01
You are 60 years old
00:45:04
and have been growing your problems for so long and you
00:45:08
want this to be solved at once, there are no
00:45:10
such medicines, and so on and so forth,
00:45:14
this is the expectation of
00:45:17
eternal such rudeness, what is
00:45:20
best described by Zhvanetsky, generally
00:45:22
speaking If we talk about
00:45:25
sociology, then we
00:45:28
don’t have a better sociologist like this at the micro level, he
00:45:31
brilliantly
00:45:33
understands all these mechanisms of
00:45:37
conformism, subordination of your thoughts and
00:45:40
so on, this is
00:45:42
anxiety, insecurity, it
00:45:46
is the basis for
00:45:50
transfer As psychoanalysts say, the
00:45:54
figure is the embodiment of strength and protection, that is,
00:45:58
well, power doesn’t have to fall on
00:46:02
Putin. Putin here is simply the
00:46:04
personification of the state of such an
00:46:06
omnipotent paternalistic state.
00:46:10
But this is precisely what is connected with the increase in the
00:46:15
authority and popularity of Putin, which
00:46:19
we see precisely in the conditions of increasing
00:46:22
anxiety, fear of the consequences of war,
00:46:26
we have 15 minutes remaining
00:46:29
questions I I’ll put it more locally, let’s say,
00:46:33
look
00:46:36
if there is any fresh data on how
00:46:41
Russians perceive this obviously
00:46:43
occurring Asian turn, which is more
00:46:47
dense, much more dense, they
00:46:50
would probably be called
00:46:52
close contacts with Beijing against the backdrop of
00:46:55
Xi Jinping’s visit,
00:46:58
but again this is not nothing something new, this
00:47:02
fits into a trend that in the last
00:47:06
few years the
00:47:09
number of friendly countries has sharply
00:47:12
decreased and remains there this is
00:47:16
Belarus China Kazakhstan fell out it was
00:47:19
this India and so on this
00:47:24
is perceived as with approval all this
00:47:28
foreign political rhetoric and
00:47:32
hopes that it will help
00:47:34
to resist the
00:47:36
United States of NATO to the West and so on,
00:47:39
this is one of the factors of such consolation,
00:47:43
but this is not today, it just hangs just as
00:47:48
another reinforcement
00:47:55
lists, once again I say lists of
00:47:58
friendly countries
00:48:00
[music]
00:48:01
Belarus and Kazakhstan rank first
00:48:06
I looked by country and by numbers about the
00:48:09
attitude of Russians towards strange West to the
00:48:12
United States of the European Union and saw that
00:48:15
they were striving for figures less than 20 Yes,
00:48:21
that very fifth part, but With all
00:48:25
this,
00:48:27
there is also an appeal to international law,
00:48:31
which you demonstrate in Medvedev in your
00:48:34
frequent telegram posts and the President
00:48:36
speaking about this here and there
00:48:40
in general, a Russian’s perception of the institutions of
00:48:42
international law
00:48:44
And by the way, that same warrant from the
00:48:48
international criminal court in The Hague
00:48:50
that was issued last week,
00:48:53
what is it? I understand that maybe there
00:48:56
were no fresh questions about the Hague, but latently there
00:48:59
is an institution, there is trust in it and,
00:49:02
accordingly, it is projected onto itself
00:49:04
Orda
00:49:06
know 10 years ago,
00:49:09
with a rather critical attitude towards the
00:49:12
Russian judicial system,
00:49:15
this and
00:49:17
more negative ones, by the way, with those courts with
00:49:21
which people interacted more often, that the
00:49:26
lower district courts themselves
00:49:31
[music]
00:49:32
in Strasbourg
00:49:35
acted as absolutely
00:49:37
authoritatively the only
00:49:41
justice of other hopes, therefore there was no
00:49:45
trust in the
00:49:48
international court how some
00:49:52
ideal justice and law
00:49:55
are preserved but
00:49:58
were preserved until recently,
00:50:02
now I think that it is
00:50:06
beginning to erode and
00:50:09
especially
00:50:11
take into account the continuity of Anti-
00:50:15
Western demagoguery propaganda continuous
00:50:20
fierce aggressive and continuous
00:50:23
nature of the impact,
00:50:24
in fact, it’s not that they are being undermined
00:50:28
Trust they simply disappear from the horizon
00:50:34
Lev Dmitrievich what can we say at the
00:50:37
moment about the immigration
00:50:40
mood in our country? This is the wave
00:50:43
that we observed in March last
00:50:45
year, then in September last year, to
00:50:48
date. In what phase is
00:50:53
it still
00:50:56
frozen? I would say the migration
00:50:59
mood was an outbreak among the
00:51:01
mobilization and at first the war, more precisely, there
00:51:04
were two humps of this kind at the beginning of the war, a sharp
00:51:08
increase in the
00:51:10
readiness to leave and after mobilization
00:51:16
in October
00:51:20
the desire to leave, after that
00:51:23
some calm began,
00:51:25
not just calm, but also
00:51:29
for those among those who think about this
00:51:32
in general
00:51:33
[music]
00:51:35
there was some
00:51:37
sobering up that you can leave but
00:51:43
settle down there very difficult Moreover,
00:51:46
many countries have indeed introduced
00:51:50
restrictions and barriers to entry for Russians,
00:51:54
so there are two factors here and the
00:52:00
absence of a direct reason for
00:52:03
pushing them out of the country, mobilization,
00:52:09
talk of mobilization, at least from
00:52:12
the top they have stopped, at least I think
00:52:15
that
00:52:16
hidden mobilization is really going on in
00:52:22
such public speeches.
00:52:25
still, this is missing, and the second
00:52:29
is the difficulties of simply
00:52:34
adapting.
00:52:38
Central Asia
00:52:42
is returning to the
00:52:47
escalation of hostilities,
00:52:55
yet another one,
00:52:59
but in principle,
00:53:03
the potential of those leaving In general, it
00:53:07
has decreased when they say that if something is
00:53:10
fixed, then a certain inevitability will be recorded. But
00:53:13
man Will is captivity, not even in a
00:53:15
sociological sense, but in what ways -he
00:53:20
lives with his existential parameters in hope A Hope
00:53:22
increases Yes in the realization that you
00:53:25
can influence something, this is how today’s
00:53:29
respondents assess the
00:53:32
remaining
00:53:35
opportunities to actually influence the situation at their disposal
00:53:39
or is this from the realm of abstraction
00:53:42
today sounds
00:53:44
No we can look at the opinions of
00:53:50
those people who are critical
00:53:57
and, accordingly, they have no opportunity to influence
00:54:06
today;
00:54:10
only among those who are critical, the
00:54:19
dominant idea is that
00:54:21
power cannot be influenced; power is sovereign and
00:54:24
self-sufficient. Although,
00:54:29
again, everything depends on the channel
00:54:31
of information, respectively, on the resources of the
00:54:34
television audience; the mood of the television audience is
00:54:37
calmer, more optimistic and
00:54:41
naturally more loyal to the authorities and believes
00:54:46
that its opinion
00:54:48
They
00:54:49
[music] are
00:54:51
more likely to be accessible to the authorities and taken into account by the
00:54:54
authorities,
00:54:57
while
00:54:59
opposition-minded groups of the
00:55:02
population They
00:55:04
understand that they are completely deprived of
00:55:07
any opportunities,
00:55:10
this is one of the internal factors of such
00:55:13
tension of frustration and a feeling of
00:55:17
hopelessness situation,
00:55:20
that is, it turns out that the conversation about such
00:55:22
internal protest activity
00:55:25
today is more or less in
00:55:27
favor of the poor. And if you pose the question
00:55:29
a little more broadly and
00:55:32
ask the question: What do surveys say about
00:55:35
society’s ability to do anything,
00:55:39
not even protest, but whatever?
00:55:41
there was no collective reaction today, there is
00:55:44
this connective tissue that
00:55:46
makes us a society. In the full
00:55:49
sense of the word, there
00:55:51
is no
00:55:55
action, a
00:55:57
very strong fear
00:56:02
of police actions,
00:56:05
on the one hand, has intensified very much recently, it
00:56:12
has reached 5th place in the list of such
00:56:16
fears of
00:56:20
arbitrariness, and has also risen in general
00:56:25
speaking over the last two years, these fears of the
00:56:32
Soviet era have risen
00:56:36
extremely high. We haven’t seen anything like this in 30 years.
00:56:41
Forty forty percent are about to be afraid
00:56:44
much more widely than people are actually critical
00:56:48
of the authorities, this is the
00:56:53
second thing that works and feels. This is a
00:56:58
thin layer of dissatisfied authorities with the regimes and the
00:57:04
policies being pursued are the
00:57:07
growing
00:57:09
hostility of the majority towards
00:57:12
them
00:57:14
when We ask How do you feel about
00:57:18
those who are leaving
00:57:20
mobilization,
00:57:23
fleeing the war abroad, then
00:57:28
more than 60 percent say extremely
00:57:32
negatively
00:57:34
to be viewed as traitors As
00:57:36
traitors as well as other things
00:57:42
migration itself is extremely negative the
00:57:45
majority of indifferent people,
00:57:48
about 25 percent, perceive it quite calmly only negatively,
00:57:56
but for them, flight from war is
00:58:01
perceived with strong condemnation, that
00:58:05
is, this is a mechanism for
00:58:08
confirming one’s own position and, in
00:58:12
a sense, a defense mechanism, a
00:58:14
state of internal discomfort,
00:58:18
bad conscience, fear, this is
00:58:21
such a
00:58:22
secondary aggression towards to those
00:58:25
who speak out who have a different
00:58:28
opinion and especially
00:58:31
try to evade war from
00:58:34
supporting regimes
00:58:38
to speak out against the majority.
00:58:40
That is, this is not very
00:58:42
rationalized, it
00:58:46
has been increasing completely in the last month, there
00:58:50
are some markers for the resource of
00:58:53
calm,
00:58:54
not even in relation to the authorities, not in
00:58:57
relation to what is happening, not in the sense of
00:59:00
normalizing ideas about the war about
00:59:03
what is happening and the calmness of such a
00:59:06
human that
00:59:09
people have at their disposal so that
00:59:11
finally it all doesn’t float like
00:59:13
red tongues of fire Whatever it is,
00:59:17
but markers it will be approximately these
00:59:22
answers or moods I don’t climb the palette
00:59:26
I don’t understand I I’m just doing
00:59:28
my own business, it’s enough for me that it’s
00:59:33
my life and that of my family, and
00:59:37
then I don’t want to think about not going in and
00:59:41
away, I’m not interested in this, it’s such a
00:59:44
protective Reflex,
00:59:46
building a barrier and controlling the
00:59:49
space of some Comfort or
00:59:52
calmness there, this is a very common
00:59:55
tactic of existence and one of
00:59:58
the ways to adapt, generally speaking, to a
01:00:00
repressive state, of course, this
01:00:04
turns into fragmentation of society, a
01:00:07
lack of solidarity
01:00:10
in the absence of
01:00:12
empathy.
01:00:13
What is compassion, sympathy for morality,
01:00:18
if you want, But this allows people
01:00:22
to exist in their niches completely. In
01:00:26
general, I can’t say comfortably, but
01:00:30
some Calmness is
01:00:32
only
01:00:35
isolated from everything unpleasant.
01:00:37
I want to listen to nothing more.
01:00:39
This is approximately the reaction. The
01:00:40
last thing I will ask about is the hope
01:00:43
that the paternalistic population associates with Putin.
01:00:48
Yes,
01:00:51
this prospect of 24 years of eternal
01:00:53
Putin,
01:00:54
what is in this Hope for the average person from
01:00:58
illusion, he rationalizes the fact that this has been
01:01:01
unfolding for a
01:01:03
quarter of a century and the situation
01:01:08
turns out to be more or less in the same place Where
01:01:10
it started
01:01:13
to come from
01:01:23
not that they love him so much
01:01:25
but he is perceived as some
01:01:29
Guarantor no change unpleasant
01:01:32
changes
01:01:34
lived for 20 years bad Is it good but
01:01:38
lived and in general better than it was in the
01:01:42
90s That's about this is logic,
01:01:47
that is, the current changes are
01:01:49
not perceived as unpleasant, they are not there,
01:01:53
it turns out there are
01:01:57
filters that do not let through
01:02:01
unwanted information, unwanted
01:02:03
arguments, people don’t want to think and
01:02:07
hear about what may be
01:02:10
following politicians
01:02:19
conscious semi-unconscious passed
01:02:29
ends this year I think
01:02:32
new interesting Levada polls will follow
01:02:35
center whose scientific director Lev
01:02:38
Gudkov today was a guest of the
01:02:39
inhale-exhale program Lev Dmitrievich I thank
01:02:42
you
01:02:43
Thank you goodbye
01:02:46
[music]
01:02:51
friends this is inhale-exhale My name is
01:02:53
Stanislav Kryuchkov today our guest
01:02:55
was the scientific director of the Levada Center for
01:02:58
sociological service, which
01:02:59
enjoys authority in the country and
01:03:01
conducts Now they are conducting these surveys that
01:03:04
each of us needs to one degree or another,
01:03:07
but I need it Stas Kryuchkov I
01:03:10
say goodbye to you subscribe to
01:03:12
Khodorkovsky Life, leave
01:03:15
your comments, share the link to this
01:03:18
video of course Take care of yourself Be
01:03:20
healthy for now
01:03:22
[music]

Description:

Лев ГУДКОВ, социолог, научный руководитель «Левада-центра», внесенного властями в РФ список «иноагентов» — гость программы Станислава Крючкова «Вдох-Выдох».О господствующих общественных настроениях, иллюзорности надежд, механизмах адаптации, распаде социальной ткани, отсутствии понимания о завтрашнем дне, конформистской консолидации, нежелании думать, повороте к Китаю, международных правовых институтах, ООН, суде в Гааге, способности к коллективной реакции и солидарности и данных социологии. В пятницу 24 марта в 17-00 на канале @khodorkovskylive Таймкоды: 00:00 Начало. Гость — Лев Гудков 00:55 Выжидание и пессимизм - господствующие социальные настроения 01:36 Динамика отношения к войне 02:20 Отношение к политическому классу 04:00 Нагнетание выдуманной угрозы 05:05 Доступ к информации 06:25 О чем думает молодежь? 07:24 Тон задает консервативное большинство 09-20 Социология действенна, просто у людей исчезли представления о будущем 10:50 Что такое тоталитарный социум? 13:11 Почему продолжает работать телевизор? 18:20 Отношение респондентов к действиям российских сил в Украине 18:50 Патернализм и отождествление себя с государством 19:46 Половина россиян желает прекращения войны. Люди не хотят слышать того, что не соответствует их представлениям 21:00 Нереалистичность переговоров 24:25 Кто такие «университетские попугаи»? 25:30 Что такое социологическое интервью 28:20 Власть уничтожает активное меньшинство 30:20 Контроль за частной жизнью 32:20 Принуждение бюрократии к репрессиям 34:30 Силовики и их роль 36:40 Система лишена страховых механизмов 38:26 Горизонт планирования в два месяца опрокидывает «стабильность» 40:20 Сокращение запросов и новые стандарты жизни 42:30 Тревожность как фоновый режим существования 44:23 Ощущение беспомощности 45:10 Михаил Жванецкий - лучший социолог 46:45 Азиатский поворот и «недружественные страны» 48:50 Гаага и доверие к международным правовым институтам 50:49 Миграционные настроения 52:00 Скрытая мобилизация 53:30 Возможность влияния на ситуацию 55:38 Разорвана социальная ткань. Страх перед возвратом массовых репрессий 57:00 Враждебность большинства к оппонентам и вторичная агрессия 59:00 Жизненная стратегия обывателя 01:01:00 Логика лояльности к Путину 01:02:34 Конец ============================= Телеграм-канал Станислава Крючкова https://t.me/photoplenka ============================= Адвокат Илья НОВИКОВ в программе «ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ»: Гаага, Мариуполь, визит Си Цзинпина, Ройзман и Навальный https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mk57MoroDQA ============================ Музыковед Михаил КАЗИНИК в программе «ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ»: История, страх и завтрашний день. Чему учит время? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ej6ZQll08K8 ============================= Киновед Наум КЛЕЙМАН в программе «ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ»: Исторический шанс, оптимизм и позитивная программа жизни https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NMWQoI37xz4 ============================= Поэт Томас ВЕНЦЛОВА в программе «ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ»: Империя и провинция, Пастернак, Ахматова, Бродский, США, эмиграция https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SZ7T-V4dt4Q ============================= Писатель Михаил ВЕЛЛЕР в программе «ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ»: Путин как пустота и что ждет впереди? youtu.be/BeZioFR2b0s ============================= Группа «БЕЛАЯ ГВАРДИЯ» и ЗОЯ ЯЩЕНКО в программе «ВДОХ-ВЫДОХ»: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=KBWk6lfZfYU ============================= БЕЛКОВСКИЙ: Путин, водка, Медведев, китайский план, Лукашенко, Павловский https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MwiHGJN5_a4 ============================= Блог Михаила Ходорковского: https://www.youtube.com/user/khodorkovskyru ============================= Плейлисты: ► Блог Ходорковского: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G7kI1pJUZbs&list=PLUpN6Si0hGl4Grv-wza2qAaE322NcoK0c ► Ответы на вопросы: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=asGc56bUvs8&list=PLUpN6Si0hGl7VIGZSi0O6vmqGTNKnqb9Y ► Интервью с Ходорковским: https://www.youtube.com/playlist?list=PLUpN6Si0hGl6NhQa9nhFk3E6bwAgml7yM ► Правозащита: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=h4WjEvgt0tg&list=PLUpN6Si0hGl7aRDjrl1vICk3jXAjFtNtG Социальные сети: ► Twitter: http://bit.ly/MBK-Twitter ► Instagram: https://www.facebook.com/unsupportedbrowser ► Telegram: https://t.me/khodorkovski ► Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/unsupportedbrowser ► ВКонтакте: http://bit.ly/MBK-VKontakte =============================

Preparing download options

popular icon
Popular
hd icon
HD video
audio icon
Only sound
total icon
All
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players

Questions about downloading video

mobile menu iconHow can I download "Лев ГУДКОВ: Пустые представления, бюрократия перед выбором и поворот в Азию / ВДОХ- ВЫДОХ" video?mobile menu icon

  • http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.

  • The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.

  • UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.

  • UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.

mobile menu iconWhich format of "Лев ГУДКОВ: Пустые представления, бюрократия перед выбором и поворот в Азию / ВДОХ- ВЫДОХ" video should I choose?mobile menu icon

  • The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.

mobile menu iconWhy does my computer freeze when loading a "Лев ГУДКОВ: Пустые представления, бюрократия перед выбором и поворот в Азию / ВДОХ- ВЫДОХ" video?mobile menu icon

  • The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.

mobile menu iconHow can I download "Лев ГУДКОВ: Пустые представления, бюрократия перед выбором и поворот в Азию / ВДОХ- ВЫДОХ" video to my phone?mobile menu icon

  • You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.

mobile menu iconHow can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Лев ГУДКОВ: Пустые представления, бюрократия перед выбором и поворот в Азию / ВДОХ- ВЫДОХ"?mobile menu icon

  • The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.

mobile menu iconHow can I save a frame from a video "Лев ГУДКОВ: Пустые представления, бюрократия перед выбором и поворот в Азию / ВДОХ- ВЫДОХ"?mobile menu icon

  • This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.

mobile menu iconWhat's the price of all this stuff?mobile menu icon

  • It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.