Download "Научная среда. Дмитрий Goblin Пучков. Что мы празднуем в День Победы"

Please wait. We're preparing links for easy ad-free video watching and downloading.

Previous video: "Доктор дъявол" фильм 4-й Эксперименты над людьми. Неизвестный суд над врачами нацистами, Нюрнберг Next video: ТРУСЫ ВТОРОЙ АРМИИ МИРА

0:00

о книге Егора Яковлева "Война на уничтожение"

0:26

о революционерах и репрессиях

0:39

смысл фальсификаций

0:48

о разрушении культурных памятников

0:50

о едином учебнике истории

0:55

о российской "элите" и кризисе

ТРУСЫ ВТОРОЙ АРМИИ МИРА

ТРУСЫ ВТОРОЙ АРМИИ МИРА

Channel: Андрей Луганский БЛОГ

"Доктор дъявол" фильм 4-й Эксперименты над людьми. Неизвестный суд над врачами нацистами, Нюрнберг

"Доктор дъявол" фильм 4-й Эксперименты над людьми. Неизвестный суд над врачами нацистами, Нюрнберг

Channel: Виктор Тарасов | Путешествие в Историю

$Речь Павла Корчагина (отрывок из к\ф "Как закалялась сталь")$

Речь Павла Корчагина (отрывок из к\ф "Как закалялась сталь")

Channel: Красная Анапа

Дмитрий Пучков

Гоблин

Политконтакт

Goblin

День Победы

История

Тверь

Политика

пропаганда

агитация

Тверской государственный университет

СССР

Россия

Великая отечественная война

00:00:04

Good afternoon, dear guests, Thank you all

00:00:06

for coming to our event in the midst of a

00:00:08

working day and a school day, today

00:00:11

Dmitry

00:00:14

Yuryevich Puchkov and Egor Nikolaevich Yakovlev were planned to be our guests,

00:00:16

but as you probably already know, today in

00:00:19

many social networks there was

00:00:21

information that today is

00:00:23

St. St. Petersburg was filled with some

00:00:24

abnormal amount of snow and Therefore,

00:00:27

we have a natural force majeure Egor

00:00:29

Nikolaevich could not attend

00:00:31

our lecture because due to a

00:00:33

trivial reason he was late for the train. However,

00:00:36

Egor Nikolaevich will come to our

00:00:38

presentation, which will take place in the evening and

00:00:41

Therefore, today we have a speaker for now him

00:00:45

Dmitry Yuryevich Puchkov please give him

00:00:49

the floor name is My name is Dmitry Puchkov nickname

00:00:52

Goblin many who are younger probably

00:00:54

know I’m busy with all sorts of different things

00:00:58

now they call it a

00:01:00

rather strange word

00:01:03

blogger That is, if before we had

00:01:06

television, now we have

00:01:08

the Internet and For example,

00:01:10

if you work on the Internet

00:01:13

that is, I have

00:01:16

125,000 visitors to my site every day, I have a

00:01:19

channel on YouTube there are more than 900,000

00:01:22

subscribers, that is, this year there will be

00:01:24

Milne Well, it turns out that I

00:01:27

alone have an audience reach that is much

00:01:30

larger than that of the television

00:01:32

channel

00:01:34

Culture insofar as I broadcast to

00:01:37

such a large number of people then I feel a

00:01:40

certain responsibility, so to speak, for

00:01:43

what

00:01:45

is brought to the masses and in order to promote

00:01:49

the right things from my point of view to the

00:01:52

masses, I invite various specialists,

00:01:55

but I didn’t

00:01:58

have time to get the hints in time and as

00:02:01

a result, I came alone, he

00:02:03

will catch up later but probably won’t make it here in time

00:02:06

I

00:02:07

guess Egor, a specially educated

00:02:11

historian, understands the subject very

00:02:13

deeply and we filmed a series of videos

00:02:16

about what the Nazis actually wanted.

00:02:20

When they came to the territory of the Soviet Union, that

00:02:24

is, many probably heard about the

00:02:26

existence of such a plan.

00:02:32

we have no

00:02:35

families in Russia where there were no participants in the

00:02:38

Great Patriotic War. But to my

00:02:45

surprise, it is written in our Constitution

00:02:48

that there is no more ideology in the country, that

00:02:51

is, with the departure of

00:02:54

communism, they said that there

00:02:57

will be no more ideology, but with ideology, it is true that it

00:03:01

changed its sign to the opposite if

00:03:04

Previously, the ideology was

00:03:06

Soviet, which, despite all its now

00:03:09

seeming disadvantages, was still for us

00:03:13

for our country, but now the ideology is

00:03:16

purely anti-Soviet, and within the framework of this

00:03:20

ideology, somehow, in my opinion, they

00:03:23

approach the history of our

00:03:28

native country in a rather strange way, as much as possible translation Well,

00:03:33

look This is extremely sad. All

00:03:35

attempts to approach such things from

00:03:39

the state side are met with either

00:03:41

indifference or outright rejection

00:03:44

because it is impossible to say something good about

00:03:46

what happened in the Soviet Union. Well, for some reason it is

00:03:49

impossible. This comes into severe

00:03:51

contradiction with what the

00:03:55

masses feel when

00:03:58

when they took part in such an action, the

00:04:01

Immortal Regiment, the Immortal Regiment action was

00:04:05

conceived by our compatriots of a

00:04:08

purely liberal persuasion as such a

00:04:11

serious anti-Soviet action, that is,

00:04:14

it was assumed that the

00:04:17

descendants of those who died in the war should

00:04:21

come to the march of the Immortal Regiment with portraits of their

00:04:25

ancestors; the portraits had tender

00:04:28

contents and symbols because this

00:04:32

Immortal Regiment It was supposed to be about

00:04:34

everyone, for example, about the Vlasov SS men and

00:04:38

others, who are supposed to be considered

00:04:42

victims of the Second World War, which,

00:04:45

as many have probably heard, was

00:04:48

started by Comrade

00:04:51

Stalin, an initiative that’s how it was

00:04:55

conceived. But as soon as it reached the

00:04:58

masses, for some reason

00:05:00

they refused to remove Soviet

00:05:02

symbols from photographs of their ancestors Everyone

00:05:05

went Well, that is, in all the photographs there are

00:05:07

people with stars with shoulder straps, buttonholes and

00:05:10

all that, and this event, conceived as severe

00:05:14

anti-Sovietism, suddenly

00:05:16

resulted in a nationwide action of respect for

00:05:20

their Soviet ancestors, that

00:05:28

is, Anti-Soviet

00:05:31

politics

00:05:33

will thaw and this is expressed as well

00:05:36

in the huge number of people who

00:05:38

come to these

00:05:42

marches of literature that would talk about

00:05:47

what was happening then, now

00:05:49

disappearing little, some strange things

00:05:52

from my point of view, to put it mildly, are constantly being imposed,

00:05:54

but let’s

00:05:56

reconsider what was there to

00:05:58

reconsider it Personally,

00:06:01

it’s not clear to me from my point of view you need

00:06:03

to refresh something, you

00:06:06

apparently forgot what happened then Well, with

00:06:09

Yegor, we actually started from afar,

00:06:12

starting with the causes of the First World

00:06:17

War, moving on to the February Revolution and

00:06:21

then to the October Revolution, and along the way,

00:06:24

Yegor outlined in sufficient detail

00:06:27

what the Nazis wanted from

00:06:31

Soviet

00:06:33

Union Naturally,

00:06:36

no one planned anything good for us, that is,

00:06:39

the territory of the Soviet Union. Well, they have had this

00:06:42

since the Middle Ages, insofar as

00:06:46

Well, I’m probably completely in the wild for you, is it more

00:06:49

interesting for me to talk or for

00:06:51

you to ask questions? And I’ve

00:06:58

been telling the answers since the gloomy times the Middle Ages

00:07:02

saw undeveloped territories here

00:07:05

lived here, as you might guess, even

00:07:07

then we are not quite people, that is, for them we are

00:07:11

not quite people Slavic - this is such an

00:07:14

inferior race incapable of

00:07:17

self-organization this is the most important thing, that is,

00:07:20

when you go to Europe Germany

00:07:22

France you probably pay attention to everyone

00:07:26

How beautiful the European

00:07:28

towns look, they are all such a

00:07:34

neat little village. As I understand it, we are

00:07:37

all from there, our slanting fences and

00:07:40

scary huts somehow give a

00:07:44

slightly different impression, and for many, it

00:07:46

immediately appears in their heads that these

00:07:48

Russians living here are not capable of

00:07:51

self-organization they

00:07:53

can’t build beautiful houses and make

00:07:56

clean streets. They can’t do anything at all.

00:07:59

It’s true, I’ll look ahead and note that when

00:08:01

these liberators came here,

00:08:03

for example, I have relatives from the Pskov province. So they drove a

00:08:08

sea of Italians there; the

00:08:10

Italians and Germans immediately began

00:08:13

to build

00:08:14

roads, cover them with slag, try to do something... then it stood

00:08:18

there to pave the asphalt for exactly

00:08:21

a year, made by the hands of the Germans in the

00:08:23

next spring, the sun sank and took on

00:08:25

our usual appearance WTO

00:08:31

that smart and Myt is worse than you, it’s not so, but

00:08:34

nevertheless they never considered us to be people, they

00:08:36

don’t consider us and are unlikely to even consider us

00:08:41

subconsciously, many of our fellow citizens,

00:08:43

they also consider people from the south worse than us and

00:08:48

also not quite people from among those who have come in large numbers, so to

00:08:51

speak, it is characteristic of

00:08:58

everyone. People they came to us repeatedly,

00:09:01

always came with military

00:09:04

force, every time they received it. So it

00:09:08

was difficult to carry it away, including in

00:09:11

World War II, but this does not stop them

00:09:14

and now they are busy with the same thing, it

00:09:18

looked like this, that is,

00:09:20

Russia was designated by the Germans as a

00:09:23

living

00:09:24

space for German colonists,

00:09:28

having arrived here, the German troops had to

00:09:31

first of all, well, there are

00:09:33

plans that are well known, the Ost plan about

00:09:37

which many people have also probably heard, it

00:09:39

was only at the stage of

00:09:41

initial formation, so to speak, but the war went

00:09:44

wrong and it was not completed to the end. But

00:09:47

the plans of the German Ministry of Agriculture are

00:09:52

well drawn up and

00:09:55

have reached us perfectly, and so in these

00:09:58

plans, those captured are highly developed

00:10:03

agricultural areas such as the

00:10:05

Kuban of Ukraine, the supply of products from there,

00:10:10

grain vegetables, will be immediately stopped insofar

00:10:13

as it is necessary to feed

00:10:16

Germany. And as soon as food is not

00:10:19

supplied, for example, to the city of Leningrad,

00:10:22

everyone there will die safely from hunger and in the

00:10:25

first year it was planned to destroy it in this way

00:10:33

when I cut it off from food supplies

00:10:37

these people will simply die, they were not needed

00:10:40

here, gradually German colonists had to move in.

00:10:42

Well, you know, when they

00:10:47

start to somehow compare But who

00:10:50

was good Who was bad Here recently,

00:10:52

some American

00:10:58

child of

00:11:00

Hitler, the whole world community

00:11:02

was terribly indignant about how this is so how

00:11:05

you can compare this at all, but

00:11:07

in your native country to say that Stalin was

00:11:09

worse than Hitler is absolutely in the order of

00:11:12

things,

00:11:15

no one has any kind of contradiction in their head. So the

00:11:20

electronic idiot that arrived

00:11:23

started working and then the German

00:11:26

troops arrived. Well, that’s actually what they were doing at the same

00:11:30

time they had abolished criminal

00:11:32

liability for war crimes

00:11:35

on the territory of the Soviet Union. That is,

00:11:36

if in Europe the war was waged in fairly

00:11:41

civilized ways and means.

00:11:44

Well, for example, as you know with the

00:11:45

French. They practically didn’t fight at all. And they

00:11:47

didn’t fight with the Poles, that is, the

00:11:50

resistance was so ridiculous

00:11:52

that, in general, there is nothing to talk about, a

00:11:53

well-known example, that it took more time to take France

00:11:59

than to take one street in Stalingrad,

00:12:02

so to speak, it’s

00:12:03

well known, but

00:12:08

I can’t replace Yegor, I’m not

00:12:12

such a great specialist in history, if

00:12:16

from my point of view, we’re all talking

00:12:18

time is accused of the fact that we were not poorly

00:12:21

prepared there. We shot all the military there

00:12:24

before the

00:12:28

war, but in 1941 we were

00:12:31

attacked by the best army on planet Earth.

00:12:35

It was the best, it conquered all of Europe

00:12:37

and no one could do anything,

00:12:40

but until Moscow again - a banal

00:12:44

example: the Germans on tanks got to Moscow

00:12:47

slower than Napoleon on horseback to the rocks,

00:12:50

while Napoleon burned Moscow and for some reason the

00:12:54

Bolsheviks didn’t let them. Well, here’s the

00:12:57

best army on planet Earth,

00:13:01

everyone loves to talk about how

00:13:03

the offensive began and what

00:13:05

monstrous results it led to. They do

00:13:08

n’t like to talk at all about

00:13:10

how it all ended,

00:13:13

how starting in the forties everything

00:13:16

turned back and the Germans were driven out even

00:13:19

worse than they drove us, and what is

00:13:22

characteristic is that for some reason we did

00:13:24

n’t exterminate their population And they weren’t shy about doing

00:13:27

anything we were studying, well, actually,

00:13:31

Yegor’s book is about where

00:13:37

Nazism came from, citizen Hitler, diligently

00:13:40

copied it from the Anglo-Saxons, it’s very

00:13:43

detailed, it’s interesting, it’s

00:13:45

written out, then it’s explained in detail what

00:13:48

they wanted. When they came to

00:13:50

us, there was nothing good for us; in

00:13:53

general, as such, it was physically tender

00:13:58

to be M this it’s over for them and for us. I

00:14:03

believe that such books and similar

00:14:07

things should be conveyed to the population

00:14:09

continuously without making feature

00:14:12

films like Stalingrad Penal Battalion there and

00:14:15

other things to describe normal

00:14:19

books to convey to the public that

00:14:22

there are such normal books, that there are

00:14:24

people who think soberly and respect

00:14:27

memory please

00:14:30

ask questions somehow like this I

00:14:34

will answer them for you Dear guests

00:14:38

Please take off your hands those who want to ask a

00:14:39

question a person will come up and you can probably

00:14:42

hear clearly now

00:14:44

Let’s approach with a microphone the

00:14:46

one who wants to ask Dmitry a question

00:14:48

and he will be on please answer him

00:14:51

[music]

00:14:58

hands of

00:15:11

the population of

00:15:13

Ista people

00:15:15

who survived

00:15:18

the blockade of Rask is not an easy time and what is

00:15:27

happening now

00:15:30

What

00:15:32

the people need Well, repeat even more

00:15:36

strongly than over time and why do

00:15:40

people appear

00:15:43

who so to speak

00:15:45

Well, words are vilified Yes, the

00:15:48

achievements of our people

00:15:52

Thank you, these are purely questions political

00:15:55

I am expressing my own point

00:15:57

of view, that’s not it, I’m not a member of any

00:16:00

parties, I

00:16:01

don’t join anything, I’m speaking

00:16:04

only on my own behalf, not on anyone’s

00:16:07

behalf, since we had the

00:16:10

Communist Revolution in

00:16:12

1917. In the ninety-first, we

00:16:15

had

00:16:16

a counter-revolution During this

00:16:18

counter-revolution, property acquired with the

00:16:22

blood of our ancestors was successfully

00:16:26

divided up in order to be divided

00:16:29

between certain people who had nothing to do with

00:16:32

this property. Well,

00:16:35

such an ideological attack was launched in

00:16:38

which they explained to everyone that the

00:16:40

Soviet Union was so bad and

00:16:42

so disgusting that it

00:16:44

all had to be taken away immediately for private

00:16:46

apartments And then effective

00:16:48

owners will handle this perfectly well.

00:16:50

Your administrative-command system is

00:16:52

absolutely not good for anything, but there

00:16:55

must be effective owners. Well,

00:16:58

what was good for? I don’t know when during the

00:17:00

same

00:17:02

war the united

00:17:05

Europe of the then European Union opposed us there were

00:17:07

approximately 400 million people and in the entire

00:17:10

Soviet Union there were less than

00:17:13

190 somehow it turned out that the worthless

00:17:17

economy of the communist Union is

00:17:22

ground up, it is ineffective, in

00:17:26

my opinion the reasoning is completely stupid

00:17:29

Here is an example of how it worked here is the

00:17:31

result the whole of Europe is under us

00:17:35

Well how to justify what we now everything

00:17:39

is turned around and pulled apart. Well, of course,

00:17:41

let us lie shamelessly. We

00:17:44

started lying much earlier than the ninety-

00:17:46

first year, but then all this generally

00:17:49

acquired an industrial

00:17:52

scale. We need to somehow justify why

00:17:55

you broke it all. Why did you break the entire

00:17:57

Soviet industry

00:17:59

if it was bad? Well, probably it is necessary

00:18:03

it was possible to make it better, that is, the question is, I have

00:18:05

an office at the red

00:18:09

triangle factory, in St. Petersburg such a red

00:18:12

triangle produced rubber products,

00:18:15

product number one. That is,

00:18:18

a gas mask, product number d. This is not what we

00:18:20

had, that’s

00:18:22

all, everything was cut, everything was cut,

00:18:25

absolutely all the equipment was cut, Everything

00:18:28

you were sold for scrap metal And why am I

00:18:32

sitting there now making videos This is of course

00:18:34

great for me I

00:18:35

even make money from this and the plant and the people

00:18:38

who worked there and where did they go and

00:18:41

what actually happened but to these sheep who

00:18:43

gave it to them they sawed everything up and

00:18:46

they threw it away and sold it and someone answered for it

00:18:50

anyway, well, I don’t know. If they

00:18:52

give you ownership of the plant and you’re an

00:18:54

effective owner, it produces

00:18:56

10,000 tons of gas masks there, for example, I

00:18:59

’m kidding. So you took ownership of it, well,

00:19:01

probably you should produce 15 or

00:19:04

maybe even 20 it should be better

00:19:06

paint gas masks and something else instead

00:19:09

you cut up the machines and sold everything And took the

00:19:11

money out of the Cordon who is

00:19:14

watching this who is watching this who

00:19:16

is responsible for this Nobody Everything is fine Everything

00:19:19

turned out great Well, insofar

00:19:21

as I think so

00:19:23

a crime against the country and against the

00:19:25

people must be justified by something

00:19:27

continuously, how to justify it can

00:19:30

only be defecated in the heads of the

00:19:33

citizens that it was so bad so bad

00:19:35

it was so disgusting that Everything that

00:19:37

has been done since the ninety-first year is

00:19:39

all wonderful and strictly for your benefit

00:19:43

Well, theses It seems that we have

00:19:47

the siege of Leningrad in general - I don’t

00:19:49

know how to put it correctly, it’s not a sore

00:19:51

subject. But we probably have a lot of

00:19:54

siege survivors who, when I

00:19:56

was little, for example, in schools, all the

00:19:58

teachers survived the siege either in

00:20:01

evacuation or inside the city,

00:20:04

naturally all this has always been

00:20:06

told first hand, well, we were children there.

00:20:09

Well, then no one felt sorry for the children,

00:20:12

like now, crazy parents then

00:20:15

told everything as it was. It was

00:20:17

pure horror and suddenly now

00:20:20

some people come out like there is a citizen of

00:20:22

Latynina and those like her are starting

00:20:25

to tell us that this is a crime of the

00:20:27

Soviet command,

00:20:29

that they are like this with the city of

00:20:31

Leningrad, they had to surrender it and then

00:20:34

people would be alive, it’s Stalin’s fault, it’s

00:20:37

he who killed 00 of the Leningraders because

00:20:42

they had to surrender. But for example, now

00:20:45

we have there was also such a wonderful

00:20:47

character, Carl Gustav Marge, who

00:20:50

last year was screwed with a commemorative

00:20:53

plaque. From our point of view, this is

00:20:57

from the North, bringing up the rear of Hitler’s family; he

00:21:02

killed a million of us with his hands, and

00:21:05

now in the city of St. Petersburg we must

00:21:08

honor the memory of this wonderful

00:21:09

Russian

00:21:11

officer, how is this, how is this even in the head,

00:21:14

it can fit into the head that Stalin did

00:21:17

n’t hang him after the end, so to speak.

00:21:20

Well, so what, he didn’t hang Tsar Mihai of Romania, on the

00:21:23

contrary, he

00:21:25

mockingly gave him the Order of Victory, why do

00:21:29

n’t you have to invent

00:21:33

something new there? heroes Well, citizen

00:21:36

Latynina says that it was necessary

00:21:38

to surrender to surrender St. Petersburg, everything would be

00:21:41

fine there are German documents in the public domain, in

00:21:46

black and white, it’s written

00:21:48

in Yegor’s book, it’s also well

00:21:51

disclosed there that there shouldn’t be any plans to take the

00:21:54

city of Leningrad,

00:21:57

he was

00:22:01

surrounded precisely in order to cut off the

00:22:04

supply routes, the supply routes were cut off and

00:22:07

everyone inside had to die quietly,

00:22:10

the Germans were worried about one single question

00:22:13

in the mass of documents: that when the Hungry

00:22:15

people trampled from there in crowds from Leningrad,

00:22:19

they would have to be shot there, there were

00:22:21

minefields and machine guns, they would have to be

00:22:23

shot But

00:22:27

no more Ruz, when thousands of them

00:22:31

will have to be felled, this is what the Germans were worried about, according to their

00:22:34

plans, the city of Leningrad. That is, when

00:22:36

everyone inside there died out, it should have been

00:22:38

razed to the ground, that is, the Finam

00:22:40

territory should have gone to the Neva to the

00:22:42

Germans. Pardon the Germans for what is

00:22:46

below.

00:22:48

Well, who is

00:22:50

Latynina to similar things from

00:22:57

here,

00:22:59

they would be there on some kind of boats. I don’t know,

00:23:00

on boats with oars, the aircraft would be equipped with this,

00:23:03

well, I don’t know, you have to be a complete

00:23:04

idiot. You at least study there. Well, at least

00:23:07

a little more specifically, Lake Ladoga is

00:23:10

not suitable for navigation at all you can't

00:23:13

swim there on anything Peter I along Ladoga

00:23:17

Peter I also dug the Ladoga Canal

00:23:21

because you can swim in the canal but

00:23:23

not in the lake because the weather there is constantly

00:23:25

changing waves go in different

00:23:27

directions any wooden ship breaks

00:23:31

right away there are no berths there There is no fleet there there is

00:23:35

nothing at all. In the same way, in

00:23:36

Leningrad there are no berths, there is no fleet, nothing.

00:23:40

In general, the supply all this happened

00:23:42

manually, they simply loaded each barge there for 3

00:23:45

days by hand and then

00:23:47

unloaded it in the same way, delivering it to the city of

00:23:50

Leningrad, that is, there are solid ones there,

00:23:53

by the way, this is also an illustrative example of what in

00:23:55

St. Petersburg there were about a million people,

00:23:57

and the whole country knows the history of the supply of this city.

00:24:01

What was the road of life with

00:24:03

what sacrifices was it associated and how

00:24:05

dangerous? But in Kolyma, according to

00:24:07

Solzhenitsyn, we had a million people

00:24:11

imprisoned for some reason. There was no road of life

00:24:14

there, you begin. be interested in

00:24:16

what you have there, citizen

00:24:18

Solzhenitsyn, 3 months of navigation in Kolyma

00:24:22

and two ships. Well, tell me how a

00:24:24

million people were brought there on two

00:24:27

ships in 3 months,

00:24:29

they ate there

00:24:30

somehow, it’s not good, it turns out

00:24:33

ugly, but from my point of view, the

00:24:36

state media have been

00:24:39

all over the place for decades this nonsense

00:24:41

is supported well if they surrendered Leningrad.

00:24:44

As soon as it was surrendered,

00:24:46

all the troops that were standing

00:24:49

around were freed. And on the northwestern front there

00:24:53

was an extremely tense situation and the most difficult battles. So they were all

00:24:56

freed and where would they go

00:24:58

near Moscow and Moscow would certainly be

00:25:01

taken immediately? as soon as they took it and we would

00:25:03

have rolled back beyond the Urals Well, it’s not clear And what

00:25:06

would have happened to us in general, well, and who in such

00:25:09

cases should we listen to Comrade Stalin

00:25:12

or a citizen of

00:25:13

Latin I don’t know, in my opinion such people

00:25:17

should not be allowed into the

00:25:19

media What if If they let you in there, there

00:25:22

must be qualified

00:25:23

specialists like Yegor Yakovlev, who

00:25:26

accidentally didn’t come, who can

00:25:32

explain in detail with numbers in their hands and documents that everything that was said to these

00:25:35

characters named Latynina is all the

00:25:38

nonsense of a madman, you have nothing

00:25:41

to do with history, you don’t understand what

00:25:44

happened, you you don’t understand what

00:25:45

results this entailed and, in general, it’s

00:25:48

like an insect that needs to be continuously

00:25:50

dissected, which is what we actually

00:25:53

borrow from them, the Nise policy,

00:25:58

because any nasty things about the

00:26:00

Soviet Union are ok to us, so in a

00:26:04

bad dream, you won’t

00:26:07

see

00:26:13

the hands of BP,

00:26:24

please

00:26:27

Hello, ask the question about

00:26:30

the need for Stalinist repressions in

00:26:32

principle and about your personal characteristics of

00:26:35

this man, I did

00:26:39

n’t take part in the repressions, I understand, and yes,

00:26:43

one more question And in general about films in

00:26:47

principle Let’s just remember two of them right away,

00:26:50

I’m already old, I understand, but

00:26:53

that’s also how- has nothing to do with

00:26:55

my previous question, but this

00:26:58

film was made by the Khrustalev machine, did

00:27:02

you watch it and how do you feel about such

00:27:05

films? Thank you

00:27:08

very much, our Great October

00:27:11

Socialist Revolution is not

00:27:13

some unprecedented event in the history of

00:27:16

mankind, that is, well, in a number of aspects of

00:27:19

the Revolution there were before that, in France, in

00:27:23

England and in Germany, all revolutions

00:27:25

occur approximately according to the same

00:27:28

scenario. First, there is a

00:27:30

coup d'etat, after that, the mass murder of

00:27:33

representatives of the previous government, then

00:27:36

a certain period of formation. And after that, the

00:27:39

comrade

00:27:40

revolutionaries unanimously slaughter each other and

00:27:43

everyone who, so to speak, is in the mix. we are

00:27:48

not an exception, despite the fact

00:27:50

that the Great October Socialist

00:27:53

Revolution was ideologically different and the

00:27:57

consequences of all actions occur in

00:27:59

exactly the same way, if

00:28:02

we explain it in a primitive way, then when our

00:28:05

own revolution ended, when the

00:28:07

civil war ended and it

00:28:10

was necessary to build a new society, when a

00:28:13

lot of ideas about the world disappeared The revolution

00:28:17

that we will start here And everyone else

00:28:19

will pick up in Europe in Germany There and everything will be trampled on,

00:28:21

no one picked up and

00:28:23

nothing was trampled and only our

00:28:26

country remains inside of which it is not even

00:28:30

clear that comrade Stalin took the

00:28:36

top leadership

00:28:38

positions in this regard, as in any

00:28:41

absolutely normal community Well, for

00:28:44

example, Leon Trotsky, an outstanding revolutionary

00:28:50

tribune, has survived to ours

00:28:57

in that Lev Davydovich was a Mega

00:29:00

orator. That is, he

00:29:02

could captivate the masses like few

00:29:05

others; he created the Red Army for us; he

00:29:09

won at the fronts; and so on and

00:29:12

so forth. his undoubted, but then

00:29:15

the paths diverged and interest arose. And how did

00:29:18

I win at the fronts? I’m all

00:29:21

primitivism

00:29:22

at the fronts, and now some Stalin is in charge.

00:29:26

This is why

00:29:28

this is unfair and this needs to be changed. And

00:29:31

insofar as revolutionaries are

00:29:34

people who professionally engaged in

00:29:38

overthrowing state power. They are

00:29:40

familiar. for example, with methods of conspiracy,

00:29:44

how to hide from the authorities,

00:29:46

hide your activities, how to identify

00:29:48

police informants, how to

00:29:50

eliminate them, so that no one sees this,

00:29:53

does not know what happened, one thing after

00:29:57

another, now there are habits of

00:30:00

the underground, this is absolutely the same thing as what is

00:30:04

proposed to be done with it, with this

00:30:06

underground, the First World War has ended

00:30:09

the war at the end of the First World War, it

00:30:12

was clear to the participants that this war

00:30:15

had not ended and after 20 years it would

00:30:18

repeat itself, so to speak, in the form of a

00:30:21

continuation of the Second World War,

00:30:23

because the issues that the

00:30:25

First World War should have resolved

00:30:28

would have been resolved and the war would have to be fought before the war and all of Europe

00:30:32

was preparing for this, it was necessary to prepare for this,

00:30:34

and in order for us to

00:30:37

prepare for war, the country needed

00:30:44

industrialism by Vitalievich Young, where he

00:30:46

tells in detail that the Tsarist

00:30:49

government issued 20,000 lemts for the First World War,

00:30:55

Thorin, by the beginning of the Second World War, 20 liters of lemtov,

00:31:00

Tory Stalin, he knew quite well that was

00:31:03

during the First World War how it ended

00:31:05

And why did it end this way? Well, in

00:31:09

order for there to be

00:31:11

industry, huge

00:31:14

masses of people must be moved to the construction sites of communism;

00:31:18

organized construction sites of communism must be

00:31:21

fed, but individual peasant farms do

00:31:24

not produce such

00:31:26

emissions; they do not, and by the way, I advise you to

00:31:31

pay attention that during the war of

00:31:33

famine we

00:31:35

didn’t have a lot of food, we ate it, but there was no famine,

00:31:39

it was solely thanks to the collective farms,

00:31:42

which, as we now know, are absolutely

00:31:44

ineffective and were not needed at all, and so it

00:31:46

was necessary to carry out collectivization in the countryside,

00:31:48

that is, it was necessary to unite all the

00:31:51

collective farms in industry it was to

00:31:53

carry out the industrialization of the Armed Forces, this

00:31:55

required an incredible effort of the

00:31:58

entire population of the country, and if in the midst of

00:32:01

this you would like to engage in

00:32:04

some interesting political

00:32:06

subversive activities, then it all

00:32:09

ended primitively and quickly either in

00:32:11

camps or fields in the head because

00:32:15

nothing else can be done, I repeat

00:32:18

that speech I wasn’t talking about ordinary citizens like

00:32:20

you and me, but about professional

00:32:23

underground workers who want to carry out

00:32:25

another coup d’etat

00:32:28

and destroy what they managed to save and

00:32:30

build. Well, what should have been done with them?

00:32:33

I’m not speaking from a cannibalistic position.

00:32:36

Let’s see how it was for everyone and

00:32:40

suddenly you’ll see what Well, if, for example,

00:32:42

we count the victims of the Great French

00:32:45

Revolution, as they call it, then in

00:32:48

numerical terms as a percentage. They

00:32:50

killed more people than the Bolsheviks, the

00:32:54

Bolsheviks, just the opposite, against the background of all

00:32:56

these

00:32:58

people are extremely smart and, to put it

00:33:03

mildly, kind-hearted, they did not

00:33:05

strive to kill a huge

00:33:07

number of people there an

00:33:09

excess like when some Cossacks slaughtered

00:33:12

others en masse, a civil war is a

00:33:15

terrible thing, read

00:33:16

Sholokhov’s stories, what it’s

00:33:18

like, regardless of whether it’s red, it’s

00:33:21

White, it’s usable with any Vla V

00:33:26

any, did

00:33:29

these

00:33:31

repressions happen? Well, how is it that our Armed Forces are

00:33:34

now clearly divided in half, some people scream that

00:33:36

you Bastards killed just anyone And others

00:33:38

are screaming Bastards It’s you And we killed only

00:33:41

those who needed to be killed, this is not so I’m

00:33:44

like this, in some way a former

00:33:46

policeman has no authority and

00:33:49

I can clearly see even in Peacetime that

00:33:52

people often

00:33:55

suffer for Well, excuse me and in medicine,

00:34:00

it happens that they cut off the wrong leg, or

00:34:03

pull out a healthy tooth, or something else, no one

00:34:06

is responsible for this. By the way, our doctors are not

00:34:08

imprisoned for such things. It happens, but rarely,

00:34:12

we had such an era when, within the framework of the

00:34:18

same Revolution, the Civil War and the

00:34:20

consequences of both were mass

00:34:23

repressions, they were soybean,

00:34:28

although they were evil. The will was And not only from the

00:34:31

desire of one party group there

00:34:33

to eliminate another group, and not only from the

00:34:36

struggle within the NKVD when one part there

00:34:38

wanted to eat the other but could not

00:34:41

shoot those they shot and those with my

00:34:45

point of view at the present moment That

00:34:47

is, everyone has already heard enough of Solzhenitsyn about the fact

00:34:50

that 100 Mino There they killed a

00:34:54

noob

00:34:56

failure archives and let's see what

00:35:00

actually happened I draw your attention to the fact that during the

00:35:02

entire period of perestroika and

00:35:04

post-perestroika

00:35:07

[music]

00:35:12

who is with numbers in his hands I studied what

00:35:16

it really was without these

00:35:18

ideological cries. And what

00:35:20

actually was. What were the victims

00:35:22

of collectivization, dispossession there, the

00:35:25

fight against these secret enemies, and

00:35:28

somehow the numbers that actually exist,

00:35:31

they absolutely do not coincide with what was

00:35:36

propagated by

00:35:37

for decades In my opinion, this is very

00:35:40

bad, that is, if they killed my grandfather,

00:35:43

then this is a tragedy for the whole family. Well, in

00:35:45

the size of the country, one grandfather does

00:35:48

not play any role in general, but it turns out

00:35:52

that you lied about 100 Mino, this is a lie, and

00:35:56

then it turned out that

00:35:59

citizens who are not very smart make people

00:36:02

laugh 700,000 people were shot, that’s also

00:36:05

Sorry, very, very much And this is a tragedy for

00:36:08

everyone

00:36:09

Well, you can’t

00:36:12

treat it like that Don’t lie If they

00:36:14

declared freedom of information Well, give

00:36:17

us normal information Show No they don’t

00:36:20

show Why they don’t show but

00:36:22

because Results there will be some that

00:36:25

will again become

00:36:26

incomprehensible; they have broken something that

00:36:29

was absolutely unclear. Well, instead,

00:36:34

Khrustalev’s

00:36:38

car and so on are brought to the attention of the population. I recommend that there

00:36:40

is a book by this, in my opinion, our

00:36:44

famous film critic Anton

00:36:47

Dolin, where he

00:36:49

takes a solid book. It consists of an

00:36:52

interview with a citizen. I

00:36:55

recommend reading Herman, the director of this film,

00:36:59

after 10

00:37:00

pages of text it is clear that

00:37:04

the citizen urgently needs medical

00:37:07

help, preferably medicinal, because there is

00:37:09

such an intensity of delirium there, the catastrophe is

00:37:13

just a catastrophe and this man carries

00:37:17

some thoughts in quotes that he broadcasts

00:37:21

to the population, he then released such a

00:37:23

feature film It’s hard to be God,

00:37:25

they didn’t watch, no, here’s a masterpiece exactly the

00:37:29

same as Khrustalev’s car. That is, this is an

00:37:31

ideologically

00:37:33

indoctrinated person who puts his rather

00:37:36

strange ideological and political

00:37:39

views into action in cinema with

00:37:42

state money. When there was

00:37:44

Soviet cinema and there were

00:37:47

Soviet producers standing behind them in dusty helmets and From

00:37:50

a Mauser they explained how to make a

00:37:52

movie, for some reason everyone turned out to be masterpieces

00:37:55

as soon as the Communist producers

00:37:58

left and people were left to their own devices

00:38:01

during perestroika, not a single one, from my

00:38:04

point of view, not a single Soviet creator

00:38:06

like Nikita Sergeevich Mikhalkov Eldar

00:38:09

Rezanov, etc., etc. one did not

00:38:13

film anything worthy of attention. So maybe it’s

00:38:17

also citizen

00:38:19

Herman. So maybe it wasn’t you, but the

00:38:22

communist producers who

00:38:25

explained to you what and how to film in order to

00:38:27

get masterpieces, but you

00:38:30

can’t do anything at all on your own. I would

00:38:33

instead in order for Khrustalev to film a car, he

00:38:35

would recommend standing in front of

00:38:37

the mirror and looking at yourself and thinking

00:38:40

why I’m like this, this would be more useful for him

00:38:47

[music]

00:39:01

Good afternoon,

00:39:03

once again I have such a question Look, at

00:39:07

least for me before I started

00:39:10

delving into it, I got to At a certain point,

00:39:14

I began to be interested in history, not a

00:39:16

school course where children want to go out and they are

00:39:19

forced to study. And

00:39:22

about the fuss, such a question may be possible. It’s

00:39:26

clear that Well, I got

00:39:29

acquainted with the work of Yegor Yakov with

00:39:32

his book. And who can you trust in

00:39:35

terms of history? After all, we are with you have

00:39:38

discussed here for a very long time and a lot that

00:39:41

so many

00:39:42

falsifications are in the most visible place

00:39:45

How to distinguish truth from untruth,

00:39:48

maybe there is some

00:39:56

recommendation

00:39:58

various historical topics but they

00:40:00

can be biased and sometimes not

00:40:03

biased For example, some

00:40:04

citizen of Svani I am specially

00:40:07

trained a historian deeply

00:40:09

engaged by

00:40:11

some citizen of the teeth, here with

00:40:14

Yegor there will be regular videos there we will

00:40:16

do it there Write a history textbook

00:40:21

about the Soviet-Nazi

00:40:25

War in Tomorrow this is not the Great Patriotic War

00:40:28

this is a Soviet-Nazi War where the

00:40:32

team of authors is busy with naturally

00:40:36

military anti-Soviet propaganda Which

00:40:39

means, from my point of view, an anti-Russian

00:40:44

Union no, in the Soviet Union everything was

00:40:47

bad and disgusting. These people, that is,

00:40:50

their actions in my understanding, lead to

00:40:54

quite understandable primitive things,

00:40:58

they want to prove there with documents,

00:41:01

journalism, they want to prove that, for

00:41:04

example, Stalin was

00:41:08

a criminal and the revolution of the seventeenth

00:41:12

year, it was

00:41:13

criminal, well, for example, made on

00:41:17

German money, that is, now such a

00:41:19

popular trend that it was such a

00:41:21

specific Maidan with German money,

00:41:24

and Lenin was a German spy and it is

00:41:27

impossible to convince these citizens, that is, from my

00:41:30

point of view. Well, as an investigator,

00:41:33

for example, I worked with secret informants,

00:41:37

paid them money and all that stuff.

00:41:42

from my point of view, it is obvious that this is

00:41:44

all documented, this is state

00:41:46

money and it is impossible to distribute it from your pocket from left to

00:41:48

right, and if Lenin was an

00:41:51

English spy, then there must be papers

00:41:54

that are German papers that are

00:41:58

in contact with German intelligence, that they

00:42:00

gave him money, this is if something is

00:42:04

not preserved there, then about money

00:42:05

will always be preserved, and if this were so,

00:42:10

then the department of citizen Goebbels

00:42:13

would have promoted it even before the start of the Second World War,

00:42:15

so look at everything that

00:42:17

is happening in Russia, it’s all with our

00:42:19

money, it was done by our people But

00:42:20

since Goebel didn’t

00:42:22

say that, so there are no such documents.

00:42:25

Why are you lying, but you can’t show

00:42:28

proof?

00:42:30

This is the question of who to believe. This is not a question of Faith; on the issue of

00:42:33

Faith, you have to go to church;

00:42:35

they work with Faith normally, but with historical

00:42:38

documents you have to work a little

00:42:40

differently, well. further, if they want to admit for

00:42:45

many years they want to organize a trial of the

00:42:48

Communist Party and he is not a communist

00:42:50

and was never a member of the Communist Party.

00:42:54

But if comrade Stalin is recognized as a

00:42:58

criminal, the

00:43:01

Communist Party will be recognized as criminal. The next

00:43:05

step is all that the Communist

00:43:08

Party under the leadership of Stalin has achieved

00:43:11

will also be recognized as criminal And First of all, the

00:43:13

results of the

00:43:16

Second World War will be criminal, which will immediately

00:43:18

entail a revision of the

00:43:20

territorial integrity of the Russian

00:43:22

Federation insofar as the

00:43:25

current Russian Federation is the

00:43:27

legal successor of the Soviet Union and

00:43:30

must be held accountable for everything that, from the point of

00:43:34

view of these people, was criminal committed by the

00:43:36

Soviet Union. That is, we have from

00:43:39

Chekryzhev Finnish Vyborg German

00:43:43

Kaliningrad and let's go,

00:43:45

everyone's claims are above their heads, first

00:43:48

they will reconsider territorial integrity and

00:43:50

then they will explain that people suffered from your

00:43:52

criminal communist regime,

00:43:57

because many fought against the communists with weapons in their hands,

00:43:59

for example,

00:44:01

Bandera's people killed them in batches of NKVD officers.

00:44:05

Well, be kind to them

00:44:08

you have to pay the forest brothers in the Baltics

00:44:11

you have to pay the basmachi in Central Asia you have to

00:44:13

pay Well, not to them themselves, but at least to the

00:44:15

descendants who have suffered so much from you, you

00:44:18

say you have a

00:44:27

union, you have all the resources to transfer under external

00:44:31

management, here is a review of territorial

00:44:34

integrity with the goal of reducing the territory of

00:44:37

Russia as such to the size of the

00:44:38

Moscow Principality and the seizure of resources

00:44:42

Well, that’s all what people

00:44:46

who talk about the criminal

00:44:48

Soviet regime are trying to achieve in my opinion

00:44:52

[music]

00:44:57

take the lie for money not for money it does

00:45:00

n’t matter either you’re a complete fool

00:45:04

you don’t understand Well, what is intelligence? intelligence is

00:45:07

the ability to calculate the consequences of one’s

00:45:09

own actions If your actions

00:45:12

lead to the dismemberment of the country and therefore to

00:45:15

civil war and the murder of millions of

00:45:18

people It’s not Ukraine here, we will be

00:45:20

10 times more terrible Well, let’s put these on

00:45:24

the scales

00:45:25

words and actions will lead

00:45:29

to such results And such will lead

00:45:32

to such results Here is the integrity of the country

00:45:34

and the lives of citizens And here is civil

00:45:36

war and mass murder, what you have to

00:45:39

believe in even if you don’t want to

00:45:42

understand anything at all, you don’t want to, then all

00:45:45

these cries I

00:45:49

don’t know about our criminal past. You

00:45:52

want your own children to die, your

00:45:54

loved ones here, well, in Russia we don’t

00:45:58

see much bench press, for example, I have a

00:46:00

lot of relatives who are Asians, Muslims and

00:46:03

not really, and those who lived among Asians and

00:46:05

Muslims, for example in

00:46:08

Uzbekistan. Well, Perestroika happened And from

00:46:12

the Caucasus and from Central Asia, because of the Caucasus,

00:46:15

Russians fled

00:46:18

en masse simply to save their own lives,

00:46:22

abandoning there, for example, you are 506 years old

00:46:27

in your entire life, and you can’t even take away anything, you

00:46:29

have to abandon everything just to

00:46:31

leave there alive, take the children away, and at least

00:46:35

something else there in general You can’t take anything, sell it

00:46:37

All the locals are walking around laughing,

00:46:40

don’t leave, we need slaves And why am I going to

00:46:43

pay you, you’ll leave tomorrow anyway,

00:46:45

I’ll borrow an apartment and everything will be

00:46:47

fine, and these people, leaving everything behind,

00:46:50

came running here. Thank God if they’re alive. And

00:46:52

how many were killed there? like in Chechnya,

00:46:55

how many Russians were there, no

00:46:57

one left at all, where are they?

00:47:00

No, on the one hand, it’s probably

00:47:03

right because civil

00:47:05

war is a bad thing and it’s

00:47:08

impossible to drown it out in any other way except by

00:47:10

silence. But these people, when you listen to

00:47:14

our liberals figures,

00:47:17

how many people did you kill during

00:47:20

perestroika, how many orphans came here

00:47:23

to you, how many do you feed them, not a single one

00:47:26

Well, let's continue the conversation That is, these are

00:47:31

irresponsible people, to put it mildly, roughly

00:47:33

speaking. You

00:47:34

can't listen to them under any

00:47:38

circumstances at all. And this is not a question of Faith. This is

00:47:41

the question of the survival of the country and the population is

00:47:44

something

00:47:49

like this Dear guests, we have time for

00:47:52

two more questions here earlier, another

00:47:55

question from Nasta

00:48:03

Dob

00:48:05

working question is related

00:48:09

to when the Germans attacked St. Petersburg and

00:48:12

there were orders to destroy the

00:48:16

parish, let's say pas conte

00:48:24

[music]

00:48:25

ter

00:48:30

Which should there should be a motivation for people

00:48:33

to destroy buildings and

00:48:37

structures that carried culture and were built by

00:48:41

subhuman people. Why should subhuman people need this? They

00:48:48

broke the Armed Forces, ruined the Armed Forces, what a waste of money, by

00:48:55

the way, you read the current books

00:49:00

there, our citizens seem to be there, so I’m

00:49:04

ironically the cultural capital is on

00:49:07

Nevsky they begin to repair the building, a

00:49:10

wild howl is received from our so-

00:49:12

called self-proclaimed

00:49:14

intelligentsia. What are you doing?

00:49:17

Don’t touch it at all; there are

00:49:18

wonderful

00:49:20

facades of the hands of so-and-so, after

00:49:23

which they are politely informed that

00:49:25

during the war, a

00:49:28

half-ton bomb hit this house; nothing came from it.

00:49:31

left It was built anew by

00:49:34

stupid juices invisible to you, so it was

00:49:37

rebuilt, it fell into disrepair, we have

00:49:39

now rebuilt it Well, deathly silence. That

00:49:42

is, you don’t even know this, and this, in

00:49:44

my opinion, is a generally monstrous page in the

00:49:47

history of the city, what damage was caused,

00:49:50

what was it Looks like Vla good little ones

00:49:53

let out what's wrong with this place

00:49:58

[music] I think it's

00:49:59

very interesting, in general, a

00:50:02

separate country in history is diligently

00:50:05

silent; it's much better to talk about

00:50:07

repressions, this is much more

00:50:25

interesting; they go to the same school in the same

00:50:29

class, apparently they study from the

00:50:32

same

00:50:34

history textbook Well, in one class there can’t

00:50:37

be 10 textbooks, it can’t. What’s the point of

00:50:44

these people teaching like this and those teaching this?

00:50:48

What’s the point? That is, children, in my

00:50:51

opinion, should have a single picture of the

00:50:53

surrounding reality, a single

00:50:56

picture of the history of these people. people like those who are

00:50:58

eager to release 100 textbooks

00:51:02

to give different points of view, I repeat,

00:51:05

a child learns from one textbook, he

00:51:08

cannot study 10 textbooks at once, this

00:51:12

is done Well, in my opinion, with the sole

00:51:15

purpose of disunity and atomization

00:51:18

of society when each citizen has a

00:51:20

completely different picture of the historical

00:51:23

past of his native country why is this

00:51:25

why the government is taking such not very

00:51:29

active steps,

00:51:33

well, we have such a

00:51:35

comrade, we heard this Evgeny Yuch, he

00:51:39

wrote his textbook in five volumes, we

00:51:42

raised money for him, 7 million rubles, he successfully

00:51:45

released it, if you are interested, you can

00:51:48

read this manual for teachers.

00:51:55

And somehow this does not focus on the fact that

00:52:00

at the World Cup In my opinion, it could be

00:52:02

focused on But insofar as

00:52:04

there is now Freedom on the Internet and citizens with

00:52:07

money, a lot of issues can be solved

00:52:09

without the state, what we actually

00:52:14

do successfully can be

00:52:17

briefly The truth about who you believe I

00:52:21

accidentally Lena would go When they already said

00:52:27

6080 there are 100 million and they knew that about

00:52:31

25-30 million of us died during the war, that’s

00:52:35

when the argument arose, the professor in front of such an

00:52:38

audience

00:52:39

organized a vote and said Let’s

00:52:42

vote for whose

00:52:45

relatives died, that is, the parents of the

00:52:48

grandparents during the war and who died

00:52:52

from repressions when during the war there

00:52:56

were

00:52:57

literally only a few hands who could not have raised

00:53:00

when repressions people

00:53:03

then this initiative in Dnepropetrovsk they

00:53:06

did the same

00:53:09

story you see That is, how can I check

00:53:12

even the

00:53:14

facts of

00:53:15

repressions I know

00:53:18

approximately I still have

00:53:27

socialism Well there it was forgotten by someone

00:53:31

And there was a

00:53:32

Leaflet So whoever proves 4 ml of those

00:53:37

repressed by Stalin for all his

00:53:40

years will receive 25

00:53:43

dollars Here is such a book, it’s against

00:53:49

me a little bit

00:54:00

like that,

00:54:03

you know,

00:54:06

I have this in relation to this a

00:54:09

clear example, that is, well, they ask the

00:54:12

question, there were certainly repressions, yes

00:54:15

And no one has ever denied this,

00:54:17

in fact, But we have

00:54:20

such a religion of

00:54:22

Christianity, and with this Christianity there are no

00:54:26

religious differences Which way to

00:54:29

walk around the altar Although Jesus Christ

00:54:31

called to love each other and

00:54:34

there were religious wars and there was, for example, the

00:54:37

Inquisition when people were burned at the stake for

00:54:39

no reason, as you know, and most

00:54:42

of them were burned in Northern Europe, in my opinion,

00:54:45

either Sweden or Germany holds the record for the

00:54:47

number of witches destroyed and Spain is not at all

00:54:49

terrible, but here the question is correct

00:54:53

VS reducing Christianity to

00:54:57

this, in my opinion, is absolutely madness,

00:55:00

religion is not about that. But human

00:55:03

society functions like this, even

00:55:05

in the best things there is always

00:55:08

bad, but the fact that Gorbachev did

00:55:12

this, from my point of view, again,

00:55:14

in relation to religion, it’s the same The

00:55:15

Pope went out onto the balcony in the

00:55:18

Vatican and told the assembled citizens,

00:55:20

dear friends of God, no, let’s disperse.

00:55:25

This is the same thing that Gorbachev

00:55:26

did with the Communist Party somehow like this,

00:55:30

and

00:55:31

Mom, a question about those Let’s wait for

00:55:35

the microphone, the last question, you

00:55:39

can hear everything

00:55:41

that the revolution is at least from the year

00:55:45

The revolution of Ivo in the first year of the year is due

00:55:48

to the fact

00:55:49

that in fact the top gave and

00:55:54

sold the country, and according to your words. This is

00:55:58

not according to my words, this is an objective

00:56:03

fact. We at the beginning began to say that

00:56:07

now the situation in the top has not changed and

00:56:11

then What awaits us and what should we do about the

00:56:14

situation changes all the time and the situation

00:56:17

that was in the early nineties in the late

00:56:20

nineties and now These are completely

00:56:23

different situations, that is, Well, for example, I

00:56:27

see it as under the influence of

00:56:31

external circumstances, our

00:56:34

elite likes it, they don’t like it, there is an example, for

00:56:37

example, Muammar Gaddafi Yes, who had

00:56:40

lying in the west money who

00:56:42

carried out some kind of activity there And they took all his

00:56:45

money and

00:56:46

confiscated it, saying that it was stolen from the people of

00:56:50

Libya and He himself was killed and, in general,

00:56:53

for many it is obvious that these same

00:56:55

many VTs had approximately the same fate when the

00:56:58

money was taken from here to the west, they say

00:57:01

they say for perestroika they took a trillion

00:57:04

dollars to the West, I draw your attention

00:57:08

in the West, no one said that this money

00:57:10

was stolen from the Russian people, no one

00:57:13

said, no one is saying and is not saying yet, but as

00:57:16

soon as the political situation

00:57:19

changes and these people need

00:57:22

money, they will also say that these Degis are Russian

00:57:26

people and now we will

00:57:29

freeze them to Russia, they will not give them back,

00:57:31

just as they never give money

00:57:34

back, and the local Elite, which does not

00:57:37

want to repeat the fate of Muammar

00:57:39

Gaddafi, will be forced to

00:57:42

take the money back and arrange everything within the country

00:57:45

so that we do not

00:57:47

depend on external influences or at

00:57:49

least these external influences had

00:57:52

minimal

00:57:55

KATO sanctions, is this good or bad for the

00:57:58

economy, it’s disgusting, it’s clear

00:58:01

that money has become scarce And everyone around is going

00:58:03

bankrupt en masse, but nevertheless,

00:58:07

some stirrings begin

00:58:10

inside, suddenly it became obvious that the

00:58:13

country needs an army just recently it

00:58:15

was not needed And now it is needed And

00:58:18

military factories work in three shifts, that

00:58:21

is, even at night, this is generally

00:58:23

unprecedented since the end of power,

00:58:27

it’s changing, but I don’t know, it’s changing in the first place.

00:58:30

So they don’t really talk about it.

00:58:32

Well, they don’t cover it because It would be necessary insofar

00:58:36

as this is all military and Is it going in that

00:58:38

direction, it’s

00:58:42

not clear that we have such a

00:58:44

situation because every year

00:58:51

you

00:58:55

think

00:58:56

I act on it

00:58:58

exactly, I act on it with the

00:59:02

same force as you, I don’t like this either, you and I

00:59:05

change this We can’t

00:59:08

call you to an armed uprising. I

00:59:11

also won’t explain to you. I won’t explain who needs to be

00:59:13

killed either, I’m sorry, and I won’t tell you what to do

00:59:17

either.

00:59:20

So, dear guests, Thank you

00:59:23

for coming, our afternoon meeting

00:59:25

is coming up once again if anyone

00:59:28

wants to talk except Dmitry

00:59:30

Yuryevich with the author of the book The War of

00:59:32

Extermination Yegor Nikolaevich

00:59:33

Yakovlev, today at 1730 in the Gorky

00:59:36

Library there will be a presentation of the book

00:59:38

where Dmitry Yuryevich will also be present,

00:59:40

thank you very much, we hope that

00:59:43

you were interesting and useful Thank you

00:59:46

Thank you

00:59:55

very much

00:59:56

L

Description:

00:00 - о книге Егора Яковлева "Война на уничтожение" 26:25 - о революционерах и репрессиях 39:02 - смысл фальсификаций 48:02 - о разрушении культурных памятников 50:14 - о едином учебнике истории 55:30 - о российской "элите" и кризисе

Preparing download options

Popular

HD video

Only sound

All

* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."

** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players

Questions about downloading video

How can I download "Научная среда. Дмитрий Goblin Пучков. Что мы празднуем в День Победы" video?

http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.

Which format of "Научная среда. Дмитрий Goblin Пучков. Что мы празднуем в День Победы" video should I choose?

The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.

Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Научная среда. Дмитрий Goblin Пучков. Что мы празднуем в День Победы" video?

The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.

How can I download "Научная среда. Дмитрий Goblin Пучков. Что мы празднуем в День Победы" video to my phone?

You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.

How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Научная среда. Дмитрий Goblin Пучков. Что мы празднуем в День Победы"?

The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.

How can I save a frame from a video "Научная среда. Дмитрий Goblin Пучков. Что мы празднуем в День Победы"?

This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.

What's the price of all this stuff?

It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.