Download "Безумие Крепчает (Максим Шевченко, Борис Кагарлицкий)"
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F485YAr2IBSY%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
Please wait. We're preparing links for easy ad-free video watching and downloading.
Similar videos from our catalog
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F4DS2BzmYOrY%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FC5w071LXF8s%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FPKbV_bPXAYw%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FWtj9owMYPiE%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252F_HdDGpSEPHQ%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FdOZdGzftyio%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252Fhf4957d0IfY%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252Fl5EgPz7gDlY%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FnA4pUxgP-tA%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252Fv7ztOrdw6O0%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
Video tags
Subtitles
Russian
00:00:10
[music]00:01:47
take it off means00:01:49
lead with the wrong word of course00:01:52
invite invite so to speak see and00:01:55
discuss in general not only the results00:01:57
elections that their correct carcinomas00:01:59
the picture is more or less clear, although maybe00:02:01
you want to say something important but to me00:02:04
it seems that we need to talk about what00:02:06
now what's next because the most00:02:08
the main thing is not what was, what will be00:02:12
let's first why sound him00:02:15
[music]00:02:16
that there is sound now00:02:19
ok dear viewers now it’s crashing again00:02:22
We're having some trouble here, but we'll get there00:02:24
hope that this is not the machinations of anyone and00:02:26
so once again dear viewers again00:02:28
hello, I'm Boris Kagarlitsky in charge00:02:31
editor, rabkor website channels and ours00:02:33
guests as promised before the elections00:02:37
Maxim Shevchenko said that I promised00:02:40
bring maxim to the word bring00:02:42
reacted very00:02:44
so sharply limited it's ironic to say that00:02:47
yes, but without handcuffs and she remembered00:02:49
what do the police tell me when or me on00:02:52
the court was planted they say but like handcuffs00:02:54
you should put it on but I might be wrong00:02:57
did not refuse dug then it00:02:59
there will be posturing, especially no one00:03:02
most likely takes photographs, but in00:03:04
In any case, the point is that00:03:07
Of course we can discuss the election results but00:03:09
It seems to me that if again Maxim wants00:03:12
just talk about the election results00:03:14
it says flag in hand but it seems to me00:03:16
it's more interesting to talk about what00:03:18
now what after the elections whatever00:03:20
situation and what awaits us even more00:03:22
that's just while we're sitting here00:03:24
we talk in general anyway00:03:26
the picture becomes everything in my opinion00:03:28
more gloomy but he again is who is not00:03:31
knows I inform you that Sergei Zuev is the rector00:03:35
Ashaninki went to the hospital yesterday with00:03:37
heart attack at the same time00:03:39
at the same time the prosecutor's office continues00:03:41
the requester was taken into custody00:03:45
from the church that was sent to prison00:03:48
the spruce narrows just burst into view00:03:51
this is an indicator of how much more00:03:54
in the political world we now find ourselves00:03:56
already in the groove selected00:03:59
political procedure during which00:04:01
one of the branches of government would be formed00:04:04
legislation simply does not exist00:04:05
we just saw more in Russia00:04:07
performance which00:04:11
had nothing to do with the process itself00:04:15
was related to the results that00:04:17
eventually00:04:18
what happened in Moscow was announced00:04:21
it's just completely outside the scope00:04:24
common sense just came out00:04:27
Sobyanin announced the list of Sobyanin and00:04:29
this list was simply not demolished, everything was demolished00:04:33
Nastya Udaltsova demolished me in I won00:04:35
I just know for sure they demolished mine, that’s all00:04:39
absolutely00:04:41
Lobanov, the beautiful Lobanov, was given the ropes00:04:43
200:04:45
you on Saturday evening I was 2800:04:48
percent it was a search of the floors and from00:04:50
hostile and the camps seem familiar00:04:54
it’s us who have sunk, you know, and that’s all there is to it00:04:58
I came, I know what we have in general00:04:59
took away the victory literally there for00:05:02
the last hour there was a personal reception00:05:04
the solution is said as they say yes so00:05:06
we were not accused of libel, well, as they say00:05:09
our masters say Moscow sparrows00:05:12
yes, in our opinion, it helped as a universal source in00:05:15
Moscow and a decision was made and this00:05:17
it was just, well, how would it be00:05:19
at the same time and as if demonstrating myself00:05:23
yourself Mr. Yano and the transition from so00:05:26
we call it a parliamentary republic00:05:27
which at least somehow imitated00:05:29
parliamentary republic just to00:05:31
feudal00:05:33
This is not the case with a feudal state in00:05:36
which siren says I am sovereign on mine00:05:40
territory Duke Sobyanin recognize the king00:05:43
Vladimir and but on my territory in my00:05:46
Duchy in my brand I decide who00:05:50
to be some deputies here,00:05:53
Sikhism you know this Mexican00:05:55
the term classic is always a mistake for sure00:05:58
Yes, which Cortes is actually there00:06:00
created when that's how it would be for what you00:06:03
criticized there and such a struggle00:06:05
jambs zm yes yes that is jambs that is00:06:07
the place of the local Morsi which he maintained00:06:10
in the region in to which until which how00:06:12
usually he was from the locals after all, but00:06:14
reported to his superiors00:06:16
it was happening that although he made the capital in00:06:19
conquered tenochtitlan and where he demolished00:06:21
Montezuma's empire and the local schools00:06:25
left anything that was a gift for a long time00:06:27
human sacrifices were made but before00:06:30
still in Mexico as a phenomenon is not screened00:06:33
but as they say, I’m not in Russia00:06:36
jambs of the deputy and in Russia this is them00:06:40
they were looking for Russia which they lost me00:06:42
Do you think this is a refund even for what you did?00:06:44
yourself not the times and Alex before Ivan00:06:48
the formidable, why fight Ivan the formidable00:06:50
boyar as a demonstration of boyar strength00:06:54
and in different regions according to different00:06:56
let's say the fugitive in St. Petersburg showed his00:06:59
quite a lot of helplessness there00:07:01
the Makarov clan seems to be completely00:07:03
dictated the terms and exactly00:07:06
Beatlesque00:07:08
there the resource aka aka turned out to be weaker00:07:10
Makarovsky resources well one way or another00:07:13
everywhere throughout the country large00:07:16
feudal groups that showed00:07:19
in different regions there are the most00:07:21
noticeable like Moscow or others00:07:23
power your strength and00:07:26
this is certainly a very interesting phenomenon00:07:29
a.p. turned out to be not omnipotent in Moscow00:07:33
Sobyanin’s behavior completely violated that00:07:37
the structure that Kiriyenko built00:07:39
legitimacy of competitiveness of minutes00:07:42
in Moscow at the behest of Sobyanin and and00:07:45
lords of Moscow cemeteries Alexey00:07:47
nemeryuk and everything happened I understand that00:07:49
you yourself and the all-Russian background00:07:52
radicalism, no, but they changed it, but00:07:55
not in the sense of what everyone said, but what00:07:57
you elections are rigged but we are just00:08:00
we tell him there are simply no more elections00:08:02
this stage is a procedure in political00:08:04
it makes no sense I agree with you00:08:06
which they of course completely removed00:08:08
political meaning there is one question it00:08:11
I was looking for a performance, I thought too00:08:14
definitely a performance but what's the point00:08:16
the performance that was shown to us here00:08:18
just like the performance there’s no way to do it00:08:20
there were no different meanings to politics00:08:23
meaning client meaning political00:08:26
management of the presidential administration he00:08:28
completely understandable show it00:08:30
to President Putin that you control what00:08:33
they are in control of the situation00:08:34
of course there was only one spectator of the performance00:08:36
Of course there is an agreement with the Communist Party of the Russian Federation00:08:39
I honestly called the number 18 19 back in March00:08:42
speaking despite the cries about what exists00:08:44
only two games and there will be a 50-on-one fight00:08:47
50 1819 there is a new party new people00:08:51
which was created on the knee in which00:08:54
about eight billion were pumped in there for00:08:56
two years, by the way, there is money there00:08:59
not unprecedented money there parts of it00:09:04
made on the basis of faberlic, as it were theirs00:09:06
regional branches were created on the basis00:09:09
companies of regional branches of the company00:09:12
faberlik which frequency is why the main ones00:09:14
sales main faberlic sales for00:09:16
boundaries between us speaking but no one and00:09:19
will never be declared a test agent00:09:20
this is not a denunciation, I am against the concept in general and00:09:24
on agents so I don't think it's00:09:25
something bad business has the right00:09:27
cosmetics there they are sold there and00:09:31
it's kind of personal and that's the thing with Marie00:09:33
they included Leonov, as it were,00:09:35
in Moscow they seemed to be dragging these same ones00:09:38
I don’t even know about Leonov00:09:41
they didn’t include it there with Leon’s badge00:09:44
Sobyaninsky is a man, it’s obvious that00:09:47
a little bit like he loosened the grip on new people00:09:50
which are the key ring of scam00:09:53
conditions you wanted to get in Moscow00:09:56
something you get our man00:09:58
evenly I think that everything is even worse00:10:02
worse, yes, because the conflict has escalated00:10:04
between Volodin Kirienko A.P. showed00:10:08
that they have a contract they can do a lot00:10:09
they can do a lot00:10:13
organize and create in the country00:10:16
we control the elections but what are we up to?00:10:19
large feudal lords do not obey00:10:21
political center Sobyanin and not00:10:23
obey Volodin, do you understand?00:10:26
goes and acts and00:10:30
this was the apotheosis and a kind of summary of everything00:10:33
article by Surkov who did not calculate these00:10:35
democracy and the term is well-fed intermediaries00:10:38
do you need well-fed intermediaries in person00:10:40
deputies00:10:41
which sets the marmots to a final few00:10:44
simplifies the situation by the fact that it’s all the same00:10:47
if we live to enter the world and everyone can00:10:49
here it is 140 minus 100 million from00:10:52
voters immediately absal some question00:10:55
we need some kind of group who will00:10:57
codify this this vote we00:11:00
you don’t have to understand legal00:11:01
nuances it's true there it's good 1 we can00:11:04
let's say, well, many people don't have00:11:07
higher education there or not a lawyer and00:11:09
that's why people should trust00:11:11
to some, but in general, why keep00:11:15
poor middlemen it was just00:11:17
article published on inauguration day00:11:18
the speaker is not the State Duma therefore00:11:21
I think that this is the process that we00:11:24
we can conditionally call it an election for us00:11:26
showed 1 quite serious fight00:11:28
very large groups of feudal lords who00:11:32
the boyars returned to the boyar system00:11:36
which00:11:38
divides and claims large enough00:11:42
pieces of power of the political system00:11:46
the struggle for the redistribution of power has already begun00:11:49
where did she leave the field?00:11:53
political legitimacy00:11:55
usual European politics which00:11:58
rely on democracy as00:12:00
representative institutions of government under00:12:02
rural places and it is carried by the authorities00:12:04
no longer in the sense that it is power00:12:06
represents the people but is in that sense00:12:08
that she represents different groups00:12:10
feudal lords can now be clear in the Duma00:12:13
see which group is in which party00:12:15
introduced by Russia into the Communist Party of the Russian Federation in the summer in other00:12:18
parties of whom representing 3g does not matter00:12:21
which party00:12:22
it doesn't matter at all00:12:23
interest volodin and type salute interest a00:12:26
n group Kiriyenko and type shoots00:12:28
interests of someone else there width00:12:31
modern Volodin I think they are an alliance00:12:34
union for neither is not the same thing00:12:36
of course yes Moscow is too serious and00:12:39
too big too powerful center00:12:41
economically and politically financial and00:12:44
you can see how Sobyanin is grouped around00:12:47
influential people there are the Yevtushenkos who00:12:49
they produce a vaccine, for example, there and so00:12:51
then of course it all goes back to one thing00:12:54
point one person glaze in vain00:12:57
new he is not the king the main viewer of Downey00:13:00
he is the emperor, that's when they asked me00:13:03
and with whom from you there is Putin Sarregre he is not00:13:05
he's not the king himself, he's never in charge00:13:07
apply for this position00:13:09
historical of all historical00:13:11
strangely enough, I can find analogies00:13:14
only francisco franco here we are extensive00:13:16
most similar to a drill00:13:19
because00:13:21
[music]00:13:22
well, a villain or00:13:24
well not a villain he has a certain00:13:28
his position is of course, well let's put it this way00:13:32
rebel against the republic and he00:13:34
destroyed the republic successively00:13:36
Franco in this case Franco but also ways00:13:38
the dictator is starting, of course the dictator00:13:41
of course this dictatorship00:13:43
authoritarian absolutely authoritarian00:13:45
fascism no no this is not fascism even more00:13:49
in addition, any attempts to sled fascist or00:13:51
other driving wheel movement00:13:53
will politically destroy this00:13:55
cardboard system in which which is not00:13:58
implies a real presence in00:14:00
her political subjects with real00:14:04
as if our ideological position00:14:06
the party, in my opinion, scored more00:14:08
five percent were specially drawn for us00:14:10
07 possible00:14:13
is there a clear political rps yes00:14:17
Russian party freedom and00:14:18
justice and atma written on the shirt00:14:20
Well, but in a few words, tell me how00:14:23
how do you see it give me how it is00:14:25
of course we couldn't00:14:27
rely on the regional office00:14:28
naturally because we didn’t receive them00:14:32
we relied on the federal list and00:14:34
for a number of candidates in the tour ganami list then00:14:37
that we had a limited budget and our00:14:40
resources were our access to00:14:42
federal channels is our access to00:14:45
Internet00:14:46
Well, this is some kind of my fame and that’s it00:14:50
including but also some other candidates yes00:14:52
and this is our agenda well dma my Damir00:14:54
Iskhakova Ruslana Kurbanov Dmitry00:14:56
Potapenko00:14:57
Maxima lips lush genes in the region00:14:59
definitely yes and00:15:01
it was a subpoena my only one00:15:04
set the national policy agenda00:15:05
for example, except for us, no one cares about this at all00:15:07
didn't say apple a little something like that00:15:09
he muttered they didn't have it00:15:11
mainstream and00:15:13
my own, yes, I took a risk, played all-in00:15:16
I don't know how this will all turn out but no00:15:20
was to take advantage of this opportunity00:15:21
just in my opinion criminal wine00:15:23
ok anyway00:15:25
Now what00:15:28
finished00:15:30
open or lohan stolen they stole from00:15:35
you and this is if you00:15:37
relatively speaking00:15:39
struggled some intrigue continues but00:15:42
it was stolen from you, maybe it was stolen from you00:15:44
would look at 2 on there at 12 at eleven00:15:47
stolen00:15:48
now the political one has simply been destroyed00:15:51
the election process as a way of forming00:15:56
as representatives of the people00:15:58
in the matter of formation, ask other authorities00:16:01
no longer exist than I think it is00:16:03
everything will be extrapolated in the same way00:16:05
on the regions, as it were, the beginning of a dashing misfortune and00:16:08
everything looks like if Sobyanin can and why in00:16:11
next year Krasnoyarsk region00:16:12
Kondratiev is not allowed, for example, or in00:16:14
Saratov elections next year or there00:16:17
in two years in Rostov it means you can00:16:18
everyone, relatively speaking, yes, now it’s throwing out00:16:22
choice of cat there will be so many choices00:16:24
often just don't00:16:28
fate of fargala konovalova sternum00:16:31
show that they are not guys00:16:33
they say why go there it is necessary00:16:37
somehow go through hydra coordination too00:16:40
naked risk00:16:42
the eighteenth year will not happen again00:16:44
so I think it hurts that your question00:16:47
correct in a situation of destruction00:16:50
external participation agenda although I think00:16:52
which should still be used in00:16:54
Heroically, elections should be used for00:16:56
I need to physically contact Sberbank now00:16:59
reaction time stagnation time in00:17:03
political sense but every time00:17:06
reactions should become like it was00:17:08
also in particular in Russian history00:17:10
Russian liberation movement00:17:12
time of intense intellectual00:17:14
Lenin's key works were00:17:17
written minutes after seven00:17:19
those years were very important00:17:22
moments related to strategy and00:17:25
tactics of the Prague liquidation party00:17:27
party conference you are in your twelfth year00:17:29
liquidationism withdraw the zm but we are with00:17:32
Bogdanov legal Marxism from the pipe00:17:35
there is a very good book by Theodor Shanin00:17:38
revolution how you changed the family just00:17:41
shown as Lenin including this00:17:44
good, still sealed, thinking about it00:17:46
results of the first Russian revolution00:17:48
forward reactions there and Teodor Shanin and you00:17:50
showed it brilliantly showed it too slice00:17:53
referring to Shanin Login and correspondent Murza00:17:56
very much too he is the history of Russian00:17:59
he has a revolution he is Shanina by the way00:18:01
I constantly quote and he says that00:18:04
Dolinin suddenly realized that the Marxist00:18:06
the scheme doesn’t work in Russia but he’s an eccentric00:18:09
greasy from00:18:10
the orthodox never went there00:18:13
break with the second international that is00:18:15
actually years when publicly00:18:18
politically nothing could be done00:18:19
there's 600:18:21
7 7 7 years to 6 more revolutions of course00:18:26
lasted 7 years, that's when the faction00:18:30
Bolshakov means when we were00:18:31
elections at 1300:18:33
Yes, it’s a gift for us, and that is, this is how you lived00:18:36
before the war on the pier yes that was it00:18:40
make the most of it00:18:43
those were the intellectual years those were the years00:18:46
at the beginning when Trotsky had it there too00:18:49
so it was what it was called00:18:52
group forward sheep that is not August00:18:54
block until the August block was called and00:18:56
Bogdo and why is there a discussion with Bogdanov00:18:59
which in my opinion entered anal and00:19:02
Russian simply philosophical philosophy00:19:04
thoughts, well, in general it was a heyday and insi00:19:07
insi intellectual comprehension is and00:19:09
on the right flank there were naturally milestones00:19:11
you understand there and everything connected with it00:19:14
and in general I think this is it right now00:19:18
a very important task may be due to00:19:20
with an understanding of this task, they too00:19:22
draw conclusions and pogrom shanin ki how00:19:25
one of the intellectual centers00:19:28
well, which is at the junction of the left00:19:31
thoughts of liberal thought because there00:19:35
are you used to the left or I will be heavenly spam00:19:37
bring 1 Yudin closer and there is, as it were,00:19:41
there are liberals and such people are right there00:19:44
consciousness that is, it is intellectual00:19:46
the club is so janine analogous to which even00:19:50
higher school of economics or university00:19:52
we are such an analogue, perhaps it is00:19:55
destruction specifically to stop and00:19:57
destroy intellectual life00:19:59
systemic in Russia and two arrests and00:20:02
attempts to arrest Sergei I will get Obukhov00:20:06
you know it will hit you with blows00:20:07
intellectually there were attempts by light00:20:10
got the hut they tried to arrest him00:20:12
but when they realized that he was a deputy00:20:14
they, as they say, they obviously didn’t have00:20:17
the papers said that Sergei Palych00:20:18
became a deputy so they got it00:20:20
attempts to arrest that intimidation00:20:23
Achiva's picture you understand time very much00:20:26
such a fine was issued and God forbid00:20:28
monstrously a fine of 200,250 thousand under00:20:32
half a million, which of course goes without saying00:20:34
ruin after ruin completely00:20:36
fines00:20:37
[music]00:20:39
so I decided that it is extremely important now00:20:42
I see a special role for workers’ correspondents in this00:20:44
which all these years remained mine00:20:47
look well00:20:48
probably the main intellectual thread00:20:51
scientific center of left thought in Russia00:20:55
this is actually an open discussion00:20:57
I don’t see any prospects right now00:21:00
political coalitions00:21:02
or dust platforms and don't want them00:21:05
I'll tell you right away to participate with us00:21:08
were determined during these elections by each00:21:10
I'm one of us00:21:13
color00:21:15
I'm not embarrassed at all by him00:21:19
clearly and clearly in00:21:23
political sense00:21:24
disassociate from the Communist Party of the Russian Federation but in human terms00:21:27
I mean, I have great sympathy00:21:29
to many members of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation, including00:21:32
for those who became a deputy, I know what’s there and00:21:34
wonderful enlightened people and those who00:21:36
did not become deputies and in which I00:21:40
I just believe especially the younger generation00:21:43
maybe they could read a little book00:21:45
I don’t even always recommend yours00:21:46
read books for undoubtedly just the format00:21:49
I have a counter question too, I’m just00:21:52
In general, I listen to you with great interest and00:21:54
it seems to me that really00:21:57
intellectual work goes there too00:21:58
you strive and this is just what I chose00:22:02
opportunities I welcome that the movement for00:22:05
the new socialism that arose our00:22:07
eyes that are quite radical00:22:09
human sense despite00:22:11
Nikolay's restrictions on payment for this00:22:14
enough in a good political sense00:22:16
radical movements I know I just see00:22:19
what do people think there?00:22:20
there are a lot of people like that there00:22:23
populist then Montego author's themes00:22:25
in the hay there is there so on but they00:22:27
undoubtedly00:22:28
radicalize the Communist Party of the Russian Federation that you are for us00:22:31
actually joined the Communist Party of the Russian Federation00:22:34
personal wife pays for Angelica00:22:37
Glazkova of course by agreement with00:22:39
Athos understands this, so what?00:22:41
that Maria of the Prussians was tired and won00:22:44
the list means it has become single-member00:22:46
to deputies00:22:47
Well, I'm sure I can by agreement00:22:50
Naturally Angelica and the city became00:22:52
Deputy, I think this is very serious00:22:55
event because in dns as far as I am00:23:00
I see00:23:01
there are very interesting processes going on there00:23:04
there is literally pressure and demand00:23:07
radicalization from below yes, as it were, Nikolai00:23:09
handkerchiefs ntam has a huge00:23:12
authority00:23:13
but this is not a sect, that is, these are not words00:23:16
the prophet there demands, as it were, activity00:23:20
and this pressure will inevitably be00:23:23
end up in the Communist Party too00:23:25
I am of course a mouse of the Communist Party nomenclature00:23:28
the matter is minimal but they have a lot of experience00:23:30
for this part number eight again00:23:33
why should he have that Misha00:23:35
Delyagin, for example, went to the same place for me00:23:37
I was interested in the result because00:23:39
do at least at the verbal level00:23:42
which will be pronounced00:23:44
show your such a radical voice00:23:48
criticism is acceptable, but Delyagin is not criticized00:23:51
from the left position00:23:53
Diogenes and somehow softer00:23:55
formulate00:23:57
delyagin delyagin corporate health00:24:00
state to put it mildly something00:24:02
I'm sure he's a wonderful person00:24:05
I have a lot of sympathy for him00:24:06
books in general yes everything is correct00:24:10
he said yes, just look at what he00:24:12
now he speaks when he speaks00:24:14
definitely anchored at Millerovo00:24:17
the voice of the people will be heard00:24:19
Mikhail Gennady Delyagin I have no doubt00:24:21
Well, I haven’t arrived now Grisha, congratulations00:24:25
here but I'm getting to where we're talking about good00:24:28
here are the elections as they were00:24:31
I thought big, as they say, this is not the place00:24:34
for discussions on them nothing more00:24:37
ball one went even further you get00:24:40
salary so why are you opposing us00:24:42
need opposition rock volodin yes here00:24:44
should not de position everyone who receives00:24:46
salary we must be united honestly00:24:48
saying sometimes they brought it into the chapel00:24:50
political party really00:24:52
opposition they could have told me00:24:55
need your salary they could00:24:56
refuse the Duma salary after all00:24:58
party that receives 4 billion00:25:01
almost within five years due to00:25:03
votes by percentage00:25:06
about three and a half 4 billion00:25:09
could pay a similar salary00:25:11
my deputy live on less why00:25:14
less is possible and so am I00:25:16
you could definitely stand up and tell Volodin00:25:20
keep your money we don't want from00:25:22
depend on you and become independent France00:25:24
They didn’t wait, of course, but not even for a minute00:25:27
ok, what should we do with this?00:25:29
decent people decent deputies00:25:31
which are still there, what would you00:25:34
I would advise them to perform00:25:36
advised me to speak and I can say that00:25:39
they hear here I am when these appeared00:25:42
data on torture in Saratov means00:25:45
soup Saratov sendo I immediately contacted00:25:48
to the deputies of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation on the echo of Moscow00:25:51
never heard me, I was looking for you00:25:54
I ask you to be the only faction that I am00:25:56
know can initiate a hearing about00:25:58
parliamentary investigation naturally00:26:01
United Russia failed very much00:26:02
interesting to see the name00:26:04
voting in general Communist Party factions all00:26:07
were for against. surprisingly00:26:10
Alexander Yushchenko and Sergei Gavrilov are like this00:26:14
Orthodox this one which is loaded with scandal00:26:17
Yushchenko was then really justified00:26:19
the press secretary has already spoken with knives00:26:21
I wasn't there when I logged out00:26:24
I got it wrong, I don't know how it happened00:26:27
I even wrote a statement there for him saying00:26:29
he is behind there and so on, but in fact00:26:31
because there to Lisa, what else is very00:26:34
seriously, this is the Saratov Federal Penitentiary Service00:26:36
Boldino territory is the question00:26:39
Vyacheslav Viktorovich who was elected00:26:41
single-mandate deputies in Saratov00:26:43
truth on your territory00:26:46
wild crimes are happening00:26:49
regarding the rights of citizens up to which there00:26:52
there are dishes there guilty innocent00:26:54
that most innocent people don't care00:26:57
I know that according to the law on the status of a deputy00:27:00
the fact that I myself used it in00:27:02
Vladimir region deputy00:27:04
has the right of the State Duma00:27:06
enter any season and any prison00:27:09
and no one can stop him00:27:11
I remember meeting any prisoner00:27:14
there in the presence00:27:15
security as opposed to the lawyer or members00:27:19
n.k. let me say as a deputy00:27:22
regional legislative assembly in the season I can00:27:24
come and the State Duma deputy may go to jail00:27:27
they cannot prevent him from entering00:27:29
I have to go if it's right for me00:27:31
there's a letter to a relative, here I am, well, well00:27:34
or the prisoner asked me adi brother00:27:36
The State Duma may not wait for this letter00:27:38
Volodin may well come there00:27:42
Moreover, a State Duma deputy can00:27:45
territory of the entire country not dative from00:27:47
who could cut down which water is chosen here00:27:50
Let's say you were elected there from a coma, that's how00:27:53
Oleg Mikhailov, but Oleg can calmly00:27:56
in Irkutsk, let’s say the sizhok is a torture chamber00:27:58
come and so on I'm sure it's00:28:02
the country will see and hear this agenda00:28:05
which I have never seen in the entire history00:28:08
In my opinion, only the Liberal Party of Russia came to the State Duma00:28:12
like this in prison because the LDPR faction00:28:14
it was always connected like, well, this00:28:17
that's right, I'll come and go to jail00:28:19
going to help people the parish itself is simple00:28:22
going to prison I already know can save a life00:28:25
man and he will not be released, but he00:28:28
I'll stop having such cases00:28:31
it’s just my arrival, just interest00:28:34
that the owner of the zone immediately [ __ ]00:28:36
there will still be a little writing there because there are problems00:28:38
will be fine there let him live there00:28:40
in six months so you will start again00:28:42
You can come back again in six months00:28:44
to this topic yes00:28:47
that is, it is very important that they00:28:50
can do this within the scope of authority00:28:52
of course no one will attend their performance00:28:54
broadcast at least they are there OP OP00:28:57
I speak for everyone on the podium of the state00:28:59
think and campbell how they perform00:29:01
so I’m not looking specifically where you are00:29:03
well, something like that, you have to look for it somehow00:29:06
really it's not00:29:08
walking00:29:09
something sometimes walks in general deputies00:29:13
have the right to meet people00:29:15
deputies have the right00:29:18
how Valery Rashkin did it00:29:21
meetings with voters weeks to do this00:29:23
on the streets so that people don’t get it later00:29:25
there are deadlines for doing this00:29:27
in various other ways the deputy has00:29:30
the right to initiate verification of credentials00:29:32
the deputies are still very large, but here they are00:29:36
this prison topic is very important00:29:38
moment is very important and00:29:41
It is characteristic that the faction is new people00:29:43
in pairs almost entirely00:29:45
abstained from voting00:29:47
voted did not receive a signal from above00:29:49
how they should vote on the bill00:29:52
which proposed the Communist Party of the Russian Federation, by the way, from the words00:29:56
Nikolai handkerchiefs but he said it was00:29:57
Angelica Eyes was like the initiator00:30:00
this idea was presented in faction00:30:04
stoned deputy kaprov is very much a doctor00:30:08
date of Ulyanovsk so I think that00:30:11
Communist Party time will be like the era itself00:30:15
like it or not, no matter how Zyuganov00:30:17
swore my love by the way there you understand00:30:20
in meetings with him they seemed to be silent00:30:22
millers and00:30:24
this same Kashin there Novikov was in response00:30:28
to Putin's question, does anyone want to look for00:30:29
tell them Putin is the only faction00:30:32
who did he address this question to?00:30:34
Communist Party of the Russian Federation after matches Yuganova Putin00:30:37
looked at Melnikov and forever00:30:39
bitten00:30:40
would you like to add anything else?00:30:43
want to00:30:44
there would be questions that00:30:48
it was understandable no one wanted00:30:50
nothing to add00:30:51
then there is such an opportunity00:30:54
so I think everything will depend on00:30:56
how much the deputies of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation especially00:30:59
single-member members will feel00:31:01
they are representatives of voters00:31:04
hostage to the fact that they owe something00:31:07
I don’t know if it’s Yuganov’s kashina or00:31:11
We'll somehow reach an agreement with the administration00:31:13
the president or Volodin yes yes it is00:31:15
unsafe yes it may be bad for them00:31:18
turn around but this is definitely not a country00:31:21
will forget it will certainly do them00:31:23
serious political figures, well00:31:25
in other words, the main question is00:31:27
question00:31:28
eternal courage now up to personal what00:31:31
in English it's called by the way00:31:33
The Russian word integrity is interesting, yes here it is00:31:35
while being true to yourself00:31:37
or your principles and00:31:40
well, somewhere strangely political00:31:43
fantasy which is just bad we always00:31:45
ready to advise comrade if they00:31:48
look for sure he won't see he went00:31:50
some comrades are watching, I think that00:31:52
there are guys who have fantasies00:31:53
fantasy everything is fine I'll be close00:31:57
imagination on Mikhail Delyagin with00:31:59
everything is great in the imagination00:32:01
practically even less political00:32:02
imagination but I remember Sartre before00:32:04
imagination put it as if but00:32:06
Imagination is necessary even in such moments00:32:08
especially because ready-made recipes00:32:10
There are no ready-made templates, they must00:32:15
remember that power does not exist like00:32:17
some dense environment of power, then their people00:32:20
desires, their relationship and also dialogues00:32:24
as we understood from Putin’s speech at00:32:26
Valdai Club00:32:27
there is no such thing as moderate00:32:30
conservatism00:32:31
just healing you're great great this is00:32:35
healthy moderate conservatism is00:32:37
accommodation has not changed anything00:32:40
nothing has changed like it is now00:32:41
it's already uncomfortable, I've achieved a lot and not00:32:44
I want something to change but that’s all00:32:46
the key idea by the way is water from real00:32:48
by the way, this is life, I’ll show you what it is00:32:51
really the idea that we don't want anything00:32:53
It’s good for us to change, but there are others who don’t00:32:55
applies very well means with this00:32:57
decided wrong yes what is your city00:33:00
the problem is yes, but there is something for us00:33:04
this is the logic of not changing anything00:33:07
it’s very dangerous because for whom00:33:10
will happen when you have five thousand security forces00:33:12
5 million security forces is not for you00:33:15
dangerous on salary will not say00:33:18
feeding is actually in order when00:33:21
the authorities rely too much on the security forces00:33:24
this is bad for one reason00:33:25
the security forces will be defeated by the husband, the security forces themselves00:33:27
what will he say stop?00:33:30
the real power is there00:33:32
it's unlikely00:33:35
It’s unlikely that these security forces will say that00:33:38
the analysis here will tell everyone who should00:33:42
who can't tell00:33:44
turned until they walked to00:33:47
ok00:33:48
yes all couples are caudillo franco00:33:51
I looked at everyone and left, I don’t see the light00:33:55
then then they killed the gi he appointed00:33:58
the successor of the general Blank who killed00:34:01
and this is the Basque review for the year00:34:04
literally how long I don’t remember yet00:34:06
Franco's life was or when we have such00:34:09
that's it yes but but but it's hot00:34:13
guys [ __ ] around the real successor and00:34:16
the Basques blew it up it was so very00:34:19
loud tourist what was it real00:34:22
successors here after the death of the form00:34:23
it turned out that there were no other candidates for00:34:27
caudillo and then began in Spain00:34:29
very interesting process when I was there00:34:31
I don’t remember which one is on the right00:34:36
[music]00:34:37
Aznar00:34:40
in short, democratization began and00:34:43
liberalization perk is back the king is00:34:45
means juan carlos00:34:47
son because his father Franco doesn't00:34:50
even allowed people to come to Spain like us00:34:52
we know because Franco was anti00:34:54
a monarchist he was not a correspondent of punishment00:34:57
Karlis K party in Spain is00:34:59
their hood is monarchical in nature00:35:02
always held back punishment00:35:05
Franco of course ideologically probably00:35:07
would have been a fascist, but he understood that00:35:11
it's hard for fascists to be because of heritage00:35:13
there he is Antonio right there to Rivera Primo00:35:17
de rivera, etc. it's like he's his father00:35:20
won’t be able to adapt to himself later00:35:21
the military did not accept the fascists anyway00:35:23
fascists phalanx st and well, romantically00:35:26
Strangely enough, poetic people are also00:35:29
in Spain everything carried it is acceptable00:35:31
Lorca hid from murderers in his house00:35:34
comrade of the phalanx 100 who you hid and00:35:37
bleach was tricked into taking away and00:35:40
shoot me later, well, I don’t want to go there00:35:43
deepen00:35:44
in short, after that the process began00:35:47
Corellia the leader of the Spanish a returned00:35:50
Corelli giving out nothing comparative00:35:53
who is experiencing the thirties here00:35:56
forties in Stalin's Soviet00:35:58
union yet00:35:59
It's a miracle he wasn't repressed00:36:02
then it’s all the same then his Brezhnev00:36:05
there he branded communism for the euro and he00:36:09
played a huge role in particular00:36:10
time of fascist coup attempt 8200:36:13
the year when the military broke into parliament00:36:15
and you can shoot everyone, lie down and that’s it00:36:17
climbed under those same ones and the correlation is00:36:20
it is known that he lit a cigarette and folded the salt in his hands00:36:23
hands soon I'm not going to the principle of parties00:36:26
it's burning, you'll shoot me, that's why kids00:36:28
you [ __ ] fascist bastards he said00:36:32
by the way, Spain overcame them00:36:36
a very important process of leaving dictatorship00:36:39
due to and this is a very complex system00:36:42
very similar to Russia because00:36:44
regional conflicts are incredible00:36:47
before terrorist conflicts00:36:48
Catalan Boston terrorism00:36:51
Asturian separatism is generally different00:36:54
languages you know us andalusia cat00:36:57
Castile and all that stuff00:37:01
they were able to help them of course00:37:04
support for the European Union and inclusion00:37:06
the European Union is everything but in general we00:37:10
We are now entering a period when our00:37:12
potential for destiny is full of strength that he00:37:15
shows everywhere, nowhere of course, no down00:37:18
I'm never really going to leave00:37:21
it's clear no one is going anywhere it's obvious otherwise00:37:24
the system will be built according to the factor00:37:26
having it as the highest point00:37:29
strategic political power00:37:32
I thought he wouldn't be president00:37:34
over perfect how can it not be00:37:36
one thing you have to constantly be like00:37:38
as if dependent on what everyone knows00:37:42
like an imitation, everyone knows none00:37:44
there is no presidential election it's all going on00:37:47
such a head of the council and therefore00:37:52
please be Iranian00:37:55
Iranian food seems to be cool00:37:58
is the guy really there or are you serious00:38:01
but it is clear that the authorities are all aurora au00:38:03
spiritual leader and then spirituality00:38:06
there is no well there is Elvira's stan00:38:08
operational security officer has a wife00:38:11
Kazakh version00:38:13
Kazakhstani in a row slightly different00:38:14
because he is Nursultan Nazarbayev00:38:16
after all, a from the party environment b00:38:19
Kazakhstan states completely00:38:21
obvious and clear national basis00:38:25
the face of the Kazakh Kazakh nation who00:38:28
went from ethnicity to political00:38:31
nations can even obviously say though00:38:33
there are difficulties with everyone there00:38:35
let's say in specifics00:38:38
this is a slightly different legitimacy of Katya00:38:41
Nazarbayev's legitimacy within00:38:42
Kazakhstan she is definitely because he00:38:45
is the leader of the Kazakh00:38:50
ethnic space or of course not00:38:52
everyone recognizes him, there is opposition00:38:55
does it appear among the body kits?00:38:58
or so on or left is enough00:39:01
the strong who criticize00:39:03
lived Azinski events even on women's00:39:07
the event is very criticism is liberal00:39:10
opposition but the elite is the national Kazakh summer00:39:13
of course it is consolidated around him00:39:15
of course the state is of an authoritarian type00:39:17
quite00:39:20
national there is no national here00:39:22
the fact is all attempts to say that I am there00:39:24
to the ruler of the Russians, we are Russians, they are, as it were,00:39:26
in Russia it’s so strange to be honest00:39:28
sound, you know, that is, Russia before00:39:31
Russia is too too diverse00:39:33
too varied too00:39:35
imperial has a history of dragging and00:39:38
the design of the plows is here, that's why they're like this00:39:41
things are therefore Spanish, so it is very00:39:44
interesting parameter means very00:39:46
unexpected because the comparison of Russia with00:39:49
in Spain I hardly heard anyone indignant00:39:51
I can really compare you with someone00:39:53
let's compare00:39:54
I won’t let Spain, I’ll pull out my thoughts to the end00:39:58
that we have such a feature at all00:40:01
Russian intelligentsia are compared00:40:04
I’ll get the best one and soon I’ll trade better00:40:07
the worst side there are parallels of analogy and00:40:09
here is a comparison with Spain that is unexpected00:40:13
me because this is a comparison00:40:16
there is no cruelest country in Europe00:40:19
This number is only in Britain00:40:22
terrible regional conflict00:40:24
but in Britain it's actually a few00:40:26
countries, let's be honest even with00:40:28
authority even without football00:40:31
commands yourself what do you need these00:40:33
I'll say more Atlanta pound separate 100:40:36
to 1 calling him and the tracks in Spain00:40:38
struggle between regional separatism00:40:41
why was it purchased in armed form?00:40:43
uprisings in different types of Basques for example00:40:47
Karlis you monarchists relied on during00:40:50
fight means with the liberals who were sitting in00:40:53
Madrid on Boston exactly and then on00:40:55
Easter new leaned and left radicals00:40:57
Bosgone was allowed at first00:40:59
conservative Catholic yes and then00:41:01
suddenly the set became the left color and in00:41:05
overall it's pretty late00:41:06
because the lands form for nationalism00:41:09
Basque for the region and in Spain it is very00:41:12
it is strongly felt that there are zones somewhere and nowhere00:41:15
Castilla doesn't work on where their capital is00:41:17
Spanish castilla on it is just not for me00:41:19
they say and it’s important for the coupon00:41:22
catalonia basquenia part ando better00:41:25
salon between Catalonia unfortunate Spaniards00:41:28
actually discriminate, of course, and00:41:31
maintaining a single format00:41:33
Spain as a single state is00:41:36
a political problem that everyone solved00:41:38
the leftists decided, the liberals decided there, Franco00:41:41
it’s just in a situation of dictatorship when everyone00:41:43
All the leaders simply blew their heads off00:41:46
for Catalan sake, he just00:41:47
shot there or all the Basques who00:41:50
performed, managed to open their mouths too00:41:52
shot but this led to00:41:55
because the problem was driven internally00:41:57
appeared this brutal tourist00:41:59
organizations really, let's be honest00:42:02
or were in Catalonia too00:42:04
a terrorist organization is not00:42:06
solved the problem, this is what happened now00:42:08
that's what we've seen now in Denmark days00:42:11
this is not so long ago and even liberals who00:42:15
Socialists rule Spain were forced00:42:17
act in completely dictatorial ways00:42:18
that is, arrest and repress00:42:21
leaders of the Catalan movement00:42:23
recognize the Catalan referendum and that's it00:42:25
stuff like that in Russia00:42:28
regional separatism as it were00:42:31
regional identity this this too00:42:33
a constant problem and you just can’t solve it00:42:36
as Franco decided or what00:42:37
Putin is trying to solve some of the problems simply00:42:39
elimination of regional sovereignty and00:42:42
the right thing to do in Russia is to decide00:42:44
the only way is federal00:42:45
agreement00:42:46
this should be a federal republic00:42:48
in which all regions have equal rights00:42:51
that is, Vladim, I am in favor of00:42:54
the Vladimir region had the same00:42:56
rights like Tatarstan were signed00:42:59
federal agreement but the first point00:43:02
of this agreement should be the main00:43:03
a political crime is00:43:05
demands for the collapse of the federation, exits from00:43:08
federation, that's what I think, and then00:43:10
the people of the regions must be provided00:43:13
maximum regional specificity00:43:15
component and these are the interests of the peoples of Russia00:43:18
our party is the only one00:43:20
spoke and formulated this during00:43:22
elections the ruling party opposes this00:43:24
in Russia there is peripheral capitalism00:43:26
which you described so beautifully because00:43:29
what does this mean that it is necessary with everyone00:43:31
regions to agree on something00:43:33
there is no exploitation of forest subsoil and so on00:43:36
On the contrary, we need to unify everything00:43:39
transfer to the province convert her pick up00:43:41
provinces to take the money and how00:43:43
gas has begun to sell these resource assets00:43:46
forest there and so on to the west to the east to whom00:43:49
anything for feeding the ruling means00:43:52
the top of the feudal her feudal00:43:54
which00:43:56
I read a lot of Frank Herbert playing there00:43:59
dune but plays quite realistically between me00:44:01
It seems that it’s not Harrison that you’ve rather read00:44:03
burns de broto in general these cheerful utopias00:44:07
60s 70s you know which one goes there00:44:10
you scored the chronicles of amber the chronicles of amber00:44:15
this is just fim's favorite book00:44:16
Ostrovsky was which seemed very00:44:19
often referred to I remember lectures film00:44:21
Viktorovich who was very close to00:44:22
current guide to he often you00:44:25
gave the example of the Chronicles of Amber like this00:44:27
there is a genuine center everything else00:44:29
means the reflection of the image there and this00:44:33
very important point just to understand00:44:34
that's why our struggle today is a struggle for00:44:38
national rights for regional rights00:44:41
this fight is about the rights of peoples therefore00:44:43
when a topic arises in Tatarstan00:44:46
language which is very important for the Tatars00:44:49
a beggar is first perceived as an infringement00:44:51
how segregation to attempts at assimilation00:44:54
I say for Russians today the fight is for00:44:57
the rights of Tatars to learn the language is a struggle for00:45:00
rights of Russians there are no separate rights today00:45:03
I think that’s actually Lenin’s position00:45:06
that these are positions clearly expressed by Lenin00:45:08
article of national pride00:45:10
Great Russians and Putin is constant and00:45:13
entourage above and ruling in Russia00:45:15
capitalist stones but they could well00:45:17
liberals say from there or children00:45:19
they live in France they are liberals but here00:45:22
as if they say we are Russian Russians00:45:25
they constantly exploit the topic00:45:26
Russian on the shell than the Russian people00:45:28
he is dying out, he is practically non-existent00:45:30
passes virtual space00:45:32
such an urban lumpen00:45:35
gestalt of the collective Lubinsky and00:45:38
and or completely grotesque forms when there00:45:41
Kadyrov or Yevkurov it turns out we are Russian00:45:45
speak up and soon I will be a gorilla00:45:47
Russian personnel here means some00:45:50
Russian tengu but I mean shin no00:45:52
so I'm a Russian officer, there's a Russian there00:45:55
there are, as it were, Russian officials independently00:45:57
by nationality00:45:59
you know this is a very important point00:46:01
There is00:46:03
that is why the analogy with Spain is very00:46:06
Interesting00:46:07
well, well, the morning is not eternal, Franco is not evening00:46:11
A00:46:12
We have the form Smertin and Oleg00:46:15
questions I have to just hand over put them on00:46:18
Even the viewer has already accumulated questions for me00:46:21
put on headphones and now00:46:25
let's work with the audience and so dear00:46:27
friends, we are waiting for questions Oleg Antonov cameras00:46:31
what kind of traveling side is this?00:46:32
Borisevich Maxim can you hear me we can hear00:46:35
yes, but at first you can't a little00:46:38
louder I'll be okay I'll be a little louder00:46:40
speak00:46:42
yesterday's question you and I when was00:46:44
Victoria Garcia Bernal streams here00:46:47
just00:46:48
by all means, that means the code is on the gene course00:46:51
Stepan writes on Boris Maxim's stream00:46:54
Shevchenko expressed that he was ready to support00:46:55
any initiatives00:46:57
who will defend the rights00:46:59
workers on their channel Maurice00:47:01
help wiki get to maxim00:47:03
maximum and ask for words00:47:05
no need to ask before I'm ready00:47:08
support00:47:10
simple help00:47:12
give me my phone, it will solve everything00:47:16
we fulfilled our obligations so on00:47:19
so it’s just given by the user00:47:22
Marat sent 600 rubles without00:47:23
any message00:47:25
so Evgeny asks Boris if00:47:29
Maxim with Grigory Yudin and Alexey00:47:31
Sakhnin they will develop a concept of anti00:47:35
methodologist will this be the one00:47:38
with a kashcheev needle, but not only no00:47:42
there is no spark, I'm happy to look for it00:47:44
I know Peter Shchedrovitsky very well00:47:45
We know this logical school very well00:47:47
I am not a methodologist myself, but I have been00:47:50
participated in seminars conducted00:47:51
Pyotr Georgich, I have all the best regards00:47:54
I relate to00:47:56
[music]00:47:58
philosophical legacy of Georgy Petrovich and00:48:00
Trinity I don’t think that any00:48:02
I don't think this is profanation00:48:05
after all, like any philosophical school00:48:07
she is true in some ways, but also in some ways she is00:48:10
it is not true that any philosophical00:48:13
position she does not claim00:48:15
the absoluteness of even Hegel and Lecant00:48:18
one can criticize Nietzsche and Schopenhauer00:48:20
Heidegger Baudrillard and even Marx00:48:23
Marx can be criticized, that's why I don't00:48:26
I want to create nothing anti methods00:48:28
logical but I think in the middle00:48:30
roads and here I understand there is no water00:48:32
open the methodology of thinking it must00:48:35
be deep meaningful and important and00:48:38
the very criticism of some philosophical school00:48:41
and is the development of philosophy forward00:48:44
this is known so to be honest I00:48:47
to the methodology of thinking to school00:48:49
I regard Shchedrovitsky with great respect00:48:51
with respect and with great interest this00:48:54
there is some subtext to the question00:48:58
the influence of the Shchedrovitsky school is already thinking00:49:02
administration I'm not doing anything wrong there00:49:04
I see because at least it allows00:49:06
systematize if this influence00:49:07
was real I don't think she's real00:49:10
that I don’t regret leaving this school00:49:13
never no it's not like that no he came out00:49:16
Komsomol and left the business, he just00:49:19
actively interacted at some point00:49:21
With00:49:22
Efim Ostrovsky we are Georgy generous and00:49:24
Peter generously Viktorovich he did not leave00:49:27
metro camp school this is wrong00:49:29
understanding later it doesn’t matter where it came from00:49:32
Kiriyenko besides him there is still a lot00:49:33
the people there are not a dictatorship, Yanin did not come out of00:49:36
this school and others behind this one00:49:38
schools believe me therefore00:49:42
if the methodology of thinking which00:49:44
allows you to organize the cutting process00:49:47
isolate the main thing, put the main thing00:49:49
that this is an association of collective00:49:51
efforts in the formation of common goals00:49:54
but the system doesn’t work like that, and even the most00:49:58
outstanding philosophers and methodologists00:50:00
once there they will act based on00:50:02
from their philosophical views or00:50:05
methodology is there, Putin’s favorite00:50:07
Ivan Ilyin let's say yes, well, he's not stupid00:50:10
philosopher although they called the sergeant major00:50:12
philosophy yes but our task but there for now00:50:14
not clearly indicated in this collection00:50:17
and from our point of view, he and he are fascist00:50:20
did not hide his sympathy for fascism00:50:22
but in general the political ones are clearly named00:50:24
tasks if he were there he turned00:50:27
just like a gray official00:50:29
executive philosophy doesn't work there00:50:32
there00:50:33
Berdyaev you would turn into such a nonsense00:50:36
I know anyone, you name it, you understand exactly00:50:38
also, oddly enough, in Stalin's00:50:40
the control system was not needed there00:50:43
I needed philosophers there00:50:46
Bukharin Bukharin's death is not because00:50:48
about the sword and met with Trotskyists in00:50:50
Europe when he was sent to study Tamara00:50:53
I'm there there is an archive of Marx and Engels before00:50:56
I'll get up to hell he was there and that's it00:50:59
clearly there is one philosopher the rest00:51:02
you understand interpreters here too00:51:05
the most important thing is that you climb into00:51:08
someone gathered their methodologies00:51:09
interprets it or something with his own00:51:11
pledge and thinking seats blather00:51:13
similarly therefore methodology of thinking00:51:16
Believe me it's wonderfully interesting00:51:18
Sergei's deep philosophical school00:51:20
dorje in which we mention he is one of00:51:22
leading00:51:25
Well, let's just say he's still in the Companions00:51:29
the first students parsley in my opinion yes yes00:51:31
his cultural policy with Peter too00:51:35
they are friends as far as I know where you cut00:51:37
I immediately came out in support of him, I remember00:51:39
lectures by Sergei Zueva on cultural00:51:42
politics is deeply interesting in00:51:44
basically a thing this is why why like this00:51:47
There is no need to think about methodology in clichés00:51:50
and don’t sin Oleg00:51:53
so here donat came Alexander Gusev00:51:56
writes respected theorists, maybe it’s time00:51:59
stop trying to lay00:52:01
modern reality about how00:52:03
fool procrustean bed marxist00:52:06
theory of Leninism and begin developing00:52:07
fresh ideas00:52:09
Of course, who should lay Procrustean00:52:12
bed and there is one problem, I’ll answer00:52:14
At once00:52:16
science and general awareness of any reality00:52:20
still requires codification of taffy00:52:23
spread out even waiting for someone's middle name00:52:25
methodology00:52:27
any reality as we know is concrete00:52:29
this one directly said they will never decompose00:52:32
without a trace this remainder yes00:52:36
You00:52:38
not specifically to Marxist any other00:52:41
then this is actually a problem then your theory yes00:52:43
it makes it really easy to understand00:52:47
like and by the way groups why art00:52:50
I also need art in my opinion00:52:52
through the image to give a more complete00:52:55
awareness or emotional perception00:52:58
no phenomenon than we logically want00:53:01
form because well, this work is somewhat00:53:04
differently that's why yes I think that00:53:09
any theory is limited but00:53:12
why do you need practice so that all the time00:53:15
testing is limited to one's own theory00:53:17
so it seems to me that00:53:20
now is the time for intellectual00:53:23
serious work yriar and slave course created00:53:26
a huge step forward on this path we will00:53:28
continue so if on the node00:53:30
in particular, I spoke on my stream00:53:33
with the idea of a round table mint is called on00:53:35
some conferences for some00:53:38
events what kind of forum of left forces am I00:53:41
I can say right away that I won’t00:53:42
participate in any form of leftist forces before00:53:44
discussion of the agenda, I first think that00:53:47
before collecting the forum left forces00:53:49
which then, as they say, will00:53:50
sign up we already had this experience yes00:53:53
I came to Sergei Udaltsov and looked for Sergei00:53:55
let's hold it under the auspices of the left front00:53:57
Serezha's left-wing forum went after that00:54:00
Vladimirovich porridge on the water but Vich Kashin00:54:01
went to Gennady Zyuganov in a number of modes00:54:03
Dmitry instructed me to take the person further00:54:05
what you saw in the big picture happened00:54:08
in the columned hall of the House of Unions, you understand this00:54:10
wasn't quite the idea I was thinking with00:54:14
Musudan fuss head start it was not a forum and00:54:18
all dreams Sakhnin and when we are with him00:54:19
they were discussing what would happen there, as if they were all00:54:21
crashed when everything was ordered00:54:23
new it was a presentation of the Communist Party of the Russian Federation as00:54:26
the leading force on the left flank, well, in00:54:29
similar pero no me pr world and00:54:31
I'm not going to participate in events00:54:33
I admit that the Communist Party of the Russian Federation is the leader00:54:36
parliamentary force on the left flank00:54:38
the position of the left opposition is unconditional00:54:41
It’s absurd to argue with this, but that doesn’t mean00:54:45
that the thought should rest there therefore00:54:49
I think that if there was a round table00:54:51
composition Boris Kagarlitsky Nikolai00:54:52
handkerchiefs for Sergei Obukhov00:54:54
Konstantin and Seeds Alexander Kolpakidi00:54:57
if they called me I would be like00:54:59
married such a round table we could00:55:01
here the round table is open like this with00:55:03
hold cameras and answer some00:55:05
a series of questions for a man, the first one I even have00:55:07
I asked now they took the NTR and it’s there00:55:09
interviews with the free press are also not00:55:13
for the sake of she asks, but Shevchenko00:55:15
said brother cruise was a reaction game00:55:18
of course of course let's delyagina00:55:21
invite the gutters and it's like okay00:55:23
further, that is, there are no questions of course00:55:25
we need to introduce this discussion Oleg then00:55:28
next question from Ivan Ivanov question00:55:31
to the maxim where in Russia I received RPS00:55:34
highest voter support for00:55:36
passed as if choosing 2021, well00:55:40
if you look at these purely formal00:55:42
the numbers they drew00:55:44
That00:55:46
this doesn't make sense answers this question00:55:49
I think that in Moscow we received very00:55:52
I also had a lot of support00:55:55
such a feeling00:55:57
although this is no longer possible00:56:00
impossible to check Oleg so next00:56:04
question from a user with it readable00:56:06
nickname question guest in conversation you00:56:08
mentioned a wild story with00:56:10
what kind of abuse of prisoners00:56:12
in your opinion, reforms are needed to00:56:15
humanize the system in September arrest00:56:17
management of the Federal Penitentiary Service criminal case in00:56:20
the management of the Federal Penitentiary Service is the same00:56:22
I think that Vladimir Osechkin is offering00:56:25
that they should all resign00:56:26
I think that this matter should just I don't00:56:29
I don’t believe for a single second that the prosecutor’s office and00:56:31
the investigative committee is investigating there00:56:33
really00:56:34
this already happened when we arrived at colony colony 600:56:37
Chelyabinsk region Kopeysk where were00:56:40
there is torture and we teach people for a season00:56:43
for six months then the zone chief became two00:56:45
for years conditionally just although they were opened00:56:47
terrible crimes00:56:51
it just has to be parliamentary00:56:53
investigation00:56:54
By the way, the Senate is higher than the upper house mother00:56:59
Ksenia Sobchak00:57:01
Lyudmila Narusova she initiated this00:57:04
investigation if it’s not in the Duma00:57:06
it turned out the senate, strangely enough here00:57:09
actually a purely procedure but there00:57:12
have more opportunities there are no00:57:13
parties on the desk awards00:57:16
and senators can create stone00:57:18
commissions of inquiry which00:57:20
Let's say the house will be blocked00:57:22
party majority vote00:57:24
United Russia is always here Lyudmila00:57:26
Narusova, she's great, she'll do this00:57:28
create Ksenia reported made big00:57:30
interview yesterday with Vladimir Osechkin them00:57:33
Sergei Savelyev and in general I think that00:57:37
this topic is extremely important, don't00:57:39
connect and here is the topic of cooperation00:57:41
it doesn’t matter that I like Narusova00:57:44
personally if growths are engaged in this00:57:46
theme then I like it if Ksenia00:57:48
Sobchak she's on fire Zyuganov at home ladies from00:57:51
at home 2 no Gennady Andrey now she00:57:54
the woman who made a journalist00:57:56
who did a great interview about torture00:57:59
with the person who00:58:01
within the framework of some kind of Hollywood plot00:58:04
thriller took there hiding from00:58:07
persecution of this terrible archive and in00:58:11
in general this is of course00:58:12
then the topic is against which the authorities have nothing00:58:16
object again and I don’t believe that00:58:19
prosecutor's office investigative committee they are00:58:22
they'll get the job done, it's easy00:58:23
it is impossible that this is not only Saratov00:58:26
and this is the Vladimir region, this is Irkutsk00:58:30
this is Krasnoyarsk where the cleaver Danach was killed00:58:32
there's a lot of far-right stuff out there00:58:34
another school in Bashkiria is definitely00:58:37
Khakassia terrible torture zones you understand00:58:40
there is Khakassia, which we were informed about00:58:43
repeatedly this00:58:46
Bishop of Saratov or Metropolitan00:58:49
who awarded the medals it turns out00:58:51
all these workers whose jobs are now00:58:53
accused of not mopping this dish and00:58:55
they stuck it in, but they had a chapel there00:58:57
opened in these terrible red zones00:58:59
and so on, that is, this00:59:02
torture it reveals not just in sin it00:59:06
as if it opens up the entire system00:59:08
because these people are in the same saunas00:59:11
sat there00:59:13
United Russia is visible there, I don’t know about the containers00:59:16
maybe governors or there alone00:59:19
at feasts they baptized each other's children00:59:22
it's like everyone00:59:25
this is a torture case, that's why I00:59:29
I think it's necessary00:59:31
pick up and here for the people of00:59:34
the chosen ones have a huge prospect to not00:59:36
managed to become a parliamentary commission00:59:37
deputies can create quite00:59:40
its own to conduct an investigation for00:59:42
this needs to be sanctioned00:59:44
parliamentary majority deputy00:59:46
has very great powers00:59:47
please go to Lyudmila Narusova00:59:50
upper house she think she's brave00:59:53
women in general I have let's say00:59:55
certain immunity in Russian00:59:57
federation due to the fact that she is a widow01:00:00
Sobchak I think there is a lot here01:00:04
great opportunities for something very important01:00:06
political actions if I were01:00:09
I would certainly do this as a deputy and01:00:11
I wouldn’t care if she shouted at me there01:00:14
they tried to put it on top, this is one of them01:00:16
reasons why not Zeppa then of course01:00:19
because I'm in the middle of the elections right away01:00:20
I said that I would definitely study01:00:22
problems of prisoners and the problem of torture01:00:24
this was before the publication of all this01:00:27
mane on one of the federal channels01:00:29
then the next question is from a Marxist01:00:32
Stephanie 100 dear comrades, kind01:00:34
evening one gets the feeling that01:00:36
performers in regional structures have already01:00:39
they don’t listen much because01:00:41
says Putin and the system works on its own01:00:43
to myself why so well the thing is that01:00:47
this means only one thing: Putin succeeded01:00:50
create something like an aquarium inside01:00:52
which you don't have to listen to01:00:54
fish listen to people01:00:55
located behind the aquarium but their food01:00:58
depends on how he gets there01:01:01
pours in I think he's shot01:01:03
quite a serious system, that is01:01:05
wait a minute so you want01:01:06
say that01:01:08
in the aquarium they can swim as they want01:01:11
and may even spa desire to eat a friend01:01:13
friend yes but the only thing that matters to me01:01:16
get in I'll say the main thing is not to get out of01:01:18
the aquarium does not show that they are not fish01:01:20
ichthyander to us who can do it by land01:01:22
in this case no one will walk01:01:24
insured and the same Sobyanin can01:01:26
enter handcuffs in one second01:01:30
asphalt I don’t know anything goes yes01:01:33
and it's very01:01:36
important point that they don’t know therefore01:01:38
Sobyanin, Putin was hoarse in falsetto01:01:42
Putin you know on Monday 5 am I01:01:44
when they supposedly counted it in Moscow01:01:47
Oleg01:01:49
to get the question means the fascist regime01:01:52
Mussolini and the question to Maxim is fascist01:01:54
Mussolini's regime for relative01:01:56
softness called dictatorship from soft01:01:57
cheese, how do you like this definition?01:01:59
in relation to Putin's Russia01:02:03
Mussolini's fascist regime was much01:02:05
softer01:02:06
because Mussolini relied on01:02:10
all critical moments to the deepest01:02:13
philosophical cultural reflection of Italy01:02:17
Italian01:02:19
between mazzini01:02:21
and garibaldi and mussolini in fact01:02:24
we have a lot in common01:02:26
we love garibaldi but garibaldi i'm sure01:02:29
I'd like to add some salt, I'm not sure what01:02:31
base, well, it’s good to hold on to the tediousness01:02:33
drowned supported by the Sudanese according to data01:02:36
serve01:02:38
Garibaldi is definitely not a fact Mazzini01:02:40
garbage did not make Mazzini and young and01:02:43
Italy which was quite like01:02:45
fascist in many ways about that01:02:47
fascist understand ideologically01:02:50
manifesto of their nation over nation people01:02:53
united and italy social reform01:02:56
huge socially01:02:59
the concept of a nation in the 19th century and that concept01:03:02
the nation that was, of course01:03:06
first ru war many things under our noses01:03:09
salt won't remind me I don't want anyone01:03:11
the editor certified the editing01:03:13
editor avanti plus gentile but not01:03:16
the last philosopher of the 20th century that's why01:03:19
it is clear that of course he is intelligent01:03:21
the level of trances the error was significant01:03:23
higher than their analogues there grams01:03:26
he could have been in prison, he was allowed to write01:03:28
notebooks and you need a notebook in the hryvnia they were01:03:31
written by no-no-no-no-no-no-no-no01:03:34
how to marry a sau in the gulag01:03:36
understand your weights by heart01:03:38
Bukharin was also given lost in prison01:03:41
sat01:03:43
before the execution he will hand over he wrote back01:03:47
I don’t know, it doesn’t hurt and I can’t even dance01:03:50
he wrote we didn’t find out whether there was any point but01:03:52
he wrote with dear Koba I love you01:03:56
I love the party all my life and I have to01:03:58
revolutions in the country both if you want01:04:00
shoot me but better send me01:04:02
to ordinary soldiers somewhere there01:04:04
I can fight with a rifle in my hand01:04:06
on your instructions you understand what I wrote01:04:09
Bukharin grunge already wrote not this one, he didn’t01:04:11
wrote dear benito boy remember how we01:04:14
Jesus drank wine with you while on the road01:04:16
of the Italian people Gramsci wrote great01:04:19
philosophical texts that you and I01:04:21
we read today who have not been where and01:04:24
muddy in the archives of the fascist secret police01:04:26
put under wraps, you know there which01:04:29
in principle, they weren’t hiding from the world, really01:04:31
after all you but they you were before steel01:04:33
available after already what's the difference01:04:36
that's why I don't delegate to Mussolini01:04:38
definitely but in general this figure01:04:41
which fits well into the context01:04:44
Italian history Italian tradition01:04:46
but what is happening here is not01:04:49
fits into the context of Russian tradition01:04:51
I think that Putinism is what we are01:04:53
we observe modern Russia and that is01:04:56
destruction of natural history01:04:59
ways of development of the Russian people of nations01:05:02
our country because Putinism01:05:04
destroys the possibility of forming01:05:06
political nation we can’t01:05:08
take a step that would seem Soviet01:05:11
the project creates a political nation01:05:14
Soviet peoples have been destroyed for 91 years01:05:16
political nation political nation01:05:19
without forming a single entity01:05:21
having civil rights but yes01:05:24
this is the European way, maybe here we have01:05:27
didn't say that a political nation01:05:29
creates collective trauma01:05:32
mur than fear murom tenesmus will be like this01:05:35
collective trauma if anyone survives and01:05:36
this is how they want to make everyone01:05:39
townspeople and townspeople are basically people01:05:41
located especially in a modern city within a city01:05:44
filled with Wi-Fi and social01:05:46
networks in a completely different01:05:48
intellectual environment more freely01:05:50
we know we don't know how everything will turn out01:05:53
there in 10-15-20 years but I think that01:05:57
formation of a political nation in Russia01:05:59
this political task is very urgent01:06:02
and of course this regime doesn’t want to end01:06:05
some politician of course you don’t want to01:06:06
vice versa and and destroy and destruction01:06:08
political process which we01:06:11
European in essence yes as delegation01:06:15
political powers as if they were01:06:18
want to balance between how they01:06:20
they hint we are Confucians but you are not Chinese01:06:23
yet you don’t have this feeling01:06:25
inner harmony you are greedy and01:06:28
social holidays up to which they devour01:06:31
and here you all are not there emperor01:06:35
no matter how much I quote Sun Tzu01:06:39
You01:06:40
extremely far you don't have it01:06:41
sensations of a single whole which is01:06:44
Chinese people since the first01:06:46
the emperor is there until Mau constantly, as it were01:06:49
existed before01:06:51
we Europeans say they destroy you01:06:56
principle of citizenship principle of personality01:06:58
the principle of solidarity is social01:07:00
is the basis of European in general01:07:03
what is called Western, yes then01:07:05
who do you get what you just01:07:07
East India Company which01:07:09
deals with watering technologies for01:07:11
the natives and how they throw them down there01:07:14
because Putin is interesting here, remember taxes01:07:17
he told me I wouldn't burn with anyone01:07:18
talked about democracy with Gandhi joked01:07:21
Putin and I think that modern01:07:23
the Russian state is not at all01:07:25
suppressed by several East Indians01:07:27
company fact can gandi can we01:07:29
Let's become such a collective Gandhi01:07:31
familiar with us01:07:32
not bad further so the question is how do you like it01:07:38
yesterday's speech by the President at01:07:40
Valdai Forum is amazing01:07:42
amazing it's fantastic deep01:07:45
amazing intro I think it's a rebuff01:07:48
gays and lesbians are given a very serious me01:07:51
I think it’s like they’re all trembling01:07:54
in the west and in our country we have a progressive01:07:57
no enlightened moderate conservatism01:08:00
enlightened no what is moderate01:08:02
conservatism no. optimistic01:08:05
healthy and moderate conservative01:08:08
433 adjectives to optimistically01:08:12
healthy and moderate here are three a01:08:15
means that we who captured held01:08:19
we won it, we will keep it01:08:21
conservative and our children can be01:08:24
anyone at least transvestites during the game01:08:26
even though lesbians live anywhere in01:08:29
London Paris New York Greenwich01:08:32
you understand the village in any way you like01:08:33
Amsterdam does not accept this optimism and01:08:38
they are still our children, that is01:08:41
maintain the status quo position as if01:08:43
managerial position East Indian01:08:45
company01:08:46
and give to your household members as if they were children and01:08:50
close person to live enjoying the benefits01:08:53
modern color you civilization status01:08:56
status on so on so next01:09:00
question01:09:01
a little off topic but it's a question at most01:09:04
what does Maxim Leonardovich think about01:09:06
philosophers of the Frankfurt school01:09:08
How are we going to endure chase co today?01:09:10
obscurantism, ethnic hatred and01:09:11
which obviously has its benefits01:09:13
recipients, well, I won’t go deeper01:09:15
far away it would be to listen to Borisovich’s lectures01:09:18
philosopher of the French school I will not myself01:09:21
build some kind of hyper intellectuals not01:09:23
I can't say that I deeply care about this01:09:24
I know everything natural reader is in01:09:26
in general terms but in general stop01:09:28
obscurantism chauvinism we need a few01:09:30
stages first stop mark infuriating01:09:32
down inside yourself this is the first01:09:35
Frankfurt school or heal the doctor01:09:38
yourself in general is the most important inside01:09:41
First of all, you need to sanitize yourself01:09:44
obscurantism of chauvinism01:09:47
Bean/and others have records of rejection01:09:52
to all sorts, but first you need to identify them01:09:55
if you really need to go there you are the person01:09:57
see01:09:59
Let's try it later in our environment01:10:02
we need to stop tyrannizing our family01:10:04
for example understand or relate there to01:10:07
janitor in the yard for Kyrgyz or Tajiks01:10:10
which Cyprus if like people of the second01:10:12
varieties stop reacting to the subway and01:10:16
and they stop explaining to others that01:10:18
Well, look, this is not a man01:10:20
knows Russian, let's teach him01:10:21
Russian for example and so on but with01:10:24
everyone doesn't have to fall into01:10:25
liberalism must protect social01:10:27
I’m right, I think that the migration flow01:10:29
which in Russia today exists for01:10:32
here are millions of labor migrants from01:10:36
Central Asia is particularly01:10:39
attempt at power01:10:42
well, in many ways hinder the creation01:10:45
working class in Russia, oddly enough01:10:47
that's because they destroy labor01:10:52
resources autochthonous people do not develop on them in any way01:10:55
vocational education as a system01:10:57
workers' collectives were not destroyed01:10:59
labor migrants are actually created01:11:02
do it themselves without meaning to these people01:11:05
I don’t blame the role of bar brokers01:11:07
forced forced strikebreakers it01:11:11
It’s just a purposeful policy01:11:14
power that makes the indigenous population01:11:19
Russia and regardless of the Russians it is01:11:21
noses in national regions is01:11:23
the problem is much more acute than the Russians01:11:25
in Soho, I know there were just conflicts01:11:28
with the Kyrgyz we were just there but serious01:11:31
by 1 Sardana was the mayor of the Yakut and01:11:33
asked the sardana about this all over him01:11:35
in Tatarstan this is quite serious01:11:37
the problem has to do with the illusion that01:11:39
ethnic community but here you go01:11:40
Orbiz Yakuts they are Turkic their languages01:11:43
similar Kyrgyz descended from the Yenisei01:11:46
So Soho Yakuts came from01:11:48
Yenisei Kyrgyz were once there01:11:51
nuance us I naturally yes but in general but01:11:54
this is generally a conflict the closer than here01:11:57
serious conflict because01:12:00
the peoples of Russia are enough enough01:12:02
relatively small, let's say01:12:05
Russian masses and their territory is much01:12:08
clearer which they occupy and not in01:12:11
the difference from the Russians is very strong01:12:12
consolidated by ancestral family01:12:14
this is forced naturally this is not the way01:12:17
there are [ __ ] people who don’t resist01:12:19
just chauvinistic assimilation01:12:21
coming from the federal government from01:12:24
Russian and delivery there is allowed in01:12:26
Yakutsk is not there for 50,000 labor01:12:30
migrants are a serious problem and it is01:12:32
all the more serious that the Kyrgyz are closer01:12:35
ethnic Yuku there than let's say Ukrainians01:12:38
here the import of Ukrainians would be on their own01:12:40
fewer problems and, oddly enough, something01:12:42
but the community authorities think about it01:12:44
are guided only by their own selfish interests01:12:46
interests fate, it is necessary to build a road and01:12:49
build budget money come here01:12:51
we will bring a million Uzbeks and Kyrgyzs01:12:53
Tajiks, let them work here until01:12:56
also minutes of what and what and disenfranchised01:12:58
slaves don't have to pay taxes verse01:13:01
don't pay us black profit there 40001:13:04
500 percent understanding that we are so Olya01:13:07
the Russians who are ready are not yet burning01:13:10
so we won’t get the job done first01:13:12
lie, I know that from the Vladimir region01:13:14
from those regions that are closer to Moscow01:13:17
here is the Aleksandrovsky district, there is strunino01:13:20
people go to Moscow to work work for01:13:22
wear 10-12 hours01:13:25
earns 50-60 thousand to feed01:13:28
their families in01:13:31
in general, people would certainly be ready01:13:34
work01:13:35
but the authorities are pursuing a completely different policy01:13:38
ruling capital and power couple is just of01:13:42
a formalizes the will of the ruling capital01:13:44
therefore, regarding the Frankfurt school01:13:48
I think that01:13:50
just need it here01:13:55
resist chauvinism and xenophobia01:13:58
which is imposed by power but together with01:14:00
those01:14:01
clearly protect, including social01:14:05
space01:14:10
citizens I cannot indigenous people01:14:12
terms are very important01:14:15
Russian civil social01:14:17
space associated with citizenship or01:14:20
then it doesn't make sense at all01:14:21
it turns out that we are citizens of Tadada01:14:23
just because we pay taxes01:14:25
understand01:14:27
for example, I spoke during the elections01:14:29
I talked about this, I also talked about this to Putin01:14:32
I used to say when I have more dick01:14:33
Council on Interethnic Relations01:14:36
and Ramodanovsky for the labor package01:14:38
migrant that is, please if you01:14:40
want to come and see the Hermitage and or01:14:43
Lenin's mausoleum you don't need a visa01:14:45
Russia I think is simple for Busan01:14:47
if you want to work in Russia that is01:14:49
sorry interior space should01:14:51
be protected it must be labor01:14:54
agreement with the employer who01:14:56
registered with the state from which01:14:57
taxes are paid and these taxes are me01:15:00
touched will be in the local budget they01:15:02
federal this is definitely medical01:15:06
insurance01:15:07
which is different from PMS which01:15:09
we have food that is paid for01:15:11
insurance companies give them01:15:13
It’s possible to earn enough by the way01:15:14
a large number of people are unconditional01:15:18
registration at place of residence and01:15:19
a person cannot come, let's say01:15:21
Moscow how is this happening now right now01:15:24
they just buy a patent with a bribe for01:15:26
20,000 while still being a due employer01:15:28
he comes to Moscow to work here01:15:30
then he moves to Yakutsk, for example no01:15:33
I'm sorry, you came to the employer here and01:15:35
registers u must be responsible for yours01:15:37
staying here as a worker01:15:40
man if you just came01:15:42
live wherever you want if you work at the choir01:15:44
then this burden on the local budget is01:15:46
Moscow Lena pieces Lina Vladimirsky01:15:49
the fourth point is the point related to01:15:53
return ticket01:15:55
if you come just as tourists then01:15:57
please yes you want then leave if01:16:00
you come to work, then this is yours.01:16:03
entry here is yours. departure labor01:16:05
resources need to be controlled and 5 this01:16:07
work visa which is not a visa01:16:10
needed but if you want to work they will give it to you01:16:12
permission, I didn't make anything up, I didn't even make it up01:16:15
when he gave lectures, she invited me01:16:17
free university of burg in switzerland there01:16:19
I had exactly the same one there for a week01:16:22
the package will be i couldn't read simple01:16:25
Schengen tourist visa not lecture01:16:27
there they didn’t specially register until01:16:30
work business visa for this01:16:32
time you understand they took permission01:16:34
permission I lived there in a lazy cat01:16:36
United States there in a hotel at01:16:38
I walked there to the Catholic University01:16:40
I'm not them I signed the contract with01:16:44
the university from which they paid01:16:45
tax there was my fee and there was tax01:16:49
Swiss than local amazed me01:16:51
this is in the budget, even for me the canton01:16:55
Pomfrey Burg city budget where was it01:16:57
in general, a bouquet and that’s ok, sushi and then01:17:01
there is in Turkey and there is in China in China01:17:04
you can start a merged business with at least one yuan01:17:06
without permits this will be your fine01:17:09
You can’t just throw him in jail in Turkey01:17:12
I just came to work and01:17:14
earning money there, it’s probably like this01:17:16
someone does but that's in general01:17:17
the only crime is considered01:17:20
the country is such a spot on the map in Eurasia01:17:23
where it is possible it is the Russian Federation01:17:26
and this in my opinion is simply because we01:17:28
East India Company then this is not01:17:30
state of states which operates01:17:33
in the interests of its citizens and we01:17:34
the state is a regulator of interests01:17:36
become a big capitalist and therefore01:17:38
French school she is wonderful but in01:17:41
in this case it is necessary to combine it and01:17:43
at the same time how to protect just well01:17:45
civil rights if we are citizens then01:17:47
what is neem?01:17:49
but it's not not not not just to01:17:52
They showed this burgundy book to the cops01:17:54
though there are still some moments01:17:56
Fine01:18:00
Oleg I still have a lot of questions01:18:03
so let's accumulate you in the past01:18:05
let's speed up it was shorter to answer such01:18:08
questions01:18:09
there are questions and almost everyone is like that01:18:11
hired enough but if we just01:18:13
I'll be able to give you a shorter answer01:18:15
next question from goodness on flint he01:18:18
wondering why in the lists RPS with AK01:18:21
there were such odious personalities as01:18:23
Ruslan Kurbanov and Maxim Sungorkin and01:18:25
cool odious for me it's not odious01:18:28
Maksimishin Gorkin author01:18:30
very important recycling law01:18:33
garbage to he was a deputy from the LDPR then01:18:36
and I immediately say that we are int y01:18:38
Republican coalition Ruslan Kurbanov01:18:40
we are a student my friend my comrade I don't know01:18:43
who cares about diodes, it’s not diode at all01:18:45
Ruslan stands for rights01:18:47
Muslims and I believe that our union and01:18:51
political comradely union is01:18:53
first honor for me ruslan01:18:55
educated man senior scientist01:18:56
employee of the Institute of Oriental Studies01:18:59
what is he odious number some mistakes01:19:01
each of us admits01:19:03
some errors public like this01:19:05
Ruslana has always stood for01:19:08
national human rights01:19:10
civil rights therefore as a member01:19:12
our Republican coalition I express01:19:15
many thanks to him for free as junk01:19:17
here they wrote here they wrote about01:19:21
regarding personality I say added01:19:23
why were they called odious personalities01:19:25
Well, according to the person who01:19:27
asks Ruslan Kurbanov, he posts on01:19:30
YouTube false provocative videos01:19:32
sowing enmity and Maxim Sungorkin murderers01:19:34
dogs dog antera that's why I know01:19:37
maximum we present everything far from the log01:19:39
it's weird being a doctor01:19:42
I don’t hear such statements from Maxims to me01:19:46
they talk about this casually but not this01:19:49
the main thing is that he is the most01:19:51
was a qualified State Duma deputy01:19:53
why didn’t he become more deputies?01:19:55
who challenged like trash burning01:19:59
plant and with those who organize these01:20:01
the landfill has already been disposed of01:20:04
developer of laws on01:20:06
European separate collection system and01:20:09
waste disposal that we run created01:20:11
hundreds of thousands of jobs, which of course01:20:13
capitalism will never be simpler01:20:15
that he always works fast here01:20:17
money01:20:19
Ruslan I don’t know what it’s all about and the throne01:20:22
be guided by some fantasies01:20:24
the fact that Ruslan is himself a Caucasus01:20:28
naturally works in the Caucasus says01:20:31
addressing Caucasians I am Caucasian great01:20:34
I know and find there and step aside there01:20:37
nuance intonation says that it’s acceptable there01:20:40
at01:20:41
Ruslana could be knocked out and suddenly01:20:43
conflict in quotes with the Ingush when01:20:46
Ruslan reasoning about this in the stream there is something there01:20:50
such spoke not very carefully about01:20:53
Ingush statehood after that01:20:54
doesn’t write there and Shevchenko is your number01:20:57
wow, let's say there, tell your friends01:21:00
Qurbani that we call in Sharia01:21:02
the court is there brother, what is the question?01:21:05
Sharia court taking into account what some kind of01:21:07
some years ago he doubted01:21:10
Ingush statehood speaking01:21:12
when it's a matter of statehood01:21:15
tried by Sharia court01:21:19
like the pauses were they I didn’t mean that01:21:21
Ruslan just called and met01:21:25
hugged and apologized to each other there01:21:27
they said there was a misunderstanding and went out01:21:30
in general everything is fine so in the Caucasus01:21:32
you always know you can always01:21:35
no-no-no this intonation is not the expression01:21:37
especially the Russian language is idiomatic01:21:41
you'll offend someone there, you'll hurt someone, that's why I01:21:44
I think that Ruslan is a wonderful person01:21:46
who do a lot for01:21:49
unity of our peoples and very01:21:51
grateful to Ruslan for his principled01:21:53
active participation in the party campaign I can01:21:56
justice Oleg so next question01:21:59
again quite voluminous means01:22:02
asks to show Maxim asks01:22:04
is marxism de facto01:22:06
metaphysical teaching with a very weak01:22:08
an attempt to replace the true transcendental01:22:11
began as a surrogate for class struggle no no01:22:15
is Marxism it is quite philosophical01:22:19
scientific doctrine01:22:20
which is exactly01:22:23
metaphysics by other than that I can judge by01:22:25
work Lenin mothers for blocking society01:22:28
rejects as such01:22:29
I'll know you better than me here01:22:33
especially him01:22:39
metaphysics as such01:22:42
Martin considers metaphysics simple01:22:45
idealism, unless of course it is01:22:48
Bogdanov school is there and so on01:22:50
so no, I think it’s a marquis01:22:53
of course not comprehensive but it is very01:22:56
important and01:22:58
the doctrine of the structure of society01:23:01
class struggle which is based on01:23:04
social analysis on economic01:23:06
analysis he just the problem is that he01:23:08
must constantly evolve like anything01:23:10
methodology understanding and description01:23:12
in reality it should develop simply01:23:15
in the Soviet Union after01:23:17
approximately 30 probably 4 inputs Marxism01:23:22
froze01:23:24
the only one who somehow developed it was01:23:26
Stalin, as paradoxical as it sounds01:23:27
there's at least Stalin's kit of new ideas01:23:30
put forward but these are books01:23:33
. authority and drive and that there was one01:23:36
the man who was will let me well01:23:38
Tambov language knowledge questions on camera well01:23:41
there is some serious claim there01:23:43
fundamentality was there or something else01:23:45
questions of Leninism are ultimately there01:23:47
there were hammered formulas: house and Lenin there01:23:50
combined the Russian scope01:23:51
American efficiency and Russian01:23:53
scope there without01:23:55
efficiency becomes voluntarism01:23:58
lightning so written American01:24:00
efficiency without revolutionary01:24:02
romanticism becomes simply dividing01:24:04
feelings are very important such as they are01:24:06
simple formulas Stalin the neck scientists01:24:09
addressed as is known to the people01:24:14
but then after his death in general01:24:17
nothing happened just the opposite01:24:19
over there tried to make a left turn01:24:21
engage in Marxism and as they say01:24:24
got the full truth you are better01:24:26
took up obari bhagavad-gita nicholas01:24:28
Kuzansky would have defended his dissertation01:24:31
probably yes it would not be you Marxism01:24:34
was the biggest crime01:24:36
Soviet Union as I understand it, Lukács01:24:39
Trotsky Gramsci is not like Gramsci was under01:24:42
philosophical notebooks were banned01:24:45
ban not those days were banned01:24:48
they just seemed to try not to notice, yeah01:24:50
they are even higher01:24:51
59 what are we actually doing now?01:24:54
there is a country that has won everyone01:24:58
everyone thinks so as Marxist01:25:00
revolution I will build a Marxist society01:25:02
was actually one of the most anti01:25:04
Marxist territories on the globe01:25:06
even mau mau you know developed there01:25:10
Marxism polemicized and challenged the CCP so01:25:13
or otherwise develops in some way to01:25:15
Marxism and who is there here?01:25:17
Chukanov Shiva is developing Marxism even01:25:19
interesting, that's why Marxism just isn't01:25:22
dogma and method and every method needs01:25:25
renewal in criticism in comprehension in01:25:28
application to practice and life01:25:30
is changing, let's say Marxism enter what01:25:34
What is workforce in the IT era?01:25:36
economics is an important issue01:25:39
I know you are just that01:25:42
intellectual center which01:25:44
the only one in Russian that develops01:25:48
well, within the framework of discourse because it is there01:25:50
video formats dice seo cops or without01:25:53
nickname storms are also interesting things but01:25:55
write out that the discourse is important01:25:57
basically written out like this01:25:59
memorable, only work reporter can do this01:26:01
besides you but also start Linkani well but he01:26:04
it’s just like there’s no lecture there01:26:06
can be seen, can't be heard, where is he?01:26:11
yes next question from Nikita if01:26:14
digital in quotes problematic in01:26:16
the agenda of the left is the new reality01:26:18
but there is almost no discussion of problems, well I01:26:21
I think this needs to be discussed01:26:23
reality in the bar potion literally now01:26:26
last in rapgar literally on the first01:26:29
page you lies page01:26:31
article about how you can still use it01:26:36
concept with long-term strength as01:26:38
digital economy and so on01:26:40
this article will become controversial, but at least01:26:42
at least I think that u are very useful for01:26:45
posing the question is very interesting01:26:47
further fall and blocked by the way slave01:26:49
no weak no text everything is fine slave01:26:52
chickens announced on agent meters core01:26:55
I knock on the ground no and sees, assuring yes01:26:59
with avery my dear it's not like you're in01:27:03
you believe them, these are some folk customs01:27:05
which, as part of culture, is still01:27:08
HIV is no longer on Tinder, why is that?01:27:10
rather to the folk culture you are fine there01:27:15
Russian advertising on01:27:18
Levi-Strauss and Kleist rus here until at night01:27:23
in short from globalization and social01:27:24
movements of the foreign agent in01:27:26
unfortunately we are liquidating mine now01:27:28
soon so on so Alexander01:27:31
sent a donation thanks for yours01:27:32
educational activities and01:27:34
St. Michael's bashing01:27:38
further then the next question again to01:27:41
Maxim from Kirill to Maxim01:27:44
evaluate recent events with and01:27:46
girls running away from the Caucasus01:27:47
strength brings back this topic completely01:27:50
ignored at the federal level01:27:54
Well this is a difficult question I01:27:58
I recently gave an interview to Lisa01:28:02
lazerson01:28:04
in detail and so we discussed this01:28:07
topic and it's just me for a very long time now01:28:09
I will answer because there is no01:28:11
there is no simple answer, but there is an unconditional answer here01:28:14
several aspects 1 I believe that in01:28:16
normal modern society01:28:18
violation of personal rights actions in01:28:21
regarding a completely year old person01:28:22
who is not under guardianship other than01:28:25
his will is a violation of the law01:28:27
so if these girls are on their own01:28:30
will01:28:31
this is if you lived in a civilized01:28:33
have been returned to normal society01:28:36
somewhere it would be right to go01:28:38
federal authorities to send bailiffs01:28:40
arrest those who take them against their will01:28:42
kidnapped to deal with their will to carry out01:28:45
court hearings there as it was in01:28:48
Britain for example would be yes where are you01:28:51
they would be placed under guardianship or protection01:28:54
don't know federal structures but we01:28:56
we live in Russia and01:29:00
first I'm sure this is an attitude01:29:03
which is within related01:29:05
even those security forces who went to01:29:07
Kazan for these Dagestan girls01:29:09
I'm sure they were distant relatives01:29:11
that it's hard for me to imagine what's going on01:29:13
some man in Dagestan so you'll go and01:29:14
my case my sister was kidnapped there01:29:17
anyone will tell you to eat sushi your sister01:29:19
Dagestani you figure it out I still have to01:29:22
grab her there she is not there inaccessibility01:29:24
I don't have a warrant for her so I have01:29:26
they went there01:29:27
then these are probably distant relatives and01:29:29
Toby doesn’t seem to justify the very fact of them01:29:32
forcible detention and transportation01:29:34
somewhere, well, the specifics of Russia are such that01:29:37
I understand life in Russia is divided into01:29:40
the fragments are so perfect01:29:43
nationalist forms and families into ancestral ones01:29:46
relations from a progressive point of view01:29:49
enlightened view of the modern01:29:51
looking from the universe from the nebula01:29:54
Andromeda walks like he's [ __ ]01:29:57
relic to tell him that in the situation01:29:59
modern chauvinistic Russia01:30:01
Internet cultural pressure on peoples01:30:03
Russia's protection of traditional family01:30:05
values is one of the forms and01:30:08
antibody production01:30:09
these small Russian peoples for01:30:12
every woman protects her identity01:30:14
in this situation it becomes not easy01:30:17
a citizen who disposes of her01:30:19
she is, as it were, the bearer of will there01:30:21
Avar people Chechen people01:30:23
of this tukhum of this type you can01:30:27
say yes but this is the Middle Ages01:30:29
what is happening in the Kremlin is not01:30:32
at least the Middle Ages there01:30:34
the Middle Ages which you explain01:30:36
can you explain why this is happening because01:30:38
there are 600,000 of them, from that the bypass of the Avars is 640,00001:30:42
they instinctively may not even01:30:44
formulating protect each of its members01:30:47
a person's family because their01:30:49
identity personal self is associated with01:30:52
ethnic01:30:55
identity and in Dagestan there are peoples01:30:57
30 thousand people each 15000 each 20 thousand01:31:00
man and we can’t stick it in01:31:03
say but it doesn't matter no it01:31:05
matters to them I'm very good01:31:08
I know this environment, I explain how they think01:31:11
I say again I don't condone this01:31:12
absolutely I'm just explaining no matter how01:31:15
paradoxically, but in this case the authorities01:31:18
darkness in the classical sense01:31:20
Tolstoy even means power01:31:22
house-building traditionalist foundations01:31:25
is a form of protection01:31:27
social ethnic group in a situation01:31:31
absolute absence of a single01:31:33
civil field lack of law01:31:36
lack of justice01:31:38
codified by the state in some way01:31:40
degree and therefore they are forced01:31:43
act absolute tape risks01:31:46
formally illegal but objective01:31:49
protecting the interests of their social or01:31:54
ethnic group is actually if01:31:57
historically compare this probably01:31:59
the situation that happened in the USA at the beginning of the 19th01:32:02
centuries before the Mormons defended declared war01:32:05
against the American government, defending their01:32:08
How is such a strange sect so strange?01:32:11
based on something you don’t understand01:32:14
This means that the Mormons were slandered anyway01:32:16
mousse restaurant and even the other side01:32:18
no they actually had angels01:32:19
death was a fighting organization01:32:22
closed I refused they refused it01:32:24
only at late at late time if01:32:27
naturally there was a conflict between01:32:29
Baptist and Lutheran majorities in01:32:32
USA and how new this is, no matter how01:32:34
evangelical education is lousy01:32:36
Mormons but I don't justify I explain01:32:40
why is this happening this is the main thing01:32:43
the culprit of these events is the federal01:32:45
power that prevents the creation of01:32:48
russian justice and justice01:32:50
in which this girl or woman01:32:52
could ask the state to protect01:32:55
she and the state would protect her after all01:32:58
similar attitudes towards women exist01:33:01
both in Corsica and Sicily, believe me01:33:03
despite the fact that Italy and France01:33:05
included in the legal framework sufficiently and01:33:08
The Basques, by the way, are quite tough01:33:10
such family ties but we see how they01:33:13
humanize along the way01:33:15
the advent of democratic modern01:33:18
legal institutions when society01:33:20
begins to trust the court more01:33:23
I don't know the law there01:33:28
which protects and declares01:33:31
state rather than the law which01:33:34
protects declares the mouth and there is a snail hum01:33:38
there or something else01:33:40
not so long ago Sicily held the hand01:33:43
the Corsican had a blood feud the same01:33:45
the thing that doesn't make sense right now01:33:47
because in both Corsica and Sicily01:33:49
the law applies and in Sicily it is01:33:52
the law came into force not so long ago in01:33:55
The hardest bloody struggle has been achieved01:33:57
destruction of traditional structures types01:33:59
mafias who relied on01:34:02
the Catholic Church and the locals there01:34:04
all sorts of these carlys, he is there and so01:34:06
then I was in Sicily specifically01:34:08
drove through these places and became01:34:11
now they have something completely different01:34:13
character01:34:14
how the Sicilians themselves have not burned for more than 20 years01:34:16
ago 20 years ago these were battle sites01:34:19
now this place is post-war, that is01:34:22
all this is no longer there, but they died there01:34:24
this war, thousands of people, journalists01:34:27
progressive communist police officers01:34:30
who fought with this, judges who01:34:32
they protected girls like these, they killed them01:34:36
then you understand these judges for this when01:34:38
they fled there so it’s not Russia’s fault01:34:41
Dagestanis is that they act like this01:34:44
how they introduced them to act them01:34:47
thousand-year-old instinct of self-preservation01:34:49
a state that does not give guilt01:34:52
modern democratic legal system01:34:55
an alternative to these ancient laws is good01:34:59
next question01:35:00
the next question is again addressed to Maxim01:35:03
so I lost it now, but I found it01:35:05
Maxim asks you why you are doing this01:35:08
live interaction with payment cards01:35:10
while payment systems demonstrate that they are not01:35:12
your friend wants them to dress up completely01:35:14
another megashop Latushkin latest streams01:35:17
says he's just fine, I'm fine01:35:19
absolutely not Ruzy matiz Latushkina I01:35:22
I just think that01:35:25
people who01:35:27
who have something to say in particular01:35:29
left flank on the opposition01:35:32
must put aside personal phobias and01:35:35
addictions and try if not01:35:37
work out01:35:39
because teamwork is01:35:41
It's still quite a complicated process01:35:43
conquer agree on some01:35:44
positions we must define positions01:35:46
it is in the ideological field that they are in the field01:35:49
you're a fool you betrayed me you went to the wrong place01:35:51
This, by the way, is what they were doing there01:35:56
already lungri Lenin Trotsky Bogdanov Martov01:35:58
just exactly 6 according to there conditionally01:36:01
they've been burning for the thirteenth year01:36:04
there was a bracketing of personal01:36:06
relations and clear and Lenin was one here01:36:10
from the catalysts of this this process01:36:12
as I understand the clear process what is common01:36:16
I have it there with Trotsky, yes, here he is01:36:20
there is unbearable in a personal matter there but he01:36:23
let's say he is extremely strong in assessment there01:36:26
history01:36:27
gorgeous there point the publicist give01:36:30
accurate analysis01:36:31
ray cd drinks marxism yes for example01:36:34
Bogdanov whether despite were friends01:36:36
closest friends are simply what they are01:36:39
why didn’t they divide us into a format, but this01:36:41
some kind of nonsense, naturally there were very01:36:44
important political moments Bogdan01:36:46
community and that means yes, just maybe01:36:50
isn't it by the way that I was wrong, this is a discussion01:36:52
Bogdanov believed that he had become lazy01:36:53
lean towards Menshevism01:36:55
Well, I blame Lenin, Lenin composed it01:36:58
Bogdanov is that he is a metaphysician01:37:00
once the tongue is added to the frost saying01:37:03
in Lenin's language the brain is still there01:37:05
I won't be the same so I'm Nicholas01:37:08
beaters, well, I’m not trying to make friends at all01:37:10
and I don’t interfere with the Communist Party of the Russian Federation new in dns01:37:13
naturally I just turn to him01:37:15
since many people contact me01:37:18
the audience is my audience there01:37:20
with an offer again, here's Kagarlitsky01:37:23
there plat ushkin from kolpakidi kolpakidi we01:37:26
we met and talked and everything seemed to be01:37:28
there are no problems here are the seeds01:37:31
you see, there you go further, yes I don’t01:37:34
hide says court face passed into01:37:36
the front no longer exists, it was simply destroyed01:37:37
he is gone as a result of all these01:37:39
serious political01:37:42
There are no more left front activities01:37:45
exist this is the result of which01:37:48
he was brought by the daredevils, that's what I'm talking about01:37:51
I can say concrete and clear01:37:52
I think it's01:37:55
well if it's not a crime okay01:37:58
crime there is no crime here01:38:01
let's just say this is the most serious01:38:04
political01:38:08
this is not a mistake it was the word calm of Iran01:38:13
after the murder of Hertz Enghien this01:38:16
more crime this mistake01:38:18
in this case it is not an error using01:38:21
debate, we ask you to blink in the Rada hall01:38:23
Maybe this is a consequence of some kind of stubbornness01:38:25
inexplicable tenacity for anything01:38:28
began to make the left front an annex to01:38:32
interests of Zyuganov and Kashin but rouge01:38:37
admits well let's continue the question01:38:39
question asked, questions left Nikita asks01:38:43
question on a Ukrainian topic, what do you think?01:38:45
about politics Anatoly Shariy is a question of how01:38:48
both Maxim and Borisovich are a populist01:38:50
European style and quite bright01:38:54
adequate01:38:55
in the Ukrainian sense in the context of Ukraine01:38:58
you need to understand blogger01:39:01
this is what I think and this is what I think01:39:05
what a strong good bright blogger01:39:07
fluent Ukrainian speakers01:39:09
in Russian having a large01:39:12
audience great popularity but he01:39:15
really scared the female group now01:39:18
because they're not weird either01:39:22
highly requested amazing story what01:39:25
similar, you can just see from the reaction that01:39:27
against the background that everyone is discredited in the ball01:39:29
unity who at least holds01:39:31
na because he doesn’t live in Ukraine world01:39:33
again what is its great advantage01:39:36
need next question next01:39:39
question hello don't you think that01:39:40
with a strong but unconscious left01:39:42
he does not have an agenda among the people01:39:44
understands and does not accept and is even afraid and01:39:47
even hates leftist forces, how about this01:39:50
you can fight at the bottom01:39:52
just give up first and drink01:39:54
these are leftists who say nothing and01:39:57
nothing to say with left brains01:39:59
anything can be called left and left01:40:02
left left be left left must01:40:04
unite I am still for the formation01:40:07
sufficiently clear and intelligible discourse01:40:09
there are a number of questions about the relationship01:40:12
states in relation to01:40:14
national question of attitude01:40:16
relatively speaking, I don’t know there01:40:20
[music]01:40:23
to some international centers of power01:40:26
China's relations in the end I'm here01:40:29
for example, I am not a supporter of01:40:31
Russia was an annex of China01:40:33
many leftists are I what is this01:40:36
I don’t think it’s a fundamental point01:40:38
Chinese socialism is not ideal01:40:41
I think it's01:40:42
I think that in general it’s only for the Chinese01:40:44
and as a service for work here as as01:40:47
vaccine01:40:49
a mixture of Mao Zedong's Sun Yat-sen and Deng01:40:53
xiaoping works only for chinese01:40:55
if you are Chinese and even then not everyone01:40:58
continental they threw off the race measures01:41:01
then it works for you but for Russians01:41:04
mycar report another should work here I01:41:06
I think we need to discuss this combination01:41:08
to us we are in general we are in the desert01:41:11
intelligent on the flank01:41:15
left but not left how to say no more01:41:18
I know about the steering wheel01:41:19
democratic probably like this01:41:21
Fine01:41:22
socially socially socialist but01:41:26
here it is necessary to say that really01:41:28
whether people who speak on behalf of whether01:41:30
extension feel pretty01:41:31
it’s unpleasant to hide it at all01:41:33
public, here you get it:01:41:35
Let's say liberated France Mélenchon01:41:37
and I carefully studied the unconquered before01:41:40
unconquered France studied pore structures01:41:43
it includes completely different01:41:44
there are a lot of organizations there01:41:46
representative offices in particular01:41:47
national organizations there food01:41:49
Berber organizations there front there01:41:52
I don't know yet different others which01:41:54
maybe not communist at all01:41:56
yes it seems to me that01:41:58
[music]01:41:59
we must fight like this Boris Yurievich01:42:02
very correctly formulated somewhere01:42:05
still in the spring01:42:06
what and this dumped when we were in Belarus01:42:09
weren't the events when we discussed confusing?01:42:11
regarding Belarus you are very much my01:42:13
I put my brains in place before the storm when01:42:16
you clearly said clearly that the fight is for01:42:17
democracy is the fight for socialism01:42:19
today that despite the rhetoric01:42:22
Lukashenko is not a socialist01:42:25
well, like a leader who acts in01:42:28
interests with tsarism in the interests of the people01:42:30
he covers it with populist rhetoric01:42:34
such patriotic interests are quite01:42:36
capitalist why state capitalism01:42:38
the worst type01:42:40
that's why democracy is basically01:42:44
no one canceled the fight for rights and01:42:47
Let's decide to fight for socialism no matter how01:42:50
paradoxically from first for capitalism01:42:51
fight a little bit in Russia01:42:53
no still not yet well I don't know much01:42:56
democracy there won't shoot me for01:42:58
I don’t know this formula, the box says that01:43:00
you say slowly introduced today01:43:03
wrote that maybe the time has come to save01:43:06
democracy from capitalism but this01:43:08
separate from the colonial organism01:43:10
certainly according to the Karen national01:43:12
mentalism operating according to the rules of 20 x01:43:15
not even 21 at least the end of the twentieth century01:43:18
with the rights of cities everything is immediately crushed01:43:22
no rights of cities no rights of citizens no01:43:26
treacherous democracy society01:43:28
silent but has no representation01:43:31
political a law b on genes01:43:33
which concerns everyone and even the institute01:43:36
problems of globalization01:43:38
Rosbalt Natasha Natalya Cherkesova01:43:41
announced, you know, that means on01:43:44
I was also an agent and called Intel Sergey01:43:47
me brazil support natural a lot01:43:49
years and and know there and so on know Victor01:43:51
Vasilyev and otherwise there is already a former head01:43:54
Fskn you understand, that is, this is even01:43:57
that is, they just shut it up all March01:44:01
individuals and agents these are all bloggers01:44:04
potentially if you donate you get01:44:06
you get the donation through Ireland like this01:44:09
or otherwise you understand through google all over01:44:11
agent turns out to be everyone on the Internet01:44:14
works or at least somehow gets paid01:44:16
one penny can be declared then01:44:18
there they are, that is, today the fight for rights01:44:22
for democracy what happened there01:44:25
decades ago for Russia super01:44:27
it is more relevant in my opinion01:44:29
than the Marxists scheme which of us is leftist who01:44:32
of us there is more left who is right is left01:44:35
anyone right anyone right01:44:37
centrist and similar things before01:44:39
you still have to live to see this, you still have to earn it01:44:41
such a discussion Oleg questions yes01:44:45
next question are you trying to build01:44:48
fight against system conformity01:44:49
the formation of verified claims against it01:44:52
including participation in parliamentary01:44:53
in quotation marks the work may be more correctly quit01:44:56
your talent to drive the realization of power01:44:59
I think pirates are related things01:45:02
firstly, it describes the beauty in01:45:05
Lenin's theses and liquidation for01:45:08
ism we don't of course we don't we don't say any01:45:11
illegal work what's the grill like there01:45:12
Bolsheviks in01:45:14
1512 there and so on in general01:45:17
today and any intellectual work01:45:19
independence free intellectual01:45:20
work is already becoming semi-legal01:45:22
work what it actually is what what01:45:26
this is what the Bolsheviks did in the tenth01:45:28
for years they just printed books and01:45:31
discussed with the workers it was prohibited01:45:35
the tsarist government is true01:45:37
workers' Marxist circles01:45:40
Putin's regime is exactly the same01:45:41
prohibit or then the next question from01:45:44
Nikita Mikhailova Maxim strong to you01:45:47
Hello dear Borisovich, welcome back01:45:49
I hug you tightly question the ruling class01:45:51
uses the nationality factor in its01:45:53
for harmful purposes what other factors01:45:55
similar types are used by the ruling01:45:58
ruling class01:46:01
patriotism01:46:05
which of course cannot be here they01:46:07
trying these virtual patriotism01:46:10
factors are certainly used01:46:13
geopolitical confrontation01:46:16
special geopolitics and just01:46:18
the territory your country occupies01:46:20
and she, even under Nicholas II, even under01:46:22
Stalin at least under Putin will be approximately01:46:24
same transport corridors no one01:46:26
Russia has not canceled this space between01:46:29
highly developed civilization of the East and01:46:32
speak out to Western civilization and01:46:40
maybe01:46:42
Well, how are we going? She's using her permission.01:46:46
information space that is01:46:47
formation of information01:46:48
space trying to01:46:52
management01:46:54
we even see that medicine is a factor01:46:57
treatment factor access to benefits even01:47:00
use minimal controls too01:47:03
that is, we can say that epidemics01:47:05
I dream about the control factor of course01:47:07
of course but she always congratulated01:47:10
Fukuda because they lived at the head of the plague01:47:13
prerogative of the state, don't make noise or01:47:15
focus does not need to be supervised and punished01:47:17
very important book, by the way I don’t mind01:47:20
against the fight against the epidemic01:47:22
which is actually dangerous for me here01:47:24
comrade died three days ago we kept01:47:26
it would be in the hands of the state01:47:28
the problem is that we don't believe01:47:30
that it is in state rubles we believe01:47:32
that it is in the hands of operating corporations01:47:34
on behalf of the state and in its own interests01:47:39
next question question maxim knows01:47:42
do you like the story with the imprisonment of everyone01:47:44
Nizhny Novgorod activist hospital01:47:46
Alexey Podnebesnogo you can somehow01:47:48
I’ll comment on my views on the decision01:47:49
this has already been said Alexey indeed01:47:53
we will forcibly imprison the psy in the hospital for01:47:55
six months01:47:56
health already 1 shaman grandmother01:48:00
we talked and wrote about it and01:48:02
I really really wish he could stand it01:48:05
this whole story from the point of view01:48:07
psychological and psychiatric01:48:08
examination of any person who01:48:12
anyone can be recognized01:48:15
behind01:48:16
as they say, if you try not to01:48:19
corresponds to no need to try01:48:20
because I even remember Soviet times01:48:22
there was such a diagnosis of increased interest01:48:25
cultural religious in literary01:48:28
sources thought this was not normal01:48:31
here they are of sluggish schizophrenia then01:48:33
low-grade schizophrenia type of this network01:48:36
like Tsvetaeva's poetry, cover and01:48:39
you quote poems there, you think about fate01:48:43
Marina baths and there worrying that you are already01:48:46
as they say, sluggish is already chlorpromazine01:48:48
yes yes yes then that means the user01:48:52
as he writes today the wind tore off the teeth01:48:54
on the wall of the Kremlin as in the song, yes there is one01:48:58
prong but they write what these forests are01:49:01
construction workers whose houses are forests of gray and01:49:04
he was hit there and what does that mean01:49:07
the earring protection was blown off by the wind today01:49:09
teeth on the cream on the Kremlin wall as in01:49:11
song the walls will collapse, all dilapidated for a long time01:49:14
saw this as a sign and this is the essence01:49:16
Russian people see the sign but so01:49:18
sit on the couch until01:49:23
[music]01:49:25
1 value on I think something is wrong with you01:49:29
will only take the stars flying by like an asterisk01:49:31
rocket question here's a question guys01:49:33
is that you saw everything01:49:35
sign of the night they are all week well01:49:37
wait, I think this is scary01:49:40
the answer from the garden of Minsk west yesterday is that01:49:44
all gays and lesbians01:49:46
puffed out their cheeks, blew, spat, and now under01:49:49
morning when it's just like the three little pigs01:49:52
will be given as dps good further so01:49:55
Question to Maxim: are you planning01:49:58
continue political activities and01:50:00
if so, in what form?01:50:02
I'm definitely planning on it01:50:04
continue in intellectual legal01:50:08
I hate forms of non-journalism too01:50:12
I don't think it's time to bring it up01:50:16
in fact, the task is to create someone01:50:18
club well left while a friend drinks this01:50:22
no we can't pick up the left forces01:50:24
permanent club can karen01:50:26
sleepy council meeting which I'm not01:50:28
I honestly think take it without Borisych without01:50:31
Nikolay on the palm of my hand completely01:50:33
real Sergei Obukhov01:50:35
he can really shape you01:50:39
issuing some kind of periodical newsletter01:50:41
you know the minutes will have to be pushed01:50:43
almost all night they do it01:50:45
this task has been detected at the moment01:50:47
definitely Oleg so next question01:50:51
how can you stop the spread01:50:53
Islam and extremism every month01:50:56
catches 10 15 people, it’s obvious that years01:51:00
in twenty when will it change01:51:01
demography demographic balance01:51:03
will blaze not childishly in some01:51:05
regions this is your thesis01:51:08
chauvinistic you think that everything01:51:09
carriers01:51:11
of a different nationality would be the conditions lying01:51:14
Islamic before civilization are01:51:16
extremists and chauvinists they are completely01:51:19
This is not how we should fight extremism01:51:21
There are three ways to explain to people01:51:24
able to speak their language and01:51:27
I operate with their concepts01:51:30
incorrectness of some positions01:51:32
participate in discussions with those who01:51:34
takes up arms create01:51:36
terrorist organizations for sure01:51:38
we must act to protect society from01:51:40
terrorism and01:51:42
in everything else we need to involve people01:51:45
normal social processes01:51:47
modern society for this society01:51:49
must be modern Putin's01:51:51
society not modern anarchy zero01:51:54
Anuar is milled and she provokes it herself01:51:57
I say it again even as in the story with01:52:00
Dagestan girls close these01:52:03
subcultural groups within themselves from01:52:05
any group that is closed inside01:52:08
she can't develop herself01:52:09
extremist worldview and attitude01:52:12
to the outside because she starts01:52:14
it is natural to form this feeling01:52:17
division by yours01:52:19
that is, correct and alien, that is01:52:22
do it wrong it's not that01:52:24
it is written in the Koran and the body is in that for you01:52:27
a school of witchcraft arose on the basis of Islam01:52:30
Averroes understand which became the basis01:52:32
philosophical school which Abelard is there01:52:35
Pierre Abelard Catholic philosopher me01:52:37
Catholic philosopher just right away01:52:39
the great French philosopher there as01:52:42
it is said but he read there and01:52:44
Averroes Muslim otherwise there was this one01:52:47
the most Arabs01:52:49
Maimonides in general is a Jewish scholar01:52:52
however, the water from the revenge of the radicals and01:52:55
Islam has radicals, you understand why01:52:57
radicalism arises why it arises01:52:59
I think extremism is because society01:53:01
does not offer an alternative development to these01:53:04
I wrote about this to groups in particular by the way01:53:07
it’s great there’s a French sociologist01:53:09
Arabic origin which one are you01:53:12
you just know he's the one on the left01:53:14
described all these01:53:16
I can’t remember now, but what for01:53:19
france for the north for could it01:53:22
there were actual problems because01:53:25
modernization of the French school there and vulture01:53:28
rash killed by islamists summer harbin lived01:53:31
Moroccan poet laureate of banking01:53:33
awards for arriving in Paris and at the same time01:53:35
there are severed heads and executions before that01:53:38
the Frenchman had his head cut off and01:53:40
photographed with the heads of Algerians and01:53:42
there was a lot of things but there is no need to put up with it01:53:45
who once between and how to01:53:48
offer modern alternatives and01:53:51
alternative future I believe that01:53:53
civil cooperation protection01:53:55
general civil rights01:53:59
respect for traditions01:54:01
national human I don’t know how01:54:05
said Indian Rossov Shankars are01:54:08
Gods or no gods doesn't change anything01:54:10
in my concept of the world, I don’t know if there is01:54:12
Is it the spirit of the Yakuts there or so on?01:54:15
Let every person believe as I do01:54:17
anyway Orkhan was my friend Cemal01:54:19
it did not matter to a Muslim believer01:54:21
relationships in building our sarkhan01:54:23
we have human relationships as well as those01:54:26
you and geddaram were squeezed, really when01:54:28
there are common ones, you need to build a common disk01:54:30
if the country builds a common01:54:33
civil social disk, believe me01:54:35
this will be the best01:54:38
antidote against extremism in everything01:54:41
other gifts with you suited perfectly01:54:47
extremism on all different extremism01:54:49
small groups breed extremism01:54:52
authorities01:54:53
this is not my thought to this Sartre between01:54:56
other things01:54:58
We have five minutes left until question 3 or01:55:01
two of them fight, I’ll fly away, let me quickly01:55:05
that means the first question01:55:06
Barse Yulechka Vo-ot Nikola Mikha the kindest01:55:10
evening and Boris Yulich is yours to everyone01:55:11
relation to the so-called package01:55:13
migrant worker to the proposed RPS with01:55:16
but it's an interesting idea01:55:19
108 listened because it's here01:55:23
different nuances but basically the idea itself01:55:27
simultaneously controls migration into01:55:30
Now is the time to guarantee the rights of migrants01:55:32
this is the right approach, then there is this01:55:36
the essence is operationally you need to look at what01:55:37
specifically do because but most01:55:40
successful example of migrant integration01:55:42
karos are built on this principle but01:55:44
now Finland itself is like this too01:55:47
the same practice, yes, that is, legal arrivals01:55:51
it's one thing to find illegality in another01:55:54
well, plus I would like one more detail01:55:57
clarified that it is necessary to distinguish between migration from and01:56:01
migration and immigration yes because01:56:04
Of course we have different social phenomena01:56:06
deliberately mixed because01:56:08
immigrants are all who want to stay and01:56:11
we need to give him the opportunity01:56:12
wants to integrate01:56:15
Accordingly, there is a different economy in01:56:17
emigration another economy before01:56:19
corresponds to the image of schools for example with01:56:22
children before Tomsk rises and the ratio in01:56:25
Russian language learning and preservation01:56:27
native language is further but also whole01:56:28
another package question but anyway I01:56:32
I would add that there should be a policy01:56:34
on immigration on immigration policy01:56:36
reasonable which you again were like that01:56:38
balanced here is an example the same as here01:56:40
speaks01:56:41
and now01:56:43
in case we need to talk about migration01:56:46
also balance immigration, that is01:56:48
so that the seedlings don’t have anything in Russia01:56:50
since in Russia there is no immigration01:56:52
politics in I will immigrate because01:56:54
that there is no right field in which Russia01:56:56
integration also takes place just people01:56:58
breathing and then there are no problems and01:57:00
ignored and01:57:02
why do you have to think as if people01:57:05
it was normal to guess01:57:07
society01:57:09
ruled by migrant workers who bring them here01:57:12
they deliver it later01:57:13
supposedly integrated actually them01:57:16
capital just don't build them man01:57:18
goes in a four-story01:57:19
school 4 shifts where you have 40 people01:57:22
will be of which 38 will mean when01:57:25
that there is no support there is no integra they01:57:27
somewhere they create nothing and that’s why01:57:30
pear should have a similar pattern01:57:32
which would allow about tender rewards01:57:34
for regulating yes yes then then whatever01:57:37
so the next question is in the provinces01:57:40
the governor is stronger than the mayor in Moscow, after all01:57:42
on the contrary, the reason is solely01:57:44
cash flows and how important was01:57:47
this position in the hierarchy of power in01:57:48
Soviet times but it’s sour now01:57:50
this immediately than briefly about the first Moscow01:57:52
the mayor and the governor are the same person in Moscow too01:57:56
Sabin has the rights of a governor according to01:57:58
in fact this is firstly secondly well with01:58:03
this union did not have a position, the mayor was the head01:58:05
executive committee which was subordinated to the first01:58:08
Victoria city committee 1 com or really was01:58:10
fairly strong political figures and01:58:13
protective measure controlled worth sushi 101:58:15
regional committee cheese actually 1 line we and01:58:18
became the first governor, by the way01:58:20
the same physically the same people and01:58:24
continuity is maintained and01:58:27
Central succession is precisely01:58:28
this is the one that's like this01:58:30
[music]01:58:32
federalism in Russia is good and convenient01:58:36
one question is just a question01:58:39
Maximov Maxim01:58:41
your opinion about the two mass shootings in01:58:45
educational institutions that were01:58:46
committed this year in Kazan and Perm01:58:49
Well, probably research can also give01:58:51
balancing with someone else01:58:52
less that you have, well, generally the code why01:58:56
this is why it happened too and01:58:58
power began to unfold and was renewed01:59:00
due to01:59:03
what has changed01:59:07
well let's just say psycho01:59:10
space society01:59:13
find out01:59:17
suicidal and this is a form of collective01:59:20
suicide that comes from one here it is01:59:23
at the turn of the 19th and 20th centuries there was a very01:59:26
widespread and actually acts01:59:29
terrorism01:59:30
they may also have a political01:59:33
direction can have such as01:59:35
eschatological mystical direction01:59:37
that is, psychopathic both here and there01:59:39
psychopaths may be involved01:59:42
but let's say Russian Serbian01:59:44
terrorism, but Kalyaev knows it01:59:48
conversation there with the Grand Duchess yes you could01:59:51
explain clearly why he wanted to kill or01:59:53
Sergei's kitchen was not there politically01:59:55
justified there were this correspondent and I01:59:58
fulfilled the will of the people enough02:00:01
metaphysical concepts with noses in hands02:00:03
in the mouth and words were I don’t compare02:00:06
of course this shooter, well he's awesome02:00:08
talks about the first ones, he prepared carefully02:00:09
why Perm this psychopath yes he has02:00:12
there was a justification he had naturally02:00:14
social psychopathy he is against salam02:00:17
itself to society can be in modern02:00:20
society needs02:00:22
[music]02:00:24
although this is a double-edged sword02:00:27
make covered accessible crazy from crazy02:00:29
consultation02:00:31
somehow the load on the02:00:34
human huge other load before02:00:36
people didn’t know such a constant load02:00:39
stranger02:00:42
symbolic reality of us on its own02:00:45
reason to let you in02:00:47
someone else's book with valentine read now02:00:50
It's not enough just to look at your phone screen02:00:52
see everything is done very accessible02:00:55
everything happens and it's objective02:00:58
reality has not changed the world has changed oh02:01:01
pedagogy and social psychology02:01:04
but the defense hasn't changed, they relate02:01:07
to school as if it were school now02:01:10
21st to 21st centuries the same somehow in which02:01:13
we studied but there was no need for our school02:01:15
protect the police tell the truth yes we don't02:01:18
they were afraid of harit schools of course maniacs02:01:19
there were some in our childhood I remember02:01:22
in my youth in Moscow there was something called Mosgaz02:01:24
Do you remember, but it was great my02:01:27
I drive it, well, just like before there was an old lady02:01:30
sex now then explained gorillas I02:01:33
there and then for twenty years people are afraid02:01:35
Chikatilo was the world about what in Soviet times02:01:38
that is, there were a psychopath, there were Monicas02:01:40
but the school children didn't know it but didn't02:01:44
because of course it was simple there02:01:46
different social mentality is different and02:01:48
in people and in children, although in our school02:01:51
there were fights there were conflicts in Moscow 802:01:54
the second year there was a Nazi march in our02:01:57
the day of Brezhnev's death I studied in German02:01:59
school, a huge swastika was painted on02:02:01
school I know until now we knew everyone who02:02:03
no one did it, naturally02:02:05
I can say that whoever did this was02:02:08
son of one of the party workers to know02:02:09
that tall like her marchers02:02:12
Nazis on the guns of eighty-two02:02:14
there were also children of high-ranking people02:02:15
employees of the Central Security Committee of the KGB there and so on this02:02:18
were like not a boy from the outskirts02:02:20
understand many ladies girls02:02:23
there are problems behind which social02:02:27
the science of society and generational02:02:31
I just have to keep up with relationships02:02:34
cards that by the way here is Shanin to rounding off02:02:37
is the same center which is in which02:02:39
I mean, to the school of economics p gaga ours02:02:41
Ninka is a scientific center even more than02:02:44
teaching in my opinion which02:02:46
deals with these we will ask how much02:02:48
I just know what I was doing as a Zulu02:02:51
I don’t know what you are doing now, but I suspect02:02:53
that if where you are and should be then it’s at02:02:56
you probably and just a discussion of anyone02:02:58
beings, space for discussion, this is necessary02:03:01
discuss because even though he gave it to headquarters02:03:03
I think the recipe is murder in any02:03:06
case it is a crime of settlement on02:03:08
personal threat even just murder02:03:10
other weapons are crimes there and02:03:13
age is not an excuse02:03:15
crimes but the only problem is02:03:18
number per adult with02:03:19
already established personal position02:03:21
socially, the person himself is responsible for02:03:24
the teenager answers after all the adults02:03:26
therefore for a crime as a teenager and02:03:28
even ask adults not only02:03:31
teachers of this school director and in there and02:03:33
so on from the children's room workers02:03:36
I don’t know the police if there is such a thing in Russia, but02:03:39
and from all children02:03:43
teenagers always ask questions about02:03:46
violence02:03:48
if you rudely accept the vizir about eros it is02:03:51
inscriptions such questions were asked by children I02:03:54
I think both in ancient Athens and in modern02:03:57
Moscow and modern London questions02:03:59
always the same for any person02:04:01
because a person lives between02:04:03
understanding that death is so02:04:06
I won’t be there, it’s impossible to realize it there02:04:08
attributed this to the need to self-determinate and02:04:10
how come I came from nowhere02:04:13
It’s also kind of unclear, but there it is02:04:15
between this there is a human02:04:17
personality by and large02:04:19
sexuality and everything else and02:04:21
it's easy in Russia02:04:24
simply given over to some kind of spontaneous02:04:26
space on the other side to entrust02:04:29
this is all for some women with purple02:04:30
hair that children will need there02:04:33
read about how it is necessary, I remember how02:04:35
my rocker youth was like this02:04:38
Among the rockers there are punks in the park of culture02:04:41
so there was a discussion junkie myself02:04:44
I've never been to I remember laughing02:04:46
all above these lectures there is light at one02:04:48
end02:04:49
the syringe will kill you the more we do it02:04:52
they told us the more they didn’t strive for02:04:53
self-destruction to the average guys02:04:55
talented bright whom I knew in my02:04:58
youth who actually were there02:05:00
just musicians, that's why it's very early02:05:02
they died, I remember how they became02:05:04
literally old people there for several years02:05:06
there is heroin use for example02:05:08
they had a terrible experience, just deadly02:05:12
but stages but this is phenomenon 1 and you yes this02:05:14
this is this and the same order senior must02:05:17
be able to talk with teenagers about02:05:19
violence and02:05:21
nature, I believe that these 9 in and case02:05:25
Kerch02:05:27
shooter perm shooter others there02:05:30
Kazan these crimes they are02:05:33
actually a very important manifestation 702:05:35
symptoms of a very terrible disease that02:05:40
society lives02:05:42
in a situation of lies and falsehood and none other than02:05:47
teenagers like a teenager who hasn't yet02:05:50
established himself in this matrix of stereotypes02:05:53
social behavior does not feel a lie02:05:56
of the older generation we know this from ourselves02:05:58
even loving our parents, how often do we02:06:01
it seemed like my dad was there at 15 years old, here I am02:06:05
thought like my beautiful one for which02:06:07
defended himself, came there to me always02:06:09
gave one helped always thought like him02:06:12
can lie like them, lie like them02:06:14
come to terms with this reality02:06:16
normal thinking I answers to this02:06:19
not always possible to get therefore I02:06:22
I think these are the deepest symptoms02:06:26
the deepest diseases of modern Russia02:06:30
illnesses02:06:31
technical like capitalism war of all02:06:34
against everyone and today I will die02:06:37
tomorrow they see great guys so02:06:41
the mighty triumph, the strong triumph02:06:43
who is padmasana in law enforcement agencies02:06:46
triumphant that law could intercede02:06:48
criminal elements are on the streets02:06:50
who have a paw in law enforcement agencies02:06:54
state of wealth acquired unjustly02:06:58
television yes not a single young man02:07:00
don't look people no one believes him02:07:02
everything is a lie and that’s why a subculture arises02:07:05
natural death sunku subculture02:07:08
fire and the subculture of violence therefore02:07:11
a morning star appears, it's absolutely02:07:13
tertiary is absolutely not original02:07:16
art genscher in my opinion02:07:18
drug propaganda02:07:21
energy discoveries there in the 60s02:07:23
County Leaf on the 13th floor or doors or02:07:26
rolling stones or song02:07:29
there's Lou Rida heroin let's say famous02:07:33
there and so on there as if whole there or02:07:36
there are books by Timothy Leary02:07:38
and bsd there was an intellectual whole02:07:41
why does this arise this protection this02:07:44
protection scary protection of teenagers02:07:47
violence in teen straight way02:07:50
protection from the lies of elders, we seem to be here02:07:53
so it all exists but this is society02:07:55
is doomed to escalate violence as well as02:07:58
acts of suicide in the tens02:08:01
twentieth century among students02:08:03
young people remember there was a whole epidemic02:08:05
suicides that they couldn't understand02:08:07
Many people wrote then and Gershenzon wrote02:08:10
wrote about it there and so on it was02:08:12
a harbinger of the horror that would come later02:08:14
happened there 17 to 20 years before these02:08:18
shot ditches there or frozen02:08:20
Absolutely violence in ice cream02:08:23
Total schizoid seems to me here02:08:26
now we need to pay attention to this02:08:28
very serious and elections that are simple02:08:32
mystify and which does not exist02:08:34
this is another crash actually02:08:39
supports02:08:41
that connect a person with society02:08:44
if the political process is here for us02:08:46
they say you choose then we understand that02:08:49
it's not real then that's it02:08:51
unreal then the person is already plunging02:08:54
into one arc inside oneself02:08:57
someone will be normal and someone will be02:09:00
for maniacs there, as they say, it’s already a trick02:09:03
it will fall like in a game of squid, so what?02:09:06
in fact the film is primitive but very02:09:09
exactly tough cruelly describing02:09:13
psychopathy in the modern world, well02:09:16
we just approached my father, I think that02:09:18
Of course, the psychopathy of the modern world is not02:09:21
very optimistic ending02:09:23
but dear marilyn conservatism yes on02:09:26
dear friends, I think it’s with psychopathy02:09:30
in the modern world we must fight not with02:09:34
help to a mental hospital as in the case when where02:09:39
I locked it there, I don’t decide anything, but with02:09:43
through social and cultural02:09:46
political changes02:09:48
I think that's where we'll end today02:09:51
so I think the question remains02:09:54
a lot but there's nothing you can do about it02:09:56
our time is limited02:09:58
at the very least thank you very much02:10:00
we will continue about02:10:03
intellectual interaction is02:10:05
obviously it goes without saying02:10:08
necessary inevitably in a good way02:10:12
inevitable and02:10:13
let's be but no one anyone from and02:10:18
you will no longer be used by fate02:10:19
left front to tragic on my02:10:22
the look should be an example for everyone yes02:10:24
and you can't allow your02:10:26
organization which is paid including02:10:29
lives and destinies02:10:31
those who associated their name and their02:10:34
fate was an application to something02:10:36
polyptych but definitely definitely me02:10:38
Do you need communication on whether technology is needed?02:10:41
serious honest conscientious02:10:43
analytics for the leaves themselves, well02:10:45
thank you everyone, thank you to those who watched02:10:47
look especially not especially including02:10:50
for those who are about a conditional donation02:10:52
thank you again to the maximum and see you again02:10:55
meet dear friends goodbyeDescription:
В гостях у "Рабкора" журналист, политический обозреватель и деятель Максим Шевченко. Максим Шевченко и Борис Кагарлицкий обсудят массовые задержания, проходящие по стране и другие актуальные политические новости России и мира. https://www.patreon.com/Rabkor https://www.donationalerts.com/r/bkagarlitsky Карта Сбербанка: 4279 3800 1452 3502 Яндекс Деньги 4100 1138 2475 623 QIWI +7 916 948 13 32 BTC 15QjHThCuNBRnUvv4gSFvRdpp3FeT8Yb72 Рекомендуем канал: @MaximShevchenko Дружественные каналы: @Vestnik_Buri, @VestnikBuriOriginals, @Agit_Prop, @PN_chanel, @TheBadComedian, @PN_chanel, @ThinkYourSelf_ThinkNow, @bondarenko_blog, @ButKorn, @Popularpolitics, @RemiMeisner, @Vasiliy_Sadonin, @spetz_tv Интервью Максима Шевченко смотрите также на каналах @svpressarutv и @zhivoygvozd
Preparing download options
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players
Questions about downloading video
How can I download "Безумие Крепчает (Максим Шевченко, Борис Кагарлицкий)" video?
http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.
Which format of "Безумие Крепчает (Максим Шевченко, Борис Кагарлицкий)" video should I choose?
The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.
Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Безумие Крепчает (Максим Шевченко, Борис Кагарлицкий)" video?
The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.
How can I download "Безумие Крепчает (Максим Шевченко, Борис Кагарлицкий)" video to my phone?
You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.
How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Безумие Крепчает (Максим Шевченко, Борис Кагарлицкий)"?
The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.
How can I save a frame from a video "Безумие Крепчает (Максим Шевченко, Борис Кагарлицкий)"?
This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.
What's the price of all this stuff?
It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.