Download "Научный Социализм. Попов М.В. [краткий учебный курс]"
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FSFnhl5aeBSo%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
Please wait. We're preparing links for easy ad-free video watching and downloading.
Table of contents
Similar videos from our catalog
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252F96Jb8VQ_1JA%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252F9ryKwFc61R8%252Fsddefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FAZqkPvX8qxc%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FQ803RDdiEGc%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FTgqoOqQYI-I%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
![глава 2. курса "НС" - РОЛЬ ТРУДА В ПРЕВРАЩЕНИИ ОБЕЗЬЯНЫ В ЧЕЛОВЕКА. Энгельс. [семинар]](/_next/image?url=https%3A%2F%2Funidownloader.com%2FcontentImages%2F80mxl7ifqpf0zWcVdZyTWXLBBs8%3D%2Ffilters%3Aquality(80)%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FaBLhnE6TAIE%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi%252FuD5acyVxjFc%252Fmaxresdefault.jpg&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252F0yEqQ-FXYQc%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252Fpd2WRPyBcgE%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
%3Aformat(webp)%2Fi.ytimg.com%252Fvi_webp%252FvH7UwMvYbm4%252Fmaxresdefault.webp&w=1139&q=75)
Video tags
Subtitles
Russian
00:00:01
[music]00:00:12
[laughter]00:00:17
hello comrades how are you today?00:00:22
stated in the video title00:00:25
we will talk about socio-economic00:00:27
formations but it’s possible to drag around00:00:31
perceive so what forms00:00:32
there are formations what are they called00:00:36
than they are defined there is a deeper00:00:40
principle and more important consequences00:00:43
which is this division by00:00:44
formation this principle is that00:00:49
fundamental determinant in00:00:51
human history00:00:52
according to Engels which are available in the00:00:58
his books the origins of a private family00:01:00
property and the state determining00:01:02
in human history is00:01:04
production and reproduction00:01:06
immediate life, that's all00:01:09
characteristic of dialectics for00:01:11
dialectical approach what before00:01:13
go into some00:01:15
a long way with the decomposition of different so00:01:18
say questions with classification however00:01:20
need to choose or determine what00:01:24
fundamental on the basis of which and00:01:27
turn around everything further like this00:01:30
this is fundamental00:01:31
a situation that Simon realizes that00:01:33
fundamental human history00:01:35
is production and reproduction00:01:38
immediate life and what is it in00:01:41
production of direct life in00:01:43
first is human production first00:01:46
what do people do they reproduce others00:01:48
people and it's not even the same matter00:01:52
that is, a man jumps a man00:01:55
humanity she is in this sense in her own way00:01:59
nature endless forever but with one00:02:03
condition the fairy is still producing funds00:02:07
material means of subsistence00:02:08
of this humanity because it00:02:10
human production would quickly00:02:12
ended if they were produced00:02:14
means of life therefore on00:02:19
initial stage of development00:02:20
of humanity this is the first production00:02:22
it was fundamental to man and this00:02:25
everything else is produced by material00:02:27
the blessings that fell to rob00:02:29
and to collecting the fruits of the roots of fishing on00:02:33
small animals and so on, that is00:02:35
this is collecting not production00:02:37
material goods00:02:38
but an attempt to take advantage of the gifts of nature00:02:41
although to take advantage of the gifts00:02:44
nature I need to run, as they say, I could do it00:02:48
Bow and arrows00:02:49
maybe make some darts00:02:50
or a copy or you need to dig holes and then00:02:55
carry the cloth so that mom can go there00:02:57
failed and went straight to the tip00:03:00
and so that you can then cut it and00:03:03
bake if you have fires if you have00:03:07
you already have fire and so on and so forth00:03:09
to support its existence and00:03:12
this is the period when it was in first place00:03:16
and reproduction of people and on the second00:03:18
place in the sense of determining the move00:03:22
historical events in second place00:03:25
it's all such material to carry around00:03:27
side of the matter comes second00:03:29
production of material goods00:03:31
this whole period is called00:03:34
primitive communal communism and why00:03:37
it's called communism but what00:03:39
primitive community this this society this00:03:41
clearly primitive, that is, that’s all00:03:43
started and in general if we are talking about something00:03:45
we say we have to start over they00:03:47
there is no middle and no end00:03:50
primal is the being that was00:03:53
some first being which was this00:03:55
here is the community and00:03:57
human existence and why coumadin00:04:00
and because it was common00:04:02
property because as we know it00:04:05
for stories and better than books00:04:10
private family origin00:04:11
I wouldn’t call it state property00:04:14
Moreover, it has already been republished more than once00:04:16
outside the Soviet era I came in admitted00:04:19
our university store there Engels00:04:22
such a beard00:04:23
small format book beautiful deception00:04:26
put it in your pocket quickly00:04:28
he describes interestingly it is considered as00:04:31
I have a detective00:04:36
there was such a case00:04:38
the eye doctor I went to ended up with00:04:44
patronymic Engels o vich well I'm next00:04:48
when I went to him for the second time00:04:50
I bought this nickname, especially since they00:04:52
they sell it there and gave it to him00:04:53
and the third time the top move went like this00:04:58
it was interesting to read, he didn't read much00:05:01
I was interested in you and how you are00:05:02
understand the eye doctor directly00:05:04
had nothing to do with this but and but00:05:07
known relationship since he is Enga Lee00:05:09
Savich he still had that's why it was00:05:16
very interesting and I recommend it to everyone because00:05:18
what is this ingress, how is it different from this00:05:20
Marx Marx writes everything clearly and that’s it00:05:23
the gulag is right, but the Hungarians are still00:05:26
they write that the fabric is so shiny00:05:28
it's interesting to say something capital00:05:30
fascinating cool well I'm at a loss00:05:35
I must say she is very interesting00:05:37
deep very strictly built there00:05:40
here are all the further ones built on00:05:42
previous and then everything unfolds00:05:44
but in the sense of fascination I will00:05:47
I think that Engels Street is of course such a window00:05:50
exit origin 7 private00:05:51
it is very much the property of the state00:05:55
interesting and very advantageous and you00:05:58
you can read this book00:06:00
move from primitive communal00:06:02
communism right up to capitalism which is already00:06:06
fraught with new general link below therefore00:06:10
that's all for those who want to quickly understand00:06:14
this whole story is the most important thing00:06:16
find out in history but from this book00:06:19
you can have it00:06:20
or you will be all sorts of historians at home00:06:23
read so many which details are all00:06:25
describe in great detail but they00:06:27
the common thread of this is lost00:06:30
thread that actually do this00:06:32
history00:06:34
and finally this is life 1 life on00:06:42
communal communism to whom there is nothing00:06:45
no longer means except for one thing:00:06:47
common communist means common don't need00:06:50
nothing to add to this what to whom00:06:52
communism is something like that00:06:54
unusually it only means one thing00:06:57
that public property is00:06:59
what were the means of production00:07:01
basic means of rodeo production00:07:03
the tools were stone knives then00:07:05
iron knives appeared, that is, axes00:07:10
also first stone, then iron and00:07:12
some other weapons and it was all in00:07:18
common property since it was common00:07:20
what other property do you offer?00:07:22
you can't call it what you can't call it00:07:24
if you approach this strictly scientifically00:07:27
if this second one was with him00:07:31
humanity lived 90 thousand years then00:07:34
this system is called communism00:07:36
so if he inserts all the questions00:07:38
how long has humanity lived?00:07:41
communism, well, I lived under communism00:07:44
90 thousand years and now lives for a couple of thousand years00:07:47
in other general conditions in other forms00:07:51
society but what happened during this time00:07:54
has grown so much during this time00:07:58
production of these tools and00:08:00
they have improved so much that00:08:03
production of material goods00:08:04
began to come out on top and became00:08:07
defining so we can say what00:08:10
Means became decisive, but it was already possible00:08:13
relying on these means of production and00:08:17
I mean that the tribes fought between00:08:20
yourself and now your tribe has won and conquered00:08:25
another tribe and before there was no point in00:08:30
in order to00:08:31
there was no music to take anyone prisoner00:08:35
only there was no point but it was impossible block00:08:37
you will be taken prisoner if you are00:08:41
working to feed yourself and this prisoner00:08:44
then the productive force of this is not00:08:46
allows tools does not allow00:08:48
feed two 1 and if you count00:08:51
that he will work but he will himself00:08:53
work here and about choruses and you are here for00:08:55
that's why you need it, that's why00:08:58
there were no prisoners, that is, there were no prisoners00:09:01
Khlebnikov was not taken, they were killed if you00:09:04
representative of another tribe if you00:09:07
defeated we kill you if we00:09:09
whitewashed00:09:10
Well, killing us and carrying this is no good00:09:13
there was no other option because of this00:09:15
but because it’s impossible to feed 200:09:18
person and vice versa as soon as one00:09:20
a person could feed two but who00:09:24
should then work as you think00:09:25
the one who conquered or the one who was conquered00:09:28
but the one who was conquered was like him00:09:30
should have been killed but they were hit00:09:33
Wilde's life was torn apart and once he was given00:09:36
life then he has to work and for nothing00:09:38
don't pretend why because it00:09:40
as if no, they just gave life and he he00:09:43
they killed him like that and here he’s just working00:09:46
on you is your slave and you can00:09:48
stand out let's say this or that00:09:52
person00:09:53
a warrior with a group of these same00:09:58
boxes and carry it at least he will00:10:01
organize their work on your own00:10:04
he obeyed, he will kill them because00:10:06
that he admires the laws of Rome00:10:09
empire so what was democracy like before00:10:12
was democracy is democracy who00:10:14
concerned this democracy concerned him00:10:18
the owner that is the morning was the owner00:10:20
decided on the principle00:10:21
that a minority of slave owners and00:10:24
there are very few free citizens there00:10:27
obeyed the decision of the majority of whom00:10:29
slave owner00:10:30
and this is the teaching: people are slaves, these are speakers00:10:33
they don't count as weapons00:10:34
and therefore the scale was what the norms were00:10:37
these norms assumed that everyone00:10:39
the slave owner can do anything00:10:41
do with your slave or rub00:10:43
and not that is, it can kill them at any time00:10:46
moment and for any reason, well, tass00:10:50
jambs and protests of slaves were suppressed00:10:52
and here democracy already worked like this00:10:55
say this is the majority00:10:56
slave owners organized themselves this way00:10:58
everyone was dragging and00:10:59
and sporty look and they all00:11:02
they are all trained with swords00:11:04
now with weapons and they solved the issue00:11:08
exist or not if suddenly in a purely00:11:10
the slaves rebelled00:11:12
then they all fall together on these00:11:14
slaves and eliminates the uprising of these slaves00:11:19
this is the natural course of history00:11:22
Well, what can you say about this society?00:11:24
Well, you can say that this is from00:11:27
primitive communal humanism gradually00:11:30
slaveholding began to grow00:11:33
society lawyer alawar table and so these00:11:39
the communities themselves fell apart and that’s why it00:11:43
was letrop it's generally on society where00:11:46
women decided everything where matriarchy was00:11:48
woman why did they decide what they were watching00:11:51
for the children and everything was needed00:11:53
there is a distribution so that no one is00:11:57
would be at a loss00:11:58
so that the children are fed because of the man00:12:01
so that they are and not because they need it again00:12:03
go after prey00:12:06
but mothers themselves must00:12:10
reproduce and therefore family00:12:13
was accordingly alone monogamous00:12:16
and polygamy, these were common children, this00:12:20
had common marriage00:12:22
so to speak, and all this is written here00:12:26
Engels I can’t tell it better00:12:28
just refer and then it took place00:12:32
transition to what00:12:33
is slavery a step forward or a step00:12:36
back00:12:37
Well, in history it’s considered a step forward00:12:40
what contributes to development00:12:43
productive forces00:12:44
transition to a slave society00:12:48
said increased casting preliminary00:12:50
they were already strong00:12:52
these were not just separate guns00:12:55
and water pipelines and viaducts were also00:12:59
palaces that are now here if you sing00:13:02
to Greece and Rome you will see those00:13:07
buildings that now exist but00:13:10
if you take, say, Khrushchev's00:13:12
the structure is now crumbling so00:13:15
they built it nice and well and here I am00:13:18
looked at these here are some buildings from00:13:22
of which large columns remained from the sky00:13:24
huge blocks of stones00:13:27
I don't know how they managed00:13:28
there are such huge multi-ton blocks00:13:31
their cards were able to raise our take00:13:35
they already had certain means00:13:37
mechanically means apparently some00:13:40
block systems00:13:42
developed but probably known to everyone00:13:47
that geometry was already developing at that time00:13:50
Physics had already begun to develop at that time00:13:52
then there were already designers who00:13:55
they did it was a car that they punched00:13:57
walls and vice versa00:13:59
could build its walls and palaces00:14:02
the kind you can envy00:14:06
the top if you come to Athens and go00:14:08
around and then there are such beautiful temples that they00:14:12
quite compete with modern buildings00:14:15
but if not so modern00:14:19
buildings don't quite compete with everyone00:14:21
buildings that were built at that time00:14:25
time this time is characterized00:14:28
slavery by the separation of labor00:14:31
Uppsala from physical labor hung over oneself00:14:34
slave owners' privileges but00:14:37
slave owners look if they were engaged00:14:39
they promoted science to you with their work00:14:41
they promoted art and introduced them to00:14:44
this is some slaves if they were00:14:47
talented as we know that goiter00:14:50
was like a slave but here he is00:14:53
without him we went to the heritage of humanity00:14:57
that is, one of the slaves00:15:01
became even cultural figures and you00:15:04
Now they said where is Lesya science exactly00:15:05
also someone Lomonosov who arrived00:15:09
from the north from a peasant family and became00:15:14
under the mask of the head of the Academy of Sciences here in00:15:18
brilliant St. Petersburg but this is already00:15:22
other times it's feudalism00:15:24
but what is characteristic of slavery, what in00:15:26
this time has begun thanks to this00:15:29
because sciences and arts appeared and00:15:31
even other cultural conquests went00:15:34
rapid development of productive forces00:15:36
so violently and that such00:15:38
means of production that are torn00:15:41
come on it was already impossible why because00:15:45
that slaves00:15:46
these are not some downtrodden people, these are00:15:49
people are quite possibly no less educated00:15:52
no less intelligent no less literate but00:15:56
these are the people who lost the tribal war00:15:59
if they lost they would carry00:16:03
if the litany games would do the same00:16:05
with those to whom they became slaves, but they00:16:09
were completely uninterested in00:16:12
to improve and do better00:16:14
use the instrument of your enslavement00:16:16
they understood perfectly well that this was what they needed00:16:18
they give it so that they can work, this is it00:16:21
what helps them even deeper is what you want00:16:26
get into this quagmire about ownership00:16:32
slave oppression and therefore they00:16:35
were negative about it00:16:37
improved the tools for them00:16:38
you didn't mean anything at all00:16:40
life is absolutely no improvement00:16:43
radiation could only00:16:45
slave owners mean nothing to you00:16:46
reminds now how under capitalism and in00:16:48
in Russia there are some improvements00:16:50
everything is expressed in the fact that we have more00:16:52
millionaires and billionaires00:16:54
for five years in a row the sixth year is underway and00:16:57
all the time00:16:58
real content goes down00:17:00
work boards this is some parallel I00:17:03
I haven’t approved anything about this yet, the project00:17:05
capitalism is far superior00:17:08
slavery in many ways and so00:17:11
further including the basis of capitalism00:17:13
what was created still lies00:17:16
then still in Rogov’s time00:17:18
but in any case this is the system00:17:22
despite its progressiveness00:17:24
compared to the first life in general00:17:26
communism it is limited limited by00:17:30
that he rests on this00:17:31
employee interest therefore00:17:34
So this is the same system as Bruce?00:17:37
it expanded developed created00:17:41
a huge state and finally these00:17:44
states fell under the blows of barbarians well00:17:49
and barbarians carrying around is a concept00:17:52
some from the point of view of these00:17:53
slave owners are barbarians from a point of view00:17:56
from the view of the barbarians, the barbarian himself is00:17:58
keep in animal position00:18:02
another person and when they were created00:18:08
new states00:18:09
in return for all the states that were00:18:11
destroyed then instead of slave owners00:18:14
instead of00:18:15
serfs appeared from slaves00:18:19
what is the difference and the only difference is00:18:21
one cannot kill, that is, you can do everything00:18:25
make with your own sausage sell00:18:28
you can pawn00:18:30
you can search and beat him with whips00:18:33
remember as much as you want as ugly00:18:36
wrote part of the hornets day at six o'clock00:18:39
I went to the hay and they beat a woman00:18:42
whip a young peasant woman and look askance00:18:46
the microphone decides but here is my muse and this00:18:49
so he dedicated all his muse to the museum00:18:52
works but that was just recently00:18:55
you understand if there if we go deep00:18:57
centuries we go to work not this00:18:59
when women were whipped on orders00:19:02
the landowner himself did not beat the landowners00:19:05
he was cultured he was educated00:19:07
well-read, he spoke Russian and00:19:10
French00:19:11
but why am I in obi00:19:12
he was, that is, as we can say now00:19:15
get a service for money, he is also on00:19:18
took the hay there and brought up a00:19:20
then they bring it back and it’s already a wallet00:19:24
and that's the difference but it's big00:19:27
the difference is that you can’t kill no it’s not00:19:30
that means they killed serfs, well00:19:32
would this be seen as legitimizing not00:19:35
there was no such thing as carrying a serious crime00:19:38
so that for the murder of a serf severely00:19:41
it's rolling in, it's rolling in after all00:19:43
not good but if someone ran away if you00:19:46
they’ll catch him here, modules from already common ones00:19:49
through the efforts of the feudal lords kosis this victory is00:19:53
more if it raises an uprising there like00:19:56
there is a bulavin or separ 1 or Pugachev then00:19:59
they even sent the best00:20:01
generals00:20:02
who knew military science who brought00:20:06
at Pugachev's execution00:20:08
the best commander in the world00:20:11
Suvorov remained00:20:14
so this is the next step00:20:18
but behind her, as you and I know, behind her00:20:23
the improvement of machines went further00:20:26
perfection and00:20:27
tools of labor and production and appeared00:20:30
not just a tool tools that00:20:33
connected to other instruments and00:20:34
because when we talk about a car it's00:20:37
already a set of tools that00:20:39
act as a whole as one00:20:41
system and00:20:42
it's one thing just a simple division00:20:47
labor then here I am making stools you00:20:52
do Ivanov's stool do00:20:54
stool petrol makes stool we00:20:56
we look at each other who is doing what and00:20:58
we learn who to why you have here quickly00:21:01
it turns out I did one thing you did or00:21:04
three so here to carry this here00:21:07
connection in one place in one00:21:09
space of people who do the same thing and00:21:12
same thing, there is some progress too00:21:15
there is a show coming with us00:21:16
qualifications so on you know how00:21:18
very different people who are the same00:21:21
does the same even when harvesting potatoes00:21:23
when weeding we want to tell the shop00:21:27
especially when there are some monotonous00:21:30
some operations are called simple00:21:35
cooperation cooperation is simple00:21:38
this is a form of labor Mars wrote when00:21:40
which many people systematically work in00:21:43
one or related00:21:44
production processes for many years00:21:46
it’s planned that our pullover is00:21:48
management management what are all sorts of00:21:52
directly public or00:21:54
joint work carried out in00:21:57
on a large enough scale it needs00:21:59
control that performs communication00:22:00
individual work and performs general00:22:05
functions resulting movement of everything00:22:07
production of the organism as a whole and mars00:22:09
this comparison sums up each and every00:22:12
the violinist controls himself00:22:14
and the orchestra needs a jury, that is00:22:18
if you have an orchestra, it’s none of your business00:22:21
the symphony won't work if you00:22:25
small chamber orchestra sometimes here00:22:28
so to speak, one violinist somehow towards the end00:22:31
shows what someone needs to be told to do00:22:34
so that everything is fine but if it's big00:22:36
orchestra without conductor00:22:38
you're probably fighting the iconic big one00:22:41
the orchestra that performed this00:22:43
already control, that is, you showed up00:22:45
management and division of labor as soon as00:22:48
and from the division of labor appeared00:22:49
manufactory and this is the manufactory that00:22:54
equipped with machines that repeatedly00:22:58
increases productivity, well00:23:00
raises what we'll say when we've done it00:23:02
looms00:23:03
the one that used to be woven by hand00:23:07
tens of thousands of steel are thrown into00:23:09
street by tens of thousands under capitalism00:23:12
but this whole movement is related to development00:23:16
productive forces and, accordingly, with00:23:18
changes in industrial relations00:23:20
look we've already looked00:23:22
slavery feudalism capitalism but this00:23:25
everything is like one big formation honestly00:23:28
proprietary property private00:23:30
different types of oppression00:23:33
operation but all this is based on00:23:36
Dolly's private property was private00:23:38
own00:23:40
slave owners including people00:23:42
now private property00:23:44
feudal lords including people and00:23:47
finally private property is00:23:50
including only for cars00:23:53
so now I'm watching some00:23:56
comrades, here are some working comrades00:23:58
that's where the owner said they instead00:24:01
to demand the conclusion of a contract00:24:05
or rather, draw up the agreement that00:24:08
is considered concluded in accordance with the labor contract00:24:10
code 61 67 neighbor labor code00:24:14
they complain that if the animal is about00:24:17
Not no on paper well it says what if00:24:20
you are allowed to work with us00:24:23
an employment contract has been concluded00:24:25
and if you are concluded, you will write00:24:29
statement of you by you00:24:30
is obliged to issue within three days00:24:33
employment contract, comrades don’t do this00:24:36
workers they feel00:24:38
on the position of serfs this means that00:24:41
Let's say the rollback we have00:24:42
happened in the USSR in Russia this is not from the frame00:24:46
just some good capitalism00:24:48
people including workers including00:24:50
workers especially young00:24:52
they went far back into the centuries of feudalism00:24:56
and behave like serfs to you this00:24:58
director of your enterprise and owner00:25:01
capitalist nobody00:25:02
he is the commander of the means of production00:25:05
you are a free man, so you sold yours00:25:08
labor for a certain price here00:25:12
since wages are the price of labor00:25:15
strength and everything and the principle you have so far00:25:18
you get paid you work for all of you00:25:21
agreement Why is he paying me? You don’t work, you do it yourself00:25:23
see in me pays people complain00:25:25
we don't get paid shook you work for the count00:25:28
work although 142 articles of labor00:25:32
the code is written, I am quoting bourgeois00:25:35
the code under which he enshrined in himself00:25:37
bourgeois freedoms which flows from00:25:39
the essence of this method of production and this00:25:42
formations00:25:43
what if you don't get paid notify your00:25:47
administration to suspend00:25:49
just don't stop working00:25:51
suspend salary payments here00:25:53
Well, so you understand that00:25:55
to find out means to receive00:25:56
confirmation that you notified if you00:25:59
Secretaries don’t treat you like that either00:26:01
the director will say nothing to shoo you away00:26:04
I won’t write to you on the second copy00:26:05
well send it00:26:06
by registered mail with notification of00:26:08
instructions have received this notification00:26:09
come to your workplace now00:26:12
sit down and open your favorite book or00:26:15
Marx's capital or labor code and00:26:17
read and if you're tired of reading the idea00:26:20
walk then come it is written in this00:26:23
You are not required to be in Article 14200:26:25
on workers but if I'm with you00:26:28
an employment contract means I work for you00:26:32
dress you don't creep me00:26:34
I'm not working the time you're telling me00:26:36
without paying somehow you pay I come00:26:38
what am I writing there that I will continue to work on00:26:41
the next day after payment of salaries or00:26:43
on the same day when salaries are paid00:26:45
if you want, write here and read everything 14200:26:48
articles and don’t think that this is special00:26:50
then well, advantage or something like that with us00:26:52
This is a progressive legal system00:26:55
bourgeois system native system with o00:26:57
that is the essence of man is free00:26:59
a worker is free, this does not mean that he00:27:02
free from nutrition you will not be free00:27:05
beer doesn't make any difference, that's why00:27:06
you need to work for this but if you00:27:08
they put you in the position of a serf00:27:10
they won’t pay at all, but the serfs00:27:12
they don't pay, why should you pay?00:27:13
I, if I am a landowner, then I have already given it to you00:27:16
you sew the earth on it, you00:27:18
stay there for three or four days00:27:21
his borscht should not work for free00:27:22
you will work in corvée for free, not00:27:25
get the land don't get access for00:27:28
you won't be able to let your cows go to pasture00:27:32
walk in the forest00:27:33
again he belongs to the landowners00:27:35
which mushrooms and which berries are you00:27:37
are you going to prepare00:27:38
so what kind of relationship is this?00:27:42
sense that this is a lie00:27:44
the owner is a gentleman, he really is a gentleman and he00:27:48
not interested in dying for example00:27:50
among feudal lords, the more peasants the better00:27:54
let them multiply00:27:56
let them be But the more souls I have, the more I00:27:58
respectable more respectable nobleman than I00:28:01
solid and gave00:28:02
and if you don’t have enough, you need at least them00:28:04
there to invent that there are dead00:28:06
souls and record them alive and what00:28:08
concerns the current capital here00:28:10
don't care and don't drag it now you00:28:12
got sick and if you are not registered as00:28:15
if there is no legal one they take you and take you out00:28:19
behind the gate and there they put battles in reserve00:28:21
metro mind is very serious after which00:28:23
maybe you can't00:28:25
work and your media and there will be nothing to eat00:28:27
no one cares anymore, everything is there00:28:29
other people they are standing in line or you00:28:32
Do you think unemployment is a natural phenomenon?00:28:34
disaster or do you think capitalists00:28:36
such fools or diode and they can’t00:28:38
count how many jobs and are similar00:28:40
there are people workers potentially00:28:43
they do it on purpose00:28:45
so that there are fewer jobs than00:28:49
why workers then to follow you00:28:52
there were two three people who always stood00:28:56
the board will immediately take your place00:28:58
as soon as you get out00:29:00
so when will you be00:29:01
suspend work it says that00:29:04
you may not be at work00:29:06
I wouldn’t recommend axes, but just in case00:29:08
sit on your own and haven’t stopped working00:29:10
and you're just having some temporary difficulties00:29:12
the owner has money let him have it00:29:14
absolutely cannot solve them like this00:29:16
capitalist, if not a capitalist, let him not00:29:18
it is played that he is a capitalist but if you00:29:21
you can't pay workers' wages like that00:29:23
don’t pretend that you are a capitalist owner00:29:26
enterprise and so on, that is, it is necessary but00:29:29
at least be on par with that00:29:30
method of producing this formation00:29:32
which is capitalist I have to00:29:34
states that today00:29:36
we can say that the majority of workers are not00:29:39
I saw myself as I should behave00:29:41
people in bourgeois society, that is, how00:29:44
free workers free sale00:29:46
its workforce00:29:47
Well, anyway, here are all 33 formations00:29:51
which we have reviewed is slavery00:29:55
and feudalism capitalism and capitalism and00:29:57
associated with machine production00:29:59
just with the manufactory where to carry it00:30:02
division of labor by Mashkov00:30:04
no, but with the machine one00:30:06
production that bottles itself00:30:08
further and develops so much that you00:30:11
is already talking about artificial00:30:13
intelligence although what art is00:30:15
intelligence is also some kind of beast00:30:18
a machine that does those functions00:30:21
Not all of which can be entrusted to machines00:30:25
functions can be entrusted to the machine, especially00:30:28
this is the function that people perform00:30:30
student of dialectics because people00:30:32
who study dialectics they operate in00:30:36
dialectical logic of not a single machine00:30:39
until today which would be some00:30:42
elements of dialectical logic carried or00:30:45
used no one simple one00:30:46
reason that this entire area is a replacement00:30:53
man and machine built on where on00:30:57
formal logic00:30:58
and formal logic includes logical00:31:00
contradictions and dialectical logic00:31:02
it includes in the consideration of contradictions00:31:05
claims that there is nothing to be00:31:08
even by another action, or rather this way00:31:12
what is identical is different what is everything00:31:14
identical is different and everything is different00:31:17
identically why, well, here we are00:31:20
different people, I’m sitting here and they’re recording me00:31:23
and you look00:31:25
search and react to what I said00:31:28
but you and I are people on our floor, but the walls00:31:31
we are different people at night different what if00:31:35
we are identical there and solemnly as00:31:36
People00:31:37
rain from 1 people there and different that is not00:31:40
there is such an identity if you open00:31:42
200:31:43
second book of the science of logic Hegel's teaching00:31:49
about the essence there you will find a category00:31:51
identities are always childhood00:31:53
different and the differences here00:31:56
distinguishes identically if the games are on00:31:59
someone writes about this directly00:32:00
a thoughtful person says such things00:32:04
what a tree is a tree a log is a log table00:32:08
this is a table it's called tautology00:32:11
repetition of the same repetition 000:32:14
then long for this autological speech00:32:16
no one will watch and turn away00:32:18
they'll wave their hand and leave, so we have to00:32:23
understand that the car doesn’t care00:32:25
by the way he thinks00:32:26
only in the binary system because00:32:30
that there is a unit when the current flows00:32:33
0 when it just doesn’t work and that’s if00:32:36
one more one appears there00:32:38
one in the next digit and here00:32:40
zero but she counts so quickly00:32:43
binary system that these numbers are here00:32:45
this size00:32:47
sandy binary system they are in00:32:49
decimal but this is for the machine and not00:32:52
it’s important, that’s a completely different task, so00:32:56
let's not confuse here are some industries00:32:59
which are built on formal logic00:33:02
Ike and dialectical while we are with you00:33:05
we can already conclude that these three00:33:08
production methods that have00:33:12
customization production method together00:33:14
stop the superstructure that's on it00:33:16
is based on a basis00:33:18
on this production method00:33:20
represent00:33:21
socio-economic formation all00:33:23
these three socio-economic00:33:24
formations have in common that particular00:33:28
ownership of the means of production00:33:29
private same part of society group00:33:33
capitalists denny rose but capitalists00:33:36
or until cooperative is acceptable when00:33:38
in capitalism it is something like that00:33:40
private enterprise00:33:41
some comrades think about the collective farm00:33:45
itself is socialist00:33:47
property nothing like that it's him00:33:50
if he ends up getting involved00:33:53
state enterprise00:33:54
state enterprise to provide00:33:56
its all work with the help of un machines00:34:00
in kind pays for what he does00:34:03
what is included in the general state plan and00:34:05
as a result we get a form of social00:34:08
state property00:34:09
property falls apart or00:34:11
the haram system is destroyed00:34:14
machine and tractor stations in which00:34:16
contains all the subjects00:34:19
the most important for the state00:34:22
agricultural implement00:34:24
that's when that's when you get it already00:34:27
from cooperatives also from private00:34:29
property and still appears00:34:30
cooperatives that were created, for example00:34:33
Sobchak asked two cooperatives from this00:34:35
his political destiny began here00:34:39
and legal cooperatives I tell you00:34:41
I will give advice because of this we will highlight00:34:43
you won't pay for this and that's all00:34:45
wisdom00:34:46
Well, that’s why, considering that actually00:34:50
here is one for the means of production and00:34:52
this is typical for slavery and00:34:57
feudalism and capitalism we can00:34:59
consider it big one big honestly00:35:03
proprietary formation means it was00:35:06
classical formation touches on00:35:08
communal communism then its denial and00:35:11
that's when the revolution happens00:35:16
socialist and better yet00:35:19
call it communist why because00:35:21
that there is no such way of socialism00:35:22
production00:35:24
there is a production method00:35:25
communist that is based on00:35:27
common ownership of funds00:35:29
production then open the root00:35:32
Marx's work as a critic of the Gothic program00:35:34
you won't find the word socialism there00:35:36
there is simply communism that is passing00:35:38
two stages of the nine phase of its development00:35:41
first he is born with my radio00:35:46
imprints of capitalism and this one00:35:48
unripe immature undeveloped socialism00:35:51
both communism isn't mature00:35:54
unripe communism let's socialism00:35:56
but Mars doesn’t have the word socialism, that’s it00:36:00
the first trout is not the boss for communism but00:36:03
when communism will not be liberated forever00:36:05
to be with these Rodionov spots to carry around00:36:07
that is, they gradually shrink and so00:36:10
he will be free from the traces of capitalism00:36:12
in economic slavery to us00:36:14
this relationship is called the second phase00:36:17
communism or the highest phase of communism and00:36:19
I have to say that this is it00:36:21
even though it's such a simple thing00:36:22
this is not a us warrior so much has not been mastered but00:36:25
that's why when Khrushchev became00:36:28
tell me that we will soon live in00:36:29
communism is all that kind00:36:31
there is, I think the bathhouse was saddened and if00:36:33
I just told them at that moment that you00:36:36
look, you've been living since 1936 because00:36:40
What00:36:41
1936 35 36 all00:36:46
lifestyles that existed except00:36:49
The communist system has already outlived its usefulness00:36:51
was patriarchal no patriarchal00:36:54
Well, maybe there are some units00:36:56
units of glass yes no that is no00:36:58
quite a large number of people who00:37:01
would you live this way something they00:37:04
grow, eat and that's it00:37:06
protein products are not entering the market anywhere00:37:10
we have outlived our usefulness, why no one in it00:37:14
only they would say choked but simply00:37:19
state production developed00:37:21
and terrible production made products00:37:24
better and cheaper you will go buy worse00:37:27
and it’s not more expensive, that’s why people didn’t come00:37:29
he lived and disappeared, he won’t come up with it00:37:32
canceled and not00:37:33
no one canceled it, you saw the solution00:37:35
why cancel gift giving on them?00:37:37
cancel was such a policy that we00:37:40
the main owners of private ones were taken away00:37:43
made public sector00:37:45
at first he was there state capitalism and00:37:48
communist way of life and gradually from00:37:50
state capitalism, all enterprises directed00:37:53
in the public interest they became00:37:55
humanistic in this sense00:37:57
and there are no other ways of life left00:38:00
no other deposits remain00:38:02
no left we got to the monitor00:38:05
mid-30s, but if people00:38:08
Of course they don’t know this and don’t understand00:38:10
couldn’t notice what was happening with us00:38:12
counter-revolution because in the first place00:38:15
the nonsense that Khrushchev said there00:38:18
in 10 years we will live in00:38:19
It's great not to know communism at all00:38:23
what is communism to say that00:38:25
in 10 years, although already consider it00:38:28
spoke in the sixty-first year00:38:29
twenty-second congress and in our00:38:32
thirty-sixth year was already built00:38:36
communism and he is not the boss from but which we00:38:39
that's all you can build00:38:41
rap for not building the second pair for the phase00:38:44
it results from development00:38:46
humanism on its own basis, that is00:38:48
based on the fact that this is communism through00:38:51
eradication of birthmarks, that is, he is so00:38:53
here, too, being clam slipped away and it’s alive00:38:56
in it what is opposite to it, including00:39:00
division division has not yet been completely overcome00:39:03
society into classes differences between00:39:06
city and countryside people physical00:39:07
people have a lot of trouble between a man and00:39:09
woman socio-economic days00:39:12
biologically who don’t live at all00:39:14
socio-economic and for that00:39:17
so that you can see what these differences are like00:39:21
manifest themselves in material production00:39:23
women were exactly 50 percent and in the Communist Party of the Soviet Union00:39:27
woman was 11 percent that is there00:39:29
where to lead then the men as soon as00:39:32
work there including such00:39:35
hard work we know at home will solve00:39:37
molder Ami and what we saw as00:39:40
lays asphalt00:39:41
it means someone with a pencil is standing in it00:39:44
time for healthy women and shovels00:39:46
they are laying out these laying out asphalt but now00:39:49
of course it's faster but now manually00:39:51
it's hard for me to be born here00:39:53
prefer non-asphalt roads00:39:55
do which are made by machine a00:39:57
let's make the bricks by hand00:39:59
spreads this thickness I work which00:40:03
replaced under capitalism poops00:40:07
in a new society when we are spoken to00:40:08
release the shift for the one that was rolled up once00:40:11
if I must say they removed it to the asphalt00:40:13
sent and then open the video again00:40:16
start warming up and00:40:18
crush and then roll up00:40:21
the machines were stacker and so on go00:40:24
the corresponding machine which indicates00:40:26
this asphalt and everything is done once or twice and no00:40:29
now they're standing there banging with hammers00:40:31
especially since we see that00:40:34
the quality is bad now and then they go00:40:36
woman and break her heels because00:40:38
these bricks are crumbling because00:40:40
what they made it from is the wrong stone00:40:43
there was a black one that had paving stones on it00:40:47
tanks can pass by and nothing will happen00:40:49
and here is the one who made the flywheel00:40:51
they didn't put in enough cement and that's why00:40:54
crumble right at the same time00:40:57
the former face of a warrior who goes to00:41:01
Smolny is where almost all of these00:41:06
the bricks crumbled, it was terrible00:41:08
after all, but you have now changed00:41:10
and so they will probably change everything00:41:12
manually, well, that's it00:41:14
What is this disclosure? This is already a movement.00:41:18
out of 5 back from communism00:41:22
which is the negation of capitalism00:41:25
what is the negation 2 and the first negation00:41:28
there was a denial of communism and it led00:41:31
k vodka big00:41:33
hour for proprietary formation00:41:36
slavery and gave for capitalism00:41:38
what are the 2 negatives, that's what you need00:41:41
to be remembered by everyone especially those who at least00:41:45
heard some basics of dialectics and at least00:41:47
Where have I seen this before?00:41:49
that there are two negatives or 1 3000:41:52
directly here directly00:41:55
was a denial of primitive communism00:41:57
there was slavery and now there was denial00:42:00
the hour on your own information has now become00:42:02
that communism that was born again on00:42:07
based on negation of private00:42:09
property00:42:10
but already enriched by everyone00:42:13
achievements of mankind throughout history00:42:15
its development I think you all00:42:17
you understand that00:42:19
and during the period of feudalism there was development and00:42:23
productive forces and sciences and arts00:42:26
there the Academy of Sciences arose at this time and00:42:29
cities were built such that00:42:32
they can’t build such beauty now00:42:34
which was in feudalism here00:42:37
capitalism cannot create why should it00:42:39
now I need money to get asked to them00:42:43
everyone needed to spend money00:42:45
had to be done beautifully because they00:42:48
I had to do it beautifully for myself00:42:49
since they died the building remained they00:42:52
made a building for centuries00:42:53
then these building beasts may be subject to00:42:56
tell people to search is used as00:42:58
public building like Tauride00:43:00
he gave the palace to one person00:43:02
Comrade Fedora00:43:03
Potemkina Catherine II and now there00:43:07
that was the Comintern congress there00:43:10
took place like at which Lenin spoke and00:43:14
like then now the assembly of the CIS countries in00:43:19
where people are sitting, how can it be00:43:21
assembly because if it's a union00:43:23
independent states, they cannot00:43:25
make no general decision because00:43:28
that the Lord is one principle if I don't00:43:29
I agree, then I don’t do it, that is, I don’t00:43:31
no state can do this00:43:34
the dream of Gorbachev who did, as it were,00:43:38
ssd constitution00:43:40
union of sovereign states but understandable00:43:43
that he couldn't finish what she00:43:44
consists of one word from what00:43:47
everyone who wants what they want decides00:43:50
because there are no common decisions in the union00:43:52
there are no sovereign states and that was00:43:54
firmly organized by Gorbachev00:43:57
fraudulent referendum in which they were drawn00:43:59
a lot of people who trusted00:44:02
this so-called general00:44:04
Secretary of the CPSU Central Committee who proposed00:44:07
answer the question you are for updated00:44:10
union of socialist00:44:13
Soviet socialist republics as00:44:16
union of sovereign states and people00:44:18
who previously sang the unbreakable union00:44:21
free republics they are sovereign they00:44:25
freely united into one00:44:26
the state voted for him00:44:29
division for sovereign and here are some00:44:33
smart guys, including all of me00:44:35
politicians and leaders of leftist parties00:44:37
they say the Soviet people published00:44:40
union no, he spoke in favor of a union of Soviet00:44:42
socialist republics as a union00:44:45
sovereign states due to destruction00:44:47
Soviet Union, dividing it into00:44:50
separate independent states00:44:51
so you want to call it CIS00:44:54
call it ssg it's the same thing it's00:44:57
synonymous with union of sovereign states and00:44:59
a union of independent states is one thing and00:45:01
the same thing is actually the Soviet Union00:45:04
destroyed by Russia under the leadership of Gregory00:45:08
Mr. Yeltsin who in the nineties00:45:10
year made a decision about what00:45:14
about what it means on Russian territory00:45:18
priority with Russian income, that is, on00:45:21
territory of Russia those laws of the Soviet00:45:25
union operates which coincides00:45:27
laws of Russia, that is, no laws00:45:29
the Soviet Union does not apply if they00:45:32
do not coincide with the laws, that is, priority00:45:34
Russia's interests reached out to her00:45:38
Belarus in a month Ukraine still a long time00:45:41
I waited and then Ukraine, but if from00:45:44
Russia Ukraine Belarus the most key00:45:48
states that created the Soviet00:45:51
in the nineties they announced that on their00:45:54
territory, union laws do not apply00:45:56
but they didn’t say so directly they said that00:45:58
here the priority of the interests of these laws00:46:01
these republics then follows the Soviet00:46:03
the union was gone and Gorbachev was already with00:46:06
characteristic of a brain with a vile desire00:46:10
deceive people and00:46:12
to tell successfully he is this00:46:14
enjoy your people with us trustingly00:46:16
as trusting as a politician cannot be00:46:18
so trusting00:46:19
they still many believe that00:46:22
our people voted for cheese00:46:23
get a newsletter online00:46:27
The Internet will immediately give you this face00:46:30
search engine here is the newsletter you are subscribed for00:46:32
union of soviet socialist00:46:33
republics as a union of sovereign states00:46:37
in which both rights and00:46:39
freedom of every person rights and freedoms00:46:42
If only we had enough housing for you00:46:44
homeless people don’t, but you have the right to housing00:46:49
maybe melon it's right in sight there is it00:46:51
more on this matter Chernyshevskaya00:46:54
great initiative was also expressed in the work00:46:56
Lenin noted that he was complaining about this00:46:59
Chernyshevsky he said that everyone has00:47:01
the right to eat on a golden platter if she has00:47:05
it is like this, it means that we are in the end00:47:09
we get this we are already there00:47:12
not only did they approach communism, but already00:47:15
say raised the issue of transformation00:47:18
back communism and in the first phase00:47:20
actors are in the opposite phase00:47:22
a trend but that’s what we have00:47:24
informal logic we have00:47:26
in the development which is the movement of the lower00:47:28
to the highest spacers complex in to the Second World War in00:47:31
There are two trends in this development00:47:33
1 coincide with the direction of development00:47:36
something called progress but a trend00:47:40
the opposite is called regression and00:47:43
if you only talk about progress and00:47:46
if you don’t see that there is regression, then you don’t00:47:51
take no action against00:47:52
reactionary regressive tendency and00:47:55
then she takes over but you understand that00:47:58
if there is a struggle and you have nothing to do00:48:00
do to counteract00:48:02
the opposite system which00:48:04
I guess I'm the trend that you00:48:06
pulls you back you will come there and we will go there00:48:08
and came back dragging around unwinding00:48:11
all this movie we came to decomposition it00:48:14
at the state casino00:48:18
Russian and came to the capitalism and00:48:22
you'll tell us everything for a long, long time, this is new00:48:24
market based socialism what is it00:48:26
real socialism beads and people00:48:29
listened to this chatter of Gorbachev while00:48:31
Yeltsin didn’t directly say what00:48:33
said this when he went to America00:48:35
united states speaking in congress00:48:38
that we defeated this00:48:41
communist idol and this one00:48:44
scoundrel criminal state balls00:48:48
here he is, after all, he was fed before this00:48:51
he was the first to carry party milk00:48:54
secretary of the Sverdlovsk regional committee later00:48:56
he was secretary of the Moscow city committee00:49:01
was a candidate member of the Politburo and then00:49:03
it turned out that in a competitive00:49:05
the fight for Gorbachev does not shine00:49:07
get to the Politburo00:49:08
he decided on another staircase for this caries00:49:11
climb up the stairs00:49:14
after all, the course of decomposition is destruction00:49:17
socialism and it is important to me that I do more00:49:19
what of this and revenge and that's why00:49:22
we can say today that we are doing well00:49:24
that there is such a Yeltsin center00:49:26
here are all the nasty things we have in00:49:29
heart say these are the crimes00:49:32
are related to the destruction of communism00:49:34
in Russia you need to collect carefully00:49:37
and take Kubaev to this center00:49:39
mine and the trash bin at home should be like this00:49:42
historical dump for everything00:49:44
associated with egg crimes00:49:47
Gorbachev's school gets that kind of money00:49:48
must be spent so that this center00:49:51
functioned and we need it all there00:49:53
collect on be sure to collect it00:49:55
visible to the memory of future generations because00:49:57
what if you go ahead and00:50:00
think that no one is bothering you and not00:50:02
opposing tendencies and listen00:50:04
fairy tales that Khrushchev told that00:50:06
if he was social he would finally win00:50:09
can win finally here you go00:50:12
on you from rise to say by00:50:15
the escalator that goes down you are going00:50:18
faster than this escalator down00:50:20
finally the grill persuaded you into00:50:22
some other Nikita Khrushchev what00:50:25
all of you have already finally risen to00:50:27
this height and you stopped and counted00:50:29
breaks little by little let's take no00:50:32
a fast escalator that moves quietly00:50:34
back you calmly went upstairs00:50:36
Well, in 15 minutes you would already be at the top00:50:38
but after a while you're through00:50:41
half an hour later you ended up downstairs like this again00:50:44
you need to understand the dialect when and nowhere00:50:46
there is no formal logic to this00:50:51
it happens that it’s final00:50:54
or class the fight has stopped class not yet00:50:58
completely destroyed destroyed only00:51:01
antagonistic classes and class struggle00:51:03
supposedly already stopped, but maybe it’s like that00:51:05
so that the class struggle will stop when00:51:09
class has not yet been completely destroyed00:51:12
there are no antagonistic classes but here00:51:14
class not antagonistic antagonism00:51:16
maybe there could be something here00:51:18
antagonism but I have influence no I don’t belong to00:51:21
to the working class and I put it at the forefront00:51:23
the interests of the working class are not yours, they are mine00:51:27
children are contrary to the interests of the worker00:51:30
class that is, if there is priority00:51:32
interests or collective farm peasantry00:51:35
or the intelligentsia this gives rise to a trend00:51:38
exactly the opposite, but if there is00:51:40
the priority of the interests of the working class is not00:51:42
because the people there are so nice00:51:45
objectively but because the working class00:51:46
objectively according to one's position00:51:49
interested in complete destruction00:51:50
classes he will then be freed00:51:52
when we won't have class divisions00:51:55
there will be no class separation when00:51:56
will occupy our free time00:51:59
more in hours than working time is00:52:03
it means who you are00:52:04
is not determined by what you do in00:52:06
the main thing during working hours is also that00:52:09
done in free time here's what00:52:13
we have to go so we listened to these00:52:16
assurances and the people ended up in Russia but00:52:18
just so trusting that I just00:52:21
You’re amazed, but what about Lenin?00:52:23
it is said that in economics and politics00:52:26
nothing can be taken at word00:52:30
need to check00:52:31
never but the one who is in economics or00:52:35
politics takes the word of that round00:52:38
I'm a fool once this one so to speak00:52:41
this when I finished reading the full one00:52:44
gathered yet hasn’t sagged completely somehow00:52:46
I didn't like it like that00:52:48
statement so to speak channel who is me00:52:50
I cut it, I was thinking how not to believe it00:52:52
people want to not believe people read00:52:55
then I get to the next one00:52:58
place here in economics or in politics00:53:00
believe the slot is a complete idiot00:53:03
Well, I already have a good crush, that’s why00:53:06
I now know that if someone does something00:53:08
says any china00:53:10
and I want to tell any story00:53:13
you need to check everything and it’s as simple as that00:53:16
things in politics in economics are not allowed00:53:19
be you ten times but now all00:53:20
advertising is based on deception00:53:23
for example, I explained it to my granddaughter like this00:53:25
Why do you think he advertises what he does?00:53:28
they advertise so good, but it's rubbish00:53:30
because no one cares about the brute00:53:33
what they won’t buy but if you advertise00:53:35
who will buy because I say you need to create00:53:39
fashion and what is fashion as Keller wrote00:53:41
from responding challenging annoying00:53:44
or as I wrote, it also hits and kills the module00:53:47
extravagance and do not like nature00:53:50
friend want to be fashionable then dress00:53:53
what is in fashion now, that is, everything in one00:53:55
and put on the same clothes, it seems00:53:57
this girl wants to be different from00:54:00
others she dresses there in those clothes00:54:02
so are all the other girls now00:54:03
I dress for the sake of it being beautiful, but it’s necessary00:54:06
everyone who produces00:54:07
skirts skirts last year they sold in00:54:11
in general, maybe they can be worn today00:54:14
maybe next year they will probably00:54:17
not for one year if the material is good00:54:19
great, you have to make a profit00:54:22
so once and again the fashion of the story is in00:54:25
boots were not so long ago such that00:54:28
it was necessary to have abrasions for bugs00:54:30
places and on the toe00:54:32
mandatory and therefore especially when00:54:34
production of them tugging and rubbing on00:54:36
such circles with at least felt so that00:54:39
then they covered it with varnish so that00:54:41
came out and you should have it like this00:54:45
all worn out and so that your jeans are USA00:54:48
were torn out00:54:49
these torn ones are much more expensive than00:54:51
nirvana and at first one might think00:54:53
what is this poor thing she doesn't even have00:54:55
6 your jeans or are they like that00:54:57
that they can't do it somehow00:55:00
do such [ __ ] no look like that00:55:03
the woman is not so beautiful here Sergei00:55:06
such a chic blouse and torn torn00:55:09
jeans with your body sticking out of them00:55:12
I remember I was at a conference00:55:17
Komsomol conference of Moscow00:55:20
district when I was a secretary at school and there00:55:23
they sang such a ditty that in the villages of00:55:29
skin peeling to show off the dress and in00:55:32
cities from Lisa's dress to show skin but00:55:37
this is already a characteristic of capitalism and00:55:39
she didn't stop just because we00:55:41
so to speak in this excursion00:55:43
which we did today in pharmacy00:55:45
settled on the society in which00:55:48
we are now living if we find ourselves in00:55:51
in capitalism the same thing lies ahead of us00:55:52
the road about which everything is written will be settled00:55:55
broadcast without giving the complete works00:55:57
this is how it is written how to make a revolution00:55:59
how to prepare a party, what to fight for if00:56:03
if you don't fight, you won't be trampled on00:56:05
you'll just live worse00:56:07
trample and oppress and you will not be with00:56:10
autumn is not easy to carry and well-fed and you are not00:56:13
you will feel like a human being00:56:15
they don’t consider you as a person and stop you00:56:18
so you need to avoid getting trampled00:56:20
act collectively that is00:56:22
remember that you are a person00:56:24
a public person and he's this one00:56:26
communist beginning he must00:56:28
support it because it is00:56:30
human beginning and this00:56:32
human nature must do the basics00:56:34
structure of the whole society as a whole00:56:37
speaking and flowing00:56:38
survive that nothing works out with00:56:40
economics why but because they are already obsolete00:56:43
it's a proprietary economy00:56:45
because everything was better with us00:56:47
Soviet Union00:56:48
faster we had a growth rate of 1 before x00:56:51
22 percent is when I read it recently00:56:55
Stalin's speeches following the first00:56:57
five-year plans00:56:58
Well, what is the current growth rate?00:57:00
This is generally terrible, but in terms of destruction00:57:03
businesses here of course here with us00:57:05
record holders00:57:06
let's say if there were 37 2000 during the war00:57:10
the enterprise lost a new knife and devastation00:57:14
then in the end this is our capitalism00:57:19
transition to capitalism 78 thousand00:57:21
enterprises, that is, this transition00:57:24
advanced formation cry promotional he00:57:27
should have produced reactionary results00:57:28
gave 78 thousand enterprises disappeared, that is00:57:32
material basis which is important00:57:34
is for the development of society according to00:57:35
granted and undermined further or no longer00:57:39
500 aircraft will pass again per year, but also 500:57:42
Only by hand can you produce cafes and00:57:44
but this is a second question, another question00:57:46
we must now understand what this is00:57:50
this is a division into formations, a division at the base00:57:53
which lies the development of productive00:57:56
forces and corresponding00:57:59
industrial relations of production00:58:00
relationships are not all the time scat type rummaged00:58:03
They don't change all the time as we go00:58:04
of course they transform all the time but here00:58:07
there are three major types of singing in total00:58:11
primitive communal communism private00:58:13
property as a formation is large and00:58:15
communism based precedes00:58:18
denial hour on your own information00:58:20
or you can count everything00:58:22
how many formations 4 primitive communal00:58:25
communism00:58:26
slavery feudalism capitalism and00:58:30
communism 55 socio-economic00:58:33
formations of everything and why communism00:58:37
infinite and eternal because negation00:58:40
denial is a statement00:58:42
negation of negation is equality with00:58:44
it was already a denial00:58:47
denial is overcome and therefore out of00:58:49
communism can only come back00:58:52
go on the way back and only here00:58:56
somewhere else here there is no yes this is a cast in00:59:01
compliance with the form of production00:59:02
social nature of man00:59:05
is a social animal of man and00:59:07
animal on the wall00:59:10
working people speaking and intelligent and00:59:13
his rationality00:59:14
must manifest itself in the fact that it must00:59:16
realize that he exists only as00:59:18
public we're all human in this00:59:20
I mean everyone should become communists00:59:23
Here's how the events pour in00:59:27
as we observe that00:59:31
is happening more and more in Russia00:59:34
attention00:59:37
thinking people are drawn to how00:59:41
the socialist society of the USSR arose00:59:45
what stages did she go through because everything00:59:49
such people are gaining more and more authority00:59:56
figures like Lenin figures and figures00:59:58
Stalin on and much of what they01:00:01
made it clearer that01:00:05
number and because even though we lost it01:00:07
wealth that was wealth01:00:11
world and world historical01:00:13
meanings but this is such wealth that01:00:17
save the meaning of this it is necessary01:00:20
Of course she won't come back on her own01:00:23
especially since she doesn’t return on her own01:00:26
it means you need to understand how01:00:28
Socialism is being created based on those01:00:32
documents that we have but also on01:00:35
those thoughts that are modern01:00:37
scientific literature01:00:39
including historical, that is, for that01:00:43
what is especially in the works of Stalin01:00:46
because only recently01:00:47
we can say that 18 houses have become available01:00:50
Stalin because when Khrushchev came01:00:54
kit01:00:55
14 15 16 then it was scattered and terminated01:01:00
publication and only thanks here first01:01:03
activities of the State University and the Russian Institute01:01:08
revolutions wars peace and revolutions and then01:01:12
thanks to titanic activity and01:01:14
comrade clubfooted former chief01:01:16
editor of the magazine communist doctor01:01:18
philosophical sciences01:01:20
Yes, this multi-volume edition appeared01:01:23
this is certainly a feat and now we can01:01:27
Let's work on Stalin to trace what happens01:01:29
actually it happened because01:01:32
he stood at the center of these events and all that01:01:35
was built was built and under it01:01:36
direct management is not01:01:38
plan that other organs worked on01:01:41
that the work of all these organs is01:01:43
moved and was carried out with01:01:46
direct management in general01:01:47
central committee of the Bolshevik party01:01:50
and Secretary General years General01:01:53
the secretary was extremely01:01:55
performance that is nothing01:01:58
left it to chance01:01:59
controlled everything and achieved movement01:02:04
at high historical speed01:02:06
which no other can compare01:02:09
the current leaders who are trying to drag01:02:12
stomp repeat or drag from a point01:02:14
from a state management perspective01:02:16
look at him here01:02:19
how is the task of transition from01:02:24
capitalism to socialism but for this01:02:28
we must first say that socialism is01:02:30
not pharmacy, although there are some in01:02:34
literature01:02:35
these gross mistakes that believe that01:02:38
socialism is one formation comonism01:02:40
other01:02:41
and even sometimes this is not expressed in01:02:45
theoretical works of socialism and01:02:47
communism as soon as you put the union and01:02:50
it turns out that these are deformations01:02:53
whether you want it or not, it's a big mistake01:02:58
the exact opposite teaching of Marx and01:03:01
Lenin about what communism is01:03:04
take a critic of the Gothic program01:03:06
Marx there the words so solid in communication are not01:03:08
present there it says that01:03:12
communism goes through two stages01:03:15
and these stages are there for a reason01:03:18
say they are declared by Marx they follow01:03:21
from the fact that there is a dialectic of development01:03:24
new formation from the old if communism01:03:28
develops from capitalism, one might say01:03:32
that the mother of communism is01:03:35
capitalism and the fact that scandals happen01:03:38
between against those who were born and who01:03:42
is matter is another question but not01:03:44
we must forget that capitalism has its time01:03:47
had its progressive meaning01:03:50
developed an attitude towards feudalism01:03:52
productive forces01:03:53
ensured the development of the proletariat one way or another01:03:57
as Mayakovsky wrote, the city robbed groups01:03:59
coffin forces lump order from machines01:04:06
thin and hunchbacked you stood up working class and01:04:09
this working class was that force01:04:13
which carried out this historic01:04:16
transition because development is in01:04:19
stories from the moment classes appeared01:04:21
through the class struggle they because01:04:24
set a goal and someone started it01:04:26
do it right what puts01:04:28
achieves goals and that great goal01:04:32
the great energy of the people that the idea01:04:35
putting on the mass becomes material01:04:37
by force but first of all it is necessary01:04:38
apply to advanced class which01:04:41
there is such a class as the worker01:04:44
class and01:04:45
transition from capitalism to communism01:04:49
communism and socialism are the lowest phase01:04:52
communism I made the working class01:04:54
difference between 1st phase and 2nd phase01:04:57
only that the first phase of this is like this01:05:00
communism which has just emerged from01:05:02
the old system in all respects bears01:05:04
an imprint of the system from which he came01:05:06
and the highest phase is communism that lived01:05:10
these prints and therefore in01:05:12
whose contradictions were associated with01:05:15
Rodion spots have already disappeared, all that remains is01:05:17
the struggle of the new with the old which is01:05:19
eternal condition of any development if01:05:23
there is a struggle between the new and the old, which means there is01:05:25
the struggle of the old with the new and if there is01:05:28
the fight between the old and the new is possible01:05:29
reversal and all this reasoning01:05:31
that they say we won’t delay the path forward, but it01:05:35
but historically, let’s not distance it, but this01:05:37
may concern hundreds of years in one01:05:40
side or hundreds of years01:05:41
moving in the other direction therefore01:05:43
say you shouldn't engage in a hat01:05:45
throw a leaf at you in relation to01:05:47
historical question and this is how01:05:50
However, everything that can be done is still being done01:05:52
tell me how it went01:05:55
transition from capitalism to the first lower01:05:59
database Communism, by the way, Stalin has a speech01:06:03
dedicated in the constitution of '36 as01:06:07
once again it is said directly that we built01:06:12
the first phase of communism is not and often it01:06:17
spoke, but he spoke very precisely here and01:06:19
very clear in a very important meeting01:06:21
also the Supreme Council you are in question with how01:06:26
I repeated once about what we built01:06:30
Phase 1 of humanism we put this underlined01:06:33
and emphasized in the same speech that01:06:34
our state is a state01:06:36
dictatorship of the proletariat from this that01:06:40
it follows that only the dictatorship of the beater then01:06:43
can build the first phase of humanism01:06:45
although we know that only a dictatorship01:06:47
the drug can hold socialism if01:06:51
refuses this at the stage of sucking01:06:53
it goes back to capital and if01:06:56
at the stage of transition to capitalism and01:07:00
communism someone leaves a dick the01:07:02
trooper is if the party and state with01:07:04
you don’t fight with them, you don’t understand them01:07:07
means there is no transition and it happens01:07:11
so there is a working class which01:07:14
established his dictatorship and this worker01:07:17
the class must create from above what it is for01:07:20
this should be done step one step 1 s01:07:23
point of view of building economic01:07:27
basics a new society seemed necessary01:07:30
to nationalize the prices, so take it01:07:32
make public own funds01:07:35
production public property01:07:36
necessary in terms of content or form in form01:07:39
very easy to see hang01:07:41
case taken away from the capitalists and seeing01:07:44
hang Soviet property01:07:45
state public property and01:07:47
so on that they are something at the very beginning01:07:51
when the working class still does not know how01:07:53
he only takes control of the state01:07:55
took power taking power he controls where01:08:00
in the state and in general everyone who governs01:08:02
well, how was the capitalist economy01:08:04
so she remains when we have passed01:08:07
finalization01:08:09
in January '18 for Toris to fall01:08:12
happened before January 18 before January01:08:15
18 workers' control was ensured01:08:20
what is worker control? does it mean01:08:22
that workers can control any01:08:25
processes they are allowed at all enterprises01:08:27
these are future leaders who are authorized01:08:30
these enterprises but these future ones01:08:33
managers should not interfere in01:08:35
what administrative functions01:08:37
capitalists because you have to between01:08:40
other things01:08:41
carry out the construction of socialism01:08:43
stop the economy because01:08:44
what if the people are hungry rosettes we01:08:47
once there he will fight with you as with01:08:50
enemies therefore, in no case01:08:53
destruction cannot be allowed01:08:56
economies that exist no matter what01:08:58
if only she had a bourgeois eye01:09:00
so about when it ended01:09:03
civil war or not which01:09:06
meant that we were leading a certain01:09:08
limitation01:09:09
that you can have up to 3 workers who is this01:09:14
this means all the big capital is already01:09:17
withdrawn from the economy small01:09:21
that is, up to 3 workers please01:09:23
maintain functioning no one to you01:09:26
does not prohibit but nowhere in their power01:09:29
Of course you won’t go during the transition period01:09:32
when the dictatorship of the proletariat is established01:09:34
and so the first thing to do is01:09:38
worker control worker control01:09:40
allows you to prepare those people who01:09:44
will take over the management function01:09:46
production01:09:47
that she said to drive away the capitalists too01:09:49
look blank it's easy to do01:09:53
management and economics in public01:09:55
interests it is difficult it follows that01:09:59
carried there is no need to nationalize everything01:10:04
why what are you01:10:06
time said we nationalize from01:10:08
We just can’t swallow it, no need01:10:11
too much price for the prince01:10:13
largest enterprise01:10:15
it is necessary to analyze which one actually01:10:17
speaking and forms the basis of socialism01:10:19
the basis of socialism is large01:10:22
machine industry which prepared01:10:25
capitalism has prepared everything for01:10:27
take socialism and make it public01:10:29
what does public property mean?01:10:31
property we have different interests01:10:34
we have workers there is a petty bourgeoisie01:10:37
so we have capitalists in the villages and01:10:41
the largest capitalist class of this01:10:43
varnishes01:10:44
biggest huge class in01:10:47
the village is developing capitalism throughout01:10:49
and in the city we need to start building01:10:54
public property01:10:57
nationalization nationalize more often01:11:00
largest enterprises like these01:11:03
which are not counted there01:11:05
three to four workers for whom they are looking for01:11:07
well, hundreds or at least01:11:10
dozens of people have been nationalized01:11:13
what do we get then state01:11:16
some property sector01:11:19
state a social communism is01:11:22
on what public nitrogen do you distinguish01:11:25
comrades of state property01:11:26
socially it's the same thing no01:11:29
and the same state this machine violence in01:11:32
interests of the advanced class public01:11:34
property is in public01:11:36
interests but01:11:37
and who embodies these social01:11:38
interests working class why because01:11:41
most complete consistently01:11:43
interested in implementation say01:11:46
forward movement most complete subsequent01:11:49
on interested therefore his interests01:11:51
are public and carrying out01:11:54
you improve the interests of the working class01:11:57
position of all other classes and layers01:11:59
I don’t understand working people at all01:12:02
exploiters therefore state01:12:06
property begins to form as01:12:09
it was just nationalized01:12:11
begins to form in two forms01:12:15
state property is that01:12:17
the share of state-owned enterprises is narrow01:12:20
very part that begins to be controlled01:12:23
workers by workers for party members and01:12:27
working class in the interests of the working class01:12:29
class it's called communist01:12:32
way of life it is small at first and then01:12:35
calculation due to what due to this01:12:37
this big way of life01:12:40
state property01:12:41
and the rest of the state01:12:44
property represents the state01:12:45
capitalist way of life why is it state01:12:49
capitalist is state01:12:50
property but01:12:51
Well, since you haven’t directed the activity yet01:12:54
public interest enterprise01:12:56
it means you have property like them01:12:58
public and which state01:13:02
what's left are state-owned and then what?01:13:05
these enterprises01:13:06
they are isolated01:13:09
individual enterprises working for their own01:13:12
fear and risk as usual01:13:13
capitalist enterprises but what01:13:16
the difference we will fight is that before01:13:18
surplus value went to the capitalists01:13:22
hotel added value01:13:23
goes to the state of the working class and what01:13:29
produce and what was produced before01:13:30
your manufacturer where to get raw materials from01:13:32
where you chose it from before, then take it from there01:13:35
where to send and where did you go first01:13:37
sent there and send but still01:13:38
nothing has changed in this world but01:13:41
what has changed is that this01:13:44
a state-owned enterprise after all01:13:45
profit goes to the state they are the capitalist01:13:50
but you can take it and install it for yourself01:13:53
any salary once it’s like01:13:55
enterprise they play whatever they01:13:56
private without already being private01:14:00
tell me to include this in this salary01:14:03
income01:14:04
that this income exceeds much01:14:07
the salary of the average worker and in fact01:14:10
in fact, there is still surplus value there01:14:12
someone didn't understand how it was in01:14:14
transition period look at growth01:14:16
oil or Gazprom or Sberbank there01:14:21
let's say supervisory advice gentlemen01:14:23
receives up to 30 million per month members01:14:26
supervisory councils per month, let’s say01:14:30
if you take a miner's salary01:14:32
probably more difficult work than01:14:34
there is no miner so besides that01:14:37
the miner gets it all in surplus01:14:40
price therefore, of these 30 million, 50 thousand01:14:44
manager's salary01:14:46
the rest is added value, well01:14:48
hidden under the guise of salary01:14:50
the same can be said about scrum01:14:53
Sberbank has 24 million members01:14:57
of the governing body receives per month01:15:00
what will they take from all these people for?01:15:03
they take old women and keep their money in this01:15:06
jar and give them growth, that is, give them01:15:09
one another the third is allowed to grow and in01:15:11
As a result, they get richer01:15:14
without producing anything, I'm not even talking about01:15:19
the fact that our industry does not01:15:21
wait until they get 2 percent01:15:23
give something they can use for01:15:29
in order to increase the pace01:15:31
economic growth accumulation do01:15:34
because these two percent01:15:36
commercial banks will increase their01:15:38
seven would be 9a the highest rate01:15:42
Our profit is no more than ten01:15:44
so if it's like this 1:06 we01:15:47
downgraded but what difference does it make to understand01:15:48
or there is no continuous function if you01:15:51
lowered to 6 and the same thing to five then01:15:54
the same yes 4 the same yes 3 inside +01:15:57
7 this will be 10 this is the border01:15:59
and only when you pass this year01:16:02
in America as the United States we are01:16:04
you look up to them in general and even then01:16:06
he slid the bank in general just acts01:16:08
in the interests of the United States of America01:16:10
such01:16:11
make two percent and you'll get this01:16:14
this picture, that is, this one01:16:17
the sector is called state capitalism, this is it01:16:20
sector from which gradually01:16:22
the communist way of life is the same company01:16:24
state actually drips01:16:26
annexes annexes clarifies01:16:28
states and this is what happened to01:16:32
1918 to 1936 it was gradual01:16:37
exhaustion of the state capitalist sector with01:16:41
one side the other side because01:16:43
it was sector exhaustion01:16:45
state capitalism and development01:16:46
socialist although state01:16:49
sector which operated in01:16:51
public interest where01:16:53
state property was01:16:54
a social form that has become01:16:57
take place01:16:58
it began to happen that these small01:17:00
private property including01:17:01
capitalist property when you01:17:04
had up to three employees it fell apart01:17:06
and yes yes completed the NEP policy and01:17:08
some understand the NEP policy as01:17:11
content of party politics in general01:17:14
transitional this is not content this is01:17:15
permission that is, who allowed allowed01:17:19
because he can’t cope yet01:17:21
state property is not01:17:23
provides everything necessary01:17:25
our say further than the population and01:17:29
industry is different that's why01:17:31
you need to leave this small one for now01:17:34
production let her bye01:17:35
functions as you01:17:38
resort to the hands of the appropriate01:17:41
branches of the economy this sector too01:17:43
is exhausted and therefore has not been exhausted01:17:47
state capitalism it is so01:17:50
say this sector has slammed shut01:17:51
since all enterprises are the same01:17:54
the plan began to function in 28 and01:17:58
the five-year plan was 1 out of 28 years throughout the NRP01:18:02
ended not because someone01:18:05
I was closing it and that’s it, so to speak, no01:18:08
there is no need to carry this around and01:18:10
problems because there was no retreat01:18:12
basically let's go back01:18:14
and according to the principle, let's allow in these01:18:16
within01:18:17
we have not yet gained strength as soon as01:18:19
gained strength competed with large01:18:22
state industry by these01:18:24
small private own but how are you01:18:26
do you think who will win, of course01:18:28
large state industry01:18:30
won what struggle in the economic01:18:32
struggle and not a political struggle at all01:18:34
political struggle is ahead and ahead01:18:36
she was now in farming01:18:39
it means that the public has won in the cities01:18:44
ownership of the means of production01:18:46
urban01:18:47
and what about agriculture?01:18:51
the picture was what happened behind it01:18:52
time at this time especially after01:18:55
land reform after01:18:56
land ownership was divided into and according to01:18:59
eaters, well, what should have started if01:19:02
you are there a commodity economy of violence01:19:04
it means things were about to get rough01:19:07
the development of capitalism and this is rapid01:19:09
the development of capitalism began with01:19:10
seventeenth year and before01:19:14
collectivization, Stalin explained that01:19:18
there are people who needed to start01:19:20
collectivization before but you can’t01:19:22
start collectivization earlier because01:19:25
start collectivization it competes with01:19:28
fist01:19:29
the hearth you can compete with the fist you01:19:32
connect the poor who have nothing01:19:35
and if the kulaks have a cult01:19:39
in fact they have tartar machines01:19:41
they have technology they have these01:19:44
certain wealth they can influence01:19:47
for organs and can combine purchases they01:19:49
can there is for myself I and so on therefore01:19:52
to refer to agriculture01:19:56
you need to be very prepared for this, but how?01:19:59
may appear first you need to create01:20:00
state farms01:20:01
rural hayato these state01:20:03
enterprises01:20:04
the way of life of a state enterprise was worn01:20:07
here they are also included in the socialist01:20:09
the way of life, although already in agriculture, is01:20:11
this is not included here01:20:13
or in the communist way and so it will be01:20:16
that's exactly what I called land01:20:18
I'm communist first01:20:19
taught when political economy like this01:20:21
called the socialist way of life and then01:20:26
I once re-read Lenin's article01:20:29
economics and politics in the era of dictatorship01:20:30
in a row and didn’t find a socialist there01:20:33
I teach the way of the match and here is the tile01:20:35
us socialism when01:20:37
but without the mask sign and indeed01:20:39
what kind of socialist to such a person01:20:40
from which is to whom does not mean general in01:20:43
common interests01:20:44
therefore from the communist contribution to01:20:46
state farms this already amounts to01:20:49
communist way of life01:20:50
in villages than state farms they01:20:53
spread widely they are less01:20:55
produced a share of products but they01:20:58
developed and all the possibilities01:21:00
were from the state if they already started01:21:02
tractors, some machines appear and01:21:05
so on, first of all to state farms01:21:07
and in state farms there are political departments about01:21:09
state farms means the working class will begin01:21:11
the village already has a working class, which means01:21:13
there is technology and this one is already a rat01:21:16
they can be viewed as in01:21:18
Soviet although everything works and this is Nicole01:21:21
kornati its already a fist he is like that01:21:23
the alternative that is on paper is like this01:21:25
the alternative is to go to state farm and01:21:26
look how the combines work there01:21:29
Tractors work there, how do they work there?01:21:31
people how they work there seeders winnowers01:21:34
mills and so on and then say here01:21:38
Salin specifically explained while we didn’t have01:21:41
there were 200 thousand tractors01:21:44
no force no collectivization01:21:48
there was no question because01:21:50
that you connect the poor, they won’t be able to01:21:53
compete with the fist and the fist is already01:21:56
'twenty-eight could do without01:21:58
in order to hand over the grain, the fist decided that01:22:01
enough of this, hurry up and mess around with this one01:22:04
authorities and we need to stop selling grain01:22:07
and at least turned us around in that sense01:22:11
what he bought what he needed by handing over selling01:22:14
industrial crops but grain did not01:22:16
hand over this currency and by grain01:22:19
the country will die and therefore this is what we can do01:22:22
note that there was Stalin's trip to01:22:25
Siberia where he showed how to01:22:26
harvest grain under these conditions01:22:30
said it means what's happening now we01:22:33
how the batch is delivered01:22:36
refuse in such conditions anything we01:22:38
let's go towards the poor or we'll go01:22:42
to the side of the fists if we go now01:22:45
he no longer wants to meet the fist01:22:49
ask he demands to increase the price and01:22:52
the poor have already given us grain at those prices01:22:56
which the state has established means01:23:00
We pay the poor people little for grain and01:23:04
fists demands my pay a lot01:23:08
start who's party is this01:23:11
kulak state we are on this road01:23:14
let's not go, who is the authority to know violence?01:23:18
fists for whom the middle peasants follow01:23:22
fists so we have to force01:23:26
how to force kulaks to hand over bread01:23:30
they want it and demand a price increase01:23:33
it means they want to speculate on01:23:35
compared to how poor we are01:23:37
the consignment01:23:38
the poor of the proletariat we must01:23:42
consider this as speculation so01:23:46
it is necessary to apply the law of speculation and01:23:48
Stalin went, his trip was known01:23:51
twenty-eighth year in Siberia01:23:54
stocking up on bread and salin from there01:23:57
relations01:23:58
drinks the look, here I am preparing bread, here I am01:24:02
I find out it turns out thinking why01:24:05
conclusion do not apply this article about01:24:07
speculation and she talked to the judges01:24:10
judges and01:24:14
prosecutors01:24:15
live in the houses of all the kulaks at the kulaks01:24:18
why do you live in the houses of the kulaks?01:24:22
because they are cleaner and better fed01:24:27
here you slide but since Stalin was01:24:30
representative of the working class after all01:24:33
they fists Stalin demanded a shield01:24:36
application of measures to speculators who are cool01:24:41
so to speak, we turned the situation around and01:24:43
forced kulaks to hand over bread who didn't01:24:46
published bread he went to chickens in01:24:50
a prison made of fists, who is it, what is it01:24:53
this is the proposal of the revolution01:24:55
just don’t forget that when01:24:58
cities solved the problem of building01:25:00
socialism and capitalism developed here01:25:03
and a large class was created, the largest01:25:06
class by quantity is quantity01:25:09
the bourgeoisie was the biggest01:25:11
Well, in Russia, can you imagine how many of these01:25:13
fists therefore means without fighting it01:25:16
the most merciless class01:25:19
no construction of socialism01:25:21
logos speech who did not perform01:25:23
demands of the working class and interfered01:25:27
public policy means them01:25:30
subjected01:25:32
repression, that is, they suppressed what01:25:36
should do what should the state do to suppress01:25:38
your opponents but if you don't01:25:41
suppress your opponents opponents01:25:44
they'll suppress their eyes, well now it's easy for us01:25:47
says here we are now01:25:50
Soviet but01:25:51
in the former Soviet Union people stopped01:25:54
suppress opponents of socialism and01:25:57
castle supporter of capitalism hour01:25:59
suppress against those who are for socialism01:26:03
this is what Comrade Stalin got01:26:05
not like that01:26:06
so that you can carry it like that01:26:08
make sure the fists win so01:26:12
weaving such a thing did not exist and could not exist in01:26:14
That's why01:26:15
it means they put pegs on your fists01:26:17
you give up the ultimatum or go to jail for01:26:20
speculation in height and speculation in the fist01:26:23
I started to get up and when I started to give up my fist01:26:25
bread01:26:26
Well, whoever didn’t turn himself in went to jail01:26:27
it's clear who01:26:30
and when it started to make a fist, it became01:26:32
pass and the middle peasants when I pass the hall01:26:34
the middle peasants then the poor peasant realized that it was his01:26:37
party what his party didn't do so01:26:40
the poor man gave away his bread cheaply at night01:26:43
here's to the kulaks and the middle peasants01:26:45
and will be worn at a different price, here is Stalin01:26:48
says we will not party days of fists01:26:50
not the middle peasants, we will start the party01:26:52
poor people and this operation was done01:26:55
and then only and still says steel01:27:02
we do this in order to fly, this is only01:27:06
surprise attack board they are certain01:27:09
there was a discovery01:27:10
decisions when we collectively zira it01:27:13
it became clear that all the questions had already become01:27:15
edge01:27:16
either we will now create collective farms or we01:27:19
slide the beast in my before01:27:22
state of constant war with fists01:27:24
war and real civil war and such01:27:27
case means but we can say that01:27:31
our wise guidance at this time is all01:27:34
spent time working on creating my own01:27:36
tractor industry and01:27:37
industry to create01:27:40
relevant types of equipment and people01:27:43
and weilok all the mechanical barons and so on01:27:51
then there is everything and here is the trail of rural01:27:55
dreams and techniques were on stream and by the time01:27:59
by the year twenty-eight we already had01:28:02
200 thousand tractors and now it’s already01:28:07
now the picture was like this being created01:28:11
collective farms01:28:12
but the state should not be added either01:28:15
they sent 25 thousand there just to call01:28:18
workers + worker on state farms plus there01:28:21
departments hurt and organization begins01:28:25
collective farms and to every collective farmer who01:28:28
went to this collective farm he was released from01:28:31
all the debts that ever existed and01:28:34
which were related to the fact that he01:28:36
to carry was tied there with varnishes at least01:28:39
throw all sorts of extortions to everyone and he01:28:41
depended he was freed from everyone and from01:28:44
taxes for several years in advance and immediately01:28:49
as soon as the collective farm was formed and you01:28:52
soon provided with equipment but no01:28:56
transferring it into ownership because01:28:58
if you give them all of this01:29:00
it will not be state property01:29:02
will not be public property01:29:03
that’s why the collective farm didn’t hand over tractors01:29:06
and created a system of machine and tractor01:29:09
stations that ensured the implementation01:29:12
everyone01:29:14
agricultural work based01:29:17
the nature of the payment and you will pay here01:29:19
products at fixed prices01:29:21
state and this means that01:29:24
the activities of collective farms were subordinated01:29:26
public interests and collective farms with01:29:30
this received significant development in01:29:34
yield significant relief Katya01:29:36
all agricultural work and the best01:29:39
equipped with equipment than the kulaks01:29:41
how you want people and how to invite them to01:29:46
collective farms can only be called one01:29:48
by the way these are people practically if you are here01:29:50
will be better than the services of fists than01:29:53
to work for the kulaks they will come here and they01:29:55
let's go here and therefore with Olga what to eat01:29:57
we should have had such hot heads before01:29:59
started there was nothing to start before01:30:01
we did not have a tractor01:30:03
industry until we created the system01:30:06
machine and tractor stations while we are not01:30:09
made such a situation immediately land in01:30:12
state property01:30:13
now tractors and machines are owned01:30:16
we have states like collective farmers01:30:19
some say they have a collective farm there01:30:21
their property is collective farm property01:30:22
the property was on course01:30:25
for sheep and goats01:30:28
fixed assets for cows and pigs01:30:32
production was in the hands of the state01:30:33
so the picture you depict is here01:30:36
there was cooperative ownership01:30:38
collective farm and here state01:30:40
property is nothing like that01:30:41
state property was on01:30:42
the most important agricultural implements01:30:44
the end of the village at the most important place on earth is01:30:48
means of production and all equipment01:30:50
this is what concerns some01:30:54
small items of means of production01:30:56
it was all owned by collective farms01:30:58
therefore, it was not the collective farms that had the equipment01:31:00
states01:31:01
if anyone who doesn't understand this doesn't understand01:31:03
What did Khrushchev do? He handed over the powder and took it.01:31:06
destroyed this system by tractor machine01:31:09
sanctions and this system allowed01:31:11
direct the activities of collective farms in01:31:13
public interests need to01:31:14
organize public property01:31:16
so that it is a systematic submission not01:31:18
only urban production but also01:31:21
agricultural production01:31:22
rural production with a common interest01:31:24
interest of the working class where it comes from01:31:26
after all, the interests of the working class are01:31:29
public then it's socialism if you01:31:31
you can't do this it's transitional01:31:33
period and that's when the whole economy was01:31:37
submitted in different forms here01:31:40
the state form is valid01:31:42
to operatively collective farm uniform with the help01:31:46
state ownership of land and01:31:49
directly to the decisive means of production01:31:51
they say it themselves01:31:52
collective farms ownership of decisive01:31:54
did not have means of production and do not need them01:31:58
it was necessary to give them in this way01:32:02
we got two forms of what 201:32:06
public property as sometimes01:32:08
you can read it here, take it from the textbook01:32:10
almost everywhere here is a race where they talk about01:32:13
this transitional period was supposedly01:32:15
state parentheses nationwide a and01:32:18
cooperative collective farm property01:32:19
or 2 socialist properties that01:32:23
this is such a socialist01:32:24
property I don't know there is01:32:27
public property if you have01:32:29
property is public after all01:32:31
socialism is your social01:32:32
there is no property, that is, property01:32:35
society but in what form can it be01:32:39
in the form of systematic subordination01:32:41
subordination of production to public01:32:43
interests then this is socialism and if01:32:46
you are a separate state01:32:47
property and separately operational01:32:49
you have collective farm property 201:32:50
property from up to two properties to01:32:52
there can be no socialism there must be01:32:55
be a property with one common wall01:32:56
why and because this is inferior communism01:32:59
phase communism means that everything should01:33:01
obey society01:33:03
they are so this is this and this is that this01:33:06
state and it’s not clear what from01:33:10
because you have cooperatives01:33:11
cooperative ownership is not01:33:13
public property and if we are 1001:33:15
let's connect to the cooperative will be cooperative01:33:18
socialism in quotes as in Yugoslavia01:33:20
built vegas catch socialism no01:33:22
could build no because the bottom is not01:33:24
socialism is created from individual01:33:28
Lenin spoke about cooperatives but already01:33:30
in relation to state01:33:31
property that01:33:34
is not the greatest distortion01:33:39
basic principles of Soviet power and complete01:33:43
rejection of socialism01:33:46
is the legitimation direct or indirect01:33:51
legalization of workers' property01:33:53
separate factory for their special01:33:55
production01:33:56
the greatest distortion of the fundamental principles01:33:59
socialism and complete rejection01:34:01
socialism is such a legalization01:34:03
therefore no about any cooperative01:34:06
there can be no speech from the middle and therefore01:34:08
we know what the first cooperatives will say01:34:10
who showed us01:34:11
under the guise that we will have01:34:13
press cooperatives with alleys01:34:14
which was promoted by the common fund recently01:34:18
it’s almost impossible to carry it here again01:34:19
we celebrated and it just started01:34:21
destruction of socialist01:34:23
public property is already direct01:34:24
when under the guise of a cooperative they created01:34:27
cooperatives in which there were a01:34:29
owners members of the cooperative and b01:34:32
workers, that is, workers, that’s all, but01:34:37
it was so transparently visible to us01:34:39
his time at the institute for promotion01:34:41
our university qualifications01:34:43
Department of Political Economy conducted01:34:45
corresponding television program01:34:47
we were economists there01:34:50
spent with Professor Smirnov and this01:34:52
was recorded on channel two or01:34:54
city television but in the hall there was01:34:57
Sobchak with his lawyers, all lawyers01:34:59
there were, but this is the most cooperative01:35:01
sign and all economists unanimously01:35:04
they said it would be capitalist01:35:06
property in its purest form and so that01:35:08
it is clear to a more or less competent economist01:35:10
that this is the real thing01:35:12
capitalist enterprise only under01:35:14
another name would be a cooperative01:35:16
this means that any shareholder on01:35:18
general that the cooperative and the shareholder read01:35:21
that a worker who works and is hired01:35:23
employees of this cooperative, what does this mean?01:35:25
he will stop this joint stock01:35:27
society to be capitalist in short01:35:31
saying this is the task01:35:33
this work solved the problem01:35:36
socialist state under01:35:38
leadership of the communist party and01:35:40
in twenty-eight we no longer had01:35:44
just like that Kaplan and general drinks01:35:47
type of program as a plan for Guyler01:35:49
we had directive planning then01:35:52
there is subordination of everything social01:35:54
production in different forms01:35:58
public economic interests then01:36:00
with the interest of the working class and this01:36:03
this is the subordination of everything socially01:36:05
production by the interests of the working class and01:36:06
meant that the transition period from01:36:09
capitalism to communism01:36:11
over the top Sean of course if people say01:36:16
would be literate enough and01:36:18
educated they would understand that01:36:20
further movement is already a transition from01:36:23
incomplete humanism to complete one01:36:25
developed humanism their developed alone01:36:28
ripe kumarit suit white they so01:36:31
Now we have won completely and finally01:36:34
you won, we are very glad where are they01:36:37
in what wars, including class ones01:36:39
wars and where things can finally be01:36:40
if someone is inclined to talk like that01:36:43
starting from what you saw finally he01:36:46
lays a very small mark on the fact that01:36:48
but if it’s final but why are you there like that01:36:50
say avoid trying to work01:36:52
especially since you thought they would convince01:36:54
finally the shark keys which01:36:56
disconnected01:36:57
how they were separated from hired workers01:37:00
they shouldn't have been left here01:37:02
class is the most hostile socialism if you01:37:04
build socialism over it was class01:37:06
liquidate how to liquidate it01:37:08
eliminates as a class no way people people01:37:11
no need to liquidate cool given01:37:13
loan how to liquidate take away opportunities01:37:14
exploits, that is, they took these fists01:37:17
and transported them within themselves and gave them land01:37:19
further opportunities to build your own houses there01:37:21
and develop with your labor, you say01:37:23
that these are helpful owners, well, you are helpful01:37:26
the owners will build there appropriate01:37:28
production and will be fine themselves01:37:31
work without operation and that steel01:37:33
make fists of the shark and begin to arrive01:37:35
only an acquaintance can return01:37:38
carry and shore those who entered the collective farms but01:37:41
there are also01:37:42
the cuts were buried and they began to kill01:37:44
rural workers and rip open the stomach and01:37:47
teacher, watch the movie01:37:50
script by Natalya Ivanova01:37:51
after all, father and son are just father and son01:37:55
son is looking for him01:37:57
the fist who killed then01:38:00
the chairman of the village council says force like this01:38:03
dealt with the teacher and finally01:38:07
he was found in the floodplains and now he is being held at prices01:38:10
at gunpoint and holding and batting this is a tale about01:38:15
flowers afraid to kill father shoot them01:38:21
they didn't spare us, a shot rang out01:38:24
that is, the revolution is just more01:38:28
bloody revolution01:38:31
took place in the village at the moment01:38:35
collectivization therefore01:38:38
with fists carried out the most merciless01:38:41
fight if it weren't for this it would have collapsed01:38:44
socialism is a food issue01:38:46
and this is also an issue in agriculture01:38:48
no question about nutrition01:38:49
social could not be01:38:51
Well, what are you saying directly to 201:38:53
foundations on a socialist city and01:38:56
capitalist village for a long time01:38:58
Soviet power cannot resist01:39:00
so our watch then01:39:02
to say protected and it’s not just that01:39:05
what we have to run in 10 years01:39:06
that path that other countries have gone through01:39:09
we have to in terms of construction01:39:11
socialism don't stretch it out01:39:12
pleasure when we have a hostile01:39:15
public sector which01:39:17
carrying food in his hands01:39:19
food can be deprived of this too01:39:22
food people and tried this one01:39:24
kulak twenty-eighth year01:39:26
this is how it is in our country01:39:30
the transition period has ended and such01:39:34
countries like China Vietnam Korea they this01:39:38
experience is taken into account and a country like Poland01:39:41
declared in the person of her Polish woman there01:39:46
united workers party that we01:39:47
Therefore, we won’t create zero as a team01:39:49
if we sucked it was built and01:39:53
then the restoration came to capitalism there01:39:55
socialism was never built it was01:39:58
built in Czechoslovakia01:39:59
it was built by the Hungarians, Bulgaria and01:40:01
Romania but never in Poland01:40:04
socialism, they are still angry01:40:06
are hissing about saying our side in01:40:09
particularly because they didn't do that01:40:11
you should have done people who01:40:14
they were going to build respectability01:40:16
did what Trevor logic did in general01:40:19
revolutionary struggle interests of the worker01:40:21
class of the Polish labor movement here01:40:24
such a picture, these are the conclusions that can be drawn01:40:27
based on how the story went01:40:32
building socialism in the USSR01:40:34
that's when we're already in the second five-year plan01:40:36
the pace of development was already rapid, but 2201:40:41
percent01:40:42
people like that don’t delve into the background of what01:40:44
now we're talking like01:40:46
increase growth rates 2 by one and a half01:40:48
percent 22 percent these are the rates01:40:51
there were such growths at that time there was a crisis01:40:54
in the West01:40:55
that is, this was of gigantic importance01:40:59
example of a socialist because01:41:01
surpassed the head but even now China01:41:04
there are 400 million billion01:41:06
has six percent and has no equal01:41:09
in the global economy01:41:11
so there is no crisis01:41:14
global crisis no crisis in01:41:15
Vietnam and was not in Korea was not in01:41:17
Laos wasn't maybe on the back it was01:41:20
crisis and only on and Russia helped and01:41:22
It seems like the crisis has been overcome01:41:24
The country is not that big and you can help01:41:26
as for the other part of the world where01:41:30
domination and capital is still there01:41:32
of course the crisis is behind this picture01:41:35
it is very important to realize who01:41:37
I want to say I want to make sure of this I want to give01:41:40
take one piece of advice, read essays01:41:43
Comrade Stalin and you will come to those01:41:45
the conclusions that I presented to you because01:41:48
I put them together under the impression of Obama01:41:50
this one I read because I01:41:52
it seemed like there was too much blame01:41:55
It's time to read this man01:41:58
let’s even say from the point of view that01:42:00
nothing so abstract01:42:03
jurisprudence if you accuse someone01:42:06
so figure out what he was doing first01:42:09
this is the greatest merit01:42:13
Comrade Stalin Communist Party01:42:15
working class of Russia who01:42:17
carried out for the first time in the world in such a small way01:42:20
the peasant side widely01:42:22
in which there were more peasants than01:42:25
they protected construction workers01:42:27
socialism and made it classic and01:42:30
exactly the same against this background01:42:32
you can clearly see what the enemies did01:42:35
socialism is not this is what01:42:36
it was going to be what was being built they became01:42:39
it's to destroy and get capitalism from01:42:45
we had a revolution in the USSR and01:42:50
to understand how it went and01:42:53
what started to happen and how we are doing01:42:55
capitalism must be restored for01:42:57
this is to understand how socialism is created01:43:01
began to understand how salt is created01:43:03
then it’s clear how to destroy it01:43:07
the main condition for01:43:09
socialism remained a dictatorship01:43:12
proletariat01:43:13
you can immediately tell if there is a dictatorship on the guitar01:43:16
otherwise it will be destroyed; socialism will not survive01:43:21
if it is also destroyed formally01:43:26
tell the program01:43:30
then this means that it has already been destroyed in01:43:34
In many ways, in practice this means that it goes01:43:38
say about got so say for01:43:39
revolution that you need one more drop01:43:42
one drop write to the program01:43:44
that no more dictatorship is needed01:43:46
pretend who can write this in01:43:48
program01:43:49
which class which class can write01:43:52
that the dictatorship of a patriot is in the program01:43:54
the party doesn't need it can write01:43:57
only a fool salt zma01:43:59
well, some people think where from01:44:01
where do these enemies come from but01:44:05
We have already answered this question01:44:07
we talked about the contradictions between socialism and01:44:09
connected by each contradiction01:44:11
opposite trends here are 5 of them01:44:14
contradictions01:44:15
there is a general movement of communism and01:44:18
opposite trend movement01:44:19
capitalism if you don't fight against01:44:22
the opposite trend is01:44:24
the opposite tendency wins and01:44:27
there is no state or01:44:29
some kind of nationwide if you have01:44:31
the state is not a dictatorship of the proletariat01:44:34
it becomes a bourgeois state and01:44:37
the one who didn't say even more about the deer01:44:40
understands that there must be either a dictatorship01:44:42
bourgeoisie or dictatorship of the proletariat then01:44:44
either a hopeless idiot or politically01:44:47
so illiterate that he is not only01:44:50
let into the podium and garden at the meeting01:44:52
it's a shame when we have a dictatorship01:44:55
was destroyed I think that comrades01:44:57
who understand a lot about this01:45:00
question they study, they understand what else01:45:06
long before we were cleared01:45:09
dictatorship portraits from the program have already been01:45:12
and socialist actions have been committed01:45:14
and not anti-socialist01:45:16
little things and big things01:45:17
firstly firstly among the peasants and among01:45:27
Stalin had supporters to see off or01:45:29
it's his business what should have been done01:45:32
opponents of socialism they should have01:45:35
intimidate the supporter you will pave over01:45:39
opportunities and show them what if they01:45:41
someone will advocate a continuation then01:45:43
lines that carried out a party under01:45:46
Stalin's leadership will destroy him01:45:48
That's the point of murder, I think01:45:51
I understand that a person who01:45:54
carried out a nuclear and missile program01:45:57
program the person who worked01:46:00
relevant authorities01:46:02
Well, there's no way he could be the one01:46:05
he was first killed by an English spy and01:46:07
then they organized some kind of court benefit01:46:11
let's say murder was its purpose01:46:14
prevent and oppose01:46:17
Khrushchev as a traitor in general matters01:46:21
working class and traitor hide01:46:23
this is simply treason to the cause of the working class01:46:26
something like this01:46:27
exotic thing or is it real01:46:30
we should have expected maybe with us01:46:32
comrades drag around blinded by success01:46:35
Soviet power and the victory of socialism and01:46:37
victory in the war01:46:39
exhausted may be such efforts01:46:41
which had to be carried out for01:46:44
in order to maintain and strengthen01:46:46
Soviet power, socialism cannot01:46:49
this is how you say it, you don’t think01:46:50
came but in the fourteenth year01:46:52
what happened throughout Europe everything01:46:55
socialist countries in which there were01:46:58
quite the workers' party who answered01:47:01
principles of workers' parties01:47:03
all these socialist parties when01:47:06
such a turn has begun or it is necessary01:47:08
vote against war loans as01:47:11
decided at the second congress01:47:14
communist international which01:47:17
Marx and Engels was also founded01:47:19
or you need to vote for the military01:47:21
loans and go to the government and what we01:47:23
we saw and we saw that almost everyone is a leader01:47:29
socialist parties overnight01:47:31
changed01:47:32
cause of the working class and went to01:47:34
bourgeois governments the choice was this01:47:36
or you go bourgeois government01:47:38
do you raise your hand against the military01:47:40
credits as raised by her German01:47:45
Social Democrat Karl Liebknecht01:47:48
so you raised your hand and sent him to prison01:47:50
as if raising your hands means you're going to01:47:53
prison and tell who else rule salvia01:47:56
all our deputies are Bolsheviks in the Duma01:47:59
everyone really raised their hand and went to01:48:01
fresh air siberia01:48:03
and what did our dear democrats do?01:48:07
we need cultural Europe cultural Europe01:48:10
educated Europe is a cultural Europe01:48:13
in the person of the leaders of the socialist01:48:15
parties voted for war credits01:48:16
staged a world battle and all these01:48:20
which they tell us and Europe is there01:48:21
energy and socialism in Sweden is social there01:48:25
there is simply no such inequality01:48:28
which United States of America are there01:48:30
or in England but there is a surplus01:48:32
value there is capitalism and they01:48:34
say these capitalists understand intelligently01:48:36
what is this socialist for?01:48:38
revolution is not so to speak01:48:39
makes sure that the level and unite are not01:48:42
so high that it wouldn't happen01:48:44
start of protests against capitalism01:48:46
more what happened about this here01:48:49
you can pay attention to the fact that01:48:53
happened with to narrow to narrow he was01:48:57
theorist Lenin says that his former01:49:00
theoretical works here are books01:49:01
proletarian revolution renegade Kautsky01:49:03
you can study them, read them because01:49:09
something Kautsky would represent01:49:11
after these events he even actually01:49:13
from the word dictatorship pirates did not01:49:15
he simply refused to refuse01:49:17
essentially, that is, study it works01:49:21
tick while he was a Marxist and01:49:23
on the contrary, he is shown to have become a renegade and01:49:25
traitors to Marxism odd nothing there01:49:27
started studying01:49:29
this is the situation so nothing like that01:49:33
especially new in our Soviet Union01:49:36
did not happen in other socialist01:49:38
countries it was already that is, if01:49:41
person nearby if not organized01:49:43
accordingly dictatorship01:49:47
helicopter for this what is needed for this01:49:49
that Soviet device was very important01:49:53
which Lenin founded in his time01:49:55
and from which they hastened to free themselves01:49:57
in '36 because advice01:50:02
on the one hand, they were preserved because01:50:03
it was impossible to go up anywhere but01:50:07
if you were not nominated01:50:10
a deputy in some labor collective01:50:12
no one could nominate except labor01:50:15
team01:50:16
so it's such an important role01:50:18
labor collectives upon nomination01:50:20
deputies at any level01:50:22
was preserved but was no longer chosen according to01:50:26
factory team according to territorial01:50:29
districts and, in addition, there was no longer01:50:33
two-stage system when chosen01:50:35
council deputies, these deputies sent01:50:38
delegates to the Congress of Soviets and even when01:50:42
there was such a system, there is such a thing01:50:46
twenty-seventh year due to the provisions of01:50:49
elections of deputies01:50:51
it corresponds to the principle of election01:50:55
deputies for factories and plants as01:50:57
it was written in the party program01:50:58
Party programs were in effect with us until 6101:51:02
year in which it was recorded01:51:03
main electoral unit and01:51:06
the main unit of the state is not01:51:17
constituency01:51:20
and the plant is not territorial electoral01:51:22
Urka plant factory01:51:24
and here and here01:51:32
due to the fact that this happened01:51:35
changes before it happened01:51:40
the change in the situation was already like this01:51:42
the point is that from the city council level01:51:45
you can direct the roost to treat that01:51:48
who was elected in some factory01:51:50
team this means such people appeared01:51:53
people are important and needed to the top01:51:56
could go there and nickname them01:51:59
recall and when everything switched to 101:52:03
step system, that is, straight to the top01:52:05
direct elections of the rector this year is real01:52:07
democracy in choice is not01:52:09
real democracy of its own if direct01:52:11
elections you can't revoke the main thing01:52:13
democratic principles is01:52:15
wrong election01:52:20
review frame here if different people are the same01:52:23
talk a lot, do little, others do a lot01:52:26
do little say you elected people01:52:29
maybe I told you little and then you01:52:30
we saw that he was a very good worker and01:52:32
you need to bet01:52:33
and the other one spoke a lot beautifully01:52:36
deputy and continued to chat and nothing01:52:38
don't do what will pour it call like a01:52:40
the review was very easy01:52:42
enterprise conference is going on01:52:44
who elected him they are allocated ducks and01:52:48
elected Muratsan elected him she recalled01:52:51
that is, if the people cannot, the working people01:52:54
the working class cannot recall01:52:56
then there is no proletarian democracy here in01:52:59
in this sense, no, and she began to rub and01:53:02
people made their way up there not the most01:53:06
dedicated to the working class and apparatus01:53:08
started to get more and more clogged and01:53:10
it turned out that there was a lot there01:53:12
Well, at least the cowards that we'll say01:53:16
against this attack con first01:53:18
tion that started the hook they didn't01:53:21
spoke01:53:22
this is what started to happen and at the same time01:53:25
committed the next 10 namely already in01:53:33
1957 no yes fifty seven01:53:49
the position was changed to say01:53:56
management of the entire economy01:54:00
was governed by our council government01:54:04
ministers01:54:05
through the industry management system were01:54:08
line ministries all overnight01:54:11
line ministries were destroyed01:54:16
All01:54:18
and control returned to the level01:54:22
income what is this what does it mean01:54:25
the management that is associated with01:54:28
technological progress and science and01:54:31
technology has all disappeared, so what?01:54:35
concerns these same economic councils, but they01:54:39
some local issues could be resolved01:54:41
unity of the economy that is required for01:54:43
ensuring public property01:54:45
disappeared01:54:49
that's what happened besides that means01:54:54
shortly after 1956 after the twentieth01:55:01
the congress was suddenly already destroyed01:55:08
the brainchild that Stalin cherished this system01:55:11
machine-tractor stations which01:55:14
ensured production subordination01:55:16
public interest means01:55:20
overnight a doctor alone as with01:55:23
by decree forced all collective farms01:55:26
buy this very equipment, all these workers01:55:30
who were there and they provided01:55:32
dictatorship in a row in the village they were01:55:35
forced to go to the city they are there anymore01:55:38
it seems that the equipment was not needed, it was transferred01:55:41
collective farm and collective farms have no play area01:55:43
the mechanical repair base was not this01:55:46
technology essentially began to disappear01:55:48
say from two combines and two01:55:49
tractors were made alone and this led to01:55:52
destruction of the system01:55:54
agricultural subordination01:55:56
production to society, that is, destroyed01:55:59
second side means first side01:56:02
the first country was destroyed01:56:04
production in cities and the second in01:56:07
villages this was still around 195601:56:13
of the year01:56:14
the destruction of ministries began even before01:56:18
'56 and this distortion continued01:56:22
and the destruction of machine and tractor01:56:24
stations in fifty-seven01:56:27
researcher at already sixty-first01:56:30
production subordination system01:56:32
the public interest was primarily01:56:35
destroyed but that didn't mean it wasn't there yet01:56:38
socialism on but since it was still01:56:40
written in as a dictatorship demand01:56:43
proletariat and generally based on this01:56:45
the requirements needed to fix all this01:56:48
change all this and this is how to say01:56:49
it would go without saying, well then01:56:51
suddenly it is announced at the congress that this is not01:56:54
we must do that Stalin won completely01:56:58
finally and working class he01:57:00
voluntarily agreed that01:57:04
Victor is cursed, that is, so boorish01:57:06
one might say the Jesuit expression was01:57:08
First Secretary's speech programs01:57:11
Khrushchev who is a traitor01:57:14
grandfathers to the cause of socialism and the enemy01:57:16
socialism number 1 from this time01:57:20
economic reform was already being prepared01:57:23
although in fact it was not economic01:57:25
reform of the already economic country currency01:57:28
which was that everything01:57:30
enterprises are not tasks to fix01:57:34
ensuring public interests and01:57:36
its task and treatment cost and price01:57:39
these products that are produced01:57:41
therefore in 196101:57:45
everyone after in the party program01:57:48
generally folk was recorded01:57:50
state place dictatorship pt row a01:57:52
it means that our state01:57:54
has become the opposite state01:57:58
some comrades not understanding what01:58:01
she stood up then the state but if she01:58:03
the opposite of the dictatorship of the proletariat01:58:04
which is the opposite01:58:06
dictatorship of the proletariat01:58:10
the opposite of dictatorship01:58:11
the proletariat is a dictatorship01:58:14
the bourgeoisie asks where the bourgeoisie is01:58:16
what did you get when did you get it01:58:19
the state is not a dictatorship of the proletariat01:58:21
it turns out that you are not01:58:25
can you prove that01:58:26
state property is01:58:27
social form because01:58:29
the state in whose interests to leave as01:58:32
you understand from01:58:33
tell them we say that in general people01:58:35
there are no such public interests if01:58:38
which apparatus will consider this national?01:58:40
interests he can act on them01:58:42
there is some kind of class criterion that has disappeared01:58:45
therefore, the interests of the whole people mean01:58:48
not in the interests of the working class and just not01:58:50
in the interests of the working class01:58:52
means measures are being taken01:58:54
contrary to the interests of the working class01:58:56
interests are opposite01:58:58
the interests of the working class in the interests01:59:00
bourgeoisie and what we got right away01:59:04
as soon as the state changed and01:59:07
became bourgeois, we succeeded right away01:59:10
that this is the device01:59:12
exempt worker and economic01:59:15
party and some others are all on her01:59:18
subordination of production by interest01:59:20
the working class began to be subjugated01:59:22
production by some other and not01:59:25
interest of the working eye what is01:59:27
the opposite interests of the worker01:59:29
class and dictatorship of the workers dictatorship01:59:31
bourgeoisie therefore some yes when how01:59:34
how capitalism came to socialism01:59:37
it just wasn’t there anymore, it wasn’t socialism anymore01:59:40
if you have a non-working state01:59:43
class and therefore property01:59:46
state not public you01:59:48
do you understand that it's government01:59:49
property is not public at all no01:59:52
neither before nor after this is one thing01:59:55
states another society01:59:56
if you have state property01:59:57
not working class states01:59:59
causes the production of public02:00:01
interests means others and this means others02:00:04
no interest in the working class02:00:05
the opposite, but it’s not immediately02:00:08
carry it as you know how it happens02:00:10
the ship is sailing, so it must leave02:00:13
from the pier he is still quietly then from everything02:00:16
further and further and further02:00:19
there is also a state monopoly02:00:21
the government of the people has already been destroyed02:00:23
farming both in the city and in the countryside, well02:00:27
further destroy it and this task02:00:29
prepared even under Khrushchev to carry it02:00:32
with a friend02:00:35
Lieberman economic reform in02:00:39
which was to change everything02:00:42
production figures for02:00:44
what were the opposite indicators02:00:46
labor productivity02:00:47
this is the main indicator of development02:00:49
production and this02:00:50
nomenclature of whether the creation of needs02:00:52
and this is the volume of sales, that is02:01:00
remove nomenclature02:01:01
and remove cost reduction and02:01:04
replace everything with three indicators02:01:07
cost sales volume profit and02:01:11
profitability all these problems are solved02:01:14
by increasing these indicators02:01:16
with the help of price increases it means it started02:01:20
a trend towards higher prices and02:01:22
its most striking manifestation was02:01:27
what was done before the reform itself02:01:30
still in Khrushchev's sixty-second year02:01:33
30 percent increased meat prices02:01:36
milk and eggs02:01:38
a campaign took place at the same time02:01:41
to reduce prices and weave therefore02:01:45
workers of Novocherkassk opposed02:01:48
like other workers, however, they were this02:01:51
dissatisfied and here he is02:01:53
showed state power and how02:01:55
dictatorship of the bourgeoisie02:01:56
even more like a fascist dictatorship then02:01:58
that she shot the workers and those who02:02:01
organized this performance and their02:02:04
shot as the instigator and as02:02:07
sometimes our press writes bourgeois02:02:09
they say they were there, they were there02:02:11
criminal and that who did not you affect02:02:13
at least touched someone with a finger, wants to maybe02:02:15
to be hit by someone or something02:02:17
the workers were mutilated, no, but they were shot02:02:20
True, there was an attempt to use tanks02:02:24
against the workers but the commander of this tank02:02:26
columns of a military general who fought02:02:31
Great Patriotic War I said02:02:33
I received this order, I'm ready for it02:02:36
execute but I don't see the enemy02:02:38
so I won't do everything and02:02:41
no use of this narrow slit02:02:45
tanks against the workers did not take place but02:02:48
nevertheless, the workers were shot at this02:02:51
edification of those about those who will be from02:02:53
the device will perform how to save a02:02:55
who will speak on behalf of the workers02:02:57
it will be like with the workers of Novocherkassk you02:02:59
want to hide you were shot and02:03:02
so that your children are left without fathers02:03:06
as things were set, that is, it began02:03:07
the real dictatorship in the city02:03:10
next next what happened start02:03:13
government sector02:03:14
he is no longer associated with the cooperative on02:03:16
collective farm because machine and tractor02:03:18
no stations means cooperative02:03:20
the collective farm sector began to crumble into02:03:22
individual private farms which02:03:24
quite definitely and quickly became02:03:27
turn into tourist02:03:29
enterprises and managers of these02:03:30
enterprises became capitalists in02:03:33
public sector is not the case here02:03:36
how did you turn out to be a state again02:03:38
capitalist way because this02:03:40
single monopoly and enterprise02:03:43
gradually freed with the help of this02:03:46
economic reform from systematic02:03:48
submission with at least some interest02:03:50
united, that is, the movement went in02:03:54
reactionary even towards02:03:57
capitalism has a place big big02:03:59
monopole let it mean bourgeois02:04:02
turned out to be separate enterprises that02:04:04
swam in such a market sea and this02:04:07
everything was destroyed until the 90s and02:04:10
in the end it turned out that this one02:04:13
government sector02:04:15
contained and now it contains more02:04:17
half of gdp is produced in02:04:20
public sector, that is, as it were02:04:22
the state monopoly remained but02:04:24
it's no longer a monopoly I don't have02:04:26
systematic introduction of capitalist02:04:28
farms02:04:29
but there are separate enterprises in it02:04:31
who line their pockets under the guise02:04:34
under the guise of salary and there is02:04:39
enterprise which02:04:44
which are states but02:04:47
a significant portion of the shares belongs to02:04:50
owners02:04:51
so to the managers of these enterprises they02:04:53
are in this sense02:04:54
and formally capitalists, that is, they02:04:57
three people perform02:04:59
or 2 they first appear as02:05:02
managers now they are02:05:04
receives money from managers under the guise of salary02:05:07
surplus value is obtained02:05:08
hidden capitalists and they also02:05:10
receive dividends, that is, they are open and02:05:13
capitalists and this is all in the state02:05:15
sector what’s good about being in the government sector?02:05:17
capitalists because you won't be eaten02:05:20
foreign capital but those who02:05:23
floats beyond state boundaries02:05:25
sectors and individual ones to carry as you throw them02:05:27
big billionaires they take risks and how02:05:30
Our practice has shown that they take risks02:05:32
fall into the clutches of already international02:05:35
monopolies when they went abroad02:05:36
ginger so we are arresting your capital and02:05:41
that's when you prove that you're sad02:05:44
we got it there legally02:05:46
we'll return it, we're not just taking it away02:05:48
arrest forever why forever a02:05:51
because there is no way to prove it02:05:53
we all know what happens here02:05:55
this was announced to me for all capitals that02:05:58
this together this means02:06:02
exemption from liability02:06:04
criminals for non-rehabilitative02:06:06
circumstances that is circumstances02:06:09
there is no rehabilitation, that is02:06:10
there was a crime but no punishment for it02:06:12
that's all you did something02:06:14
violated02:06:15
well, you are not punished to name it yourself02:06:17
carry therefore everyone knows this abroad02:06:20
that's why our people float it out there but the test02:06:24
lecturers float away and others want02:06:27
in one pile to be it to say together02:06:30
exist at the same time it has, as it were,02:06:33
private shop from another country they02:06:35
support each other and like this02:06:37
exists in droves, which means we have what02:06:40
sector we have a voice02:06:41
capitalist sector and we have02:06:44
sector from capitalist to rural02:06:46
economy in simply capitalist02:06:48
agriculture and we have private02:06:50
capitalists were obtained already in the 90s02:06:52
by privatizing what it is02:06:55
privatization didn't solve anything02:06:57
she privatization made separate02:06:59
capitalists and the aggregate to the pedals02:07:01
traces as Lenin said collective02:07:03
capitalists have within02:07:04
public sector so to speak02:07:06
what we have we already have small-scale goods02:07:09
squirrel commodity sector also has it all02:07:11
time people like you see all the time02:07:14
strived to create this small business02:07:16
small business then petty bourgeois who02:07:19
thinks about how to become real02:07:20
capitalists this is the body of a chicken which02:07:22
they want to let them flap their wings02:07:24
fly in and one chicken of some kind on02:07:26
some kind of perch02:07:27
and the bulk will fly in, then the soup will come02:07:31
because big capital if it02:07:34
he destroys capitalism02:07:35
small rusts young very plant or02:07:38
vice versa02:07:39
let's say in other countries now in02:07:41
developed capitalist02:07:43
petty bourgeois sector involved02:07:46
such large programs because it02:07:49
is built into the ordering system02:07:52
another thing is that we don’t have that, we don’t have that.02:07:54
thinks it's something from a small business02:07:57
will create and we must always support it for02:07:59
capitalism that needs to be supported is behind02:08:00
and I am writing this which is more02:08:03
progressive large capital or small02:08:05
It is clear to the bourgeoisie that big capital is in02:08:08
economically, that is02:08:10
today we have what sectors02:08:11
public industrial sector02:08:14
private and economic capitalism in02:08:18
city and hour for business02:08:19
capitalism in the patriarchal village02:08:22
We have virtually no farming02:08:24
there is a petty bourgeois sector both in the city and02:08:26
the village will have so that we02:08:28
came back, this means that02:08:32
the revolution reached us first02:08:35
level02:08:36
politically, that is, a dictatorship arose02:08:39
bourgeoisie02:08:40
1 2 express and implement all these02:08:43
transformation02:08:44
and the bourgeoisie appeared in our country as soon as02:08:47
only you removed the bathory dictatorship otherwise02:08:49
as I said, I’m sure what you don’t understand02:08:52
there must be either a dictatorship p3 or else02:08:54
dictatorship of the bourgeoisie02:08:55
either he's a hopeless idiot or02:08:57
so politically illiterate that02:08:59
its not only for three years and the meeting02:09:02
letting my son in is what it used to be02:09:05
was called a party economic asset02:09:07
turned02:09:09
collective bourgeois and this collective02:09:11
the bourgeoisie is partially divided partially02:09:14
people stood out from it and among us02:09:16
in the nineties it was already common02:09:18
socialism and it began to destroy our02:09:21
economy and solve this problem which02:09:24
tries to the current government02:09:25
decide to somehow increase the birth rate02:09:27
and our birth rate immediately dropped02:09:29
down and mortality went up and02:09:33
This cross of Russia appeared earlier in02:09:37
we had the birth rate up and the death rate02:09:41
down and now they crossed paths and02:09:43
mortality rate still exceeds in the nineties02:09:46
years and no such pitiful measures to02:09:49
there is no support for maternity capital02:09:51
they won't solve the problem because02:09:53
carry is connected with our device02:09:56
economics this is the picture of what I mean02:09:59
I wanted to let you know how it went02:10:02
transition period from socialism to02:10:06
capitalism began in 1961 and02:10:09
ended in ninety-one 3002:10:14
years and here is the transition period from02:10:16
capitalism to socialism thanks in part to02:10:20
including the colossal efforts of the party and02:10:22
direct comrade Stalin02:10:24
The federal period ended in 1802:10:27
years, that is, there was socialism after all02:10:30
solidly and built and they broke it very much02:10:32
it will take a long time to break down those enterprises now02:10:35
which have long been no longer socialist but02:10:38
these little people came who they are02:10:40
can't get along with a big guy02:10:42
truly high-tech02:10:44
production only talks about02:10:46
artificial intelligence and they02:10:47
there will be no ordinary intelligence02:10:51
celebrate another anniversary of02:10:54
birth on her already deceased doctor02:10:59
Economic Doctor of Philosophy02:11:01
Honored Worker of Russian Science02:11:03
Federation Vasily Koshchei lime it which02:11:07
and drag was a bright star on02:11:10
firmament of our social science02:11:13
which02:11:14
firstly, he was the most brilliant and02:11:17
original and secondly was a man02:11:20
the brave are not afraid, then his father-in-law02:11:23
no matter how much against this truth02:11:25
performed and he completely turned over02:11:28
our idea of what02:11:30
political economy are progressive02:11:32
we are like penny-pinchers, as we are used to02:11:36
capitalism02:11:37
save save on mo in small things02:11:40
save in every single02:11:42
production and it seemed to us if02:11:45
that you didn't understand what we came to02:11:47
socialism although in our practice02:11:50
the thirties it was already present02:11:52
tribute is important how much you spend on02:11:55
some thing, otherwise it’s important what kind of savings02:11:58
you will get labor for the whole society once02:12:01
we consider it national economic02:12:03
efficiency from its consumption but here02:12:06
for example, everyone will agree that the plane02:12:09
costs more than a bicycle 002:12:13
First of all, the bike will be a bit far02:12:15
get to London and secondly02:12:18
but you have to go there through there is02:12:22
now the tunnel and you can do a lot of great02:12:25
there to travel by land, in short, but for02:12:27
you will save, but can you imagine how much02:12:31
the ruin of these planes is necessary Ira02:12:33
Droma it is necessary to teach pilots this is necessary02:12:37
the mechanic should keep it from the factory which02:12:40
would build this requirement on the material02:12:42
don’t build it even though you were the first02:12:45
airplanes, including wooden ones, yes, but you02:12:48
you can't do anything now, you02:12:49
do you understand what speeds and what02:12:52
requirements for that is, here they are modern02:12:54
we need composite materials that do not02:12:55
we have everything02:12:56
country of production not because we are not02:12:58
we can but because we have all already become02:13:00
look for those traitors with a light hand02:13:02
buy socialism abroad if02:13:04
let's buy there and then we will02:13:06
just order from some warehouse and from where02:13:11
extracts to carry his natural02:13:12
fossils and we will get everything02:13:14
and we can't do anything02:13:16
we can't influence anything02:13:18
of course make a plane in this sense02:13:20
seems really unprofitable02:13:22
savings colossal colossal for02:13:25
in order to get you in, of course02:13:28
what are the speeds that a tackle gives02:13:30
rocket to laughter rocket space02:13:32
technology, especially where the most open02:13:36
wide field under socialism02:13:38
it opens why I won earlier02:13:42
this is also a space competition02:13:44
socialism is another matter, what then02:13:46
lost but he lost connection with the transition02:13:48
capitalism but because if we have02:13:52
single property then to be the most02:13:54
a large global company that can02:13:57
produce the most expensive things and the most02:14:00
They are expensive to produce and from a point of view02:14:03
in terms of labor savings in consumption02:14:06
the most profitable, that is, it must be considered02:14:10
How did you produce some kind of product?02:14:14
production02:14:15
how much savings will she give?02:14:19
consumers la and now be considered02:14:22
how much will it save when will it be02:14:25
two of these with three four five in folk02:14:28
his economy then demolish entire industries02:14:29
this way you will get savings02:14:35
national economic02:14:36
and what needs to be subtracted from it must be subtracted02:14:38
production costs must be deducted02:14:41
There are also operating costs02:14:43
current repairs02:14:44
or one major overhaul is needed02:14:46
assume and that's all because if already02:14:48
one major repair was done by 2 beams02:14:50
no need to do it, let's get a new one, that is02:14:52
must be counted02:14:54
national economic economy naranja02:14:56
clearly the savings do not come from principle02:14:59
we are very effective and yours02:15:01
the machine is a very effective device there02:15:05
very efficient tractor or bulldozer02:15:10
but if he is alone, imagine this02:15:13
that you put it in central Africa02:15:15
there he somewhere in the lines is murmuring a question or not02:15:18
the question is how many there will be02:15:21
yes if you just multiply them02:15:23
do a lot then you get more02:15:26
hole to be on savings minus02:15:29
costs from production to maintenance02:15:33
and for repairs during service02:15:35
and during the lifespan here is the main one02:15:39
indicator that is, national economic02:15:41
saving labor, this is what you need02:15:44
proclaim this must be done and to02:15:46
even with capitalism it attracts affairs02:15:49
because the bigger they save everything02:15:52
monopoly it already takes the monopoly is not in02:15:54
within some small02:15:55
enterprise or even large02:15:57
enterprises, it takes savings within02:16:00
volume's entire monopoly on the field sometimes02:16:02
seize not only territory and02:16:05
carry a significant number of citizens02:16:09
and the population of a given country but also02:16:11
several other countries and probably you02:16:13
Can you imagine that our modern ones are there?02:16:16
means practically I'm a nerve02:16:19
it is made with labor and even though it is very02:16:21
many workers from different countries02:16:24
there is a monopoly on already shows us02:16:26
there is no monopoly within02:16:28
divisions at the enterprise if there and02:16:30
there are prices at which one enterprise02:16:32
these are just transfer prices02:16:34
called this autumn of this is not there02:16:35
exchange is cooperation monopoly so02:16:38
operation cooperation02:16:39
By definition, Mars is this shape02:16:42
labor in which many persons systematically02:16:44
works in one or connected with each other02:16:48
production processes or other02:16:51
where Mars said what is it about02:16:54
management that all sorts of things directly02:16:56
Is joint work social?02:16:59
carried out in a fairly large02:17:00
scale needs management that02:17:06
carries out communication and dual work and02:17:08
performs the functions arising from02:17:11
not the entire production of the body in02:17:13
in general, we must not forget that if speech02:17:15
it's about monopoly and or we are the field02:17:18
addressed to the benefit of all the people and this is02:17:21
and there is socialism by definition02:17:23
single capitalist monopoly but02:17:26
for the benefit of the whole people02:17:28
would mean socialism and so would monopolies02:17:31
that's how it wins, that's how socialism won02:17:33
Of course Stalin was the largest monopoly02:17:34
so I won against everyone and here I am02:17:38
national economic monopole should02:17:41
calculate national economic savings02:17:43
labor minus the labor that went into02:17:47
production of this product02:17:49
directly public02:17:51
and under capitalism and under capitalism02:17:54
on the contrary, labor for production is saved02:17:57
this product that is exchanged with02:18:00
others, that is, not here and02:18:02
this peoples and clearly saves here02:18:04
the one who made the path saves02:18:06
does the count count?02:18:09
savings02:18:10
which goes about and was called introduced02:18:13
maybe on the contrary we spend more than02:18:16
We used to spend all three of us standing there02:18:18
larger factories from us02:18:21
built in the 20s and 30s, the twenties were the most02:18:24
built large factories in the world so that they02:18:27
Well, of course there were more costs alone02:18:29
savings from these factories who will become02:18:31
began to be produced en masse when02:18:33
we began to produce more than 20002:18:36
thousands of tractors a year, of course you can02:18:39
carry out collectivization revolution in02:18:41
village if you can't produce02:18:43
then you can't do anything and that's why02:18:45
there will be no tree revolution there02:18:48
capitalism will develop and flourish02:18:51
fists and poverty at the other pole02:18:54
so either you take the costs into minus02:19:00
this is in the consumer at the cost level02:19:01
economy directly public02:19:03
or02:19:04
but through costs expressed in02:19:06
cost output fineness and02:19:08
do you exist, it's capitalist02:19:10
the measure is the opposite here02:19:12
capitalism and socialism themselves and02:19:14
manifests itself under capitalism02:19:16
cost is the main thing and therefore from how much02:19:19
the more the cost the more02:19:22
wealth02:19:23
in your hands and here the more nor02:19:28
being on savings, it doesn’t matter what it is02:19:31
what do you have there for that you are pure savings02:19:33
the more net national economic02:19:36
saving the richer society to society02:19:38
and they think we take all the savings otherwise02:19:41
use of this machine02:19:43
this primarily applies to the means02:19:45
production and subtract the costs for it02:19:48
production at a minus, we take costs and02:19:50
the cost of her dexterity maintenance in02:19:54
during operation02:19:55
this is the approach these are the criteria02:19:58
efficiency of means of production02:20:01
who developed them we take this02:20:04
the same performance criteria in relation to02:20:06
we prepare for people and improve their skills02:20:07
than school, university and so on special02:20:11
Coal technician on courses can be considered that02:20:14
here comes one worker's place02:20:16
different but higher qualified02:20:18
the general meaning of his qualifications is that he02:20:21
can provide in alliance with those02:20:23
progressive means of production02:20:25
great labor savings but for you02:20:28
you have to expend energy02:20:30
spend so much on promotion02:20:32
beds and end let's save the fight02:20:34
I have been training in them for five years as a specialist02:20:36
both bachelors are four years old02:20:38
damn dropouts and what if you02:20:40
make a half-educated person, then you are not an expert02:20:42
can provide savings02:20:44
national economics so here is a specialist02:20:46
gives the people economic savings but02:20:49
you need to deduct the costs of preparing this02:20:51
specialist, that is, his salary is there02:20:53
teachers, equipment specialists including02:20:56
number of machines that will not be for02:20:58
production to teach02:21:00
specialists to use them is all in02:21:03
minus and plus02:21:05
only the savings you get02:21:07
from what you add to new funds02:21:11
production of a new person who what02:21:15
more qualified i.e. increase02:21:17
qualifications as your criterion too02:21:20
has a net labor saving from this02:21:23
there is still one more area left for advancement02:21:26
production of consumer goods02:21:28
no, what to do with the criterion but if02:21:30
now in the capitalist world the common thing is02:21:34
more to hide the volume of trade turnover than02:21:36
the more profit the better02:21:38
profit and profit how to make it, well, how to02:21:40
make take from the oil real you02:21:42
replace coconut oil with palm oil02:21:45
shi is that something else we need to take oil for?02:21:48
throw away the cocoa and put it from there02:21:50
just cocoa powder in aglaya candies02:21:53
throw it away for meat, it's fatty to push soy02:21:56
push bone meal at push casino02:21:59
potash starch but you never know what02:22:03
usually you can still make sausages02:22:05
moreover, we have a means that02:22:07
allows you to color02:22:09
fragrant this sausage is another thing02:22:12
it will of course be worse in quality and02:22:14
worse and worse how to be here is not an easy criterion02:22:18
solved means the criteria by which02:22:22
then evaluate the enterprise by production02:22:24
consumer goods this is savings02:22:30
labor for consumers from use and02:22:34
this subject, that is, you have moved from02:22:36
one item with the same02:22:39
consumer qualities of legs are more02:22:41
cheap endpapers this will be expressed in the fact that02:22:48
there are savings, but these savings can02:22:50
be divided in half one part02:22:53
savings02:22:54
the one who produces02:22:56
use to improve02:22:59
the situation of the workers themselves02:23:01
enterprise the second part it is02:23:05
national economic but roughly speaking02:23:07
if prices for something have decreased, what are you talking about?02:23:09
you can buy this at a reduced price02:23:14
buy another one additionally yourself or02:23:16
on the contrary, you drag to use this02:23:18
saving to work less02:23:20
and get more time that is if02:23:24
there is a line of price reduction then you thereby02:23:28
as little as possible02:23:29
go to work don't go to work02:23:31
don't go to work overtime02:23:33
on Saturdays and Sundays02:23:35
don't lie about extra work but02:23:37
on the contrary, follow the line of contraction02:23:41
working day, that is, the criterion for02:23:44
enterprises producing these items02:23:46
phenomenon is the amount of price reduction but these02:23:51
The enterprise also produces new02:23:52
products about which you will not say that02:23:55
the price is reduced or increased that is02:23:58
therefore this criterion only applies02:24:00
to those products that have already been produced02:24:03
so that for manufactured products02:24:06
criteria for price reductions, here's the more02:24:07
reduced the price02:24:08
the more you and Katya02:24:12
should be encouraged as an enterprise02:24:14
socialist but so to speak one thing02:24:17
it leaves such as one can say02:24:20
the backlash, that is, can be reduced more02:24:22
can you use some of the reductions?02:24:25
you just need to encourage yourself02:24:28
workers, can we give this society02:24:30
let society encourage and it’s good if02:24:32
society will encourage, say, if you02:24:34
gave a billion savings to society, well02:24:38
take yourself 100 million it's good02:24:41
to lose from this, that is, it is not necessary02:24:44
afraid to carry enrichment02:24:47
worker must be afraid of exploitation02:24:50
enrichment then why be afraid but let it be02:24:52
people if people are rich under socialism02:24:54
these are the people who gave a lot for02:24:56
society and since they gave a lot for02:24:58
society here you can on them02:25:00
look at these people so between02:25:02
it was different if the person was winning02:25:03
started something outstanding did for02:25:06
countries and now a person will mature02:25:08
a fancy car started by a bandit or02:25:12
the life of someone like this bandit02:25:15
or some official about whom02:25:18
it is known that he has a lot of stuff02:25:20
real estate02:25:21
and there are also promotions that don’t take place02:25:24
through which advertisements when are they announced?02:25:28
what is going to be carried is analyzed before02:25:31
elections which sleeves are property02:25:33
no one asks how much someone has02:25:35
what kind of bags does the car ask for sex?02:25:38
land property and apartment a02:25:40
if I have three factories02:25:41
but it doesn’t show up in the questionnaire like this02:25:45
that is, I’m advertising an indicator for02:25:48
enterprises producing items02:25:50
consumption amount price reduction for02:25:52
for manufactured products from those that02:25:56
has already been produced and the new one will come from02:25:58
next year under the same criteria02:26:00
until she comes here that's all02:26:03
we have three criteria for the enterprise02:26:05
producing the people's means of production02:26:07
being on saves the steering wheel from them02:26:09
use02:26:10
we need to find out how much we saved02:26:12
and give us back some of those savings.02:26:14
constantly you have to get how you02:26:16
you know how it is with writers who02:26:19
they wrote then the fee goes and goes and02:26:21
so the enterprise owes stupidity02:26:23
regression of production, that's where the savings are02:26:26
it turned out to be 10 percent please02:26:28
here I also use Verta 10 more02:26:32
you feel sorry for these ten percent02:26:35
percent that how great it won’t be02:26:37
rich residents should not feel sorry for02:26:39
These people give 90 percent of their soul02:26:41
come on, you've become richer, you feel bad if you02:26:44
they will recover richer if you02:26:47
get richer you shouldn't02:26:49
should be good you should on them02:26:51
equal others are those who raise02:26:53
their qualifications if they are from this02:26:55
advanced training provides enormous02:26:57
effect, well then these are for those who increase02:27:00
qualifications to encourage them so that they02:27:03
let him benefit from it too02:27:04
national economic effect and result02:27:07
some kind but they are taller02:27:08
welfare and finally people who02:27:12
reduce prices and thereby ensure02:27:15
immediate improvement02:27:17
blessings from customers you read02:27:19
the smartphone was charged for bread for so much02:27:23
cheat rubles and now it’s much less02:27:25
Well done, otherwise we get the opposite02:27:28
Grandfather came and got this money from him02:27:32
wrapped will be everything counts no02:27:34
grandpa this is not enough, okay I02:27:37
I went to buy a machine, it’s clear that02:27:40
Grandfather already although one of the bread is no longer02:27:42
can buy your bread has now grown02:27:44
more than he can02:27:46
buy that is the third is02:27:49
purchase of consumer goods when02:27:52
criterion for the enterprise's activity02:27:54
is the amount of price reduction for02:27:56
the products they produce are like this02:28:00
say this in the shortest summary02:28:03
consumer theories cost theory02:28:06
development of socialism02:28:08
steve professor film his basil02:28:11
Yakovlevich which he developed02:28:13
together with Victor running debts but I02:28:16
joined them in due time and in02:28:18
participated in a number of joint books02:28:21
including choosing a new course at a publishing house02:28:24
thought ninety-one ninety02:28:28
year and02:28:29
lessons and prospects for socialism in Russia02:28:31
the future belongs to the labor society but I'm honest02:28:34
I will say that my task was here rather02:28:37
propaganda in the sense that I02:28:39
tried or tried to express this02:28:42
theory02:28:43
more briefly than say Vasil general then02:28:47
did it and he explained it in a very complicated way02:28:49
and so to speak, as if you imagine02:28:53
it means you came into your room02:28:55
a little closet in the closets many departments in02:28:58
them am from the shelves she has every shelf drawers and02:29:01
Now if you rummage through all the drawers then02:29:04
there is this deepening02:29:06
but my my mission was to02:29:09
to summarize, and now I’m thinking about02:29:12
how to summarize this theory02:29:15
because the more briefly you present it, the02:29:16
more people will be able to perceive it and02:29:19
use it because it is profitable02:29:22
it will be for someone02:29:24
to everyone, especially if we tell everyone about her02:29:27
the revival of socialism is necessary02:29:28
revive so that this is social02:29:30
marveled faster than he did02:29:32
socialism02:29:33
which actually approached this02:29:36
already in the Soviet Union and what do we have02:29:39
the rate was new at about 24 percent in02:29:41
year02:29:42
first five 24 percent per year before02:29:46
we are faced with such a problem as02:29:52
briefly and concisely understand what is in02:29:57
general broad subject deep02:30:00
scientific02:30:01
field and deep requires scientific knowledge02:30:05
but anyway02:30:07
no matter how deep it is always02:30:09
you need to find a form in which you can02:30:12
hold it in one head and hold it02:30:15
its not sometime after there 10 20 years02:30:18
studying and that's when it's needed02:30:20
need it now02:30:21
and everyone wants to move from simple02:30:25
contemplation or to the search for correctness02:30:28
because there is a lot of correctness and from the very02:30:31
much less because true02:30:34
when we talk about the truth it is already02:30:36
inconsistency because no not like that02:30:39
correctness that would not exist02:30:41
connected with incorrectness there are no such things02:30:43
good people who wouldn't exist02:30:45
you have no shortage of such scoundrels02:30:47
which would not have any advantages02:30:51
who helps them to the terraces in confidence02:30:53
there are no such savings in which there would be no02:30:56
there are no omissions or disadvantages02:31:00
production methods that would be02:31:03
definitely positive and there are no such02:31:06
political structures or02:31:09
state forms that would have02:31:12
only dignity and did not contain02:31:14
shortcomings I think everyone could02:31:16
put question 1 think about this topic02:31:18
and take it apart, but for the reason that we don’t02:31:22
we spread across the tree today02:31:26
We will try to work with you in a concise form.02:31:29
say it in this form02:31:33
suggest but how is it against02:31:36
imagine02:31:38
economic system of socialism02:31:40
economic system of socialism which02:31:43
if you understand that this is economic02:31:45
socialist system02:31:46
then here, for example, the state is all already02:31:49
know02:31:50
it fulfills certain economic02:31:52
functions without ceasing to be the state and02:31:55
especially because she's also a dying breed02:31:57
the state has also heard about it all02:32:00
here if this is an economic system02:32:03
socialism then under socialism leadership02:32:07
roles has working class means working class02:32:10
it is built into this economic system02:32:12
they are just an object02:32:13
operation or board for those who02:32:16
gives his labor and then there are such02:32:19
big people who decide where this goes02:32:22
the hardest part is how to use it, what is it02:32:25
there is a place for consciousness to pour out here02:32:29
what shall we say in the science of logic of Hegel02:32:31
considered in the doctrine of the concept02:32:32
because in general socialism and02:32:35
socialist development is wrong02:32:37
what is happening is that we are setting some goals and02:32:40
then there goes no we first scientifically02:32:42
we are developing actually developing02:32:45
those trends that stem from the very02:32:49
nature02:32:50
socialism its contradictions then these02:32:53
we formalize trends in the form of plans and if02:32:56
we are making plans to go out then I think that’s it02:32:58
understand that you always code something02:33:00
plan and implement02:33:02
then every plan goes wrong sometimes like this02:33:06
they speak beautifully and expressed themselves like that02:33:08
then when we had socialism what was the plan02:33:11
it is an economic policy instrument02:33:13
party do you know at least one instrument02:33:15
which doesn't get dull even if you need a shovel02:33:18
sharpen02:33:19
ax knives need sharpening knife02:33:21
sharpen the length in general like even a razor02:33:24
which you have to shave without you02:33:26
sharpen although search if it’s not enough02:33:29
people who still remember how to shave yes02:33:32
and your dangerous one day decided to try it02:33:35
how sharp is it line immediately 1 to02:33:37
half a finger there to the depth so sharpen02:33:41
necessary to solve this02:33:42
the problem itself can all heal if02:33:45
you damaged02:33:46
but you must understand that every thing is theirs02:33:50
every system and every02:33:54
actually existing in reality02:33:58
the phenomenon has two sides and they02:34:02
are in a fight and they include02:34:06
contradictions if you are contradictions in02:34:09
if you don’t see something, it doesn’t mean it’s yours02:34:11
no, this means that you have not reached the truth02:34:14
so I don't mean to say what if02:34:17
you something02:34:18
you don’t see any contradiction or02:34:21
do you observe it expressed then you02:34:22
misunderstand no you all02:34:25
you understand correctly or almost everything02:34:27
understand correctly but correctness and02:34:28
truth is different concepts truth02:34:31
always presupposes understanding02:34:35
disclosing this inconsistency02:34:37
inconsistency if you02:34:39
don't be fooled by contradictions if you are with me02:34:41
at least you don’t see any shortcomings02:34:43
speech or expression or action02:34:46
means your understanding carries me on02:34:49
I can say the same thing about Karl02:34:52
what is it they are watching or listening to if you02:34:54
you will prove that you only have02:34:57
negative qualities I won't believe it02:35:00
there are no such negative people who02:35:02
they can't do anything good or02:35:05
they don't do this doesn't happen it's people like02:35:08
people do something like that and vice versa02:35:11
such positive people who would02:35:13
there were no shortcomings and there weren’t any02:35:15
shortcomings that manifested themselves02:35:17
There are no negative scales either02:35:19
so that there is no stilt in02:35:21
our understanding02:35:22
we need to rise up not to give up02:35:26
I won’t give up my knowledge, but I’ll jump off it02:35:29
lay your head down so that they02:35:31
instead of any steps there are shelves02:35:34
shelves in which there is different knowledge02:35:37
laid out here and such knowledge02:35:39
economic here political here02:35:41
legally that you saw a single whole02:35:44
living developing whole society02:35:46
society develops like a living organism02:35:48
and the infinite society is eternal02:35:51
and each individual is included in02:35:54
view view endless and eternal individual he02:35:58
of course, but it is endless in its own way02:36:03
essentially a human being02:36:06
infinite because the essence of man02:36:08
this is probably what everyone has heard of what mars is about02:36:10
I say the essence of man is social02:36:13
they are biological although human head02:36:16
social creature times public02:36:18
infinite society is eternal therefore02:36:20
want to be endless eternal02:36:22
do something for society and02:36:24
carry this and it will be your infinity and02:36:27
forever and ever you will be in his memory02:36:29
folk and probably this is not only02:36:33
such beautiful phrases but probably you02:36:35
Do you understand that we’ll say Tchaikovsky like this02:36:37
brilliant works and many times more02:36:39
now performing during Tchaikovsky's lifetime02:36:41
I thought he would be happy to listen02:36:44
and beethoven of course especially taking into account02:36:47
that is, these problems were in02:36:50
life, including probably with hearing02:36:52
I would be glad too, I found out how long ago02:36:54
Beethoven is performed a lot and therefore02:36:56
no matter how long it has been since we02:36:58
talking about classics, what is it?02:37:00
classic classic is what is modern02:37:02
it's always the root02:37:04
vital, that is, not everything is included in the root02:37:06
carry something, you know how it is in weight02:37:08
some leaves fall off02:37:11
pistils and stamens may fall off, but then02:37:14
that like roots it always remains02:37:16
so don't rush to him in class02:37:18
modern therefore a person can do anything02:37:20
Anything you want to do you need to rely on02:37:22
classics, well, I think it's simple02:37:25
must be kept in mind and this must be taken into account02:37:27
mind and when considering socialism that02:37:29
we must say about socialism what02:37:31
we know the process of lenses this society02:37:33
based on public property02:37:37
that's right, that's right, but that's not all02:37:40
the world is only correct but you know02:37:43
what socialism is to carry more accurately02:37:46
its name is that it is communism at first02:37:49
phase02:37:50
what do flags mean conscience fly like02:37:54
understand something phase well you can say on02:37:57
first stage at the first stage at the first02:38:01
stage which 1 is on a niche or above a niche then02:38:05
there is what it is to the question about what02:38:06
is socialism you can answer this02:38:09
communism02:38:10
some find it difficult even02:38:13
it's hard to say but what a bastard we are02:38:15
built socially but you also built02:38:17
you built for coins no we patrols02:38:20
USSR why not so with Alex this is what it is02:38:22
to coins that's who you don't know what02:38:24
socially then communism in the first phase02:38:27
Everyone probably knows this, or almost everyone02:38:30
everyone knows the difference between the lowest phase02:38:33
communism from higher fat or better said02:38:35
so it’s as if there is a certain phase, but no02:38:37
phase if there is communism not developed02:38:41
form02:38:42
there is communism in rally one video in what02:38:45
here underdevelopment is not just in02:38:47
one thing that all the birthmarks are like02:38:49
interview02:38:50
that is, under communism in the first beginning02:38:53
when he is born for a long time it is02:38:57
no one defined time, not Marx and02:38:59
Engels is not lazy Annie you and I are not02:39:01
warmed up how long the phase will last02:39:03
socialism phrase of liberation from birthmarks02:39:06
spots to the pedal, but some thought that02:39:09
now we will defeat the socialist02:39:11
revolution in the civil war and will have02:39:13
us that a transition period will begin from02:39:17
capitalism communism and it will cost02:39:22
during this transition period we need to do02:39:23
we must first create a state02:39:25
industry is one problem you solved02:39:28
her but imagine Russia02:39:30
the peasant side and here is capitalism02:39:33
in the village it developed rapidly why02:39:35
violently but because the Bolsheviks gave the land02:39:37
to the peasants, since they gave the land02:39:40
peasants, not that she wouldn’t02:39:41
state turnover it became02:39:43
state land and the peasants are not02:39:45
owners but they are forever and02:39:47
received free use02:39:49
this means capitalism has received the conditions for02:39:52
of its rapid development is also a commodity02:39:53
production gives birth to capitalism02:39:55
gave birth and we received a grandiose class02:39:58
capitalists of the village who repeatedly02:40:01
superior to those capitalists who are already02:40:04
won the mountains by number and by02:40:06
malice and the way they treat02:40:10
to those whom they exploit and so02:40:13
this is a transition period to what communism02:40:17
and this problem was solved in the Soviet02:40:21
union team zero vote agriculture02:40:23
not so team zira and like some02:40:26
think once-once-once-once many different things02:40:28
cooperatives02:40:29
and that he will have many cooperatives this02:40:32
there will be cooperative socialism as in02:40:34
Yugoslavia, that is, capitalism is not02:40:37
it will work out like this, you just need socialism02:40:39
because socialism is based on 102:40:41
property a-102:40:42
they 2 as they wrote in the bad textbook02:40:44
open any bad textbook they are all02:40:46
bad and it says state government02:40:49
generally popular and cooperative02:40:52
own02:40:53
and this is not so state-owned, then I’m ready02:40:57
forum what is public property02:40:59
cooperatives also mean socially02:41:00
therefore socialism is communism02:41:03
but in the first phase what is our first s02:41:06
the radio is stained capital but that's all in general02:41:08
what are birthmarks from capitalism02:41:11
spots are negation or expression02:41:13
socialism denial I think you don't02:41:15
you will insist that birthmarks are something02:41:18
this is an expression of your drag and normal02:41:21
skin02:41:22
this is a kind of denial of her, that’s even02:41:24
moles are separate, what is this denial02:41:26
these are the denials this is from the denial this02:41:29
the moment of socialism itself is what you need02:41:32
learn to have is not correct and02:41:36
only understanding of socialism and this02:41:38
correct understanding that this is a system02:41:39
based on public property02:41:41
such a system is based on public02:41:43
features which in every way02:41:45
has the opposite opposite02:41:48
moment and time has the opposite02:41:51
moment that is the contradiction between02:41:52
the communist nature of socialism and02:41:55
its denial is something to check in02:42:00
everyone if you don't see this somewhere02:42:03
manifestations means somewhere you are not here02:42:05
finished watching, that is, it’s correct yours02:42:08
understanding has not reached the truth in everything02:42:11
economic political fight02:42:13
deceit mars by the way to cover02:42:15
Elovskaya programs and02:42:18
Lenin in the state of his sheets and02:42:19
spoke in economic terms himself and02:42:22
mentally bears the imprint of that system of02:42:25
which he came out and explained in02:42:29
economically you I think what if02:42:31
you and I will understand that in economic02:42:33
respect, it bears the imprint of that02:42:35
capitalism is enough what it is02:42:38
and morality is based on02:42:40
to whom economics02:42:42
so how does it cost to steal?02:42:44
economically there is still 102:42:47
the imprint of capitalism in communism and you02:42:50
you don’t see him in morality, that means02:42:52
that no one thought of it or msi02:42:55
if you have us you see a lot of fools02:42:58
or a lot of people who can't02:42:59
think correctly think what is it02:43:02
this is an imprint of capitalism because02:43:04
that capitalism does not require people02:43:05
understood if they understand everything02:43:07
it will be impossible to operate for02:43:10
so that they behave appropriately02:43:13
way they went, worked and created02:43:15
wealth for capitalists is necessary so that02:43:17
they were idiots, let them drink beer02:43:19
plays the pin with a shaft and that's enough, that's all02:43:23
so the imprints of this are the person in02:43:25
don't tell us anything, we don't need to02:43:26
your science doesn't need any theory, we02:43:29
better let's go and make money, not you02:43:31
they will earn money on you therefore02:43:34
it is in all respects therefore if02:43:36
Marx and Engels02:43:37
Marx and Engels and Lenin would not say02:43:39
that in all respects it was possible02:43:41
it would be enough to say that02:43:42
economically once in02:43:44
economically means in everything02:43:46
in general about combat, but if we talk about it02:43:48
then we must from this economic02:43:50
relationship goes to the next but02:43:52
first let's formulate02:43:54
then the contradiction of the first phases of communism02:43:57
or communism in the first phase which02:44:00
is universal02:44:01
if we bet on this now02:44:03
full stop and finished and consider that you have already02:44:05
the main thing you know about socialism socialism02:44:09
this is communism02:44:14
denial in itself associated with02:44:17
passing02:44:18
from capitalism and therefore two02:44:20
trends exist in the movement towards the moon02:44:22
there is a tendency towards the development of incomplete02:44:26
communism into complete immature communism02:44:28
mature02:44:29
didn’t sing ripe here from to please here02:44:32
times you will disperse as creators of the developed02:44:34
socialism if socialism is developed then02:44:38
to complete the colony and if he hasn’t yet02:44:43
full so it doesn’t mean the world is undeveloped02:44:46
how can socialism be developed?02:44:49
if the developed talent was complete02:44:50
communism has no place in this category02:44:53
with which the kpss died the kpss died with02:44:56
the concept of developed socialism on the lips02:44:59
from this harris these sounds were heard from everywhere02:45:02
words that we have developed socialism to him02:45:04
corresponds to the state of the whole people02:45:06
although such states do not exist in02:45:09
nature, all states are concepts of class and02:45:11
we'll get to it later, here's one02:45:14
tendency to move forward and and but02:45:17
somehow everything was always seen at the villa02:45:19
which we are going in what we got that you are going02:45:22
forward how you are defined in society02:45:24
go forward and back forward02:45:26
this is a communist gain02:45:29
the nature of socialism and the weakening02:45:31
these birthmarks for fewer fools02:45:34
it would be better to understand with higher education and02:45:37
so on leaned out more consciousness02:45:39
saying more about the priority of public02:45:43
somehow personal but somehow narrow02:45:46
limited and so on therefore this02:45:49
this is the main road the main trend is02:45:52
this is the strengthening of communist nature with02:45:56
salt weakening and its negation02:46:00
weakening does not mean absence02:46:02
that is, this is a long process and if02:46:05
people decided that it was over they immediately02:46:08
were thrown back into capitalism02:46:11
how did we end up how is this because02:46:13
that we decided that we were really sailing02:46:17
in fact, although we know in principle we know that02:46:19
we are swimming against the current of the river but we gave up02:46:22
threw the oars the first one told us02:46:24
secretary and Nikita Khrushchev02:46:26
that social has won completely02:46:28
finally give up the oars02:46:30
sit and do what you want and can02:46:34
you can open the bottle yourself protection02:46:36
sing songs and here we are on these very02:46:39
a bottle with a singing dog threw us out02:46:42
on the threshold because since you are not moving02:46:44
forward to the current it's coming to the web02:46:46
the current is not that strong and it is possible02:46:48
it was possible to overcome it if you row well02:46:50
you were told there is no need for grief, how do you like it02:46:52
they said that there is no need to row; the class is fighting02:46:54
stopped it was said to give02:46:57
parties to the congress class fish stopped02:46:59
Zarlin won completely and finally02:47:01
there is the very idea of struggle02:47:04
thrown away although there is one no no02:47:09
famous book by Lenin and very much so02:47:11
famous why because Lenin02:47:13
I tried to pass on our experience to all my comrades02:47:17
from other countries it is a childhood disease02:47:19
novelty in communism and it’s just here02:47:22
tried to overcome this childhood illness to02:47:24
in fact, people didn’t see the point in carrying02:47:27
what is being built here in the Soviet02:47:29
What's the point of dictatorship in Russia?02:47:31
the proletariat and to which the proletariat is02:47:34
what but he could just have this fabric here02:47:36
working class states yes that is what it is02:47:39
formal understanding external understanding02:47:41
essentially a dictatorship of pirates than a dictatorship02:47:44
the proletariat has a stubborn struggle02:47:47
bloody and bloodless violent02:47:51
and peaceful military and economics and against02:47:54
strengths and traditions of the old society and what02:47:58
happened in the ussr in russia forces of tradition02:48:02
old society02:48:03
got the better of whom they got the better of02:48:07
over those who stopped fighting if you02:48:10
stopped fighting02:48:11
we went out on the carpet and I fight02:48:14
and you decided that I want to fight him02:48:17
they stopped fighting long ago and lost and02:48:20
how therefore that well what is the conclusion in02:48:23
about the first and main contradiction02:48:24
moving forward is overcoming02:48:27
the opposite tendency is allowed02:48:29
this is a contradiction of a struggle which is not at all02:48:33
fight otherwise you will be with someone unknown02:48:34
they and why fight that negative02:48:37
trends02:48:38
for the full development of socialism02:48:40
collagen, consider it the first one02:48:44
says the first chapter of our drag with02:48:47
you sound book or video book about02:48:50
socialism is closed02:48:51
that means now she is devoted to us02:48:54
agenda and on the table or as it is now02:48:58
he likes to say what our agenda is02:49:01
yes, any agenda can be accepted by everyone02:49:03
his opposite decisions to me02:49:04
I'm surprised by these conversations with you02:49:06
agenda, yes, there will be an agenda about02:49:08
hanging I won't be hanged so-and-so02:49:11
will give you a summons, do you need a decision on02:49:13
this agenda so here we have in this02:49:16
case is really on the agenda02:49:17
the question of what is up to us02:49:19
it turns out production on one side02:49:22
and on the one hand she is like a whole02:49:25
the wall is no longer directly02:49:27
commodity well because you are in communism02:49:29
speak as loud as your tongue can02:49:31
turn around and say that communism is a product02:49:33
being a commodity product02:49:35
production production for exchange me02:49:38
it doesn't matter what I do, what matters is what I do02:49:40
for this I will have him who doesn't care02:49:42
produces a product if it is actually a product02:49:45
really don’t care what it will be like02:49:47
the goods as long as they can be sold02:49:49
so you see what they are selling now02:49:51
such goods that have02:49:52
use value02:49:53
or is it use value02:49:55
artificially invented and induced02:49:57
here he sells say a tattoo you can02:50:01
get a tattoo but you probably know02:50:03
that you can get hepatitis C which02:50:05
very difficult to cure and others hung02:50:09
they can make your oval more beautiful02:50:11
faces but you were a beautiful girl02:50:13
stayed behind the kind of woman's bath and behold02:50:16
many media figures are already from this02:50:19
suffered and what's the matter is that02:50:21
it's very expensive I can afford it02:50:24
you can afford it02:50:26
thief ugly dragging a monster because of her own02:50:30
the money you got for carrying around02:50:32
your art and your successes02:50:35
that is, there is no methane, socialism is not a commodity02:50:39
production and non-commodity02:50:41
directly public that's accurate02:50:43
the title is correct correct that's all02:50:45
this is not a true understanding of myself on this02:50:49
put . you heard the recording02:50:51
these pants, don’t tell me how it’s like that, yeah02:50:53
right here it’s the exact opposite with02:50:54
these are these phenomena02:50:56
opposite phenomena are connected by the fact that02:50:58
we have such a directly public02:51:00
production which is in all02:51:03
relationships bears the imprint of that system of02:51:06
which came from which farm came from02:51:08
our directly public pass02:51:10
from commodity means there is marketability02:51:12
Please note the goods have not been sent02:51:15
nearby commodity production next to02:51:17
directly public immediately it02:51:18
it would take us somewhere02:51:19
transition period here is the sector02:51:21
directly to the public here02:51:23
commodity02:51:24
but that was before ’36, just like that02:51:28
this is where it all ends, all our everything02:51:30
socially and in all this public02:51:33
there is his denial that is you me02:51:35
put at the factory, I'm standing at the machine and you02:51:38
you say Mihalovich should produce02:51:41
what a bastard you are, products on your lathe02:51:44
machine in the interests of the general where I am and02:51:47
proposed in the interests of society in the most02:51:48
Dubai Tom how can I earn more02:51:50
the day is not that important02:51:52
Maybe standing there I’ll suggest it, otherwise it’s important02:51:56
what will I get for this02:51:58
and they are just my whim or trick02:52:01
and this is set in the form itself02:52:04
socialist organization02:52:05
production we distribute everything02:52:09
products first02:52:11
through written funds and through the fund02:52:15
distribution by work02:52:16
here is Viktor Ivan Zhigalko candidate02:52:18
economic sciences and rector02:52:20
university worker correspondent02:52:22
working day fund I calculated that 5202:52:25
percent of goods in the USSR02:52:28
distributed distributed through02:52:31
public funds02:52:32
it's easy to believe this is housing well you02:52:36
just look at the numbers02:52:38
the cost of housing is education which02:52:41
all lard for a fee and medicine medicine02:52:45
dimensionless, will you regret it02:52:48
some money to be02:52:50
alive stay alive you won't regret it02:52:53
That's why02:52:54
there are no high prices in medicine, they are all02:52:57
we are not enough02:52:59
because there are doctors who already02:53:01
stopped being doctors and became02:53:03
businessmen, but they won’t excuse you from not being the best02:53:05
life because they got into this02:53:06
society where you want and by the way02:53:09
spin now so that's a contradiction02:53:15
exists between being02:53:17
production in the interests of society and at the same time02:53:20
at the same time there are attempts to produce or02:53:25
work not in the interests of society02:53:28
aul create the interests of society so that02:53:29
get the night on first place for02:53:31
the worker can go out for anyone else02:53:35
what he does for society and what he02:53:37
but otherwise he can’t do anything02:53:39
get what he gets through02:53:42
distribution by work02:53:43
and he works for this02:53:46
reward for reward and for the sake of02:53:48
reward for rewards all02:53:50
works at a time to get02:53:52
salary but he doesn’t work for the sake of02:53:57
society02:53:58
ara is not only about receiving salaries and02:54:00
how does this differ from the actions of someone who02:54:03
produces commercial goods and nothing02:54:06
is different, that's why Lenin says02:54:11
How many scoundrels have we found here?02:54:13
among all workers, including even02:54:15
party printing houses who want a02:54:18
give society less and worse and take02:54:21
They want more and better money from himDescription:
Путеводитель по Научному Социализму от Михаила Васильевича Попова! Эта, самая полная подборка краткого курса, специально для изучающих Марксизм-Ленинизм. Источником исходного материала послужил цикл лекций М.В., записанный для Лектория Красного университета. : 00:00:11 Содержание 00:00:18 Общественно-экономические формации 00:59:24 От Капитализма к Социализму 01:42:45 Реставрация Капитализма 02:10:50 Потребительно-стоимостная теория развития Социализма 02:29:45 Диалектика Социализма :
Preparing download options
* — If the video is playing in a new tab, go to it, then right-click on the video and select "Save video as..."
** — Link intended for online playback in specialized players
Questions about downloading video
How can I download "Научный Социализм. Попов М.В. [краткий учебный курс]" video?
http://unidownloader.com/ website is the best way to download a video or a separate audio track if you want to do without installing programs and extensions.
The UDL Helper extension is a convenient button that is seamlessly integrated into YouTube, Instagram and OK.ru sites for fast content download.
UDL Client program (for Windows) is the most powerful solution that supports more than 900 websites, social networks and video hosting sites, as well as any video quality that is available in the source.
UDL Lite is a really convenient way to access a website from your mobile device. With its help, you can easily download videos directly to your smartphone.
Which format of "Научный Социализм. Попов М.В. [краткий учебный курс]" video should I choose?
The best quality formats are FullHD (1080p), 2K (1440p), 4K (2160p) and 8K (4320p). The higher the resolution of your screen, the higher the video quality should be. However, there are other factors to consider: download speed, amount of free space, and device performance during playback.
Why does my computer freeze when loading a "Научный Социализм. Попов М.В. [краткий учебный курс]" video?
The browser/computer should not freeze completely! If this happens, please report it with a link to the video. Sometimes videos cannot be downloaded directly in a suitable format, so we have added the ability to convert the file to the desired format. In some cases, this process may actively use computer resources.
How can I download "Научный Социализм. Попов М.В. [краткий учебный курс]" video to my phone?
You can download a video to your smartphone using the website or the PWA application UDL Lite. It is also possible to send a download link via QR code using the UDL Helper extension.
How can I download an audio track (music) to MP3 "Научный Социализм. Попов М.В. [краткий учебный курс]"?
The most convenient way is to use the UDL Client program, which supports converting video to MP3 format. In some cases, MP3 can also be downloaded through the UDL Helper extension.
How can I save a frame from a video "Научный Социализм. Попов М.В. [краткий учебный курс]"?
This feature is available in the UDL Helper extension. Make sure that "Show the video snapshot button" is checked in the settings. A camera icon should appear in the lower right corner of the player to the left of the "Settings" icon. When you click on it, the current frame from the video will be saved to your computer in JPEG format.
What's the price of all this stuff?
It costs nothing. Our services are absolutely free for all users. There are no PRO subscriptions, no restrictions on the number or maximum length of downloaded videos.