background top icon
background center wave icon
background filled rhombus icon
background two lines icon
background stroke rhombus icon

Download "Николай Платошкин. Интервью Красному радио."

input logo icon
Video tags
|

Video tags

Время Платошкина
платошкин последнее
СССР
хрущев
Ленин
Subtitles
|

Subtitles

subtitles menu arrow
  • ruRussian
Download
00:00:00
Nikolai Nikolaevich the people's forces the
00:00:03
left we will say so have the teachings of
00:00:06
Lenin, first of all you can't say
00:00:09
People's power you are an orthodox dinosaur we must
00:00:11
say the left movement is so good the left
00:00:13
movement has the teachings of Lenin Karl Marx
00:00:16
No it's not called that it's called
00:00:19
Toli sulo Marxism or suo Marxism I
00:00:23
just forgot koche can I say no
00:00:30
I hope that the young will forgive me so
00:00:32
after all let’s take our
00:00:35
country like this We have the teachings of Lenin What
00:00:39
teachings do our class friends rely on in
00:00:44
quotes these are you
00:00:47
mean the capitalists see they are what brother But
00:00:51
we don’t no teachings teaching - it’s all
00:00:54
artificial remember how it is Grie say
00:01:01
tomorrow and will be a chicken
00:01:05
that this is the person who doesn’t care about
00:01:08
today Yes, that’s me, that is, the capitalist is
00:01:11
telling you so spit on all these
00:01:13
chimeras, you’ll get some dough, drink a beer,
00:01:16
go somewhere, tear it off will come the
00:01:19
next day you will get dough buy
00:01:23
a beer Well, the
00:01:25
yoke with the
00:01:31
poet is proudly written in the Russian Constitution,
00:01:34
but there is no logic, this is the sun,
00:01:37
what do you understand, man, that’s about it, I don’t
00:01:39
care in principle, the sun, this is an approximate
00:01:43
translation Yes, we don’t have any
00:01:44
worldview, we are on the world without
00:01:47
asking to know when the brewery is open here,
00:01:51
what hours and when there is fresh beer
00:01:58
in a second Our species has aged H
00:02:02
sapi man has grown from the animal world and
00:02:05
by the way he grew up then Well, from
00:02:08
when do we even count before us, there
00:02:11
were Neanderthals,
00:02:12
Denisovan people, this in honor of a cave in the
00:02:15
Altai Territory, by the way, before that
00:02:18
there were tikan
00:02:25
[music]
00:02:29
Well, about like us. And if
00:02:31
you look at it like this, they are not extinct now in some places.
00:02:33
Yes, they were stronger, they had a more
00:02:37
powerful chest. They could live in a
00:02:40
colder climate. Well, because this is how
00:02:42
their body was structured, they were
00:02:44
so squat, they kept the heat there, I don’t
00:02:47
know, but an average Neanderthal could have
00:02:50
raised our ancestor. I don’t know,
00:02:52
toss it in, let’s say, and catch it again, they would have been
00:02:54
healthy, but they would have died out because our species
00:02:58
is considered from the moment when man became
00:03:00
engage in abstract thinking What
00:03:02
is this worldview? Yes, the
00:03:05
Neanderthals hunted there, I don’t know, they ate a
00:03:09
mammoth. They slept, they lit a fire,
00:03:13
they could use it, and so on.
00:03:16
Yes, every day the mammoths disappeared. They
00:03:18
followed them, which means they are the same hunters
00:03:21
as tigers. I don’t know. There are lions there.
00:03:30
figurines, that is, to engage in some kind of
00:03:32
[ __ ] from the point of view of everyday life. This is
00:03:35
how it is now, why do we need ideology? Does it feed you or
00:03:38
something? All these beliefs of yours.
00:03:41
But when a person began to develop
00:03:43
abstract thinking, look, he began to
00:03:46
build cities, he learned to cultivate
00:03:49
cereals, because he is not just I saw
00:03:51
some kind of grass growing there
00:03:58
[music]
00:04:02
and why does it grow here and not there?
00:04:05
Or maybe we should grow it and so on, yes, that
00:04:08
is, the higher the level of abstract
00:04:10
thinking a person has, the more of a
00:04:11
person he is, fascism and fascism is always an
00:04:15
extreme form of capitalism he says that we do
00:04:18
n’t need all this Zamora fascism when
00:04:20
it was born In what year do you know
00:04:28
someone and here is the famous
00:04:32
Nazi greeting it was taken from the Italian
00:04:34
fascists And they took it in turn in
00:04:38
Ancient Rome they say this Roman
00:04:40
greeting is a fascist he what else do you need once barking
00:04:44
says whatever you want Well, you want to punch
00:04:48
someone in the eye, yes, but only to the one to whom we
00:04:50
tell Yes, in general, we don’t need it at all. But
00:04:53
before fascism, people also did what they
00:04:55
wanted. Absolutely right. Absolutely right,
00:04:58
and that’s why
00:05:00
fascism says we are a fascist - This is real
00:05:04
human ideology we don’t demand anything from anyone we do
00:05:06
n’t need to, well, you want to
00:05:09
go to a brothel Why should you
00:05:11
think about whether this is good from a
00:05:15
moral point of view, morality, this is what Hitler
00:05:17
said, all this is too much to say, we should
00:05:21
behave like this, he said it all the time
00:05:29
uh, she understand, she’s a Suva person.
00:05:32
Sorry, you can’t write on the streets. Yes, he’ll
00:05:34
tell you why you can’t ask a question at the World Cup if
00:05:38
you want to. Yes, you can’t beat someone, you can’t
00:05:40
offend the weak. Why can’t you why
00:05:42
you all the time?
00:05:48
you see, they were the fascists
00:05:50
who realized that if they proclaimed this,
00:05:54
or as Old Man Makhno says, we don’t
00:05:56
need any state there, rob nab
00:05:59
then they will be robbed too. Therefore, any
00:06:02
fascism is looking for an object
00:06:05
of robbery, which means that the Italian fascists have
00:06:08
Ethiopia there, Libya, they need them, and this is
00:06:11
this We are not people, we are people, but they are not, yes, Hitler has it.
00:06:14
You understand, first the Jews are there,
00:06:16
then the Slavs, not us, the Germans are normal. But
00:06:18
we can’t rob ourselves without letting our
00:06:21
whole theory apply to ourselves.
00:06:24
What if someone is stronger than Hitler?
00:06:27
can it give you something in the eye? No, no,
00:06:29
comrade,
00:06:30
this doesn’t concern us, this concerns all of them, this
00:06:32
concerns all of them, this concerns the Armed Forces, these nations are
00:06:35
so inferior, let’s say,
00:06:38
capitalism is all about this, just like
00:06:41
You understand, if I’m rich, if yes,
00:06:44
no, I’m not a fascist you say that I’m a liberal But if
00:06:47
I’m rich, then I’ll win in court against you and not
00:06:50
you because I’ll hire the best lawyer And
00:06:53
you’re a weakling, so in general it’s better not to
00:06:55
meddle anywhere, and finally, if you do
00:06:57
n’t have enough money, you’re a fool yourself, remember to marry
00:07:01
Balzaminov Yes, that merchant is there
00:07:03
asks the official How much
00:07:05
do you get? Well, that’s what he told him. He says,
00:07:07
Oh, but I say, I think that if
00:07:10
a person says he can’t
00:07:12
earn money, then he actually has no reason to live, but
00:07:14
he was so taken aback, he says, Oh, and
00:07:18
what should
00:07:20
we do with such people? into forced labor There Let the
00:07:23
cop something After all, this merchant probably did
00:07:26
n’t consider himself a fascist, it’s true, but
00:07:29
the theory of man
00:07:32
is an owl hater But if a person is poor,
00:07:35
then he’s not worthy of living with the Nazis, since
00:07:38
if a person with such a cut in his eyes is
00:07:39
also unworthy, what difference does it make? We
00:07:43
we say that all people are brothers, One
00:07:46
for all, all for one, what needs to be seen is that a
00:07:49
person is in trouble, he needs to help, he needs to
00:07:52
extend a hand and not just say, well, in
00:07:55
trouble, but does this concern me or something?
00:07:58
When it touches me,
00:08:00
then I will sort it out, that is the germ of
00:08:02
fascism is in capitalism itself, as in a
00:08:05
society based on rejection of each
00:08:08
other on the principle Man is a wolf to man
00:08:10
Yes, you are preventing me from getting this
00:08:13
job Yes, I will do everything against
00:08:16
you Yes, of course, everything that is there does not
00:08:19
contradict the Criminal Code, but as
00:08:22
Marx said, the EU
00:08:29
sweat before the threat, Marx added to be
00:08:32
hanged, so our
00:08:35
socialist society is more complicated, it’s
00:08:37
about like a school. Yes, if you
00:08:39
Ask first-graders Do you want to
00:08:41
go to school? Yes, well, what’s the point of
00:08:45
sitting there? You better
00:08:48
go for a walk there, then Yes, if you
00:08:51
If you don’t educate people with the
00:08:54
help of the state Because we do
00:08:56
n’t have any other tool So far, that’s
00:08:59
all it will be, and fascism doesn’t
00:09:02
educate anyone, it says No, no, no
00:09:04
Do what you want But not in relation
00:09:06
to you and me But here the attitude of all these
00:09:08
people, we are not interfering with you in any way,
00:09:11
now hundreds of people will come running in the comments.
00:09:14
Well, with approximately this opinion,
00:09:16
I don’t want the state to prohibit me from doing anything,
00:09:29
then these are all
00:09:33
the bastards of the council. No, they’ll come
00:09:35
to record some kind of composition. And
00:09:37
what- Someday daddy will bring
00:09:41
his girlfriend here, you know, the big-lipped,
00:09:45
stupidly stupid one, but daddy has money
00:09:48
and he’ll say don’t
00:09:50
write down this [ __ ], I’ll pay you,
00:09:54
write down this one, my favorite one,
00:09:57
she wants it, I’m going to the distribution of this for
00:10:01
what we have now and it’s happening here
00:10:04
now if you turn off the plywood. Everyone has
00:10:06
a phonogram, that is, the people. It
00:10:10
’s just going to be amazing to listen to there.
00:10:13
Most of the comrades have nothing there. And what about our people,
00:10:15
they don’t know how to sing, or maybe their voices
00:10:18
are gone? No, of course, but it’s just that
00:10:21
these people don’t have the strength of connection and money to
00:10:24
get through, and finally, when all these
00:10:28
people say I need your advice, I
00:10:31
’ll figure it out myself. But when the wheel of the
00:10:34
richer people rolls over them, that’s where the
00:10:37
struggle for socially begins. What is this,
00:10:41
why wasn’t my book published? But this is from afar
00:10:45
this is a disgrace where is
00:10:47
the state where are
00:10:48
law enforcement agencies looking where is
00:10:50
public opinion Sorry but say that
00:11:00
And the most important thing is clear that to any
00:11:03
creative person who has
00:11:05
some other organ the bad council
00:11:07
rejected something Well of course he will
00:11:10
walk and talk Well Well,
00:11:13
if you take the singers and singers of the
00:11:15
Soviet period Well, whom we found
00:11:17
Well, who will tell me that they have bad
00:11:20
voices? Well, who understands? You
00:11:23
may not agree with the repertoire there.
00:11:29
Magomayev is
00:11:36
voiceless singers illiterate musicians
00:11:40
Well, what about I want now
00:11:42
a person will come in the comments I want to
00:11:45
do what Well, here’s what to do if this
00:11:49
person wants to be interrupted by someone
00:11:51
richer Well, that means he ran into that
00:11:55
freedom in quotes that he wanted here I
00:11:58
understand
00:12:00
you, in fact, this is not so I
00:12:04
must say there is their advice, they are now in a
00:12:08
different way,
00:12:09
the question is just what are they missing And
00:12:12
what are they not missing the boy’s word from
00:12:15
their point of view, the most beautiful Well, that’s
00:12:18
how they think You see, that’s their point
00:12:19
view And to be honest,
00:12:21
several people have already contacted us,
00:12:23
Deputy Loko, who were
00:12:25
outraged that their film scripts were killed
00:12:29
on formal grounds, the reasons there
00:12:32
are Well, I don’t know, maybe the film
00:12:34
turned out not very good either, but
00:12:37
the reasons for which they were not allowed to
00:12:39
film the filming or something they didn’t receive
00:12:41
government support Yes, they
00:12:43
understand, they’re not even bureaucratic And
00:12:46
some of them are generally semi-funny But the
00:12:49
experts will tell you this, they decided that what
00:12:52
has changed is Absolutely nothing about this, it’s
00:12:55
just a different matter then VKi
00:13:00
You understand, that’s when a person says Yes,
00:13:02
we will support you or on the contrary, let’s
00:13:05
say no one would sanction
00:13:08
songs or compositions. Well, with some kind of
00:13:10
obscene content, I’ll give it to you in the eye, let’s
00:13:12
assume something like that because of the
00:13:14
salt, why should we, as a society,
00:13:17
sponsor it with
00:13:19
taxpayers’ money, not with our own? for their
00:13:21
[ __ ] like this
00:13:24
[music]
00:13:28
that Soviet cinema and Soviet music
00:13:30
They were different, let’s say if I can
00:13:33
watch some Soviet film
00:13:35
and clearly say it was filmed there in the
00:13:37
fifties or for example in the
00:13:38
sixties, that is, it doesn’t matter, well,
00:13:42
genres were somewhat different and the vision of the
00:13:44
problems may even be problems Even they
00:13:46
were the same but the vision was different
00:13:48
it was noticeable And not only there by the
00:13:50
costumes Yes by the fashion you can determine
00:13:53
seven there No of course by the way they were solved
00:13:59
ru saying so that the person so that the plot was
00:14:03
fascinating but at the same time, so that people
00:14:05
go out and think,
00:14:07
think, films are being made now so that
00:14:10
people don’t think this is the equivalent of a beer.
00:14:13
Yes, here’s a man. Went there, Lenin,
00:14:16
let’s assume Why was he against
00:14:18
excessive drinking there,
00:14:20
not because he was an alcoholic, some kind of
00:14:22
hypocrite OVO, but no one saw once in
00:14:26
emiya
00:14:29
kani there to talk Well, you have to
00:14:32
order something there in some restaurant
00:14:34
eatery, otherwise they won’t let you in. Well,
00:14:36
they ordered a
00:14:37
mug of beer in Switzerland So that
00:14:40
Lenin drank more than a mug, no one saw
00:14:42
Why And Lenin thought that this was
00:14:45
just a waste of time now I’m going to drink two
00:14:46
mugs. Well, as they say, I’m free
00:14:49
until the end of the day. Why waste this
00:14:54
time? He reasoned something like this, now
00:14:56
it’s the other way around. Well, what are you and what are you?
00:15:00
Why should you rack your brains over these
00:15:02
thoughts? And you don’t drink. Well done, too.
00:15:05
go play computer games there,
00:15:08
don’t like it either, well, watch some, watch them
00:15:09
now, they are showing animated films for
00:15:12
adults.
00:15:15
You see, this is what
00:15:17
used to be in the heading Visiting a fairy tale.
00:15:19
There, people under 14 watched it. Yes, there is a
00:15:23
children’s movie, a children’s movie for life,
00:15:26
there is something with
00:15:30
there, artists are not even needed In general, a
00:15:32
long time ago, why did they draw
00:15:34
anyone with computer graphics?
00:15:37
Even with three ears, there’s no problem at all, there’s
00:15:39
only Shrek, that’s what’s standing there Yes, a
00:15:42
brilliant work
00:15:44
was watched there by hundreds of millions, maybe even
00:15:45
billions, but there’s noo Well, well This is what they
00:15:49
would have shown to schoolchildren in Soviet times,
00:15:50
probably yes. Well, well, in the
00:15:53
program of the movement for a new Socialism there are
00:15:55
outs;
00:15:59
you will be in the program;
00:16:10
take
00:16:12
the right one there And this one knows this
00:16:14
director, that’s why we’ll swing him
00:16:21
all for one, so that this
00:16:24
ideology is encouraged, so we will
00:16:27
proceed from the fact that these multi-
00:16:29
composite VS films
00:16:32
are promoted. Can the x council be wrong?
00:16:34
Yes, of
00:16:35
course there were mistakes there in Soviet times there
00:16:38
were also examples Give me
00:16:41
now and I’m thinking just that I’m just sure
00:16:43
that they were, of course And ours there are
00:16:46
outstanding Well, let’s say yes Here’s an example
00:16:50
I had no idea in Soviet times
00:16:52
for example 201
00:16:55
[music]
00:16:59
con life regarding this society yes
00:17:03
Previously, he supported it later I quickly
00:17:06
saw the light when, by the way, I realized that
00:17:09
there was no advice, but there was no money for him, so to
00:17:12
speak, well, such films are
00:17:16
painful, they are not good, so he went there, he was
00:17:19
beaten by Rezanov, at the end of his life,
00:17:22
no one gave him anything,
00:17:31
he would have been filmed, so the year he
00:17:34
came out, but allegedly saying that Suslov, who
00:17:37
was then in charge of
00:17:39
ideology, saw it or even
00:17:42
just saw the poster and
00:17:44
I banned it. Well, then during
00:17:47
perestroika there, when these many
00:17:49
films were taken off the shelves,
00:17:53
VM was surprised
00:17:59
that it was just the film Man from Nowhere, it’s
00:18:02
not like it’s about the Soviet one in my opinion,
00:18:04
well, in short, about the clash of the morality of our
00:18:07
society with the morality of savages Yes, well,
00:18:11
who in themselves may not be
00:18:13
bad people Yes, but
00:18:15
they are infected with all this Well, in short, there were
00:18:18
clashes with capitalism,
00:18:20
but for some reason they didn’t happen, then Votka
00:18:29
also didn’t have any concepts before
00:18:33
perestroika this is the Ilcha outpost Well, or I’m
00:18:36
20 years old there in different variations
00:18:38
the film is called differently, in my opinion it’s just
00:18:40
brilliant Who wants to see how
00:18:43
our country lived in the early sixties What
00:18:45
people thought about what they puzzled over
00:18:49
What they argued about what’s good what’s bad is that it’s
00:18:54
just pano’s guide
00:19:00
without a plot And he’s like this, you know, it
00:19:03
really seems like a chronicle,
00:19:05
but it’s just the lives of young people. People
00:19:07
are described, it seems like there are no
00:19:09
dramatic turns there,
00:19:11
no one kills anyone, no one there
00:19:14
divorces each other in horror and it seems like
00:19:17
a film like this, as if the party
00:19:19
authorities decided, it’s about nothing, it may be good, but it’s also
00:19:27
brilliant, it’s just that it’s up to everyone
00:19:31
to decide, so there were mistakes, but again they
00:19:35
will always be as long as the state exists, the
00:19:37
state is a
00:19:39
bureaucratic mechanism, to a greater extent to a
00:19:41
lesser extent, but even the Socialist
00:19:43
even socialist,
00:19:46
let’s say the same Vladimirovich Lenin,
00:19:49
when he was already ill, when he was in
00:19:54
Gorki, but even to the extent when
00:19:57
he had his last stroke there and he
00:19:59
could no longer speak or write. Well, to
00:20:03
that extent, he wrote the so-called
00:20:06
last letters Yes, here are the last letters
00:20:08
of Lenin, we usually say that he
00:20:11
basically gave a characterization of
00:20:13
Stalin to Trotsky because he was very
00:20:15
afraid that with his departure the party
00:20:18
might split due to personal
00:20:19
contradictions Yes, that was all there too, but the
00:20:22
main thing in these letters is completely
00:20:24
different in Niš
00:20:28
[music]
00:20:30
with what was on the third year Well,
00:20:33
when he got sick, he was not entirely
00:20:36
happy to put it mildly. But to be honest, I was
00:20:39
very dissatisfied with what he
00:20:42
wrote. Yes, we did a lot of
00:20:46
heroic deeds there, we defeated the interventionists
00:20:48
there, the White Guards are really in power
00:20:50
there. in the hands of representatives of
00:20:52
Christian workers. But the worst thing that
00:20:54
haunts us. I’m exaggerating this, but he
00:20:57
wrote it is that we have inherited the
00:20:59
worst bureaucratic habits of the old
00:21:03
regime, that instead of us there are the old
00:21:05
tsarist officials who, well, glumilino,
00:21:08
before everyone there, demanded that everyone there wear a hat in front of them.
00:21:10
they were filming who were winding up
00:21:13
all the affairs there, Lenin wrote to us,
00:21:16
Unfortunately, the owls of the bureaucracy
00:21:19
What Mayakovsky also wrote about, remember about the
00:21:21
meetings yes Or I would have won like a wolf
00:21:24
with bureaucracy There is no respect for the mandate
00:21:27
Lenin came to two conclusions
00:21:31
then, but unfortunately you see they were not
00:21:34
heard because it seems to me that
00:21:37
Lenin’s last letter And their party
00:21:41
somehow didn’t understand. I would say this because
00:21:44
I understood or didn’t want to understand, no, I didn’t
00:21:46
understand. I think that there was some kind of desire there, you
00:21:48
just see Lenin was perceived as
00:21:51
Ilyich comes out to the podium. Yes, and for example, what about
00:21:54
the situation in the country First second third
00:21:57
need to be done First second third or is he
00:22:00
writing something about the next tasks of the
00:22:02
Soviet government Everything is right there, this is what is
00:22:04
needed, this is this and here it’s like
00:22:07
a reflection, the impression was created that
00:22:09
they are not finished, maybe that Lenin
00:22:13
now I’ve started to write this, and then
00:22:15
he’ll probably add something else, something for now, it
00:22:17
seems like someone wrote Lenin, two
00:22:20
things need to be sharply
00:22:23
diluted. The Soviet party apparatus,
00:22:26
including workers. Well, for example, here’s the
00:22:28
Central Committee of the Party. Yes, which Well, that’s
00:22:30
real manages everything Yes, the
00:22:33
same number of workers from the
00:22:36
machine should be added there. Well, so that the connection with the people would
00:22:39
be more or less clear. Well,
00:22:43
apparently they decided how, well, what is the Worker? Well, well, he
00:22:47
came from the machine and will decide the
00:22:50
issue of helping the Chinese revolutionaries,
00:22:52
for example, or no Well, where did he get
00:22:56
such information? Yes, in principle, what
00:22:58
Vladimir Ivich proposes is actually
00:23:00
correct. Yes, but you have to think about it, and the most
00:23:03
important thing is that he wrote here, of course he
00:23:05
stunned everyone. And by the way, those who now
00:23:09
consider us some kind of fighters against
00:23:11
dictatorship poured over these weirdos Yes,
00:23:14
what Lenin wrote about Socialism is not
00:23:18
Marx’s, not Engels’s about Socialism as a
00:23:20
transitional phase, so there is capitalism with
00:23:23
it. It’s clear that Marx described it in
00:23:25
Capital, he just laid it all out
00:23:26
normally,
00:23:29
too, everyone understands Yes, from each according to his
00:23:31
abilities to each according to his need But
00:23:34
between them, in order to build from one to
00:23:36
another, there lies a long transition
00:23:38
period somewhere less long in
00:23:41
some country more. It’s called
00:23:42
Socialism, no one has written anything about it.
00:23:44
Well, really Yes, they wrote that it
00:23:47
will be that there will be a process of growth
00:23:51
from one society to another. Socialism
00:23:54
And what kind of socialism will it be? Socialism than what,
00:23:58
in other words, Where is the textbook? This is why we need to do this
00:24:01
now. Many obscurantists
00:24:04
say, for example, lism is necessary there. A
00:24:06
foreign trade monopoly
00:24:08
or a
00:24:10
political dictatorship has never been written about by Lenin,
00:24:13
that these are obligatory factors. Yes, they
00:24:15
can be of course, depending on this
00:24:17
or that country. But Stalin, for example,
00:24:19
believed that after the war, the new
00:24:21
socialist
00:24:23
countries of Europe needed a dictatorship and a
00:24:29
new form of transition to socialism.
00:24:31
I call it People’s
00:24:33
Democracy, a multi-party system, a united front of
00:24:37
different forces, which was not the case in Soviet Russia.
00:24:40
Stalin said, but simply because
00:24:42
we have it turned out that there was a civil war, a
00:24:45
civil war. It doesn’t have to happen
00:24:47
during the transition from one system to
00:24:49
another, so Lenin called it that
00:24:53
fasting
00:24:58
is a system of civilized cooperators,
00:25:00
Lenin said. In my opinion, then it’s
00:25:03
simple, yes, Lenin wrote during the non-
00:25:06
new economic policy that he the
00:25:08
very same beginning and where the market
00:25:10
mechanisms were, well, somehow the majority of
00:25:13
the parties believed that p - well, there for
00:25:16
several years Yes, now we’ll somehow
00:25:18
come to our senses Then we strangled them all there
00:25:20
again Well, that’s what actually
00:25:22
happened Yes, although Stalin in the twenty-
00:25:24
fifth year, together with Bukharin, he said that
00:25:26
he was not serious, and for a long time that the fist is a
00:25:28
peaceful puma gateway to Socialism. And Bukharin,
00:25:31
as you remember, and Stalin said,
00:25:33
enrich
00:25:34
for which then Bukharin suffered. Although in
00:25:38
general, he and Stalin then said it
00:25:40
together that this would last for a long time, that is,
00:25:43
Lenin I was tormented by the
00:25:47
thought that how can we make the economy
00:25:50
more efficient than under capitalism And at the same
00:25:53
time, so that, as under capitalism, it
00:25:55
pours money into only one pocket and
00:25:57
vgi to everyone and he came to the model of cooperation
00:26:01
Yes, well, the simplest cooperative that
00:26:04
we all know is the collective farm Yes
00:26:06
collective farming everyone laughs at this
00:26:09
But nothing is more effective in
00:26:11
reality No one has yet come up with a cooperative movement in Europe, the
00:26:13
cooperative movement is flourishing, they have their
00:26:17
own banks there, they have their own
00:26:19
manufacturing enterprises there, their own
00:26:22
stores, smm,
00:26:30
that a person is new until he is educated, he
00:26:32
cannot work for free just like that Well,
00:26:35
preferably but he doesn’t want to do it yet,
00:26:37
of course they tried and introduced it,
00:26:39
subbotniks, for example, well, they built it from
00:26:43
what was And when a person is told Well,
00:26:46
go and work on your day off and for free
00:26:49
Well, the conscious will say, yes, we work for ourselves,
00:26:52
and the
00:26:54
majority of others came from that world
00:26:58
[music ]
00:26:59
that is, civilized cooperation is a
00:27:02
combination of market mechanisms so
00:27:04
that the end result of labor is
00:27:07
cooperation, that is, general Yes, it was good for everyone, and
00:27:12
this idea of ​​Lenin, in my opinion, was not understood,
00:27:14
of course in the USSR, you
00:27:17
know this kind of cooperation. In the applied sense of the word,
00:27:20
there, of course, it has always
00:27:22
existed Consumer cooperation
00:27:24
But it was just the purchase of
00:27:27
goods,
00:27:28
so the population did it, the cooperatives
00:27:31
bought and sold Hence the name of the
00:27:34
rural stores Rural rural
00:27:37
consumer cooperatives was called that, but
00:27:40
Lenin did not just mean the
00:27:42
utilitarian task of buying onions from the population there
00:27:45
and selling, he meant that in general
00:27:48
the state would don’t abandon it, it
00:27:51
should become a structure of civilized,
00:27:54
independent relatively
00:27:55
cooperative units, but you see,
00:27:59
Unfortunately, this whole theory How Lenin
00:28:01
could have done this, of course, could have been developed in detail,
00:28:04
explained to
00:28:06
everyone, he simply didn’t have time Yes,
00:28:09
his path in life had ended And
00:28:12
others turned out to be Well, not very good at it Are you
00:28:14
ready or what in modern language
00:28:17
can a small business be called cooperation? Yes, I
00:28:19
think that it is possible and what to do. How can this be?
00:28:23
After all, as you know, any small business
00:28:26
strives to become big,
00:28:28
and here there are two ways to become
00:28:31
big, so if you ask anyone Who
00:28:33
makes shurma, let’s assume Well so
00:28:35
to make it clearer Well, here’s a classic Little
00:28:37
bi or bakes pies there for sale It doesn’t
00:28:41
matter whether you think seriously These people
00:28:44
believe that they will become billionaires
00:28:47
someday Yes, most of these people
00:28:50
all over the world, by the way, not only here they are, well,
00:28:54
not just right here they
00:28:56
make ends meet, although this happens too. Well, from this
00:28:59
you started there, I don’t know. You
00:29:02
will never become a billionaire, people like
00:29:04
Elon Musk beat Gase, they show everything on them.
00:29:07
But this is an
00:29:09
exception that confirms the rule and not
00:29:12
one of them could get promoted. without
00:29:14
the state, of course, in no case. But
00:29:17
how can small businesses be made so that small businesses,
00:29:20
as you say, become
00:29:22
richer? First of all, in my opinion, this absolutely does not
00:29:25
contradict
00:29:27
the idea of ​​socialism. As such,
00:29:29
Socialism is not about the fact that everyone should become
00:29:32
equally poor. No, how once
00:29:35
Socialism What is communism about? That everyone
00:29:37
should
00:29:38
become equally rich both in the
00:29:41
material and cultural sense of the
00:29:44
word, well now hundreds of people
00:29:46
will come and write in the comments. And who will
00:29:48
clean the toilets?
00:29:59
create
00:30:00
a cooperative, that is, there are several
00:30:03
shawarma producers, let’s assume if
00:30:05
they combine their efforts in sales
00:30:08
first yes Well, for example, why should we
00:30:11
all keep 150 stalls there and
00:30:13
pay rent for them? Yes, maybe we can
00:30:16
make one We produce there, he sells, we
00:30:19
divide the profit from such cooperation which in
00:30:22
Europe, but everywhere you go already to
00:30:24
cooperative production,
00:30:29
you will be meat, this is us, using the example of
00:30:31
shawarma, you are there, I don’t know, you will
00:30:33
buy spices, this is always the scale of production,
00:30:36
this is people will always get rich, because
00:30:38
collective farms, too, you see, here we have a collective farm, they
00:30:41
say yes in the USSR there were collective farms
00:30:44
not just millionaires but billionaires But
00:30:47
where the people lived there were much more prosperous than
00:30:50
there I don’t know Well, let’s assume there is a
00:30:52
Soviet engineer there, you know, that is,
00:30:55
because they united, it’s just
00:30:58
always, even if you take ordinary
00:31:00
capitalism Yes, mergers and acquisitions are constantly going on
00:31:03
Yes One enterprise wants to
00:31:06
absorb a competitor to increase
00:31:09
production another to take his
00:31:11
market Well, that is, to grow Yes, but under
00:31:15
capitalism this happens every day,
00:31:17
but it all goes into the pockets of two or three people,
00:31:19
the owners Yes, because the scale of production has increased
00:31:22
or the market has increased, as a
00:31:24
rule, the workers whom they exploit
00:31:28
In general, it’s even worse for them, in fact,
00:31:30
yes, because so many workers are no longer
00:31:32
necessary if we unite, and under
00:31:35
socialism the same process leads
00:31:38
to the fact that the more collective your type of
00:31:41
production, the more prosperous you live.
00:31:44
You see, this is all simple, in
00:31:46
fact, just alone enterprises can
00:31:49
belong to a small collective, this is a
00:31:52
cooperative, others, to a large collective,
00:31:55
this is the state, this is also a collective, but
00:31:57
it’s also big. Draw parallels between
00:32:00
what you just said and the Soviet
00:32:04
period, in Soviet times, you see in our country
00:32:07
Socialism was developing Yes, he, too,
00:32:10
all sorts of weirdos are chatting that Khrushchev took
00:32:13
some kind of then he abolished the political dictatorship
00:32:15
Although Stalin actually did it Yes
00:32:17
and he did it correctly, well, he attributes it all,
00:32:20
for example, Khrushchev
00:32:22
attributes something else to Brezhnev, look,
00:32:23
we had different socialism at different times
00:32:25
[music] Well, for
00:32:26
example,
00:32:29
it was not where most of the
00:32:33
control levers were market Although the
00:32:35
state under Nepa owned, as the
00:32:38
Bolsheviks then said, commanding
00:32:40
heights transport heavy industry
00:32:43
large metallurgical factories
00:32:45
engineering But trade in
00:32:48
consumer goods there production of fabrics and
00:32:50
production of food products, strictly speaking,
00:32:53
was then the participant's
00:32:56
individual owner services services restaurants
00:33:00
there that's all Why it was closed down
00:33:03
NP I once again said that Stalin
00:33:05
actually argued with Trotsky. Trotsky said
00:33:08
that this is all [ __ ], this means a departure
00:33:11
from socialism in general in itself, that it was
00:33:14
you and the fist who gathered there
00:33:16
brother, it was Stalin who said And Bukharin
00:33:19
that the fist is growing Socialism they They said
00:33:22
in response something like the following: Yes, that
00:33:27
while we have command levers, we have a dictum, we
00:33:32
can press the fist with a
00:33:34
tax, we can straighten it a little, that is, we
00:33:38
have power if we have Political
00:33:40
power, we KTU the direction of movement Where
00:33:43
this fist should either go with us Well,
00:33:47
or he no longer will be a fist Yes, but
00:33:49
why did they turn it off? Not because Marx
00:33:52
wrote it somewhere in Engels. Moreover,
00:33:54
Lenin has an international situation, that is, a
00:33:58
certain feature that is not inherent in
00:34:01
socialism in general, or Soviet
00:34:04
socialism, or Polish; it’s just that when
00:34:06
Hitler came to power, it became clear
00:34:08
there would be war therefore, all the country’s resources
00:34:12
must be combined in one hand, including the village, if there would
00:34:15
not have been this military threat,
00:34:18
which was seen in time, but there would have been no
00:34:22
collectivization because
00:34:23
collectivization was seen as a
00:34:25
source of quickly obtaining funds in the
00:34:27
form of grain exports in order to
00:34:29
buy in the West as soon as possible
00:34:32
industrial equipment well-known
00:34:35
expression steel we need to jump over
00:34:37
the period that they went through in 200 years in
00:34:39
10 otherwise we will be crushed again if there weren’t
00:34:42
this military threat let’s imagine
00:34:45
Well, here Socialism would have developed
00:34:47
differently, I think that with us it would have gone
00:34:49
further collectivization
00:34:51
would have happened for us anyway, because if this is the law of
00:34:54
production,
00:35:00
girls carry out and live better. But it’s one thing
00:35:04
when you thought that this would
00:35:07
happen slowly. People will look and
00:35:09
say, Yes, it’s really better like this,
00:35:12
here it was necessary to break everyone over the
00:35:14
knee just because Hitler came to
00:35:16
power, that is, you see how some
00:35:19
situations that are not Marx
00:35:22
Enge in
00:35:30
Otto are bad in relation to calling Ren with or any other
00:35:34
impression when a
00:35:36
mortal threat hangs over you and you need to change the
00:35:39
economic life in the country, not
00:35:41
because Marx states this on the 4th third page
00:35:44
because otherwise you will not survive,
00:35:46
just further development of the post-war
00:35:49
country Well, before
00:35:58
he banned abortions after the war for some
00:36:00
time. Well, again, not because it was written in the
00:36:03
program of the Bolsheviks or the
00:36:04
Communists because the
00:36:06
huge decline in the male population
00:36:09
was the task Well, how would this decline be sharp
00:36:12
to make up for but also believed that under these
00:36:14
conditions abortions Well, that’s how it is But
00:36:17
if the Bolsheviks limited themselves to this
00:36:21
there is no huge program for the construction of
00:36:24
housing for families of the Mas VH go this is not just
00:36:28
prohibitions Yes, this is even closer to what it is
00:36:32
but again what about abortions from Marx Engels
00:36:35
and Lenin are somehow there with
00:36:37
abortions Socialism Impossible or
00:36:40
vice versa No, it was simply dictated by
00:36:42
the situation further Monopoly of foreign
00:36:46
trade Yes Lenin, in
00:36:50
fact, by the way, Stalin was for its abolition,
00:36:53
when Lenin was sick Trotsky was for its
00:36:56
preservation
00:36:58
and they are both Stalin Trotskys
00:37:01
There was a struggle between them just then on many
00:37:03
issues and, as Lenin correctly noted,
00:37:05
the struggle was mainly of a personal nature. There were no
00:37:08
fundamental differences there. In my opinion, there were no fundamental differences.
00:37:10
Well, they both just wanted to be
00:37:13
the first; no one questioned Lenin’s authority.
00:37:16
Although Lenin did not
00:37:17
hold any positions, but this there was
00:37:20
Lenin, his position was Lenin, the
00:37:23
smartest, the most intelligent, the wisest,
00:37:26
they turned to him, and Lenin’s position was
00:37:29
very correct, he said something like this in
00:37:32
general. A monopoly of foreign trade is
00:37:34
not a sign of socialism, but in our
00:37:38
specific conditions, twenty-two twenty-
00:37:40
three, when us and
00:37:42
the West are very bad at that time they had not yet
00:37:44
settled these relations They have not
00:37:47
yet recognized us diplomatically many
00:37:49
began in the year twenty-four this is
00:37:50
all the streak of recognition so-called
00:37:53
now it is necessary Why Because it is necessary to
00:37:55
accumulate everything in the hands of the state
00:37:57
so that
00:37:58
this is what we lost during the wars that is,
00:38:02
Monopoly means that we, the state,
00:38:04
will dictate that there is
00:38:07
no need to buy perfume abroad yet. But machines are necessary
00:38:09
because, well, now they are more important, but
00:38:12
Lenin is precisely the current period, if the
00:38:16
economy gets back on its feet, then he did not see
00:38:18
any sign of obligatory there should
00:38:20
be a Monopoly,
00:38:28
you know, like how the monks in the monasteries sit
00:38:30
there, something bison, but as Lenin wrote,
00:38:33
read, read, live together,
00:38:36
they couldn’t, that’s the Monopoly of foreign
00:38:39
trade, everything where Marx Ege Len
00:38:42
says Socialism, the dash is obligatory
00:38:45
Monopoly of foreign trade,
00:38:47
maybe it’s by the way in It
00:38:50
often happens in capitalist countries. It’s precisely in such
00:38:52
periods that post-war military horses
00:38:55
happen that nonito zeri from this suggests that post-
00:38:59
war England it was England. A
00:39:02
socialist country, right. Well,
00:39:04
why What kind of stupidity? In short,
00:39:07
you see, they say Khrushchev
00:39:11
canceled some artels there or something else
00:39:13
this is all sweat, this is still the same nonsense
00:39:16
Khrushchev, on the contrary,
00:39:19
to liberate the collective farm, collective farming
00:39:22
is good
00:39:23
when at the initial stage when you can
00:39:28
Well, decide What is the price of your products Well, for
00:39:31
example, here we are gathered there on the collective farm,
00:39:33
let's grow sugar beets
00:39:37
because they are more profitable And in that time
00:39:41
of course It was after the military development of the
00:39:44
collective farm that they robbed in a good sense a second
00:39:46
time because it was necessary to look for a source of
00:39:48
restoration of the national economy,
00:39:50
look at the
00:39:52
dream under Kolya,
00:39:57
our peasantry created this Yes, from
00:39:59
which then all the surplus product was taken,
00:40:02
but not for the pitchforks in Courchevel But for
00:40:06
the construction of factories that then
00:40:08
they came to this village in the form of tractors,
00:40:10
combines and so on, and it would seem that
00:40:12
the village began to breathe, everything was fine, the peasants
00:40:15
began to understand that they had made a sacrifice,
00:40:17
they now began to live better,
00:40:20
work, and then the war, imagine the war
00:40:23
that destroyed the Armed Forces to zero, just
00:40:25
before Sheremetyevo, better than RAO ours suffered,
00:40:29
who
00:40:30
restored, again at the expense of the
00:40:32
village, again they took it from the collective farms
00:40:36
Well, almost everything, yes, because no one
00:40:39
gave us loans abroad at that time,
00:40:41
Stalin asked for a loan from America, they didn’t
00:40:45
give it to us, you just understand, so the
00:40:47
village literally had to spend
00:40:49
15 years for the second time the money practically expired
00:40:52
in order to raise the country, but then it
00:40:55
began to
00:40:57
give the collective farmers passports and the
00:41:00
state sharply increased the prices for their
00:41:02
products. Because before, well, the collective farms were
00:41:04
simply told that
00:41:06
next year you must produce so much
00:41:08
grain there; the price is none of your business; you give us the grain
00:41:11
Let me make it clear that in these conditions, well,
00:41:14
what difference does it make whether there is cooperation or not,
00:41:16
the truth is they tell you this, you should
00:41:18
not this, but this
00:41:25
why are
00:41:27
we producing this in our
00:41:29
area better? It’s better to grow this. This
00:41:31
tells us no, for the state this is
00:41:32
more important now that we have gone through this
00:41:36
post-war period, the policy of the Soviet
00:41:38
government in relation to
00:41:40
agriculture has changed. Not because
00:41:42
Khrushchev began to disavow someone there It’s
00:41:44
just that an
00:41:46
economic opportunity has arisen
00:41:48
to interest people in the countryside, not
00:41:50
like this is what you’ll grow, otherwise
00:41:52
portbill will be on the table, but because guys, we’ll
00:41:55
now give you incentives to
00:41:58
grow this because it’s more
00:42:01
profitable for you and the whole people at the same time,
00:42:05
and our rate of agricultural growth is
00:42:07
the times of Khrushchev were the
00:42:10
highest in the world, neither before nor after, they have
00:42:12
not been repeated in our country. So far, yes, they gave incentives,
00:42:15
but this does not mean that Stalin’s policies
00:42:17
were worse than Khrushchev’s, or vice versa, it
00:42:19
means that the situation in the country was just
00:42:22
like that at that time, plus that’s what he says ruv
00:42:25
closed the arts there, firstly, this is not true.
00:42:28
Yes, secondly, there was
00:42:29
a point, why
00:42:32
were there artels after the war? This
00:42:35
was also clear. Because all the
00:42:36
enterprises were in ruins in our
00:42:38
country, imagine they were only built
00:42:40
in the thirties, only they turned around,
00:42:43
you can say yes, there was still a generation of
00:42:46
engineers there that didn’t have time to change, it was all
00:42:49
destroyed That’s why Stalin allowed
00:42:52
markets and commercial restaurants,
00:42:54
remember Sharapov went there The meeting place
00:42:57
cannot be changed Aria
00:43:00
Astori and of course, by the way, many people
00:43:03
were indignant at that time, like how we
00:43:06
live on cards, remember the cards were stolen
00:43:08
from women, she’s crying there, like, How are
00:43:10
we going to live And at the same time, Yes, there’s an
00:43:13
Astri restaurant sitting there,
00:43:16
of course, many didn’t like it, then
00:43:18
where is Socialism, but Stalin believed that the
00:43:21
economy had been restored
00:43:27
to meet needs,
00:43:28
markets appeared, they were legalized,
00:43:31
appeared so-called free prices,
00:43:34
but this is not again because it was
00:43:37
written somewhere. Well, because there
00:43:39
simply wasn’t enough goods then,
00:43:41
well, there wasn’t any. Yes,
00:43:43
and people received some kind of minimum
00:43:47
subsistence on cards at so-
00:43:48
called card prices, because what is
00:43:51
that? the card is not just a card,
00:43:53
it’s you coming to the store, it says you
00:43:56
for example, there’s 500 g of black bread,
00:43:59
you have this card
00:44:09
to cut 100 kg of bread, only 500 g,
00:44:14
on the other hand, please, there’s a
00:44:17
market nearby, everything is the same, yes, there’s at least
00:44:20
100 kg you can buy at free so-
00:44:23
called commercial prices, that is, in the
00:44:25
USSR there were double
00:44:29
years, do you think that this was
00:44:31
written somewhere or something by Marx? It’s just that
00:44:33
these are the consequences of a monstrous War when Well,
00:44:36
people had to be fed, watered, supplied
00:44:38
Well, in any way until it is restored
00:44:41
the industry is large, yes And when people do
00:44:44
n’t start getting it, when it was
00:44:46
restored in 1947,
00:44:49
cards were canceled but the prices became average
00:44:53
Yes, there were cheap cards, expensive
00:44:58
commercial ones Yes, and the prices were uniform,
00:45:01
made in the middle, that is, the prices increased,
00:45:05
so when they tell me Well, that’s it
00:45:06
prices decreased more closely. That's right.
00:45:08
Because the task was after
00:45:10
1947, prices increased and prices
00:45:13
increased greatly compared to card prices.
00:45:16
Yes, of course, you could
00:45:19
now buy more, but wages did not increase,
00:45:23
but the
00:45:25
management of the owl was to reduce these uniform prices that
00:45:29
increased after forty seventh year,
00:45:32
to a more acceptable level for the Working People,
00:45:35
as the economy developed, this was
00:45:38
done like this question: Is this an
00:45:41
inevitability under socialism? No, these are
00:45:44
features of the development of the Soviet
00:45:46
Union, which suffered
00:45:54
[music]
00:45:57
than what should this be due to? Yes,
00:46:00
the state should not regulate
00:46:03
prices, interfere with this actively, and for the
00:46:06
most socially significant goods, but at the
00:46:09
same time, relatively speaking, not to say, but we
00:46:11
believe that everyone in the hairdressing salon should give
00:46:13
everyone a haircut for 2
00:46:15
rubles, there is no point in it. You see,
00:46:18
here competition should already work in these industries
00:46:21
Yes, so that prices are at a
00:46:24
low level because well, it’s high It’s
00:46:27
just that no one will go to the neighbors But as
00:46:30
for basic things, of course,
00:46:33
look Why Khrushchev thought that
00:46:36
this commerce must be ended Yes,
00:46:39
because it played its role, that is, the
00:46:42
country recovered and the country
00:46:45
was faced with the task of active development, which is
00:46:47
no the artel cannot do the
00:46:51
artel in Ko
00:46:58
Ore Ino again Can take on the function of
00:47:02
providing for people without commercial
00:47:04
markets Yes, of course, these
00:47:07
same collective farm people left them there Yes, but why Because
00:47:09
the cooperator was allowed to sell
00:47:12
their surplus please, here you are,
00:47:14
the state sold You something
00:47:17
all that's left is to take it and sell it's not a question at all
00:47:20
once the
00:47:29
United States has achieved military parity, without which we
00:47:31
would have perished, artisans can make some kind of
00:47:34
artels. Well, what a laugh, that is, the
00:47:37
era of
00:47:41
artisanal post-war years, it was now possible to
00:47:44
engage in the development of large-scale
00:47:46
modern production, both in
00:47:49
the countryside and into industry That’s all
00:47:52
you understand, I don’t understand their pitfalls, I’ll think about how
00:47:57
all these artisans are going to zero for
00:47:59
something. They’re tired of them. Yes, it’s all nonsense, it’s all
00:48:02
just a handicraftsman in these conditions, or
00:48:05
an individual farmer, let’s assume Yes, he himself went to the
00:48:07
collective farm because he could not compete with them
00:48:11
just understand, it began
00:48:13
to die out on its own in the new modern
00:48:16
economy that has appeared in our
00:48:19
country Thank you for your answers please

Description:

Николай Платошкин - историк, дипломат, политик.

Preparing download options

popular icon
Popular
hd icon
HD video
audio icon
Only sound
total icon
All
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players

Questions about downloading video

mobile menu iconHow can I download "Николай Платошкин. Интервью Красному радио." video?mobile menu icon

  • http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.

  • The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.

  • UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.

  • UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.

mobile menu iconWhich format of "Николай Платошкин. Интервью Красному радио." video should I choose?mobile menu icon

  • The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.

mobile menu iconWhy does my computer freeze when loading a "Николай Платошкин. Интервью Красному радио." video?mobile menu icon

  • The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.

mobile menu iconHow can I download "Николай Платошкин. Интервью Красному радио." video to my phone?mobile menu icon

  • You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.

mobile menu iconHow can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Николай Платошкин. Интервью Красному радио."?mobile menu icon

  • The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.

mobile menu iconHow can I save a frame from a video "Николай Платошкин. Интервью Красному радио."?mobile menu icon

  • This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.

mobile menu iconWhat's the price of all this stuff?mobile menu icon

  • It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.